Validating the sensor assembly using parameters of the sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly
By using sensor signal parameters to validate vibratory meter assemblies, changes in conduit properties are detected in real-time, ensuring accurate measurements and reducing process disruptions.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2024533788
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2021-12-06
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-19
- Estimated Expiration
- 2041-12-06
AI Technical Summary
Vibratory meters, such as Coriolis flowmeters, face challenges due to changes in conduit properties over time, such as erosion, corrosion, or coating, which affect measurement accuracy by altering the conduit's mechanical properties, leading to measurement bias.
Meter electronics validate the sensor assembly using parameters of the sensor signal, calculating relationships between sensor signals to detect changes in conduit properties by comparing current values to baseline values, allowing for real-time monitoring without interrupting the process.
This method enables accurate and continuous validation of sensor assemblies, detecting changes in conduit properties like stiffness, residual flexibility, and damping, thereby maintaining measurement accuracy and reducing process interruptions.
Smart Images

Figure 2024543229000001_ABST
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The embodiments described below relate to validating a sensor assembly in a vibratory meter, and more particularly, to validating the sensor assembly using a sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly. [Background technology]
[0002] Vibratory meters, such as, for example, Coriolis mass flow meters, liquid densitometers, gas densitometers, liquid viscometers, gas / liquid specific gravity meters, gas / liquid relative density meters, and gas molecular weight meters, are commonly known and used to measure fluid parameters. Generally, a vibratory meter comprises a sensor assembly and meter electronics. The sensor assembly may be communicatively coupled to the meter electronics and provide a sensor signal to the meter electronics. The sensor assembly may include a conduit configured to vibrate in response to a driving force imposed by an actuator that receives a drive signal from the meter electronics. The actuator may be referred to as a driver.
[0003] When a conduit is used in a sensor assembly, the conduit may be filled with a material having a property to be measured. The material in one or more conduits of the sensor assembly may be flowing or stationary. The sensor assembly may be used to measure one or more fluid parameters, such as mass flow rate, density, or other properties of the material in the sensor assembly. More specifically, there may be one or more transducers attached to one or more conduits that are configured to convert vibrational motion into a sensor signal. These transducers may be referred to as pick-off sensors. Pick-off sensors are generally located at the inlet and outlet portions of one or more conduits.
[0004] As mentioned above, the vibratory meter may be a Coriolis flowmeter. A Coriolis flowmeter includes one or more conduits connected in line in a pipeline or other transport system to carry materials, such as fluids, slurries, and / or the like, in the system. Each conduit may be considered to have a set of natural vibration modes, including, for example, simple bending, torsional, radial, and coupled modes. In a Coriolis flow measurement application, the conduit is excited in one or more vibration modes as material flows through the conduit, and the motion of the conduit is measured at spaced points along the conduit. During flow, the vibrating tube and the flowing mass are coupled to each other by the Coriolis force, causing a phase difference in vibration between the ends of the tube. The phase difference may be directly proportional to the mass flow rate and may be measured as the phase difference between two sensor signals provided by pick-off sensors.
[0005] For example, the mass flow rate of a material may be proportional to the phase difference or time delay between two sensor signals, where the time delay may include the phase difference divided by the frequency. Thus, the mass flow rate may be determined, for example, by multiplying the time delay by a proportionality constant or calibration factor, which may be referred to as a flow calibration factor (FCF). The FCF may reflect the material and mechanical properties of the flow tube. The FCF may be determined by a calibration process prior to installation of the flow meter in a pipeline or other conduit. In the calibration process, a material is flowed through the conduit at a known flow rate, and the proportionality constant between the phase difference or time delay and the flow rate is calculated and recorded as the FCF.
[0006] One advantage of Coriolis flowmeters is that the accuracy of the measured mass flow rate is not affected by wear of moving components in the flowmeter. More specifically, the only moving parts are the vibrating conduit and any sensors or transducers attached to the vibrating conduit. Nevertheless, there is a problem that the conduit may change over time. More specifically, changes in the conduit may cause changes in the mechanical properties of the conduit. For example, changes in the conduit may change the stiffness of the conduit from an initial representative stiffness value (or an original measured stiffness value) over the life of the vibrating flowmeter. The changes may be caused by erosion, corrosion, coating, damage, etc. As a result, the initial factory calibration value, sometimes called the reference factor or FCF value, may cause measurement bias over time as the conduit is corroded, eroded, or otherwise altered.
[0007] Thus, a change may be detected by calculating a stiffness value of the conduit and comparing it to a baseline stiffness value. This comparison may be referred to as validating the meter or sensor assembly. The baseline stiffness value may be determined at approximately the same time that the FCF is calculated. If the current stiffness value differs from the baseline stiffness value, a change may have occurred in the conduit. Other conduit parameters such as residual flexibility, sensor mass and damping may be used as well. However, calculating values for these and other conduit parameters may make real-time measurements difficult and may result in interruptions to the customer's process to perform the calculations. Calculating values for conduit parameters may be avoided by somehow using parameters of the sensor signal to detect changes in one or more conduits of the sensor assembly. Thus, to validate the sensor assembly, it is necessary to use parameters of the sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly. Summary of the Invention
[0008] Meter electronics are provided for validating a sensor assembly using parameters of sensor signals provided by the sensor assembly. According to one embodiment, the meter electronics includes an interface communicatively coupled to the sensor assembly, the interface configured to receive two sensor signals, and a processing system communicatively coupled to the interface. The processing system is configured to calculate a sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals and compare the calculated sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals to a baseline sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals.
[0009] A method is provided for using parameters of sensor signals provided by a sensor assembly to validate the sensor assembly. According to one embodiment, the method includes calculating a sensor signal parameter relationship value between two sensor signals and comparing the calculated sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals to a baseline sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals.
[0010] Meter electronics are provided for validating a sensor assembly using parameters of a sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly. According to one embodiment, the meter electronics comprises an interface configured to receive a left pickoff sensor signal and a right pickoff sensor signal from the meter assembly, and a processing system communicatively coupled to the interface. The processing system is configured to determine a current first sensor assembly validation value and a current second sensor assembly validation value, compare the current first sensor assembly validation value to a first baseline sensor assembly validation value to determine a first sensor assembly validation shift, and compare the current second sensor assembly validation value to a second baseline sensor assembly validation value to determine a second sensor assembly validation shift, and determine a condition of the conduit based on the first sensor assembly validation shift and the second sensor assembly validation shift. At least one of the current first sensor assembly validation value and the current second sensor assembly validation value comprises a sensor signal parameter relationship value.
[0011] Meter electronics are provided for validating a sensor assembly using a parameter of a sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly. According to a first embodiment, the method includes determining a current first sensor assembly validation value and a current second sensor assembly validation value, comparing the current first sensor assembly validation value to a first baseline sensor assembly validation value to determine a first sensor assembly validation shift, comparing the current second sensor assembly validation value to a second baseline sensor assembly validation value to determine a second sensor assembly validation shift, and determining a condition of the conduit based on the first sensor assembly validation shift and the second sensor assembly validation shift. At least one of the current first sensor assembly validation value and the current second sensor assembly validation value comprises a sensor signal parameter related value.
[0012] Meter electronics are provided for validating a sensor assembly using parameters of a sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly. According to one embodiment, the meter electronics comprises a processing system including a storage system configured to store a central tendency value of the sensor assembly validation values and a variance value of the sensor assembly validation values. The processing system is configured to retrieve the central tendency value and the variance value from the storage system and determine a probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value to detect whether the central tendency value differs from a baseline sensor assembly validation value. The sensor assembly validation value is based on a sensor signal parameter value.
[0013] Meter electronics are provided for validating a sensor assembly using parameters of a sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly. According to one embodiment, the method includes obtaining a central tendency value of the sensor assembly validation value and a variance value of the sensor assembly validation value from storage in the meter electronics of the vibratory meter, and determining a probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value to determine whether the central tendency value differs from a baseline of sensor assembly validation values. The baseline sensor assembly validation value is based on the sensor signal parameter values.
[0014] Aspects According to one aspect, meter electronics for validating a sensor assembly using parameters of sensor signals provided by the sensor assembly includes an interface communicatively coupled to the sensor assembly, the interface configured to receive two sensor signals, and a processing system communicatively coupled to the interface, the processing system configured to calculate a sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals and compare the calculated sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals to a baseline sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals.
[0015] Preferably, the meter electronics being configured to calculate a sensor signal parameter relationship value between two sensor signals includes the meter electronics being configured to calculate a sensor signal parameter relationship value between a left pickoff sensor signal voltage value and a right pickoff sensor signal voltage value.
[0016] Preferably, the meter electronics being configured to calculate a sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals includes the meter electronics being configured to calculate one of a ratio and a difference between two sensor signal parameter values of the two sensor signals.
[0017] Preferably, the meter electronics being configured to compare the calculated sensor signal parameter relationship value with the baseline sensor signal parameter relationship value includes the meter electronics being configured to calculate a difference between the calculated sensor signal parameter relationship value and the baseline sensor signal parameter relationship value.
[0018] Preferably, the two sensor signals include two of a drive signal, a left pickoff sensor signal, and a right pickoff sensor signal.
[0019] Preferably, the meter electronics is further configured to determine a status of the sensor assembly based on a comparison of the calculated sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals and a baseline sensor signal parameter relationship value.
[0020] According to one aspect, a method for validating a sensor assembly using parameters of sensor signals provided by the sensor assembly includes calculating a sensor signal parameter relationship value between two sensor signals and comparing the calculated sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals to a baseline sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals.
[0021] Preferably, calculating a sensor signal parameter relationship value between two sensor signals includes calculating a sensor signal parameter relationship value between a left pickoff sensor signal voltage value and a right pickoff sensor signal voltage value.
[0022] Preferably, calculating a sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals comprises calculating one of a ratio and a difference between two sensor signal parameter values of the two sensor signals.
[0023] Preferably, comparing the calculated sensor signal parameter relationship value with the baseline sensor signal parameter relationship value includes calculating a difference between the calculated sensor signal parameter relationship value and the baseline sensor signal parameter relationship value.
[0024] Preferably, the two sensor signals include two of a drive signal, a left pickoff sensor signal, and a right pickoff sensor signal.
[0025] Preferably, the method further comprises determining a state of the sensor assembly based on a comparison of the calculated sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals and a baseline sensor signal parameter relationship value.
[0026] According to one aspect, meter electronics for validating a sensor assembly using parameters of a sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly includes an interface configured to receive a left pickoff sensor signal and a right pickoff sensor signal from the meter assembly, and a processing system communicatively coupled to the interface. The processing system is configured to determine a current first sensor assembly validation value and a current second sensor assembly validation value, compare the current first sensor assembly validation value to a first baseline sensor assembly validation value to determine a first sensor assembly validation shift, and compare the current second sensor assembly validation value to a second baseline sensor assembly validation value to determine a second sensor assembly validation shift, and determine a condition of the conduit based on the first sensor assembly validation shift and the second sensor assembly validation shift. At least one of the current first sensor assembly validation value and the current second sensor assembly validation value comprises a sensor signal parameter relationship value.
[0027] Preferably, the first sensor assembly validation shift represents a physical stiffness change in the conduit between the driver and the left pickoff, and the second sensor assembly validation shift represents a physical stiffness change in the conduit between the driver and the right pickoff.
[0028] Preferably, the sensor signal parameter relationship value is one of a ratio and a difference of two sensor signal parameter values.
[0029] Preferably, the sensor signal parameter relationship value is determined based on two of a left pickoff sensor signal parameter, a right pickoff sensor signal parameter, and a drive signal parameter.
[0030] Preferably, the processing system is further configured to provide an alarm based on the determined condition of the conduit.
[0031] Preferably, the condition of the conduit includes at least one of erosion, corrosion, damage, and coating of the conduit of the sensor assembly.
[0032] Preferably, the processing system is further configured to determine a condition of the conduit based on at least one of the stiffness, residual flexibility, damping, and mass of the conduit.
[0033] According to one aspect, a method for validating a sensor assembly using a parameter of a sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly includes determining a current first sensor assembly validation value and a current second sensor assembly validation value, comparing the current first sensor assembly validation value to a first baseline sensor assembly validation value to determine a first sensor assembly validation shift, comparing the current second sensor assembly validation value to a second baseline sensor assembly validation value to determine a second sensor assembly validation shift, and determining a condition of the conduit based on the first sensor assembly validation shift and the second sensor assembly validation shift, wherein at least one of the current first sensor assembly validation value and the current second sensor assembly validation value comprises a sensor signal parameter relationship value.
[0034] Preferably, the first sensor assembly validation shift represents a physical stiffness change in the conduit between the driver and the left pickoff sensor, and the second sensor assembly validation shift represents a physical stiffness change in the conduit between the driver and the right pickoff sensor.
[0035] Preferably, the sensor signal parameter relationship value is one of a ratio and a difference of two sensor signal parameter values.
[0036] Preferably, the sensor signal parameter relationship value is determined based on two of a left pickoff sensor signal parameter, a right pickoff sensor signal parameter, and a drive signal parameter.
[0037] Preferably, the method further comprises providing an alarm based on the determination of the condition of the conduit.
[0038] Preferably, the conduit condition includes at least one of erosion, corrosion, damage, and coating of the vibratory meter conduit.
[0039] According to one aspect, a meter electronics for validating a sensor assembly using parameters of a sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly includes a processing system including a storage system configured to store a central tendency value of the sensor assembly validation values and a variance value of the sensor assembly validation values. The processing system is configured to retrieve the central tendency value and the variance value from the storage system and determine a probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value to detect whether the central tendency value differs from a baseline sensor assembly validation value. The baseline sensor assembly validation value is based on the sensor signal parameter value.
[0040] Preferably, the sensor assembly validation value is one of an LPO / RPO voltage ratio value, a DRV / LPO voltage ratio value, and a DRV / RPO voltage ratio value.
[0041] Preferably, the processing system being configured to determine the probability based on the central tendency value and the dispersion value comprises the processing system being configured to calculate a t-value and to calculate said probability using the t-value.
[0042] Preferably, the processing system being configured to determine the probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value includes the processing system being configured to calculate the degrees of freedom based on a number of sensor assembly validation measurements.
[0043] Preferably, being configured with a processing system to determine a probability based on a central tendency value and a dispersion value includes being configured with a processing system to calculate a standard error based on a standard deviation and degrees of freedom.
[0044] Preferably, the standard error is calculated using the following formula:
number
[0045] Preferably, the variance value is a pooled standard deviation that includes the standard deviation of the sensor assembly validation measurement and the baseline sensor assembly validation measurement.
[0046] Preferably, the probabilities include confidence intervals for the central tendency values.
[0047] Preferably, the confidence interval is compared to 0 to detect if the confidence interval does not include 0, and to detect if the central tendency value is not equal to the baseline sensor assembly validation value, and if the confidence interval includes 0, to detect that the central tendency value is equal to the baseline sensor assembly validation value.
[0048] Preferably, the central tendency value is the sensor assembly validation value and the confidence interval for the sensor assembly validation value is calculated using the following formula: CI=SV mean ±CI range ; Where: CI is the confidence interval of the sensor assembly validation value, S.V. mean is the sensor assembly validation value obtained from the storage system; CI range is the confidence interval range calculated based on the standard deviation and t-value.
[0049] Preferably, the confidence interval range is calculated using the following formula: CI range =stderror pooled ·t student,99.8 ; Where: stderror pooled is the pooled standard error of the sensor assembly validation measurements, t student,99.8is a t-value calculated based on the significance level and degrees of freedom determined from several sensor assembly validation measurements, including the sensor assembly validation value.
[0050] Preferably, the processing system is further configured to set a bias deadband, and if the central tendency value is less than the bias deadband, the sensor assembly validation value is not detected as different from the baseline sensor assembly validation value.
[0051] Preferably, the processing system being configured to determine a probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value comprises the processing system being configured to determine a confidence interval based on the central tendency value and the variance value.
[0052] Preferably, the baseline sensor assembly validation values include a central tendency value and a variance value of the baseline sensor assembly validation values.
[0053] Preferably, the central tendency value of the baseline sensor assembly validation values is the mean of the baseline sensor assembly validation values and the variance value of the baseline sensor assembly validation values is the standard deviation of the baseline sensor assembly validation values.
[0054] Preferably, the meter electronics being configured to detect whether the central tendency value differs from a baseline sensor assembly validation value includes the meter electronics being configured to determine whether a probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value does not overlap with a probability of the baseline sensor assembly validation value.
[0055] Preferably, the probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value includes a confidence interval determined based on the central tendency value and the variance value, and the probability of the baseline sensor assembly validation value includes a confidence interval determined based on the baseline sensor assembly validation measurements.
[0056] Preferably, the meter electronics is configured to determine whether the probability based on the central tendency value overlaps with the probability of the baseline sensor assembly verification value according to the following formula, that is, LHS = |μ measured - μ baseline |; RHS = 2 * (σ measured - σ baseline ); calculate and, when LHS < RHS, determine that the probability of the central tendency value and the variance value obtained from the memory system overlaps with the probability of the baseline sensor assembly verification value. This includes that the meter electronics is configured as such.
[0057] Preferably, the baseline standard deviation is calculated according to the following formula. σ baseline = dead band * μ baseline
[0058] According to one aspect, a method for verifying a sensor assembly using parameters of a sensor signal supplied by the sensor assembly includes obtaining a central tendency value of a sensor assembly verification value and a variance value of the sensor assembly verification value from a storage device in meter electronics of a vibratory meter, and determining a probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value to determine whether the central tendency value is different from a baseline sensor assembly verification value. The baseline sensor assembly verification value is based on sensor signal parameter values.
[0059] Preferably, the sensor assembly verification value is one of an LPO / RPO voltage ratio value, a DRV / LPO voltage ratio value, and a DRV / RPO voltage ratio value.
[0060] Preferably, determining the probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value includes calculating a t-value and calculating the probability using the t-value.
[0061] Preferably, determining the probability based on the central tendency and variance values includes calculating the degrees of freedom based on several sensor assembly validation measurements.
[0062] Preferably, determining the probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value includes calculating a standard error based on the standard deviation and the degrees of freedom.
[0063] Preferably, the standard error is calculated using the following formula:
number
[0064] Preferably, the variance value is a pooled standard deviation that includes the standard deviation of the sensor assembly validation measurement and the baseline sensor assembly validation measurement.
[0065] Preferably, the probabilities include confidence intervals for the central tendency values.
[0066] Preferably, the confidence interval is compared to 0 to detect if the confidence interval does not include 0, and to detect if the central tendency value is not equal to the baseline sensor assembly validation value, and if the confidence interval includes 0, to detect that the central tendency value is equal to the baseline sensor assembly validation value.
[0067] Preferably, the central tendency value is the sensor assembly validation value and the confidence interval for the sensor assembly validation value is calculated using the following formula: CI=SV mean ±CI range ; Where: CI is the confidence interval of the sensor assembly validation value, S.V. mean is the sensor assembly validation value obtained from the storage system (204), CI rangeis the confidence interval range calculated based on the standard deviation and t-value.
[0068] Preferably, the confidence interval range is calculated using the following formula: CI range =stderror pooled ·t student,99.8 ; Where: stderror pooled is the pooled standard error of the sensor assembly validation measurements, t student,99.8 is a t-value calculated based on the significance level and degrees of freedom determined from several sensor assembly validation measurements, including the sensor assembly validation value.
[0069] Preferably, the method further comprises setting a bias deadband, where if the central tendency value is less than the bias deadband, the sensor assembly validation value is not detected as different from the baseline sensor assembly validation value.
[0070] Preferably, determining a probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value includes determining a confidence interval based on the central tendency value and the variance value.
[0071] Preferably, the baseline sensor assembly validation values include a central tendency value and a variance value of the baseline sensor assembly validation values.
[0072] Preferably, the central tendency value of the baseline sensor assembly validation values is the mean of the baseline sensor assembly validation values and the variance value of the baseline sensor assembly validation values is the standard deviation of the baseline sensor assembly validation values.
[0073] Preferably, detecting whether the central tendency value differs from the baseline sensor assembly validation value includes determining whether a probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value does not overlap with a probability of the baseline sensor assembly validation value.
[0074] Preferably, the probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value includes a confidence interval determined based on the central tendency value and the variance value, and the probability of the baseline sensor assembly verification value includes a confidence interval determined based on the baseline sensor assembly verification measurement value.
[0075] Preferably, determining whether the probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value overlaps with the probability of the baseline sensor assembly verification value is based on the following formula, namely, LHS = |μ measured - μ baseline |; RHS = 2 * (σ measured - σ baseline ); calculating the following, and when LHS < RHS, determining that the probability of the central tendency value and the variance value obtained from the storage device overlaps with the probability of the baseline sensor assembly verification value. This includes.
[0076] Preferably, the standard deviation of the baseline system assembly verification value is calculated according to the following formula. σ baseline = dead band * μ baseline
Brief Description of the Drawings
[0077] The same reference numerals represent the same elements in all the drawings. It should be understood that the drawings are not necessarily drawn to scale. [Figure 1] A vibrating meter 5 configured to verify a sensor assembly using parameters of a sensor signal supplied by the sensor assembly is shown. [Diagram 2] A block diagram of a vibrating meter 5 is shown, including a block diagram representation of meter electronics 20 configured to verify a sensor assembly using parameters of a sensor signal supplied by the sensor assembly. [Diagram 3]1 illustrates meter electronics 20 configured to validate a sensor assembly using parameters of a sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly. [Figure 4] 4 shows a graph 400 illustrating the correspondence between the stiffness of a sensor assembly and the difference between sensor signal parameters. [Diagram 5] A method 500 is illustrated for validating a sensor assembly, such as the sensor assembly 10 described above, using a parameter of a sensor signal of the sensor assembly. [Figure 6] 6 illustrates a method 600 for validating a sensor assembly using a parameter of a sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly. [Figure 7] 7 illustrates a method 700 for validating a sensor assembly using a parameter of a sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0078] 1-7 and the following description provide specific examples to teach those skilled in the art how to make and use the best mode of embodiments for validating a sensor assembly using parameters of a sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly. For the purpose of teaching the principles of the invention, some conventional aspects have been simplified or omitted. Those skilled in the art may appreciate variations from these examples that fall within the scope of the present disclosure. As will be appreciated by those skilled in the art, the features described below can be combined in various ways to form multiple variations for detecting changes in the sensor assembly using a sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly. As a result, the embodiments described below are not limited to the specific examples described below, but are limited only by the claims and their equivalents.
[0079] FIG. 1 illustrates a vibratory meter 5 configured to validate a sensor assembly using parameters of a sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly. As shown in FIG. 1, the vibratory meter 5 includes a sensor assembly 10 and meter electronics 20. The sensor assembly 10 is responsive to mass flow rate and density of a process material. The meter electronics 20 is connected to the sensor assembly 10 via leads carrying a sensor signal 100. As can be appreciated, the sensor signal 100 includes an RTD signal, a drive signal, and left and right sensor signals. The meter electronics 20 may be configured to use the sensor signal 100 to calculate and provide density, mass flow rate, temperature information, and the like on a port 26.
[0080] The sensor assembly 10 includes a pair of manifolds 150 and 150', flanges 103 and 103' having flange necks 110 and 110', a pair of parallel conduits 130 and 130', a driver 180, a resistance temperature detector (RTD) 190, and a pair of pick-off sensors 170l and 170r. The conduits 130 and 130' have two essentially straight inlet legs 131, 131' and outlet legs 134, 134' that converge towards each other at the conduit mounting blocks 120 and 120'. The conduits 130, 130' bend at two symmetrical locations along their lengths and are essentially parallel throughout their lengths. The brace bars 140 and 140' function to define an axis W and W' about which each conduit 130, 130' oscillates. The legs 131, 131' and 134, 134' of the conduits 130, 130' are fixedly attached to conduit mounting blocks 120 and 120' which are fixedly attached to manifolds 150 and 150'. This provides a continuous, closed material path through the sensor assembly 10.
[0081] When flanges 103 and 103' having holes 102 and 102' are connected via inlet end 104 and outlet end 104' to a process line (not shown) carrying the process material being metered, the material enters the meter at inlet end 104 through orifice 101 in flange 103 and is directed through manifold 150 to conduit mounting block 120 having surface 121. Within manifold 150, the material is split and directed through conduits 130, 130'. Upon exiting conduits 130, 130', the process material is recombined into a single stream in block 120' having surface 121' and manifold 150' before being directed to outlet end 104' which is connected to the process line (not shown) by flange 103' having hole 102'.
[0082] The conduits 130, 130' are selected to have substantially the same mass distribution, moment of inertia and Young's modulus about bending axes WW and W'-W', respectively, and are appropriately mounted in the conduit mounting blocks 120, 120'. These bending axes pass through the brace bars 140, 140'. Insofar as the Young's modulus of the conduit changes with temperature and this change affects the flow rate and density calculations, an RTD 190 is mounted in the conduit 130' to continuously measure the temperature of the conduit 130'. The temperature of the conduit 130', and therefore the voltage appearing across the RTD 190 for a given current passing therethrough, is governed by the temperature of the material passing through the conduit 130'. The temperature dependent voltage appearing across the RTD 190 is used by the meter electronics 20 in a known manner to compensate for changes in the modulus of elasticity of the conduits 130, 130' due to any changes in the conduit temperature. The RTD 190 is connected to the meter electronics 20 by leads 195.
[0083] Both conduits 130, 130' are driven in opposite directions about their respective bending axes W and W' in what is called the first out-of-phase bending mode of the vibratory meter by a driver 180. This driver 180 may comprise any of a number of well known configurations, such as a magnet attached to conduit 130' and opposing coils attached to conduit 130 through which an alternating current flows to vibrate both conduits 130, 130'. An appropriate drive signal 185 is applied by the meter electronics 20 via leads to driver 180.
[0084] Meter electronics 20 receives the RTD temperature signal on lead 195 and the sensor signal 165 appearing on lead 100 carrying left and right sensor signals 165l, 165r, respectively. Meter electronics 20 generates a drive signal 185 appearing on a lead to driver 180 to vibrate conduits 130, 130'. Meter electronics 20 processes the left and right sensor signals 165l, 165r and the RTD signal from lead 195 to calculate the mass flow rate and density of material passing through sensor assembly 10. This information, along with other information, is applied by meter electronics 20 as a signal via path 26. A more detailed description of meter electronics 20 follows below.
[0085] FIGURE 2 illustrates a block diagram of a vibratory meter 5, including a block diagram representation of meter electronics 20 configured to validate the sensor assembly using parameters of a sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly. As shown in FIGURE 2, the meter electronics 20 is communicatively coupled to the sensor assembly 10. As previously described with reference to FIGURE 2, the sensor assembly 10 includes left and right pickoff sensors 170l, 170r, a driver 180, and a temperature sensor 190, which are communicatively coupled to the meter electronics 20 via a set of leads 100 over a communication channel 112.
[0086] The meter electronics 20 provides the drive signals 185 over the leads 100. More specifically, the meter electronics 20 provides the drive signals 185 to a driver 180 within the sensor assembly 10. Additionally, sensor signals 165, including a left sensor signal 165l and a right sensor signal 165r, are provided by the sensor assembly 10. More specifically, in the illustrated embodiment, the sensor signals 165 are provided by left and right pickoff sensors 170l, 170r within the sensor assembly 10. As can be appreciated, the sensor signals 165 are provided to the meter electronics 20 via the communication channel 112, respectively.
[0087] Meter electronics 20 includes a processor 210 communicatively coupled to one or more signal processors 220 and one or more memories 230. Processor 210 is also communicatively coupled to user interface 30. Processor 210 is communicatively coupled to a host via a communications port on port 26 and receives power via power port 250. Processor 210 may be a microprocessor, although any suitable processor may be used. For example, processor 210 may be comprised of sub-processors, such as a multi-core processor, a serial communications port, a peripheral interface (e.g., a serial peripheral interface), on-chip memory, I / O ports, and the like. In these and other embodiments, processor 210 is configured to perform operations on received and processed signals, such as digitized signals.
[0088] The processor 210 may receive the digitized sensor signal from one or more signal processors 220. The processor 210 may also be configured to provide information such as phase difference, characteristics of the fluid in the sensor assembly 10, etc. The processor 210 may provide the information to a host via a communication port. The processor 210 may also be configured to communicate with one or more memories 230 to receive and / or store information in the one or more memories 230. For example, the processor 210 may receive a calibration factor and / or a sensor assembly zero (e.g., a phase difference when the flow is zero) from the one or more memories 230. Each of the calibration factor and / or the sensor assembly zero may be associated with the vibratory meter 5 and / or the sensor assembly 10, respectively. The processor 210 may use the calibration factor to process the digitized sensor signal received from the one or more signal processors 220.
[0089] The one or more signal processors 220 are shown as consisting of an encoder / decoder (CODEC) 222 and an analog-to-digital converter (ADC) 226. The one or more signal processors 220 may condition an analog signal, digitize a conditioned analog signal, and / or provide a digitized signal. The CODEC 222 is configured to receive the sensor signal 165 from the left and right pickoff sensors 170l, 170r. The CODEC 222 is also configured to provide a drive signal 185 to the driver 180. In alternative embodiments, more or fewer signal processors may be used.
[0090] As shown, the sensor signal 165 is provided to the CODEC 222 via a signal conditioner 240. The drive signal 185 is provided to the driver 180 via the signal conditioner 240. Although the signal conditioner 240 is shown as a single block, the signal conditioner 240 may be comprised of signal conditioning components such as two or more op-amps, filters such as low-pass filters, voltage-to-current amplifiers, etc. For example, the sensor signal 165 may be amplified by a first amplifier and the drive signal 185 may be amplified by a voltage-to-current amplifier. The amplification may allow the magnitude of the sensor signal 165 to be close to the full-scale range of the CODEC 222.
[0091] In the illustrated embodiment, the one or more memories 230 are comprised of a read only memory (ROM) 232, a random access memory (RAM) 234, and a ferroelectric random access memory (FRAM®) 236. However, in alternative embodiments, the one or more memories 230 may be comprised of more or less memory. Additionally or alternatively, the one or more memories 230 may be comprised of different types of memory (e.g., volatile, non-volatile, etc.). For example, a different type of non-volatile memory, such as an erasable programmable read only memory (EPROM), may be employed in place of the FRAM 236. The one or more memories 230 may be storage devices configured to store process data, such as drive or sensor signals, mass flow or density measurements, etc.
[0092] Mass flow measurements can be generated according to the following equation:
number
number
[0093] The measured time delay Δt includes an operationally derived (i.e., measured) time delay value that includes a time delay present between pickoff sensor signals, for example, when the time delay is due to the Coriolis effect associated with the mass flow rate through the vibratory meter 5. The measured time delay Δt is a direct measurement of the mass flow rate of the flowing material as it flows through the vibratory meter 5. The zero flow time delay Δt0 includes a time delay at zero flow rate. The zero flow time delay Δt0 is a zero flow value that may be determined at the factory and programmed into the vibratory meter 5. The zero flow time delay Δt0 is an exemplary zero flow value. Other zero flow values, such as phase difference, time difference, etc., determined at the zero flow condition may be used. The value of the zero flow time delay Δt0 may not change even when flow conditions are changing. The mass flow rate value of the material flowing through the vibratory meter 5 is determined by multiplying the difference between the measured time delay Δt and a reference zero flow value Δt0 by a flow calibration factor FCF. The flow calibration factor FCF is proportional to the physical stiffness of the vibratory meter.
[0094] With respect to density, the resonant frequency at which each conduit 130, 130' may vibrate may be a function of the square root of the spring constant of the conduit 130, 130' divided by the total mass of the conduit 130, 130' with the material. The total mass of the conduit 130, 130' with the material may be the mass of the conduit 130, 130' plus the mass of the material in the conduit 130, 130'. The mass of the material in the conduit 130, 130' is directly proportional to the density of the material. Thus, the density of this material may be proportional to the square of the period that the conduit 130, 130' containing the material vibrates multiplied by the spring constant of the conduit 130, 130'. Thus, by determining the period that the conduit 130, 130' vibrates and scaling the result appropriately, an accurate measure of the density of the material contained in the conduit 130, 130' may be obtained. The meter electronics 20 can determine a period or resonant frequency using the sensor signal 165 and / or the drive signal 185. The conduits 130, 130' can vibrate in more than one vibration mode. As described in more detail below, the meter electronics 20 can also perform validation of the sensor assembly.
[0095] 3 illustrates meter electronics 20 configured to validate the sensor assembly 10 using parameters of the sensor signal 100 provided by the sensor assembly 10. As shown in FIG. 3, the meter electronics 20 includes an interface 301 and a processing system 302. The meter electronics 20 receives a vibration response from a sensor assembly, such as the sensor assembly 10 described above. The meter electronics 20 can process the vibration response to obtain flow characteristics of the flowing material flowing through the sensor assembly 10. The meter electronics 20 can also perform checks, verifications, calibration routines, etc. to ensure that the flow characteristics of the flowing material are accurately measured.
[0096] The interface 301 may receive the sensor signal 165 from one of the pickoff sensors 170l, 170r shown in Figures 1 and 2. The interface 301 may also be configured to receive the drive signal 185, for example, from the signal conditioner 240. Although the drive signal 185 is shown as being provided by the signal conditioner 240, a back EMF may be provided from the sensor assembly 10 to the meter electronics 20 due to vibrations of the conduit 130 within the sensor assembly 10. Thus, the interface 301 may be configured to receive the sensor signal 100 shown in Figure 2.
[0097] The interface 301 may perform any necessary or desired signal conditioning, such as any manner of formatting, amplification, buffering, etc. Alternatively, some or all of the signal conditioning may be performed in the processing system 302. Additionally, the interface 301 may enable communication between the meter electronics 20 and an external device. The interface 301 may be capable of any manner of electronic, optical, or wireless communication. The interface 301 may provide information based on the vibration response. The interface 301 may be coupled to a digitizer, such as the CODEC 222 shown in FIG. 2, where the sensor signal includes an analog sensor signal. The digitizer samples and digitizes the analog sensor signal to generate a digitized sensor signal.
[0098] The processing system 302 performs operations of the meter electronics 20 and processes flow measurements from the sensor assembly 10. The processing system 302 executes one or more processing routines, thereby processing the flow measurements to generate one or more flow characteristics. The processing system 302 is communicatively coupled to the interface 301 and configured to receive information from the interface 301.
[0099] The processing system 302 may comprise a general purpose computer, a microprocessing system, a logic circuit, or any other general purpose or customized processing device. Additionally or alternatively, the processing system 302 may be distributed across multiple processing devices. The processing system 302 may also include any type of integrated or stand-alone electronic storage medium, such as a storage system 304.
[0100] The storage system 304 may store vibratory meter parameters and data, software routines, constant values, and variable values. In one embodiment, the storage system 304 includes routines executed by the processing system 302, such as operational routines 310. The processing system 302 may be further configured to execute other routines, such as zero calibration and zero verification routines for the vibratory meter 5. The storage system may also store statistics, such as the mean, standard deviation, confidence intervals, etc.
[0101] The operating routine 310 may determine a mass flow value 312 and a density value 314 based on the sensor signals received by the interface 301. The mass flow value 312 may be a frequency independent mass flow value, a directly measured mass flow value, etc. The mass flow value 312 may be determined from the sensor signals, such as the time delay between the left pickoff sensor signal and the right pickoff sensor signal. The density value 314 may also be determined from the sensor signals, for example, by determining the frequency from one or both of the left and right pickoff sensor signals.
[0102] As previously mentioned, a sensor assembly such as the sensor assembly 10 described with reference to FIGS. 1 and 2 can be verified by calculating conduit parameter values, such as stiffness, mass, damping, residual flexibility, etc., of the sensor assembly and comparing the calculated conduit parameter values to baseline conduit parameter values. However, such calculations can make real-time measurements difficult and can result in interruptions to a customer's process. In addition, some calculations, such as gain-attenuation methods, that may be used to calculate the conduit parameter values can be sensitive to system noise and changes in process conditions. This can limit the sensor assembly verification routine to low or no flow conditions, or other conditions that are sufficiently stable for the calculation of the conduit parameter values. As described in more detail below, these and other problems can be avoided by verifying the sensor assembly using parameters of the sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly.
[0103] 3, the storage system 304 can include sensor signal parameter values 320. As shown in FIG. 3, the sensor signal parameter values 320 can include, for example, a drive voltage value 322, an LPO voltage value 324, and an RPO voltage value 326. The drive voltage value 322, the LPO voltage value 324, and / or the RPO voltage value 326 can be determined in real time, for example, during a customer process, during calibration using a known fluid, etc. Thus, the drive voltage value 322, the LPO voltage value 324, and / or the RPO voltage value 326 may or may not be the same sensor parameter value used to calculate the mass flow value 312 and / or the density value 314. As can be appreciated, the drive voltage value 322, the LPO voltage value 324, and / or the RPO voltage value 326 can be measured, determined, obtained, and / or calculated substantially simultaneously.
[0104] The sensor signal parameter values 320 can be used to calculate one or more current sensor assembly validation values 330 based on the sensor signal parameter values 320. For example, the meter electronics 20, or more specifically the processing system 302, may be configured to determine sensor signal parameter values such as a drive voltage value 322, an LPO voltage value 324, and / or an RPO voltage value 326 of the sensor signal. The sensor signal parameter may be an amplitude of the sensor signal, although any suitable sensor signal parameter may be used. As can be appreciated, the amplitude of the sensor signal may be a voltage, a current, or a power, although any suitable amplitude may be used. The meter electronics 20 or the processing system 302 may also be configured to calculate sensor signal parameter relationship values from the sensor signal parameter values. The meter electronics 20, or more specifically the processing system 302, may be configured to store the sensor signal parameter relationship values as current sensor assembly validation values 330 in the storage system 304.
[0105] 3 , the current sensor assembly validation values 330 include sensor signal electrical parameter related values such as a current LPO / RPO voltage ratio value 332, a current DRV / LPO voltage ratio value 334, and a current DRV / RPO voltage ratio value 336, although more or fewer current sensor assembly validation values 330 may be measured, determined, obtained, calculated, and / or stored by the illustrated meter electronics 20 or alternative meter electronics. As can be appreciated, the current LPO / RPO voltage ratio value 332, the current DRV / LPO voltage ratio value 334, and the current DRV / RPO voltage ratio value 336 may be sensor signal electrical parameter related values. For example, alternative meter electronics may be configured to only measure, determine, obtain, calculate, and / or store pickoff sensor signal related values such as the current LPO / RPO voltage ratio value 332 because the current LPO / RPO voltage ratio value 332 can be used to reliably detect a significant number, e.g., a majority, of changes to the conduit under process conditions that are not similar to the calibration conditions from which the baseline sensor assembly validation value is calculated.
[0106] By way of example, the baseline LPO / RPO voltage ratio value may be calculated during calibration of the FCF of a given vibratory meter. After the vibratory meter is installed at a customer site, the customer can run a sensor assembly verification routine while the vibratory meter is measuring the mass flow rate and / or density of a process fluid under process conditions different from the conditions under which the baseline LPO / RPO voltage ratio value was calculated, as described in more detail below.
[0107] The gain decay method for calculating the stiffness value of the conduit is as follows:
number
[0108] As mentioned before, stiffness measurement requires calculations that can make real-time measurement difficult and may require the customer to interrupt the process. To determine how to avoid such problems, the appropriate stiffness ratios listed above can be taken as follows:
number
[0109] As can be seen, some terms in equation [4] cancel. More specifically, the drive current and tube frequency terms cancel. The pickoff and driver sensitivity terms BL PO , B.L. DR may be assumed to be the same or may be compensated for later, resulting in the following relationship:
number
[0110] Equation [5] is the ratio of the voltages of the left and right pickoff signals, V LPO / V RPO is the inverse of the ratio of stiffness to damping (ζ R / ζ L )K R / KL Thus, a change in either the left and right tube damping or the left and right tube stiffness can result in a change that is detected by taking the ratio of the pickoff voltages. As previously mentioned, the sensor signal parameter may be the amplitude of the sensor signal. Thus, equation [5] can be expressed, for example, as the ratio of the amplitudes (e.g., voltage, current, power, etc.) of the sensor signals, i.e., A LPO / A RPO This can be generalized to:
[0111] As can be appreciated, the voltages of the left and right pickoff sensor signals are parameters of the sensor signals and therefore do not require calculations similar to those required to calculate a conduit parameter value such as conduit stiffness. Furthermore, equation [5] above indicates that the ratio of the voltages of the left and right pickoff sensor signals can be used to detect changes in stiffness. Changes that can be detected may be limited to asymmetric changes in the left and right stiffness of the conduit. More specifically, if a change in the conduit causes a proportional change in left and right stiffness, the ratio of the voltages may not detect a change.
[0112] Symmetrical changes to the conduit can be detected by determining whether the voltage of the left sensor signal or the voltage of the right sensor signal has changed relative to a baseline value. For example, the ratio of the voltage of the left pickoff sensor signal to the drive signal and the ratio of the voltage of the right pickoff sensor signal to the drive signal can be compared to the respective baseline values. However, such a comparison may require that the state of the sensor assembly is the same as when the baseline values are determined. Thus, although it may be necessary to interrupt a customer process to detect symmetrical changes in the conduit of a vibratory meter using the parameters of the sensor signals, the calculations required for stiffness values can be avoided.
[0113] 3, the storage system may include a baseline sensor assembly validation value 340. The baseline sensor assembly validation value 340 may include baseline sensor signal parameter related values. For example, as shown in FIG. 3, the baseline sensor assembly validation value 340 may include baseline sensor signal parameter related values such as a baseline LPO / RPO voltage ratio value 342, a baseline DRV / LPO voltage ratio value 344, and a baseline DRV / RPO voltage ratio value 346. The "DRV" term may be a value of the voltage of the drive signal provided to the driver, which may be the same as the drive voltage value 322, although any suitable sensor signal parameter may be employed. Similarly, the "LPO" and "RPO" terms may be left and right pickoff voltage values, respectively, which may be the same as the LPO and RPO voltage values 324, 326, although any suitable sensor signal parameter may be employed.
[0114] The baseline sensor assembly validation value 340 may be determined during a factory calibration, a customer calibration, or by any other suitable routine that establishes a reference value against which subsequent calculations can be compared. The baseline sensor assembly validation value 340 may be related to a flow calibration factor used in a flow measurement (e.g., operational FCF) determined simultaneously with the baseline sensor assembly validation value 340. Thus, changes to one or more conduits since the operational FCF and baseline sensor assembly validation value 340 were determined may result in inaccurate measurements.
[0115] An LPO / RPO voltage ratio value, such as the current LPO / RPO voltage ratio value 332 described above with reference to FIG. 3, may be used to detect changes in the conduit of the sensor assembly. That is, a sensor assembly validation value shift may be used to detect changes in the conduit of the sensor assembly. For example, a ratio shift, such as a voltage ratio shift, may be defined as the difference between the current LPO / RPO voltage ratio value 332 and a baseline LPO / RPO voltage ratio value 342. The ratio shift may be expressed as a percentage of the baseline LPO / RPO voltage ratio value 342.
[0116] As can be appreciated, a viable sensor assembly verification should indicate that no changes are occurring in one or more conduits when no changes are occurring in the conduits. Also, as can be appreciated, this should be true at different flow rates if the sensor assembly verification is viable during process flow conditions. The table below shows that the voltage ratio shift can be relatively small over the entire flow range. More specifically, each flow meter type was exposed to no flow and maximum flow conditions. For each type of flow meter, the percent shift between the LPO / RPO voltage ratio value at the no flow condition and the LPO / RPO voltage ratio value at the maximum flow condition was calculated. The results are tabulated and shown in Table 1 below.
[0117] [Table 1]
[0118] As can be seen, the percentage values of the voltage ratio shift are very small across the various types of flowmeters exposed to no-flow and maximum-flow conditions with no changes occurring in one or more conduits. This indicates that the change in the LPO / RPO voltage ratio is likely not due to differences in flow rates. Thus, the LPO / RPO voltage ratio can be a reliable indicator of the condition of one or more conduits. For example, a change in the LPO / RPO voltage ratio relative to a baseline LPO / RPO voltage ratio is unlikely to be due to a change in the flow rate of material flowing through one or more conduits.
[0119] A reliable indication of a change in one or more conduits of a sensor assembly may also need to be correlated with a mechanical property of the one or more conduits. For example, if a change in one or more conduits causes the LPO / RPO voltage ratio to have a rate of change equal to the rate of change in stiffness, then the LPO / RPO voltage ratio may be a reliable indication of a change in one or more conduits. The table below shows that a ratio shift is present in various types of meters when a change in one or more conduits is caused by an etchant in one or more conduits of each type of meter.
[0120] [Table 2]
[0121] As can be seen, the shift in the LPO / RPO voltage ratio is equivalent to a shift in the LPO / RPO stiffness ratio. As can also be seen, the shift was independent of the meter electronics attached to the sensor assembly. Similar results are obtained with different sensor assemblies as shown in Table 3 below.
[0122] [Table 3]
[0123] Thus, a parameter such as an LPO / RPO voltage ratio value of the sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly can detect changes in one or more conduits of the sensor assembly. As can be appreciated, other parameters can be used, including those based on the current, power, resistance, etc. of the sensor signal from the sensor assembly. Additionally or alternatively, other parameter relationships can be used, such as differences between parameters of the sensor signals. Furthermore, parameters of signals other than the sensor signal, such as the voltage of the drive signal, can be used. The parameters of the sensor signal are not calculated and can consistently detect changes in one or more conduits of the sensor assembly.
[0124] FIG. 4 illustrates a graph 400 showing the correspondence between the stiffness of the sensor assembly and the difference between the sensor signal parameters. As shown in FIG. 4, the graph 400 includes a corrosion path axis 410, a pickoff voltage delta axis 420, and a stiffness delta axis 430. The corrosion path axis 410 is unitless, the pickoff voltage delta axis 420 is in volts, and the stiffness delta axis 430 is in newton meters / radian, although any suitable units may be used. The graph 400 also includes a sensor assembly validation value delta plot 440. As shown in FIG. 4, the sensor assembly validation value delta plot 440 includes a stiffness delta plot 442 and a pickoff delta plot 444.
[0125] As can be seen, the stiffness delta plot 442 and the pickoff delta plot 444 are approximately linear with respect to the corrosion path axis 410. Also, as can be seen, the stiffness delta plot 442 and the pickoff delta plot 444 have approximately corresponding slopes, albeit with different abscissa scaling. Thus, a linear relationship can exist between the pickoff voltage delta values and the stiffness delta values, suggesting that the pickoff voltage delta can reliably detect changes in the conduits of the sensor assembly that may cause stiffness shifts.
[0126] As described above with reference to FIG. 3, one or more comparisons between a current sensor assembly validation value, such as one of the current sensor assembly validation values 330, and a baseline sensor assembly validation value, such as one of the baseline sensor assembly validation values 340, can be used to detect and identify changes in a sensor assembly, such as the sensor assembly 10 described above. For example, the sensor assembly validation value can be based on a sensor signal parameter. By way of example, the sensor assembly validation value can be an LPO / RPO voltage ratio, a DRV / LPO voltage ratio, or a DRV / RPO voltage ratio, although any suitable sensor signal parameter ratio can be used. Additionally or alternatively, differences between sensor signal parameters can be used. Thus, for example, the current sensor assembly validation value 330 and the baseline sensor assembly validation value 340 can be based on sensor signal parameters such as an LPO voltage, an RPO voltage, and / or a DRV voltage.
[0127] As also described in the above description, the sensor assembly validation value shift can be used to detect and identify changes in the sensor assembly. More specifically, the above description describes that changes in the sensor signal parameters are correlated with changes in the stiffness of the sensor assembly. Thus, the sensor assembly validation value based on the sensor signal parameters can be used to detect and identify changes in the sensor assembly.
[0128] The correlation between the stiffnesses of the sensor assemblies may also be location specific. For example, the DRV / LPO voltage ratio may be correlated with the stiffness of the conduit between the location of the left pickoff sensor and the location of the driver on the conduit. The stiffness of the conduit between the left pickoff location and the driver location may be referred to as the LPO stiffness. Thus, under similar or the same process conditions, as the LPO stiffness decreases over time for a given drive current, the conduit may undergo a larger displacement at the location of the left pickoff sensor, which may be referred to as the LPO displacement. This larger LPO displacement may induce a higher LPO voltage value. As a result, the DRV / LPO voltage ratio may decrease as the LPO stiffness decreases. A similar correlation may exist between the DRV / RPO voltage ratio and the RPO stiffness.
[0129] As previously discussed, asymmetric changes in the conduits can cause asymmetric changes in the LPO and RPO voltages. Similar asymmetric changes can occur in other sensor signal parameters, such as power, current, etc. The asymmetric changes in the LPO and RPO voltages can be quantified by using a current LPO / RPO voltage ratio value 332 and a baseline LPO / RPO voltage ratio value 342. For example, the current LPO / RPO voltage ratio value 332 may be compared (e.g., subtracted, divided, etc.) to the baseline LPO / RPO voltage ratio value 342.
[0130] Symmetrical changes in the sensor assembly conduit can be detected by comparing the current sensor assembly validation value to a baseline sensor assembly validation value. For example, the current DRV / LPO voltage ratio value 334 can be compared to the baseline DRV / LPO voltage ratio value 344. Additionally or alternatively, a 2DRV / (LPO*RPO) voltage ratio can be used to detect symmetrical changes in the conduit as well, since a symmetrical decrease in the stiffness of the conduit can cause a larger displacement in both the left and right pickoff sensors. However, such ratios using only one of the drive or sensor signals to detect symmetrical changes in the conduit may require that the process conditions are the same as when the baseline ratio value was determined. Additionally or alternatively, a calculated stiffness value of the conduit can be used, which may not require that the conditions are the same as when the baseline stiffness value was calculated. These and other current sensor assembly validation values can be used individually to detect changes and may even detect and distinguish between symmetrical and asymmetrical changes, but may not identify the underlying conditions that cause the change in the sensor signal parameter.
[0131] A shift or change in the sensor assembly validation value may be defined as a comparison between a current sensor assembly validation value and a baseline sensor assembly validation value that indicates a change has occurred within the sensor assembly conduit. This sensor assembly validation value shift or change may be characterized as "low" or "decreasing," "high" or "increasing," or "null" or "static," etc. Additionally or alternatively, a quantitative value may be used. A combination of two or more sensor assembly validation value shifts or changes may be used to identify the underlying condition of the conduit.
[0132] For example, as previously discussed, a "low" DRV / LPO voltage ratio shift may indicate a decrease in the physical stiffness of the conduit 130, 130' between the driver 180 and the left pickoff sensor 170l. A "high" DRV / RPO voltage ratio shift may indicate an increase in the physical stiffness of the conduit 130, 130' between the driver 180 and the right pickoff sensor 170l. The combination of a "low" DRV / LPO voltage ratio shift and a "high" DRV / RPO voltage ratio shift may correlate with a particular condition, such as a process causing corrosion of the conduit proximate the inlet of the conduit and coating of the conduit proximate the outlet of the conduit.
[0133] The processing system 302 can further process these values to generate toggle indicators that indicate only an increase or decrease in the physical stiffness of the conduit 130, 130' between the driver 180 and the left pickoff sensor 1701. These values and / or toggle indicators can be utilized to determine an underlying change in the stiffness of the conduit 130, 130' as shown in the truth table below.
[0134] [Table 4]
[0135] As can be seen, a combination of LPO / RPO voltage ratio, LPO stiffness change, and RPO stiffness change can be used to distinguish between different possible changes in the conduits 130, 130'. For example, both Cases J and N have an LPO / RPO voltage ratio that is "bottom right" and an RPO stiffness change that is "low". However, the LPO stiffness change in Case J is "low" and the LPO stiffness change in Case N is "high". Case J is shown as a possible erosion / corrosion of the conduits 130, 130' and Case N is shown as a possible coating of the conduits 130, 130'.
[0136] Although the above tables utilize LPO stiffness changes, RPO stiffness changes, and LPO / RPO voltage ratios to determine the condition of the conduits 130, 130', any suitable means, such as alternative tables, logic, objects, relationships, circuits, processors, routines, etc., may be used to determine the condition within the conduits. For example, only LPO stiffness changes and RPO stiffness changes may be utilized to determine the condition of the conduits 130, 130'. However, as may be appreciated, utilizing the LPO / RPO voltage ratio may allow for a more specific determination of the condition of the conduits 130, 130'.
[0137] Additionally or alternatively, the actual values of the LPO stiffness change, RPO stiffness change, and / or LPO / RPO voltage ratio can be used to determine the condition of the conduit instead of the toggle indicator. For example, the condition determined by the above table can be supplemented by the further step of determining that, for example, if the LPO / RPO voltage ratio is relatively small "right low," then case J is likely to be corrosion rather than erosion. That is, the relatively small "right low" LPO / RPO voltage ratio can be due to the more uniform nature of the corrosion compared to erosion, which may be more prevalent at the entrance to the conduit.
[0138] Statistical methods that calculate the probability of an outcome can be used to detect changes in a vibratory meter, but due to their complexity could not be performed by the meter electronics 20. For example, P and T statistics can be used to test whether a null hypothesis is met for a given data set. Rejecting the null hypothesis does not determine whether a condition exists in the vibratory meter, but rather that the absence of a condition is false. In the case of sensor assembly validation, the null hypothesis can be stated as "the current sensor assembly validation results have the same mean as the baseline sensor assembly validation results." If this null hypothesis is not proven, then it can be assumed that changes in the vibratory meter will cause the mean of the current sensor assembly validation results to not be the same as the baseline sensor assembly validation results.
[0139] As an example, in a t-test, the t-value can be calculated using the following formula:
number
number
[0140] In the context of sensor assembly validation, μ0 is a baseline sensor assembly validation value, such as a baseline LPO / RPO voltage ratio value. The sensor assembly validation measurement is a sample average for comparison to the baseline sensor assembly validation value.
number
[0141] As mentioned before, a t-test can be used to test the null hypothesis, which is that for sensor assembly validation, the sample mean
number
[0142] However, P values are difficult to calculate with limited computational resources. For example, P values can be calculated on a computer workstation with an operating system and statistical software, but may not be easily calculated on an embedded system. The meter electronics 20 described above may be an embedded system with limited computational resources. Furthermore, the ability to reject the null hypothesis in-situ or in real-time on the meter electronics can prevent the meter electronics 20 from sending false alarms while also accurately detecting changes in the conduits 130, 130', which is a significant improvement over using predetermined alarm limits.
[0143] For this purpose, a confidence interval that takes advantage of the limited computing resources of the meter electronics 20 is used instead of the P value. As a result, the confidence interval can be calculated using an embedded code on the meter electronics 20. For example, the meter electronics 20 can store the current sensor assembly validation value and the standard deviation value of the current sensor assembly validation value in two registers. As can be understood, the above t value can be calculated using the current sensor assembly validation value by using the significance level α and the degrees of freedom. As an example, the significance level α may be set to 0.01, which is a 99% confidence level. The number of times of some sensor assembly validation tests can be set to 5 times. Therefore, the pooled degrees of freedom is determined to be 2·(5−1)=8. The two-tailed Student's t value can be calculated from the significance level α and the pooled degrees of freedom using the Student's t value function as follows:
number
[0144] A pooled standard deviation of the sensor assembly validation values associated with the left and right pickoff sensors 170l, 170r may also be used. In the general case, the calculation of the pooled standard deviation may be complicated. However, because the meter electronics 20 stores the standard deviation of the sensor assembly validation values in a register, the pooled standard deviation may simply be the stored standard deviation. A pooled standard error may also be calculated and is defined as follows:
number
[0145] The confidence interval range can be calculated using the standard error and t-value determined above as follows: CI range =stderror pooled t student,99.8 [9] CI range =stderrorpooled 3.36 Finally, the confidence interval can be calculated using the mean of the sensor assembly validation measurements and the confidence interval range, as shown in the following equation: CI=SV mean ±CI range
[10]
[0146] The confidence interval can be used to test the null hypothesis by determining whether the confidence interval includes 0.0. If the confidence interval includes 0.0, the null hypothesis is not rejected and the sensor assembly validation passes. If the confidence interval does not include 0.0, the null hypothesis is rejected and a sensor assembly validation failure can be signaled.
[0147] By using the confidence interval instead of a P-value, where the meter electronics 20 stores the sensor assembly validation value and the standard deviation value of the sensor assembly validation value, the calculation is relatively simple and can be performed using embedded code. For example, the meter electronics 20, which may not have sufficient computing resources to calculate a P-value, can calculate the confidence interval to perform on-the-fly or real-time statistical analysis. Also, as can be appreciated, the confidence interval can be used to test a null hypothesis at a desired confidence level.
[0148] In addition to the confidence interval, a bias deadband can be defined around zero to account for bias in the sensor assembly validation value measurement. Bias in the sensor assembly validation value measurement can be due to mounting, density, temperature gradients, or other conditions of the vibratory meter that can affect the sensor assembly validation measurement. This bias deadband in the t-test is a value around zero where small biases with small variations that would otherwise cause the confidence interval check to reject the hypothesis do not reject the hypothesis. Thus, this bias deadband can be set to a value that reduces the number of false alarms sent by the meter electronics 20.
[0149] In the example of a confidence interval compared to 0, the bias deadband is the range around 0, and if 0 is not within the confidence interval, but some portion of the bias deadband is within the confidence interval, then the null hypothesis is not rejected. Mathematically, this test can be expressed as whether the mean value of the sensor assembly validation measurements, sometimes called the sensor assembly validation mean, is less than the bias deadband. Or, using the nomenclature discussed above, i.e.
number
[0150] The bias deadband can be implemented alone or in combination with other deadbands. For example, the bias deadband can be implemented in conjunction with a variable deadband. In one example, variation =db bias / t student,99. The fluctuation deadband can be determined from, where db variation is the fluctuation deadband. The fluctuation deadband can be compared to the standard deviation of the sensor assembly validation values to determine whether to reject the null hypothesis. In one example, the bias deadband may be compared as described above, and the fluctuation deadband may be compared to the standard deviation as follows:
number
number
number
[0151] A preferred method of testing the null hypothesis may be to use two confidence intervals that are independent of the pooled standard deviation. If it cannot be assumed that the standard deviation of the baseline measurements is the same as the standard deviation of the sensor assembly validation measurements, it may be preferable to use two confidence intervals. The first confidence interval (e.g., baseline confidence interval) may consist of the baseline mean and baseline standard deviation. The second confidence interval (e.g., measurement or meter validation confidence interval) may consist of the measurement mean and measurement standard deviation of the measurements made during the sensor assembly validation.
[0152] In this example, the first confidence interval may be an exemplary baseline sensor assembly validation value, although any suitable value, including a probability value, may be the baseline sensor assembly validation value. The second confidence interval may be a probability determined from a measured mean and a measured standard deviation. That is, as described below, the measured mean may be a central tendency value and the measured standard deviation may be a variance value used to validate a sensor assembly, such as the sensor assembly 10 described above, by comparing the probability to the baseline sensor assembly validation value.
[0153] For two overlapping confidence intervals, if the first and second confidence intervals overlap, then the change (e.g., no damage) may not be detected. Otherwise, the change is detected. The overlap of the two confidence intervals may be determined using any suitable method. For example, the overlap of the two confidence intervals may be determined by comparing the difference between the measured mean and the baseline mean, and the difference between the measured standard deviation value and the baseline standard deviation value. The comparison may include terms simply referred to as a calculated left hand side (LHS) value and a calculated right hand side (RHS) value, although any suitable terminology may be used. If the LHS value is less than the RHS value, then there is an overlap and damage may be detected accordingly. Otherwise, there is no overlap and therefore damage may not be detected. The following formulas
[11] -
[13] illustrate this method. LHS=|μ measured-μ baseline |;
[11] RHS=2*(σ measured -σ baseline ); and
[12] LHS <RHS
[13] Where: μ measured is the mean value (i.e., an exemplary central tendency value) of the sensor assembly validation measurements, μ baseline is the average value (i.e., an exemplary central tendency value) of the baseline values run for subsequent sensor assembly validations, σ measured is the standard deviation (i.e., an exemplary variance) of the sensor assembly validation measurements; σ baseline is the standard deviation (i.e., an exemplary variance) of the measured baseline values for subsequent sensor assembly validation.
[0154] A factor of "2" may be used in the calculation of the RHS value to allow for a 95% probability in both confidence intervals. Other values may be used. As can be appreciated, the mean values of the sensor assembly validation measurements and the baseline values may be determined by any suitable method. In the following equation
[14] , the standard deviation of the baseline values is determined by multiplying the mean value of the baseline values by the deadband value. σ baseline =dead band*μ baseline
[14]
[0155] However, once calculated, when confidence interval checks are performed, the null hypothesis may not be rejected due to bias in the sensor assembly validation measurements.
[0156] 5 illustrates a method 500 that uses parameters of a sensor signal of a sensor assembly, such as the sensor assembly 10 described above, to validate the sensor assembly. As shown in FIG. 5, the method 500 calculates a sensor signal parameter relationship value between two sensor signals at step 510. The sensor signal of step 510 may be the sensor signal 100 described above with reference to FIGS. 1 and 2, although any suitable sensor signal may be used. At step 520, the method 500 compares the calculated sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals to a baseline sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals. The comparison may be performed by the processing system 302 described above, although any suitable processor or processing system may be used.
[0157] In step 510, calculating a sensor signal parameter relationship value between two sensor signals may include calculating a sensor signal parameter relationship value between a left pickoff sensor signal voltage value and a right pickoff sensor signal voltage value. Additionally, calculating a sensor signal parameter relationship value between two sensor signals may include calculating one of a ratio and a difference between two sensor signal parameter values of the two sensor signals. For example, the sensor signal parameter relationship may include Equation [5] above, but using a difference between the left pickoff sensor signal voltage and the right pickoff sensor signal voltage. In another alternative, the sensor signal parameter relationship may be a ratio between the left pickoff sensor signal voltage and the right pickoff sensor signal voltage when the right pickoff sensor signal voltage is in the numerator.
[0158] Additionally or alternatively, comparing the calculated sensor signal parameter relationship value to the baseline sensor signal parameter relationship value may include calculating a difference between the calculated sensor signal parameter relationship value and the baseline sensor signal parameter relationship value. For example, if the sensor signal parameter relationship exceeds Equation [5], the comparison may be, for example, between the following sensor signal parameter relationships:
number
number
number
number
[0159] The above sensor signal parameter relationship value delta
number
number
[0160] As mentioned above, the two sensor signals may include two of the drive signal, the left pickoff sensor signal, and the right pickoff sensor signal. For example, in the above equation [5], the two sensor signals are the left and right pickoff sensor signals, and the sensor signal parameters are the voltages of the left and right pickoff sensor signals. Alternatively, for example, the two sensor signals may include the drive signal and one of the left and right sensor signals. As an example, the ratio of the drive signal voltage to the left pickoff sensor signal voltage may be used. However, as mentioned above, using the ratio of the drive signal voltage to the left pickoff sensor signal voltage may require that the customer's process is terminated, and that the conditions used to calculate the sensor signal parameter relationship values may need to be the same as the conditions used to obtain the baseline sensor signal parameter relationship values.
[0161] The method 500 may further include determining a state of the sensor assembly based on a comparison of the calculated electrical parameter relationship value to a baseline electrical parameter relationship value between the two or more sensor signals. For example, a sensor signal parameter value delta that is non-zero between the left and right sensor signals may indicate that an asymmetric change has occurred. This may be due to, for example, uneven etching, erosion, or the like. As may be appreciated, if the sensor signal parameter relationship delta is zero or within an acceptable range, it may be concluded that either no change or a symmetric change has occurred. Thus, the method 500 may proceed further to determine whether a symmetric change has occurred by, for example, terminating a customer process and determining whether the sensor signal parameter relationship between the drive signal and the left or right pickoff sensor signal has changed relative to the baseline, and additionally or alternatively, the method 500 may further determine that a value based on a conduit parameter, such as stiffness, damping, etc., has changed to further determine a state of the sensor assembly.
[0162] As previously discussed, more than one comparison between the sensor assembly validation values may be used. Additionally, changes in the sensor assembly validation values may also be employed. For example, as shown below, a combination of sensor assembly validation shifts may be used to detect and identify the condition of a conduit within a sensor assembly.
[0163] FIG. 6 illustrates a method 600 for validating a sensor assembly using a parameter of a sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly. As shown in FIG. 6, the method 600 determines a current first sensor assembly validation value in step 610. In step 620, the method 600 compares the current first sensor assembly validation value to a first baseline sensor assembly validation value to determine a first sensor assembly validation shift. The method 600 also compares the current second sensor assembly validation value to a second baseline sensor assembly validation value to determine a first sensor assembly validation shift in step 630. In step 640, the method 600 determines a condition of the conduit based on the first sensor assembly validation shift and the second sensor assembly validation shift. At least one of the current first sensor assembly validation value and the current second sensor assembly validation value comprises a sensor signal parameter related value. The method 600 can be executed on a meter electronics, such as the meter electronics 20 described above. The method 600 can also include additional steps and / or various sub-steps.
[0164] For example, a first sensor assembly validation shift can represent a physical stiffness change of the conduit between the driver and the left pickoff, and a second sensor assembly validation shift can represent a physical stiffness change of the conduit between the driver and the right pickoff. By way of example, as previously described, a physical stiffness change of the conduit between the driver and the left pickoff sensor can be correlated (e.g., a linear relationship) with a DRV / LPO voltage ratio value, and a physical stiffness of the conduit between the driver and the right pickoff can be correlated (e.g., a linear relationship) with a DRV / LPO voltage ratio value.
[0165] The sensor signal parameter relationship value may be one of a ratio and a difference of two sensor signal parameter values. In addition, the sensor signal parameter relationship of the conduit may be determined based on two of the left pickoff sensor signal parameter, the right pickoff sensor signal parameter, and the drive signal parameter. For example, a DRV / LPO voltage ratio value and / or a DRV / LPO voltage ratio value may be employed. However, a difference such as a DRV / LPO voltage difference value and a DRV / RPO voltage difference value may alternatively or additionally be used. Although the value of the ratio may not depend on the common factor of the numerator and denominator, a ratio may be advantageous because the common factor can effectively scale the difference value.
[0166] The method 600 may also provide an alert based on the determination of the conduit condition. For example, the meter electronics 20 described above may send a message via the port 26 described above. Additionally or alternatively, the method 600 may display a message on a user interface connected to the meter electronics. As previously described, the conduit condition may include at least one of erosion, corrosion, damage, and coating of the vibratory meter conduit. As can be appreciated from the foregoing description, the condition may be detected and identified by using a combination of sensor assembly validation shifts determined based on a comparison between a current sensor assembly validation value and a baseline sensor assembly validation value, which may be any suitable comparison, including a statistical comparison, as the following description will illustrate, and may or may not be used in combination with other comparisons, and may or may not use statistical methods.
[0167] 7 illustrates a method 700 for validating a sensor assembly using parameters of a sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly. As shown in FIG. 7, the method 700, at step 710, retrieves a central tendency value and a variance value from a storage system. The method 700 may be executed on a meter electronics, such as the meter electronics 20. Thus, a process system, such as the aforementioned processing system 302, may retrieve the central tendency value from a storage system, such as the aforementioned storage system 304. At step 720, the method 700 determines a probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value to detect whether the central tendency value differs from a baseline value.
[0168] In the method 700, the sensor assembly validation value may be based on a sensor signal parameter value. For example, the sensor assembly validation value may be one of the LPO / RPO voltage ratio value, the DRV / LPO voltage ratio value, and the DRV / RPO voltage ratio value described above. The sensor signal parameter value may be of a sensor signal from a sensor assembly, such as the sensor assembly 10 described above. Thus, the sensor assembly validation value may be used to validate the sensor assembly 10 or any suitable sensor assembly.
[0169] The method 700 can also determine a probability based on a central tendency value and a variance value, including calculating a t-value and calculating a probability using the t-value. For example, determining a probability based on a central tendency value and a variance value can include calculating degrees of freedom based on several sensor assembly validation measurements. Determining a probability based on the meter stiffness can include calculating a standard error based on a standard deviation and degrees of freedom, as described above. For example, the standard error can be calculated using Equation [8] above. The variance value can be a pooled standard deviation that includes the standard deviation of the sensor assembly validation measurements and the baseline sensor assembly validation measurements. The probability can be a confidence interval for the central tendency value, such as a confidence interval calculated using Equation
[10] above.
[0170] As previously mentioned, more than one probability may be used. For example, a first probability, such as a first confidence interval, may be based on baseline sensor assembly validation measurements, and a second probability, such as a second confidence interval, may be based on measurements taken for sensor assembly validation. By way of example, the first confidence interval may be calculated from a mean and a standard deviation of the baseline sensor assembly validation values. For example, the mean of the baseline sensor assembly validation values may be the average value of the baseline sensor assembly validation measurements, and the standard deviation of the baseline sensor assembly validation values may be the standard deviation value of the baseline sensor assembly validation measurements.
[0171] Thus, the method 700 can determine a probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value by determining a confidence interval based on the central tendency value and the variance value. As can be appreciated, the baseline sensor assembly validation value can include a central tendency value and a variance value of the baseline sensor assembly validation values. The central tendency value of the baseline sensor assembly validation values can be the mean of the baseline sensor assembly validation values, and the variance value of the baseline sensor assembly validation values can be the standard deviation of the baseline sensor assembly validation values.
[0172] Method 700 can detect whether the central tendency value differs from the baseline sensor assembly validation value by determining whether the probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value does not overlap with the probability of the baseline sensor assembly validation value. The probability can be based on the central tendency value, the variance value includes a confidence interval determined based on the central tendency value and the variance value, and the probability of the baseline sensor assembly validation value includes a confidence interval determined based on the baseline sensor assembly validation measurements. Method 700 can determine that the probability of the central tendency value and the variance value obtained from the memory overlaps with the probability of the baseline sensor assembly validation value if Equation
[13] is true. Method 700 can determine the baseline standard deviation using Equation
[14] above.
[0173] The vibratory meter 5, meter electronics 20, and methods 500-700 described above validate the sensor assembly using parameters of the sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly. For example, the method 500 executing on the meter electronics 20 validates the current sensor signal parameter relationship.
number
number
[0174] Method 500 may also perform additional validation, such as based on the parameter relationships between the drive signal and the pick-off sensor signal discussed above, determining conduit parameter values (e.g., stiffness, residual flexibility, mass, etc.), etc., to further determine the condition causing the change in the sensor assembly. For example, additional validation of the sensor assembly may determine whether a symmetric change has occurred even if an asymmetric change is not detected using only the parameters of the pick-off sensor signal. In another example, additional validation of the sensor assembly may determine what type of asymmetric change has occurred. In this example, parameters of only the pick-off sensor signal may be used to determine that an asymmetric change has occurred in the sensor assembly, and additional validation may determine what condition caused the asymmetric change. As an example, etching may cause only asymmetric changes, while erosion may cause both asymmetric and symmetric changes.
[0175] Methods 500-700 may also perform additional steps based on the validation. For example, method 500 may flag a sensor assembly, such as sensor assembly 10 described above, as having a condition. Additionally or alternatively, method 500 may result in a diagnosis including information regarding what the condition is likely to be. By way of example, method 500 may cause meter electronics 20 to transmit a message via port 26 to a remote computing resource, such as a customer network, terminal, computer station, etc., that a condition has been detected and that the detected condition is likely corrosion of a conduit in the sensor assembly. Additionally or alternatively, meter electronics 20 may cause a display of meter electronics 20 or a display communicatively coupled to the meter electronics to display a message, window, text banner, and / or information regarding the condition indicating that a sensor assembly condition has been detected.
[0176] The sensor signal parameter values may be determined with relatively few computing resources, thereby utilizing the resources of the meter electronics 20 more efficiently. Also, the sensor signal parameter relationship values may be calculated without terminating a customer process. For example, as explained above, the sensor signal parameter relationship values, particularly the pickoff sensor signal parameter relationship values, were consistent at zero flow rate and maximum flow rate for a given unchanging sensor assembly. Furthermore, statistical methods may be used that require fewer computing resources. Furthermore, when calculating sensor signal parameter relationship values, such as the pickoff sensor signal parameter relationship values, the conditions (e.g., temperature, pressure, etc.) of the sensor assembly and / or meter electronics need not be the same as the conditions of the sensor assembly and / or meter electronics when the baseline sensor signal parameter relationship values are determined.
[0177] The detailed description of the above embodiments is not an exhaustive description of all embodiments that the inventors contemplate within the scope of the present specification. Indeed, as will be appreciated by those skilled in the art, certain elements of the above-described embodiments can be combined or removed in various ways to produce further embodiments, which are within the scope and teachings of the present specification. Also, as will be appreciated by those skilled in the art, the above-described embodiments may be combined in whole or in part to produce additional embodiments within the scope and teachings of the present specification.
[0178] Thus, while specific embodiments are described herein for illustrative purposes, various equivalent modifications are possible within the scope of the present disclosure, as those skilled in the art will recognize. The teachings provided herein may be applied to other vibratory meters, meter electronics methods for validating a sensor assembly using parameters of a sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly, as well as the embodiments described above and illustrated in the accompanying drawings. Thus, the scope of the above embodiments should be determined from the following claims.
Claims
1. 1. A meter electronics system for validating a sensor assembly using a parameter of a sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly, the system comprising: an interface (301) communicatively coupled to the sensor assembly (10), the interface (301) configured to receive two sensor signals (100); a processing system (302) communicatively coupled to the interface (301), Calculating a sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals (100); comparing the calculated sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals (100) to a baseline sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals (100); A processing system (302) configured to The meter electronics (20) comprises:
2. 2. The meter electronics (20) of claim 1, wherein the meter electronics (20) being configured to calculate the sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals (100) comprises the meter electronics (20) being configured to calculate the sensor signal parameter relationship value between a left pickoff sensor signal voltage value and a right pickoff sensor signal voltage value.
3. 2. The meter electronics (20) of claim 1, wherein the meter electronics (20) being configured to calculate the sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals (100) comprises the meter electronics (20) being configured to calculate one of a ratio and a difference between two sensor signal parameter values of the two sensor signals (100).
4. 2. The meter electronics of claim 1, wherein the meter electronics (20) being configured to compare the calculated sensor signal parameter relationship value to the baseline sensor signal parameter relationship value comprises the meter electronics (20) being configured to calculate a difference between the calculated sensor signal parameter relationship value and the baseline sensor signal parameter relationship value.
5. 2. The meter electronics of claim 1, wherein the two sensor signals include two of a drive signal, a left pickoff sensor signal, and a right pickoff sensor signal.
6. 2. The meter electronics of claim 1, further configured to determine a status of the sensor assembly based on the comparison of the calculated sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals and the baseline sensor signal parameter relationship value.
7. 1. A method for validating a sensor assembly using a parameter of a sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly, comprising: Calculating a sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals; comparing the calculated sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals to a baseline sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals; The method includes:
8. 8. The method of claim 7, wherein calculating the sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals includes calculating the sensor signal parameter relationship value between a left pickoff sensor signal voltage value and a right pickoff sensor signal voltage value.
9. The method of claim 7 , wherein calculating the sensor signal parameter relationship value between the two sensor signals comprises calculating one of a ratio and a difference between two sensor signal parameter values of the two sensor signals.
10. 8. The method of claim 7, wherein comparing the calculated sensor signal parameter relationship values to baseline sensor signal parameter relationship values comprises calculating a difference between the calculated sensor signal parameter relationship values and the baseline sensor signal parameter relationship values.
11. The method of claim 7 , wherein the two sensor signals include two of a drive signal, a left pickoff sensor signal, and a right pickoff sensor signal.
12. 8. The method of claim 7, further comprising determining a state of the sensor assembly based on the comparison of the calculated sensor signal parameter relationship values between the two sensor signals and the baseline sensor signal parameter relationship values.
13. 1. A meter electronics system for validating a sensor assembly using a parameter of a sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly, the system comprising: an interface (301) configured to receive a left pickoff sensor signal and a right pickoff sensor signal from the meter assembly (10); a processing system (302) communicatively coupled to the interface (301), determining a current first sensor assembly validation value and a current second sensor assembly validation value; comparing the current first sensor assembly validation value to a first baseline sensor assembly validation value to determine a first sensor assembly validation shift; comparing the current second sensor assembly validation value to a second baseline sensor signal parameter relationship value to determine a second sensor assembly validation shift; determining a condition of the conduit (130, 130') based on the first sensor assembly verification shift and the second sensor assembly verification shift; A processing system (302) configured to Equipped with at least one of the current first sensor assembly validation value and the current second sensor assembly validation value comprises a sensor signal parameter relationship value. Meter electronics (20).
14. the first sensor assembly verification shift represents a physical stiffness change of the conduit (130, 130') between a driver (180) and a left pickoff; the second sensor assembly verification shift represents a physical stiffness change of the conduit (130, 130') between the driver (180) and the right pickoff; The meter electronics (20) of claim 13.
15. The meter electronics (20) of claim 13 or 14, wherein the sensor signal parameter relationship value is one of a ratio and a difference of two sensor signal parameter values.
16. The meter electronics (20) of any one of claims 13 to 15, wherein the sensor signal parameter relationship value is determined based on two of a left pickoff sensor signal parameter, a right pickoff sensor signal parameter, and a drive signal parameter.
17. The meter electronics (20) of any one of claims 13 to 16, wherein the processing system (302) is further configured to provide an alarm based on the determined condition of the conduit (130, 130').
18. 18. The meter electronics (20) of any one of claims 13 to 17, wherein the condition of the conduit (130, 130') comprises at least one of erosion, corrosion, damage, and a coating of the conduit (130, 130') of the sensor assembly (10).
19. 19. The meter electronics (20) of any one of claims 13 to 18, wherein the processing system (302) is further configured to determine the condition of the conduit (130, 130') based on at least one of stiffness, residual flexibility, damping, and mass of the conduit (130, 130').
20. 1. A method for validating a sensor assembly using a parameter of a sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly, comprising: determining a current first sensor assembly validation value and a current second sensor assembly validation value; comparing the current first sensor assembly validation value to a first baseline sensor assembly validation value to determine a first sensor assembly validation shift; comparing the current second sensor assembly validation value to a second baseline sensor assembly validation value to determine a second sensor assembly validation shift; determining a condition of the conduit based on the first sensor assembly verification shift and the second sensor assembly verification shift; Including, at least one of the current first sensor assembly validation value and the current second sensor assembly validation value comprises a sensor signal parameter relationship value. method.
21. the first sensor assembly validation shift represents a physical stiffness change of the conduit between a driver and a left pickoff sensor; the second sensor assembly validation shift represents a physical stiffness change of the conduit between the driver and a right pickoff sensor. The method of claim 20.
22. 22. The method of claim 20 or 21, wherein the sensor signal parameter relationship value is one of a ratio and a difference of two sensor signal parameter values.
23. 23. The method of claim 20, wherein the sensor signal parameter relationship value is determined based on two of a left pickoff sensor signal parameter, a right pickoff sensor signal parameter, and a drive signal parameter.
24. 24. The method of any one of claims 20 to 23, further comprising providing an alert based on the determining of the condition of the conduit.
25. 25. The method of any one of claims 20 to 24, wherein the condition of the conduit comprises at least one of erosion, corrosion, damage, and a coating of the conduit of a vibratory meter.
26. 1. A meter electronics (20) for validating a sensor assembly (10) using a parameter of a sensor signal provided by the sensor assembly (10), comprising: a processing system (302) including a storage system (304) configured to store a central tendency value of a sensor assembly validation value and a variance value of the sensor assembly validation value, the processing system (302) comprising: Obtaining the central tendency value and the variance value from the storage system (304); determining a probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value to detect whether the central tendency value differs from a baseline sensor assembly validation value; It is configured as follows: the baseline sensor assembly validation value is based on a sensor signal parameter value; Meter electronics (20).
27. 27. The meter electronics of claim 26, wherein the sensor assembly validation value is one of an LPO / RPO voltage ratio value, a DRV / LPO voltage ratio value, and a DRV / RPO voltage ratio value.
28. 28. The meter electronics of claim 26 or 27, wherein the processing system (302) being configured to determine the probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value comprises the processing system (302) being configured to calculate a t-value and calculate the probability using the t-value.
29. 29. The meter electronics of claim 26, wherein the processing system is configured to determine the probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value comprises the processing system is configured to calculate degrees of freedom based on several sensor assembly validation measurements.
30. 30. The meter electronics of claim 29, wherein the processing system (302) configured to determine the probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value comprises the processing system (302) configured to calculate a standard error based on a standard deviation and the degrees of freedom.
31. The standard error is calculated using the following formula: [0023] Where: stddev pooled is the standard deviation, n DOF is the degree of freedom, The meter electronics (20) of claim 30.
32. 32. The meter electronics (20) of any one of claims 26 to 31, wherein the variance value is a pooled standard deviation that includes standard deviations of sensor assembly validation measurements and baseline sensor assembly validation measurements.
33. 33. The meter electronics (20) of any one of claims 26 to 32, wherein the probability comprises a confidence interval of the central tendency value.
34. The confidence interval is compared to 0; detecting that the central tendency value is not equal to the baseline sensor assembly validation value if the confidence interval does not include zero; detecting that the central tendency value is equal to the baseline sensor assembly validation value if the confidence interval includes zero; The meter electronics (20) of claim 33.
35. the central tendency value is a sensor assembly validation value, and the confidence interval for the sensor assembly validation value is calculated using the formula: CI=SV mean ±CI range ; Where: CI is the confidence interval of the sensor assembly validation value; S.V. mean is the sensor assembly validation value obtained from the storage system (204); CI range is the confidence interval range calculated based on the standard deviation and t-value, 35. The meter electronics (20) of claim 33 or 34.
36. The confidence interval range is calculated using the following formula: CI range =stderror pooled ・t student,99.8 ; stderror pooled is the pooled standard error of the sensor assembly validation measurement, t student,99.8 is a t-value calculated based on a significance level and degrees of freedom determined from a number of the sensor assembly validation measurements including the sensor assembly validation value; The meter electronics (20) of claim 35.
37. 37. The meter electronics of claim 26, wherein the processing system is further configured to set a bias deadband, and wherein the sensor assembly validation value is not detected as different from the baseline sensor assembly validation value if the central tendency value is less than the bias deadband.
38. 28. The meter electronics of claim 26 or 27, wherein the processing system (302) configured to determine the probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value comprises the processing system (302) configured to determine a confidence interval based on the central tendency value and the variance value.
39. 40. The meter electronics (20) of claim 38, wherein the baseline sensor assembly validation value comprises a central tendency value and a variance value of the baseline sensor assembly validation value.
40. The central tendency value of the baseline sensor assembly verification value is the average of the baseline sensor assembly verification values, and the variance value of the baseline sensor assembly verification values is the standard deviation of the baseline sensor assembly verification values. The meter electronic device (20) according to claim 39.
41. The meter electronic device (20) being configured to detect whether the central tendency value is different from the baseline sensor assembly verification value includes that the meter electronic device (20) is configured to determine whether the probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value overlaps with the probability of the baseline sensor assembly verification value. The meter electronic device (20) according to claim 26 or 27.
42. The probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value includes a confidence interval determined based on the central tendency value and the variance value, and the probability of the baseline sensor assembly verification value includes a confidence interval determined based on the baseline sensor assembly verification measurement value. The meter electronic device (20) according to claim 41.
43. The meter electronic device (20) being configured to determine whether the probability based on the central tendency value overlaps with the probability of the baseline sensor assembly verification value is the following formula, that is, LHS=|μ measured -m baseline |; RHS=2*(σ measured -s baseline ); calculate When LHS < RHS, it is determined that the probability of the central tendency value and the variance value obtained from the storage system (304) overlaps with the probability of the baseline sensor assembly verification value. including that the meter electronic device (20) is configured as such. The meter electronic device (20) according to claim 41.
44. The baseline standard deviation is calculated according to the following formula. s baseline =dead band*μ baseline The meter electronic device (20) according to claim 43.
45. A method for verifying a sensor assembly using parameters of a sensor signal supplied by the sensor assembly, obtaining a central tendency value of sensor assembly verification values and a variance value of the sensor assembly verification values from a storage device in a meter electronic device of a vibrating meter; determining a probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value to determine whether the central tendency value is different from a baseline sensor assembly verification value including. the baseline sensor assembly validation value is based on a sensor signal parameter value; method.
46. 46. The method of claim 45, wherein the sensor assembly validation value is one of an LPO / RPO voltage ratio value, a DRV / LPO voltage ratio value, and a DRV / RPO voltage ratio value.
47. 47. The method of claim 45 or 46, wherein determining the probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value comprises calculating a t-value and calculating the probability using the t-value.
48. 48. The method of claim 45, wherein determining the probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value comprises calculating degrees of freedom based on several sensor assembly validation measurements.
49. 49. The method of claim 48, wherein determining the probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value comprises calculating a standard error based on a standard deviation and the degrees of freedom.
50. The standard error is calculated using the following formula: ##EQU00024## Where: stddev pooled is the standard deviation, n DOF is the degree of freedom, 50. The method of claim 49.
51. 51. The method of any one of claims 45 to 50, wherein the variance value is a pooled standard deviation including the standard deviation of a sensor assembly validation measurement and a baseline sensor assembly validation measurement.
52. 52. The method of any one of claims 45 to 51, wherein the probability comprises a confidence interval for the central tendency value.
53. The confidence interval is compared to 0; detecting that the central tendency value is not equal to the baseline sensor assembly validation value if the confidence interval does not include zero; detecting that the central tendency value is equal to the baseline sensor assembly validation value if the confidence interval includes zero; 53. The method of claim 52.
54. the central tendency value is the sensor assembly validation value, and the confidence interval for the sensor assembly validation value is calculated using the formula: CI=SV mean ±CI range ; Where: CI is the confidence interval of the sensor assembly validation value; S.V. mean is the sensor assembly validation value obtained from the storage system (204); CI range is the confidence interval range calculated based on the standard deviation and t-value, 54. The method of claim 52 or 53.
55. The confidence interval range is calculated using the following formula: CI range =stderror pooled ・t student,99.8 ; Where: stderror pooled is the pooled standard error of the sensor assembly validation measurement, t student,99.8 is a t-value calculated based on a significance level and degrees of freedom determined from a number of the sensor assembly validation measurements including the sensor assembly validation value; The method of claim 54.
56. Further including setting a bias dead zone, when the central tendency value is smaller than the bias dead zone, the sensor assembly verification value is not detected as different from the baseline sensor assembly verification value, the method according to any one of claims 45 to 55.
57. Determining the probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value includes determining a confidence interval based on the central tendency value and the variance value, the method according to claim 45 or 46.
58. The baseline sensor assembly verification value includes a central tendency value and a variance value of the baseline sensor assembly verification value, the method according to claim 57.
59. The central tendency value of the baseline sensor assembly verification value is the average of the baseline sensor assembly verification values, and the variance value of the baseline sensor assembly verification value is the standard deviation of the baseline sensor assembly verification values, the method according to claim 58.
60. Detecting whether the central tendency value is different from the baseline sensor assembly verification value includes determining whether the probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value overlaps with the probability of the baseline sensor assembly verification value, the method according to claim 45 or 46.
61. The probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value includes a confidence interval determined based on the central tendency value and the variance value, and the probability of the baseline sensor assembly verification value includes a confidence interval determined based on the baseline sensor assembly verification measurement values, the method according to claim 59.
62. Determining whether the probability based on the central tendency value and the variance value does not overlap with the probability of the baseline sensor assembly verification value is as follows: LHS=|μ measured -m baseline |; RHS=2*(σ measured -s baseline ); Calculating When LHS < RHS, determining that the probability of the central tendency value and the variance value obtained from the storage device overlaps with the probability of the baseline sensor assembly verification value Including The method according to claim 60.
63. The standard deviation of the baseline system assembly verification value is calculated according to the following formula s baseline =dead band*μ baseline The method according to claim 61.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Vibrational flow meter and methods and diagnostics for meter verification
JP2017504031A
Vibration meter change detection and identification
JP2020532717A
Detecting a change in a vibratory meter based on two baseline meter verifications
WO2020036586A1
