Electronic component reuse support system and electronic component reuse support method

The electronic component reuse support system addresses the challenge of supply and demand imbalance by standardizing and selecting electronic components based on functional blocks and LCA, enhancing reuse rates and recycling efficiency while reducing environmental impact.

WO2024247337A1PCT designated stage expired Publication Date: 2024-12-05HITACHI LTD
View PDF 3 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
PCT/JP2023/046757
Authority / Receiving Office
WO · WO
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2023-06-02
Filing Date
2023-12-26
Publication Date
2024-12-05

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The existing methods for electronic component reuse face challenges in maintaining a balance between supply and demand due to changes in product specifications and sales discontinuation, leading to a decrease in reusable components and disrupted recycling rates.

Method used

An electronic component reuse support system that uses a computer to standardize and select electronic components based on functional blocks, calculating performance and Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) to identify common components that can be reused across multiple products, thereby improving recycling rates and reducing environmental impact.

Benefits of technology

The system enhances the reuse rate of electronic components by making them common across multiple products, improving the recycling rate and contributing to reduced environmental impact by optimizing the selection of electronic components for reuse and recycling.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure JP2023046757_05122024_PF_FP_ABST
    Figure JP2023046757_05122024_PF_FP_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

Provided are an electronic component reuse support system and an electronic component reuse support method that contribute to reduction of an environmental load by improving the recycling rate of electronic components. The electronic component reuse support system uses a computer to support reuse of electronic components for a target product on which a plurality of functional blocks constituted by a plurality of electronic components are mounted, the system being characterized in that: a storage unit of the computer stores a function blocking program for performing block division of data of the target product, said data being divided into data of the functional blocks, a grouping program for performing grouping for each functional block having the same function, and a common component selection program for calculating the performance and the LCA of the functional block in each group so as to determine the electronic component to be used in the functional block having the best evaluation value; a calculation unit of the computer executes the function blocking program so as to divide, into blocks and by function and performance, data of a plurality of types of functional blocks mounted on a plurality of target products, executes the grouping program, thereby grouping the divided functional blocks by function and performance, and executes the common component selection program, thereby calculating the performance and LCA of each functional block for each group so as to determine and present, as a common electronic component, the electronic component used in the functional block having the best evaluation value.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Electronic component reuse support system and electronic component reuse support method

[0001] The present invention relates to an electronic component reuse support system and an electronic component reuse support method.

[0002] In recent years, in the industrial systems field, it has become increasingly important to achieve both high reliability and environmental friendliness in electronic systems in order to ensure long-term operation and reduce environmental impact.

[0003] To create products that are both highly reliable and environmentally friendly, it is essential to design the parts used in the products to have a long lifespan to ensure stable operation of the products, and to recycle parts that have sufficient remaining life when the products are disposed of so that they can be used in new products, thereby recycling resources.

[0004] In the field of industrial systems, there is a growing demand to calculate and evaluate GHG / CO2 emissions using LCA (Life Cycle Assessment) at each stage of a product's life cycle (manufacturing / distribution / use / disposal).

[0005] When considering recycling electronic components to improve LCA, since electronic components are made up of various materials, reducing them down to the material level generates a large amount of waste. For this reason, it is considered optimal to reuse electronic components at the component level.

[0006] With regard to the reuse of electronic components, Patent Document 1 proposes, with the aim of predicting and evaluating as accurately as possible the environmental impact and costs arising from a group of products in a multi-generational product series and enabling reuse and recycling to be carried out, "storing information on items to be reused and recycled, using this information to select items to be reused and recycled that can be diverted from recovered products into new products, performing life cycle modeling to combine the selected items to be reused and recycled in order to assemble the new products, approximately predicting the collection distribution of products to be reused as a superposition of two or more arbitrary shapes in order to predict the collection amount of items to be reused and recycled using the life cycle model, setting at least one of the arbitrary shapes as a peak at the product value life or product useful life, and evaluating the environmental impact and costs to be borne in the case of reuse or recycling based on the prediction results."

[0007] Japanese Patent Application Laid-Open No. 2003-203138

[0008] However, with conventional methods, when electronic parts are collected and reused after the end of product use, it is assumed that all reusable electronic parts can be used in newly manufactured products.However, there is a possibility that the number of products in which parts can be reused may decrease or disappear due to factors such as parts changes to expand the functionality or improve performance of the newly manufactured product, or the discontinuation of sales of the product.

[0009] In other words, as the number of users of collected electronic parts decreases, the balance between the amount of collected electronic parts (supply) and the destinations for reuse (demand) is disrupted, and the recycling rate falls. For this reason, when designing and developing products that incorporate electronic parts that are intended to be reused, it is essential to plan the demand and supply of reused parts by making them reusable in other products in advance.

[0010] In light of the above, the present invention addresses the issue of a decrease in the number of uses for reusable electronic parts due to changes in product specifications or the discontinuation of product sales, by standardizing the types of electronic parts installed in a single product and the types of electronic parts used in multiple products while satisfying product specifications and LCA, thereby expanding the range of products and components for which recovered reusable parts can be used, improving the recycling rate of electronic parts and contributing to a reduction in the environmental burden. We provide an electronic part reuse support system and method.

[0011] In view of the above, the present invention provides an electronic component reuse support system that uses a computer to support the reuse of electronic components in a target product equipped with a plurality of functional blocks each composed of a plurality of electronic components, wherein the computer's memory stores a functional blocking program that uses data of the target product to divide the data into functional blocks, a grouping program that groups functional blocks of the same function, and a common components selection program that calculates the performance and LCA of the functional blocks in each group and determines the electronic components to be used in the functional block with the highest evaluation value, and the computer's calculation unit executes the functional blocking program to divide data of a plurality of types of functional blocks equipped in a plurality of target products into blocks by function / performance, executes the grouping program to group the divided functional blocks by function / performance, and executes the common components selection program to calculate the performance and LCA of each functional block for each group and determine and present the electronic components to be used in the functional block with the highest evaluation value as common electronic components.

[0012] The present invention provides an electronic component reuse support method that uses a computer to support the reuse of electronic components in a target product equipped with a plurality of functional blocks each composed of a plurality of electronic components, wherein a memory unit of the computer stores a functional blocking program that uses data of the target product to divide the data into functional blocks, a grouping program that groups functional blocks with the same function, and a common components selection program that calculates the performance and LCA of the functional blocks in each group and determines the electronic components to be used in the functional block with the highest evaluation value, and an arithmetic unit of the computer executes the functional blocking program to divide the data of a plurality of types of functional blocks equipped in the plurality of target products into blocks by function / performance, executes the grouping program to group the divided functional blocks by function / performance, and executes the common components selection program to calculate the performance and LCA of each functional block for each group and determine and present the electronic components to be used in the functional block with the highest evaluation value as common electronic components.

[0013] According to the present invention, by standardizing parts used in a plurality of products, the reuse rate of electronic parts can be improved.

[0014] FIG. 1 is a diagram showing an example of the schematic configuration of a processor system suitable for applying an electronic component reuse support system according to an embodiment of the present invention. FIG. 2 is a diagram showing an example of the configuration of a circuit board as an example of an electronic component handled by the present invention. FIG. 3 is a diagram showing an example of the configuration of an electronic component reuse support system. FIG. 4 is a diagram showing an example of a netlist as circuit board 30 data D1. FIG. 5 is a diagram showing an example of design data as circuit board 30 data D1. FIG. 6 is a diagram showing an example of data of function blocks 31, 32, 33 obtained by analyzing circuit board data D1 by a function blocking program Pr1. FIG. 7 is a flow chart showing an example of a process for standardizing electronic components. FIG. 8 is a diagram showing the usage stages of the present invention.

[0015] Hereinafter, an embodiment of the present invention will be described with reference to the drawings.

[0016] 1 is a diagram showing an example of the general configuration of a processor system suitable for applying an electronic component reuse support system according to an embodiment of the present invention. The processor system 10 is configured by connecting a storage unit DB, a processor 12, and a user interface 13 via a bus 11.

[0017] The storage unit DB is composed of a program storage unit DB1 and a data storage unit DB2. The program storage unit DB1 includes a function blocking program Pr1, a grouping program Pr2, and a common component selection program Pr3 as programs that are read out and executed by the processor 12. The data storage unit DB2 includes a circuit board database DB21 that stores circuit board data D1, a component characteristic database DB22 that stores component characteristic data D2, and a group database DB23 that stores group data D3.

[0018] The processor 12 refers to the programs Pr1, Pr2, Pr3 and the databases DB21, DB22, DB23 in response to instructions given by the user OP via the user interface 13, stores the obtained results in the databases DB21, DB22, DB23 as appropriate, and also visualizes and presents the processing results to the user via the user interface 13.

[0019] 2 shows an example of the configuration of a circuit board as an example of an electronic component of a target product handled by this invention. Circuit board 30 is composed of multiple functional blocks, such as a power supply unit 31, a sensor unit 32, and a communication unit 33. Furthermore, each of functional blocks 31, 32, and 33 is composed of circuit components (31a-31c, 32a-32c, and 33a-33c) such as resistors, inductors, capacitors, operational amplifiers, and memories.

[0020] This invention aims to establish an electronic component reuse support system that enables the common use of circuit components. Examples of electronic components that are particularly desirable for reuse include operational amplifiers and memory. For example, in the case of operational amplifiers (Example 1 of commonality), semiconductor manufacturers manufacture and sell semiconductors with similar performance, and manufacturers use different semiconductors for each product / board based on the designer's experience and track record. Therefore, if a single semiconductor can be standardized across products based on LCA, reuse can be promoted. Similarly, in the case of memory (Example 2 of commonality), semiconductor manufacturers sell semiconductors based on performance (capacity), and manufacturers use the minimum memory capacity required for each product / board. Therefore, if a single semiconductor can be standardized across products based on performance (capacity) and LCA, reuse can be promoted.

[0021] 3 is a diagram showing an example of the configuration of an electronic component reuse support system. Circuit board data D1 for circuit board 30 is stored in circuit board database DB21, component characteristic data D2 for circuit components (31a-31c, 32a-32c, 33a-33c) is stored in component characteristic database DB22, and group data D3 for function blocks 31, 32, and 33 is stored in group database DB23 in advance, with additional data being added sequentially. Also, by displaying function blocking program Pr1, grouping program Pr2, and common component selection program Pr3, the system clearly shows what each program Pr inputs and what it obtains.

[0022] 4a and 4b are diagrams showing an example of data D1 (circuit board data) for a circuit board 30 stored in the circuit board database DB21. The netlist D1A in Fig. 4a is data that expresses the circuit wiring in text, and Fig. 4b shows design data D1B organized as information including, for example, a parts list D1a, design specification data D1b, a reference subgraph data group D1c, and block designation data / labeling data D1d. These data are either saved in advance or newly entered by the user to instruct analysis.

[0023] 5 shows an example of data for functional blocks 31, 32, and 33 obtained by analyzing data D1 (circuit board data) for circuit board 30 by function block program Pr1. This determines the configuration of the functional blocks possessed by each board. In this example, it is determined that board 1, board 2, and board 3 are mounted inside device A, and that board 1 has a 12V power supply and temperature sensor function, board 2 has a 15V power supply and communication function, and board 3 has a 15V power supply and temperature sensor function block. Note that determining the configuration of the functional blocks possessed by each board is a preliminary step to the next process, and the configuration itself is positioned as an intermediate product, so it is not shown as a database configuration.

[0024] In this way, the circuit board database DB1 contains circuit data (netlists, etc.) and design specification data for multiple circuit boards mounted on multiple devices. The function blocking program Pr1 reads the data in the circuit board database DB1 related to each circuit board of each device specified by the user OP, divides the circuit into blocks based on function and performance from the netlist shown in Figure 4a and the design specification data shown in Figure 4b, and outputs data with a configuration such as the example shown in Figure 5.

[0025] There are several methods for processing the functional block program Pr1. For example, this process can be performed automatically using graph database mining processing, or the circuit can be divided into blocks based on design specification data that indicates the range of functional blocks specified by the designer.

[0026] 6 is a diagram showing the contents obtained as a result of the grouping program processing. It is a diagram showing an example of a group data configuration. The grouping program Pr2 groups the function blocks by their functions and performance based on the function block data (function block data) D1 of FIG. 5, outputs the example data configuration shown in this figure as function block data D3, and stores it in the group database DB3.

[0027] The group data D3 in Figure 6 is a group D3a that conversely groups together equipment types D3b and board types D3c that have the same functions and performance from the perspective of function and performance. For example, equipment types D3b and D3c whose function is a temperature sensor and whose performance is 0-120 degrees are organized as boards 1 and 3 of equipment A, boards 2 and 4 of equipment B, and boards 1 and 2 of equipment C.

[0028] There are several methods for processing the grouping program Pr2. For example, this process can be performed automatically using graph database mining processing, or functional blocks can be grouped based on design specification data that indicates the labeling of the functions and performance of each functional block specified by the designer.

[0029] Although no examples are shown for the component characteristic data D2 stored in the component characteristic database DB22 in FIGS. 1 and 3, the specifications and characteristics of various components used on the board are stored.

[0030] 3 shows the data contents of each database DB1, DB2, and DB3, as well as the function block program Pr1 and grouping program Pr2 for obtaining this data. Based on this premise, the series of processing programs shown in FIG. 7 are executed in the processor system 10 shown in FIG.

[0031] 7 is a flow diagram showing an example of a process for standardizing electronic components. This process begins in process step S41 when the user OP specifies the target product and board via the user interface 13.

[0032] In processing step S41, the function blocking program Pr1 is executed to read the netlist D1A and design data D1B of the target board from the circuit board database DB1 and divide the board into circuit blocks, thereby obtaining data for the function blocks 31, 32, and 33 in FIG. 4. In processing step S42, the grouping program Pr2 is executed to store the grouped circuit block data D2 in the group database DB2. The processing up to this point is as described above. The subsequent processing is carried out based on this premise.

[0033] As the next step, the common parts selection program Pr3 is executed. In the common parts selection program Pr3, processing steps S43 to S46 are executed in sequence. Here, the target product and board specified by the user OP are analyzed, and the group data D2 stored in the group database DB2 is processed as the target. In the example of FIG. 4, the target data is the device type and board type with a function of a temperature sensor and a performance of 0-120 degrees.

[0034] Specifically, in processing step S43, the functional block data for one group is read from the group database DB2, and the LCA of each functional block is calculated. Next, in processing step S44, the performance of each functional block is compared to check whether the performance of all functional blocks can be included. Also in processing step S44, the calculated LCAs of each functional block are compared, and the electronic components with the best performance are selected as common electronic components. Finally, in processing step S45, the circuit data of the board replaced with the common components is replaced and saved in the circuit board database DB3.

[0035] In process step S46, the process is repeated until the process for all groups is completed, and in process step S47, the circuit board with the replaced electronic components is redesigned. Note that the processes in process steps S46 and S47 correspond to the component replacement change design in FIG. 3.

[0036] Returning to Figure 3, this figure shows an example of the overall configuration of a system for standardizing electronic components. As shown in this figure, when the electronic components of each board mounted on product A and product B are input into a processor system 10, the processor system extracts the components that can be standardized and outputs the circuit data (net list / component list) after standardization.

[0037] In the example shown in the figure, for given product A and product B, after the processing of the present invention, components A, B, and C on board 1 of product A are selected electronic components, and component C on board 2 of product A, component A on board 1 of product B, and components A and B on board 2 of product B are common components.

[0038] 8 is a diagram showing the stages of use of the present invention, which shows that the present invention can be used in the stages of use planning and detailed design among the series of stages from the conceptual design stage to the stages of use planning, detailed design, parts procurement, manufacturing, inspection, and shipping.

[0039] Specifically, for example, after the circuit board specifications are formulated and detailed design is performed within the engineering chain, the detailed design circuit data and design specification data are input into the processor system 10 to obtain the common circuit data (netlist / components list). The designer verifies the common circuit data (through simulation analysis, etc.) to confirm that there are no problems in terms of device specifications, device operation, maintenance, and electronic component procurement. This constitutes an electronic component reuse support system that can contribute to the reuse of electronic components.

[0040] In summary, the processor system 10 shown in FIG. 1 specifically selects common electronic components from circuit data (netlists / components lists) for multiple types of circuit boards mounted on multiple products, and replaces the electronic components of functional blocks in the group with the selected common electronic components. The processor system 10 also extracts and groups functional blocks from the circuit data (netlists / components lists) by function / performance, and selects the electronic components with the best LCA performance among the functional blocks in the group. The processor system 10 also outputs the circuit data (netlists / components lists) after replacement with the common electronic components. This processor system 10 standardizes electronic components used in each product, expanding the scope of reuse and improving the reuse rate of electronic components.

[0041] In the second embodiment, various processes in the series of processes shown in FIG. 7 will be collectively described.

[0042] First, there are multiple ways to implement each processing flow in Figure 7. For example, one example of functional block processing is graph database mining. In this case, the circuit structure described in the netlist is treated as a graph topology, and all of the subgraphs are generated. The circuit corresponding to this subgraph is determined to be one circuit block. As a method for generating subgraphs, for example, techniques such as Oblivious and HDRF, which are distributed graph processing, are used.

[0043] Another example of functional block processing is designation by the designer, who specifies a circuit range for each function in advance when designing the target circuit board. During circuit block processing, this specified range is determined as one circuit block.

[0044] One example of grouping processing is graph database mining. In this case, a reference subgraph is prepared in advance for each circuit function and performance. Graph isomorphism search processing is used to determine whether each subgraph obtained in the functional block processing is isomorphic to the reference subgraph. Graph isomorphism search processing uses, for example, a greedy search method.

[0045] Another example of grouping is labeling by the designer, where circuit blocks are designated and labeled with their functions and capabilities when designing the target circuit board.

[0046] It is advisable to consider the following points when selecting common components. First, regarding lifespan, it is best to select electronic components with the lowest power consumption (lowest heat generation) in order to extend the lifespan of electronic components assuming reuse. Regarding the environment, it is best to calculate the LCA (Life Cycle Assessment) of the electronic components and select the components with the best GHG / CO2 emissions. Regarding economy, it is best to take economic efficiency into consideration and select the "cheapest electronic components" or "components that can be most stably procured." It is also best to combine the viewpoints of lifespan, environment, and economy, assign weights to each, and add them all up to select the electronic components with the best balance.

[0047] Furthermore, LCA is recommended to use low power consumption, low environmental load materials, and reuse parts.

[0048] 10: Processor system DB: Storage unit 11: Bus 12: Processor 12 13: User interface 13 Connected by the bus 11. DB1: Program storage unit DB2: Data storage unit Pr1: Functional block program Pr2: Grouping program Pr3: Common component selection program DB21: Circuit board database DB22: Component characteristics database DB23: Group database 30: Circuit board 31: Power supply unit 32: Sensor unit 33: Communication unit 31a-31c, 32a-32c, 33a-33c: Circuit components

Claims

1. An electronic component reuse support system that uses a computer to support the reuse of electronic components for a target product equipped with multiple functional blocks composed of multiple electronic components, wherein the computer's memory unit stores a function blocking program that uses data of the target product to block-divide data of the functional blocks, a grouping program that groups the functional blocks having the same function, and a common components selection program that calculates the performance and LCA of the functional blocks in each group and determines the electronic components used in the functional block with the highest evaluation value, and the computer's calculation unit executes the function blocking program to block-divide data of multiple types of functional blocks equipped in multiple target products by function / performance, executes the grouping program to group the divided functional blocks by function / performance, and executes the common components selection program to calculate the performance and LCA of each functional block for each group, and determines and presents the electronic components used in the functional block with the highest evaluation value as common electronic components.

2. An electronic component reuse support system as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that the computer memory unit further holds data on the target product, grouped data and data on electronic components.

3. An electronic component reuse support system as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that the LCA is one or more of low power consumption, usage rate of low environmental load materials, and reuse of parts.

4. An electronic component reuse support system as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that the data of the target product is a netlist, which is data expressing circuit wiring in text form, and design data.

5. An electronic component reuse support system as described in claim 1, characterized in that by executing the common component selection program, the performance and LCA of each functional block for each group are calculated, and the functional block with the best evaluation value is determined to be a common functional block and presented.

6. An electronic component reuse support system according to claim 1, wherein the common electronic components are semiconductor components such as operational amplifiers or memories.

7. A method for supporting the reuse of electronic components using a computer for a target product equipped with a plurality of functional blocks composed of a plurality of electronic components, wherein a memory unit of the computer stores a functional blocking program for dividing data of the target product into blocks of the functional blocks, a grouping program for grouping the functional blocks having the same function, and a common components selection program for calculating the performance and LCA of the functional blocks in each group and determining the electronic components used in the functional block with the highest evaluation value, and an arithmetic unit of the computer executes the functional blocking program to divide data of a plurality of types of the functional blocks equipped in the plurality of target products into blocks by function / performance, executes the grouping program to group the divided functional blocks by function / performance, and executes the common components selection program to calculate the performance and LCA of each functional block for each group and determine and present the electronic components used in the functional block with the highest evaluation value as common electronic components.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Device and method for supporting product life cycle plan and medium device for recording program

    JP1999288427A

  • Development method and reuse method for reuse parts, and electric apparatus

    JP2002215681A

  • System, which uses set base design method, for supporting design of optimized product

    JP2010055466A