METHOD AND DEVICE FOR SELECTING A TYPE OF PIPE FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF A FLUID DISTRIBUTION NETWORK
A software tool optimizes energy and environmental costs in road reconstruction by using Darcy and Colebrook-White formulas and lifecycle assessments to select environmentally friendly pipeline materials, addressing the inefficiencies in existing methods and reducing the environmental and operational costs of soil compaction and pipeline installation.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- FR2016050509
- Authority / Receiving Office
- FR · FR
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2016-01-22
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-01
- Estimated Expiration
- 2036-01-22
AI Technical Summary
Existing methods for soil compaction and pipeline installation in road reconstruction lack comprehensive consideration of energy requirements and environmental impacts, particularly in urban and semi-urban areas, and fail to account for the specific environmental costs associated with pipeline materials and their lifecycle.
A software tool (referred to as '54') calculates and optimizes energy and environmental costs by integrating the Darcy and Colebrook-White formulas for pressure loss calculations, considers the environmental impacts of pipeline materials, and evaluates the lifecycle costs of pipeline materials, including production, recycling, and installation, to select the most environmentally friendly and cost-effective option.
The software tool provides optimized energy and environmental performance by accurately calculating pressure losses and lifecycle impacts, enabling the selection of pipes with reduced environmental footprint and operational costs, thus enhancing the sustainability of road reconstruction projects.
Smart Images

Figure 00000041_0000 
Figure 00000041_0001 
Figure 00000042_0000
Abstract
Description
For scenarios A and C, where compaction takes place, the following data are used: 15 Energy requirement for soil compaction Abbreviation Unit Value Compaction rate rc m3 of earth / h 50 Diesel consumption by the engine Cc liter / h 1 Diesel characteristics - Density - Lower calorific value d LHV kg / L MJ / kg 0.84 43.3 Ce xdx 1HF Enoroio ra wmptictags (MJ) = Fotee compacted (m3) x Road reconstruction depends on the laying environment. Thus: - in rural areas there is no road reconstruction; - in urban areas the road is rebuilt for the entire width of the trenches; - in semi-urban areas, the road is rebuilt to half the width of the trenches. The calculation of the environmental cost of assembling CEA42 pipelines is thus estimated. For most of the pipeline solutions that can be evaluated in the 54 software, the pipelines are locked during assembly, with the possibility of installing a joint. In this case, no additional environmental impact is considered. Welded steel pipelines can be assembled on site. In this case, the 'welding, gas, steel / RER' dataset from ecoinvent v2.2 is used as a basis by the 54 software to estimate the environmental impacts of pipeline assembly. The environmental operating cost CEE is provided by the sum of the environmental operating cost for pumping CEE1, the environmental cost of cathodic protection CEE2, the environmental cost of repairs CEE3 and the environmental cost of fluid losses due to leaks CEE4. Thus, CEE=CEE1+CEE2+CEE3+CEE4. The environmental operating cost for CEE1 pumping takes into account the environmental impacts of producing the electricity consumed for pumping. Electricity production is modeled according to the electricity mix of the study area, defined as a general parameter. Pumping is necessary to cope with the elevation gradient between the two ends of the network and the pressure losses. Head losses are hydraulic energy losses caused mainly by the viscosity of water and its friction against the pipe walls. They result in an increase in energy consumption for pumping. The daily energy requirements for pumping (in kWh / day) are calculated as follows: Or : E: daily pumping energy (kWh / day) d: daily pumping duration (h / day) - user-defined g: gravitational constant (m / s2), with g = 9.81 Q: flow rate (m3 / s) - user defined EG: elevation gradient (m) - user defined j: pressure losses (in m of fluid per m of pipe) L: network length (in m) heff: hydraulic efficiency (default set to 70%) eeff: electricity efficiency (default set to 70%) Pressure losses are calculated using the Darcy and Colebrook-White formulas. The Darcy formula is the general formula for pressure loss calculations: aa O2 Tcz.g,ID5 Or : j: pressure losses (in m of fluid per m of pipe) A: coefficient of pressure losses determined using the Colebrook formula- White ID: inner diameter of the pipe (m) The Colebrook-White formula is used to calculate the pressure loss coefficient: 1 / 2.51 * X loy I + ini -y jl xH e. -yJL 3.71.I DJ Or : Re: Reynolds number (unitless) p: kinematic viscosity of the fluid at operating temperature (m2 / s or St) - the fluid considered here is water and the kinematic viscosity is 1.31x102 m2 / s k: equivalent pipe surface roughness3 (m) 3k is not equal to the height of imperfections of the surface under study; it is a theoretical concept that represents the roughness of surfaces. In the Colebrook-White formula, the first term of the logarithmic function corresponds to the pressure losses due to the internal friction of the liquid acting on itself. The second term corresponds to the pressure losses caused by the friction of the liquid against the pipe wall (k = 0 for an ideally smooth pipe). Default roughness of pipes, if applicable with an internal coating Material Inner lining K, equivalent surface roughness (mm) Ductile iron (all products) Blast furnace cement mortar CHF 0.03 Portland cement mortar 0.03 PUR (polyurethane) 0.005 DUCTAN (ethylene / acrylic copolymer) 0.005 Welded steel Portland cement mortar 0.03 Epoxy 0.005 PE No lining 0.002 PVC No coating 0.005 Bi-oriented PVC No coating 0.005 GRP No coating 0.005 The environmental operating cost for CEE2 cathodic protection (if applicable) takes into account the environmental impacts of generating the electricity consumed for cathodic protection. Only ductile iron and welded steel pipelines may require cathodic protection. Electricity production is modeled according to the electricity mix of the study area. The environmental operating cost for CEE3 repairs takes into account the environmental impacts of replacing pipes in the event of failure. A failure is assumed to have the same environmental impact as the acquisition and dismantling of the pipeline. Thus, software 54 estimates that the environmental impact of replacing the pipeline in the event of failure is: - that of a new pipeline produced, transported, laid; - to which is added the impact of dismantling an old pipeline as well as its disposal in landfill or incineration or recycling. The environmental operating cost due to fluid losses due to CEE4 leaks takes into account the environmental impacts of treating drinking water lost due to recorded leaks. This life cycle stage is modeled using the ecoinvent v2.2 'tap water, at user / RER' dataset for water treatment data, excluding environmental impacts related to the infrastructure that provides water supply. Finally, the environmental cost of recycling CER corresponding to phase 204 of figure 5 is formed from the sum of the environmental cost of dismantling CER1, the environmental cost of end-of-life treatment of the pipes CER2 and the environmental cost, generally consisting of a gain, of recycling the material CER3. So, CER=CER1+CER2+CER3. The environmental cost of recycling by dismantling CER1 is determined as follows. The calculation performed by the 54 software is based on the fact that the pipeline is only dismantled if a new pipeline has to be laid. The impact of removal and dismantling is thus attributed to the newly laid pipeline. The environmental cost of recycling by treating CER2 waste is determined as follows. The user provides the percentage of pipes that are removed and dismantled at the end of their service life, as well as the percentage of pipes that are recycled. Dismantled and non-recycled pipes, usually plastic, are considered to be landfilled or incinerated. Pipes that are not removed and therefore remain underground are considered inert. Therefore, no environmental impact is recorded. End-of-life transportation is not included in Software 54. The environmental cost of recycling by the potential benefit linked to end-of-life recovery CER3 takes into account several CER31 and CER32 benefits detailed below. So, CER3=CER31+CER32. The CER31 potential benefit for a plastic pipe incinerated with energy recovery takes into account incineration with heat recovery and electricity generation. The heat and electricity recovery calculations are based on the lower heating values and are calculated as follows: - 20% of the district heating efficiency, which replaces light fuel oil heating - 10% of the electrical efficiency, modeled with the electrical mix of the area where the product reaches its end of life Advantageously, the following lower calorific values (ecoinvent v2.2) are used: - PE: 42.47 MJ / kg - PVC and bi-oriented PVC: 21.51 MJ / kg - PRV: 31.7 MJ / kg The potential CER32 benefit from recycling materials is taken into account as shown below. Recycling is only considered for ductile iron and welded steel pipes. For both materials, the environmental impact of recycling is - according to EN 15804 - the balance between the potential impacts associated with the recycling process (i.e. production from scrap) and the potential benefit (negative impact) from the fact that the material produced from scrap would avoid the production of material from ores. A recycling efficiency of 100% (ratio between the quantity of waste collected and the quantity of recycled material produced) is assumed. For ductile iron or steel materials containing recycled materials, the potential benefits and impacts are allocated to the pipeline studied. The distribution of the impacts and benefits of recycling is carried out according to the European standard EN 15804 for Environmental Declarations of Construction Products, Annex A. The following formulas are used by the 54 software to calculate the net environmental impacts for materials from both a raw material and a material recovery perspective: NetImpactsRaMfMatgTials = (1 -<) **Es »etImpactsKstgrialBgmsry = R2 » (1 - * (Ek - Er J Or : recycled material content of the pipeline (%) r2: quantity of pipe sent for recycling (%) Ev: environmental impacts linked to production from materials extracted from the natural environment (for example, the production of cast iron from iron ore) Es: environmental impacts linked to production from recycled materials (e.g. from scrap metal) £R: environmental impacts linked to the recycling process (for example the transformation into scrap of part of the welded steel pipes at the end of their life) environmental impacts linked to avoiding the extraction of raw materials from the natural environment through the recycling of certain materials At the end of the calculation of the financial and environmental evaluation functions by the calculator, a choice of pipe is made by the calculator at step 306. The pipe retained from among the different types of pipes evaluated is for example the pipe having obtained the best ranking in the financial evaluation function and / or in the environmental evaluation function 5. In step 308, the installation of the pipes chosen in step 306 is carried out and the network thus formed is operated for a determined period of time before being recycled.
Claims
CLAIMS 1.- Device for selecting a type of pipe comprising specific computer resources suitable for: (a) create (100) a technical and economic database for at least two types of selected pipes; b) enter (102) into a calculator the characteristic data of the project common to all types of pipes and the data specific to each type of pipe; c) calculating (104), for each type of pipe selected, at least one evaluation function (CF, CE) over a predetermined operating period; d) choosing (306) the pipe type based on the comparative results of the evaluation functions for the different pipe types; the types of pipes include at least two types included in the group consisting of: - ductile iron pipes; - welded steel pipes; - polyethylene pipes; - polyvinyl chloride pipes; - bi-oriented polyvinyl chloride pipes; and - fiberglass reinforced plastic pipes. 2.- Selection device according to claim 1, characterized in that at least one evaluation function (CF, CE) comprises: - the cost of acquiring the pipes (CFA; CEA); - the cost of operating the network over a predetermined period of time (CFE; CEE). 3.- Selection device according to claim 2, characterized in that the acquisition cost (CFA) comprises one or more of the costs included in the group consisting of: - the financial cost of acquiring the pipes (CFA1); - the financial cost of financing (CFA2); - the financial product of the subsidy (CFA3); - the financial cost of installation (CFA4). 4.- Selection device according to any one of claims 2 to 3, characterized in that the operating cost (CFE) comprises one or more of the costs included in the group consisting of: - the financial cost of pumping (CFE1); - the financial cost of repair (CFE2); - the financial cost of maintenance (CFE3); - the financial cost of fluid losses due to leaks (CFE4). 5.- Selection device according to claim 2, characterized in that said at least one evaluation function comprises: - the cost of recycling pipes (CFR, CER). 6.- Selection device according to claim 5, characterized in that the recycling cost (CFR) comprises one or more of the costs included in the group consisting of: - the financial cost of dismantling (CFR1); - the financial product from recycling (CFR2). 7Selection device according to any one of claims 2 to 6, characterized in that the acquisition cost (CEA) comprises one or more of the costs included in the group consisting of: - the environmental cost of raw materials (CEA1); - the environmental cost of manufacturing pipes (CEA2); - the environmental cost of transporting pipes (CEA3); and - the environmental cost of laying the pipes (CEA4). 8.- Selection device according to any one of claims 2 to 7, characterized in that the operating cost (CEE) comprises one or more of the costs included in the group consisting of: - the environmental cost of pumping (CEE1); - the environmental cost of cathodic protection (CEE2); - the environmental cost of repair (CEE3); and - the environmental cost of fluid losses due to leaks (CEE4). 9.- Selection device according to claim 4 or 8, characterized in that the financial cost of fluid losses due to leaks (CFE4) and the environmental cost of fluid losses due to leaks (CEE4) is calculated from the quantity of fluid 5.1¾ lost per 1m3 of fluid for year N, this quantity of fluid lost being calculated as follows: Or : ; :S5,;„ is the forecast index of annual increase in water losses WLfinai are the water losses at the end of the service life in m3 / year Final is the expected service life, expressed in years N is the age of the pipeline And : = L * * 365..25 Or : l is the length of the network, in km is the linear water loss index at the end of the forecast service life. 10.- Selection device according to claim 5 or 6, characterized in that the recycling cost (CER) comprises one or more of the costs included in the group consisting of: - the environmental cost of dismantling (CER1); - the environmental cost of treatment (CER2); and - the environmental product of recycling (CER3). 11.- Selection device according to any one of the preceding claims, characterized in that said predetermined operating duration is between 75 and 125 years. 12.- Selection device according to any one of the preceding claims, characterized in that the characteristic data of the project comprise one or more of the data included in the group consisting of: - the geographical location of the network; - the installation location; - the length of the network; - the network operating pressure; - the type of distribution; and - the nominal diameter of the pipes. 13.- Method of installing a fluid distribution network comprising: a) a phase of selecting a type of pipe for the creation of a fluid distribution network comprising the steps of: a*) create (100) a technical and economic database for at least two types of selected pipes; b*) enter (102) into a calculator the characteristic data of the project common to all types of pipes and the data specific to each type of pipe; c*) calculating (104), for each type of pipe selected, at least one evaluation function (CF, CE) over a predetermined operating period; d*) choosing (306) the type of pipe based on the comparative results of the evaluation functions for the different types of pipes; b) a phase of laying pipes of the type selected to create the distribution network; the types of pipes include at least two types included in the group consisting of: - ductile iron pipes; - welded steel pipes; - polyethylene pipes; - polyvinyl chloride pipes; - bi-oriented polyvinyl chloride pipes; and - fiberglass reinforced plastic pipes.
