Risk evaluation method

The risk assessment method systematically evaluates chemical substance risks during building demolition by determining handling, scattering, and exposure levels, ensuring safer demolition practices and cost efficiency.

JP2024158936AActive Publication Date: 2024-11-08KAJIMA CORP
View PDF 6 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2023074579
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2023-04-28
Publication Date
2024-11-08
Estimated Expiration
2043-04-28

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing methods for assessing risks posed by chemical substances during the demolition of buildings equipped with equipment handling such substances are not systematic and do not adequately evaluate the potential hazards, leading to potential health risks for demolition workers.

Method used

A risk assessment method that evaluates the risk levels of chemical substances by determining handling amounts, scattering levels, exposure levels, and risk levels based on the amount of chemical substances handled and their expected scattering during demolition, using flowcharts and tables to classify these levels into various categories.

Benefits of technology

This method allows for a systematic and appropriate evaluation of risks, enabling safer demolition practices by selecting appropriate work styles and reducing excessive equipment and costs.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 2024158936000001_ABST
    Figure 2024158936000001_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

To provide a risk evaluation method which can properly evaluate risk resulting from chemical materials produced upon demolition of a facility and a building.SOLUTION: A risk evaluation method includes: a handling amount level determination process of determining a handling amount level responding to a handling amount of chemical materials handled by a facility upon its operation or a handling amount level responding to a handling amount of chemical materials handled upon demolition; a dispersion level determination process of determining a dispersion level responding to a degree of dispersion of chemical materials predicted upon demolition; an exposure level determination process of determining an exposure level responding to a degree in which a demolition operator is exposed to the chemical materials based on the handling amount level and the dispersion level; and a risk level determination process of determining a risk level responding to a risk of chemical materials based on the exposure level and an exposure limit value of chemical materials affecting health of the demolition operator. Thus, the risk level for each of a facility and a building to be demolished is determined.SELECTED DRAWING: Figure 2
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[Technical field]

[0001] The present invention relates to a method for risk assessment. [Background technology]

[0002] Patent Document 1 discloses a manufacturing device for manufacturing highly pharmacologically active pharmaceutical ingredients. Patent Document 1 also discloses that, because highly pharmacologically active pharmaceutical ingredients may affect the health of workers, the work is carried out in a physically enclosed containment device such as an isolator as a measure to prevent the dispersion of pharmaceutical powder (containment of pharmaceutical powder). [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]

[0003] [Patent Document 1] JP 2015-194382 A Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]

[0004] When demolishing a building that contains equipment that handles chemical substances that may have an effect on the human body, such as that described in Patent Document 1, it is necessary to consider the possibility that chemical substances may remain or be attached not only to the equipment itself but also to the piping, ceiling, walls, etc. connected to the equipment's isolator.

[0005] The risks posed by chemicals when demolishing such buildings are considered on a case-by-case basis, but this has not been systematically considered, and it is difficult to say that the risks have been appropriately evaluated.

[0006] An object of the present invention is to provide a risk assessment method capable of appropriately assessing the risks posed by chemical substances when demolishing a building equipped with facilities that handle chemical substances. [Means for solving the problem]

[0007] The present invention is a risk assessment method for evaluating risks posed by chemical substances when demolishing equipment that handles chemical substances and a building in which the equipment is installed, and includes a handling amount level determination step for determining a handling amount level corresponding to the handling amount of the chemical substance handled by the equipment when the equipment was in operation, or a handling amount level corresponding to the handling amount of the chemical substance to be handled during demolition; a dispersion level determination step for determining a dispersion level corresponding to the degree of dispersion of the chemical substance predicted during demolition; an exposure level determination step for determining an exposure level corresponding to the degree of exposure of demolition workers to the chemical substance based on the handling amount level and the dispersion level; and a risk level determination step for determining a risk level corresponding to the risk of the chemical substance based on the exposure level and the exposure limit value of the chemical substance that affects the health of the demolition workers, and thus determines a risk level for each of the equipment and building to be demolished. Effect of the Invention

[0008] According to the present invention, the risks posed by chemical substances when demolishing a building that contains facilities that handle chemical substances can be appropriately evaluated, and an appropriate work form can be selected. [Brief description of the drawings]

[0009] [Figure 1] 1 is a floor plan of a building in which a facility for handling chemical substances according to an embodiment of the present invention is provided. [Diagram 2] 1 is a flowchart showing a flow for determining a risk level of equipment according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Diagram 3] 1 is a table showing the scattering levels of equipment according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 4] 1 is a table for determining exposure levels for equipment according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Diagram 5] 1 is a table for determining a risk level of equipment according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 6] 1 is a table showing a list of equipment required for dismantling work according to risk levels according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 7]1 is a flowchart showing a flow for determining a risk level of a building according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 8] 1 is a table showing the scattering levels of a building according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 9] 1 is a table for determining exposure levels for a building according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 10] 1 is a table for determining a risk level of a building according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 11] 1 is a table for determining a ventilation level according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 12] 1 is a table for determining an adjusted risk level for a building according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 13] FIG. 2 is a diagram showing an example of a ventilation duct connected to equipment according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 14] FIG. 2 is a diagram showing an example of a ventilation duct connected to an air conditioning system of a building according to an embodiment of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

[0010] Hereinafter, an embodiment of the present invention will be described with reference to the drawings.

[0011] The present invention relates to a risk assessment method for assessing risks posed by chemical substances when demolishing a building 1 in which facilities 90 that handle chemical substances are installed.

[0012] First, an example of a research and production facility for highly pharmacologically active pharmaceutical ingredients will be briefly described with reference to Figure 1. Figure 1 shows a floor plan of a building 1 in which equipment 90 for handling chemical substances is installed.

[0013] As shown in Figure 1, within building 1 there are provided a management room 10, a changing room 20, an entrance side shower room 30A, an exit side shower room 30B, a anteroom 40, a shower room 50, an adjustment room 60A, an adjustment room 60B, a storage room 70, and a machine room 80.

[0014] The control room 10 is a space where workers perform clerical work, etc. An air conditioning device (not shown) is provided on the ceiling of the control room 10.

[0015] The changing room 20 is a space for workers to put on and take off clean wear. The workers put on clean wear in the changing room 20 when working in the anteroom 40, the adjustment room 60A, or the adjustment room 60B.

[0016] The entrance shower cubicle 30A is provided with an air shower device (not shown) for removing dust particles and microorganisms attached to clothing. When a worker enters the anteroom 40 from the changing room 20, he or she enters the entrance shower cubicle 30A, and the air shower device removes dust particles and microorganisms attached to the clothing before entering the anteroom 40. This prevents dust particles and microorganisms from being brought into the anteroom 40 and the adjustment rooms 60A and 60B.

[0017] The exit side shower room 30B is provided with an air shower device for removing fine particles of highly pharmacologically active drugs and the like that are attached to clothing when moving from the anteroom 40 to the changing room 20. When a worker leaves the anteroom 40 to the changing room 20, the worker enters the exit side shower room 30B, and after removing fine particles of highly pharmacologically active drugs and the like that are attached to clothing with the air shower device, the worker leaves the changing room 20. This makes it possible to prevent fine particles of highly pharmacologically active drugs and the like from being carried out to the outside from the anteroom 40 and the adjustment rooms 60A, 60B.

[0018] The anteroom 40 functions as a buffer space between the control room 10 and the preparation rooms 60A, 60B. The presence of the anteroom 40 makes it possible to prevent the highly pharmacologically active drug from leaking from the preparation rooms 60A, 60B to the outside of the control room 10, etc., in the event that the highly pharmacologically active drug leaks from the preparation rooms 60A, 60B for some reason. The anteroom 40 is connected to a storage room 70 in which raw materials and the like are stored.

[0019] The adjustment rooms 60A and 60B are provided with equipment 90 for producing highly pharmacologically active drugs or for conducting research on highly pharmacologically active drugs. The equipment 90 includes a grinder, a weighing and dispensing machine, etc. These pieces of equipment 90 are equipped with a negative pressure booth, a glove box, etc. depending on the situation in which highly pharmacologically active drugs are handled.

[0020] A shower room 50 is provided between the anteroom 40 and the adjustment rooms 60A, 60B. A water shower device is provided in the shower room 50. In the event of an emergency (exposure to radiation), the worker uses the water shower device to wet out any fine particles of highly pharmacologically active drugs adhering to their clothing, removes their outermost clothing, and retreats to the anteroom 40.

[0021] In the machine room 80, there are arranged power supply equipment for driving the equipment 90 and the air conditioner, a drive source for the air conditioner, a filter device, and the like.

[0022] In research and production facilities configured in this way, chemical substances such as highly pharmacologically active pharmaceutical ingredients that have strong medicinal effects on the human body in small amounts, such as anticancer drugs, may be used or produced. When dismantling a research or production facility that handles such chemical substances, the chemical substances may scatter, causing health damage to the dismantling workers. For this reason, it is necessary to determine in advance the equipment and work guidelines to be used during dismantling work, depending on the risks posed by the chemical substances used or produced in the research or production facility.

[0023] Furthermore, if the risk of chemical substances is not evaluated appropriately, there is a risk that the equipment and work required for dismantling will be excessive. Therefore, in this embodiment, in order to appropriately evaluate the risk of chemical substances, a risk level is determined based on the flowcharts of Figs. 2 and 7. Note that the risk level in this embodiment is an index indicating the degree (risk) of an impact on the health of dismantling workers. Below, the procedure for determining the risk level will be specifically described with reference to Figs. 2 and 7.

[0024] First, a method for determining the risk level Lrm regarding the facility 90 to be dismantled will be described with reference to the flowchart shown in FIG.

[0025] In step S1, the target chemical substance is identified. Specifically, information on the chemical substance used in the facility 90 to be dismantled is obtained. The method of obtaining information on the chemical substance is, for example, to identify the target chemical substance by referring to a data sheet obtained from the operator of the production facility or research institute. Note that the chemical substance referred to here includes not only highly pharmacologically active drugs but also all chemical substances that were used in the facility 90 and may have an effect on the human body. Furthermore, the facility 90 is not limited to production equipment and research equipment that use or produce chemical substances, but also includes ancillary equipment such as ventilation ducts 91 (see FIG. 13) connected to these.

[0026] In step S2, the handling amount level Lvm is determined. Specifically, the handling amount of the chemical substance handled when dismantling the equipment 90 is estimated, and the handling amount level Lvm according to this handling amount is determined. The handling amount here corresponds to the remaining amount of the chemical substance remaining in the equipment 90 to be dismantled. For example, a case will be described in which the equipment 90 is a ventilation duct 91 (see FIG. 13) of an air conditioner attached to a pharmaceutical preparation device 90A. First, a part of the ventilation duct 91 is determined as a sample area, and the amount of the target chemical substance remaining in this sample area is measured. Then, based on the measured remaining amount of the chemical substance and the size of the sample area (length, surface area, volume, etc.), the remaining amount of the chemical substance in the entire ventilation duct 91 to be dismantled is estimated. In this embodiment, the handling amount level Lvm is divided into three levels according to the handling amount, for example, small (less than 1 kg), medium (1 kg or more to less than 1 t), and large (1 t or more). Note that the process in this step S2 corresponds to the "handling amount level determination process" in the claims.

[0027] In addition, it is preferable to set the sample area so as to include a location where a large amount of chemicals is expected to remain, such as the vicinity of the drug preparation device 90A or the bent portion 91A of the ventilation duct 91. By including such a location where a large amount of chemicals is expected to remain in the sample area, it is possible to prevent the remaining amount of chemicals in the entire dismantling target, that is, the amount of chemicals handled during dismantling, from being underestimated. If the above-mentioned location is included in the sample area, there is a high possibility that the estimated remaining amount of chemicals will be greater than the actual remaining amount. However, estimating the risk level assuming a large remaining amount will act in a safer direction for the dismantling worker. Therefore, the sample area is set so as to include a location where a large amount of chemicals is expected to remain. This makes it possible to more reliably ensure the safety of the dismantling worker.

[0028] In step S3, the scattering level Lfm is determined. The scattering level is an index indicating the degree of scattering of chemical substances predicted at the time of dismantling, and in this embodiment, as shown in FIG. 3, the scattering level Lfm is divided into three levels, low, medium, and high. Specifically, the equipment 90 to be dismantled is divided into one of the three scattering levels Lfm, low, medium, and high, based on the size (shape) of the particles of the chemical substances in the sample area and the degree of adhesion of the chemical substances. In the example shown in FIG. 3, the degree of adhesion of the chemical substances is divided into two cases, a case where the chemical substances are unlikely to adhere to a wall surface and scatter, and a case where the chemical substances are not adhered to a wall surface and scatter, but it may be divided more finely.

[0029] The dispersion level Lfm is classified by visual inspection and tactile examination by the worker. For example, if tactile examination reveals that the chemical substance is attached to a wall surface and will not come off, the possibility of the chemical substance dispersing is low. For this reason, even if the size (shape) of the chemical substance particles determined by visual inspection is equivalent to "medium" or "small," the dispersion level Lfm is classified as "low" (see FIG. 3). Note that the process in step S3 corresponds to the "dispersal level determination process" in the claims.

[0030] The classification of the dispersion level Lfm is not limited to the visual inspection of the worker, but may be based on the average particle size of the chemical substance, for example, measured as the average particle size defined by "arithmetic mean value of particle diameter" in JIS Z 8901 (2006) "Test powder and test granules". The degree of adhesion is also not limited to the palpation of the worker, but may be determined based on a known adhesion test.

[0031] In step S4, an exposure level Lem is determined. The exposure level is an index showing the degree to which the demolition workers are exposed to the chemical substances. In this embodiment, as shown in FIG. 4, the exposure level Lem is divided into four levels, Lem1 to Lem4. Specifically, the equipment 90 to be dismantled is divided into one of the exposure levels Lem1 to Lem4 based on the amount (remaining amount) of the chemical substances handled estimated in step S2 and the dispersion level Lfm determined in step S3. The exposure levels Lem are Lem1, Lem2, Lem3, and Lem4 in order from the lowest exposure level. The process in step S4 corresponds to the "exposure level determination process" in the claims.

[0032] In step S5, a risk level Lrm is determined according to the risk of the chemical substance during the dismantling work of the facility 90. As shown in FIG. 5, in this embodiment, the risk level Lrm is divided into four levels, Lrm1 to Lrm4. The risk level Lrm is determined based on the exposure level Lem determined in step S4 and the exposure limit value OEL of the target chemical substance. The exposure limit value OEL [μg / m3] is an occupational exposure level, which is a permissible exposure concentration at which it is assumed that no health effects are observed even if a worker works in an environment where the target chemical substance exists during a working time per day (8 hours / day to 40 hours / week). The exposure limit value OEL [μg / m3] is a value verified and determined by the operator of the production facility or research institute using the permissible concentration indicated by the Japan Society for Occupational Health, the Control of Toxic Chemical Substances for Health (COSHH) in the UK, the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH), etc.

[0033] The risk level Lrm thus determined is determined for each piece of equipment 90 to be dismantled. During dismantling work, the equipment corresponding to the risk level Lrm shown in Fig. 6 is used. Although not shown, work guidelines corresponding to the risk level Lrm (necessity of a cleaning room, work procedures during dismantling work, etc.) are also set for each risk level Lrm. Note that the process in step S5 corresponds to the "risk level determination process" in the claims.

[0034] Next, a method for determining a risk level Lrb for the building 1 to be demolished will be described with reference to the flowchart shown in Fig. 7. The risk level Lrb for the building 1 is determined for each section by dividing the building 1 into predetermined sections. The predetermined sections are of any size, and are set for each room, such as the control room 60A, the control room 60B, and the storage room 70, for example.

[0035] In step S11, the target chemical substance is identified. Specifically, information on the chemical substance used or produced in the facility 90 while the facility 90 was in operation is obtained. The method of obtaining information on the chemical substance includes, for example, referring to a data sheet obtained from the operator of the production facility or research institute to identify the target chemical substance. The chemical substance referred to here includes not only highly pharmacologically active drugs but also all chemical substances used in the facility 90 that may affect the human body. The building 1 is not limited to structural members such as pillars and walls, but also includes incidental equipment such as ventilation ducts 11 (see FIG. 14) of an air conditioner attached to a ceiling or the like.

[0036] In step S12, the handling amount level Lvb is determined. Specifically, the handling amount level Lvb is estimated based on the handling amount of the chemical substance handled by the equipment 90 installed in each section when the equipment 90 is in operation. Specifically, the handling amount of the chemical substance handled by the equipment 90 per unit time (for example, per day) is estimated based on the specifications of the equipment 90 or a work schedule. If the handling amount when the equipment 90 was in operation (in the past) was large, there is a possibility that a large amount of the chemical substance has been dispersed or remained in the building 1. Therefore, in this embodiment, the handling amount level Lvb is determined in this manner.

[0037] In this embodiment, the handling amount level Lvb is classified into three levels, for example, small (less than 1 kg), medium (1 kg or more but less than 1 t), and large (1 t or more), depending on the handling amount of the chemical substance handled by the facility 90 when the facility 90 was in operation. Note that the process in step S12 corresponds to the "handling amount level determination process" in the claims.

[0038] In step S13, the dispersion level Lfb is determined. In this embodiment, as shown in FIG. 8, the dispersion level Lfb is divided into three levels: low, medium, and high. Specifically, the dispersion level Lfb is divided into one of the three levels: low, medium, and high, based on the size (shape) of the particles of the chemical substance handled by the equipment 90 installed in each section to be dismantled during operation of the equipment 90. Note that the process in step S13 corresponds to the "dispersal level determination process" in the claims.

[0039] In step S14, the exposure level Leb is determined. In this embodiment, as shown in FIG. 9, the exposure level Leb is divided into four levels, Leb1 to Leb4. Specifically, the building 1 to be demolished is divided into one of the exposure levels Leb1 to Leb4 based on the amount of chemical substances handled estimated in step S12 and the dispersion level Lfb determined in step S13. The exposure levels Leb are Leb1, Leb2, Leb3, and Leb4 in order of decreasing degree of exposure. The process in step S14 corresponds to the "exposure level determination process" in the claims.

[0040] In step S15, a risk level Lrb is determined according to the risk of the chemical substances involved in the demolition work of the building 1. As shown in Fig. 10, in this embodiment, the risk level Lrb is divided into four levels, Lrb1 to Lrb4. The risk level Lrb is determined based on the exposure level Leb determined in step S14 and the exposure limit value OEL of the target chemical substance. Note that the process in step S15 corresponds to the "risk level determination process" in the claims.

[0041] In step S16, the ventilation level Lab is determined. The ventilation level Lab is determined based on the table shown in FIG. 11. Specifically, the ventilation level Lab is determined based on the ventilation device attached to the equipment 90 installed in the area to be dismantled when the equipment 90 was in operation. The ventilation levels Lab are Lab1, Lab2, Lab3, and Lab4 in order of decreasing ventilation degree (ventilation performance). The process in step S16 corresponds to the "ventilation level determination process" in the claims.

[0042] In step S17, the risk level Lrb is corrected. Specifically, the risk level Lrb is corrected based on the risk level Lrb determined in step S15 and the ventilation level Lab determined in step S16. If the ventilation performance of the equipment 90 installed in the section to be demolished is high, the possibility of chemical substances being released from the equipment 90 is low, and therefore the possibility of chemical substances being deposited or attached to the building 1 in that section is also low. Therefore, when the ventilation level Lab is high, the risk level Lrb of the building 1 is corrected to be low. Specifically, the risk level Lrb is corrected based on the table shown in FIG. 12, and the corrected risk level Lrc is determined. Note that this step in step S17 corresponds to the "risk correction step" in the claims.

[0043] The corrected risk level Lrc thus determined is determined for each section of the building 1 to be demolished. During demolition work, for example, the demolition work is performed using equipment corresponding to the corrected risk level Lrc shown in FIG.

[0044] It is not essential to perform steps S16 and S17. If steps S16 and S17 are not performed, the risk level Lrb acts in a direction safer for the dismantling workers than the corrected risk level Lrc.

[0045] In this manner, in this embodiment, the risk levels Lrm and Lrb are determined based on the amount of chemical substances handled, the degree of dispersion of the chemical substances, the degree of exposure of workers, and the exposure limit value OEL, allowing appropriate evaluation of the risk posed by chemical substances during dismantling.

[0046] Furthermore, since the risk levels Lrm and Lrb due to chemical substances are determined systematically as shown in the flowcharts of Figures 2 and 7, the risks due to chemical substances during dismantling can be evaluated more appropriately.

[0047] In addition, by determining risk levels Lrm and Lrb for each of the building 1 and equipment 90 to be demolished, excessive equipment and work can be prevented, costs can be prevented from increasing, and work efficiency can be improved.

[0048] Furthermore, risk can be more appropriately evaluated by dividing the building 1 to be demolished into predetermined sections and determining a risk level Lrb for each section. Note that when determining sections, it is not necessary to divide by room, and for example, multiple rooms may be treated as one section if the risk levels Lrb are estimated to be the same. Specifically, for example, the entrance-side shower cubicle 30A, the exit-side shower cubicle 30B, and the anteroom 40 may be treated as one section. In this way, the number of times the risk level Lrb is determined can be reduced, while the risks associated with the demolition work can be appropriately evaluated.

[0049] Conversely, one room may be divided into two sections. Specifically, for example, anteroom 40 may be divided into a section near entrance-side shower cubicle 30A and exit-side shower cubicle 30B, and a section near shower cubicle 50. This allows for a more appropriate assessment of the risks associated with the dismantling work.

[0050] In addition, by assessing risk using the corrected risk level Lrc, which is the risk level Lrb corrected based on the ventilation level Lab, it is possible to prevent the risk of the building from being over-evaluated. This prevents excessive equipment and work, suppresses increases in costs, and improves work efficiency.

[0051] In the above embodiment, an example was described in which the remaining amount of chemical substance remaining in the equipment 90 is used as the handling amount of the chemical substance to be handled at the time of dismantling to determine the handling amount level Lvm of the equipment 90. However, this is not limited to this, and the handling amount level Lvm of the equipment 90 at the time of dismantling may be determined based on the handling amount of the chemical substance when the equipment 90 is in operation.

[0052] In the above embodiment, the handling amount level Lvb of the building 1 is determined based on the handling amount of the chemical substance handled by the equipment 90 when the equipment 90 is in operation. However, the present invention is not limited to this, and the handling amount level Lvb of the building 1 at the time of demolition may be determined based on the remaining amount of the chemical substance remaining in the building 1. When estimating the remaining amount of the chemical substance in the building 1, it is considered that the ceiling space or the floor and walls near the preparation device are set as the sample area. However, since the floor and walls may be washed before demolition, it is preferable to determine the sample area of ​​the remaining amount of the chemical substance while taking into consideration the arrangement of the equipment 90, the air conditioning device, etc.

[0053] In the above embodiment, the airborne particle level Lfm is determined by visual inspection or palpation by an operator. However, the airborne particle level Lfm may be estimated from the past manufacturing history of the equipment 90.

[0054] Although the embodiments of the present invention have been described above, the above-mentioned embodiments merely show some of the application examples of the present invention, and it is not intended that the technical scope of the present invention be limited to the specific configurations of the above-mentioned embodiments. [Explanation of symbols]

[0055] 1. Building 11...Ventilation duct 90...Equipment 90A···Drug preparation equipment (equipment) 91...Ventilation duct

Claims

1. A risk assessment method for assessing a risk posed by a chemical substance when dismantling a facility that handles the chemical substance and a building in which the facility is installed, comprising the steps of: a handling amount level determination step of determining a handling amount level according to the handling amount of the chemical substance handled by the facility when the facility was in operation, or a handling amount level according to the handling amount of the chemical substance handled when the facility was dismantled; a dispersion level determination step of determining a dispersion level according to a degree of dispersion of the chemical substances predicted during dismantling; an exposure level determination step of determining an exposure level according to a degree to which a demolition worker is exposed to the chemical substance based on the handling amount level and the dispersion level; and a risk level determination step of determining a risk level according to a risk of the chemical substance based on the exposure level and an exposure limit value of the chemical substance that affects the health of a dismantling worker, A risk assessment method for determining the risk level for each of the facilities and buildings to be demolished.

2. 2. The risk assessment method according to claim 1, A risk assessment method in which, when determining the handling amount level of the facility, the remaining amount of the chemical substance remaining in the facility is taken as the handling amount of the chemical substance to be handled at the time of dismantling, and the handling amount level of the facility is determined.

3. 2. The risk assessment method according to claim 1, A risk assessment method in which, when determining the handling volume level of the building, the handling volume level is determined based on the handling volume of the chemical substance handled by the facility when the facility was in operation.

4. 2. The risk assessment method according to claim 1, A risk assessment method comprising: dividing the building to be demolished into predetermined sections; and determining the risk level of the demolition work of the building for each section.

5. 5. A risk assessment method according to claim 4, comprising: a ventilation level determination step of determining a ventilation level according to a degree of ventilation of the equipment installed in the section when the equipment was in operation; A risk assessment method further comprising a risk correction step of correcting the risk level of the demolition work of the building in the area to be demolished based on the risk level in the area and the ventilation level.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Dismantling system for waste treatment facilities

    JP2003130316A

  • Introduction management method of chemical substance, information processing apparatus, program, recording medium and chemical substance integrated management system

    JP2004326707A

  • Work process optimization support method and work process optimization support device

    JP2022124906A

  • Maintenance plan support method and maintenance plan support device

    JP2023047190A

  • Exposure dose measurement simulation apparatus and method

    WO2021215657A1