Elastic actuator

WO2024243515A1PCT designated stage expired Publication Date: 2024-11-28MASSACHUSETTS INST OF TECH
View PDF 2 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
PCT/US2024/031002
Authority / Receiving Office
WO · WO
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2023-05-24
Filing Date
2024-05-24
Publication Date
2024-11-28

Smart Images

  • Figure US2024031002_28112024_PF_FP_ABST
    Figure US2024031002_28112024_PF_FP_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

An actuator includes a motor and a gear train. The gear train is configured to couple the motor to a load and includes a first gear with a toothed outer section and a central section coupled to the toothed outer section by an elastic inner section. A difference in an angle of rotation of the toothed outer section and an angle of rotation of the central section causes tensile and / or compressive stress in the elastic inner section.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

ELASTIC ACTUATORCROSS-REFERENCES TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

[0001] This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Application No. 63 / 468.599 filed May 24, 2023.BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

[0002] Enabling machines to use human tools is the next step to bringing robots from carefully crafted manufacturing plants into the outside world. Advancements in high level control methods such as neural networks have enabled robots to learn and perform tasks in previously unseen environments without being explicitly programmed for them. One of the areas which has thrived as a result of this has been robotic hand manipulation.

[0003] To date, there is no standard robotic hand hardware platform for researchers to work with. Previous designs from the early 2010s such as the Robonaut II or DLR hand are not commercially available and newer designs have not reached a stage of maturity that older designs have. One reason for the lack of standardization is the complexity of fitting ten or more actuators and transmissions in the space of a human hand. Some designers have resorted to placing the motors in the forearm and routing tendons made of cables such as fishing line to the fingers. This can cause robustness issues, as each tendon requires several parts like pulleys to minimize friction. Furthermore, each tendon passes through a moving wrist. With so many moving parts, at least one is bound to fail. Shadow dexterous hand, one of the most popular robotic hands, is reported to snap a tendon every few days when run continuously. When it comes to training neural networks to use them, this causes a severe limitation, as they require vast amounts of real-world data. This is not helped by the fact that maintenance is incredibly complicated, requires significant knowledge of the system to fix, and hours of repair time. New paradigms to enable more robust robotic actuators are needed.SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

[0004] Mechanical devices such as robots are often required to interact with their environment to perform tasks. When the environment includes humans or sensitiveobjects, mechanical devices are specially designed such that operation of the device is safe for both the mechanical device and humans or objects in the environment.

[0005] Series elastic actuators are a type of actuator that can be used in mechanical devices to improve safety of interactions between mechanical devices and their environments. In general, series elastic actuators are actuators that introduce elasticity between a motor and a load driven by the motor. The introduced elasticity lowers the reflected inertia coming to a stop induces when the load being driven by the series elastic actuator collides with an element in the environment, preventing damage to the element in the environment and damage to the actuator itself. Conventional series elastic actuators introduce elasticity between the motor and the load by coupling the motor to the load through a coil spring. More specifically, series elastic actuators typically include a motor that drives a gear drive, where the last element of the gear drive is coupled to the load through a coil spring.

[0006] Aspects described herein relate to a series elastic actuator that is scaled down to a size suitable for use, for example, in a fully actuated robotic hand. The scaled down series elastic actuator is compact enough to be located at the joints of the fingers of the robotic hands, obviating the need to use fragile “tendons” to connect the motors to the elements of the fingers.

[0007] One limiting factor for scaling down the series elastic actuator is the amount of space required by the coil spring in the design. Aspects described herein address this limitation by introducing elasticity into one of the gears of the gear train, eliminating the need for a coil spring. In one aspect, a specially designed “elastic gear” has three concentric sections: an outer section with teeth, an inner section with an opening for receiving a shaft (e.g., a shaft attached to the load), and an elastic section sandwiched between the outer section and the inner section.

[0008] In operation, when the load collides with an object in the environment, the load quickly stops moving, but the inertia of the motor prevents the motor from stopping as quickly as the load. The elastic section of the specially designed gear stores some or all of the inertial energy of the motor, preventing damage to the gear train or to the object in the environment.

[0009] Different designs of the gear are possible, but one example of a design that performs well has a non-circular (e.g., substantially diamond shaped) elastic section and a non-circular (e.g., substantially diamond shaped) inner section. The diamond shapereduces sheer stress on the interfaces between the elastic section and the inner and outer sections to prevent the three sections from detaching from each other. Instead, the elastic section is subjected tensile and / or compressive stress.

[0010] Other designs of the gear may be of a single material, but fabricated (e.g., 3D printed) to act as a torsion spring. For example, gear designs may include internal flexures that act as torsion springs.

[0011] In yet other aspects, a robotic finger has its components chosen to replicate movement of the human hand. Series elastic actuators positioned at joints of the finger are designed to have a size equivalent to that of a human knuckle, while meeting functional requirements of torque, inertia, and bandwidth that resemble human functionality.

[0012] In a general aspect, an actuator includes a motor and a gear train. The gear train is configured to couple the motor to a load and includes a first gear with a toothed outer section and a central section coupled to the toothed outer section by an elastic inner section. A difference in an angle of rotation of the toothed outer section and an angle of rotation of the central section causes tensile and / or compressive stress in the elastic inner section.

[0013] Aspects may include one or more of the following features.

[0014] The actuator may be a series elastic actuator. The elastic inner section may be non-circular. The elastic section may be diamond shaped, star shaped, or square shaped. The elastic section may be made from an elastomeric material such as rubber. The elastic section may be a flexure structure formed between the toothed outer section and the central section.

[0015] The actuator may be sized and shaped according to a size and shape of a human joint (e.g., a knuckle joint). A robotic finger may include one or more of the actuators located at its joints. The size of the motor, the gearing ratio of the gear train, and the stiffness of the elastic inner section may be designed according to functional requirements for torque, inertia, bandwidth, and size, the functional requirements corresponding to the operation of a human hand.

[0016] The elastic inner section may be subjected to pure shear stress when the actuator is impacted. The elastic inner section may be subjected to both compression and sheer stress when the actuator is impacted.

[0017] Aspects may have one or more of the following advantages.

[0018] Aspects advantageously relate to a robotic finger that provides human performance in a small form factor and removes limitations on robotic manipulation research by providing a reliable standard hardware platform.

[0019] Some conventional designs rely on putting larger motors in the forearm and routing tendons to the finger, but this introduces significant complexity in the transmission. Aspects described herein advantageously address this drawback by introducing a torque dense and impact resistant series elastic actuator that is small enough to fit inside robotic fingers. The finger design advantageously matches optimized parameters from fundamental analysis of the characteristic physics equations. Impact resistance is advantageously enabled by a novel elastic coupling that is also a gear, allowing it to be part of the transmission, saving space.

[0020] Aspects relate to a robotic actuator that advantageously can be used in robotic hands with simpler transmissions, leading to more robustness. This in turn can help create a stable base hardware platform for robotic manipulation.

[0021] Other features and advantages of the invention are apparent from the following description, and from the claims.BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0022] FIG. l is a side view of an elastic actuator.

[0023] FIG. 2 is a top view of the elastic actuator of FIG. 1.

[0024] FIG. 3 is a first set of physical specifications for the elastic actuator.

[0025] FIG. 4 is a second set of physical specifications for the elastic actuator.

[0026] FIG. 5 is a mechanical system diagram for the elastic actuator.

[0027] FIG. 6 is a first elastic gear design.

[0028] FIG. 7 is a second elastic gear design.

[0029] FIG. 8 is a third elastic gear design.DETAILED DESCRIPTION1 OVERVIEW

[0030] Referring to FIGs. 1 and 2 an elastic actuator 100 includes a motor 102 coupled to a fingertip 103 by a gear train 104 and a linkage 106. In general, rotation of the motor 102 causes a series of gears of the gear train 104 to rotate. As the series of gears rotates, the gear train 104 engages the linkage 106, which translates the rotational motion into the articulate movement of the fingertip 103. In some examples, the gear train 104 includes an elastic gear 108 that eliminates the need for a coil spring in the elastic actuator 100, thereby reducing amount of space required to introduce elasticity into the actuator while still meeting torque, bandwidth, and impact resistance requirements.

[0031] The gear train 104, the motor 102, and the elastic gear 108 are carefully designed to minimize the amount of space each element requires while meeting design requirements, as is described below. Before addressing the design choices for the gear train 104, the motor 102, and the elastic gear 108, the functional requirements of the design are discussed and the problems of motor sizing, transmission (gear train) stiffness, and transmission gearing are characterized.2 FUNCTIONAL REQUIREMENTS

[0032] The actuator described herein is configured to have enough power and torque to play piano keys if integrated directly into a robotic finger of human size. The actuator design has three components (1) torque and bandwidth requirements, (2) resistance to impacts and compliance, and (3) a human form factor.

[0033] In one example, values for the three components above are determined by analyzing slow-motion footage of a professional piano player playing the piano with different dynamics ranging from the lowest, pianississimo, to the loudest, fortississimo. In general, these dynamics represent the lowest and hardest a player is capable of playing at. The total inertia of the system is determined by measuring the inertia of a human finger and every moving component of a piano key along with their corresponding transmission ratios.

[0034] Referring to FIG. 3, aa summary of the measured values is shown. While the maximum angular velocity of the knuckle joint while pressing a piano key is 32 RPM, human fingers in the air can go much faster than that. The maximum angular velocity of a human finger is roughly 200 RPM. This is important to consider for resistance to impacts. Resistance to impacts is defined as being capable of handling a full-speed inelastic collision against a fixed, unmoving object.

[0035] Referring to FIG. 4, the functional requirements of the elastic actuator strive to match the size of a human finger, which is represented by the parameters shown in the figure (e.g., a knuckle width of 19mm, etc.).3 SERIES ELASTIC ACTUATOR CHARACTERIZATION

[0036] There are three main components that go into designing the actuator to meet the functional requirements described above: (1) the motor size, (2) the transmission stiffness, and (3) the transmission gearing. The motor size determines how much power and torque the actuator can produce. The stiffness determines how much impact torque the actuator will experience and the bandwidth of the finger. The transmission gearing ends up being the first part that breaks, so it determines how much torque the actuator can handle before failing. Referring to FIG. 5, the following sections characterize the problems that are solved to correctly design the motor, transmission, and gear spring to achieve the desired design requirements.3.1 Motor Sizing

[0037] For a small form -factor human finger-like actuator to be feasible, the motor must be fit within predetermined sizing requirements that ensure it can be placed inside the fingers. Motor size is therefore optimized.

[0038] Torque requirements are derived from the information in FIGs. 3 and 4. For example, the inertia of the actuator and the maximum desired acceleration are. The total inertia (Jtotal) of the motor + piano key + piano internal elements + robot finger is 0.0082 kgm2, while the torque on the finger due to piano key gravity (Tload) is 0.12 Nm.

[0039] In some examples, the torque that can be derived from a motor is determined using the maximum electromagnetic shear stress (rem). The electromagnetic shear stressrepresents the maximum possible shear stress can exist across the outside surface area of the stators of the motor. A gear train with ratio ( N ) is used to reach a final desired torque.

[0040] The first characteristic equation is determined by combining these equations:LE)22. )

[0041] Comparing how long the fingers are in full-speed movements vs. at a standstill the approximate duty cycle can be determined as ~ 40%. As a result, a maximum remof 0.2 bar can be achieved with stock motors. For maximum controllability, ( n ) between the motor and the load should be less than 10, but ideally close to 1.

[0042] The value of Jmby is approximated by taking the Mini Cheetah actuator ( Jmc,Dmc, Lmc) and proportionally scaling it. Inertia scales with MR2for a disk. In some examples, it is complicated to measure the mass function for a motor purely based on rotor diameter, as the thickness of the magnets varies. However, in some examples, stock motors with sizes sufficient for use in the elastic actuator magnets with a thickness that scales linearly with diameter.

[0043] Combining this with the equation for AD2above results in the following equation, which allows varying the \motor based on our torque requirements, and a desired inertia ratio, where cmc= 9.38 kg / m2. Because the inertia ratio metric being less than 10 is useful in cases where the finger is in the air, J, can be set to:3.2 Transmission Stiffness and Torsional Spring

[0044] The stiffness of the transmission determines how much bandwidth the actuator has and the peak torque due to impact that is received. The transmission can be made very stiff, and thus have a higher bandwidth, but that means it will see higher peak torques and will need a stronger transmission. The transmission can also be made very elastic and thus very resistant to impacts, but then the bandwidth could be too low to do any agile behaviors like playing piano. The transmission is designed to be somewhere between those extremes to have the best performance possible while maintaining the impact peak torque at a safe point.

[0045] Assuming the actuator makes a full-speed collision against an object and the load end comes to a complete stop, then all the inertial energy from the motor and the transmission will be stored into the spring.

[0046] The peak torque from the collision will be at this maximum spring displacement.

[0047] For the bandwidth of the system, the open-loop force bandwidth can be approximated as the natural frequency of the motor. The open-loop force bandwidthmntnrwhich is the bandwidth of T, s)lTtf.s ) is useful to determine what torque profiles can be used. The natural frequency of the load, a>n loadis also determined from 6ioads')l0motors'), which provides insight into how fast the load can be moved with an ideal motor.

[0048] In the case of playing piano, the inertia of the load will end up being much higher than that of the motor, so we chose to have the bandwidth of the load while playing the piano be the driving factor when choosing the stiffness. The minimum stiffness we need in order to play the piano is:3.3 Transmission Gearing

[0049] For the transmission, one of the gears will be the first to lead to failure. This point leads to the maximum allowed stiffness k. . The Lewis equation is used to calculate the bending stress on the gears that will lead to failure. These gears have a module ( m gear ratio to the output of ( Ngear), width of (), safety factor ( SF ), material yield strength (crv), and Lewis factor ( / ):

[0050] The maximum stiffness before gear breakage is determined as:4 ELASTIC ACTUATOR DESIGN

[0051] The gear train, motor, and elastic element for the elastic actuator 100 are designed based on the series elastic actuator characterization above.4.1 Gear Train Design

[0052] Before sizing the motor, the load that a gear train small enough to fit in the elastic actuator 100 is capable of sustaining is determined. The determined load restricts the range of gear ratios that can be used in the actuator 100.

[0053] In some examples, the maximum allowable height of a gear in the gear train is 15mm (see the functional requirements of FIG. 4). In the design of FIGs. 1 and 2, 0.5 module gears are used, as there are stock gear options available at this size. For a gear of 15mm diameter made of carbon steel ( / = 0.35, (j,. = 415mPa,m = 0.5mm ), would result in a maximum driving torque of 0.36 Nm for every 1 mm of width using a safety factor of 3 for longevity (according to the equations in section 3.2). To be able to drive 0.67 Nm of torque at the last stage requires at least 2 mm of width at the last stage. For that reason, in some examples, all the gears in the actuator design have at least 2 mm in width.

[0054] In some examples, the maximum gear ratio is limited to around 8: 1 through three stages of 2: 1 reduction (as can be seen in FIG. 1). A benefit of having this type of low gear reduction is that friction from early gear stages does not get scaled as much, leading to a lower torque dead band.

[0055] In some examples, a gear ratio of 6: 1 is used to due to motor selection, with a 1 :2, 1:2, 1 : 1.5 setup.4.2 Motor Selection

[0056] In general, to minimize the width of the elastic actuator, the motor is sized to fit between two walls (see FIG. 2). In order to maximize torque, the diameter of the motor is maximized. For example, the length of the torque is lined up with the width of the finger, to provide room for the motor to grow in diameter while constraining length. A length (L) of 10mm is approximately the amount of space available inside of the knuckle. Using this value alongside the values from FIG. 4, a proper motor for the elastic actuator 100 can be identified.

[0057] Ideally, the inertia ratio between the load and motor of the actuator 100 is close to one for controllability, however, this may result in a motor that has a very high gear ratio (100+) and small diameter. Using the characterization in section 3.1 above, an optimal diameter of 4.1mm, but with a gear ratio of 125: 1 is identified. This may be possible using a planetary gearbox or other methods; however, this would end up losing significant efficiency, reduce back drivability due to friction, and add significant space. At the same time, a gearbox for a 4mm motor would have gears too small to be capable of holding the required torques. This can be problematic because the limit on the gear ratio of 8: 1 (discussed above) means the ideal transmission cannot be used and a compromise is required. By implementing an 8: 1 gear ratio, the diameter must be 17mm to meet the required torque. With these values, the inertia ratio is 4. Based on the spaceconstraints, this system would be a working one, despite having a higher inertia ratio than desired.

[0058] Interest in RC quadcopters and cars has increased the availability of motors of this size. Most of them are rated for high speeds, like propellers for micro drones, but there is a series of motors that are of the desired size and built for torque density. These are motors used for camera gimbals. These motors feature low kV values of 100-500 (RPM / V), and low cogging torques. These properties lead to smooth operation when in position control. The smallest stock gimbal motor found is size 2204, with a can OD of 28mm and can length of 13mm. This motor is rated for 0.13 Nm of torque, and 1920 RPM. This is about 35% less torque than the ideal model of a motor this size, but more than enough for use in the elastic actuator 100. Due to the increased torque from the 17mm optimal size, an 8: 1 gear ratio is not required and a 6: 1 ratio is used to decrease size even further while still meeting torque requirements. This leads to a final inertia ratio of 1.39.4.3 Elastic Element

[0059] Referring to FIGs. 6-8, due to the need to optimize for size, a coil spring is too large for use in the transmission. So, rather than using a coil spring, the second stage input gear is designed to act as a torsional spring — it is an elastic gear. For example, the torsional spring is integrated into the second stage input gear by using 2mm x 2mm square rubber O-rings 620 sandwiched between an inside portion 622 press-fit onto the shaft (not shown), and an outer ring 624 that holds the gear teeth as seen in Figure 6. This design allows elasticity without adding any space.

[0060] FIGs. 6-8 show three different designs for the elastic gear. The elastic gear 608 of FIG. 6 stretches from pure shear. The elastic gear 708 of FIG. 7 stretches from pure compression. The elastic gear 808 of FIG. 8 uses both compression and shear.

[0061] In some examples, the the maximum and minimum stiffnesses allowed for the elastic actuator 100 system are: k. ,mii mm= 5.17 Nm / rad and ktorswn m^ = 22.9 Nm / rad .These values are defined at the output of the actuator. Since the elastic element is in the second stage after which has a 1.5:1 gear reduction to the output, the stiffness needed from the physical spring is: ktorswn / 1.52. This leads us to an elastic coupling stiffness range of 2.24 Nm / rad to 10.16 Nm / rad.

[0062] When evaluated using simplified models of shear and compression, the elastic gear 608 of FIG. 6 ends up with a stiffness of 0.69 Nm / rad, the elastic gear 708 of FIG. 7 with a stiffness of 12.15 Nm / rad, and the elastic gear 808 of FIG. 8 allows modulation between the two and one example has a stiffness of 5.41 Nm / rad.4.4 Other Elements

[0063] In some examples, each of the gears is press fit onto 3mm diameter shafts, undersized by 18 ± 3 / zm using high speed reamers. Each gear train shaft is 3mm in diameter and is supported by oil embedded sleeve bearings on each side rated for 95N of radial loading. The shear stress in the press fit interface is 11.8 MPa when at full torque, significantly below the shear strength of carbon steel.

[0064] Two 16-bit MA782 encoders are added on the outside of the structure for position sensing, one before and one after the elastic element. This allows for both position and force sensing, Tup to a resolution of 4mNm.

[0065] The first stage includes a belt (shown in FIG. 1) that is a 3mm wide MXL timing belt and is fully rated for long-term use. The third stage includes another belt that is strength rated for twice the force it is expected to endure.

[0066] A number of embodiments of the invention have been described.Nevertheless, it is to be understood that the foregoing description is intended to illustrate and not to limit the scope of the invention, which is defined by the scope of the following claims. Accordingly, other embodiments are also within the scope of the following claims. For example, various modifications may be made without departing from the scope of the invention. Additionally, some of the steps described above may be order independent, and thus can be performed in an order different from that described.

Claims

WHAT IS CLAIMED IS:

1. An actuator comprising: a motor; and a gear train configured to couple the motor to a load, the gear train including a first gear with a toothed outer section and a central section coupled to the toothed outer section by an elastic inner section; wherein a difference in an angle of rotation of the toothed outer section and an angle of rotation of the central section causes tensile and / or compressive stress in the elastic inner section.

2. The actuator of claim 1 wherein the actuator is a series elastic actuator.

3. The actuator of claim any one of claims 1 and 2 wherein the elastic inner section is circular.

4. The actuator of claim 3 wherein the elastic inner section is subjected to pure shear stress when the actuator is impacted.

5. The actuator any one of claims 1 to 4 wherein the elastic inner section is noncircular.

6. The actuator of any one of claims 1 to 5 wherein the elastic inner section is diamond shaped.

7. The actuator of claim 6 wherein the elastic inner section is subjected to both compression and shear stress when the actuator is impacted.

8. The actuator of any one of claims 1 to 7 wherein the elastic section is star shaped.

9. The actuator of any one of claims 1 to 8 wherein the elastic section is square shaped.

10. The actuator of any one of claims 1 to 9 wherein elastic section is made from an elastomeric material11. The actuator of any one of claims 1 to 10 wherein the elastic section is a flexure structure formed between the toothed outer section and the central section.

12. The actuator of any one of claims 1 to 11 wherein the actuator is sized and shaped according to a size and shape of a finger.

13. The actuator of any one of claims 1 to 12 wherein the actuator is included in a robotic finger.

14. The actuator of claim 13 wherein the load is an articulated section of the robotic finger.

15. The actuator of claim 13 wherein the robotic finger includes a plurality of joints.

16. The actuator of claim 15 wherein the robotic finger includes one or more actuators located at the joints.

17. The actuator of any one of claims 1 to 16 wherein at least one of a size of the motor, a gearing ratio of the gear train, and a stiffness of the elastic inner section is designed according to functional requirements for torque, inertia, bandwidth, and size.

18. The actuator of claim 18 wherein the functional requirements correspond to the operation of a human hand.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Articulated robot actuator

    US20180133894A1

  • Robot finger driving module using differential gear characteristics and robot hand including the same

    US8894117B1