Material rupture determination method, material rupture determination device and program
The method and device use a rupture limit function based on maximum principal strain and strain gradient to accurately predict fracture modes in automobile body members, improving design efficiency and reducing testing costs.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2023079482
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-05-12
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-22
AI Technical Summary
Existing methods struggle to uniformly evaluate complex fracture modes such as tensile fracture, tensile bending fracture, and bending fracture in automobile body members during collisions, leading to inaccurate fracture judgments and potential failure in designed deformation modes.
A method and device for determining material fracture using the finite element method (FEM) that considers the relationship between maximum principal strain and strain gradient in the thickness direction, incorporating a rupture limit function derived from VDA bending tests and FEM analysis to predict fracture modes accurately.
Enables accurate prediction of fracture modes, reducing the need for physical collision tests and enabling cost-effective, efficient design of automobile components to withstand collisions.
Smart Images

Figure 2024163668000001_ABST
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present invention relates to a method, an apparatus and a program for determining fracture of a material, and more particularly to a method and apparatus for determining fracture of a metal material, taking into account the deformation mode of the material. [Background technology]
[0002] The development of a body structure that can reduce the impact of a collision is always one of the most important issues for automobiles. One of the methods to deal with a collision is to absorb the collision energy by the structural members of the automobile and protect the passenger space. Therefore, when designing the body structure of an automobile, the structure is designed with collisions in mind, and within this, for example, analysis of the collision deformation of the body structural members is performed using FEM (finite element method) analysis, including the determination of fracture.
[0003] For example, Patent Document 1 proposes a method for predicting fracture by estimating the tensile bending fracture limit strength of a material and judging the risk of bending fracture of the material from the relationship with the tension acting on the bent part.Also, for example, Patent Document 2 proposes a method for predicting fracture by evaluating the deformation limit on a sheared surface based on an index value obtained from the gradient of the surface strain distribution in the plate thickness direction on the sheared surface and the gradient of the surface strain distribution in the bending ridge direction in press bending of a sheared metal plate. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0004] [Patent Document 1] JP 2012-33039 A [Patent Document 2] International Publication No. 2019 / 017136 [Patent Document 3] International Publication No. 2020 / 204059 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0005] In order to absorb collision energy, it is important that structural members deform in the mode intended during the design. If material fracture occurs during the deformation process, the intended deformation mode will not occur, and sufficient energy absorption performance may not be achieved.
[0006] Furthermore, as the strength of steel plates increases, their ductility decreases, and the material fracture modes during collision deformation of automobile bodies are becoming more diverse. For example, in steel plates called ultra-high tensile steels with a tensile strength of 980 MPa or more, in addition to material fracture due to in-plane tensile force during collision deformation (tensile fracture), material fracture due to bending deformation caused by buckling (bending fracture) and material fracture due to a combination of these (tensile bending fracture) may occur. In other words, not only do the deformation forms of deformed components during a collision differ depending on the part, but even in the same part, the deformation form may change as the deformation progresses, making the material fracture modes for each part more complex, making it difficult to determine fracture when designing an automobile body structure.
[0007] In contrast, the method in Patent Document 1 predicts bending fracture strength from the relationship between tension and elongation for each inner bend radius and judges fracture in tensile bending. However, this method only predicts fracture under tensile bending deformation and cannot be applied to cases where fracture occurs only from bending deformation alone, such as simple bending, where almost no tension is applied.
[0008] The method of Patent Document 2 is a technology limited to special areas that undergo stretch flange deformation on the shear processing surface during press forming, and has limitations in its application to fracture determination for complex fracture modes such as components subjected to collision deformation.
[0009] In order to solve the above problems, the present invention aims to provide a material fracture determination method, device, and program that uniformly evaluates complex fracture modes (tensile fracture, tensile bending fracture, and bending fracture) that may occur in automobile body components during a collision. The present invention aims to provide a material fracture determination method, device, and program that uniformly evaluates all fracture modes. [Means for solving the problem]
[0010] The present inventors have conducted extensive research to achieve the above object and have obtained the following findings.
[0011] [a] In tensile fracture, a simple uniaxial tensile stress acts on the test piece, and the cross section of the test piece in the thickness direction stretches uniformly before breaking. At this time, no bending deformation occurs in the test piece. In other words, if we look at the strain gradient in the thickness direction of the test piece (the difference between the maximum principal strain on the surface and the maximum principal strain at the center of the thickness divided by half the thickness), in tensile fracture, the strain distribution is uniform in the thickness direction (the maximum principal strain is the same on the surface and the center of the thickness), so the strain gradient in the thickness direction is also 0 (zero). On the other hand, bending fracture occurs when a bending moment acts on a test piece, causing it to break with bending deformation. Generally, when bending deformation is applied to a test piece, the maximum principal strain in the outer surface layer of the bend (hereinafter referred to as the "outer maximum principal strain") increases with respect to the center of the thickness of the test piece, and the strain gradient in the thickness direction of the test piece (hereinafter simply referred to as the "thickness direction strain gradient") increases. When the bending deformation increases and the maximum principal strain in the outer surface layer of the bend reaches a limit value, the test piece breaks. The outer maximum principal strain at the time of fracture when this bending deformation is applied is several times larger than the maximum principal strain at tensile fracture in simple tensile deformation (deformation in a so-called uniaxial tensile test) (hereinafter referred to as the "tensile limit strain"). The inventors noticed that the maximum principal strain on the outer surface layer of the bend (maximum principal strain on the outer side of the bend) increases with the increase in the strain gradient in the plate thickness direction, and conceived the possibility of uniformly expressing complex fracture modes (not only tensile fracture and bending fracture, but also fracture due to deformation that is a combination of tensile deformation and bending deformation (tensile bending fracture)) and proceeded with development.
[0012] [stomach] The bending fracture behavior can be obtained by evaluating the fracture of materials using the plate bending test standard VDA238-100 (hereinafter referred to as the "VDA bending test") of the German Association of the Automotive Industry (Verband Der Automobilindustrie (VDA)). In other words, the maximum principal strain of the outer surface layer of the bend in bending deformation mode can be obtained from the results of the VDA bending test. Since this VDA bending test does not involve tensile stress and fracture occurs only due to bending deformation, the maximum principal strain of the outer surface layer of the bend at fracture (outer maximum principal strain of bending) is the largest (hereinafter, the maximum principal strain of the outer surface layer of the bend at fracture in this VDA bending test is referred to as the "maximum principal strain limit of bending").
[0013] It is difficult to directly measure the limit maximum principal strain at the time of fracture in a VDA bending test, but it is possible to obtain the maximum principal strain of the outer surface layer of the bend (limit maximum principal strain at the fracture point) from the VDA bending angle information obtained in a VDA bending test using FEM (finite element method) analysis. On the other hand, in the case of tensile fracture, the specimen elongates uniformly in the thickness direction, so the magnitude of the maximum principal strain at fracture (equivalent to the maximum principal bending strain) is equal to the n-value (work hardening exponent) of the steel material used as the specimen.
[0014] [cormorant] Next, the inventors carried out experiments by using a test method that simultaneously loads a tensile load (also called tensile tension) and bending deformation, and reproducing various composite fracture modes by changing the punch tip radius and applying tensile forces to both ends of the test piece. The value of the maximum principal strain of the outer surface layer of the bend (outer maximum principal strain of the bend) at the time of fracture in the composite fracture mode is determined by the amount of bending deformation and the loading state of the tensile load. Therefore, the inventors carried out an investigation together with FEM analysis and found that the fracture limit function, which is the relationship between the outer maximum principal strain of the bend and the gradient of the maximum principal strain in the plate thickness direction (plate thickness direction strain gradient) at the time of fracture in the composite fracture mode, can be approximated by a nearly linear relationship (the relationship of a first-order function). That is, in a plane with the thickness direction strain gradient as the horizontal axis (X axis) and the outer maximum principal strain as the horizontal axis (Y axis) (hereinafter, the plane defined by the X axis and Y axis is called the "strain gradient-maximum principal strain plane"), it was found that it is expressed by a line segment connecting the point (fracture point) plotted by the outer maximum principal strain at fracture and the thickness direction strain gradient and the n value point that is the vertical axis intercept (hereinafter, this line segment is called the "fracture limit line", and the slope of this fracture limit line is called the "fracture limit gradient"). Note that, since the limit maximum principal strain obtained by the VDA bending test is the upper limit of the outer maximum principal strain at fracture, after the fracture limit line reaches the limit maximum principal strain, it is convenient to consider the outer maximum principal strain to be constant at this limit maximum principal strain.
[0015] In other words, in the region where the bending outer maximum principal strain is larger than the fracture limit function, it is predicted that the component will fracture. For example, in a crash analysis of an automobile body structure using FEM or the like, if the maximum principal strain of the bending outer surface layer of each component (bending outer maximum principal strain) and the strain gradient in the plate thickness direction (plate thickness direction strain gradient) are known, it was discovered that if the bending outer maximum principal strain obtained in the crash analysis is larger than the bending outer maximum principal strain (calculated value) obtained by substituting the plate thickness direction strain gradient into the previously obtained fracture limit function, it is possible to determine that the component in question has fractured.
[0016] [workman] Next, when similar tests were performed on test pieces of the same steel but with different thicknesses, it was found that the slope of the fracture limit line (fracture limit gradient) changed significantly depending on the thickness of the test piece. From this, it was found that once the thickness of the steel is determined, the fracture limit gradient is almost determined on the strain gradient - maximum principal strain plane. (Figure 2 shows a conceptual diagram of the relationship between thickness and fracture limit gradient.) Therefore, it was found that if the relationship between the thickness of the steel and the fracture limit gradient, as well as the n-value of the steel and the maximum principal bending strain limit in the VDA bending test are understood in advance, it is possible to obtain the fracture limit function according to the thickness of the component using that steel.
[0017] [O] Next, the effects of changing the type of steel, i.e., changing the n-value, were examined in detail. Similar tests were conducted using steel with different n-values as test pieces, and it was found that the fracture limit gradient changed slightly depending on the n-value, even for the same plate thickness. It was then discovered that the accuracy of the fracture limit function used to determine fracture could be improved by correcting the fracture limit gradient according to the n-value (Fig. 3 shows a conceptual diagram of the relationship between the n-value and the fracture limit gradient).
[0018] [mosquito] Furthermore, we investigated the effect of element size when applying the above knowledge to structural analysis using FEM. As a result, we found that the fracture limit gradient itself is not affected by the element size. However, we found that the maximum principal strain at tensile fracture (tensile limit strain) and the limit maximum principal bending strain at bending fracture during VDA bending tests are affected by the element size. Therefore, we found that the accuracy of the fracture limit function used to determine fracture can be improved by correcting the tensile limit strain and the limit maximum principal bending strain during VDA bending tests according to the element size in FEM analysis.
[0019] The present invention has been made based on the above findings, and the gist of the present invention is as follows.
[0020] [1] A method for determining fracture of a component by deformation analysis using the finite element method (FEM), comprising: (a) a limiting maximum principal strain, which is a maximum principal strain value at the outer surface layer of a test piece made of a material constituting the component when the test piece breaks in a VDA bending test; and The relationship between the bending outer maximum principal strain, which is the maximum principal strain at the bending outer surface layer of the test piece at the time of fracture in a test in which a tensile load and a bending deformation are simultaneously applied to the test piece, and the plate thickness direction strain gradient, which is the gradient of the maximum principal strain in the plate thickness direction; A step of determining a fracture limit function, which is a function of the maximum principal strain on the outer side of bending with respect to the strain gradient in the thickness direction according to the thickness, from the n value, which is the work hardening exponent of the material, and the thickness of the test piece; (b) determining a maximum principal strain on the outer side of the bending member and a strain gradient through the thickness direction for each element of the member by a deformation analysis of the member using a finite element method; (c) for each of the elements, the thickness direction strain gradient obtained by the deformation analysis using the finite element method and the bending outer maximum principal strain obtained from the fracture limit function according to the thickness of the member; The bending outer maximum principal strain obtained by the deformation analysis using the finite element method is compared, determining whether the member is broken; (d) outputting a determination result as to whether the member is broken; A method for determining fracture of a member, comprising: [2] In the step of determining the fracture limit function, The limit maximum principal bending strain at the time of fracture in the VDA bending test is determined from the limit VDA bending angle of the test piece at the time of fracture in the VDA bending test and a finite element method; In the strain gradient-maximum principal strain plane, which is a plane with the plate thickness direction strain gradient on the horizontal axis and the bending outer maximum principal strain on the vertical axis, When the breaking limit function is a linear function, the slope of the breaking limit function is defined as the breaking limit gradient. Passing through the point of n value that is the intercept of the vertical axis, A fracture limit line is obtained, which is a line segment having an upper limit equal to the limit bending maximum principal strain, and a fracture limit gradient corresponding to the thickness of the test piece obtained from the previously obtained relationship between the thickness and the fracture limit gradient is set as a gradient; The method for determining fracture of a member according to [1] above, wherein the fracture limit line is the fracture limit function. The relationship between the plate thickness and the fracture limit gradient is as follows: In the strain gradient-maximum principal strain plane, for each thickness of the test piece, Passing through the point of the n value that is the intercept of the vertical axis, A straight line is approximated from points plotted from the maximum principal strain on the outer side of bending and the strain gradient in the plate thickness direction in a test in which the tensile load and bending deformation are simultaneously applied to the test piece, and the slope of the straight line thus obtained can be determined as the fracture limit gradient at the plate thickness. [3] The fracture determination method for a component according to [2] above, further comprising correcting the fracture limit gradient based on a relationship between a previously determined n value and the fracture limit gradient and the n value of the material of the component. [4] The tensile limit strain corresponding to the element size used in the deformation analysis of the FEM is calculated based on a relationship between the element size in the FEM analysis obtained in advance and a tensile limit strain which is a maximum principal strain at the time of tensile fracture in a tensile test of the material of the member, and the calculated tensile limit strain is set as a lower limit value of the fracture limit function; and The method for determining fracture of a component according to any one of the items [1] to [3], further comprising determining a limit maximum principal bending strain corresponding to the element size used in the FEM deformation analysis based on a relationship between the element size in the FEM analysis and the limit maximum principal bending strain of the material of the component, the limit maximum principal bending strain being set as an upper limit value of the fracture limit function. [5] The method for determining whether or not the component has fractured, comprising converting the tensile limit strain, the maximum principal bending strain limit, and the fracture limit function into a tensile limit stress, a maximum principal bending stress limit, and a fracture limit stress function based on the relationship between strain and stress of the material of the component, determining a thickness direction stress gradient, which is the gradient of the maximum principal stress at the bending outer surface layer and the maximum principal stress in the thickness direction, for each element of the component, and determining whether or not the component has fractured. [6] The method for determining fracture of a member according to any one of [1] to [5], wherein the member is a steel material having a tensile strength of 980 MPa or more. [7] A component fracture determination device using deformation analysis using the finite element method (FEM), (a) a limiting maximum principal strain, which is a maximum principal strain value at the outer surface layer of a test piece made of a material constituting the component when the test piece breaks in a VDA bending test; and The relationship between the bending outer maximum principal strain, which is the maximum principal strain at the bending outer surface layer of the test piece at the time of fracture in a test in which a tensile load and a bending deformation are simultaneously applied to the test piece, and the plate thickness direction strain gradient, which is the gradient of the maximum principal strain in the plate thickness direction; A fracture limit function generating unit that generates a fracture limit function, which is a function of the bending outer maximum principal strain with respect to the thickness direction strain gradient according to the thickness, from the n value, which is the work hardening exponent of the material, and the thickness of the test piece; (b) a component simulation execution unit that calculates a bending maximum principal strain and a thickness direction strain gradient for each element of the component by a deformation analysis of the component using a finite element method; (c) for each element, the bending outer maximum principal strain obtained from the plate thickness direction strain gradient obtained by the member simulation execution unit and the fracture limit function according to the plate thickness of the member obtained by the fracture limit function generation unit; The maximum principal strain on the outer side of the bending calculated by the member simulation execution unit is compared, A break determination unit that determines whether the member is broken; (d) a determination result output unit that outputs a determination result as to whether the member is broken or not; A component fracture determination device comprising: [8] In the breaking limit function generating unit, The limit maximum principal bending strain at the time of fracture in the VDA bending test is determined from the limit VDA bending angle of the test piece at the time of fracture in the VDA bending test and a finite element method; In the strain gradient-maximum principal strain plane, which is a plane with the plate thickness direction strain gradient on the horizontal axis and the bending outer maximum principal strain on the vertical axis, When the breaking limit function is a linear function, the slope of the breaking limit function is defined as the breaking limit gradient. Passing through the point of n value that is the intercept of the vertical axis, The fracture limit gradient corresponding to the plate thickness of the test piece obtained from the previously obtained relationship between the plate thickness and the fracture limit gradient is set as a gradient, and a fracture limit line is obtained which is a line segment having an upper limit equal to the limit bending maximum principal strain; The fracture determination device for a component described in [7], wherein the fracture limit line is the fracture limit function. The relationship between the plate thickness and the fracture limit gradient is as follows: In the strain gradient-maximum principal strain plane, for each thickness of the test piece, Passing through the point of the n value that is the intercept of the vertical axis, A straight line is approximated from points plotted from the maximum principal strain on the outer side of bending and the strain gradient in the plate thickness direction in a test in which the tensile load and bending deformation are simultaneously applied to the test piece, and the slope of the straight line thus obtained can be determined as the fracture limit gradient at the plate thickness. [9] In the breaking limit function generating unit, The fracture determination device for a component according to [8], wherein the fracture limit gradient is corrected based on a relationship between a previously determined n value and the fracture limit gradient and the n value of the material of the component.
[10] In the breaking limit function generating unit, The tensile limit strain corresponding to the element size used in the deformation analysis of the FEM is calculated based on a relationship between the element size in the FEM analysis obtained in advance and a tensile limit strain which is a maximum principal strain at the time of tensile fracture in a tensile test of the material of the member, and the calculated tensile limit strain is set as a lower limit value of the fracture limit function; and The fracture determination device for a component according to any one of claims [7] to [9], further comprising: determining a limit maximum principal bending strain corresponding to the element size used in the FEM deformation analysis based on a relationship between the element size in the FEM analysis and the limit maximum principal bending strain of the material of the component, the limit maximum principal bending strain being set as an upper limit value of the fracture limit function.
[11] The device for determining whether or not the component has fractured is described in any one of [7] to
[10] above, which converts the tensile limit strain, the maximum principal bending strain limit, and the fracture limit function into a tensile limit stress, a maximum principal bending stress limit, and a fracture limit stress function based on the relationship between strain and stress of the material of the component, determines a thickness direction stress gradient, which is the gradient of the maximum principal stress at the bending outer surface layer and the maximum principal stress in the thickness direction, for each element of the component, and determines whether or not the component has fractured.
[12] A program for determining fracture of a component by deformation analysis using the finite element method (FEM), (a) a limiting maximum principal strain, which is a maximum principal strain value at the outer surface layer of a test piece made of a material constituting the component when the test piece breaks in a VDA bending test; and The relationship between the bending outer maximum principal strain, which is the maximum principal strain at the bending outer surface layer of the test piece at the time of fracture in a test in which a tensile load and a bending deformation are simultaneously applied to the test piece, and the plate thickness direction strain gradient, which is the gradient of the maximum principal strain in the plate thickness direction; A fracture limit function is generated from the work hardening exponent n value of the material and the thickness of the test piece, which is a function of the bending outer maximum principal strain with respect to the thickness direction strain gradient according to the thickness; (b) generating the maximum principal strain and the through-thickness strain gradient for each element of the member by a deformation analysis of the member using a finite element method; (c) for each of the elements, the thickness direction strain gradient obtained by the deformation analysis using the finite element method, and the bending outer maximum principal strain obtained from the fracture limit function according to the plate thickness of the member; The bending outer maximum principal strain obtained by the deformation analysis using the finite element method is compared, determining whether the member is broken; (d) outputting a determination result as to whether the member is broken or not; A component fracture determination program that causes a computer to execute a process.
[13] When generating the fracture limit function, The limit maximum principal bending strain at the time of fracture in the VDA bending test is determined from the limit VDA bending angle of the test piece at the time of fracture in the VDA bending test and a finite element method; In the strain gradient-maximum principal strain plane, which is a plane with the plate thickness direction strain gradient on the horizontal axis and the bending outer maximum principal strain on the vertical axis, When the breaking limit function is a linear function, the slope of the breaking limit function is defined as the breaking limit gradient. Passing through the point of n value that is the intercept of the vertical axis, The fracture limit gradient corresponding to the plate thickness of the test piece obtained from the previously obtained relationship between the plate thickness and the fracture limit gradient is set as a gradient, and a fracture limit line is obtained which is a line segment having an upper limit equal to the limit bending maximum principal strain; The component fracture determination program according to
[12] , wherein the fracture limit line is the fracture limit function. The relationship between the plate thickness and the fracture limit gradient is as follows: In the strain gradient-maximum principal strain plane, for each thickness of the test piece, Passing through the point of the n value that is the intercept of the vertical axis, A straight line is approximated from points plotted from the maximum principal strain on the outer side of bending and the strain gradient in the plate thickness direction in a test in which the tensile load and bending deformation are simultaneously applied to the test piece, and the slope of the straight line thus obtained can be determined as the fracture limit gradient at the plate thickness. Effect of the Invention
[0021] The present invention makes it possible to uniformly evaluate multiple fracture modes (tensile fracture, tensile bending fracture, and bending fracture) that may occur in automobile body components during a collision, and to accurately determine fracture of the components. This makes it possible to significantly reduce the number of crash tests on actual automobile components, and even to omit crash tests. In addition, components that prevent fracture during a collision can be designed on a computer, which contributes to significant cost reductions and shortened development times. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0022] [Figure 1] FIG. 1 is a conceptual diagram showing an example of a breaking limit line. [Diagram 2] FIG. 2 is a conceptual diagram showing an example of the relationship between plate thickness and fracture limit gradient. [Diagram 3] FIG. 3 is a conceptual diagram showing an example of the relationship between the n value and the fracture limit gradient. [Figure 4] Fig. 4 is a schematic diagram for explaining a test in which a tensile load and bending deformation are applied simultaneously. Fig. 4(a) is a schematic diagram for explaining an outline of the test, and Fig. 4(b) is a schematic diagram for explaining an enlarged view of the tip of the punch. [Diagram 5] FIG. 5 is a conceptual diagram explaining the effect of element size on the fracture limit line in FEM analysis. [Figure 6] FIG. 6 is an explanatory diagram showing the test results for a 980 MPa class steel plate having a plate thickness of 1.4 mm. [Figure 7] FIG. 7 is an explanatory diagram showing the test results for a 980 MPa class steel plate having a plate thickness of 2.0 mm. [Figure 8] FIG. 8 is an explanatory diagram showing the test results for a 1500 MPa class steel plate having a plate thickness of 1.4 mm. [Figure 9] FIG. 9 is a conceptual diagram showing a breakage determination device according to one embodiment of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0023] The present invention will be described in detail below with reference to an embodiment thereof, taking as an example a deformation analysis of an automobile body member made of a steel plate having a tensile strength of 980 MPa or more, which is the material of the automobile body member. First, a method of determining fracture of the member will be described.
[0024] [Steps to obtain the breaking limit function] As described above, the present invention was developed by focusing on the fact that the critical maximum principal strain at which fracture occurs changes depending on the strain gradient in the plate thickness direction, and by imagining that the composite fracture modes (tensile fracture, tensile bending fracture, and bending fracture) can be expressed in a unified manner. In the tensile fracture mode, the strain gradient is 0 (zero), but in the bending fracture mode, the maximum principal strain of the bending outer surface layer becomes the critical bending maximum principal strain, and fracture occurs. Therefore, in the fracture of an automobile body member in which tensile fracture and bending fracture are combined, which actually occurs, it is considered that the fracture occurs when the maximum principal strain of the bending outer surface layer at that time (bending outer maximum principal strain) exceeds a certain maximum principal strain while having a strain gradient. Therefore, if the function of the maximum principal strain of the outer surface layer of the bend when fracture occurs (maximum principal strain on the outer side of the bend) is calculated in advance, using the strain gradient in the thickness direction as a variable, the maximum principal strain on the outer side of the bend that leads to fracture can be calculated from the gradient of the maximum principal strain in the thickness direction (strain gradient in the thickness direction) in the combined deformation state of the component to be predicted to fracture in the deformation analysis of the component using FEM (finite element method) (hereinafter sometimes simply called "FEM analysis"). If the maximum principal strain on the outer side of the bend of the component is larger than the maximum principal strain on the outer side of the bend that leads to fracture calculated using this function, it can be determined that a fracture has occurred in the FEM analysis. This function of the maximum principal strain on the outer side of the bend that leads to fracture against the strain gradient in the thickness direction is called the "fracture limit function."
[0025] First, we will explain how to obtain the characteristic values of the bending fracture mode by a VDA bending test and obtain the fracture limit function. A test piece is made from the same steel as the component to be analyzed, a VDA bending test is performed, and the limit maximum principal strain of the outer surface layer of the bent part at the time of bending fracture (limit maximum principal strain of bending) can be obtained using FEM analysis. The limit maximum principal strain of bending obtained by this VDA bending test is the upper limit value of the outer maximum principal strain of bending at the fracture limit function (fracture limit line) on a plane (strain gradient - maximum principal strain plane) with the plate thickness direction strain gradient as the horizontal axis (X axis) and the outer maximum principal strain as the vertical axis (Y axis).
[0026] The value of the maximum principal strain of the outer surface layer of the bend (the maximum principal strain of the outer surface of the bend), which is the fracture limit in the composite fracture mode, is determined by the bending deformation amount and the loading state of the tensile load. Therefore, in order to reproduce this, a tensile bending deformation test was performed using a test device 101 that simultaneously loads a tensile load and a bending deformation as shown in FIG. 4. First, a tensile bending test was performed on a test piece 102 made of a 980 MPa-class steel plate (meaning a steel plate with a tensile strength of 980 MPa to 1080 MPa). The test piece 102 had a plate thickness of 1.4 mm, and the tip R (radius) 115 of the punch 114 was set to 2 mm, 4 mm, or 8 mm. The test piece 102 was sandwiched between a pair of rolls 117 and a punch 114, and the punch 114 was pressed against the test piece 102. In this state, the test piece 102 was bent and a tensile load 116 was applied from the left and right directions, so that the tensile load and bending deformation could be applied simultaneously. The time when a fracture or necking occurred from the outer surface layer of the bent test piece was determined to be the time of fracture. By changing the tip R 115 of the punch 114 and the tensile load (left-right force in Figure 4) 116 on both ends of the test piece, the strain gradient in the thickness direction of the test piece 102 (the difference between the maximum principal strain 111 on the surface layer of the plate and the maximum principal strain 112 at the center of the plate thickness divided by half the plate thickness t) and the maximum principal strain 111 on the outside of the bending change, making it possible to reproduce various tensile bending fracture modes.
[0027] Using FEM analysis that reproduced the test of simultaneously applying the tensile load and bending deformation, the maximum principal strain on the outside of the bend at the time when the fracture occurred was obtained, and the strain gradient in the plate thickness direction was obtained by dividing the difference between the maximum principal strain on the surface and the plate thickness center by half the plate thickness. When these test results were plotted on the strain gradient-maximum principal strain plane, it was found that the relationship between the maximum principal strain on the outside of the bend at the time of fracture and the strain gradient in the plate thickness direction was almost linear (a linear function relationship), as shown in Figure 1. In other words, on the strain gradient-maximum principal strain plane, the approximate straight line (line segment) obtained from these test results becomes the fracture limit function (fracture limit line). The intercept of the fracture limit line with the vertical axis corresponds to the work hardening exponent (n value) of the material (steel).
[0028] Furthermore, the test specimens were made 1.2mm and 2.0mm thick, and similarly to the case of the 1.4mm thick plate, the relationship between the maximum principal strain on the outside of the bending and the strain gradient in the plate thickness direction at the time of fracture was obtained from the test and FEM analysis in which the tensile load and bending deformation were simultaneously applied. When the slope of the fracture limit line on the strain gradient-maximum principal strain plane (fracture limit gradient) was investigated, it was found that the fracture limit gradient increases with increasing plate thickness, and that the relationship changes almost linearly (as a linear function) with respect to the plate thickness, as shown in Figure 2. Figure 1 shows a conceptual diagram of the fracture limit line. Figure 2 shows the relationship between plate thickness and fracture limit gradient. When bending fracture is reached, if the same steel type is used, the maximum principal strain on the outside of the bending is almost the same regardless of the plate thickness, so the limit maximum principal strain on the bending obtained by the VDA bending test is almost the same. In other words, it is the upper limit of the fracture limit function (fracture limit line) where the maximum principal strain on the outside of the bending is maximum.
[0029] The relationship between plate thickness and fracture limit gradient can be found as follows. First, in the strain gradient-maximum principal strain plane, the bending outer maximum principal strain at fracture and the plate thickness direction strain gradient obtained by a test in which a tensile load and bending deformation are simultaneously applied to a test piece and an FEM analysis are plotted. Next, for each plate thickness of the test piece, a straight line is found that passes through the n value point that is the intercept of the vertical axis and is approximated from the plotted points. The slope of the straight line found is the fracture limit gradient at that plate thickness. The fracture limit gradient can be found for each plate thickness. There is no particular limitation on the method of finding the approximate straight line. For example, it can be found by the least squares method.
[0030] [Correction by work hardening exponent (n value)] Next, we investigated the effect of different steel grades, i.e., different n values, such as 590MPa, 980MPa, and 1500MPa. Using steel materials with the same thickness and n values of 0.18, 0.12, and 0.07, we performed tests in which the same tensile load and bending deformation were simultaneously applied, and from FEM analysis, we obtained the maximum principal strain on the outside of the bend and the strain gradient in the thickness direction at the time of fracture, and obtained the fracture limit line. We then obtained the gradient of the fracture limit line on the strain gradient-maximum principal strain plane, and obtained the relationship between the fracture limit gradient and the n value, as shown in Figure 3. As a result, we found that the fracture limit gradient also varies slightly depending on the n value. We can assume that the relationship between the n value and the limit fracture gradient is linear, and we found that it is effective to correct the fracture limit gradient using the following formula 1. As shown in Figure 3, we found that the fracture limit gradient decreases slightly with an increase in the n value. Therefore, when the steel of the test piece used to determine the fracture limit line is taken as the reference steel and its n-value is taken as the reference n-value (n0), the fracture limit slope can be corrected using the n-value of the steel to be evaluated using the following formula 1.
[0031] Corrected fracture limit gradient = k × fracture limit gradient of reference steel material Formula 1 where k = (a·n+b) / (a·n0+b), where a and b are constants in the approximation formula (fracture limit slope = a × n value + b) that shows the relationship between the fracture limit slope and the n value, and can be calculated using experimental data, for example, by least-squares approximation.
[0032] The effect of the n value on the fracture limit gradient is small compared to the effect of plate thickness, so the fracture limit gradient can be considered to be determined mainly by plate thickness. However, by correcting for this n value, the accuracy of the fracture limit line is improved, and so is the accuracy of fracture judgment.
[0033] [Step to calculate maximum principal strain on the outer side of each element and strain gradient through the plate thickness] The method of analyzing the deformation of a component using the finite element method (FEM) and finding the maximum principal strain for each element is not particularly limited. Methods used in normal deformation analysis of components can be used. For example, it is possible to reduce the element size of parts that are particularly desired to be analyzed in detail or parts where breakage is expected. In addition, the method of dividing elements is not particularly limited, so it can be determined appropriately. Reducing the element size and increasing the number of elements improves the calculation accuracy, but increases the calculation time. Conversely, reducing the element size and decreasing the number of elements shortens the calculation time, but decreases the calculation accuracy. When performing local stress analysis such as collision deformation analysis of an automobile body, it is desirable to make the element size as small as possible for parts where stress is expected to concentrate, parts where bending deformation is applied, parts where breakage is expected, etc.
[0034] [Fracture determination step] By analyzing the deformation of a component using FEM, the maximum principal strain for each element and the gradient of the maximum principal strain in the thickness direction (thickness direction strain gradient) of the part corresponding to that element can be obtained. The obtained bending outer maximum principal strain and thickness direction strain gradient can be compared with the fracture limit function (fracture limit line) obtained by the above method to determine whether the part corresponding to the element has fractured. In particular, the fracture limit function (fracture limit line) can be compared with the maximum principal strain in the element corresponding to the bending outer surface layer of the component (bending outer maximum principal strain) and the thickness direction strain gradient in that element to determine whether the element has fractured. The criteria and method for determination are not particularly limited.
[0035] For example, the strain gradient in the plate thickness direction obtained by a deformation analysis of a component using FEM is applied to a fracture limit function (fracture limit line) to determine the outer maximum principal strain at which composite fracture is predicted (predicted maximum principal strain at fracture). By comparing the predicted maximum principal strain at fracture obtained with the outer maximum principal strain at fracture obtained by FEM deformation analysis, it is possible to determine whether the part corresponding to that element will fracture. More specifically, when the outer maximum principal strain at fracture obtained by FEM deformation analysis is greater than the outer maximum principal strain at bending (predicted principal strain at fracture) obtained by the fracture limit function (fracture limit line), it can be determined that the part corresponding to that element will fracture.
[0036] [Correction by FEM element size] We investigated the effect of element size used in deformation analysis with FEM on the fracture limit line. As a result, we found that the accuracy of fracture determination can be improved by using a fracture limit line in which the upper and lower limits that the fracture limit line can take are modified to values determined by the element size.
[0037] Generally, local necking occurs at the site where tensile strain is applied and fracture occurs. In the finite element method, the calculated strain of this local necking varies depending on the element size used. The coarser the element size, the less accurate the deformation state of the local necking is calculated, resulting in a rounded value. In other words, it is known that the coarser the element size, the smaller the calculated strain value. Therefore, even if the same member is modeled with different element sizes, in order to detect fracture at the timing when the same tensile boundary condition is applied, the fracture limit line must also be corrected according to the element size. When the inventor performed FEM analysis using a model with various elements, it was confirmed that even when the element size was changed, the strain fracture limit gradient hardly changed, but the upper and lower limits of the fracture limit line changed slightly. Figure 5 shows a schematic diagram of the effect of element size on the upper and lower limits of the fracture limit line in FEM analysis.
[0038] Since the lower limit of the fracture limit line corresponds to the limit strain (tensile limit strain) at the time of tensile fracture in a tensile test (plane strain tension), the tensile limit strain can be determined as the lower limit according to the element size of the model to be evaluated using the relationship between element size and tensile limit strain shown below. In other words, since it is known that the tensile limit strain varies with the element size, tensile strength of the steel plate, Swift coefficient K, n value, and plate thickness, it can be calculated, for example, using the following approximation formula. In conclusion, it was found that the limit bending maximum principal strain leading to fracture due to effects such as necking becomes larger than the n value, so the lower limit of the fracture limit line increases, and that this increases as the element size becomes smaller. ε * =k1 M -K2 however, ε * : Tensile limit strain, M: Element size K1: Function of tensile strength K2: Function of tensile strength, Swift coefficient K, n value, and plate thickness
[0039] The upper limit of the fracture limit line corresponds to the maximum principal strain on the outer side at the limit VDA bending angle of the material being evaluated. Therefore, using the relationship between the element size and the maximum principal strain on the outer side at the limit VDA bending angle shown below, the upper limit of the maximum principal strain on the outer side at the limit VDA bending angle according to the element size of the model being evaluated can be determined.
[0040] First, the maximum principal strain on the outer side of bending at fracture (when the critical VDA bending angle is obtained) can be expressed as a function of the critical VDA bending angle and plate thickness, regardless of the steel type. For example, the following formula is proposed in Patent Document 3. εs=d·ln(α)+e εs: Maximum principal strain on the outer side of bending at break α: Limit VDA bending angle d, e: Coefficients expressed as a function of plate thickness t. For example, they can be expressed as a polynomial of plate thickness t.
[0041] Next, the maximum principal strain on the outer side of the bending in the FEM analysis can be expressed as a function of the element size, plate thickness, and the maximum principal strain on the outer side of the bending at the time of fracture described above. For example, the following formula has been proposed (Patent Document 3): εc=aM b +c εc: Maximum principal strain of outer surface layer corresponding to element size M: Element size a, b, c: Coefficients expressed as a function of the above εc (maximum principal strain on the outer side of bending at break) and plate thickness t. For example, they can be expressed as a linear equation consisting of plate thickness t and εc.
[0042] Detailed calculations are omitted, but in conclusion, it was found that the smaller the element size, the closer the maximum value of the fracture limit line is to the maximum principal bending strain limit, and the larger the element size, the lower the maximum value of the fracture limit line is.
[0043] [Fracture determination by converting strain into stress] In general, the fracture limit line assuming strain is based on proportional load, i.e., on the assumption that bending deformation progresses in a single direction, and it is known that if the bending direction changes during deformation or if the bending direction is changed, the fracture limit also changes and the fracture limit is not uniquely determined. In contrast, when considering the collision deformation of an automobile, automobile parts are generally formed by press molding, and the strain applied during collision is likely to be in a different direction from the direction of the strain received during press molding, and when the strain applied during molding is also taken into consideration, the deformation path changes during collision, and when the fracture limit line assuming strain is used, there are cases in which fracture cannot be predicted with sufficient accuracy.
[0044] It is known that stress is a value that increases reflecting the result of work hardening, and even if the deformation path changes during deformation, it is a value that increases according to the accumulation of strain, and the fracture limit is uniquely determined. In addition, strain can be converted to stress using the general strain increment theory, in which the direction of strain increment coincides with the direction of deviatoric stress. In other words, in the process of determining the fracture limit function (fracture limit line), each value using strain is converted to stress, and then a fracture limit function (fracture limit line) based on stress can be determined. At the same time, in the process of acquiring the state of each element by deformation analysis using FEM, strain is replaced with stress, the maximum principal stress of the bending outer surface layer is acquired, and the gradient of the principal stress in the plate thickness direction is acquired, and it is possible to judge whether or not fracture will occur in the member in collision deformation by comparing with the fracture limit function (fracture limit line) replaced with the stress. When fracture is predicted by converting it into stress, it is possible to accurately predict fracture even if the deformation path changes.
[0045] Specifically, the index derived from the above-described strain is replaced with stress to obtain the following index related to the principal stress, and the fracture is judged. That is, by the test in which the above-described tensile load and bending deformation are simultaneously applied, Obtain the relationship between the fracture limit gradient and plate thickness due to the principal stress, - Understand the tensile limit stress at the time of tensile breakage in a tensile test (plane strain field) - Determine the relationship between the fracture limit slope and plate thickness, On the principal stress-stress gradient plane, the fracture limit line is determined with the tensile limit stress as the vertical intercept and the fracture limit gradient as the slope.
[0046] Next, FEM deformation analysis is used to determine the maximum principal stress of the element of interest and the principal stress gradient in the plate thickness direction. The predicted principal fracture stress obtained from the fracture limit line according to the plate thickness and the determined principal stress gradient is then compared with the principal stress determined by FEM analysis to determine whether the element in question will fracture.
[0047] In other words, the tensile limit strain, bending limit maximum principal strain, and fracture limit gradient are converted into the tensile limit stress, bending limit maximum principal stress, and fracture limit stress gradient, and the thickness direction stress gradient, which is the gradient of the maximum principal stress at the bending outer surface layer and the maximum principal stress in the thickness direction, is obtained for each element of the component, and it is possible to determine whether the component has fractured.
[0048] moreover, -Relationship between the fracture limit gradient and n value due to principal stress, -Relationship between element size and plane strain tensile limit stress, The relationship between element size and the maximum principal stress on the outer surface of the bend at the critical VDA bending angle; By using the above, the accuracy of the determination of whether or not the breakage occurs can be improved.
[0049] [Step to output judgment result] The conclusion reached in the fracture determination step, i.e., the determination result as to whether or not the component has fractured, is output. There are no particular limitations on the output method. For example, in a deformation analysis of a component using FEM, it is advisable to output the fractured component so that the fractured part can be seen. In this case, the fracture determination result is output by sending information that a fracture has occurred to an analysis device incorporating FEM.
[0050] [Breakage detection device] Next, a component fracture determination device according to the present invention will be described using one embodiment as an example. This embodiment is an apparatus that executes the embodiment of the component fracture determination method described above, and the content is the same as the component fracture determination method described above. Therefore, the detailed description will be based on the component fracture determination method described above, and the description will focus on the characteristics of the apparatus.
[0051] FIG. 9 is a diagram showing a fracture determination device according to the embodiment. The fracture determination device 1 has a communication unit 11, a storage unit 12, an input unit 13, an output unit 14, and a processing unit 20. The communication unit 11, the storage unit 12, the input unit 13, the output unit 14, and the processing unit 20 are connected to each other via a bus 15. The fracture determination device 1 creates a fracture limit function (fracture limit fracture line) from the characteristic values of the steel material constituting the member and a VDA bending test, and executes a collision deformation simulation of an automobile body structure or the like by FEM. The fracture determination device 1 determines whether each of the elements will fracture or not from the bending outer maximum principal strain and the plate thickness direction strain gradient of each of the elements output by the collision deformation simulation based on the generated fracture limit function (fracture limit line). In one example, the fracture determination device 1 is a computer capable of executing a simulation by FEM.
[0052] The communication unit 11 has a wired communication interface circuit such as Ethernet (registered trademark) etc. The communication unit 11 communicates with a server (not shown) etc. via, for example, a LAN.
[0053] The storage unit 12 includes, for example, at least one of a semiconductor storage device, a magnetic tape device, a magnetic disk device, and an optical disk device. The storage unit 12 stores an operating system program, a driver program, an application program, data, and the like used for processing in the processing unit 20. For example, the storage unit 12 stores, as an application program, a breakage determination processing program for executing a breakage determination process for determining breakage of each element.
[0054] Furthermore, the storage unit 12 stores, as application programs, a collision deformation simulation program for executing a collision deformation simulation using FEM, etc. The fracture determination processing program and the collision deformation simulation program, etc. may be installed into the storage unit 12 using a known setup program, etc., from a computer-readable portable recording medium, such as a CD-ROM or a DVD-ROM.
[0055] The storage unit 12 also stores various data used in the breakage determination process and the collision deformation simulation. For example, the storage unit 12 stores input information 120 such as collision information used in the breakage determination process and the collision deformation simulation.
[0056] The input information 120 includes the material properties and plate thickness of the steel material, element size indicating the size of elements in a collision deformation simulation using FEM, shape information of the member to be analyzed (including the plate thickness of each part), information on the steel material constituting each part of the member, information on element division of the member, etc. The material properties of the steel material include tensile strength, Young's modulus, Poisson's ratio, density, n value, etc. It also includes VDA bending test information such as the VDA bending angle obtained when the steel material is subjected to a VDA bending test.
[0057] In addition, information about the fracture limit function (fracture limit line) generated by the fracture limit function generating unit is also temporarily stored in the storage unit. In another example, information about correction of the fracture limit function (fracture limit line), such as a correction coefficient of the fracture limit function (fracture limit line) based on the n value and a correction coefficient based on the element size, is included.
[0058] Furthermore, input data for a collision deformation simulation using FEM is also stored in the storage unit 12. Furthermore, the storage unit 12 may temporarily store temporary data related to a predetermined process.
[0059] The input unit 13 may be any device capable of inputting data, such as a touch panel or a keyboard. An operator can input characters, numbers, symbols, and the like using the input unit 13. When the input unit 13 is operated by an operator, it generates a signal corresponding to the operation. The generated signal is then supplied to the processing unit 20 as an instruction from the operator.
[0060] The output unit 14 may be any device capable of displaying video, images, etc., such as a liquid crystal display or an organic EL (Electro-Luminescence) display. The output unit 14 displays video corresponding to video data supplied from the processing unit 20, images corresponding to image data, etc. The output unit 14 may also be an output device that prints video, images, characters, etc. on a display medium such as paper.
[0061] The processing unit 20 has one or more processors and their peripheral circuits. The processing unit 20 centrally controls the overall operation of the fracture determination device 1, and is, for example, a CPU. The processing unit 20 executes processing based on programs (driver programs, operating system programs, application programs, etc.) stored in the storage unit 12. The processing unit 20 can also execute multiple programs (application programs, etc.) in parallel.
[0062] The processing unit 20 has an information acquisition unit 21, a fracture limit function generation unit 22, a member simulation execution unit 23, a fracture determination unit 24, and a determination result output unit 25. Each of these units is a functional module realized by a program executed by a processor included in the processing unit 20. Alternatively, each of these units may be implemented in the fracture determination device 1 as firmware.
[0063] The fracture limit function generating unit 22 realizes the function in the fracture limit generating step described in the fracture determination method in the fracture determination device.
[0064] The member simulation execution unit 23 realizes the function of the step of determining the bending outer maximum principal strain and the plate thickness direction strain gradient described in the fracture determination method within the fracture determination device.
[0065] The breakage determination unit 24 realizes the function of the step of determining whether or not a member is broken, explained in the breakage determination method, within the breakage determination device.
[0066] The determination result output unit 25 realizes the function of the step of outputting the determination result described in the above-mentioned breakage determination method in the breakage determination device.
[0067] The functions realized by the fracture limit function generating unit 22, the component simulation executing unit 23, the fracture judgment unit 24, and the judgment result output unit 25 in this fracture judgment device have been explained in the above-mentioned fracture judgment method, so the explanation will be omitted here.
[0068] The information acquisition unit 21 realizes the function of exchanging information (data) required and generated information with the memory unit 12, input unit 13, and output unit 14 so that the fracture limit function generation unit 22, component simulation execution unit 23, fracture judgment unit 24, and judgment result output unit 25 can realize their respective functions within the fracture judgment device.
[0069] [Break Judgment Program] An embodiment of a component fracture determination program according to the present invention is for causing a processing unit of the fracture determination device to execute the embodiment of the component fracture determination method in cooperation with each element of the fracture determination device, and the content of the program is the same as that of the component fracture determination method. Therefore, the detailed description will be based on the component fracture determination method and the fracture determination device. EXAMPLES
[0070] An embodiment of the present invention will be described. In a test apparatus 101 shown in Fig. 4 for simultaneously applying a tensile load and bending deformation, a punch 114 with a punch tip radius R115 of 4 mm was used to apply a tensile load 116 to both ends of a test piece 102 made of a 980 MPa steel plate with a thickness of 1.4 mm (n value = 0.12) until it broke. As a result, as shown in Fig. 6, breakage occurred at a tensile load 116 of 26.1 kN.
[0071] In response to this, the test in which the above-mentioned tensile load and bending deformation were applied simultaneously was reproduced by deformation analysis using FEM.The material properties were defined for the 980 MPa-class steel plate used in the experiment, modeled with a mesh size of 1 mm, and an FEM analysis model was constructed to match the above-mentioned test.
[0072] In addition, using these data and data obtained from the VDA bending test, the fracture limit line of 980 MPa class steel plate was previously determined in a plane (strain gradient-maximum principal strain plane) with the thickness direction strain gradient on the horizontal axis and the maximum principal strain on the outer side of the bend on the vertical axis, using the method described above.
[0073] In the deformation analysis using FEM, the strain gradient in the plate thickness direction of the element at the bend top of the test piece and the maximum principal strain on the outer side of the bend were obtained, and were sequentially compared with the fracture limit line of a 980 MPa-class steel plate to determine the tensile load at the timing when the fracture limit line was exceeded, which was 27.1 kN. In other words, the tensile load at fracture in the FEM analysis according to the present invention was 27.1 kN, whereas the tensile load at fracture in the experiment was 26.1 kN, confirming that it was possible to predict very close results.
[0074] On the other hand, as a comparative example, we also verified a conventional method that does not take into account the strain gradient in the plate thickness direction and simply predicts fracture when the maximum principal strain on the outer side of the bend reaches the tensile limit strain (i.e., n value = 0.12). In this case, fracture was predicted earlier than in the experiment, and the tensile load at that time was 19.9 kN.
[0075] We also verified a conventional method that does not take into account the strain gradient in the plate thickness direction, but simply predicts that the fracture will occur when the maximum principal strain on the outer side of the bend reaches the limit maximum principal strain obtained in the VDA bending test. In this case, the fracture was predicted to occur later than in the experiment, and the tensile load at that time was 30.1 kN.
[0076] In all of the conventional methods, the difference between the tensile load at break obtained in the experiment and the actual tensile load was large, and the experimental results could not be predicted with a high degree of accuracy. The results are shown in Figure 6.
[0077] Next, the results of a similar test performed on a 980 MPa class steel plate (n value = 0.12) with a plate thickness of 2.0 mm are shown in Figure 7. The tensile load at break determined in the experiment was 34.2 kN, while the FEM analysis according to the present invention gave a value of 33.9 kN. As a comparison example, when judged using the tensile limit strain, which is the conventional method, the value was 27.8 kN, and when judged using the maximum principal bending limit strain, the value was 40.9 kN. It was confirmed that accuracy was greatly improved by applying the FEM analysis according to the present invention.
[0078] Furthermore, FIG. 8 shows the results of a similar test performed on a 1500 MPa class steel plate (meaning a steel plate with a tensile strength of 1500 MPa to 1650 MPa) (n value = 0.07) with a thickness of 1.4 mm. The tensile load at break was 29.8 kN obtained in the experiment, whereas the FEM analysis according to the present invention gave a value of 29.9 kN. As a comparative example, when judged using the tensile limit strain, which is the conventional method, the value was 28.8 kN, and when judged using the maximum principal bending limit strain, the value was 38.9 kN. It was confirmed that the accuracy was greatly improved by applying the FEM analysis according to the present invention.
[0079] From these results, it was confirmed that the experimental breaking load can be predicted with high accuracy by applying the present invention. [Industrial Applicability]
[0080] The present invention can be applied to the analysis of complex deformation such as the collision deformation of components, and can be used in, for example, the automobile industry, the machinery industry, and the civil engineering and construction industry. [Explanation of symbols]
[0081] 1. Fracture detection device 11 Communications Department 12 Storage section 13 Input section 14 Output section 15 Bus 20 Processing section 21 Information Acquisition Department 22 Breaking limit function generator 23 Component Simulation Execution Department 24 Breakage Judgment Section 25 Judgment result output section 101 Test equipment for simultaneously applying tensile load and bending deformation 102 Test Piece 111 Maximum principal strain of outer surface layer of bending 112 Maximum principal strain at thickness center 113 Test piece center line 114 Punch 115 Punch tip R (radius) 116 Tensile Load 117 rolls t Plate thickness
Claims
1. A method for determining fracture of a member by deformation analysis using a finite element method (FEM), comprising the steps of: (a) a limiting maximum principal strain, which is a maximum principal strain value at an outer surface layer of a test piece when the test piece made of the material constituting the member breaks in a VDA bending test; and The relationship between the bending outer maximum principal strain, which is the maximum principal strain at the bending outer surface layer of the test piece at the time of fracture in a test in which a tensile load and a bending deformation are simultaneously applied to the test piece, and the plate thickness direction strain gradient, which is the gradient of the maximum principal strain in the plate thickness direction; A step of determining a fracture limit function, which is a function of the maximum principal strain on the outer side of bending with respect to the strain gradient in the thickness direction according to the thickness, from the n value, which is the work hardening exponent of the material, and the thickness of the test piece; (b) determining a bending maximum principal strain and a thickness direction strain gradient for each element of the member by a deformation analysis of the member using a finite element method; (c) for each of the elements, the thickness direction strain gradient obtained by the deformation analysis using the finite element method and the bending outer maximum principal strain obtained from the fracture limit function according to the plate thickness of the member; The bending outer maximum principal strain obtained by the deformation analysis using the finite element method is compared, determining whether the member is broken; (d) outputting a determination result as to whether the member is broken; A method for determining fracture of a member, comprising:
2. In the step of determining the fracture limit function, The limit maximum principal bending strain at the time of fracture in the VDA bending test is determined from the limit VDA bending angle of the test piece at the time of fracture in the VDA bending test and a finite element method; In the strain gradient-maximum principal strain plane, which is a plane with the plate thickness direction strain gradient on the horizontal axis and the bending outer maximum principal strain on the vertical axis, When the breaking limit function is a linear function, the slope of the breaking limit function is defined as the breaking limit gradient. Passing through the point of the n value that is the intercept of the vertical axis, The fracture limit gradient corresponding to the plate thickness of the test piece obtained from the previously obtained relationship between the plate thickness and the fracture limit gradient is set as a gradient, and a fracture limit line is obtained which is a line segment having an upper limit equal to the limit bending maximum principal strain; The method for determining fracture of a member according to claim 1 , wherein the fracture limit line is the fracture limit function.
3. 3. The method for determining fracture of a member according to claim 2, further comprising correcting the fracture limit gradient based on a previously determined relationship between the n value and the fracture limit gradient and the n value of the material of the member.
4. The tensile limit strain corresponding to the element size used in the deformation analysis of the FEM is calculated based on a relationship between the element size in the FEM analysis, which is previously calculated, and a tensile limit strain, which is a maximum principal strain at the time of tensile fracture in a tensile test of the material of the member, and the calculated tensile limit strain is set as a lower limit value of the fracture limit function; and The method for determining fracture of a member according to any one of claims 1 to 3, further comprising: determining a limit maximum principal bending strain corresponding to the element size used in the FEM deformation analysis based on a relationship between the element size in the FEM analysis and the limit maximum principal bending strain of the material of the member, the limit maximum principal bending strain being set as an upper limit value of the fracture limit function.
5. A method for determining whether a component is broken according to any one of claims 1 to 3, comprising converting the limit bending maximum principal strain and the fracture limit function into a tensile limit stress, a limit bending maximum principal stress, and a fracture limit stress function based on a relationship between the strain and stress of the material of the component, determining a thickness direction stress gradient, which is a gradient of the maximum principal stress at the bending outer surface layer and the maximum principal stress in the thickness direction, for each element of the component, and determining whether the component is broken.
6. 5. A method for determining whether a component has fractured as described in claim 4, further comprising converting the tensile limit strain, the bending maximum principal strain limit, and the fracture limit function into a tensile limit stress, a bending maximum principal stress limit, and a fracture limit stress function based on a relationship between strain and stress of the material of the component, determining a thickness direction stress gradient, which is a gradient of the maximum principal stress at the bending outer surface layer and the maximum principal stress in the thickness direction, for each element of the component, and determining whether the component has fractured.
7. The method for determining fracture of a member according to any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein the member is a steel material having a tensile strength of 980 MPa or more.
8. A device for determining fracture of a member by deformation analysis using a finite element method (FEM), (a) a limiting maximum principal strain, which is a maximum principal strain value at an outer surface layer of a test piece when the test piece made of the material constituting the member breaks in a VDA bending test; and The relationship between the bending outer maximum principal strain, which is the maximum principal strain at the bending outer surface layer of the test piece at the time of fracture in a test in which a tensile load and a bending deformation are simultaneously applied to the test piece, and the plate thickness direction strain gradient, which is the gradient of the maximum principal strain in the plate thickness direction; A fracture limit function generating unit that generates a fracture limit function, which is a function of a bending outer maximum principal strain with respect to a thickness direction strain gradient according to the thickness, from an n value that is a work hardening exponent of the material and a thickness of the test piece; (b) a member simulation execution unit that calculates a bending outer maximum principal strain and the plate thickness direction strain gradient for each element of the member by a deformation analysis of the member using a finite element method; (c) for each element, the bending outer maximum principal strain obtained from the plate thickness direction strain gradient obtained by the member simulation execution unit and the fracture limit function according to the plate thickness of the member obtained by the fracture limit function generation unit; The maximum principal strain on the outer side of the bending calculated by the member simulation execution unit is compared, a breakage determination unit that determines whether the member is broken; (d) an output unit that outputs a determination result as to whether the member is broken or not; A component fracture determination device comprising:
9. In the breaking limit function generating unit, The limit maximum principal bending strain at the time of fracture in the VDA bending test is determined from the limit VDA bending angle of the test piece at the time of fracture in the VDA bending test and a finite element method; In the strain gradient-maximum principal strain plane, which is a plane with the plate thickness direction strain gradient on the horizontal axis and the maximum principal strain of the bending outer surface layer on the vertical axis, When the breaking limit function is a linear function, the slope of the breaking limit function is defined as the breaking limit gradient. Passing through the point of the n value that is the intercept of the vertical axis, The fracture limit gradient corresponding to the plate thickness of the test piece obtained from the previously obtained relationship between the plate thickness and the fracture limit gradient is set as a gradient, and a fracture limit line is obtained which is a line segment having an upper limit equal to the limit bending maximum principal strain; The member fracture determination device according to claim 8 , wherein the fracture limit line is the fracture limit function.
10. In the breaking limit function generating unit, 10. The component fracture determination device according to claim 9, wherein the fracture limit gradient is corrected based on a previously determined relationship between the n value and the fracture limit gradient and the n value of the material of the component.
11. In the breaking limit function generating unit, The tensile limit strain corresponding to the element size used in the deformation analysis of the FEM is calculated based on a relationship between the element size in the FEM analysis, which is previously calculated, and a tensile limit strain, which is a maximum principal strain at the time of tensile fracture in a tensile test of the material of the member, and the calculated tensile limit strain is set as a lower limit value of the fracture limit function; and The fracture determination device for a member according to any one of claims 8 to 10, further comprising: determining a limit maximum principal bending strain corresponding to the element size used in the FEM deformation analysis based on a relationship between the element size in the FEM analysis and the limit maximum principal bending strain of the material of the member, the limit maximum principal bending strain being set as an upper limit value of the fracture limit function.
12. The device for determining whether or not the component has broken is described in any one of claims 8 to 10, which converts the limit bending maximum principal strain and the fracture limit function into a tensile limit stress, a limit bending maximum principal stress, and a fracture limit stress function based on a relationship between the strain and stress of the material of the component, and determines a stress gradient in the plate thickness direction, which is a gradient of the maximum principal stress at the bending outer surface layer and the maximum principal stress in the plate thickness direction, for each element of the component, and determines whether or not the component has broken.
13. 12. The device for determining fracture of a member according to claim 11, wherein the tensile limit strain, the bending maximum principal strain limit, and the fracture limit function are converted into a tensile limit stress, a bending maximum principal stress limit, and a fracture limit stress function based on the relationship between strain and stress of the material of the member, and a thickness direction stress gradient, which is the gradient of the maximum principal stress at the bending outer surface layer and the maximum principal stress in the thickness direction, is determined for each element of the member, and whether or not the member has fractured is determined.
14. A program for determining fracture of a component by deformation analysis using the finite element method (FEM), (a) a limiting maximum principal strain, which is a maximum principal strain value at an outer surface layer of a test piece when the test piece made of the material constituting the member breaks in a VDA bending test; and The relationship between the bending outer maximum principal strain, which is the maximum principal strain at the bending outer surface layer of the test piece at the time of fracture in a test in which a tensile load and a bending deformation are simultaneously applied to the test piece, and the plate thickness direction strain gradient, which is the gradient of the maximum principal strain in the plate thickness direction; A fracture limit function is generated from the work hardening exponent n value of the material and the thickness of the test piece, which is a function of the bending outer maximum principal strain with respect to the thickness direction strain gradient according to the thickness; (b) generating a bending maximum principal strain and a thickness direction strain gradient for each element of the member by a deformation analysis of the member using a finite element method; (c) for each of the elements, the thickness direction strain gradient obtained by the deformation analysis using the finite element method, and the bending outer maximum principal strain obtained from the fracture limit function according to the plate thickness of the member; The bending outer maximum principal strain obtained by the deformation analysis using the finite element method is compared, determining whether the member is broken; (d) outputting a determination result as to whether the member is broken or not; A component fracture determination program that causes a computer to execute a process.
15. When generating the fracture limit function, The limit maximum principal bending strain at the time of fracture in the VDA bending test is determined from the limit VDA bending angle of the test piece at the time of fracture in the VDA bending test and a finite element method; In the strain gradient-maximum principal strain plane, which is a plane with the plate thickness direction strain gradient on the horizontal axis and the bending outer maximum principal strain on the vertical axis, When the breaking limit function is a linear function, the slope of the breaking limit function is defined as the breaking limit gradient. Passing through the point of the n value that is the intercept of the vertical axis, The fracture limit gradient corresponding to the plate thickness of the test piece obtained from the previously obtained relationship between the plate thickness and the fracture limit gradient is set as a gradient, and a fracture limit line is obtained which is a line segment having an upper limit equal to the limit bending maximum principal strain; The member fracture determination program according to claim 14 , wherein the fracture limit line is set as the fracture limit function.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Method and device for breaking estimation, program and recording medium
JP2007232715A
Method for specifying limit strain of elongation flange, and method for determining press forming acceptance / rejection
JP2014115269A
Fracture prediction method, fracture prediction device, and program
JP2019158415A
Testing method of bending stress and testing apparatus thereof
US20140174195A1
Steel material fracture prediction method, fracture prediction device, program, and recording medium
WO2020204059A1
Cited By
Bending test method for rolling forming limit
CN119915650A
Fracture prediction method and device, program, and recording medium
JP2025130073A
Fracture prediction method and device, program and recording medium
JP7791496B2
