Personnel optimization device, personnel optimization method, and personnel optimization program
The personnel optimization device uses predictive modeling and linear regression to optimize personnel allocation across multiple bases, addressing inefficiencies in existing systems by minimizing total staffing while maintaining service levels.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2020174443
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2020-10-16
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-06
- Estimated Expiration
- 2040-10-16
AI Technical Summary
Existing personnel allocation systems struggle to optimize personnel numbers based on varying service demands, leading to inefficiencies when the number of personnel does not proportionally adjust to changes in the number of services.
A personnel optimization device and method that utilizes predictive modeling to calculate the optimal number of personnel by analyzing service area attributes, workload, and historical service data, employing linear regression and machine learning to minimize total personnel across multiple bases.
Enables efficient personnel allocation by accurately predicting service demands and optimizing personnel distribution, reducing overall staffing needs while maintaining service levels.
Smart Images

Figure 0007577966000001 
Figure 0007577966000002 
Figure 0007577966000003
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present invention relates to a personnel optimization device, a personnel optimization method, and a personnel optimization program, and more particularly to a personnel optimization device, a personnel optimization method, and a personnel optimization program that optimize the personnel allocation of bases that are installed or positioned to serve as a base for providing a specified service. [Background technology]
[0002] A personnel allocation system has been proposed that plans the optimal number of personnel for each day and time period at a parcel delivery base (see, for example, Patent Document 1). This personnel allocation system notifies the delivery base of the delivery destination of the number of parcels for each delivery base by desired delivery date and delivery time period, making it possible to allocate personnel at the delivery base according to the number of parcels. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0003] [Patent Document 1] JP 2009-157546 A Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0004] However, while the personnel allocation system described in Patent Document 1 is suitable when a relationship exists in which the number of personnel increases or decreases in proportion to the increase or decrease in the number of luggage, it is difficult to optimize the number of personnel when it is difficult to grasp the relationship between the number of luggage and the number of personnel.
[0005] The present invention has been made in consideration of the above problems, and has an object to realize a personnel optimization device, a personnel optimization method, and a personnel optimization program that are capable of optimizing personnel at bases. [Means for solving the problem]
[0006] The personnel optimization device of the present invention includes a service number by location storage unit that stores the number of service cases by location, which is the number of service operations that occur for each location in the service target area of the location that is the basis for providing a specified service operation; a prediction model generation unit that uses attribute information of the service target area of the location and the number of service cases by location to generate a prediction model that models the relationship between the location and the number of service cases by location; a service number by area prediction unit that uses the prediction model to calculate the number of service cases by area for a service area based on attribute information that represents the attributes of a service area that is different from the service target area; a workload calculation unit that calculates the workload of the service area based on the number of service cases by area; a personnel model generation unit that uses the number of personnel for each service area and the workload of the service area to generate a personnel model that models the number of personnel and the workload; and an optimal solution calculation unit that calculates the optimal number of personnel for the location based on the personnel model.
[0007] It is preferable that the personnel model generation unit uses the number of personnel for each service area and the workload of the service area to model the number of personnel and the workload by a linear regression model.
[0008] It is preferable that the optimal solution calculation unit calculates a combination of bases so as to minimize the total number of personnel at the bases.
[0009] The personnel optimization method of the present invention includes a step of storing the number of service cases by location in a service area by location storage unit, the number of service cases by location being the number of service cases for each location that occurred in the service area of the location that is the basis for providing a predetermined service operation; a prediction model generation step of generating a prediction model that models the relationship between the location and the number of service cases by location using attribute information of the service area of the location and the number of service cases by location by a prediction model generation unit; and a step of generating an attribute representing an attribute of a service area different from the service area by using the prediction model. the number of services by area prediction step of calculating the number of services by area for the service area based on performance information by a service number by area prediction unit; a workload calculation step of calculating the workload of the service area based on the number of services by area by a workload calculation unit; a personnel model generation step of generating a personnel model that models the number of personnel and the workload by using the number of personnel for each service area and the workload of the service area by a personnel model generation unit; and an optimal solution calculation step of calculating an optimal number of personnel for the base based on the personnel model by an optimal solution calculation unit.
[0010] The personnel optimization program of the present invention causes a computer to execute the following steps: a service number by location storage step for storing the number of service cases by location, which is the number of service cases for each location that occurred in the service area of a location that is the basis for providing a specified service operation; a prediction model generation step for generating a prediction model that models the relationship between the location and the number of service cases by location using attribute information of the service area of the location and the number of service cases by location; a service number by area prediction step for calculating the number of service cases by area for a service area based on attribute information that represents the attributes of a service area that is different from the service area using the prediction model; a workload calculation step for calculating the workload of the service area based on the number of service cases by area; a personnel model generation step for generating a personnel model that models the number of personnel and the workload using the number of personnel for each service area and the workload of the service area; and an optimal solution calculation step for calculating the optimal number of personnel for the location based on the personnel model. Effect of the Invention
[0011] According to the present invention, it is possible to realize a personnel optimization device, a personnel optimization method, and a personnel optimization program capable of optimizing personnel at bases. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0012] [Figure 1] 1 is a diagram showing an overall configuration of a personnel optimization system according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Diagram 2] FIG. 2 is a diagram showing a functional block configuration of a personnel optimization device according to the present embodiment. [Diagram 3] FIG. 2 is a diagram illustrating a hardware configuration of a personnel optimization device according to the present embodiment. [Figure 4] FIG. 2 is a diagram showing cities, wards, towns and villages that are service areas of bases A to C according to the present embodiment. [Diagram 5] 1 is a diagram showing the area, population, and business volume of a base according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 6]1 is a diagram showing the area, personnel relative to population, business quantity, and business volume for each base according to the present embodiment. FIG. [Figure 7] FIG. 2 is a diagram showing travel times (intercity times) between bases and municipalities according to the present embodiment. [Figure 8] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing the relationship between the workload and the optimal number of personnel according to the present embodiment. [Figure 9] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing the calculation results of the optimal number of personnel for each base according to the present embodiment. [Figure 10] 10 is a flowchart illustrating a processing procedure in an optimal solution calculation unit according to the present embodiment. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0013] [1] Overview of the embodiment of the present invention First, a typical embodiment of the invention disclosed in this application will be outlined. In the following description, as an example, reference numerals in the drawings corresponding to components of the invention are given in parentheses.
[0014] [1] A personnel optimization device (2) according to a representative embodiment includes a base-specific service number storage unit (65) that stores the number of service cases by base, which is the number of service operations for each base that occurred in the service target area of the base (A, B, C) that serves as the basis for providing a specified service operation; a prediction model generation unit (41) that uses attribute information of the service target area of the base and the number of service cases by base to generate a prediction model that models the relationship between the base and the number of service cases by base; a service number prediction unit (42) by area that uses the prediction model to calculate the number of service cases by area for a service area based on attribute information that represents the attributes of a service area different from the service target area; a workload calculation unit (43) that calculates the workload (G) of the service area based on the number of service cases by area; a personnel model generation unit (51) that generates a personnel model that models the number of personnel and the workload using the number of personnel for each service area and the workload of the service area; and an optimal solution calculation unit (52) that calculates the optimal number of personnel for the base based on the personnel model.
[0015] [2] In the above [1], the personnel model generation unit (51) uses the number of personnel for each service area and the workload (G) of the service area to model the number of personnel and the workload (G) using a linear regression model.
[0016] [3] In the above [1] or [2], the optimal solution calculation unit (52) calculates a combination of each base so as to minimize the total number of personnel at the bases.
[0017] [4] A personnel optimization method according to a representative embodiment includes a step of storing the number of service cases by location in a service area by location storage unit (65) that is the number of service cases by location that occurred in the service area of the locations (A, B, C) that are the basis for providing a predetermined service operation; a prediction model generation step of generating a prediction model that models the relationship between the locations and the number of service cases by location using attribute information of the service area of the locations and the number of service cases by location in a prediction model generation unit (41); and a step of using the prediction model to generate a prediction model for a service area other than the service area. The system includes an area-by-area service count prediction step in which an area-by-area service count prediction unit (42) calculates the area-by-area service count in the service area based on attribute information representing attributes; a workload calculation step in which a workload calculation unit (43) calculates the workload (G) of the service area based on the area-by-area service count; a personnel model generation step in which a personnel model generation unit (51) generates a personnel model that models the number of personnel and the workload using the number of personnel for each service area and the workload of the service area; and an optimal solution calculation step in which an optimal number of personnel for the base is calculated by an optimal solution calculation unit (52) based on the personnel model.
[0018] [5] A personnel optimization program according to a representative embodiment causes a computer to execute the following steps: a service number by location storage step for storing the number of service cases by location, which is the number of service cases that occurred at each location in the service target area of the locations (A, B, C) that are the basis for providing a specified service operation; a prediction model generation step for generating a prediction model that models the relationship between the locations and the number of service cases by location using attribute information of the service target area of the locations and the number of service cases by location; a service number by area prediction step for calculating the number of service cases by area of a service area based on attribute information that represents the attributes of a service area that is different from the service target area using the prediction model; a workload calculation step for calculating the workload (G) of the service area based on the number of service cases by area; a personnel model generation step for generating a personnel model that models the number of personnel and the workload using the number of personnel for each service area and the workload of the service area; and an optimal solution calculation step for calculating the optimal number of personnel for the location based on the personnel model.
[0019] [2] Specific examples of embodiments A specific example of this embodiment will be described below with reference to the drawings. In the following description, the same reference numerals are used to designate components common to this embodiment, and repeated description will be omitted. It should be noted that the drawings are schematic, and the arrangement of each element, data format, communication method, etc. may differ from reality.
[0020] Fig. 1 is a diagram showing the overall configuration of a personnel optimization system 1 according to this embodiment. The personnel optimization system 1 shown in the figure is a system that optimizes the personnel allocation of the remaining maintained bases (hereinafter, these may be simply called "bases") that are already established in the prefecture at present and serve as the bases for personnel performing service operations, and that are the bases for the execution of service operations, for example, multiple cities, wards, towns, and villages in a certain prefecture, when there is a consolidation or closure of the bases.
[0021] In this case, service work includes, in utility-related public works such as electricity, gas, water, and communications, targeting access equipment such as power lines, gas pipes, water, and communication lines connected to customer equipment, and customer equipment such as power demand equipment, heat source equipment, water equipment, and communications equipment, and work responding to damage to access equipment caused by natural disasters, investigating malfunctions of customer equipment, and responding to requests for equipment updates, etc. However, service work is not limited to these utility-related public works, but can target any customer equipment, and can include various other work responding to breakdowns, repairs, inspections, etc. of that customer equipment.
[0022] The manpower optimization system 1 can optimize the current manpower at each base even when there is no consolidation or closure of bases. The manpower optimization system 1 can estimate the minimum number of personnel required to provide the most efficient service operations at each base in the service area.
[0023] In this specification, the following description will be given using municipalities in a prefecture as an example, but the present invention is not limited to this and may be applicable to municipalities in any prefecture, or may be applicable to a service area of a base on a regional or national level. The personnel optimization system 1 is not only applicable to utility-related public service businesses, but also to all business types including dispatch work to customers, such as goods delivery businesses, mobile product sales businesses, and food delivery businesses, and is applicable to decisions on the establishment, consolidation, and closure of dispatch origin bases that handle delivery, sales, takeout, and other services for customers. In addition, the system can be applicable to decisions on the establishment, consolidation, and closure of facilities in public works such as the operation of fire stations and schools.
[0024] In this case, for example, in the manpower optimization system 1, a call center (not shown) of an operator that accepts requests for service work receives a direct call from a location such as an ordinary home or business in any city, ward, town, or village that has requested the service work (hereinafter, these may be referred to as a location where there is demand for the service work, i.e., a "demand point"), and sets the travel time, which is the number of minutes it takes to travel from any base to the demand point, as the service level evaluation time.
[0025] For example, in this embodiment, the service level evaluation time is set to 40 minutes as an example, but the present invention is not limited to this, and the travel time set as the service level evaluation time can be arbitrarily determined depending on the location, such as the suburbs of the city center or the suburbs. Also, not only when a service operation is requested, but also when the operator detects information on a service outage such as a power outage, it is possible to set the travel time from the time of detection to the demand point as the service level evaluation time.
[0026] 1, the personnel optimization system 1 includes a personnel optimization device 2 and a plurality of client terminal devices 5a to 5d. The personnel optimization device 2 is configured to be connectable to a network 4, and is connected to external information processing devices such as the plurality of client terminal devices 5a to 5d via the network 4.
[0027] The network 4 is, for example, a wide area network (WAN) such as the Internet. The personnel optimization device 2 and the client terminal devices 5a to 5d of the personnel optimization system 1 are configured to be connectable to the network 4 by wired or wireless communication, and are capable of transmitting and receiving data to and from each other.
[0028] The client terminal devices 5a to 5d are client-side information processing devices that request the optimal bases and the number of personnel at the bases that can minimize personnel to the personnel optimization device 2 as a server. The client terminal devices 5a to 5d can receive and display an output screen that is the optimal bases and the number of personnel (the estimation result of the optimal number of personnel) estimated by the personnel optimization device 2. However, the client terminal devices 5a to 5d do not necessarily have to request the optimal bases and the number of personnel from the personnel optimization device 2, and the personnel optimization device 2 may itself determine the optimal bases and the number of personnel and simply receive them. Examples of the client terminal devices 5a to 5d include various information processing devices (computers) such as personal computers, tablet terminals, and smartphones. The client terminal devices 5a to 5d are configured to be connectable to the network 4, and therefore can also be connected to external information processing devices such as the personnel optimization system 1 via the network 4 for communication.
[0029] Next, a specific description will be given of the configuration of the personnel optimization device 2 in the personnel optimization system 1. Fig. 2 is a diagram showing a functional block configuration of the personnel optimization device 2 according to this embodiment. Fig. 3 is a diagram showing a hardware configuration of the personnel optimization device 2 according to this embodiment.
[0030] The personnel optimization device 2 is, for example, an information processing device (computer) such as a PC (Personal Computer) or a server, and is a device that estimates the workload (described later) for each city, ward, town, and village according to a pre-installed personnel optimization program, and then calculates bases that can minimize the number of personnel to be allocated and the number of personnel at the bases based on the workload. Note that this is not performed solely by the personnel optimization device 2, but rather the personnel optimization program may be provided from the personnel optimization device 2 to the client terminal devices 5a to 5d online or offline (for example, a predetermined package storing the personnel optimization program), and these client terminal devices 5a to 5d may function as personnel optimization devices.
[0031] 2, the workforce optimization device 2 has, as functional blocks, a communication unit 20, a data input / output unit 30, a workload estimation unit 40, a workforce estimation unit 50, a storage unit 60, and a display unit 70. Each of these functional blocks is realized by the cooperation of hardware resources constituting an information processing device as the workforce optimization device 2 with software (workforce optimization program) installed in the information processing device.
[0032] As shown in FIG. 3, the workforce optimization device 2 includes, as hardware resources, a calculation device 101, a storage device 102, an I / F (Interface) device 103, an input device 104, an output device 105, and a bus 106.
[0033] The programs 111 stored in the storage device 102 include personnel optimization programs and basic programs that cause a computer to function as each functional unit of the personnel optimization device 2 of this embodiment, and are pre-installed in the storage device 102, for example.
[0034] In addition, the data 112 stored in the memory device 102 is data that has been stored or will be stored in the city / ward / town / village basic information memory unit 61, base basic information memory unit 62, route memory unit 63, city / ward / town / village specific task memory unit 64 and base specific task memory unit 65 of the memory unit 60, which will be described later.
[0035] The program 111 and the data 112 may be distributed via a network, or may be distributed in a state in which they are written on a computer-readable storage medium (non-transitory computer readable medium) such as a CD-ROM.
[0036] The personnel optimization device 2 will be described below. For example, if multiple cities, wards, towns, and villages in a certain prefecture are currently set as service target areas where there is demand for service work, there are currently three bases ("Base A", "Base B", and "Base C") such as sales offices already set up in the certain prefecture, and multiple cities, wards, towns, and villages are assigned to each of the bases A to C as their service target areas without overlapping. However, a city, ward, town, and village may partially overlap with multiple bases A to C.
[0037] In such a situation, when there is a request to merge two of the current three bases to reduce the number of bases to two, the personnel optimization device 2 estimates which of "base A", "base B" and "base C" is the most suitable base to merge, and determines the number of personnel to be allocated to the new base resulting from the merger and the bases that will not be merged, that is, it is a device that optimizes or reallocates bases and personnel. Naturally, the personnel optimization device 2 can set various numbers of bases to be maintained, such as reducing three bases to two, reducing to one base, or reducing ten bases to seven bases. Of course, these three bases are not limited to existing bases, and may be, for example, a case in which three bases, all of which are planned to be established in the future, are reduced to two bases.
[0038] We will now explain each functional block of the personnel optimization device 2. The communication unit 20 is a functional unit for communicating with an external information processing device. Specifically, the communication unit 20 transmits and receives data to and from the multiple client terminal devices 5a to 5d in the personnel optimization system 1 via the above-mentioned predetermined network (e.g., LAN) 4.
[0039] The data input / output unit 30 of the workforce optimization device 2 is an input / output interface such as a keyboard, a pointing device, etc. However, this is not limited to this, and data can be input / output wirelessly via a tablet terminal, a smartphone, etc. The data input / output unit 30 inputs various data to the memory unit 60 and stores it, and reads various data from the memory unit 30 and outputs it to the workload estimation unit 40 and the workforce estimation unit 50.
[0040] Next, a description will be given of the storage unit 60. The storage unit 60 has a city / ward / town / village basic information storage unit 61, a base basic information storage unit 62, a route storage unit 63, a city / ward / town / village specific task storage unit 64, and a base specific task storage unit 65, and various data are stored or read out via the data input / output unit 30.
[0041] The city, ward, town, village basic information storage unit 61 is a part of the storage unit 60 in which basic information (hereinafter, this may be referred to as "city, ward, town, village basic information") including the area, population, and the address of the government office used as the center of the city, ward, town, village (hereinafter, this may be referred to as "city, ward, town, village office address") of each city, ward, town, village input by the operator via the data input / output unit 30 is stored. Here, the city, ward, town, village basic information such as the area, population, and address of the city, ward, town, village office is also attribute information that represents the attributes of the city, ward, town, village. The area and population of the city, ward, town, village basic information are official attribute information that are published on the homepage of the city, ward, town, village, etc. In addition, the city, ward, town, village basic information includes the address of the city, ward, town, village office, but is not limited to this. As the location information of the center representing the city, ward, town, village, etc., the center of gravity of the city, ward, town, village on a map, the center of gravity of the population, and various other positions may be used as the location information representing the city, ward, town, village.
[0042] Furthermore, the basic information of municipalities may include not only the area, population, and location of municipal offices, but also the number of contracts for access equipment and customer equipment, the number of contracts, the household density, the population density, the business density, the age-weighted average, the proportion of aged buildings, etc. This basic information of municipalities may be stored, for example, in any of the client terminal devices 5a to 5d or from an external information processing device via the network 4 and the communication unit 20.
[0043] For example, assume that there are three bases A to C in a certain prefecture, and that hh city, ab city, cd city, gh city, aa town, jj town, cc town, and gg town are set as the service area of base A, kk city, mn city, ef city, and op city are set as the service area of base B, and uv city, ss town, wx town, qr town, st town, and kl town are set as the service area of base C, as shown in Figures 4 and 5. In this case, for example, base A is located in cd city, base B is located in ef city, and base C is located in st town.
[0044] As shown in Figure 5, the service area of base A is one of the cities hh, which has an area of 186.96 km 2 The population of hh is 195,633, and is stored in the basic city, town, and village information storage unit 61 as basic city, town, and village information (attribute information) of hh city. 2 The population of 110,046 is stored in the basic information storage unit 61 as the basic information of the city, town, and village of ab. The city, town, and village of ab is 194.9 km away from the city of cd, which is one of the service target areas of the base A. 2 The population of 88,078 is stored as the city, ward, town, and village basic information for cd city in the city, ward, town, and village basic information storage unit 61. Similarly, the areas and populations of the five cities, ward, town, and villages from gh city to gg town, which are one of the service target areas of base A, are stored as the city, ward, town, and village basic information in the city, ward, town, and village basic information storage unit 61.
[0045] For the cities KK, MN, EF, and OP, which are in the service area of base B, city, ward, town, and village basic information (attribute information such as area, population, etc.) for each city, ward, town, and village is stored in the city, ward, town, and village basic information storage unit 61. Similarly, for the cities UV, SS, WX, QR, ST, and KL, which are in the service area of base C, city, ward, town, and village basic information (attribute information such as area, population, etc.) for each city, ward, town, and village is stored in the city, ward, town, and village basic information storage unit 61.
[0046] The base basic information storage unit 62 (personnel number storage unit) is a part of the storage unit 60 that stores the total area of all cities, wards, towns, and villages assigned to a certain base in the service area, the total population of the cities, wards, towns, and villages, and the number of personnel assigned to the base. For example, as shown in FIG. 6, the cities, wards, towns, and villages assigned to base A are hh city, ab city, cd city, gh city, aa town, jj town, cc town, and gg town, so the total area of these eight cities, wards, towns, and villages is 818.3 km2. 2 The total population of the eight cities, wards, towns, and villages, 578,101 people, and the number of personnel assigned to base A, 5 people, are stored in the base basic information storage unit 62 by the data input unit 30 as base basic information of base A.
[0047] In addition, the cities, wards, towns, and villages assigned to base B are kk, mn, ef, and op, so the total area of these four cities, wards, towns, and villages is 644.5 km2. 2 The total population of the four cities, wards, towns, and villages, 185,358 people, and the number of personnel assigned to base B, 5 people, are stored in the base basic information storage unit 62 as the base basic information of base B.
[0048] In addition, the cities, wards, towns, and villages assigned to base C are UV City, SS Town, WX Town, QR Town, ST Town, and KL Town, so the total area of these six cities, wards, towns, and villages is 583.6 km2. 2 The total population of the six cities, wards, towns, and villages, 66,438 people, and the number of personnel assigned to base C, 2, are stored in the base basic information storage unit 62 as the base basic information of base C.
[0049] The route storage unit 63 is a portion of the storage unit 60 that stores one-way travel time (hereinafter, this may be referred to as "intercity time") required to travel a distance corresponding to a route from a certain base to the location of a city, ward, town, or village office in the service area by vehicle such as an automobile (including motorcycles, bicycles, etc.). Such travel time (intercity time) is stored by the operator via the data input / output unit 30, but the travel time may be automatically calculated and stored by a route calculation device (not shown) based on geographic information such as the latitude and longitude of the location of base A and the location of the government office. Note that the route storage unit 63 may store one-way distances between cities instead of travel times.
[0050] For example, as shown in FIG. 7, the intercity time required for one-way travel from base A to No. 3-1, XX-cho, which is the municipality of hh city assigned to base A, is 16 minutes, the intercity time required for one-way travel from base A to No. 2-2, XX-cho, which is the municipality of ab city, is 6 minutes, and so on, and finally, the intercity time required for one-way travel from base A to ▲□57-2, gg town, which is the municipality of gg town, is 57 minutes. These intercity times (one-way travel times) are stored in the route memory unit 63. Similarly, the intercity times required for one-way travel to multiple municipalities assigned to base B and the intercity times required for one-way travel to multiple municipalities assigned to base C are also stored in the route memory unit 63.
[0051] The city / ward / town / village-specific service number storage unit 64 is a portion of the storage unit 60 in which the city / ward / town / village-specific service number is stored, which indicates the number of services for each city / ward / town / village in the past year (the total number of services that would have been requested for all service operations such as damage due to natural disasters, malfunction investigations, and equipment updates) calculated by the area-specific service number prediction unit 42 described later. The city / ward / town / village-specific service number will be described later.
[0052] The storage unit 65 for storing the number of service cases by location is a portion of the storage unit 60 in which the number of service cases by location in the past year for service work such as damage due to natural disasters, malfunction investigations, and equipment updates for each location is stored, which is input by the operator via the data input / output unit 30. In other words, the number of service cases by location is the value of the number of service cases that occurred at a certain location in the past year, and is known data compiled by the call center of the location.
[0053] As shown in Figure 6, in all cities, wards, towns, and villages in base A, the total number of "damage caused by natural disasters" service operations was 2,088 per year, the total number of "malfunction investigation" service operations was 191 per year, and the total number of "equipment renewal" service operations was 879 per year, so a total of 3,158 service operations existed at base A in the past year, and these 3,158 cases are the number of services by base A.
[0054] At base B, the total number of service operations for "damage due to natural disasters" was 1,903 cases per year, the total number of service operations for "malfunction investigations" was 527 cases per year, and the total number of service operations for "equipment renewals" was 728 cases per year, so a total of 3,158 service operations existed at base B over the past year, and these 3,158 cases are the number of services by base B.
[0055] At base C, the total number of service operations for "damage due to natural disasters" was 417 cases per year, the total number of service operations for "malfunction investigations" was 215 cases per year, and the total number of service operations for "equipment renewals" was 148 cases per year, so a total of 780 service operations existed at base C over the past year, and these 780 cases are the number of services by base C.
[0056] Next, the workload estimation unit 40 will be described. The workload estimation unit 40 is a functional unit that estimates the workload G (described later) for each city, ward, town, and village. The workload estimation unit 40 has a prediction model generation unit 41, a service number prediction unit by area 42, and a workload calculation unit 43.
[0057] The prediction model generation unit 41 is a functional unit that inputs attribute information (explanatory variable data) such as area or population for each of the bases A to C, which is the base basic information (FIG. 6) read from the base basic information storage unit 62 via the data input / output unit 30, and the number of services for each base for the bases A to C (objective variable data) read from the base-specific task storage unit 65 via the data input / output unit 30 as teacher data, performs machine learning, and generates a prediction model that learns and models the relationship between the attribute information (explanatory variable data) and the number of services for each base (objective variable data), and stores the model in an internal storage area. Incidentally, as the attribute information, either the area or the population, or only some other attribute information may be used. Here, for generating the prediction model, for example, a neural network called a multilayer perceptron may be adopted as a machine learning model. The prediction model may be a multiple regression model.
[0058] The area-specific service number prediction unit 42 is a functional unit that predicts the number of service cases by city, ward, town, and village using the prediction model generated by the prediction model generation unit 41. Here, although the number of service cases in the past year at each base is stored in the base-specific task storage unit 65, the actual number of service cases that occurred in each city, ward, town, and village is unknown, so the area-specific service number prediction unit 42 calculates the number of service cases by city, ward, town, and village.
[0059] When the area and population of each city, ward, town, or village is input as attribute information via the data input / output unit 30 to the prediction model generated by the prediction model generation unit 41, the area-specific service number prediction unit 42 can calculate the number of services for each city, ward, town, or village corresponding to the city, ward, town, or village. For example, as shown in FIG 5, the area-specific service number prediction unit 42 can calculate the number of services for each city, ward, town, or village corresponding to the city, ward, town, or village via the data input / output unit 30. 2When the area and population of 195,633 are input, the prediction model can calculate the number of services for hh city as 561 based on the area and population. In this way, the area-specific service number prediction unit 42 calculates the number of services for each city, ward, town, and village, and stores them in the city, ward, town, and village-specific service number storage unit 64.
[0060] In this case, as shown in Fig. 5, the city / ward / town / village-specific service count storage unit 64 stores 561 city / ward / town / village-specific service counts in hh city of base A, 389 city / ward / town / village-specific service counts in ab city, 415 city / ward / town / village-specific service counts in cd city, ..., and 377 city / ward / town / village-specific service counts in gg town. The total number of city / ward / town / village-specific service counts assigned to base A is 3,158, the same as the number of base-specific services for base A (see Fig. 6).
[0061] Furthermore, the city / ward / town / village service count storage unit 64 stores 800 city / ward / town / village service counts for kk city in base B, 781 city / ward / town / village service counts for mn city, 801 city / ward / town / village service counts for ef city, and 775 city / ward / town / village service counts for op city. The total number of city / ward / town / village services assigned to base B is 3158, the same as the number of services by base for base B (see FIG. 6). Incidentally, the number of services by base for base A and the number of services by base for base B are the same value, but this is by coincidence and has no particular meaning.
[0062] Furthermore, the city / ward / town / village service count storage unit 64 stores 133 city / ward / town / village service counts in uv city, 137 city / ward / town / village service counts in ss town, 131 city / ward / town / village service counts in wx town, 131 city / ward / town / village service counts in qr town, 112 city / ward / town / village service counts in st town, and 136 city / ward / town / village service counts in kl town. The total number of city / ward / town / village service counts assigned to these locations C is 780, the same as the location-specific service count for location C.
[0063] The workload calculation unit 43 is a functional unit that converts the number of services by city, ward, town, and village into a workload (task time) for each city, ward, town, and village that is close to the actual situation, based on the number of services by city, ward, town, and village stored in the city, ward, town, and village service number storage unit 64, the round trip travel time (intercity time) from the base to the location of the government office stored in the route storage unit 63, the round trip travel time from the location of the government office to the actual demand point, and the work time required at the demand point (local), and stores this in an internal storage area. However, in this embodiment, the workload calculation unit 43 does not include the work time required at the demand point (local) in the calculation in order to shorten and simplify the process, and the following explanation will be given.
[0064] Specifically, the workload calculation unit 43 can estimate the workload G for each city, ward, town, or village using the following formula (1) based on the average total travel time ta (=(t1+t2) / 2), which is the sum of the one-way travel time t1 from the location of a government office with city, ward, town, or village basic information to the nearest base (hereinafter, this may be referred to as the "nearest base") and the travel time t2 from the next adjacent base to the location of that government office, the travel time tc within the city from the location of the government office to the actual demand point, and the number of services Gc in that city, ward, town, or village. Here, in formula (1), the "2" used in 2·(ta+tc) means the round-trip travel time. G=Gc×2·(ta+tc)……………………………………………………(1) Here, when using travel time to calculate the workload G, if it is not possible to determine the base from which the business travels to the customer's demand point will begin, it is desirable, in terms of calculation accuracy, to calculate the workload G based on the travel time from the city, town, or village that constitutes the service area to multiple bases.
[0065] However, this is not a limitation, and in order to shorten processing time and simplify processing, the workload calculation unit 43 may estimate the workload G according to the following formula (2) by multiplying the one-way travel time t1 (minutes) from the location of the government office in the basic city / ward / town / village information to the nearest base by the number of services by city / ward / town / village Gc in that city / ward / town / village. This simplifies the processing in the workload calculation unit 43, and therefore the processing time can be shortened. Here, in formula (2), the "2" used in 2t means the round-trip travel time. G=Gc×2·t1………………………………………………………………(2)
[0066] Next, a description will be given of the personnel estimation unit 50. The personnel estimation unit 50 is a functional unit that, when a request is made by an operator of the personnel optimization device 2 or the client terminal devices 5a to 5d to reduce the number of bases from the current three to two, estimates a base among "base A," "base B," and "base C" that can minimize the number of personnel to be allocated and the number of personnel at that base, for example.
[0067] The personnel estimation unit 50 has a personnel model generation unit 51 and an optimal solution calculation unit 52. The personnel model generation unit 51 receives the total value of the workload G for each city, ward, town, and village calculated by the workload calculation unit 43 of the workload estimation unit 40 for each base station in charge of the workload G, and the number of personnel assigned to the base station stored in the base station basic information storage unit 62, via the data input / output unit 30. The personnel model generation unit 51 is a functional unit that generates a personnel model that models the relationship between the workload G of the base station and the number of personnel at the base station using the total value of the workload G for each base station and the number of personnel at the base station. This personnel model can generate a linear regression model by performing a regression calculation for the exponential function shown in equation (3) of the relationship between the workload G and the number of personnel using, for example, the Cobb-Douglas production function. In this case, by using the exponential function, a linear regression model can be generated that takes elasticity into account as one of the variables, as shown in FIG. 8, and a model that is close to the relationship between the current number of personnel and the workload can be generated. In addition, an AI model may be generated instead of the above personnel model. G=α・Number of personnel β………………………………………………………………(3) G: workload, α: constant, β: elasticity
[0068] The optimal solution calculation unit 52 is a functional unit that can calculate the bases that can minimize the number of personnel to be allocated and the number of personnel at the bases, using the calculation object parameters input as initial calculation conditions by the operator via the data input / output unit 30, the total value of the workload G for each base, and the number of personnel at the bases in a personnel model. Here, the calculation object parameter is the number of bases N (in this case, "N=2" since the number of bases to be ultimately maintained is reduced from three to two) which represents the number of bases to be maintained.
[0069] The optimal solution calculation unit 52 calculates optimal base candidates that match the calculation objective parameters according to the personnel model. For example, if it is desired to reduce the current three bases (bases A to C) to two bases (bases A and B, or bases A and C, or bases B and C), the number of bases N is 2. When the number of bases N is input as a calculation object parameter from the data input / output unit 30, the optimal solution calculation unit 52 assumes that one base will be merged with any other base, and calculates the two bases with the smallest total number of personnel as the optimal bases and the number of personnel. That is, the selected two bases and the number of personnel are calculated as the optimal solution. The optimal solution calculation unit 52 uses a so-called grid search method that comprehensively calculates all combinations of bases to calculate the two bases with the smallest number of personnel from the trial results. In this case, the optimum solution calculation unit 52 creates an optimum solution calculation result screen Ans as shown in FIG. 9, for example, and displays it on the display unit 70 or transmits it to the client terminal devices 5a to 5d via the communication unit 30 and the network 4.
[0070] Specifically, in trial 1, bases A and B are merged and base C is maintained, in which case the current number of personnel at bases A+B is 10, and the current number of personnel at base C is 2. In contrast, the optimal number of personnel at bases A+B calculated by the optimal solution calculation unit 52 is 6.4, and the optimal number of personnel at base C is 1.9. In trial 2, bases B and C are merged while base A is maintained, in which case the current number of personnel at bases B+C is 7, and the current number of personnel at base A is 5. In contrast, the optimal number of personnel at bases B+C calculated by the optimal solution calculation unit 52 is 4.7, and the optimal number of personnel at base A is 4.2. In trial 3, bases A and C are merged while base B is maintained, in which case the current number of personnel at bases A+C is 7, and the current number of personnel at base B is 5. In contrast, the optimal number of personnel at bases A+C calculated by the optimal solution calculation unit 52 is 4.9, and the optimal number of personnel at base B is 4.
[0071] Based on the calculation results shown in Fig. 9, the optimal solution calculation unit 52 calculates the combination of bases and the number of personnel for each base that minimizes the total number of personnel, which is the sum of the numbers of personnel at all bases, as the optimal solution. In the case of Fig. 9, the total number of personnel in the combination of trial 1 is 8.3, the total number of personnel in the combination of trial 2 is 8.9, and the total number of personnel in the combination of trial 3 is 8.9. Therefore, the optimal solution calculation unit 52 calculates that, as in trial 1, the number of bases is reduced to two by merging base A and base B, and the number of personnel at base A and base B is changed to 6.4 (actually, 6 or 7 is appropriate), and the number of personnel at base C is changed to 1.9 (actually, 2 is appropriate), as the optimal solution.
[0072] Next, the process flow of the optimal solution calculation unit 52 in the personnel estimation unit 50 will be described with reference to a flowchart. Fig. 10 is a flowchart showing the process flow by the optimal solution calculation unit 52. When the optimal solution calculation unit 52 receives in step SP1 that a calculation object parameter (number of bases N) has been set or changed via the data input / output unit 30, it proceeds to the next step SP2.
[0073] In step SP2, the optimal solution calculation unit 52 combines the current bases so that the total number of bases is N, calculates the optimal number of personnel from the total workload of the combined bases using a personnel model, and proceeds to the next step SP3.
[0074] In step SP3, the optimal solution calculation unit 52 determines whether or not the optimal numbers of personnel in step SP2 have been calculated for all combinations when reducing the number of bases from three to two. If the optimal numbers of personnel have been calculated for all combinations (step SP3: YES), the process proceeds to the next step SP4, and if calculation of the optimal numbers of personnel for all combinations has not been completed (step SP3: NO), the process returns to the next step SP2.
[0075] In step SP4, the optimal solution calculation unit 52 compares the sums of the optimal numbers of personnel (total numbers of personnel) calculated for each combination of bases.
[0076] In step SP5, the optimal solution calculation unit 52 calculates a combination of two bases that minimizes the sum of the optimal numbers of personnel (total number of personnel) for each combination of bases. Then, the optimal solution is output to the display unit 70 as the two bases and their numbers of personnel that constitute the combination, and the process flow ends.
[0077] According to the present embodiment, when reducing the three bases, A to C, to two bases, the personnel optimization device 2 can use the prediction model and the personnel model to calculate the optimal number of personnel in accordance with the current workload as the number of personnel at the two new bases. The personnel model is generated using a production function, and therefore takes into account elasticity and assumes situations in which work efficiency is improved, such as when multiple tasks are performed consecutively at the same location. This allows the personnel estimation unit 50 to estimate the number of personnel that is closer to the relationship between the current number of personnel and the amount of work. In addition, the personnel optimization device 2 can calculate the optimal number of personnel for each combination of bases and present it to the operator via the calculation result screen Ans (FIG. 9). Furthermore, the personnel optimization device 2 can output the two bases with the smallest total number of personnel as the optimal solution. In addition, the personnel optimization device 2 converts the number of service cases by city, ward, town, and village into a workload that reflects the actual situation, and calculates candidate locations and the number of personnel using that workload, thereby enabling more accurate calculation of candidate locations and the number of personnel.
[0078] [3] Other embodiments In the above embodiment, the personnel optimization device 2 performs all combination calculations for all bases, but the present invention is not limited to this. The personnel optimization device 2 may receive base combination information from a client terminal and return personnel number information for the base combination, or the processing may be distributed between the personnel optimization device 2 and the client terminal devices 5a to 5d. In this case, the above-mentioned processing is executed by the entire personnel optimization system 1. Furthermore, the above configurations of the workforce optimization system 1, the workforce optimization device 2, and the client terminal devices 5a to 5d are merely examples, and the specific configurations are not limited to these.
[0079] In addition, the above-mentioned personnel estimation unit 50 calculates the number of personnel at each base so as to minimize the total number of personnel at the bases to be maintained, but the personnel estimation unit 50 may calculate the number of personnel at each base so as to maximize the reduction in the number or reduction rate of personnel at the bases to be maintained. Specifically, as shown in FIG. 9, the optimal reduction in the number of personnel or the reduction rate compared to the current number of personnel at each base may be calculated, and the combination of bases with the largest reduction in the number or reduction rate may be set as the optimal solution. In FIG. 9, in terms of the reduction in the number of personnel, the combination of bases A+B and base C in trial 1 is preferable because it has the largest reduction in the number of personnel (-3.7 people), and in terms of the reduction rate of personnel, the combination of bases A+C and base B in trial 3 is preferable because it has the largest reduction rate (-49%).
[0080] Moreover, the above-mentioned flowchart by the optimal solution calculation unit 52 shows an example for explaining the flow of processing in the optimal solution calculation unit 52, and is not limited to this. That is, each step of the flowchart by the optimal solution calculation unit 52 is a specific example, and is not limited to this flow. For example, the order of some steps may be changed, other processing may be inserted between the processing of each step, and in some cases, the processing of some steps may be performed in parallel.
[0081] The above-mentioned personnel estimation unit 50 calculates, as an optimal solution, a combination of bases that can minimize the optimal number of personnel calculated by a personnel model from the workload of each base. Furthermore, for example, when it is calculated that merging bases A and B is optimal, the configuration may be such that it calculates whether to abolish base A or base B by comparing the service level evaluation time in the case of only base A when base A is maintained and base B is abolished with the service level evaluation time in the case of only base B when base A is abolished and base B is maintained. [Explanation of symbols]
[0082] 1...personnel optimization system, 2...personnel optimization device, 4...network, 5a-5d...client terminal device, 20...communication unit, 30...data input / output unit, 40...workload calculation unit, 41...prediction model generation unit, 42...service number prediction unit by area, 43...workload calculation unit, 50...personnel estimation unit, 51...personnel model generation unit, 52...optimal solution calculation unit, 60...memory unit, 61...city / ward / town / village basic information memory unit, 62...base basic information memory unit, 63...route memory unit, 64...city / ward / town / village service number memory unit, 65...base number of service number memory unit, 70...display unit, 101...arithmetic unit, 102...memory device, 111...program, 112...data, 103...I / F device, 104...input device, 105...output device, 106...bus.
Claims
1. a storage unit for storing the number of service cases by location, which is the number of service cases by location that occurred in the service target area of the location that is the base when providing a predetermined service; a prediction model generation unit that performs machine learning using attribute information of the service target area of the base and the number of services by base as training data to generate a prediction model that learns and models a relationship between the attribute information and the number of services by base; a region-specific service number prediction unit that uses the prediction model to calculate the number of services by region in a service region different from the service target area based on attribute information that represents attributes of the service region; A workload calculation unit that calculates a workload of the service area based on the number of services by area; a personnel model generation unit that receives input of the number of personnel for each service area, which is a response variable, and the volume of work in the service area, which is an explanatory variable, and generates a personnel model in which the relationship between the number of personnel and the volume of work is modeled using a linear regression model; an optimal solution calculation unit that combines bases to achieve a set target number of bases, and calculates an optimal number of personnel for the combined bases using the personnel model from a total value of the workload of the combined bases; A personnel optimization device comprising:
2. The personnel optimization device of claim 1, wherein the linear regression model is generated by performing a regression calculation of the relationship between the workload and the number of personnel with respect to an exponential function shown in equation (1). G = α・Number of personnel β ... (1) Here, G is the workload, α is a constant, and β is elasticity.
3. 3. The personnel optimization device according to claim 1, wherein the optimal solution calculation unit calculates a combination of the bases so as to minimize a total number of personnel at the bases.
4. A step of storing the number of service cases by location, in which the computer stores the number of service cases by location, which is the number of service cases for each location that occurred in the service target area of the location that is the base when providing a predetermined service; a prediction model generation step in which a computer inputs attribute information of the service target area of the base and the number of services by the base as training data and performs machine learning to generate a prediction model that learns and models a relationship between the attribute information and the number of services by the base; a prediction step of calculating the number of services by area in a service area different from the service target area based on attribute information representing attributes of the service area by using the prediction model; A task amount calculation step in which the computer calculates a task amount of the service area based on the number of services by area; a staffing model generation step in which the computer inputs the number of staff for each service area, which is a response variable, and the volume of work in the service area, which is an explanatory variable, to generate a staffing model in which the relationship between the number of staff and the volume of work is modeled using a linear regression model; An optimal solution calculation step in which the computer combines locations to achieve a set target number of locations, and calculates an optimal number of personnel for the combined locations using the personnel model from a total value of the workload of the combined locations; A workforce optimization method having the following features:
5. For computers, a storage step of storing the number of service cases by location, which is the number of service cases by location that occurred in the service target area of the location that is the base when providing a predetermined service; a prediction model generation step of inputting attribute information of the service target area of the base and the number of services by the base as training data and performing machine learning to generate a prediction model that learns and models a relationship between the attribute information and the number of services by the base; a region-by-region service number prediction step of calculating the number of services by region in a service region different from the service target area based on attribute information representing attributes of the service region using the prediction model; A workload calculation step of calculating a workload of the service area based on the number of services by area; a personnel model generation step of inputting the number of personnel for each service area, which is a response variable, and the volume of work in the service area, which is an explanatory variable, to generate a personnel model in which the relationship between the number of personnel and the volume of work is modeled by a linear regression model; an optimal solution calculation step of combining bases to achieve a set target number of bases, and calculating an optimal number of personnel for the combined bases using the personnel model from a total value of the workload of the combined bases; A workforce optimization program that enables
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Turning device
JP1984026819A
Operation support method and apparatus for rainwater drainage pump field
JP2001227044A
Personnel assignment system, device for delivery, device for distribution, personnel assignment method, and personnel assignment program
JP2009157546A
Site analysis system
JP2011227794A
