Route planning device for traffic control system
The route planning device dynamically adjusts aircraft exclusive spaces to ensure safe and efficient navigation by accounting for performance declines, addressing inefficiencies and safety risks in vertical takeoff and landing operations.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2021100769
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2021-06-17
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-15
- Estimated Expiration
- 2041-06-17
AI Technical Summary
Existing route planning technologies for vertical takeoff and landing aircraft fail to account for potential declines in aircraft maneuverability due to actuator failures or power issues, leading to unsafe and inefficient operation, particularly in challenging weather conditions or proximity to obstacles.
A route planning device that dynamically adjusts the exclusive space of each aircraft based on its performance and conditions, allowing for real-time replanning to ensure safe and efficient navigation by minimizing the exclusive space required, even when maneuverability deteriorates.
Enables safe and efficient simultaneous takeoff and landing operations by planning routes that maintain minimum proximity distances and adapt to changing aircraft performance, enhancing operational efficiency and safety.
Smart Images

Figure 0007584360000001 
Figure 0007584360000002 
Figure 0007584360000003
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present invention relates to a route planning device for an aircraft traffic control system. [Background technology]
[0002] In recent years, attention has been focused on the social use of drones and other aircraft capable of vertical take-off and landing, examples of which include their use in agriculture, logistics, and human transportation. However, the stable and safe operation and navigation of aircraft requires high skills and specialized knowledge, and at present, it is not easy to use and operate them, including in terms of cost.
[0003] On the other hand, with the advancement of self-driving technology for automobiles, research and development of autonomous navigation technology for aircraft is being actively pursued, and it is expected that autonomous vertical take-off and landing aircraft will take advantage of the skies. To operate autonomous vertical take-off and landing aircraft safely and efficiently, it is necessary to have take-off and landing ports and take-off and landing operation control systems that can be linked with these aircraft.
[0004] In particular, to reduce operational costs, it is necessary to improve operational efficiency, and in applications such as logistics, it is necessary to have takeoff and landing ports and takeoff and landing operation control systems that allow multiple aircraft to take off and land simultaneously safely and with space efficiency. Note that from here on, vertical takeoff and landing aircraft may be abbreviated to simply "aircraft."
[0005] To enable vertical take-off and landing aircraft to take off and land space-efficiently and without collisions, it is sufficient to simply set the allowable approach distance between aircraft (the tolerance for the relative distance between each aircraft) short, and then plan the route from the start position coordinates to the end position coordinates of each aircraft so that the distance between each aircraft is greater than or equal to the allowable approach distance at all times.
[0006] However, for example, in bad weather, strong winds, or downwash (wind blowing down) from other aircraft, the attitude and flight position coordinates of the aircraft may be disturbed, so the allowable proximity distance must be long enough to take these external risks into consideration. There is also the risk of bird strikes. If there are obstacles to flight, such as flocks of birds, the route must be planned taking into account the risk of contact between the aircraft and the obstacles.
[0007] An example of a technology for planning the path of a mobile body that takes into account risks caused by the external environment of the machine is Patent Document 1. Patent Document 1 describes a mobile robot system equipped with a path planning unit for the mobile robot that plans the path of the mobile robot to achieve a specified objective, which recognizes potential risk areas on the planned path with a group of sensors, probabilistically quantifies the occurrence of risks in the potential risk areas as a "possibility," evaluates the possibility of the mobile robot traveling the path (achieving the specified objective) based on this, and when the possibility is low, the path planning unit re-executes the path planning so as to increase the possibility of achieving the specified objective. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0008] [Patent Document 1] JP 2017-010234 A Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0009] When the technology of Patent Document 1 is used in a takeoff and landing flight control system that plans the takeoff and landing paths of a vertical takeoff and landing aircraft, the following problems arise.
[0010] Generally, in the event of a deterioration in the performance or stoppage of an actuator due to a power machinery failure or a drop in power supply voltage, etc., the aircraft's maneuvering performance may be reduced, but the aircraft is designed with redundant systems to enable it to continue flying safely. In other words, even if one actuator stops, flight can continue by utilizing the other actuators.
[0011] When the maneuverability of the aircraft, such as thrust or turning power, is reduced, for example in strong winds, the aircraft's attitude and flight position coordinates are easily disturbed, and if there is another aircraft nearby, there is a risk of collision. Also, if there is an obstacle nearby, there is a risk of contact with the obstacle.
[0012] Therefore, the permissible approach distance between an aircraft with reduced maneuverability and other aircraft, as well as the distance between the aircraft and obstacles, must be significantly longer than that for a normal aircraft, and in this case the route of each aircraft must be planned based on such permissible approach distances.
[0013] In the approach of treating the risk of such "deterioration of aircraft maneuvering performance" as a "risk that may occur on the route" and replanning the route using the technology of Patent Document 1, the probability that the performance deterioration or stoppage of the aircraft's actuators may occur is generally designed to be sufficiently low, so it is judged to be a low risk and does not trigger a route replanning. Therefore, it is difficult to say that a safe route plan considering the possibility of "deterioration of aircraft maneuvering performance" can be achieved.
[0014] On the other hand, if a route is planned that takes into account the possibility of a "deterioration in aircraft maneuverability" and sets a sufficiently long allowable approach distance to allow safe flight without colliding with other aircraft or obstacles even in the event of a "deterioration in aircraft maneuverability," then the space occupied by each aircraft will become larger, the efficiency of utilization of the space above and around the takeoff and landing ports will decrease, and it will be difficult to sufficiently improve operational efficiency.
[0015] The present invention has been made in consideration of such problems, and aims to provide a route planning device for a traffic control system that is capable of allowing multiple aircraft to take off and land simultaneously safely and with space efficiency, even when a significant deterioration in aircraft maneuverability occurs. [Means for solving the problem]
[0016] In view of the above, the present invention provides a route planning device for a traffic control system that provides an aircraft with a route for its navigation, the route planning device comprising: an exclusive space design unit that designs an exclusive space for each of a plurality of aircraft based on the performance and status of the aircraft in a route plan at the beginning of the aircraft's navigation; and a route planning unit that plans a route from the start point position coordinates to the end point position coordinates of each aircraft based on the start point position coordinates, the end point position coordinates, and the exclusive space of each aircraft, so that other aircraft and obstacles do not invade the exclusive space of each aircraft at all times when the aircraft navigates from the start point position coordinates to the end point position coordinates, and provides the route to each aircraft, the route planning device detecting a deterioration in performance of an aircraft while the aircraft is navigating, redesigning the exclusive space of the aircraft with deteriorated performance based on information on the current position coordinates, performance, and status of the aircraft with deteriorated performance, replanning the route for each of the plurality of aircraft so that other aircraft and obstacles do not invade the redesigned exclusive space, and providing the route to each aircraft. Effect of the Invention
[0017] According to the present invention, when there is no degradation of the aircraft's maneuvering performance, a route can be planned with spatial efficiency at the minimum allowable approach distance, and even when there is a degradation of the aircraft's maneuvering performance, a safe and efficient route can be planned. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0018] [Figure 1] FIG. 1 is a diagram showing an example of the configuration of a traffic control system according to a first embodiment of the present invention. [Diagram 2] A diagram showing the flight behavior of aircraft A when it is a vertical take-off and landing aircraft. [Diagram 3] A diagram showing the flight behavior of aircraft A and B when they are vertical take-off and landing aircraft. [Figure 4] A diagram showing a case where aircraft A is unable to follow route 9 due to strong winds and deviates from it. [Diagram 5] FIG. 13 is a diagram for explaining the behavior of the aircraft when its functionality is impaired. [Figure 6] 3 is a processing flow of the path planning device 2. [Figure 7]FIG. 13 is a diagram for explaining replanning including changing the end point of another aircraft. [Figure 8] A diagram to explain replanning, including reducing the space occupied by other aircraft. [Figure 9] FIG. 11 is a diagram showing a configuration example of a traffic control system according to a third embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 10] FIG. 11 is a diagram showing a configuration example of a traffic control system according to a fourth embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 11] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing an example of evaluation items of safety levels. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0019] Hereinafter, embodiments of the present invention will be described with reference to the drawings. In each drawing, components having a common function are given the same reference numerals, and duplicated explanations may be omitted. EXAMPLES
[0020] FIG. 1 shows an example of the configuration of a traffic control system according to a first embodiment of the present invention.
[0021] In the system of FIG. 1, a traffic management system 1 that manages and controls the takeoff and landing of a plurality of aircraft (such as vertical takeoff and landing aircraft) includes a route planning device 2. It plans and provides takeoff and landing routes for aircraft A and B according to the purpose of each aircraft, and guides the aircraft. The route planning device 2 consists of a route planning unit 3 and an exclusive space design unit 4, and both have a mechanism for sharing information with each other via a communication unit 5.
[0022] The traffic control system 1 controls the traffic of aircraft within a controlled airspace, and the route planning device 2 plans and provides routes to a group of aircraft within the controlled airspace. When aircraft A and aircraft B are within a controlled airspace, the route planning device 2 provides routes 9 and 10 planned by the route planning unit 3 to aircraft A and aircraft B, respectively, via the communication device 6, and aircraft A and aircraft B navigate in accordance with the provided routes.
[0023] The route planning unit 3 plans a route from the start point position coordinates to the end point position coordinates based on the exclusive space of each machine designed by the exclusive space design unit 4. Here, the exclusive space of the machine is a three-dimensional space linked to each machine. Vertical take-off and landing aircraft often have rotors that generate thrust in the vertical direction. Specific examples of vertical take-off and landing aircraft include hexacopters, which have multiple simple rotors that do not have a mechanically variable structure such as the pitch angle of the rotor blades, control the rotation speed of the rotors to control the motion of the aircraft, and configure a redundant system with more rotors than the minimum number required to control the motion of the aircraft.
[0024] In this case, even if one rotor is unable to generate thrust for some reason, the aircraft's motion can be controlled by appropriately controlling the rotation speed of the other five rotors. Most aircraft are configured with redundant systems for such actuators from the perspective of safe flight.
[0025] The route planning device 2 has a function of receiving performance degradation flag information 11 indicating a performance degradation of each aircraft, and navigation information 12 such as aircraft position, performance, status, etc. from aircraft (e.g., aircraft A and aircraft B) in the controlled airspace via a communication device 6 as shown in Fig. 1. Note that the navigation information 12 and performance degradation flag information 11 are collectively referred to as aircraft information 13.
[0026] Specifically, the performance degradation flag information 11 is a notification signal issued by the aircraft when the performance of the aircraft is degraded due to a breakdown in the aircraft's power machinery, a drop in the power supply voltage, or the like causing an actuator to stop or perform poorly, to request the route planning device 2 to re-plan the route.
[0027] Fig. 2 shows the state of navigation when the aircraft A is a vertical take-off and landing aircraft. In Fig. 2, the navigation objective of the aircraft A is to land from the current position to a take-off and landing port 28 on the ground 29, that is, to move from a start point position coordinate 26 of the current position to an end point position coordinate 27 on the take-off and landing port. When a route 9 from the start point position coordinate 26 to the end point position coordinate 27 is provided by the route planning device 2, the aircraft A can achieve the navigation objective by navigating in accordance with this route 9.
[0028] In FIG. 2, the space associated with the aircraft A is the exclusive space 21 of the aircraft A, and here, the exclusive space 21 in a simple definition is shown. In other words, the exclusive space 21 of the aircraft A is defined as a sphere with a radius 23 centered on the aircraft center 22. The advantage of this definition is the simplicity with which the exclusive space volume of the aircraft A can be designed with only one parameter, the radius 23. Note that the exclusive space 21 can be defined as any solid body that can form a three-dimensional space, such as a cube or a rectangular parallelepiped, in addition to a sphere.
[0029] The route planning unit 3 grasps the start point position coordinates 26 and the end point position coordinates 27 according to the purpose of the aircraft A, plans a route 9, and provides this to the aircraft A, but at this time, the route 9 is designed taking into consideration the exclusive space 21 of the aircraft A. In other words, a route is planned such that no obstacles such as other aircraft or birds will invade the exclusive space 21 of the aircraft A at any time when the aircraft A moves from the start point position coordinates 26 to the end point position coordinates 27. In addition, the route is planned so that the maneuvering performance of the aircraft A can sufficiently follow it. The route planned by the route planning unit 3 is time series data in which the position coordinates of the aircraft are managed by time.
[0030] Fig. 3 shows the state of flight when aircraft A and aircraft B are vertical take-off and landing aircraft. The route planning unit 3 also simultaneously plans the route of another aircraft (for example, aircraft B) as shown in Fig. 3. At this time, it is necessary to know the exclusive space 21 of aircraft A and the exclusive space 32 of aircraft B, and the route planning unit 3 plans a route for each of the exclusive spaces 21, 32 of aircraft A and B so that the other aircraft does not invade.
[0031] Fig. 3 shows a case where the routes of aircraft A and aircraft B intersect at a future time. For example, in Fig. 3, route 9 with aircraft A's traveling direction 34 and route 10 with aircraft B's traveling direction 35 intersect at intersection 38. Even in this case, if routes are planned as time-series data, a route can be planned such that one aircraft does not invade the exclusive space of the other aircraft at any time. For example, a route can be planned such that aircraft B passes through intersection 38 after aircraft A passes through intersection 38 and is sufficiently away from intersection 38.
[0032] Returning to Figure 1, in planning such routes 9 and 10, the route planning unit 3 needs to understand the exclusive spaces 21, 32 of each aircraft A and B, and the exclusive space design unit 4 is responsible for designing the exclusive spaces 21, 32 of each aircraft A and B and providing them to the route planning unit 3.
[0033] The exclusive space design unit 4 can simply set the radius 23 of the aircraft A to a predetermined value that is independent of the time, and can design the radius 23 to be extremely large, particularly to reduce the risk of collision with other aircraft to almost zero.
[0034] However, if this were to happen, the airspace above the takeoff and landing port and its surrounding areas would be occupied by aircraft A's exclusive space 21, meaning that other aircraft would not be able to take off or land, let alone navigate around the takeoff and landing port, which would significantly reduce operational efficiency.
[0035] The operational efficiency mentioned here indicates how many aircraft can land and take off per unit time in a given area (there may be multiple areas) on the ground for a single aircraft to take off and land in. If users were to pay for the number of takeoffs and landings, the route planning device 2 of the traffic control system 1 would be required to improve operational efficiency from a business perspective.
[0036] To improve operational efficiency, it is necessary to design the exclusive space for each aircraft to be the minimum necessary without the risk of collision with other aircraft or contact with obstacles. The reason for providing exclusive space is to ensure safety. For example, if aircraft A is navigating in strong winds, the wind may disturb the aircraft's attitude, and in some cases, it may deviate from the route.
[0037] Fig. 4 is a diagram showing a case where aircraft A deviates from route 9 due to strong winds and is unable to follow it. In Fig. 4, route 9 of aircraft A and route 10 of aircraft B are planned based on their respective exclusive spaces 21 and 32, and it is planned that there will be no collision between aircraft A and B when they navigate along routes 9 and 10.
[0038] In contrast, when navigating an area with strong winds 41, it is assumed that aircraft A will deviate from route 9 due to the influence of the strong winds and navigate along trajectory 43. Even in such a case, however, the route planning unit 3 can plan and provide a route that promotes safe navigation without the risk of aircraft A colliding with aircraft B by planning route 9 that takes into account the exclusive space 21 that is set to a large size, as shown in Figure 4.
[0039] In Figure 4, the radius 23 of the exclusive space 21 of the aircraft A is constant throughout the entire route 9, including the area of strong winds 41. However, if the traffic control system 1 can grasp the wind volume and direction for each navigation area using a weather radar or the like, the radius 23 of the exclusive space 21 can be designed to be shorter in areas where the impact of wind is small and navigation is stable, thereby narrowing the aircraft's exclusive spatial area and contributing to improved operational efficiency.
[0040] 4, the design of radius 23 of exclusive space 21 may be changed depending on the maneuvering performance of aircraft A. For example, if aircraft A can generate high thrust and turning force and can sufficiently withstand the drag caused by strong wind 41, there is no need to design radius 23 of exclusive space 21 of aircraft A to be wide even in a strong wind area.
[0041] In addition, if obstacles such as birds can be detected using LiDAR (Laser Imaging Detection and Ranging) or cameras, it is effective to design the exclusive area to be large when navigating close to the obstacle in order to reduce the risk of contact with the obstacle.
[0042] By designing the exclusive space for each aircraft in this way, the exclusive space can be changed depending on the aircraft's maneuvering performance, weather conditions, and the presence or absence of obstacles, which keeps the exclusive space for each aircraft to a minimum, contributing to improved operational efficiency.
[0043] Since the exclusive space design unit 4 is responsible for designing the exclusive space of each machine, the exclusive space design is given as time series data. Taking machine A as an example, the exclusive space 21 of machine A may have a radius 23 as time series data. The process contents in the route planning unit 3 and exclusive space design unit 4 will be explained below using formulas.
[0044] In the following explanation using mathematical expressions, the radius r that defines the exclusive space of the aircraft k is expressed as a function of time t as rk(t), and the path p of the aircraft k is expressed as a position coordinate vector as pk(t), expressed in time series. The maneuverability performance of the aircraft k is expressed as Ck, the weather conditions around the aircraft as Wk(t), and the obstacle information as Ok.
[0045] At this time, based on the explanation so far, the exclusive space design unit 4 can simply express the exclusive space as a time series design for M aircraft, taking into account the maneuvering performance and weather conditions of each aircraft, as in equation (1), and the exclusive space design unit 4 provides such rk(t), k=1 to M to the route planning unit 3. [Number 1] rk(t)=G(Ck, Ok, Wk(t), t), k=1~M ···(1) The route planning unit 3, simply, plans the route of each aircraft as equation (2) based on rk(t) and obstacle information provided by the exclusive space design unit 4, and provides pk(t), k=1 to M for aircraft k. [Number 2] pk(t)=F(rk(t), Ok, t), k=1~M ···(2) Specifically, if the relative distance between any unit i and unit j is Eij(t) and the relative distance between unit i and obstacle q is Diq(t), then a path pk(t) can be designed to satisfy equations (3) and (4) for all time, all units, and all obstacles. Note that ||X|| is the norm of X, and max(X, Y) is an operator that means the larger of X and Y. [Number 3] ||Eij(t)-max(ri(t), rj(t))||>0··(3) [Number 4] ||Diq(t)-ri(t)||>0 (4) In addition, when designing an exclusive space, for example, when taking into account the weather conditions around the aircraft, the position coordinates of the aircraft must be known, that is, information on the route pk(t) is required.
[0046] Therefore, the exclusive space design unit 4 may acquire route candidates from the route planning unit 3 via the communication unit 5 in FIG. 1, for example, and design the exclusive space based on the candidates. The route of the vehicle k may be planned by simultaneous planning problems by the route planning unit 3 and the exclusive space design unit 4, and the exclusive space and the route may be simultaneously optimized to satisfy predetermined evaluation items and constraints set in the route plan. The predetermined evaluation items are, for example, the reduction in route length and travel time from the start point position coordinates to the end point position coordinates, etc., from the viewpoint of improving operation efficiency. The constraints are, for example, the curvature of the route must be less than a predetermined value, etc., from the viewpoint of the ride comfort of the vehicle.
[0047] However, the route planning device 2 described above is not sufficient in providing a safe and efficient route plan when aircraft performance is degraded, for example, when the rotor stops due to a power machine failure or the like, the rotor output is reduced due to battery deterioration, or the rotor operation duration is reduced, etc. Note that the performance degradation flag information 11 shown in Fig. 1 indicating the performance degradation is information indicating the occurrence of such factors.
[0048] If there is a significant degradation in aircraft performance, for example if there is insufficient thrust or turning power to counter the resistance caused by strong winds, or if there is not enough flight time remaining, the route based on the exclusive space before the degradation in aircraft performance cannot be adequately followed, resulting in a risk of collision with other aircraft or obstacles, or of not being able to reach the final position coordinates.
[0049] If the exclusive space design unit 4 were to design an exclusive space taking into consideration the deterioration of aircraft performance in advance, it would be possible to design the exclusive space based on the failure rate of the aircraft, for example. However, since the failure rates of devices such as actuators, sensors, and batteries of aircraft, which are basically designed with an emphasis on safety, are designed to be quite low, designing the exclusive space based on the failure rate of the aircraft would not be sufficient as an indicator for ensuring sufficient exclusive space.
[0050] On the other hand, if the exclusive space is designed assuming an aircraft with reduced performance in order to ensure safety even when aircraft performance is degraded, the exclusive space must be large. In a state where the aircraft performance is not degraded, this will result in a sufficient amount of surplus exclusive space, leading to reduced operational efficiency.
[0051] The route planning device 2 of this embodiment shown in FIG. 1 provides a route plan that is safe and has good operational efficiency, taking into consideration such deterioration in aircraft performance.
[0052] Fig. 5 is a diagram for explaining the behavior of the aircraft when its performance is degraded. Taking the case where aircraft A and aircraft B are the targets of route planning as shown in Fig. 1 as an example, the behavior of the route planning device 2 will be explained for a case where, in a case where both aircraft complete navigation from the start point position coordinates to the end point position coordinates (end point 51, end point 52) according to given routes 9 and 10 from time t0 to time te as shown in Fig. 5, a significant decrease in aircraft performance occurs in aircraft A at time ta.
[0053] FIG. 6 shows a process flow of the route planning device 2. This process flow is composed of a pre-processing part (processing steps S61 to S63) that creates and provides routes 9 and 10 in advance at the early stage of the flight of the aircraft A and B, and a flight process part (processing steps S64 to S71) that provides corrected routes to the aircraft A and B according to changes in the situation during flight. The early stage of flight is, for example, before takeoff when the aircraft takes off from an airfield, or when the aircraft enters a controlled area of a traffic control system and a route for landing is required. According to the pre-processing of this process flow, in the first processing step S61, the route planning device 2 acquires navigation information 12 such as aircraft position, performance, and status, and purpose as aircraft information 13 from each of the aircraft A and B via the communication device 6 at time t0 in FIG. 5. Note that the aircraft information 13 is a concept that also includes the performance degradation flag information 11, but it is assumed that sufficient aircraft maintenance is performed at this early stage of flight, and the navigation information 12 can be used.
[0054] Here, the aircraft position is a three-dimensional position coordinate, the performance is the specification information of the aircraft's maneuvering performance and navigation performance, and the status is the degree of degradation of the maneuvering performance and navigation performance against the rated performance, specifically, the soundness level of the navigation-related devices such as actuators, sensors, batteries, etc. Also, the purpose is the aircraft's request regarding takeoff and landing, for example, a request to the flight control system 1 such as "I want to land at port X within a certain number of minutes."
[0055] Next, in a processing step S62, the route planning device 2 calculates the start point position coordinates and the end point position coordinates (end point 51 and end point 52 in FIG. 5) based on the aircraft positions and the purpose of each aircraft at time t0. A route connecting them (route 9 and route 10 in FIG. 5) is planned. At this time, the exclusive space design unit 4 calculates the maneuverability performance Ck of each aircraft based on the performance and state of each aircraft, and calculates the exclusive space rk(t) of each aircraft using equation (1). The route planning unit 3 plans a route for each aircraft using equation (2) based on rk(t). Next, in processing step S63, routes 9 and 10 are provided to each aircraft via the communication device 6 at time t0(+Δt). In response to this, each aircraft becomes able to navigate in accordance with the route from the start point position coordinates to the end point position coordinates designed at time t0(+Δt).
[0056] The aircraft A and B that have obtained the information on the routes 9 and 10 are able to navigate from time t0(+Δt) onwards, and in the navigation state, as shown in processing step S70, the route planning device 2 obtains navigation information 12 and performance degradation flag information 11 as aircraft information 13 from the aircraft A and B at regular time intervals. Note that in processing step S70, the route planning device 2 may obtain only the performance degradation flag information 11 from the aircraft A and B at regular time intervals.
[0057] As a result, in process step S64, the route planning device 2 checks from time to time whether or not there has been a report of a performance degradation flag 11 from each aircraft. If there has been no report, in process step S68 in Fig. 6, it is determined whether to continue or end the route planning. For example, this is done by detecting that the end time te in Fig. 5 has passed and ending the plan in process step S69, and if it is before time te, the process returns to process step S70, and this is repeatedly executed while the aircraft is underway.
[0058] In the example of Fig. 5, it is assumed that a significant degradation in aircraft performance occurs in aircraft A at time ta, and at this time, in the flow of Fig. 6, in processing step S65 at time ta, a report of significant degradation in aircraft performance is provided from aircraft A to the route planning device 2 via communication device 6 as performance degradation flag information 11, and the route planning device 2 acquires and confirms navigation information 12 including the aircraft position, performance, and status of aircraft A. Here, the aircraft position is the three-dimensional position coordinates of aircraft A at time ta, the performance is specification information such as the aircraft's maneuvering performance and navigation performance, and the status is the degree of degradation of the maneuvering performance and navigation performance relative to the rated performance.
[0059] In processing step S66, the exclusive space design unit 4 designs the radius 23 of the exclusive space 21 of the aircraft A to be sufficiently large, as shown after time ta in Fig. 5, according to the degree of performance degradation of the aircraft A. That is, the exclusive space design unit 4 calculates the maneuverability performance Ck(k=A) of the aircraft A according to the degree of performance degradation of the aircraft A based on the performance and state of the aircraft A, and calculates the exclusive space rk(t)(k=A), t=ta to te of the aircraft A using equation (1), thereby ensuring that the aircraft A can continue safe navigation.
[0060] Furthermore, in processing step S66, the path planning unit 3 redesigns the path of the aircraft A based on the exclusive space 21 of the aircraft A designed by the exclusive space design unit 4. That is, based on rk(t) (k=A), the path pk(t) (k=A), t=ta~te (path 55 in FIG. 5) of the aircraft A is redesigned using equation (2). At this time, the redesigned path 55 is one that can be sufficiently followed even by the aircraft A with reduced performance, taking into consideration, for example, its resistance to wind, its low curvature, its short distance, and the like.
[0061] The replanned route 55 is provided to vehicle A via communication device 6 in process step S67.
[0062] So far, the redesign of the route 9 of the aircraft A with deteriorated performance has been described, but if a sufficiently large radius 23 is set in accordance with the degree of performance deterioration of the aircraft A, there may be a risk that another aircraft B traveling in accordance with an already provided route (e.g., route 10 in FIG. 5) may invade the exclusive space of the aircraft A. Conversely, when the route planning device 2 redesigns the route of the aircraft A at time ta, there may be a case where it is unable to replan a route that does not cause the other aircraft B to invade the exclusive space of the aircraft A.
[0063] In consideration of such a situation, the route planning device 2 also acquires the performance and status of an aircraft (e.g., aircraft B) that is present at least within a predetermined distance from aircraft A at time ta, and re-plans the routes of these aircraft (where k = 1 to n).
[0064] That is, in processing step S65, the route planning device 2 acquires navigation information 12 such as the aircraft position, performance, status, etc. of aircraft A as well as navigation information 12 such as the aircraft position, performance, status, etc. of aircraft (k=1 to n) (e.g., aircraft B) via the communication device 6.
[0065] The exclusive space design unit 4 calculates the maneuvering performance Ck of each aircraft based on navigation information 12 such as the degree of performance degradation of aircraft A and the performance and status of the aircraft (k=1 to n), and designs the exclusive space 21 of aircraft A and the exclusive spaces of the aircraft (k=1 to n) based on equation (1).In this case, the exclusive space 21 of aircraft A is designed to be sufficiently large to ensure that safe navigation can be continued.
[0066] In addition, the route planning unit 3 redesigns the route pk(t) k=1~n, A, t=ta~te of each aircraft based on the exclusive space rk(t), k=1~n, A, t=ta~te of each aircraft designed by the exclusive space design unit 4. At this time, the redesigned route 55 is one that can be sufficiently followed even by the aircraft A with reduced performance, taking into consideration, for example, that it is less susceptible to the influence of wind, has a low curvature, is short in distance, etc., and the routes of the other aircraft are redesigned so that there is no risk of intrusion into the exclusive space 21 of the aircraft A.
[0067] 5, the route of the other aircraft is re-planned in such a way that the end point position coordinates of the other aircraft (e.g., end point 52 of aircraft B) are not changed, and there may still be cases where the other aircraft may invade the exclusive space 21 of aircraft A. For this reason, when executing the processing of the processing steps S65, S66, and S67, it is advisable to take measures taking the following points into consideration.
[0068] Fig. 7 is a diagram for explaining replanning including a change in the end point of another aircraft. To deal with such a case, the route planning device 2 should have a function of prioritizing the safe navigation of the aircraft A as shown in Fig. 7, changing the end point position coordinate of the other aircraft (aircraft B) from end point 52 to end point 72, and then designing the route of the other aircraft. The change in the end point position coordinate in this case is, for example, a change in the landing port (ground area), etc.
[0069] In addition to changing the destination of other aircraft, it is also preferable to have a function to change the destination position coordinates (destination 51) of aircraft A whose performance has deteriorated. This is in consideration of dealing with cases where the cruising distance is insufficient and it is difficult to reach the destination 51, such as when only auxiliary power is left due to battery failure.
[0070] Fig. 8 is a diagram for explaining replanning including reduction of the exclusive space of the other aircraft. In addition, as for the replanning of the other aircraft, it is preferable to have a function of designing a route that ensures safe navigation of the aircraft A with reduced performance by narrowing the exclusive space of the other aircraft (exclusive space 32 of the aircraft B) according to the aircraft position, performance, and state of the other aircraft after time ta, as shown in Fig. 8. For example, this is in consideration of a case where it is necessary to navigate in cooperation with the aircraft A with reduced performance so as not to interfere with the safe navigation of the aircraft A by making full use of the performance of the other aircraft other than the aircraft A with reduced performance that is above the rated performance.
[0071] According to the route planning device 2 of the traffic control system 1 of this embodiment, which provides routes for takeoff and landing to multiple aircraft, routes can be planned with spatial efficiency at the minimum allowable approach distance for multiple aircraft when there is no deterioration in the aircraft's maneuvering performance, and even if there is a deterioration in the aircraft's maneuvering performance, a safe and efficient route can be planned.
[0072] In addition, the aircraft targeted by the path planning device 2 of this embodiment may be an aircraft other than a vertical take-off and landing aircraft, and is not limited to an aircraft capable of autonomous flight, but may also be an aircraft piloted by a pilot.
[0073] In addition to aircraft, the path planning device 2 of this embodiment can also be used for mobility with three-dimensional freedom of movement (spacecraft, submarines, etc.), as well as mobility that runs on the ground, such as automobiles, robots, and trains.
[0074] Further, in the path planning device 2 of this embodiment, the redesign of the path is triggered by a deterioration in the performance of the aircraft, but the request for redesign may be triggered by a significant deviation from an already designed path.
[0075] In addition, the aircraft targeted by the route planning device 2 of this embodiment are not limited to aircraft of a single model, type, or specifications. The route planning device 2 is provided with a mechanism for obtaining aircraft specification information, etc., as the "performance," and is therefore capable of handling such aircraft differences. EXAMPLES
[0076] A method of detecting a decrease in aircraft performance will be described in Example 2. In FIG. 1 of Example 1, the aircraft A transmits performance decrease flag information 11, and in processing step S64 of FIG. 6, the presence or absence of the performance decrease flag information 11 is set as a condition for route correction.
[0077] In this regard, the performance degradation flag information 11 in the first embodiment is intended mainly for serious cases where the performance degradation and stoppage of the actuator occurs due to a breakdown in the power machinery of the aircraft, a drop in the power supply voltage, etc. In contrast, some of the various specifications and performance of the aircraft can be grasped numerically, and for example, a drop in the power supply voltage may be a situation that requires immediate measures depending on the level, but in many cases, it is possible to predict a performance degradation at a minor stage.
[0078] According to FIG. 1, the aircraft information 13 available to the route planning device 2 includes not only the performance degradation flag information 11 but also navigation information 12 such as the aircraft position, performance, and status. By focusing in particular on the navigation information 12 such as performance and status and monitoring the level of the information, it becomes possible to use it as a condition for route correction that can replace the "presence or absence of performance degradation flag information 11" in processing step S64.
[0079] In this way, it is preferable that the detection conditions for performance degradation in the present invention are logically configured to include not only serious conditions but also minor conditions that are predictive. In the first and second embodiments, the detection conditions for performance degradation utilize the information transmitted from the aircraft as the aircraft information 13. EXAMPLES
[0080] Example 3 also refers to a method for detecting a decline in aircraft performance. However, while examples 1 and 2 involve information transmission from the aircraft, it is anticipated that there may be cases where there are limitations to the information transmission from the aircraft. Therefore, in example 3, a performance evaluation of the aircraft viewed from the outside world is described.
[0081] 9 shows a configuration example of a route planning device 2 according to a third embodiment. This embodiment is a case where the route planning device 2 of the traffic control system 1 of the first and second embodiments has a different means for grasping the performance degradation of the aircraft.
[0082] An aircraft with degraded performance is not necessarily able to fully grasp the extent of the performance degradation of the aircraft itself, and in the worst case, it is possible that the performance degradation may not be reported to the route planning device 2 via the communication device 6.
[0083] In the third embodiment, a traffic control system 1 including a route planning device 2 that can handle such a case is provided. The traffic control system 1 of the present embodiment is configured with the route planning device 2 and an observation device 93, and the route planning device 2 is configured by adding an aircraft performance estimation unit 92 to the route planning device 2.
[0084] As shown in FIG. 9, the path planning device 2 will be described taking as an example a case where paths of an aircraft A and an aircraft B are planned.
[0085] The observation device 93 observes from the outside the navigation behavior of all aircraft within the managed airspace of the traffic control system 1, or aircraft within the observable area of the observation device 93, and provides the observed information to the aircraft performance estimation unit 92 via communication path 95.
[0086] If the performance of aircraft A deteriorates while the aircraft A is traveling in accordance with a route already planned by the route planning device 2, but the route planning device 2 does not receive any information about the deterioration in aircraft performance from the aircraft A via the communication device 6, the route planning device 2 redesigns the route based on the information obtained from the aircraft performance estimation unit 92.
[0087] The aircraft performance estimation unit 92 is responsible for estimating the degree of performance degradation of each aircraft from the flight behavior of the aircraft obtained from the observation device 93.
[0088] Here, the observation device 93 refers to a group of sensors installed on the ground that can acquire aircraft position information from hundreds to thousands of meters ahead and speed information from the time derivative thereof, such as LiDAR, radar (Radio Detection and Ranging), stereo camera, etc. Note that the position and speed information of the aircraft group may be acquired from a group of sensors installed on an aircraft other than the ground.
[0089] The aircraft performance estimation unit 92 constantly estimates the degree of performance degradation of each aircraft based on the position and speed information of each aircraft obtained from the observation device 93 and the performance and status of each aircraft already obtained at the time of route design, and if it determines that the degree of performance degradation is significant, it provides a performance degradation flag on behalf of the aircraft whose performance has deteriorated.In response to this, the route planning device 2 redesigns the route in the route planning unit 3 and exclusive space design unit 4.
[0090] According to the route planning device 2 of the traffic control system 1 of this embodiment, which provides routes for takeoff and landing to multiple aircraft, routes can be planned with spatial efficiency at the minimum allowable approach distance for multiple aircraft when there is no deterioration in the aircraft's maneuvering performance, and even when there is a deterioration in the aircraft's maneuvering performance and the performance and status cannot be obtained from the aircraft, a safe and efficient route can be planned.
[0091] In addition, when some information regarding performance and status is obtained from an aircraft with degraded performance, or when only some of the obtained information regarding performance and status is utilized, the aircraft performance estimation unit 92 of the route planning device 2 in this embodiment may integrate this information with position and speed information of each aircraft obtained from the observation device 93 to estimate the degree of performance degradation of each aircraft.
[0092] It is not necessarily the case that an aircraft with degraded performance will be able to correctly grasp all information regarding its own performance and status, and it is also possible that an aircraft that does not have the ability to fully grasp its performance and status will be targeted for route planning in the first place.
[0093] In such a case, the route planning device 2 provides a means for grasping the performance and state, and the aircraft performance estimation unit 92, which is equipped with a mechanism for integrating the information provided by the aircraft and comprehensively judging the degree of deterioration in the aircraft performance, can more reliably detect the deterioration in the aircraft performance and provide a performance deterioration flag. As a result, it is possible to provide a highly safe route planning device 2. EXAMPLES
[0094] 10 shows the configuration of the route planning device 2 of the traffic control system 1 according to the fourth embodiment of the present invention. In this embodiment, a level determination unit 102 is added to the route planning device 2 of the traffic control system 1 according to the third embodiment.
[0095] The level determination unit 102 determines the safety level of each aircraft based on navigation information 12 such as the aircraft position, performance, and status of each aircraft. In the third embodiment, when a significant degradation in the performance of an aircraft occurs, the route planning unit 3 and the exclusive space design unit 4 redesign the exclusive space and replan the route based on navigation information 12 such as the aircraft position, performance, and status of the aircraft with degraded performance, but there is an advantage in that safety is made clearer when replanning is performed in accordance with a quantitatively evaluated safety level. The level determination unit 102 is provided in the route planning device 2 for this purpose.
[0096] Therefore, the route planning unit 3 and the exclusive space design unit 4 of this embodiment redesign the exclusive space and replan the route based on the safety level provided from the level determination unit 102. Note that the level determination unit 102 may determine the safety level taking into account the degree of performance degradation of each aircraft obtained from the aircraft performance estimation unit 92.
[0097] In addition, the traffic control system 1 of this embodiment is equipped with an observation device 105, which, in addition to the observation device 93 of Example 2, includes a sensor such as a Doppler LiDAR that can grasp wind conditions, and the level determination unit 102 may acquire this information via the communication path 106 and determine the safety level taking this information into consideration.
[0098] The safety level is calculated quantitatively, for example, from four items related to aircraft performance: thrust, turning force, flight time, and wind conditions, as shown in Figure 11. Figure 11 shows a case where the performance of aircraft A has deteriorated, with some rotors coming to a complete stop, thrust and turning force decreasing to 50% or less of the rated performance of aircraft A, strong wind conditions, and ample flight time remaining.
[0099] In such a case, the route planning unit 3 and the exclusive space design unit 4 obtain the safety levels of the four items shown in FIG. 11 from the level determination unit 102 via the communication path 103 and the communication path 104, and based on this, in order to enable the aircraft A with reduced performance to navigate safely, the exclusive space is enlarged and the route to the end position coordinates is planned by prioritizing a route with good (weak) wind conditions and low curvature over a shorter route length.
[0100] In addition, since the thrust and turning force of aircraft A are reduced and the degree of freedom in planning the route of aircraft A is not high, if necessary, the route planning unit 3 and the exclusive space design unit 4 simultaneously redesign the routes of other aircraft other than aircraft A to increase the degree of freedom in redesigning the route of aircraft A.
[0101] In this embodiment, the route planning device 2 of the traffic control system 1 that provides routes for takeoff and landing to multiple aircraft makes it possible to plan a safe and efficient route based on clear guidelines, even if a deterioration in the aircraft's maneuvering performance occurs, due to the quantification of the safety level by the level determination unit 102.
[0102] In addition to the four items shown in FIG. 11, the safety level evaluation items may include items related to weather conditions such as rainfall, atmospheric pressure, and temperature, and items related to obstacles such as flocks of birds.
[0103] Also, the safety level may be calculated as a scalar value as the weighted sum of each item as shown in Fig. 11, and provided as a representative value of the safety level to the route planning unit 3 and the exclusive space design unit 4. In this case, since the safety level in the route planning unit 3 and the exclusive space design unit 4 is simplified compared to that in Fig. 11, it is not possible to perform detailed route replanning that takes into account each of thrust, wind conditions, flight time, etc., but there is an advantage in that the route replanning logic can be simplified. [Explanation of symbols]
[0104] 1: Traffic control system 2: Path planning device 3: Path planning section 4: Private Space Design Department 21, 32: Private space 9, 10: Route 11: Performance degradation flag information 12: Navigation information 13: Aircraft information 26: Starting point position coordinates 27: End point coordinates 92: Aircraft Performance Estimation Division 93: Observation equipment 102: Level judgment section
Claims
1. A route planning device of a traffic control system that provides a route related to the navigation of an aircraft, The route planning device includes an exclusive space design unit that designs an exclusive space for each of a plurality of aircraft based on the performance and state of the aircraft in route planning at the beginning of the aircraft's flight, and a route planning unit that, based on the start point position coordinates, end point position coordinates, and the exclusive space of each aircraft, plans a route from the start point position coordinates to the end point position coordinates so that no other aircraft or obstacles enter the exclusive space of each aircraft at all times when the aircraft travels from the start point position coordinates to the end point position coordinates, and provides the route to each aircraft, The route planning device of a traffic control system detects a decline in performance of each aircraft after the initial stage of the aircraft's flight, redesigns the exclusive space of the aircraft with degraded performance based on the current position coordinates, performance and status information of the aircraft with degraded performance, replans the routes of the multiple aircraft so that the other aircraft or obstacles do not enter the redesigned exclusive space, and provides the routes to each of the aircraft.
2. The route planning device for a traffic control system according to claim 1, The route planning device of the flight control system is characterized in that it detects a performance degradation of the aircraft after the early stage of the aircraft's flight based on performance degradation flag information that the aircraft detects and transmits after detecting a performance degradation in the aircraft itself.
3. The route planning device for a traffic control system according to claim 1, The route planning device of the flight control system is characterized in that it receives information on the current position coordinates, performance and status of the aircraft transmitted by the aircraft, and detects a deterioration in the performance of the aircraft after the initial stage of the aircraft's flight based on the received information.
4. The route planning device for a traffic control system according to claim 1, A route planning device for an air traffic control system, comprising an aircraft performance estimation unit that observes an aircraft in flight from the ground or from another flying vehicle and estimates aircraft performance, wherein the route planning device detects a deterioration in the performance of the aircraft during flight based on the estimation results of the aircraft performance estimation unit.
5. The route planning device for a traffic control system according to claim 1, The route planning device of the traffic control system is characterized in that the route planning device redesigns the exclusive space of the aircraft whose performance has deteriorated in a direction to expand it in accordance with the degree of performance deterioration.
6. The route planning device for a traffic control system according to claim 1, The path planning device includes: A route planning device for an air traffic control system, characterized in that it redesigns the exclusive space of the other aircraft based on information on the current position coordinates, performance and status of the other aircraft, and then replans the routes of the multiple aircraft.
7. The route planning device for a traffic control system according to claim 1, The route planning device of the traffic control system is characterized in that the route planning device changes the end point of another aircraft.
8. The route planning device for a traffic control system according to claim 1, A route planning device for an air traffic control system, characterized in that the route planning unit can request the exclusive space design unit to redesign the exclusive space of each of the aircraft.
9. The route planning device for a traffic control system according to claim 1, the route planning device includes a level determination unit that acquires information on current position coordinates, performance, and status of the aircraft whose performance has been degraded, acquires wind condition information from a device capable of observing wind conditions, and evaluates a safety level of the aircraft whose performance has been degraded based on the acquired information; A route planning device for a traffic control system, characterized in that the evaluation results are provided to the exclusive space design unit and the route planning unit, and exclusive space design and route replanning are carried out based on the safety level evaluation results.
10. The route planning device for a traffic control system according to claim 4, The route planning device for an air traffic control system is characterized in that the aircraft performance estimation unit estimates the performance and state of the aircraft, whose performance has been degraded, based on information obtained from a group of sensors installed on the ground or another flying vehicle and information on the performance and state of the aircraft obtained from the aircraft.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Automatic collision preventor for ship
JP1986030000A
Moving robot system and moving robot control method
JP2017010234A
Flying control device and flying control system
WO2019146516A1
Information processing device
WO2020121664A1
