Meta Secondary Radar
The full-duplex meta-secondary sensor system addresses the limitations of simultaneous detection and identification in air traffic control by using orthogonal channels and filtering operations, enhancing detection reliability and reducing costs.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2021064569
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2020-04-16
- Filing Date
- 2021-04-06
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-21
- Estimated Expiration
- 2041-04-06
AI Technical Summary
Current air traffic control systems face limitations in simultaneous detection and identification due to synchronous mode operations, leading to reduced detection reliability and increased operational and maintenance costs, particularly with secondary radar, ADS-B squitter, and IFF interrogator systems.
A full-duplex meta-secondary sensor system with an antenna having SUM, DIFF, and CONT channels, allowing simultaneous and independent transmission and reception of signals, and filtering operations tailored to each protocol, ensuring orthogonal operation of ADS-B, Mode S, and IFF identification.
Achieves approximately 75% temporal coverage in synchronous mode and 100% in asynchronous mode, reducing detection thresholds and operational costs by optimizing signal processing and radiation patterns, enabling simultaneous and efficient monitoring and identification.
Smart Images

Figure 0007588023000001 
Figure 0007588023000002 
Figure 0007588023000003
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present invention relates to the field of air traffic control (ATC). [Background technology]
[0002] At present, air traffic control is mainly based on secondary radar, whose detection reliability is widely recognized. Secondary radar ensures synchronous mode monitoring of aircraft by SSR and Mode S protocols. Besides, ground ATC utilizes asynchronous reception of enhanced ADS-B (Automatic Dependent Surveillance-Broadcast) squitters provided to ensure on-board collision avoidance (TCAS: Traffic Alert and Collision Avoidance System), thus providing a part of the interactive surveillance system.
[0003] This surveillance can be used in conjunction with IFF (Identification Friend or Foe) type surveillance, where an IFF interrogator ensures the identification of the aircraft according to various military protocols.
[0004] Within the single structure that brings these sensors together, the operational exploitation of these various activities simultaneously requires: - Simultaneous listening to secondary radar and IFF interrogators (if an IFF interrogator is used). These modes are time-delayed and separate. ATC monitoring for a target aircraft that is SSR but also Mode S, where 2-3 BDS (commB data selector) registers per aircraft are sampled in succession as required by the user in the conventional manner; Optionally, IFF identification by protocol (whose primary military protection is to introduce a long variable delay in response in addition to the distance-related duration, thus inherently requiring long target aircraft emissions) In order to guarantee this, we are subject to the dwell time limitations of the target machine. - Listening in asynchronous mode on civilian ADS-B squitter or military Mode 5 squitter. This listening operation is Particularly polluted by synchronous interrogation transmissions, which are numerous, especially in Mode S (at least two and three interrogations per aircraft); Asynchronous mode listening operation is inherently omnidirectional and is therefore associated with lower detection and decoding probabilities in the presence of many target aircraft due to the lack of azimuth selectivity.
[0005] As an example, considering that there are 1200 aircraft per antenna revolution, two BDSs are extracted per target aircraft, and a re-interrogation rate of about 1.5, i.e. 3600 interrogations during about 20 μs (related to various external factors such as garbled responses, transponder occupancy, target aircraft movements, etc.) (durations are taken from ICAO Annex 10 Vol IV), the duration of the garble phenomenon due only to synchronous interrogation is about 140 μs for an extended Mode S response, i.e. 504 ms is polluted per 4 seconds of antenna revolution, which corresponds to about 13% of the duration of the listening operation. In particular, due to its synchronous mode operation, the secondary radar does not require isolation between its transmit chain and its receive chain, since they operate at different times, so that in the conventional scheme the transmission leakage has a level in the receive chain close to the maximum magnitude response normally expected from an aircraft, thus making simultaneous listening operation impossible during the duration of the interrogation. Thus, for existing radars, perturbations from synchronous transmissions necessarily limit the probability of detecting an ADS-B squitter to less than 87% (this maximum does not take into account all other possible environmental reasons for non-detection, such as response and ADS-B squitter garbling phenomena, multipath, etc.).
[0006] In addition, the ATC secondary radar antenna is designed to operate in a synchronous mode with the target aircraft residing in a plane perpendicular to the aerial's primary panel, and as a result, its 360 degree electromagnetic coverage required for listening in asynchronous mode has limitations, which are described in more detail below.
[0007] To avoid these problems, the prior art, disclosed for example in documents FR 3019905 A1 and FR 2658967 A1, separates these various activities and the architecture matches the specificity of each activity to guarantee the best possible performance. Conventional ADS-B reception therefore often consists of two back-to-back 180° antennas associated with two independent receivers to guarantee better detection than a single 360° omnidirectional antenna, which are separate from the radar antenna when co-located. In addition, IFF identification is often performed at the expense of Mode S monitoring in the antenna rotation and in the sector concerned by IFF identification, due to the lack of dwell time to perform the two simultaneously in the azimuth angles required for IFF identification.
[0008] As a result, performing all of these monitoring and identification activities generates high operational and maintenance costs, especially when considering purchase, infrastructure, ownership and network connectivity costs. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0009] [Patent Document 1] French Patent Application Publication No. 3019905 [Patent Document 2] French Patent Application Publication No. 2658967 Summary of the Invention [Means for solving the problem]
[0010] One of the objects of the invention is, in particular, to obtain a low-cost integrated interrogation and surveillance system that offers a performance substantially comparable to that of independent systems. To this end, the subject of the invention is a secondary radar including an antenna, the antenna having a radiation pattern forming a sum channel designated SUM, a radiation pattern forming a difference channel designated DIFF, and a pattern forming a control channel designated CONT, a first transmit and receive chain associated with the SUM channel, a second transmit and receive chain associated with the CONT channel, and a receive chain associated with the DIFF channel, - each of said transmit and receive chains can transmit and receive simultaneously, in such a way that said chains operate independently of each other, the transmit chain includes a filtering operation for filtering signals transmitted at 1090 MHz, the receive chain includes a filtering operation for filtering signals transmitted at 1030 MHz, and said receive chain associated with a DIFF channel includes a filtering operation for filtering signals transmitted at 1030 MHz, and the signal level at the receiver remains unchanged during synchronization interrogation transmission; - the processing means includes matching the frequency band of the receiver with the characteristics of each of the transaction protocols used; a secondary radar, in which the receiving chains of the SUM, DIFF and CONT channels are capable of simultaneously listening in synchronous and asynchronous modes to signals received from a target aircraft via the SUM, DIFF and CONT patterns, respectively, and the operations of listening in synchronous and asynchronous modes are independent of each other, and the signal level at the receiving end remains unchanged during synchronous interrogation transmission.
[0011] In one particular embodiment, the CONT pattern consists of a front radiation pattern forming a channel designated CONT_Front and a back radiation pattern forming a channel designated CONT_Back, and the CONT_Front and CONT_Back patterns are processed separately in such a way that each of the transmit and receive chains is applied to the CONT_Front and CONT_Back channels.
[0012] The radar includes, for example, a kit for expanding the radiation pattern of the CONT_Back channel, the kit being arranged on the rear side of the antenna, the kit comprising: - A first patch to fill the elevation detection hole, called the cone of silence, - a second patch to fill the detection hole at azimuth angle 90°, - A second patch to fill the detection hole at -90° azimuth It includes three radiating patches.
[0013] Each of the transmit chains includes a filtering operation dedicated to the rejection of parasitic signals transmitted, for example, at 1090 MHz.
[0014] Each of the receive chains includes a filtering operation dedicated to rejecting parasitic signals, for example at 1030 MHz, emanating from the transmit channel.
[0015] In the case of having a mission ATC surveillance, the radar may, for example, listen separately over the pattern for ADS-B squitters, independent of synchronization transactions.
[0016] In the case of having as mission IFF discrimination, the radar performs synchronous IFF detection, for example, independent of synchronous SSR and Mode S transactions.
[0017] In the case of having as mission IFF identification, the radar may, for example, perform simultaneous listening operations separately over the pattern for Mode 5 Level 2 squitters, independent of synchronization transactions.
[0018] In the case of having a mission control in an aviation environment, the radar may, for example, perform simultaneous listening operations separately over the pattern for any type of secondary response, independent of synchronization transactions.
[0019] The radar transmits consecutively during an all-call interrogation period and a roll-call interrogation period, the roll-call interrogation being initiated, for example, during the all-call interrogation period.
[0020] The radar transmits continuously during the all-call interrogation period and the roll-call interrogation period, and all-call listening operations started during the all-call period continue, for example, into the roll-call period.
[0021] Other features and advantages of the present invention will become apparent from the following description taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0022] [Figure 1a] FIG. 1 is a diagram of an exemplary embodiment of a conventional secondary radar. [Figure 1b] 1 is a diagram of an exemplary embodiment of a radar according to the present invention; [Figure 2a] 1 shows possible steps of the implementation of the present invention. [Figure 2b] 1 is an example of a sequence of transactions performed by a prior art radar. [Figure 2c] 4 is an example of a sequence of transactions performed by a radar according to the invention; [Diagram 3] 1 is a diagram of one of the steps described above. [Figure 4a]1 is a presentation of the gain of the three patterns SUM, CONT_Front and CONT_Back of the antenna as a function of azimuth angle between + / - 180°. [Figure 4b] 13 is a presentation of the contribution of the extension of the CONT_Back pattern in azimuth, according to the present invention. [Figure 4c] A presentation of the gain of the three patterns SUM, CONT_Front and CONT_Back of the antenna as a function of elevation angle from -60° to +180°. [Figure 4d] 13 is a presentation of the contribution of the extension of the CONT_Back pattern in elevation angle, according to the present invention. [Diagram 5] Prior art management of all-call and roll-call transactions. [Figure 6] 1 is an example of management of all-call and roll-call transactions in a radar according to the present invention. [Figure 7] 4 is another example of managing transactions in a radar according to the present invention. [Figure 8a] FIG. 13 is a diagram of a kit for extending the CONT_Back pattern of the ATC secondary antenna. [Figure 8b] FIG. 1 shows the principle of the implementation of a kit for extending the CONT_Back pattern in an ATC secondary antenna. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0023] In order to reduce the various costs mentioned in the introduction, the present invention proposes a certain system, called a full-duplex meta-secondary sensor, which comprises: - A conventional secondary radar that ensures synchronous mode monitoring of aircraft by means of SSR and Mode S protocols; - IFF interrogators to ensure aircraft identification via Mode 4 and Mode 5 protocols; - Enhanced ADS-B squitter asynchronous receiver (DF17 / 18), - Mode 5 Level 2 Squatter Asynchronous Receiver It consolidates all the activities of ground sensors such as the GNSS satellites, while still leveraging the same overhead structures (rotors, antennas, motors, rotary joints, cables, etc.) and the same infrastructure.
[0024] The solution provided by the present invention is therefore to exploit the specificity of these various activities in the context of the resources common to them in the meta-secondary sensor in order to orthogonalize them. By "orthogonalize" we mean making them independent of each other, thus obtaining the same performance for each of them, whether they are operating alone or all running at the same time.
[0025] Therefore, the metasensor - simultaneous transmission and reception of various signals, ensuring complete independence of the transmission and reception tasks by exploiting the dual-frequency aspect characteristic of secondary radars (transmission at 1030 MHz and reception at 1090 MHz) (in the following, the term "full duplex" is used to refer to such an operating mode in which transmission and reception are simultaneous); - performing filtering operations that are adapted to the characteristics of each of the adopted protocols (i.e. filtering operations that allow only the processing of frequency bands that contain useful signals, as shown in FIG. 1b, as described below); - Listening in synchronous mode for the purpose of simultaneously performing ATC surveillance (SSR and Mode S) and IFF identification (military encryption modes); - Listen in asynchronous mode via various physically available antenna patterns (i.e. depending on the aerial architecture), but also improve the radar radiation characteristics for asynchronous mode listening operation only, to ensure better coverage at high elevation angles and near 100% temporal listening operation in azimuth angles.
[0026] Thus, "full duplex" operation according to the present invention: - enabling asynchronous mode listening operation (ADS-B or Mode 5 Level 2 squitter) to be performed without suffering from perturbations due to synchronous emissions; - allowing, within the Mode S protocol, to optimize the duration of the sequence of roll-call transactions (the so-called Roll-Call Period (RC)) and thus to reduce the lower limit of the target aircraft's dwell time (which is particularly important in the case of radars with high rotation speeds (typically, for example, speeds of 4 seconds per antenna revolution are conventional in airport configurations) although this is not the only case) (see Figure 6); - to detect target aircraft as they enter the radar's electromagnetic range (and thus to lock out these entering targets early in order to eliminate the DF11 responses they generate following the UF11 interrogations of this radar) without interfering with the operational performance of the radar, i.e. without modifying the duration of the all-call period dedicated to this purpose, independently of the optimization of the RC (see Figure 7), Otherwise, their response potential will be wasted unnecessarily, Otherwise contamination will occur, i.e. these responses will constitute contamination to other radars, especially the ones closest to the target aircraft.
[0027] Filtering operations consistent with each protocol adopted make it possible to obtain, at the receiver, an analysis band as wide as necessary and completed by these filtering operations consistent with the useful signal band of each protocol (i.e. both due to the spectrum of its modulation and the frequency stability of the transponder's carrier), which allows a reduction in the noise level and therefore a lowering of the detection threshold in order to process weaker signals and thus further improve the range.
[0028] Thus, by operating in independent asynchronous modes of simultaneous listening via three or four patterns of conventional ACT antennas, - At the receiving side, by processing the SUM, DIFF, CONT_Front and CONT_Back patterns independently, Guaranteeing approximately 75% temporal coverage at medium distances for synchronous mode listening operation (see Figure 4a); Better detection of simultaneous squitters by exploiting differences (if any) in off-bore sight angles of simultaneous squitters to reduce the rather long (120 μs) overlap of responses that causes non-detection of the squitters; - In addition, by perfecting the radiation pattern of the radar's ATC secondary antenna for its asynchronous mode detection function, Guaranteeing coverage in the no-signal cone (Cos) (see Fig. 4d), Guarantee 100% temporal coverage over the maximum distance for both ADS-B and IFF (see Figure 4b) This will be possible.
[0029] The features and advantages of the present invention presented above will be explained below with reference to the figures.
[0030] Figure 1a, as will be recalled, shows a diagram of a conventional ATC surveillance radar, where only Mode S and SSR synchronous mode operation is expected. The transmit and receive chains 401, 402 possess a level of isolation just sufficient to guarantee non-destruction in the case of infinite SWR at the output of the processing cabinet. The CONT_Front and CONT_Back patterns of the ATC secondary antenna are merged with Aerial 1, 2 (CONT pattern), because signals that cannot be said to be strictly on the axis of the antenna (i.e. the axis of SUM) are simply rejected, regardless of whether they come from the front or the back.
[0031] FIG. 1b shows a diagram of a device according to the invention. Through the proposed architecture, the properties of the "full duplex" meta-secondary sensor presented above are obtained. In particular, this architecture ensures the simultaneous operation of various secondary protocols with little impact between the protocols. It therefore ensures that for each protocol, when operating simultaneously with the other protocols, the same performance is achieved as is achievable with the antenna structure of the sensor while the other protocols are inactive. The architecture of FIG. 1b is an evolution of the conventional architecture of a secondary radar shown in FIG. 1a. Some of the following description will explain the components already present in the conventional radar of FIG. 1a. The additional elements are highlighted using very bold lines.
[0032] In its conventional operating configuration, the secondary radar operates in a synchronous mode, i.e. it emits an interrogation and waits for a matching reply, which allows it to locate through measurements (in terms of azimuth and distance) and identify the target aircraft (typically via its address in the Mode S protocol).
[0033] To perform this task effectively, the radar is equipped with an antenna 1 with a number of patterns 11, 12, 13, 14, whose role, in the conventional way, is to: - summation pattern 11 (hereinafter denoted SUM) for interrogating the target device and detecting the target device's synchronization response, - Difference pattern 12 (denoted DIFF) for precise positioning of the target aircraft in the SUM beam; Advantageously, in the context of one option of the invention, two patterns are possible, namely: A first control pattern 13 (denoted CONT_Front) for blocking and rejecting responses coming from target aircraft facing the antenna and not in the main SUM beam; A second control pattern 14 (denoted CONT_Back) for blocking and rejecting replies coming from target aircraft at the rear of the antenna (and therefore not necessarily in the main SUM beam). (Thus, this option can employ separate processing of three or four patterns of antennas) Control pattern (denoted CONT) (see Figure 1a) It is. The remainder of the invention takes into account this configuration using CONT_Front and CONT_Back patterns, and these two patterns are potentially processed separately. References to the CONT channel potentially include the CONT_Front and CONT_Back channels for the example of FIG. 1b.
[0034] The rotating joint 2 for the rotating antenna and the antenna down cable are - RF coupling of the transmitted signal at 1030 MHz and the received signal at 1090 MHz between the rotating and fixed parts of the radar, independently for four patterns (SUM, DIFF, CONT_Front and CONT_Back); - Distribution of azimuth positions 201 of the antenna's main lobe axis guarantee.
[0035] The duplexer 3 ensures RF coupling of the signals transmitted at 1030 MHz and received at 1090 MHz independently for the four patterns. For this purpose, the duplexer 3 includes a circulator associated with each channel. In the example of FIG. 1b, the three circulators 311, 313, 314 decouple the transmission at 1030 MHz and the reception at 1090 MHz of the SUM, CONT_Front and CONT_Back channels, respectively. In a purely synchronous operation, the listening operation is performed only through the main lobe of the radar (i.e. through the SUM and DIFF channels) after the transmission phase over the SUM and DIFF channels. Since the DIFF channels only operate in reception, the circulator 312 operates only in one direction and only routes the received signals obtained through the antenna (the circulator is optional and its use in DIFF has no other purpose than to balance the signals between SUM and DIFF for the purpose of measuring the angle error). In synchronous mode, the act of listening over the CONT channel has no purpose other than to reject responses received with more energy in the CONT pattern followed by the SUM pattern.
[0036] Filters 311', 313', 314' are placed upstream of the circulators for the SUM, CONT_Front and CONT_Back channels. These filters are primarily used downstream in transmission to filter out harmonics of the transmitted signal. The same filters also serve in reception to protect against frequencies outside the secondary radar's useful band (i.e., approximately 1020-1100 MHz).
[0037] Thus, the SUM and CONT channels are used for both transmission and reception. For ease of reading, in FIG. 1b (and FIG. 1a), only the transmission and reception circuitry 4 of the SUM channel is shown (the circuits for the CONT channel and for the CONT_Front and CONT_Back channels are the same); The architecture of the transmit and receive circuits 4' of the CONT channel (Fig. 1a) and the CONT_Front / CONT_Back channels (Fig. 1b), respectively, is similar to that of the SUM, - Circuit 4" of the DIFF channel is not shown and is identical to that of the reception of the SUM.
[0038] The space-time management 5 ensures the real-time management of the interrogation periods and associated listening periods of the various secondary protocols (IFF, SSR and Mode S protocols). The specific protocol-specific signal processing 6 exploits the signals obtained via the various patterns SUM, DIFF, CONT_Front and CONT_Back separately.
[0039] Referring again to FIG. 1b, we now describe the transmit and receive part 4 associated with the SUM channel and located between the circulator 311 and the space-time management 5 and signal processing 6 of the duplexer. This transmit / receive part 4 includes adaptations specific to the invention. In particular, the SUM transmit chain 401 transmitting at 1030 MHz incorporates additional filtering operations 4A, 4B dedicated to transmit noise reduction, and more particularly to rejection of parasitic signals at 1090 MHz, in order to maintain the level of the residual noise after the combining 311 at the receiver noise level. The transmit chain includes a first amplifier 8 performing a first amplification, followed by a first filter 4A. The first filter 4A is followed by a second amplifier 8', which is a power amplifier and conveys the transmit signal, followed by a second filter 4B.
[0040] The SUM receive chain 402 operating at 1090 MHz conventionally comprises a low noise amplifier 9 and an analogue-to-digital converter (ADC) 9'. The SUM receive chain 402 also comprises, like the transmit chain, an adaptation specific to the present invention, specifically an additional filtering operation 4C, 4D dedicated to the rejection of the parasitic 1030 MHz signals originating from the transmit channel in order to keep the coupling level at the circulator (or due to the aerial SWR) and baseband aliasing to the noise level of the receiver. In particular, the receive channel comprises an input filter 4C upstream of the low noise amplifier 9. This filter, which is a bandpass filter, - selecting a receiving signal in a frequency band of about 1090 MHz; - Strongly reject the frequency band around 1030MHz emitted by the transmit chain is intended. The setup of FIG. 1b is a particular exemplary embodiment that includes a local oscillator (LO) 10 (oscillating at 1030 MHz) shared between a transmit channel 401 and a receive channel 402.
[0041] Upstream of the first amplifier 8 of the transmission channel, the transmission signal is modulated by a modulator 12 at the frequency of a local oscillator 10 (i.e. at 1030 MHz). A filter 4E is inserted between the oscillator and the modulator and is intended to filter out the 1090 MHz noise. Before the analog / digital conversion 9' of the reception channel, the reception signal is mixed with the signal of the local oscillator by a mixer 11 and then filtered by a bandpass filter 13. A filter 4D is placed at the output side of the ADC 9' to filter the 1030 MHz signal.
[0042] The DIFF channel, which operates only in reception, includes a receive chain similar to the receive chain 402 of the SUM channel, specifically including filtering operations 4C, 4D for filtering the signal transmitted at 1030 MHz. The SUM, DIFF and CONT transmit and / or receive chains all operate independently of each other.
[0043] The four patterns of a civil ATC antenna are processed separately, thereby requiring one four-channel receiver (or a three-channel receiver if CONT_Front and CONT_Back are merged into a single CONT, as is customary and shown in FIG. 1a).
[0044] Before any decoding of the response, each signal processing operation 6 independently matches its analysis band to the characteristics of the protocol for which its response is detected. This filtering operation, which is adapted to each protocol used, makes it possible to obtain better performance by reducing the noise level and thus allows a lowering of the detection threshold independently for each protocol in order to process weaker signals.
[0045] Figure 2a shows the steps of the implementation of the present invention. This implementation requires at least two steps.
[0046] The first step 21 allows a conventional Mode S secondary radar to be converted into a "full-duplex" meta-secondary sensor according to the invention. This step 21 orthogonalizes the various protocols and makes the radar suitable for asynchronous reception. The orthogonalization here means making the processing operations of the protocols completely independent. In practice, the orthogonalization of the protocols means: - in the 1090 MHz receiving chain at 211, through the rejection of the 1030 MHz interrogation to the noise level of the 1090 MHz chain as shown by filters 4C, 4D in Fig. 1b; - in the 1030 MHz transmit chain at 212, via rejection of signals transmitted at 1090 MHz below the noise of the 1090 MHz receive as shown by filters 4A, 4B in FIG. 1b; - At the receiving end, specifically: BW_IFF>BW_SSR>BW_MS>BW_ADS-B (BW_IFF, BW_SSR, BW_MS and BW_ADS-B are the bandwidths of IFF, SSR, Mode S and ADS-B respectively) By matching the analysis bandwidth (BeamWidth_BW) to the characteristics of the adopted protocol (213), so that - In asynchronous mode, Through the largest number of independent patterns present in the secondary radar, This is achieved by listening simultaneously, Optionally, the CONT_Front and CONT_Back patterns can be processed separately (214); Optionally, a kit 215 can also be employed to extend the receive-only CONT_back pattern to ensure RF coverage at high elevation angles and that RF coverage is complete over 360° azimuth.
[0047] In a second step 22, operationally: - In the field of civil air traffic control or ATC surveillance, By listening simultaneously in asynchronous mode for ADS-B squitters via three or four patterns separately, independent of synchronization activity. By optimizing the duration of the sequence of roll-call transactions (so that the roll-call listening period occurs simultaneously with the all-call transmission period) without any major constraints other than non-overlapping listening periods to avoid "response garbling" and non-overlapping questions (which is inherently achieved because of a single transmitter), - in the field of military air traffic control 24 or IFF identification, Through an IFF interrogator (with the only restriction of accessing transmission resources shared with SSR / Mode S surveillance and performing its identification transactions); By listening separately and simultaneously via three or four patterns for Mode 5 Level 2 squitters, independent of synchronous activity. - In the field of control of 25 aviation environments, By listening separately and simultaneously via three or four patterns for any type of secondary response, regardless of synchronization activity (including asynchronous interference called FRUIT (False Replies Unsynchonized In Time)). Protocol orthogonality is exploited.
[0048] Figures 2b and 2c show the sequencing of IFF and SSR / Mode S interrogations for a radar according to the prior art and for a radar according to the invention, respectively. Figure 2b thus illustrates conventional operation according to the prior art through an example of the sequencing of three successive periods: - Period N+2: All Call (AC) for All Call SSR and Mode S transactions only - Period N+3: Roll Call (RC) for Roll Call Mode S transactions only - Period N+1: Military mode exclusive IFF If the target aircraft has ample dwell time, the radar can, in the best case, interleave periods according to the sequencing shown in Figure 2b above. When dwell time is tight, i.e., the antenna rotation rate is high (the most common case), the radar performs military IFF discrimination at the expense of civilian surveillance, and the three periods cannot occur in the available dwell time.
[0049] Figure 2c shows an example of operation according to the invention. In this case, transactions can overlap from one period to the next, in particular IFF identification can span periods N+2 and N+3. In particular, radars according to the invention perform IFF transactions at their own specific rate (completely different from the rate of SSR and Mode S transactions), independent of the AC and RC periods, which are still dedicated to SSR mode and Mode S. This functional orthogonalization (see Figure 2a) exploits the RF isolation of transmit and receive (see Figure 2b), thereby: - IFF detection (see periods N+1 and N+3 in Figure 2c) despite many Mode S transmissions - Mode S detection (see periods N+1 and N+2 in Figure 2c) despite a small number of IFF transmissions This allows for simultaneous IFF military identification and civilian surveillance, even at high radar rotation speeds.
[0050] FIG. 3 shows an example of operational exploitation according to step 23 described above, which optimizes ATC surveillance. This exploitation example is shown for three aircraft 31, 32, 33 present in the environment of a radar according to the invention. ADS_B squitters are simultaneously listened to via the radar's SUM pattern, via the DIFF pattern, via the CONT_Front pattern and via the CONT_Back pattern. These simultaneous listening operations allow avoidance of overlap of asynchronous responses of target aircraft located at different off-boresight angles, thus improving their detection and decoding. The aircraft broadcast (30) asynchronous ADS-B responses in all directions. Thus, the response of the first aircraft 31 is received via the SUM pattern, the response of the second aircraft 32 via the CONT_Front pattern and the response of the third aircraft 33 via the CONT_Back pattern. Thus, in this example, independent ADS-B reception per antenna pattern allows the detection of these three squitters, even if they are simultaneous in time.
[0051] Figure 4a shows the gain of the conventional ATC secondary antenna pattern of Figure 1a as a function of azimuth angle. More precisely, Figure 4a quantifies, via a plot over 360° (+ / -180° with respect to the antenna), the amplitude of the signal received from a given target aircraft as a function of its azimuth angle relative to the radar's antenna axis 40. In synchronous operation of the radar, the dominant pattern is the SUM, which ensures the transmission of valid interrogations and the reception of valid responses, whereas the role of the CONT_Front and CONT_Back patterns is to ensure that they are higher side lobes of the SUM pattern, i.e., provide relative gain to avoid false radar detections (from targets not on axis). In contrast, in asynchronous mode reception of ADS-B and IFF squitters, the role of CONT_Front and CONT_Back dominates, and their absolute gain defines the range of the ADS-B receiver, whose 360° coverage is reflected in the temporal coverage of the listening operation for the squitter. In medium-range ADS-B, the temporal coverage of the listening operation performed via CONT_Front and CONT_Back is of the 75% class, which is a consequence of the design of the conventional ATC secondary antenna, and as a result, in its main plane (i.e. +90° and −90° in azimuth) the radiation is zero, which does not in any way disadvantage the synchronous operation of the radar perpendicular to the plane of this antenna; - On the antenna axis, the gain of CONT_Front is intentionally attenuated in synchronous mode. This intentional lowering of the gain of CONT_Front is provided to ensure a clear distinction in azimuth between itself and the radar beam in synchronous mode.
[0052] Thus, listening via SUM (or even via DIFF) in addition to listening via CONT_Front allows to ensure a temporal coverage of about 5% by compensating for the drop in gain of the CONT_Front pattern perpendicular to the plane of the antenna. Overall, independent and even simultaneous listening in asynchronous mode via two or three antenna patterns (SUM, CONT or SUM, CONT_Front, CONT_Back) allows to ensure that asynchronous mode listening operation has a temporal coverage of about 80% in medium-range ADS-B and remains at least 50% in maximum-range ADS-B. Figure 4b shows the complementarity of the azimuth radiation 41 of the CONT_Back pattern according to the invention. The aim is to guarantee a radiation pattern at the receiver side at 1090 MHz with equal levels over the entire coverage of the CONT. Thus, reception of ADS-B and IFF squitter is guaranteed up to the maximum distance ADS-B and IFF with 100% listening time coverage. FIG. 4c shows the gain of the conventional ATC secondary antenna pattern of FIG. 1a as a function of elevation angle. The SUM, CONT_Front and CONT_Back patterns are shown, each for their maximum azimuth angle. - In the conventional method, the SUM pattern has a maximum value about 15 to 20 dB higher than the CONT_Front (see Figure 4a). - The leakage 42 of the SUM pattern on the front panel in the direction opposite to the perpendicular to the plane of the antenna is lower than -35 dB for the conventional method. By design, the ATC secondary antenna is found to exhibit a very large gain drop at high elevation angles (i.e., elevation angles greater than 50°). As a result, the secondary radar will not detect within the cone of no signal (CoS) that traditionally extends from an elevation angle of 45°. The ADS-B function integrated into the radar exhibits the same type of CoS when using the same antenna. Figure 4d shows the complementarity of the CONT_Back pattern elevation radiation 43 according to the invention, the purpose of which is to ensure that even at very high elevation angles (>85°) a 1090 MHz receive radiation pattern is present, thereby enabling ADS-B and IFF squitter reception via the extension of the CONT_Back pattern to this high elevation angle.
[0053] Figures 5 and 6 show the advantages of the present invention with respect to the sequencing of roll-call and all-call transactions. More specifically, Figure 5 shows the conventional sequencing adopted in prior art radars, and Figure 6 shows the optimized sequencing in the radar according to the present invention, in relation to the second step 22 described with reference to Figure 2a.
[0054] In Fig. 5, periods of all-call (AC) and roll-call (RC) transactions alternate successively at rates 51, 52. By way of example, Fig. 5 shows four successive periods in the order m, m+1, m+2, m+3 during the dwell time of the radar's antenna lobe, corresponding successively to AC and RC periods. These AC and RC periods are distinct, as are the transmit and receive phases involved.
[0055] The AC and RC interrogation rates 61, 62 shown in Fig. 6 corresponding to the radar according to the invention are different and the RC period is shorter. In particular, the invention advantageously allows the optimization of the duration of the sequence of roll call transactions, since it is possible to transmit or not transmit roll call transmissions during the roll call or all call listening phase. More particularly, the invention provides: - Reduced duration of RC period, - Interleaving of AC and RC periods (selective listening for RC initiation during AC periods) and therefore allows for a lower limit on the target aircraft's dwell time. Here, the antenna lobe covers seven AC or RC stages (m to m+6).
[0056] Figure 7 shows another possibility for the sequencing of AC and RC periods for a radar according to the invention. The sequencing of AC and RC periods is, for example, the same as in the case of Figure 5. In order to be able to manage an aircraft before it enters the operational coverage of the radar, the RC listening operation 71 started in the AC period continues even when the RC transaction phase starts, which necessarily starts with an interrogation (synchronous mode), so that no dwell time is lost with respect to a target aircraft present in the operational coverage. The objective here, independent of the preceding RC period optimization (see Figure 6), is to detect target aircraft outside the radar's operating range (but within its electromagnetic range) and to reduce the number of DF11 replies these target aircraft generate in response to this radar interrogation. Many DF11 replies are - Unnecessarily dissipating their response potential, - Their responses contaminate other radars, especially those closest to the target aircraft.
[0057] FIG. 8a shows a diagram of a kit 215 for extending the 1090 MHz receive side CONT_back pattern (see FIG. 2a) in both azimuth (approximately −90° and +90°) and elevation (greater than 50° elevation) in a three pattern antenna configuration presented as an example. This kit 215 is added to the conventional structure of antenna 1, which is - a set of radiating dipoles 80 with P rows and N columns on the front side (forming the patterns SUM, DIFF and CONT_Front); - P rows and 1 column of radiating dipoles forming the rear CONT_Back pattern 90 It consists of: A distribution circuit 800, which is well known in the art, distributes the signal to the SUM, DIFF and CONT (CONT_Front and CONT_Back) channels. This kit for extending the CONT_Back pattern is intended to fill in the detection holes shown in particular in Figures 4a to 4d, as will be explained below. In order not to disturb the synchronous operation of the radar, the pattern extension 215 is limited to the requirements (i.e., those related to the reception of ADS-B and IFF squitters). The extension is introduced on the opposite side of the front panel, thus extending the CONT_Back, as shown in the exemplary embodiment shown in FIG. 8b. The radiating part of the extension kit, in a plane, a first orientation patch 81 for filling the no-signal cone at an azimuth angle of 180°, the orientation plane of which has an elevation inclination of approximately 110°; a second orientation patch 82 for filling the right detection hole at an azimuth angle of 90°, the orientation plane of which has an elevation inclination of approximately 0°; - a third orientation patch 83 to fill the left detection hole at an azimuth angle of -90°, whose orientation plane has an elevation inclination of approximately 0°; The azimuth direction is divided into three directional patches 81, 82, 83 (e.g., with lobes of about + / - 35°). The signal is routed between the distribution circuit and the P rows and one column of radiating dipoles 90 and the three patches 81, 82, 83 (conventional CONT_Back) and is implemented in a conventional manner by a set of circulators, couplers and summers.
[0058] Figure 8b shows one possible configuration of these radiating elements 81, 82, 83 on a conventional ATC secondary antenna 1 according to the invention. The "right" patch 82 and the "left" patch 83 are each located at the rear end of the plane of the antenna. The patch 81 assigned to the no signal cone is located centrally behind the plane of the antenna. [Explanation of symbols]
[0059] 1 Antenna 2 Rotary joint 3 Duplexer 4 First transmit and receive chain 4' Second transmit and receive chain 4” Receive Chain 4A filtering operation 4B Filtering Operation 4C Filtering Operation 4D Filtering Behavior 4E Filtering Operation 5 Space-time management 6 Processing Means 8 First Amplifier 8' Second Amplifier 9. Low Noise Amplifier 9' Analog / Digital Converter 10 Local Oscillator 11 Mixer 11 Patterns 12 Modulator 12 Patterns 13 Bandpass Filter 13 Patterns 14 Patterns 31 Aircraft 32 Aircraft 33 Aircraft 40 Axis 41 Azimuth direction radiation 42 Leak 43 Elevation radiation 51 Rate 52 Rate 61 Rate 62 Rate 63 Roll Call Questions 71 Roll call listening behavior 80 ATC secondary antenna 81 First Patch 82 Second Patch 83 Third Patch 90 ATC Antenna 201 Azimuth 215 Kit 311 Circulator 312 Circulator 313 Circulator 314 Circulator 311' LP Filter 313' LP Filter 314' LP Filter 401 Outbound Chain 402 Inbound Chain 800 distribution circuit
Claims
1. A secondary radar including an antenna (1) having a radiation pattern forming a sum channel designated SUM, a radiation pattern forming a difference channel designated DIFF, and a pattern forming a control channel designated CONT, a first transmit and receive chain (4) associated with the SUM channel, a second transmit and receive chain (4') associated with the CONT channel, and a receive chain (4") associated with the DIFF channel; said transmit and receive chains (4, 4') each being capable of transmitting and receiving simultaneously, in such a way that said chains operate independently of each other, said transmit chain (401) comprising filtering operations (4A, 4B) for filtering signals transmitted at 1090 MHz, said receive chain (402) comprising filtering operations (4C, 4D) for filtering signals transmitted at 1030 MHz, said receive chain (4") associated with said DIFF channel comprising filtering operations (4C, 4D) for filtering signals transmitted at 1030 MHz, said receive chain (4") comprising filtering operations (4C, 4D) for filtering signals transmitted at 1030 MHz, said receive side signal level remaining unchanged during synchronization interrogation transmissions, the processing means (6) including matching the frequency band of the receiver with the characteristics of each of the transaction protocols used; the receiving chains of the SUM, DIFF and CONT channels are capable of simultaneously listening in synchronous and asynchronous modes to signals received from a target machine via the SUM, DIFF and CONT patterns, respectively, the operations of listening in synchronous and asynchronous modes being independent of each other, and the signal level at the receiving end remains unchanged during synchronous interrogation transmissions; A secondary radar comprising:
2. 2. The secondary radar according to claim 1, characterized in that the CONT pattern is composed of a front radiation pattern forming a channel designated CONT_Front and a rear radiation pattern forming a channel designated CONT_Back, the CONT_Front and CONT_Back patterns being processed separately in such a way that each of the transmit and receive chains (401, 402) is applied to the CONT_Front channel and the CONT_Back channel.
3. 3. A secondary radar according to claim 2, characterized in that it includes a kit for expanding the radiation pattern of the CONT_Back channel, said kit being placed on the rear side of the antenna (1), said kit comprising: a first patch (81) to fill the detection hole in the elevation direction, called the no-signal cone; a second patch (82) for filling the detection hole at an azimuth angle of 90°, a third patch (83) to fill the detection hole at an azimuth angle of −90° A secondary radar, which includes three radiating patches.
4. A secondary radar according to any one of claims 1 to 3, characterized in that each of said transmission chains includes a filtering operation (4A, 4B) dedicated to the rejection of parasitic signals transmitted at 1090 MHz.
5. A secondary radar according to any one of claims 1 to 4, characterized in that each of the reception chains includes a filtering operation (4C, 4D) dedicated to rejecting parasitic signals of 1030 MHz emanating from the transmission channel.
6. A secondary radar as claimed in any one of claims 1 to 5, characterized in that it has as its mission ATC surveillance (23) the simultaneous listening operation is performed separately via said pattern for ADS-B squitters, independent of the synchronization transaction.
7. A secondary radar according to any one of claims 1 to 6, characterized in that it performs synchronous IFF detection independently of synchronous SSR and Mode S transactions by having as mission IFF discrimination.
8. A secondary radar as claimed in any one of claims 1 to 7, characterized in that it performs simultaneous listening operations separately over the pattern for Mode 5 Level 2 squitters, independent of synchronization transactions, by having as a mission IFF identification.
9. A secondary radar according to any one of claims 1 to 8, characterized in that it performs simultaneous listening operations separately through said patterns for any type of secondary response, independent of synchronization transactions, by having as a mission control of the aviation environment (25).
10. 10. A secondary radar according to claim 1, characterized in that it transmits consecutively during an all-call interrogation period and a roll-call interrogation period, the roll-call interrogation (63) being initiated during the all-call interrogation period.
11. A secondary radar as described in any one of claims 1 to 10, characterized in that it transmits continuously during an all-call interrogation period and a roll-call interrogation period, and an all-call listening operation (71) started during the all-call period continues even after the roll-call period begins.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Monopulse secondary surveillance radar
EP3273262A1
Device for coupling at least two emitters and / or receivers to a common antenna.
FR2658967A1
SECONDARY SURVEILLANCE RADAR WITH HIGH REFRESH RATE
FR3019905A1
Measurement method for antenna pattern of secondary radar, and secondary radar implementing the same
JP2019109228A
Method for characterizing the density of mode s interrogations and reponses and secondary radar implementing such a method
WO2020043825A1
