Measurement method for chloride ion concentration in concrete structures using laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy
By pre-irradiating the water-affected surface of concrete specimens with a pulsed laser before LIBS, the method addresses the inefficiencies of potentiometric titration and aligns LIBS results with traditional methods, providing accurate and rapid chloride ion concentration measurements.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2021087434
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2021-05-25
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-21
- Estimated Expiration
- 2041-05-25
AI Technical Summary
The existing potentiometric titration method for measuring chloride ion concentration in concrete structures is labor-intensive, time-consuming, and costly, and laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS) measurements at the concrete surface are affected by water, leading to discrepancies in chloride ion concentration results.
A method involving the removal of the water-affected surface layer of a concrete specimen using pulsed laser irradiation before performing LIBS measurements to obtain chloride ion concentration results that match those of potentiometric titration.
This approach allows for accurate and rapid determination of chloride ion concentration in concrete structures, aligning with potentiometric titration results by eliminating the influence of water on LIBS measurements.
Smart Images

Figure 0007587913000006 
Figure 0007587913000007 
Figure 0007587913000008
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present invention relates to a method for detecting chloride ion concentration in a concrete structure. More specifically, the present invention relates to a method for measuring the chloride ion concentration of a test specimen wet-collected from a concrete structure by laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (hereinafter, referred to as LIBS in this specification). [Background technology]
[0002] In order to evaluate salt damage (i.e., rebar corrosion) of reinforced concrete (RC) structures located in coastal areas, concrete specimens are taken from the RC structures and the depth distribution (concentration distribution) of chloride ion concentration inside the concrete is determined using a method specified by the Japan Industrial Planning Standards (JIS) (potentiometric titration method).
[0003] However, the potentiometric titration method requires the extraction of concrete cores from structures, crushing the cores, and measuring the concentration, which requires a great deal of effort, time, and cost. For this reason, there is a demand for an alternative measurement method that is cheaper and faster than potentiometric titration and can determine the concentration.
[0004] In response to such demands, the inventors of the present application have developed LIBS, a method for measuring the concentration of elements in concrete based on the observation of emission spectra, that is, a method for measuring the concentration of each element contained in an object by irradiating the object with pulsed laser light and performing spectroscopic measurement of the plasma generated at that time (e.g., Patent Documents 1 and 2). [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0005] [Patent Document 1] JP 2009-068969 A [Patent Document 2] JP 2017-009323 A Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0006] In recent years, it has been observed that the chloride ion concentration distribution measured by LIBS on the surface of test specimens taken from concrete structures does not match the value obtained by potentiometric titration. Since the concrete structure in this case was made using blended cement, a test specimen was made using blended cement to investigate the cause of the discrepancy in the chloride ion concentration distribution obtained by LIBS and potentiometric titration. As a result, it was found that the difference in elemental composition between normal cement and blended cement does not affect the calculation of the chloride emission intensity. On the other hand, it was found that the free chloride on the surface of the concrete was washed away by water, which is used as a lubricant to suppress frictional heat when taking a test specimen from a concrete structure, and the chloride ion concentration decreased. This tendency was also observed when concrete made using normal cement was measured by LIBS, although it was only on the very surface layer. In other words, it was found that LIBS measures the very surface layer of the concrete, but the surface layer is easily affected by water.
[0007] An object of the present invention is to provide a measurement method that, when measuring the salt content of concrete by LIBS using test specimens collected by a wet method, can obtain results that are generally consistent with the chloride ion concentration distribution obtained by potentiometric titration. [Means for solving the problem]
[0008] In order to achieve this objective, the inventors measured test specimens taken from concrete structures collected from on-site, and investigated the reason for the discrepancy in the chloride ion concentration distributions determined by LIBS and potentiometric titration.As a result, they found that the difference in elemental composition between ordinary cement and blended cement did not affect the calculation of chlorine luminescence intensity, but suggested that the water used to reduce frictional heat when carving out the test specimens from the concrete structures washed away free chloride on the surface of the test specimens from the concrete structures, reducing the chloride ion concentration.
[0009] The method of measuring chloride ion concentration in a concrete structure using LIBS of the present invention is based on such findings, and when a test specimen is wet-collected from a concrete structure and the chloride ion concentration is measured using LIBS, the surface of the test specimen that has come into contact with water is removed, and then a pulsed laser light is irradiated to the location where the surface has been removed, and the actual measurement of the chloride ion concentration using LIBS is performed.
[0010] Here, the thickness of the surface of the test piece to be removed is preferably at least 0.3 mm or more.
[0011] In addition, the surface of the test specimen may be removed by repeatedly irradiating the laser at the same position on the surface of the test specimen that has been in contact with water, or by having the laser light pass the same position repeatedly. Effect of the Invention
[0012] According to the method for measuring chloride ion concentration in a concrete structure using LIBS as described in claim 1, when measuring the salt content of concrete using LIBS using a test specimen collected by a wet method, the results obtained are generally consistent with the chloride ion concentration distribution obtained by potentiometric titration. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0013] [Figure 1] FIG. 1 is a schematic diagram showing an example of an experimental apparatus for performing LIBS measurement. [Diagram 2] FIG. 1 is an explanatory diagram of a mortar test specimen formed by joining a mortar test specimen without chloride and a mortar test specimen with chloride, (A) showing the chloride ion concentration distribution diagram, and (B) showing a cut surface of the mortar test specimen. [Diagram 3] FIG. 1 is a schematic explanatory diagram of a method for measuring a wet-cut surface and a grinder surface. [Figure 4] This is a distribution diagram of chlorine emission intensity on the wet cut surface of mortar (test specimen N) using ordinary cement. [Diagram 5] This is a distribution map of chlorine emission intensity on the grinder surface of test specimen N. [Figure 6] This is a distribution diagram of chlorine emission intensity on the wet cut surface of mortar (specimen FB) using fly ash cement type B. [Figure 7] This is a distribution diagram of chlorine emission intensity on the grinder surface of test specimen FB. [Figure 8] This is a distribution graph of chlorine emission intensity on the wet cut surface of blast-furnace cement type B (test specimen BB). [Figure 9] This is a distribution map of chlorine emission intensity on the grinder surface of test specimen BB. [Figure 10] 1 is a graph showing the dependence of chlorine emission intensity on the number of irradiations at a point where chloride is present on specimen N. [Figure 11] 13 is a graph showing the dependence of the emission intensity of chlorine on the number of irradiations at a portion of test specimen FB where chloride is present. [Figure 12] 13 is a graph showing the dependence of the emission intensity of chlorine on the number of irradiations at a point where chloride is present on test specimen BB. [Figure 13] FIG. 2 is an explanatory diagram regarding the definition of the maximum height Rz of roughness. [Figure 14] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing the dependency of Rz on the number of laser light irradiations in the irradiation mark of specimen N. [Figure 15] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing the dependency of Rz on the number of laser light irradiations in the irradiation mark of the test specimen FB. [Figure 16] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing the dependency of Rz on the number of laser light irradiations in the irradiation mark of the test piece BB. [Figure 17] FIG. 13 is a spectrum diagram of a mortar test specimen. [Figure 18] FIG. 13 is a graph showing the luminescence intensity of chlorine from a mortar test specimen. [Figure 19] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing the emission intensity of titanium in a mortar specimen. [Figure 20] FIG. 13 is a graph showing the luminescence intensity of chlorine from a mortar specimen after immersion in salt water. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0014] DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS Hereinafter, the configuration of the present invention will be described in detail based on the embodiments shown in the drawings.
[0015] LIBS is a method for measuring the concentration of each element contained in a measurement object by irradiating the measurement object with pulsed laser light and spectroscopically measuring the plasma generated at that time. For example, a relationship between the signal intensity (emission intensity of the chlorine emission line) obtained by LIBS and the chloride ion concentration is obtained in advance using a sample with a known chloride ion concentration, and the chloride ion concentration is obtained from the emission intensity of chlorine when an unknown sample is measured. It is a well-known technology as a type of calibration curve method. Details are omitted here, but please refer to, for example, JP 2002-296183 A, JP 2009-68969 A, JP 2013-190411 A, JP 2019-019749 A, etc.
[0016] In this embodiment, the object to be measured is a test specimen (sometimes commonly referred to as a "core") extracted by a wet method from a concrete structure. Here, when extracting a test specimen (core extraction) from a concrete structure, the concrete is cooled with water to prevent deterioration of the concrete due to frictional heat. For this reason, the inventors and others have clarified through experiments that in concrete in which the proportion of fixed chlorides that are fixed in mortar and do not move with moisture is small and the proportion of free chlorides that exist in the mortar in the form of ions and move with moisture is large, a large amount of free chlorides flow out when the core is extracted, and the chloride ion concentration is lower than the value obtained by potentiometric titration.
[0017] Therefore, in the present embodiment, when measuring the chloride ion concentration in a concrete structure using LIBS, a test specimen is taken from the concrete structure in a wet manner and the chloride ion concentration is measured using LIBS. After removing the surface of the test specimen that has come into contact with water, the actual measurement of the chloride ion concentration using LIBS is performed.
[0018] The surface layer removal, which removes the surface of the test specimen that has been in contact with water prior to the actual measurement, is not limited to a specific method and can be performed, for example, by irradiating a laser beam or grinding with a grinder or the like to remove the part of the test specimen surface that is affected by water, but is preferably performed by irradiating a laser beam, and more preferably by pre-irradiation with a pulsed laser beam used for LIBS. In this case, the pre-irradiation with a laser beam to remove the part of the test specimen surface that is affected by water and the actual measurement of chloride ion concentration by LIBS can be performed simultaneously by irradiating the position where the surface has been removed with a pulsed laser beam.
[0019] Here, the surface layer removal by irradiation with the laser light may be performed repeatedly at the same position on the surface of the test body in contact with water, or the laser light may pass the same position repeatedly. For example, the same pulsed laser light as the pulsed laser light used in the main measurement of the LIBS measurement may be repeatedly irradiated at a fixed position, or the same position may be repeatedly scanned. In addition, the pre-irradiation of the laser light and the main measurement of the LIBS measurement may be performed continuously or separately, but in this embodiment, the pre-irradiation in which the pulsed laser light is repeatedly irradiated at the same position of the test body is performed a predetermined number of times, and the plasma is spectroscopically measured only at the predetermined number of times to obtain the chloride ion concentration. However, this is not particularly limited, and in some cases, the main measurement may be performed after a time has elapsed after the pre-irradiation of the laser light.
[0020] The pre-irradiation of the laser light removes at least the surface layer of the concrete affected by water on the surface of the test specimen to a depth where it is not affected. According to the experiments of the present inventors, the emission intensity of chlorine monotonically increases with the number of irradiations and tends to saturate at a certain number of irradiations or more. This is thought to be because the surface layer of the cut surface of the core is removed by the laser light irradiation, and the surface not affected by water is gradually exposed. Although the relationship between the number of irradiations in the pre-irradiation of the laser light and the emission intensity of chlorine varies slightly depending on the type of cement, for example, if the pulse laser light used to measure the chloride ion concentration with LIBS is irradiated about 70 to 80 times, the increase in the emission intensity of chlorine tends to saturate to a certain extent in the case of concrete made of blast furnace cement, while the emission intensity of chlorine is expected to increase to a certain extent in the case of concrete made of fly ash cement or portland cement. If it is irradiated about 100 times, the increase in the emission intensity of chlorine tends to saturate in the case of concrete made of fly ash cement, and a further increase in the emission intensity of chlorine is expected in the case of concrete made of portland cement. And, when the number of irradiations was about 150 times, the increase in the emission intensity of chlorine was saturated or tended to be saturated, regardless of the type of cement. On the other hand, even if the number of irradiations was increased more than necessary, the emission intensity simply increased was saturated, and when the number of irradiations exceeded 200 times, for example, the surface was slightly scraped and the focused diameter of the laser light changed, so that the spectral intensity tended to decrease over the entire wavelength range. In view of these, the pre-irradiation of the laser light is considered to be in the range of 70 to 200 times, preferably in the range of 100 to 150 times, and more preferably about 150 times, by the pulsed laser light used in the LIBS measurement. Of course, this is not limited depending on the laser energy or spot diameter of the laser light, and the number of irradiations is appropriately selected.
[0021] The amount of surface layer to be removed (or the depth from the surface) required to expose a surface not affected by water by coring can be achieved not only by prior irradiation with laser light, but also by grinding processing using a grinder, etc., so a specific amount of surface layer to be removed is at least 0.3 mm, preferably 0.35 mm or more, more preferably 0.4 mm or more, even more preferably 0.45 mm or more, even more preferably 0.5 mm or more, and most preferably at least 0.55 mm or more.
[0022] In addition, in this embodiment, the pre-irradiation laser light is a pulsed laser light used in the main LIBS measurement, but in some cases, laser light of different conditions, such as a pulsed laser light or continuous laser light, different from the conditions of the laser output, spot diameter, etc. during LIBS measurement may be used.
[0023] The pre-irradiation of the laser light and the main measurement in the LIBS measurement are not limited to a specific device, but may be performed using, for example, the device with the configuration shown in FIG. 1 or the measurement device of JP 2017-9323 A. In this case, the test object can be rotated relative to a fixed laser optical system to perform circular scanning on the same circumference, or the test object can be rotated while moving in the axial direction to perform spiral scanning. For this reason, it is possible to perform pre-irradiation and main measurement by repeatedly irradiating the laser light at the same position on a fixed test object and then moving to the next different position, and it is also possible to perform the necessary pre-irradiation of the laser and the main measurement of the LIBS measurement by repeatedly passing the laser light through the same position in a circular or spiral manner.
[0024] In other words, the laser may be repeatedly applied to the same location in a point-like or linear manner to eliminate the influence of water. LIBS measurements may be performed at multiple points in a spiral, or the test body may be rotated around the central axis to perform measurements for one revolution at multiple measurement points aligned in the circumferential direction of the cylindrical outer surface, the test body may then be moved a predetermined distance in the axial direction and then rotated again around the axis to perform measurements for one revolution in the circumferential direction, the test body may then be moved in the axial direction, and the same process may be repeated.
[0025] After the preliminary irradiation with the laser light, the LIBS is used to measure the emission intensity from the test specimen. Specifically, the outer peripheral surface of the test specimen is irradiated with a pulsed laser light to ablate the substances contained in the concrete, and the light emitted from the substances that have been turned into plasma by this ablation is received and separated into wavelengths to obtain an emission spectrum. Based on the emission spectrum, the substances contained in the test specimen are identified and their concentrations are calculated as necessary.
[0026] The method of irradiating the laser light in LIBS is not limited to a specific mode as long as the laser light is irradiated to the test piece to generate plasma, and a single laser light may be irradiated (also called a single pulse mode), or two laser lights may be irradiated (also called a double pulse mode). For example, the second harmonic of a Nd:YAG laser may be used as the laser light, and a polarizing beam splitter may be used to irradiate the same location twice with a time difference. In this case, for example, the laser energy for the first and second irradiations may be set to 30 mJ and 50 mJ, and the time from the second laser light irradiation to reception may be set to 0.5 μs, and the exposure time may be set to 5 μs.
[0027] As described above, in the chloride ion concentration measurement method of this embodiment, a cylindrical test specimen obtained by wet cutting has its surface in contact with water as a lubricant irradiated with laser light in advance, thereby removing the surface of the test specimen to a depth that will not be affected by contact with water (in other words, the affected concrete surface layer is removed in advance by laser irradiation), and then the main LIBS measurement is performed, thereby obtaining results that generally agree with the chloride ion concentration distribution obtained by potentiometric titration.
[0028] The above-described embodiment is one example of a preferred embodiment of the present invention, but the present invention is not limited to this embodiment and various modifications can be made without departing from the gist of the present invention. EXAMPLES
[0029] Example 1 In order to clarify the depth of the test specimen surface layer that needs to be removed in order to measure the surface not affected by water, a mortar test specimen was produced and the luminescence intensity of chlorine was measured. Table 1 shows the mix ratio for the mortar test specimen. Water (W) was tap water, cement (C) was either OPC (ordinary Portland cement), FA (fly ash) cement type B, or blast-furnace cement type B, and standard sand was used for the fine aggregate (S), with the water-binder ratio set at 0.5. For mixing, mortar mixed with tap water (chloride-free test specimen) and mortar mixed with 10 kg / m2 chloride ion concentration after mixing were compared. 3 In this study, we will call the specimen using ordinary Portland cement as the cement specimen N, the specimen using fly ash cement type B as the cement specimen FB, and the specimen using blast furnace cement type B as the cement specimen BB.
[0030] [Table 1]
[0031] The above two types of mortar were poured into a cylindrical formwork with a diameter of 50 mm and a length of 100 mm, demolded after 24 hours, and sealed curing was performed for 28 days. After that, the cylindrical mortar specimens, the chloride-free specimen and the chloride-containing specimen, were joined using epoxy resin to prepare a cylindrical specimen with a difference in chloride ion concentration along the cylindrical axis. The joined mortar specimen was then wet-cut in the cylindrical axis direction so as to divide it into two at the center along the axis center, simulating wet core drilling. Although not shown in the figure, in this example, the chloride-free specimen and the chloride-containing specimen were cut to an appropriate length with a cutter before being joined.
[0032] The LIBS measurement using the above-mentioned mortar test specimen was carried out using, for example, the experimental apparatus shown in FIG. 1. In the figure, reference numeral 1 denotes a one-axis stage (Y-axis), 2 denotes an automatic stage (X-axis), 3 denotes a dichroic mirror, 4 denotes a bandpass filter, 5 denotes a lens, 6 denotes an optical fiber, 7 denotes a spectrometer, 8 denotes an ICCD camera, 9 denotes a computer for controlling the device, etc., 10 denotes a delay pulse generator, 11 denotes a laser, 12 denotes a laser, 13 denotes a polarizing beam splitter, and 14 denotes a test specimen. The second harmonic of a Nd:YAG laser was used as the laser light, and the same location was irradiated with the laser light twice with a time difference using the polarizing beam splitter 13. By irradiating the laser light twice, the lower detection limit is improved. The light emission of the plasma generated by the laser light irradiation was measured by the spectrometer 7 and the detector. The laser energy for the first and second irradiations was set to 30 mJ and 50 mJ, the time from the second laser light irradiation to reception was set to 0.5 μs, and the exposure time was set to 5 μs. Here, the preliminary irradiation of the pulsed laser light for removing the surface layer that had been in contact with the water of the test specimen was performed using, for example, a pulsed laser light with a laser energy of 30 mJ.
[0033] Figure 2 shows the cut surface of the jointed mortar specimen. The chloride ion concentration distribution is stepped, so if there is no influence of water, the chlorine emission intensity should change in a stepped manner. In the measurement, a line of 80 mm was measured so as to straddle the specimen with and without chloride. As shown in Figure 3, the LIBS measurement was performed by scanning the laser light in a line under the condition that the laser light was irradiated 20 times per location, and scanning the same line 10 times (equivalent to 200 irradiations), removing the surface layer of the specimen, performing LIBS, and obtaining the measurement data of the wet cut surface. After 10 scans, the surface layer was removed using a grinder, and the measured points that became grooves were polished until they were no longer visible to the naked eye. After polishing, the positions near the grooves were measured using LIBS, and the measurement data of the grinder surface was obtained.
[0034] Figures 4 to 9 show the luminescence intensity distribution of chlorine obtained for each test specimen. To make it easier to see, the measurement results of the 1st, 5th, and 10th scans (equivalent to 20, 100, and 200 irradiations) are shown. The 320 pieces of spectral data, which correspond to intervals of 8 mm, were classified one by one, and the spectra classified as mortar were integrated and averaged, after which the spectral intensity per spectrum was normalized, and this was multiplied by the volume ratio (volume fraction) of mortar to the concrete to obtain the luminescence intensity of chlorine.
[0035] For all specimens, the chlorine emission intensity was almost zero for the chloride-free specimens, indicating that the movement of salt due to wet cutting had almost no effect on the measurement results. Also, the chlorine emission intensity on the grinder surface of the chloride-containing specimens varied greatly, but the effect of the number of irradiations was almost nonexistent. This is thought to be because the distribution of chlorine emission intensity on the grinder surface is due to the surface being exposed after the surface layer has been removed and not affected by water. On the other hand, when polishing was done manually, the surface layer could not be removed uniformly from the cross section, and the mortar was removed preferentially over the aggregate, resulting in unevenness on the grinder surface.
[0036] On the other hand, the chlorine emission intensity distribution on the wet-cut surface of specimen N tended to increase as the number of irradiations increased. The same tendency was observed for specimen FB. For specimen BB, there were some cases where the chlorine emission intensity was partially reversed between the 100th and 200th irradiations, but since this was within the range of variation in emission intensity, it can be said that there was a tendency for the emission intensity to increase generally as the number of irradiations increased. This is thought to be because the surface layer of the wet-cut surface of the core was removed by laser light irradiation, gradually exposing the surface that was not affected by water.
[0037] Here, the chlorine emission intensity in the range measured for the chloride-containing specimens was integrated and averaged, and the change with respect to the number of irradiations was examined. Figures 10 to 12 show the dependence of the chlorine emission intensity on the number of irradiations for each specimen. The measurement results for the grinder surface were roughly constant even with an increase in the number of irradiations for specimen BB, and slightly decreased with an increase in the number of irradiations for specimens N and FB. However, the measurement results for the grinder surface showed that, although there was some variation in the chlorine emission intensity for all specimens, it did not change significantly with an increase in the number of irradiations. From this, it is believed that by removing the surface layer of the cut surface with the grinder, it was possible to expose a surface that was not affected by water.
[0038] On the other hand, the measurement results of the wet cut surface showed that the chlorine emission intensity generally increased monotonically with the number of irradiations, and tended to saturate after a certain number of irradiations. This is thought to be because the surface of the cut surface of the core was removed by laser light irradiation, gradually exposing the surface that was not affected by water. Furthermore, for test piece BB, the chlorine emission intensity decreased after 140 irradiations, but since the same tendency was seen on both the wet cut surface and the grinder surface, this is thought to be due to the influence of surface irregularities and not the influence of water.
[0039] The relationship between the number of irradiations in the pre-irradiation of the laser light and the emission intensity of chlorine tends to increase simply with the number of irradiations, although there are some differences depending on the type of cement. For example, in the case of test specimen BB, as shown in Figure 12, if the pulsed laser light used to measure the chloride ion concentration with LIBS was irradiated about 70 to 80 times, the increase in the emission intensity of chlorine tended to saturate. In the case of test specimen FB, as shown in Figure 11, the emission intensity of chlorine also tended to saturate. On the other hand, in the case of test specimen N, as shown in Figure 10, an increase in the emission intensity of chlorine was observed, but further increase is expected. If it was irradiated about 100 times, the emission intensity of chlorine was saturated in the case of test specimen FB, and the emission intensity of chlorine further increased in the case of test specimen N. And if it was irradiated about 150 times, the increase in the emission intensity of chlorine was saturated or tended to saturate, regardless of the type of cement (type of test specimen). In view of these, the pre-irradiation of the laser light before the main measurement in this embodiment is considered to be at least 70 times or more, preferably 100 times or more, more preferably 140 times or more, and even more preferably at least 150 times or more. Of course, depending on the laser energy or spot diameter of the laser light, the number of irradiations is not limited to this, and the number of irradiations is appropriately selected. On the other hand, there is a problem that the emission intensity, which increases simply even if the number of irradiations increases, saturates, and when it exceeds 200 times, the spectral intensity decreases overall with the change in the focusing diameter of the laser light, and the emission intensity of chlorine appears to decrease. Therefore, although the effect of water on the measurement result is mitigated by repeated irradiation, it is necessary to consider that the emission intensity tends to decrease by slightly scraping the surface of the test piece.
[0040] In general, the more fixed chlorides there are, the less salt is washed away. It has also been reported that the higher the replacement rate of OPC with ground granulated blast furnace slag, the higher the proportion of fixed chlorides. Therefore, it is considered that less salt was washed away from specimen BB than from specimen N. However, since factors other than the cement type (water-binder ratio, neutralization, etc.) also affect the increase or decrease in fixed chlorides, the strength of the effect of washing away cannot be explained only by the difference in cement type, and it is considered necessary to scrape off a certain amount of the surface layer. From this result, it is considered that by irradiating the laser light at least 150 times under these measurement conditions, a surface that is not affected by water will be exposed regardless of the type of cement. It was also found that in order to avoid the influence of water, it is effective to remove the surface layer of the specimen using a grinder or laser light irradiation.
[0041] The surface layer removal required to expose the surface unaffected by water in this wet cutting can be performed not only by irradiation with laser light but also by grinding processing using a grinder, etc., so further investigation was conducted on the specific amount of surface layer removal (in other words, the depth).
[0042] In order to grasp the depth of the irradiation mark, the roughness of the irradiation mark was measured according to JIS B 0601-2001. An optical three-dimensional shape measuring device was used for surface observation and roughness measurement of the test specimen. When observing the irradiation mark, the height of the part not irradiated with the laser light was not uniform, and the height of the valley part of the irradiation mark was also not uniform. This is because the unevenness of the unirradiated part is caused by air bubbles contained in the mortar, and the unevenness of the valley part of the irradiation mark is caused by fine aggregate. In general, concrete and mortar have air bubbles inside because a few percent of air is entrained during mixing. In addition, when irradiated with laser light, cement paste, which is softer than aggregate, is preferentially removed, so unevenness is observed when viewed microscopically. Thus, since there are unevenness both in the unirradiated part, which is the height standard, and in the valley part of the irradiation mark, the maximum height Rz of the roughness from the cross-sectional shape of the irradiation mark was taken as the depth of the irradiation mark. Rz is defined as the difference between the maximum and minimum surface heights in a certain section, as shown in Figure 13.
[0043] The images of the line marks left by irradiating the laser beam on the wet cut surface of the mortar specimen were taken at 80x magnification and superimposed to create a single image, and image analysis was used to adjust the inclination of the image and determine the reference surface. To investigate the depth of the mortar removed, roughness measurements were performed in image areas where there was no missing height data and no coarse aggregate. Since the roughness differed for each measurement position, 30 cross sections were measured in the vertical direction of the photograph, and the average Rz value and standard deviation were calculated.
[0044] Figures 14 to 16 show the dependence of Rz on the number of laser irradiations in the irradiation marks obtained for each specimen. The type of cement and the presence or absence of chlorides did not have a significant effect on Rz. In addition, Rz increased almost linearly with respect to the number of irradiations. For specimen FB, Rz tended to saturate slightly, which is thought to be due to the cone-shaped cross section. As the depth of the irradiation mark increases due to laser irradiation, the apparent focused diameter of the laser light increases because the laser light is irradiated not only to the valley of the irradiation mark but also to the side surface to generate plasma. As a result, it is thought that the laser energy density per unit area decreases with the number of irradiations, and the amount of mortar removed decreases with the number of irradiations.
[0045] According to the dependence of the chlorine emission intensity on the number of irradiations for each specimen shown in Figures 10 to 12, although there are some differences depending on the type of cement, the emission intensity tends to simply increase with the number of irradiations. For example, the irradiation mark depth of the specimen BB shown in Figure 12 after 70 to 80 irradiations is about 0.3 mm when the results of Figure 16 are interpolated. Moreover, the irradiation mark depth of the specimen N shown in Figure 10 and the specimen FB shown in Figure 11 after 100 irradiations is about 0.4 mm when the results of Figure 14 are interpolated, and about 0.45 mm when the results of Figure 15 are interpolated. And, after about 150 irradiations, the increase in the chlorine emission intensity was saturated or tended to saturate, regardless of the type of cement (type of specimen). The irradiation mark depth after 150 irradiations is about 0.55 mm when the results of Figure 14 are interpolated, and about 0.56 mm when the results of Figure 15 are interpolated. Considering these, the surface layer removal amount required to expose the surface not affected by water by wet cutting is at least 0.3 mm or more, preferably 0.35 mm or more, more preferably 0.4 mm or more, even more preferably 0.45 mm or more, even more preferably 0.5 mm or more, and most preferably at least 0.55 mm or more. Here, it is considered that the washing away of salt is less in the test specimen BB than in the test specimen N. However, since factors other than the cement type (water-binder ratio, presence or absence of carbonation, etc.) also affect the increase or decrease of fixed chloride, the strength of the influence of washing away cannot be explained only by the difference in the cement type, and it is considered necessary to scrape off a certain amount of the surface layer. Therefore, it is considered that the surface not affected by water is exposed by irradiating the laser light at least 150 times under the present measurement conditions. In other words, it is considered that by removing at least 0.55 mm or more of the surface layer of the mortar, it is possible to expose the surface not affected by water used in wet cutting, regardless of the type of cement. The same is true for concrete made of coarse aggregate and mortar, as salt does not penetrate into the aggregate, and it is thought that it is sufficient to remove the surface layer to a similar depth.
[0046] <Effect of element composition> In this example, we focused on the elemental composition of fly ash cement as a type of blended cement. In addition, considering that the mineral composition of fine and coarse aggregates varies greatly depending on the site where they are collected and that water-soluble substances including chlorides move within mortar, we used standard sand as fine aggregate and measured mortar specimens to evaluate the effect of elemental composition on measurements.
[0047] The chemical composition of concrete materials is shown in Tables 2 and 3. The chemical composition of standard sand is shown in the figures provided by the Japan Cement Association, and the chemical composition of ordinary Portland cement and fly ash is shown in the literature [Takeshi Yamamoto, Tsutomu Kanazu, Applicability Evaluation of Accelerated Scientific Test Method (API Method) for Evaluating Pozzolanic Reactivity of Fly Ash, Concrete Engineering Journal, Vol. 26 (2004) 171-176.]. The composition of each inorganic compound is often different between ordinary Portland cement and fly ash, and when the LIBS measurement results differ between mortar using ordinary Portland cement and mortar mixed with fly ash and ordinary Portland cement, it is difficult to evaluate which compound is affecting the measurement. Therefore, in addition to the test specimens corresponding to fly ash cement types A to C using two types of fly ash as shown in Tables 4 and 5, we decided to individually evaluate the inorganic compounds contained in fly ash more than ordinary Portland cement by adding each inorganic compound to ordinary Portland cement.
[0048] [Table 2]
[0049] [Table 3]
[0050] [Table 4]
[0051] [Table 5]
[0052] It has been reported in LIBS literature that the emission intensity of chlorine may change when the composition ratio of silicon and the particle size of the fine aggregate contained in the mortar are different [C. Gottlieb, S. Millar, S. Grothe and G. Wilsch, 2Devaluation of spectral LIBS data derived from heterogeneous materials using cluster algorithm,Spectrochim. Acta B, Vol.134 (2017) 58-68.]. In particular, the effect is large when the particle size is smaller than the focused diameter of the laser light. Therefore, inorganic compound powder with a small particle size within the range that can be procured was used as an additive. Since the specific surface areas of fly ash types I to III are different, it would be desirable to also prepare test specimens using fly ash types I and III, but it is difficult to prepare test specimens with both particle size and composition adjusted. Therefore, as described below, we decided to consider the particle size of the inorganic compound.
[0053] The additives used this time, except for water-soluble compounds, do not contribute to the hydration reaction, so they are used with the intention of simulating the elements contained in fly ash, but in the mix, the additives are considered to be a substitute for fine aggregate (i.e., an external ratio), and the conditions were set as follows: water cement 0.5, fine aggregate and additive to cement weight ratio ((S+A) / C) 3, and the amount of water and additives was adjusted so that the proportion of additives in the total mortar volume was greater than the composition ratio of compounds contained in fly ash cement type C. In other words, by using additives, a mortar specimen was created in which only certain elements had a proportion equivalent to that of fly ash cement type C. When additives were different from the compounds shown in Table 2, the molar mass ratio was taken into consideration.
[0054] For example, when Na2CO3 is used as an additive instead of Na2, when the concentration of the additive is A, the concentration of Na2O contained in the additive was calculated as A × 61.979 (molar mass of Na2O) / 105.989 (molar mass of Na2CO3).
[0055] As it is believed that there will be no change in the LIBS measurement results unless there is a significant decrease in compressive strength, it was decided not to obtain fresh properties such as slump, air content, and mortar temperature. To create the test specimen, a formwork measuring 40 mm in height x 40 mm in width x 160 mm in depth was prepared, and the mortar was poured into the formwork after adding the measured additives when mixing. After demolding, the test specimen was cured underwater, and demolded after 28 days of curing. The specimen was then wet-cut in the axial direction of the cylinder so as to divide it in two at the center, simulating wet core extraction.
[0056] To simulate salt penetration, one of the cut specimens was immersed in salt water. First, the specimen was vacuum degassed, and then immersed in artificial seawater (aquamarine for metal corrosion) for vacuum saturation. After leaving it to stand for about 15 hours, the specimen was removed from the artificial seawater tank. A part of the specimen was split open, and a silver nitrate solution was sprayed onto the split surface. The specimen was then used for measurement after the disappearance of the color reaction over the entire cut surface, i.e., salt penetration, was confirmed.
[0057] The cut surface of the above-mentioned mortar specimen was subjected to LIBS measurement on the line using the LIBS experimental apparatus shown in Figure 1.
[0058] In the spectrum analysis, in order to avoid the influence of bias in the mortar material near the formwork surface, 600 spectra were used, which were measured within a 30 mm range excluding the ends of the test specimen, from the spectrum data obtained in one measurement, as shown by the solid line in Figure 17. The 60 spectra within a 3 mm range were then integrated and averaged to calculate the chlorine emission intensity according to the definition described below, and the average value and standard deviation of the chlorine emission intensity were obtained.
[0059] The emission intensity was calculated by using the straight line connecting both ends of the spectrum (dashed line in the figure) as the baseline, as shown in Figure 17, and the height from the spectrum peak to the baseline (arrow in the figure) as the emission intensity. For chlorine, the peak wavelength was set to 837.72 nm, and the baseline was set to a straight line passing through the positions of 837.00 nm and 840.00 nm. For titanium, the peak wavelength was set to 841.23 nm, and the baseline was set to a straight line passing through the positions of 840.87 nm and 841.50 nm.
[0060] Figures 18 and 19 show the emission intensities of chlorine and titanium when the mortar specimens were measured on the 148th day of age. A, B, and C in the figures represent specimens FA-A, FA-B, and FA-C. The dashed line is an extrapolation of the value when the specimen OPC was measured. Although the specimens do not contain chloride, the emission intensity of chlorine is about 0.02 to 0.03 for all specimens. This is because the emission line of titanium was observed at almost the same position (837.78 nm) as the emission line wavelength of chlorine shown in Figure 17, and the emission intensity of chlorine could not be calculated accurately.
[0061] Compared to specimen OPC, the luminescence intensity of chlorine and titanium was higher in specimens FA-A, FA-B, FA-C, and Ti. From this, it is considered that the reason why the luminescence intensity of chlorine is calculated to be higher in specimens FA-A, FA-B, and FA-C is due to the fact that the fly ash contains a small amount of titanium.
[0062] Figure 20 shows the luminescence intensity of chlorine when measuring mortar specimens (aged 71 days) immersed in saltwater. Compared to specimens that were not immersed, the luminescence intensity of chlorine increased in the immersed specimens, but the luminescence intensity of each specimen showed a similar trend. From this, it can be considered that salt penetration does not affect the calculation of chlorine luminescence intensity, and that chlorine luminescence intensity increases in proportion to the chloride ion concentration.
[0063] From the above results, it was found that, among the elements contained in large quantities in fly ash, only titanium affected the measurement. On the other hand, it was found that the measurement results of specimens using ordinary Portland cement also showed that trace amounts of titanium contained in fine aggregate affected the measurement. From this, it was found that the effect of titanium must be taken into consideration when measuring concrete using fly ash cement, just as in concrete using ordinary Portland cement, and that the major elements contained in fly ash other than titanium do not affect the measurement. It was also found that this effect can occur in the same way even if salt has penetrated into the concrete. So far, a data analysis method has been developed to mitigate the effect of titanium on the calculation of chlorine emission intensity by calculating the emission intensity of titanium and averaging the spectra whose intensity is below a certain value [Shuzo Eto, Takashi Fujii, Proposal of a rapid measurement method for chloride ion concentration in concrete using LIBS, Central Research Institute of the Electric Power Industry Research Report H15005 (2016) 1-15.]. This method may enable quantitative measurement even when measuring specimens containing a certain amount of titanium.
[0064] In other words, since the difference in elemental composition between concrete using ordinary cement and concrete using blended cement does not affect the measurement of chloride ion concentration, it is thought that the difference with potentiometric titration method is caused by the water used as a lubricant when collecting the test specimens.
Claims
1. When wet specimens are taken from concrete structures and chloride ion concentrations are measured using laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy, After removing the surface of the test specimen that had been in contact with water, The portion where the surface has been removed is irradiated with a pulsed laser beam, and a main measurement of the chloride ion concentration is performed using laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy. Characterized by A method for measuring chloride ion concentration in concrete structures using laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy.
2. 2. The method for measuring chloride ion concentration in a concrete structure using laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy according to claim 1, wherein the removal of the surface of the test specimen is at least 0.3 mm.
3. 3. A method for measuring chloride ion concentration in a concrete structure using laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy as described in claim 1 or 2, characterized in that the removal of the surface of the test specimen is carried out by repeatedly irradiating the same position of the surface of the test specimen that has been in contact with water with a laser to remove it.
4. 3. A method for measuring chloride ion concentration in a concrete structure using laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy as described in claim 1 or 2, characterized in that the removal of the surface of the test specimen is performed by repeatedly passing a laser beam through the same position on the surface of the test specimen that has been in contact with water.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Analysis method and apparatus for metal scrap
JP1988311150A
Method and device for inspecting concrete
JP2002296183A
Method and device for measuring substances containing concrete
JP2009068969A
Concrete inclusion measurement method and measurement device
JP2017009323A
Measurement method, measurement device and measurement program for carbon concentration in steel
JP2017173045A
