Method for detecting a winding error in a transformer of an electric energy supply network

The method uses an incremental negative sequence current differential to enhance the sensitivity of winding fault detection in transformers, addressing the insensitivity of conventional methods by exceeding a threshold and meeting additional stabilization criteria, thus improving fault detection and transformer safety.

WO2024240490A1PCT designated stage expired Publication Date: 2024-11-28SIEMENS AG
View PDF 3 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
PCT/EP2024/062560
Authority / Receiving Office
WO · WO
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2023-05-23
Filing Date
2024-05-07
Publication Date
2024-11-28

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Conventional protection methods for transformers in power supply networks are insufficiently sensitive to detect winding faults, particularly short circuits between transformer windings, as they cause only a small increase in current at the terminals, making early detection difficult.

Method used

The method employs an incremental negative sequence current differential as a trigger variable, formed by the absolute difference between the current negative sequence current differential and one phase-shifted by one mains frequency period, exceeding a predetermined threshold to meet the tripping criterion, with additional stabilization criteria to enhance sensitivity and reliability.

Benefits of technology

This approach significantly increases the sensitivity of fault detection, allowing for earlier identification of winding faults, reducing the risk of damage from internal short circuits by generating an error signal when specific criteria are met, thereby enhancing the safety and reliability of transformer protection.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure EP2024062560_28112024_PF_FP_ABST
    Figure EP2024062560_28112024_PF_FP_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention relates to a method for detecting a winding error in a transformer (1) of an AC-voltage-carrying electrical energy supply network (3,4), in which phase-conductor-related current measurement values are detected on the high-voltage side (H) and the low-voltage side (X) of the transformer; counterpart system current values ( I 2TH , I 2TX) are determined from the phase-conductor-related current measurement values for the high-voltage side (H) and the low-voltage side (X); the counterpart system current differential ( I 2D <sb / >= I I 2TH +<sb / > I 2TX I<sb / >) is formed from the absolute total of the counterpart system current values; a trigger variable is defined with the aid of the counterpart system current differential and a trigger criterion is defined with the aid of the trigger variable, and for which counterpart system current differential at least one stabilisation criterion is specified; wherein an error signal is generated if at least one stabilisation criteria is fulfilled in addition to the trigger criterion. This method intends to increase the sensitivity for detecting winding errors. It is proposed that an incremental counterpart system current differential ΔI 2D is used as the trigger variable, which counterpart system current differential is formed as an absolute difference between an actual counterpart system current differential I 2D and a counterpart system current differential I b 2D which is phase-shifted by a network frequency period, wherein the trigger criterion is fulfilled when the absolute value of the incremental counterpart system differential (ΔI 2D =IΔI 2DI) exceeds a previously specified threshold value.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[0001] 202309639 1 Description Method for detecting a winding fault in a transformer of an electrical power supply network The invention relates to a method for detecting a winding fault in a transformer of an alternating current electrical power supply network, in which phase-conductor-related current measurements are recorded on the high-voltage side (H) and the low-voltage side (X) of the transformer; from the phase-conductor-related current measurements for the high-voltage side (H) and the low-voltage side (X), negative-sequence system current values ​​( ^^ ଶ்ு , be determined; from the absolute sum of the negative sequence current values, the negative sequence current differential ( ^^ ଶ^ ൌ ห ^^ ଶ்ு ^ ^^ ଶ்^ห) is formed; a tripping variable is defined with the aid of the negative sequence current differential and a tripping criterion is defined with the aid of the tripping variable; and in which at least one stabilization criterion is specified; wherein a fault signal is generated if, in addition to the tripping criterion, at least one stabilization criterion is met. The invention further relates to a protection unit. Transformers in power supply networks are now protected using a variety of protection methods. In addition to the so-called Buchholz protection, in which gas formation in the transformer oil is monitored, differential protection is primarily used today. Here, differential currents determined at the protected object are evaluated. To increase safety, additional overcurrent protection methods, earth fault differential protection and, depending on the power rating, impedance protection are used.202309639 2 The types of faults in transformers are very diverse, since internal faults in particular can occur. These are caused by short circuits between the turns of the transformer windings. Interturn faults can occur, for example, when transformers are switched on, since the high inrush currents in the windings generate strong vibrations and thus strong mechanical loads, which can lead to interturn faults. The detection of interturn faults in transformers requires a sensitive protection mechanism. With many of the protection methods mentioned above, internal faults are difficult to detect, since although a very high current can flow within a short-circuited turn, this current is hardly measurable from the outside. Thus, interturn faults are generally difficult to detect, since they only cause a very small increase in the current at the transformer terminals.However, the current at the fault location is very high due to short-circuited windings and is very dangerous for the transformers. The protective devices commonly used today measure the line currents on both sides of the transformer and detect an internal fault through the differential current occurring in the event of a turn-to-turn short circuit. However, this generally does not achieve sufficient sensitivity to detect turn-to-turn short circuits early on. Therefore, with conventional protection principles, internal faults in transformers must expand to the point where they can be detected externally via the differential current or overcurrents. US Pat. No. 7,812,615 B2 and EP 3595 144 B1 each disclose methods for detecting a turn-to-turn short circuit in a transformer. These methods are based on determining the negative sequence current on the high- and low-voltage sides of the transformer.The negative sequence current is virtually zero during fault-free operation of the transformer. A protection method that works with negative sequence currents is also known from patent specification US 7,903,381 B2. The object of the invention is to provide a method of the type mentioned above that enables even more sensitive detection of a winding fault in a transformer. This object is achieved according to the invention by using an incremental negative sequence current differential Δ ^^. ଶ^ is used as a trigger value, which is the absolute difference from a current negative sequence current differential ^^ ଶ^ and a negative sequence current differential phase-shifted by one grid frequency period ^^ ଶ ^ ^ is formed, whereby the tripping criterion is met when the absolute value of the incremental negative sequence current differential (∆ ^^ ଶ^ ൌ ห∆ ^^ ଶ^ห) exceeds a previously defined threshold value. A protection unit according to the invention is configured to carry out the method according to the invention. The invention makes use of the known approach that, in addition to a first main criterion, referred to here as the triggering criterion, an auxiliary or stability criterion must be met in order to trigger a fault signal. Within the scope of the invention, however, the sensitivity of the triggering criterion is significantly increased. According to the invention, the negative sequence current differential is replaced by 202309639 4 ^^ ଶ^ as a trigger variable an incremental negative sequence current differential ∆ ^^ ଶ^and leave the triggering criterion untouched, so that it is met when a previously defined threshold is exceeded by the triggering value, as in the prior art. Within the scope of the invention, an incremental limit negative sequence current differential serves as the threshold. Within the scope of the invention, it was recognized that the incremental negative sequence current differential can be easily determined. The negative sequence current differential ^^ ଶ^ is a vector quantity. In the steady-state non-fault case, a negative sequence current differential occurs ^^ ଶ^ generally only occurs as a result of measurement errors. The negative sequence current differential ^^ ଶ^ However, it is a periodically recurring quantity. Thus, the absolute difference of a current negative sequence current differential ^^ ଶ^ and a negative sequence current differential which is phase-shifted by one period, i.e., one period behind in time, should be in the zero range. This applies when the transformer is operating fault-free. Only in the event of a fault does a significant increase in the incremental negative sequence current differential occur, which indicates a winding fault. Therefore, the triggering criterion is set more sensitively within the invention than the triggering criteria of the prior art. It remains specific and therefore indicates a winding fault, i.e., a short circuit inside the transformer. Within the scope of the invention, the negative sequence current differential ^^ ଶ^as usual. First, the currents of all phase conductors of all windings are measured. Within the scope of the invention, the transformer can also have more than two windings. The method according to the invention is suitable for transformers with any number of windings. Such a 202309639 5 transformer has, for example, three, four, or five windings. To record the currents flowing in the phase conductors of all windings, inductive current transformers are used, for example. These inductively detect the current of a phase conductor and provide analog measurement signals on the output side, from which the current in the respective phase conductor is determined after calibration. The analog measurement signals can be sampled over time to obtain measured values. The measured values ​​obtained in this way can then be digitized using an analog-to-digital converter. This results in phase-conductor-related current measured values.However, these statements are only to be understood as examples and are not intended to limit the scope of the invention in any way. In order to compare the currents of the phase conductors of one winding with the currents of the phase conductors of another winding, correction calculations, more precisely phase and coupling correction calculations, must be carried out. However, these correction calculations are known from the prior art, so they need not be discussed in detail here. The currents are then mathematically decomposed into independent symmetries, i.e. into the currents of the positive sequence system, the negative sequence system, and the zero sequence system, thereby obtaining the "measured" positive sequence system current, the negative sequence system current, and the zero sequence system current. This method is also known to those skilled in the art. Further explanations can therefore be omitted here.The negative sequence current is almost zero during fault-free operation of a winding k of a transformer T. The positive sequence current is referenced in the index of the symbol for the current measurements I with the number 1, the negative sequence current with the number 2, and the zero sequence current with the number 0. Assuming a transformer with two windings, i.e. one which has a primary or high-voltage winding H and a secondary or low-voltage winding X, the negative sequence current of the high-voltage winding H of the transformer T is ^^. ଶ்ு, where the underscore of I indicates that it is a phasor value, meaning the negative-sequence system current was measured or, more accurately, determined in phase. The index D refers subsequently to a differential value, meaning here the absolute difference between values ​​measured or determined on both sides of the transformer. The current negative-sequence system current differential ^^ ଶ^ In the above example, therefore, . A quantity that is phase-shifted by one period of the grid frequency, i.e., one period back in time, is referred to below with a superscript b. Accordingly, the negative sequence current differential that is phase-shifted by one period is written as follows: ^^ ଶ ^ ^. The incremental negative sequence current differential ∆ ^^ ଶ^ therefore results from This is also a vector variable. Within the scope of the invention, the absolute value of the incremental negative sequence current differential is used as the trigger variable, which is calculated as follows: 202309639 7 If this trigger value exceeds a limit or, in other words, threshold value, which was determined, for example, as a parameter based on preliminary tests, the trigger criterion is met within the scope of the invention. The threshold value can also be determined with the aid of analytical calculations. In principle, this trigger criterion can be used within the scope of the invention together with any other criteria that deviate from the trigger criterion. These further criteria are referred to below as stabilization criteria. However, the following stabilization criteria are preferably used within the scope of the invention. According to the invention, an error signal is triggered if the trigger criterion and at least one stabilization criterion are met. Advantageously, an error signal is triggered if, in addition to the trigger criterion, several stabilization criteria are met.The reliability of the method according to the invention is further increased by using several auxiliary or stabilization criteria. According to a preferred variant, a fault signal is triggered if, in addition to the trigger criterion, all stabilization criteria are met. This variant is based on the realization that winding faults are difficult to reliably detect. Therefore, if not one or more, but all of the stabilization criteria presented here are used, it can be concluded with a high degree of certainty that a winding short circuit has occurred if a fault signal is present. According to a further advantageous embodiment of the method according to the invention, a true effective current value is determined for each period of the alternating current, and a first stabilization variable is calculated using the true effective current value.Within the scope of the invention, it was recognized that the true RMS values, which are more commonly known to a person skilled in the art by the term "true RMS values," include not only the fundamental component of a quantity, but also higher-order harmonic components, the latter occurring in the event of a short circuit between turns. According to a suitable further development in this regard, the true RMS current values ​​( ^^. ்^ோெௌ ^^ ) for each phase conductor (a, b, c) of a transformer winding (k) is determined phase-dependently, whereby from the current true effective current values, true effective current values ​​( ^^ ் ^ ^ ோெௌ ^^ ) obtaining incremental effective values ​​∆ ^^ ்^ோெௌ ^,^ for each winding (k) phase conductor-related, whereby an average value is then calculated over all phase conductors (a,b,c) of said winding (k) to obtain an average incremental winding current effective value (∆ ^^ ∑ோெௌ,^ ) is formed for each winding, with the effective winding current values ​​(∆ ^^ ∑ோெௌ,^ ) of all windings (k) of the transformer are compared with each other and the largest effective winding current value (∆ ^^ ^ ) is determined as the second stabilization quantity, whereby a first stabilization criterion is met if the tripping quantity has the largest effective winding current value (∆ ^^ ^) multiplied by a previously determined factor (C). 202309639 9 According to this variant of the invention, a reliable auxiliary or stabilization criterion is defined with the aid of the true effective current values, which indicates winding faults. In order to check for the presence of the first stabilization criterion, the tripping and stabilization variables must be compared with each other. For further explanation, reference is made to the comments on Figure 2. In a further variant of the invention, to determine a second stabilization variable ^^ ^^ଶ the vectorial difference between the incremental negative sequence current differential ∆ ^^ ଶ^ and the incremental positive sequence current differential ∆ ^^ ^^formed and normalized to the absolute value of the incremental negative sequence current differential, whereby a second stabilization criterion is met if the second stabilization variable falls below a previously defined threshold. The idea underlying this embodiment of the invention is that in the event of a winding fault, not only the absolute values ​​of the incremental positive and negative sequence currents are identical, but also their phase positions. Therefore, incremental values ​​are again formed. Reference is made to the above explanations. In other words, the positive and negative sequence current differentials, which are phase-shifted by one period of the grid frequency, are subtracted from the currently measured positive and negative sequence current differentials. The absolute value is then calculated in each case. This results in the second stabilization variable ^^ ^^ଶ as follows: To eliminate potential implementation problems, it is suggested that normalization to the absolute value of the incremental countercurrent differential 202309639 10 is only performed if this is greater than or equal to a minimum limit. Otherwise, ^^ ^^ଶ be set equal to zero. A minimum limit of 0.01, for example, can be considered. Within the scope of the invention, a third stabilization variable can be determined using the absolute value of an incremental zero-sequence current differential (ห∆ ^^ ^^ ห). In this variant, the zero-sequence system is considered and used to detect winding faults. According to a suitable further development in this regard, the absolute value of the incremental zero-sequence current differential is calculated to obtain the third stabilization variable ( ^^ ^^ଶ ) to the absolute value of the incremental counterflow differential (ห∆ ^^ ଶ^ห) is standardized, whereby a third stabilization criterion is met if the third stabilization variable falls below a previously defined threshold. The procedure for determining incremental variables is as explained above. First, the zero-sequence current differential is calculated. For this purpose, the absolute difference between the zero-sequence currents measured on both sides of the transformer is formed. The zero-sequence current differential preceding it by one period is subtracted from the current zero-sequence current differential, and then the absolute value of this difference is calculated. This results in the incremental zero-sequence current differential, a phasor variable whose absolute value provides the third stabilization variable ^^ ^^ଶ calculated as follows. ^^ ห∆ ^^^^ห ^ ^ଶ ൌ ห ∆ ^^ଶ^ห202309639 11 To eliminate potential problems during implementation, it is proposed that normalization to the absolute value of the incremental negative sequence current differential be performed only if this is greater than or equal to a minimum limit. Otherwise, normalization should be performed to the minimum limit. A possible minimum limit is, for example, 0.01. Within the scope of the invention, the grid frequency is the frequency of the AC voltage of the power grid. Within the scope of the invention, it was recognized that the incremental zero-sequence current differential, which can be easily determined from the phase-conductor-related current measurements, has a predetermined ratio to the incremental negative sequence current differential in the event of a fault. In the event of a turn-to-turn fault, this ratio is never exceeded. According to a suitable further development, a fourth stabilization variable ( ^^ ^^ଶ) using the angular difference between the incremental zero current differential (∆ ^^ ^^ ) and the incremental countercurrent differential ∆ ^^ ଶ^ determined, whereby a fourth stabilization criterion is met if the fourth stabilization variable falls below a limit angle. For the determination of the incremental variables, please refer to the explanations above. Here, too, it is recommended to use the fourth stabilization criterion only as suggested if the incremental zero-sequence current differential and the incremental countercurrent differential are greater than or equal to a minimum value. Otherwise, ^^ ^^ଶ be set equal to zero. 202309639 12 Within the scope of the invention, it was also recognized that the phase position between the incremental zero current differential (∆ ^^ ^^ ) and the incremental countercurrent differential can be calculated in the event of a fault. The phase angle calculated in this way is always smaller than a specified limit angle in the event of a turn-to-turn short circuit or turn-to-turn fault in the transformer. If this limit is exceeded, the fourth stabilization criterion is met. Further advantages arise if each stabilization criterion is based on an associated stabilization variable that differs from the stabilization variables also used in the method according to the invention.The invention is explained in more detail below with reference to exemplary embodiments, wherein like reference numerals refer to components with the same function and wherein Figure 1 shows an embodiment of a transformer to which the method according to the invention can be applied, and Figure 2 shows a diagram to explain the first stabilization criterion. Turning faults in transformers of power supply networks place particular demands on the protection technology that monitors the transformer. It is true that high currents can flow within a transformer between the turns that are incorrectly connected due to a turn-to-turn short circuit. However, these are hardly measurable at the outer terminals of the transformer, i.e. its connections, and can therefore be difficult to detect with conventional protection concepts such as differential protection or overcurrent protection. Turning faults arise, for example, from strong mechanical loads, e.g.B. vibrations, within the transformer or due to aging of the insulation between the windings. The high currents flowing between the faulty windings can lead to local overheating and to the propagation of the fault in the transformer and must therefore be detected as early as possible by a protective device monitoring the transformer. Figure 1 shows a transformer 1 and a protective unit 2 according to the invention, on which the method according to the invention is implemented. The transformer 1 is only illustrated schematically with reference to its windings, wherein a high-voltage winding is galvanically connected with its terminal H to a first power supply network 3 which has a high-voltage potential, and a low-voltage winding is galvanically connected with its terminal X to a second power supply network 4 which has a lower high-voltage potential than the first power supply network 3.In the following, the winding connected to terminal H is referenced with H and the winding connected to terminal X with X. The power supply networks 3, 4 each have three phase conductors a, b and c. The phase conductors of winding H are connected to an earthed star point. The low-voltage winding X has a delta connection. The same applies to the connected power supply networks 3 and 4 respectively. In winding H of the transformer, a turn fault 7 in phase conductor a is illustrated. 202309639 14 For each of the phase conductors a, b, c, an AC voltage symbol 5 indicates that the phase conductor carries an alternating current. The currents ^^ flow in the phase conductors of the power supply network 3. ் ^ ு ^ , ^^ ் ^ ு ^ , ^^ ் ^ ு ^, where the indices a, b, and c refer to the respective phase conductors. In the power supply network 4, the currents ^^ flow in the phase conductors a, b, and c. ் ^ ^ ^ , ^^ ் ^ ^ ^ , ^^ ் ^ ^ ^ . Inductive current transformers 6 are used to detect these currents, which are connected on the output side to the protection unit 2. As explained above, the detected currents ^^ ் ^ ு ^ , ^^ ் ^ ு ^ , ^^ ் ^ ு ^The measured current values ​​are sampled and converted into digital current values ​​by analog-to-digital conversion. The method described above can thus be carried out by the protection unit 2, which has a microprocessor (not shown in the figure) and a memory unit on which the software necessary for implementing the method according to the invention, as well as threshold or limit values, are stored. Figure 2 shows a two-dimensional coordinate system to illustrate the first stabilization criterion explained above. In the coordinate system shown, the largest effective winding current value ∆ ^^ is on the abscissa. ^ in arbitrary units (pu). The ordinate shows the trigger value, i.e. the absolute value of the incremental negative sequence current differential ∆ ^^ ଶ^also in arbitrary units. In the diagram, in a region a, a constant incremental negative sequence current differential ∆ ^^ ଶ^ from 0.03 a horizontal straight line up to an intersection ∆ ^^ ^ = 0.1. This horizontal line represents a minimum threshold for the trigger criterion ∆ ^^ ଶ^ In this area, the first stabilization criterion is always fulfilled. 202309639 15 From the aforementioned intersection of ∆ ^^ ^ = 0.1, a straight line with a defined gradient, here 0.4, follows in an area marked b in Figure 2. If the trigger value ∆ ^^ ଶ^ above this straight line, the first stabilization criterion is met.

Claims

202309639 16 claims 1. Method for detecting a winding fault in a transformer (1) of an alternating current electrical power supply network (3, 4), in which - phase-related current measured values ​​are recorded on the high-voltage side (H) and the low-voltage side (X) of the transformer (1); - from the phase-related current measured values ​​for the high-voltage side (H) and the low-voltage side (X), negative-sequence system current values ​​( ^^ ଶ்ு , ^^ ଶ்^ ) are determined; - from the absolute sum of the negative sequence current values, the negative sequence current differential is formed; - a tripping variable is defined with the aid of the negative sequence current differential and a tripping criterion is defined with the aid of the tripping variable; and in which - at least one stabilization criterion is defined; - wherein a fault signal is generated if, in addition to the tripping criterion, at least one stabilization criterion is met, characterized in that - an incremental negative sequence current differential ∆ ^^ ଶ^ is used as a trigger value, which is the absolute difference from a current negative sequence current differential ^^ ଶ^ and a negative sequence current differential phase-shifted by one system frequency period ^^ ଶ ^ ^ is formed, whereby the tripping criterion is met when the absolute value of the incremental negative sequence current differential (∆ ^^ ଶ^ ൌ ห∆ ^^ ଶ^ ห) exceeds a previously defined threshold value.

2. Method according to claim 1, 202309639 17 characterized in that an error signal is triggered if, in addition to the triggering criterion, several stabilization criteria are met.

3. Method according to claim 2, characterized in that an error signal is triggered if, in addition to the triggering criterion, all stabilization criteria are met.

4. Method according to one of the preceding claims, characterized in that for each period of the alternating current, a true effective current value is determined and a first stabilization variable is calculated using the true effective current value.

5. Method according to claim 4, characterized in that the true effective current values ​​( ^^ ்^ோெௌ ^^) are determined for each phase conductor (a, b, c) of a transformer winding (k) in a phase-dependent manner, whereby the current effective current values ​​( ^^ ் ^ ^ ோெௌ ^^ ) obtaining incremental effective values ​​∆ ^^ ்^ோெௌ ^,^ for each winding (k) are subtracted, whereby an average value is then calculated over all phase conductors (a,b,c) of the said winding (k) to obtain an average incremental winding current effective value (∆ ^^ ∑ோெௌ,^ ) is formed for each winding, with the effective value of the winding current then all windings (k) of the transformer (1) are compared 202309639 18 and the largest effective winding current value (∆ ^^ ^) is determined as the first stabilization quantity, whereby a first stabilization criterion is met if the tripping quantity has the largest effective winding current value multiplied by a previously determined factor (C).

5. Method according to one of the preceding claims, characterized in that for determining a second stabilization variable ^^ ^^ଶ the vectorial difference between the incremental negative sequence current differential ∆ ^^ ଶ^ and an incremental positive-sequence current differential ∆ ^^ ^^formed and normalized to the absolute value of the incremental negative sequence current differential, wherein a second stabilization criterion is met if the second stabilization variable falls below a previously defined threshold value.

6. Method according to one of the preceding claims, characterized in that a third stabilization variable is determined using the absolute value of an incremental zero sequence current differential 7. Method according to claim 6, characterized in that the absolute value of the incremental zero current differential is determined to obtain the third stabilization variable ( ^^ ^^ଶ ) to the absolute value of the incremental counterflow differential (ห∆ ^^ ଶ^ ห) is standardized, whereby a third stabilization criterion is met if the third stabilization variable falls below a previously defined threshold value. 202309639 19 8. Method according to one of the preceding claims, characterized in that a fourth stabilization variable ( ^^ ^^ଶ ) using the angle difference between the incremental zero current differential and the incremental counter current differential is determined, wherein a fourth stabilization criterion is met when the fourth stabilization variable falls below a limit angle.

9. Method according to one of the preceding claims, characterized in that each stabilization criterion is based on an associated stabilization variable which deviates from the stabilization variables of stabilization criteria also used in said method.

10. Protection unit (2) for generating a fault signal in the event of a winding fault in a transformer (1) in an alternating current electrical power supply network (3, 4), characterized in that said protection unit (2) is configured to carry out a method according to one of the preceding claims.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Traction device with integrated fan

    EP3595144A1

  • Method and device for fault detection in transformers or power lines

    US7812615B2

  • Negative sequence differential element

    US7903381B2