A method for assessing the life loss of P92 steel based on Z-phase compositional differences

By measuring the mass fractions of Cr and Nb in P92 steel using focused ion beam technology and transmission electron microscopy combined with energy dispersive spectroscopy, and calculating the lifetime loss rate using a nonlinear model, the problem of not being able to identify early risks of Z-phase nucleation and quantitatively assess lifetime loss in existing technologies has been solved, achieving high-precision, micro-damage lifetime assessment.

CN123116559APending Publication Date: 2026-11-17HUANENG ANYUAN POWER GENERATION CO LTD +1
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202611195130.4
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2026-08-07
Publication Date
2026-11-17

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing technologies cannot accurately identify the early risk of Z-phase nucleation in P92 steel, cannot quantitatively assess the life loss of long-term P92 steel, and the sampling process affects structural integrity.

Method used

Thin-film samples were extracted using focused ion beam technology. The mass fractions of Cr and Nb were measured using a spherical aberration-corrected transmission electron microscope and energy dispersive spectroscopy. The lifetime loss rate was calculated using a nonlinear model. The oxide layer was removed through surface pretreatment to reduce sampling damage.

Benefits of technology

It achieves accurate identification of early risks in Z-phase nucleation, quantitative assessment of P92 steel life loss, sampling damage at the microgram level with no impact on structural integrity, and the assessment results are objective and reliable.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN123116559A_ABST
    Figure CN123116559A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

This invention provides a method for assessing the life loss of P92 steel based on Z-phase compositional differences, belonging to the technical field of life assessment for high-temperature components in thermal power units. It can at least partially solve the problems in existing technologies such as the inability to identify early risks of Z-phase nucleation in long-term P92 steel, large assessment errors, and the lack of quantitative assessment standards. The invention includes: pre-treating the surface of the sampling area of ​​the P92 steel component to be assessed to remove the oxide layer; extracting thin-film samples containing a coexisting MX and Z-phase structures using focused ion beam technology; measuring the mass fractions of Cr and Nb elements in the MX and Z-phase regions using aberration-corrected transmission electron microscopy combined with energy dispersive spectroscopy; calculating the Cr and Nb elemental differences; and calculating the life loss rate and determining the life loss level using a nonlinear model based on the elemental differences. This invention achieves quantitative life loss assessment of long-term P92 steel based on the chemical evolution law of the Z-phase.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] This invention relates to the field of life assessment technology for high-temperature components of thermal power units, specifically to a method for assessing the life loss of P92 steel based on Z-phase composition differences. Background Technology

[0002] With the large-scale commissioning of supercritical and ultra-supercritical thermal power units in my country, an increasing number of pressure-bearing components made of P92 martensitic heat-resistant steel have entered or are about to enter long-term service, with service times approaching or exceeding 100,000 hours. During long-term high-temperature service, the nanoscale strengthening phase MX phase composed of NbC and VN in P92 steel gradually transforms into the Cr-rich Z phase NbCrN. This transformation from the MX phase to the Z phase leads to a sharp decline in the precipitation strengthening effect of P92 steel, which is the core mechanism of creep strength failure in long-term service P92 steel.

[0003] Currently, the industry's assessment of long-service P92 steel mainly relies on traditional hardness testing and the observation of the evolution of the M23C6 and Laves phases using scanning electron microscopy. However, these methods are extremely insensitive to the signals of Z-phase nucleation and growth. A few studies have attempted to determine the degree of aging by observing the morphology of the Z-phase using transmission electron microscopy, but these are limited to qualitative descriptions and cannot yet achieve quantitative assessment.

[0004] Existing technologies for assessing the lifespan of long-term P92 steel have the following shortcomings. First, in the early stages of the nucleation and growth of the Z phase within the MX phase, the macroscopic mechanical properties and conventional microstructure of the material show no significant changes, making this early aging signal undetectable by traditional methods. Second, for P92 steel with service times approaching or exceeding 100,000 hours, the error in conventional mechanical property assessments can reach over 50%, and the qualitative grading error based on scanning electron microscopy observations also exceeds 30%, failing to accurately distinguish between the two different risk stages of 70% and 90% lifespan loss. Third, traditional assessment methods require cutting large-sized samples, which can significantly impact the structural integrity of in-service pressure-bearing components. Fourth, the industry has not yet established a quantitative assessment standard for the aging of P92 steel based on Z phase evolution, and the assessment results are highly dependent on the personal experience of the testing personnel.

[0005] Therefore, how to provide a high-precision assessment method that can identify early risks of Z-phase nucleation, quantitatively assess the life loss of long-term P92 steel based on the chemical evolution law of Z-phase, and minimize sampling damage is a technical problem that urgently needs to be solved in the field of life assessment technology for high-temperature components of thermal power units. Summary of the Invention

[0006] The present invention aims to solve at least one of the technical problems existing in the prior art, and to provide a method for evaluating the life loss of P92 steel based on the difference in Z phase composition.

[0007] To achieve the above objectives, this invention provides a method for assessing the life loss of P92 steel based on Z-phase compositional differences, comprising: Step S1: The surface of the sampling area of ​​the P92 steel component to be evaluated is pretreated to remove the oxide layer, expose the fresh metal substrate, and a thin sheet sample containing the MX phase and Z phase coexisting structure is extracted on the pretreated surface using focused ion beam technology. Step S2: The co-occurrence structure of the MX phase and Z phase in the thin section sample was characterized by aberration-corrected transmission electron microscopy combined with energy dispersive spectroscopy, and the mass fractions of Cr and Nb elements in the MX phase region and the Z phase region were measured respectively. Step S3: Calculate the Cr elemental difference based on the mass fraction obtained in step S2. Difference between Nb and other elements : ; ; in, The mass fraction of Cr element in the Z phase. The mass fraction of Cr element in the MX phase. The mass fraction of Nb element in the MX phase. The mass fraction of Nb element in the Z phase; Step S4: According to the above and stated The lifetime loss rate was calculated using a nonlinear model to characterize the accelerated degradation effect in the later stages of Z-phase evolution. And according to the said lifespan loss rate Determine the life loss level of the P92 steel component.

[0008] Furthermore, in step S1, the surface pretreatment uses electrolytic polishing or mechanical grinding to remove the surface oxide layer of the sampling area, with a removal depth of 50μm~200μm.

[0009] Furthermore, in step S1, before the focused ion beam technique extracts the thin-film sample, a protective layer is deposited on the pretreated surface; the sampling point diameter of the thin-film sample is no greater than 3 mm, and the sampling depth is no greater than 2 mm.

[0010] Furthermore, in step S1, when the focused ion beam technique extracts the thin film sample, a first-energy ion beam is used for coarse cutting, and then a second-energy ion beam with a lower energy than the first energy is used for fine cutting; the thickness of the thin film sample is no greater than 100 nm, and the surface flatness is no greater than 5 nm.

[0011] Further, the first energy is 30 keV, the second energy is 5 keV, and the ion beam is... Ion beam.

[0012] Further, in step S2, the accelerating voltage of the aberration-corrected transmission electron microscope is 200 kV, the beam current is 0.5 nA, and the spatial resolution is no greater than 1 nm; the characterization of the MX phase and Z phase co-occurrence structure includes line scan and area scan analysis, and the step size of the line scan is 0.5 nm; at least 5 different MX phase and Z phase co-occurrence structures are randomly selected for measurement, and the average value is taken as the final result of the mass fraction of the Cr element and the Nb element.

[0013] Further, in step S4, the calculation formula for the nonlinear model is: ; in, The term refers to the lifespan attrition rate, expressed as a percentage. The Cr element difference is expressed in %. The Nb element difference is expressed in percent.

[0014] Furthermore, in step S4, the rule for classifying the lifespan loss level is as follows: When the Less than 5% and the When the percentage is less than 3%, the P92 steel component is determined to be in the middle of its service life, and the inspection cycle is 1 year. When the Not less than 5% and less than 15%, and the aforementioned When the percentage is not less than 3% and less than 8%, the P92 steel component is determined to be in the late stage of service, and the inspection cycle is shortened to within 6 months. When the Not less than 15% and the aforementioned If the percentage is not less than 8%, the P92 steel component is considered to be at the end of its service life, and it is recommended to replace the component immediately.

[0015] Furthermore, in step S2, the mass fraction of V element in the MX phase region and the Z phase region is also measured; In step S4, when the and stated When the different hierarchical intervals are inconsistent, the calculation result of the nonlinear model shall prevail, and the V-element difference degree shall be introduced. and interface dislocation density The lifetime attrition rate is corrected, and the corrected lifetime attrition rate is... for: ; ; in, The lifetime loss rate is calculated for the nonlinear model. For the V element's degree of difference, The mass fraction of V element in the MX phase. The mass fraction of V element in the Z phase. The interfacial dislocation density of the MX-Z phase coexisting structure is given in units of 1. The lifetime loss rate was obtained statistically from bright-field images obtained by transmission electron microscopy; The lifespan loss level is determined as the final assessment result.

[0016] Furthermore, the P92 steel component to be evaluated is the main steam pipe or high-temperature reheat steam pipe of a supercritical or ultra-supercritical unit with a service life of not less than 100,000 hours.

[0017] The beneficial effects of this invention are as follows: This invention reveals and utilizes for the first time the chemical evolution law of the nucleation and growth of the Z phase within the MX phase. By quantitatively measuring the difference in Cr and Nb element content between the Z and MX phases, the aging degree of P92 steel is characterized. This invention overcomes the technical bottleneck that traditional hardness testing and scanning electron microscopy observation are insensitive to Z phase nucleation signals. It can detect aging signals in the early stage of Z phase nucleation and effectively identify the risk of the end of the life in advance.

[0018] This invention employs a combination of "surface pretreatment to remove oxide layer + focused ion beam minimally invasive sampling". Under the premise of eliminating the interference of surface contamination caused by long-term service on component analysis, the sampling damage is controlled at the microgram level, which has almost no impact on the structural integrity of in-service pressure-bearing components and can complete the test without long-term downtime.

[0019] This invention employs a nonlinear model with an exponential term to calculate the lifetime loss rate. This model can characterize the accelerated degradation effect of creep strength in the later stage of Z-phase evolution. When the two element difference indices are not in the same grade range, the V element difference and interface dislocation density are introduced as correction parameters, making the evaluation results more conservative and reliable. It can accurately distinguish the end-of-life risk stage where the lifetime loss exceeds 80%.

[0020] This invention establishes evaluation standards based on quantitative analysis of elemental composition. The evaluation results are objective, repeatable, and verifiable, eliminating the subjectivity of traditional qualitative evaluations that heavily rely on the personal experience of testing personnel. Attached Figure Description

[0021] Figure 1 This is an overall flowchart of the P92 steel life loss assessment method based on Z-phase composition difference according to an embodiment of the present invention; Figure 2 This is a schematic diagram illustrating the characterization and compositional analysis of the MX phase and Z phase coexisting structure in an embodiment of the present invention. Figure 3 This is a schematic diagram of the life loss classification assessment and index inconsistency correction process according to an embodiment of the present invention. Detailed Implementation

[0022] To make the objectives, technical solutions, and beneficial effects of this application clearer, the following detailed description, in conjunction with the accompanying drawings and specific embodiments, further illustrates this application. It should be understood that the specific embodiments described in this specification are merely for explaining this application and are not intended to limit it.

[0023] The overall technical solution of the P92 steel life loss assessment method based on Z-phase composition difference of the present invention will be described first.

[0024] See Figure 1 The P92 steel life loss assessment method based on Z-phase composition difference of the present invention includes steps S1 to S4, and each step is described in detail below.

[0025] Step S1 involves pre-treating the surface of the sampling area of ​​the P92 steel component to be evaluated to remove the oxide layer, expose the fresh metal substrate, and then using focused ion beam technology to extract a thin sheet sample containing a symbiotic structure of MX and Z phases on the pre-treated surface.

[0026] During long-term high-temperature service, P92 steel components develop a multi-layered oxide film composed of Fe3O4 and Fe2O3 on their outer surface. Simultaneously, deposits and corrosion products from the service environment adhere to the surface. Directly sampling and analyzing the composition of areas containing the oxide layer and surface contaminants would severely interfere with the quantitative accuracy of target elements such as Cr, V, and Nb in subsequent energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) analysis, due to the enriched Fe and O elements in the oxide layer and other elements in the surface contaminants. Therefore, this step first performs surface pretreatment on the sampling area to remove the oxide layer and surface contaminants to a predetermined depth. This ensures that the area to be analyzed is entirely within a fresh, unaffected metal matrix, guaranteeing the representativeness of the compositional analysis data to the true state of the matrix.

[0027] The surface pretreatment refers to a cleaning process that removes the surface material of the sampling area to a preset depth through material removal methods. Possible surface pretreatment methods include electropolishing and mechanical grinding. Both methods remove the surface layer of the sampling area to a preset depth exceeding the oxide layer thickness, exposing the fresh, unoxidized metal substrate. Electropolishing removes surface material through electrochemical dissolution, without introducing mechanical deformation or processing stress layers. The exposed metal substrate retains its original service state, which is beneficial for the accuracy of subsequent component analysis. Mechanical grinding removes surface material through mechanical contact between the abrasive and the surface. It is simple to operate, requires less equipment, and is suitable for testing scenarios where electropolishing is not feasible. The removal depth should be determined based on the actual oxide layer thickness, which can be measured through prior metallographic observation or energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS). In a preferred embodiment, the removal depth is 50 μm to 200 μm, a range that covers the oxide layer thickness formed on P92 steel under different service temperatures and service times.

[0028] After surface pretreatment, a thin-film sample containing a coexisting MX and Z phase structure is extracted from the pretreated surface using focused ion beam (FIB) technology. FIB technology utilizes a focused ion beam to perform sub-micron precision local cutting and extraction on the sample surface, enabling the precise fabrication of nanometer-thick thin-film samples within minute areas.

[0029] The common characteristics of the focused ion beam technology are: it utilizes a focused ion beam to perform local cutting on a preset area and extract a thin-film sample; the cutting process is highly controllable, with sub-micron level positioning accuracy; the prepared thin-film sample thickness can reach the nanometer level; and the sampling area is small, causing minimal damage to the component surface. In alternative embodiments, different types of ion sources can be used to achieve focused ion beam cutting, including gallium ion sources, xenon plasma ion sources, and helium ion sources. The commonality among these different ion sources is that they can all generate an ion beam focused to a nanometer-scale beam spot and perform local cutting. In a preferred embodiment, a gallium ion source is used. In a further preferred embodiment, the focused ion beam preparation of the thin-film sample employs a high-low energy stepwise cutting method: first, a first-energy ion beam is used to coarsely cut and form the overall outline of the thin film; then, a second-energy ion beam with a lower energy than the first energy is used to refine the surface of the thin film. The first-energy ion beam has a high cutting rate, used for rapid roughing of the thin-film contour; the second-energy ion beam, due to its lower energy, has a shallower ion implantation depth and a thinner sputtering damage zone, effectively reducing interference from ion implantation on the sample surface composition and ensuring the quantitative accuracy of subsequent energy dispersive spectroscopy analysis in the thin-film surface region. In a preferred embodiment, the first energy is 30 keV, the second energy is 5 keV, and the ion beam is... Ion beam.

[0030] To prevent damage to the sample surface from the focused ion beam during the initial cutting stage, a protective layer can be deposited on the pretreated surface before extracting the thin-film sample using focused ion beam technology. This protective layer can be a platinum or carbon protective layer, and its function is to absorb the sputtering energy of the incident ion beam during the initial cutting stage, preventing irreversible damage to the microstructure and composition of the upper surface region of the thin-film sample. In a preferred embodiment, the protective layer is a platinum protective layer with a thickness of 100 nm.

[0031] The sampling area of ​​the thin-film sample should be controlled within a small size range to minimize damage to in-service pressure-bearing components. In a preferred embodiment, the sampling point diameter is no greater than 3 mm, the sampling depth is no greater than 2 mm, and the amount of damage from sampling is at the microgram level, which has almost no impact on the structural integrity of in-service pressure-bearing components.

[0032] The thickness and surface quality of the thin-film sample must meet the requirements of electron beam penetration and scattering conditions for subsequent energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) analysis. In a preferred embodiment, the thickness of the thin-film sample is no greater than 100 nm, and the surface flatness is no greater than 5 nm. A thickness of no more than 100 nm ensures sufficient electron beam penetration through the thin film in the transmission electron microscope (TEM), reducing the decrease in spatial resolution and compositional quantification errors caused by multiple electron scattering. A surface flatness of no more than 5 nm reduces the impact of differences in electron beam scattering paths caused by surface unevenness on the spatial uniformity of the EDS signal.

[0033] Step S2 involves characterizing the coexisting structure of the MX and Z phases in the thin-film sample using aberration-corrected transmission electron microscopy combined with energy dispersive spectroscopy, and measuring the mass fractions of Cr and Nb elements in the MX phase region and the Z phase region, respectively.

[0034] The purpose of this step is to obtain quantitative composition data of the target elements in the coexisting MX and Z phases at nanometer-level spatial resolution, which will serve as the input for the elemental difference calculation in step S3.

[0035] Aberration-corrected transmission electron microscopy (Cs-corrected TEM) compensates for spherical aberration in electromagnetic lenses using a spherical aberration corrector, reducing the electron beam probe size to the sub-angstrom level and achieving sub-nanometer spatial resolution. This allows for the differentiation and separate characterization of the microstructure and elemental composition of the MX and Z phase regions. Energy dispersive spectrometers (EDS) utilize the one-to-one correspondence between the energy of characteristic X-rays and elemental types to acquire and analyze the energy and count of characteristic X-rays excited by the electron beam, enabling qualitative and quantitative analysis of elements in micro-regions. The combination of aberration-corrected TEM and EDS enables the quantitative determination of elemental mass fractions in micro-regions at nanometer-level spatial resolution.

[0036] The characterization refers to the process of simultaneously acquiring information on the morphology, crystal structure, and elemental distribution of the coexisting MX and Z phases using the high-resolution imaging function of an aberration-corrected transmission electron microscope and the elemental analysis function of an energy dispersive spectrometer. The characterization can employ, but is not limited to, the following analytical methods: line scan analysis and area scan analysis. Line scan analysis involves acquiring energy dispersive spectrometer signals point-by-point along a selected scan line to obtain the spatial distribution curve of the mass fraction of each element along the line direction; area scan analysis involves acquiring energy dispersive spectrometer signals point-by-point within a selected rectangular region to obtain a two-dimensional spatial distribution map of the mass fraction of each element. Both methods share the characteristic of acquiring energy dispersive spectrometer signals point-by-point with nanometer-scale step sizes and can quantitatively provide the mass fraction of each target element in the MX and Z phase regions. In a preferred embodiment, both line scan and area scan analyses are used simultaneously, with a line scan step size of 0.5 nm.

[0037] Measuring the mass fractions of Cr and Nb elements in the MX phase region and the Z phase region respectively means extracting the mass fraction data of Cr and Nb elements at each collection point in the MX phase region and the Z phase region from the energy dispersive spectroscopy data obtained by online scanning or area scanning, and calculating their average values ​​respectively. The measurement accuracy for each element is not less than ±0.5%.

[0038] To ensure data representativeness, multiple different MX-Z phase coexisting structures should be randomly selected for measurement, and the average value of the measurement results for each structure should be taken as the final elemental content result. In a preferred embodiment, at least five different MX-Z phase coexisting structures are randomly selected for measurement.

[0039] In a preferred embodiment, the aberration-corrected transmission electron microscope (TEM) uses an accelerating voltage of 200 kV, a beam current of 0.5 nA, and a spatial resolution of no more than 1 nm. The accelerating voltage of 200 kV ensures sufficient penetration of the electron beam into thin-film samples with a thickness of no more than 100 nm, while the beam current of 0.5 nA ensures a sufficient energy spectrum signal count rate while avoiding excessive beam current that could cause irradiation damage to the nanoscale phase structures in the thin-film sample. The measured mass fractions of Cr and Nb are output to step S3.

[0040] Step S3 involves calculating the Cr elemental difference based on the mass fraction obtained in step S2. Difference between Nb and other elements .

[0041] The purpose of this step is to transform the quantitative component data obtained in step S2 into a quantitative index that can characterize the degree of chemical evolution of phase Z, and use it as input for the lifetime loss rate calculation in step S4.

[0042] The chemical evolution of the Z phase within the MX phase, involving nucleation and growth, is accompanied by a characteristic element migration pattern: as NbCrN in the Z phase nucleates and grows, Cr in the matrix continuously accumulates in the Z phase region, gradually increasing the Cr content in the Z phase. Simultaneously, the Nb elements originally present in the MX phase are consumed and absorbed by the Z phase, gradually decreasing the Nb content in the MX phase. The Nb content in the Z phase also remains relatively low due to continuous outward diffusion. Therefore, the difference in Cr content between the Z and MX phases, and the difference in Nb content between the MX and Z phases, both increase monotonically with the deepening of Z phase evolution, quantitatively reflecting the chemical evolution process of the Z phase.

[0043] Cr elemental difference It is defined as the mass fraction of Cr in the Z phase minus the mass fraction of Cr in the MX phase, and is used to reflect the Cr enrichment level of the Z phase. The larger the value, the higher the enrichment degree of Cr element in the Z phase, and the more advanced the chemical evolution of the Z phase. The calculation formula is: ; Nb elemental differences Defined as the mass fraction of Nb elements in the MX phase minus the mass fraction of Nb elements in the Z phase, it reflects the degree to which the MX phase is consumed and devoured by the Z phase. The larger the value, the greater the loss of Nb element in the MX phase, and the more severe the loss of precipitation enhancement effect of the MX phase. The calculation formula is: ; in, The mass fraction of Cr element in the Z phase. The mass fraction of Cr element in the MX phase. The mass fraction of Nb element in the MX phase. The mass fraction of Nb element in the Z phase is given.

[0044] In a further implementation, the V element difference degree can also be calculated. As an auxiliary criterion, the difference in V elements. Defined as the mass fraction of V element in the MX phase minus the mass fraction of V element in the Z phase, it helps reflect the degree to which the VN component in the MX phase is consumed by the Z phase. The calculation formula is: ; in, The mass fraction of V element in the MX phase. The mass fraction of V element in the Z phase.

[0045] Calculated and It is output to step S4.

[0046] Step S4 is based on the above. and stated The lifetime loss rate was calculated using a nonlinear model to characterize the accelerated degradation effect in the later stages of Z-phase evolution. And according to the said lifespan loss rate Determine the life loss level of the P92 steel component.

[0047] The purpose of this step is to convert the quantitative elemental difference index obtained in step S3 into the percentage of life loss of P92 steel components, and to provide a graded assessment conclusion and inspection cycle recommendation.

[0048] The nonlinear model refers to... and As input variables, with lifetime attrition rate The regression model for the output introduces an exponential term to characterize the nonlinear characteristics of accelerated creep degradation in the later stages of Z-phase evolution. During the early stages of Z-phase evolution, the MX phase only forms tiny Z-phase nuclei internally, and the overall precipitation strengthening effect of the MX phase does not significantly decrease, resulting in slow lifetime loss. However, in the later stages of evolution, the Z phase grows rapidly and engulfs the MX phase, accelerating the loss of the MX phase's precipitation strengthening effect and accelerating lifetime loss. Linear models cannot accurately describe this accelerated degradation behavior (slow at the beginning, fast at the end), therefore a nonlinear model with an exponential term is required.

[0049] The nonlinear model can take, but is not limited to, the following forms: nonlinear regression models containing power-law terms and nonlinear regression models containing exponential function terms. The commonality among these various forms of nonlinear models is that they all use... and As the independent variable, with As the dependent variable, all of them introduce an exponential or power-law term greater than 1 to accelerate the growth of lifetime loss rate with the increase of elemental difference, and can capture the accelerated deterioration effect in the later stage of Z phase evolution.

[0050] In a preferred embodiment, the nonlinear model employs a power-law nonlinear regression model based on experimental data fitting, and the calculation formula is as follows: ; in, This represents the lifespan attrition rate, expressed as % . The chromium elemental variation is expressed in % (%). The Nb elemental variability is expressed as a percentage. (Formula omitted for brevity) The index is 1.2, which is greater than 1, reflecting the characteristic that the contribution of Cr element difference to lifetime loss increases rapidly with the increase of difference. The index is 0.9, close to 1, reflecting the characteristic that the contribution of Nb element difference to lifetime loss increases almost linearly with the increase of difference; constant term 22 is the baseline offset, reflecting the basic lifetime loss of P92 steel caused by other aging mechanisms before the Z phase has nucleated.

[0051] According to the lifespan loss rate Determining the life loss level of the P92 steel component refers to... The calculation results are compared with preset grading thresholds to provide corresponding loss levels and inspection cycle recommendations. Simultaneously, to facilitate rapid on-site assessment, a system based on... and The numerical range grading evaluation rules are used in combination.

[0052] The grading and evaluation rules may include, but are not limited to, the following classification methods: a two-parameter joint interval classification method and a single threshold classification method based on the percentage of lifetime loss rate. Both methods share the commonality of using the degree of Z-phase chemical evolution as the grading basis, dividing lifetime loss into at least three levels, and corresponding to different recommended inspection cycles. In a preferred embodiment, the following method is adopted: and The joint interval partitioning method has the following specific rules: when Less than 5% and When the percentage is less than 3%, the P92 steel component is considered to be in the middle of its service life, with a life loss of less than 50%, and it is recommended to conduct a follow-up inspection every year; when Not less than 5% and less than 15%, and When the percentage is not less than 3% and less than 8%, the P92 steel component is considered to be in the late stage of service, with a life loss of 50% to 80%, and it is recommended to shorten the inspection cycle to within 6 months; when Not less than 15% and When the loss rate is not less than 8%, the P92 steel component is considered to be at the end of its service life, with a life loss exceeding 80%, and it is recommended to replace the component immediately.

[0053] In practical engineering applications, the following may occur: and When the two indicators fall within different grading intervals, the calculation result of the nonlinear model should be taken as the standard, and auxiliary parameters should be introduced to correct the life loss rate. These correction parameters include the V-element difference. and interface dislocation density . It reflects the extent to which the VN component in the MX phase is consumed by the Z phase, serving as a supplementary source of information for the two main indicators, Cr and Nb. This reflects the lattice mismatch and stress concentration at the interface between the MX and Z phases. A higher dislocation density indicates a greater interfacial incompatibility between the Z and MX phases, resulting in a more significant decrease in the material's creep resistance. (Corrected lifetime loss rate) Calculate using the following formula: ; in, The lifetime loss rate is calculated using a nonlinear model. V represents the degree of difference in elements, expressed as a percentage. Interface dislocation density, in units of The values ​​were obtained statistically from bright-field images obtained by transmission electron microscopy. The corrected lifetime loss rate was used. The lifespan loss level is determined as the final assessment result.

[0054] It can simultaneously characterize the interface morphology of the coexisting structures of the MX phase and the Z phase. When the Z phase forms a continuous encapsulation layer or obvious dislocation aggregation occurs at the interface, it can serve as auxiliary evidence to support the evaluation conclusion, but does not change the quantitative calculation results.

[0055] The above is a description of the overall technical solution of this invention. It can be seen that the thin-film sample containing the MX phase and Z phase coexistence structure output in step S1 provides the nanoscale test object after eliminating surface interference for the high-resolution characterization and compositional analysis in step S2; the mass fractions of Cr and Nb elements output in step S2 provide direct calculation input for the elemental difference calculation in step S3; the output of step S3... and This provides a quantitative index characterizing the degree of chemical evolution of the Z-phase for the nonlinear model calculation in step S4; step S4 is based on and The life loss rate is calculated and the life loss level is determined, and the assessment conclusion is output. The output of each step serves as the basis for subsequent steps, jointly achieving a quantitative life loss assessment of long-term service P92 steel based on the Z-phase chemical evolution law.

[0056] The method of the present invention will be described in detail below through specific embodiments.

[0057] Example 1 This embodiment uses the P92 high-temperature reheat steam pipeline of Unit 3 of a power plant, which has been in service for 92,000 hours, as the evaluation object, combined with... Figures 1 to 3 The specific execution process of the method of the present invention is described.

[0058] Step S1: A minimally invasive sampling area was selected on the outer arc surface of the elbow of the high-temperature reheat steam pipeline of the unit. First, the oxide layer thickness was determined in the selected area using pre-existing metallographic observation and energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS). In this embodiment, the oxide layer thickness was measured to be 55 μm. The surface oxide layer was removed using electrolytic polishing, reaching a depth of approximately 60 μm, exceeding the oxide layer thickness and exposing the fresh metal substrate. The electrolyte for electrolytic polishing was a solution formed by mixing perchloric acid and ethanol at a volume ratio of 1:9, with an electrolysis voltage of 20V and an electrolysis time of 30s.

[0059] After electropolishing, thin-film samples were extracted from the pretreated surface using focused ion beam (FIP) technology. First, a 100 nm thick platinum protective layer was deposited in the target area to prevent damage to the sample surface from subsequent ion beam cutting. Then, a 30 keV ion beam was used. Ion beam rough cutting forms the overall contour of the thin sheet, with a cutting area of ​​15 μm in length, 10 μm in width, and 8 μm in depth. After rough cutting, an ion beam with an energy of 5 keV is used. Ion beam refining was used to remove the damage layer formed by high-energy ion implantation during the roughing stage on both sides of the thin film. The sampling point diameter was 2 mm and the sampling depth was 1.5 mm. Finally, a thin film sample with a thickness of 90 nm and a surface flatness of 4 nm was prepared, which contained multiple MX phase and Z phase coexisting structures.

[0060] Step S2: Transfer the thin-section sample obtained in Step S1 to an aberration-corrected transmission electron microscope (TEM). Set the accelerating voltage to 200 kV and the beam current to 0.5 nA. First, locate and identify the coexisting structures of the MX and Z phases in the thin-section sample one by one in high-resolution imaging mode. The MX phase exhibits NaCl-type face-centered cubic crystal structure characteristics in the TEM, while the Z phase exhibits tetragonal crystal structure characteristics. In the coexisting structure of the MX and Z phases, the Z phase usually appears as a morphology where the Z phase nucleates and gradually grows inside the MX phase.

[0061] On the located MX and Z phase coexisting structures, line scan and area scan analyses were performed using an energy dispersive spectrometer (EDS). The line scan step size was set to 0.5 nm, and the line scan direction was perpendicular to the interface direction between the MX and Z phases. The area scan region covered the entire MX and Z phase coexisting structure, with an acquisition time of 200 ms per point. Five different MX and Z phase coexisting structures were randomly selected for measurement. For each structure, EDS data of the MX phase region and the Z phase region were extracted, and the mass fraction of each target element was calculated.

[0062] After averaging the measurement results of the five structures, the following final elemental content results were obtained: the average mass fraction of Cr in the MX phase region was 9.1%, and the average mass fraction of Nb was 0.63%; the average mass fraction of Cr in the Z phase region was 12.3%, and the average mass fraction of Nb was 0.41%.

[0063] Step S3: Based on the mass fraction obtained in step S2, calculate the Cr elemental variation and Nb elemental variation using the following formulas: ; ; Step S4: Calculate the results in step S3. and Substitute into the nonlinear model to calculate the lifetime loss rate: ; According to the tiered assessment rules Less than 5%, If the percentage is less than 3%, and both indicators fall within the same grading range (the first tier), the P92 steel component is determined to be in the middle of its service life, with a lifespan loss of approximately 46%. It is recommended to conduct a follow-up inspection every year.

[0064] Implementation results: Follow-up testing over the following year showed that the same sampling location near the pipeline... It slowly increased from 3.2% to 3.5%. The rate of Z-phase evolution slowly increased from 0.22% to 0.25%, and the life loss rate increased from 46% to 48%, which is consistent with the judgment conclusion in the middle of service and verifies the accuracy of the assessment results.

[0065] Example 2 This embodiment uses a P92 high-temperature reheat steam pipeline in a power plant that has been in service for 118,000 hours as the evaluation object. In this embodiment, the following occurs... and When two indicators are in different grade intervals, the focus is on explaining the process of introducing auxiliary parameters to correct the inconsistency.

[0066] Step S1: Perform surface pretreatment on the sampling area according to the method in Example 1. In this example, the oxide layer thickness was measured to be 75 μm beforehand, and approximately 80 μm of the surface oxide layer was removed by electropolishing. The electrolyte composition, electrolysis voltage, and electrolysis time for electropolishing were the same as in Example 1.

[0067] After electropolishing, thin-film samples were extracted from the pretreated surface using focused ion beam technology. Following the deposition of a 100 nm platinum protective layer, a 30 keV ion beam was used. Ion beam coarse cutting, followed by 5keV energy... Ion beam finishing was used to prepare a thin-film sample with a thickness of 85 nm and a surface flatness of 3.5 nm. The sampling point diameter was 2.5 mm and the sampling depth was 1.8 mm.

[0068] Step S2: The thin-film sample obtained in step S1 is transferred to an aberration-corrected transmission electron microscope (TEM). The accelerating voltage is set to 200 kV and the beam current to 0.5 nA. In this embodiment, six different co-occurring MX and Z phase structures are randomly selected for line scan and area scan analysis, with a line scan step size of 0.5 nm. Since this embodiment also requires calculation of the V elemental difference, the mass fraction of V element is simultaneously extracted from the energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) data.

[0069] After averaging the measurement results of the six structures, the following final elemental content results were obtained: the average mass fraction of Cr in the MX phase region was 8.7%, the average mass fraction of Nb was 0.74%, and the average mass fraction of V was 2.43%; the average mass fraction of Cr in the Z phase region was 16.2%, the average mass fraction of Nb was 0.27%, and the average mass fraction of V was 0.33%.

[0070] Step S3: Calculate the degree of difference for each element based on the mass fraction obtained in step S2. ; ; ; Step S4: Calculate the results in step S3. and Substitute into the nonlinear model to calculate the lifetime loss rate: ; In this embodiment, It falls within the second tier, 5% to 15%, while Still less than 3%, falling within the first tier, the two indicators occupy different tiers. Following the inconsistency handling rules in step S4, the calculation result from the nonlinear model is used, while also introducing the V element difference degree. and interface dislocation density Correction.

[0071] The dislocation density at the interface was obtained by statistically analyzing the interface regions of the six MX-Z coexisting structures using transmission electron microscopy (TEM) bright-field images. ,Right now .

[0072] The corrected lifetime attrition rate is calculated as follows: ; The corrected life loss rate is approximately 89%, exceeding 80%. Based on the comprehensive assessment, the P92 steel component is at the end of its lifespan, and it is recommended to replace the component as soon as possible.

[0073] Implementation Results: The pipeline was replaced within 6 months of this assessment. Laboratory creep rupture tests were conducted on samples taken from the replaced pipe section. The test results showed that the remaining creep life of the pipe section did not exceed 15,000 hours, confirming the assessment conclusion that the pipe section was at the end of its service life.

[0074] Example 3 This embodiment uses the P92 main steam pipeline of a power plant that has been in service for 105,000 hours as the evaluation object. The surface pretreatment is performed by mechanical grinding to illustrate the execution process and applicability of the method of the present invention under different pretreatment methods.

[0075] Step S1: Select a minimally invasive sampling area in the straight section of the main steam pipeline of the unit. Since the testing in this embodiment is performed on-site during unit maintenance, and electropolishing equipment is not available on-site, mechanical grinding is used for surface pretreatment. First, 120-mesh silicon carbide sandpaper is used to perform preliminary grinding on the sampling area to remove loose oxide scale and adhering substances. Subsequently, 400-mesh, 800-mesh, and 1200-mesh silicon carbide sandpaper are used for progressive fine grinding. The pre-measured oxide layer thickness is 65 μm, and the removal depth of mechanical grinding is controlled to approximately 100 μm, exceeding the oxide layer thickness to expose the fresh metal substrate. The processing stress layer introduced by mechanical grinding is approximately 5 μm thick. This processing stress layer is located on the outermost layer of the ground surface and is removed by low-energy (5 keV) fine finishing during subsequent focused ion beam preparation of thin-film samples, without affecting the accuracy of the tissue analysis.

[0076] After mechanical grinding, thin-film samples were extracted from the pretreated surface using focused ion beam technology. Following the deposition of a 100 nm platinum protective layer, a 30 keV ion beam was used. Ion beam coarse cutting, followed by 5keV energy... Ion beam finishing. In this embodiment, the 5keV finishing step removes the rough-cut damage layer and simultaneously eliminates residual influence areas from the approximately 5μm processing stress layer introduced by mechanical grinding that might have penetrated into the sample depth, ensuring that the microstructure in the thin-section sample remains completely in its original, unaffected service state. The final thin-section sample has a thickness of 95nm and a surface flatness of 4.5nm. The sampling point diameter is 2.8mm, and the sampling depth is 1.6mm.

[0077] Step S2: Transfer the thin-film sample obtained in step S1 to an aberration-corrected transmission electron microscope (TEM). Set the accelerating voltage to 200 kV and the beam current to 0.5 nA. Randomly select five different MX-Z phase co-occurrence structures and perform line scan and area scan analyses respectively. The line scan step size is 0.5 nm.

[0078] After averaging the measurement results of the five structures, the following final elemental content results were obtained: the average mass fraction of Cr in the MX phase region was 8.9%, and the average mass fraction of Nb was 0.68%; the average mass fraction of Cr in the Z phase region was 14.8%, and the average mass fraction of Nb was 0.33%.

[0079] Step S3: Calculate the degree of difference for each element based on the mass fraction obtained in step S2. ; ; Step S4: Calculate the results in step S3. and Substitute into the nonlinear model to calculate the lifetime loss rate: ; According to the tiered assessment rules It falls within the second tier, 5% to 15%, while Still less than 3%, falling into the first tier, the two indicators occupy different tiers. This is based on the calculation results of a non-linear model. Based on the standard, if the percentage falls within the 50% to 80% range, the P92 steel component is determined to be in the late stage of service, and it is recommended to shorten the inspection cycle to within 6 months. In this embodiment, due to... The value has not exceeded the 80% threshold, and the inconsistency is relatively minor. Therefore, the result of the nonlinear model calculation is used directly for determination, without the need to introduce [other methods]. and Correction.

[0080] Implementation Results: This embodiment verifies the feasibility of using mechanical grinding for surface pretreatment when electropolishing conditions are not available on-site. Follow-up testing over the next six months showed that... It increased from 5.9% to 6.4%. The percentage of life loss increased from 0.35% to 0.39%, and the life loss rate increased from 68% to 71%. The Z-phase evolution is still progressing, which is consistent with the judgment conclusion of the later stage of service.

[0081] The three embodiments described above address three typical scenarios: mid-service pipeline assessment, end-of-life pipeline assessment, and pipeline assessment under on-site mechanical grinding pretreatment conditions. They verify the applicability of the method of the present invention under different service times, different Z-phase evolution stages, and different pretreatment conditions. The common technical route of the three embodiments follows the execution flow of steps S1 to S4. The core differences are: different surface pretreatment methods (electrolytic polishing in embodiments one and two, and mechanical grinding in embodiment three); different Z-phase evolution degrees, corresponding to different elemental difference values ​​and lifespan loss levels; and different levels of auxiliary parameter correction (embodied in embodiment two, where the two indicators are in different grading intervals). Introduced when it exceeds 80% and Correction.

[0082] In summary, the embodiments of the present invention have at least the following technical effects: This invention, by quantitatively measuring the difference in Cr and Nb element content between the Z and MX phases, transforms the element migration patterns during the chemical evolution of the Z phase into a quantifiable lifetime loss index, enabling the detection of aging signals in the early stages of Z phase nucleation. Example 1 verifies that this invention can detect aging signals in the mid-service stage, when lifetime loss is approximately 46%. and It identifies aging signals and provides accurate service stage determination.

[0083] This invention employs a combination of surface pretreatment to remove the oxide layer and focused ion beam micro-invasive sampling. The sampling point diameter is no greater than 3 mm and the depth is no greater than 2 mm, which has almost no impact on the structural integrity of in-service pressure-bearing components. The sampling damage in Examples 1 to 3 is all at the microgram level, and the testing can be completed without long-term unit shutdown.

[0084] This invention uses a nonlinear model with an exponential term to calculate the life loss rate. Example 2 verifies that in the extremely high-risk stage where the life loss is about 89%, this invention can accurately identify the end of the life and provide replacement recommendations by introducing a correction mechanism for V element difference and interface dislocation density. Subsequent creep fracture tests confirm the accuracy of the evaluation conclusions.

[0085] It is understood that the above embodiments are merely exemplary implementations used to illustrate the principles of the present invention, and the present invention is not limited thereto. For those skilled in the art, various modifications and improvements can be made without departing from the spirit and essence of the present invention, and these modifications and improvements are also considered to be within the scope of protection of the present invention.

Claims

1. A method for evaluating the life consumption of P92 steel based on the difference in Z-phase components, characterized by, include: Step S1: Pre-treat the surface of the sampling area of ​​the P92 steel component to be evaluated, and extract thin sheet samples containing the MX phase and Z phase coexisting structure on the pre-treated surface using ion beam cutting technology; Step S2: Characterize the micro-area elemental composition of the coexisting MX phase and Z phase in the thin-film sample, and measure the mass fractions of Cr and Nb in the MX phase region and the Z phase region, respectively; Step S3: Calculate the Cr elemental difference based on the mass fraction obtained in step S2. Difference between Nb and other elements ; Step S4: According to the above and stated The lifetime loss rate was calculated using a nonlinear model to characterize the accelerated degradation effect in the later stages of Z-phase evolution. And based on the said lifespan loss rate Determine the life loss level of the P92 steel component.

2. The method for assessing the life loss of P92 steel based on Z-phase compositional differences according to claim 1, characterized in that, In step S1, the surface pretreatment uses electrolytic polishing or mechanical grinding to remove the surface oxide layer of the sampling area, with a removal depth of 50μm~200μm.

3. The method for assessing the life loss of P92 steel based on Z-phase compositional differences according to claim 1, characterized in that, In step S1, the ion beam cutting technology is focused ion beam technology, and the ion source used in the focused ion beam technology is a gallium ion source, a xenon plasma ion source, or a helium ion source. Before the focused ion beam technique extracts the thin-film sample, a protective layer is deposited on the pretreated surface; the sampling point diameter of the thin-film sample is no greater than 3 mm, and the sampling depth is no greater than 2 mm.

4. The method for assessing the life loss of P92 steel based on Z-phase compositional differences according to claim 3, characterized in that, In step S1, when the ion beam cutting technology extracts the thin film sample, a first-energy ion beam is used for rough cutting, and then a second-energy ion beam with a lower energy than the first energy is used for fine cutting; the thickness of the thin film sample is no greater than 100nm, and the surface flatness is no greater than 5nm.

5. The method for assessing the life loss of P92 steel based on Z-phase compositional differences according to claim 4, characterized in that, The first energy is 30 keV, the second energy is 5 keV, and the ion beam is... Ion beam.

6. The method for assessing the life loss of P92 steel based on Z-phase compositional differences according to claim 1, characterized in that, In step S2, the elemental composition characterization of the micro-area is performed using an aberration-corrected transmission electron microscope combined with an energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS). The accelerating voltage of the aberration-corrected transmission electron microscope is 200 kV, the beam current is 0.5 nA, and the spatial resolution is no greater than 1 nm. The characterization of the MX phase and Z phase co-occurrence structure includes line scan and area scan analysis, with a line scan step size of 0.5 nm. At least five different MX phase and Z phase co-occurrence structures are randomly selected and measured respectively, and the average value is taken as the final result of the mass fraction of the Cr and Nb elements.

7. The method for assessing the life loss of P92 steel based on Z-phase compositional differences according to claim 1, characterized in that, In step S3, the Cr element difference is calculated. Difference between Nb and other elements : ; ; in, The mass fraction of Cr element in the Z phase. The mass fraction of Cr element in the MX phase. The mass fraction of Nb element in the MX phase. The mass fraction of Nb element in the Z phase; In step S4, the calculation formula for the nonlinear model is: ; in, The term refers to the lifespan attrition rate, expressed as a percentage. The Cr element difference is expressed in %. The Nb element difference is expressed in percent.

8. The method for assessing the life loss of P92 steel based on Z-phase compositional differences according to claim 7, characterized in that, In step S4, the classification rule for the lifespan loss level is as follows: When the Less than 5% and the When the percentage is less than 3%, the P92 steel component is determined to be in the middle of its service life, and the inspection cycle is 1 year. When the Not less than 5% and less than 15%, and the aforementioned When the percentage is not less than 3% and less than 8%, the P92 steel component is determined to be in the late stage of service, and the inspection cycle is shortened to within 6 months. When the Not less than 15% and the aforementioned If the percentage is not less than 8%, the P92 steel component is considered to be at the end of its service life, and it is recommended to replace the component immediately.

9. The method for assessing the life loss of P92 steel based on Z-phase compositional differences according to claim 8, characterized in that, In step S2, the mass fraction of V element in the MX phase region and the Z phase region is also measured. In step S4, when the and stated When the different hierarchical intervals are inconsistent, the calculation result of the nonlinear model shall prevail, and the V-element difference degree shall be introduced. and interface dislocation density The lifetime attrition rate is corrected, and the corrected lifetime attrition rate is... for: ; ; in, The lifetime loss rate is calculated for the nonlinear model. For the V element's difference degree, The mass fraction of V element in the MX phase. The mass fraction of V element in the Z phase. The interfacial dislocation density of the MX-Z phase coexisting structure is given in units of 1. The lifetime loss rate was obtained statistically from bright-field images obtained by transmission electron microscopy; The lifespan loss level is determined as the final assessment result.

10. The method for assessing the life loss of P92 steel based on Z-phase compositional differences according to any one of claims 1 to 9, characterized in that, The P92 steel components to be evaluated are the main steam pipes or high-temperature reheat steam pipes of supercritical or ultra-supercritical units with a service life of not less than 100,000 hours.