A method for analyzing tunnel excavation face stability under seismic load conditions
Through the non-associated flow law and quasi-static method, the calculation formula of the ultimate support pressure and damage area of the tunnel palm surface under the action of earthquake is derived, and the analysis of the stability of the tunnel excavation surface in the existing technology is solved. Inadequately, the accuracy and rationality verification of tunnel excavation surface stability analysis under seismic load conditions has been achieved.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202111518823.X
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2021-12-13
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-22
- Estimated Expiration
- 2041-12-13
AI Technical Summary
In the prior art, non-associated flow laws have little impact on the stability analysis of tunnel excavation surfaces, especially under seismic load conditions, it is difficult to accurately calculate the ultimate support pressure and damage zone.
The quasi-static method based on the non-associative flow law is used to derive the calculation formula of the ultimate support pressure and damage area of the tunnel under the action of earthquakes, and the rationality of the theoretical method is verified through the numerical model, and parameter analysis is carried out to quantify excavation. effect of surface stability.
A reasonable calculation method is provided, which considers the comprehensive influence of non-associated flow law and seismic loads, verifies the accuracy of the theoretical model, quantifies the impact of relevant parameters on the stability of excavation surfaces, and improves the design of the palm surface of the tunnel. accuracy.
Smart Images

Figure CN114186344B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention belongs to the technical field of shield construction, and in particular relates to a tunnel excavation face stability analysis method under earthquake load conditions. Background Art
[0002] At present, the proportion of tunnels in transportation infrastructure is increasing. The main reasons are their high safety, high degree of mechanization and low impact on the surrounding environment. If the support force of the excavation face is not well controlled, serious accidents may occur. For example, if the support pressure of the face is not enough to balance the earth pressure, the face may collapse (Horn, 1961; Vermeer et al., 2002; Li et al., 2018; Luo et al., 2018; Wan et al., 2019; Zhang et al., 2020), otherwise ground uplift may occur (Klotz et al., 2006; Li et al., 2019). Therefore, based on the above reasons, providing a reasonable support pressure for the excavation working face is crucial to the stability of the face. At the same time, more attention should be paid to how to reasonably calculate the support pressure.
[0003] Some scholars have studied the stability of the tunnel face through different methods, and provided references for verifying the accuracy of numerical simulation and theoretical analysis through laboratory centrifuge tests (Chambon and Corte, 1994; Takano, et al., 2006; Lu et al., 2019) or 1g model tests (Kirsch, 2010; Berthoz, et al., 2012; Chen et al., 2013; Zhang et al., 2016). Model tests can obtain relatively intuitive test results, but they are costly and time-consuming. With the improvement of computer computing efficiency, numerical simulation, including finite element method (Vermeer et al., 2002; Ibrahim et al., 2015; Jin et al., 2019; Tang et al., 2019), finite difference method (Zhu et al., 2010; Senent, et al., 2013; Senent, et al., 2015) and discrete element method (Funatsu, et al., 2008; Chen, et al., 2011; Wu, et al., 2020), has been carried out by some scholars to study the stability of tunnel faces under different soil and tunnel parameters. In addition, theoretical analysis is one of the most important methods to obtain the ultimate support pressure and failure zone, including limit equilibrium method (Anagnostou and Kovári, 1994; Jancsecz and Steiner, 1994) and limit analysis method.
[0004] The limit equilibrium method is widely used to construct force or moment equilibrium equations to derive the ultimate support pressure value (Chen et al., 2015; Yu et al., 2020; Liang et al., 2021). The limit analysis method (Chen, 1975), including the lower bound theorem (Ukritchon and Keawsawasvong, 2019) and the upper bound theorem (Leca and Dormieux, 1990; Zhao et al., 2019), has been widely used in the derivation of the limit support force due to its strict assumptions and more accurate results. Mollon, et al., (2011a) proposed a rotation model based on spatial discretization technology to study the influence of pore water pressure on the stability of the tunnel face (Pan and Dias, 2016). The rotation model was improved by changing the upper part to analyze the stability of the tunnel face (Zou et al., 2019). Leca and Dormieux (1990) proposed the failure mechanism of truncated rigid cones, and improved the calculation accuracy by increasing the number of truncated cones (Soubra et al., 2008). Based on the numerical simulation results, some scholars (Zhang et al., 2015; Li et al., 2020) proposed improved failure models and compared them with other existing methods. Some scholars have gradually paid attention to the impact of seismic effects on tunnel safety (Yu et al., 2016&2018). The pseudo-static method is widely used to study the safety of long unsupported tunnels because of its convenience (Chakraborty and Kumar, 2013; Saada et al., 2013). Based on the nonlinear Mohr-Coulomb criterion and the Hoek-Brown failure criterion, the pseudo-static method is used for face reliability analysis (Zhang et al., 2017; Zhang et al., 2019). Based on the pseudo-static method, an upper limit finite element analysis was performed to calculate the magnitude of the internal compressive pressure required to support the tunnel (Sahoo and Kumar, 2012 & 2014). However, in the existing literature, there are few studies on the stability of tunnel faces considering seismic effects. In addition, previous studies have conducted stability analysis of shield tunnel faces under the assumption that the soil obeys the relevant flow law (Chen, 1975). In fact, the soil is subject to the relevant flow law, that is, the shear dilatancy angle is equal to the soil friction angle This is just a special case (Vermeer and de Borst, 1984; Vermeer, 1990). Some scholars have studied the influence of non-associated flow laws on landslide stability (Wang et al., 2001; Yang and Huang, 2009). However, there are few literatures on the influence of non-associated flow laws on the tunnel face.
[0005] Through the above analysis, the problems and defects of the existing technology are as follows: Currently, there is little research on the impact of non-associated flow laws on the tunnel face.
[0006] The difficulty of solving the above problems and defects is: 1. Consider the influence of non-associated flow law and seismic load on the stability of excavation surface; 2. Verify rationality; 3. Parameter analysis.
[0007] The significance of solving the above problems and defects is:
[0008] 1. Comprehensively consider the non-associated flow law and seismic load, derive the formula and provide the calculation method;
[0009] 2. Numerical simulation proves that the theoretical method is reasonable;
[0010] 3. The model proposed in this paper is used to quantify the influence of relevant parameters on the stability of the excavation face. Summary of the invention
[0011] In view of the problems existing in the prior art, the present invention provides a method for analyzing the stability of a tunnel excavation face under seismic load conditions.
[0012] The present invention is implemented as follows: a tunnel excavation face stability analysis method under seismic load conditions, the tunnel excavation face stability analysis method under seismic load conditions comprising:
[0013] Step 1: Based on the non-associated flow law, the stability limit analysis of the tunnel excavation face is carried out, and the calculation formula of the tunnel face limit support pressure and failure zone under earthquake action is derived by using the quasi-static method;
[0014] Step 2: A numerical model is established based on the quasi-static method to verify the rationality of the theoretical model in analyzing the stability of the tunnel face;
[0015] Step three: perform parameter analysis using theoretical methods.
[0016] Furthermore, in step 1, the non-associated flow rule is specifically:
[0017] The soil is not subject to the relevant flow rules and the dilatancy coefficient η is defined as follows:
[0018]
[0019] Among them, ψ and denote the dilatancy angle and friction angle respectively;
[0020] η is usually less than 1. In the limit analysis, the influence of non-associative flow rules is taken into account and the soil parameters are corrected. The correction formula is as follows:
[0021]
[0022]
[0023] where c * and denote the corrected cohesion and corrected friction angle, respectively.
[0024] Furthermore, in step one, the limit analysis of tunnel excavation face stability includes: failure mechanism analysis, geometric characteristic analysis, seismic force analysis, and limited support pressure analysis.
[0025] Further, the failure mechanism analysis is specifically as follows:
[0026] A new model is established based on the existing multi-block model, which consists of five truncated cones and a distributed force. When analyzing the stability of the tunnel face, an improved mechanism that depends on five angular parameters (α, β1, β2, β3 and β4) is used to study the influence of seismic action on the tunnel face based on the non-associated flow law.
[0027] Assume the diameter is D, the coverage depth is C, and an overload σ is applied to the surface S ; In addition, the uniform pressure is expressed as σ T Representation; As the coverage depth increases, a collapsed arch is formed; The model consists of five truncated cones and the distributed forces caused by the truncated ellipsoid or ellipsoid.
[0028] Furthermore, the geometric characteristic analysis is specifically as follows:
[0029] Based on the failure model, the variable is defined as β i (for 1≤i≤4) and α1, respectively define the semi-axis lengths of the ellipse as a1(b1), a i+1 (b i+1 )(for1≤i≤4) and a5(b5); The intersection of the first truncated cone and the tunnel surface is an ellipse. When the area in front of the tunnel collapses and may expand to the surface, the semi-axis length is derived as follows:
[0030]
[0031]
[0032] in
[0033]
[0034]
[0035] The areas A1 and A2 between two frustums i and i+1 are i,i+1 (1≤i≤4) is as follows:
[0036]
[0037] A i,i+1 =πa i,i+1 b i,i+1 (9)
[0038] A5=πa5b5 (10)
[0039] A6=πa6b6 (11)
[0040] The volume of the frustum V1,V i (for 2≤i≤4) and V5 can be calculated; when the upper frustum intersects the ground, that is, C0>C, V6 can be calculated as follows:
[0041]
[0042] In contrast, V6 is defined as follows:
[0043]
[0044] Furthermore, the seismic force analysis is specifically as follows:
[0045] The dynamic effect is simplified to the inertial force acting on the object, the seismic force k h G and k v G is the seismic force on the tunnel face, and its relationship is expressed as follows:
[0046] k v G=ξk h G (14)
[0047] Where k h and k v are the horizontal and vertical seismic effect coefficients respectively, ξ is the proportionality coefficient; G is the soil weight;
[0048] The limited support pressure analysis is specifically as follows:
[0049] According to the upper limit theorem, the stability of the tunnel face should meet the following conditions:
[0050] P e ≤P v (15)
[0051] Power of external load P e, including the power of the support pressure P T , power of additional load P S , power per unit weight of soil P γ And the total power P generated by horizontal and vertical seismic forces γ ', can be calculated by equations (16)-(20);
[0052] P T = -A1 cosασ T v1 (16)
[0053] P S =v5 sin(2β2+2β4+α)A6σ S (17)
[0054]
[0055]
[0056] P e =P T +P S +P γ +P γ ' (20)
[0057] Based on the upper bound theorem, combined with equations (15)-(19), it can be obtained in the following way:
[0058]
[0059] Where N γ ,N c and N S are dimensionless coefficients representing the effects of soil weight, cohesion and additional load, and N γ With N S It can be calculated by the formula;
[0060]
[0061] N c and N S Related to the following classic formula:
[0062]
[0063] The optimal solution in cohesive friction soil can be obtained based on the maximization of five variables (α, β1, β2, β3, β4) by using the mathematical procedure in equation (21).
[0064] Furthermore, in step 2, the rationality of the theoretical model in analyzing the stability of the tunnel face is verified, and the specific process is as follows:
[0065] To verify the accuracy of the theoretical model based on non-associated flow law in the study of seismic stability of shield tunnels, the results obtained from the theoretical model were compared with the numerical simulation results;
[0066] A series of numerical analyses were performed using a finite difference computer program to calculate the ultimate support pressure and the failure zone.
[0067] Furthermore, in the step three, parameter analysis is performed by a theoretical method, including: the influence of the horizontal seismic effect coefficient and the influence of the vertical seismic effect coefficient;
[0068] The influence of horizontal seismic effect coefficient includes: the influence of horizontal seismic effect coefficient on ultimate support pressure and the influence of horizontal seismic effect coefficient on damage area;
[0069] The influence of the vertical seismic effect coefficient includes: the influence of the vertical seismic effect coefficient on the ultimate support pressure and the influence of the vertical seismic effect coefficient on the damage area.
[0070] Combining all the above-mentioned technical solutions, the advantages and positive effects of the present invention are as follows: Based on the non-associated flow law, the present invention uses the quasi-static method to derive the calculation formula for the ultimate support pressure and the damage area of the tunnel face under earthquake action. Then, a numerical model is established based on the quasi-static method to verify the rationality of the theoretical model in analyzing the stability of the tunnel face. In addition, the parameter analysis is carried out by theoretical methods. The present invention will provide a reference for the design of support pressure in shield tunnel construction. The results show that the model is reasonable for the stability analysis of the tunnel face considering the seismic effect. In addition, when designing the ultimate support pressure of the tunnel face, not only the seismic effect but also the non-associated flow law should be considered, especially in soils with high friction angles or unit weights. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0071] Figure 1 It is a flow chart of a tunnel excavation face stability analysis method under seismic load conditions provided by an embodiment of the present invention.
[0072] Figure 2 It is a schematic diagram of a new 3D improved fault mechanism provided by an embodiment of the present invention.
[0073] Figure 3 It is a combined schematic diagram of an improved 3D failure mechanism provided by an embodiment of the present invention.
[0074] Figure 3 Middle: Figure a, the mechanism breaks through the surface; Figure b, schematic diagram of the mechanism not reaching the surface.
[0075] Figure 4 It is a schematic diagram of a numerical model provided by an embodiment of the present invention.
[0076] Figure 5The embodiment of the present invention only considers k h Schematic diagram of the effect of shear dilatancy coefficient on ultimate support pressure at different friction angles.
[0077] Figure 5 Middle: Figure a, clay conditions 1 to 12; Figure b, sand conditions 13 to 24.
[0078] Figure 6 This is a consideration provided by the embodiment of the present invention. h Schematic diagram of the effect of shear dilatancy coefficient on ultimate support pressure at different friction angles with ξ.
[0079] Figure 6 Middle: Figure a, clay working conditions 25-36; Figure b, sand working conditions 37-48.
[0080] Figure 7 It is a schematic diagram comparing the failure areas between the existing mechanism and the numerical solution provided by an embodiment of the present invention.
[0081] Figure 7 Middle: Figure a, working condition 9; Figure b, working condition 21; Figure c, working condition 34; Figure d, working condition 46;
[0082] Figure 8 It is a schematic diagram of the influence of the horizontal seismic effect coefficient on the ultimate support pressure under different friction angles provided by an embodiment of the present invention.
[0083] Figure 8 Middle: Figure a, Figure b, k h vsσ T .
[0084] Fig. 9 It is a schematic diagram of the influence of the horizontal seismic effect coefficient under different viscosities on the ultimate support pressure provided by an embodiment of the present invention.
[0085] Fig. 9 Middle: Figure a, cvsσ T ; Figure b, k h vs σ T .
[0086] Fig.10 It is a schematic diagram of the influence of the horizontal seismic effect coefficient on the ultimate support pressure at different unit weights provided by an embodiment of the present invention.
[0087] Fig.10 Middle: Figure a, γ vs σ T ; Figure b, k h vsσ T .
[0088] Fig.11It is a schematic diagram of the influence of the horizontal seismic effect coefficient on the ultimate support pressure under different shear expansion coefficients provided in an embodiment of the present invention.
[0089] Fig.12 It is a schematic diagram of the influence of the horizontal seismic effect coefficient on the damage area provided by an embodiment of the present invention.
[0090] Fig.13 It is a schematic diagram of the influence of the vertical seismic effect coefficient at different friction angles on the ultimate support pressure provided by an embodiment of the present invention.
[0091] Fig.13 Middle: Figure a, Figure b, ξ vs σ T .
[0092] Fig.14 It is a schematic diagram of the influence of different viscous sagging seismic effect coefficients on the ultimate support pressure provided by an embodiment of the present invention.
[0093] Fig.14 Middle: Figure a, cvsσ T ; Figure b, ξ vs σ T .
[0094] Fig.15 It is a schematic diagram of the influence of different unit weight sagging seismic effect coefficients on the ultimate support pressure provided by an embodiment of the present invention.
[0095] Fig.15 Middle: Figure a, γ vs σ T ; Figure b, ξ vs σ T .
[0096] Fig.16 It is a schematic diagram of the influence of the vertical seismic effect coefficient on the ultimate support pressure under different shear expansion coefficients provided in an embodiment of the present invention.
[0097] Fig.17 It is a schematic diagram of the influence of the vertical seismic effect coefficient on the damage zone provided by an embodiment of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0098] In order to make the purpose, technical solution and advantages of the present invention more clearly understood, the present invention is further described in detail below in conjunction with the embodiments. It should be understood that the specific embodiments described herein are only used to explain the present invention and are not used to limit the present invention.
[0099] In view of the problems existing in the prior art, the present invention provides a method for analyzing the stability of a tunnel excavation face under seismic load conditions. The present invention is described in detail below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.
[0100] The method for analyzing the stability of tunnel excavation face under earthquake load conditions provided by the present invention can also be implemented by other steps by ordinary technicians in the industry. Figure 1 The tunnel excavation face stability analysis method under seismic load conditions provided by the present invention is only a specific embodiment.
[0101] like Figure 1 As shown, the tunnel excavation face stability analysis method under earthquake load conditions provided by the embodiment of the present invention includes:
[0102] S101: Based on the non-associated flow law, the stability limit analysis of the tunnel excavation face is carried out, and the calculation formulas for the ultimate support pressure and failure zone of the tunnel face under earthquake action are derived using the pseudo-static method.
[0103] S102: A numerical model is established based on the quasi-static method to verify the rationality of the theoretical model in analyzing the stability of the tunnel face.
[0104] S103: Parameter analysis by theoretical methods.
[0105] In S101 provided in the embodiment of the present invention, the non-associated flow rule is specifically:
[0106] The soil is not subject to the relevant flow rules and the dilatancy coefficient η is defined as follows:
[0107]
[0108] Among them, ψ and denote the dilatancy angle and friction angle respectively;
[0109] η is usually less than 1. In the limit analysis, the influence of non-associated flow rules is taken into account, the soil parameters are modified, and the modified formula is as follows:
[0110]
[0111]
[0112] where c * and denote the corrected cohesion and corrected friction angle, respectively.
[0113] In S101 provided in the embodiment of the present invention, the limit analysis of the stability of the tunnel excavation face includes: failure mechanism analysis, geometric characteristic analysis, seismic force analysis, and limited support pressure analysis;
[0114] The failure mechanism analysis is specifically as follows:
[0115] A new model is established based on the existing multi-block model, which consists of five truncated cones and a distributed force. When analyzing the stability of the tunnel face, an improved mechanism that depends on five angular parameters (α, β1, β2, β3 and β4) is used to study the influence of seismic action on the tunnel face based on the non-associated flow law.
[0116] Assume the diameter is D, the coverage depth is C, and an overload σ is applied to the surface S ; In addition, the uniform pressure is expressed as σ T Representation; As the coverage depth increases, a collapsed arch is formed; The model consists of five truncated cones and the distributed forces caused by the truncated ellipsoid or ellipsoid.
[0117] The geometric characteristics analysis is specifically as follows:
[0118] Based on the failure model, the variable is defined as β i (for 1≤i≤4) and α1, respectively define the semi-axis lengths of the ellipse as a1(b1), a i+1 (b i+1 )(for1≤i≤4) and a5(b5); The intersection of the first truncated cone and the tunnel surface is an ellipse. When the area in front of the tunnel collapses and may expand to the surface, the semi-axis length is derived as follows:
[0119]
[0120]
[0121] in
[0122]
[0123]
[0124] The areas A1 and A2 between two frustums i and i+1 are i,i+1 (1≤i≤4) is as follows:
[0125]
[0126] A i,i+1 =πa i,i+1 b i,i+1 (9)
[0127] A5=πa5b5 (10)
[0128] A6=πa6b6 (11)
[0129] The volume of the frustum V1,V i (for 2≤i≤4) and V5 can be calculated; when the upper rigid cone intersects the ground, that is, C0>C, V6 can be calculated as follows:
[0130]
[0131] In contrast, V6 is defined as follows:
[0132]
[0133] The seismic force analysis is specifically as follows:
[0134] Simplify the dynamic effect into the inertial force acting on the object, the seismic force k h G and k v G is the seismic force on the tunnel face, and its relationship is expressed as follows:
[0135] k v G=ξk h G (14)
[0136] Where k h and k v are the horizontal and vertical seismic effect coefficients respectively, ξ is the proportionality coefficient; G is the soil weight.
[0137] The limiting support pressure analysis is specifically as follows:
[0138] According to the upper limit theorem, the stability of the tunnel face should meet the following conditions:
[0139] P e ≤P v (15)
[0140] Power of external load P e , including the power of the support pressure P T , power of additional load P S , power per unit weight of soil P γ And the total power P generated by horizontal and vertical seismic forces γ ', can be calculated by equations (16)-(20);
[0141] P T = -A1cosασ T v1 (16)
[0142] P S =v5sin(2β2+2β4+α)A6σ S (17)
[0143]
[0144]
[0145] P e =P T +P S+P γ +P γ ' (20)
[0146] Based on the upper bound theorem, combined with equations (15)-(19), it can be obtained in the following way:
[0147]
[0148] Where N γ ,N c and N S are dimensionless coefficients representing the effects of soil weight, cohesion and additional load, and N γ With N S It can be calculated by the formula;
[0149]
[0150] N c and N S Related to the following classic formula:
[0151]
[0152] The optimal solution in cohesive friction soil can be obtained based on the maximization of five variables (α, β1, β2, β3, β4) by using the mathematical procedure in equation (21).
[0153] In S102 provided in the embodiment of the present invention, the rationality of the theoretical model in analyzing the stability of the tunnel face is verified, and the specific process is as follows:
[0154] To verify the accuracy of the theoretical model based on non-associated flow law in the study of seismic stability of shield tunnels, the results obtained from the theoretical model were compared with the numerical simulation results;
[0155] A series of numerical analyses were performed using a finite difference computer program to calculate the ultimate support pressure and the failure zone.
[0156] In S103 provided in the embodiment of the present invention, parameter analysis is performed by a theoretical method, including: the influence of the horizontal seismic effect coefficient and the influence of the vertical seismic effect coefficient;
[0157] The influence of horizontal seismic effect coefficient includes: the influence of horizontal seismic effect coefficient on ultimate support pressure and the influence of horizontal seismic effect coefficient on damage area;
[0158] The influence of the vertical seismic effect coefficient includes: the influence of the vertical seismic effect coefficient on the ultimate support pressure and the influence of the vertical seismic effect coefficient on the damage area.
[0159] The technical solution of the present invention is described in detail below in conjunction with specific embodiments.
[0160] 1. Analytical Model
[0161] 1.1 Considering non-associative flow rules
[0162] It is usually assumed that soil materials follow relevant flow rules (Chen, 1975). In fact, most soils are not subject to relevant flow rules, and the shear dilatancy coefficient η is defined as follows:
[0163]
[0164] Among them, ψ and represent the dilatancy angle and friction angle respectively.
[0165] It is worth noting that η is usually less than 1. Davis, (1968) suggested to consider the influence of non-associative flow rules in limit analysis and modify soil parameters (Wang et al., 2001; Kumar, 2004; Yang and Huang, 2009; Mollon et al., 2011b). The modified formula is as follows:
[0166]
[0167]
[0168] where c * and denote the corrected cohesion and corrected friction angle, respectively.
[0169] 1.2 Tunnel excavation face stability limit analysis
[0170] 1.2.1 Failure mechanism
[0171] like Figure 2 As shown in the figure, a new model consisting of five truncated cones and a distributed force is proposed based on the existing multi-block model (Soubra et al., 2008; Zhang et al., 2015). The calculation accuracy of this model has been improved when analyzing the stability of the tunnel face (Mollone et al., 2010). Therefore, the following will use the improved mechanism that depends on five angle parameters (α, β1, β2, β3 and β4) to study the influence of seismic action on the tunnel face based on the non-associated flow law.
[0172] like Figure 3 As shown, assuming that the diameter is D, the coverage depth is C, and an overload σ is applied to the surface S In addition, the uniform pressure is expressed by σ T At the same time, Figure 3(a) illustrates the situation where the tunnel front zone collapses and may extend to the surface due to low cover depth or insufficient surrounding rock strength. Conversely, as the cover depth increases, a collapsed arch can be formed (see Figure 3 (b)). Specifically, the model consists of five truncated cones and the distributed forces caused by the truncated ellipsoid or spheroid.
[0173] 1.2.2 Geometric characteristics
[0174] Based on the failure model, the variable is defined as β i (for1≤i≤4) and α1, which can be described based on geometric relationships (Han et al., 2016; Li et al., 2020). The semi-axis lengths of the ellipse are defined as a1(b1), a i+1 (b i+1 )(for1≤i≤4) and a5(b5). It should be noted that the intersection of the first truncated cone and the tunnel surface is an ellipse, and the semi-axis length of the ellipse is given by Han et al. (2016). In addition, when the area in front of the tunnel collapses and may extend to the surface, the semi-axis length is derived as follows:
[0175]
[0176]
[0177] in
[0178]
[0179]
[0180] Equation (7) was proposed by Jaky (1944) and cited by some scholars (Michalowski and Asce, 2005; Zhang et al., 2015; Zou et al., 2019). Therefore, the areas A1 and A2 between the two frustums i and i+1 are i,i+1 (1≤i≤4) is as follows:
[0181]
[0182] A i,i+1 =πa i,i+1 b i,i+1 (9)
[0183] A5=πa5b5 (10)
[0184] A6=πa6b6 (11)
[0185] like Figure 3 As shown, the volume of the frustum V1, V i(for 2≤i≤4) and V5 can be calculated (Han et al., 2016). When the upper rigid cone intersects the ground, that is, C0>C, V6 can be calculated as follows:
[0186]
[0187] In contrast, V6 is defined as follows:
[0188]
[0189] 1.2.3 Earthquake force
[0190] The quasi-static method is an approximate calculation method for solving dynamic problems. Its basic idea is to simplify the dynamic effect into the inertial force acting on the object. h G and k v G The earthquake force on the tunnel face is as follows Figure 2 As shown, the relationship is expressed as follows (Xuetal., 2018, 2019):
[0191] k v G=ξk h G (14)
[0192] Where k h and k v are the horizontal and vertical seismic effect coefficients respectively, ξ is the proportionality coefficient; G is the soil weight.
[0193] 1.2.4 Limiting support pressure
[0194] According to the upper bound theorem (Chen, 1975), the stability of the tunnel face should meet the following conditions:
[0195] P e ≤P v (15)
[0196] Power of external load P e , including the power of the support pressure P T , power of additional load P S , power per unit weight of soil P γ And the total power P generated by horizontal and vertical seismic forces γ ', can be calculated by equations (16)-(20).
[0197] P T = -A1cosασ T v1 (16)
[0198] P S =v5sin(2β2+2β4+α)A6σ S (17)
[0199]
[0200]
[0201] P e =P T +P S +P γ +P γ ' (20)
[0202] Based on the upper bound theorem, combined with equations (15)-(19), it can be obtained in the following way:
[0203]
[0204] Where N γ ,N c and N S are dimensionless coefficients representing the effects of soil weight, cohesion and additional load, and N γ With N S It can be calculated by the formula;
[0205]
[0206] Numerical results show that N c and N S Related to the following classic formula (Zhang et al., 2015):
[0207]
[0208] The optimal solution in cohesive friction soil can be obtained based on the maximization of five variables (α, β1, β2, β3, β4) by using the mathematical procedure in equation (21).
[0209] 2 Numerical simulation and verification
[0210] In order to verify the accuracy of the theoretical model based on the non-associated flow law in the study of the seismic stability of shield tunnels, the results obtained from the theoretical model were compared with the results of numerical simulation. A series of numerical analyses were carried out using a finite difference computer program to calculate the ultimate support pressure and the failure zone. The parameters used in the simulation of each case are shown in Table 1. In addition, the other parameters of the soil are as follows: unit weight γ is 17 kN / m 3 , the elastic bulk modulus is 20 MPa, and the Poisson's ratio ν is 0.35.
[0211] Table 1 Calculation parameters
[0212]
[0213] like Figure 4As shown, the model shows half of the circular tunnel for symmetry reasons. The single-step excavation method was simulated, focusing on the stability of the tunnel face. When performing the numerical simulation, 25 m of excavation was performed in one step (see Figure 4 ). In addition, the displacement of the excavated tunnel perimeter is fixed. It is worth noting that the pseudo-static method uses a constant coefficient to describe the acceleration. Taking the intensity of 8 as an example, the horizontal earthquake effect coefficient is 0.2 (GB50909-2014).
[0214] 2.1 Comparison of ultimate support pressure
[0215] like Figure 5 As shown in (a), under different friction angles, the values obtained by numerical simulation and theoretical model gradually decrease with the increase of shear dilatancy coefficient. When the shear dilatancy coefficient increases from 0.0 to 1.0, the analytical and numerical solutions decrease by 14.2% and 9.5%, respectively. Moreover, the results of the theoretical model are improved by 3.5% to 7.9% compared with the values obtained by numerical simulation. When the dilatancy coefficient increases from 0.0 to 1.0, the analytical and numerical solutions decrease by 6.7% and 6.0%, respectively. In addition, when η = 1.0, the percentage difference between the numerical simulation and the theoretical model is about 1.1%.
[0216] A similar pattern can be found in sandy soils, when the friction angle When the shear expansion coefficient affects the friction coefficient, Figure 5 (b) The results of the theoretical model are 6.3% to 10.0% higher than those of the numerical simulation. When η = 1.0, the σ obtained by the above method is T The percentage difference is about 1.0%. In addition, the non-associative flow rule has an effect on σ T The influence of the friction angle is greater, and more attention should be paid to the soil with larger friction angle. In summary, the curvatures of the two curves obtained by numerical simulation and theoretical model are almost the same in different cases.
[0217] When ξ=1, the relationship curve of shear expansion coefficient is as follows Figure 6 As shown. Figure 6 As shown in (a), the friction angle When the shear coefficient increases from 0.0 to 1.0, the analytical and numerical solutions decrease by 12.6% and 7.4%, respectively. Moreover, the results of the theoretical model are about 15.1% to 19.7% higher than those of the numerical simulation. In the case of , as the dilatancy coefficient increases from 0.0 to 1.0, the analytical and numerical solutions decrease by 5.9% and 4.0%, respectively. Figure 6 (b) shows that when the friction angle When the shear dilatancy coefficient increases, the σ obtained by different methods T The results of the theoretical model are about 10.3% to 14.1% higher than those of the numerical simulation. When the shear dilatancy coefficient increases from 0.0 to 1.0, the reductions are 3.6% and 1.8%, respectively.
[0218] In summary, the curvatures of the two curves obtained from numerical simulation and theoretical model are almost consistent when considering different vertical earthquakes. At the same time, it is found that as the friction angle increases, the deviation between the numerical simulation results and the theoretical model is larger.
[0219] 2.2 Comparison of damage areas
[0220] like Figure 7 As shown, working condition 9 (c = 10kPa, k h =0.2,ξ=0), working condition 21(c=0kPa,k h =0.2,ξ=0), working condition 34 (c=10kPa,k h =0.2,ξ=1) and condition 46 (c=0kPa,k h =0.2,ξ=1) and the given model. The damage area given by the above method considering only the horizontal seismic effect coefficient is consistent, especially the upper part. In other words, the theoretical method is not very effective when considering k h or ξ, the stability analysis of the tunnel face is effective and reasonable.
[0221] 3 Dynamic stability analysis
[0222] 3.1 Influence of horizontal seismic effect coefficient
[0223] In order to analyze the influence of horizontal seismic force on the ultimate support pressure of shield tunnel face based on non-associated flow law, the variation law of ultimate support pressure and failure zone under different soil parameters was obtained through theoretical model.
[0224] 3.1.1 Influence of horizontal seismic effect coefficient on ultimate support pressure
[0225] For constant cohesion c and unit weight γ, the influence of horizontal seismic effect coefficient on the ultimate support pressure under different friction angles is as follows: Figure 8 As shown. It can be found that as the friction angle The increase gradually decreases ( Figure 8 ), the larger the horizontal seismic effect coefficient, the greater the The more sensitive the change. (c=5kPa, η=0.6, γ=17kN / m 3 ), k h= 0.5 is higher than k h = 0.0, the result increased by 125%. In addition, the comparison results show that horizontal seismic forces need to be considered. Figure 8 (b) shows that the smaller the friction angle in the soil, the greater the influence of the horizontal seismic effect coefficient on the ultimate support pressure.
[0226] For the friction angle When the unit weight γ is constant, the influence of the horizontal seismic effect coefficient on the ultimate support pressure of various cohesion forces is as follows: Fig. 9 As soil cohesion increases, Fig. 9 (a) shows a linear decrease, indicating that cohesion has a significant effect on the seismic effect coefficient at different levels. η=0.6,γ=17kN / m 3 ), k h = 0.5 when σ T K h = 0.0 increases by 133%. Fig. 9 (b) It can be seen that the ultimate support pressure of different clayey soils is affected by the horizontal seismic effect coefficient to the same extent.
[0227] Fig.10 Shown in The influence of the horizontal seismic effect coefficient on the ultimate support pressure of different unit weights when and c are constant. Fig.10 As shown in (a), σ T The value of increases linearly. It can be seen that in k h = 0.5, the value of the ultimate support pressure σ T It is most affected by the unit weight of soil. Fig.10 (b) shows that k h For σ T The influence of 3 of soil layer.
[0228] For the friction angle When the cohesion c and unit weight γ are constant, Fig.11 The relationship between the ultimate support pressure, horizontal seismic effect coefficient and shear expansion coefficient is given. Fig.11 In the above equation, the σ of different levels of earthquake effect coefficient is T The value decreases with the increase of shear expansion coefficient, and the slope gradually decreases. h The larger the σ T The above analysis shows that when designing the tunnel face, not only the horizontal seismic effect coefficient but also the non-associated flow law should be considered.
[0229] 3.1.2 Influence of horizontal earthquake effect coefficient on the damage area
[0230] At the friction angle and cohesion c=5kPa, with k h Increase, Fig.12 A comparison of the damage area obtained with the existing mechanism under different horizontal seismic effect coefficients is given. Since the damage area is similar when the shear dilation coefficient is between 0.0 and 1.0, only the case of shear dilation coefficient η = 0.6 is plotted. It can be found that the horizontal seismic force (i.e., k h >0) is larger than when the earthquake force is not considered.
[0231] In summary, when the shear dilatancy coefficient η is constant, the influence of the horizontal seismic force on the failure zone of the shield tunnel face is significant and tends to become larger with the increase of the horizontal seismic effect coefficient.
[0232] 3.2 Influence of vertical seismic effect coefficient
[0233] When the horizontal seismic effect coefficient is 0.1 to 0.5, it is found through mathematical calculation that the change law of the shield tunnel face is roughly the same. h =0.4.
[0234] 3.2.1 Influence of vertical seismic effect coefficient on ultimate support pressure
[0235] When γ and c are constant, the vertical seismic effect coefficient at different friction angles has an influence on σ T The impact of Fig.13 shown. Fig.13 (a) It gradually decreases with the increase of friction angle, and has nothing to do with the value of friction angle. Vertical seismic effect coefficient. σ T The value pair More sensitive, the curvature of the curve gradually slows down. (c=5kPa, η=0.6, γ=17kN / m 3 ) in the case of ξ=1.0 and ξ=-1.0, σ T The values of are 30% and 41% different from the results when ξ=0.0. In addition, the comparison results show that the influence of vertical seismic force is more important, which means that ignoring vertical seismic force is very unstable, especially when ξ=1.0. Fig.13 (b) It can be found that the soil layer with a small friction angle is more affected by the vertical seismic effect coefficient.
[0236] For γ and The constant value of Fig.14 The influence of vertical seismic effect coefficient on the ultimate support pressure under various cohesion is given. Fig.14As shown in (a), as the cohesive force c increases, σ T decreases linearly. Similarly, Fig.14 (a) also shows that it is crucial to consider the vertical seismic force when calculating the ultimate support pressure. For example, when c = 6 kPa ( η=0.6,γ=17kN / m 3 ),ξ=1.0,σ T The value of is 30% higher than that when ξ=0.0. Fig.14 (b) shows the tunnel face σ in soils with different cohesion T have the same sensitivity to ξ.
[0237] Fig.15 The influence of the vertical seismic effect coefficient on the ultimate support pressure at different unit weights is given. The ultimate support pressure increases linearly with the increase of unit weight or vertical seismic effect coefficient. In addition, it has been seen that the vertical seismic force should be taken seriously, especially in soils with higher unit weights. The reason is that the face of the tunnel in soils with higher unit weights is more sensitive to the vertical seismic force.
[0238] For a certain friction angle The relationship between cohesion c and unit weight γ, ultimate support pressure, vertical seismic effect coefficient and shear expansion coefficient is as follows: Fig.16 As shown in Figure 2, the vertical seismic effect coefficient has a significant influence on the ultimate support pressure of the tunnel face regardless of the shear dilation coefficient. In addition, the vertical seismic effect coefficient σ T The value decreases with the increase of shear dilatancy coefficient, and the slope is basically the same. In addition, when η = 0.2 (ξ = 1.0), the increase can reach 11% relative to the case of η = 1.0.
[0239] In summary, it is unreasonable to ignore vertical seismic forces or to use the relevant flow law when calculating the tunnel face.
[0240] 3.2.2 Influence of vertical seismic effect coefficient on damage zone
[0241] At the friction angle and the cohesion c remains unchanged, Fig.17 The influence of the vertical seismic effect coefficient on the damage zone is given. It seems that with the increase of the vertical seismic effect coefficient, the damage zone gradually decreases.
[0242] According to the above analysis, the ultimate support pressure is the largest when ξ = 1, but the damage zone is the smallest in the above three cases. This phenomenon can be explained as follows: When the ultimate support pressure is calculated by equation. Equation (21) can be obtained by mathematical procedures that the dimensionless coefficient of soil weight increases with the increase of the vertical seismic effect coefficient, and other dimensionless coefficients (N s and N c) remains unchanged. In addition, N γ It depends not only on volume, but also on speed and the product of trigonometric functions.
[0243] 4 Results
[0244] Based on the non-associative flow law and the quasi-static method, this paper uses a three-dimensional truncated cone mechanism to estimate the ultimate support pressure and failure zone of the tunnel face under earthquake action. A series of numerical simulations were carried out to verify the rationality of the theoretical model. Then, parameter analysis was performed using theoretical methods. The main conclusions are as follows:
[0245] (1) In the context of the kinematic method of limit analysis, based on the law of non-associated flow, the quasi-static method is used to derive the calculation formulas for the ultimate support pressure and failure area of the tunnel face considering earthquake effects. This method provides a new idea for the design of the ultimate support pressure of the tunnel face.
[0246] (2) The variation trend of the ultimate support pressure under earthquake action with the shear dilation coefficient obtained by this model is consistent with the numerical simulation results. In addition, the failure areas under different conditions are compared, and the results correspond to each other.
[0247] (3) Both horizontal and vertical seismic effect coefficients have a significant impact on the calculation of the ultimate support pressure of the tunnel face, especially in soils with high friction angles or unit weights. In addition, when designing the ultimate support pressure of the tunnel face, not only the seismic effect but also the non-associated flow law should be considered.
[0248] (4) When the shear dilation coefficient η is constant, the damaged area of the shield tunnel face tends to increase with the increase of the horizontal seismic effect coefficient. At the same time, the damaged zone gradually decreases with the increase of the vertical seismic effect coefficient.
[0249] The above description is only a specific implementation mode of the present invention, but the protection scope of the present invention is not limited thereto. Any modifications, equivalent substitutions and improvements made by any technician familiar with the technical field within the technical scope disclosed by the present invention and within the spirit and principle of the present invention should be covered by the protection scope of the present invention.
Claims
1. A method for analyzing the stability of a tunnel excavation face under seismic load conditions, characterized in that: The tunnel excavation face stability analysis method under seismic load conditions comprises: Step 1: Based on the non-associated flow law, the stability limit analysis of the tunnel excavation face is carried out, and the calculation formula of the tunnel face limit support pressure and damage area under earthquake action is derived by using the quasi-static method; Step 2: A numerical model is established based on the quasi-static method to verify the rationality of the theoretical model in analyzing the stability of the tunnel face; Step 3: Parameter analysis through theoretical methods; In step 1, the non-associated flow rule is specifically: the soil is not constrained by the relevant flow rules, and the shear expansion coefficient η is defined as follows: Among them, ψ and denote the dilatancy angle and friction angle respectively; η is usually less than 1. In the limit analysis, the influence of non-associative flow rules is used to modify the soil parameters and the modified formula is as follows: Where c represents cohesion, c * and denote the modified cohesion and modified friction angle, respectively; In the step 1, the limit analysis of tunnel excavation face stability includes: failure mechanism analysis, geometric characteristics analysis, seismic force analysis, and limit support pressure analysis; The failure mechanism analysis is specifically as follows: Based on the existing multi-block model, a new model is established, which consists of five truncated cones and a distributed force. When analyzing the stability of the tunnel face, an improved mechanism that depends on five angular parameters α, β1, β2, β3 and β4 is used to study the influence of seismic action on the tunnel face based on the non-associated flow law. The diameter is D, the coverage depth is C, and an overload σ is applied to the surface. S ; In addition, the uniform pressure is expressed as σ T Representation; As the coverage depth increases, a collapsed arch is formed; The model consists of five truncated cones and the distributed forces caused by the truncated ellipsoid or ellipsoid; The geometric characteristic analysis is specifically as follows: Based on the failure model, the variable is defined as β i , 1≤i≤4 and α1, respectively define the semi-axis lengths of the ellipse as a1, b1, a i+1 , b i+1 , 1≤i≤4 and a5, b5; the intersection of the first truncated cone and the tunnel surface is an ellipse. When the area in front of the tunnel collapses and may expand to the surface, the semi-axis length is derived as follows: in: The areas A1 and A2 between two frustums i and i+1 are i,i+1 , 1≤i≤4 is as follows: A i,i+1 =πa i,i+1 b i,i+1 (9) A5=πa5b5 (10) A6=πa6b6 (11) The volume of the frustum V1,V i , 2≤i≤4 and V5 are calculated; when the semi-ellipsoid intersects the ground, that is, C0>C, V6 is calculated as follows: In contrast, V6 is defined as follows: The seismic force analysis is specifically as follows: the dynamic effect is simplified into the inertial force acting on the object, and the seismic force k h G and k v G is the seismic force on the tunnel face, and the relationship is expressed as follows: k v G=ξk h G (14) Where k h and k v are the horizontal and vertical seismic effect coefficients respectively, ξ is the proportionality coefficient; G is the soil weight; The ultimate support pressure analysis is as follows: According to the upper limit theorem, the stability of the tunnel face should meet the following conditions: P e ≤P v (15) Power of external load P e , including the power of the support pressure P T , power of additional load P S , power per unit weight of soil P γ And the total power P generated by horizontal and vertical seismic forces γ ', calculated by equations (16)-(20); P T =-A1cosασ T v1 (16) P S =v5sin(2β2+2β4+α)A6σ S (17) P e =P T +P S +P γ +P γ ' (20) Where γ represents the unit weight; Based on the upper bound theorem, combined with equations (15)-(19), we can obtain: Where N γ ,N c and N S are dimensionless coefficients representing the effects of soil weight, cohesion and additional load, and N γ With N S Calculated by formula; Based on the numerical simulation results, N c and N S Related to the following classic formula: The optimal solution in cohesive friction soil is obtained based on the maximization of five variables α, β1, β2, β3, β4 by using the mathematical procedure in equation (21); In the step 2, the rationality of the theoretical model in analyzing the stability of the tunnel face is verified, and the specific process is: to verify the accuracy of the theoretical model based on the non-associated flow law in the study of the seismic stability of the shield tunnel, the results obtained by the theoretical model are compared with the numerical simulation results; A series of numerical analyses were performed using a finite difference computer program to calculate the ultimate support pressure and failure zone; In the step 3, parameter analysis is performed by theoretical methods, including: the influence of the horizontal seismic effect coefficient and the influence of the vertical seismic effect coefficient; The influence of horizontal seismic effect coefficient includes: the influence of horizontal seismic effect coefficient on ultimate support pressure and the influence of horizontal seismic effect coefficient on damage area; The influence of the vertical seismic effect coefficient includes: the influence of the vertical seismic effect coefficient on the ultimate support pressure and the influence of the vertical seismic effect coefficient on the damage area.
Citation Information
Cited By
Method and system for determining supporting pressure of tunnel face of oppositely excavated tunnel and medium
CN115828627A
A method, system, and medium for determining support pressure for a tunnel face being excavated
CN115828627B
Method and system for determining supporting pressure of tunnel face of oppositely excavated tunnel and medium
CN115935481A
Method, system, and medium for determining support pressure for a tunnel face being excavated
CN115935481B
