A multi-dimensional vulnerability risk rating method for power monitoring systems

By establishing security vulnerability sets and asset metadata sets, combining inverted indexing algorithms and network-wide data crawling technology, multi-dimensional risk ratings for vulnerabilities in power monitoring system are achieved, solving the problem of incomplete vulnerability ratings in the existing technology, and improving the The scientificity and applicability of the ratings.

CN113553597BActive Publication Date: 2024-11-29STATE GRID SHANDONG ELECTRIC POWER CO +3
View PDF 3 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202111029571.4
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2021-09-03
Publication Date
2024-11-29
Estimated Expiration
2041-09-03

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The existing power monitoring system lacks timely sorting and controlling the system asset unit data and published vulnerability information, and cannot calculate the adhesion between system asset unit and vulnerability risks, and cannot perform multi-dimensional vulnerability risk ratings.

Method used

A multi-dimensional vulnerability risk rating method for power monitoring system is proposed, including establishing a security vulnerability set, improving asset metadata set, vulnerability intelligent scanning and vulnerability adhesiveness calculation, optimizing asset data query through inverted indexing algorithm, combining data crawling across the network Use technology to perform multi-dimensional vulnerability risk rating.

Benefits of technology

It realizes timely discovery of vulnerabilities in the power monitoring system and multi-dimensional risk rating, enhances asset unit management and vulnerability adhesion calculation capabilities, and improves the scientificity and applicability of the rating.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN113553597B_ABST
    Figure CN113553597B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The present invention discloses a multi-dimensional vulnerability risk rating method for a power monitoring system, which includes the steps of establishing a security vulnerability set, improving an asset metadata set, intelligent vulnerability scanning, reproducing new vulnerabilities, and multi-dimensional vulnerability risk rating. The method can autonomously discover vulnerabilities in the power monitoring system and timely perform vulnerability risk rating from multiple dimensions by reproducing the vulnerabilities. The advantages of the method proposed by the present invention compared with the traditional method are reflected in the addition of functions such as autonomous hot reproduction of vulnerabilities, hot pudding repair, and multi-dimensional risk rating. It has the advantages of scientific and reasonable methods, strong applicability, and good effects.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present invention relates to electric power monitoring technology, and in particular to a multi-dimensional electric power monitoring system vulnerability risk rating method. Background Art

[0002] At present, the vulnerability risk rating of the power monitoring system mainly consists of three parts: vulnerability scanning, vulnerability adhesion calculation, and vulnerability risk rating. Vulnerability scanning refers to a security detection behavior based on the vulnerability database, through scanning methods such as operating systems and network applications to detect the security of designated equipment systems and discover exploitable vulnerabilities; vulnerability adhesion calculation is to analyze the correlation between system equipment and vulnerability information; vulnerability risk rating refers to the level assessment of security risks based on the threats faced by information assets in the system, the weaknesses of the system, and the impact caused by the invasion. The current security vulnerabilities in the power monitoring system often come from the operating system, interface software, chip firmware, application software of the programmable controller host computer, and network communication protocols. To conduct vulnerability risk rating, we should first obtain the equipment information in the power monitoring system, and then establish a vulnerability set based on the equipment, and then find the proof of concept (POC) and vulnerability exploit (EXP) corresponding to each vulnerability in the vulnerability set, and combine the vulnerability records with high historical similarity to judge the difficulty of repair and the diffusion coefficient. Then, we should conduct a risk assessment on the harm caused by the vulnerability and generate a vulnerability risk rating report. Currently released protection systems usually use a device and task whitelist mechanism to only allow the operating system to run trusted objects. Before any program runs, it must be paused for protection system inspection. For vulnerabilities generated in the operating system and device firmware, the only way to patch and prevent vulnerabilities is to regularly collect vulnerability information and release system updates. Therefore, the existing protection system still has the following problems:

[0003] (1) Lack of timely organization and control of system asset unit data and published vulnerability information;

[0004] (2) There is a lack of calculation of the adhesion between system asset units and various vulnerability risks, and it is impossible to analyze the correlation between asset unit status and vulnerabilities;

[0005] (3) It is impossible to conduct multi-dimensional risk rating of potential vulnerability risks. Summary of the invention

[0006] The main purpose of the present invention is to improve and innovate the existing monitoring and protection system in combination with the power monitoring system, and propose a multi-dimensional power monitoring system vulnerability risk rating method that is scientific, reasonable, highly applicable, and effective. The method can effectively scan the power monitoring system for vulnerabilities, calculate the viscosity of vulnerabilities, and perform vulnerability risk rating in multiple dimensions based on the authenticity and complexity of the vulnerabilities and the difficulty of repairing them.

[0007] The technical solution adopted by the present invention is: a multi-dimensional power monitoring system vulnerability risk rating method, including: establishing a security vulnerability set; improving an asset metadata set; intelligent vulnerability scanning; vulnerability adhesion calculation; and multi-dimensional vulnerability risk rating.

[0008] Furthermore, the establishment of the security vulnerability set includes: organizing different types of security vulnerabilities such as operating systems, interface software, and chip firmware to establish a security vulnerability set. There are three sources for collecting vulnerabilities: one is real-time acquisition of common vulnerability disclosures in public networks, national information security vulnerability sharing platforms, and vulnerability information in China's national information security vulnerability database; the second is data analysis of authoritative vulnerability notification platforms in public networks; and the third is specific processing of notification data from the vulnerability monitoring platform within the power monitoring system. The three-party data are integrated according to a unified standard to establish a security vulnerability set; the security vulnerability set contains the following ten metadata: information security vulnerability Internet general number Vuln_Publ ic_Name, information security vulnerability power monitoring system internal standard number Vuln_Internal_Name, vulnerability name Vuln_Name, vulnerability details Vuln_Desc, product corresponding to the vulnerability Vuln_Product, version range of products affected by the vulnerability Vuln_Affect_Version, vulnerability type Vuln_Type, vulnerability threat level Vuln_Threat_Level, vulnerability collection source VulnOrigin, vulnerability collection time Vuln_Timestamp, the model is expressed as: VULN={Vuln_Public_Name, Vuln_Internal_Name, Vuln_Name, Vuln_Desc, Vuln_Product, Vuln_Affect_Version, Vuln_Type, Vuln_Threat_Level, Vuln Origin, Vuln_Timestamp}.

[0009] Furthermore, the sound asset metadata set includes: the asset metadata set mainly includes data of various related software and hardware existing in the system, specifically as follows: hardware device model HW_Model, firmware model FW_Model, operating system type OS_Type, operating system version number OS_Version, upper-layer component product Middleware_Product, upper-layer component product version number Middleware_Version, application product APP_Product, application version number APP_Version, application plug-in product Plugin_Product, application plug-in version number Plugin_Version, and the model is expressed as DEV={HW_Model, FW_Model, OS_Type, OS_Version, Middleware_Product,Middleware_Version, APP_Product, APP_Version, Plugin_Product, Plugin_Version}.

[0010] Furthermore, the vulnerability intelligent scanning includes: the vulnerability intelligent scanning draws on the inverted index algorithm, firstly optimizes the inverted index of the asset metadata set when the system is idle, extracts the products corresponding to all asset data, creates a list of all non-repetitive product names, and then records the assets corresponding to each product, and optimizes the total number of product indexes to q, that is, when querying the assets corresponding to the product, only q queries are required at most, so as to improve the search efficiency and accuracy.

[0011] Furthermore, the vulnerability adhesion calculation includes: calculating the adhesion of the vulnerability obtained by scanning and the element in the asset metadata set, generating the structural unit data of each part of the vulnerability operating environment, that is, the operating system model and middleware product name of the element, etc., to form the vulnerability reproduction environment configuration data. The adhesion is mainly manifested in the correlation between the newly-issued vulnerability and the relevant application of the asset element, the intermediate component, and the upper operating system. These three types of data are combined into a vulnerability trigger factor set, the vulnerability trigger factor set is abstracted, a three-dimensional coordinate system is defined, a mathematical model is established, and the newly-issued vulnerability is recorded as a point. , and record the asset elements as points , thereby calculating the adhesion between the newly-issued vulnerability and the asset element, selecting the asset element with the highest adhesion, and determining the set of vulnerability trigger factors that are most likely to cause the vulnerability. The vulnerability adhesion calculation formula is as follows:

[0012] (1).

[0013] Furthermore, the multi-dimensional vulnerability risk rating includes: according to the obtained vulnerability trigger factor set, using the whole network data crawling technology to obtain the POC, EXP, etc. in the public vulnerability report of the new vulnerability, combining the vulnerability types with high similarity in the vulnerability trigger factor set, querying the vulnerability propagation record, judging the difficulty of patching and the diffusion coefficient, finding out whether the vulnerability has a pudding released, and dividing the threat level from multiple dimensions such as vulnerability authenticity, vulnerability complexity, historical similarity, and vulnerability patching difficulty. The rating formula is defined as:

[0014] (2)

[0015] in, is the vulnerability risk value, To query the vulnerability risk factor, is the vulnerability propagation time risk coefficient, is the risk factor of vulnerability propagation quantity, , , It can be adjusted according to actual conditions, but must meet , Indicates whether the query vulnerability POC / EXP returns a value, if it exists, it is 0, if not, it is 1. is the propagation time of similar vulnerabilities, is the number of devices infected by similar vulnerabilities during the propagation period, The number of times the vulnerability was spread after the patch was released. The total number of vulnerability propagation is calculated by calculating the vulnerability risk value, thereby achieving multi-dimensional vulnerability risk rating.

[0016] Advantages of the present invention: Aiming at the existing security protection problems of power monitoring systems, the present invention creatively proposes a multi-dimensional power monitoring system vulnerability risk rating method, which can autonomously discover vulnerabilities in the power monitoring system and timely reproduce the vulnerabilities from multiple dimensions for vulnerability risk rating. Compared with the traditional method, the advantages of the present invention are reflected in the addition of asset unit management, calculation of asset unit and vulnerability adhesion, multi-dimensional risk rating and other functions, and has the advantages of scientific and reasonable methods, strong applicability, good effect and the like.

[0017] In addition to the above-described purposes, features and advantages, the present invention has other purposes, features and advantages. The present invention will be further described in detail with reference to the accompanying drawings. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0018] The drawings constituting a part of this application are used to provide a further understanding of the present invention. The illustrative embodiments of the present invention and their descriptions are used to explain the present invention and do not constitute improper limitations on the present invention.

[0019] Figure 1It is a flow chart of the multi-dimensional power monitoring system vulnerability risk rating method of the present invention;

[0020] Figure 2 This is a data flow diagram of the multi-dimensional power monitoring system vulnerability risk rating method of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0021] In order to make the purpose, technical solution and advantages of the present invention more clearly understood, the present invention is further described in detail below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings and embodiments. It should be understood that the specific embodiments described herein are only used to explain the present invention and are not intended to limit the present invention.

[0022] Reference Figure 1 and Figure 2 A multi-dimensional vulnerability risk rating method for a power monitoring system includes: establishing a security vulnerability set; improving an asset metadata set; intelligent vulnerability scanning; vulnerability adhesion calculation; and multi-dimensional vulnerability risk rating.

[0023] The establishment of the security vulnerability set includes: sorting out different types of security vulnerabilities in operating systems, interface software, chip firmware, etc., and establishing a security vulnerability set. The sources of vulnerability collection are three: one is real-time acquisition of Common Vulnerabilities & Exposures (CVE) in public networks, China National Vulnerability Database (CNVD), China National Vulnerability Database of Information Security (CNVD), and China National Vulnerability Database of Information Security (CNVD). The first step is to analyze the vulnerability information in the public network (CNNVD), the second step is to analyze the data of the authoritative vulnerability notification platform in the public network, and the third step is to perform specific processing on the notification data of the vulnerability monitoring platform inside the power monitoring system, and then integrate the data of the three parties according to the unified standard to establish a security vulnerability set; the security vulnerability set includes the following ten metadata: information security vulnerability Internet universal number Vuln_Public_Name, information security vulnerability power monitoring system internal standard number Vuln_Internal_Name, vulnerability name Vuln_Name, vulnerability details Vuln_Desc, vulnerability corresponding product Vuln_Product, vulnerability affected product version range Vuln_Affect_Version, vulnerability type Vuln_Type, vulnerability threat level Vuln_Threat_Level, vulnerability collection source Vuln Origin, vulnerability collection time Vuln_Timestamp, the model is expressed as: VULN={Vuln_Public_Name, Vuln_Internal_Name, Vuln_Name, Vuln_Desc, Vuln_Product, Vuln_Affect_Version, Vuln_Type, Vuln_Threat_Level, Vuln Origin, Vuln_Timestamp}.

[0024] The sound asset metadata set includes: the asset metadata set mainly includes data of various related software and hardware existing in the system, specifically as follows: hardware device model HW_Model, firmware model (version number) FW_Model, operating system type OS_Type, operating system version number OS_Version, upper-layer component product Middleware_Product, upper-layer component product version number Middleware_Version, application product APP_Product, application version number APP_Version, application plug-in product Plugin_Product, application plug-in version number Plugin_Version, and the model is expressed as DEV={HW_Model, FW_Model, OS_Type, OS_Version, Middleware_Product,Middleware_Version, APP_Product, APP_Version, Plugin_Product, Plugin_Version}.

[0025] The vulnerability intelligent scanning includes: in order to confirm whether there is an element in the collection that has a new match or a similar situation in the security vulnerability set, the vulnerability intelligent scanning draws on the inverted index algorithm, firstly optimizes the inverted index of the asset metadata set when the system is idle, extracts the products corresponding to all asset data, creates a list of all non-repetitive product names, and then records the assets corresponding to each product, and optimizes the total number of product indexes to q, that is, when querying the assets corresponding to the product, only q queries are required at most, so as to improve the search efficiency and accuracy.

[0026] The vulnerability adhesion calculation includes: calculating the adhesion of the vulnerability obtained by scanning and the element in the asset metadata set, generating the structural unit data of each part of the vulnerability operating environment, that is, the operating system model of the element, the product name of the middleware, etc., to form the vulnerability reproduction environment configuration data. The adhesion is mainly manifested in the relevance of the new vulnerability (NewVuln) to the relevant application (Plugin) of the asset element (Asset), the intermediate component (App), and the upper operating system (OS). The three types of data are combined into a vulnerability trigger factor set, the vulnerability trigger factor set is abstracted, a three-dimensional coordinate system is defined, a mathematical model is established, and the new vulnerability is recorded as a point , and record the asset elements as points , thereby calculating the adhesion between the newly-issued vulnerability and the asset element, selecting the asset element with the highest adhesion, and determining the set of vulnerability trigger factors that are most likely to produce the vulnerability. The vulnerability adhesion calculation formula is as follows:

[0027] (1).

[0028] The multi-dimensional vulnerability risk rating includes: according to the obtained vulnerability trigger factor set, using the whole network data crawling technology to obtain the POC, EXP, etc. in the public vulnerability report of the new vulnerability, combined with the vulnerability type with high similarity in the vulnerability trigger factor set, querying the vulnerability propagation record, judging the difficulty of patching and the diffusion coefficient, finding out whether the vulnerability has a pudding released, and dividing the threat level from multiple dimensions such as vulnerability authenticity, vulnerability complexity, historical similarity, and vulnerability patching difficulty. The rating formula is defined as:

[0029] (2)

[0030] in, is the vulnerability risk value, To query the vulnerability risk factor, is the vulnerability propagation time risk coefficient, is the risk factor of vulnerability propagation quantity, , , It can be adjusted according to actual conditions, but must meet , Indicates whether the query vulnerability POC / EXP returns a value, if it exists, it is 0, if not, it is 1. is the propagation time of similar vulnerabilities, is the number of devices infected by similar vulnerabilities during the propagation period, The number of times the vulnerability was spread after the patch was released. The total number of vulnerability propagation is calculated by calculating the vulnerability risk value, thereby achieving multi-dimensional vulnerability risk rating.

[0031] The software program of the present invention is compiled based on automation, network security and computer processing technology, which is a technology familiar to those skilled in the art.

[0032] The above description is only a preferred embodiment of the present invention and is not intended to limit the present invention. Any modifications, equivalent substitutions, improvements, etc. made within the spirit and principle of the present invention should be included in the protection scope of the present invention.

Claims

1. A multi-dimensional power monitoring system vulnerability risk rating method, characterized in that: include: Establish a set of security vulnerabilities; Improve asset metadata set; Vulnerability intelligent scanning; Vulnerability adhesion calculation; Multi-dimensional vulnerability risk rating; The establishment of the security vulnerability set includes: After sorting out different types of security vulnerabilities in operating systems, interface software, and chip firmware, a security vulnerability set is established. There are three sources for collecting vulnerabilities. The first is real-time acquisition of vulnerability information from common vulnerability disclosures in public networks, national information security vulnerability sharing platforms, and China's national information security vulnerability database. The second is data analysis of authoritative vulnerability reporting platforms in the public network. The third is processing the notification data of the internal vulnerability monitoring platform of the power monitoring system. The three-party data are integrated according to unified standards to establish a security vulnerability set; the security vulnerability set contains the following ten metadata: information security vulnerability Internet general number Vuln_Public_Name, information security vulnerability power monitoring system internal standard number Vuln_Internal_Name, vulnerability name Vuln_Name, vulnerability details Vuln_Desc, vulnerability corresponding product Vuln_Product, vulnerability affected product version range Vuln_Affect_Version, vulnerability type Vuln_Type, vulnerability threat level Vuln_Threat_Level, vulnerability collection source Vuln Origin, vulnerability collection time Vuln_Timestamp, model representation is: VULN={Vuln_Public_Name, Vuln_Internal_Name, Vuln_Name, Vuln_Desc, Vuln_Product, Vuln_Affect_Version, Vuln_Type, Vuln_Threat_Level, Vuln Origin, Vuln_Timestamp}; The robust asset metadata set includes: The asset metadata set mainly includes the data of various software and hardware related to the system, as follows: hardware device model HW_Model, firmware model FW_Model, operating system type OS_Type, operating system version number OS_Version, upper-layer component product Middleware_Product, upper-layer component product version number Middleware_Version, application product APP_Product, application version number APP_Version, application plug-in product Plugin_Product, application plug-in version number Plugin_Version. The model is represented as DEV={HW_Model, FW_Model, OS_Type, OS_Version, Middleware_Product, Middleware_Version, APP_Product, APP_Version,Plugin_Product, Plugin_Version}; The vulnerability intelligent scanning includes: Vulnerability intelligent scanning uses the inverted index algorithm. First, when the system is idle, the inverted index of the asset metadata set is optimized. The products corresponding to all asset data are extracted to create a list of all non-repeated product names. Then, the assets corresponding to each product are recorded. The total number of optimized product indexes is q, that is, when querying the assets corresponding to the product, only q queries are required at most, so as to improve search efficiency and accuracy. The vulnerability adhesion calculation includes: Calculate the adhesion between the scanned vulnerabilities and the metadata in the asset metadata set, generate the structural unit data of each part of the vulnerability operating environment, that is, the operating system model of the metadata application and the product name of the middleware, and form the vulnerability reproduction environment configuration data. The adhesion is mainly manifested in the correlation between the new vulnerability and the relevant application of the asset metadata, the intermediate component situation, and the upper operating system situation. These three types of data are combined into a vulnerability trigger factor set, which is abstracted, a three-dimensional coordinate system is defined, a mathematical model is established, and the new vulnerability is recorded as a point , recording asset metadata as points , thereby calculating the adhesion between the newly-issued vulnerability and the asset metadata, and selecting the asset metadata with the highest adhesion, thereby determining the set of vulnerability trigger factors that are most likely to produce the vulnerability. The vulnerability adhesion calculation formula is as follows: (1); The multi-dimensional vulnerability risk rating includes: According to the obtained vulnerability trigger factor set, the whole network data crawling technology is used to obtain the POC and EXP in the public vulnerability report of the new vulnerability. Combined with the vulnerability types with high similarity in the vulnerability trigger factor set, the vulnerability propagation record is queried to determine the difficulty of patching and the diffusion coefficient, and to find out whether the vulnerability has a pudding released. The threat level is divided from multiple dimensions such as vulnerability authenticity, vulnerability complexity, historical similarity, and vulnerability patching difficulty. The rating formula is defined as: (2) in, is the vulnerability risk value, To query the vulnerability risk factor, is the vulnerability propagation time risk coefficient, is the risk factor of vulnerability propagation quantity, , , It can be adjusted according to actual conditions, but must meet , Indicates whether the query vulnerability POC / EXP returns a value, if it exists, it is 0, if not, it is 1. is the propagation time of similar vulnerabilities, is the number of devices infected by similar vulnerabilities during the propagation period, The number of times the vulnerability was spread after the patch was released. The total number of vulnerability propagation is calculated by calculating the vulnerability risk value, thereby achieving multi-dimensional vulnerability risk rating.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Multidimensional risk assessment method

    CN104268714A

  • Vulnerability scanning method and system

    CN104346565A

  • Network asset fingerprint identification method, system and device

    CN110324310A