METHOD AND SYSTEM FOR DETERMINING THE CONDITIONS FOR AN AIRCRAFT RUNWAY

DE602021021898T2Active Publication Date: 2024-11-13SAFRAN AIRCRAFT ENGINES SAS +3
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
DE602021021898
Authority / Receiving Office
DE · DE
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2020-12-11
Filing Date
2021-12-01
Publication Date
2024-11-13
Estimated Expiration
2041-12-01

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Current methods for determining airport runway conditions are unreliable and imprecise, relying on subjective pilot reports, imprecise friction coefficient measurements, and limited sensor data, leading to inefficient runway usage and potential safety issues.

Method used

A method and system that acquire and combine multiple data sources, including braking parameters and taxiing conditions, using weighting coefficients to develop a track coefficient with a confidence index, ensuring consistency and reliability of runway condition assessment.

Benefits of technology

Provides a reliable and relevant assessment of runway conditions, optimizing runway usage and reducing closures by integrating diverse data sources and adjusting weighting coefficients based on relevance and time, resulting in a comprehensive Runway Condition Code (RWYCC) compliant with GRF regulations.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.
Patent Text Reader
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[0001] The present invention relates, in general, to the optimization of airport traffic and the reduction of the number of runway closures which can have very significant financial consequences for airport operators.

[0002] More particularly, the invention relates to determining the conditions of the landing runways of an airport in order to optimize the use of the runways, while satisfying safety requirements.

[0003] Currently, airport operators must monitor runway conditions. This monitoring is carried out either from radio reports provided by aircraft just after landing, or from friction coefficient measurements taken using test trucks that circulate on the runways, or from sensors buried on the runway that determine the type and height of contaminants, or from meteorological probes, or from manual observations and measurements by a runway inspector, or from the manual combination of all these data sources.

[0004] The radio reports provided by the pilot upon landing can be somewhat subjective. Regarding friction coefficient measurements, this data source is also imprecise, since the test truck used to perform the measurements cannot effectively simulate the taxiing of an aircraft, particularly a large aircraft, so the measurements taken are relatively imprecise. In addition, this data source requires the runways to be closed during measurement. Measurements from buried sensors represent only a 1cm2 sample on a runway several kilometers long. The same is true of manual measurements by runway inspectors.

[0005] It is also known to estimate a slip indicator of an airport runway by detecting the lateral deviation of an aircraft from a reference trajectory, or to monitor the deceleration of an aircraft based on braking data.

[0006] Document US 10 202 204 B1 discloses a complete method and apparatus for commercial transport aircraft, flight operations and flight safety, and in particular, providing increased safety by measuring, monitoring, managing and controlling aircraft runway operations, which include takeoffs and landings, as well as all associated maneuvers. Document US 2019 / 156682 A1 discloses a system for improving aircraft landing conditions by considering data provided by aircraft that have landed before. Document US 2010 / 079308 A1 discloses a method for supervising an aircraft landing phase by also considering runway parameters. Document FR 3 077 913 A1 discloses a method for aiding decision-making before the start of an aircraft's final descent in view of the conditions of a landing runway.Document US 2015 / 142388 A1 discloses a method for determining a friction coefficient of a runway by aggregating friction coefficients for different locations of the runway.

[0007] In view of the above, the aim of the invention is to provide a status report of aircraft runway conditions that is of increased reliability and relevance and that can be used to optimize runway use by airport operators. In addition, the objective is to bring all these available measurement sources into line with each other and to add new, more reliable methods, weighted according to the relevance of each data source.

[0008] The invention therefore relates, according to a first aspect, to a method for determining runway conditions for aircraft, which comprises the steps of: acquiring a set of data groups of different types for the evaluation and observation of runway degradation conditions; developing weighting coefficients for each data group; filtering the data; determining, for each data group, a partial runway condition; modifying the weighting coefficients for each data group; and combining the partial runway conditions to develop a runway coefficient associated with a confidence index developed from modified weighting coefficients.

[0009] Advantageously, during filtering, the data are grouped by braking zone segments each associated with braking zone segment identification information, dating information for said data, segment position information and a modified weighting coefficient.

[0010] According to another characteristic of the method according to the invention, during the acquisition of the data, first data relating to braking parameters of the aircraft and second data developed on the ground relating to the taxiing conditions of the aircraft are acquired.

[0011] The first data are advantageously acquired when the aircraft is taxiing on the landing runway at a speed below a threshold value.

[0012] According to another characteristic, at the end of the filtering step, the first data relating to the braking parameters are provided to a calculation stage capable of developing a time-stamped track friction coefficient and a modified weighting coefficient.

[0013] Advantageously, during the step of calculating the friction coefficient, the friction coefficient is calculated from the first filtered data and the second filtered data.

[0014] The method may further comprise a step of decoding the first data and a step of decoding the second data.

[0015] For example, the second data includes aircraft position data, runway condition data, and weather data.

[0016] Advantageously, the weighting coefficient resulting from the filtering step is modified according to the time or the sampling frequency of the data.

[0017] The method may further comprise a prior step of initializing weighting coefficients for each group of data.

[0018] According to yet another characteristic of the method according to the invention, during the step of determining the partial track condition, data from another data group is used.

[0019] It is possible to provide that the runway coefficient is developed for different sectors of the runway, in particular by third of the runway. In addition, a history of the runway coefficients can be developed.

[0020] The invention also relates to a system for determining landing runway conditions for aircraft, this system comprising: means for acquiring a set of data groups of different types for the evaluation and observation of runway degradation conditions; means for assigning weighting coefficients to the data of the data groups; data filtering means; and calculation means configured to determine, for each data group, a partial runway condition and to modify the weighting coefficients of each data group; said calculation means being capable of combining the partial track states to develop a track coefficient associated with a confidence index developed from the modified weighting coefficients.

[0021] Other aims, characteristics and advantages of the invention will appear on reading the following description, given solely by way of non-limiting example, and made with reference to the appended drawings in which: [ Fig 1 ] illustrates the general architecture of a system for determining landing runway conditions in accordance with the invention; [ Fig 2 ] is a block diagram of a runway condition determination system according to the invention, showing the main functional platforms of the system; [ Fig 3 ] is a flowchart showing the main phases of data acquisition and processing for the development of the track coefficient; [ Fig 4 ] is a flowchart illustrating the acquisition of data relating to aircraft braking parameters; [ Fig 5 ] illustrates data filtering; [ Fig 6 ] illustrates the calculation of the friction coefficient µ seen by the aircraft; and [ Fig 7 ] schematically shows an example of a report following the method for determining track conditions according to the invention.

[0022] It has been represented on the figure 1 an exemplary embodiment of a system for determining runway conditions for aircraft according to the invention.

[0023] This system is designed to calculate and provide a Runway Condition Code (RWYCC) for various sections of an airport's runways and to provide runway conditions to the airport operator to enable them to optimize runway operations, particularly by reducing runway closures. This RWYCC coefficient complies with the current GRF (Global Reporting Format) regulations according to RTM.0704.

[0024] This RWYCC coefficient is developed from various data sources and is provided with a confidence index reflecting the reliability of the calculated coefficient.

[0025] The RWYCC coefficient is in particular developed from initial data relating to aircraft braking parameters and from second data developed on the ground relating to the aircraft's taxiing conditions.

[0026] Also referring to the figure 2 , the first D1 data are delivered by the aircraft, after landing, in the form of a radio report.

[0027] This may, for example, include data including aircraft type, aircraft weight, wheel speed relative to the ground, hydraulic brake pressure, flight phase, thrust reverser status, brake pedal depress, GPS positions, etc.

[0028] The second data D2 relates more specifically to track conditions and is delivered by sensors C, by radar data Rd, by weather reports W or measurements delivered by test trucks Tt.

[0029] For example, sensors are used to determine the possible presence of contaminants, such as water, snow, stagnant water, mud, etc., the thickness of the contaminant, the surface condition of the runway, for example dry, wet, wet slippery, the ground temperature, etc.

[0030] The radar data is used to determine the position of the aircraft, and the test truck provides a coefficient of friction.

[0031] The runway condition determination system essentially comprises a data acquisition and calculation platform 1 which acquires the various data groups D1 and D2 useful for the evaluation and observation of the degradation conditions of the airport runways, and calculates, for each runway section, for example for each third of the runway, a runway coefficient associated with a confidence index. This platform 1 also provides a human-machine interface accessible for example by means of a computer application API by the airport manager G who provides this information to the air traffic controller Ctrl to deliver this information to the aircraft in flight A.

[0032] Platform 1 thus comprises an interface I for collecting and processing flight data which receives the data D1 delivered by the aircraft, a stage II for storing and decoding data receiving the first data D1 decoded by interface I and the second data D2 and a stage III for calculating receiving the data decoded by the stage II for storing and decoding and configured to calculate from the decoded data the track coefficients each associated with a confidence index, in a format suitable for being presented on the API interface.

[0033] We will now describe with reference to the figure 3 the main steps of the method for determining track conditions in accordance with the invention.

[0034] As can be seen, this method comprises two phases of data acquisition and processing carried out in parallel for the acquisition and processing of the first and second groups of data D1 and D2.

[0035] As regards, firstly, the braking data of the D1 aircraft, during a first stage 2, the raw data are acquired.

[0036] As visible on the figure 4 , this first step 2 is initiated upon landing, as soon as the aircraft comes into contact with the runway (step 3).

[0037] If this is the case, the braking data are recorded by interface I (step 4). These data are recorded as long as the aircraft is on the runway and the ground speed is above a limiting speed, for example ten knots (step 5). Outside of these conditions, the recording is stopped (step 6). In the following step 7, it is checked whether the data transmission conditions are met and, if so, the recorded raw data are transmitted and stored by the storage and decoding stage II (step 8).

[0038] Transmission conditions may be determined by aircraft type, airline and destination airport.

[0039] At the end of this data capture phase, the raw data are decoded (step 9) by the data storage and decoding stage II then filtered and processed by the third calculation stage III (step 10).

[0040] It will be noted that the collection and processing interface I and the storage stage II assign to each group of data a weighting coefficient, respectively K1, with regard to the first group of data D1 and K2, with regard to the second group of data D2. Thus, by way of non-limiting example, the radar data are associated with a weighting coefficient 25, the data from the sensors are associated with a coefficient equal to 30, the meteorological data have a coefficient equal to 20 and the braking data have a coefficient of 25.

[0041] For each data group, a partial runway condition is calculated and the evolution of runway conditions is determined, associated with an estimate of the evolution of a confidence index from the calculated runway conditions.

[0042] The weighting coefficient K1 or K2 of a subset is conditioned during the process by the weighting of the data group, the relevance of the analyzed data, their sampling frequency and the dating of the acquired data, as a function of time, the confidence index degrading as a function of time, without new data.

[0043] The weighting coefficients are also modified if data from another group is taken into account.

[0044] In fact, the processing of each data group is capable of using, as input, raw data from another group of raw decoded data.

[0045] For example, braking data can be combined with radar data to correlate the position seen by the aircraft with that given by the radar. Similarly, braking data can be combined with data from sensors to use, depending on the context, braking data to optimize and correlate calculations.

[0046] For example, if radar data is not available, aircraft positioning data available in the on-board computers is used.

[0047] Note that, by default, this radar data is not present, and we will use the data that is in the aircraft, in addition to the wheel speeds, the aircraft speed, the pedal pressure,

[0048] In fact, a negative temperature and snowfall announced by the sensors will imply a predominance of the runway coefficient associated with a contaminated runway.

[0049] The subsequent calculation of the track coefficient results from the merger of the results from each group of data weighted by the modified weighting coefficient and incorporates an average confidence index resulting from the weighting of the coefficients of each subset of data.

[0050] In reference to the figure 5 , the filtering algorithm is applied in parallel to various data configurations, namely to standard qualification data or company-specific qualification data. In this figure, for the sake of clarity, only the processing performed on one data configuration has been illustrated, the processing being otherwise performed on the other data configurations.

[0051] For each data type, the braking zone of the track is divided into braking zones (step 11). For each braking zone, it is then determined whether the braking is manual braking or automatic braking. However, the data are used differently, depending on whether it is manual braking (step 12) or automatic braking (step 13). If it is manual braking (step 12), the recorded or unrecorded data are formatted separately by QAR quick access recording (steps 14 and 15). If it is automatic braking, it is checked whether a maximum braking coefficient is reached on each braking zone (step 16).

[0052] When filtering, the weighting coefficients are updated depending on the nature of the braking, automatic braking, generally involving braking with a lower braking coefficient, involving an increase in the K'1 weighting coefficients, while recording the data by QAR involving a decrease in the K'1 weighting coefficients.

[0053] The braking segments are thus formatted according to the nature of the braking and by type of recording (step 17).

[0054] For each braking segment, a vector is developed, each vector identifying the segment, the segment type and the modified weighting coefficient K'1 assigned to the data.

[0055] In addition, each segment is associated with data, a timestamp, position and braking phase.

[0056] Furthermore, the filtering implemented is temporal filtering and is specific to each type of data.

[0057] Additionally, filtering is performed based on the data sampling rate to standardize the sampling rate used for data acquisition by weighting the data differently based on its sampling rate.

[0058] At the end of the filtering step, the first data D1 relating to the aircraft braking parameters are processed by calculation stage III to calculate the runway friction coefficient µ (step 18).

[0059] In reference to the figure 6 , this calculation is carried out from the filtered data Df identified by the track segment and the track type and, where appropriate, from filtered data Df' coming from another data group.

[0060] As for the braking data, this is integrated with the data type information.

[0061] The data type is a vector that allows you to know the type of braking, the type of precision, the type of aircraft or equipment, etc.

[0062] If other data is available, for example data from sensors or radar, it is also integrated into the calculation and a Boolean variable Var is set to "TRUE" to indicate that the weighting coefficient associated with this data can be improved.

[0063] If this is not the case, the boolean variable Var is set to "FALSE" to indicate that the weighting coefficient will not be affected.

[0064] For example, the calculation of the friction coefficient µ seen by the aircraft is carried out by prior learning obtained from data from aircraft that have already landed or from experimental data, and uses a model estimated from this data, the friction coefficient then being obtained by prediction from the filtered data.

[0065] Of course, the prediction is updated as the training base is enriched with new data received.

[0066] Various types of techniques can be used for this purpose.

[0067] For example, we will use a Random Forest algorithm to predict the value of a friction coefficient from the decoded data.

[0068] In calculation step 18 of the friction coefficient, the weighting coefficient K1" is modified according to the position of the braking zone.

[0069] In the following step 19, a partial RCC track condition is defined locally from the value of the friction coefficient and, at the end of step 19, the weighting coefficient K1" is modified as a function of time (K1‴), the oldest data being assigned a degraded confidence coefficient.

[0070] As seen on the figure 3 , the second data D2 produced on the ground relating to the taxiing conditions of the aircraft also undergo steps 2, 9 and 10 of capture, decoding and filtering. However, the filtered data are directly used for the calculation of the partial runway condition RCC (step 19). It is only at the end of the step of calculating the partial runway condition that the weighting coefficient is modified as a function of time (K'2).

[0071] In the next step 20, the track coefficient is calculated, this track coefficient being associated with a confidence index calculated from the modified weighting coefficients. This calculation is carried out from the sum of the weighted local track states.

[0072] In other words, the RWYCC track coefficient is developed from the following relationship: RWYCC = ∑ RCC × K ‴ ∑ K ‴

[0073] This provides an overall track coefficient for each section of track, accompanied by a confidence index IC, the value of which depends on the time of data acquisition and the position of the braking zone.

[0074] Finally, during the final step 21, the track coefficient and the confidence index available for each sector of the track are delivered to the API computer application, advantageously accessible online.

[0075] It has been represented on the figure 7 an example of the implementation of such a report.

[0076] The API application provides, for example, a window illustrating different tracks, here two in number, comprising several sectors S1, S2, S3, S4, S5, S6 each identified.

[0077] Each sector is associated with a track coefficient RWYCC, here Rwycc1 to Rwycc6 i associated with its confidence index IC, here IC1 to IC6.

[0078] In addition, each sector is associated with the list of entries Dlij to D6ij, each associated with a weighting coefficient Klij to K6ij. A history of the track coefficients RWYCC i (t) each associated with their confidence index Ic i (t) can also be provided to enable the development of a trend in the variation of the track coefficients to provide decision support based on the history of the variation of the track coefficients.

Claims

1. Method for determining aircraft landing runway conditions, comprising the steps of: - acquiring a set of data groups (D1, D2) of different types for evaluating and monitoring deteriorating runway conditions; - deriving weighting coefficients (K1, K2) for each data group; - filtering the data; - determining, for each data group, a partial runway condition (RCC); - modifying the weighting coefficients of each data group; and - combining the partial runway conditions to derive a runway coefficient (RWYCC) associated with a confidence index (CI) derived from the modified weighting coefficients.

2. Method according to claim 1, wherein, during filtering, the data is grouped by braking zone segments, each associated with braking zone segment identification information, dating information of said data, segment position information and a modified weighting coefficient.

3. Method according to one of claims 1 or 2, wherein, during the data acquisition, first data (D1) relating to braking parameters of the aircraft and second data (D2) derived from the ground relating to taxiing conditions of the aircraft are acquired.

4. Method according to claim 3, wherein the first data (D1) is acquired as long as the aircraft is taxiing on the runway at a speed below a threshold value.

5. Method according to one of claims 3 and 4, wherein, at an end of the filtering step, the first data relating to the braking parameters is supplied to a calculating step (III) adapted to derive a time-stamped coefficient of friction (µ) de the runway and a modified weighting coefficient.

6. Method according to claim 5, wherein, during the step of calculating the coefficient of friction (µ), the coefficient of friction is calculated from first filtered data and second filtered data.

7. Method according to any one of claims 3 to 6, comprising a step of decoding the first and second data.

8. Method according to any one of claims 3 to 7, wherein the second data comprises aircraft position data, data on the conditions of the runway and meteorological data.

9. Method according to any one of claims 1 to 8, wherein the weighting coefficient derived from the filtering step is modified as a function of time or a sampling frequency of the data.

10. Method according to any one of claims 1 to 9, comprising a prior step of initialising weighting coefficients for each data group.

11. Method according to any one of claims 1 to 10, wherein during the step of determining the partial runway condition, data from another data group is used.

12. Method according to any one of claims 1 to 11, wherein the runway coefficient (RWYCC) is derived for different sectors of the runway, in particular for each third of the runway, and wherein a history of runway coefficients is compiled.

13. System for determining aircraft landing runway conditions, comprising: - means (I, II) for acquiring a set of data groups of different types for evaluating and monitoring deteriorating runway conditions; - means (I, II) for assigning weighting coefficients to each data group; - filtering and calculating means (III) configured for determining, for each data group, a partial runway condition, and for modifying weighting coefficients of each data group; and - the calculating means (III) being adapted to combine partial runway conditions for producing a runway coefficient associated with a confidence index derived from modified weighting coefficients.