Dynamic evaluation method and system of electric energy substitution implementation indicators based on variable weight optimization
Through variable weight optimization and dynamic evaluation methods, the problems of data abnormalities and stage changes in the electric energy substitution evaluation model are solved, dynamic evaluation and comprehensive evaluation of the electric energy substitution project are realized, the accuracy of the evaluation and self-correction ability are improved, and the project's Flexible management.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202410923882.2
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-07-11
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-12
- Estimated Expiration
- 2044-07-11
AI Technical Summary
The existing electrical energy substitution evaluation model cannot effectively deal with the impact of data abnormalities and data changes in the substitution process, resulting in decision-making deviations, and traditional models cannot timely monitor and evaluate progress and equipment updates at different stages, resulting in improper project management, affecting project progress and Results.
The variable weight optimization method is used to optimize the subjective and objective combination weights, introduce corrected parameter feedback optimization, and build a dynamic evaluation model through the butterfly optimization algorithm and the advantage and disadvantage solution distance method to realize the implementation indicator evaluation of each stage of the electrical energy substitution project.
It realizes dynamic and comprehensive evaluation of the implementation indicators of the electricity substitute project, reflects the impact of the changes in the index data, improves the accuracy and self-correction ability of the evaluation, can promptly reflect equipment updates and policy changes, and supports flexible management of the project.
Smart Images

Figure CN118469406B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention belongs to the technical field of new energy for electric power systems, and in particular, relates to a method and system for dynamically evaluating electric energy substitution implementation indicators based on variable weight optimization. Background Art
[0002] Electricity substitution is one of the emerging low-carbon technologies, which refers to the use of electricity to replace or reduce the use of traditional energy in various applications. This process can effectively improve fuel efficiency and promote green energy use. According to the entire process of electricity production, transportation and consumption, electricity substitution technology mainly covers the following three aspects: First, on the electricity production side, replace the consumption of fossil energy such as coal, take the source as the starting point, and realize the green and clean power supply. Second, on the electricity transportation side, replace coal transportation, and give priority to the transmission of clean electricity from afar. Third, on the electricity consumption side, replace the consumption of fossil energy and give priority to the use of electricity. For example, promote projects such as replacing coal with electricity and replacing gas with electricity. Traditional industrial boilers, coal kilns, and central heating mostly use coal-fired forms. By promoting large-scale heat pumps, electric boilers, electric heating and other equipment, the utilization rate of electricity in terminal energy is increased. Although the electricity generated by renewable energy is uncertain, these energy sources hardly produce greenhouse gas emissions during the power generation process. By replacing traditional energy with electricity, greenhouse gas emissions can be significantly reduced and the impact of climate change can be mitigated.
[0003] Therefore, introducing electric energy substitution technology into the power system is an effective way to achieve carbon emission reduction. By evaluating the relevant indicators of its implementation benefits, we can make better decisions from multiple aspects such as economy, environment and technology, so as to promote the sustainable development of my country's power system and further improve my country's energy efficiency.
[0004] However, the traditional electric energy substitution evaluation model proposed in the existing evaluation technology still has some defects. First, although the weight optimization in the traditional model attempts to recombine the main and second-class weights through an algorithm to consider the subjectivity of the evaluation subject and the objectivity of the data, this constant weight decision still has obvious limitations. It cannot cope with the impact of data anomalies or data changes during the substitution process on the evaluation results, so it is easy to lead to decision-making deviations in practical applications.
[0005] Secondly, electric energy replacement projects are often a long-term and phased process. However, traditional holistic evaluation models fail to effectively deal with this project characteristic. They can often only conduct a one-time overall evaluation of the entire project, and cannot timely monitor and evaluate the progress and equipment updates of different stages during the replacement process. This untimely evaluation may cause project managers to be unable to effectively adjust the project direction, ultimately affecting the progress and results of the project.
[0006] In addition, since the holistic evaluation needs to consider a large amount of data and variables, the data processing volume is large and the calculation complexity is high, which can easily lead to inaccurate and inefficient evaluation results. This is particularly serious because the evaluation results directly affect the decision-making and investment direction of the project.
[0007] Finally, traditional holistic assessments often oversimplify when considering economic and policy factors. They ignore the actual impact of economic and policy changes at different stages on power substitution projects. This simplification may lead to a disconnect between project decisions and the external environment, making it impossible for projects to effectively adapt to market changes and policy adjustments. Summary of the invention
[0008] In order to solve the deficiencies in the prior art, the present invention provides a method and system for dynamic evaluation of electric energy substitution implementation indicators based on variable weight optimization. The variable weight method is used to optimize the subjective and objective combined weights, so that the optimized combined weights can effectively reflect the impact of changes in indicator data; and, considering the degree of completion between the implementation of different substitution stages and the final goal of the project, correction parameters are introduced to feedback optimize the combined weights to obtain the final comprehensive weights. Finally, based on the comprehensive weights, taking into account the equipment update status and economic and policy factors at different substitution stages, a dynamic evaluation model for electric energy substitution is proposed to realize the evaluation of implementation indicators at each implementation stage of electric energy substitution projects.
[0009] The present invention adopts the following technical solution.
[0010] The present invention proposes a dynamic evaluation method for electric energy substitution implementation indicators based on variable weight optimization, comprising:
[0011] According to the characteristics of various types of electricity substitution projects, corresponding implementation indicators are constructed;
[0012] At the beginning of the implementation phase of the electric energy substitution project, the first and second weights of each implementation indicator are calculated respectively, and the first and second weights are dynamically modified by the variable weight method to obtain the first and second variable weights; the butterfly optimization algorithm is used to determine the combined variable weights by using the first and second variable weights; the target values of the implementation indicators are collected, and the weighted sum of the target values of the implementation indicators and the combined variable weights is used as a dynamic evaluation model; the superior and inferior solution distance method is used to dynamically evaluate the implementation indicators of the electric energy substitution project by using the dynamic evaluation model;
[0013] At the end of the implementation phase of the electric energy substitution project, the inverse of the ratio between the completion value of the implementation indicator and the target value during the implementation phase is used as the phase correction coefficient, and the combined variable weight is corrected using the phase correction coefficient to obtain the comprehensive weight; the completion value of the implementation indicator is collected, and the weighted sum of the completion value of the implementation indicator and the comprehensive weight is used as the comprehensive evaluation model; the superior and inferior solution distance method is used, and the comprehensive evaluation model is used to comprehensively evaluate the implementation indicators of the electric energy substitution project.
[0014] According to the characteristics of various types of electricity substitution projects, corresponding implementation indicators are constructed, including:
[0015] Distinguish the types of electricity replacement projects in different industries, including electricity-to-coal replacement projects and electricity-to-oil replacement projects;
[0016] Establish implementation indicators for electricity-to-coal replacement projects, including: initial investment and construction costs, operation and maintenance costs, unit energy supply benefits, carbon dioxide emission reductions, carbon utilization benefits, technology maturity, and government support;
[0017] Establish implementation indicators for projects that replace oil with electricity, including: average peak-to-valley difference, average load factor, charging equipment utilization rate, charging plan completion rate, service revenue, average queuing time, average charging time, unit charging time, and public recognition.
[0018] At the beginning of the implementation phase of the electric energy substitution project, the first and second weights of each implementation indicator are calculated respectively, and the first and second weights are dynamically modified by the variable weight method to obtain the first and second variable weights; the butterfly optimization algorithm is used to determine the combined variable weights by using the first and second variable weights, including:
[0019] Based on the analytic hierarchy process, the target layer, criterion layer and indicator layer are constructed according to the implementation stage of the electric energy substitution project;
[0020] The evaluation subject uses triangular fuzzy numbers to Implementation indicators For Implementation indicators The relative importance of is scored to construct a comprehensive fuzzy judgment matrix; among them, , is the number of indicators; the comprehensive fuzzy judgment matrix satisfies the following relationship:
[0021] ,
[0022] In the formula, is the comprehensive fuzzy judgment matrix, For the evaluation subject Implementation indicators For Implementation indicators The comprehensive fuzzy score given by the relative importance of OK The elements of the column, , is the number of indicators;
[0023] Based on the comprehensive fuzzy judgment matrix Implementation indicator data and Implementation indicators corresponding to Comprehensive fuzzy score , ,……, , using the first triangular fuzzy function to obtain the Implementation indicator data meets the target Importance , ,……, ; Use the Implementation indicator data meets the target The importance is calculated using the following relationship: The comprehensive importance of the implementation indicators:
[0024] ,
[0025] In the formula, For the The comprehensive importance of the implementation indicators, To find the sign of the tensor product;
[0026] According to the comprehensive importance of each implementation indicator, based on the second triangular fuzzy function, the The probability that the comprehensive importance of the implementation indicator of the first item is greater than or equal to the comprehensive importance of the implementation indicators of the other items; and The probability that the comprehensive importance of the implementation indicator is greater than or equal to the comprehensive importance of other implementation indicators is calculated using the following relationship: The relative importance of this implementation indicator compared to other implementation indicators:
[0027] ,
[0028] In the formula, For the Implementation indicators The relative importance of It is The overall importance of the implementation indicators Greater than or equal to The overall importance of the implementation indicators degree of possibility;
[0029] The relative importance of the implementation indicators constitutes a column vector , after normalizing the column vector, we get the first type of weight vector ,in, For the Implementation indicators The first type of weight satisfies the following relationship:
[0030] ,
[0031] In the formula, , They are column vectors The minimum and maximum values in ;
[0032] The entropy weight method is used to calculate the second type of weights.
[0033] Comprehensive fuzzy scoring Satisfies the following relationship:
[0034] ,
[0035] In the formula, It is Evaluation subject targets indicators right The fuzzy score given by the relative importance of , is the number of evaluation subjects.
[0036] And, fuzzy scoring and They satisfy the following relationships respectively:
[0037] , ,
[0038] In the formula, , and They are Evaluation subject targets indicators right The minimum, median, and maximum fuzzy scores given by their relative importance.
[0039] The first triangular fuzzy function satisfies the following relationship:
[0040] ,
[0041] In the formula, is the first triangular fuzzy function, indicating the implementation index data The importance of meeting the objectives; , , are the minimum, middle and maximum values of the fuzzy score respectively.
[0042] The second triangular fuzzy function satisfies the following relationship:
[0043] ,
[0044] In the formula, is the second triangular fuzzy function, indicating the comprehensive importance of the first implementation indicator Greater than or equal to the comprehensive importance of the implementation indicators of Article 2 degree of possibility; , , They are the minimum, middle and maximum values of the fuzzy score of the implementation indicator of Article 1; , , They are the minimum, middle and maximum values of the fuzzy score of the implementation indicator of Article 2 respectively.
[0045] The variable weight method is used to dynamically modify the first and second type of weights, including:
[0046] Establish separately The state vector corresponding to the first type of weight of the implementation indicator and the state vector corresponding to the second type of weight ,in, Respectively The implementation indicator state variables of the first type of weight, Implementation indicator state variables of the second type of weights;
[0047] Based on the variable weight penalty factor, the subjective state variable weight vector is established and objective state variable weight vector , where the first The element is related to the objective state variable weight vector The elements satisfy the following relationship:
[0048] ,
[0049] ,
[0050] In the formula, are the subjective state variable weight vectors and objective state variable weight vector The elements and elements; is the variable weight penalty factor; , Respectively The qualified limit of the implementation indicator state variable of the first type of weight, The qualified limit of the implementation indicator state variable of the second type of weight;
[0051] Using the subjective state variable weight vector and the objective state variable weight vector, the first type of weight and the second type of weight are respectively modified according to the following relationship:
[0052] ,
[0053] ,
[0054] In the formula, For the Implementation indicators The modified first-category weights, For the Implementation indicators The modified second category weights.
[0055] Using the first type of variable weights and the second type of variable weights, the butterfly optimization algorithm is used to determine the combined variable weights, including:
[0056] for Implementation indicators, the first type of variable weight set , the second type of variable weight set , the first type of variable weight set and the second type of variable weight set are combined according to the following relationship to obtain the combined variable weight set , , No. Combination variable weights Satisfies the following relationship:
[0057] ,
[0058] In the formula, and Respectively The first type of variable weights and the The combination coefficients corresponding to the second type of variable weights;
[0059] A combined variable weight optimization model is established, in which the objective function of the model satisfies the following relationship:
[0060] ,
[0061] In the formula, , They are and Difference, and The spectral norm of the difference; the constraints of the model satisfy the following relationship:
[0062] ,
[0063] Based on the combined variable weight optimization model, the butterfly optimization algorithm is used to optimize the combination coefficients.
[0064] The butterfly optimization algorithm based on chaotic mapping and Cauchy mutation is used to optimize the combination coefficients, including:
[0065] The chaotic sequence is generated by chaotic mapping, and the initial position sequence of the butterfly individuals in the butterfly optimization algorithm is determined by the following relationship:
[0066] ,
[0067] In the formula, , are the upper and lower limits of the initial position sequence respectively; Representative The sequence of initial positions of the butterflies; For the Iterated chaotic sequence;
[0068] Based on the adaptive weight coefficient, the global search and local mining positions in the butterfly optimization algorithm are updated according to the following relationship:
[0069] ,
[0070] In the formula, For the A butterfly in the The position vector in iterations; For the A butterfly in the The position vector in iterations; is the current global optimal solution; is a random number in [0,1]; For the A butterfly in the The position vector in iterations; For the A butterfly in the The position vector in iterations; For the The scent of a butterfly; represents the adaptive weight coefficient; is the current iteration number;
[0071] The Cauchy mutation operator is used to perform Cauchy mutation on the optimal solution in the current iteration, and the new optimal solution satisfies the following relationship:
[0072] ,
[0073] In the formula, is the new optimal solution obtained after Cauchy mutation; is the standard Cauchy distribution function.
[0074] At the end of the implementation phase of the electric energy substitution project, the reciprocal of the ratio between the completion value and the target value of the implementation indicator during the implementation phase is used as the phase correction coefficient. The combined variable weight is corrected using the phase correction coefficient to obtain the comprehensive weight, which satisfies the following relationship:
[0075] ,
[0076] In the formula, The first Combination variable weights The corresponding stage correction parameters, is the comprehensive weight set.
[0077] The present invention also proposes a dynamic evaluation system for electric energy substitution implementation indicators based on variable weight optimization, comprising: an indicator establishment module, a dynamic evaluation module and a comprehensive evaluation module;
[0078] The indicator establishment module is used to construct corresponding implementation indicators according to the characteristics of various types of electric energy substitution projects;
[0079] The dynamic evaluation module is used to calculate the first and second weights of each implementation indicator at the beginning of the implementation stage of the electric energy substitution project, and dynamically modify the first and second weights by using the variable weight method to obtain the first and second variable weights; using the first and second variable weights, the butterfly optimization algorithm is used to determine the combined variable weights; collecting the target values of the implementation indicators, and using the weighted sum of the target values of the implementation indicators and the combined variable weights as the dynamic evaluation model; using the superior and inferior solution distance method, and using the dynamic evaluation model to dynamically evaluate the implementation indicators of the electric energy substitution project;
[0080] The comprehensive evaluation module is used to use the inverse of the ratio between the completion value of the implementation indicator and the target value during the implementation phase as the phase correction coefficient at the end of the implementation phase of the electric energy substitution project, and use the phase correction coefficient to correct the combined variable weight to obtain the comprehensive weight; collect the completion value of the implementation indicator, and use the weighted sum of the completion value of the implementation indicator and the comprehensive weight as the comprehensive evaluation model; adopt the superior and inferior solution distance method, and use the comprehensive evaluation model to comprehensively evaluate the implementation indicators of the electric energy substitution project.
[0081] The dynamic evaluation module includes: the dynamic evaluation module includes: a first type weight calculation unit, a second type weight calculation unit, a variable weight correction unit and a combined variable weight unit;
[0082] The first type of weight calculation unit is used to construct the target layer, the criterion layer and the indicator layer based on the analytic hierarchy process according to the implementation stage of the electric energy substitution project;
[0083] The evaluation subject uses triangular fuzzy numbers to Implementation indicators For Implementation indicators The relative importance of is scored to construct a comprehensive fuzzy judgment matrix; among them, , is the number of indicators; the comprehensive fuzzy judgment matrix satisfies the following relationship:
[0084] ,
[0085] In the formula, is the comprehensive fuzzy judgment matrix, For the evaluation subject Implementation indicators For Implementation indicators The comprehensive fuzzy score given by the relative importance of OK The elements of the column, , is the number of indicators;
[0086] Based on the comprehensive fuzzy judgment matrix Implementation indicator data and Implementation indicators corresponding to Comprehensive fuzzy score , ,……, , using the first triangular fuzzy function to obtain the Implementation indicator data meets the target Importance , ,……, ; Use the Implementation indicator data meets the target The importance is calculated using the following relationship The comprehensive importance of the implementation indicators:
[0087] ,
[0088] In the formula, For the The comprehensive importance of the implementation indicators, To find the sign of the tensor product;
[0089] According to the comprehensive importance of each implementation indicator, based on the second triangular fuzzy function, the The probability that the comprehensive importance of the implementation indicator of the first item is greater than or equal to the comprehensive importance of the implementation indicators of the other items; and The probability that the comprehensive importance of the implementation indicator is greater than or equal to the comprehensive importance of other implementation indicators is calculated using the following relationship: The relative importance of this implementation indicator compared to other implementation indicators:
[0090] ,
[0091] In the formula, For the Implementation indicators The relative importance of It is The overall importance of the implementation indicators Greater than or equal to The overall importance of the implementation indicators degree of possibility;
[0092] The relative importance of the implementation indicators constitutes a column vector , after normalizing the column vector, we get the first type of weight vector ,in, For the Implementation indicators The first type of weight satisfies the following relationship:
[0093] ,
[0094] In the formula, , They are column vectors The minimum and maximum values in ;
[0095] A second type of weight calculation unit, used for calculating the second type of weight using an entropy weight method;
[0096] Variable weight correction unit, used to establish The state vector corresponding to the first type of weight of the implementation indicator and the state vector corresponding to the second type of weight ,in, Respectively The implementation indicator state variables of the first type of weight, Implementation indicator state variables of the second type of weights;
[0097] Based on the variable weight penalty factor, the subjective state variable weight vector is established and objective state variable weight vector , where the first The element is related to the objective state variable weight vector The elements satisfy the following relationship:
[0098] ,
[0099] ,
[0100] In the formula, are the subjective state variable weight vectors and objective state variable weight vector The elements and elements; is the variable weight penalty factor; , Respectively The qualified limit of the implementation indicator state variable of the first type of weight, The qualified limit of the implementation indicator state variable of the second type of weight;
[0101] Using the subjective state variable weight vector and the objective state variable weight vector, the first type of weight and the second type of weight are respectively modified according to the following relationship:
[0102] ,
[0103] ,
[0104] In the formula, For the Implementation indicators The modified first-category weights, For the Implementation indicators The modified second category weights;
[0105] Combined variable weight unit, used for Implementation indicators, the first type of variable weight set , the second type of variable weight set , the first type of variable weight set and the second type of variable weight set are combined according to the following relationship to obtain the combined variable weight set , , No. Combination variable weights Satisfies the following relationship:
[0106] ,
[0107] In the formula, and Respectively The first type of variable weights and the The combination coefficients corresponding to the second type of variable weights;
[0108] A combined variable weight optimization model is established, in which the objective function of the model satisfies the following relationship:
[0109] ,
[0110] In the formula, , They are and Difference, and The spectral norm of the difference; the constraints of the model satisfy the following relationship:
[0111] ,
[0112] Based on the combined variable weight optimization model, the butterfly optimization algorithm is used to optimize the combination coefficients.
[0113] Comprehensive assessment module, including: stage correction unit;
[0114] The stage correction unit is used to correct the combined variable weights at the end of the implementation stage of the electric energy substitution project, taking the inverse of the ratio between the completion value and the target value of the implementation indicator in the implementation stage as the stage correction coefficient, and using the stage correction coefficient to obtain the comprehensive weight, which satisfies the following relationship:
[0115] ,
[0116] In the formula, The first Combination variable weights The corresponding stage correction parameters, is the comprehensive weight set.
[0117] A terminal comprises a processor and a storage medium; the storage medium is used to store instructions; the processor is used to operate according to the instructions to execute the steps of the method.
[0118] A computer-readable storage medium stores a computer program, which implements the steps of the method when executed by a processor.
[0119] The beneficial effects of the present invention are that, compared with the prior art, at least the present invention proposes the use of a variable weight method to optimize the subjective and objective combined weights, and no longer uses the constant weight decision in the traditional indicator weight calculation, so as to timely reflect the impact of changes in indicator data; at the same time, by introducing correction parameters, the combined weights are again feedback optimized to reflect the degree of completion between the implementation of different replacement stages and the ultimate goal of the project, so that the final comprehensive weight presents a self-correcting improvement capability; and, taking into account the phased characteristics of factors such as the update of electric energy replacement equipment and economic policies, the electric energy replacement is divided into stages, and the electric energy replacement evaluation calculation of the new stage is carried out according to the update of the electric energy replacement equipment, so as to realize the dynamic evaluation of the entire replacement process. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0120] Figure 1 It is a flow chart of a method for dynamic evaluation of electric energy substitution implementation indicators based on variable weight optimization proposed by the present invention;
[0121] Figure 2 It is a structural block diagram of the benefit evaluation index system for implementing electric energy substitution in an embodiment of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0122] In order to make the purpose, technical scheme and advantages of the present invention clearer, the technical scheme of the present invention will be clearly and completely described below in conjunction with the drawings in the embodiments of the present invention. The embodiments described in this application are only embodiments of a part of the present invention, rather than all embodiments. Based on the spirit of the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without making creative work belong to the protection scope of the present invention.
[0123] The present invention proposes a dynamic evaluation method for electric energy substitution implementation indicators based on variable weight optimization, comprising:
[0124] At the beginning of the implementation phase of the electric energy substitution project, the first and second weights of each implementation indicator are calculated respectively, and the first and second weights are dynamically modified by the variable weight method to obtain the first and second variable weights; the butterfly optimization algorithm is used to determine the combined variable weights by using the first and second variable weights; the target values of the implementation indicators are collected, and the weighted sum of the target values of the implementation indicators and the combined variable weights is used as a dynamic evaluation model; the superior and inferior solution distance method is used to dynamically evaluate the implementation indicators of the electric energy substitution project by using the dynamic evaluation model;
[0125] Among them, at the starting point of the implementation phase of the electric energy substitution project, the first type of weight and the second type of weight of each implementation indicator are calculated respectively. In a preferred but non-restrictive embodiment, the first type of weight can be the first type of weight, and the second type of weight can be the second type of weight.
[0126] At the end of the implementation phase of the electric energy substitution project, the inverse of the ratio between the completion value of the implementation indicator and the target value during the implementation phase is used as the phase correction coefficient, and the combined variable weight is corrected using the phase correction coefficient to obtain the comprehensive weight; the completion value of the implementation indicator is collected, and the weighted sum of the completion value of the implementation indicator and the comprehensive weight is used as the comprehensive evaluation model; the superior and inferior solution distance method is used, and the comprehensive evaluation model is used to comprehensively evaluate the implementation indicators of the electric energy substitution project.
[0127] like Figure 1 As shown, the method includes:
[0128] Step 1: Construct corresponding implementation indicators according to the characteristics of various types of electricity substitution projects.
[0129] Specifically, according to the electricity substitution method, the types of electricity substitution projects in different industries are distinguished, and an evaluation index system corresponding to the implementation process of various types of electricity substitution projects is established. In the embodiment, the established electricity substitution implementation benefit evaluation index system is as follows: Figure 2 shown.
[0130] Specifically, step 1 includes:
[0131] Step 1.1, distinguish the types of electricity substitution projects in different industries according to the electricity substitution method, including but not limited to: "electricity replacing coal" type electricity substitution projects and "electricity replacing oil" type electricity substitution projects.
[0132] The present invention first divides the electric energy substitution projects in different industries into "electricity replacing coal" type electric energy substitution projects and "electricity replacing oil" type electric energy substitution projects according to the different electric energy substitution methods, and constructs a corresponding implementation indicator system based on the purpose principle, relevance principle, standardization principle, comprehensive principle and simplicity principle of the indicator system, combined with the typical characteristics of the two types of electric energy substitution projects in actual operation.
[0133] Step 1.2, establish implementation indicators for "electricity replacing coal" type electricity substitution projects, including but not limited to: initial investment and construction costs, operation and maintenance costs, unit energy supply income, carbon dioxide emission reduction, carbon utilization benefits, technology maturity and government support.
[0134] In the embodiment, the "electricity replacing coal" type of power substitution project mainly considers the benefits of power substitution from three aspects: economic characteristics, environmental characteristics and social development characteristics, and selects the initial investment and construction cost, operation and maintenance cost, unit energy supply income, carbon dioxide emission reduction, carbon utilization benefit, technology maturity and government support as the evaluation indicators of this type of project, realizing a comprehensive evaluation of the implementation benefits of the "electricity replacing coal" type of power substitution project. The implementation benefit evaluation indicators of the "electricity replacing coal" type of power substitution project include:
[0135] 1) Economic characteristics
[0136] Economic cost assessment is an important part of the evaluation of "electricity replacing coal" type power substitution projects because it helps to evaluate the financial feasibility of project implementation. Economic cost assessment can provide an in-depth understanding of the costs and benefits associated with the project and help identify potential financial risks or challenges that may arise during implementation. In the embodiment, indicators for evaluating the economic benefits of the integrated energy system include but are not limited to: initial construction cost, operation and maintenance cost, and unit energy supply income.
[0137] 1.1) Initial investment and construction cost
[0138] The initial investment and construction cost refers to the one-time equipment construction investment required for the construction of an "electricity-replacing-coal" type of power replacement project, including the investment in power conversion equipment and energy storage equipment. The present invention defines the initial investment and construction cost as follows:
[0139] (1)
[0140] In the formula, The initial investment and construction cost; The number of energy conversion devices; For energy conversion equipment Unit capacity investment cost; is the number of energy storage devices; For energy storage devices Unit capacity investment cost; For energy conversion equipment Configuration capacity; For energy storage devices Configuration capacity.
[0141] 1.2) Operation and maintenance costs
[0142] Operation and maintenance costs refer to the costs incurred during the operation of "electricity replacing coal" type power replacement projects, including the fuel cost of equipment and the cost of inspection and maintenance. Evaluating the operation and maintenance costs of a project helps determine the long-term economic feasibility of the project and identify potential areas for cost savings or efficiency improvements. The system operation and maintenance costs are defined as follows:
[0143] (2)
[0144] (3)
[0145] In the formula, The operating costs of electricity replacement projects such as "electricity replacing coal"; Maintenance costs for electricity replacement projects such as "electricity replacing coal"; For the The number of days per year with typical-like days; , They are The unit price of electricity and gas at the time; , , are the unit maintenance costs of electrical, thermal and cold energy storage equipment respectively; , They are the power purchased for electricity and the power purchased for gas; , , It is the operating power of the electrical, thermal and cold energy storage equipment; , Energy conversion device Unit maintenance cost and operating power; For the Parks, is the total number of parks included in the electric energy replacement project, For the Typical day, is the total number of typical day types, For the evaluation cycle; is the number of energy conversion devices.
[0146] 1.3) Unit energy supply income
[0147] Unit energy supply revenue refers to the revenue generated by each unit of energy supplied by the "electricity replacing coal" type of electric energy replacement project. It is an important indicator for economic cost assessment because it helps to determine the profitability of this type. The present invention defines unit energy supply revenue as the ratio of the system's electricity, heat, and cooling sales revenue to the system's electric, heat, and cooling energy supplied to users, satisfying the following relationship:
[0148] (4)
[0149] In the formula, The unit energy supply income; For the revenue from electricity sales; For sales revenue; For the proceeds of cold sales; Supplying electricity to users for the system; Supplying thermal energy to the system for users; Supply the system with cold energy for users.
[0150] 2) Environmental characteristics
[0151] Since the efficiency of electric energy is significantly higher than other forms of traditional energy such as gas and fossil energy, the application of electric energy substitution technology in the "electricity replacing coal" type of electric energy substitution projects can significantly reduce the carbon dioxide emissions of the system. Therefore, the invention uses indicators such as carbon dioxide emission reduction and carbon utilization efficiency to evaluate the carbon emission improvement of "electricity replacing coal" type of electric energy substitution projects.
[0152] 2.1) Carbon dioxide emission reduction
[0153] Carbon dioxide emission reduction mainly refers to the carbon emissions reduced by improving energy efficiency through electric energy substitution technology, which satisfies the following relationship:
[0154] (5)
[0155] In the formula, To reduce carbon dioxide emissions; For equipment The carbon emission coefficient generated by producing a unit of energy before electricity substitution; is the carbon emission coefficient generated by producing unit electricity; For equipment The amount of electricity replaced; is the total number of electric energy replacement devices.
[0156] 2.2) Carbon utilization benefits
[0157] For "electricity replacing coal" type power replacement projects that contain carbon capture and utilization equipment, the captured CO2 can be converted into useful products or fuels through the carbon utilization link, thereby reducing emissions and creating economic opportunities. Carbon dioxide can be used as a raw material for the production of chemicals such as methanol and ethanol, the production of building materials and fertilizers for plants. These are all occasions for carbon utilization, which can not only save the cost of carbon dioxide treatment, but also create value from the captured carbon while reducing the demand for fossil fuel raw materials. The definition of carbon utilization benefits is as follows:
[0158] (6)
[0159] In the formula, For carbon utilization benefits; , Use the The economic benefits and costs of each carbon utilization method for a unit amount of carbon; The cost of dealing with carbon emissions in traditional ways; To use The proportion of captured carbon used by various carbon utilization methods; is the number of ways to use carbon; The amount of carbon captured by the carbon capture device.
[0160] 3) Characteristics of social development
[0161] In addition to the quantitative indicators mentioned above, qualitative indicators are equally important in the evaluation process of "electricity replacing coal" type power substitution projects, because qualitative indicators are a supplement to quantitative indicators and provide a more complete picture of system performance. In addition, the use of qualitative indicators for evaluation can also incorporate the influence of government policies and public opinion. The policies formulated by the government or the public opinion may have different values and priorities from the optimal technical solution, which may not be reflected by quantitative indicators. The present invention uses social development indicators composed of technology maturity and government support to evaluate the integrated energy system.
[0162] 3.1) Technology maturity
[0163] In the power system, electric energy substitution technology is still an emerging technology. Its technical maturity determines whether the project can be successfully implemented and put into use. Adding this indicator to the evaluation system can accelerate the breakthrough of emerging technologies in technical bottlenecks to improve system efficiency.
[0164] Technology maturity can be assessed based on several factors: 1) Research and development: the level of investment in research and development of these technologies, and the rate of new advances and improvements. 2) Manufacturing and deployment: the availability of reliable and cost-effective equipment, and the rate of adoption of these technologies in the market. 3) Performance and efficiency: the performance and efficiency of the technology for electric energy substitution and carbon capture, utilization and storage. 4) Maintenance and durability: the lifespan and durability of the equipment used in these technologies, and the ease and cost of maintenance and repair. In this invention, technology maturity is defined as the technology maturity score for electric energy substitution, which satisfies the following relationship:
[0165] (7)
[0166] In the formula, is the technology maturity indicator, and its value is [0,1].
[0167] 3.2) Government support
[0168] Government policies and regulations can have a significant impact on the deployment of technologies for "electricity replacing coal" type power replacement projects. Governments can provide various types of support to promote the development and deployment of such projects. Government support may include fiscal incentives, tax breaks, research funding and regulatory frameworks. In addition, governments can also set standards for the performance of integrated energy systems, which can help promote the development and advancement of these technologies. The intensity of government support is defined as follows:
[0169] (8)
[0170] In the formula, It is the government support strength indicator, and its value is [0,1].
[0171] Step 1.3, establish implementation indicators for "electricity replacing oil" type electricity substitution projects, including but not limited to: average peak-to-valley difference, average load rate, charging equipment utilization rate, charging plan completion rate, service revenue, average waiting time, average charging time, unit charging time and public recognition.
[0172] In the embodiment, in actual electric energy replacement projects in the transportation industry, electric vehicles are often used to replace traditional fuel vehicles. The present invention, based on the principles of building an evaluation index system, considers factors such as the actual conditions of project implementation and data availability, and constructs an evaluation index system for the implementation benefits of "electricity replacing oil" type electric energy replacement projects. The evaluation index system is constructed from three aspects: grid load characteristics, operational capacity characteristics, and user experience characteristics, and includes a total of 9 evaluation indicators. The specific indicator descriptions are as follows:
[0173] 1) Grid load characteristics
[0174] The grid load characteristics mainly examine the impact of the operation of electric vehicle charging stations on the grid, specifically including two evaluation indicators: average peak-to-valley difference and average load rate.
[0175] 1.1) Average peak-to-valley difference
[0176] The average peak-to-valley difference represents the average value of the difference between the peak load and the valley load of the power grid throughout the day after the electric vehicle charging station is connected to the power grid. The smaller the average peak-to-valley difference, the greater the contribution to the evaluation of the operating efficiency of the charging station; it satisfies the following relationship:
[0177] (9)
[0178] In the formula, is the average peak-to-valley difference; It is the peak load of the power grid throughout the day; It is the peak value of the power grid load throughout the day.
[0179] 1.2) Average load rate
[0180] The average load rate represents the ratio of the average load of the power grid to the peak load after the electric vehicle charging station is connected to the power grid. The greater the average load rate, the greater the contribution to the evaluation of the operating efficiency of the charging station; it satisfies the following relationship:
[0181] (10)
[0182] In the formula, represents the average compliance rate; is the average load of the power grid throughout the day; It is the peak load of the power grid throughout the day.
[0183] 2) Operational capability characteristics
[0184] The operational capability characteristics mainly examine the daily operation of electric vehicle charging stations, and specifically include three indicators: charging equipment utilization rate, charging plan completion rate and service revenue.
[0185] 2.1) Utilization rate of charging equipment
[0186] The charging equipment utilization rate represents the ratio of the actual operating hours of the charging equipment to the full-load operating hours of the charging equipment. The higher the charging equipment utilization rate, the greater its contribution to the evaluation of the operating efficiency of the charging station; it satisfies the following relationship:
[0187] (11)
[0188] In the formula, The utilization rate of charging equipment; The actual operating hours of the charging equipment; The number of hours the charging equipment runs at full capacity.
[0189] 2.2) Charging plan completion rate
[0190] The charging plan completion rate represents the ratio of actual output power to possible output power. The higher the charging plan completion rate, the greater the contribution to the evaluation of charging station operation efficiency; it satisfies the following relationship:
[0191] (12)
[0192] In the formula, The completion rate of the charging plan; is the actual output power; For the possible output power.
[0193] 2.3) Service income
[0194] Service income refers to the income from three channels: facility usage fees, charging electricity fees, and government subsidies. The higher the service income, the greater the contribution to the evaluation of charging station operation efficiency; the following relationship is satisfied:
[0195] (13)
[0196] In the formula, For service income; Fees for use of facilities; Electricity fee for charging; The government subsidizes the cost.
[0197] 3) User experience characteristics
[0198] The user experience characteristics mainly examine the user experience when charging electric vehicles at charging stations. Specifically, they include four indicators: average waiting time, average charging time, unit charging cost, and public recognition.
[0199] 3.1) Average waiting time
[0200] The average queuing time represents the average time it takes for electric vehicles to charge from the time they arrive at the charging location. The shorter the average queuing time, the greater the contribution to the evaluation of the operating efficiency of the charging station; it satisfies the following relationship:
[0201] (14)
[0202] In the formula, represents the average queue time; is the total number of electric vehicles that need to be charged; For the The time it takes for an electric vehicle to be charged from the time it arrives at the charging station to the time it is charged.
[0203] 3.2) Average charging time
[0204] The average charging time represents the average time spent by electric vehicles from the beginning to the end of charging. The shorter the average charging time, the greater the contribution to the evaluation of the operating efficiency of the charging station; it satisfies the following relationship:
[0205] (15)
[0206] In the formula, represents the average queue time; is the total number of electric vehicles that need to be charged; For the The time it takes for an electric vehicle to charge from the beginning to the end.
[0207] 3.3) Unit charging cost
[0208] The unit charging cost refers to the fee that users need to pay when charging an electric vehicle for one unit of electricity at a charging station. The lower the unit charging cost, the greater the contribution to the evaluation of the operating efficiency of the charging station; it satisfies the following relationship:
[0209] (16)
[0210] In the formula, Represents the unit charging cost of electric vehicles; the cost of charging electric vehicles; Charge the car with electricity.
[0211] 3.4) Public recognition
[0212] Public opinion reflects the public's overall attitude towards "electricity instead of oil" type power replacement projects, which can provide insights into the effectiveness of project implementation and public acceptance. Public acceptance is defined as follows:
[0213] (17)
[0214] In the formula, It is an index of public recognition, and its value is [0,1].
[0215] Step 2, at the starting point of the implementation phase of the electric energy substitution project, calculate the first and second weights of each implementation indicator respectively, and use the variable weight method to dynamically modify the first and second weights to obtain the first and second variable weights; using the first and second variable weights, use the butterfly optimization algorithm to determine the combined variable weights.
[0216] When optimizing weights, the main and second-category weights are recombined through an algorithm, which only solves the combination of the subjectivity of the evaluation subject and the objectivity of the data. It cannot reflect the impact of changes in implementation indicators caused by data anomalies or data changes during the substitution process on the evaluation results.
[0217] Compared with the existing technology, the method at least includes adding variable weight theory to the triangular fuzzy hierarchical analysis method to calculate the first type of weights and the entropy weight method to calculate the second type of weights, and combining the correction parameters with the combined weight calculation to obtain the comprehensive weights, thereby realizing the optimization of weights in the dynamic evaluation model of implementation indicators of electric energy substitution projects.
[0218] Based on the above problems, the present invention aims to optimize and adjust the weights by introducing variable weight theory and correction parameters, highlighting that the main and second-category weights in each stage change adaptively as the values of various evaluation indicators change, and realize the improved self-correction capability of the proposed evaluation model, filling the gap in the prior art in the field of electric energy substitution evaluation, and providing a more comprehensive, flexible and accurate dynamic evaluation method, thereby providing strong support for the smooth implementation and management of electric energy substitution projects.
[0219] Specifically, step 2 includes:
[0220] Step 2.1, at the beginning of the implementation phase of the electric energy substitution project, based on the analytic hierarchy process, combined with the evaluation subject scoring method and the triangular fuzzy method, the first-category weight of each implementation indicator is calculated.
[0221] In the calculation of the first type of weight, the Delphi method and the analytic hierarchy process are widely used, but the above methods have certain problems in calculating the weights of evaluation indicators, such as the cumbersome process of determining the weights of evaluation indicators, the unreasonable values of evaluation indicator weights, etc. In order to avoid these problems leading to large deviations in the evaluation results, the present invention adopts a new evaluation method combining triangular fuzzy number geometric features and analytic hierarchy process, and introduces fuzzy mathematics theory to take into account uncertainty factors, making the decision process more objective and scientific, and improving the reliability and robustness of the decision results.
[0222] The Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) is a decision-making method that combines quantitative analysis with qualitative analysis. The relative importance of each evaluation target and the reasonable allocation of weights for each target are mainly determined by the decision maker's experience. The weights are used to determine the scores of each decision plan on each target, and the plans are ranked accordingly. Based on the analytic hierarchy process, the first type of weights obtained by using the evaluation subject's scoring will produce different results due to the replacement of the evaluation subject. However, in fact, there is a trend of consistency in the evaluation subject's scoring, that is, the scores are given within a certain score range. Therefore, if the advantages of the evaluation subject's scoring are fully utilized to avoid the impact of the differences between each score, it will become the goal of optimizing the first type of weights. The present invention proposes to combine the evaluation subject scoring method with the triangular fuzzy method based on the analytic hierarchy process to calculate the first type of weights of each implementation indicator, as follows:
[0223] Step 2.1.1, based on the analytic hierarchy process, construct the target layer, criterion layer and indicator layer according to the implementation stage of the electric energy substitution project;
[0224] Specifically, the electric energy substitution project is implemented in stages and therefore includes multiple implementation stages. In each implementation stage, not only are there differences in the benefit goals and construction scale of the electric energy substitution project, but also in factors such as electrical equipment renewal, economy, and politics. Therefore, when constructing the target layer, criterion layer, and indicator layer based on the hierarchical analysis method, it is necessary to consider the different implementation stages of the electric energy substitution project. This method of constructing weights in stages can not only ensure that the obtained weights reflect the characteristics of the implementation stage of the electric energy substitution project, but also ensure that the phased implementation is consistent with the overall goal of the electric energy substitution project through the construction and optimization of weights in each stage.
[0225] Step 2.1.2: The evaluation subject uses triangular fuzzy numbers to Implementation indicators For Implementation indicators The relative importance of is scored to construct a comprehensive fuzzy judgment matrix that satisfies the following relationship:
[0226] ,
[0227] In the formula, is the comprehensive fuzzy judgment matrix, For the evaluation subject Implementation indicators For Implementation indicators The comprehensive fuzzy score given by the relative importance of OK The elements of the column, , is the number of indicators;
[0228] Among them, comprehensive fuzzy scoring Satisfies the following relationship:
[0229] ,
[0230] In the formula, It is Evaluation subject targets indicators right The fuzzy score given by the relative importance of , is the number of evaluation subjects.
[0231] Among them, fuzzy scoring and They satisfy the following relationships respectively:
[0232] , ,
[0233] In the formula, , and They are Evaluation subject targets indicators right The minimum, median, and maximum fuzzy scores given by their relative importance.
[0234] Step 2.1.3, based on the comprehensive fuzzy judgment matrix Implementation indicator data and Implementation indicators corresponding to Comprehensive fuzzy score , ,……, , using the first triangular fuzzy function to obtain the Implementation indicator data meets the target Importance , ,……, ; Among them, the first triangular fuzzy function satisfies the following relationship:
[0235] ,
[0236] In the formula, is the first triangular fuzzy function, indicating the implementation index data The importance of meeting the objectives; , , are the minimum, middle and maximum values of the fuzzy score respectively.
[0237] Use the Implementation indicator data meets the target The importance is calculated using the following relationship The comprehensive importance of the implementation indicators:
[0238] ,
[0239] In the formula, For the The comprehensive importance of the implementation indicators, is the sign for the tensor product.
[0240] Step 2.1.4, according to the comprehensive importance of each implementation indicator, based on the second triangular fuzzy function, obtain the The possibility that the comprehensive importance of the implementation indicator is greater than or equal to the comprehensive importance of other implementation indicators; among which, the second triangular fuzzy function satisfies the following relationship:
[0241] ,
[0242] In the formula, is the second triangular fuzzy function, indicating the comprehensive importance of the first implementation indicator Greater than or equal to the comprehensive importance of the implementation indicators of Article 2 degree of possibility; , , They are the minimum, middle and maximum values of the fuzzy score of the implementation indicator of Article 1; , , They are the minimum, middle and maximum values of the fuzzy score of the implementation indicator of Article 2 respectively.
[0243] Use the The probability that the comprehensive importance of the implementation indicator is greater than or equal to the comprehensive importance of other implementation indicators is calculated using the following relationship: The relative importance of this implementation indicator compared to other implementation indicators:
[0244] ,
[0245] In the formula, For the Implementation indicators The relative importance of It is The overall importance of the implementation indicators Greater than or equal to The overall importance of the implementation indicators degree of possibility.
[0246] Step 2.1.5, The relative importance of the implementation indicators constitutes a column vector , after normalizing the column vector, we get the first type of weight vector ,in, For the Implementation indicators The first type of weight satisfies the following relationship:
[0247] ,
[0248] In the formula, , They are column vectors The minimum and maximum values in .
[0249] Step 2.2, use the entropy weight method to calculate the second type of weight.
[0250] The weight calculation process of the objective weighting method is not affected by human subjective judgment, but is calculated based on the relationship between the original data and mathematical methods. Therefore, the objective weighting method has a solid mathematical theoretical foundation and can produce relatively reliable and fair weight results. In practical applications, the objective weighting method is widely used for comprehensive evaluation and decision analysis.
[0251] The entropy weight method is a weight determination method based on information entropy. It gives the degree of influence of each indicator on the overall energy system according to the relative degree of change between the indicators, thereby calculating the weight of each indicator, and the weight of the indicator with a large degree of change is also large. Because the present invention mainly conducts dynamic evaluation on different stages of electric energy substitution, the calculation characteristics of the entropy weight method can better reflect the changes in the weight of indicators at each stage. Compared with other methods, the entropy weight method is more suitable for subsequent variable weight calculations, so the present invention uses the entropy weight method to calculate the second type of weights to improve the scientificity and rationality of decision-making.
[0252] Specifically, step 2.2 includes:
[0253] 1) Assume a total Evaluation objects, Evaluation indicators, establish the initial evaluation matrix :
[0254] ,
[0255] In the formula, Indicates The first evaluation object evaluation indicators, is the number of evaluation objects, is the number of evaluation indicators.
[0256] 2) Normalize the initial evaluation matrix so that each element has a value between 0 and 1. The larger the value, the better. It is processed according to the positive indicator. Otherwise, it is processed according to the negative indicator, as shown in the following formula:
[0257] ,
[0258] In the formula, After standardization, The first evaluation object evaluation indicators; , The maximum and minimum values of all evaluation indicators of all evaluation objects are taken respectively.
[0259] Use positive and negative indicators to construct a standard evaluation matrix .
[0260] 3) Calculate the Under the evaluation index The proportion of evaluation objects in this indicator :
[0261] ,
[0262] 4) Calculate the Information entropy of evaluation index :
[0263] ,
[0264] 5) Calculate the The information utility of an evaluation index :
[0265] ,
[0266] 6) Calculate the second type of weight vector using the following relationship:
[0267] , ,
[0268] In the formula, For the Implementation indicators The second type of weights.
[0269] Step 2.3, use the variable weight method to dynamically modify the first type of weights and the second type of weights to obtain the first type of variable weights and the second type of variable weights.
[0270] Although the calculation method of the first and second weights proposed in the present invention takes into account the subjectivity of the evaluation subject and the objectivity of the data, it is still a constant decision and cannot reflect the impact of changes in decision indicator data on the evaluation results. In addition, in the actual evaluation of electric energy substitution, if a certain indicator data seriously exceeds the standard, even if other indicator data are qualified, it will lead to the situation that the electric energy substitution of the entire system is unqualified, that is, the electric energy substitution evaluation has an obvious "short board effect". In order to ensure that the final weight can effectively avoid the short board effect, it is necessary to give a greater weight to unqualified indicators. The present invention uses a variable weight method to dynamically adjust the first and second weights, so that the optimized weights can effectively reflect the impact of indicator changes. The specific calculation process is as follows:
[0271] Step 2.3.1, respectively establish The state vector corresponding to the first type of weight of the implementation indicator and the state vector corresponding to the second type of weight ,in, Respectively The implementation indicator state variables of the first type of weight, The implementation indicator state variables of the second type of weights.
[0272] Step 2.3.2: Based on the variable weight penalty factor, establish the subjective state variable weight vector and objective state variable weight vector , where the first The element is related to the objective state variable weight vector The elements satisfy the following relationship:
[0273] ,
[0274] ,
[0275] In the formula,
[0276] are the subjective state variable weight vectors and objective state variable weight vector The elements and elements;
[0277] is a variable weight penalty factor, and in the embodiment, the value is 0.1;
[0278] , Respectively The qualified limit of the implementation indicator state variable of the first type of weight, The qualified limit of the implementation indicator state variable of the second type of weight.
[0279] Step 2.3.3, using the subjective state variable weight vector and the objective state variable weight vector, respectively modify the first type of weight and the second type of weight according to the following relationship:
[0280] ,
[0281] ,
[0282] In the formula, For the Implementation indicators The modified first-category weights, For the Implementation indicators The modified second category weights.
[0283] By performing variable weight optimization on the first and second weights, it is shown that the main and second weights in each stage change adaptively with the changes in the values of various evaluation indicators, thereby achieving adaptive adjustment of the weights in each stage.
[0284] Step 2.4, using the first type of variable weights and the second type of variable weights, the butterfly optimization algorithm is used to determine the combined variable weights.
[0285] The first type of weight reflects the evaluation subject's opinion, and the second type of weight reflects the impact of the actual value of the indicator on the weight. If only one of them is considered during power quality assessment, a reasonable and effective assessment cannot be achieved. Before actual assessment, the two need to be combined to ensure that the weight can comprehensively reflect the impact of the main and second type of weights. To this end, the present invention introduces the idea of game theory and combines the main and second type of weights after weighting based on the butterfly optimization algorithm.
[0286] for Implementation indicators, the first type of variable weight set , the second type of variable weight set , the first type of variable weight set and the second type of variable weight set are combined according to the following relationship to obtain the combined variable weight set , , No. The combined variable weights satisfy the following relationship:
[0287] ,
[0288] In the formula, and Respectively The first type of variable weights and the The combination coefficient corresponding to the second type variable weight.
[0289] As long as the combination coefficient is determined and , the combination of the main and second type variable weights can be realized through the above formula. At the same time, in order to ensure that the combined variable weights can achieve the NASH equilibrium between the two, a combined variable weight optimization model is established, in which the objective function of the model satisfies the following relationship:
[0290] ,
[0291] In the formula, , They are and Difference, and The spectral norm of the difference; the constraints of the model satisfy the following relationship:
[0292] ,
[0293] Based on the combined variable weight optimization model, the butterfly optimization algorithm is used to optimize the combination coefficients, and the distribution ratio of the main and second type variable weights in the combined variable weights is optimized.
[0294] The combined variable weight optimization model is a nonlinear optimization problem. Commonly used solution methods include least square method, Newton method, butterfly optimization algorithm, etc., but when the dimension of the problem is too large, the above methods have the problem of complex calculation and easy to fall into the local optimal solution. Compared with the above algorithm, the butterfly optimization algorithm has strong global search ability, strong adaptability, and is suitable for parallel processing, which can avoid local optimal solutions, thereby making the evaluation result more accurate. Therefore, the present invention adopts a butterfly optimization algorithm based on chaotic mapping and Cauchy variation to solve the combined weight optimization model.
[0295] The butterfly optimization algorithm is a new global optimization algorithm proposed by scholars based on the foraging and courtship behaviors of butterflies. It is divided into two stages: global search and local mining. In the global search stage, whenever a butterfly senses the scent of the optimal butterfly in the search space, it will move towards the optimal butterfly; when the butterfly cannot sense any butterfly, it will wander around irregularly, which is the local mining stage. The mathematical formula for the scent generated by butterflies in the butterfly optimization algorithm is:
[0296] ,
[0297] In the formula, is the intensity of aroma perception; is the butterfly sensory factor, which is generally taken as 0.01; is the stimulus intensity; is a power index based on the mode, and its value range is generally [0,1].
[0298] In order to avoid the model solution falling into the local optimal value, the present invention adopts the butterfly optimization algorithm based on chaotic mapping and Cauchy mutation to solve the optimization model. The details are as follows:
[0299] First, the chaotic sequence is generated by using Tent chaotic mapping, and the population is initialized so that the population can be more evenly distributed in the solution space in the early stage, so as to better search for the optimal value. The process is as follows:
[0300] ,
[0301] In the formula, For the Iterated chaotic sequence; For the Iterated chaotic sequence; is the population number; is the current iteration number; for Based on the chaotic sequence generated above, the initial position sequence of the butterfly individuals in the butterfly optimization algorithm is as follows:
[0302] ,
[0303] In the formula, , are the upper and lower limits of the initial position sequence respectively; Representative The sequence of initial positions of the butterflies.
[0304] Secondly, in the social search and local mining stages of the butterfly optimization algorithm, an adaptive weight coefficient is introduced to update the search formula. This coefficient can change with the number of iterations. At the same time, the position information of the three individuals is used to control the movement direction and distance of the current butterfly individual, thereby improving the algorithm's optimization accuracy. The expression of the adaptive weight coefficient is as follows:
[0305] ,
[0306] In the formula, represents the adaptive weight coefficient; is the current iteration number; is the maximum number of iterations. Based on the adaptive weight coefficient, the improved global search and local mining position update formula is:
[0307] ,
[0308] In the formula, For the A butterfly in the The position vector in iterations; For the A butterfly in the The position vector in iterations; is the current global optimal solution; is a random number in [0,1]; For the A butterfly in the The position vector in iterations; For the A butterfly in the The position vector in iterations; For the The scent of a butterfly.
[0309] Finally, the Cauchy mutation operator is used to perform Cauchy mutation on the optimal solution in the current iteration, which can not only improve the diversity of the population, but also make the population more widely distributed in the search space, thereby achieving the goal of escaping the local optimal value. The improvements are as follows:
[0310] ,
[0311] In the formula, is the new optimal solution obtained after Cauchy mutation; is the standard Cauchy distribution function.
[0312] Compared with traditional optimization algorithms, the butterfly optimization algorithm has stronger global search capabilities and can avoid the model solution falling into the local optimal solution. In the evaluation of electric energy substitution, the use of the butterfly optimization algorithm can make the optimization results of the combined weights more accurate and improve the accuracy of the final evaluation results.
[0313] Step 2.5, at the end of the implementation phase of the electric energy substitution project, the inverse of the ratio between the completion value and the target value of the implementation indicator during the implementation phase is used as the phase correction coefficient, and the combined variable weight is corrected using the phase correction coefficient to obtain the comprehensive weight.
[0314] Since the second type of weights are obtained based on the analytic hierarchy process, the target layer, criterion layer and indicator layer are all constructed according to the various implementation stages of the electric energy substitution project. The weights constructed in each stage should also avoid the "short board effect" caused by the low completion of some indicators. Therefore, it is proposed to use the inverse of the ratio between the completion value and the target value of the implementation indicator in the implementation stage as the stage correction coefficient, and use the stage correction coefficient to correct the combined variable weights to obtain the comprehensive weights. Not only can it ensure that the obtained weights reflect the characteristics of the implementation stage of the electric energy substitution project, but also through the construction and optimization of the weights in each stage, it can ensure that the staged implementation is consistent with the overall goal of the electric energy substitution project.
[0315] Since the ratio between the completion value and the target value of the implementation indicator during the implementation phase can only be obtained after the current implementation phase is completed, compared with the main second-type weight variable processing, which is a forward optimization performed before the implementation phase begins, the stage correction realizes a feedback optimization at the end of the implementation phase. When the comprehensive weights obtained by optimization are used to evaluate the stages, the evaluation results of the stages can better reflect the actual situation of project implementation. Using the comprehensive weights obtained by optimization as the initial weights for the next implementation phase is more guiding for the project and can make the evaluation results more in line with the project planning goals.
[0316] Specifically, the comprehensive weight set Satisfies the following relationship:
[0317] ,
[0318] In the formula, The first The stage correction parameter corresponding to the combined variable weight.
[0319] Step 3: At the beginning of the implementation phase of the electric energy substitution project, the target value of the implementation indicator is collected, and the weighted sum of the target value of the implementation indicator and the combined variable weight is used as the dynamic evaluation model; the superior and inferior solution distance method is used to dynamically evaluate the implementation indicators of the electric energy substitution project using the dynamic evaluation model;
[0320] At the end of the implementation phase of the electric energy substitution project, the completion value of the implementation indicator is collected, and the weighted sum of the completion value of the implementation indicator and the comprehensive weight is used as the comprehensive evaluation model; the superior and inferior solution distance method is adopted, and the comprehensive evaluation model is used to comprehensively evaluate the implementation indicators of the electric energy substitution project.
[0321] Traditional evaluation methods do not consider the correlation between indicators and there is a problem that the indicators are equidistant from the positive and negative ideal solutions. In order to overcome the above defects, the present invention introduces the grey correlation theory into the calculation process of the superior and inferior solution distance method (TOPSIS), and considers the distance and correlation between each indicator and the optimal and the worst solution sequence, and constructs a new fit calculation formula.
[0322] Specifically, step 3 includes:
[0323] Step 3.1, collect the implementation indicator data during the implementation phase, and use the weighted sum of the implementation indicator data and the comprehensive weight as the comprehensive evaluation model;
[0324] Specifically, an initial evaluation matrix is established based on the implementation indicator data. ,in, is the number of objects to be evaluated, is the number of implementation indicators. Multiplying with the initial evaluation matrix to obtain the weighted evaluation matrix satisfies the following relationship:
[0325] ,
[0326] Step 3.2, using the superior and inferior solution distance method and a comprehensive evaluation model to dynamically evaluate the implementation indicators of the electric energy substitution project;
[0327] Specifically, determine the initial optimal and worst solution sequence of the weighted evaluation matrix , , satisfying the following relationship:
[0328] ,
[0329] In the formula, , are the optimal and worst solution sequences respectively. elements.
[0330] The distance between each solution to be evaluated and the optimal and worst solution sequences is calculated using the following relationship:
[0331] ,
[0332] ,
[0333] In the formula, , Respectively The distance between the optimal and the worst solution sequences.
[0334] The following relationship is used to calculate the relationship between any two sequences in the scheme to be evaluated. Correlation coefficient of evaluation index The correlation coefficient represents the correlation degree of the sequence with respect to the index. The larger the value, the closer the two sequences are to each other. The higher the correlation between the evaluation indicators, the higher the
[0335] ,
[0336] ,
[0337] In the formula, , are any two sequences in the scheme to be evaluated with respect to the The best and worst correlation coefficients of the evaluation indicators; is the resolution coefficient, and its preferred value is 0.5.
[0338] Using the correlation coefficient, the positive and negative correlation of the schemes to be evaluated in the implementation stage with respect to the optimal and worst solution sequences is calculated using the following relationship. The calculation expression is as follows:
[0339] ,
[0340] ,
[0341] In the formula, , They are respectively the positive correlation of the scheme to be evaluated with respect to the optimal solution sequence and the negative correlation with respect to the worst solution sequence.
[0342] The bigger and The smaller the value, the better the scheme to be evaluated, and vice versa.
[0343] The distance between the solution to be evaluated and the optimal and worst solution sequences in the implementation phase is expressed as follows: , , positive correlation with the optimal solution sequence of the scheme to be evaluated , about the negative correlation of the worst solution sequence Perform fitting to obtain characteristic indicators that satisfy the following relationship:
[0344] ,
[0345] In the formula, , They are positive characteristic index and negative characteristic index respectively; and They are all fitting coefficients, and the preferred values are all 0.5.
[0346] Using the positive characteristic index and negative characteristic index, the following relationship is used to calculate the The degree of fit of the solution under the implementation phase to be evaluated :
[0347] ,
[0348] The greater the fit of the plan within the implementation stage to be evaluated, the better the plan is.
[0349] The method proposed in the present invention is gradually carried out according to the implementation stage of the electric energy substitution project when evaluating the implementation index. The evaluation index system, weight coefficient calculation method and implementation index evaluation method proposed in the present invention can be used in each implementation stage to obtain the benefit evaluation results that meet the characteristics of the implementation stage. The implementation of electric energy substitution is a process project, and the replaced equipment is not transformed in one go. The traditional electric energy substitution evaluation model is usually an overall evaluation of the electric energy substitution project after transformation, and fails to achieve a phased evaluation during the substitution process. It is difficult for the evaluation model to timely reflect the update of electric energy substitution equipment at different stages. In the method proposed in the present invention, the dynamic evaluation results of the current implementation stage can assist in timely self-correction during the implementation of the project, which helps to improve the implementation benefits of the electric energy substitution project. The comprehensive evaluation results of the current implementation stage are the starting point of the next implementation stage, and the benefit shortcomings in the project implementation process are discovered in time, so as to take measures to improve the implementation indicators that affect the benefits. Compared with the traditional evaluation method, the dynamic evaluation proposed in the present invention is more accurate, and through the evaluation calculations of each stage, the calculation amount of the overall evaluation is reduced, and the evaluation results are more convincing.
[0350] The present invention also proposes a dynamic evaluation system for electric energy substitution implementation indicators based on variable weight optimization, comprising: an indicator establishment module, a dynamic evaluation module and a comprehensive evaluation module;
[0351] The indicator establishment module is used to construct corresponding implementation indicators according to the characteristics of various types of electric energy substitution projects;
[0352] The dynamic evaluation module is used to calculate the first and second weights of each implementation indicator at the beginning of the implementation stage of the electric energy substitution project, and dynamically modify the first and second weights by using the variable weight method to obtain the first and second variable weights; using the first and second variable weights, the butterfly optimization algorithm is used to determine the combined variable weights; collecting the target values of the implementation indicators, and using the weighted sum of the target values of the implementation indicators and the combined variable weights as the dynamic evaluation model; using the superior and inferior solution distance method, and using the dynamic evaluation model to dynamically evaluate the implementation indicators of the electric energy substitution project;
[0353] The comprehensive evaluation module is used to use the inverse of the ratio between the completion value of the implementation indicator and the target value during the implementation phase as the phase correction coefficient at the end of the implementation phase of the electric energy substitution project, and use the phase correction coefficient to correct the combined variable weight to obtain the comprehensive weight; collect the completion value of the implementation indicator, and use the weighted sum of the completion value of the implementation indicator and the comprehensive weight as the comprehensive evaluation model; adopt the superior and inferior solution distance method, and use the comprehensive evaluation model to comprehensively evaluate the implementation indicators of the electric energy substitution project.
[0354] The dynamic evaluation module includes: a first type weight calculation unit, a second type weight calculation unit, a variable weight correction unit and a combined variable weight unit;
[0355] The first type of weight calculation unit is used to construct the target layer, the criterion layer and the indicator layer based on the analytic hierarchy process according to the implementation stage of the electric energy substitution project;
[0356] The evaluation subject uses triangular fuzzy numbers to Implementation indicators For Implementation indicators The relative importance of is scored to construct a comprehensive fuzzy judgment matrix; among them, , is the number of indicators; the comprehensive fuzzy judgment matrix satisfies the following relationship:
[0357] ,
[0358] In the formula, is the comprehensive fuzzy judgment matrix, For the evaluation subject Implementation indicators For Implementation indicators The comprehensive fuzzy score given by the relative importance of OK The elements of the column, , is the number of indicators;
[0359] Based on the comprehensive fuzzy judgment matrix Implementation indicator data and Implementation indicators corresponding to Comprehensive fuzzy score , ,……, , using the first triangular fuzzy function to obtain the Implementation indicator data meets the target Importance , ,……, ; Use the Implementation indicator data meets the target The importance is calculated using the following relationship The comprehensive importance of the implementation indicators:
[0360] ,
[0361] In the formula, For the The comprehensive importance of the implementation indicators, To find the sign of the tensor product;
[0362] According to the comprehensive importance of each implementation indicator, based on the second triangular fuzzy function, the The probability that the comprehensive importance of the implementation indicator of the first item is greater than or equal to the comprehensive importance of the implementation indicators of the other items; and The probability that the comprehensive importance of the implementation indicator is greater than or equal to the comprehensive importance of other implementation indicators is calculated using the following relationship: The relative importance of this implementation indicator compared to other implementation indicators:
[0363] ,
[0364] In the formula, For the Implementation indicators The relative importance of It is The overall importance of the implementation indicators Greater than or equal to The overall importance of the implementation indicators degree of possibility;
[0365] The relative importance of the implementation indicators constitutes a column vector , after normalizing the column vector, we get the first type of weight vector ,in, For the Implementation indicators The first type of weight satisfies the following relationship:
[0366] ,
[0367] In the formula, , They are column vectors The minimum and maximum values in ;
[0368] A second type of weight calculation unit, used for calculating the second type of weight using an entropy weight method;
[0369] Variable weight correction unit, used to establish The state vector corresponding to the first type of weight of the implementation indicator and the state vector corresponding to the second type of weight ,in, Respectively The implementation indicator state variables of the first type of weight, Implementation indicator state variables of the second type of weights;
[0370] Based on the variable weight penalty factor, the subjective state variable weight vector is established and objective state variable weight vector , where the first The element is related to the objective state variable weight vector The elements satisfy the following relationship:
[0371] ,
[0372] ,
[0373] In the formula, are the subjective state variable weight vectors and objective state variable weight vector The elements and elements; is the variable weight penalty factor; , Respectively The qualified limit of the implementation indicator state variable of the first type of weight, The qualified limit of the implementation indicator state variable of the second type of weight;
[0374] Using the subjective state variable weight vector and the objective state variable weight vector, the first type of weight and the second type of weight are respectively modified according to the following relationship:
[0375] ,
[0376] ,
[0377] In the formula, For the Implementation indicators The modified first-category weights, For the Implementation indicators The modified second category weights;
[0378] Combined variable weight unit, used for Implementation indicators, the first type of variable weight set , the second type of variable weight set , the first type of variable weight set and the second type of variable weight set are combined according to the following relationship to obtain the combined variable weight set , , No. Combination variable weights Satisfies the following relationship:
[0379] ,
[0380] In the formula, and Respectively The first type of variable weights and the The combination coefficients corresponding to the second type of variable weights;
[0381] A combined variable weight optimization model is established, in which the objective function of the model satisfies the following relationship:
[0382] ,
[0383] In the formula, , They are and Difference, and The spectral norm of the difference; the constraints of the model satisfy the following relationship:
[0384] ,
[0385] Based on the combined variable weight optimization model, the butterfly optimization algorithm is used to optimize the combination coefficients.
[0386] Comprehensive assessment module, including: stage correction unit;
[0387] The stage correction unit is used to correct the combined variable weights at the end of the implementation stage of the electric energy substitution project, taking the inverse of the ratio between the completion value and the target value of the implementation indicator in the implementation stage as the stage correction coefficient, and using the stage correction coefficient to obtain the comprehensive weight, which satisfies the following relationship:
[0388] ,
[0389] In the formula, The first Combination variable weights The corresponding stage correction parameters, is the comprehensive weight set.
[0390] In view of the problem that the traditional index system cannot reflect the serious over-standard of a certain index due to data anomalies or data changes during the substitution process, the present invention introduces a variable weight method to adjust the obtained main and second category weights, so that the optimized weights can effectively reflect the impact of index changes, and can effectively reflect the "short board effect" phenomenon caused by data anomalies or changes in a certain index, greatly improving the accuracy of subsequent comprehensive evaluation. In addition, by introducing correction parameters, the initial combination weight obtained by optimization is corrected, so that the final comprehensive weight presents a self-correction improvement capability.
[0391] On this basis, the present invention takes into account the equipment update situation in different replacement stages and designs a dynamic evaluation model for electric energy substitution, that is, adding a feedback iteration link of equipment replacement situation to the traditional evaluation method, so that the benefit evaluation of the electric energy substitution project can better reflect the changes in equipment replacement, thereby obtaining a more scientific, comprehensive, accurate and objective evaluation result, and providing support for the promotion and application of electric energy substitution technology.
[0392] The present invention proposes a dynamic evaluation method for the implementation benefits of electric energy substitution based on variable weight optimization. It mainly improves the shortcomings of traditional electric energy substitution evaluation through innovations in weight optimization and dynamic evaluation, making the evaluation of the implementation benefits of electric energy substitution projects more accurate, thereby screening out electric energy substitution plans with higher economic benefits, environmental friendliness, and conducive to technological innovation and sustainable development, so as to achieve the purpose of reducing costs, improving the environment, and enhancing energy security. The invention specifically includes four aspects: constructing an evaluation index system for the implementation benefits of electric energy substitution, weight optimization, improving the comprehensive evaluation model of TOPSOS, and overall dynamic evaluation.
[0393] Firstly, according to the typical characteristics of the two types of electric energy substitution technologies, "electricity replacing coal" and "electricity replacing oil", in actual operation, a corresponding indicator system for evaluating the implementation effect of electric energy substitution is established; secondly, the main and second category weights of each indicator are determined by the triangular fuzzy hierarchy method and the entropy weight method respectively, and the two are dynamically adjusted by the variable weight theory in consideration of the abnormal or missing data, so as to ensure that the main and second category weights can effectively reflect the "short board effect" caused by the excessive difference of a certain indicator; then, the main and second category weights are optimized and reorganized by the PSO optimization algorithm to obtain the initial combination weights, and the correction parameters are introduced on this basis to optimize and adjust the initial combination weights again to reflect the implementation of the phased project and the completion of the final goal; then, the implementation effect of electric energy substitution is evaluated and ranked by improving the distance method of superior and inferior solutions; finally, the update status of the electric energy substitution equipment in this stage is returned to the indicator calculation step, and the electric energy evaluation calculation of the new stage is carried out according to the latest substitution status, so as to realize the dynamic evaluation of the entire substitution process, so as to make the evaluation method of the present invention more accurate and reliable.
[0394] It is worth noting that the evaluation subject in the present invention is preferably but not limited to a person skilled in the art, an expert natural person, or an expert system that uses artificial intelligence technology and computer technology and has a large amount of expert-level knowledge and experience in this field.
[0395] The present disclosure may be a system, a method and / or a computer program product. The computer program product may include a computer-readable storage medium carrying computer-readable program instructions for causing a processor to implement various aspects of the present disclosure.
[0396] A computer-readable storage medium may be a tangible device that can hold and store instructions used by an instruction execution device. A computer-readable storage medium may be, for example, but not limited to, an electrical storage device, a magnetic storage device, an optical storage device, an electromagnetic storage device, a semiconductor storage device, or any suitable combination of the above. More specific examples (a non-exhaustive list) of computer-readable storage media include: a portable computer disk, a hard disk, a random access memory (RAM), a read-only memory (ROM), an erasable programmable read-only memory (EPROM or flash memory), a static random access memory (SRAM), a portable compact disk read-only memory (CD-ROM), a digital versatile disk (DVD), a memory stick, a floppy disk, a mechanical encoding device, such as a punch card or a raised structure in a groove on which instructions are stored, and any suitable combination of the above. The computer-readable storage medium used herein is not to be interpreted as a transient signal itself, such as a radio wave or other freely propagating electromagnetic wave, an electromagnetic wave propagating through a waveguide or other transmission medium (e.g., a light pulse through a fiber optic cable), or an electrical signal transmitted through a wire.
[0397] The computer-readable program instructions described herein can be downloaded from a computer-readable storage medium to each computing / processing device, or downloaded to an external computer or external storage device via a network, such as the Internet, a local area network, a wide area network, and / or a wireless network. The network can include copper transmission cables, optical fiber transmissions, wireless transmissions, routers, firewalls, switches, gateway computers, and / or edge servers. The network adapter card or network interface in each computing / processing device receives the computer-readable program instructions from the network and forwards the computer-readable program instructions for storage in the computer-readable storage medium in each computing / processing device.
[0398] The computer program instructions for performing the operations of the present disclosure may be assembly instructions, instruction set architecture (ISA) instructions, machine instructions, machine-dependent instructions, microcode, firmware instructions, state setting data, or source code or object code written in any combination of one or more programming languages, including object-oriented programming languages, such as Smalltalk, C++, etc., and conventional procedural programming languages, such as "C" language or similar programming languages. The computer-readable program instructions may be executed entirely on the user's computer, partially on the user's computer, as a separate software package, partially on the user's computer, partially on a remote computer, or entirely on a remote computer or server. In the case of a remote computer, the remote computer may be connected to the user's computer through any type of network, including a local area network (LAN) or a wide area network (WAN), or may be connected to an external computer (e.g., using an Internet service provider to connect through the Internet). In some embodiments, by using the state information of the computer-readable program instructions to personalize an electronic circuit, such as a programmable logic circuit, a field programmable gate array (FPGA), or a programmable logic array (PLA), the electronic circuit may execute the computer-readable program instructions, thereby implementing various aspects of the present disclosure.
[0399] Finally, it should be noted that the above embodiments are only used to illustrate the technical solutions of the present invention rather than to limit it. Although the present invention has been described in detail with reference to the above embodiments, ordinary technicians in the relevant field should understand that the specific implementation methods of the present invention can still be modified or replaced by equivalents, and any modifications or equivalent replacements that do not depart from the spirit and scope of the present invention should be covered within the scope of protection of the claims of the present invention.
Claims
1. A dynamic evaluation method for implementation indicators of electric energy substitution based on variable weight optimization, which distinguishes the types of electric energy substitution projects in different industries, including electric energy substitution projects that replace coal with electricity and electric energy substitution projects that replace oil with electricity; characterized in that: The following steps are involved: Establish implementation indicators for projects that replace coal with electricity, including: initial investment and construction costs, operation and maintenance costs, unit energy supply income, carbon dioxide emission reduction, carbon utilization benefits, technical maturity and government support; Establish implementation indicators for projects that replace oil with electricity, including: average peak-to-valley difference, average load rate, charging equipment utilization rate, charging plan completion rate, service revenue, average queuing time, average charging time, unit charging time and public recognition; At the beginning of the implementation stage of the electric energy substitution project, based on the hierarchical analysis method, combined with the evaluation subject scoring method and the triangular fuzzy method, the first type of weight of each implementation indicator is calculated, the second type of weight of each implementation indicator is calculated by the entropy weight method, and the first type of weight and the second type of weight are dynamically modified by the variable weight method to obtain the first type of variable weight weight and the second type of variable weight weight; using the first type of variable weight weight and the second type of variable weight weight, the butterfly optimization algorithm is used to determine the combined variable weight weight; the target value of the implementation indicator is collected, and the weighted sum of the target value of the implementation indicator and the combined variable weight weight is used as the dynamic evaluation model; the superior and inferior solution distance method is used, and the dynamic evaluation model is used to dynamically evaluate the implementation indicators of the electric energy substitution project; The variable weight method is used to dynamically modify the first and second type of weights, including: Establish separately The state vector corresponding to the first type of weight of the implementation indicator and the state vector corresponding to the second type of weight ,in, Respectively The implementation indicator state variables of the first type of weight, Implementation indicator state variables of the second type of weights; Based on the variable weight penalty factor, the subjective state variable weight vector is established and objective state variable weight vector , where the first The element is related to the objective state variable weight vector The elements satisfy the following relationship: (10) (11) In the formula, are the subjective state variable weight vectors and objective state variable weight vector The elements and elements; is the variable weight penalty factor; , Respectively The qualified limit of the implementation indicator state variable of the first type of weight, The qualified limit of the implementation indicator state variable of the second type of weight; Using the subjective state variable weight vector and the objective state variable weight vector, the first type of weight and the second type of weight are respectively modified according to the following relationship: (12) (13) In the formula, For the Implementation indicators The modified first-category weights, For the Implementation indicators The modified second-class weights are For the Implementation indicators The first-class weights, For the Implementation indicators The second type of weights; At the end of the implementation phase of the electric energy substitution project, the inverse of the ratio between the completion value of the implementation indicator and the target value during the implementation phase is used as the phase correction coefficient, and the comprehensive weight is obtained by multiplying the phase correction coefficient with the combined variable weight. The completion value of the implementation indicator is collected, and the weighted sum of the completion value of the implementation indicator and the comprehensive weight is used as the comprehensive evaluation model. The superior and inferior solution distance method is used to use the comprehensive evaluation model to comprehensively evaluate the implementation indicators of the electric energy substitution project.
2. The method for dynamic evaluation of electric energy substitution implementation indicators based on variable weight optimization according to claim 1 is characterized in that: At the beginning of the implementation phase of the electric energy substitution project, based on the analytic hierarchy process, combined with the evaluation subject scoring method and the triangular fuzzy method, the first-class weights of each implementation indicator are calculated, and the second-class weights of each implementation indicator are calculated using the entropy weight method. The first-class weights and the second-class weights are dynamically modified using the variable weight method to obtain the first-class variable weights and the second-class variable weights. Using the first type of variable weights and the second type of variable weights, the butterfly optimization algorithm is used to determine the combined variable weights, including: Based on the analytic hierarchy process, the target layer, criterion layer and indicator layer are constructed according to the implementation stage of the electric energy substitution project; Using triangular fuzzy numbers to Implementation indicators For Implementation indicators The relative importance of is scored to construct a comprehensive fuzzy judgment matrix; among them, , is the number of indicators; the comprehensive fuzzy judgment matrix satisfies the following relationship: (1) In the formula, is the comprehensive fuzzy judgment matrix, For the evaluation subject Implementation indicators For Implementation indicators The comprehensive fuzzy score given by the relative importance of OK The elements of the column, , is the number of indicators; Based on the comprehensive fuzzy judgment matrix Implementation indicator data and Implementation indicators corresponding to Comprehensive fuzzy score , ,……, , using the first triangular fuzzy function to obtain the Implementation indicator data meets the target Importance , ,……, ; Use the Implementation indicator data meets the target The importance is calculated using the following relationship The comprehensive importance of the implementation indicators: (2) In the formula, For the The comprehensive importance of the implementation indicators, To find the sign of the tensor product, To use the first triangular fuzzy function to obtain the Implementation indicator data meets the target importance, ; According to the comprehensive importance of each implementation indicator, based on the second triangular fuzzy function, the The probability that the comprehensive importance of the implementation indicator of the first item is greater than or equal to the comprehensive importance of the implementation indicators of the other items; and The probability that the comprehensive importance of the implementation indicator is greater than or equal to the comprehensive importance of other implementation indicators is calculated using the following relationship: The relative importance of this implementation indicator compared to other implementation indicators: (3) In the formula, For the Implementation indicators The relative importance of It is The overall importance of the implementation indicators Greater than or equal to The overall importance of the implementation indicators degree of possibility; The relative importance of the implementation indicators constitutes a column vector , after normalizing the column vector, we get the first type of weight vector ,in, For the Implementation indicators The first type of weight satisfies the following relationship: (4) In the formula, , They are column vectors The minimum and maximum values in ; The entropy weight method is used to calculate the second type of weights.
3. The method for dynamic evaluation of electric energy substitution implementation indicators based on variable weight optimization according to claim 2 is characterized in that: Comprehensive fuzzy scoring Satisfies the following relationship: (5) In the formula, It is Evaluation subject targets indicators right The fuzzy score given by the relative importance of , is the number of evaluation subjects; And, fuzzy scoring and They satisfy the following relationships respectively: (6) (7) In the formula, , and They are Evaluation subject targets indicators right The minimum, middle and maximum values of the fuzzy scores given by the relative importance of It is Evaluation subject targets indicators right The fuzzy score given by the relative importance of , is the number of evaluation subjects.
4. The method for dynamic evaluation of electric energy substitution implementation indicators based on variable weight optimization according to claim 2 is characterized in that: The first triangular fuzzy function satisfies the following relationship: (8) In the formula, is the first triangular fuzzy function, indicating the implementation index data The importance of meeting the objectives; , , are the minimum, middle and maximum values of the fuzzy score respectively.
5. The method for dynamic evaluation of electric energy substitution implementation indicators based on variable weight optimization according to claim 2 is characterized in that: The second triangular fuzzy function satisfies the following relationship: (9) In the formula, is the second triangular fuzzy function, indicating the comprehensive importance of the first implementation indicator Greater than or equal to the comprehensive importance of the implementation indicators of Article 2 degree of possibility; , , They are the minimum, middle and maximum values of the fuzzy score of the implementation indicator of Article 1; , , They are the minimum, middle and maximum values of the fuzzy score of the implementation indicator of Article 2 respectively.
6. The method for dynamic evaluation of electric energy substitution implementation indicators based on variable weight optimization according to claim 1 is characterized in that: Using the first type of variable weights and the second type of variable weights, the butterfly optimization algorithm is used to determine the combined variable weights, including: for Implementation indicators, the first type of variable weight set , the second type of variable weight set , the first type of variable weight set and the second type of variable weight set are combined according to the following relationship to obtain the combined variable weight set , , No. Combination variable weights Satisfies the following relationship: (14) In the formula, and Respectively The first type of variable weights and the The combination coefficients corresponding to the second type variable weights are: and Respectively The first type of variable weights and the The second type of variable weights; A combined variable weight optimization model is established, in which the objective function of the model satisfies the following relationship: (15) In the formula, , They are and Difference, and The spectral norm of the difference; the constraints of the model satisfy the following relationship: (16) Based on the combined variable weight optimization model, the butterfly optimization algorithm is used to optimize the combination coefficients.
7. The method for dynamic evaluation of electric energy substitution implementation indicators based on variable weight optimization according to claim 6 is characterized in that: The butterfly optimization algorithm based on chaotic mapping and Cauchy mutation is used to optimize the combination coefficients, including: The chaotic sequence is generated by chaotic mapping, and the initial position sequence of the butterfly individuals in the butterfly optimization algorithm is determined by the following relationship: (17) In the formula, , are the upper and lower limits of the initial position sequence respectively; Representative The sequence of initial positions of the butterflies; For the Iterated chaotic sequence; Based on the adaptive weight coefficient, the global search and local mining positions in the butterfly optimization algorithm are updated as follows: (18) In the formula, For the A butterfly in the The position vector in iterations; For the A butterfly in the The position vector in iterations; is the current global optimal solution; is a random number in [0,1]; For the A butterfly in the The position vector in iterations; For the A butterfly in the The position vector in iterations; For the The scent of a butterfly; represents the adaptive weight coefficient; is the current iteration number; The Cauchy mutation operator is used to perform Cauchy mutation on the optimal solution in the current iteration, and the new optimal solution satisfies the following relationship: (19) In the formula, is the new optimal solution obtained after Cauchy mutation; is the current global optimal solution; is the standard Cauchy distribution function.
8. The method for dynamic evaluation of electric energy substitution implementation indicators based on variable weight optimization according to claim 6 is characterized in that: At the end of the implementation phase of the electric energy substitution project, the reciprocal of the ratio between the completion value and the target value of the implementation indicator during the implementation phase is used as the phase correction coefficient. The combined variable weight is corrected using the phase correction coefficient to obtain the comprehensive weight, which satisfies the following relationship: (20) In the formula, The first Combination variable weights The corresponding stage correction parameters, is the comprehensive weight set.
9. A dynamic evaluation system for implementation indicators of electric energy substitution based on variable weight optimization, which distinguishes the types of electric energy substitution projects in different industries, including electric energy substitution projects that replace coal with electricity and electric energy substitution projects that replace oil with electricity; It is characterized in that include: Indicator establishment module, dynamic evaluation module and comprehensive evaluation module; The indicator establishment module is used to establish the implementation indicators of the electricity-to-coal substitution project, including: initial investment and construction cost, operation and maintenance cost, unit energy supply income, carbon dioxide emission reduction, carbon utilization benefit, technology maturity and government support; establish the implementation indicators of the electricity-to-oil substitution project, including: average peak-to-valley difference, average load rate, charging equipment utilization rate, charging plan completion rate, service income, average queuing time, average charging time, unit charging time and public recognition; The dynamic evaluation module is used to calculate the first-class weights of each implementation indicator at the beginning of the implementation stage of the electric energy substitution project based on the hierarchical analysis method, combined with the evaluation subject scoring method and the triangular fuzzy method, and the second-class weights of each implementation indicator are calculated by the entropy weight method. The first-class weights and the second-class weights are dynamically corrected by the variable weight method to obtain the first-class variable weights and the second-class variable weights; the butterfly optimization algorithm is used to determine the combined variable weights by using the first-class variable weights and the second-class variable weights; the target values of the implementation indicators are collected, and the weighted sum of the target values of the implementation indicators and the combined variable weights is used as the dynamic evaluation model; the superior and inferior solution distance method is used to use the dynamic evaluation model to dynamically evaluate the implementation indicators of the electric energy substitution project; The dynamic evaluation module uses a variable weight method to dynamically modify the first type of weight and the second type of weight; the dynamic evaluation module includes a variable weight modification unit; the variable weight modification unit is used to establish The state vector corresponding to the first type of weight of the implementation indicator and the state vector corresponding to the second type of weight ,in, Respectively The implementation indicator state variables of the first type of weight, Implementation indicator state variables of the second type of weights; Based on the variable weight penalty factor, the subjective state variable weight vector is established and objective state variable weight vector , where the first The element is related to the objective state variable weight vector The elements satisfy the following relationship: (10) (11) In the formula, are the subjective state variable weight vectors and objective state variable weight vector The elements and elements; is the variable weight penalty factor; , Respectively The qualified limit of the implementation indicator state variable of the first type of weight, The qualified limit of the implementation indicator state variable of the second type of weight; Using the subjective state variable weight vector and the objective state variable weight vector, the first type of weight and the second type of weight are respectively modified according to the following relationship: (12) In the formula, For the Implementation indicators The modified first-class weights, For the Implementation indicators The modified second-class weights are For the Implementation indicators The first-class weights, For the Implementation indicators The second type of weights; The comprehensive evaluation module is used to use the inverse of the ratio between the completion value of the implementation indicator and the target value during the implementation phase as the phase correction coefficient at the end of the implementation phase of the electric energy substitution project, and obtain the comprehensive weight by multiplying the phase correction coefficient with the combined variable weight; collect the completion value of the implementation indicator, and use the weighted sum of the completion value of the implementation indicator and the comprehensive weight as the comprehensive evaluation model; adopt the superior and inferior solution distance method, and use the comprehensive evaluation model to conduct a comprehensive evaluation of the implementation indicators of the electric energy substitution project.
10. The electric energy substitution implementation index dynamic evaluation system based on variable weight optimization according to claim 9 is characterized in that: The dynamic evaluation module also includes: a first type weight calculation unit, a second type weight calculation unit, and a combined variable weight unit; The first type of weight calculation unit is used to construct the target layer, the criterion layer and the indicator layer based on the analytic hierarchy process according to the implementation stage of the electric energy substitution project; The evaluation subject uses triangular fuzzy numbers to Implementation indicators For Implementation indicators The relative importance of is scored to construct a comprehensive fuzzy judgment matrix; among them, , is the number of indicators; the comprehensive fuzzy judgment matrix satisfies the following relationship: (21) In the formula, is the comprehensive fuzzy judgment matrix, For the evaluation subject Implementation indicators For Implementation indicators The comprehensive fuzzy score given by the relative importance of OK The elements of the column, , is the number of indicators; Based on the comprehensive fuzzy judgment matrix Implementation indicator data and Implementation indicators corresponding to Comprehensive fuzzy score , ,……, , using the first triangular fuzzy function to obtain the Implementation indicator data meets the target Importance , ,……, ; Use the Implementation indicator data meets the target The importance is calculated using the following relationship The comprehensive importance of the implementation indicators: (22) In the formula, For the The comprehensive importance of the implementation indicators, To find the sign of the tensor product, To use the first triangular fuzzy function to obtain the Implementation indicator data meets the target importance, ; According to the comprehensive importance of each implementation indicator, based on the second triangular fuzzy function, the The probability that the comprehensive importance of the implementation indicator of the first item is greater than or equal to the comprehensive importance of the implementation indicators of the other items; and The probability that the comprehensive importance of the implementation indicator is greater than or equal to the comprehensive importance of other implementation indicators is calculated using the following relationship: The relative importance of this implementation indicator compared to other implementation indicators: (23) In the formula, For the Implementation indicators The relative importance of It is The overall importance of the implementation indicators Greater than or equal to The overall importance of the implementation indicators degree of likelihood; The relative importance of the implementation indicators constitutes a column vector , after normalizing the column vector, we get the first type of weight vector ,in, For the Implementation indicators The first type of weight satisfies the following relationship: (24) In the formula, , They are column vectors The minimum and maximum values in ; A second type of weight calculation unit, used for calculating the second type of weight using an entropy weight method; Combined variable weight unit, used for Implementation indicators, the first type of variable weight set , the second type of variable weight set , the first type of variable weight set and the second type of variable weight set are combined according to the following relationship to obtain the combined variable weight set , , No. Combination variable weights Satisfies the following relationship: (29) In the formula, and Respectively The first type of variable weights and the The combination coefficients corresponding to the second type of variable weights are: and Respectively The first type of variable weights and the The second type of variable weights; A combined variable weight optimization model is established, in which the objective function of the model satisfies the following relationship: (30) In the formula, , They are and Difference, and The spectral norm of the difference; the constraints of the model satisfy the following relationship: (31) Based on the combined variable weight optimization model, the butterfly optimization algorithm is used to optimize the combination coefficients.
11. The electric energy substitution implementation index dynamic evaluation system based on variable weight optimization according to claim 10 is characterized in that: Comprehensive assessment module, including: stage correction unit; The stage correction unit is used to correct the combined variable weights at the end of the implementation stage of the electric energy substitution project, using the inverse of the ratio between the completion value and the target value of the implementation indicator in the implementation stage as the stage correction coefficient, and obtain the comprehensive weight by using the stage correction coefficient to satisfy the following relationship: (32) In the formula, The first Combination variable weights The corresponding stage correction parameters, is the comprehensive weight set.
12. A terminal comprising a processor and a storage medium; characterized in that: The storage medium is used to store instructions; The processor is used to operate according to the instructions to execute the steps of the method for dynamically evaluating electric energy substitution implementation indicators based on variable weight optimization as described in any one of claims 1-8.
13. A computer-readable storage medium having a computer program stored thereon, characterized in that: When the program is executed by a processor, the steps of the method for dynamically evaluating electric energy substitution implementation indicators based on variable weight optimization as described in any one of claims 1 to 8 are implemented.
