Method for determining wear volume of slip ring seal in event of single wear event by means of temporally high-resolution temperature measurements
Through high-resolution temperature measurement and thermocouple device, the accuracy and prediction problems of slip ring seal wear measurement are solved, the accurate measurement of wear and the prediction of seal failure moments are achieved, and the service life prediction capability of seals is improved .
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202380028906.1
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2022-03-21
- Filing Date
- 2023-02-14
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-08
AI Technical Summary
The prior art is difficult to accurately measure the wear and wear rate of slip ring seals, especially in hard materials such as silicon carbide rings, and traditional methods have limitations on measurement locations, low sensitivity, high cost, difficult signal filtration, insufficient computing power, etc. Problems, making it difficult to predict the service life and failure time of the seal.
By measuring temperature changes at high resolution in the slip ring seal, using temperature changes to infer wear characteristics, combined with the thermocouple temperature measurement device, the direct measurement of the tribological state and the calculation of the wear amount are realized, and the failure time of the seal is predicted. .
High-precision measurement and prediction of slip ring seal wear is realized, and the service life and failure time of the seal can be effectively predicted in practical applications, reducing the testing cost and complexity.
Smart Images

Figure CN118922702A_ABST
Abstract
Description
[0001] Technical field of the invention
[0002] Slip ring seals (Figure 1) are mechanical elements for sealing rotating conveying devices. Almost all pumps and compressors used throughout the world belong to conveying devices. The purpose of slip ring seals is to maximize the tightness or minimize leakage with low energy consumption. The main elements of slip ring seals are slip rings and mating rings. The main seal occurs between the two rings, between which there is a sealing gap in the submicron range. Due to the requirement to minimize emissions (leakage), the height of the sealing gap is also minimized. This leads to contact between slip ring and mating ring at a varying time frequency during operation and thus to wear. Without this contact between slip ring and mating ring, there would be no wear.
[0003] The invention relates to a measuring method which determines the wear and the wear rate (wear per unit time). This makes it possible for the first time during operation of a mechanical slide seal to determine the expected service life of the mechanical slide seal with practicable accuracy.
[0004] Background of the Invention
[0005] For more than two decades, various methods have been used to measure wear (wear volume, wear height) and wear rate in mechanical seals. In principle, a distinction is made between measurement methods using direct variables and measurement methods using indirect variables. The following belong to direct measurement methods:
[0006] Wear height
[0007] Tracer
[0008] The following are indirect measurement methods:
[0009] Vibration (structure-borne sound, oscillation)
[0010] Digital twin: combination of temperature, pressure, speed, fluid, and geometry
[0011] Torque
[0012] ·leakage
[0013] ·temperature
[0014] Wear height: Wear height sensing is a feasible measurement method according to the current state of the art in order to determine wear. For this purpose, for example, a wear element is applied in the sealing gap. If the height or thickness of the wear element changes, for example, the electrical resistance of the wear element changes.
[0015] Another design variant is to introduce a contact into the body to be worn, which contacts send a signal when they are reached due to wear. A plurality of contacts at different wear heights is possible.
[0016] However, this solution has the disadvantage of limited measurement space and sensitivity, especially for rings made of very hard materials such as silicon carbide, because wear of a few micrometers (1-10 μm) is sufficient to significantly affect the sealing function of sliding ring seals with silicon carbide rings.
[0017] Tracers: Wear measurements based on tracers are high-resolution. For this purpose, the slide ring and the counter ring are doped with a tracer, which can then be measured outside the slide ring seal with the wear product in the gaseous or liquid state. However, the technical complexity for such measurements is very high. Therefore, such measurements are usually only used in laboratories.
[0018] Vibrations: Active and passive vibration measurements in all technically relevant frequency ranges are state of the art and are used for condition analysis of pumps and mechanical seals.
[0019] Two main technical disadvantages can be identified: Vibration measurements have the problem of having to function in an environment full of extraneous sound signals. Filtering of seal-related signals is very expensive and sometimes even not feasible beyond laboratory use.
[0020] The use of an excited measuring system can improve the filtering of the relevant signals. However, the response function does not describe the wear characteristics, but rather the change in μm between the slip ring and the mating ring. 2 The connection area within the range and its size distribution (of each contact surface).
[0021] Digital twin: Digital twin is a model-based mapping of the characteristics of a component with respect to various target parameters. For slide ring seals, the parameters fluid temperature, rotational speed, fluid pressure, and other fluid properties including the seal geometry and material properties are sufficient to calculate the sealing gap that occurs between the slide ring and the mating ring. In the model, it is always assumed that there is a sealing gap, no matter how small it is. The surfaces of the slide ring and the mating ring do not touch each other in the model. Therefore, it cannot be used to calculate contact-based wear of slide ring seals.
[0022] In principle, a non-steady-state modeling of wear on an atomic basis is conceivable, but is impeded by the dimensions of the contacts that are necessary for this purpose, which are caused by the limited computing power of current large computers.
[0023] Torque: Mechanically decoupled measurement of the torque between slip ring and counter ring is possible, but is technically very complex and often technically not feasible due to lack of installation space.
[0024] Leakage: Measuring the leakage and its temporal course in the event of a blockage of a sealing system with two slide ring seals ( FIG. 3 ) is a good indicator for elucidating the sealing function of the two slide ring seals.
[0025] In the case of a simple-functioning slide ring seal, leakage can be measured only on the side facing away from the pressure, i.e. towards the surroundings. However, this is technically possible only if the seal has a higher leakage as standard. The seal has a sealing gap which ensures a correspondingly normal, slightly higher leakage. Due to the lack of contact between the slide ring and the counter ring, no wear occurs, unless the seal comes into contact during the start-up and closing processes.
[0026] In contrast, seals in contact exhibit leakage that is usually practically unmeasurable, since the vast majority of the leakage (especially in the case of water applications) evaporates. Furthermore, even when the leakage or the sealing gap approaches zero, critical wear states occur. Critical wear states cannot be detected with the aid of leakage measurements in the case of seals in contact.
[0027] Temperature: The measurement of the temperature of the sliding ring and the mating ring in the sliding ring seal is known in the art. Estimation of the normal temperature T N (Figure 4). However, the temperature does not describe the wear, wear state and wear rate of the slip ring and the counter ring. It is determined by the temperature of the medium to be sealed, the medium properties, the seal design and the rotational speed. It is part of the measurement method "digital twin" already described.
[0028] The following documents are cited for the prior art:
[0029] / 1 / DE102007026743A1
[0030] / 2 / DE102018125969A1
[0031] / 3 / DE19724308A1
[0032] / 4 / EP3139072A1
[0033] / 5 / EP3502525A1
[0034] Description of the Invention
[0035] The present invention is proposed against the background of the prior art described above, the object of the present invention being to provide a feasible method with which it is possible to measure and accumulate the wear of slide rings and counter rings in slide ring seals and thus to predict technical failures with high quality with respect to the probability of occurrence to be expected in time.
[0036] This task is solved by a measurement method that In a temporally high-resolution manner Measuring the temperature at the slip ring or mating ring as an indirect variable. Surprisingly, it has been shown that when measuring the temperature of the slip ring or mating ring in a slip-ring seal with high temporal resolution, typical temperature changes occur (FIG. 4), which allow direct inferences about the wear behavior. The typical measurement time of such an event is usually in the range of a few milliseconds to 60 seconds, which is much shorter than the "normal temperature" (T N ), temperature change (T V =f(t)) is less than 10K.
[0037] In the case of macroscopic "contact" of two moving surfaces (here the contact surfaces of the slip ring and the mating ring), three tribological states can typically be described on a small length scale: atomic contact with surface connection at the molecular level (so-called cold welding (Figure 5)), atomic contact with inert surfaces (small shear forces) and surfaces between which a thin liquid film is sheared. All three tribological states result in a total shear force or, when the shear force is related to the normal force, in a friction coefficient. It has been shown that the proportion of cold welded contacts is unstable. However, cold welded contacts in any case, depending on the material pairing and external boundary conditions of the slip ring and the mating ring, result in the sudden detachment of the smallest material component from the contact surface. This process (detachment) consumes energy, since the surface becomes larger (surface energy) during detachment. However, a brief increase in temperature is then generated on a very small time scale (Figure 4, T V ). This is due to the dislodged material components which are then comminuted and discharged in the sealing gap. The more particles are dislodged and the longer they remain in the sealing gap, the higher and longer the measured short-term temperature increase will be. The discharge process depends on the seal (geometry, material, pressure, temperature, rotational speed, fluid, etc.) and can therefore be reproduced surprisingly well. That is, the area (A) under the function T=f(t) V ) is proportional to the friction work and the sought wear volume in a seal-specific manner. According to the invention, the method can be used very simply to measure or calculate the total friction on a large time scale. Only a temperature measuring device is required, such as a thermocouple in the slide ring or the mating ring, ideally in the stationary ring of the slide ring seal. The measured temperature time variation depends on the heat source of the slide ring seal (friction caused by wear particles) and the heat transfer boundary conditions and storage boundary conditions, as described. If the heat transfer boundary conditions are known, there is also the possibility of expanding the measurement method for friction measurement in such a way that the individual friction events (dry running, wear due to external particles, wear due to detached particles, size of the particles) can be examined tribologically more deeply.
[0038] In practice, it is often difficult to test each seal design used in the laboratory in its actual application. However, a feasible solution is achieved here according to the measuring method described in the present invention. Assuming that the mechanical seal always wears similarly again and again under constant boundary conditions, the possibility is obtained that the failure time can be predicted. For this purpose, a so-called first sacrificial seal is used to calibrate the maximum possible wear until failure with the aid of the measuring method described. The subsequent seals that are installed later use the results of the sacrificial seal.
Claims
1. A method for determining the wear volume of a mechanical slide ring seal in the event of a single wear event, wherein: The temperature (T V ), where by measuring the temperature (T V ) and then the function of the measured temperature change (T V = f(t)) is integrated to determine the normal temperature (T) corresponding to the temperature variation of the slide ring seal in the absence of wear in the case of a short-term temperature change (dt) of less than 60 s. N ) compared to the measured temperature change (T V = the area under f(t) (A V ), where the determined area (A V ) is multiplied by a seal-specific factor to calculate the wear volume.
2. The method according to claim 1, wherein: Determine the total wear and the wear rate at time t.
3. The method according to claim 2, wherein: The total wear is correlated with the technically maximum possible wear in order to be able to predict the time at which the seal will fail.
4. The method according to claim 3, wherein: The probability of occurrence of a seal failure with each new failure event is improved by taking historical failure events into account.
5. A method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein: The method for determining the wear volume of a mechanical seal is divided into two sub-processes (A, B): A: The area (A) is determined in a decentralized evaluation unit at a location close to the slide ring seal. V ); B: The determined area (A V ) is transmitted to a central evaluation unit which combines the seal-specific factors with the calculated area with the aid of the seal specifications in order to be able to calculate the wear volume.
6. A method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein: The seal-specific factors are predetermined by laboratory measurements.
7. A method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein: The seal-specific factor is calculated on the basis of a single measurement of the installed mechanical slide seal over its entire service life, ie from the first commissioning of the seal until failure.
8. A method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein: Operating state-dependent wear levels are formed which offer the operator of the seal the possibility of minimizing wear in a targeted manner by avoiding wear levels with high wear.
9. A method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein: Individual wear events are associated with specific causes, such as dry running or the intrusion of foreign particles from the suspension to be sealed into the sealing gap.
10. The method according to claims 1 and 2, wherein: For all individual wear events, the average area (A V ) is used as a starting point, so that in order to determine the total wear, only the number of individual wear events is multiplied by a seal-specific factor.
