An optimization model for dispatching emergency medical rescue resources for large-scale sports events
By combining emergency medical theory and volunteer strength in the emergency medical resource scheduling model, resource scheduling is optimized in stages, and the problem that the existing model is not classified by injury and does not consider volunteer strength is solved, and efficient medical resource scheduling and The wounded are transferred.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202111126909.8
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2021-09-28
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-26
- Estimated Expiration
- 2041-09-28
AI Technical Summary
The existing emergency medical resource scheduling model fails to effectively combine emergency medical theory, fails to classify resource scheduling according to the injury situation of the injured, and does not consider the medical transport power of volunteers, resulting in low resource scheduling efficiency and poor rescue effect.
An emergency medical rescue resource scheduling optimization model based on integer linear multi-objective planning is proposed, which is divided into two stages: on-site treatment and transfer and post-delivery. Combined with emergency medical theory, ambulances, rescue helicopters and volunteer vehicles are used to determine the injury of the injured. Distinguish the priority of transport and optimize resource scheduling.
It improves the efficiency of medical resource scheduling, reduces the mortality rate, improves the treatment rate, ensures that the injured are given priority to transport the wounded according to the injury, and improves the resource utilization rate.
Smart Images

Figure CN114334102B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to the field of emergency medical rescue resource allocation for emergencies, and in particular to an emergency medical rescue resource scheduling optimization model for emergencies of large-scale sports events. Background Art
[0002] With the development of society, the number of various sports events held in my country has increased significantly, and the scale of various sports events has also increased. During large-scale sports events, due to the large scale and high density of personnel gathering, if an emergency occurs, it is likely to cause serious consequences. A major point in reducing the harm of such emergencies is to scientifically call on medical resources to provide timely on-site treatment and transfer and evacuation of the wounded. Therefore, more and more researchers are focusing on establishing a more scientific and practical medical resource scheduling model. Different from ordinary resource scheduling, emergency medical resource scheduling needs to be combined with the characteristics of emergency medicine itself, that is, the actual process of emergency medical rescue is hierarchical treatment and classified treatment. The so-called hierarchical treatment is a hierarchical treatment system that divides the medical rescue process into first-level treatment at the disaster site, second-level treatment during transportation, third-level treatment in the rear hospital, and fourth-level treatment for rehabilitation treatment. The first and second level treatments are divided into four basic stages, namely search and positioning, on-site treatment, triage, and transfer and evacuation. The so-called triage treatment means to classify the wounded, distinguish between the critically injured, seriously injured, lightly injured and the dead, and adopt different transfer and delivery orders for different triage classifications.
[0003] Researchers have achieved a lot of research results in the dispatch of emergency medical rescue resources, but these research results generally have three weak links: first, the dispatch of emergency medical rescue resources is equated with ordinary resource dispatch, and the emergency medical rescue resource dispatch model is not reasonably established in combination with emergency medical theory; second, only the number of wounded is used as the research object of the model, and the wounded injuries are not triaged and classified, and the wounded are distinguished according to their injuries as the research object of the model; third, only official medical rescue resources such as ambulances and rescue helicopters are used as the research object of the model, and the existing volunteer medical transport force is not included in the model research object. In view of the above three problems existing in the traditional emergency medical resource dispatch model, the present invention proposes a multi-objective optimization model for the phased dispatch of emergencies in large-scale sports events, closely combines the theory and practice of emergency medical rescue, scientifically formulates resource dispatch plans, and effectively improves the efficiency of medical resource dispatch. Summary of the invention
[0004] Aiming at the three weak links commonly existing in existing research results, the present invention proposes an optimization model for the dispatch of emergency medical rescue resources for emergencies in large-scale sports events, namely, a phased optimization model for dispatching emergency medical rescue resources based on integer linear multi-objective programming, distinguishing different stages of emergency medical rescue, and transferring and evacuating the wounded according to the results of triage. The model is divided into two parts. The first part is a multi-objective optimization model for dispatching emergency medical resources in the on-site treatment stage, and the second part is a multi-objective optimization model for dispatching emergency medical resources in the transfer and evacuation stage. The model takes into account that the primary purpose of emergency medical rescue is to maintain the vital signs of the wounded and to transfer the wounded to the rear hospital for treatment in a timely manner. Emergency medical resources are clearly defined as rescue tools such as ambulances, rescue helicopters, and volunteer vehicles that have the ability to carry the wounded, which conforms to the practice of emergency medical rescue for many years. The model is applied to the dispatch of emergency medical rescue resources for emergencies in large-scale sports events. It can combine multiple factors such as resource transportation time, venue acceptance capacity, rear hospital acceptance capacity, and volunteer rescue capacity to scientifically formulate resource dispatch plans to ensure high resource dispatch efficiency and good emergency rescue effects.
[0005] To achieve the above purpose, the technical solution adopted by the model proposed in the present invention is as follows:
[0006] Step 1: Establish and solve a multi-objective optimization model for the dispatch of emergency medical resources during the on-site treatment phase of emergencies in large-scale sports events, and generate a medical resource dispatch plan from emergency sites to affected venues according to the type of emergency and the number of injured.
[0007] Step 2: Establish and solve a multi-objective optimization model for emergency medical resource scheduling in the transfer and evacuation phase of large-scale event emergencies, and generate an optimization plan for resource allocation from the demand venue to the rear hospital and a plan for the transfer of the wounded based on the triage data returned from the on-site treatment phase.
[0008] Step 1 is implemented as follows:
[0009] Step 1.1: On-site treatment phase rescue requires the dispatch of emergency medical resources from the first aid site to the required venue. First, set the model parameters for the dispatch of emergency medical rescue resources in the on-site treatment phase.
[0010] The parameters are set as follows:
[0011] 1) Assume that there are currently I emergency sites and J venues. Let i=1, 2, 3, ..., I represent the i-th emergency site, and j=1, 2, 3, ..., J represent the j-th venue.
[0012] 2) Set the number of emergency resource types L. Use l=1, 2, 3, ..., L to represent different types of emergency resources, such as ambulances, rescue helicopters, volunteer vehicles, etc.
[0013] 3) Set the number of injured people P in the venue j , represents the number of injured people reported by the jth venue.
[0014] 4) Set the number of resources that can be called by the emergency station E il , which represents the number of the lth type of emergency resources that can be called upon by the i-th emergency station.
[0015] 5) Set the resource dispatch time t from the emergency station to the rear venue ijl , represents the time required to dispatch the lth type of resources from the ith emergency station to the jth venue. Since special channels will be set up during large-scale events, it can be assumed that the roads will not be blocked, that is, the resource dispatch time is stable and unchanged.
[0016] 6) Set the rescue capacity of a single Category l resource in the on-site rescue phase l , indicating that a single resource of type l can rescue a l personal.
[0017] 7) Set a 0-1 variable h to indicate whether the venue accepts a certain type of resource jl :
[0018]
[0019] Assume that l = 1 and l = 2 correspond to ambulance and rescue helicopter respectively, then h 1,1 =1,h 1,2 =0 means that the first venue cannot accommodate helicopters but allows ambulances, so a helicopter cannot be dispatched to the first venue and only an ambulance can be sent for rescue.
[0020] 8) Set the decision variable X ijl , which represents the number of the lth type of emergency resources deployed from the i-th emergency station to the j-th venue.
[0021] Step 1.2: Set the objective function of the emergency medical rescue resource scheduling model in the on-site treatment stage.
[0022] The objective function is set as follows:
[0023]
[0024] Objective function (1) indicates that the on-site rescue model should minimize the total arrival time of all emergency resources.
[0025]
[0026] Objective function (2) indicates that the total rescue capacity of the dispatched rescue resources should be as large as possible.
[0027]
[0028] The linear weighted method is used to combine objective function (1) and objective function (2) as the final objective function of the on-site treatment stage model, namely objective function (3), to ensure that the model solution can meet multiple objectives at the same time, namely, the total arrival time of emergency resources is as small as possible and the total rescue capacity of emergency resources is as large as possible. The weight of each sub-objective of the final objective function is c 11 、c 12 Determined by the decision maker's decision focus.
[0029] Step 1.3: Set the constraints of the emergency medical rescue resource scheduling model in the on-site treatment stage.
[0030] The constraints are set as follows:
[0031]
[0032] Formula (4) indicates that the rescue capacity of emergency resources dispatched to each venue by all emergency stations should not be less than the estimated number of injured people in each venue, meeting the minimum needs of each venue.
[0033]
[0034] Formula (5) indicates that the number of various emergency resources dispatched from each emergency station should not be higher than the emergency resources equipped by each station and should be within the available range of each station.
[0035]
[0036] Formula (6) indicates that different venues have different acceptance capacities for each type of emergency resource. If the jth venue cannot accept the lth type of emergency resource, then the corresponding h jl = 0, each emergency station does not need to dispatch the lth type of resources to the venue. Formula (5) can be used to limit the number of i stations when h jl = 0 when X ijl =0.
[0037]
[0038] Formula (7) represents the decision variable X ijl A non-negative integer.
[0039] Step 1.4: Use lingo18.0 or other operations research software to solve the multi-objective model of the on-site treatment stage and obtain the emergency medical rescue resource scheduling plan for the on-site treatment stage.
[0040] Step 2 is implemented as follows:
[0041] Step 2.1: Rescue in the transfer and evacuation phase requires the dispatch of emergency resources from the disaster-stricken venue to the rear hospital. First, the parameters of the emergency medical rescue resource dispatch model in the transfer and evacuation phase are set.
[0042] The parameters are set as follows:
[0043] 1) Set the current number of venues I and the number of rear hospitals J. Let i=1, 2, 3, ..., I represent the i-th venue, and j=1, 2, 3, ..., J represent the j-th rear hospital.
[0044] 2) Set the number of emergency resource types L. Use l=1, 2, 3, ..., L and other numbers to represent different types of emergency resources, such as ambulances, rescue helicopters, volunteer vehicles, etc.
[0045] 3) Set the number of injury levels of the injured to N = 3. n = 1 represents the critical level, n = 2 represents the severe level, and n = 3 represents the mild level.
[0046] 4) Set the number of injured people P in the venue after the injury classification in , represents the number of injured persons with injury level n in the i-th venue.
[0047] 5) Set the number of resources that can be called by each venue E il , which indicates the number of the lth type of emergency resources available for the ith venue.
[0048] 6) Set the resource dispatch time t from the venue to the rear hospital ijl , represents the time required to dispatch the lth type of resources from the ith venue to the jth rear hospital. Since special channels will be set up during large-scale events, it can be assumed that the roads will not be blocked, that is, the resource dispatch time is stable and unchanged.
[0049] 7) Set the total rescue capacity b of a single Category l resource in the transfer and evacuation phase l , which means that a single resource of type l can be transferred to b at most. l A wounded person.
[0050] 8) Set the treatment capacity S of a single Category 1 resource for critically injured patients during the transport and evacuation phase l , represents the maximum number of S that a single resource of category l can be transferred and delivered l Critically injured.
[0051] 9) Set the treatment capacity Z of a single Category 1 resource for seriously injured patients during the transfer and evacuation phase l , represents the maximum number of times a single resource of type l can be transferred and delivered to Z l Seriously injured;
[0052] 10) Set a 0-1 variable h to indicate whether the rear hospital accepts a certain type of resourcejl :
[0053]
[0054] Assume that l = 1, l = 2, and l = 3 correspond to ambulance, rescue helicopter, and volunteer vehicle, respectively, then h 11 =1,h 12 =0,h 13 =1 means that the first hospital cannot accommodate helicopters but is allowed to accept ambulances and volunteer vehicles. Therefore, it is impossible to arrange a helicopter to dispatch to the first rear hospital, and only ambulances or volunteer vehicles can be sent for rescue.
[0055] 11) Set the maximum number of patients that the rear hospital can accept C j , represents the maximum number of patients that the jth hospital can accept at one time. Since the treatment of lightly injured patients takes a short time and does not occupy hospital beds, we assume that lightly injured patients transferred to rear hospitals do not occupy the number of patients that the hospital can accept.
[0056] 12) The golden time T1 for treating critically ill patients is set, which means that if the critically ill patients can be transferred to a rear hospital for further treatment within T1 after receiving necessary first aid measures, they are successfully treated, otherwise they will die.
[0057] 13) Set the maximum treatment time T2 for seriously injured patients, which means that if seriously injured patients cannot be transferred to rear hospitals for further treatment within T2 after taking comparative first aid measures, they will be converted into critically ill patients.
[0058] 14) Set 0-1 variable D ijnl , R ijnl , W ijnl , used to indicate the situations in which the injured died, were treated, or were treated as critically injured in the scenario of using the first-class emergency resources to transport the injured with level n injuries from the i-th venue to the j-th rear hospital. Considering the particularity of emergency medical rescue, it is necessary to consider that the seriously injured will turn into the critically injured after a certain period of time, so the judgment criteria of the treatment effect parameter value are different for the injured with different injury levels.
[0059] For critically ill patients with n=1, if the transfer time exceeds the golden rescue time T1 or the patient is not transferred, the treatment is ineffective and the patient dies. Otherwise, the patient can be treated as a critically ill patient.
[0060]
[0061] For n=2 seriously injured patients, if the transfer time is within the maximum rescue time limit T2, the injured patient will be treated as a seriously injured patient; if the transfer time exceeds T2 and is less than T1+T2, the injured patient will be treated as a critically injured patient; if the transfer time exceeds T1+T2 or the injured patient is not transferred, the injured patient will die.
[0062]
[0063] For the lightly injured with n=3, there is no death, and the set condition for receiving treatment is to be transferred to the rear hospital without time limit, so the corresponding three parameters D, R, and W are fixed values.
[0064] D ij3l =0 R ij3l =1 W ij3l =0
[0065] 15) Set the decision variable X ijl 、a ijnl Where X ijl represents the number of type l emergency resources deployed from the i-th venue to the j-th rear hospital, a ijnl Represents the total number of injured persons with level n injuries who are equipped with the lth type of emergency resources on the road from the i-th venue to the j-th rear hospital.
[0066] Step 2.2: Set the objective function of the emergency medical rescue resource scheduling model in the transfer and evacuation phase.
[0067] The objective function is set as follows:
[0068]
[0069] Objective function (8) indicates that the model in the post-transportation stage should minimize the total number of deaths. The number of deaths includes the total number of light-severity and above casualties who died due to long transfer time and failure to be transferred.
[0070]
[0071] The objective function (9) indicates that the number of patients whose serious condition is converted to critical condition due to long transfer time should be minimized.
[0072]
[0073] The objective function (10) indicates that the total number of people who receive treatment should be maximized, because if the lightly injured are not transferred, they are considered to have not received treatment. Therefore, the objective function (9) mainly considers that more lightly injured people receive treatment.
[0074]
[0075] Objective function (11) indicates that the average transfer time of each emergency resource in the scheduling scheme should be as small as possible. Because there is no time limit for the transfer of lightly injured patients, in order to further ensure that the injured are treated as soon as possible, the requirement of minimum average time is added to avoid choosing a longer route.
[0076]
[0077] The objective function (12) indicates that the number of unused medical resource locations in the scheduling plan should be as small as possible, that is, the resource utilization rate should be as high as possible.
[0078]
[0079] The linear weighted method is used to combine the above five objective functions, namely objective functions (8) to (12), as the final objective function of the transfer and evacuation stage model, namely objective function (13), to ensure that the model solution can simultaneously meet multiple objectives, namely, the number of deaths is as small as possible, the number of seriously ill patients transferred to critically ill patients is as small as possible, the total number of patients treated is as large as possible, the average transfer time is as short as possible, and the resource utilization rate is as high as possible. The weight c of each sub-objective of the final objective function is 21 、c 22 、c 23 、c 24 、c 25 Determined by the decision maker's decision focus.
[0080] Step 2.3: Set the constraints of the emergency medical rescue resource scheduling model in the transfer and evacuation phase.
[0081]
[0082] Constraint (14) indicates that the number of emergency resources dispatched from each venue should be within the available range of each venue.
[0083]
[0084] Formula (15) indicates that all emergency resources can only be sent to rear hospitals that can accept such emergency resources.
[0085]
[0086] Formula (16) indicates that the number of injured people actually transferred to each venue does not exceed the known number of injured people.
[0087]
[0088] Formula (17) indicates that the number of light-severity and above wounded transferred to each rear hospital should be within the hospital's capacity.
[0089]
[0090] Formula (18) indicates that the number of critically injured patients transported by a single emergency resource cannot exceed the upper limit.
[0091]
[0092] Formula (19) indicates that the number of seriously injured patients transported by a single emergency resource cannot exceed the upper limit.
[0093]
[0094] Formula (20) indicates that the total number of wounded transported by a single emergency resource should not exceed the upper limit of the total rescue capacity, and each emergency resource should be able to transport the wounded with the maximum rescue capacity.
[0095]
[0096] Formula (21) represents the decision variable X ijl 、a ijnl All are non-negative integers.
[0097] Step 2.4: Based on the solution of the transfer and evacuation stage, reasonably arrange the wounded transportation plan for each medical resource, and obtain the final plan for the transfer and evacuation of the wounded in the transfer and evacuation stage. The specific implementation ideas are as follows:
[0098] First, use lingo18.0 or other operations research software to solve the model of the post-transportation stage and obtain the solution results, including X ijl and a ijnl The two types of variables correspond to the number of emergency resources on each route and the number of wounded with different injuries of different resource types. For the medical resources and wounded on each transfer and evacuation route, the wounded are arranged to each emergency resource according to the priority of the wounded's condition and the priority of the type of medical resources. The priority of the wounded's condition is: critically injured > seriously injured > lightly injured, that is, the wounded with more serious injuries are arranged for transfer and evacuation first; the priority of resource types is: rescue helicopter > ambulance > volunteer vehicle, that is, the plan for carrying the wounded with medical resources that arrive at the venue in a short time and have more complete medical equipment is arranged first. In the process of arranging the wounded, it is necessary to consider the ability of each medical resource to rescue critically injured and the total ability to rescue the wounded at the same time. Using this idea to arrange the wounded can ensure that the wounded with more serious injuries are given priority for rapid transfer, and that the wounded are given priority to use rescue helicopters and ambulances with more complete medical equipment for transfer.
[0099] Compared with the prior art, the resource scheduling model of the present invention has the following beneficial effects:
[0100] 1. The present invention discloses an optimization model for dispatching emergency medical rescue resources for emergencies in large-scale sports events, which combines multi-objective planning theory with the actual operation process of emergency medical rescue and the practice of volunteer participation in disaster rescue over the years. It focuses on minimizing the mortality rate and maximizing the rescue rate, utilizes the concept of rescue timeliness of emergency medicine, and systematically optimizes rescue resources such as helicopters, ambulances, and volunteer vehicles and their loading solutions, thus overcoming the shortcomings of the prior art that the injured are not transported and evacuated according to their injuries and that the volunteer rescue force is not considered.
[0101] 2. The present invention discloses an optimization model for dispatching emergency medical rescue resources for sudden incidents in large-scale sports events. It is closely integrated with the actual operation process of emergency medical rescue and divides the resource dispatching model into two stages: on-site rescue and transfer and delivery, which reduces the complexity of the model and makes the model more in line with the actual situation of emergency medical rescue.
[0102] 3. The present invention discloses an optimization model for scheduling emergency medical rescue resources for sudden incidents in large-scale sports events. In the resource scheduling process at the transfer and delivery stage, the decision variables are flexibly divided into two categories: vehicles and wounded persons, thereby reducing the complexity of model calculation and improving the efficiency of model calculation. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0103] Figure 1 The present invention proposes a flow chart of an optimization model for dispatching emergency medical rescue resources for emergencies in large-scale sports events.
[0104] Figure 2 It is a schematic diagram of the distribution of venues and emergency stations during the on-site treatment stage assumed in the present invention.
[0105] Figure 3 It is a schematic diagram of the distribution of venues and rear hospitals in the post-transportation stage assumed in the present invention.
[0106] Figure 4 It is a flow chart for generating a medical resource wounded transportation plan in the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0107] The technical solution of the present invention is further described below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings and embodiments.
[0108] like Figure 1 As shown, the optimization model for dispatching emergency medical rescue resources for large-scale sports events disclosed in this embodiment has the following specific implementation steps:
[0109] Step 1: Establish and solve the multi-objective optimization model for emergency medical resource scheduling during the on-site treatment phase of major sports events. Figure 2As shown, this embodiment assumes three competition zones based on the actual situation, among which the relevant units involved in the on-site treatment stage are 5 venues and 11 emergency resource stations. Assuming that there are emergencies in venues in all three competition zones, the task of the on-site treatment stage model is to generate a medical resource dispatch plan from the emergency stations to the affected venues according to the number of injured people in each affected venue.
[0110] The following assumptions are made about the relevant data:
[0111] The number of injuries assumed for each venue is shown in Table 1 .
[0112] Table 1 Assumptions on the number of injured in venues
[0113] Venues Venue 1 Venue 2 Venue 3 Venue 4 Venue 5 Number of injured 32 25 40 30 28
[0114] The number of resources available at each emergency site is assumed to be shown in Table 2.
[0115] Table 2 Assumptions on the number of resources available at each emergency station
[0116]
[0117] The dispatch time assumptions of different emergency resources from various emergency resource stations to various venues are shown in Table 3. Since special event channels will be set up during large-scale events, it can be assumed that the roads will not be blocked, that is, the dispatch time of resources from emergency stations to the affected venues is stable and unchanged.
[0118] Table 3 Assumptions on the dispatching time of different emergency resources from various emergency stations to various venues
[0119]
[0120] In addition, it is assumed that except for venue 4, which cannot accommodate helicopters, all other venues can accommodate ambulances and helicopters. According to the relevant information on medical rescue resources, it is assumed that each ambulance can rescue up to 3 wounded people, and each rescue helicopter can rescue up to 6 wounded people.
[0121] Step 1.1: Set the parameters of the emergency medical rescue resource scheduling model in the on-site treatment stage.
[0122] 1) Assume that there are currently I=11 emergency stations and J=5 venues. Let i=1, 2, 3, ..., 11 represent the i-th emergency station, and j=1, 2, 3, 4, 5 represent the j-th venue.
[0123] 2) It is assumed that the current emergency resources are divided into L=2 categories, that is, the emergency resources that can be called upon in the on-site treatment stage are ambulances and helicopters. l=1 represents an ambulance and l=2 represents a rescue helicopter.
[0124] 3) Set the number of injured people P in the venuej , represents the number of injured people reported by the jth venue, corresponding to Table 1, P1=32, P2=25, P3=40, P4=30, P5=28.
[0125] 4) Set the number of resources that can be called by the emergency station E il , represents the number of the first-class emergency resources that can be called by the first-class emergency station, corresponding to Table 2, E 11 =5, E 12 =2, E 21 =4,E 22 =0,......,E 11,1 =6, E 11,2 =2.
[0126] 5) Set the resource dispatch time t from the emergency station to the rear venue ijl , which represents the time required for dispatching the lth type of resources from the i-th emergency station to the j-th venue. Corresponding to Table 3, t 111 =28, t 112 =15,t 121 =30, t 122 =15,......,t 581 =73,t 582 =40.
[0127] 6) Set the rescue capacity of a single Category l resource in the on-site rescue phase l From the assumptions, we can see that a1=3 means that one ambulance can rescue 6 people, and a2=6 means that one helicopter can rescue 6 people.
[0128] 7) Set a 0-1 variable h to indicate whether the venue accepts a certain type of resource jl :
[0129]
[0130] From the assumption, we know that except h 42 =0, the rest h jl =1.
[0131] 8) Set the decision variable X ijl , which represents the number of the lth type of emergency resources deployed from the i-th emergency station to the j-th venue.
[0132] Step 1.2: Set the objective function of the emergency medical rescue resource scheduling model in the on-site treatment stage.
[0133] The objective function is set as follows:
[0134]
[0135] Objective function (1) indicates that the on-site rescue model should minimize the total arrival time of all emergency resources.
[0136]
[0137] Objective function (2) indicates that the total rescue capacity of the dispatched rescue resources should be as large as possible.
[0138]
[0139] The linear weighted method is used to combine objective function (1) and objective function (2) as the final objective function (3) of the on-site treatment stage model, thereby ensuring that the model solution can simultaneously meet multiple objectives, namely, the total arrival time of emergency resources is minimized and the total rescue capacity of emergency resources is maximized. 11 =1, c 12 =1.
[0140] Step 1.3: Set the constraints of the emergency medical rescue resource scheduling model in the on-site treatment stage.
[0141] The constraints are set as follows:
[0142]
[0143] Formula (4) indicates that the rescue capacity of emergency resources dispatched to each venue by all emergency stations should not be less than the estimated number of injured people in each venue, meeting the minimum needs of each venue.
[0144]
[0145] Formula (5) indicates that the number of various emergency resources dispatched from each emergency station should not be higher than the emergency resources equipped by each station and should be within the available range of each station.
[0146]
[0147] Formula (6) indicates that different venues have different acceptance capacities for each type of emergency resource. If the jth venue cannot accept the lth type of emergency resource, then the corresponding h jl =0, each emergency station does not need to dispatch the lth type of resources to the venue.
[0148]
[0149] Formula (7) represents the decision variable X ijl A non-negative integer.
[0150] Step 1.4: Lingo18.0 is used to solve the multi-objective model of the on-site treatment stage. The solution results are shown in Table 4.
[0151] Table 4 Results of the number of resources dispatched from each emergency station to the venue during the on-site treatment phase
[0152]
[0153] By analyzing the solution results, it can be found that resource scheduling only occurs between venues and sites in the same competition area, which meets the actual requirement of avoiding transfer between different competition areas as much as possible. Moreover, the sites supported by resources for each venue include sites that are relatively close, meeting the need to arrive at the scene as quickly as possible. According to the rescue capacity of various emergency resources, it can be calculated that the rescue capacity under this plan is 162 people, which is slightly larger than the reported number of injured people, 155. From the above analysis, it can be seen that the solution meets the actual needs.
[0154] Step 2: Construct and solve a multi-objective optimization model for emergency medical resource scheduling during the transportation and evacuation phase of large-scale event emergencies. Figure 3 As shown, the post-transportation stage of this embodiment is connected to the on-site treatment stage, and the relevant units include 5 venues and 8 rear hospitals. The model task of the post-transportation stage is to generate a resource allocation optimization plan from the required venue to the rear hospital and a wounded transfer plan based on the triage data returned from the on-site treatment stage.
[0155] The following assumptions are made about the relevant data:
[0156] After the on-site rescue phase, the medical staff counted and obtained detailed information on the triage of the injured in each venue. The injuries of the injured in each venue are shown in Table 5.
[0157] Table 5 Assumptions on the injuries of the injured in the venue
[0158] <![CDATA[P in ]]> Critical Heavy Light Venue 1 4 11 15 Venue 2 6 8 10 Venue 3 5 15 20 Venue 4 1 10 20 Venue 5 3 6 20
[0159] The availability of medical resources at each venue is assumed to be shown in Table 6, where the number of ambulances and helicopters is calculated from the resources dispatched during the on-site treatment phase.
[0160] Table 6 Assumptions on the availability of medical resources in venues
[0161]
[0162]
[0163] The time assumptions for different emergency resources from each venue to the rear hospital are shown in Table 7. In addition, we assume that the time for volunteer vehicles provided by volunteers to get from each venue to the rear hospital is the same as that of ambulances. Since special event lanes will be set up during large-scale events, we believe that the roads will not be blocked, that is, the time for different emergency resources to be dispatched from each venue to the rear hospital remains stable.
[0164] Table 7 Assumptions on the time required for different emergency resources to travel from various venues to the rear hospital
[0165]
[0166] The maximum number of wounded that the rear hospital can accept is assumed to be shown in Table 8.
[0167] Table 8 Assumptions on the maximum number of wounded admitted by rear hospitals
[0168] Hospital Hospital 1 Hospital 2 Hospital 3 Hospital 4 Hospital 5 Hospital 6 Hospital 7 Hospital 8 Number of people accepted 15 10 10 10 10 15 5 10
[0169] In addition, assuming that rear hospitals 2 and 5 cannot accommodate helicopters, and rear hospital 7 cannot accommodate ambulances and volunteer vehicles, other hospitals can accommodate ambulances, helicopters, and volunteer vehicles. According to relevant information on medical rescue resources, it is assumed that each ambulance can rescue up to 3 wounded, including at most 1 critically ill patient; it is assumed that each rescue helicopter can rescue up to 6 wounded, including at most 2 critically ill patients; it is assumed that each volunteer vehicle can rescue up to 2 wounded, and due to the lack of necessary medical equipment, both wounded are lightly injured. According to relevant information on emergency medicine, it is assumed that the golden treatment time for critically ill patients is 30 minutes, and the maximum treatment time for severely ill patients is 60 minutes.
[0170] Step 2.1: Rescue in the transfer and evacuation phase requires the dispatch of emergency resources from the disaster-stricken venue to the rear hospital. First, the parameters of the emergency medical rescue resource dispatch model in the transfer and evacuation phase are set.
[0171] The parameters are set as follows:
[0172] 1) Set the current number of venues I = 5, and the number of rear hospitals J = 8. Use i = 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 to represent the i-th venue, and use j = 1, 2, 3, ..., 8 to represent the j-th rear hospital.
[0173] 2) Set the number of emergency resource types L = 3. In addition to ambulances and helicopters, the emergency resources that can be called upon in the transport and evacuation stage also include volunteer vehicles. l = 1 represents an ambulance, l = 2 represents a rescue helicopter, and l = 3 represents a volunteer vehicle.
[0174] 3) Set the number of injury levels N for the injured. n=1 represents the critical level, n=2 represents the severe level, and n=3 represents the mild level.
[0175] 4) Set the number of injured people P in the venue after the injury classification in , represents the number of injured persons with injury level n in the ith venue, corresponding to Table 5, P 11 =4,P 12 =11,P 13 =15, ..., P52 =6,P 53 =20.
[0176] 5) Set the number of resources that can be called by each venue E il , represents the number of the first-class emergency resources that can be called upon in the ith venue, corresponding to Table 6, E 11 =5, E 12 =3,E 13 =18,...,E 52 =5, E 53 =10.
[0177] 6) Set the resource dispatch time t from the venue to the rear hospital ijl , which represents the time required for the dispatch of the lth type of resources from the i-th venue to the j-th rear hospital. The corresponding table 7 has t 111 =18, t 112 =15,t 113 =18,...,t 581 =25,t 582 =15,t 583 =25.
[0178] 7) Set the total rescue capacity b of a single Category l resource in the transfer and evacuation phase l b1=3 means that an ambulance can transport up to 3 people, b2=6 means that a helicopter can transport up to 6 people, and b3=2 means that a volunteer vehicle can transport up to 2 people.
[0179] 8) Set the treatment capacity S of a single Category 1 resource for critically injured patients during the transport and evacuation phase l S1=1 means that an ambulance can transport at most 1 critically injured patient, S2=2 means that a helicopter can transport at most 2 critically injured patients, and S3=0 means that volunteer vehicles cannot transport critically injured patients.
[0180] 9) Set the treatment capacity Z of a single Category 1 resource for seriously injured patients during the transfer and evacuation phase l Z1=3 means that an ambulance can transport up to 3 seriously injured patients, Z2=6 means that a helicopter can transport up to 6 seriously injured patients, and Z3=0 means that volunteer vehicles cannot transport seriously injured patients.
[0181] 10) Set a 0-1 variable h to indicate whether the rear hospital accepts a certain type of resource jl :
[0182]
[0183] From the assumption, we know that except h 22 =0,h 52 =0,h71 =0,h 73 =0, the rest h jl =1.
[0184] 11) Set the maximum number of patients that the rear hospital can accept C j , represents the maximum number of patients accepted by the jth hospital at one time, corresponding to Table 8, C1=15, C2=10, C3=10, ..., C8=10.
[0185] 12) The golden time for treating critically ill patients is set as T1 = 30 min, which means that if a critically ill patient can be transferred to a rear hospital for further treatment within 30 minutes after receiving necessary first aid measures, the critically ill patient will be successfully treated, otherwise the critically ill patient will die.
[0186] 13) The maximum treatment time for seriously injured patients is set as T2 = 60min, which means that if seriously injured patients cannot be transferred to rear hospitals for further treatment within 60 minutes after taking comparative emergency measures, they will be converted into critically ill patients.
[0187] 14) Set 0-1 variable D ijnl , R ijnl , W ijnl , which is used to indicate the situations in which the wounded with level n injuries die, are treated, or are treated as critically injured in the scenario of using the lth type of emergency resources to transport the wounded with level n injuries from the ith venue to the jth rear hospital.
[0188] For critically ill patients with n=1, if the transfer time exceeds the golden rescue time T1 or the patient is not transferred, the treatment is ineffective and the patient dies. Otherwise, the patient can be treated as a critically ill patient.
[0189]
[0190] For n=2 seriously injured patients, if the transfer time is within the maximum rescue time limit T2, the injured patient will be treated as a seriously injured patient; if the transfer time exceeds T2 and is less than T1+T2, the injured patient will be treated as a critically injured patient; if the transfer time exceeds T1+T2 or the injured patient is not transferred, the injured patient dies;
[0191]
[0192] For the lightly injured with n=3, there is no death, and the set condition for receiving treatment is to be transferred to the rear hospital without time limit, so the corresponding three parameters D, R, and W are fixed values.
[0193] D ij3l =0 R ij3l =1 Wij3l =0
[0194] 15) Set the decision variable X ijl 、a ijnl Where X ijl represents the number of type l emergency resources deployed from the i-th venue to the j-th rear hospital, a ijnl Represents the total number of injured persons with level n injuries who are equipped with the lth type of emergency resources on the road from the i-th venue to the j-th rear hospital.
[0195] Step 2.2: Set the objective function of the emergency medical rescue resource scheduling model in the transfer and evacuation phase.
[0196] The objective function is set as follows:
[0197]
[0198] Objective function (8) represents the model of the post-transportation stage, which minimizes the total number of deaths. The number of deaths includes the total number of light-severity and above casualties who died due to long transfer time and failure to be transferred.
[0199]
[0200] The objective function (9) indicates that the number of patients whose serious condition is converted to critical condition due to long transfer time should be minimized.
[0201]
[0202] The objective function (10) indicates that the total number of people who receive treatment should be maximized, because lightly injured patients who are not transferred are considered to have not received treatment. Therefore, the objective function (10) mainly considers that more lightly injured patients receive treatment.
[0203]
[0204] Objective function (11) indicates that the average transfer time of each emergency resource in the scheduling scheme should be as small as possible. Because there is no time limit for the transfer of lightly injured patients, in order to further ensure that the injured are treated as soon as possible, the requirement of minimum average time is added to avoid choosing a longer route.
[0205]
[0206] The objective function (12) indicates that the number of unused medical resource locations in the scheduling plan should be as small as possible, that is, the resource utilization rate should be as high as possible.
[0207]
[0208] The linear weighted method is combined with the above five objective functions, namely objective functions (8) to (12), as the final objective function of the model for the post-transport stage, namely objective function (13), to ensure that the model solution can simultaneously meet multiple objectives, namely, the number of deaths is as small as possible, the number of seriously injured patients transferred to critically ill patients is as small as possible, the total number of patients treated is as large as possible, the average transfer time is as short as possible, and the resource utilization rate is as high as possible. In this embodiment, the decision-making focus is taken according to c 21 =1, c 22 =1, c 23 =1, c 24 =1, c 25 =1.
[0209] Step 2.3: Set the constraints of the emergency medical rescue resource scheduling model in the transfer and evacuation phase.
[0210]
[0211] Constraint (14) indicates that the number of emergency resources dispatched from each venue should be within the available range of each venue.
[0212]
[0213] Formula (15) indicates that all emergency resources can only be sent to rear hospitals that can accept such emergency resources.
[0214]
[0215] Formula (16) indicates that the number of injured people actually transferred to each venue does not exceed the known number of injured people.
[0216]
[0217] Formula (17) indicates that the number of light-severity and above wounded transferred to each rear hospital should be within the hospital's capacity.
[0218]
[0219] Formula (18) indicates that the number of critically injured patients transported by a single emergency resource cannot exceed the upper limit.
[0220]
[0221] Formula (19) indicates that the number of seriously injured patients transported by a single emergency resource cannot exceed the upper limit.
[0222]
[0223] Formula (20) indicates that the total number of wounded transported by a single emergency resource should not exceed the upper limit of the total rescue capacity, and each emergency resource should be able to transport the wounded with the maximum rescue capacity.
[0224]
[0225] Formula (21) represents the decision variable X ijl 、a ijnl All are non-negative integers.
[0226] Step 2.4: Use the solution of the transfer and evacuation stage to reasonably arrange the wounded transportation plan for each medical resource. The implementation method is:
[0227] First, Lingo18.0 is used to solve the model of the post-transportation stage and obtain the solution results, including X ijl and a ijnl There are two types of variables, corresponding to the number of emergency resources and the number of wounded with different injuries on each route. For the medical resources and wounded on each transfer and evacuation route, the wounded are arranged to each emergency resource according to the priority of the wounded's condition and the priority of the type of medical resources. The priority of the wounded's condition is: critically injured > seriously injured > lightly injured, that is, the wounded with more serious injuries are arranged for transfer and evacuation first; the priority of resource types is: rescue helicopters > ambulances > volunteer vehicles, that is, the medical resources with shorter arrival time at the venue and more complete medical equipment are arranged first. In the process of arranging the wounded, it is necessary to consider both the ability of each medical resource to rescue critically injured patients and the total ability to rescue wounded patients. The process of generating a wounded transportation plan for a certain type of resource on each transfer and evacuation route is as follows: Figure 4 shown.
[0228] The final plan for the transfer of the wounded in the transfer and evacuation phase is shown in Table 9.
[0229] Table 9 Transfer plan for the wounded during the transfer and evacuation phase
[0230]
[0231]
[0232] Analysis of the transfer plan shows that the actual number of injured people in the transfer and evacuation stage is 154. Based on the results of the on-site treatment stage plan, volunteer vehicles are added, and the overall rescue capacity fully meets the needs. Under this plan, the wounded are all classified and transferred, the number of deaths is 0, the number of people treated in critical condition is 19, the total number of people treated is 154, no serious wounded are transferred to critical condition, and the treatment success rate reaches 100%. The transfer of wounded people occurs between venues with shorter resource transfer time and rear hospitals in the same competition area, and there is no cross-competition area transfer. In addition, individual emergency resources are used to the maximum extent, and transfer is basically achieved under full load. From the above analysis, it can be seen that the solution meets the actual needs.
[0233] The specific description above further illustrates the purpose, technical solutions and beneficial effects of the invention in detail. It should be understood that the above is only a specific embodiment of the present invention and is not intended to limit the scope of protection of the present invention. Any modifications, equivalent substitutions, improvements, etc. made within the spirit and principles of the present invention should be included in the scope of protection of the present invention.
Claims
1. An optimization model for dispatching emergency medical rescue resources for large-scale sports events, characterized in that: The following steps are involved: Step 1: Establish and solve a multi-objective optimization model for the dispatch of emergency medical resources during the on-site treatment phase of major sports events, and generate a medical resource dispatch plan from emergency sites to affected venues based on the number of injured; Step 2: Establish and solve the multi-objective optimization model for emergency medical resource scheduling in the transport and evacuation phase of large-scale event emergencies, and generate the resource allocation optimization plan from the required venues to the rear hospitals and the wounded transport plan based on the triage data returned from the on-site treatment phase; In step 1, the steps to establish and solve the resource scheduling model are as follows: Step 1.1: Set the parameters of the emergency medical rescue resource scheduling model during the on-site treatment phase: 1) Assume that there are currently F emergency stations and G venues, f = 1, 2, 3, ..., F represents the fth emergency station, and g = 1, 2, 3, ..., G represents the gth venue; 2) Set the current emergency resources to be divided into L categories, and use l = 1, 2, 3, ..., L to represent different emergency resources, such as ambulances, rescue helicopters, volunteer vehicles, etc.; 3) Set the number of injured people P in the venue g , represents the estimated number of injured persons in the g-th venue; 4) Set the number of resources that can be called by the emergency station M fl , represents the number of the lth type of emergency resources that can be called by the fth emergency station; 5) Set the resource dispatch time from the emergency station to the rear venue fgl , represents the time required for dispatching the lth type of resources from the fth emergency station to the gth venue; 6) Set the rescue capacity r of a single category l resource in the on-site rescue phase l , indicating that a single resource of type l can rescue r l wounded; 7) Set a 0-1 variable v to indicate whether the venue accepts a certain type of resource gl : 8) Set the decision variable K fgl , represents the number of the lth type of emergency resources deployed from the fth emergency station to the gth venue; Step 1.2: Set the objective function of the emergency medical rescue resource scheduling model in the on-site treatment stage; The objective function is set as follows: The linear weighted method is used to combine objective function (1) and objective function (2) as the final objective function of the on-site treatment stage model, namely objective function (3), to ensure that the model solution can simultaneously meet multiple objectives, namely, the total arrival time of emergency resources is minimized and the total rescue capacity of emergency resources is maximized; the weight c of each sub-objective of objective function (3) is 11 、c 12 Determined by the decision maker’s decision focus; Step 1.3: Set the constraints of the emergency medical rescue resource scheduling model in the on-site treatment phase, including constraints (4)-(7): Step 1.4: Use lingo18.0 or other operations research software to solve the multi-objective model of the on-site treatment stage and obtain the emergency medical rescue resource scheduling plan for the on-site treatment stage; In step 2, the steps to establish and solve the resource scheduling model are as follows: Step 2.1: Set the parameters of the emergency medical rescue resource scheduling model in the transfer and evacuation phase; 1) Set the current number of venues I and the number of rear hospitals J, use i=1, 2, 3, ..., I to represent the i-th venue, and use j=1, 2, 3, ..., J to represent the j-th rear hospital; 2) Set the number of emergency resources types L, and use numbers such as l = 1, 2, 3, ..., L to represent different emergency resources, such as ambulances, rescue helicopters, volunteer vehicles, etc.; 3) Set the number of injury levels of the injured to N=3, with n=1 representing the critical level, n=2 representing the severe level, and n=3 representing the mild level; 4) Set the number of injured people P in the venue after the injury classification in , represents the number of injured persons with injury level n in the i-th venue; 5) Set the number of resources that can be called by each venue E il , represents the number of the first-class emergency resources that can be called upon by the ith venue; 6) Set the resource dispatch time t from the venue to the rear hospital ijl , represents the time required to dispatch the lth type of resources from the i-th venue to the j-th rear hospital; 7) Set the total rescue capacity b of a single Category l resource in the transfer and evacuation phase l , which means that a single resource of type l can be transferred to b at most. l wounded; 8) Set the treatment capacity S of a single Category 1 resource for critically injured patients during the transport and evacuation phase l , represents the maximum number of S that a single resource of category l can be transferred and delivered l Critically injured patients; 9) Set the treatment capacity Z of a single Category 1 resource for seriously injured patients during the transfer and evacuation phase l , represents the maximum number of times a single resource of type l can be transferred and delivered to Z l Seriously injured; 10) Set a 0-1 variable h to indicate whether the rear hospital accepts a certain type of resource jl ; 11) Set the maximum number of patients that the rear hospital can accept C j , represents the maximum number of patients that the jth hospital can accept at one time. Since the treatment of lightly injured patients takes a shorter time and does not occupy hospital beds, we believe that the lightly injured patients transferred to the rear hospital do not affect the number of patients that the hospital can accept; 12) Set the golden treatment time T1 for critically ill patients, which means that if a critically ill patient can be transferred to a rear hospital for further treatment within T1 after receiving necessary emergency treatment, the critically ill patient will be successfully treated, otherwise the critically ill patient will die; 13) Set the maximum treatment time T2 for seriously injured patients, which means that if seriously injured patients cannot be transferred to rear hospitals for further treatment within T2 after receiving necessary emergency treatment, they will be converted into critically ill patients; 14) Set 0-1 variable D ijnl , R ijnl , W ijnl , used to indicate the situations in which the injured with level n injuries are sent from the i-th venue to the j-th rear hospital using the l-th type of emergency resources, and the injured die, are treated, or are treated as critically injured. In view of the particularity of emergency medical rescue, it is necessary to consider that the seriously injured will turn into the critically injured after a certain period of time, so the judgment criteria of the treatment effect parameter value are different for the injured with different injury levels; For critically ill patients with n=1, if the transfer time exceeds the golden rescue time T1 or the patient is not transferred, the treatment is ineffective and the patient dies. Otherwise, the patient can be treated as a critically ill patient. For n=2 seriously injured patients, if the transfer time is within the maximum rescue time limit T2, the injured patient will be treated as a seriously injured patient; if the transfer time exceeds T2 and is less than T1+T2, the injured patient will be treated as a critically injured patient; if the transfer time exceeds T1+T2 or the injured patient is not transferred, the injured patient dies; For the lightly injured with n=3, there is no death. The condition for them to receive treatment is to be transferred to the rear hospital without time limit. Therefore, the corresponding three parameters D, R, and W are fixed values. D ij3l =0 R ij3l =1 W ij3l =0 15) Set the decision variable X ijl 、a ijnl; Where X ijl represents the number of first-class emergency resources deployed from the ith venue to the jth rear hospital, a ijnl represents the total number of injured persons with level n injuries who are equipped with the first-class emergency resources on the road from the i-th venue to the j-th rear hospital; Step 2.2: Set the objective function of the emergency medical rescue resource scheduling model in the transfer and evacuation phase: The linear weighted method is combined with objective functions (8) to (12) as the final objective function of the model for the post-transport phase, namely objective function (13), to ensure that the model solution can simultaneously meet multiple objectives, namely, the number of deaths is as small as possible, the number of seriously injured patients transferred to critically ill patients is as small as possible, the total number of patients treated is as large as possible, the average transfer time is as short as possible, and the resource utilization rate is as high as possible; the weight c of each sub-objective of objective function (13) is 21 、c 22 、c 23 、c 24 、c 25 Determined by the decision maker’s decision focus; Step 2.3: Set the constraints of the emergency medical rescue resource scheduling model in the transfer and evacuation phase, including constraints (14)-(21); Step 2.4: According to the solution of the transfer and evacuation stage, the wounded transportation plan of each medical resource is reasonably arranged to obtain the final plan of the transfer and evacuation stage; the arrangement idea of the wounded transportation plan is as follows: First, Lingo18.0 or other operations research software is used to solve the transfer and evacuation stage model to obtain the solution results, including X ijl and a ijnl The two types of variables correspond to the number of emergency resources and the number of wounded with different injuries on each route. For the medical resources and wounded on each transfer and evacuation route, the wounded are arranged to each emergency resource according to the priority of the wounded's condition and the priority of the type of medical resources. The priority of the wounded's condition is: critically injured > seriously injured > lightly injured, that is, the wounded with more serious injuries are arranged for transfer and evacuation first. The priority of resource types is: rescue helicopters > ambulances > social vehicles, that is, the medical resources with shorter arrival time and more complete medical equipment are arranged first. In the process of arranging the wounded, it is necessary to consider the ability of each medical resource to rescue critically injured patients and the total ability to rescue wounded patients.
