A calculation method for time-varying stability safety guarantee rate of arch dams
Through the calculation method of time-varying stability and safety guarantee rate of the arch dam, the problem of failure to consider the uncertainty of material parameters in the traditional method is solved. The finite element model and Monte Carlo method are used to evaluate the anti-slip stability and overload safety coefficient of the dam shoulder to achieve A more accurate assessment of time-varying stability and safety of arch dams.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202410469544.6
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-04-18
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-05
- Estimated Expiration
- 2044-04-18
AI Technical Summary
Traditional methods fail to fully consider the uncertainty of material parameters when evaluating the stability and safety of high-arch dam shoulders, resulting in large deviations in the evaluation results, making it difficult to accurately invert the time-varying laws of dams and foundation materials, and affecting the scientific nature of structural operation. Evaluate.
The time-varying stability and safety guarantee rate calculation method of the arch dam is used, and the parameter average and distribution types affecting the safety of the arch dam in each period are obtained, parameter values are generated randomly, and a finite element model is constructed to calculate the anti-slip stability time-varying safety coefficient and overload of the dam shoulder. Safety coefficient, establish a response equation, and use the Monte Carlo method to randomly obtain the distribution type and statistical characteristics of the safety coefficient, thereby evaluating the time-varying stability and safety guarantee rate of the arch dam.
The arch dam shoulder anti-slip stability and overload safety coefficient are achieved more accurately, providing a more reliable time-varying stability and safety guarantee rate of the arch dam, and improving the accuracy and reliability of the evaluation.
Smart Images

Figure CN118446043B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention relates to the field of arch dam safety monitoring, and in particular to a method for calculating a time-varying stability safety guarantee rate of an arch dam. Background Art
[0002] Arch dams have excellent mechanical properties, strong overload capacity, high safety, and economical construction costs. They are one of the dam types widely used in dam construction at home and abroad. High arch dams have complex terrain and geological conditions, large hydraulic loads, high stress levels, and significant time-varying characteristics of material parameters. It is difficult to evaluate the time-varying risks of operating performance and structural safety. Original performance analysis is an important means to evaluate the long-term safe operating performance of high arch dams. Effective analysis of the evolution of arch dam deformation and stress performance is of great significance to ensure engineering safety. During the long-term service of arch dams, the time-varying characteristics of their material parameter performance and environmental effects such as hydraulic loads are significant, resulting in the evolution of their working performance being a nonlinear dynamic process. However, traditional methods mainly use a single instability safety factor for evaluation, without considering the uncertainty of material parameters. Therefore, how to make full use of the original monitoring data of the dam, invert the time-varying laws of the dam and foundation material parameters, construct their time-varying models, reasonably evaluate the operating performance of the dam structure, and scientifically evaluate the stability safety guarantee rate of the arch dam shoulder are key scientific and technological problems that need to be solved. Summary of the invention
[0003] In view of the above-mentioned deficiencies in the prior art, a method for calculating the time-varying stability safety guarantee rate of an arch dam provided by the present invention solves the problem that the prior method uses a single instability safety factor to evaluate the stability safety guarantee rate of an arch dam abutment, resulting in large deviations in the evaluation results.
[0004] In order to achieve the above-mentioned object of the invention, the technical solution adopted by the present invention is:
[0005] A method for calculating the time-varying stability safety guarantee rate of an arch dam is provided, which comprises the following steps:
[0006] S1. Obtain the mean value of the parameters affecting the safety of the arch dam in each period according to the parameters of the target arch dam; set the distribution type and coefficient of variation of the parameters affecting the safety of the arch dam in each period;
[0007] S2. According to the mean, distribution type and coefficient of variation of the parameters affecting the safety of the arch dam in each period, the parameter values affecting the safety of the arch dam in each period are randomly generated, and several finite element arch dam models are constructed in different time periods through orthogonal tests;
[0008] S3. Extract the normal stress and shear stress of the centroid of the bottom sliding surface unit of the most dangerous sliding body of the dam abutment in the finite element arch dam model, the normal stress and shear stress of the centroid of the side sliding surface unit, and the area of each sliding surface, and calculate the time-varying safety factor of the dam abutment anti-sliding stability corresponding to the sliding body by using stress algebra and ratio method;
[0009] S4. The ratio of the upstream water pressure load to the initial water pressure load value when the finite element arch dam model reaches the critical instability state is used as the overload safety factor corresponding to the sliding body;
[0010] S5. Establish a response equation in which the parameters affecting the safety of the arch dam are respectively the time-varying safety factor of the dam shoulder anti-sliding stability and the overload safety factor corresponding to the sliding body, and use the least square method to fit the coefficients in the response equation to obtain the fitted response equation;
[0011] S6. Based on the fitted response equation, the Monte Carlo method is used to randomly select the parameters that affect the safety of the arch dam, and the distribution type and statistical characteristics of the anti-sliding stability safety factor and overload safety factor of the dam abutment in each period are obtained;
[0012] S7. Select the time-varying stability safety guarantee rate of the arch dam based on the distribution type and statistical characteristics of the anti-sliding stability safety factor and overload safety factor of the dam abutment in each time period; the time-varying stability safety guarantee rate of the arch dam includes the time-varying safety guarantee rate of the anti-sliding stability of the arch dam abutment in each time period and the safety guarantee rate of the ultimate bearing capacity of the arch dam abutment in each time period.
[0013] Furthermore, the parameters affecting the safety of the arch dam in each time period in step S1 are the physical parameters of the target arch dam and the foundation, including the elastic modulus of the target arch dam, the cohesion of the target arch dam, the internal friction angle of the target arch dam, the elastic modulus of the foundation, the cohesion of the foundation, the internal friction angle of the foundation, the upstream water level and the downstream water level.
[0014] Furthermore, the calculation expression of the time-varying safety factor of the dam abutment anti-sliding stability corresponding to the finite element arch dam model in step S3 is:
[0015]
[0016] Where K S (t) is the time-varying safety factor of the dam abutment anti-sliding stability corresponding to the sliding body at time t; f z '(t) and c' z (t) are the shear friction coefficient and shear cohesion of the bedrock where the sliding body is located at time t; σ i (t) is the normal stress at the centroid of the i-th sliding surface unit at time t; τ i (t) is the shear stress at the centroid of the i-th sliding surface unit at time t; A i is the area of the i-th sliding surface unit; n is the total number of sliding surface units.
[0017] Furthermore, the overload safety factor K of the sliding body P The calculation expression is:
[0018]
[0019] Where γ is the specific gravity of water; H0 is the normal water storage level of the arch dam; ΔH is the height difference between the normal water storage level of the arch dam and the water level when the arch dam is destroyed; H is the water level when the arch dam is destroyed.
[0020] Furthermore, the parameters affecting the arch dam safety in step S5 and the time-varying safety factor K of the dam abutment anti-sliding stability corresponding to the sliding body are S The corresponding response equation is expressed as:
[0021]
[0022] where x j is the jth parameter affecting the safety of the arch dam; a 1,j 、b 1,j and c1 are the parameters to be fitted; m is the total number of parameters affecting the safety of the arch dam.
[0023] Furthermore, the expression of the response equation of the parameter affecting the arch dam safety and the overload safety factor corresponding to the sliding body in step S5 is:
[0024]
[0025] where x j is the jth parameter affecting the safety of the arch dam; a 1,j 、b 1,j and c1 are the parameters to be fitted; m is the total number of parameters affecting the safety of the arch dam.
[0026] Furthermore, the specific method of step S7 includes the following sub-steps:
[0027] S7-1. Based on the distribution type and statistical characteristics of the anti-sliding stability safety factor of the dam abutment in each period, the corresponding density function is constructed, that is, the anti-sliding stability density function is obtained;
[0028] S7-2. Construct a corresponding density function based on the distribution type and statistical characteristics of the overload safety factor in each period, that is, obtain an overload density function;
[0029] S7-3, respectively set the anti-sliding stability safety factor value of the dam abutment in each period and the overload safety factor value in each period, and calculate the area corresponding to the anti-sliding stability safety factor value of the dam abutment in each period and the area corresponding to the overload safety factor value in each period through the corresponding density function;
[0030] S7-4. The result of deducting the area corresponding to the anti-sliding stability safety factor value of the dam shoulder in each period from 1 is used as the time-varying safety guarantee rate of the anti-sliding stability of the arch dam shoulder in each period; the result of deducting the area corresponding to the overload safety factor value in each period from 1 is used as the ultimate bearing safety guarantee rate of the arch dam shoulder in each period.
[0031] The beneficial effects of the present invention are as follows: the method performs safety factor analysis based on the time-varying law of the inversion parameters and the finite element calculation of the upstream reservoir water level, extracts the normal stress and shear stress of the centroid of the bottom sliding surface and the side sliding surface unit of the most dangerous sliding body of the dam shoulder, and the area of each sliding surface, and uses the stress algebra and ratio method to calculate the time-varying safety factor of the dam shoulder anti-sliding stability, so as to obtain the time-varying overload safety factor of the arch dam more accurately. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0032] Figure 1 is a schematic diagram of the process of this method;
[0033] Figure 2 It is a sliding mode diagram of the left bank slider in the embodiment;
[0034] Figure 3 It is a sliding mode diagram of the right bank slider in the embodiment;
[0035] Figure 4 The curve of safety factor of anti-sliding stability of the left bank abutment versus water level duration in the embodiment;
[0036] Figure 5 The curve of safety factor of anti-sliding stability of the right bank abutment versus water level duration in the embodiment;
[0037] Figure 6 is the time-varying law of the overload safety factor in the embodiment;
[0038] Figure 7 The relationship between the overload safety factor and the number of iterations in the period from 2021.9 to 2022.9 in the embodiment;
[0039] Figure 8(a) shows the distribution of the overload plastic zone at 979m elevation during the period from 2021.9 to 2022.9 (Kp = 3);
[0040] Figure 8(b) shows the distribution of the overload plastic zone at 1030m elevation during the period from September 2021 to September 2022 (Kp = 3);
[0041] Figure 8(c) shows the distribution of the overload plastic zone at 1081 m elevation during the period from 2021.9 to 2022.9 (Kp = 3);
[0042] Figure 8(d) shows the distribution of the overload plastic zone at an elevation of 1135 m during the period from 2021.9 to 2022.9 (Kp = 3);
[0043] Figure 8(e) shows the distribution of overload plastic zone (Kp = 3) at the 0+60m section (left bank) during the period from 2021.9 to 2022.9;
[0044] Figure 8(f) shows the distribution of overload plastic zone (Kp = 3) at section 0+110m (left bank) during the period from 2021.9 to 2022.9;
[0045] Figure 8(g) shows the distribution of overload plastic zone (Kp = 3) at section 0+470m (right bank) during the period from 2021.9 to 2022.9;
[0046] Figure 8(h) shows the distribution of overload plastic zone (Kp = 3) at section 0+520m (right bank) during the period from 2021.9 to 2022.9;
[0047] Figure 8(i) shows the distribution of the overload plastic zone on the upstream face of the dam during the period from September 2021 to September 2022 (Kp = 3);
[0048] Figure 8(j) shows the distribution of overload plastic zone on the downstream face of the dam during the period from September 2021 to September 2022 (Kp = 3);
[0049] Figure 9(a) shows the distribution of the overload plastic zone at 979m elevation during the period from September 2021 to September 2022 (Kp = 5);
[0050] Figure 9(b) shows the distribution of the overload plastic zone at 1030m elevation during the period from September 2021 to September 2022 (Kp = 5);
[0051] Figure 9(c) shows the distribution of the overload plastic zone at 1081 m elevation during the period from 2021.9 to 2022.9 (Kp = 5);
[0052] Figure 9(d) shows the distribution of the overload plastic zone at an elevation of 1135 m during the period from 2021.9 to 2022.9 (Kp = 5);
[0053] Figure 9(e) shows the distribution of overload plastic zone (Kp = 5) at the 0+60m section (left bank) during the period from 2021.9 to 2022.9;
[0054] Figure 9(f) shows the distribution of overload plastic zone (Kp = 5) at section 0 + 110 m (left bank) during the period from 2021.9 to 2022.9;
[0055] Figure 9(g) shows the distribution of overload plastic zone at section 0+470m (right bank) during the period of 2021.9 to 2022.9 (Kp=5);
[0056] Figure 9(h) shows the distribution of overload plastic zone (Kp = 5) at section 0+520m (right bank) during the period from 2021.9 to 2022.9;
[0057] Figure 9(i) shows the distribution of the overload plastic zone on the upstream face of the dam during the period from September 2021 to September 2022 (Kp = 5);
[0058] Figure 9(j) shows the distribution of overload plastic zone on the downstream face of the dam during the period from September 2021 to September 2022 (Kp = 5);
[0059] Figure 10(a) shows the distribution of the overload plastic zone at 979m elevation during the period from 2021.9 to 2022.9 (Kp = 6.4);
[0060] Figure 10(b) shows the distribution of the overload plastic zone at 1030m elevation during the period from 2021.9 to 2022.9 (Kp = 6.4);
[0061] Figure 10(c) shows the distribution of the overload plastic zone at 1081 m elevation during the period from 2021.9 to 2022.9 (Kp = 6.4);
[0062] Figure 10(d) shows the distribution of the overload plastic zone at an elevation of 1135 m during the period from 2021.9 to 2022.9 (Kp = 6.4);
[0063] Figure 10(e) shows the distribution of overload plastic zone (Kp = 6.4) at the 0+60m section (left bank) during the period from 2021.9 to 2022.9;
[0064] Figure 10(f) shows the distribution of overload plastic zone (Kp = 6.4) at section 0+110m (left bank) during the period from 2021.9 to 2022.9;
[0065] Figure 10(g) shows the distribution of overload plastic zone (Kp = 6.4) at section 0+470m (right bank) during the period from 2021.9 to 2022.9;
[0066] Figure 10(h) shows the distribution of overload plastic zone (Kp = 6.4) at section 0+520m (right bank) during the period from 2021.9 to 2022.9;
[0067] Figure 10(i) shows the distribution of the overload plastic zone on the upstream face of the dam during the period from September 2021 to September 2022 (Kp = 6.4);
[0068] Figure 10(j) shows the distribution of overload plastic zone on the downstream face of the dam during the period from 2021.9 to 2022.9 (Kp = 6.4);
[0069] Figure 11(a) shows the safety factor K of the left bank abutment against sliding in the first period S1 Distribution map;
[0070] Figure 11(b) shows the anti-sliding stability safety factor K of the right bank abutment in the first period S1 Distribution map;
[0071] Figure 11(c) shows the safety factor K of the left bank abutment against sliding in the second period S2 Distribution map;
[0072] Figure 11(d) shows the anti-sliding stability safety factor K of the right bank abutment in the second period S2 Distribution map;
[0073] Figure 11(e) shows the safety factor K of the left bank abutment against sliding in the third period S3 Distribution map;
[0074] Figure 11(f) shows the anti-sliding stability safety factor K of the right bank abutment in the third period S3 Distribution map;
[0075] Figure 11(g) shows the safety factor K of the left bank abutment against sliding in the fourth period S4 Distribution map;
[0076] Figure 11(h) shows the anti-sliding stability safety factor K of the right bank abutment in the fourth period S4 Distribution map;
[0077] Figure 11(i) shows the safety factor K of the left bank abutment against sliding in the fifth period S5 Distribution map;
[0078] Figure 11(j) shows the anti-sliding stability safety factor K of the right bank abutment in the fifth period S5 Distribution map;
[0079] Figure 11(k) shows the safety factor K of the left bank abutment against sliding in the sixth period S6 Distribution map;
[0080] Figure 11(l) shows the anti-sliding stability safety factor K of the right bank abutment in the sixth period S6 Distribution map;
[0081] Figure 11(m) shows the safety factor K of the left bank abutment against sliding in the seventh period S7 Distribution map;
[0082] Figure 11(n) shows the anti-sliding stability safety factor K of the right bank abutment in the seventh period S7 Distribution map;
[0083] Fig.12 This is the overload safety factor distribution diagram. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0084] The specific implementation modes of the present invention are described below so that those skilled in the art can understand the present invention. However, it should be clear that the present invention is not limited to the scope of the specific implementation modes. For those of ordinary skill in the art, as long as various changes are within the spirit and scope of the present invention as defined and determined by the attached claims, these changes are obvious, and all inventions and creations utilizing the concept of the present invention are protected.
[0085] like Figure 1 As shown in FIG. 1 , the calculation method for the time-varying stability safety guarantee rate of the arch dam includes the following steps:
[0086] S1. Obtain the mean value of the parameters affecting the safety of the arch dam in each period according to the parameters of the target arch dam; set the distribution type and coefficient of variation of the parameters affecting the safety of the arch dam in each period;
[0087] S2. According to the mean, distribution type and coefficient of variation of the parameters affecting the safety of the arch dam in each period, the parameter values affecting the safety of the arch dam in each period are randomly generated, and several finite element arch dam models are constructed in different time periods through orthogonal tests;
[0088] S3. Extract the normal stress and shear stress of the centroid of the bottom sliding surface unit of the most dangerous sliding body of the dam abutment in the finite element arch dam model, the normal stress and shear stress of the centroid of the side sliding surface unit, and the area of each sliding surface, and calculate the time-varying safety factor of the dam abutment anti-sliding stability corresponding to the sliding body by using stress algebra and ratio method;
[0089] S4. The ratio of the upstream water pressure load to the initial water pressure load value when the finite element arch dam model reaches the critical instability state is used as the overload safety factor corresponding to the sliding body;
[0090] S5. Establish a response equation in which the parameters affecting the safety of the arch dam are respectively the time-varying safety factor of the dam shoulder anti-sliding stability and the overload safety factor corresponding to the sliding body, and use the least square method to fit the coefficients in the response equation to obtain the fitted response equation;
[0091] S6. Based on the fitted response equation, the Monte Carlo method is used to randomly select the parameters that affect the safety of the arch dam, and the distribution type and statistical characteristics of the anti-sliding stability safety factor and overload safety factor of the dam abutment in each period are obtained;
[0092] S7. Select the time-varying stability safety guarantee rate of the arch dam based on the distribution type and statistical characteristics of the anti-sliding stability safety factor and overload safety factor of the dam abutment in each time period; the time-varying stability safety guarantee rate of the arch dam includes the time-varying safety guarantee rate of the anti-sliding stability of the arch dam abutment in each time period and the safety guarantee rate of the ultimate bearing capacity of the arch dam abutment in each time period.
[0093] The parameters affecting the safety of the arch dam in each period in step S1 are the physical parameters of the target arch dam and the foundation, including the elastic modulus of the target arch dam, the cohesion of the target arch dam, the internal friction angle of the target arch dam, the elastic modulus of the foundation, the cohesion of the foundation, the internal friction angle of the foundation, the upstream water level and the downstream water level.
[0094] The calculation expression of the time-varying safety factor of the dam abutment anti-sliding stability corresponding to the finite element arch dam model in step S3 is:
[0095]
[0096] Where K S (t) is the time-varying safety factor of the dam abutment anti-sliding stability corresponding to the sliding body at time t; f z '(t) and c'z (t) are the shear friction coefficient and shear cohesion of the bedrock where the sliding body is located at time t; σ i (t) is the normal stress at the centroid of the i-th sliding surface unit at time t; τ i (t) is the shear stress at the centroid of the i-th sliding surface unit at time t; A i is the area of the i-th sliding surface unit; n is the total number of sliding surface units.
[0097] Overload safety factor K of sliding body P The calculation expression is:
[0098]
[0099] Where γ is the specific gravity of water; H0 is the normal water storage level of the arch dam; ΔH is the height difference between the normal water storage level of the arch dam and the water level when the arch dam is destroyed; H is the water level when the arch dam is destroyed.
[0100] The parameters affecting the arch dam safety in step S5 and the time-varying safety factor K of the dam abutment anti-sliding stability corresponding to the sliding body S The corresponding response equation is expressed as:
[0101]
[0102] where x j is the jth parameter affecting the safety of the arch dam; a 1,j 、b 1,j and c1 are the parameters to be fitted; m is the total number of parameters affecting the safety of the arch dam.
[0103] The expression of the response equation of the parameters affecting the arch dam safety and the overload safety factor corresponding to the sliding body in step S5 is:
[0104]
[0105] where x j is the jth parameter affecting the safety of the arch dam; a 2,j 、b 2,j and c2 are the parameters to be fitted; m is the total number of parameters affecting the safety of the arch dam.
[0106] The specific method of step S7 includes the following sub-steps:
[0107] S7-1. Based on the distribution type and statistical characteristics of the anti-sliding stability safety factor of the dam abutment in each period, the corresponding density function is constructed, that is, the anti-sliding stability density function is obtained;
[0108] S7-2. Construct a corresponding density function based on the distribution type and statistical characteristics of the overload safety factor in each period, that is, obtain an overload density function;
[0109] S7-3, respectively set the anti-sliding stability safety factor value of the dam abutment in each period and the overload safety factor value in each period, and calculate the area corresponding to the anti-sliding stability safety factor value of the dam abutment in each period and the area corresponding to the overload safety factor value in each period through the corresponding density function;
[0110] S7-4. The result of deducting the area corresponding to the anti-sliding stability safety factor value of the dam shoulder in each period from 1 is used as the time-varying safety guarantee rate of the anti-sliding stability of the arch dam shoulder in each period; the result of deducting the area corresponding to the overload safety factor value in each period from 1 is used as the ultimate bearing safety guarantee rate of the arch dam shoulder in each period.
[0111] In one embodiment of the present invention, according to the engineering geological data of a certain arch dam, the structural surfaces that affect the stability of the left bank abutment are: β21, β28, β41, and f54, f61, f34, f99, f100. The right bank f12, f1, etc. are far away from the arch end, and f16 and f29 are located on the upstream side of the arch end, which are difficult to form a sliding block; f6, f37, β8, etc. are small in scale and do not pose a threat to the anti-sliding stability of the dam abutment after local treatment. The structural surfaces that affect the stability of the right bank abutment are: β4, β43, β62, β68, β69, β82, β85, β114 and f65, f77, f83, f90. In addition, there are six groups of joints and fissures in the dam area: ① Near SN / E∠60°~80°; ② N10°~30° W / SW∠50°~80°; ③ N15°~30° E / NW∠50°~70°; ④ Near EW / N (or S)∠60°~65°, mainly on the left bank of the upper dam site; ⑤ N10°~30° E / SE∠35°~50°; ⑥ Gently inclined cracks, with large variations in attitude upstream and downstream and left and right banks. The left bank is mainly N60°~90° W / SW∠5°~18° and near SN / E∠17°~26°, and the right bank is mainly N0°~40° E / SE∠6°~25° and N45°~76° W / SW∠2°~5°. The analysis revealed that the controlling occurrences of the left and right banks are: (1) Left bank: β21 dyke, fault f54, fissures ④, ③, and ⑥; (2) Right bank: β4, fault f65, fissures ⑤, and ⑥. Therefore, the key slip mode of the arch dam is as follows: Figure 2 and Figure 3 shown.
[0112] The time series of the anti-sliding stability safety factor of the left and right bank abutments from July 2015 to September 2022 is calculated by this method. The time series curves of the anti-sliding stability safety factor of the left and right bank abutments and the water level are shown in the figure below: Figure 4 and Figure 5As shown in the figure, the anti-sliding stability safety factor of the left and right bank abutments both show a trend of gradually decreasing over time, but eventually basically tend to be stable. Since the arch dam was only in operation for 7 years during the calculation period, in the initial operation period, combined with the time-varying law of the inversion parameters, the concrete strength development did not stop, the elastic modulus gradually increased over time, and the strength development gradually tended to be stable; during the water storage process, geological materials such as bedrock, dykes and faults will deteriorate. After a period of operation, due to the adjustment of material stress and deformation, the deterioration of material mechanical parameters will also tend to be stable. Combined with the time-varying law of the inversion parameters, the internal friction angle φ of the bedrock strength parameter gradually decreases over time and eventually tends to be stable. Therefore, the anti-sliding stability safety factor of the left and right bank abutments gradually decreases and eventually tends to be stable, which is in line with the general operation law of hydraulic structures. The safety factor of the left bank abutment is stable at about 5.0, and the safety factor of the right bank abutment is stable at about 6.0. SL 282-2003 "Concrete Arch Dam Design Code" stipulates that the 1st-level arch dam building should meet the allowable safety factor of abutment stability [K] = 3.5 under normal operating conditions. The safety factor of the left and right bank abutments against sliding stability meets the requirements of the code. At the same time, the safety factor of the left and right bank abutments against sliding stability has a good negative correlation with the water level. When the water level rises, the safety factor of the dam abutment against sliding stability decreases, and when the water level drops, the safety factor of the dam abutment against sliding stability increases, which is in line with the general law.
[0113] In order to analyze the plastic yield process and final failure mode of the arch dam body and abutment (foundation) rock mass, the overwater level method was used to increase the water pressure upstream of the dam body according to the time periods divided in the parameter inversion until the calculation did not converge. The overload safety factor of the arch dam in each time period was obtained. The time-varying law of the overload safety factor and the generation and evolution process and failure mode of the plastic zone of the arch dam and foundation under various levels of water pressure after the parameters were stabilized (September 2021 to September 2022) were studied.
[0114] The overload safety factor of the high arch dam in each period is as follows: Figure 6 As shown. Overload safety factor K P It tends to decrease gradually with time, but the amplitude is small. Its time-varying law and the reason for forming this law are consistent with the dam abutment stability safety factor, and it finally stabilizes at 6.4.
[0115] The relationship between the overload safety factor calculated by the overload method and the number of iterations in the last period from September 2021 to September 2022 is as follows: Figure 7As shown; the distribution diagrams of the plastic zones of the dam body and foundation are shown in Fig. 8(a), Fig. 8(b), Fig. 8(c), Fig. 8(d), Fig. 8(e), Fig. 8(f), Fig. 8(g), Fig. 8(h), Fig. 8(i), Fig. 8(j), Fig. 9(a), Fig. 9(b), Fig. 9(c), Fig. 9(d), Fig. 9(e), Fig. 9(f), Fig. 9(g), Fig. 9(h), Fig. 9(i), Fig. 9(j), Fig. 10(a), Fig. 10(b), Fig. 10(c), Fig. 10(d), Fig. 10(e), Fig. 10(f), Fig. 10(g), Fig. 10(h), Fig. 10(i) and Fig. 10(j). The progressive failure process of the dam and foundation is analyzed as follows:
[0116] When K p =3.0, the right bank β4 has a plastic zone at 1090m-1140m, β8 has a large area of plastic zone at 845m-980m, β43 has a large range of plastic zone at 885m-1049m, and the right dam shoulder β62 has a certain range of plastic zone at 1090m-1180m; the left bank β21 plastic zone is expanded, β8 distributed on the left bank has a certain range of plastic zone, and β20 and fault f54 have sporadic plastic zones; the bedrock below the 6#-19# dam section has a certain range of plastic zone; a small range of plastic zone appears at the heel of the upstream dam surface 14# and 15# dam sections.
[0117] When K p =5.0, a large-scale plastic zone appears in β4 on the right bank at 1060m-1145m near the shoulder of the dam, and the plastic zones of β8, β43 and β62 continue to expand; the plastic zone of β21 on the left bank continues to expand along the river, a large-scale plastic zone appears in β8 distributed on the left bank, and the plastic zones of β20 and f54 expand; the distribution range of the plastic zone of the bedrock near the foundation surface continues to expand, and plastic zones appear in the rock mass on the left and right banks of the crown arch; at this time, a certain range of plastic zones appears at the heel of the 14# and 15# dam sections of the dam body, and extends downstream to 2 / 3 of the bottom thickness, sporadic plastic zones appear at the heel of 4#, 7#, 24#, 27# and other dam sections, a certain range of plastic zones appears at the elevation of 980m-1130m on the downstream dam surface of 11#-18# dam sections, and sporadic plastic zones appear at the toe of 9#, 10#, 17#, 19# and other dam sections.
[0118] When K p=6.4, the finite element calculation no longer converges. Large-scale plastic zones appear in β4, β8, β43 and β62 on the right bank; large-scale plastic zones appear in β21, f54 and β8 on the left bank, and the range of β20 plastic zone continues to expand; large-scale plastic zones appear in the bedrock of the dam body, and the right bank is higher than the left bank as a whole; at this time, large-scale plastic zones appear in the dam body, and the plastic zones of 14# and 15# dam sections on the upstream side of the dam body are formed from the dam heel to the dam toe. At the same time, the 1#, 4#, 6#, 7#, 18#, 22#, 24#, 27# and 29# dam sections have plastic zone expansion due to tension, and the 9#, 10#, 16#, 17#, 18#, 19# dam sections have compression plastic zones at the dam toe and expand to the upstream side. The plastic zones on the left and right banks are generally distributed symmetrically.
[0119] Under incremental overload, the overall plastic zone of the dam and foundation appears earlier at medium and low elevations than at high elevations. At the same time, due to the large number of structural surfaces on the right dam shoulder, the plastic zone on the right bank develops earlier than that on the left bank, and the range of the plastic zone is larger than that on the left bank.
[0120] In this embodiment, the coefficient of variation of parameters such as the bulk density and Poisson's ratio of the dam concrete and bedrock is small, so randomness is not considered. The elastic modulus, cohesion, friction angle and upstream water level of the dam concrete, bedrock, dykes and faults, a total of 22 random variables are considered, including 7 inverted time-varying parameters, which are calculated separately according to the divided time periods. Taking the first time period as an example, the statistical characteristics of each parameter are shown in Table 1.
[0121] Table 1: Statistical characteristics of material parameters of arch dam and foundation in the first period
[0122]
[0123] Orthogonal test design was performed on the above random parameters, 128 test schemes were constructed and finite element calculations were performed. Here, the overload safety factor guarantee rate was calculated under the condition that the overload safety factor was stable to 6.4, and the anti-sliding stability safety factor K of the dam shoulder in each period was constructed. s And overload safety factor K P The response surface equation is used, and the Monte Carlo method is used to sample the dam abutment anti-sliding stability safety factor K at each time period. s And overload safety factor K P The distribution law of the safety degree guarantee rate is then calculated. The anti-sliding stability safety factor of the left and right bank abutments of the arch dam under normal water level in each period is shown in Table 2. The safety factor guarantee rate and relative error under different sampling times of the Monte Carlo method are shown in Tables 3 and 4. It can be seen from the table that when the sampling number increases to 10 7 When sampling 10 6 The relative error of the safety guarantee rate calculated in each calculation is less than 0.1%, so the sampling of 10 7 times to meet the computational requirements.
[0124] The guaranteed rate of allowable safety factor of dam abutment design in each period and the guaranteed rate and statistical characteristic value of overload safety factor 6.4 in the last period are shown in Tables 5 and 6. The probability density and cumulative distribution curves are shown in Figures 11(a), 11(b), 11(c), 11(d), 11(e), 11(f), 11(g), 11(h), 11(i), 11(j), 11(k), 11(l), 11(m), 11(n) and 11(n). Fig.12 .
[0125] Table 2: Safety factors for the anti-sliding stability of the left and right dam shoulders at different periods under normal water level
[0126]
[0127] Table 3: Safety factor guarantee rate and relative error under different sampling times
[0128]
[0129] Table 4: Safety factor guarantee rate and relative error under different sampling times
[0130]
[0131] Table 5: Allowable safety factor guarantee rate of dam abutment anti-sliding stability design in each period and overload safety factor guarantee rate and statistical characteristic value in the last period
[0132]
[0133] Table 6: Allowable safety factor guarantee rate of dam abutment anti-sliding stability design in each period and overload safety factor guarantee rate and statistical characteristic value in the last period
[0134]
[0135] According to the KS test results of each safety degree sequence, the significance is greater than 0.05, indicating that the anti-sliding stability safety factor and overload safety factor of the left and right bank abutments of the high arch dam in each period are subject to normal distribution under the random fluctuation of parameters. The guarantee rate of the stability safety factor of the left and right bank abutments in each period is greater than the design allowable safety factor [K] = 3.5, which is 99.99%, and the guarantee rate is relatively high. Therefore, it is more reasonable to judge the stability method by the stability safety factor of the abutments to meet the allowable safety factor. The guarantee rate of the overload safety factor of 6.4 is 46.98%, which is much lower than the guarantee rate of the anti-sliding stability safety factor of the left and right bank abutments in each period to meet the design allowable safety factor [K] = 3.5. Therefore, the overload safety factor calculated by the overload method is too high to judge the stability standard of the arch dam and is not reliable enough.
[0136] In summary, the present invention is based on the time-varying parameters of dam and foundation materials, adopts the orthogonal experimental method to design experiments, establishes the response surface equations of the dam abutment anti-sliding stability safety factor and the overload safety factor, determines the distribution type and statistical characteristics of each material and load, and adopts the Monte Carlo method to reveal the distribution characteristics of the dam abutment stability safety factor and the overload safety factor in each time period. An arch dam time-varying stability safety guarantee rate evaluation method is proposed. Relevant personnel can evaluate the stability of the arch dam according to the time-varying safety guarantee rate of the arch dam abutment anti-sliding stability or the ultimate bearing safety guarantee rate of the arch dam abutment in each time period.
Claims
1. A method for calculating the time-varying stability safety guarantee rate of an arch dam. It is characterized in that The following steps are involved: S1. Obtain the mean value of the parameters affecting the safety of the arch dam in each period according to the parameters of the target arch dam; Set the distribution type and coefficient of variation of the parameters that affect the arch dam safety in each period; S2. According to the mean, distribution type and coefficient of variation of the parameters affecting the safety of the arch dam in each period, the parameter values affecting the safety of the arch dam in each period are randomly generated, and several finite element arch dam models are constructed in different time periods through orthogonal tests; S3. Extract the normal stress and shear stress of the centroid of the bottom sliding surface unit of the most dangerous sliding body of the dam abutment in the finite element arch dam model, the normal stress and shear stress of the centroid of the side sliding surface unit, and the area of each sliding surface, and calculate the time-varying safety factor of the dam abutment anti-sliding stability corresponding to the sliding body by using stress algebra and ratio method; S4. The ratio of the upstream water pressure load to the initial water pressure load value when the finite element arch dam model reaches the critical instability state is used as the overload safety factor corresponding to the sliding body; S5. Establish a response equation in which the parameters affecting the safety of the arch dam are respectively the time-varying safety factor of the dam shoulder anti-sliding stability and the overload safety factor corresponding to the sliding body, and use the least square method to fit the coefficients in the response equation to obtain the fitted response equation; S6. Based on the fitted response equation, the Monte Carlo method is used to randomly select the parameters that affect the safety of the arch dam, and the distribution type and statistical characteristics of the anti-sliding stability safety factor and overload safety factor of the dam abutment in each period are obtained; S7. Select the time-varying stability safety guarantee rate of the arch dam based on the distribution type and statistical characteristics of the anti-sliding stability safety factor and overload safety factor of the dam abutment in each time period; the time-varying stability safety guarantee rate of the arch dam includes the time-varying safety guarantee rate of the anti-sliding stability of the arch dam abutment in each time period and the safety guarantee rate of the ultimate bearing capacity of the arch dam abutment in each time period.
2. According to the method for calculating the time-varying stability safety guarantee rate of an arch dam according to claim 1, It is characterized in that The parameters affecting the safety of the arch dam in each period in step S1 are the physical parameters of the target arch dam and the foundation, including the elastic modulus of the target arch dam, the cohesion of the target arch dam, the internal friction angle of the target arch dam, the elastic modulus of the foundation, the cohesion of the foundation, the internal friction angle of the foundation, the upstream water level and the downstream water level.
3. According to claim 1, a method for calculating the time-varying stability safety guarantee rate of an arch dam, It is characterized in that The calculation expression of the time-varying safety factor of the dam abutment anti-sliding stability corresponding to the finite element arch dam model in step S3 is: Where K S (t) is the time-varying safety factor of the dam abutment anti-sliding stability corresponding to the sliding body at time t; f z '(t) and c' z (t) are the shear friction coefficient and shear cohesion of the bedrock where the sliding body is located at time t; σ i (t) is the normal stress at the centroid of the i-th sliding surface unit at time t; τ i (t) is the shear stress at the centroid of the i-th sliding surface unit at time t; A i is the area of the i-th sliding surface unit; n is the total number of sliding surface units.
4. According to claim 1, a method for calculating the time-varying stability safety guarantee rate of an arch dam, It is characterized in that Overload safety factor K of sliding body P The calculation expression is: Where γ is the specific gravity of water; H 0 is the normal water storage level of the arch dam; ΔH is the height difference between the normal water storage level of the arch dam and the water level when the arch dam is destroyed; H is the water level when the arch dam is destroyed.
5. According to claim 3, a method for calculating the time-varying stability safety guarantee rate of an arch dam, It is characterized in that The parameters affecting the arch dam safety in step S5 and the time-varying safety factor K of the dam abutment anti-sliding stability corresponding to the sliding body S The corresponding response equation is expressed as: where x j is the jth parameter affecting the safety of the arch dam; a 1,j 、b 1,j and c 1 is the parameter to be fitted; m is the total number of parameters affecting the safety of the arch dam.
6. A method for calculating the time-varying stability safety guarantee rate of an arch dam according to claim 4, It is characterized in that The expression of the response equation of the parameters affecting the arch dam safety and the overload safety factor corresponding to the sliding body in step S5 is: where x j is the jth parameter affecting the safety of the arch dam; a 2,j 、b 2,j and c 2 is the parameter to be fitted; m is the total number of parameters affecting the safety of the arch dam.
7. The method for calculating the time-varying stability safety guarantee rate of an arch dam according to claim 1, It is characterized in that The specific method of step S7 includes the following sub-steps: S7-1. Based on the distribution type and statistical characteristics of the anti-sliding stability safety factor of the dam abutment in each period, the corresponding density function is constructed, that is, the anti-sliding stability density function is obtained; S7-2. Construct a corresponding density function based on the distribution type and statistical characteristics of the overload safety factor in each period, that is, obtain an overload density function; S7-3, respectively set the anti-sliding stability safety factor value of the dam abutment in each period and the overload safety factor value in each period, and calculate the area corresponding to the anti-sliding stability safety factor value of the dam abutment in each period and the area corresponding to the overload safety factor value in each period through the corresponding density function; S7-4. The result of subtracting the area corresponding to the anti-sliding stability safety factor of the dam abutment in each period from 1 is taken as the time-varying safety guarantee rate of the anti-sliding stability of the arch dam abutment in each period; The area corresponding to the overload safety factor value in each period is deducted from 1 as the ultimate bearing safety guarantee rate of the arch dam abutment in each period.
