Prediction model building device and prediction device
The predictive model construction device uses machine learning to accurately predict reactor water radioactivity and discharge temperature, addressing complex correlations and parameter changes, ensuring safe operation and regulatory compliance.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2021080635
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2021-05-11
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-26
- Estimated Expiration
- 2041-05-11
AI Technical Summary
Existing prediction models for reactor water radioactivity concentration and water discharge temperature in nuclear power plants struggle with accuracy due to complex correlations that are difficult to express mathematically, and they fail to account for changes in model parameters over time, leading to discrepancies between calculated and actual measurements.
A predictive model construction device using machine learning models to learn from training data that includes reactor water metal corrosion product concentrations and water discharge information, incorporating measurable plant state quantities and seawater information, with verification models to ensure accuracy.
Enables highly accurate prediction of reactor water radioactivity concentration and water discharge temperature, allowing for effective shielding and temperature control, thereby reducing worker exposure and adhering to regulatory standards.
Smart Images

Figure 0007590264000009 
Figure 0007590264000010 
Figure 0007590264000011
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present invention relates to a prediction model building device and a prediction device for reactor water radioactivity concentration and water discharge information of a nuclear power plant. [Background technology]
[0002] Known examples of nuclear power plants (also simply referred to as plants) include boiling water nuclear power plants and pressurized water nuclear power plants. In these plants, stainless steel or nickel-based alloys are used in the main components, such as the reactor pressure vessel, in the water-contacting parts in order to suppress corrosion. Furthermore, in these plants, a part of the cooling water (hereinafter also referred to as reactor water) present in the reactor pressure vessel is purified by a reactor water purification device, and metal impurities present in the reactor water in small amounts are actively removed.
[0003] Even if the above-mentioned corrosion prevention measures are taken, the presence of very small amounts of metal impurities in the reactor water is unavoidable, and some of the metal impurities adhere to the outer surface of the fuel rods in the form of metal oxides. The metal elements contained in the metal impurities adhered to the outer surface of the fuel rods undergo nuclear reactions when irradiated with neutrons emitted from the nuclear fuel material in the fuel rods, and become radioactive nuclides such as cobalt-60, cobalt-58, chromium-51, and manganese-54. Some of the radioactive nuclides that adhere to the outer surface of the fuel rods in the form of oxides dissolve into the reactor water as ions depending on the solubility of the oxides that have been incorporated. The radioactive nuclides are also released into the reactor water as insoluble solids called clad.
[0004] Some of the radionuclides in the reactor water are removed by the reactor water purification system. However, the radionuclides that are not removed accumulate on the surfaces of structural components that come into contact with the reactor water while circulating through the recirculation system together with the reactor water. As a result, radiation is emitted from the surfaces of the structural components, causing radiation exposure to personnel performing periodic inspections. The radiation exposure dose of each employee is managed so that it does not exceed a specified value. However, in recent years, this specified value has been lowered, and it has become necessary to reduce the radiation exposure dose of each employee as low as economically possible.
[0005] Under these circumstances, predicting the radiation exposure dose at the next regular inspection and then formulating a shielding plan, workforce plan, and judging the need for decontamination is an effective measure to reduce the total radiation exposure dose. Predicting the radiation exposure dose requires predicting the piping dose, and since the piping dose is strongly dependent on the reactor water radioactivity concentration during operation, it is important to predict the transition of the reactor water radioactivity concentration during the plant's operation period. In addition, since the radiation exposure dose at the next regular inspection is predicted and used in the regular inspection plan, the prediction must be made as soon as possible.
[0006] As a prediction device for the radioactivity concentration in reactor water, there is a water quality diagnostic system for reducing the dose rate in the primary system of a nuclear reactor that utilizes a physical and chemical simulation model, as described in Patent Document 1. This water quality diagnostic system predicts the future plant dose rate using a simulation model (mass balance model) that estimates changes in radioactivity in the cooling water by inputting the current water quality conditions, and diagnoses whether the current water quality conditions are good or bad based on the results.
[0007] The technology of Patent Document 1 requires that a simulation model and model parameters exist and be optimized. However, in reality, model parameters change over time, and as operation continues, equipment and materials are replaced, and the difference between model calculation values and actual measurements may become large.
[0008] The self-learning diagnosis and prediction device described in Patent Document 2 automatically corrects model parameters in response to changes over time in the plant specifications, characteristics, etc., to prevent deterioration of prediction accuracy, and also has the function of improving the model through self-learning. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0009] [Patent Document 1] Japanese Patent Application Publication No. 64-063894 [Patent Document 2] Japanese Patent Application Publication No. 06-289179 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0010] The technology described in Patent Document 2 optimizes model parameters of a model set based on a physical model or a chemical model and adjusts the contribution of the model, and the model must be prepared in advance. For this reason, the correlation between the state quantity of the predicted target and the state quantity used as input must be described as a formula. The correlations between the state quantities expressed in the mass balance model are optimized by optimizing the model parameters. However, although correlations are possible, if the correlations are complex and difficult to express mathematically, it is not possible to build an appropriate model. For this reason, there is a demand for accurate prediction of the state quantities of a plant even when correlations that are complex and cannot be expressed mathematically are included.
[0011] In addition to predicting the radioactivity concentration of reactor water, plants are also required to manage the temperature of warm wastewater (discharged water). More specifically, in plants, seawater is used to cool the steam that is generated from the heat produced by nuclear fission and turns the turbines, and it is necessary to comply with regulations regarding the range of temperature rise of seawater (warm wastewater, discharged water) as well as reducing the radioactivity concentration of the reactor water. Because the temperature depends on the seawater temperature at the time of water intake and the thermal output of the reactor, it is required to predict the temperature at the time of discharge (or the temperature difference from when water was taken in, also written as discharged water information) along with the radioactivity concentration of the reactor water.
[0012] The present invention has been made in consideration of the above problems, and has an object to provide a prediction model construction device and a prediction device that construct a prediction model that enables highly accurate prediction of the reactor water radioactivity concentration and discharge water information of a nuclear power plant. [Means for solving the problem]
[0013] In order to solve the above-mentioned problems, the prediction model construction device of the present invention has a learning unit that constructs a prediction model by having a machine learning model learn training data that includes, as input data, measurable plant state quantities and seawater information, and includes, as first output data, a first reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration related to a first reactor water radioactive metal, which is an actual value, and discharge water information, and also has a learning unit that constructs a verification index model by having a machine learning model learn training data that includes, as input data, plant state quantities and seawater information, and includes, as second output data, a second reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration related to a second reactor water radioactive metal different from the first reactor water radioactive metal, which is an actual value, and discharge water information. Effect of the Invention
[0014] According to the present invention, it is possible to provide a prediction model construction device and a prediction device that construct a prediction model that enables highly accurate prediction of reactor water radioactivity concentration and water discharge information in a nuclear power plant. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0015] [Figure 1] 1 is an overall system configuration diagram of a nuclear power plant according to an embodiment; [Diagram 2] 1 is a diagram for explaining the principle of a prediction device according to an embodiment; [Diagram 3] FIG. 2 is a diagram for explaining a mass balance model of the transfer behavior of metal corrosion products into reactor water according to the embodiment. [Figure 4] 1 is a functional configuration diagram of a reactor water radioactivity concentration / discharge water temperature prediction device according to an embodiment. [Diagram 5] FIG. 4 is a diagram illustrating an example of objective variable data according to the embodiment. [Figure 6] FIG. 11 is a diagram illustrating an example of verification index data according to the embodiment. [Figure 7] 1 is a diagram for explaining the configuration of data that is the source of teacher data for a prediction model in a learning process according to the present embodiment. FIG. [Figure 8] 1A and 1B are diagrams for explaining the configuration of data that is the source of input data and output data of a prediction model in a prediction process according to an embodiment. [Figure 9] 11 is a flowchart for explaining a process of creating a prediction model in the prediction process according to the embodiment. [Figure 10] 11 is a flowchart for explaining a process of creating a validation index prediction model in the prediction process according to the embodiment. [Figure 11] 11 is a flowchart for explaining a process of creating a consistency determination model in a prediction process according to the embodiment. [Figure 12] 11 is a flowchart for explaining a prediction result consistency verification process in the prediction process according to the embodiment. [Figure 13] 11 is a flowchart for explaining a consistency determination process in the prediction process according to the embodiment. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0016] Hereinafter, an embodiment of the present invention will be described with reference to the drawings. The following description and drawings are examples for explaining the present invention, and appropriate omissions and simplifications have been made for clarity of explanation. The present invention can be implemented in various other forms. Unless otherwise specified, each component may be singular or plural.
[0017] In the drawings explaining the embodiments, the same reference numerals are used to designate parts having the same functions, and repeated explanations thereof will be omitted.
[0018] In order to facilitate understanding of the invention, the position, size, shape, range, etc. of each component shown in the drawings may not represent the actual position, size, shape, range, etc. Therefore, the present invention is not necessarily limited to the position, size, shape, range, etc. disclosed in the drawings.
[0019] When there are multiple components having the same or similar functions, they may be described by using the same reference numerals with different subscripts. However, when there is no need to distinguish between these multiple components, the subscripts may be omitted.
[0020] Before describing a reactor water radioactivity concentration / discharge water temperature prediction device (a prediction model construction method and a prediction method) in an embodiment for carrying out the present invention, a nuclear power plant that is the subject of prediction will be described.
[0021] 1 is a diagram showing the overall system configuration of a nuclear power plant P100 according to an embodiment. A schematic configuration of the nuclear power plant P100 (e.g., a boiling water nuclear power plant) to which a reactor water radioactive concentration / discharge water temperature prediction device according to this embodiment is applied will be described with reference to FIG.
[0022] The nuclear power plant P100 includes a reactor P1, a turbine P3, a condenser P4, a reactor cleanup system, and a water supply system. The reactor P1 installed in a reactor containment vessel P11 has a reactor pressure vessel P12 incorporating a reactor core P13. A cylindrical core shroud P15 installed in the reactor pressure vessel P12 surrounds the reactor core P13. A plurality of fuel assemblies (not shown) are loaded in the reactor core P13. Each fuel assembly includes a plurality of fuel rods filled with a plurality of fuel pellets made of nuclear fuel material. An annular downcomer P17 is formed between the inner surface of the reactor pressure vessel P12 and the outer surface of the core shroud P15. A plurality of internal pumps P21 are installed at the bottom of the reactor pressure vessel P12. The impeller of the internal pump P21 is disposed at the lower part of the downcomer P17.
[0023] The feedwater system is configured by installing a condensate pump P5, a condensate purifying device P6, a feedwater pump P7, a low-pressure feedwater heater P8, and a high-pressure feedwater heater P9 in this order on a feedwater piping P10 that connects the condenser P4 and the reactor pressure vessel P12. A hydrogen injection device P16 is connected to the feedwater piping P10 between the condensate purifying device P6 and the feedwater pump P7 by a hydrogen injection piping P18. An opening / closing valve P19 is provided on the hydrogen injection piping P18.
[0024] The reactor cleanup system is configured by installing, in this order, a cleanup system isolation valve P23, a cleanup system pump P24, a regenerative heat exchanger P25, a non-regenerative heat exchanger P26, and a reactor water cleanup device P27 in a stainless steel cleanup system piping (stainless steel member) P20 that connects the reactor pressure vessel P12 and the feedwater piping P10. The residual heat removal system provided in the nuclear power plant P100 has a residual heat removal system piping P28, one end of which is connected to the reactor pressure vessel P12 and connected to the downcomer P17, and the other end of which is connected to the inside of the reactor pressure vessel P12 above the core P13. A residual heat removal system pump P29 and a heat exchanger (cooling device) P30 are installed in this residual heat removal system piping P28. One end of the cleanup system piping P20 is connected to the residual heat removal system piping P28 upstream of the residual heat removal system pump P29.
[0025] Cooling water (reactor water) present in the downcomer P17 in the reactor pressure vessel P12 is pressurized by an internal pump P21 and guided to a lower plenum below the reactor core P13. The reactor water is supplied from the lower plenum to the reactor core P13 and heated by heat generated by nuclear fission of the nuclear fuel material contained in the fuel rods of the fuel assemblies. A part of the heated reactor water becomes steam. This steam is guided from the reactor pressure vessel P12 through the main steam pipe P2 to the turbine P3, rotating the turbine P3. A generator (not shown) connected to the turbine P3 is rotated, generating electricity. The steam discharged from the turbine P3 is condensed in the condenser P4 to become water.
[0026] Condenser P4 is a type of heat exchanger that uses seawater taken in at the intake port to cool the steam and turn it back into water. The heated wastewater, whose temperature has increased by cooling the steam, is discharged from the discharge port. The difference between the temperature at the time of intake (intake temperature) and the temperature at the time of discharge (discharge temperature) is specified to be 7 to 8°C. For this reason, the plant is operated while adjusting the seawater flow rate and thermal output.
[0027] The water condensed in the condenser P4 is supplied as feedwater through a feedwater piping P10 into the reactor pressure vessel P12. The feedwater flowing through the feedwater piping P10 is pressurized by a condensate pump P5, impurities are removed by a condensate purifier P6, the pressure is further increased by a feedwater pump P7, and the feedwater is heated by a low-pressure feedwater heater P8 and a high-pressure feedwater heater P9. Extracted steam extracted from the main steam piping P2 and the turbine P3 by an extraction piping P14 is supplied to the low-pressure feedwater heater P8 and the high-pressure feedwater heater P9, respectively, and serves as a heating source for the feedwater.
[0028] The reactor water in the reactor pressure vessel P12 contains metal corrosion products contained in the feed water and products generated by corrosion of structural materials in the reactor pressure vessel P12, so a certain percentage of the reactor water is purified by the reactor water purification system. The reactor water in the reactor pressure vessel P12 is supplied to the regenerative heat exchanger P25 and the non-regenerative heat exchanger P26 through the purification system piping P20 branched off from the residual heat removal system piping P28 by the operation of the purification system pump P24, and is cooled to about 50°C by these heat exchangers. The cooled reactor water passes through the reactor water purification device P27 to remove metal corrosion products contained in the reactor water, is heated by the regenerative heat exchanger P25, and is then merged with the feed water flowing in the feed water piping P10 and supplied to the reactor pressure vessel P12.
[0029] When the operation of the reactor P1 is stopped, all the control rods (not shown) are inserted into the core. The nuclear fission reaction of the nuclear fuel material is stopped by inserting all the control rods, and the operation of the reactor P1 is stopped. The heat remaining in the equipment in the reactor core P13 and the reactor pressure vessel P12 is removed by the evaporation of the reactor water, but when the temperature drops to a certain level, the efficiency of heat removal by the evaporation of the reactor water decreases, so when the reactor water temperature drops to about 150°C, the equipment in the reactor core P13 and the reactor pressure vessel P12 is cooled using the residual heat removal system. That is, the reactor water in the reactor pressure vessel P12 is supplied to the heat exchanger P30 through the residual heat removal system piping P28 by driving the residual heat removal system pump P29, and the reactor water is then cooled in the heat exchanger P30 and returned to the reactor pressure vessel P12.
[0030] When a nuclear reactor is in operation, the reactor water contains radioactive metal corrosion products, including cobalt-60, which adhere to structural materials depending on their concentration. Personnel performing periodic inspections are exposed to radiation due to radiation emitted by radioactive nuclides that have adhered to the structural materials.
[0031] Next, the principle of the reactor water radioactive concentration / discharge water temperature prediction device (hereinafter simply referred to as "prediction device") of this embodiment will be described with reference to FIG.
[0032] It is known that a physical model shown in the mass balance model in Figure 3 holds between the metallic corrosion products contained in the feed water into the reactor P1 and the metallic corrosion products generated by the corrosion of the structural materials inside and outside the reactor that are in contact with the reactor water.
[0033] The mass balance model is a physical model that describes the dynamic behavior of metallic corrosion products contained in the feed water and metallic corrosion products generated by the corrosion of the structural materials inside and outside the reactor that are in contact with the reactor water, by the macroscopic law of conservation of mass. The metallic corrosion products are redeposited on the surfaces of the fuel rods and the structural materials inside and outside the reactor through the reactor water, and are removed from the system by the reactor water purification system. The solid and dashed arrows in Figure 2 indicate the transfer by the crud and ions.
[0034] The mass balance model of metal corrosion products is described by the simultaneous differential equations shown in (Equation 1) to (Equation 8) below.
number
[0035]
number
[0036]
number
[0037]
number
[0038]
number
[0039]
number
[0040]
number
[0041]
number
[0042] In the above formula, the variables and parameters have the following meanings: C: Metal corrosion product concentration in reactor water (concentration of metal corrosion products in reactor water, e.g., concentration of iron, nickel, cobalt, etc.) t: time V: Amount of reactor water held F f :Water supply flow rate Cf : Concentration of metal corrosion products in the feed water (Concentration of metal corrosion products in the feed water) X: Generation rate of metal corrosion products generated by corrosion of reactor internal structural materials ζ: Dissolution or detachment constant of fuel rod deposits ζ p 1 : Dissolution or peeling constant of deposits on reactor internal structure ζ p 2 : Dissolution or peeling constant of deposits on external structural materials
[0043] M: Amount of metal corrosion products accumulated on the fuel rod m1: Amount of metal corrosion products that adhere to and accumulate on the surfaces of structural materials inside the reactor m2: Amount of metal corrosion products that adhere to and accumulate on the surface of structural materials outside the reactor δ: adhesion constant to fuel rod β: Removal rate in the reactor cleanup system δ p 1 : adhesion constant to reactor internal structural materials δ p 2 : Adhesion constant to external structural materials S1: Surface area of structural materials inside the reactor S2: Surface area of structural material outside the furnace
[0044] R: Concentration of radioactive metal corrosion products in reactor water (Concentration of radioactive metal corrosion products in reactor water, e.g., concentration of cobalt 60, cobalt 58, manganese 54, etc.) Y: Generation rate of radioactive metal corrosion products caused by corrosion of reactor internal structural materials A: Amount of radioactive metal corrosion products accumulated on the fuel rod Γ1: Amount of radioactive metal corrosion products that adhere to and accumulate on the surfaces of structural materials inside the reactor Γ2: Amount of radioactive metal corrosion products that adhere to and accumulate on the surface of structural materials outside the reactor λ: Decay constant of radioactive metal corrosion products G: Production rate of radionuclides on the fuel rod G1: Production rate of radioactive nuclides on reactor internal structural materials
[0045] Among the above variables, C, C f, F f , R, and Γ2 are state quantities that can be measured during operation, and M, A, and Γ1 are state quantities that can be measured when the fuel rods are removed from the reactor during shutdowns such as periodic inspections. V, S1, and S2 are plant parameters specific to the plant. λ, G, and G1 are physical constants determined according to the nuclide of the radioactive metal corrosion product, and X, Y, ζ, and ζ p 1 , ζ p 2 , δ, δ p 1 , δ p 2 In principle, β is a model parameter. Note that m1 and m2 are quantities of state that are usually difficult to measure, since they cannot be distinguished between those that have attached from the water side and those that have arisen due to corrosion of the structural material.
[0046] The metal corrosion product to be predicted in the prediction device of this embodiment is cobalt-60. On the other hand, it is considered that metal corrosion products other than the prediction target also follow the above-mentioned mass balance model. Therefore, it is expected that there is a strong correlation between the metal corrosion products contained in the feedwater and cobalt-60, which is a metal corrosion product generated due to corrosion of the structural materials inside and outside the reactor that are in contact with the reactor water, while there is also a strong correlation between the metal corrosion products contained in the feedwater and metal corrosion products other than cobalt-60 generated due to corrosion of the structural materials inside and outside the reactor that are in contact with the reactor water (cobalt-58 and iron are given as examples in FIG. 2). And, based on these correlations, it is expected that there is also a strong correlation between the concentration of cobalt-60 and the concentrations of cobalt-58 and iron.
[0047] Therefore, in the prediction device of this embodiment, a first learning model is generated that learns the correlation between the metal corrosion products contained in the feedwater and cobalt-60, which is a metal corrosion product generated with the corrosion of structural materials inside and outside the reactor that are in contact with the reactor water, and a second learning model is generated that learns the correlation between the metal corrosion products contained in the feedwater and metal corrosion products other than cobalt-60 generated with the corrosion of structural materials inside and outside the reactor that are in contact with the reactor water. Then, (1) the first learning model predicts the concentration of the metal corrosion products of cobalt-60 based on the metal corrosion products contained in the actual feedwater, (2) the second learning model predicts the concentration of the metal corrosion products other than cobalt-60 based on the metal corrosion products contained in the actual feedwater, and (3) predicts the concentration of the metal corrosion products of cobalt-60 predicted from the concentration of the metal corrosion products other than cobalt-60, and the validity of the result of (1) is judged based on the difference between the result of (1) and the result of (3) (both predicting the concentration of the metal corrosion products of cobalt-60).
[0048] The reactor water radioactivity concentration / discharge water temperature prediction device for predicting the reactor water radioactivity concentration and discharge water temperature in the nuclear power plant P100 according to this embodiment will be described below. The reactor water radioactivity concentration / discharge water temperature prediction device predicts the concentrations of cobalt-60, cobalt-58, chromium-51, manganese-54, etc. in the reactor water, and the discharge water temperature. Machine learning technology is used for the prediction.
[0049] The reactor water radioactivity concentration / discharge water temperature prediction device according to this embodiment can predict the concentration of radioactive metal corrosion products and the discharge water temperature with high accuracy. Using this prediction, plant operators can create and implement plans to reduce radiation exposure by lowering the reactor water radioactivity concentration during operation, installing shielding, or carrying out chemical decontamination, while adhering to regulations for temperature management of discharge water (warm wastewater).
[0050] 4 is a functional configuration diagram of a prediction device 100 according to this embodiment. The prediction device 100 is a computer, and includes a control unit 110, a model storage unit 120, a data storage unit 130, and an input / output unit 140. The prediction device 100 receives operation data such as thermal output from a process computer P110 used in the nuclear power plant P100, and output data from a measuring instrument P120 installed in the nuclear power plant P100.
[0051] The model storage unit 120 is composed of a RAM (Random Access Memory), a ROM (Read Only Memory), an SSD (Solid State Drive), etc., and has a prediction model storage unit 121 in which a prediction model is stored, a verification index model storage unit 122 in which a verification index model is stored, and a consistency judgment model storage unit 123 in which a consistency judgment model is stored.
[0052] The prediction model stored in the prediction model memory unit 121 is a machine learning learning model, for example a neural network, that uses plant state quantities and seawater information as input data (explanatory variables) and the concentration of metal corrosion products of cobalt-60 as output data (objective variable).
[0053] The verification index model stored in the verification index model storage unit 122 is a machine learning learning model, for example a neural network, that uses plant state quantities and seawater information as input data (explanatory variables) and uses metal corrosion product concentrations other than cobalt-60 (in this embodiment, cobalt-58, iron, and nickel as described later) as output data (objective variables).
[0054] The consistency determination model stored in the consistency determination model memory unit 123 is a machine learning learning model, for example a neural network, that uses metal corrosion product concentrations other than cobalt-60 as input data (explanatory variables) and the metal corrosion product concentration of cobalt-60 as output data (objective variable).
[0055] Here, the plant state quantities referred to in this embodiment include plant data, feed water data, and reactor water quality data of the nuclear power plant P100. The plant state quantities also include plant state quantities such as the in-reactor residence time of the fuel assemblies loaded in the core P13 (see FIG. 1) and the electric output. The seawater information is the intake water temperature (seawater temperature at the intake port) and the discharge water temperature (warm discharge water temperature at the discharge port). The seawater information may include information such as the temperature and position of ocean currents that affect the intake water temperature.
[0056] The data storage unit 130, like the model storage unit 120, is composed of a RAM, a ROM, an SSD, etc., and has an explanatory variable data storage unit 131 in which explanatory variable data is stored, an objective variable data storage unit 132 in which objective variable data is stored, and a verification index data storage unit 133 in which verification index data is stored.
[0057] The explanatory variable data stored in the explanatory variable data storage unit 131 includes the above-mentioned plant state quantities and seawater information.
[0058] The objective variable data stored in the objective variable data storage unit 132 has, as an example, a data structure as shown in Fig. 5. As shown in Fig. 5, objective variable data 200 has a date 201 and a reactor water cobalt-60 ion concentration 202 as entries.
[0059] The verification index data stored in the verification index data storage unit 133 has, as an example, a data structure as shown in Fig. 6. As shown in Fig. 6, the verification index data 210 has, as entries, a date 211, a reactor water cobalt-58 ion concentration 212, a reactor water iron crud concentration 213, and a reactor water nickel ion concentration 214.
[0060] The input / output unit 140 receives data from the process computer P110 and the measuring instrument P120, and stores the data in the plant state quantity / seawater information database 150. The input / output unit 140 also includes a display, keyboard, and mouse (not shown), and receives operations from a user of the prediction device 100 and displays data such as prediction results.
[0061] The control unit 110 is composed of a CPU (Central Processing Unit), and has a learning unit 111, a prediction unit 112, a consistency determination model creation unit 113, and a verification unit 114. The learning unit 111 performs a learning process using the explanatory variable data stored in the explanatory variable data storage unit 131 as teacher data (learning data) and generates a prediction model for predicting the radioactive concentration and discharge water temperature of the reactor water and a verification index prediction model.
[0062] The prediction unit 112 inputs explanatory variable data to the generated prediction model and the verification index model, and executes a prediction process for predicting the radioactive concentration and discharge water temperature of the reactor water.
[0063] The consistency determination model creation unit 113 performs a learning process using the verification index data stored in the verification index data storage unit 133 as input data, and generates a consistency determination model that predicts the objective variable data.
[0064] The verification unit 114 compares the concentration of metal corrosion products of cobalt-60 in the reactor water, which is the output result of the prediction model, with the concentration of metal corrosion products of cobalt-60 in the reactor water, which is the output result of the consistency determination model, and verifies the validity of the concentration of metal corrosion products of cobalt-60 in the reactor water, which is the output result of the prediction model.
[0065] The details of the processes performed by the learning unit 111, the prediction unit 112, the consistency determination model creation unit 113, and the verification unit 114 will be described later with reference to FIGS.
[0066] 7 is a diagram for explaining the configuration of data that is the source of teacher data for a prediction model in a learning process according to this embodiment. In this embodiment, an example of predicting the future three years (36 months) from data for the past three years (36 months) will be explained.
[0067] The data set 230 shown in Fig. 7 is a data set that is the source of one set of teacher data starting from the first month. The data set 230 includes plant state quantities and seawater information (intake water temperature and discharge water temperature) from the first month to the 36th month as input data (original data for the input data). The data set 230 also includes reactor water radioactivity concentration of cobalt-60 (also referred to as cobalt-60 concentration) and discharge water temperature from the 37th month to the 72nd month as output data (original data for the output data). These data are stored in the explanatory variable data storage unit 131.
[0068] The plant state quantities that can be measured (actual data) included in each of the plant state quantities from 1st to 36th months, such as feedwater flow rate, feedwater metal corrosion product concentration, reactor water metal corrosion product concentration, reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration, reactor water purification flow rate, duration of fuel assemblies in the reactor, electrical output, intake water temperature, and discharge water temperature, are included as input data for the prediction model.
[0069] The cobalt-60 concentration and discharge water temperature (actual measurements) from the 37th to 72nd months are included as output data of the prediction model (concentration of radioactive metal corrosion products in reactor water and discharge water temperature).
[0070] The input data and output data described above constitute one set of teacher data for the prediction model. In the same manner, one set of teacher data is generated from the data set 240 starting from the second month. By repeating this process, 30 sets of teacher data (a data set of teacher data) for the prediction model are generated from the plant state quantities including cobalt-60 and seawater information from the first month to the 101st month. The teacher data that is the input of the prediction model includes the plant state quantities that can be measured, seawater information (intake water temperature and discharge water temperature), and predicted values of the plant state quantities. The teacher data that is the output of the prediction model includes the reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration (cobalt-60 concentration), which is an actual measurement value, and discharge water information (discharge water temperature).
[0071] FIG. 8 is a diagram for explaining the configuration of data that is the source of input data for a prediction model in a prediction process according to this embodiment and output data.
[0072] In FIG. 7, the base month is the month in which the prediction process is executed, and the prediction unit 112 predicts the cobalt-60 concentration and discharge water temperature from one to 36 months after the base month based on the plant state quantity and seawater information for the past 36 months including the base month.
[0073] In detail, the input data for the prediction model include measurable plant state quantities, such as the feedwater flow rate, feedwater metal corrosion product concentration, reactor water metal corrosion product concentration, reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration, reactor water purification flow rate, duration of fuel assemblies in the reactor, and electrical output, which are included in the plant state quantities from 35 months prior to the base month through the base month, as well as seawater information including the intake water temperature and discharge water temperature (actual measurement data).
[0074] The cobalt-60 concentration and discharge water temperature from 1 to 36 months after the reference date are included as output data (prediction results) of the prediction model.
[0075] Note that the data shown in FIG. 7 and FIG. 8 is related to the prediction model, but the data related to the validation index model is similar, so the description thereof will be omitted here.
[0076] Next, the operation of the prediction device 100 of this embodiment will be described with reference to the flowcharts of FIGS.
[0077] FIG. 9 is a flowchart for explaining a process of creating a prediction model in the prediction process according to the embodiment.
[0078] First, the learning unit 111 of the prediction device 100 reads the objective variable data 200 from the objective variable data storage unit 132 (S901). Next, the learning unit 111 reads the explanatory variable data from the explanatory variable data storage unit 131 (S902). Furthermore, the learning unit 111 creates a regression model in which the explanatory variable data is input data and the objective variable data 200 is output data (S903). Then, the learning unit 111 stores the regression model created in S903 in the prediction model storage unit 121 as a prediction model (S904).
[0079] FIG. 10 is a flowchart for explaining the process of creating a validation index prediction model in the prediction process according to the embodiment.
[0080] First, the learning unit 111 of the prediction device 100 reads the validation index data 210 from the validation index data storage unit 133 (S1001). Next, the learning unit 111 reads the explanatory variable data from the explanatory variable data storage unit 131 (S1002). Furthermore, the learning unit 111 creates a regression model in which the explanatory variable data is input data and the validation index data 210 is output data (S1003). Then, the learning unit 111 stores the regression model created in S1003 in the validation index model storage unit 122 as a validation index model (S1004).
[0081] FIG. 11 is a flowchart for explaining the process of creating a consistency determination model in the prediction process according to the embodiment.
[0082] First, the consistency determination model creation unit 113 of the prediction device 100 reads the objective variable data 200 from the objective variable data storage unit 132 (S1101). Next, the consistency determination model creation unit 113 reads the verification index data 210 from the verification index data storage unit 133 (S1102). Furthermore, the consistency determination model creation unit 113 creates a regression model in which the verification index data 210 is used as input data and the objective variable data 200 is used as output data (S1103). Then, the consistency determination model creation unit 113 stores the regression model created in S1103 in the consistency determination model storage unit 123 as a consistency determination model (S1104).
[0083] FIG. 12 is a flowchart for explaining a prediction result consistency verification process in the prediction process according to the embodiment.
[0084] First, the prediction unit 112 of the prediction device 100 reads explanatory variable data from the explanatory variable data storage unit 131 (S1201).
[0085] Next, the prediction unit 112 reads a prediction model from the prediction model storage unit 121 (S1202). Furthermore, the prediction unit 112 inputs the explanatory variable data read in S1201 to the prediction model read in S1202 to obtain a predicted value (prediction result) of the objective variable data (S1203).
[0086] In parallel with this, the prediction unit 112 reads the validation index model from the validation index model storage unit 122 (S1204). Furthermore, the prediction unit 112 inputs the explanatory variable data read in S1201 to the prediction model read in S1204 to obtain a predicted value (prediction result) of the validation index data (S1205).
[0087] Next, the verification unit 114 of the prediction device 100 performs a consistency determination process (S1206). The details of the consistency determination process will be described later. Then, the verification unit 114 outputs the result of the consistency determination process of S1206.
[0088] FIG. 13 is a flowchart for explaining the consistency determination process in the prediction process according to the embodiment, and is a flowchart showing details of the consistency determination process in S1206 in FIG.
[0089] First, the verification unit 114 of the prediction device 100 reads the consistency judgment model from the consistency judgment model storage unit 123 (S1301). Next, the verification unit 114 inputs the predicted value of the verification index data acquired in S1205 of Fig. 12 into the consistency judgment model to obtain an estimated value of the objective variable data (S1302).
[0090] Then, the verification unit 114 compares the estimated value of the objective variable data acquired in S1302 (the estimated result of Cobalt 60) with the predicted value of the objective variable data acquired in S1203 of Fig. 12 (the predicted result of Cobalt 60), and judges whether or not the difference therebetween is equal to or smaller than a predetermined error value (S1203). Note that it is preferable to set the error value in advance.
[0091] If the result of the judgment in S1203 is that the error is below the predetermined error value (YES in S1203), the verification unit 114 sets the consistency judgment result to "YES" (S1204), and if the result of the judgment in S1203 is that the error is above the predetermined error value (NO in S1203), the verification unit 114 sets the consistency judgment result to "NO" (S1205).
[0092] As described above in detail, according to the prediction device 100 of this embodiment, it is possible to verify the consistency and validity of the prediction results of the concentration of metal corrosion products of Cobalt-60.
[0093] It is possible to create a learning model based on a mass balance model and predict the concentration of metal corrosion products of cobalt-60 using this learning model. On the other hand, it is difficult to guarantee the accuracy of the concentration of metal corrosion products of cobalt-60 based on the learning model using the learning model alone. According to the prediction device 100 of this embodiment, it is possible to verify the predicted value of the concentration of metal corrosion products of cobalt-60 obtained by the prediction model using the predicted value of the concentration of metal corrosion products other than cobalt-60 obtained by the verification index model and the estimated value of the concentration of metal corrosion products of cobalt-60 obtained by the consistency judgment model. As a result, the consistency and validity of the concentration of metal corrosion products of cobalt-60 obtained by the prediction model can be verified, and the concentration of metal corrosion products of cobalt-60 with higher accuracy can be obtained.
[0094] The present invention is not limited to the above-mentioned embodiment, but includes various modified examples. The above-mentioned embodiment has been described in detail to clearly explain the present invention, and is not necessarily limited to those having all of the configurations described. It is also possible to replace a part of the configuration of one embodiment with the configuration of another embodiment, and it is also possible to add the configuration of another embodiment to the configuration of one embodiment. It is also possible to add, delete, or replace a part of the configuration of each embodiment with another configuration.
[0095] For example, in the above-described embodiment, it is possible to retrain the prediction model using the estimation result of the metal corrosion product concentration of Cobalt-60 obtained by the consistency determination model.
[0096] In addition, the above-mentioned configurations, functions, processing units, processing means, etc. may be realized in part or in whole by hardware, for example, by designing them as integrated circuits. In addition, the above-mentioned configurations, functions, etc. may be realized in software by a processor interpreting and executing a program that realizes each function. Information such as the program, table, file, etc. that realizes each function can be stored in a memory, a recording device such as a hard disk or SSD, or a recording medium such as an IC card, SD card, or DVD.
[0097] In addition, the control lines and information lines shown are those that are considered necessary for the explanation, and not all control lines and information lines in the product are necessarily shown. In reality, it can be considered that almost all components are connected to each other. (Appendix 1) Concentrations of radioactive metal corrosion products in reactor water and seawater discharge in nuclear power plants A predictive model construction device for constructing a predictive model for predicting information, The input data includes measurable plant state quantities and seawater information, and the first output data is As the data, the first reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product for the first reactor water radioactive metal, which is an actual measured value, The concentration and the teacher data including the discharge information are trained in a machine learning model to generate the prediction model. and constructing a second input data including the plant state quantity and the seawater information. As the output data, the second reactor water radioactive metal, which is different from the first reactor water radioactive metal, which is the actual measurement value, is Teacher data including a second reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration related to metal and the discharge water information A learning section that trains a machine learning model to build an indicator model for validation. A predictive model construction device comprising: (Appendix 2) Concentrations of radioactive metal corrosion products in reactor water and seawater discharge in nuclear power plants A predictive model construction device for constructing a predictive model for predicting information, The input data includes measurable plant state quantities and seawater information, and the first output data is As the data, the first reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product for the first reactor water radioactive metal, which is an actual measured value, The concentration and the teacher data including the discharge information are trained in a machine learning model to generate the prediction model. and constructing a second input data including the plant state quantity and the seawater information. As the output data, the second reactor water radioactive metal, which is different from the first reactor water radioactive metal, which is the actual measurement value, is Teacher data including a second reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration related to metal and the discharge water information A learning unit that constructs a validation indicator model by training a machine learning model; The measurable plant state quantities and the seawater information are used as input data, and the prediction model and and inputting the first reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration and the The first output data consisting of discharge water information, the second reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration, and a prediction unit for calculating the second output data consisting of the water discharge information; The validity of the first output data is verified based on the first and second output data. Verification department and A prediction device comprising: (Appendix 3) the first reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration and the second reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration The prediction device according to claim 2, characterized in that there is a strong correlation between the (Appendix 4) The second output data is used as input data, and the first output data is used as output data. A consistency judgment model is constructed by training the training data on a machine learning model. Equipped with a creation department, The verification unit inputs the second output data to the consistency determination model. The first output data and the second output data are input to the prediction model. and verifying the validity of the first output data by comparing the first output data with the first output data obtained by the R The prediction device according to (Appendix 2) is characterized in that (Appendix 5) The verification unit inputs the second output data to the consistency determination model. The first output data and the second output data are input to the prediction model. If the difference between the first output data and the second output data is equal to or smaller than a predetermined value, the first output data is considered valid. The prediction device according to claim 4, further comprising: (Appendix 6) The measurable plant state quantities include the feedwater flow rate of the reactor water, the feedwater metal corrosion product, concentration, reactor water metal corrosion product concentration, reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration, reactor water purification flow rate, fuel collection At least one of the following: duration of stay in the reactor, and electrical output The prediction device according to (Appendix 2) is characterized in that (Appendix 7) The seawater information included in the input data includes an intake temperature and a discharge temperature of the seawater, The discharge water information included in the first and second output data includes a discharge temperature of the seawater. The prediction device according to (Appendix 2) is characterized in that (Appendix 8) The first reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration is Cobalt 60, Cobalt 58, and The concentration of radioactive metal corrosion products in the reactor water of the N-Ga-54 The prediction device according to (Appendix 2) is characterized in that (Appendix 9) The second reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration is cobalt 58, iron and nickel. The concentration of radioactive metal corrosion products in the reactor water is either The prediction device according to (Appendix 2) is characterized in that [Explanation of symbols]
[0098] 100... Prediction device 110... Control unit 111... Learning unit 112... Prediction unit 113... Consistency judgment model creation unit 114... Verification unit 120... Model storage unit 121... Prediction model storage unit 122... Verification index model storage unit 123... Consistency judgment model storage unit 130... Data storage unit 131... Explanatory variable data storage unit 132... Objective variable data storage unit 133... Verification index data storage unit 140... Input / output unit 150... Seawater information database 200... Objective variable data 210... Verification index data 230... Data set 240... Data set
Claims
1. A prediction model construction device for constructing a prediction model for predicting a concentration of radioactive metal corrosion products in reactor water and seawater discharge information of a nuclear reactor in a nuclear power plant, comprising: A learning unit that constructs the prediction model by training a machine learning model with training data including, as input data, a measurable plant state quantity and seawater information, and including, as first output data, a first reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration related to a first reactor water radioactive metal, which is an actual value, and the discharge water information, and that constructs a verification index model by training a machine learning model with training data including, as input data, the plant state quantity and the seawater information, and including, as second output data, a second reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration related to a second reactor water radioactive metal different from the first reactor water radioactive metal, which is an actual value, and the discharge water information. A predictive model construction device comprising:
2. A prediction device, comprising: a learning unit for constructing a prediction model for predicting a reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration and seawater discharge information of a reactor in a nuclear power plant, the learning unit including, as input data, a measurable plant state quantity and seawater information, and constructing the prediction model by having a machine learning model learn training data including, as first output data, a first reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration related to a first reactor water radioactive metal, which is an actual value, and the discharge information, and also, the learning unit including, as input data, the plant state quantity and the seawater information, and constructing a verification index model by having a machine learning model learn training data including, as second output data, a second reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration related to a second reactor water radioactive metal different from the first reactor water radioactive metal, which is an actual value, and the discharge information; a prediction unit which inputs the measurable plant state quantity and the seawater information as input data into the prediction model and the verification index model, and calculates the first output data consisting of the first reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration and the discharge water information, and the second output data consisting of the second reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration and the discharge water information; a verification unit that verifies the validity of the first output data based on the first and second output data; A prediction device comprising:
3. 3. The prediction device according to claim 2, wherein there is a strong correlation between the first reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration and the second reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration.
4. a consistency determination model creation unit that constructs a consistency determination model by training a machine learning model on teacher data in which the second output data is used as input data and the first output data is used as output data; The verification unit verifies the validity of the first output data by comparing the first output data obtained by inputting the second output data to the consistency determination model with the first output data obtained by the prediction unit inputting the measurable plant state quantity and the seawater information to the prediction model. The prediction device according to claim 2 .
5. The prediction device according to claim 4, wherein the verification unit determines that the first output data is valid if a difference between the first output data obtained by inputting the second output data to the consistency determination model and the first output data obtained by the prediction unit by inputting the measurable plant state quantity and the seawater information to the prediction model is equal to or less than a predetermined value.
6. The measurable plant state quantity includes at least one of the reactor water feedwater flow rate, the reactor water metal corrosion product concentration, the reactor water metal corrosion product concentration, the reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration, the reactor water purification flow rate, the in-reactor residence time of the fuel assembly, and the electrical output. The prediction device according to claim 2 .
7. The seawater information included in the input data includes an intake temperature and a discharge temperature of the seawater, The discharge water information included in the first and second output data includes a discharge temperature of the seawater. The prediction device according to claim 2 .
8. The first reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration is a reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration of any one of cobalt 60, cobalt 58, and manganese 54. The prediction device according to claim 2 .
9. The second reactor water radioactive metal corrosion product concentration is any one of cobalt-58, iron, and nickel. The prediction device according to claim 2 .
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Water quality diagnostic system
JP1989063894A
Self learning diagnosis for plant, estimation and device therefor
JP1994289179A
Apparatus and method for analyzing power plant water quality
JP1999503834A
Nuclear power plant
JP2014153305A
Predictive model construction method and prediction method
JP2021050939A
