Driving of an SMA acuator in a haptic assembly
Patent Information
- Application Number
- PCT/GB2024/051307
- Authority / Receiving Office
- WO · WO
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2023-05-18
- Filing Date
- 2024-05-20
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-21
Smart Images

Figure GB2024051307_21112024_PF_FP_ABST
Abstract
Description
[0001] DRIVING OF AN SMA ACUATOR IN A HAPTIC ASSEMBLY
[0002] The present invention relates to driving of a shape memory alloy, SMA, actuator in a haptic assembly that is arranged on actuation of the SMA actuator to provide a haptic effect.
[0003] In haptic devices, it may be desired to drive the haptic assembly to provide a haptic effect that is vibratory. This may be achieved by supplying a sequence of drive pulses to the SMA element of the SMA actuator, which may typically be an SMA wire. On the supply of each pulse, the SMA element is heated and contracts. Between pulses the SMA element cools. The frequency and amplitude of the vibration is limited by the cooling rate of the SMA element.
[0004] Each time the SMA actuator is actuated by a drive pulse, a discrete amount of energy is delivered to the SMA element and this energy results in contraction of the SMA actuator. The specific amount of displacement achieved for a given SMA element depends on a number of factors, including: the force applied to the SMA element (pre-load), the energy supplied by the drive pulse, and the initial temperature of the SMA element. Similarly, the cooling rate depends on the temperature of the SMA element and the ambient temperature of the surroundings of the SMA element, typically air. To maintain a continuous haptic effect, it is therefore critical that the correct amount of energy is delivered to the SMA element in a drive pulse to achieve a displacement which corresponds to the amount the SMA element can cool between drive pulses. This is difficult to achieve, particularly in situations in which the vibratory effect is maintained for long periods of time.
[0005] Open-loop control is typically implemented, and in this case it is necessary to select the power of the drive pulses without knowledge of the temperature of the SMA element. Delivery of too much energy per drive pulse may result in temperature of the SMA element gradually increasing over time. The SMA element reaching a high temperature can lead to the SMA element not being able to cool between pulses sufficiently to be extended again. This means that the SMA element does not contract when the next pulse is applied and thus the haptic effect is no longer produced. Increasing the temperature of the SMA element can also lead at some point during the sequence of drive pulses to burnout of the SMA element, that is to the temperature of the SMA element reaching levels that cause damage to the SMA element. The risk of such burnout and / or reduction in haptic effect can be mitigated by reducing the power of each drive pulse, but the required margin typically results delivery of too little energy per drive pulse. This results in insufficient temperature being achieved to maintain an equal displacement throughout the haptic effect, such that the haptic effect is degraded.
[0006] It would be desirable to reduce such difficulties. According to a first aspect of the present invention, there is provided a method of driving a shape memory alloy, SMA, actuator comprising an SMA element in a haptic assembly that is arranged on actuation of the SMA actuator to provide a haptic effect, the method comprising: supplying a sequence of drive pulses to the SMA element so that the haptic effect is vibratory; determining a value of an electrical parameter of the SMA element; and controlling one or more characteristics of the drive pulses on the basis of the determined value of the electrical parameter so that the SMA element is maintained in a predetermined state of a phase transition of the SMA element.
[0007] In this manner, the value of an electrical parameter of the SMA element may be used to control one or more characteristics of the drive pulses in a manner that the SMA element is maintained in a predetermined state of a phase transition of the SMA element over successive cycles of the sequence of drive pulses. In this manner, it is possible to deliver the correct amount of energy to the SMA wire in each drive pulse to achieve a displacement equal to the amount the SMA element can cool during the supply of the sequence of drive pulses. This allows the vibratory haptic effect to be maintained without burnout of the SMA element and without degradation of the haptic effect.
[0008] The value of the electrical parameter of the SMA element may be determined during the supply of the sequence of drive pulses.
[0009] Advantageously, the predetermined state of a phase transition of the SMA element may provide a maximum rate of change of displacement while the SMA element cools between the drive pulses.
[0010] By controlling the SMA element to provide a maximum rate of change of displacement while the SMA element cools, the state of a phase transition in which the SMA element is maintained is optimal in terms of providing the maximum amplitude of the haptic effect in a given period, or conversely maximum frequency of vibratory motion of a given amplitude. In other words, the state of phase transition of the SMA element is maintained such that the rate of cooling of the SMA element between pulses is maximised. An amount of energy can thus be supplied which causes the element to contract by a maximum amount within the constraints of the rate of cooling of the SMA element. This leads to an optimal (e.g. maximum) amplitude of vibration which can be maintained without a gradual increase in temperature over time and without a reduction in amplitude over time.
[0011] The term maximum may refer to a value which is the absolute maximum value or which is approximately maximum, for example within 10%, 5% or 1% of the absolute maximum value. Advantageously, the step of determining a value of an electrical parameter may comprise: determining a measure of the electrical resistance of the SMA element; and deriving the value of the electrical parameter from the determined measure of electrical resistance of the SMA element.
[0012] In a first option, the electrical parameter may be an average of the determined measure of electrical resistance over at least one drive pulse cycle; and the step of controlling the one or more characteristics (e.g. power) of the drive pulses may be performed using closed loop feedback control to drive the determined value of the electrical parameter towards a target value.
[0013] This is an advantageous approach for achieving the benefits of the first aspect of the invention.
[0014] Thus, according to a second aspect of the present invention, there is provided a method of driving an actuator comprising a shape memory alloy element in a haptic assembly that is arranged on actuation of the SMA element to provide a haptic effect, the method comprising: supplying a sequence of drive pulses to the SMA element so that the haptic effect is vibratory; determining a measure of the electrical resistance of the SMA element and determining a value of an average of the determined electrical resistance over at least one drive pulse cycle; and controlling one or more characteristics of the drive pulses on the basis of the determined value of the average of the electrical resistance using closed loop feedback control to drive the determined value of the average of the electrical resistance towards a target value. The measure of the electrical resistance of the SMA element may be determined during the supply of the sequence of drive pulses.
[0015] In this manner, the average of the electrical resistance of the SMA element may be used to control one or more characteristics of the drive pulses in a manner that the SMA element is maintained in a predetermined state of a phase transition of the SMA element over successive cycles of the sequence of drive pulses.
[0016] Advantageously, the electrical parameter may be an average of the determined measure of electrical resistance over plural drive pulse cycles.
[0017] In one approach to implement this option, the target value may be a predetermined calibration value.
[0018] In another approach to implement this option, the method may further comprise: before supplying the sequence of drive pulses to the SMA element, supplying an initial drive signal for heating the SMA element; and during the supply of the initial drive signal, determining a measure of the electrical resistance of the SMA element and detecting a maximum value of the determined measure of electrical resistance, wherein the target value is a predetermined margin below the detected maximum value.
[0019] In a second option, the electrical parameter may be a rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with time, and the step of controlling the one or more characteristics of the drive pulses may be performed so that the rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with time is controlled, e.g. maximised. For example, the one or more characteristics of the drive pulses may be controlled so that the rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with time is driven towards a target value.
[0020] This is an advantageous approach for achieving the benefits of the first aspect of the invention.
[0021] Thus, according to a third aspect of the present invention, there is provided a method of driving a shape memory alloy, SMA, actuator comprising an SMA element in a haptic assembly that is arranged on actuation of the SMA element to provide a haptic effect, the method comprising: supplying a sequence of drive pulses to the SMA element so that the haptic effect is vibratory; determining a measure of the electrical resistance of the SMA actuator and determining a value of a rate of change of electrical resistance with time; and controlling one or more characteristics of the drive pulses so that the rate of change of electrical resistance with time is controlled, e.g. maximised. The measure of the electrical resistance of the SMA actuator may be determined during the supply of the sequence of drive pulses.
[0022] In this manner, the rate of change of electrical resistance of the SMA element with time may be used to control one or more characteristics of the drive pulses in a manner that the SMA element is maintained in a predetermined state of a phase transition of the SMA element over successive cycles of the sequence of drive pulses.
[0023] Advantageously, the step of controlling the one or more characteristics of the drive pulses may be performed so that the magnitude of the rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with time is maximised using a numerical optimisation method.
[0024] For example, the rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with time may be: the rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance while the SMA element heats while power is being supplied; the rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance while the SMA element cools between the pulses; or a combination of the rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance while the SMA element heats during the pulses and the rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance while the SMA element cools between the pulses.
[0025] In a third option, the step of determining the value of an electrical parameter may further comprise: estimating a temperature of the SMA element from the determined measure of electrical resistance or from a history of the power of the drive pulses (or from a combination of both the determined measure of electrical resistance and a history of the power of the drive pulses), the electrical parameter may be a rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with the estimated temperature, and the step of controlling one or more characteristics of the drive pulses may be performed so that the rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with the estimated temperature is controlled, e.g. maximised. For example, the one or more characteristics of the drive pulses may be controlled so that the rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with the estimated temperature is driven towards a target value.
[0026] Advantageously, the step of controlling the one or more characteristics of the drive pulses is performed so that the magnitude of the rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with estimated temperature is maximised using a numerical optimisation method.
[0027] This is an advantageous approach for achieving the benefits of the first aspect of the invention.
[0028] Thus, according to a fourth aspect of the present invention, there is provided a method of driving an actuator comprising a shape memory alloy, SMA, element in a haptic assembly that is arranged on actuation of the SMA element to provide a haptic effect, the method comprising: supplying a sequence of drive pulses to the SMA element so that the haptic effect is vibratory; determining a measure of the electrical resistance of the SMA element; estimating a temperature of the SMA element (for example from the determined measure of electrical resistance and / or from a history of the power of the drive pulses); and determining a value of a rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with the estimated temperature; and controlling one or more characteristics of the drive pulses so that the rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with the estimated temperature is controlled, e.g. maximised. The measure of the electrical resistance of the SMA element may be determined during the supply of the sequence of drive pulses.
[0029] In this manner, the determined measure of electrical resistance of the SMA element with the estimated temperature may be used to control one or more characteristics of the drive pulses in a manner that the SMA element is maintained in a predetermined state of a phase transition of the SMA element over successive cycles of the sequence of drive pulses.
[0030] In any aspect of the present invention, the one or more characteristics of the drive pulses may include, for example, one or more of: the pulse duty of the drive pulses; the frequency of the drive pulses; and the amplitude of the drive pulses.
[0031] In some applications, the haptic effect may be a movement of an external part of a handheld device. In some applications, the haptic effect may be a movement of an internal part of the handheld device, the internal part having sufficient mass that the relative movement may be felt by a user holding the device in which the SMA actuator is embodied.
[0032] In some typical applications, the sequence of drive pulses may be supplied over a period of at least 0.02 seconds. Optionally, the sequence of drive pulses may be supplied over a period of at least 0.03 seconds, 0.1 seconds, 0.2 seconds, 0.5 seconds, 1 second or 2 seconds.
[0033] In some typical applications, the sequence of drive pulses may comprise at least 5 pulses. Optionally, the sequence of drive pulses may comprise at least 10, 20, 30, 40 or 50 pulses.
[0034] In some typical applications, the drive pluses may have a frequency of at least 5Hz. Optionally, the drive pluses may have a frequency of at least 10, 20, 50 or 100Hz.
[0035] In some typical applications, the drive pluses may have a frequency of at most 500 Hz. Optionally, the drive pluses may have a frequency of at most 200 or 300 Hz.
[0036] According to a further aspect of the present invention, there is provided a control circuit for a shape memory alloy, SMA, actuator comprising an SMA element in a haptic assembly that is arranged on actuation of the SMA actuator to provide a haptic effect, wherein the control circuit is arranged to: supply a sequence of drive pulses to the SMA element so that the haptic effect is vibratory; determine a value of an electrical parameter of the SMA element (optionally during the supply of the sequence of drive pulses); and control one or more characteristics of the drive pulses on the basis of the determined value of the electrical parameter so that the SMA element is maintained in a state of a phase transition of the SMA element providing a maximum rate of change of displacement while the SMA element cools between the drive pulses.
[0037] Such a control circuit implements a method according to the first aspect of the present invention, and has the same advantages. Similarly, according to a yet further aspect of the present invention, there is provided a control circuit that implements a method according to the second, third or fourth aspect of the present invention. A haptic device may comprise a control circuit according to these aspects of the present invention and a haptic assembly comprising a shape memory alloy, SMA, actuator comprising an SMA element, the haptic assembly being arranged on actuation of the SMA actuator to provide a haptic effect. The SMA actuator may comprise one or more SMA elements.
[0038] According to a yet further aspect of the present invention, there is provided a computer program configured, on execution by a processor, to cause the processor to carry out a method of controlling driving of a shape memory alloy, SMA, actuator comprising an SMA element in a haptic assembly that is arranged on actuation of the SMA actuator to provide a haptic effect, the method comprising: controlling a drive circuit to supply a sequence of drive pulses to the SMA element so that the haptic effect is vibratory; receiving a value of an electrical parameter of the SMA element; and controlling the drive circuit to control one or more characteristics of the drive pulses on the basis of the received value of the electrical parameter so that the SMA element is maintained in a state of a phase transition of the SMA element providing a maximum rate of change of displacement while the SMA element cools between the drive pulses. The value of the electrical parameter may be received during the supply of the sequence of drive pulses.
[0039] Such a computer program implements a method according to the first aspect of the present invention. Alternatively according to this aspect of the present invention, there is provided a computer program that implements a method according to the second, third or fourth aspect of the present invention.
[0040] While the aspects of the present invention discussed above are related to driving of a haptic assembly that is arranged on actuation of the SMA actuator to provide a haptic effect that is vibratory, similar advantages may be achieved in driving of an SMA actuator in other types of assembly to provide a vibratory motion. Thus, the first aspect of the present invention may be generalised to provide a method of driving an SMA actuator comprising an SMA element in an assembly that is arranged on actuation of the SMA actuator to provide relative displacement of components, the method comprising: supplying a sequence of drive pulses to the SMA element so that the relative displacement is vibratory; determining a measure of the electrical resistance of the SMA actuator and determining a value of a rate of change of electrical resistance with time; and controlling one or more characteristics of the drive pulses so that the SMA element is maintained in a predetermined state of a phase transition of the SMA element. The measure of the electrical resistance of the SMA actuator may be determined during the supply of the sequence of drive pulses. The other aspects of the present invention set out above may be generalised in the same manner.
[0041] Embodiments of the present invention will now be described by way of non-limitative example with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which:
[0042] Fig. 1 is a schematic side view of a haptic assembly including an SMA element;
[0043] Fig. 2 is a graph of desired displacement against time for a haptic assembly during delivery of a haptic effect;
[0044] Fig. 3 is a graph of displacement and velocity against time for a typical haptic assembly during delivery of a haptic effect;
[0045] Fig. 4 is a diagram of the circuitry of a haptic device including the haptic assembly of Fig. 1 and a control circuit;
[0046] Fig. 5 is a graph of voltage against time for a sequence of drive pulses;
[0047] Fig. 6 is a graph of resistance against temperature for a typical SMA element;
[0048] Fig. 7 is a diagram of the functional blocks of a controller of the control circuit of Fig. 4 during implementation of a method of driving the SMA element;
[0049] Fig. 8 is a flow chart of a method of deriving a target value for use in an example of the method of driving the SMA element implemented by the functional blocks of Fig. 7;
[0050] Figs. 9 and 10 are diagram of the functional blocks of the controller of the control circuit of Fig. 4 during implementation of an alternative option for the method of driving the SMA element, Figs. 9 and 10 showing two different examples for temperature estimation; a
[0051] Figure 11A is a graph of voltage against time for an example pulse;
[0052] Figure 11B is a graph of displacement against time for the pulse illustrated in Figure 11A;
[0053] Figure 12A is a graph of voltage against time for a further example pulse; and
[0054] Figure 12B is a graph of displacement against time for the pulse illustrated in Figure 12A.
[0055] Fig. 1 shows a haptic assembly 1 to which methods of control described below may be applied. The haptic assembly 1 includes an SMA actuator 2 that comprises an SMA element 3 that is a length of SMA wire in this example.
[0056] The SMA actuator 3 is connected between a support structure 4 and a movable element 5. The SMA actuator 3 is arranged so that on actuation the change in displacement of the SMA element 3 drives movement of the movable element 5 with respect to the support structure 4. In this example, the movable element 5 is an external part of a handheld device 6, such as a button or other user input device. In this example, the relative movement is laterally across outer surface of the handheld device 6. This provides a haptic effect as the relative movement may be felt by a user touching the moveable element 5 or holding the handheld device 6. In general, the haptic assembly 1 may take any form that provides a haptic effect. In an alternative example where the movable element 5 is an external part of a handheld device 6, then the relative movement may be inwardly and outwardly of the handheld device 6. In an alternative example, the movable element 5 may be internal to the handheld device 6 and have sufficient mass that the relative movement may be felt by a user holding the handheld device 6.
[0057] Other examples of haptic assemblies to which the methods of control described below may be applied are disclosed in WO2018 / 046937A1, WO2019 / 162708A1 and WO2021 / 148814A1, all of which are incorporated herein by reference in their entireties.
[0058] In the methods of control described below, the SMA actuator 2 is actuated by supplying a sequence of drive pulses to the SMA element 3 so that the haptic effect is vibratory.
[0059] By way of example, Fig. 2 shows the desired displacement against time for the haptic assembly 1 during delivery of such a vibratory haptic effect. As can be seen, after an initial increase in displacement from a rest position, the displacement is vibratory and of constant amplitude. In principle, the SMA actuator 2 is able to perform very high activation frequencies but is limited in frequency of the haptic effect by the cooling rate of the SMA element 3.
[0060] However, this is difficult to achieve in practice. Each time the SMA actuator 2 is actuated by a drive pulse, a discrete amount of energy is delivered to the SMA element 3 and this energy correlates to the displacement of the SMA actuator 2. The specific amount of displacement achieved for a given SMA element 3 depends on a number of factors, including: the force applied to the SMA element 3 (pre-load), the energy supplied by the drive pulse, and the initial temperature of the SMA element 3. Similarly, the cooling rate depends on the temperature of the SMA element 3 and the ambient temperature of the surroundings of the SMA element 3, which is air in this example. To maintain a continuous haptic effect, it is therefore critical that the correct amount of energy is delivered to the SMA element to achieve a displacement equal to the amount the SMA element can cool during supply of the sequence of drive pulses.
[0061] If open-loop control were to be implemented, then it would be necessary to select the power of the drive pulses without knowledge of the temperature of the SMA element 3. Delivery of too much energy per drive pulse would result in temperature of the SMA element 3 gradually increasing over time, leading at some point during the sequence of drive pulses to cessation of the haptic effect and possibly burnout of the SMA element 3, that is to the temperature of the SMA element 3 reaching levels that cause damage to the SMA element 3. The risk of such cessation of haptic effect and / or burnout can be mitigated by reducing the power of each drive pulse, but the required margin typically results delivery of too little energy per drive pulse. This results in insufficient temperature being achieved to maintain an equal displacement throughout the haptic effect, such that the haptic effect is degraded.
[0062] Fig. 3 shows an example of typical, non-ideal driving achieved using open-loop control. As can be seen from the trace of displacement in Fig. 3, the displacement of each cycle of the sequence of drive pulses is vibratory and so produces a vibratory effect, but the displacement increases over successive cycles until the sequence of drive pulses ends (at about 210 ms in this example), after which the displacement returns to a rest position. This overall increase in displacement arises because the SMA element 3 is increasing in temperature and the state of a phase transition of the SMA element 3 changes.
[0063] In some cases, the increase in temperature may cause damage to the SMA element 3, often referred to as burnout. However, the power of the drive pulses is difficult to select as it depends on the factors discussed above and in some cases where the power of the drive pulse is reduced then the size of the haptic effect is reduced, resulting in a poor haptic performance.
[0064] As can be seen from the trace of velocity in Fig. 3, over each cycle of the drive pulses there is a positive velocity during the supply of the drive pulse itself and a negative velocity as the SMA element 3 cools between the drive pulses. As the displacement increases over successive drive pulses, the magnitude of these velocities changes, initially increasing as the temperature of the SMA element 3 increases up to a maximum, after which it decreases.
[0065] Thus, for continuous vibratory motions, it is desirable to maximise the velocity, so as to maximise the amplitude of the displacement in a given period of the drive pulses, or conversely to maximise the frequency of displacement of a given amplitude. To achieve this, it is desired to maintain the SMA element 3 in the state of the phase transition of the SMA element 3 providing a maximum rate of change of displacement while the SMA element cools between the drive pulses, corresponding to the peak in velocity in the example of open-loop control shown in Fig. 3. This may be achieved using the methods of control described below. On heating of SMA, the SMA transitions from a first material phase to a second material phase. In the case of a shape memory alloy, on heating the SMA transitions from martensite to austenite. The state of the phase transition (as referred to herein) refers to the proportion of the SMA element that is in the austenite phase compared to the proportion that is in the martensite phase.
[0066] Fig. 4 shows the circuitry of a haptic device 10 including the haptic assembly 1 of Fig. 1 in which a method of control is implemented. The haptic device 10 also includes a control circuit 11 including the following components. The control circuit 11 includes a drive circuit 12 that is arranged to generate a sequence of drive pulses and supply them to the SMA element 3 for driving the SMA actuator 2 so that the haptic effect is vibratory. The drive circuit 12 may have a conventional construction for applying a drive signal to an SMA element 3. The control circuit may be implemented on an integrated circuit chip.
[0067] Fig. 5 illustrates an example of drive pulses that may be applied in such a sequence. In this example, the drive circuit 12 has a constant-voltage output, so the amplitude of the drive pulses is a constant voltage Vp, although a constant-current output is similarly possible. In this example, the drive pulses are rectangular. The drive pulses have a period Pp and are delivered in a cycle of frequency / (i.e. a cycle period 1 / f) so that the pulse duty of the drive pulses is (Pp. / ). It is convenient to form rectangular drive pulses by implementing the drive circuit 12 as a voltage source and a switching circuit, but this is not essential and in general terms the drive pulses may have any shape, depending on the construction of the drive circuit 12.
[0068] The sequence of drive pulses is distinct from applications of SMA actuators that use pulse width modulation (PWM) control to provide precision control of displacement. In such PWM control, the drive signal takes the form of a sequence of pulses, but the cycle period is chosen to be shorter than the response time of the SMA actuator so that the resultant displacement is not vibratory, but is a slow motion aggregated over multiple cycle periods. If such PWM control were applied to the haptic assembly 1 shown in Fig. 1, then no vibratory haptic effect would be provided because the user would not perceive the displacement within each cycle. Thus, to provide a vibratory haptic effect, the sequence drive pulses have a cycle period that is longer than the response time of the haptic assembly 1 so that the displacement within each cycle period is perceived by the user.
[0069] The parameters of sequence of drive pulses are chosen so that the haptic assembly 1 provides the desired vibratory haptic effect. Although three drive pulses are shown in Fig. 5, the sequence will typically consist of a larger number of drive pulses. Some non-limitative examples that may be applied in any combination are as follows.
[0070] The sequence of drive pulses may be supplied over a period of at least 0.02 seconds. Optionally, the sequence of drive pulses may be supplied over a period of at least 0.03 seconds, 0.1 seconds, 0.2 seconds, 0.5 seconds, 1 second or 2 seconds.
[0071] The sequence of drive pulses may comprise at least 5 pulses. Optionally, the sequence of drive pulses may comprise at least 10, 20, 30, 40 or 50 pulses. The drive pluses may have a frequency of at least 5 Hz. Optionally, the drive pluses may have a frequency of at least 10, 20, 50 or 100Hz.
[0072] The drive pluses may have a frequency of at most 500 Hz. Optionally, the drive pluses may have a frequency of at most 200 or 300 Hz.
[0073] The control circuit 11 also includes a controller 13 that is arranged to control the drive circuit 12. The controller 13 controls the drive circuit 12 to generate the sequence of drive pulses. The controller 13 may control one or more characteristics of the drive pulses to vary the power of the drive pulses over each successive cycle. Various characteristics of the drive pulses may be controlled. Non-limitative examples of characteristics that may be controlled include one or more of: the pulse duty of the drive pulses; the frequency of the drive pulses; and the amplitude of the drive pulses.
[0074] In this example, the controller 13 is implemented by a processor 14 that executes a computer program that is configured, on execution, to cause the processor to carry out the method of controlling the SMA actuator 2. As an alternative to such a software implementation, the controller 13 may be implemented in hardware, or partly in hardware and partly in software.
[0075] The control circuit 11 also includes a measurement circuit 15 that is arranged to measure the electrical resistance of the SMA element 3 and to output a signal representing a measure of the electrical resistance. The measurement circuit 15 may have any suitable form, some non-limitative examples being as follows. In the case that the drive circuit 12 has a constant-current output, the measurement circuit 15 may be a voltage detection circuit operable to detect the voltage across the SMA actuator 3 as the measure of its electrical resistance. In the case that the drive circuit 12 has a constant-voltage output, the measurement circuit 15 may be a current detection circuit operable to detect the current through the SMA actuator 3 as the measure of its electrical resistance. For a higher degree of accuracy, the measurement circuit 15 may comprise a voltage detection circuit and a current detection circuit operable to detect the voltage and current across the SMA actuator 3 and to derive the ratio thereof as a measure of the electrical resistance of the SMA actuator 3.
[0076] Such resistance monitoring of the SMA element 3 effectively enables monitoring of the temperature the SMA element 3 due to the relationship between temperature and resistivity of SMA material, as shown in the typical example shown in Fig. 6.
[0077] Fig. 7 illustrates an implementation of the controller 13 to provide a control method of controlling the haptic assembly 1. In particular, Fig. 7 shows functional blocks of the controller, which correspond to steps of the method of control, and operate as follows.
[0078] In functional block Fl, the controller 13 produces a control signal 20 that is supplied to the drive circuit 12 and controls the drive circuit 12 to generate the sequence of drive pulses and supply them to the SMA element 3.
[0079] Functional block F2 receives the measure 21 of the electrical resistance of the SMA element 3 from the measurement circuit 15. The measures 21 of resistance may be filtered, for example via a median filter for the removal of noise. In functional block F2, during the supply of the sequence of drive pulses in functional block Fl, the controller 13 derives a value of an electrical parameter of the SMA element 3 from the measure 21 of the electrical resistance of the SMA element 3.
[0080] In functional block F3, during the supply of the sequence of drive pulses in functional block Fl, the controller 13 controls one or more characteristics of the drive pulses derived in functional block Fl on the basis of the determined value of the electrical parameter from functional block F2. This step is performed in a manner that the SMA element 3 is maintained in a predetermined state of a phase transition of the SMA element 3 over successive cycles of the sequence of drive pulses. In this manner, the SMA element 3 is maintained in a state that avoids burnout. Specifically, the predetermined state provides a maximum rate of change of displacement while the SMA element 3 cools between the drive pulses to provide optimal haptic performance, as discussed above. The way this is achieved is through use of the electrical parameter derived from the measure 21 of electric resistance of the SMA element 3. This effectively provides for temperature monitoring of the SMA element 3 in a manner that drive pulses having the correct power can be delivered to the SMA element 3. Optionally, additional accuracy could be gained using feedback from a temperature sensor such as a thermistor to monitor ambient temperature around the SMA element 3 to tune the power delivery.
[0081] Several different electrical parameters may be derived in functional block F2 for use in functional block F3, for example as follows.
[0082] A first option for the control method shown in Fig. 7 is as follows.
[0083] In this case, the electrical parameter derived in functional block F2 is an average of the determined measure of electrical resistance over at least one cycle of the drive pulses, preferably over plural cycles of the drive pulses. The average may be determined within the drive pulses themselves in each cycle, within the gaps between the drive pulses, or within the entire cycle including both the drive pulses themselves and the gaps therebetween. Consequently, in functional block F3, the controller 13 controls the power of the drive pulses using closed loop feedback control to drive the determined value of the electrical parameter towards a target value that is selected to maintain the SMA element 3 in the predetermined state of a phase transition of the SMA element 3 over successive cycles. The closed loop feedback control may use a conventional feedback technique.
[0084] Two approaches to deriving the target value are as follows.
[0085] In the first approach, the target value may be a predetermined calibration value. In this case the target value may be derived in a calibration process performed at the time of manufacture of the haptic device 10 and stored in the controller 13. In this manner, it is possible to optimise the performance to the characteristics of individual haptic devices 10, which may in general vary. One approach for such a calibration process is to supply drive signals to the SMA element 3 using PWM control to find the maximum continuous motion and record the mean resistance in this condition as the target value. Such a calibration process effectively allows iteration through temperature to derive a curve for resistance against temperature, for example of the type as shown in Fig. 6. This may be used to determine the temperature at which the slope has maximum magnitude.
[0086] Fig. 8 is a flow chart of a method of deriving a target value for use in an example of the method of driving the SMA element implemented by the functional blocks of Fig. 7.
[0087] In the second approach, the target value may be derived by the controller 13 by implementing the method shown Fig. 8 in the controller 13. This method is performed as follows.
[0088] This method is performed before supplying the sequence of drive pulses to the SMA element 3, so the SMA element 3 is in a cold state below the transition temperature at which a phase transition causes contraction of the SMA element 3.
[0089] In step SI, the controller 13 controls the drive circuit to supply an initial drive signal to the SMA element that heats the SMA element 3.
[0090] In step S2, during the supply of the initial drive signal, the controller 13 receives the measure of the electrical resistance of the SMA element 3 from the measurement circuit 15.
[0091] In step S3, during the supply of the initial drive signal, the controller 13 detects a maximum value of the determined measure of electrical resistance. This maximum value is characteristic of the commencement of contraction of the SMA element 3 caused by the phase transition of the SMA element 3.
[0092] In step S4, the controller 13 sets the target value at a predetermined margin below the maximum value detected in step S3. The margin is based on prior knowledge of the relationship between the stroke of the SMA actuator 3 and resistance so that the target value maintains the SMA element 3 in the predetermined state of a phase transition of the SMA element 3 over successive cycles.
[0093] In step S5, the controller 13 performs the control method described above with reference to Fig. 7 using the target value derived in step S4.
[0094] A second option for the control method shown in Fig. 7 is as follows.
[0095] In this case, the electrical parameter derived in functional block F2 is a rate of change of the determined measure 21 of electrical resistance with time.
[0096] Various rates of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with time may be applied, including the following non-limitative examples.
[0097] The rate of change of the determined measure 21 of electrical resistance may be the rate while the SMA element 13 heats during the drive pulses themselves.
[0098] The rate of change of the determined measure 21 of electrical resistance may be the rate while the SMA element cools in the gaps between the drive pulses. As the rate of heating during the drive pulses and the rate of cooling in the gaps between the drive pulses are maximised at the same state of the phase transition of the SMA element 3, use of either of these rates produces an equivalent control.
[0099] For similar reasons, the rate of change of the determined measure 21 of electrical resistance may be a combination of the rate while the SMA element heats during the drive pulses themselves and the rate while the SMA element cools in the gaps between the drive pulses.
[0100] Consequently, in functional block F3, the controller controls the one or more characteristics of the drive pulses so that the rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with time is maximised. Thus, this method directly controls the SMA element 3 to provide the optimal haptic effect.
[0101] The maximisation of the rate in functional block F3 may be performed using any suitable numerical optimisation method, for example a gradient descent method, wherein a history of the controlled characteristics of the drive pulse is stored and used to find and maintain the maximum rate of change of resistance with time.
[0102] A specific example is as follows.
[0103] The control in functional block F3 is performed on an inner control loop with a set period that is significantly shorter than the cycle period of the drive pulses. Resistance is measured every control loop cycle. At the start of a waveform period the loop counter is reset to zero and power is applied. When the loop counter exceeds the value proportional to the desired duty cycle the resistance of the SMA element 3 is recorded (Rl). The resistance of the SMA element may be measured whilst power is applied to the SMA element. Alternatively, a separate, lower-voltage circuit may be used for determining resistance in which case the power need not be applied to the SMA element during resistance measurement.
[0104] When the loop counter gets to a value corresponding to a waveform period, the resistance is recorded (R2). The rate of motion during cooling is then found for that waveform period as (Rl-R2) / N where N is the number of loop cycles between the two resistance measurements. An alternative to avoid division and minimise noise is to take the sum of resistance changes over the cooling period up to a power of two count, then bit shifting to find the average.
[0105] On completion of this inner loop (or the calculation spread over the following loop to avoid lumpy processing) an outer control loop takes the cooling rate, or an average or sum over a set number of outer loop cycles, which may be re-set if the pulse duty is changed or filtered in some other way. This measure of the cooling rate is compared to a stored value of cooling rate at a different pulse duty. If the cooling rate is higher than the reference value, then the pulse duty is adjusted to further increase the rate. This may be by applying an offset to the present duty by an amount proportional to the difference between the current rate and a reference rate, the proportionality constant being determined empirically to give a desired adaptation rate and stability. Equally, if the cooling rate is lower than the reference value then the pulse duty is adjusted to increase the rate again. This process is then repeated: if the cooling rate has increased, the previous reference value is replaced with the new cooling rate and the pulse duty is further incremented in the same direction. If the cooling rate has reduced, the pulse duty is incremented in the opposite direction. In some embodiments the ambient air temperature may be taken into account in controlling the duty. For example, the current rate of cooling or a recent history (e.g. the cooling rate for a set of the most recent pulses) may be taken into account in adjusting the duty in order to account for the ambient air temperature increasing over time as the air is heated up by the wire.
[0106] An example of the iterative process described above is now provided.
[0107] The device is initially idle. A sequence of drive pulses train initially has a frequency of 100 Hz. As a first step, the controller 13 applies an initial drive signal to raise the temperature of the SMA element 13 to its transition temperature. The power of this initial drive signal may be determined based on the known volume of SMA material in the SMA element 3 or determined empirically for the part or design. Confirmation that the SMA element 3 has started to transition is obtained by monitoring the measure 21 of resistance and detecting a maximum. It may be that the drop in resistance from this maximum is also controlled to provide the initial pulse and to ensure the SMA element 3 is within its phase transition region.
[0108] The initial default pulse duty is 50%. The inner loop rate is 5kHz. The counter limit for the active drive pulse is set to 25 and the counter limit for the pulse period to 50. Drive pulses are applied and the resistance velocity recorded.
[0109] The pulse parameters are un-changed for 10 pulses (for this example we assume the outer loop runs every 10 pulses, this could be any number but is set such that the time allowed for the number of drive pulses is sufficient for the average temperature of the SMA element 3 to stabilise between duty settings), at which point mean rate is recorded as 400 units, this is set as a reference rate.
[0110] A further 10 pulses later the average rate has increased to 430 units, this is faster than the previous value, so is stored as the reference. 10 pulses later the average rate (over the last 10 pulses) is 350 units. This is a decrease (a threshold may be applied here so no change is made if the rate is within say 20 units, for example, of the reference rate) so the pulse duty is decreased by 1 unit (in this example we assume 1 unit change at a time).
[0111] 10 drive pulses later, the rate is still 350 so the duty is decreased by 1 again. 10 pulses later the mean rate is 440 units. This replaces the previously stored reference rate. 10 cycles later the measured average rate is 441. A threshold of 5 units is applied here, so no change is made and the pulse duty does not oscillate about the optimal value, which may not be an integer number of inner loop cycles. In the event that a maximum rate is arrived at, both decreasing and increasing the duty will cause the rate to move away from an optimal value which may result in a small oscillation about the optimal cooling rate.
[0112] In order to start, an initial value of the pulse duty must be set and time allowed for the cooling rate to stabilise. This may be done by monitoring the rate of resistance change during cooling (rate during heating could also be used)
[0113] A third option for the control method is as follows. This method may be viewed as a refinement of the second option for the control method. The rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with respect to temperature (rather than time) is used.
[0114] Accordingly, in the third option, the electrical parameter derived in functional block F2 is a rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with the estimated temperature. Accordingly, the control method shown in Fig. 7 is modified to estimate a temperature of the SMA element 3 as shown in Figs. 9 and 10, which show two different examples for the estimation of the temperature of the SMA element 3.
[0115] The method of each of Figs. 9 and 10 include functional blocks Fl to F3 which are the same as shown in Fig. 7 and so the description thereof applies here also and will not be repeated.
[0116] In addition, each of Figs. 9 and 10 include a functional block F4, in which the controller estimates the temperature of the SMA element 13.
[0117] In the example of Fig. 9, the temperature in functional block F4 is estimated from the measure 21 of electrical resistance determined by the measurement circuit 15.
[0118] In the example of Fig. 10, the temperature in functional block F4 is estimated from a history of the power of the drive pulses.
[0119] Accordingly, the rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with the estimated temperature derived in functional block F4 uses the output of functional block F4, as well as the measure 21 of resistance from the measurement circuit 15.
[0120] Consequently, in functional block F3, the controller controls the one or more characteristics of the drive pulses so that the rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with the estimated temperature is maximised.
[0121] As with the second option for the control method, the maximisation of the rate in functional block F3 may be performed using any suitable numerical optimisation method, for example a gradient descent method, wherein a history of the controlled characteristics of the drive pulse is stored and used to find and maintain the maximum rate of change of resistance with time. This may use an approach similar to the example for the second option set out above.
[0122] In the control methods disclosed herein, the SMA element is supplied with drive pulses. Referring to figure 5, as described above the pulses may have a period Pp and may be delivered in a cycle of frequency / (i.e. a cycle period 1 / f) so that the pulse duty of the drive pulses is (Pp. / ). Applying such a pulse may comprise switching the voltage on at the start of the period and off again at the end of the period Pp, i.e. applying power continuously within the pulse. Such a pulse is shown in Figure 11A. The resulting displacement over time is shown in Figure 11B.
[0123] Alternatively, the pulse itself may comprise a set of one or more shorter pulses. In other words, applying the pulse may comprise switching the voltage on and off multiple times within the pulse such that power is supplied to the SMA element intermittently. Such a pulse is shown in Figure 12A. The resulting displacement over time is shown in Figure 12B. This difference (as between continuous and intermittent pulses) will provide a different haptic effect.
[0124] Where a pulse is referred to in any of the methods described herein, such pulse may be continuous or intermittent.
[0125] The above-described SMA actuator assemblies comprise at least one SMA element. The term 'shape memory alloy (SMA) element' may refer to any element comprising SMA. The SMA element may be described as an SMA wire. The SMA element may have any shape that is suitable for the purposes described herein. The SMA element may be elongate and may have a round cross section or any other shape cross section. The cross section may vary along the length of the SMA element. The SMA element might have a relatively complex shape such as a helical spring. It is also possible that the length of the SMA element (however defined) may be similar to one or more of its other dimensions. The SMA element may be sheet-like, and such a sheet may be planar or non-planar. The SMA element may be pliant or, in other words, flexible. In some examples, when connected in a straight line between two components, the SMA element can apply only a tensile force which urges the two components together. In other examples, the SMA element may be bent around a component and can apply a force to the component as the SMA element tends to straighten under tension. The SMA element may be beam-like or rigid and may be able to apply different (e.g. non-tensile) forces to elements. The SMA element may or may not include material(s) and / or component(s) that are not SMA. For example, the SMA element may comprise a core of SMA and a coating of non-SMA material. Unless the context requires otherwise, the term 'SMA element' may refer to any configuration of SMA material acting as a single actuating element which, for example, can be individually controlled to produce a force on an element. For example, the SMA element may comprise two or more portions of SMA material that are arranged mechanically in parallel and / or in series. In some arrangements, the SMA element may be part of a larger SMA element. Such a larger SMA element might comprise two or more parts that are individually controllable, thereby forming two or more SMA elements. The SMA element may comprise an SMA wire, SMA foil, SMA film or any other configuration of SMA material. The SMA element may be manufactured using any suitable method, for example by a method involving drawing, rolling or deposition and / or other forming process(es). The SMA element may exhibit any shape memory effect, e.g. a thermal shape memory effect or a magnetic shape memory effect, and may be controlled in any suitable way, e.g. by Joule heating, another heating technique or by applying a magnetic field. It will be appreciated that there may be many other variations of the above-described examples. For example, embodiments described herein have referred to shape memory alloy but they may equally apply to shape memory materials generally, e.g. shape memory polymers.
[0126] The term 'predetermined' is used herein to describe a state of a phase transition of an SMA element. For example, a method according to a first aspect of the present invention comprises controlling one or more characteristics of the drive pulses on the basis of a determined value of the electrical parameter so that the SMA element is maintained in a predetermined state of a phase transition of the SMA element over successive cycles of the sequence of drive pulses. It will be appreciated that the term 'predetermined' does not require a specific numerical value to be determined before drive pulses are supplied, for example. Instead, it refers generally to a state of a phase transition which has certain desired characteristics. For example, the predetermined state of the phase transition may be one in which a rate of change of displacement (i.e. velocity) of the SMA element while it cools between pulses falls within a certain range, e.g. is maximised, or has certain characteristics. For example, a method in which the rate of cooling is determined for a particular duty and then the duty incremented depending on a comparison between the updated cooling rate and a previous cooling rate (corresponding to a previous, different duty), as described above, involves the control of one or more characteristics of the drive pulses on the basis of a determined value of an electrical parameter so that the SMA is maintained in a predetermined state of a phase transition of the SMA element over successive cycles of the sequence of drive pulses.
[0127] Similarly, it will be appreciated that the predetermined state of a phase transition may not necessarily refer to a single numerical value but optionally a range of values of a certain parameter.
Claims
Claims1. A method of driving a shape memory alloy, SMA, actuator comprising an SMA element in a haptic assembly that is arranged on actuation of the SMA actuator to provide a haptic effect, the method comprising: supplying a sequence of drive pulses to the SMA element so that the haptic effect is vibratory; determining a value of an electrical parameter of the SMA element; and controlling one or more characteristics of the drive pulses on the basis of the determined value of the electrical parameter so that the SMA element is maintained in a predetermined state of a phase transition of the SMA element over successive cycles of the sequence of drive pulses.
2. A method according to claim 1, wherein the predetermined state of a phase transition of the SMA element provides a maximum rate of change of displacement while the SMA element cools between the drive pulses.
3. A method according to claim 1 or 2, wherein the step of determining a value of an electrical parameter comprises: determining a measure of the electrical resistance of the SMA element; and deriving the value of the electrical parameter from the determined measure of electrical resistance of the SMA element.
4. A method according to claim 3, wherein the electrical parameter is an average of the determined measure of electrical resistance over at least one drive pulse cycle; and the step of controlling the one or more characteristics of the drive pulses is performed using closed loop feedback control to drive the determined value of the electrical parameter towards a target value.
5. A method according to claim 4, wherein the electrical parameter is an average of the determined measure of electrical resistance over plural drive pulse cycles.
6. A method according to claim 4 or 5, wherein the target value is a predetermined calibration value.
7. A method according to claim 4 or 5, wherein the method further comprises: before supplying the sequence of drive pulses to the SMA element, supplying an initial drive signal for heating the SMA element; and during the supply of the initial drive signal, determining a measure of the electrical resistance of the SMA element and detecting a maximum value of the determined measure of electrical resistance, wherein the target value is a predetermined margin below the detected maximum value.
8. A method according to claim 3, wherein the electrical parameter is a rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with time, and the step of controlling the one or more characteristics of the drive pulses is performed so that the rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with time is maximised.
9. A method according to claim 8, wherein the step of controlling the one or more characteristics of the drive pulses is performed so that the magnitude of the rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with time is maximised using a numerical optimisation method.
10. A method according to claim 8 or 9, wherein the rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with time is: the rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance while the SMA element heats during the pulses; the rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance while the SMA element cools between the pulses; or a combination of the rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance while the SMA element heats during the pulses and the rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance while the SMA element cools between the pulses.
11. A method according to claim 3, wherein the step of determining the value of an electrical parameter further comprises: estimating a temperature of the SMA element from the determined measure of electrical resistance or from a history of the power of the drive pulses, the electrical parameter is a rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with the estimated temperature, and the step of controlling one or more characteristics of the drive pulses is performed so that the magnitude of the rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with the estimated temperature is maximised.
12. A method according to claim 11, wherein the step of controlling the one or more characteristics of the drive pulses is performed so that the magnitude of the rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with estimated temperature is maximised using a numerical optimisation method.
13. A method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the one or more characteristics of the drive pulses includes one or more of: the pulse duty of the drive pulses; the frequency of the drive pulses; and the amplitude of the drive pulses.
14. A method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the haptic effect is a movement of an external part of a handheld device.
15. A method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the sequence of drive pulses is supplied over a period of at least 0.02 seconds, optionally at least 0.1 seconds.
16. A method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the sequence of drive pulses comprises at least 5 pulses, optionally at least 10 pulses, optionally at least 20 pulses.
17. A method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the drive pluses have a frequency of at least 5Hz, optionally at least 10 Hz, optionally at least 100 Hz.
18. A method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the drive pluses have a frequency of at most 500 Hz.
19. A control circuit for a shape memory alloy, SMA, actuator comprising an SMA element in a haptic assembly that is arranged on actuation of the SMA actuator to provide a haptic effect, wherein the control circuit is arranged to: supply a sequence of drive pulses to the SMA element so that the haptic effect is vibratory; determine a value of an electrical parameter of the SMA element; and control one or more characteristics of the drive pulses on the basis of the determined value of the electrical parameter so that the SMA element is maintained in a predetermined state of a phase transition of the SMA element over successive cycles of the sequence of drive pulses.
20. A haptic device comprising: a control circuit according to claim 19; and a haptic assembly comprising a shape memory alloy, SMA, actuator comprising an SMA element, the haptic assembly being arranged on actuation of the SMA actuator to provide a haptic effect.
21. A computer program configured, on execution by a processor, to cause the processor to perform a method of controlling the driving of a shape memory alloy, SMA, actuator comprising an SMA element in a haptic assembly that is arranged on actuation of the SMA actuator to provide a haptic effect, the method comprising: controlling a drive circuit to supply a sequence of drive pulses to the SMA element so that the haptic effect is vibratory; receiving a value of an electrical parameter of the SMA element; and controlling the drive circuit to control one or more characteristics of the drive pulses on the basis of the value of the electrical parameter so that the SMA element is maintained in a predetermined state of a phase transition of the SMA element over successive cycles of the sequence of drive pulses.
22. A method of driving an actuator comprising a shape memory alloy element in a hapticassembly that is arranged on actuation of the SMA element to provide a haptic effect, the method comprising: supplying a sequence of drive pulses to the SMA element so that the haptic effect is vibratory; and determining a measure of the electrical resistance of the SMA element and determining a value of an average of the determined electrical resistance over at least one drive pulse cycle; and controlling one or more characteristics of the drive pulses on the basis of the determined value of the average of the electrical resistance using closed loop feedback control to drive the determined value of the average of the electrical resistance towards a target value.
23. A method of driving a shape memory alloy, SMA, actuator comprising an SMA element in a haptic assembly that is arranged on actuation of the SMA element to provide a haptic effect, the method comprising: supplying a sequence of drive pulses to the SMA element so that the haptic effect is vibratory; determining a measure of the electrical resistance of the SMA actuator and determining a value of a rate of change of electrical resistance with time; and controlling one or more characteristics of the drive pulses so that the rate of change of electrical resistance with time is maximised.
24. A method of driving an actuator comprising a shape memory alloy, SMA, element in a haptic assembly that is arranged on actuation of the SMA element to provide a haptic effect, the method comprising: supplying a sequence of drive pulses to the SMA element so that the haptic effect is vibratory; and determining a measure of the electrical resistance of the SMA element; estimating a temperature of the SMA element from the determined measure of electrical resistance or from a history of the power of the drive pulses; and determining a value of a rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with the estimated temperature; and controlling one or more characteristics of the drive pulses so that the rate of change of the determined measure of electrical resistance with the estimated temperature is maximised.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Haptic feedback control assembly
WO2018046937A1
Haptic button with sma
WO2019162708A1
SMA haptic assembly
WO2021148814A1
Haptic feedback control assembly
GB2602740A
Device for Transmitting Information to a Living Being
US20120212442A1
