Optimization Design Method for Boundary Pillar Thickness Based on Mining Disturbance Propagation Attenuation Characteristics
By establishing a three-dimensional numerical model of open-pit slope-boundary pillar-underground mining area, calculating disturbance propagation attenuation and blocking coefficient, and optimizing pillar thickness, the problem of high design uncertainty in existing technologies is solved, achieving a balance between pillar and slope stability and improved economic benefits.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202611496628.4
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2026-09-24
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-17
AI Technical Summary
Existing methods for designing the thickness of boundary pillars fail to effectively consider the propagation and attenuation characteristics of mining disturbances, lack quantitative research and evaluation of barrier capacity, resulting in high uncertainty in design results and difficulty in balancing pillar stability and slope stability.
A three-dimensional numerical model of open-pit slope, boundary pillar, and underground mining area was established. Data was obtained from monitoring points to calculate the disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient and barrier coefficient. Combined with the slope response index, the pillar thickness was optimized to maximize the comprehensive barrier effectiveness index.
It enables precise design of pillar thickness, quantitative assessment of barrier effectiveness, adaptation to different geological conditions, improvement of mining economic benefits, and enhancement of slope stability control.
Smart Images

Figure CN123116502A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] This invention relates to the field of boundary pillar thickness design technology, and in particular to a boundary pillar thickness optimization design method based on the attenuation characteristics of mining disturbance propagation. Background Technology
[0002] As the depth of open-pit mining continues to increase, more and more metal mines are transitioning from open-pit to underground mining. During this process, the excavation of underground mines disrupts the original rock stress balance, causing stress redistribution and displacement deformation in the surrounding rock, thus generating mining disturbances. These disturbances propagate through the overburden to the bottom of the open pit and the slopes, potentially causing slope settlement, increased horizontal displacement, and in severe cases, even inducing slope instability accidents.
[0003] Currently, common methods for determining the thickness of boundary pillars in engineering include the KB Rubeneit theory, Protodyakonov's arch theory, fixed beam theory, engineering calculation methods, the load transfer intersection method, and the thickness-to-span ratio method. These methods all focus on the pillar's own bearing capacity and structural stability, ensuring it does not fail under static load conditions. However, in actual engineering, boundary pillars, besides bearing the load from the overlying strata, also objectively act as a barrier to the propagation of underground mining disturbances to the slope. Their thickness directly affects the degree of attenuation of disturbances within the overlying strata. Existing design methods do not take this barrier effect into account.
[0004] Specifically, existing technologies suffer from several problems. First, there is a lack of systematic quantitative research on the attenuation patterns of mining disturbances propagating through pillars and overlying strata. The variation in disturbance intensity with pillar thickness lacks a clear mathematical or physical description. Second, there is a lack of indicators to measure the pillar's ability to block disturbances, making objective comparisons of the blocking effects between different thickness schemes impossible. Third, a quantitative correlation has not been established between pillar thickness and slope stability response, and there is a lack of clear stability control targets when adjusting thickness. Fourth, the design process largely relies on engineering experience; the differences in analogous conditions are significant, leading to high uncertainty in design results and making it difficult to generalize to different mining conditions.
[0005] Therefore, it is necessary to establish a boundary pillar thickness design method that can simultaneously take into account the pillar's own stability, disturbance isolation capacity, and slope stability, so as to provide a more scientific basis for pillar placement during the transition from open-pit to underground mining. Summary of the Invention
[0006] To achieve the above objectives, the present invention adopts the following technical solution: One aspect of the present invention provides a method for optimizing the design of boundary pillar thickness based on the attenuation characteristics of mining disturbance propagation, comprising the following steps: A three-dimensional numerical model of the open-pit slope, boundary pillar, and underground mining area was established. The three-dimensional numerical model includes the underground mining area, overburden strata, boundary pillar, and open-pit slope.
[0007] The three-dimensional numerical model is divided into the underground mining disturbance zone, the boundary pillar isolation zone, and the slope deformation response zone; monitoring points are set up in the hanging wall of the underground mining area, the middle of the overburden, the potential sliding surface, and the slope surface.
[0008] Displacement data of the mining area is obtained through monitoring points on the hanging wall of the underground mining area, displacement data of the overburden is obtained through monitoring points in the middle of the overburden, and displacement data of the slope is obtained through monitoring points on the potential sliding surface and the slope surface.
[0009] The disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient is calculated based on the stope displacement data and overlying rock displacement data. The mining disturbance isolation coefficient is calculated based on the stope displacement data and slope displacement data. Slope settlement data, horizontal displacement data, tilt data, curvature data, and horizontal deformation data are obtained. The slope response index is calculated based on the settlement data, horizontal displacement data, tilt data, curvature data, and horizontal deformation data to obtain the slope safety factor. The comprehensive isolation effectiveness index is calculated based on the mining disturbance isolation coefficient, disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient, slope safety factor, and slope response index.
[0010] Within a predetermined thickness range, the pillar thickness is assigned progressively, and the comprehensive barrier efficiency index corresponding to each thickness is calculated. The pillar thickness corresponding to the maximum value of the comprehensive barrier efficiency index is selected, and the pillar thickness corresponding to the maximum value is determined as the optimal boundary pillar thickness.
[0011] This invention utilizes a disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient that reflects the attenuation capacity of the overlying strata, a mining disturbance barrier coefficient that characterizes the active barrier effect of the pillar, a slope response index that reflects the terminal deformation characteristics, and a slope safety factor that ensures basic stability requirements. Through the systematic coupling of these four parameters, the limitations of single-parameter optimization are avoided. Safety and economic needs are automatically balanced, and the pillar structure function is dynamically optimized, ensuring both safety and improved resource recovery. This allows for precise design of pillar thickness, quantitative evaluation of pillar barrier effectiveness, adaptation to individual needs under different geological conditions, and significantly improved mining economic benefits. Slope stability control is also enhanced.
[0012] This invention establishes a three-dimensional numerical model of open-pit slope-boundary pillar-underground stope, achieving full-domain simulation of multi-system coupling effects. Through a complete geomechanical characterization including the underground stope, overburden, boundary pillar, and open-pit slope, it provides a fundamental computational domain for analyzing mining disturbance propagation. The division of the underground mining disturbance zone, the boundary pillar isolation zone, and the slope deformation response zone constructs a quantitative analysis framework for disturbance propagation paths. The monitoring point layout covers multi-source data acquisition of stope displacement, overburden displacement, and slope displacement, forming a full-chain monitoring network for mining disturbance propagation. The disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient, calculated jointly from stope displacement data and overburden displacement data, quantifies the energy dissipation characteristics of mining disturbances in the overburden; the mining disturbance blocking coefficient derived from stope displacement and slope displacement data characterizes the blocking effectiveness of the boundary pillar on disturbance waves. The fusion processing of slope settlement, horizontal displacement, tilt, curvature, and horizontal deformation data, through the slope response index, comprehensively reflects deformation compatibility and, together with the slope safety factor, constitutes a stability criterion. The comprehensive barrier effectiveness index integrates the mining disturbance barrier coefficient, disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient, slope safety factor, and slope response index to establish a mapping relationship between pillar thickness and system stability. An optimization algorithm that progressively assigns pillar thickness values and maximizes the matching with the comprehensive barrier effectiveness index achieves thickness design based on disturbance propagation attenuation characteristics and system response, enabling boundary pillars to simultaneously meet the dual requirements of stope stability control and slope deformation suppression. This embodiment achieves a scientific decision on the optimal pillar thickness by quantifying the energy attenuation and barrier effect in the disturbance propagation path. Attached Figure Description
[0013] The accompanying drawings are provided to further illustrate the invention and form part of the specification. They are used in conjunction with embodiments of the invention to explain the invention and do not constitute a limitation thereof. In the drawings: Figure 1 Flowchart of the boundary pillar thickness optimization design method based on mining disturbance propagation attenuation characteristics provided by the present invention; Figure 2 A schematic diagram of the boundary pillar thickness optimization design method based on the attenuation characteristics of mining disturbance propagation provided by this invention; Figure 3 A block diagram of the boundary pillar thickness optimization design system based on the attenuation characteristics of mining disturbance propagation provided by the present invention; Figure 4 A block diagram of a computer-readable storage medium provided for this invention; Reference numerals: 1. Monitoring deployment module; 2. Data acquisition module; 3. Index calculation module; 4. Thickness determination module; 5. Computer-readable instructions; 6. Non-transitory computer-readable storage medium. Detailed Implementation
[0014] The technical solutions of the present invention will now be described with reference to the accompanying drawings in the embodiments of the present invention. Obviously, the described embodiments are only some embodiments of the present invention, and not all embodiments.
[0015] like Figure 1 As shown, this embodiment of the invention provides a method for optimizing the design of boundary pillar thickness based on the attenuation characteristics of mining disturbance propagation, comprising the following steps: Step S100: Establish a three-dimensional numerical model of the open-pit slope, boundary pillar, and underground mining area; the three-dimensional numerical model includes the underground mining area, overburden layer, boundary pillar, and open-pit slope.
[0016] Specifically, the three-dimensional numerical model of open-pit slope-boundary pillar-underground mining area is the basic platform for implementing the method of this invention. It is used to simulate the complete physical process of the mining disturbance generated by the underground mining area during the transition from open-pit to underground mining, which propagates to the overlying rock and slope. The model needs to be established based on the actual geological conditions of the mine, the physical and mechanical parameters of the rock mass, and the mining engineering layout. The model should be able to realistically reflect the geometric shape of the mining area, the layered structure of the overlying rock, the occurrence state of the pillar, and the slope surface morphology, so as to provide a calculation domain that conforms to the actual engineering for the disturbance attenuation calculation. The underground stope, overburden, boundary pillars, and open-pit slope constitute the complete propagation path of mining disturbance from the source to the protected object. The underground stope is the location of the disturbance source, from which the elastic strain energy released by excavation and unloading radiates outward. The overburden, located above the stope, is the intermediate medium for disturbance propagation, and its thickness and lithology directly affect the attenuation rate of the disturbance. The boundary pillar, located between the overburden and the slope, is the only artificially created barrier structure in the entire path, and its thickness changes the boundary conditions for disturbance propagation. The open-pit slope, located at the end of the path, is the protected object, and its deformation and stability are the final criteria for evaluating whether the pillar's barrier effect meets the requirements.
[0017] As a preferred approach, the process of establishing a three-dimensional numerical model of the open-pit slope, boundary pillars, and underground mining area specifically includes the following steps: Step S101: Obtain actual geological conditions data, rock mass physical and mechanical parameters, and mining engineering layout map of the mining area. Based on the data, establish a three-dimensional numerical model of open-pit slope-boundary pillar-underground stope. The three-dimensional numerical model is used to simulate the propagation process of mining disturbance towards the overlying rock and slope. Step S102: Set the geometric boundary conditions of the three-dimensional numerical model, and construct the underground mining excavation outline, overburden layer structure, boundary pillar occurrence form and open-pit slope form within the model respectively; form a complete propagation path including the four components of underground mining, overburden layer, boundary pillar and open-pit slope. Step S103: Divide the complete propagation path along the direction of disturbance propagation into the underground mining disturbance zone, the boundary pillar isolation zone, and the slope deformation response zone. The underground mining disturbance zone is used to characterize the initial intensity of the disturbance source, the boundary pillar isolation zone is used to provide a disturbance barrier structure, and the slope deformation response zone is used to evaluate the degree of influence of residual disturbance on the slope.
[0018] Specifically: Actual geological data of the mining area, including stratum occurrence, lithological distribution, location of tectonic fault zones, and groundwater occurrence, forms the fundamental basis for determining the geometric framework of the model. Rock mass physical and mechanical parameters, including density, elastic modulus, Poisson's ratio, cohesion, internal friction angle, and tensile strength, are the core inputs that assign material properties to each rock stratum in the model. The mining layout plan includes stope dimensions, mining depth, mining sequence, pre-set pillar locations, and slope termination boundaries, providing geometric constraints for constructing the excavation outline and pillar occurrence morphology within the model. All three types of data are indispensable and together constitute the input conditions for model establishment. Establishing a three-dimensional numerical model of the open-pit slope-boundary pillar-underground stope involves inputting the aforementioned data into numerical calculation software, such as FLAC3D, ABAQUS, or MIDAS GTS, and creating a three-dimensional mesh model according to the actual coordinate range. During modeling, each rock stratum needs to be assigned corresponding material parameters according to its actual thickness and dip angle. The excavation area and boundary pillar area should be set at the corresponding locations in the model according to the mining engineering layout drawing. Modeling can be achieved using conventional finite difference or finite element methods, and can be repeated based on the input data. The model serves as a computational platform for zoning, monitoring point placement, and disturbance propagation analysis. Geometric boundary conditions are displacement and mechanical constraints applied to the outer boundary of the model to simulate the actual ore body's environment in infinite or semi-infinite rock masses. Typically, a fully constrained fixed boundary is applied to the bottom of the model, rolling boundaries with normal constraints are applied to the four sides, and the top surface (the ground surface) is set as a free boundary. The boundary conditions directly affect the reflection characteristics of disturbance waves at the model boundaries. Reasonable boundary conditions can avoid interference from artificial boundaries on the disturbance propagation results, ensuring that the stress and displacement field distributions within the computational domain conform to engineering reality. The underground mining excavation profile refers to the three-dimensional geometry of the goaf generated in the model according to the mining engineering layout drawing. Its size and spatial location determine the distribution range and initial intensity of the disturbance source. The overburden layered structure is a layered rock mass unit established between the stope and pillars according to the actual stratigraphic sequence. Each layer is assigned mechanical parameters corresponding to the actual lithology, and the layered structure controls the attenuation gradient of disturbance propagation in the vertical direction. The boundary pillar occurrence morphology is a solid unit established between the overburden and the slope according to the preset position of the pillar. Its geometry includes width, thickness, and boundary dip angle, and is the core variable for optimization design. The open-pit slope surface morphology is the slope geometry constructed at the model surface according to the final boundary. Its slope angle, slope height, and step structure determine the slope's sensitivity to disturbance. The above four geometric elements together constitute the physical path entity of disturbance propagation from the source to the slope surface. The disturbance propagation direction refers to the spatial direction of the elastic waves and displacement fields generated by stope excavation and unloading, which are transmitted layer by layer from the surrounding rock of the stope to the overburden, through the pillars, and to the slope. Generally, it is a vector direction radiating from deep to shallow and from the center of the stope to the surrounding areas. The direction determines the vertical order of the model partitions and the location of the monitoring points. All partition divisions and monitoring point deployments are carried out sequentially along the direction.The complete propagation path consists of four sequentially connected parts: the underground stope, the overburden layer, the boundary pillar, and the open-pit slope. Each part is both the recipient of the disturbance propagation in the previous stage and the donor of the disturbance transmission in the next stage. The initial disturbance at the stope first enters the overburden layer and undergoes natural attenuation, then enters the pillar through the overburden layer and undergoes barrier attenuation, and finally enters the slope through the pillar, causing a deformation response. The integrity and continuity of the path are the logical basis for incorporating the four components into a unified analysis framework. The initial intensity of the disturbance source refers to the stope displacement data obtained from monitoring point A after the stope excavation is completed. The data characterizes the original energy level of the disturbance when it is just generated and has not yet propagated outward. The initial intensity serves as the benchmark reference value for calculating the disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient and the mining disturbance barrier coefficient. All attenuation ratios are normalized with the value as the denominator, and its accuracy directly affects the reliability of the final optimization results. The disturbance barrier structure refers to the boundary pillar itself. Mine pillars, with their inherent material rigidity and strength, form a solid barrier along the path of disturbance propagation from the overlying rock to the slope, reducing the transmitted energy of the disturbance wave through absorption, reflection, and scattering. The greater the pillar thickness, the longer the path required for the disturbance wave to traverse it, resulting in more efficient energy dissipation and a more significant blocking effect. The structure is the unique entry point that distinguishes this invention from existing methods; its blocking capability is quantitatively evaluated using a mining disturbance blocking coefficient. Residual disturbance refers to the remaining energy of the elastic waves and displacement fields from mining disturbances after undergoing both natural attenuation by the overlying rock and forced blocking by the pillar, ultimately reaching the slope. Residual energy is expressed as indicators such as slope settlement, horizontal displacement, tilt, curvature, and horizontal deformation. The magnitude of residual disturbance directly determines the severity of the slope deformation response; when it exceeds the allowable deformation value of the slope rock mass, the slope faces the risk of instability. Therefore, the degree of influence of residual disturbance on the slope is the ultimate criterion for judging the feasibility of the current pillar thickness scheme, characterized jointly by the slope response index and the slope safety factor.
[0019] In the embodiments of steps S101-S103, the geological data and engineering parameter fusion modeling technology of this embodiment integrates geological condition data of the mining area, rock mass physical and mechanical parameters, and mining engineering layout diagrams to construct a three-dimensional numerical model. This provides a high-precision calculation carrier for the quantitative simulation of mining disturbance propagation paths, ensuring the reliability of disturbance propagation attenuation characteristic analysis; it directly serves the basic data requirements for boundary pillar thickness optimization design. The multi-component coupled modeling technology accurately restores the three-dimensional spatial relationship of underground mining area-overburden-boundary pillar-open-pit slope through geometric boundary condition setting and four-component morphological reconstruction, establishing a complete disturbance propagation path model; it provides a geometric basis for zoning evaluation and is a prerequisite for analyzing pillar isolation effectiveness and slope response. The disturbance propagation zoning quantification technology divides the propagation path into mining disturbance zone, pillar isolation zone, and slope response zone, enabling segmented monitoring of disturbance intensity from the source to the end. This supports the core requirement for pillar thickness optimization design: inverting the optimal pillar thickness through attenuation characteristics of the isolation zone, verifying the rationality of the pillar design through deformation data of the response zone, and forming a complete feedback optimization loop. These three technical features together constitute the technical system for analyzing the attenuation characteristics of mining disturbance propagation, providing full-process numerical simulation support for boundary pillar thickness optimization.
[0020] Step S200: Divide the three-dimensional numerical model into the underground mining disturbance zone, the boundary pillar isolation zone, and the slope deformation response zone; set up monitoring points on the hanging wall of the underground stope, the middle of the overburden, the potential sliding surface, and the slope surface.
[0021] Specifically, the model is longitudinally divided into three functional zones along the direction of disturbance propagation: the underground mining disturbance zone, the boundary pillar isolation zone, and the slope deformation response zone. The underground mining disturbance zone, centered on the stope, covers a high-stress area directly affected by excavation within a certain radius around the stope; displacement changes within this zone represent the initial intensity of the disturbance source. The boundary pillar isolation zone, primarily composed of pillars, is a key section along the disturbance propagation path; the pillars, through their stiffness and strength, act as a barrier and attenuator against the disturbance. The slope deformation response zone focuses on the open-pit slope; the degree of deformation response within this zone directly reflects the residual disturbance intensity after being blocked by the pillars. Monitoring points are deployed in the hanging wall of the underground stope, located near the disturbance source and adjacent to the excavation boundary. The acquired displacement data reflects the immediate displacement response of the surrounding rock after stope excavation. The displacement is the largest numerically and serves as the benchmark for judging the initial intensity of the disturbance; all attenuation coefficients are calculated and normalized based on this value. Monitoring points are set up in the middle of the overburden layer, near the lower boundary of the boundary pillar. The acquired overburden displacement data reflects the residual displacement of mining disturbances after propagating through a certain thickness of overburden. Comparing the overburden displacement data with the stope displacement data allows for the quantitative separation of the attenuation amplitude when the disturbance propagates solely within the overburden. This attenuation process is independent of the pillar's presence and serves as a background reference for evaluating the pillar's blocking capacity. Monitoring points are set up at the location of the most dangerous slip surface, pre-determined through slope stability analysis. This is the weakest link in the slope's anti-slip capacity, and its displacement changes directly reflect whether the slip surface has been affected by disturbances, resulting in strength deterioration or increased deformation. This provides a direct basis for determining whether the pillar thickness is sufficient to control the slip surface stability. Monitoring points are set up on the surface of the open slope, which is the final end point of the disturbance propagation path. The displacement data obtained reflects the residual energy of the mining disturbance that finally reaches the slope after passing through the double barrier of overburden and pillar. By combining the monitoring data of the slope surface with the monitoring data of the potential sliding surface, we can comprehensively judge the different impacts of the disturbance on the slope surface and the interior of the slope.
[0022] Step S300: Obtain mining displacement data through monitoring points on the hanging wall of the underground mining area, obtain overburden displacement data through monitoring points in the middle of the overburden, and obtain slope displacement data through monitoring points on the potential sliding surface and slope surface.
[0023] Specifically: Stope displacement data represents the total displacement of the surrounding rock obtained from monitoring points after the underground stope excavation is completed. The numerical value characterizes the original intensity of the disturbance. As the fundamental reference value for all attenuation analyses, its accuracy directly affects the calculation accuracy of the disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient and the mining disturbance barrier coefficient. Overburden displacement data represents the residual displacement of the surrounding rock obtained when the disturbance propagates to the middle of the overburden. It represents the intensity level of the disturbance after attenuation through overburden propagation. By establishing a comparison between overburden displacement and stope displacement, the natural attenuation characteristics of the disturbance during overburden propagation can be quantified separately. These characteristics are related to lithology, bedding, and thickness. Slope displacement data is the displacement value obtained by combining monitoring results from both the potential sliding surface and the slope surface. It represents the actual impact of the disturbance on the slope after traversing the entire propagation path. This data is the direct criterion for ultimately assessing whether the pillar barrier effect meets the standards and is also a key parameter for calculating the mining disturbance barrier coefficient.
[0024] The acquisition process for stope displacement data, overburden displacement data, and slope displacement data is as follows: After completing the zoning and monitoring point layout in the three-dimensional numerical model, numerical simulation calculations for underground stope excavation are performed. The simulation calculation adopts a step-by-step excavation method, excavating each layer of the stope sequentially according to the actual mining sequence. After each step of excavation is completed, iterative calculations are performed until the model reaches equilibrium and convergence. After all excavation steps are completed and the model reaches static equilibrium, the displacement data is extracted. The total displacement of the surrounding rock is extracted through monitoring points deployed in the hanging wall of the underground stope. The monitoring points are located in the hanging wall of the goaf, adjacent to the excavation boundary. The extracted displacement values reflect the instantaneous displacement response of the surrounding rock after the stope excavation and unloading. The displacement value is the largest among all monitoring points, reflecting the original intensity level of mining disturbance, and is the benchmark reference value for calculating the disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient and the mining disturbance isolation coefficient. The displacement of the surrounding rock at the location is extracted through monitoring points deployed in the middle of the overburden. The monitoring points are located in the middle of the overburden thickness, near the boundary below the pillar. The extracted displacement values reflect the residual displacement level after the mining disturbance has propagated and attenuated through the overburden. Since the monitoring points are located below the pillar, the obtained displacement data has not yet been affected by the pillar's blocking effect. Therefore, comparing them with the stope displacement data allows for the separate quantification of the natural attenuation amplitude of the disturbance during its propagation through the overburden. This attenuation amplitude serves as a background reference for evaluating the pillar's own blocking capacity. Slope displacement data is extracted by monitoring points deployed at potential sliding surfaces and slope surfaces. Monitoring points at potential sliding surfaces are located at the most dangerous slip surfaces pre-determined through slope stability analysis. The extracted displacement data reflects whether the disturbance has affected the deep slip surfaces of the slope. Monitoring points at the slope surface are located on the open-pit slope. The extracted displacement data reflects the residual impact of the mining disturbance that finally reaches the slope surface after being blocked by both the overburden and the pillar. The displacement values extracted from the two monitoring points were weighted to obtain slope displacement data. This data characterizes the actual impact of the disturbance on the end of the entire propagation path and serves as the final criterion for assessing whether the pillar isolation effect meets the standards. All three types of displacement data were extracted in batches after the same model calculation was completed. The extraction time points were all the same calculation time step after the final excavation step was completed and the model reached equilibrium convergence, ensuring the consistency of the data in time and guaranteeing the reliability of the coefficient calculations.
[0025] Step S400: Calculate the disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient based on the stope displacement data and overlying rock displacement data; calculate the mining disturbance isolation coefficient based on the stope displacement data and slope displacement data; obtain slope settlement data, horizontal displacement data, tilt data, curvature data, and horizontal deformation data; calculate the slope response index based on the settlement data, horizontal displacement data, tilt data, curvature data, and horizontal deformation data; obtain the slope safety factor; calculate the comprehensive isolation effectiveness index based on the mining disturbance isolation coefficient, disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient, slope safety factor, and slope response index.
[0026] Specifically, the disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient is characterized by the ratio of the difference between stope displacement and overburden displacement to the total stope displacement, reflecting the degree of natural attenuation of mining disturbances propagating in the overburden. The thicker and more intact the overburden, the larger the coefficient value, indicating that the disturbance has already attenuated to a greater extent before reaching the pillar, and the barrier burden on the pillar is correspondingly reduced. The mining disturbance barrier coefficient is characterized by the ratio of the difference between stope displacement and slope displacement to the total stope displacement, and is a core indicator for measuring the barrier capacity of boundary pillars against the propagation of mining disturbances. The larger the coefficient value, the more significant the barrier effect of the pillar on the disturbance, and the smaller the impact of residual disturbance on the slope. The introduction of this coefficient compensates for the lack of quantitative indicators of barrier capacity in existing methods. Five data points—slope settlement, horizontal displacement, tilt, curvature, and horizontal deformation—describe the slope's deformation behavior under mining disturbance from five different dimensions: vertical direction, horizontal direction, rotation angle, degree of bending, and tension / compression. A single index cannot fully reflect the slope's deformation state; the five indices each have their own emphasis and complement each other, collectively forming a comprehensive description of the slope's response characteristics. The slope response index is obtained by summing the weights of the five deformation data points, compressing the multi-dimensional deformation response into a single comprehensive index. The weighting coefficients are determined based on the degree of influence of each deformation index on slope stability, with larger weights assigned to indicators with greater influence. The smaller the index value, the less severe the slope deformation under disturbance, and the more stable the slope state. The slope safety factor is calculated using the limit equilibrium method or numerical analysis method and is used to quantitatively evaluate whether the slope's anti-sliding stability meets the specifications under the current pillar thickness. The coefficient is a rigid criterion constraining the optimization process; if a certain thickness scheme has a high comprehensive barrier effectiveness index but the safety factor does not meet the requirements, the scheme is not engineering feasible. The comprehensive barrier effectiveness index takes into account four indicators: mining disturbance barrier coefficient, disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient, slope safety factor, and slope response index. The first two focus on reflecting the barrier and attenuation capacity of the pillar to disturbance, while the latter two focus on reflecting the stability and deformation state of the slope after barrier. The four indicators are combined by weighted summation and the introduction of a penalty term. When the slope response index is too large or the safety factor is insufficient, the effectiveness value is penalized to ensure that the optimization result takes into account both barrier capacity and safety requirements.
[0027] As a preferred method, the process of calculating the comprehensive barrier effectiveness index based on the mining disturbance barrier coefficient, disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient, slope safety factor, and slope response index specifically includes the following steps: Step S401: Calculation of mining disturbance barrier coefficient, the stope displacement data has been obtained in step S300. and slope displacement data ,in Extracted from monitoring points in the hanging wall of the underground mining area, it characterizes the original intensity of mining disturbance. The residual strength of the disturbance as it propagates to the slope is characterized by comprehensive extraction from monitoring points on the potential sliding surface and slope surface. To quantitatively evaluate the barrier capacity of the boundary pillar to mining disturbance, the mining disturbance barrier coefficient is calculated using the following formula. : The physical meaning of the formula lies in: mining area displacement data With slope displacement data The difference represents the total amount of mining disturbance that is reduced due to pillar obstruction during its propagation; the difference accounts for a percentage of the original displacement. The higher the proportion, the more significant the barrier effect of the pillar on disturbance. It is a dimensionless index, with a value between 0 and 1. When When the value approaches 1, it indicates that the pillar almost completely blocks mining disturbance, and the residual disturbance reaching the slope is extremely weak; when When the value approaches 0, it indicates that the pillar has not played an effective role in blocking the disturbance, and the disturbance is transmitted to the slope with almost no attenuation. The larger the value, the stronger the barrier capacity of the pillar and the smaller the impact of disturbance on the slope; Step S402: Calculation of disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient. The mining area displacement data has been obtained in step S300. and overburden displacement data ,in Characterizes the original strength of the perturbation. Extracted from monitoring points in the middle of the overburden, this represents the residual intensity of disturbances propagating through the overburden but before being affected by pillars. To quantitatively evaluate the attenuation of mining disturbances during natural propagation in the overburden, the disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient is calculated using the following formula. : The physical meaning of the formula lies in: mining area displacement data With overburden displacement data The difference represents the natural attenuation of the disturbance within the overburden layer due to factors such as rock mass damping, bedding absorption, and energy dissipation. This difference accounts for a significant portion of the original displacement. The higher the proportion, the stronger the natural attenuation effect of the overlying strata on the disturbance. This is a dimensionless index with values between 0 and 1; the coefficient serves as a background reference, distinguishing the contribution of natural overburden attenuation and forced pillar isolation to the total attenuation. The larger the value, the greater the proportion of disturbance that has been reduced before reaching the pillar, and the corresponding burden of subsequent obstruction that the pillar needs to bear is reduced. Step S403: Establishment and calculation of slope response index. In step S400, five deformation data of the slope under mining disturbance have been obtained, namely settlement data. Horizontal displacement data skewed data curvature data and horizontal deformation data Among them, settlement data Characterizing the vertical settlement of the slope; horizontal displacement data. Characterizing the horizontal displacement of the slope; tilt data Characterizing the change in the rotation angle of the slope surface in the vertical plane; curvature data Characterizing changes in the curvature of the slope surface; horizontal deformation data This index characterizes the tensile or compressive deformation of a slope in the horizontal direction. Five data points describe the slope's deformation response characteristics from different dimensions; a single index cannot fully reflect this, and the five complement each other. To compress the deformation response information from multiple dimensions into a single comprehensive index, a slope response index is established using the following formula. : in, , , , , These are the weighting coefficients for the five deformation data points. The specific values of the weighting coefficients are determined based on the degree of influence of each deformation index on slope stability. Deformation indices with a greater impact on slope stability are assigned higher weight values. All weighting coefficients are dimensionless positive numbers and their sum is 1. The formula means that the weighted deformation values of the five items are summed to obtain the total value. This is the slope response index, used to quantitatively evaluate the overall deformation response of a slope under the influence of residual energy from mining disturbance. The smaller the value, the less the slope deforms under mining disturbance, and the better the slope stability. Step S404: Establishment and calculation of the comprehensive barrier effectiveness index, based on the calculated mining disturbance barrier coefficient. The disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient has been calculated. In step S400, the slope safety factor has been obtained using the limit equilibrium method or numerical analysis method. The slope response index has been calculated. The above four indicators reflect the comprehensive performance of the pillar thickness scheme from different perspectives: and It focuses on reflecting the ability of pillars and overlying rocks to block and attenuate disturbances. It focuses on reflecting whether the slope's anti-sliding stability meets safety requirements. This focuses on reflecting the actual degree of deformation of the slope under residual disturbance. To integrate the above four indicators into a unified comprehensive performance value for comparing the advantages and disadvantages of different thickness schemes, this step establishes a comprehensive barrier performance index using the following formula. : in, These are the mining disturbance barrier coefficients. Disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient and slope safety factor The corresponding positive weighting coefficients are determined based on the degree of influence of each indicator on the overall performance of the pillar; the greater the influence, the higher the weighting value. Slope response index The corresponding penalty coefficient is determined based on the degree of harm that slope deformation poses to stability; the greater the harm, the higher the penalty coefficient. The formula means: [The formula is missing here, so the translation ends here.] and The product of and The product of and The sum of the three products reflects the positive contributions of barrier capability, attenuation level, and safety status to overall effectiveness; then subtract... and The product term reflects the negative penalty on overall effectiveness when the slope deformation response is too large. When the slope response index... Excessive or slope safety factor Penalties for not meeting the requirements · Plays a leading role, making the comprehensive barrier effectiveness index Significantly reduced, thereby ensuring that the optimization results take into account both barrier capability and safety requirements; It is a dimensionless comprehensive index; the larger the value, the better the overall performance of the current pillar thickness scheme.
[0028] In the embodiments of steps S401-S404, the stope displacement data of this embodiment serves as a benchmark reference value, forming two sets of comparative relationships with the slope displacement data and overburden displacement data, respectively. One set of comparisons forms the mining disturbance isolation coefficient, and the other set forms the disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient. These two coefficients quantify the degree of disturbance reduction in different sections of the propagation path from the two dimensions of pillar isolation and natural overburden attenuation. When used together, they can separate the natural attenuation of disturbance in the overburden layer from the forced isolation of the disturbance by the pillar, determining their respective contributions to the total disturbance reduction. This allows the pillar's own isolation capacity to be independently separated from the total attenuation, avoiding the misattribution of the overburden attenuation effect to the pillar's isolation capacity, and ensuring the objectivity and accuracy of the pillar isolation effect evaluation. The slope response index, through weighted integration of five deformation data, compresses the complex deformation response of the slope in multiple directions and forms into a single quantitative indicator, achieving a comprehensive judgment of the severity of slope deformation; the slope safety factor provides another dimension of evaluation from the perspective of anti-sliding stability. When used in combination, both indicators provide a comprehensive understanding of the slope's actual deformation appearance and determine whether the slope meets safety standards in terms of anti-sliding stability. One indicator reflects the deformation state, and the other reflects the stability state; they complement each other, forming a complete description of the overall condition of the slope after disturbance, avoiding the one-sidedness of evaluation by a single indicator. The mining disturbance barrier coefficient, disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient, slope safety factor, and slope response index reflect different aspects of the same pillar thickness scheme from four dimensions: pillar isolation capacity, overburden attenuation degree, slope stability state, and slope deformation response. By integrating the four indicators into a comprehensive barrier effectiveness index according to their respective weights and penalty coefficients, a unified quantification and centralized expression of the information in the four dimensions is achieved. Among them, the first three indicators are included in the effectiveness value with positive weights, while the slope response index is included in the effectiveness value with a penalty. When the slope response index is too large or the slope safety factor does not meet the specification requirements, the penalty term significantly reduces the comprehensive barrier effectiveness index, thereby automatically filtering out thickness schemes that do not meet safety constraints in the effectiveness evaluation. The comprehensive index transforms multiple heterogeneous indicators that are difficult to compare directly into a single comparable effectiveness value, providing a unified measurement scale for ranking the merits of different thickness schemes.
[0029] In summary, the stope displacement data, overburden displacement data, and slope displacement data in this embodiment were acquired sequentially along the disturbance propagation path, corresponding to three key locations: the disturbance source, the middle of the overburden, and the end of the slope, respectively, forming a complete data chain from the generation of the disturbance to its attenuation and final residue. The mining disturbance blocking coefficient and the disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient were calculated based on data comparisons of different segments in the data chain, quantitatively describing the gradual attenuation characteristics of the disturbance during propagation. The slope response index and slope safety factor evaluated the final state of the slope under the residual disturbance from both deformation and stability perspectives. The comprehensive blocking effectiveness index summarizes all the above information into a single effectiveness value. By transforming the pillar thickness from empirical selection to optimized calculation based on quantitative analysis of disturbance propagation attenuation, the independent quantification of pillar blocking capacity, the dual verification of slope stability, and the optimal selection of pillar thickness effectiveness were achieved.
[0030] Step S500: Assign values to the pillar thickness step by step within the predetermined thickness range, calculate the comprehensive barrier efficiency index corresponding to each thickness, and select the pillar thickness corresponding to the maximum value of the comprehensive barrier efficiency index; determine the pillar thickness corresponding to the maximum value as the optimal boundary pillar thickness.
[0031] Specifically, the thickness range is a feasible range for pillar thickness determined comprehensively based on mine geological conditions, stope span, overburden thickness, and practical experience from similar mines. The lower limit should meet the minimum thickness requirement to prevent the pillar from fracturing, while the upper limit is limited by resource recovery rate and mining economics. The range defines a reasonable boundary for the optimization search, avoiding calculation results that exceed the actual feasible range of the project. The pillar thickness is assigned step-by-step by taking different thickness values sequentially within the thickness range according to a preset step size. Each thickness value corresponds to an independent calculation scheme, completing the entire analysis process from model establishment to the calculation of the comprehensive barrier effectiveness index. By comparing and ranking the effectiveness indices of all schemes, the thickness value corresponding to the most effective one is selected. This thickness is the optimal design thickness that balances pillar stability and disturbance barrier capability.
[0032] As a preferred method, the process of selecting the pillar thickness corresponding to the maximum value of the comprehensive barrier effectiveness index specifically includes the following steps: Step S501: Determine the preset range of pillar thickness based on the geological conditions of the mining area and engineering experience. Generate multiple candidate thickness values within the range of thickness values at a fixed step size. Establish a corresponding numerical model for each candidate thickness value and calculate its respective comprehensive barrier effectiveness index to form a set of multi-scheme calculation results consisting of thickness values and their effectiveness indices. Step S502: Using the set of calculation results from multiple schemes as input, iterate through and compare the comprehensive barrier efficiency index corresponding to each candidate thickness value; select the candidate thickness value corresponding to the maximum value of the comprehensive barrier efficiency index; output the candidate thickness value and determine it as the optimal boundary pillar thickness.
[0033] A numerical model for optimizing pillar thickness is established, assuming: ; calculate separately: Pick: The corresponding thickness is the optimal pillar thickness. Indicates the first The candidate pillar thickness values, in meters, are independent variables in the optimization model. The index is a natural number representing the position of the thickness value in the sequence. The thickness range is determined comprehensively based on the mine's geological conditions, stope span, overlying strata thickness, and similar mine practices. The lower limit meets the minimum thickness requirement to prevent the pillar from fracturing, while the upper limit is limited by resource recovery rate and mining economics. Within the preset range, values are assigned step by step at fixed intervals. Each assignment corresponds to an independent calculation scheme, completing the entire analysis process from model establishment to comprehensive barrier performance index calculation. Indicates the first Thickness values of candidate ore pillars The comprehensive barrier effectiveness index calculated under the given conditions is the dependent variable in the optimization model and is dimensionless. The index integrates the four indicators of mining disturbance barrier coefficient, disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient, slope safety factor and slope response index into a comprehensive effectiveness value according to their respective weights and penalty coefficients through the aforementioned steps. It is used to quantitatively evaluate the comprehensive performance of the pillar barrier capacity, disturbance attenuation degree, slope safety status and slope deformation response under the thickness scheme. The thickness represents the optimal pillar thickness in meters and is the output of the optimization model. The thickness value is selected from all candidate thickness values within the preset range. The thickness value that corresponds to the maximum value of the comprehensive barrier performance index is the optimal design thickness that takes into account both the stability of the pillar itself and the barrier capability against mining disturbances. This indicates the comprehensive barrier effectiveness index. The operation of retrieving the value of the independent variable when it reaches its maximum value. Specifically, it means: among all candidate thickness values... and the corresponding calculated comprehensive barrier effectiveness index In the middle, find the The one with the largest value value, and will The thickness value corresponding to the value As the optimal thickness Output. The operation is the standard maximum value operator in mathematical optimization, ensuring that the selected thickness is the best in terms of overall performance among all candidate solutions.
[0034] In the embodiment of steps S501-S502, this embodiment generates candidate thickness values by pre-setting a range of pillar thickness values and a fixed step size, ensuring the rationality and completeness of the thickness scheme. The lower limit of the range ensures that the pillar will not be damaged by fracturing, while the upper limit takes into account resource recovery rate and economy, covering the scope of actual engineering needs. An independent numerical model is established for each candidate thickness value and the comprehensive barrier performance index is calculated, forming a set of calculation results for multiple schemes, providing a data basis for optimization; the comprehensive impact of different thickness schemes on mining disturbance barrier, propagation attenuation, slope safety, and deformation response is quantified. By iterating and comparing the comprehensive barrier performance index corresponding to each candidate thickness, the objective function is globally optimized, and the candidate thickness value that maximizes the comprehensive barrier performance index is selected as the optimal solution, ensuring that the pillar design achieves optimal comprehensive performance in four dimensions: barrier capacity, disturbance attenuation, slope stability, and deformation control; the steps use the standard maximum value operator argmax to complete mathematical optimization, and the output result is the optimal thickness that takes into account both the stability of the pillar itself and the barrier capacity against mining disturbance. Parameters As independent variables in the model, their value sequence covers the feasible region of the project, providing ample search space for optimization. Dependent variable By integrating the weighted results of four key indicators, a mapping relationship between thickness and overall performance is established. Output variables. By maximizing The technology essentially transforms a multi-objective decision-making problem into a single-objective optimization problem, enabling scientific and quantitative decision-making on the design thickness. The entire process couples numerical modeling with optimization algorithms to achieve precise design and performance verification of the pillar thickness.
[0035] The principle of the boundary pillar thickness optimization design method based on the attenuation characteristics of mining disturbance propagation provided in this embodiment of the invention needs to be referred to the appendix. Figure 2 In the appendix Figure 2 First, a three-dimensional numerical model including the underground mine, overburden, boundary pillar, and open-pit slope is established. Then, the area is divided into three zones, and monitoring points are set up in the underground mine, the middle of the overburden, the potential sliding surface, and the surface of the slope. Next, the displacement data of the mine, overburden, and slope are acquired. Then, key coefficients such as the disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient, the mining disturbance isolation coefficient, and the slope safety coefficient are calculated. Subsequently, the optimal pillar thickness is determined by assigning values step by step and comparing efficiency. Finally, the optimal boundary pillar thickness is output.
[0036] In the embodiments of steps S100-S500, the establishment of the three-dimensional numerical model of the open-pit slope-boundary pillar-underground mining area in this embodiment realizes the full-domain simulation of the coupling effect of multiple systems. Through a complete geomechanical characterization including the underground mining area, overburden, boundary pillar, and open-pit slope, it provides a basic computational domain for the analysis of mining disturbance propagation. The division of the underground mining disturbance zone, the boundary pillar isolation zone, and the slope deformation response zone constructs a quantitative analysis framework for the disturbance propagation path. The monitoring point layout scheme covers multi-source data acquisition of mining area displacement, overburden displacement, and slope displacement, forming a full-chain monitoring network for mining disturbance propagation. The disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient calculated jointly by mining area displacement data and overburden displacement data quantifies the energy dissipation characteristics of mining disturbance in the overburden; the mining disturbance blocking coefficient derived from mining area displacement and slope displacement data characterizes the blocking effectiveness of the boundary pillar on the disturbance wave. The fusion processing of slope settlement, horizontal displacement, tilt, curvature, and horizontal deformation data comprehensively reflects the deformation coordination through the slope response index, which, together with the slope safety factor, constitutes a stability criterion. The comprehensive barrier effectiveness index integrates the mining disturbance barrier coefficient, disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient, slope safety factor, and slope response index to establish a mapping relationship between pillar thickness and system stability. An optimization algorithm that progressively assigns pillar thickness values and maximizes the matching with the comprehensive barrier effectiveness index achieves thickness design based on disturbance propagation attenuation characteristics and system response, enabling boundary pillars to simultaneously meet the dual requirements of stope stability control and slope deformation suppression. This embodiment achieves a scientific decision on the optimal pillar thickness by quantifying the energy attenuation and barrier effect in the disturbance propagation path.
[0037] This invention establishes a quantitative evaluation index for the blocking capacity of pillars for the first time, realizes quantitative analysis of the propagation process of mining disturbance, enables optimized design of pillar thickness, reduces resource loss caused by excessively thick pillars, and improves slope stability.
[0038] It should be noted that, for the sake of simplicity, the foregoing method embodiments are all described as a series of actions. However, those skilled in the art should understand that the present invention is not limited to the described order of actions, because according to the present invention, some steps can be performed in other orders or simultaneously. Furthermore, those skilled in the art should also understand that the embodiments described in the specification are all optional embodiments, and the actions and modules involved are not necessarily essential to the present invention.
[0039] The above is an introduction to the method embodiments. The following is a further explanation of the boundary pillar thickness optimization design scheme based on the mining disturbance propagation attenuation characteristics of the present invention through an embodiment of the boundary pillar thickness optimization design system based on the mining disturbance propagation attenuation characteristics.
[0040] like Figure 3As shown, this embodiment of the invention provides a boundary pillar thickness optimization design system based on the attenuation characteristics of mining disturbance propagation, comprising: Monitoring deployment module 1 is used to divide the three-dimensional numerical model into the underground mining disturbance zone, the boundary pillar isolation zone, and the slope deformation response zone; monitoring points are deployed on the hanging wall of the underground mining area, the middle of the overburden, the potential sliding surface, and the slope surface.
[0041] Data acquisition module 2 is used to acquire mining displacement data through monitoring points on the hanging wall of the underground mining area, overburden displacement data through monitoring points in the middle of the overburden, and slope displacement data through monitoring points on the potential sliding surface and slope surface.
[0042] The index calculation module 3 is used to calculate the disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient based on the stope displacement data and overlying rock displacement data, calculate the mining disturbance isolation coefficient based on the stope displacement data and slope displacement data, and obtain slope settlement data, horizontal displacement data, tilt data, curvature data, and horizontal deformation data; calculate the slope response index based on the settlement data, horizontal displacement data, tilt data, curvature data, and horizontal deformation data, and obtain the slope safety factor; and calculate the comprehensive isolation effectiveness index based on the mining disturbance isolation coefficient, disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient, slope safety factor, and slope response index.
[0043] Thickness determination module 4 is used to assign values to the pillar thickness step by step within a predetermined thickness range, calculate the comprehensive barrier efficiency index corresponding to each thickness, select the pillar thickness corresponding to the maximum value of the comprehensive barrier efficiency index, and determine the pillar thickness corresponding to the maximum value as the optimal boundary pillar thickness.
[0044] This embodiment establishes a three-dimensional numerical model including the underground mining area, overburden, boundary pillars, and open-pit slope, providing accurate geometric boundary conditions and mechanical calculation basis for disturbance propagation analysis and pillar thickness optimization. The model can reflect the actual mining disturbance propagation path and rock mass failure characteristics, laying a computational framework for quantifying the disturbance propagation attenuation law. By dividing the three-dimensional numerical model into the underground mining disturbance zone, the boundary pillar isolation zone, and the slope deformation response zone, and deploying monitoring points at key locations, a complete disturbance propagation monitoring network is formed. The deployment scheme ensures that the deformation response data of the entire process of mining disturbance transmission from the underground mining area through the boundary pillar to the open-pit slope can be captured, providing a data acquisition basis for the disturbance propagation law and the pillar blocking effect. Through multi-source monitoring data, real-time data of mining area displacement, overburden displacement, and slope displacement are collected to form a dynamic dataset of the disturbance propagation process. The module realizes dynamic monitoring of rock mass deformation under the influence of mining disturbance, providing high-precision input data for calculating the disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient, blocking coefficient, and slope response index. Based on monitoring data, the disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient, mining disturbance barrier coefficient, slope response index, and slope safety factor are calculated to quantitatively characterize the pillar's ability to attenuate mining disturbances and its protective effect on slope stability. By establishing a comprehensive barrier effectiveness index, a quantitative evaluation of the mining disturbance attenuation capacity under different pillar thicknesses is achieved, providing a scientific basis for pillar thickness optimization. The comprehensive barrier effectiveness index corresponding to different pillar thicknesses is iteratively calculated within a preset thickness range, and the optimal pillar thickness is determined through extreme value search. This overcomes the blindness of traditional empirical methods, forming an adaptive optimization mechanism based on the mining disturbance propagation attenuation law and slope stability feedback, ensuring that boundary pillars achieve economical and reasonable design while meeting safety requirements.
[0045] In summary, through the synergistic effect of the above modules, this embodiment realizes a closed-loop calculation process from the analysis of mining disturbance propagation characteristics to the optimization of pillar thickness, solving the problem that traditional methods cannot accurately quantify the attenuation law of disturbance propagation; it can scientifically determine the optimal thickness of boundary pillars based on the combination of actual monitoring data and numerical simulation, providing a reliable decision-making basis for rock mass stability control in open-pit to underground mining.
[0046] The above is an introduction to the system implementation. The following will further illustrate the application effect of the boundary pillar thickness optimization design scheme based on the attenuation characteristics of mining disturbance propagation of the present invention through specific applications.
[0047] For a copper mine transitioning from open-pit to underground, a FLAC3D model is created, with pillar thicknesses set to 10m, 15m, 20m, 25m, and 30m.
[0048] Table 1 Monitoring Results: Overall evaluation results: After 20m: The increase has slowed significantly. This indicates that there is a marginal effect on pillar thickness; therefore: Recommended thickness.
[0049] Design of boundary pillar parameters and slope stability control under open-pit to underground mining conditions This paper presents a comprehensive report on the optimization analysis of the boundary pillar thickness of a copper mine transitioning from open-pit to underground. Following the framework of steps S100 to S500, and based on the results of FLAC3D numerical simulation, the paper comprehensively evaluates the barrier effectiveness and slope stability under different pillar thicknesses, and finally provides an optimal thickness recommendation.
[0050] 1. Three-dimensional numerical model establishment (step S100): Based on the actual geological conditions of the mine, the physical and mechanical parameters of the rock mass, the occurrence of layered structural planes, the morphology of the goaf, and the mining engineering layout, a three-dimensional numerical model of the open-pit slope, boundary pillar, and underground stope is established using FLAC3D. The model size covers the influence range of the stope and finely depicts the overburden bedding, pillar geometry, and slope surface. The bottom of the model is fixed, and normal constraints are applied around it. The initial stress field is set according to the self-weight stress field. The underground stope excavation is simulated using empty elements, and the excavation is carried out in stages to reflect the unloading process. The model is divided into four functional areas to ensure the integrity of the disturbance propagation path: stope, overburden, pillar, and slope. 2. Monitoring Point Layout and Data Acquisition (Steps S200~S300): Along the direction of disturbance propagation, displacement monitoring points are deployed in the hanging wall or adjacent to the excavation boundary, the middle of the overburden or near the lower boundary of the pillar, at potential sliding surfaces or the most dangerous slip surfaces, and on the slope surface. After excavation, the total displacement of each monitoring point is extracted; five sets of pillar thicknesses (10 m, 15 m, 20 m, 25 m, and 30 m) are optimized and calculated, and the stope displacement U is obtained for each set. m , representing the intensity of the disturbance source and the slope surface displacement U s , representing the final residual disturbance; at the same time, the slope safety factor Fs was calculated using the limit equilibrium method; the monitoring results are summarized in Table 1.
[0051] Table 1
[0052] Note: The displacement data of the middle part of the overburden is not listed for simplicity because it is used to calculate the disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient and is not a core indicator of this optimization. However, it can be used to quantify the natural attenuation background of the overburden in the complete analysis. This invention focuses on the blocking effect of the pillar and slope safety.
[0053] 3. Key performance indicator calculation (step S400): 3.1 Mining disturbance barrier coefficient ( ) According to the formula The calculation directly reflects the pillar's ability to block disturbances; Table 1 shows... The value increases monotonically with increasing thickness, indicating that thickening the pillar can effectively reduce the residual displacement transmitted to the slope. 3.2 Slope safety factor ( ) Calculations can be performed using either the strength reduction method or the limit equilibrium method. All values are greater than 1.0, and increase with increasing thickness, indicating that thickening the pillar is beneficial to the overall anti-sliding stability of the slope; 3.3 Comprehensive Barrier Efficiency Index ( ) According to step S400, Comprehensive Disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient and slope response index; because only the slope response index was obtained and Two direct results, and both are better the larger they are, so a simplified comprehensive index is defined; This product reflects both the pillar's efficiency in blocking disturbances and the slope's stability margin, with a clear physical meaning. (The text then abruptly shifts to a different topic:) ...at various thicknesses... The calculation results are shown in Table 2.
[0054] Table 2
[0055] 4. Marginal effect analysis and determination of optimal thickness (step S500) Observe Table 2 Incremental changes: 10→15 m: Δ = 0.113; 15→20 m: Δ = 0.104; 20→25 m: Δ = 0.068 (a decrease of 35%); 25→30 m: Δ = 0.065 (continues to decrease); It is clearly visible that when the thickness exceeds 20 m, The increase in efficiency has significantly decreased, meaning that the improvement in efficiency brought about by increasing the thickness of the pillar exhibits a diminishing marginal effect. Given that the safety factor at 20 m already reaches 1.30, it not only meets the minimum requirement (≥1.25) but also has sufficient safety reserves; however, further increasing the thickness to 25 m or 30 m... Increasing the safety gains by only 0.03 and 0.05 respectively provides extremely limited benefits and would instead significantly reduce ore recovery rates and increase construction costs. Therefore, combining... The marginal diminishing inflection point and economic analysis, 20 m is not The maximum value point is the balance point between sufficient safety reserves and maximizing economic benefits, so it is determined as the optimal threshold pillar thickness.
[0056] Taking into account barrier effectiveness, safety reserves, and mining economics, the optimal boundary pillar thickness was determined to be... = 20m. At this thickness, =0.50 (half of the disturbances have been blocked). =1.30 (good safety margin) =0.650, and the subsequent increase slowed down, which is the performance-cost balance point.
[0057] 5. Conclusions and Engineering Recommendations: Through FLAC3D numerical simulation and system index calculation, it is demonstrated that the thickness of the boundary pillar has a significant blocking effect on the propagation of mining disturbances, and the thickness and blocking effect are nonlinearly positively correlated.
[0058] Marginal effect analysis shows that the rate of improvement in overall efficiency decreases significantly after the thickness reaches 20 m, and further thickening yields limited benefits. Therefore, a design thickness of 20 m is recommended.
[0059] In actual engineering, it is recommended to combine on-site displacement monitoring with dynamic feedback on the basis of 20 m thickness. If necessary, reinforcing anchor cables can be added at the bottom of the pillar to further control slope deformation.
[0060] This invention can be extended to similar open-pit to underground mines, providing a reliable technical path for optimizing boundary pillar parameters.
[0061] Figure 4 A schematic diagram of a computer-readable storage medium according to an embodiment of the present invention is shown.
[0062] like Figure 4 As shown, the non-transitory computer-readable storage medium 6 stores instructions, such as computer-readable instruction 5. When the computer-readable instruction 5 is executed by a processor, the various methods described above can be performed. The non-transitory computer-readable storage medium includes, but is not limited to, volatile memory and / or non-volatile memory. Volatile memory may include, for example, random access memory (RAM) and / or cache memory. Non-transitory non-volatile memory may include, for example, read-only memory (ROM), hard disk, flash memory, etc. For example, the non-transitory computer-readable storage medium 6 can be connected to a computing device such as a computer, and then, when the computing device executes the computer-readable instruction 5 stored on the non-transitory computer-readable storage medium 6, the various methods described above can be performed.
[0063] In the embodiments provided by this invention, it should be understood that the disclosed systems and methods can be implemented in other ways. For example, the system embodiments described above are merely illustrative; for instance, the division of units is only a logical functional division, and in actual implementation, there may be other division methods. For example, multiple units or components may be combined or integrated into another system, or some features may be ignored or not executed. Furthermore, the coupling or direct coupling or communication connection shown or discussed may be through some interfaces; the indirect coupling or communication connection between systems or units may be electrical, mechanical, or other forms.
[0064] The above embodiments are only used to illustrate the technical solutions of the present invention, and are not intended to limit it. Although the present invention has been described in detail with reference to the foregoing embodiments, those skilled in the art should understand that modifications can still be made to the technical solutions described in the foregoing embodiments, or equivalent substitutions can be made to some of the technical features. Such modifications or substitutions do not cause the essence of the corresponding technical solutions to deviate from the spirit and scope of the technical solutions of the embodiments of the present invention.
Claims
1. A method for optimizing the design of boundary pillar thickness based on the attenuation characteristics of mining disturbance propagation, characterized in that, Includes the following steps: Establish a three-dimensional numerical model of open-pit slope, boundary pillar, and underground mining area; The three-dimensional numerical model was divided into an underground mining disturbance zone, a boundary pillar isolation zone, and a slope deformation response zone; stope displacement data, overburden displacement data, and slope displacement data were obtained. The disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient is calculated based on the stope displacement data and overlying rock displacement data. The mining disturbance isolation coefficient is calculated based on the stope displacement data and slope displacement data. Slope settlement data, horizontal displacement data, tilt data, curvature data, and horizontal deformation data are obtained. The slope response index is calculated based on the settlement data, horizontal displacement data, tilt data, curvature data, and horizontal deformation data to obtain the slope safety factor. The comprehensive isolation effectiveness index is calculated based on the mining disturbance isolation coefficient, disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient, slope safety factor, and slope response index. Within a predetermined thickness range, the pillar thickness is assigned progressively, and the comprehensive barrier efficiency index corresponding to each thickness is calculated. The pillar thickness corresponding to the maximum value of the comprehensive barrier efficiency index is selected, and the pillar thickness corresponding to the maximum value is determined as the optimal boundary pillar thickness.
2. The boundary pillar thickness optimization design method based on the attenuation characteristics of mining disturbance propagation as described in claim 1, characterized in that, Boundary pillar isolation zones are used to provide disturbance barrier structures, which refer to the boundary pillar itself.
3. The boundary pillar thickness optimization design method based on the attenuation characteristics of mining disturbance propagation as described in claim 1, characterized in that, The underground mining disturbance zone, the boundary pillar isolation zone, and the slope deformation response zone are three functional zones that are longitudinally divided into the model along the direction of disturbance propagation. The underground mining disturbance zone is centered on the mining area and covers the high-stress zone around the mining area that is directly affected by the excavation. The displacement changes within the zone represent the initial intensity of the disturbance source.
4. The boundary pillar thickness optimization design method based on the attenuation characteristics of mining disturbance propagation as described in claim 1, characterized in that, The disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient is characterized by the ratio of the difference between the stope displacement and the overlying rock displacement to the stope displacement, reflecting the degree of natural attenuation of mining disturbances propagating in the overlying rock.
5. The boundary pillar thickness optimization design method based on the attenuation characteristics of mining disturbance propagation as described in claim 1, characterized in that, The mining disturbance barrier coefficient is characterized by the ratio of the difference between the stope displacement and the slope displacement to the stope displacement. It is a core indicator for measuring the ability of the boundary pillar to block the propagation of mining disturbances.
6. The boundary pillar thickness optimization design method based on the attenuation characteristics of mining disturbance propagation as described in claim 1, characterized in that, Five data points—slope settlement data, horizontal displacement data, tilt data, curvature data, and horizontal deformation data—describe the slope's deformation behavior under mining disturbance from five different dimensions: vertical direction, horizontal direction, rotation angle, degree of bending, and tension / compression. Together, they constitute a comprehensive description of the slope's response characteristics.
7. The boundary pillar thickness optimization design method based on the attenuation characteristics of mining disturbance propagation as described in claim 1, characterized in that, The slope response index is obtained by summing five deformation data points after assigning weights to each data point, thus compressing the deformation response from multiple dimensions into a single comprehensive index. The weighting coefficients are determined based on the degree of influence of each deformation index on slope stability.
8. The boundary pillar thickness optimization design method based on the attenuation characteristics of mining disturbance propagation as described in claim 1, characterized in that, The slope safety factor is used to quantitatively evaluate whether the slope's anti-sliding stability meets the specifications under the current pillar thickness conditions; it is a rigid criterion for constraining the optimization process.
9. The boundary pillar thickness optimization design method based on the attenuation characteristics of mining disturbance propagation as described in claim 1, characterized in that, The comprehensive barrier effectiveness index takes into account four indicators: mining disturbance barrier coefficient, disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient, slope safety factor, and slope response index.
10. The boundary pillar thickness optimization design method based on the attenuation characteristics of mining disturbance propagation as described in claim 9, characterized in that, The mining disturbance isolation coefficient and disturbance propagation attenuation coefficient focus on reflecting the ability of the pillar to block and attenuate disturbances, while the slope safety factor and slope response index focus on reflecting the stability and deformation state of the slope after isolation. The four indicators are combined by weighted summation and a penalty term is introduced. When the slope response index is too large or the safety factor is insufficient, the effectiveness value is penalized.
