Method for evaluating implementation effect of traffic stabilization measure combination
By obtaining the implementation probability and traffic information of the sub-region in the combination of traffic stability and tranquility measures, and evaluating the effect of the combination of measures with inverse probability weighting methods, the problem of low evaluation efficiency and accuracy in the prior art is solved, and traffic stability and tranquility is achieved Efficient evaluation and comparability analysis of the combination of measures.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202411463946.1
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-10-21
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-22
- Estimated Expiration
- Not applicable · inactive patent
AI Technical Summary
The existing combination of traffic stability and tranquility measures cannot be accurately defined and evaluated the implementation effect of multiple combinations of measures, and is susceptible to interference factors, resulting in low evaluation efficiency and accuracy.
By obtaining the combination of measures corresponding to multiple sub-regions of the evaluation area, the implementation probability of each sub-region is determined, and the inverse probability weighting method is used to evaluate the implementation effect of each combination of measures combined with traffic information to reduce the impact of interference factors.
Improve evaluation efficiency and accuracy, realize synchronous evaluation and comparability analysis of multiple combinations of measures, and reduce evaluation errors.
Smart Images

Figure CN119005756A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention relates to an implementation effect evaluation method for a combination of traffic calming measures, and belongs to the technical field of road design. Background Art
[0002] Traffic calming is a general term for speed reduction technology in road design. It aims to reduce the speed of motor vehicles through hard facilities (such as physical measures, etc.) and soft facilities (such as policies, legislation, technical standards, etc.) of the road system, prompt motor vehicle drivers to change reckless driving behavior, and reduce the negative impact of motor vehicles on residents' living environment, thereby achieving the purpose of improving road traffic safety and improving the quality of life of residents.
[0003] In order to clarify the actual effects of various traffic calming measures and their combinations, and to provide a scientific basis for the planning and management of subsequent related facilities, it is necessary to evaluate the effectiveness of implemented traffic calming measures. However, the existing evaluation methods cannot accurately define and evaluate the implementation effects of multiple traffic calming measures in combination, and it is difficult to effectively reduce the impact of interference factors other than traffic calming measures on the evaluation results, resulting in low evaluation efficiency and accuracy. Summary of the invention
[0004] The present invention provides a method for evaluating the implementation effect of a combination of traffic calming measures, which can solve the problem that the prior art cannot evaluate the implementation effects of a combination of multiple traffic calming measures and is easily affected by interference factors.
[0005] The present invention provides a method for evaluating the implementation effect of a combination of traffic calming measures, the method comprising: S1. Obtain a combination of measures corresponding to each of the multiple sub-areas of the assessment area; S2. determining the implementation probability of each combination of measures for each sub-region according to the traffic information of multiple sub-regions before and after the implementation of the traffic calming measures in the assessment region; S3. Determine the implementation effect of each measure combination according to the implementation probability, the traffic information and the measure combinations corresponding to all sub-areas.
[0006] Optionally, the plurality of sub-areas include a plurality of first sub-areas where traffic calming measures have been implemented and a plurality of second sub-areas where traffic calming measures have not been implemented.
[0007] Optionally, the traffic information includes built environment information, population information and vehicle traffic information of each sub-area before the assessment area implements traffic calming measures; and the number of traffic accidents in each sub-area after the assessment area implements traffic calming measures.
[0008] Optionally, S3 is specifically: S31, determining an inverse probability weighted value of each measure combination corresponding to the number of traffic accidents in each sub-region according to the implementation probability, the number of traffic accidents, and the measure combinations corresponding to all sub-regions; S32. Determine the implementation effect of each combination of measures according to the inverse probability weighted value.
[0009] Optionally, the S31 is specifically: According to the measure combinations corresponding to all sub-regions, the discrimination coefficient of each sub-region corresponding to each measure combination is determined; An inverse probability weighted value of each measure combination corresponding to each sub-region is determined according to the discrimination coefficient, the implementation probability and the traffic accident volume.
[0010] Optionally, the S32 is specifically: The difference between the sum of the inverse probability weighted values of all first sub-regions corresponding to any measure combination and the sum of the inverse probability weighted values of all second sub-regions is determined as the implementation effect of the corresponding measure combination.
[0011] Optionally, the implementation probability of each combination of measures corresponding to each sub-region is determined in S2, specifically: Logistic models were used to determine the probability of implementation of each combination of measures for each sub-region.
[0012] Optionally, after S2, the method further includes: When any implementation probability is less than a preset probability, the corresponding sub-region is removed from the multiple sub-regions; The implementation probability of each measure combination corresponding to each sub-region in the updated multiple sub-regions is re-determined until all implementation probabilities are greater than or equal to the preset probability.
[0013] Optionally, the built environment information includes road network density, residential land proportion, commercial land proportion and green land proportion.
[0014] Optionally, the vehicle traffic information includes the annual average daily transit motor vehicle traffic volume and the annual average daily transit non-motor vehicle traffic volume.
[0015] The beneficial effects that the present invention can produce include: The present invention selects multiple sub-regions in the assessment area where traffic calming measures have been implemented and multiple sub-regions where traffic calming measures have not been implemented, and determines the implementation probability of each measure combination corresponding to each sub-region based on the traffic information of multiple sub-regions before and after the implementation of traffic calming measures in the assessment area, and then determines the implementation effect of each measure combination in the assessment area in combination with the measure combinations actually implemented in all sub-regions and related traffic information, thereby achieving synchronous evaluation of multiple measure combinations implemented in the assessment area, which is beneficial to improving evaluation efficiency and reducing evaluation errors. At the same time, since the implementation effects of multiple measure combinations are all obtained based on the same evaluation process and traffic information, this makes the evaluation results of different measure combinations comparable, which is beneficial to comparative analysis of multiple measure combinations.
[0016] The present invention uses the inverse probability weighting method to process the relevant data of multiple sub-areas, which can narrow the inherent differences in traffic safety levels between the sub-areas, thereby reducing the impact of interference factors other than traffic calming measures on the assessment, which is conducive to improving the accuracy of the assessment. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0017] Figure 1 A flow chart of a method for evaluating the implementation effect of a combination of traffic calming measures provided in an embodiment of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0018] The present invention is described in detail below in conjunction with embodiments, but the present invention is not limited to these embodiments.
[0019] The embodiment of the present invention provides a method for evaluating the implementation effect of a combination of traffic calming measures, such as Figure 1 As shown, the method includes: S1. Obtain a combination of measures corresponding to each of the multiple sub-areas of the assessment area; S2. Determine the implementation probability of each combination of measures for each sub-region based on the traffic information of multiple sub-regions before and after the implementation of traffic calming measures in the assessment region; S3. Determine the implementation effect of each measure combination according to the implementation probability, traffic information and the measure combinations corresponding to all sub-areas.
[0020] Specifically, the plurality of sub-areas include a plurality of first sub-areas where traffic calming measures have been implemented and a plurality of second sub-areas where traffic calming measures have not been implemented.
[0021] Specifically, the measure combination is a combination setting of multiple traffic calming measures, and the multiple traffic calming measures may include speed limit signs, physical speed limit facilities, bicycle or pedestrian lanes, etc. It is worth noting that this embodiment only considers the measure combination actually implemented in all first sub-areas and all second sub-areas.
[0022] For example, the settings of the three traffic calming measures in the sub-area, namely speed limit signs, physical speed limit facilities and dedicated lanes, are represented as , and , then: If a speed limit sign has been set in the sub-area If no speed limit sign is set ; If physical speed limit facilities have been installed in the sub-area If no physical speed limit facilities are set up ; Dedicated lanes have been set up in the sub-areas No dedicated lanes are set up .
[0023] Since each traffic calming measure has two settings: set and not set, a total of eight measure combinations can be obtained by combining the settings of the three traffic calming measures. The measure combinations are represented as , assuming that the sub-area will only set up physical speed limit facilities under the condition that speed limit signs are set up, that is, and If the corresponding two measure combinations do not exist, then the number of measure combinations actually implemented in multiple sub-regions is six, which can be expressed as: (1) In formula (1), The six values of correspond to six measure combinations.
[0024] Specifically, traffic information may include the built environment information, population information, and vehicle traffic information of each sub-region before the assessment area implements traffic calming measures; and the traffic accident volume of each sub-region after the assessment area implements traffic calming measures. .
[0025] Among them, built environment information can include road network density , the proportion of residential land , Commercial land share and the proportion of parks and green areas ; Population information can include population density and employment population density ; Vehicle traffic information can include the annual average daily cross-border motor vehicle traffic volume and the annual average daily non-motorized vehicle traffic volume .
[0026] Assume that there are sub-regions, then sub-region and They can be expressed as and .
[0027] After collecting the traffic data of all sub-areas, a traffic data table as shown in Table 1 can be formed.
[0028] Table 1 Traffic data table
[0029] In this embodiment, the implementation probability of each combination of measures corresponding to each sub-region is determined in S2, which may be specifically: A logistic model was used to determine the probability of implementation of each combination of measures in each sub-region.
[0030] Specifically, the calculation formula of the implementation probability can be expressed as: (2) In formula (2), is the probability of implementation; Combination of measures The value of , and ; They are The regression coefficient of .
[0031] In this embodiment, all sub-areas and The value of is input into the logic model for calculation, and the corresponding measure combination , we can get a set of regression coefficients Then, the regression coefficients and , Substituting the value of into formula (2), we can get the corresponding combination of measures for each sub-region The probability of implementation .
[0032] This embodiment will Sub-regional response measures The implementation probability is set to , then each sub-region corresponds to a set of implementation probabilities, namely .
[0033] Further, after S2, the method may further include: When any implementation probability is less than the preset probability, the corresponding sub-region is removed from the multiple sub-regions; the implementation probability of each measure combination corresponding to each sub-region in the updated multiple sub-regions is re-determined until all implementation probabilities are greater than or equal to the preset probability.
[0034] Specifically, the range of the preset probability can be [0.01, 0.05]. When any one of a set of implementation probabilities of a sub-area is less than the preset probability, it means that the traffic safety situation of the sub-area is not comparable with that of other sub-areas. At this time, the sub-area should be removed from all sub-areas, and S1 and S2 should be repeated for the updated multiple sub-areas until all implementation probabilities are greater than or equal to the preset probability.
[0035] After obtaining the implementation probabilities of all sub-areas, an implementation probability data table as shown in Table 2 can be formed.
[0036] Table 2 Implementation probability data table
[0037] In this embodiment, S3 may specifically be: S31, determining an inverse probability weighted value of each measure combination corresponding to the number of traffic accidents in each sub-region according to the implementation probability, the number of traffic accidents, and the measure combinations corresponding to all sub-regions; S32. Determine the implementation effect of each combination of measures based on the inverse probability weighted value.
[0038] Further, S31 may specifically be: According to the measure combinations corresponding to all sub-regions, the discrimination coefficient of each sub-region corresponding to each measure combination is determined; The inverse probability weighted value of each measure combination corresponding to each sub-area is determined based on the discriminant coefficient, implementation probability and traffic accident volume.
[0039] Specifically, this embodiment determines the discrimination coefficient according to the combination of measures actually implemented in each sub-region. Sub-regional response measures The discriminant coefficient is ,but: when When true, ;when When it is not true, .
[0040] Specifically, when With When the combination of measures actually implemented in each sub-region is consistent, is true.
[0041] For example, if The combination of measures actually implemented in each sub-region is ,but: because This is consistent with the combination of measures actually implemented in this sub-region, i.e. is true, so Sub-regional response measures The discriminant coefficient ; because This does not correspond to the combination of measures actually implemented in this sub-region, i.e. is not true, so Sub-regional response measures The discriminant coefficient .
[0042] Specifically, the calculation formula for the inverse probability weighted value of the traffic accident volume in each sub-area corresponding to each measure combination is: (3) In formula (3), For the Sub-regional response measures The discriminant coefficient of For the The number of traffic accidents in each sub-area; For the Sub-regional response measures The probability of implementation; For the Traffic accidents in each sub-area Combination of countermeasures The inverse probability weighted value of .
[0043] The present invention uses the inverse probability weighting method to process the relevant data of multiple sub-areas, which can narrow the inherent differences in traffic safety levels between the sub-areas, thereby reducing the impact of interference factors other than traffic calming measures on the assessment, which is conducive to improving the accuracy of the assessment.
[0044] After the inverse probability weighted values of all sub-regions are obtained, an inverse probability weighted value data table as shown in Table 3 can be formed.
[0045] Table 3 Inverse probability weighted value data table
[0046] Further, S32 may specifically be: The difference between the sum of the inverse probability weighted values of all first sub-regions corresponding to any measure combination and the sum of the inverse probability weighted values of all second sub-regions is determined as the implementation effect of the corresponding measure combination.
[0047] Specifically, the calculation formula for the implementation effect of each combination of measures is: (4) In formula (4), For the Traffic accidents in each sub-area Combination of countermeasures The inverse probability weighted value of ; For the Traffic accidents in each sub-area Combination of countermeasures The inverse probability weighted value of ; For the Combination of measures implementation effect.
[0048] It is understandable that for the second sub-area where no traffic calming measures were implemented, hour, , ,therefore, ( ) is actually a combination of all the corresponding measures in the first sub-region ( ) is the sum of the inverse probability weighted values of ; for the first sub-area where traffic calming measures have been implemented, hour, , , while for the second sub-area where no traffic calming measures were implemented, hour, , ,therefore, In fact, all the second sub-region corresponding measures are combined The sum of the inverse probability weighted values of .
[0049] The present invention selects multiple sub-regions in the assessment area where traffic calming measures have been implemented and multiple sub-regions where traffic calming measures have not been implemented, and determines the implementation probability of each measure combination corresponding to each sub-region based on the traffic information of multiple sub-regions before and after the implementation of traffic calming measures in the assessment area, and then determines the implementation effect of each measure combination in the assessment area in combination with the measure combinations actually implemented in all sub-regions and related traffic information, thereby achieving synchronous evaluation of multiple measure combinations implemented in the assessment area, which is beneficial to improving evaluation efficiency and reducing evaluation errors. At the same time, since the implementation effects of multiple measure combinations are all obtained based on the same evaluation process and traffic information, this makes the evaluation results of different measure combinations comparable, which is beneficial to comparative analysis of multiple measure combinations.
[0050] The above are only a few embodiments of the present application and do not constitute any form of limitation to the present application. Although the present application is disclosed as above with preferred embodiments, it is not intended to limit the present application. Any technician familiar with the profession, without departing from the scope of the technical solution of the present application, using the technical content disclosed above to make slight changes or modifications are equivalent to equivalent implementation cases and fall within the scope of the technical solution.
Claims
1. A method for evaluating the implementation effect of a combination of traffic calming measures, characterized in that: The method comprises: S1. Obtain a combination of measures corresponding to each of the multiple sub-areas of the assessment area; S2. determining the implementation probability of each combination of measures for each sub-region according to the traffic information of multiple sub-regions before and after the implementation of the traffic calming measures in the assessment region; S3. Determine the implementation effect of each measure combination according to the implementation probability, the traffic information and the measure combinations corresponding to all sub-areas.
2. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that The plurality of sub-areas include a plurality of first sub-areas where traffic calming measures have been implemented and a plurality of second sub-areas where traffic calming measures have not been implemented.
3. The method according to claim 2, characterized in that The traffic information includes built environment information, population information and vehicle traffic information of each sub-area before the assessment area implements traffic calming measures; and the number of traffic accidents in each sub-area after the assessment area implements traffic calming measures.
4. The method according to claim 3, characterized in that The S3 is specifically: S31, determining an inverse probability weighted value of each measure combination corresponding to the number of traffic accidents in each sub-region according to the implementation probability, the number of traffic accidents, and the measure combinations corresponding to all sub-regions; S32. Determine the implementation effect of each combination of measures according to the inverse probability weighted value.
5. The method according to claim 4, characterized in that The S31 is specifically: According to the measure combinations corresponding to all sub-regions, the discrimination coefficient of each sub-region corresponding to each measure combination is determined; An inverse probability weighted value of each measure combination corresponding to each sub-region is determined according to the discrimination coefficient, the implementation probability and the traffic accident volume.
6. The method according to claim 4, characterized in that The S32 is specifically: The difference between the sum of the inverse probability weighted values of all first sub-regions corresponding to any measure combination and the sum of the inverse probability weighted values of all second sub-regions is determined as the implementation effect of the corresponding measure combination.
7. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that The implementation probability of each combination of measures corresponding to each sub-region is determined in S2, specifically: Logistic models were used to determine the probability of implementation of each combination of measures for each sub-region.
8. The method according to claim 7, characterized in that After S2, the method further includes: When any implementation probability is less than a preset probability, the corresponding sub-region is removed from the multiple sub-regions; The implementation probability of each measure combination corresponding to each sub-region in the updated multiple sub-regions is re-determined until all implementation probabilities are greater than or equal to the preset probability.
9. The method according to claim 3, characterized in that: The built environment information includes road network density, residential land proportion, commercial land proportion and green land proportion.
10. The method according to claim 3, characterized in that The vehicle traffic information includes the annual average daily transit motor vehicle traffic volume and the annual average daily transit non-motor vehicle traffic volume.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Multi-objective evaluation method of calming designs of open campus
CN108416099A
Traffic road safety evaluation method based on Gaussian process regression analysis
CN113313357A
Influence effect analysis method after implementation of traffic safety management specifications
CN114639237A
Assessment method of traffic organization optimization scheme, electronic equipment and storage medium
CN115497301A
Method for evaluating influence of physical isolation fence in middle of highway road on traffic flow
CN118334867A
