Apparatus and Method for Predicting Effect of Electric Motor Replacement Based on Measurement Data

The apparatus and method address the challenge of inaccurate motor replacement predictions by using actual operational data to calculate power consumption and savings rates, considering load and speed variations, and recommending optimal scenarios for improved efficiency and cost-effectiveness.

KR103045960B1Active Publication Date: 2026-11-10주식회사파란에너지
View PDF 4 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
KR1020260092231
Authority / Receiving Office
KR · KR
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2026-05-21
Publication Date
2026-11-10
Estimated Expiration
2046-05-21

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing methods for evaluating motor replacement effectiveness fail to accurately predict power consumption and savings rates due to variations in load factor, rotational speed, power factor, and efficiency degradation, leading to unreliable assessments of cost savings and operating conditions.

Method used

An apparatus and method that utilizes actual operation-related data of existing motors to calculate expected power consumption and savings rates by considering load rate, rotational speed, and power factor, and provides scenarios like speed control and impeller trimming to optimize motor replacement.

Benefits of technology

Accurately predicts power consumption and savings rates under real-world conditions, accounting for changes in rotational speed and load patterns, and recommends optimal operating conditions and construction methods based on field applicability and economic feasibility.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure R1020260092231_ABST
    Figure R1020260092231_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The present invention relates to an apparatus and method for predicting the effect of motor replacement, which calculates reference data representing the existing operating state of an existing motor using operation-related data including at least one of nameplate data and measurement data of an existing motor, and calculates a predicted value of the replacement effect for one or more replacement or operating scenarios to which the motor to be replaced is applied based on the reference data. In addition, the present invention reflects the actual operating state of existing electric motors and allows for the comparison of multiple replacement or operating scenarios, such as simple direct connection, speed control, or impeller trimming, thereby providing information necessary for determining investment feasibility, operating conditions, and construction methods prior to replacement.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technology Field

[0001] The present invention relates to an apparatus and method for predicting the effect of motor replacement, which predicts power consumption or savings rate when applying a motor to be replaced using data related to the operation of an existing motor. Background Technology

[0002] Electric motors are widely used to drive rotary loads such as pumps, fans, and blowers in industrial sites, building facilities, water treatment facilities, or process facilities. Over time, the efficiency of electric motors may decrease, or they may operate in a manner unsuitable for the operating conditions of the facilities. Accordingly, attempts are being made to reduce energy consumption by replacing existing electric motors with higher-efficiency motors.

[0003] Conventionally, when evaluating the effectiveness of motor replacement, there were cases where the nameplate efficiency of the existing motor was simply compared with that of the replacement motor, or savings were calculated based on rated capacity. However, motors in the field do not always operate at rated load, and actual power consumption and efficiency can vary depending on the load factor, rotational speed, power factor, operating time, load patterns, and efficiency degradation due to long-term operation.

[0004] Furthermore, the power requirements of rotary loads, such as pumps, can vary depending on changes in rotational speed. Therefore, even if the motor to be replaced has high efficiency, the power consumption of the entire system may differ from expectations if the rotational speed or operating point changes after replacement. In such cases, it may be difficult to reliably assess the cost savings, appropriate operating conditions, or suitable construction methods after replacement based solely on differences in efficiency. Prior art literature

[65535] 0001. Registered Patent Publication No. 10-2759809 (Published Jan. 24, 2025) The problem to be solved

[0005] The present invention can provide an apparatus and method for predicting the effect of motor replacement that can predict power consumption or savings rate when applying a motor to be replaced, tailored to field operating conditions, by utilizing actual operation-related data of existing motors.

[0006] In addition, the present invention can provide a motor replacement effect prediction device and method that supports the determination of a replacement method or operating conditions suitable for the site by considering the existing operating state and replacement or operating scenarios together, rather than determining the replacement effect based solely on the efficiency information of the motor to be replaced. means of solving the problem

[0007] The prediction device of the present invention may include: an input unit that receives operation-related data including nameplate data or measurement data of an existing motor; a data processing unit that calculates reference data representing the existing operating state of the existing motor based on the operation-related data; a scenario calculation unit that calculates a replacement effect prediction value for one or more replacement or operating scenarios to which the motor to be replaced is applied based on the reference data; and an output unit that outputs the replacement effect prediction value, and the replacement effect prediction value may include at least one of the expected power consumption or expected reduction rate of the motor to be replaced.

[0008] In addition, the scenario calculation unit can calculate the estimated power consumption for speed control in a speed control scenario in which the electric motor to be replaced is operated by a speed control device to correspond to a target RPM operating point or target frequency condition, and can calculate the estimated power consumption for impeller trimming in an impeller trimming scenario in which the impeller outer diameter, impeller shape, trimming ratio, or pump characteristics of the pump are adjusted. The output unit can output at least one of recommended operating conditions or recommended construction methods based on the calculation results of the speed control scenario or the impeller trimming scenario. Effects of the invention

[0009] The present invention can predict the replacement effect by reflecting the actual operating conditions of the existing motor, rather than a method of simply comparing the nameplate efficiency of the existing motor with the nameplate efficiency of the motor to be replaced.

[0010] In addition, since the present invention can calculate reference data corresponding to the existing operating state using the actual active power, load rate, rotational speed, power factor, or estimated actual efficiency of the existing electric motor, it is possible to compare the state before and after replacement under the same or corresponding operating conditions.

[0011] Furthermore, the present invention can reflect the effect of changes in the rotational speed of the motor to be replaced on the load power requirements in rotary loads such as pumps. Accordingly, even if the efficiency of the motor itself is improved, it is possible to predict in advance cases where the savings effect is reduced due to an increase in rotational speed or a change in the operating point.

[0012] In addition, the present invention can compare multiple replacement or operation scenarios, such as simple direct connection, speed control, and impeller trimming. Accordingly, it can provide information necessary to determine whether speed control is required, whether impeller trimming is suitable, or whether simple direct connection is possible, depending on field conditions.

[0013] Furthermore, the present invention can consider not only expected power consumption or expected savings rate but also load variability, load patterns, costs, payback period, and operational stability. Therefore, rather than simply providing a scenario with a high savings rate, it can provide recommended operating conditions or construction methods that consider field applicability, economic feasibility, and operational stability.

[0014] In addition, since the present invention can update field correction values, operating point deviation correction values, efficiency models, or recommendation judgment criteria using actual measurement data after replacement, the accuracy of subsequent equipment diagnosis or prediction of subsequent replacement effects can be improved. Brief explanation of the drawing

[0015] FIG. 1 is a configuration diagram of the motor replacement effect prediction device of the present invention. FIG. 2 is a flowchart of the calculation of the operating state of an existing motor of the present invention. FIG. 3 is a flowchart of the calculation of the estimated actual efficiency and pump shaft power of the present invention. FIG. 4 is a flowchart of the calculation of replacement scenarios of the present invention. FIG. 5 is a flowchart of the comparison of multiple scenarios and recommendation output of the present invention. FIG. 6 is an example diagram of a user input screen that receives operation-related data and replacement target information from the prediction device of the present invention. FIG. 7 is an example diagram of a diagnostic result screen that outputs the existing operating state and recommendation information by replacement or operating scenario from the prediction device of the present invention. Specific details for implementing the invention

[0016] With reference to FIGS. 1 to 7, the apparatus and method for predicting the effect of electric motor replacement based on measurement data according to the present invention will be described.

[0017] The present invention relates to an apparatus and method for calculating an existing operating state using nameplate data (D100) and measurement data (D150) of an existing induction motor (10) in an facility where a pump (12) is driven by an induction motor (10), and calculating an expected power consumption or expected reduction rate for each application scenario of a motor to be replaced based on the calculated existing operating state.

[0018] The induction motor (10) of the present invention may be a motor installed and operating at the site to drive a pump (12). The pump (12) may be a load device for transporting or circulating fluid, and the rotational force of the existing induction motor (10) may be transmitted to the pump (12) through the shaft connection part (14). The shaft connection part (14) may represent a power transmission path between the output shaft of the existing induction motor (10) and the input shaft of the pump (12), and may include a coupling, a shaft, a pulley, a reduction gear, or a combination thereof.

[0019] It can be used to predict the effect of replacing an induction motor (10) with a high-efficiency motor such as an IE5 synchronous motor. The IE5 synchronous motor may be a permanent magnet synchronous motor, a line-start permanent magnet synchronous motor, a synchronous reluctance motor, or a high-efficiency synchronous motor equivalent thereto.

[0020] However, the present invention is not limited to a specific efficiency class or a specific motor structure, and can be applied even when replacing an existing induction motor (10) with a replacement motor having different efficiency characteristics, rotational speed characteristics or control characteristics.

[0021] One of the key aspects of the present invention is that, rather than simply comparing the nameplate efficiency of the existing induction motor (10) with the nameplate efficiency of the motor to be replaced, the existing induction motor (10) is first estimated to have a load rate, rotational speed, power factor, actual efficiency, and a state of reduced efficiency due to long-term operation in the actual field, and then the expected power consumption or expected savings rate after replacement is calculated based on the results.

[0022] Generally, the nameplate data (D100) of an induction motor indicates performance under rated conditions. However, in field facilities, existing induction motors (10) may not be operated at rated load, and depending on the actual operating point, the rotational speed, power factor, and efficiency may differ from rated conditions, and a decrease in efficiency may occur due to aging from long-term operation. Therefore, if the replacement effect is calculated based only on rated efficiency, the actual power consumption of the existing facilities and the actual power level delivered to the pump (12) may not be accurately reflected.

[0023] Additionally, the pump (12) may be a load whose power requirements may vary depending on changes in rotational speed. If the motor to be replaced drives the pump (12) at a higher rotational speed than the existing induction motor (10), even if the efficiency of the motor itself is improved, the power requirements of the pump (12) increase, which may reduce the overall power consumption reduction effect or, in some cases, fail to produce the expected reduction effect. In the embodiments of the present invention, the replacement effect can be calculated by reflecting such changes in rotational speed, changes in load rate, and field operating conditions.

[0024] Therefore, the calculation of the replacement effect of the present invention can be distinguished from a method that directly converts the efficiency difference of individual motor components into a power saving amount. The data processing unit (50) first standardizes the load rate, rotational speed, power factor, and efficiency status of the existing induction motor (10), and the scenario calculation unit (60) can compare the simple direct connection, speed control, and impeller trimming scenarios of the motor to be replaced based on the standardized operating status.

[0025] Pump shaft power (D310) may refer to the mechanical power estimated to be delivered to the shaft of the pump (12), excluding internal losses of the motor from the electrical input consumed by the existing induction motor (10) during actual operation. Instead of simply using the actual effective power (D160) as the power consumed before replacement, the pump shaft power (D310) is calculated by reflecting the estimated actual efficiency (D300), and this can be used as a reference value for comparing simple direct drive operation, speed control operation, and impeller trimming operation based on the same workload.

[0026] In the present invention, simple direct operation may refer to a scenario in which the motor to be replaced is connected to the pump (12) and operated without separate speed control or pump operating point adjustment.

[0027] Speed ​​control operation may refer to a scenario in which the rotational speed of the motor to be replaced is controlled to match the target RPM, target frequency, or target operating point using an inverter, a variable speed drive unit, a frequency converter, or a speed control unit equivalent thereto.

[0028] Impeller trimming may refer to a construction scenario in which the operating point of the pump (12) is adjusted by changing the impeller outer diameter, impeller shape, or pump characteristics of the pump (12) to reflect changes in required power according to similarity laws.

[0029] FIG. 1 shows the configuration of a replacement effect prediction device according to one embodiment of the present invention.

[0030] According to FIG. 1, the replacement effect prediction device may include at least one of a measurement unit (20), a nameplate data input unit (30), a measurement data input unit (40), a data processing unit (50), a scenario calculation unit (60), an output unit (70), a recommendation output unit (72), an information input unit (80), and a comparison judgment unit (150).

[0031] The measuring unit (20) can measure the operating state of the existing induction motor (10). The measuring unit (20) can measure at least one of the voltage, current, power, power factor, frequency, or rotational speed supplied to the existing induction motor (10). The measuring unit (20) may include a power meter, a voltage sensor, a current sensor, a power factor meter, a rotational speed sensor, a frequency meter, a pressure sensor, a flow sensor, a vibration sensor, or a communication-type power meter, and may be connected to the power line, control panel, inverter output terminal, power meter, rotational speed sensor, or field measuring device of the existing induction motor (10).

[0032] The nameplate data input unit (30) can receive nameplate data (D100) of an existing induction motor (10). The nameplate data (D100) may include at least one of the rated capacity (D110), rated efficiency (D120), rated RPM (D130), and rated power factor (D140) of the existing induction motor (10). The nameplate data (D100) may be entered directly by a user, or it may be entered from facility management data, inspection records, equipment ledgers, captured images of motor nameplates, specifications, motor databases, OCR recognition results, QR code recognition results, or existing databases.

[0033] The measurement data input unit (40) can receive measurement data (D150) of the existing induction motor (10). The measurement data (D150) may include at least one of actual active power (D160), actual RPM (D170), and actual power factor (D180). The actual active power (D160) may refer to the active power that the existing induction motor (10) is actually consuming in the field.

[0034] The actual RPM (D170) may refer to the actual rotational speed of the existing induction motor (10) or pump (12). The actual power factor (D180) may refer to the actual operating power factor of the existing induction motor (10). The measurement data (D150) may include at least one of voltage, current, frequency, apparent power, reactive power, operating time, flow rate, pressure, valve opening, discharge pressure, suction pressure, or operating status data, depending on the embodiment.

[0035] The measurement data input unit (40) may receive corrected measurement data (D190). The corrected measurement data (D190) may be any one of the measurement channel, phase, polarity, connection status, instrument settings, time synchronization, outliers, data quality status, or measurement data corrected by a data preprocessing process.

[0036] When correction measurement data (D190) is input, the data processing unit (50) can calculate or update the actual active power (D160), actual RPM (D170), or actual power factor (D180) using the correction measurement data (D190). However, the correction measurement data (D190) is input data that can be used optionally and is not limited to a specific measurement correction method.

[0037] The data processing unit (50) can calculate at least one of the current load rate (D210), normal estimated RPM (D220), normal estimated power factor (D230), applied RPM (D240), applied power factor (D250), estimated actual efficiency (D300), and pump shaft power (D310) of the existing induction motor (10) using nameplate data (D100) and measurement data (D150).

[0038] The data processing unit (50) can estimate the current efficiency level at which the existing induction motor (10) is driving the pump (12) by reflecting the difference between the rated conditions and the actual operating conditions of the existing induction motor (10). At this time, the normal estimated RPM (D220) and the normal estimated power factor (D230) can be used as normal reference values ​​corresponding to the current load rate (D210), and the difference between the actual measured value and the normal reference value can be reflected as a correction factor for calculating the estimated actual efficiency (D300).

[0039] The scenario calculation unit (60) can calculate the expected power consumption for each application scenario of the motor to be replaced based on the pump shaft power (D310) calculated by the data processing unit (50). The scenario calculation unit (60) can perform at least one of a simple direct connection calculation step (S300), a speed control calculation step (S310), and an impeller trimming calculation step (S320). The scenario calculation unit (60) can calculate at least one of a simple direct connection expected power consumption (D430), a speed control expected power consumption (D440), an impeller trimming expected power consumption (D450), and an expected reduction rate for each scenario (D460).

[0040] The output unit (70) can output the calculation results of the scenario calculation unit (60). The output unit (70) can output at least one of the following: simple direct connection estimated power consumption (D430), speed control estimated power consumption (D440), impeller trimming estimated power consumption (D450), estimated savings rate by scenario (D460), recommended operating conditions (D550), and recommended construction method (D560). The output unit (70) can provide the calculation results to a screen, report, data file, management server, equipment diagnostic system, or energy management system.

[0041] The recommendation output unit (72) can output recommended operating conditions (D550) or recommended construction methods (D560) based on the judgment result of the comparison judgment unit (150). The recommended operating conditions (D550) may include at least one of the target RPM of the motor to be replaced, the target operating point, the speed control range, the pump operating point, the operating limit conditions, the measurement verification conditions, or the post-verification conditions. The recommended construction methods (D560) may include simple direct connection, application of a speed control device, impeller trimming, a combination of speed control and impeller trimming, or a site-customized construction method.

[0042] The information input unit (80) can receive information on the replacement target (D350). The information on the replacement target (D350) may include at least one of the rated capacity, rated efficiency, synchronous speed (D360), operable speed range, control method, efficiency curve, cost, installation conditions, or field application limitations of the motor to be replaced. The information on the replacement target (D350) can be used by the scenario calculation unit (60) to calculate the expected power consumption after replacement.

[0043] FIG. 6 illustrates an example in which an information input unit (80), a nameplate data input unit (30), a measurement data input unit (40), and an output unit (70) are implemented in the form of a user screen. Referring to FIG. 6, the user input screen may include at least one of a motor nameplate data area, a field measurement data area, and a solution and construction environment setting area.

[0044] The motor nameplate data area can receive or display at least one of rated capacity (D110), rated efficiency (D120), rated RPM (D130), and rated power factor (D140), and the field measurement data area can receive or display at least one of actual active power (D160), actual power factor (D180), and actual RPM (D170).

[0045] The solution and construction environment setting area may receive or display at least one of the target efficiency, impeller outer diameter, similarity index, or construction conditions of the motor to be replaced as replacement target information (D350).

[0046] The output unit (70) can display on the screen an execution command to output a diagnostic report or construction specifications based on the above input value.

[0047] The service name, URL, item name, example numerical value, and screen layout shown in FIG. 6 may be actual implementation examples or explanatory examples. However, the input method of the present invention is not limited to the screen configuration of FIG. 6, and the information input unit (80) may receive operation-related data or replacement target information (D350) through file upload, sensor linkage, facility management system, energy management system, management server, external database, or other user interface.

[0048] The comparison judgment unit (150) can determine the recommended scenario by comparing the calculated values ​​(D470) for each scenario and considering load variability (D500), load pattern (D510), cost (D520), payback period (D530), and operational stability (D540). The comparison judgment unit (150) can recommend not only the scenario with the highest energy saving rate but also a scenario that satisfies actual field applicability, economic feasibility, and operational stability.

[0049] FIG. 7 illustrates an example in which a recommendation output unit (72) outputs a calculated value and recommendation information to a diagnosis result screen. Referring to FIG. 7, the diagnosis result screen may display at least one of a current load rate (D210), a normal estimated power factor (D230), and a normal estimated RPM (D220) as a result of establishing a normal baseline, and may display at least one of a load rate correction value (D320), a field correction value (D390), and an RPM deviation correction value (D330) as a result of correction or penalty calculation.

[0050] In addition, the diagnostic result screen may display at least one of the estimated actual efficiency (D300), pump shaft power (D310), calculated value by scenario (D470), estimated power consumption for simple direct connection (D430), estimated power consumption for speed control (D440), estimated savings rate by scenario (D460), recommended operating conditions (D550), and recommended construction method (D560).

[0051] In FIG. 7, the recommended driving condition (D550) may include at least one of the target frequency, target RPM driving point, speed control range, or setting value per driving mode of the speed control device.

[0052] The recommended construction method (D560) may include at least one of the impeller trimming processing ratio, the impeller outer diameter after trimming, the trimming target operating point, or the commissioning verification condition.

[0053] The table, graph, item name, service name, URL, and numerical value of FIG. 7 may be an example according to specific facility conditions, and the recommendation output unit (72) may provide the same information through other screen configurations, reports, data files, management servers, facility diagnostic systems, or energy management systems.

[0054] At least one of the data processing unit (50), scenario calculation unit (60), output unit (70), and information input unit (80) may be implemented as a separate device or as a functional block within a single computing device or server. Additionally, each component may be implemented as part of a field terminal, a cloud server, a facility management system, an energy diagnostic device, or a motor replacement design device.

[0055] The data processing unit (50) calculates the actual operating state of the existing induction motor (10), and the scenario calculation unit (60) calculates the operating state after replacement based on the calculated actual operating state. By distinguishing between the calculation of the existing operating state and the calculation of the replacement scenario in this way, the actual operating characteristics of the field equipment can be reflected more accurately than a method that simply calculates the savings rate based only on the efficiency information of the motor to be replaced.

[0056] Figure 2 shows the flow of calculating the operating state of a conventional induction motor according to the present invention.

[0057] In FIG. 2, the data processing unit (50) can first calculate the rated input power (D200) using the nameplate data (D100). The nameplate data (D100) may include at least one of the rated capacity (D110), rated efficiency (D120), rated RPM (D130), and rated power factor (D140).

[0058] The rated capacity (D110) may be the rated output or rated load capacity of the existing induction motor (10). The rated efficiency (D120) may be the efficiency with which the existing induction motor (10) converts input power into output power under rated conditions.

[0059] In the rated input power calculation step (S100), the data processing unit (50) can calculate the rated input power (D200) using the rated capacity (D110) and the rated efficiency (D120). The rated input power (D200) can correspond to the input power required when the existing induction motor (10) is operated at the rated output.

[0060] For example, the rated input power (D200) can be calculated by dividing the rated capacity (D110) by the rated efficiency (D120). If the rated capacity (D110) is provided in horsepower, kilowatts, or other units, the data processing unit (50) can calculate the rated input power (D200) after performing the necessary unit conversion. Depending on whether the rated capacity (D110) is based on output or input, whether a service factor is reflected, or whether the unit system of the nameplate data (D100) is different, the data processing unit (50) can apply a correction factor.

[0061] The rated input power (D200) can be used as a reference power comparable to the actual active power (D160). If the actual active power (D160) is directly compared with the rated capacity (D110) without reflecting the rated efficiency (D120), the current load rate (D210) may be distorted due to the mixing of the nameplate output reference value and the electrical input reference value. The present invention can establish a reference value comparable to the actual active power (D160) by calculating the rated input power (D200) using both the rated capacity (D110) and the rated efficiency (D120).

[0062] In the current load rate calculation step (S110), the data processing unit (50) can calculate the current load rate (D210) using the rated input power (D200) and the actual active power (D160). The current load rate (D210) can indicate how much load the existing induction motor (10) is operating under compared to the rated conditions. For example, the current load rate (D210) can be calculated by comparing the actual active power (D160) with the rated input power (D200).

[0063] The current load rate (D210) can be used as a reference value to calculate the normal estimated RPM (D220), normal estimated power factor (D230), estimated actual efficiency (D300), and pump shaft power (D310) thereafter. This is because the efficiency, rotational speed, and power factor of the existing induction motor (10) may vary depending on the load rate.

[0064] The current load rate (D210) can be calculated by time of day, by operating mode, or by load pattern using measured values ​​over a certain period. For example, the data processing unit (50) can calculate multiple current load rates (D210) by distinguishing between daytime operation, nighttime operation, maximum demand operation, low load operation, seasonal operation, or process-specific operation sections. In this case, the scenario calculation unit (60) calculates the expected power consumption and expected savings rate for each operating section, and the comparison judgment unit (150) can generate a final recommendation result by reflecting the weights for each section.

[0065] In the normal estimated RPM calculation step (S120), the data processing unit (50) can calculate the normal estimated RPM (D220) using the rated RPM (D130) and the current load rate (D210). The normal estimated RPM (D220) may be the expected rotational speed assuming that the existing induction motor (10) operates normally at the current load rate (D210).

[0066] As the load increases, the slip of the induction motor may increase and the rotational speed may decrease, and when the load decreases, it may operate at a rotational speed higher than the rated load condition. Therefore, it is difficult to represent the current rotational speed of the existing induction motor (10) solely by the rated RPM (D130). The data processing unit (50) can calculate the normal estimated RPM (D220) by reflecting the rotational speed change characteristics according to the current load rate (D210).

[0067] The data processing unit (50) can calculate the difference between the synchronous speed and the rated RPM (D130) as the rated slip component, and calculate the normal estimated RPM (D220) by correcting the rated slip component according to the current load rate (D210). For example, as the current load rate (D210) decreases, the slip component decreases, so the normal estimated RPM (D220) can approach the synchronous speed, and as the current load rate (D210) approaches the rated load, the normal estimated RPM (D220) can approach the rated RPM (D130). This calculation method is merely one example, and the normal estimated RPM (D220) can be calculated based on the number of poles, frequency, rated slip, manufacturer-specific characteristics, load characteristics, measurement history, or lookup table of the induction motor (10).

[0068] Calculating the normal estimated RPM (D220) may be important for calculating the rotational speed increase rate (D380) during simple direct operation of the motor to be replaced. Even if the rated RPM (D130) of the existing induction motor (10) is indicated as a specific value, if the current load rate (D210) is low, the actual normal operating RPM may be closer to the synchronous speed than the rated RPM (D130). In this case, it may be desirable to calculate the rotational speed increase rate (D380) based on the normal estimated RPM (D220) or the applicable RPM (D240) that reflects the current load rate (D210), rather than the rated RPM (D130).

[0069] In the actual RPM determination step (S130), the data processing unit (50) can determine whether the actual RPM (D170) exists. If the actual RPM (D170) is included in the measurement data (D150), the data processing unit (50) can use the actual RPM (D170) as the applied RPM (D240). If the actual RPM (D170) does not exist, the data processing unit (50) can use the normal estimated RPM (D220) as the applied RPM (D240).

[0070] In this way, the data processing unit (50) can reflect the field measurement value when the actual RPM (D170) is available, and when the actual RPM (D170) is not available, it can use the normal estimated RPM (D220) based on the current load rate (D210) as the applied RPM (D240). Accordingly, the operating state of the existing induction motor (10) can be calculated even in a site where a rotational speed sensor is not installed, and the accuracy of the calculation can be improved by using the measurement value in a site where a rotational speed sensor is installed.

[0071] In the actual RPM determination step (S130), the data processing unit (50) can determine not only whether the actual RPM (D170) exists but also whether the actual RPM (D170) is reliable. For example, if the actual RPM (D170) is input as 0, a missing value, an error value, or a value outside a predetermined possible range, the data processing unit (50) may not use the actual RPM (D170) as the applied RPM (D240) but may use the normal estimated RPM (D220) as the applied RPM (D240).

[0072] In addition, if the actual RPM (D170) is lower than the normal estimated RPM (D220) by more than a certain range, the data processing unit (50) can calculate an RPM deviation correction value (D330) by considering the possibility of increased slip, increased rotor loss, overload, increased mechanical friction, abnormality of the shaft connection part (14), or abnormality of the pump load.

[0073] However, the data processing unit (50) does not conclude that the cause of the rotational speed deviation is a single cause of failure, and can reflect the influence that the deviation may have on the efficiency estimation of the existing induction motor (10) as a correction factor.

[0074] In the normal estimated power factor calculation step (S140), the data processing unit (50) can calculate the normal estimated power factor (D230) using the rated power factor (D140) and the current load rate (D210). The normal estimated power factor (D230) may be the power factor expected when assuming that the existing induction motor (10) operates normally at the current load rate (D210).

[0075] The power factor of an induction motor may vary depending on the load rate. At a low load rate, the power factor may decrease due to the influence of the excitation current, and at a load above a certain level, it may operate at a level close to the rated power factor (D140). Therefore, the data processing unit (50) can calculate the normal estimated power factor (D230) using the rated power factor (D140) and the current load rate (D210).

[0076] The normal estimated power factor (D230) can be calculated by reflecting a value corresponding to the degree of reduction of the current load factor (D210) from the rated power factor (D140). In another embodiment, the normal estimated power factor (D230) can be calculated based on the load factor-power factor characteristic curve of the induction motor (10), manufacturer data, field measurement history, lookup table, regression model, or empirical correction formula.

[0077] If the rated power factor (D140) does not exist, the data processing unit (50) can estimate the normal estimated power factor (D230) using the motor capacity, number of poles, voltage rating, efficiency rating, or average value of the same equipment group.

[0078] In the actual power factor determination step (S150), the data processing unit (50) can determine whether an actual power factor (D180) exists. If the actual power factor (D180) is included in the measurement data (D150), the data processing unit (50) can use the actual power factor (D180) as the applied power factor (D250).

[0079] If the actual power factor (D180) does not exist, the data processing unit (50) can use the normal estimated power factor (D230) as the applied power factor (D250).

[0080] In this way, the data processing unit (50) reflects the measured value when there is an actual power factor (D180), and when there is no actual power factor (D180), it can use the normal estimated power factor (D230) based on the current load factor (D210) as the applied power factor (D250). Accordingly, even when the power measuring device does not directly provide the power factor, the operating state of the existing induction motor (10) can be estimated.

[0081] In the actual power factor determination step (S150), the data processing unit (50) can determine not only whether the actual power factor (D180) exists but also whether the actual power factor (D180) is reliable.

[0082] For example, if the actual power factor (D180) is entered as 0, a missing value, an error value, or a value outside the possible operating range, the data processing unit (50) may exclude the actual power factor (D180) and use the normal estimated power factor (D230) as the applied power factor (D250).

[0083] Additionally, if the actual power factor (D180) is lower than the normal estimated power factor (D230), the data processing unit (50) can calculate a power factor deviation correction value (D340) by considering the possibility of increased reactive current, increased winding loss, power quality issues, motor degradation, or other increased electrical losses.

[0084] However, the data processing unit (50) does not conclude that the cause of the power factor deviation is a single cause of failure, and can reflect the influence that the deviation may have on the efficiency estimation of the existing induction motor (10) as a correction factor.

[0085] The subsequent calculation input value (D260) may include at least one of the current load rate (D210), rated efficiency (D120), actual active power (D160), applied RPM (D240), normal estimated RPM (D220), applied power factor (D250), and normal estimated power factor (D230). The subsequent calculation input value (D260) may be provided for the calculation of the estimated actual efficiency and the calculation of the pump shaft power.

[0086] Generating the subsequent output input value (D260) as a separate data bundle is intended to distinguish the step of calculating the reference value and determining the application value from the step of efficiency correction and shaft power calculation.

[0087] Accordingly, the data processing unit (50) can organize the absence of a measured value, the quality of the measured value, the result of calculating the current load rate (D210), and the result of calculating the normal estimated value, and then transmit it to a subsequent step of calculating the estimated actual efficiency (D300). The subsequent input values ​​(D260) may be generated in multiple ways by time period, by operating mode, by load section, or by equipment.

[0088] The flow of FIG. 2 of the present invention may vary the calculation path depending on whether the actual RPM (D170) and the actual power factor (D180) exist. When both the actual RPM (D170) and the actual power factor (D180) exist, the data processing unit (50) may use the measured values ​​as the applied RPM (D240) and the applied power factor (D250).

[0089] If only the actual RPM (D170) exists, the actual RPM (D170) can be used as the applied RPM (D240) and the normal estimated power factor (D230) can be used as the applied power factor (D250).

[0090] If only the actual power factor (D180) exists, the normal estimated RPM (D220) can be used as the applied RPM (D240) and the actual power factor (D180) can be used as the applied power factor (D250).

[0091] If neither the actual RPM (D170) nor the actual power factor (D180) exists, the normal estimated RPM (D220) and the normal estimated power factor (D230) can be used as the applied RPM (D240) and the applied power factor (D250), respectively.

[0092] According to this configuration, the operation of the embodiment of the present invention is not limited to the completeness of the field measurement data (D150).

[0093] That is, even if some measured values ​​of the actual RPM or actual power factor are missing, the data processing unit (50) can continue to calculate the operating state of the existing induction motor (10) by using the normal estimated RPM (D220) or normal estimated power factor (D230), calculated based on the nameplate data (D100), actual active power (D160), and current load rate (D210), as a substitute value. In addition, if the actual RPM (D170) or actual power factor (D180) is additionally measured, the accuracy of the calculation can be increased by using the corresponding measured value as the applied RPM (D240) or applied power factor (D250).

[0094] Even if rotational speed sensors and power factor measuring devices are not necessarily installed at every site, the operating status of the existing induction motor (10) can be calculated using nameplate data (D100), actual active power (D160), and load rate-based estimates. Additionally, the accuracy of the calculation can be increased as more measurement values ​​are added.

[0095] The normal estimated RPM (D220) and normal estimated power factor (D230) are not used only as values ​​to replace the actual RPM (D170) and actual power factor (D180). The normal estimated RPM (D220) and normal estimated power factor (D230) can also be used as comparison criteria to determine whether the current operating state of the existing induction motor (10) deviates from the normal load rate characteristics.

[0096] If the applied RPM (D240) differs from the normal estimated RPM (D220), the data processing unit (50) may determine that the rotational speed deviation may affect the actual efficiency of the existing induction motor (10) or the operating point of the pump (12). If the applied power factor (D250) differs from the normal estimated power factor (D230), the data processing unit (50) may determine that the power factor deviation should be reflected in the estimation of the actual efficiency of the existing induction motor (10).

[0097] Figure 3 shows the flow of the estimated actual efficiency and pump shaft power calculation of the present invention.

[0098] Referring to FIG. 3, the data processing unit (50) can calculate at least one of a load rate correction value (D320), an RPM deviation correction value (D330), a power factor deviation correction value (D340), an estimated actual efficiency (D300), and a pump shaft power (D310) using a subsequent calculation input value (D260).

[0099] In the load rate correction step (S200), the data processing unit (50) can calculate a load rate correction value (D320) using the current load rate (D210). The load rate correction value (D320) may be a value for correcting the difference that may occur between the rated efficiency (D120) and the actual efficiency when the existing induction motor (10) is operated at a load rate other than the rated load.

[0100] The efficiency of the electric motor generally varies depending on the load rate. The efficiency appears high near the rated load, and the efficiency may be relatively low at an excessively low load rate. Therefore, if the current load rate (D210) is low or high, the data processing unit (50) does not use the rated efficiency (D120) as the actual efficiency, but calculates a load rate correction value (D320) based on the current load rate (D210) and reflects it in the estimated actual efficiency (D300).

[0101] The load rate correction value (D320) may be a correction value that increases as the current load rate (D210) becomes lower than the rated load. In another embodiment, the load rate correction value (D320) may be calculated based on motor capacity, efficiency rating, number of poles, load characteristics, manufacturer's efficiency curve, field measurement history, or lookup table.

[0102] For example, in partial load operation, an increase in the relative proportion of fixed losses, the influence of magnetization current, a decrease in power factor, or an increase in other losses may occur, so the data processing unit (50) can reflect these factors in the load rate correction value (D320).

[0103] In the RPM deviation correction step (S210), the data processing unit (50) can calculate an RPM deviation correction value (D330) using the applied RPM (D240) and the normal estimated RPM (D220). The RPM deviation correction value (D330) may be a value for reflecting the effect that the difference has on the actual efficiency estimation when the actual or applied rotational speed of the existing induction motor (10) differs from the normal estimated RPM (D220) corresponding to the current load rate (D210).

[0104] If the applied RPM (D240) appears lower or higher than the normal estimated RPM (D220), this may mean that the load condition, slip, measurement condition, operating condition, or equipment condition may differ from the usual expectation. The data processing unit (50) calculates this rotational speed deviation as an RPM deviation correction value (D330) and can reflect it when calculating the estimated actual efficiency (D300).

[0105] The RPM deviation correction value (D330) can be calculated by converting the difference between the normal estimated RPM (D220) and the applied RPM (D240) into a ratio to the synchronous speed, the normal estimated RPM (D220), or the applied RPM (D240). In another embodiment, the RPM deviation correction value (D330) can be calculated based on the magnitude of the RPM deviation, the duration of the RPM deviation, the current load rate (D210), vibration data, current data, or field correction coefficient, etc. If the applied RPM (D240) is equal to the normal estimated RPM (D220) or is within the normal range, the data processing unit (50) can set the RPM deviation correction value (D330) to 0 or a predetermined minimum value.

[0106] In the power factor deviation correction step (S220), the data processing unit (50) can calculate a power factor deviation correction value (D340) using the applied power factor (D250) and the normal estimated power factor (D230). The power factor deviation correction value (D340) may be a value intended to reflect the effect of the difference on the actual efficiency estimation when the actual or applied power factor of the existing induction motor (10) differs from the normal estimated power factor (D230) corresponding to the current load rate (D210).

[0107] If the applied power factor (D250) appears lower than the normal estimated power factor (D230), the existing induction motor (10) may be affected by a low load rate, abnormal operating conditions, power quality issues, or changes in load characteristics. The data processing unit (50) calculates this power factor deviation as a power factor deviation correction value (D340) and can reflect it when calculating the estimated actual efficiency (D300).

[0108] The power factor deviation correction value (D340) can be calculated based on the ratio or difference between the normal estimated power factor (D230) and the applied power factor (D250). For example, as the applied power factor (D250) decreases, a larger current may flow to obtain the same effective power, and losses may increase due to the increase in current; therefore, the data processing unit (50) may reflect the magnitude of the power factor deviation as a factor reducing efficiency. If the applied power factor (D250) is equal to the normal estimated power factor (D230) or is within the normal range, the data processing unit (50) may set the power factor deviation correction value (D340) to 0 or a predetermined minimum value.

[0109] In the actual efficiency calculation step (S230), the data processing unit (50) can calculate the estimated actual efficiency (D300) using the rated efficiency (D120), the load rate correction value (D320), the RPM deviation correction value (D330), and the power factor deviation correction value (D340). The estimated actual efficiency (D300) may be an estimated value of the efficiency with which the existing induction motor (10) converts input power into output power under current operating conditions.

[0110] The estimated actual efficiency (D300) can be calculated by applying a load rate correction value (D320), an RPM deviation correction value (D330), and a power factor deviation correction value (D340) to the rated efficiency (D120). The data processing unit (50) can reflect the efficiency degradation or efficiency change according to the current load rate (D210) as the load rate correction value (D320), reflect the difference between the applied RPM (D240) and the normal estimated RPM (D220) as the RPM deviation correction value (D330), and reflect the difference between the applied power factor (D250) and the normal estimated power factor (D230) as the power factor deviation correction value (D340).

[0111] Accordingly, the data processing unit (50) can reflect the influence of field operating conditions, which are not apparent in the rated efficiency (D120) alone, in the estimated actual efficiency (D300).

[0112] The load rate correction value (D320), RPM deviation correction value (D330), and power factor deviation correction value (D340) can each be implemented as an additive correction value, a subtractive correction value, a multiplication correction coefficient, an efficiency curve-based correction value, a lookup table-based correction value, or a regression equation-based correction value.

[0113] In addition, each correction value may be set differently depending on the motor's capacity, number of poles, rated rotational speed, efficiency class, years of service, operating time, load type, or field diagnostic data.

[0114] The method for calculating the estimated actual efficiency (D300) is not limited to a specific formula. The data processing unit (50) may use various calculation models to estimate the actual efficiency of the existing induction motor (10) by utilizing the relationship between the current load rate (D210), the applied RPM (D240), the normal estimated RPM (D220), the applied power factor (D250), the normal estimated power factor (D230), and the rated efficiency (D120). For example, the data processing unit (50) may use an efficiency curve by load rate, manufacturer characteristic data, a model based on field measurement data, or an empirical formula-based model.

[0115] The data processing unit (50) may apply an upper or lower limit so that the estimated actual efficiency (D300) does not exceed a technically feasible range. Additionally, the data processing unit (50) may reflect each correction value using an addition method, a subtraction method, a multiplication method, a weighted sum method, or a function method for each interval. Accordingly, the estimated actual efficiency (D300) can be flexibly calculated according to field conditions without fixing specific field coefficients or internal experience values.

[0116] In the pump shaft power calculation step (S240), the data processing unit (50) can calculate the pump shaft power (D310) using the actual active power (D160) and the estimated actual efficiency (D300). The pump shaft power (D310) can correspond to the shaft power that the existing induction motor (10) is delivering to the pump (12) under current operating conditions. That is, the pump shaft power (D310) may be a value converted from the input power of the existing induction motor (10) into the output power that actually drives the pump (12).

[0117] The data processing unit (50) can calculate the pump shaft power (D310) by applying the estimated actual efficiency (D300) to the actual active power (D160). Since the actual active power (D160) is the power consumed by the existing induction motor (10) from the power source and the estimated actual efficiency (D300) is the ratio at which the input power is converted into output power, the current shaft power delivered to the pump (12) can be calculated by using these.

[0118] The actual active power (D160) is the electrical input value from the perspective of a meter or power meter, and not all of it is used for the fluid transfer operation of the pump (12). Some of the power may be consumed as stator losses, rotor losses, iron losses, mechanical losses, or other losses of the existing induction motor (10).

[0119] Therefore, to determine whether the same amount of work is performed after applying the motor to be replaced, it is desirable to set the pump shaft power (D310) as the reference value rather than the actual active power (D160) itself.

[0120] The load factor correction value (D320), RPM deviation correction value (D330), or power factor deviation correction value (D340) can be used as inputs to calculate the estimated actual efficiency (D300). The values ​​directly connected to the pump shaft power (D310) may be the actual active power (D160) and the estimated actual efficiency (D300). By separating the efficiency correction step and the shaft power reference value calculation step in this way, the efficiency estimation of the existing motor and the standardization of the pump's (12) workload can be clearly separated.

[0121] The pump shaft power (D310) can be used as a reference load for calculating the replacement effect. This is intended to use the level of power currently provided by the existing induction motor (10) to the pump (12) as a reference when calculating the expected power consumption of the motor to be replaced. If identical or corresponding pump operating conditions are not used as a reference when comparing before and after replacement, the savings effect due to improved motor efficiency and the power change due to the change in the pump operating point may be mixed.

[0122] Accordingly, the present invention does not simply use the actual effective power (D160) as the existing power consumption, but converts it into pump shaft power (D310) through the estimated actual efficiency (D300), and then uses the pump shaft power (D310) as a reference value for calculating the replacement scenario. Accordingly, the replacement effect can be calculated by distinguishing between the electrical input state of the existing induction motor (10) and the mechanical load state of the pump (12).

[0123] When the pump shaft power (D310) is used as a reference value, regardless of whether the motor to be replaced has higher efficiency than the existing induction motor (10), it can be distinguished whether the pump (12) is actually performing the same amount of work or whether it is forming a larger flow rate or head condition by increasing the rotational speed. The present invention can reduce the mixing of the effect of improving motor efficiency and the change in power due to the change in the pump operating point.

[0124] Figure 4 shows the replacement scenario calculation flow according to one embodiment of the present invention.

[0125] According to FIG. 4, the scenario calculation unit (60) can perform at least one of a simple direct connection calculation step (S300), a speed control calculation step (S310), and an impeller trimming calculation step (S320) based on the pump shaft power (D310).

[0126] The pump shaft power (D310) can be indicated together with the shaft connection (14). The pump shaft power (D310) may be a reference value corresponding to the shaft power path transmitted from the existing induction motor (10) to the pump (12).

[0127] The scenario calculation unit (60) can use the efficiency, synchronous speed (D360), rated capacity, number of poles, frequency, allowable load range, allowable speed range, controllability, or speed control device applicability of the motor to be replaced included in the replacement target information (D350).

[0128] Even if the motor to be replaced is an IE5 synchronous motor, the scenario calculation unit (60) can reflect the change in rotational speed after replacement and the change in required power of the pump (12) together, without considering only the improvement in efficiency of the IE5 synchronous motor.

[0129] The simple direct connection calculation step (S300) may be a step for calculating the expected power consumption when the motor to be replaced is connected to the pump (12) without separate speed adjustment. In the simple direct connection calculation step (S300), the scenario calculation unit (60) may calculate the expected power consumption (D430) for simple direct connection using at least one of the synchronous speed (D360) of the motor to be replaced, the applied RPM (D370), the rotational speed increase rate (D380), the field correction value (D390), and the operating point deviation correction value (D395).

[0130] The synchronous speed (D360) may be the rotational speed when the motor to be replaced is operated under specified power frequency and pole number conditions (number of poles condition). If the motor to be replaced is an IE5 synchronous motor, the synchronous speed (D360) may be the synchronous rotational speed of the corresponding IE5 synchronous motor. The synchronous speed (D360) is not limited to a specific value and may vary depending on the specifications, frequency, number of poles, or control method of the motor to be replaced.

[0131] The applied RPM (D370) may be a reference rotational speed used to calculate the rotational speed increase rate (D380) in the simple direct connection calculation step (S300). The applied RPM (D370) may be the same as the applied RPM (D240) of FIG. 2, or may be a rotational speed provided to the simple direct connection calculation step (S300) in correspondence with the existing operating state calculated in FIG. 2.

[0132] The applicable RPM (D370) is not limited to a specific point in time or specific equipment in terms of its designation, and in the text, it may be described as the applicable RPM corresponding to the operating state before replacement in accordance with the context of the simple direct connection calculation step (S300).

[0133] The rotational speed increase rate (D380) can be calculated based on the difference or ratio between the synchronous speed (D360) and the applied RPM (D370). If the synchronous speed (D360) of the motor to be replaced is higher than the applied RPM (D370) of the existing operating state, the rotational speed of the pump (12) may increase, and accordingly, the power required by the pump (12) may also increase.

[0134] The scenario calculation unit (60) can calculate the change in power required for the pump (12) during simple direct operation using the rotational speed increase rate (D380) and the field correction value (D390). The field correction value (D390) may be a correction value that reflects at least one of the pump similarity law, pump characteristic curve, pipe loss, static head, operating point, fluid characteristics, or equipment aging condition. The field correction value (D390) may be implemented as a specific index or coefficient and may be set based on a lookup table, field measurement data, equipment specification data, or an empirical formula.

[0135] When the pump (12) is a centrifugal pump, the flow rate, head, power, etc. may change depending on the change in rotational speed. For example, the flow rate is generally proportional to the rotational speed, the head is generally proportional to the square of the rotational speed, and the power may change depending on the cube of the rotational speed or the field correction index.

[0136] The scenario calculation unit (60) can calculate the required shaft power of the pump during simple direct operation by applying an index value based on the ratio of the synchronous speed (D360) and the applied RPM (D370) to the current pump shaft power (D310). The index value is not limited to a specific value and can be set according to pump characteristics, piping conditions, static head, field measurement history, or conservative prediction criteria.

[0137] The operating point deviation correction value (D395) may be a correction value to reflect the degree to which the operating point of the pump (12) deviates from the existing operating point or the target operating point due to the simple direct operation of the motor to be replaced. For example, if the pump (12) deviates from the vicinity of the maximum efficiency point, or if the flow rate or head conditions differ from the existing operating conditions, the scenario calculation unit (60) can correct the expected power consumption (D430) for simple direct operation using the operating point deviation correction value (D395).

[0138] The operating point deviation correction value (D395) may reflect at least one of the following factors: increased flow rate, increased head, increased valve loss, internal recirculation, risk of cavitation, overflow operation, increased bearing load, or reduced pump efficiency. The scenario calculation unit (60) may not calculate the expected power consumption based solely on the simple rotational speed ratio, but may also consider the possibility of additional loss or reduced stability due to changes in the actual pump operating point.

[0139] In the efficiency application step (S314), the scenario calculation unit (60) may apply the efficiency of the motor to be replaced. If the motor to be replaced is an IE5 synchronous motor, the efficiency application step (S314) may be a step of applying the efficiency of the IE5 synchronous motor. However, the efficiency application step (S314) is not limited to a specific efficiency class and may be implemented as a step of applying the rated efficiency, partial load efficiency, efficiency by speed, or efficiency by operating point of the motor to be replaced.

[0140] The estimated power consumption (D430) for simple direct connection can be calculated using the power required for the pump (12) in simple direct connection operation and the efficiency of the motor to be replaced. The estimated power consumption (D430) for simple direct connection can be compared with the actual active power (D160) of the existing induction motor (10) to calculate the estimated reduction rate for simple direct connection operation.

[0141] For example, the scenario calculation unit (60) can calculate the expected power consumption (D430) for simple direct connection by dividing the shaft power required for the pump during simple direct connection operation by the efficiency of the motor to be replaced. In this case, the efficiency of the motor to be replaced may be a value that reflects not only the rated efficiency but also the efficiency by load rate, efficiency by operating point, or the manufacturer's efficiency curve.

[0142] The simple direct connection calculation step (S300) can reflect both the effect of improving the efficiency of the motor to be replaced and the effect of increasing the pump's power requirement due to the increase in rotational speed. This point may be one of the important features of the present invention. Even if the efficiency of the motor to be replaced is higher than that of the existing induction motor (10), if the rotational speed of the pump (12) increases due to simple direct connection operation, the pump (12) may perform more work. In this case, some or all of the effect of improving the motor efficiency may be offset by the increase in the pump's power requirement. The present invention can calculate the possibility of such offset before replacement and can provide information for determining whether simple direct connection operation is suitable compared to speed control or impeller trimming.

[0143] The speed control calculation step (S310) may be a step for calculating the expected power consumption when controlling the rotational speed of the motor to be replaced to match the target operating conditions. The speed control calculation step (S310) may include at least one of a target RPM operating point (D400), a target speed control step (S312), and an efficiency application step (S314).

[0144] The target RPM operating point (D400) may be a rotational speed or operating point set so that the pump (12) satisfies the target flow rate, target head, work volume corresponding to the existing operating state, or energy saving target. The target RPM operating point (D400) may be determined based on the applicable RPM (D240), pump shaft power (D310), field operating conditions, load pattern (D510), or user setting values, etc.

[0145] In the target speed control step (S312), the scenario calculation unit (60) can calculate the pump power required when the motor to be replaced is operated at the target RPM operating point (D400). The target speed control step (S312) can be implemented using an inverter, a variable speed drive device, a motor controller, or an equipment control system. However, the present invention is not limited to the structure of a specific speed control device.

[0146] In the target speed control step (S312), the scenario calculation unit (60) can calculate the pump shaft power required for speed control by applying a similarity law or a field correction index based on the ratio of the target RPM operating point (D400) and the applied RPM (D370) to the current pump shaft power (D310).

[0147] In another embodiment, the scenario calculation unit (60) can calculate the pump required shaft power during speed control by reflecting the ratio of reduction from the pump required shaft power during simple direct connection to the target RPM operating point (D400).

[0148] The efficiency application step (S314) may also be performed in the speed control calculation step (S310). The scenario calculation unit (60) can calculate the speed control estimated power consumption (D440) by applying the efficiency of the motor to be replaced at the target RPM operating point (D400). The speed control estimated power consumption (D440) can be compared with the actual active power (D160) of the existing induction motor (10), the simple direct connection estimated power consumption (D430), or the estimated power consumption of other scenarios.

[0149] In the speed control calculation step (S310), in addition to the efficiency of the motor to be replaced, the efficiency of the speed control device, inverter losses, reactor losses, filter losses, control panel losses, or partial load efficiency curve may be additionally reflected. For example, the estimated power consumption for speed control (D440) can be calculated by dividing the shaft power required by the pump during speed control by the applied efficiency that reflects the efficiency of the motor to be replaced and the efficiency of the speed control device.

[0150] The speed control calculation step (S310) may have the following characteristics.

[0151] The speed control calculation step (S310) can compare the motor to be replaced by matching it to a rotational speed or workload condition corresponding to the existing operating state.

[0152] In addition, the speed control calculation step (S310) can achieve additional savings by adjusting the rotational speed to match the actual required operating point of the pump (12).

[0153] In this way, the speed control calculation step (S310) can compensate for the limitations of simple direct operation and optimize the efficiency improvement effect of the motor to be replaced together with the pump operation conditions.

[0154] The scenario calculation unit (60) can generate a plurality of target RPM operating points (D400) based on at least one of load variability (D500), load pattern (D510), flow rate demand per time period, pressure control target, process requirement condition or user input condition, and can calculate the expected power consumption and expected savings rate for each target RPM operating point (D400).

[0155] Speed ​​control scenarios can support both comparison based on equal workload and optimization of actual operation.

[0156] The impeller trimming calculation step (S320) may be a step for calculating the expected power consumption when trimming the impeller of the pump (12) or adjusting the pump operating point. The impeller trimming calculation step (S320) may include at least one of a trimming target operating point (D410), pump power required after trimming (D420), and an efficiency application step (S314).

[0157] The trimming target operating point (D410) may be a flow rate, head, rotational speed, or shaft power condition, etc., that the pump (12) is set to reach after impeller trimming. The trimming target operating point (D410) may be set based on an existing operating point, a target operating point, a load pattern (D510), a pump characteristic curve, or field operating conditions, etc.

[0158] The pump power required after trimming (D420) may be the power required by the pump (12) at the target operating point after impeller trimming. The scenario calculation unit (60) can calculate the pump power required after trimming (D420) using the pump shaft power (D310), the trimming target operating point (D410), the field correction value (D390), or the operating point deviation correction value (D395).

[0159] The pump power required after trimming (D420) can be calculated based on changes in impeller outer diameter, changes in impeller shape, pump characteristic curve, manufacturer's pump curve, similarity law, field correction value (D390), operating point deviation correction value (D395), or actual operating data.

[0160] For example, the scenario calculation unit (60) can calculate the pump required power (D420) after trimming by reflecting the ratio of the flow rate, head, or rotational speed equivalent value of the target operating point after trimming to the current pump shaft power (D310).

[0161] The scenario calculation unit (60) can calculate the expected power consumption (D450) for impeller trimming by applying the efficiency of the motor to be replaced to the pump power required after trimming (D420). The expected power consumption (D450) for impeller trimming can be compared with the actual effective power (D160) of the existing induction motor (10), the expected power consumption (D430) for simple direct connection, the expected power consumption (D440) for speed control, or the expected power consumption of other scenarios.

[0162] In the efficiency application step (S314) of the impeller trimming scenario, not only the efficiency of the motor to be replaced but also changes in pump efficiency after trimming, dynamic balancing status, deviation from the operating point, changes in internal pump losses, or a margin for performance degradation after construction may be additionally reflected. Accordingly, the estimated power consumption (D450) for impeller trimming may not be a value obtained by simply applying the motor efficiency, but may be an estimated value that reflects the field conditions after adjusting the pump operating point.

[0163] The impeller trimming calculation step (S320) may be useful under conditions of small load variability or constant operation. For example, when the pump (12) is operated for a long time under constant flow rate or head conditions, it may be more economical to adjust the pump operating point through impeller trimming rather than adding a speed control device.

[0164] On the other hand, when the load variability is large, the result of the speed control calculation step (S310) can be evaluated more favorably.

[0165] In the scenario-specific output value generation step (S330), the scenario calculation unit (60) can generate a scenario-specific output value (D470) including at least one of a simple direct connection estimated power consumption (D430), a speed control estimated power consumption (D440), an impeller trimming estimated power consumption (D450), and a scenario-specific estimated reduction rate (D460).

[0166] The expected reduction rate (D460) for each scenario can be calculated by comparing the actual effective power (D160) of the existing induction motor (10) with the expected power consumption of each scenario. The expected reduction rate (D460) for each scenario can be calculated for the simple direct connection scenario, the speed control scenario, and the impeller trimming scenario, respectively.

[0167] The expected savings rate (D460) for each scenario may be positive, zero, or negative. If the expected power consumption of a specific scenario is lower than the power consumption based on the existing operating standard, a positive savings rate may be calculated; if it is similar, a savings rate close to zero may be calculated; and if it is higher, a negative savings rate or a power consumption increase rate may be calculated. Embodiments of the present invention do not assume that the savings rate is necessarily positive even in simple direct connection scenarios, and can identify in advance conditions where actual savings are difficult by reflecting the increase in rotational speed and the increase in pump power requirements.

[0168] The scenario-specific calculation value (D470) may include not only the estimated power consumption but also at least one of the estimated power savings, estimated savings rate, estimated savings cost, operating conditions, construction conditions, applicability, or cautionary conditions. The scenario-specific calculation value (D470) may be provided to the comparison judgment unit (150).

[0169] Figure 5 shows the flow of multiple scenario comparison and recommendation output according to an embodiment of the present invention.

[0170] Referring to FIG. 5, the comparison judgment unit (150) can compare multiple scenarios using a scenario-specific calculated value (D470) and a judgment condition. The judgment condition may include at least one of load variability (D500), load pattern (D510), cost (D520), payback period (D530), and operational stability (D540).

[0171] In the comparison judgment step (S400), the comparison judgment unit (150) can compare at least one of the simple direct connection estimated power consumption (D430), speed control estimated power consumption (D440), impeller trimming estimated power consumption (D450), and the estimated reduction rate by scenario (D460). The comparison judgment unit (150) can determine the recommended target scenario by considering the site operating conditions and construction conditions together, rather than simply selecting only the lowest estimated power consumption.

[0172] Load variability (D500) may indicate how much the load of the pump (12) changes by time of day, season, process, or operating mode. The load pattern (D510) may include at least one of the operating time of the pump (12), flow rate variation, head variation, stop and start pattern, peak load, or average load.

[0173] Load variability (D500) can be calculated based on the fluctuation range of actual active power (D160), the fluctuation range of flow rate data, the fluctuation range of pressure data, the load rate distribution by operating time period, the load rate histogram, the standard deviation, the coefficient of variation, or the frequency of occurrence by load interval. The load pattern (D510) can be classified into a constant load type, a day-night variation type, a seasonal variation type, a batch process type, an intermittent operation type, a peak load type, or a multi-stage operation type. These load variability (D500) and load pattern (D510) can be used as criteria to determine which method, speed control or impeller trimming, is suitable for the site.

[0174] When the load variability (D500) is large, the comparison judgment unit (150) can favorably evaluate the speed control scenario according to the speed control calculation step (S310). This is because the speed control scenario can adjust the rotational speed according to the load change. Conversely, when the load variability (D500) is small and the device is operated for a long time at a constant operating point, the comparison judgment unit (150) can favorably evaluate the impeller trimming scenario according to the impeller trimming calculation step (S320).

[0175] Costs (D520) may include costs related to the motor to be replaced, speed control device, impeller trimming, installation work, control panel change, operation stoppage, or maintenance. The payback period (D530) may be calculated using the cost (D520) and the expected savings cost according to each scenario. Operational stability (D540) may include at least one of the possibility of maintaining the target operating point of the pump (12), the possibility of cavitation, the possibility of overload, control stability, equipment vibration, or operating safety conditions.

[0176] The cost (D520) may include at least one of the following: the cost of purchasing the motor to be replaced, the cost of installing the speed control device, the cost of manufacturing the control panel, the cost of installing the reactor or filter, the cost of wiring work, the cost of impeller trimming work, the cost of disassembling and assembling the pump, the cost of balancing, the cost of commissioning, the cost of maintenance, or ancillary costs.

[0177] The payback period (D530) can be calculated using the expected savings rate (D460) by scenario, facility operating time, power unit price, demand rate, seasonal power rate, or maintenance cost savings effect.

[0178] Operational stability (D540) may include motor overload risk, pump overflow risk, cavitation risk, minimum flow rate condition, pressure fluctuation, water hammer, bearing load, possibility of seal damage, power harmonics, electromagnetic noise, speed control stability, or limiting of the operating range after impeller trimming.

[0179] The comparison judgment unit (150) may exclude a scenario from recommendation or lower its priority if the cost (D520) is excessively high, the payback period (D530) is long, or the operational stability (D540) is low, even if the expected savings rate is high. Additionally, even if the expected savings rate is relatively low, it may recommend a scenario with low installation costs, a short payback period (D530), and high operational stability (D540).

[0180] The comparison judgment unit (150) assigns a weight to at least one of the expected reduction rate, cost (D520), payback period (D530), load variability (D500), load pattern (D510), and operational stability (D540), and can determine a recommended scenario based on the weighted sum score.

[0181] In other embodiments, the comparison judgment unit (150) can determine a recommendation scenario using a rule-based judgment, a threshold-based judgment, a lookup table, a regression equation, or an optimization algorithm.

[0182] In the recommendation output step (S410), the recommendation output unit (72) can output recommended operating conditions (D550) and recommended construction methods (D560) based on the result of the comparison judgment step (S400). The recommended operating conditions (D550) may include at least one of the operating rotational speed of the motor to be replaced, the target RPM operating point (D400), operating settings by load pattern, speed control conditions, or operating limit conditions.

[0183] The recommended construction method (D560) may include at least one of simple direct connection, application of a speed control device, impeller trimming, motor replacement specifications, pump operating point adjustment, or a combination thereof. Simple direct connection, speed control, and impeller trimming may be recommended candidates corresponding to each scenario and are not limited to new calculation steps that are independently calculated again in FIG. 5.

[0184] The recommended output unit (72) can output the expected power consumption, expected savings rate, cost, payback period, or reason for application for each scenario, along with the recommended operating conditions (D550) and recommended construction method (D560). Accordingly, the user can review not only whether to simply replace the motor to be replaced, but also additional operating conditions or construction methods such as speed control or impeller trimming.

[0185] The comparison judgment unit (150) can generate warning information for the simple direct connection scenario if the expected power consumption (D430) of the simple direct connection is higher than the actual effective power (D160) or if the expected reduction rate of the simple direct connection scenario is lower than a predetermined standard.

[0186] For example, if the synchronous speed (D360) is higher than the applied RPM (D370), the pump power required increases due to the rotational speed increase rate (D380), and the expected power consumption (D430) for simple direct connection is not sufficiently reduced as a result of reflecting the operating point deviation correction value (D395), the recommended output unit (72) may output information that the cost-saving effect of simple direct connection operation is low or that speed control or impeller trimming needs to be reviewed.

[0187] When the load variability (D500) is large, the comparison judgment unit (150) may prioritize recommending a speed control scenario. In sites with large load variability, the required flow rate may vary by time period or process, so it may be difficult to satisfy all operating conditions with only fixed impeller trimming.

[0188] Recommended operating conditions (D550) may include at least one of a target RPM operating point (D400), target frequency, control range, target pressure, target flow rate, minimum operating speed, maximum operating speed, or a set value for each operating mode. Recommended construction method (D560) may include whether to install a speed control device, a control panel, a sensor linkage, or an auxiliary device.

[0189] When load variability (D500) is small and the load pattern (D510) is constant, the comparison judgment unit (150) may prioritize recommending an impeller trimming scenario. In a site where the load is constant, the operating point of the pump (12) can be adjusted to the target operating point through impeller trimming without installing a speed control device, which may be advantageous in terms of cost (D520) and payback period (D530).

[0190] Recommended operating conditions (D550) may include a trimming target operating point (D410), target flow rate, target head, allowable operating range after trimming, commissioning verification conditions, or post-verification conditions. Recommended construction methods (D560) may include at least one of impeller disassembly, outer diameter machining, dynamic balancing, consumable replacement, pump reassembly, commissioning, or instrumentation verification.

[0191] The comparison judgment unit (150) can output a simple direct connection as a recommended construction method (D560) when the expected power consumption (D430) of the simple direct connection is sufficiently low, the rotational speed increase rate (D380) is small, the operating point deviation correction value (D395) is below a predetermined standard, and the simple direct connection is advantageous in terms of cost (D520) and payback period (D530).

[0192] On the other hand, the comparison judgment unit (150) does not always recommend simple direct connection, and can determine whether to recommend simple direct connection by considering at least one of the following together: expected power consumption for simple direct connection (D430), expected savings rate per scenario (D460), possibility of pump overload, operating point deviation correction value (D395), load variability (D500), and operating stability (D540).

[0193] The recommendation output unit (72) may not output recommendation results as only one scenario, but may output multiple scenarios along with priorities. For example, the recommendation output unit (72) may output one of speed control, impeller trimming, and simple direct connection as the highest priority recommendation, and output other scenarios as auxiliary candidates or cautionary candidates.

[0194] In addition, estimated power consumption, estimated savings rate, estimated cost, estimated payback period, and operational precautions for each scenario can be output together.

[0195] In the verification correction step (S420), the data processing unit (50), the scenario calculation unit (60), or the comparison judgment unit (150) may generate verification correction data (D580) using actual measurement data (D570) after replacement. The actual measurement data (D570) after replacement may include actual power consumption, actual RPM, actual power factor, operating time, flow rate, head, or load pattern after the installation of the motor to be replaced.

[0196] Verification correction data (D580) can be generated by comparing the calculated values ​​(D470) for each scenario calculated before replacement with the actual measured data (D570) after replacement. The verification correction data (D580) can be used to correct field correction values ​​(D390), operating point deviation correction values ​​(D395), the efficiency model of the efficiency application step (S314), the judgment criteria of the comparison judgment step (S400), or the calculation model for the same type of equipment in the future. According to the embodiment, the verification correction data (D580) can be used for statistical correction using the difference between the predicted value and the actual value, correction by section, or correction by equipment group.

[0197] The verification correction data (D580) may include at least one of the difference between the predicted power consumption and the actual power consumption, the difference between the predicted reduction rate and the actual reduction rate, the correction value of the applied field correction value (D390), the correction value of the operating point deviation correction value (D395), the correction value of the similarity law index, or the correction value of the recommendation judgment criterion. The verification correction data (D580) is not limited to simple post-reporting data but can be used as feedback data to improve the accuracy of subsequent scenario calculations.

[0198] The verification correction step (S420) may be an optional subsequent step for verifying the replacement effect after the fact. One of the key aspects of the present invention is to standardize the existing operating state and calculate multiple scenarios before replacement, but using actual measurement data (D570) after replacement can improve the accuracy of the calculation model and reflect it in the next equipment diagnosis or next replacement decision.

[0199] The existing operating state is estimated from the nameplate data (D100) and measurement data (D150) of the existing induction motor (10), and the pump shaft power (D310) is calculated using the actual active power (D160) and the estimated actual efficiency (D300). Based on the calculated pump shaft power (D310), the expected power consumption and expected savings rate for multiple scenarios after replacement can be calculated. It is possible to predict the effect of replacement by reflecting the actual load and operating conditions of the field equipment, rather than a method that judges the savings effect based only on the efficiency information of the motor to be replaced.

[0200] In the simple direct connection scenario of the present invention, it can be reflected that an increase in the rotational speed of the motor to be replaced may increase the power required by the pump. Therefore, even if the efficiency of the motor to be replaced is high, it is possible to calculate in advance the case where the pump (12) is operated at a higher rotational speed and requires more power. The result of the calculation can serve as a criterion for determining whether simple direct connection operation is appropriate or whether speed control or impeller trimming is required.

[0201] The present invention can calculate the expected power consumption when the rotational speed of the motor to be replaced is adjusted to the target RPM operating point (D400) through a speed control scenario. The replacement effect can be compared based on the workload corresponding to the existing operating state, or the cost-saving effect can be calculated by operating the pump (12) to the target operating point required at the site.

[0202] Through impeller trimming scenarios, the expected power consumption resulting from mechanical operating point adjustment under constant load or over-designed pump conditions can be calculated. Impeller trimming can be recommended in sites where applying a speed control device is not economical or where constant operating point adjustment alone is sufficient due to small load variability.

[0203] The comparison judgment unit (150) may consider at least one of the scenario-specific calculated value (D470), load variability (D500), load pattern (D510), cost (D520), payback period (D530), and operational stability (D540). It may provide recommended operating conditions (D550) and recommended construction methods (D560) that consider field applicability, economic feasibility, and stability, rather than simply a scenario with a high expected reduction rate.

[0204] Each data and step of the present invention is not limited to being performed only in the specific order shown in the drawings. For example, at least one of the rated input power calculation step (S100), current load rate calculation step (S110), normal estimated RPM calculation step (S120), normal estimated power factor calculation step (S140), actual RPM determination step (S130), and actual power factor determination step (S150) may be performed in parallel or with some order changed depending on the form of the calculation model or input data.

[0205] In addition, at least one of the load rate correction step (S200), RPM deviation correction step (S210), power factor deviation correction step (S220), actual efficiency calculation step (S230), and pump shaft power calculation step (S240) may be implemented as independent processing modules or may be performed within a single efficiency estimation model or a single data processing routine.

[0206] At least one of the simple direct connection calculation step (S300), the speed control calculation step (S310), the impeller trimming calculation step (S320), and the scenario-specific calculation value generation step (S330) may be performed entirely or partially depending on the field conditions.

[0207] At least one of nameplate data (D100), measurement data (D150), calibration measurement data (D190), replacement target information (D350), load variability (D500), load pattern (D510), cost (D520), payback period (D530), operational stability (D540), actual measurement data after replacement (D570), and verification calibration data (D580) may be provided as a database, file, sensor signal, user input, data received through a communication network, or data linked to an external system.

[0208] The output unit (70) can output the calculation results in a form understandable to the user. The output unit (70) can generate at least one of a report including current status information of the existing induction motor (10), estimated actual efficiency (D300), pump shaft power (D310), estimated power consumption for simple direct connection (D430), estimated power consumption for speed control (D440), estimated power consumption for impeller trimming (D450), estimated savings rate by scenario (D460), recommended operating conditions (D550), and recommended construction method (D560). The output unit (70) can output the results of each scenario in the form of a table, graph, savings rate comparison table, operating point comparison diagram, report text, or construction proposal.

[0209] The measurement data (D150) may be at least one of real-time data, average data over a certain period, representative operating point data, maximum load data, minimum load data, or section data by load pattern. Depending on the type of measurement data (D150), the data processing unit (50) may calculate the current load rate (D210), applied RPM (D240), applied power factor (D250), estimated actual efficiency (D300), and pump shaft power (D310), etc., based on a single operating point or multiple operating sections.

[0210] The data processing unit (50) can classify the measurement data (D150) collected over a certain period into low-load, medium-load, and high-load sections according to the magnitude of the actual active power (D160), time period, process operation mode, flow rate, or pressure. For each operation section, the data processing unit (50) can calculate at least one of the current load rate (D210), normal estimated RPM (D220), normal estimated power factor (D230), applied RPM (D240), applied power factor (D250), estimated actual efficiency (D300), and pump shaft power (D310).

[0211] The scenario calculation unit (60) can calculate the estimated power consumption for simple direct connection (D430), the estimated power consumption for speed control (D440), the estimated power consumption for impeller trimming (D450), and the estimated reduction rate (D460) for each scenario for multiple operation sections. The comparison judgment unit (150) can determine the recommended operation conditions (D550) and recommended construction method (D560) by summing the calculated values ​​for each section using time weighting or load pattern weighting.

[0212] For example, in the case of a pump system where high-load operation is frequent during the day and low-load operation is frequent at night, the speed control scenario can demonstrate significant savings in the low-load range. Conversely, in the case of a pump system that is always operated at a constant load, the impeller trimming scenario may be more economically advantageous. Embodiments of the present invention can determine a recommended construction method (D560) by reflecting these differences in operating ranges.

[0213] The replacement target information (D350) may be information regarding a single replacement target motor or information regarding multiple candidate motors. When the information input unit (80) receives replacement target information (D350) for multiple candidate motors, the scenario calculation unit (60) generates a scenario-specific calculation value (D470) for each candidate motor, and the comparison judgment unit (150) can compare the motor candidates with the operation or construction scenarios.

[0214] The information input unit (80) can receive information regarding the rated efficiency, synchronous speed (D360), rated capacity, number of poles, frequency, efficiency curve by load rate, controllable speed range, applicable speed control device specifications, installation feasibility, power conditions, or cost for multiple candidate motors. In this case, the comparison judgment unit (150) can compare the expected power consumption, expected savings rate, cost (D520), payback period (D530), and operational stability (D540) for each motor candidate and recommend a suitable replacement motor.

[0215] Recommended operating conditions (D550) may include at least one of the target rotational speed of the motor to be replaced, operating frequency, speed control range, operating settings by load pattern, seasonal operating settings, or time-of-day operating settings. Recommended construction methods (D560) may include simple motor replacement, installation of a speed control device, impeller trimming, pump replacement, adjustment of piping conditions, or a combination thereof.

[0216] The simple direct connection calculation step (S300), the speed control calculation step (S310), and the impeller trimming calculation step (S320) do not necessarily all need to be performed. For example, if impeller trimming is impossible due to site conditions, only the simple direct connection calculation step (S300) and the speed control calculation step (S310) may be performed. If the application of a speed control device is impossible, only the simple direct connection calculation step (S300) and the impeller trimming calculation step (S320) may be performed.

[0217] The prediction method of the present invention may include at least one of a nameplate data input step, a measurement data input step, a rated input power calculation step (S100), a current load rate calculation step (S110), a normal estimated RPM calculation step (S120), an actual RPM determination step (S130), a normal estimated power factor calculation step (S140), an actual power factor determination step (S150), a load rate correction step (S200), an RPM deviation correction step (S210), a power factor deviation correction step (S220), an actual efficiency calculation step (S230), a pump shaft power calculation step (S240), a simple direct connection calculation step (S300), a speed control calculation step (S310), a target speed control step (S312), an efficiency application step (S314), an impeller trimming calculation step (S320), a scenario-specific calculation value generation step (S330), a comparison judgment step (S400), a recommendation output step (S410), and a verification correction step (S420).

[0218] At least one of the data processing unit (50), scenario calculation unit (60), comparison judgment unit (150), output unit (70), and recommendation output unit (72) may be implemented as a software module executed by one or more processors. Additionally, these configurations may be implemented as a field control panel, an energy management system, a cloud server, a local computer, a tablet terminal, a mobile terminal, a web-based application, or an equipment diagnostic device. A program according to an embodiment of the present invention may include instructions that cause a computer to execute the method and may be stored on a computer-readable recording medium.

[0219] The field correction value (D390) and the operating point deviation correction value (D395) may be preset values, or they may be values ​​updated based on actual measurement data (D570) and verification correction data (D580) after replacement. Accordingly, the embodiment of the present invention can improve calculation accuracy through repeated field application.

[0220] The corrected measurement data (D190) may be data generated by another measurement correction device or measurement correction algorithm. The present invention may use the corrected measurement data (D190) as input data, but is not limited by a specific correction method for generating the corrected measurement data (D190).

[0221] The pump (12) of the present invention may be a centrifugal pump, but the technical concept of the present invention may also be applied to other rotary load devices in which the required power changes according to the change in rotational speed. For example, embodiments of the present invention may be applied to fans, blowers, compressors, or other rotary fluid machines. In this case, the pump shaft power (D310) may be understood as a value corresponding to the shaft power delivered to the corresponding rotary load device.

[0222] The motor to be replaced by the present invention may be an IE5 synchronous motor, but the technical concept of the present invention is not limited to an IE5 class motor. The motor to be replaced may be an IE4, IE5, or other high-efficiency motor, and may be a synchronous motor, a permanent magnet motor, a reluctance motor, an inverter-driven motor, or other high-efficiency drive device.

[0223] At least one of the actual active power (D160), actual RPM (D170), actual power factor (D180), rated capacity (D110), rated efficiency (D120), rated RPM (D130), rated power factor (D140), synchronous speed (D360), field correction value (D390), operating point deviation correction value (D395), cost (D520), payback period (D530), and operating stability (D540) of the present invention is not limited to a specific value. These values ​​may vary depending on the specifications of the field equipment, operating conditions, measurement period, type of motor to be replaced, or user settings.

[0224] The present invention can calculate the replacement effect by not only viewing the actual operating state of the existing induction motor (10) from the perspective of electrical input, but converting it into a reference value from the perspective of load, which is pump shaft power (D310).

[0225] Furthermore, the present invention can calculate not only the efficiency improvement of the electric motor to be replaced, but also the change in pump power requirements due to changes in rotational speed and operating point adjustment scenarios. The present invention can provide information necessary for assessing investment feasibility before replacement, selecting a replacement method, setting operating conditions, and post-replacement verification.

[0226] In this way, the present invention calculates a current load rate (D210) using nameplate data (D100) and measurement data (D150) of an existing induction motor (10), calculates a normal estimated RPM (D220) and a normal estimated power factor (D230) based on the current load rate (D210), and determines an applied RPM (D240) and an applied power factor (D250) depending on whether an actual RPM (D170) or an actual power factor (D180) exists.

[0227] In addition, the present invention can calculate an estimated actual efficiency (D300) using a rated efficiency (D120), a load rate correction value (D320), an RPM deviation correction value (D330), and a power factor deviation correction value (D340), and can calculate a pump shaft power (D310) using actual active power (D160) and the estimated actual efficiency (D300).

[0228] Based on the pump shaft power (D310), the estimated power consumption for simple direct connection (D430), the estimated power consumption for speed control (D440), the estimated power consumption for impeller trimming (D450), and the estimated reduction rate by scenario (D460) are calculated, and the calculated value by scenario (D470) is compared with load variability (D500), load pattern (D510), cost (D520), payback period (D530), and operational stability (D540) to output recommended operating conditions (D550) and recommended construction methods (D560).

[0229] Accordingly, the present invention allows for the comparison of multiple replacement or operation scenarios, including simple direct connection, speed control, and impeller trimming, at the same reference load before replacing the existing induction motor (10) with a replacement motor. Accordingly, it has the advantage of being able to determine in advance whether the efficiency improvement effect of the replacement motor is offset by an increase in pump rotational speed, whether speed control is required, whether impeller trimming is economical, or which operating conditions and construction methods are suitable for the site. Explanation of the symbols

[0230] 10... Induction motor 12... Pump 14... Shaft connection part 20... Measurement part 30... Nameplate data input section 40... Measurement data input section 50... Data Processing Unit 60... Scenario Calculation Unit 70... Output section 72... Recommended output section 80... Information input section 150... Comparison and judgment section D100... Nameplate data D110... Rated capacity D120... Rated efficiency D130... Rated RPM D140... Rated power factor D150... Measurement data D160... Actual active power D170... Actual RPM D180... Actual power factor D190... Corrected measurement data D200... Rated input power D210... Current load rate D220... Estimated normal RPM D230... Estimated normal power factor D240... Applicable RPM D250... Applicable Power Factor D260... Subsequent output input value D300... Estimated actual efficiency D310... Pump shaft power D320... Load factor correction value D330... RPM deviation correction value D340... Power factor deviation correction value D350... Replacement Target Information D360... Synchronization Speed D370... Applied RPM D380... Rotational speed increase rate D390... Field correction value D395... Operating point deviation correction value D400... Target RPM operating point D410... Trimming target operating point D420... Pump power requirement after trimming D430... Estimated power consumption for simple direct connection D440... Speed ​​Control Estimated Power Consumption D450... Impeller Trimming Estimated Power Consumption D460... Estimated savings rate by scenario D470... Calculated value by scenario D500... Load variability D510... Load pattern D520... Cost D530... Payback period D540... Driving Stability D550... Recommended Driving Conditions D560... Recommended installation method D570... Actual measurement data after replacement D580... Verification correction data S100... Rated input power calculation step S110... Current load rate calculation step S120... Normal estimated RPM calculation step S130... Actual RPM determination step S140... Normal estimated power factor calculation step S150... Actual power factor determination step S200... Load factor correction step S210... RPM deviation correction step S220... Power factor deviation correction step S230... Actual efficiency calculation step S240... Pump shaft power calculation step S300... Simple direct connection calculation step S310... Speed ​​control calculation step S312... Target speed control step S314... Efficiency application step S320... Impeller trimming calculation step S330... Scenario-specific calculation value generation step S400... Comparison and judgment stage S410... Recommendation output stage S420... Verification and calibration steps

Claims

Claim 1 An input unit receiving operation-related data including nameplate data or measurement data of an existing motor; a data processing unit calculating reference data representing the existing operating state of the existing motor based on the operation-related data; a scenario calculation unit calculating a replacement effect prediction value for one or more replacement or operation scenarios to which the motor to be replaced is applied based on the reference data; and an output unit outputting the replacement effect prediction value; wherein the replacement effect prediction value includes at least one of the expected power consumption or expected reduction rate of the motor to be replaced, the data processing unit classifies the measurement data into a plurality of operation sections according to at least one of time period, operating mode, load section, season, or process, and the scenario calculation unit calculates the replacement effect prediction value for each of the plurality of operation sections. Claim 2 In claim 1, the nameplate data includes rated performance information of the existing motor, the measurement data includes actual operating state information of the existing motor, and the prediction device receives replacement target information including at least one of efficiency information, rotational speed information, control conditions, installation conditions, and cost information of the motor to be replaced. Claim 3 In claim 1, the data processing unit calculates the rated input power based on the rated capacity and rated efficiency included in the nameplate data, and calculates the current load rate of the existing motor by comparing the actual active power included in the measurement data with the rated input power. Claim 4 In claim 1, the data processing unit calculates a normal estimated RPM corresponding to the rotational speed when the existing motor is normally operated at the current load rate based on at least one of the rated RPM, synchronous speed, or rated slip component of the existing motor and the current load rate, and calculates a normal estimated power factor corresponding to the power factor when the existing motor is normally operated at the current load rate based on the rated power factor of the existing motor and the current load rate. Claim 5 In claim 1, the data processing unit determines one of the actual RPM or the normal estimated RPM as the applicable RPM and one of the actual power factor or the normal estimated power factor as the applicable power factor, depending on whether the actual RPM and the actual power factor included in the measurement data exist and whether the confidence condition is satisfied. Claim 6 In claim 1, the data processing unit is a prediction device that calculates the estimated actual efficiency of the existing motor based on at least one of the current load rate, the deviation between the applied RPM and the normal estimated RPM, and the deviation between the applied power factor and the normal estimated power factor. Claim 7 In claim 1, the data processing unit calculates a reference power by applying an estimated actual efficiency to the actual effective power included in the measurement data, and when the load driven by the existing electric motor is a pump, the prediction device uses the reference power as the pump shaft power to compare the replacement or operation scenario based on the same workload. Claim 8 delete Claim 9 An input unit receiving operation-related data including nameplate data or measurement data of an existing motor; a data processing unit calculating reference data representing the existing operating state of the existing motor based on the operation-related data; a scenario calculation unit calculating a replacement effect prediction value for one or more replacement or operating scenarios to which the motor to be replaced is applied based on the reference data; and an output unit outputting the replacement effect prediction value; wherein the replacement effect prediction value includes at least one of the expected power consumption or expected reduction rate of the motor to be replaced, and the scenario calculation unit calculates the expected power consumption of the simple direct connection by reflecting the difference or ratio between the rotational speed of the motor to be replaced and the rotational speed corresponding to the existing operating state of the existing motor, for a simple direct connection scenario in which the motor to be replaced is connected to a pump without speed control or pump operating point adjustment. Claim 10 An input unit receiving operation-related data including nameplate data or measurement data of an existing motor; a data processing unit calculating reference data representing the existing operating state of the existing motor based on the operation-related data; a scenario calculation unit calculating a predicted value of replacement effect for one or more replacement or operation scenarios to which the motor to be replaced is applied based on the reference data; and an output unit outputting the predicted value of replacement effect; wherein the predicted value of replacement effect includes at least one of the expected power consumption or expected reduction rate of the motor to be replaced, and the scenario calculation unit calculates the expected power consumption of the speed control using the load required power at the target RPM operating point or target frequency condition and the efficiency of the motor to be replaced for a speed control scenario in which the motor to be replaced is operated by a speed control device to correspond to a target RPM operating point or target frequency condition. Claim 11 An input unit receiving operation-related data including nameplate data or measurement data of an existing motor; a data processing unit calculating reference data representing the existing operating state of the existing motor based on the operation-related data; a scenario calculation unit calculating a predicted replacement effect value for one or more replacement or operating scenarios to which the motor to be replaced is applied based on the reference data; and an output unit outputting the predicted replacement effect value; wherein the predicted replacement effect value includes at least one of the expected power consumption or expected reduction rate of the motor to be replaced, and the scenario calculation unit calculates the expected power consumption for impeller trimming using the pump power required at the trimming target operating point and the efficiency of the motor to be replaced for an impeller trimming scenario in which the impeller outer diameter, impeller shape, trimming ratio, or pump characteristics of the pump are adjusted. Claim 12 In claim 1, the scenario calculation unit calculates an expected reduction rate for each scenario by comparing the expected power consumption for each replacement or operation scenario with the existing standard power consumption for operation, and the prediction device processes the expected reduction rate for each scenario into a value that can be calculated as a positive reduction rate, a reduction rate corresponding to 0, or a negative reduction rate. Claim 13 The prediction device according to claim 1, wherein the prediction device includes a comparison judgment unit and a recommendation output unit, wherein the comparison judgment unit compares the replacement effect prediction value together with at least one of load variability, load pattern, cost, payback period, and operational stability, and the recommendation output unit outputs at least one of recommended operating conditions or recommended construction methods based on the comparison result. Claim 14 An input unit receiving operation-related data including nameplate data or measurement data of an existing motor; a data processing unit calculating reference data representing the existing operating state of the existing motor based on the operation-related data; a scenario calculation unit calculating a replacement effect prediction value for one or more replacement or operation scenarios to which the motor to be replaced is applied based on the reference data; an output unit outputting the replacement effect prediction value; and a comparison judgment unit comparing the replacement effect prediction value; wherein the replacement effect prediction value includes at least one of the expected power consumption or expected reduction rate of the motor to be replaced, and the comparison judgment unit increases the priority of the speed control scenario when the load variability is large, and increases the priority of the impeller trimming scenario when the load variability is small or corresponds to a constant load type. Claim 15 A prediction device comprising: an input unit receiving operation-related data including nameplate data or measurement data of an existing motor; a data processing unit calculating reference data representing the existing operating state of the existing motor based on the operation-related data; a scenario calculation unit calculating a replacement effect prediction value for one or more replacement or operation scenarios to which the motor to be replaced is applied based on the reference data; an output unit outputting the replacement effect prediction value; and a comparison judgment unit comparing the replacement effect prediction value; wherein the replacement effect prediction value includes at least one of the expected power consumption or expected savings rate of the motor to be replaced; and wherein the data processing unit, the scenario calculation unit, or the comparison judgment unit generates verification correction data based on the difference between actual post-replacement measurement data collected after the installation of the motor to be replaced and the replacement effect prediction value, and updates at least one of a correction value, an efficiency model, or a recommendation judgment criterion used for subsequent replacement effect prediction using the verification correction data.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Drainage pump station asynchronous motor reactive compensation analysis calculation method

    CN108832864A

  • Method for calculating the efficiency and torque of running motors

    KR100973511B1

  • Motor parameter estimation method and apparatus

    US20050071095A1

  • System and method to determine electric motor efficiency nonintrusively

    US20080300827A1