System for selecting a trajectory for an aircraft equipped with an automatic navigation and guidance system for automatic nagivation and guidance on a trajectory

EP4463677A1Pending Publication Date: 2024-11-20THALES SA
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
EP2023700785
Authority / Receiving Office
EP · EP
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2022-01-14
Filing Date
2023-01-12
Publication Date
2024-11-20

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Current autonomous aircraft navigation systems lack the capability for safe and autonomous trajectory selection in response to hazards, particularly in Beyond Visual Line of Sight operations, relying on remote pilots for decision-making and pre-planned landing areas, with no comprehensive solution combining autonomy and safety.

Method used

A trajectory selection system with an automatic guidance system on board the aircraft, featuring a module for calculating and validating flight and diversion trajectories, using aerodynamic, propulsion, and navigation performance data to ensure flightability and respond to hazards, allowing for real-time adaptation and updates.

Benefits of technology

Ensures safe and autonomous navigation by providing validated trajectories for all potential hazards, reducing the need for remote operator intervention and enhancing flight safety, even in complex environments.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 1.1
    Figure 1.1
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention relates to a system for selecting a trajectory for an aircraft equipped with an automatic navigation and guidance system (SNGA) for automatic navigation and guidance on a trajectory, said system being computer-implemented and comprising: - a computing module (Calc_Traj) for computing a flight mission trajectory for the aircraft and diversion trajectories; - an analysis and validation module (TrajDB_Checker) for analysing and validating mission and diversion trajectories present in a database (TrajDB); - said database (TrajDB), which is on board the aircraft, comprising a flight mission trajectory and diversion trajectories that are validated by the analysis and validation module (TrajDB_Checker), and being configured to store a new flight mission trajectory and new diversion trajectories that are transmitted by the computing module (Calc_Traj) for analysis by the analysis and validation module, and configured, in the event of said new flight mission and diversion trajectories being validated by the analysis and validation module (TrajDB_Checker), to update the validated flight mission and diversion trajectories; - a selection module for selecting the flight trajectory (Sel_Traj) from among the validated flight mission and diversion trajectories based on values of operating parameters of the aircraft allowing the presence of one of said hazards to be determined, configured to transmit said selected trajectory to the automatic navigation and guidance system (SNGA) for automatic navigation and guidance on a trajectory on board the aircraft.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

DESCRIPTION Title of the invention: System for selecting the trajectory of an aircraft equipped with a navigation system and automatic guidance on a trajectory

[0001] The invention relates to a trajectory selection system for an aircraft provided with an automatic navigation and guidance system on a trajectory.

[0002] The technical field of the invention is that of autonomous aircraft navigation, such as a drone or an airplane equipped with an automatic navigation and guidance system.

[0003] The field of operation is that of drones remotely operated in BVLOS, for acronym of "Beyond Visual Line of Sight", out of the visual range of a teleoperator, and autonomous aircraft more generally, which may include an aircraft initially piloted by a crew who has lost the ability to pilot (hypoxia, incapacity of a single pilot, etc.). During a mission, the aircraft may encounter a certain number of hazards to be dealt with, as illustrated in [Fig.1].

[0004] These hazards may be dangerous weather conditions, dangerous traffic, a failure or malfunction of the propulsion or control surfaces or any part of the aircraft or its equipment having an impact on flight performance, a loss of the C2 communication link with the tele-operator, taking into account unforeseen external instructions (air traffic control, tele-operator, pilot on the ground, etc.), a conflict with the terrain (potential collision between the aircraft and the terrain), or over-energy (aircraft too high or too fast leading to excessive speed during landing) with a view to an emergency landing...

[0005] The goal is to provide safe and autonomous navigation of an aircraft.

[0006] Autonomous navigation means that the aircraft can autonomously modify its navigation in order to adapt either to a change in the mission or to the hazards of the mission.

[0007] Safe navigation means that navigation has a level of criticality corresponding to the risk levels assessed for the aircraft's mission. This document assumes that functions other than navigation (propulsion, control surfaces, etc.) have the required levels of criticality with regard to the objectives of flight safety according to the class of aircraft concerned (drone, commercial aviation, etc.).

[0008] Autonomous drone solutions exist, but are limited to micro-drones operating in secure areas. Research is being conducted for autonomous drones operating in an urban environment. In particular, a NASA article, "Onboard Decision-Making for Nominal and Contingency slIAS Flight," by Joshua Baculi & Corey Ippolito, 2019, is known, which describes hazard management for a drone using onboard trajectories. This article does not address issues regarding navigation safety at all.

[0009] For larger drone missions, if we consider the regulations (see EASA, “Easy Access Rules for Unmanned Aircraft Systems”, June 2021), the solution currently adopted for safe navigation is to use the remote pilot as a backup in the event of unforeseen circumstances (for decision-making and possibly calculating a new trajectory) and to land the drone urgently in areas planned during mission preparation.

[0010] There is currently no solution that combines both autonomy and safety of navigation in the event of an emergency.

[0011] One aim of the invention is to overcome the problems mentioned above.

[0012] According to one aspect of the invention, there is provided a system for selecting the trajectory of an aircraft provided with an automatic guidance system on a trajectory, implemented by computer, comprising: - a module for calculating a flight mission trajectory of the aircraft and diversion trajectories in the event of a hazard occurring during the mission trajectory, on board the aircraft or on the ground, these trajectories being able to be of the 2D or more type, with or without transition between segments; - a module for analyzing and validating mission and diversion trajectories present in a database, on board the aircraft, and comprising: - a sub-module for verifying the flyability of each trajectory by verifying the suitability of the trajectory with technical characteristics of the aircraft representative of the aircraft's performance; and - a sub-module for verifying that the diversion trajectories can respond to a set of specific hazards, at any time during the mission trajectory; - said database, on board the aircraft, comprising a flight mission trajectory and diversion trajectories validated by the analysis and validation module, and being configured to store a new flight mission trajectory and new diversion trajectories transmitted by the calculation module for the purposes of analysis by the analysis and validation module, and configured to, in the event of validation of said new flight mission and diversion trajectories by the analysis and validation module, update the validated flight mission and diversion trajectories; - a module for selecting the flight trajectory from among the validated flight mission and diversion trajectories, based on values of aircraft operating parameters making it possible to determine the presence of one of said hazards, configured to transmit said selected trajectory to the automatic navigation and guidance system on a trajectory, on board the aircraft.

[0013] The volability of a trajectory is the fact that a trajectory is flyable or not; a trajectory being flyable if the aircraft is capable of flying this trajectory, i.e. the trajectory is continuous and compatible with the aircraft's performance.

[0014] In one embodiment, the sub-module for verifying the flyability of each trajectory is configured to verify the suitability of the trajectory with the technical characteristics of the aircraft representative of the performance of the aircraft including technical characteristics representative of aerodynamic performance, propulsion performance, and performance of the navigation and automatic guidance system of the aircraft.

[0015] According to one embodiment, the sub-module for verifying the flyability of each trajectory is configured to use packages to estimate the values of the technical characteristics representative of the aerodynamic performances, the propulsion performances, and the performances of the navigation and automatic guidance system of the aircraft.

[0016] A package quantitatively represents a capability of the aircraft. An example of a package might be the ability to climb at a given vertical speed.

[0017] In one embodiment, the sub-module for verifying the flyability of each trajectory is configured to use modeling to estimate the values of the technical characteristics representative of the aerodynamic performance, propulsion performance, and performance of the navigation and automatic guidance system of the aircraft.

[0018] According to one embodiment, the verification sub-module that the diversion trajectories make it possible to respond to a set of determined hazards, at any time of the mission trajectory is configured to translate a hazard into a set of rules to be verified depending on the aircraft.

[0019] For example, the sub-module for verifying that the diversion trajectories can respond to a set of determined hazards is configured to translate a failure hazard by the following rule: - for the flight mission trajectory, it is possible to land within a predefined time, for example at most 30 minutes, possibly using a diversion trajectory.

[0020] For example, the sub-module for verifying that the diversion trajectories can respond to a set of determined hazards is configured to translate a collision hazard with an obstacle listed by the following rule: - for any trajectory among the flight mission trajectory and the diversion trajectories, the trajectory does not encounter any listed obstacle.

[0021] For example, the sub-module for verifying that the diversion trajectories can respond to a set of determined hazards is configured to translate a collision hazard with an obstacle not listed by the following rule: - for any trajectory among the flight mission trajectory and the diversion trajectories, it is possible to make a U-turn at any point of the trajectory without encountering a listed obstacle, the U-turn depending on the state vector (speed and roll) and the wind allowing to travel in the opposite direction the same trajectory safe with respect to listed and unlisted obstacles.

[0022] For example, the aircraft is a drone or an airplane.

[0023] The invention will be better understood by studying a few embodiments described as non-limiting examples and illustrated by the appended drawings in which:

[0024] [Fig.1] schematically illustrates a drone mission, according to one aspect of the state of the art;

[0025] [Fig.2] schematically illustrates a trajectory selection system for an aircraft equipped with an automatic trajectory guidance system, implemented by computer, according to one aspect of the invention;

[0026] [Fig.3] schematically illustrates an assembly comprising a mission trajectory and a diversion mission assembly, according to another aspect of the invention;

[0027] [Fig. 4] schematically illustrates an analysis and validation module of the system of [Fig. 2], according to another aspect of the invention;

[0028] [Fig.5] schematically illustrates a sub-module for verifying the flyability of each trajectory, according to another aspect of the invention;

[0029] [Fig.6] schematically illustrates a sub-module for verifying that the diversion trajectories make it possible to respond to a set of determined hazards, at any time during the mission trajectory, according to another aspect of the invention; and

[0030] [Fig.7] schematically illustrates the validation of the database comprising a flight mission trajectory and diversion trajectories validated by the analysis and validation module, according to one aspect of the invention.

[0031] Throughout the figures, elements with identical references are similar.

[0032] [Fig.2] schematically represents a trajectory selection system for an aircraft equipped with an automatic GA guidance system on a trajectory, implemented by computer.

[0033] The system includes a Calc_Traj calculation module for an aircraft flight mission trajectory and diversion trajectories in the event of a hazard occurring during the mission trajectory.

[0034] The system also includes a TrajDB_Checker analysis and validation module for mission and diversion trajectories present in a TrajDB database, including: - a VV sub-module for verifying the flyability of each trajectory by verifying the suitability of the trajectory with technical characteristics of the aircraft representative of the aircraft's performance; and - a VA verification sub-module that the diversion trajectories allow to respond to a set of determined hazards, at any time of the mission trajectory.

[0035] The TrajDB database comprises a flight mission trajectory and diversion trajectories validated by the analysis and validation module TrajDB_Checker, and is configured to store a new flight mission trajectory and new diversion trajectories transmitted by the calculation module Calc_Traj for analysis by the analysis and validation module. The TrajDB database is also configured to, in the event of validation of said new flight mission trajectories and diversion by the analysis and validation module TrajDB_Checker, update the validated flight mission trajectories and diversion trajectories.

[0036] The system also comprises a Sel_Traj selection module for the flight trajectory from among the validated flight mission and diversion trajectories, based on values of aircraft operating parameters making it possible to determine the presence of one of said hazards, configured to transmit said selected trajectory to the automatic guidance system on a trajectory.

[0037] The Calc_Traj calculation module for an aircraft flight mission trajectory and diversion trajectories in the event of a hazard occurring during the mission trajectory performs its trajectory calculations in the open world (no design constraints linked to operational safety).

[0038] For each aircraft mission, the Calc_Traj calculation module calculates a set of trajectories corresponding to the mission trajectory and all contingency or diversion trajectories linked to predetermined hazards that may occur during the mission as illustrated in [Fig.3].

[0039] The Calc_Traj calculation module can recalculate a new set of trajectories during the mission (in case of modification of the latter). This function can be hosted either on the ground in a data center or "data center" in English or on an on-board computer or "Edge Computer" in English for reasons of latency or availability of the ground-on-board link, redundant if necessary, in order to guarantee the availability of the calculation.

[0040] When the Calc_Traj calculation module is located on the ground, the new set of trajectories is transmitted to the aircraft via ground / onboard connectivity. For a drone, the C2 link between the drone and its ground station can be used. In the case of aircraft, the various cockpit and / or cabin connectivity means can be used (Satcom, VHF, Air-to-Ground). Specific protocols and gateways (AFCDI type) can be used to update the onboard database with the new set of trajectories.

[0041] Once calculated, this set of trajectories is loaded into a database on board the aircraft and the TrajDB_Checker analysis and validation module verifies the set of trajectories. It includes two sub-modules.

[0042] As illustrated in [Fig.4], the flight verification sub-module returns OK status if the aircraft can actually fly the trajectory (match between the trajectory and the drone's performance), and returns NOK (for Not OK) otherwise.

[0043] The verification sub-module that the diversion trajectories allow to respond to a set of determined hazards, at any time of the mission trajectory or verification of the hazards to be treated returns the OK status if the set of trajectories allows to manage all the predefined hazards until the end of the mission (Concretely, at any time and for any hazard, there is a compatible trajectory of this hazard allowing to finish the mission). It returns NOK otherwise.

[0044] As illustrated in [Fig.4], the TrajDB_Checker mission and diversion trajectories analysis and validation module calculates a status which can take the following values: - OK: the TrajDB trajectory database is secure: the TrajDB_Checker mission and diversion trajectory analysis and validation module returns OK. It allows the aircraft to carry out its mission and cope with the hazards to be dealt with. - NOK: TrajDB trajectory database is not secure: TrajDB_Checker mission and diversion trajectory analysis and validation module returns NOK. Either one of the trajectories cannot be flown by the aircraft, or trajectories are missing to deal with one of the hazards.

[0045] Thus, the return status of TrajDB_Checker is OK only if the statuses of both sub-functions (volatility check and hazard check) are OK. In all other cases, the status is NOK.

[0046] The flyability check function is illustrated in [Fig.5]. This function is called for each trajectory in the base to be checked. It uses data on the aircraft's performance: these performances include aerodynamic performance, propulsion performance (e.g., possible climb rate and turn radius), and the performance of the navigation and automatic guidance system. This function determines whether the aircraft is capable of following the trajectory. For example, if the trajectory includes a slope greater than the aircraft's maximum climb rate, then the function returns NOK.

[0047] In a first embodiment, the VV flight verification submodule may be implemented using packages to represent the performance of the aircraft and its guidance. In a second embodiment, it is possible to use an executable model of the aircraft and use a fast simulation. In a third embodiment, the function may use a corridor of predefined size and return NOK only if the aircraft can follow its trajectory while remaining within the corridor.

[0048] The VA sub-module for verifying the hazards to be processed consists of a set of rules to be verified. The translation of the hazards into a series of rules is done during the design of the VA sub-module for verifying hazards. The following table gives an example of rules derived from hazards:

[0049] These rules will depend on the aircraft in question. For example, the range of an aircraft may vary in the event of an engine failure. Some of these rules may require information to be stored in databases onboard the aircraft. For example, it may be necessary to have an obstacle database to verify that no listed obstacles are crossing a trajectory.

[0050] [Fig.6] illustrates the hazard checking function for the three hazards / rules given in the table below.

[0051] The VA sub-module for hazard verification can also use the concept of a corridor around the trajectory.

[0052] The TrajDB_Checker mission trajectory and diversion analysis and validation module is designed as an avionics function module hosted by the aircraft. Thus, this module is developed and qualified with the design constraints to ensure availability and integrity constraints.

[0053] This TrajDB_Checker mission trajectory and diversion analysis and validation module is called before each mission and the aircraft cannot take off if the TrajDB trajectory database has not been validated. It is also called each time the TrajDB trajectory database is modified. If the verification fails, then the modification is not accepted and the aircraft remains on the old version of the TrajDB trajectory database. Thus, the aircraft always flies with a valid TrajDB trajectory database. It is in this mechanism, illustrated in [Fig.7], that the inventiveness of the solution lies, because it ensures the autonomy of the aircraft in a safe manner (since it has at all times a set of valid trajectories for all possible hazards of the mission, and this from the initialization of the mission).

[0054] The Sel_Traj flight path selection module on board chooses the correct trajectory from the trajectories in the TrajDB database throughout the mission. This decision-making integrates operational logic as a pilot on board would have done. It uses the sensors on board the aircraft to identify hazards and possibly change trajectory. In particular, the Sel_Traj flight path selection module can switch to a trajectory diversion based on the identified hazard(s). It is also an avionics function module hosted by the aircraft.

[0055] Finally, the SNGA automatic navigation and guidance system guides the aircraft along the chosen trajectory. It is an avionics function module hosted by the aircraft.

[0056] In an implementation variant, a function module, on board the aircraft, for calculating trajectories associated with a flight plan database determined in the open world can be inserted between the calls of the Sel_Traj flight path selection module and the SNGA automatic navigation and guidance system on a trajectory. The flight plans obtained can be based on the information published in an A424 navigation database (capacity adapted to commercial aviation flights having to be inserted into General Air Traffic (GAT) for example) or on free routes, not constrained by existing procedures (capacity adapted to drone-type missions following a gas pipeline for example).

[0057] The system according to the invention allows safe and autonomous navigation, because the trajectory database TrajDB being validated by a TrajDB_Checker module of avionics function, for any hazard, there is a validated trajectory to complete the mission. The execution of this trajectory is carried out by avionics function modules.

[0058] Since navigation is autonomous and safe, communication between a ground operator (teleoperator or remote pilot) and the aircraft is no longer necessary for flight safety (the aircraft is still capable of completing the mission autonomously). Loss of this communication is no longer a critical event. Similarly, the workload of a teleoperator is reduced, allowing them, for example, to track a fleet of aircraft instead of being tied to just one.

[0059] Trajectories are calculated in the open world, so it is possible to use all open world resources to obtain mission trajectories. For example, if the aircraft is a drone carrying out an inspection mission of a power line or a gas pipeline, it is possible to use the operator's GIS (Geographic Information System) to calculate these trajectories. It is also possible to adapt the trajectory calculation to a new type of mission. or to improve the calculation of trajectories without modifying the avionics functions of the aircraft.

[0060] Trajectories can also be calculated on a platform on board the aircraft (but not avionics), this allows the trajectory database to be updated during the mission and to use the aircraft sensors as input data for the trajectory calculation. It can be used for missions tracking a moving target, in this case, the trajectories depend on the sensors allowing the target to be tracked (for example an optronic ball) and are calculated at a high frequency (a few seconds). It is also possible to use this calculation on board for an aircraft avoidance function: if a conflict with traffic, or a meteorological event is detected by the aircraft sensors (type camera) then a new trajectory calculation is triggered in order to avoid this conflict.

[0061] The present invention can be applied to any aircraft and in particular to - drones carrying out missions in risky environments (flying over inhabited areas, flying in controlled areas). - commercial aircraft with a single-pilot crew, the probability of incapacitation of which does not cover the flight safety requirements as defined by existing standards.

Claims

DEMANDS 1. A computer-implemented aircraft trajectory selection system equipped with an automatic navigation and guidance system (ANSG) on a trajectory, comprising: - a calculation module (Calc_Traj) for a flight mission trajectory of the aircraft and diversion trajectories in case of an unforeseen event during the mission trajectory, carried on board the aircraft or on the ground; - an analysis and validation module (TrajDB_Checker) for mission and diversion trajectories present in a database (TrajDB), installed on board the aircraft, and comprising: - a sub-module (VV) for verifying the flightability of each trajectory by checking the trajectory's suitability with technical characteristics of the aircraft that are representative of the aircraft's performance; and - a sub-module (VA) for verifying that the diversion trajectories allow for responding to a set of determined hazards, at any time during the mission trajectory; - said database (TrajDB), on board the aircraft, comprising a flight mission trajectory and diversion trajectories validated by the analysis and validation module (TrajDB_Checker), and being configured to store a new flight mission trajectory and new diversion trajectories transmitted by the calculation module (Calc_Traj) for analysis by the analysis and validation module, and configured to, in the event of validation of said new flight mission and diversion trajectories by the analysis and validation module (TrajDB_Checker), update the validated flight mission and diversion trajectories; - a flight trajectory selection module (Sel_Traj) from among the validated flight mission and diversion trajectories, based on aircraft operating parameter values ​​allowing the presence of one of said hazards to be determined, configured to transmit said selected trajectory to the automatic navigation and guidance system (SNGA) on a trajectory, on board the aircraft.

2. A system according to claim 1, wherein the flightability verification sub-module (VV) of each trajectory is configured to verify the suitability of the trajectory with the aircraft's technical characteristics representative of the aircraft's performance, including technical characteristics representative of aerodynamic performance, performance of propulsion, and performance of the aircraft's automatic navigation and guidance system.

3. System according to claim 2, wherein the flightability verification sub-module (VV) for each trajectory is configured to use packages to estimate the values ​​of technical characteristics representative of aerodynamic performance, propulsion performance, and the performance of the aircraft's automatic navigation and guidance system.

4. System according to claim 2, wherein the flightability verification sub-module (VV) for each trajectory is configured to use modeling to estimate the values ​​of technical characteristics representative of aerodynamic performance, propulsion performance, and the performance of the aircraft's automatic guidance navigation system.

5. System according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the sub-module (VA) for verifying that the diversion trajectories allow for responding to a set of determined hazards, at any time of the mission trajectory, is configured to translate a hazard into a set of rules to be verified depending on the aircraft.

6. System according to claim 5, wherein the sub-module (VA) for verifying that the rerouting trajectories allow a response to a set of determined hazards is configured to translate a failure hazard by the following rule: - for the flight mission trajectory, it is possible to land within a predefined time frame, possibly using a diversion trajectory.

7. System according to claim 5 or 6, wherein the sub-module (VA) for verifying that the diversion trajectories allow for responding to a set of determined hazards is configured to translate a collision hazard with a listed obstacle by the following rule: - for any trajectory among the flight mission trajectory and the diversion trajectories, the trajectory does not encounter any listed obstacles.

8. System according to any one of claims 5 to 7, wherein the verification submodule (VA) that the diversion trajectories allow to respond to a set of determined hazards is configured to translate a collision hazard with an unlisted obstacle by the following rule: for any trajectory among the flight mission trajectory and the diversion trajectories, it is possible to make a U-turn at any point of the trajectory without encountering a listed obstacle.

9. System according to any one of the preceding claims wherein the aircraft is a drone or an airplane.