Method for simulating at least partial operation of automated machine for manufacturing or packaging consumer product
The integration of CAD environments with motion control software for automatic machines addresses simulation complexity and time issues, enabling real-time actuator behavior simulation and remote issue resolution, improving production efficiency and reducing travel costs.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2024056590
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2023-03-29
- Filing Date
- 2024-03-29
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-06
AI Technical Summary
Existing simulation methods for automatic machines are complex and time-consuming, making it difficult to identify and resolve design issues, especially in multi-machine systems, and do not accurately reflect the real behavior of actuators due to reliance on oscilloscope graphs and theoretical 3D modeling.
A method and apparatus that integrates a computer-aided design environment with motion control software to simulate the operation of machine parts, allowing real-time control and visualization of actuator behavior, including collision detection and zero-point verification, using processors and interfaces to synchronize actual machine operations with virtual models.
Facilitates efficient and economical simulation of automatic machine operations, enabling early detection of design errors and reducing travel costs by allowing remote monitoring and resolution of issues, thus enhancing production efficiency and reducing downtime.
Smart Images

Figure 2024156614000001_ABST
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS This patent application claims priority from Italian Patent Application No. 102023000006141, filed on March 29, 2023, the entire disclosure of which is incorporated herein by reference.
[0002] The present invention relates to a method for simulating the operation of at least part of an automated machine for manufacturing or packaging consumer products, which can be advantageously applied, but is not limited to, to the simulation of the operation of an automated machine for producing packs, which will be explicitly mentioned in the following description without loss of generality. [Background technology]
[0003] Automated manufacturing machines usually comprise a number of actuators that act on consumer products (e.g. cigarette packs, food products, sanitary absorbent articles, etc.) to change their shape, structure or position. Typically, said actuators are electric motors or pneumatic cylinders, integrally connected to machine parts of various shapes and dimensions designed to process the consumer products. Due to the continuous increase in production volumes, automated machines are becoming more and more complex, both in terms of smaller machine parts that must perform more complex operations, and in terms of the increasing number of active parts of the automated machines, such as motors or sensors. This complexity makes it difficult for manufacturers to identify and solve design problems and errors by simulation. Simulations are usually performed with motion controllers, which provide as output of the simulation graphs that are not always easy to read. In other words, debugging the operation of the actuators of an automated machine is currently done with oscilloscope graphs that show its logic (which is not intuitive).
[0004] However, such graphs make it difficult for users to understand the details of the last followers' behavior, which are often connected to the motor by a reduction unit or a crank mechanism, and as a result, it is difficult to accurately understand the behavior mode of the last followers in shared spaces where collisions may occur.
[0005] This problem is obviously exacerbated when multiple machines are connected in series.
[0006] In recent years, simplified graphics virtual visual models have been developed in simulation environments of motion controllers (e.g. TwinCAT®) to check for the presence or absence of a collision.
[0007] However, generating these graphics requires additional time on top of the design time, resulting in a significant increase in machine delivery times.
[0008] At the same time, 3D modeling programs, also known as CAD (Computer Aided Design), allow multiple parts of an automated machine to be linked together so that the movement of one of them causes the others to move as well. This allows designers to test the correct movement of parts that are linked together, but not parts that are driven by different motors (where the designer would operate the parts manually, for example with a mouse).
[0009] In recent years, simulation with 3D modeling programs has become more advanced, allowing designers to record videos from a fixed viewpoint and simulate the movement of parts, where the position of one or more parts is updated in a predefined way. However, this solution is used to test theoretical movements, not real movements, i.e. movements that exist in the programs of the motion controllers that actually control the electric motors of automated machines.
[0010] Therefore, it is not possible without great effort to obtain a simulation at the logic level of the motion controller, PLC or industrial PC where the laws of operation and how they are programmed can be simultaneously debugged visually.
[0011] Therefore, it is necessary to improve the usability of visual simulations so that manufacturers can check the correct execution / writing of code and the designed operating laws without having to spend days simplifying 3D models and implementing internal models of motion controllers. Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0012] The object of the present invention is to provide a method for simulating the operation of at least part of an automated machine for manufacturing or packaging consumer products, which at least partially overcomes the above-mentioned drawbacks and at the same time is easy and economical to implement. [Means for solving the problem]
[0013] According to the present invention there is provided a method for simulating the operation of at least a part of an automated machine for manufacturing or packaging consumer products as claimed in the accompanying claims, and also an apparatus for simulating the operation of at least a part of an automated machine for manufacturing or packaging consumer products for carrying out said method.
[0014] The appended claims describe preferred embodiments of the invention and form an integral part of this specification. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0015] The invention will now be described with reference to the accompanying drawings, which show some non-limiting embodiments thereof. [Figure 1] FIG. 1 is a schematic perspective view of an automated manufacturing machine for producing packs. [Diagram 2]FIG. 2 is a schematic perspective view of a virtual three-dimensional model of a portion of the automated manufacturing machine of FIG. [Diagram 3] FIG. 3 is a schematic structural diagram of an apparatus according to the present invention, with some details removed for greater clarity. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0016] FIG. 1 shows diagrammatically an automatic machine 1 for the production of consumer products, in particular an automatic production machine 1 for the production of cigarette packs.
[0017] In the drawings, like numbers and like reference characters indicate like elements or components having like functions.
[0018] For purposes of the present invention, the term "second" component does not imply the presence of a "first" component, and indeed these terms are merely used as labels to improve clarity and should not be construed as limiting.
[0019] The elements and features contained in the various preferred embodiments, including the drawings, as explained below, can for this reason be combined with one another without exceeding the scope of protection of the present patent application.
[0020] The automated machine 1 comprises a number of movable operating elements 2 designed to process consumer products 3 (in the embodiment shown in FIG. 1 , cigarette packs 4). In particular, the automated machine 1 comprises a part 5 (e.g. a packaging or pack-forming unit) with a set of actuators 6, each actuator 6 being mechanically connected to at least one respective movable operating element 2 for performing one or more processing operations on one or more products 3.
[0021] According to some preferred but non-limiting embodiments, as shown in the attached figures, the actuator 6 comprises an electric motor (particularly of the brushless type). According to other non-limiting embodiments, the actuator 6 also comprises operating elements other than an electric motor (such as pneumatic or hydraulic cylinders, electrically actuated cylinders, etc.).
[0022] According to one aspect of the invention, an apparatus 7 is provided for simulating the operation of a first part 5 of an automated machine 1 for manufacturing or packaging a consumer product 3. In particular, the apparatus 7 may be comprised in the circuit of the automated machine 1 (e.g. in an interface device 8 such as a control panel 9 with an industrial PC) or may be located in a mobile system 10 such as a tablet 11 or a designer's PC.
[0023] As shown in the non-limiting embodiment of FIG. 2, the device 7 comprises a first processor 12 configured to define, in a computer-aided design environment 14 (also known as a CAD program of known type, not described in detail, e.g. Inventor®, Creo®, Solid Edge®, etc.), a (virtual) three-dimensional model 13 of a part 5 of the automated machine 1, the operation of which has to be simulated.
[0024] For example, the first processor 12 may be the processor or one of the processors of the mobile system 10 or the interface device 8 (in particular one of the processors of the PC of the designer of the part 5).
[0025] Furthermore, the device 7 preferably comprises a second processor 15 configured to execute software SW for controlling the operation of one or more movable operating elements 2 of the part 5 of the automatic machine 1.
[0026] In particular, the control software SW is configured to, in use, control the actual movement of the part 5 of the machine 1. In other words, the movement control software SW is a program which controls the electric motors or actuators 6 which move the movable movement elements 2 of the part 5 once the part 5 has been manufactured.
[0027] The software SW is executed by the second processor 15 both to directly control the actuators 6 and to simulate the behavior of the actuators 6, and thus the elements 2, before the machine 1 is assembled. In other words, the software SW is essentially the software that controls the operation of the parts 5 of the automatic machine 1 (or the entire automatic machine 1) and, during the design phase, is typically used to obtain the oscilloscope graphs mentioned at the beginning of this specification.
[0028] For example, the second processor 15 may be the processor or one of the processors of the mobile system 10 or the interface device 8 (in particular one of the processors of the PC of the designer of the part 5).
[0029] Furthermore, the apparatus 7 comprises a control unit 16 configured to connect the first processor 12 to the second processor 15 by means of an interface 17, preferably a software interface (e.g. API), and to exchange data sets DS (for established commanded positions P for one or more mobile operating elements 2 or elements connected thereto at given times t1, t2, ..., tn) from the motion control software SW to the aided design environment 14.
[0030] In some non-limiting cases, the control unit 16 preferably monitors and controls the first processor 12 , the second processor 15 , and the interface 17 .
[0031] Preferably, but not by way of limitation, the first processor 12, the second processor 15 and the control unit 16 are provided in (or can be) the same computer, for example the tablet 11 or a designer's PC.
[0032] In particular, the control unit 16 is configured to simulate the movement of one or more movable operating elements 2 in the assisted design environment 14 by changing the position (in the virtual three-dimensional space) of the one or more movable operating elements 2 in accordance with a dataset DS relating to a commanded position P.
[0033] According to a further aspect of the invention, a computer-implemented method for simulating operation of at least a part 5 of an automated machine 1 for manufacturing or packaging a consumer product 3 is provided.
[0034] The method first comprises a step of defining a three-dimensional model 13 in a computer-aided design environment 14. This definition can be performed by importing one or more components connected and / or linked to one another, by directly designing the components in the environment 14 or by a combination of these activities. This results in, in particular, in a three-dimensional model 13 of a part 5 of the automated machine, the movement of which has to be simulated and which includes the respective one or more mobile operating elements 2.
[0035] Furthermore, the method comprises a step of programming or exporting software SW for controlling the operation of one or more mobile operating elements 2 of the part 5 of the automatic machine 1. In particular, as mentioned above, the control software SW is designed to control the actual operation of the part 5 of the machine 1, when in use.
[0036] The method preferably comprises the steps of: at successive time points t1, t2, ..., tn (as shown in the non-limiting embodiment of FIG. 2): - extracting, during execution of the motion control software SW, a data set DS relating to commanded positions P at given times t1, t2, ..., tn of one or more mobile motion elements 2 or elements 18 connected thereto; - transmitting a data set DS relating to a commanded position P to an aided design environment 14; - simulating the movement of one or more mobile operating elements 2 in an assisted design environment by modifying the position of the one or more mobile operating elements 2 according to a data set DS relative to a commanded position P; periodically repeating In particular, during the extraction step, the second processor 15 displays a software interface table 19 containing data DS relating to positions P established by the software SW at particular times t1, t2, . . . , tn.
[0037] The interface 17 then preferably retrieves the software interface table 19 (processing / translating it, if necessary, according to a predefined protocol) and transmits it to the first processor 12, which (controlled by the control unit 16) modifies the position of the element 2 on the basis of the data DS contained in the table 19, thus simulating instantaneously the successive positions of the mobile operating element 2 in the three-dimensional model 13 of the environment 14. In this way, it is possible to move inside the environment 14, while the mobile operating element 2 and / or other virtual objects connected to it move according to the software interface table 19, according to known methods.
[0038] Preferably, but not exclusively, communication between the aided design environment 14 and the running motion control software SW is performed in real time (via interface 17).
[0039] Preferably, but not in a limiting manner, in the assisted design environment 14, each movable operating element 2 of the three-dimensional model 13 is connected in a constrained manner to at least one shaft 20 configured to be operated by the motion control software SW (e.g., by the intermediation of an electric actuator). In other words, in the case of FIG. 3, the element 18 connected to the movable operating element 2 is the respective shaft 20.
[0040] Preferably, according to some preferred embodiments, the data set DS, i.e. the software interface table 19, comprises a commanded position P, preferably an absolute position, preferably an angle, of the respective shaft 20 of each movable operating element 2.
[0041] Preferably, but not exclusively, shaft 20 is the follower / output element of actuator 6 and thus is, for example, the output shaft of a reduction gear unit coupled to the rotor of an electric motor.
[0042] According to some non-limiting embodiments, the steps of extraction, propagation and simulation are performed periodically at successive time points at intervals of 10 ms or more, in particular 20 ms or more, in order to lighten the display of the simulation in the assisted design environment 14. In other words, the sampling / refresh time of the data set DS in the software interface table 19 is at least 10 ms, in particular 20 ms or more.
[0043] Preferably, but not in a limiting manner, in this case, in order to enable smooth display of the simulation, the method preferably further comprises a step of interpolating successive positions P of the same movable operating element 2 via the support design environment 14 (according to known techniques and therefore not described in detail).
[0044] In some preferred, non-limiting embodiments, the method further comprises a step of visually or mechanically verifying using an aided design environment (e.g., using known tools, not described in detail, for calculating distances and / or interferences), in particular interrupting the simulating step by pausing the operation of the motion control software SW to verify the distances between the mobile operating elements 2 and / or the distances from the fixed parts of the automatic machine 1, and / or the phasing of the movements of the mobile operating elements 2 in case of a shared workspace, and / or the zero point of the mobile operating elements 2 starting in the calculation of the position (in particular in case of the absolute position). In fact, by assuming a predetermined absolute position for the shaft 20 of the virtual three-dimensional model 13, the above can be visually verified by mechanical constraints that can be set through the environment 13 between the elements 2 and the shaft 20 (which is then actually controlled by the software SW). In this way, possible errors in the design, software, or even just the determination of the zero point of the electronic cam can be highlighted and detected.
[0045] According to some non-limiting embodiments, the automatic machine 1 comprises a control unit designed to control the state, position and dynamics of the mobile operating element 2 (and therefore also the actuator) and a recording system (not shown), in particular in real time, configured to record a track (i.e. to record a series of operating variables characterizing the operation of the automatic machine 1). For example, the recording system can be a computer, a processor, a printed circuit board, etc. In particular, the automatic machine 1 comprises a writeable memory (in particular a non-volatile one) connected to the recording system, on which the values of the operating variables to be recorded (i.e. the track) can be written.
[0046] Preferably, but not exclusively, the data set DS is extracted during execution of the motion control program on the real machine 1, so that its motion can be remotely analysed by a simulation step.
[0047] In some non-limiting cases, the recorded tracks containing the values of the recorded manipulated variables are used to generate a software interface table 19 (also called an “intermediate table”) that contains the positions P of the movable operating element (or, in other words, the shaft 20).
[0048] In another non-limiting example, the actual machine 1 and the device 7 are directly connected (via the Internet, assuming there are no bandwidth limitations) so that the actual machine 1 directly generates the data for the software interface table 19. In this way, an operator standing at a distance from the automated machine 1 can see exactly what is happening and what has happened with the automated machine 1, even from a considerable distance away, reducing service and travel costs for the automated machine manufacturer.
[0049] Preferably, but not exclusively, in addition to what has been disclosed so far, the method further comprises the step of extracting, during the execution of the motion control software SW, a data set DP relating to the presence or absence of one or more consumer products 3 at each given position at the time t1, t2, ..., tn. In other words, the method involves generating a further software interface table 21 (or an augmentation of table 19) containing logical presence information (presence / absence) relating to an article at a given position of the part 5 of the machine 1, in the same principle as used for the software interface table 19 disclosed above. For example, in one row of table 21 there is a positive data item relating to the presence at time t1 of a pack 4 in a sheet 22 of a drum 23 (as shown in FIG. 3).
[0050] As a result, although not limiting, the method further includes a step of transmitting the dataset DP regarding presence or absence to the assisted design environment 14 and a step of visually simulating the presence or absence of one or more products 3 at each given position (e.g., sheet 22) based on the dataset DP regarding presence or absence.
[0051] Generally speaking, therefore, the information regarding the presence or absence of a product is generated in any case in a fictitious manner by a part of the motion control software SW (which is disabled after the simulation, since it is of no use for the actual handling of the automatic machine 1).
[0052] In use, each designer works in their own development environment (the software designer works in the software development environment, the machine designer works in the environment 14 with a known CAD program). The software SW moves the actuators 6 independently of the environment 14, which receives in real time (through the interface 17 and the software interface table 19) the positions to be set for the virtual actuators 6. In case of long update times for the table 19, in order to reduce the load on the simulation environment 14, the positions at successive time points t1, t2, ..., tn are interpolated with each other, allowing the designer to see exactly how the software SW will make the real automatic machine 1 operate.
[0053] 2 exemplarily shows three successive time points t1, t2, ..., tn, where the first processor 15 provides the interface with three respective software interface tables 19 containing the positions X, Y, ..., N of the axes M1, M2, ..., Mn at the successive time points 1, 2, ..., n, respectively. These positions, preferably but not necessarily in degrees, for each axis (i.e. actuator 6), are sent to the first processor 12, which sets them as the successive positions of the actuators 6 in the virtual model 13.
[0054] The non-limiting embodiment of Fig. 3 shows a part 5 of an automatic machine 1 in which several mobile operating elements 2 (in particular two pushing elements 24 and two drums 23) share a working area in the area of a seat 22. In particular, a position of a follower shaft 20 is set, which is connected in the environment 14 to the mobile operating elements 2 either directly, as in the case of the drums 23, or via a three-point mechanism, as in the case of a pinion and rack connecting the shaft 20 to the pushing elements.
[0055] The device 7 is configured (and therefore programmed) to carry out the method described above.
[0056] Although the invention described above relates to a particular precise embodiment, its scope of protection should not be considered as limited to the exemplary embodiment, since it includes all variations, modifications or simplifications that would be obvious to a person skilled in the art, such as, for example, adding further steps, adding different types of generation of software interface tables, adding different types of calculations for determining the actuator positions or adding different types of simulations, using models or algorithms other than those described above, etc.
[0057] The present invention has many advantages.
[0058] Firstly, it enables communication between the software design environment and the mechanical design environment (CAD), in particular allowing designers to check the correctness of their software SW.
[0059] Furthermore, the correct zero point of the machine can be tested before the machine is assembled and the control of the electric actuators can be verified before the automated machine is assembled.
[0060] Furthermore, the present invention improves the efficiency of resolving potential faults, especially sporadic faults, thereby eliminating the need for technicians to travel to resolve issues affecting actuators.
[0061] In particular, the method disclosed above allows for checking for unexpected and undesirable events in real time or after they have actually occurred, either remotely.
[0062] Furthermore, the present invention allows sporadic problems to be resolved without necessarily stopping production since the recording or transmission of operating variables is done on-line while the machine is running.
[0063] Finally, the present invention enhances the software architecture to allow manufacturers to identify unexpected operating conditions during the design of an automated machine, possibly due to miscommunication or failure between different departments. Discovering and resolving such unexpected conditions is otherwise very difficult, since these defects can only be found during testing of the assembled automated machine, resulting in delayed delivery. [Explanation of symbols]
[0064] 1 Automatic Machine 2. Operational Elements 3 Consumer products 4 Pack 5 parts 6 Actuators 7 Equipment 8 Interface Devices 9. Control Panel 10. Mobile Systems 11 Tablet 12 First Processor 13 3D Model 14 Design environment 15 Second Processor 16 Control Unit 17 Interface 18 Connected Elements 19 Software Interface Table 20 Shaft 21 Software Interface Table 22 sheets 23 Drums 24 Pushing elements DP Presence Dataset DS Location Dataset P Commanded position SW Operation control software Time t1 Time t2 At tn
Claims
1. 1. A computer-implemented method for simulating the operation of at least a part (5) of an automated machine (1) for manufacturing or packaging a consumer product (3), comprising: - defining, in a computer-aided design environment (14), a three-dimensional model (13) of a part (5) of the automated machine (1) whose operation is to be simulated, the part (5) of the automated machine (1) comprising one or more movable operating elements (2); - programming a motion control software (SW) of the one or more movable motion elements (2) of the part (5) of the automatic machine (1), the motion control software (SW) being designed, in use, to command the actual motion of the part (5) of the automatic machine (1); Including, The method comprises: - extracting, during execution of said motion control software (SW), a data set (DS) relating to commanded positions (P) at given times (t1, t2, . . . , tn) of said one or more movable motion elements (2) or elements connected thereto; - transmitting said data set (DS) for a commanded position (P) in an aided design environment (14); - simulating, in said assisted design environment (14), a movement of said one or more mobile operating elements (2) by modifying a position of said one or more mobile operating elements (2) according to said data set (DS) with respect to a commanded position (P); periodically at successive time points, A method comprising:
2. 2. The method of claim 1, wherein communication between the aided design environment (14) and the running motion controlling software (SW) occurs in real time.
3. 3. The method according to claim 1 or 2, wherein in the aided design environment (14), each movable operating element (2) is connected in a constrained manner to at least one shaft (20) configured to be operated by the motion control software (SW), and the data set (DS) comprises the commanded position (P), preferably an absolute value, preferably an angle, of the respective shaft (20) of each movable operating element (2).
4. The method of claim 3, wherein each said shaft (20) is a follower / output element (20) of an actuator (6).
5. 2. The method of claim 1, wherein the steps of extraction, propagation and simulation are performed periodically at successive time points spaced apart by at least 10 ms, in particular at least 20 ms.
6. 6. The method of claim 5, comprising the step of interpolating successive positions of the same movable operating element (2) via the assisted design environment (14).
7. The method according to claim 1, further comprising a step of visually or mechanically checking, by the aided design environment (14), the distances between the mobile operating elements (2) and / or to fixed parts of the automatic machine (1) and / or the phasing of the motion of the mobile operating elements (2) in a shared workspace and / or the zero point of the mobile operating elements (2) from which the calculation of the position starts, in particular pausing the execution of the motion control software (SW) to interrupt the simulation step.
8. 2. The method according to claim 1, wherein the data set (DS) is extracted during the execution of the program for motion control on a real machine (1) and the remote motion thereof is analysed by a simulation step.
9. - extracting, during said execution of said operation control software (SW), a data set (DP) relating to the presence or absence of one or more products (3) at each of the predetermined times (t1, t2, . . . , tn); transmitting said data set (DP) of presence / absence to said assisted design environment (14); - visually simulating the presence or absence of said one or more products (3) at each given location according to said dataset of presence or absence (DP); The method of claim 1 further comprising:
10. 1. A device for simulating the operation of at least a part (5) of an automatic machine (1) for manufacturing or packaging a consumer product (3), comprising: a first processor (12) configured to define, in a computer-aided design environment (14), a three-dimensional model (13) of said part (5) of an automated machine (1) whose operation is to be simulated, said part (5) of the automated machine (1) including one or more movable operating elements (2); a second processor (15) configured to execute software (SW) for controlling the motion of the one or more movable operating elements (2) of the part (5) of the automated machine, the software (SW) for controlling the motion being configured, in use, to control the actual motion of the part (5) of the automated machine; a control unit (16) connecting the first processor (12) to the second processor (15) and configured to exchange, at given times (t1, t2, . . . , tn), a data set (DS) relating to a commanded position (P) of the one or more mobile operating elements (2) or elements connected thereto, from the motion control software (SW) to the aided design environment (14); Equipped with the control unit (16) is configured to simulate the movement of the one or more mobile operating elements (2) in the assisted design environment (14) by modifying the positions of the one or more mobile operating elements (2) according to the data set (DS) of commanded positions (P); Device.
11. The apparatus of claim 10, wherein the first processor (12), the second processor (15) and the control unit (16) are included in the same computer.
