Process planning support system
The process planning support system optimizes work processes in radioactive environments by using 3D modeling and real-time data to adjust work speeds and priorities, addressing inefficiencies and safety concerns in waste removal operations.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2023072495
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-04-26
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-08
- Estimated Expiration
- Not applicable · inactive patent
AI Technical Summary
Existing process planning systems fail to adequately account for the unique challenges of working in environments contaminated with radioactive materials, such as high radioactivity concentrations and low subcriticality, leading to inefficiencies and safety concerns during waste removal operations.
A process planning support system that utilizes a 3D model of the contaminated environment, incorporates real-time data, and performs safety simulations to optimize work processes, ensuring safety constraints are met by adjusting work speeds and priorities based on changing radioactivity levels.
Enables safe and efficient planning of work processes in radioactive environments by addressing the challenges of high radioactivity and low subcriticality, reducing waiting times and ensuring compliance with safety thresholds.
Smart Images

Figure 2024157871000001_ABST
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present invention relates to a process planning support system that supports planning of work processes in an environment contaminated by radioactive materials. [Background technology]
[0002] As background technology in this technical field, Patent Document 1 describes a process planning support system and a process planning method that aim to improve the accuracy of demolition work periods for generating robot work sequences, support recovery from process delays, and determine the feasibility of possible demolition processes from a large search space, and states that "a process planning support method is used to plan a process for a robot to perform work in a work area using a computer, the computer generates and visualizes process information by determining work operation elements by stochastic optimization of the robot's movement path, posture, and procedure sequence that satisfy the work period deadline, dose restrictions, and work safety regulations for each work area within a virtual space consisting of a 3D measurement point cloud and on-site dose information for the work area where the on-site condition changes as the robot works, and within a search range that can be calculated within a set time range." [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0003] [Patent Document 1] Patent Publication No. 2022-55632 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0004] Patent Document 1 proposes creating a work plan using a robot, but does not fully consider the possibility of creating a plan for a work process when the work is performed in an environment contaminated by radioactive materials.
[0005] In contrast, for example, when planning a work process for removing radioactive waste, it is necessary to reproduce situations such as the time it takes to remove contaminated areas due to radioactive materials with high radioactivity concentrations, and the need to support the creation of a plan that is safe and highly efficient by reproducing the situation of waiting for the movement of a storage canister containing debris due to low criticality. Such a process planning support system is required to "plan a work plan with high work throughput while ensuring safety constraints based on spatial information that changes from time to time."
[0006] In view of the above, an object of the present invention is to provide a process planning support system suitable for planning work in an environment contaminated by radioactive materials. [Means for solving the problem]
[0007] In view of the above, the present invention provides a process planning support system for supporting the planning of work processes for treating work objects in an environment contaminated by radioactive materials, the process planning support system comprising: an input unit for inputting various data measured in the environment contaminated by radioactive materials; a three-dimensional model that represents the environment contaminated by radioactive materials in three dimensions; a general process simulation unit that gives work processes and work speeds in the environment contaminated by radioactive materials; a priority determination unit that sets calculation priorities for subspaces of the environment contaminated by radioactive materials in the three-dimensional model that represents the three-dimensional representation; a measurement value allocation unit that allocates calculated values and measurement values to work objects in the environment contaminated by radioactive materials and parts that process the work objects in the three-dimensional model that represents the three-dimensional representation; and a physical VR simulation unit that calculates a safety index that indicates the safety of the environment contaminated by radioactive materials when a work process for treating a work object is performed in the three-dimensional model, and is characterized in that the process planning support system calculates a work process and work speed at which the safety index is equal to or less than a threshold value. Effect of the Invention
[0008] According to the present invention, a process planning support system suitable for planning work in an environment contaminated by radioactive materials can be provided. More specifically, according to the embodiment of the present invention, it is possible to contribute to supporting the generation of a plan that is safe and has high work efficiency by reproducing a situation in which it takes a long time to remove a portion contaminated by radioactive materials with a high radioactivity concentration, or a situation in which a storage canister containing debris needs to be moved due to low subcriticality. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0009] [Figure 1] FIG. 1 is a diagram showing an example of the configuration of a process plan support system according to a first embodiment of the present invention. [Diagram 2] FIG. 1 shows an example of a demolition site 30 for removing radioactive waste as an environment contaminated by radioactive materials. [Figure 3a] FIG. 2 is a diagram showing an example of a representation of a 3D model M with radioactive attributes that is to be updated by the model update device 5. [Figure 3b] A diagram showing an example of the configuration of an environmental 3D model M with radioactive attributes. [Figure 4] FIG. 2 is a diagram showing an example of a sequence of a target outline process simulation. [Diagram 5] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing an example of subcriticality management. [Figure 6] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing an example of the relationship between the amount of dust generated and the site boundary amount rate. [Figure 7] FIG. 11 is a diagram showing an example of a process flow for adjusting a work speed based on a safety index. [Figure 8] A diagram showing an example of the created planned process and the visualization of the physical VR simulation. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0010] Hereinafter, embodiments of the present invention will be described with reference to the drawings. EXAMPLES
[0011] In the embodiment of the present invention, a process planning support system for supporting the planning of work processes in a radioactively contaminated environment will be described.
[0012] 2 shows an example of a demolition site 30 for removing radioactive waste from a radioactively contaminated environment. In this case, a demolition robot R1 for dismantling an object to be demolition 31, a transport robot R2 for transporting the dismantled cut pieces 35, a storage robot R3 for storing the transported cut pieces 35, and the like are introduced to the demolition site 30 in a radioactively contaminated environment, and in many cases, work is performed in an unmanned environment.
[0013] The object 31 to be dismantled is radioactively contaminated, and there are some locations 33a, 33b, and 33c with high radioactivity concentrations and surface dose rates depending on the location. These values also change as the dismantling progresses.
[0014] 2 in a radioactive contaminated environment, the process planning support system uses a virtual space 3D model of the dismantling object to create a process plan for the procedure for proceeding with the dismantling of the dismantling object 31. Therefore, in the virtual space 3D model, it is necessary to simulate the dismantling object 31 and various robots R, as well as the time-series changes in the radioactivity concentration and surface dose rate as a radioactive environment, and reflect these in the process plan.
[0015] 1 shows an example of the configuration of a process plan support system according to a first embodiment of the present invention. The process plan support system 10 configured using a computer is configured with a storage unit DB, an input unit, a calculation unit CPU, an input device 1, and an output device 2 as main components. Note that some of these components may be connected and configured on the cloud via a network.
[0016] The memory unit DB is made up of a drawing database DB1 that stores drawing data D1 of the demolition site 30, a measurement point cloud and radiation database DB2 that stores the measurement point cloud and radiation data D2 of the demolition site 30, and a 3D model database DB3 that stores the radiation attributed environmental 3D model M. Various measurement data DS of the demolition site is taken in from the input unit, and this is stored in the measurement point cloud and radiation database DB2 as the measurement point cloud and radiation data D2, and is also used for processing in the calculation unit CPU.
[0017] If we functionally express the processing contents in the CPU of the computer, it can be said that it is roughly equipped with a process simulation device 4, a model update device 5, a calculation value, measurement data allocation device 6, a subspace calculation priority determination device 7, a physical VR simulation device 8, and a safety index reference work speed adjustment device 9.
[0018] These functions generally function as follows: First, the general process simulation device 4 executes a general process simulation to calculate the operation time of each individual process. Here, an individual process is an appropriately set unit process such as a process for removing cut pieces or a process for transporting cut pieces, and the standard processing time for each of these processes is estimated by the general process simulation.
[0019] Next, the model update device 5 uses the estimated results of the work times of the individual processes to carry out update processing of various settings of the radioactive attribute-attached environmental 3D model M based on theoretical values and measured value data. This is to optimize various settings such as the operating characteristics of the radioactive attribute-attached environmental 3D model M based on the results of validity evaluation using, for example, estimated values, theoretical values, and measured values.
[0020] A calculation value / measurement data allocation device 6 allocates calculation values and measurement values such as dose rate to each part of the radioactivity attribute-attached environmental 3D model M (for example, each part of the object to be dismantled 31 and each part of various robots R). A subspace calculation priority determination device 7 determines the subspace calculation priority in descending order of radioactivity and maximum dose rate.
[0021] The physical VR simulation device 8 performs a physical VR simulation of various robots R and the like operating in the radioactive environment 3D model M, and calculates safety indicators such as the degree of subcriticality and site boundary dose rate that change as the work progresses.
[0022] If all the safety index values are below the thresholds as a result of the safety index calculation, the safety index reference work speed adjustment device 9 outputs the adjusted process sequence with the speed together with the process data. If any of the safety index values is above the threshold, the speed adjustment of the safety index reference work is performed, the model state is returned to the state before the calculation, and the calculation is repeated until all the safety index values are below the thresholds.
[0023] FIG. 3a is a diagram showing an example of a representation of a 3D model M with radioactive attributes that is an update target by the model update device 5. Here, the 3D model M with radioactive attributes shows an example in which a dismantling target 31 is simulated as three-dimensional information by orthogonal XYZ axes. Specifically, in order to indicate an approximate space (area) in the 3D model, it is expressed by a coordinate range expressed by each XYZ axis by information 3301, 3302, 3303 called a center line. For example, coordinates 3, 2, 2 indicate an area of (X3 to X4, Y2 to Y3, Z2 to Z3). It goes without saying that parts other than the dismantling target 31 are also simulated as three-dimensional information in the same way.
[0024] Fig. 3b is a diagram showing an example of the configuration of the radiation-attribute-attached environmental 3D model M. Here, the radiation-attribute-attached environmental 3D model M from the radiation-attribute-attached environmental 3D model database DB3 is characterized, particularly the dismantling object 31, by its number (No.), coordinates, radioactivity concentration [Bq / cm3], maximum surface dose rate [Gy / h], and area [cm2] as shown in table TB. Note that information about parts other than the dismantling object 31 is also stored as tabular information.
[0025] 4 is a diagram showing an example of the sequence of the outline process simulation to be performed. This sequence example is composed of multiple processes Pr, including a debris crushing process Pr1, a cut piece removal process Pr2, and a storage canister movement process Pr3. The cut pieces 35 and the storage canister (storage robot R3) are treated as containers for storing the material quantities as the output of each process.
[0026] The execution time of each process Pr varies depending on the changes in the crushing speed, crushing size 431, removal speed 432, and movement speed 433. In addition, if the cut pieces 35 and storage can (storage robot R3) cannot be processed smoothly, a waiting state will occur, so the set speed must be adjusted manually or automatically (441, 442).
[0027] Fig. 5 is a diagram showing an example of subcriticality management, which is treated as one of the safety indicators. In this diagram, the horizontal axis indicates time and the vertical axis indicates the number of neutrons, and the diagram shows the trend of time change in the number of neutrons in each state of a subcritical state 913, a critical state 912, and a supercritical state 911.
[0028] For example, let us consider a situation in which the fuel debris is dismantled and the cut pieces 35 extracted from the state represented by the environmental 3D model M in Fig. 2 are packed into a storage canister (storage robot R3). At this time, the cut pieces 35 contain nuclear fuel material, and neutrons generated when nuclear fission occurs can be detected. Until the number of neutrons generated at this time increases over time, this can be treated as a subcritical state 913, so there is no safety problem.
[0029] On the other hand, the critical state 912 where the change in the number of neutrons exceeds 1 and the over-critical state 911 are not safe, so to prevent such states, it is necessary to adjust the way in which the cut pieces 35 are packed into the storage canister (storage robot R3). In this case, since it is necessary to increase the number of storage canisters (storage robots R3), the cut piece removal speed 432 becomes slower and the work process becomes longer.
[0030] Figure 6 is a diagram showing an example of the relationship between the amount of generated dust, which is treated as another safety index, and the site boundary dose rate. In this figure, the horizontal axis shows time and the vertical axis shows the dose rate. Dust is generated by the debris crushing process Pr1 in Figure 4. The surrounding dose rate and the dose rate at the site boundary increase due to the diffusion of radioactive materials contained in this dust into space. As the amount of dust increases, the dose rate tends to increase, but due to changes in the shape of the dust particles, the dose rate is calculated in the range from curve 922 to curve 921 in Figure 6. At this time, if the site boundary dose rate is not to exceed a threshold value, for example 500 μSv / h, it is necessary to reduce the amount of dust generated by taking measures such as suppressing the crushing speed.
[0031] Figure 7 is a diagram showing an example of the process flow of work speed adjustment based on safety indexes. This shows a general flow of the process of the device shown in Figure 1. This process is used in situations where a new work process plan is made, or where a plan has already been made and on-site work is being carried out according to the plan, but an unexpected problem occurs and the plan is re-planned from this stage in accordance with the current situation as a measure against the problem.
[0032] The present invention can be applied to either of these cases, and in the former case, the process starts from step S11, and in the latter case, the process starts from step S12. Note that the following explanation will be given using the former case as an example, but this is only different in the starting conditions, and there is no significant difference in the sense that the actual process starts from step S13.
[0033] In the initial process when planning a new work process, first in process step S11, the work speed of each process is set by the general process simulation device 4. The speeds set at this time may be based on actual values or theoretical values. This is because the initial values of the work speed of each process are merely set here, and the model is appropriately corrected according to each speed experienced to reflect the progress of the process thereafter.
[0034] Then, in processing step S12, the calculation priority of the subspaces is determined in the order of, for example, the highest radioactivity and the highest maximum dose rate as shown in Fig. 3. As a result, for the dismantling target 31 in Fig. 1, the calculation order of the regions (subspaces) 33a, 33b, and 33c with high radioactivity concentration and surface dose rate is set to a high priority, and the situation is grasped with priority.
[0035] In processing step S14, calculated values and measured values such as dose rate are assigned to each part of the model (for example, each part of the object to be dismantled 31 and each part of each robot R). In processing step S15, a physical VR simulation is performed to show that each robot R and the like are operating in the environmental 3D model M as shown in Fig. 2, and safety indexes such as the changing subcriticality in Fig. 5 and the site boundary dose rate in Fig. 6 are calculated.
[0036] The calculation result is judged in process step S17, and if all safety index values are below the threshold value (true in process step S17), the adjusted process sequence with speed is output together with the process data in process step S19. If any of the safety index values are above the threshold value (false in process step S17), the speed of the safety index reference work is adjusted in process step S18, the model state is returned to the state before the calculation, and the calculations from process steps S13 to S17 are repeated until all safety index values are below the threshold value.
[0037] The specific processing contents in processing step S18 are to slow down the work speed, adjust the distance, adjust the time spent on site, and replace dismantled equipment within the standards of the safety index.
[0038] In step S16, the 3D model of the environment with radioactive attributes is updated sequentially at appropriate timing based on the measurement point cloud, the measured dose rate data, and the radiation data estimated from the dose rate, according to the result of the physical VR simulation in step S15. Note that the initial model is created based on the drawing data D1, and is updated based on the measurement point cloud, the radiation data D2, and other measurement data DS.
[0039] FIG. 8 shows an example of the visualization of the created planned process and the physical VR simulation. Here, an example of a display consisting of a plurality of display components is shown as an example 20 of the display screen of the display device 2. In this display, an example of a sequence 21 of the outline process simulation shown in FIG. 4, an example 22 of the demolition site 30 shown in FIG. 2, a progress status 23 of each process of crushing the demolition object 31, removing the cut pieces, and moving the cut pieces, a criticality characteristic 24 as a safety index shown in FIG. 5, and a site boundary dose rate 25 shown in FIG. 6 are displayed. In addition, the screen has selection buttons B1, B2, B3, and B4 for selecting each mode of process, update, physical VR, and sequence output. In addition to these, it is preferable that the display can display safety-related indexes such as the amount of dust generated that affects the surrounding dose rate, the margin of exposure limit for workers on site, and the concentration of other contaminated radioactive materials.
[0040] Then, in accordance with a predetermined process sequence, in sequence example 21 of the outline process simulation, the debris crushing speed 431, the cut piece removal speed 432, and the storage canister movement speed 433 are set manually or automatically, and the outline process simulation is performed by pressing the process simulation start button B1.
[0041] Also, by importing the calculated values and measured values and pressing the model update button B2, the work time calculated in the outline process simulation is reflected, and the state of the physical VR simulation is displayed in 3D after pressing the physical VR simulation button B3, as in the example 22 of the demolition site 30. At that time, the work time and timing of each process are also displayed in the process data 23.
[0042] If any of the safety evaluation index values do not satisfy the set state, they are displayed as the criticality characteristic 24, the site boundary dose rate 25, or warning information, and the related work speeds 431, 432, and 433 are changed manually or automatically, and the calculations are repeated again. When all the safety evaluation indexes are below the thresholds, the sequence output button B4 can be pressed, and by pressing this button, process data with work priority order and work time can be output.
[0043] As described above, the process planning support system of this embodiment can contribute to supporting the creation of plans that are safe and have high work efficiency by reproducing situations such as when it takes a long time to remove highly radioactive materials or when a storage canister containing debris must be moved due to low subcriticality. [Explanation of symbols]
[0044] 1: Input device 2:Display device 4: Process simulation equipment overview 5: Model update device 6: Calculation and measurement data allocation device 7: Subspace calculation priority determination device 8: Physical VR simulation device 9: Safety index standard work speed adjustment device DB1: Drawing data database DB2: Measurement point cloud, radioactivity data database DB3: Environmental 3D model database with radiation attributes DS: Measurement data
Claims
1. A process planning support system for supporting planning of a work process for treating a work object in a radioactive contaminated environment, comprising: the system comprises an input unit for inputting various data measured in a radioactively contaminated environment, a three-dimensional model that represents the radioactively contaminated environment in three dimensions, an outline process simulation unit that gives work processes and work speeds in the radioactively contaminated environment, a priority determination unit that sets priorities of calculations for subspaces of the radioactively contaminated environment in the three-dimensional model that represents the three-dimensional environment, a calculated value / measured value allocation unit that assigns calculated values and measured values to work objects in the radioactively contaminated environment and parts that process the work objects in the three-dimensional model that represents the three-dimensional environment, and a physical VR simulation unit that calculates a safety index that indicates the safety of the radioactively contaminated environment when a work process that processes the work objects is performed in the three-dimensional model, A process planning support system that determines the work process and the work speed that will cause the safety index to be equal to or lower than a threshold value.
2. 2. The process planning support system according to claim 1, The process planning support system is characterized in that the priority determination unit determines the priority of calculations for a subspace of the radioactively contaminated environment of the three-dimensional model represented in three dimensions, based on the magnitude of the spatial dose rate in the radioactively contaminated environment and the magnitude of radioactivity data for preventing criticality.
3. 2. The process planning support system according to claim 1, When the safety index is equal to or greater than a threshold value, the process planning support system adjusts the work speed, updates the model, changes the simulation priority, and adjusts the work speed again from a physical VR simulation unit, thereby outputting an adjusted process sequence.
4. 2. The process planning support system according to claim 1, A process planning support system comprising a model update unit that incorporates changes in the radioactively contaminated environment and updates the three-dimensional model using measured radiation dose rates, dust measurement results, and 3D measurement point clouds in the radioactively contaminated environment.
5. 2. The process planning support system according to claim 1, The process planning support system, wherein the safety index is any one of subcriticality, site boundary dose rate, dust generation amount, worker exposure limit, and contaminant radioactivity concentration.
6. 2. The process planning support system according to claim 1, The processing of the work object in the radioactive contaminated environment includes storing cut pieces of the work object in a storage canister; The display device is a process planning support system that visualizes and displays situations in which the debris removal work becomes rate-limiting because the storage canister cannot be filled with more cut pieces than its storage limit, situations in which work must be temporarily stopped and the storage canister moved because the amount of dust generated and the site boundary dose rate are reaching their limits, and situations in which work must be carried out with fewer workers because some workers are close to their radiation exposure limits.
7. 2. The process planning support system according to claim 1, The processing of the work object in the radioactive contaminated environment includes storing cut pieces of the work object in a storage canister; A process planning support system characterized by having a display device that executes simultaneous parallel work at multiple locations based on an adjusted process sequence in a VR simulation unit and visualizes the changes in various safety indexes while linking them.
8. 2. The process planning support system according to claim 1, A process planning support system that adjusts parameters and sequences through process simulation, calculates the expected dust amount and dose rate, calculates the number of fission neutrons generated by storing cut pieces in a storage canister, and determines the priority of work subspaces with combinations that maintain the site boundary dose rate upper limit and subcriticality.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Process plan creation support system and process plan creation method
JP2022055632A
