Device and deformation analysis method
The device and method create a simplified yet accurate three-dimensional finite element model for shield tunnels by modeling bolt rigidity and contact forces, effectively addressing the challenge of accurately representing force transmission between linings.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2023076231
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-05-02
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-15
AI Technical Summary
Existing methods struggle to accurately model the interaction between the primary and secondary linings of shield tunnels, particularly in expressing force transmission, and there is a need for a simplified yet accurate three-dimensional finite element method to analyze the stress state of the secondary lining.
A device and method that generate a three-dimensional finite element model by inputting steel segment joint shapes and bolt fastening portions, modeling bolt rigidity with axial and shear direction springs, and using initial tightening forces as loads, while accounting for contact forces between steel segment joints.
This approach allows for a simple and highly accurate three-dimensional finite element method model, reproducing experimental results with high precision, especially in simulating deformation and stress states of shield tunnel linings.
Smart Images

Figure 2024160825000001_ABST
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present disclosure relates to an apparatus and a method for deformation analysis. [Background technology]
[0002] In recent years, there has been a strong demand for measures to prevent deterioration of social infrastructure, and there has been an increasing demand for maintenance and management techniques for shield tunnels that have been built for telecommunications, railways, water supply, etc. Relatively old shield tunnels have a structural type in which a secondary lining of unreinforced concrete is installed on the inside of a primary lining of steel segments.
[0003] In this type of structure, the structural performance of the secondary lining is not usually evaluated during design. However, it is considered effective to include the secondary lining in the evaluation of the remaining strength after construction. This is because by making it possible to evaluate the stress state of the secondary lining, it is possible to anticipate applications such as estimating that the yield stress of the primary lining has been applied due to corrosion of the primary lining, which cannot be visually inspected, in the vicinity of a crack in the secondary lining.
[0004] Here, there is an example of analysis using a calculation method based on the widely used beam-spring model. [Prior art documents] [Non-patent literature]
[0005] [Non-Patent Document 1] Ikuo Fujimoto, Makoto Nakajima, Sadao Kimura, Jun Koizumi, "A Study on Calculation of Sectional Forces by Beam-Spring Model Calculation Method", Tunnel Engineering Research Papers and Reports Vol. 8, November 1998, Report (39), pp. 307-312 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0006] The interaction between the primary and secondary linings can be modeled by inter-lining springs. However, there are many constraints on modeling the interaction between linings, so there are challenges in reproducing the stress state of the secondary lining. In particular, it is difficult to express the force transmission between steel and concrete using the inter-lining springs of the beam-spring model.
[0007] This problem can be solved by the three-dimensional finite element method, which allows for modeling with a high degree of freedom. However, there are few examples of analysis of steel segment shield tunnels using the three-dimensional finite element method. In addition, Izumi S, Yokoyama T, Iwasaki A, Sakai S, Three-dimensional finite element analysis of tightening and loosening mechanism of threaded fastener, Eng. Fail. Anal. 12(4), 604 - 615, 2005., a detailed model that includes modeling of the thread is described. On the other hand, it is not clear how much the model can be simplified to shorten the calculation time while maintaining the required accuracy.
[0008] Therefore, an object of the present disclosure is to provide an apparatus for generating a three-dimensional finite element method model easily and with high accuracy. [Means for solving the problem]
[0009] The device according to one embodiment includes a data input unit that receives input of the shapes of a plurality of steel segment joints and the shapes of bolt fastening portions of a bolt that fastens the plurality of steel segment joints; A condition input unit that receives input of boundary conditions including an action on the plurality of steel segment joints, an initial tightening force of the bolt, and a support condition; A model generation unit that generates a three-dimensional finite element method model from the shapes of the plurality of steel segment joints, the shapes of the bolt fastening parts, and the boundary conditions input to the condition input unit, which are input to the data input unit; a model output unit that outputs the three-dimensional finite element method model generated by the model generation unit; Equipped with The model generation unit The stiffness of the bolt fastening portion is modeled as a spring that deforms in the axial and shear directions, The displacement between the two nodes of the spring is made equal to the displacement of the edge of a bolt hole into which the bolt can be inserted, which is formed in the plurality of steel segment joints, and the initial tightening force of the bolt is modeled as a load; Contact between the steel segment joints is modeled by inter-joint contact forces.
[0010] A deformation analysis method according to one embodiment includes inputting the shapes of a plurality of steel segment joints and the shapes of bolt fastening portions of bolts fastening the plurality of steel segment joints into an apparatus; Inputting boundary conditions including actions on the plurality of steel segment joints, initial tightening forces of the bolts, and support conditions into the apparatus; A three-dimensional finite element method model is generated by the device from the shapes of the plurality of steel segment joints, the shapes of the bolt fastening portions, and the boundary conditions; Performing a deformation analysis of the plurality of steel segment joints using a finite element method solver based on the three-dimensional finite element method model; Including, generating the three-dimensional finite element model, Modeling the stiffness of the bolted joint as a spring that deforms in an axial direction and a shear direction; The displacement between both nodes of the spring is made equal to the displacement of the edge of the bolt hole into which the bolt can be inserted, which is formed in the plurality of steel segment joints, and the initial tightening force of the bolt is modeled as a load; modeling contact between the plurality of steel segment joints with inter-joint contact forces; Includes. Effect of the Invention
[0011] According to the present disclosure, it is possible to provide an apparatus for generating a three-dimensional finite element method model simply and with high accuracy. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0012] [Figure 1] FIG. 1 is a block diagram showing a schematic configuration of an apparatus according to an embodiment of the present disclosure. [Diagram 2] FIG. 1 shows two steel segments fastened together with a bolt. [Diagram 3] FIG. 1 is a diagram showing an example of a primary lining composed of a large number of steel segments. [Figure 4] FIG. 2 is a diagram showing an example of a three-dimensional finite element method model generated by a model generation unit. [Diagram 5] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing an example of modeling the initial tightening force of a bolt as a concentrated load on both nodes of a spring in a three-dimensional finite element method model. [Figure 6] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing an example of modeling the initial tightening force of a bolt as a distributed load on the area of a steel segment joint on the bolt head side that is in contact with the corresponding washer in a three-dimensional finite element method model. [Figure 7] 2 is a flowchart for explaining a deformation analysis method for a steel segment joint executed by the device and finite element method solver of FIG. 1 . [Figure 8] FIG. 2 is a diagram showing a three-dimensional finite element method model created by a model generation unit of the device in FIG. 1. [Figure 9] FIG. 1 shows two steel segment joints bolted together and in positive bending. [Figure 10] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing analytical results and experimental values regarding the relationship between the bolt axial force increment and the acting moment. [Figure 11] FIG. 11 is a diagram showing analytical results and experimental values regarding the relationship between a joint rotation angle and an acting moment. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0013] Hereinafter, embodiments of the present disclosure will be described.
[0014] (About the device) An overview of an apparatus 1 according to an embodiment of the present disclosure will be described with reference to Fig. 1. The apparatus 1 includes a data input unit 10, a condition input unit 20, a model generation unit 30, and a model output unit 40. The apparatus 1 may include a storage unit 50. The model output unit 40 outputs a three-dimensional finite element method model to a finite element method solver 100. The finite element method solver 100 performs deformation analysis.
[0015] The device 1 is, for example, a computer such as a server device, etc. The device 1 is capable of communicating with a finite element method solver 100 via a network.
[0016] The data input unit 10 receives input of the shapes of multiple steel segment joints and the shapes of bolt fastening parts of bolts. The bolt fastening parts are parts that fasten multiple steel segment joints. Examples of these shapes will be described below with reference to FIG. 2.
[0017] FIG. 2 shows two steel segment joints 220a, 220b fastened by a bolt 210. Specifically, the steel segment joints 220a, 220b are flat. Bolt holes are formed in the thickness direction of the steel segment joints 220a, 220b. The bolt holes may be through holes. The radius of the bolt holes may be, for example, 8 mm. The inner surface of the bolt holes may be threaded. In this case, the shape of the threads does not need to be input.
[0018] The bolt 210 passes through the bolt hole and the nut 230. Here, the nut 230 may be tightened, and the nut 230 and the head of the bolt 210 may fasten the steel segment joints 220a, 220b. Note that although the entire bolt 210 and the nut 230 are shown here, the shapes of only the vicinity of the area of the bolt 210 and the nut 230 that contacts the steel segment joints 220a, 220b may be input as the shape of the bolt fastening portion. Also, the shapes of the threaded portions of the bolt 210 and the nut 230 may not be input.
[0019] A more complicated shape may be input to the data input unit 10. For example, the data input unit 10 can generate a three-dimensional finite element method model of the cylindrical primary lining 310 shown in FIG. 3. A secondary lining 320, a tertiary lining, etc. may further exist. The secondary lining 320 may be made of unreinforced concrete. The primary lining 320 is made of a large number of steel segment joints including steel segment joints 311a, 311b, and 311c. The steel segment joint 311a may be fastened to the steel segment 311b adjacent in the circumferential direction of the primary lining 310 by bolts. The steel segment joint 311a may be fastened to the steel segment joint 311c adjacent in the axial direction of the primary lining 310 by bolts. These bolts may be embedded in the steel segment joints 311a, 311b, and 311c. Both longitudinal edges of the steel segment joint 311a may be shifted in the circumferential direction of the primary lining 310 with respect to both longitudinal edges of the steel segment joint 311c.
[0020] The condition input unit 20 shown in FIG. 1 receives input of boundary conditions including the actions on the multiple steel segment joints, the initial tightening force of the bolts, and the support conditions.
[0021] The actions on the multiple steel segment joints input to the condition input unit 20 may include dead loads such as earth pressure and water pressure. The actions do not have to be applied uniformly to the structure. For example, a greater earth pressure may be applied below the steel segment joints than above them.
[0022] The initial tightening force of the bolt input to the condition input unit 20 will be described. When the nut 230 shown in FIG. 2 is tightened, an axial force pulling the bolt 210 in the axial direction acts on the bolt 210, causing the bolt 210 to elongate. When the bolt 210 elongates, a restoring force acts on the bolt 210. The steel segment joints 220a, 220b are fastened by the restoring force. This restoring force may be input as the initial tightening force. The initial tightening force of the bolt may be different for each bolt.
[0023] The support conditions input to the condition input unit 20 are conditions that determine the behavior of the boundary between adjacent steel segments. Specifically, a condition that adjacent steel segments are fastened with bolts (pins) can be specified. A condition that the contact surfaces of adjacent steel segments are bonded (fixed) can also be specified.
[0024] The model generation unit 30 generates a three-dimensional finite element method model from the shapes of multiple steel segment joints and the shapes of bolt fastening parts input to the data input unit 10 and the boundary conditions input to the condition input unit 20.
[0025] The model generator 30 models the stiffness of the bolted fastener with a spring that deforms in the axial and shear directions. In the example shown in FIG. 4, the stiffness of the bolted fastener may be modeled with a first spring 410 that deforms in the axial direction and a number of second springs that deform in the shear direction. The first spring 410 may be located at a position where the axis of the bolt is present. The second springs may be located in a plane that passes through the axial center of the first spring 410 and is perpendicular to the first spring 410. The second spring may be composed of two springs that face in different directions. The two springs may be perpendicular to each other.
[0026] The model generating unit 30 makes the displacement between both nodes of the spring equal to the displacement of the edge of a bolt hole, into which a bolt can be inserted, formed in a plurality of steel segment joints. Specifically, as shown in FIG. 4, the axial position of the upper end of a first spring 410, which is disposed on the shaft of the bolt and deforms in the axial direction, may be equal to the axial position of the upper edge of the bolt hole. Furthermore, the axial position of the lower end of the first spring 410 may be equal to the axial position of the lower edge of the bolt hole. Furthermore, the magnitude of the shear direction displacement of the edge of the bolt hole may be proportional to the strain of the second spring.
[0027] The model generation unit 30 models the initial tightening force of the bolt using a load.
[0028] The model generation unit 30 may model the initial tightening force of the bolt as a concentrated load on both nodes of the spring. Specifically, as shown in Fig. 5, the initial tightening force may be modeled as a concentrated load applied to two nodes 510p (only one is shown) of the first spring 510. This makes the generated three-dimensional finite element method model simpler, and thus may reduce the cost of deformation analysis by the finite element method solver 100.
[0029] A plurality of steel segment joints may be fastened by bolts via one or more washers. For example, as shown in FIG. 6, a first washer 630 having a radius of 16 mm may be in contact with the bolt head and the outer surface of the steel segment joint 620. In such a case, the model generating unit 30 may model the initial fastening force of the bolt by the bolt head as a distributed load applied to the area of the steel segment joint that is in contact with the first washer 630. Specifically, the initial fastening force by the bolt head may be modeled as a distributed load applied to the area of the outer surface of the steel segment joint on the bolt head side (for example, a mesh forming the outer surface) that is in contact with the first washer 630. This makes the deformation around the bolt hole 620h smaller than when the initial fastening force of the bolt is modeled as a concentrated load, and the yield behavior around the bolt hole 620h may be closer to the actual behavior.
[0030] When a second washer is present on the outer surface of the steel segment joint on the nut side, the initial tightening force by the nut may be modeled as a distributed load applied to the area of the steel segment joint that is in contact with the second washer.
[0031] The model generating unit 30 may model the contact between the multiple steel segment joints 220a, 220b with an inter-joint contact force as shown in Fig. 2. The inter-joint contact force represents the competition between the steel segment joints 220a, 220b. The inter-joint contact force may be oriented in a direction perpendicular to the contact surface of the multiple steel segment joints 220a, 220b. The inter-joint contact force may also include a friction force.
[0032] The model generation unit 30 divides an analysis domain defined by the shapes of the multiple steel segment joints 220a, 220b and the shape of the bolt fastening portion of the bolt 210 inputted to the data input unit 10 into finite elements without gaps. A mesh division pattern may be prepared in advance. Elements may be automatically generated using a method based on an automatic element division algorithm. The size of the elements may be determined based on the required accuracy of the analysis.
[0033] The model output unit 40 outputs the three-dimensional finite element method model generated by the model generation unit 30 to the finite element method solver 100. The model output unit 40 may output the three-dimensional finite element method model to the finite element method solver 100 by wired or wireless communication. The model output unit 40 may output the three-dimensional finite element method model to the finite element method solver 100 by using a storage medium.
[0034] The storage unit 50 stores the shapes of the multiple steel segment joints 220a, 220b and the shapes of the bolt fastening parts of the bolts 210 input to the data input unit 10, the boundary conditions input to the condition input unit 20, and the three-dimensional finite element method model generated by the model generation unit 30. The device 1 can also store this information in cloud storage via a network. In this configuration, the storage unit 50 can be omitted.
[0035] The finite element method solver 100 performs deformation analysis of the multiple steel segment joints 220a, 220b based on a three-dimensional finite element method model. As a result of the deformation analysis, the axial force and elongation of the bolt 210, the rotation angle of the steel segment joints 220a, 220b, etc. are calculated.
[0036] According to this embodiment, the model generation unit 30 models the stiffness of the bolt fastening part with springs (first spring and second spring) that deform in the axial and shear directions. The model generation unit 30 models the initial tightening force of the bolt 210 with a load after making the displacement between both nodes of the first spring 410 equal to the displacement of the edge of the bolt hole into which the bolt 210 can be inserted, which is formed in the multiple steel segment joints 220a, 220b. The model generation unit 30 models the contact between the multiple steel segment joints 220a, 220b with the contact force between the joints. With these configurations, the device 1 can generate a simple and highly accurate three-dimensional finite element method model.
[0037] (Deformation analysis method for steel segment joints) Next, a method for analyzing deformation of a steel segment joint, which is executed by the apparatus 1 and the finite element method solver 100 in this embodiment, will be described with reference to the flowchart of FIG.
[0038] In step S100, the shapes of the multiple steel segment joints and the shape of the bolt fastening portion of the bolt fastening the multiple steel segment joints are input to the device 1. More specifically, the shapes of the two steel segment joints 220a, 220b shown in Fig. 2 are input to a data input unit 10 (see Fig. 1) of the device 1. Also, the shape of the bolt 210 fastening the two steel segment joints 220a, 220b in the vicinity of the area in contact with the steel segment joints 220a, 220b is input to the data input unit 10.
[0039] In step S101, boundary conditions including actions on the multiple steel segment joints, initial bolt tightening force, and support conditions are input to the device 1. More specifically, earth pressure, water pressure, etc. are input to a condition input unit 20 of the device 1 as the actions on the multiple steel segment joints. The restoring force of the bolts fastened to the steel segment joints 220a, 220b is input to the condition input unit 20 as the initial bolt tightening force. A state in which adjacent steel segment joints 220a, 220b are fastened to each other with a bolt is input to the condition input unit 20 as a support condition of the boundary condition.
[0040] In step S102, the device 1 generates a three-dimensional finite element model from the shapes of the multiple steel segment joints, the shape of the bolt fastening portion, and the boundary conditions. Here, the device 1 models the stiffness of the bolt fastening portion with a first spring 410 (see FIG. 4) that deforms in the axial direction and a second spring that deforms in the shear direction. The device 1 models the initial tightening force of the bolt 210 with a load after making the displacement between both nodes of the first spring 410 equal to the displacement of the edge of the bolt hole into which the bolt 210 can be inserted, which is formed in the multiple steel segment joints 220a, 220b (see FIG. 2). The device 1 models the contact between the multiple steel segment joints 220a, 220b with the contact force between the joints.
[0041] In step S103, the finite element method solver 100 performs deformation analysis of the multiple steel segment joints 220a, 220b based on the three-dimensional finite element method model. As a result of the deformation analysis, the bolt axial force, the moment acting around the bolt hole, the rotation angle of the steel segment joint, etc. are calculated. After step S103, the method ends. EXAMPLES
[0042] A bending test of a steel segment joint was modeled and deformation analysis was performed using the device 1 according to the embodiment of the present disclosure, and will be described below. The test was performed in accordance with Hirotomo Murakami and Jun Koizumi, On the Behavior of Segment Joints in Segments for Shield Construction, Proceedings of the Japan Society of Civil Engineers, vol. 1980, no. 296, pp. 73-86, 1980. The test will be described below.
[0043] In this test, as shown in FIG. 8, there are two steel segment joints 820a and 820b. One steel segment joint 820a is composed of a first part 820a1 in the shape of a rectangular column extending horizontally and a second part 820a2 extending upward from the first part 820a1. In the first part 820a1, the top surface 820au and the bottom surface are wider than the side surface 820as. The shape of the other steel segment joint 820b is similar to that of the steel segment joint 820b.
[0044] Before a force (eccentric load) P described later is applied, an end face 820at (see FIG. 9) of the second part 820a2 of the steel segment joint 820a opposite to the first part 820a1 is in contact with an end face 820bt of the second part 820b2 of the steel segment joint 820b opposite to the first part 820b1. These end faces 820at, 820bt are fastened by a bolt 910. Hereinafter, the angle formed by the end faces 820at, 820bt in a side view of the first part 820a1 of the steel segment joint 820a and the first part 820b1 of the steel segment joint 820b is referred to as a joint rotation angle θ.
[0045] A bottom surface of a first portion 820a1 of the steel segment joint 820a is fixed to the floor near a second portion 820a2. A bottom surface of a first portion 820b1 of the steel segment joint 820b is fixed to the floor near a second portion 820b2.
[0046] A force (eccentric load) P is applied from the longitudinal outside of the steel segment joints 820a and 820b to the upper end of the first portion 820a1 of the steel segment joint 820a and the upper end of the first portion 820b1 of the steel segment joint 820b by a hydraulic jack. In this state, a downwardly convex bend (positive bend) is generated in the steel segment joints 820a and 820b. In this state, the joint rotation angle θ, the axial force of the bolt 910, and the acting moment that generates the joint rotation angle θ were measured.
[0047] The following describes a three-dimensional finite element method model created by the device 1 according to an embodiment of the present disclosure. The model generation unit 30 of the device 1 divided each of the two steel segment joints 820a, 820b into seven meshes in the longitudinal direction. In the example model 1, the model generation unit 30 modeled the initial tightening force of the bolt 910 as a concentrated load on both nodes of the spring. In the example model 2, the model generation unit 30 modeled the initial tightening force of the bolt 910 as a distributed load distributed over an area of a circle centered on the bolt hole and equal to the diameter of the washer, excluding the bolt hole.
[0048] Based on the created 3D finite element model, deformation analysis of multiple steel segment joints was performed using a finite element solver to obtain the joint rotation angle θ, the axial force of bolt 910, and the acting moment that generates the joint rotation angle θ. The finite element solver used was Abaqus from Dassault Systèmes.
[0049] Fig. 10 shows the relationship between the axial force increment of the bolt 910 and the acting moment, and Fig. 11 shows the relationship between the joint rotation angle θ and the acting moment.
[0050] 10 and 11, it was found that Example Model 1 and Example Model 2 created by the device 1 according to the embodiment of the present disclosure were able to reproduce the experimental values with high accuracy.
[0051] From FIG. 10, it can be seen that in Example Model 2, the acting moment at which the axial force of bolt 910 begins to increase is smaller than in Example Model 1, and the yield around the bolt hole was able to be brought closer to the start of yielding in the experimental results.
[0052] From FIG. 11, it can be seen that the increase in the joint rotation angle after the onset of yielding around the bolt hole is larger than the experimental value in Example Models 1 and 2 (up to about 30%), but this is not considered to be a problem in practical use as a simplified 3D finite element method model. [Explanation of symbols]
[0053] 1 device 10 Data Entry Section 20 Condition input section 30 Model Generation Unit 40 Model output section 50 Storage section 100 Finite element method solver 210 Volts 220a, 220b Steel segment joints 230 Nut 310 Primary Lining 311a, 311b, 311c Steel segments 320 Secondary Lining 410,510,610 First spring 620 Steel segment joint 620h Bolt hole 630 First washer 820a, 820b Steel segment joints 820a1,820b1 Part 1 820a2,820b2 2nd part 820au top 820as side 820at,820bt end face 910 Volts
Claims
1. A data input unit that receives input of the shapes of a plurality of steel segment joints and the shapes of bolt fastening portions of bolts that fasten the plurality of steel segment joints; A condition input unit that receives input of boundary conditions including an action on the plurality of steel segment joints, an initial tightening force of the bolt, and a support condition; A model generation unit that generates a three-dimensional finite element method model from the shapes of the plurality of steel segment joints, the shapes of the bolt fastening parts, and the boundary conditions input to the condition input unit, which are input to the data input unit; a model output unit that outputs the three-dimensional finite element method model generated by the model generation unit; Equipped with The model generation unit The stiffness of the bolt fastening portion is modeled as a spring that deforms in the axial and shear directions, The displacement between the two nodes of the spring is made equal to the displacement of the edge of a bolt hole into which the bolt can be inserted, which is formed in the plurality of steel segment joints, and the initial tightening force of the bolt is modeled as a load; modeling contact between the plurality of steel segment joints with inter-joint contact forces; Device.
2. The model generation unit models the initial tightening force of the bolt as a concentrated load on both nodes of the spring.
2. The apparatus of claim 1.
3. The plurality of steel segment joints are fastened by the bolts via washers, The model generation unit models the initial tightening force of the bolt as a distributed load on the areas of the plurality of steel segment joints that are in contact with the corresponding washers.
2. The apparatus of claim 1.
4. The contact force between the joints includes a friction force. An apparatus according to any one of claims 1 to 3.
5. Inputting the shapes of a plurality of steel segment joints and the shapes of bolt fastening portions of bolts fastening the plurality of steel segment joints into the device; Inputting boundary conditions including actions on the plurality of steel segment joints, initial tightening forces of the bolts, and support conditions into the apparatus; Generating a three-dimensional finite element method model from the shapes of the plurality of steel segment joints, the shapes of the bolt fastening portions, and the boundary conditions by the device; Performing a deformation analysis of the plurality of steel segment joints using a finite element method solver based on the three-dimensional finite element method model; Including, generating the three-dimensional finite element model, Modeling the stiffness of the bolted joint as a spring that deforms in an axial direction and a shear direction; The displacement between both nodes of the spring is made equal to the displacement of the edge of the bolt hole into which the bolt can be inserted, which is formed in the plurality of steel segment joints, and the initial tightening force of the bolt is modeled as a load; modeling contact between the plurality of steel segment joints with inter-joint contact forces; Including, A method for deformation analysis of steel segmental joints.
