Load scheduling system for increased utilization and storage of solar energy in electrical form
The automatic load scheduling system addresses the inefficiencies in solar energy systems by dynamically scheduling loads and leveraging the grid for charging, optimizing solar energy utilization and storage with generic batteries, resulting in reduced costs and environmental impact.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- PCT/IN2024/050305
- Authority / Receiving Office
- WO · WO
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2023-05-26
- Filing Date
- 2024-03-23
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-05
AI Technical Summary
Existing solar energy systems face inefficiencies due to the fluctuating nature of solar power generation, leading to wasted energy and the need for specialized batteries, as users struggle to manually optimize energy usage and storage, resulting in high costs and environmental impact.
An automatic load scheduling system that utilizes an artificially intelligent heuristic to optimize solar energy utilization and storage, allowing for the use of generic inverter-suitable batteries by dynamically scheduling loads based on solar input and leveraging the grid for charging, thereby minimizing energy waste and battery costs.
The system achieves near-optimal solar energy utilization and storage, reducing grid charges and battery costs by using generic batteries, ensuring efficient energy extraction and storage even during fluctuating solar conditions, with demonstrated reductions in electricity bills and battery expenses.
Smart Images

Figure IN2024050305_05122024_PF_FP_ABST
Abstract
Description
[0001] LOAD SCHEDULING SYSTEM FOR INCREASED UTILIZATION AND STORAGE OF SOLAR ENERGY IN ELECTRICAL FORM
[0002] Field of the Invention:
[0003] The field of the invention is solar energy storage and utilization in electrical form, using batteries, for example.
[0004] Background of the Invention:
[0005] Environment issues have captured the popular imagination. It is therefore imperative to direct Smart Home / Office design towards sustainable, environment- friendly practices. Resources and practices such as the sun, sky, gravity, and maintenance-freedom offer themselves with renewed vigour to the discerning audience. We teach here a globally optimal solar energy storage and utilization system using an exemplar deployment context, that is the smart home / office testbed for our operations, called the Adbhut House, the residence address of the inventor, given above.
[0006] Solar energy has long been recognized and developed as a renewable energy source, with little or no pollution or other detrimental environmental effects. Solar energy capture is commonly carried out in two forms, as electrical energy, using photovoltaic solar panels, or heat, using water heating solar panels based on black body absorption. Both varieties of the panels are depicted in the image embedded in Figure 1 here, the top panels being photovoltaic, the ones on the slope being the black body variety.
[0007] Solar energy captured by photovoltaic panels is commonly handled in two ways: (a) run an electrical load either locally or remotely, or (b) store the energy in batteries locally for later use. Batteries being expensive both economically as well as environmentally (a lot of recycling and processing has to be carried out to contain the environmental and economic costs), a strong political initiative exists worldwide to bypass the batteries option and work with option (a) alone. A common form this initiative manifests itself in are subsidies for solar energy wherein the local produce of solar energy is bought back by the grid for transportation to a local or remote load. The road to hell is said to be paved with good intentions, and the initiative here has yet to manifest its merit and well-founded-ness beyond subsidies, as this solution, demands the change of the basic nature of the electrical grid from a broadcaster of energy from a generation source to a multitude of consumers, to a peer-to-peer network where anyone can be the source and anyone the consumer. Transportation of energy is inherently expensive, transmission losses in conduction being intense, with amelioration using high voltages being non-trivial for a peer-to- peer expectation besides causing other loss issues.
[0008] For the purpose of this disclosure, therefore, we focus on localizing solar energy use as a practical way forward. This includes local storage using batteries and we restrict our attention to the entire energy processing and use being in electrical form.
[0009] In this restricted domain, the domain regardless being capable of serving a remote load with the implied losses, we find a lack of optimality vis-a-vis the fluctuating nature of solar power in the prior art solutions offered. Solar energy fluctuates all the time, with climate, seasons, weather, the hour of the day, dust, smog and so on. When solar power goes down, e.g. late in the afternoon, or under cloud cover, or otherwise, the ability to utilize the reduced generation suffers tremendously. Optimality is not just about attempting always to use the solar power on offer (from nature). It is about the completeness in extracting the entirety of the power. For example, suppose the power generating photovoltaic panels are open circuited on the load branch. Then absolutely 0% of the entire power is used, the system simply generating a high voltage difference on the open circuited ends and doing no work. Now consider using this load branch exclusively to charge batteries. When the batteries are fully charged, they will accept no more and hence again the generated power is wasted (damaging the batteries can also be carried out this way). It is therefore imperative that the system be loaded appropriately at various times of a solar day so that complete or optimal extraction of the solar power can be attempted.
[0010] Here comes the quandry: a typical solar system leaves the loading out of its definition as being the user’s prerogative. The onus is on the user and the system by itself does not care as to whether it is being used capably. As we show in this disclosure, it is very hard on the user to carry out the manual practice and discipline needed to load the system capably for the fluctuating nature of the solar power that is generated. Hence a lot of solar energy is wasted, which can be avoided by an automatic system loader, were such an artificially-intelligent entity around to be used.
[0011] Another problem forced by the fluctuating solar power is the specialized batteries it requires. The industry now offers solar inverter batteries as a separate category of batteries, segmenting the market of batteries and forcing buyers to buy only segment- specific batteries for warranty coverage. Economies of scale apply to large segments only, therefore de-segmenting the market, besides simplifying battery construction is good from both economic and environmental perspectives. Summary of the Invention:
[0012] Accordingly, the present invention provides an automatic load scheduling system for increased solar energy utilization and storage that is:
[0013] 1. Near optimal in being able to utilize or store the fluctuating solar energy that is generated.
[0014] 2. Facilitates the use of generic inverter-suitable batteries, regardless of solar energy fluctuation.
[0015] The specific novel apparatus, arrangement, and functioning that realize the above benefits is detailed in the claims section below.
[0016] Brief Description of the Accompanying Drawings:
[0017] These and other features, aspects, and advantages of the present invention will become better understood when the following detailed description is read with reference to the accompanying drawings in which like characters represent like parts throughout the drawings, wherein:
[0018] Figure 1. shows the preferred circuit model for operating the solar inverter system under low solar input in particular
[0019] Figure 2 is a flowchart depicting the load scheduler for the solar system during the day
[0020] Figure 3 is a flowchart depicting the load scheduler for the solar system during the night
[0021] Figure 4 shows the latest electricity bill, manifesting never-before-seen gains for a period of 3 months.
[0022] Skilled artisans will appreciate that elements in the drawings are illustrated for simplicity and may not have been necessarily been drawn to scale. For example, the dimensions of some of the elements in the drawings may be exaggerated relative to other elements to help to improve understanding of aspects of the present invention. Furthermore, the one or more elements may have been represented in the drawings by conventional symbols, and the drawings may show only those specific details that are pertinent to understanding the embodiments of the present invention so as not to obscure the drawings with details that will be readily apparent to those of ordinary skill in the art having benefit of the description herein. Detailed Description of the Invention:
[0023] It should be noted that the steps of a method may be providing only those specific details that are pertinent to understanding the embodiments of the present invention and so as not to obscure the disclosure with details that will be readily apparent to those of ordinary skill in the art having benefit of the description herein.
[0024] All methods described herein can be performed in any suitable order unless otherwise indicated herein or otherwise clearly contradicted by context. The use of any and all examples, or exemplary language (e.g. “such as”) provided with respect to certain embodiments herein is intended merely to better illuminate the invention and does not pose a limitation on the scope of the invention.
[0025] It should be apparent to those skilled in the art that many more modifications besides those already described are possible without departing from the inventive concepts herein. Moreover, in interpreting the specification, all terms should be interpreted in the broadest possible manner consistent with the context. In particular, the terms “comprises” and “comprising” should be interpreted as referring to elements, components, or steps in a nonexclusive manner, indicating that the referenced elements, components, or steps may be present, or utilized, or combined with other elements, components, or steps that are not expressly referenced. Where the specification refers to at least one of something selected from the group consisting of A, B, C .... and N, the text should be interpreted as requiring only one element from the group, not A plus N, or B plus N, etc. scenarios.
[0026] Modelling a solar inverter as a simplified, idealized DC core, that then allows the notion of complete extraction of solar power to become definable, we have the model depicted in Figure 1, namely, a battery bank with a driving EMF Ei and an internal resistance Ri charged by solar panels comprising a driving EMF E2 and an internal resistance R2, the parallel duo driving a load L. The direction of these currents are shown explicitly in the circuit branches. The battery bank branch has its on-site Adbhut House image depicting it explicitly in a surrounding rectangle of dashed lines, the branch comprising an equivalent battery symbol for the pure EMF and a resistance symbol for the internal resistance. Similarly the solar panels branch is annotated with its own Adbhut House image and depicted. The load makes up a resistance by itself in parallel. Here is what we observe using Kirchoff’s Current and Voltage Laws: Ei — Ii Ri - E2 + I2 R2 — 0
[0027] E1 - I1 R1 - (Ii + I2) L = 0
[0028] E2- 12R2 - (Ii + I2) L = 0
[0029] When Ei = E2, then the currents driving the load are in inverse proportion of the internal resistances, namely,
[0030] I2 / I1 = R1 / R2, and there is no charging of the battery bank 1.
[0031] When E2 -Ei > 0, then
[0032] E2 - Ei = I2 R2 - Ii Ri > 0, which is only possible if I2 grows and Ii reduces, possibly becoming negative, implying charging of the batteries as well as running the parallel load L. For complete extraction of power, L is maximized, draining the batteries fast, as well as short-circuiting the panels to draw out the maximum that they can generate. The artificially intelligent (Al) heuristic we derive from this model later caps the maximum load, for reasons including circuit protection and hence is near optimal at best, and not optimal, as an absolute.
[0033] In other words, for charging the batteries bank, the solar drive has to be substantially larger than the stored charge / voltage in the batteries else the only way to make use of the solar input is to load the inverter externally, which then serves to discharge the inverter batteries to some extent, but regardless, is able to utilize the solar input. The trick then, is to make up for the lost charge of the batteries later, using the grid supply if needed. This way, the entire solar input of a day, good or bad, is utilized, resulting in near perfect efficiency, using the grid as leverage to pull this off. A stable grid voltage then has the concomitant benefit of more efficient charging of the batteries, with just about any inverter-compatible battery getting charged satisfactorily, avoiding a need to build or use specialized batteries for a fluctuating solar input.
[0034] If the solar drive is meagre, i.e. E2 -Ei is a small positive, and no load is placed, then the load branch is open and hence the small positive only drives a minor charging current, resulting in almost no charging and hence no solar utilization.
[0035] Proceeding with this result, we build a scheduler for the solar inverter, that yields perfect use of the solar input, scheduling loads and charging accordingly, to obtain the result. The lessons picked up for our heuristic design are:
[0036] 1. Load the system substantially, as only then comes an attempt to reach optimality near enough. 2. If the batteries charge or remain plateaued, despite the above load, then clearly large utilization of the large solar input is being successful
[0037] 3. Else the large load is draining the batteries also, or exclusively, on a dark sky day, i.e. E2 -Ei < 0., wherein if the day is bright, then, the load can optionally be reduced to apply lesson 2 above, or for a dark sky day, the load can be either reduced or switchover to grid supply made, or both. Batteries drained under lesson 3 here have to be replenished later by either grid supply, or the application of lesson 2 above.
[0038] Lesson 2 clearly makes for near optimal solar use; lesson 3 also does, except on a dark sky day, i.e. when there is no solar input , i.e. E2 -Ei < 0. Since there is no solar input on a dark sky day, then trivially, solar utilization is best (i.e., 100% of a 0 input was utilized, namely 0). On a bright day, at most the solar utilization is ratioed according the internal resistances vis-a-vis the stored charge, but that is still a substantial utilization of the meagre solar input. If the batteries’ discharge is made up under lesson 2 later, then clearly the solar utilization of the day is substantial. The lessons above therefore provide for near optimal solar utilization that our heuristic next automates. The heuristic, shown in Figure 2, also Figure 3, clearly manifests the lessons in the flowchart of its activities, as we shall explain below further.
[0039] A secondary objective of the solar system, after near optimal solar input utilization is to minimize grid charges. It is nice to design the system up front of a scale that meets the entire electrical input need of a user. Since the user need varies with the season, winter and summer being expensive due to the increased cooling / heating needs in the seasons, a static system size either overshoots the need for many seasons, or undershoots them. From an environmental and economic perspective, it is imperative to reduce the repetitive battery costs, so designing for minimized battery banks, maybe even the minimal possible from off-the-shelf inverter-suitable batteries, is desirable. This choice limits the battery bank capacity available, which in turn limits the extent to which a nightly load can be supported by solar, the rest, necessarily falling upon the grid to support. Grid thus is necessary in our design, from both a nightly perspective and the optimality perspective, that falls back on grid in its lessons above. The rest of the solar system, e.g. its panels can be large, the overshoot in low-use seasons being reducible by simply shutting the excess parts / panesl down for a season. An undershoot for all seasons may also be allowed, in contexts where space for panels is limited, e.g. in flats. For a season, in particular a day, however, the capacity of the solar system is fixed, and so is the battery bank capacity. Since no solar generation occurs at night, at most one, full capacity C of the battery bank charge is available for use at night. If at the end of the solar day, a fraction x of the capacity C, in KWH, is the status of the batteries’s energy, then in the night, xC KWH supply can come from the preceding day’s solar, if the system is allowed to be fully drained in the night. Any further load in the night has to be supplied by the grid, only the starting and ending points of the batteries charge are fixed to xC and 0 respectively. To avoid deep discharge of the batteries, the bottom value may be pegged to a threshold T higher than 0, reducing nightly spend to xC - T. Another reason for a reasonable value of T comes from the alternative function of an inverter, as a backup system against grid failure, so retaining a significant T can well be a design decision.
[0040] Suppose the peak power generation capacity of a system’s panels is P in a given season / day. Then capping the maximum load also at P is a reasonable choice for the maximum load that is supportable by the system, even though this will almost always drain the batteries as the average generated power is lower. Following the lessons, the x at the end of the solar day may be low, reducing the nightly load supported, but reliance on grid charging the batteries with a stable voltage for the wellness of the batteries then mandates that the nightly load be large enough to ensure lots of grid charging, or alternatively, that C be low, or minimal, which then resonates as another push for minimal, cheap batteries. A low C however reduces the degree of freedom available to the scheduler in the day, to borrow energy from a future solar moment, by spending battery charge in the interim to be replenished by the solar moment later. Nightly load can easily be high in peak-use seasons, so the wellness function can suffer only during off-peak seasons, such as spring and autumn, for a high C and low nightly use. Off peak seasons also have a low day time energy use, so x can also be high for such a day, and overcharging during the day from low use can be a problem, which then can be easily solved by shutting down some of the excess panel capacity during that season. Increasing nightly and daily spend during such days may still be useful, for example by defining excess, luxury uses, such as excess water / climate heating / cooling during the season or electric vehicle charging gratis during the season. We call such loads as splurge loads, that can be entertained optionally by the system at a low, but non-zero priority.
[0041] The scheduler endeavours to keep the daytime charged status of batteries between T and C, starting the solar day typically near T, but not necessarily. The flowchart in Figure 2 depicts the overall cyclic nature of the scheduler in a solar day or after the inverter has been reset due to user-mandated overloading. In EMF terms, T represents a low Ei, so even if E2 is low at the day’s start, the difference can be substantial favouring quick charging in the morning. Loading in the morning is gradual so the scheduler entertains a voltage rise for the batteries in the morning.
[0042] A load is defined as a pair, a power rating, and an expected running time that it needs. Additionally, it may demand a fixed scheduling time or dependencies such as precedence or succession vis-a-vis other loads. All loads are considered breakable into multiple time slots whose expected cumulative time is equal to the expected time of the load run in one contiguous slot. All loads have the same default priority, unless a higher priority or lower splurge priority is specified explicitly. Load turn off upon completion is automatic, but can also be scheduler dictated, for example, when the load is broken across time slots with the scheduler dictating a turn off.
[0043] For a given season, a day’s bright solar generation capacity graph is defined and made available to the system apriori. The curve is well below the peak capacity P, as it represents average solar generation on a bright day, as opposed to the absolute peak capacity. The scheduler monitors the battery bank voltage and tries to schedule loads, higher priority first, such that the cumulative power of the scheduled loads is close to the curve of the day. Going above the curve is allowed, if the batteries’s voltage is high, else, underloading is done to allow the batteries to charge up. In general, the scheduler seeks to keep the batteries voltage mobile, wherein the charging activity shows solar utilization in itself and discharging shows solar utilization under (large) load. The scheduler seeks to get its non-splurge loads completed as early as possible leaving only the optional splurge loads to run in the afternoon. Early completion generally meets the user climate control mandates well, since in early morning, users typically seek fresh airing of the house as opposed to closed climate control.
[0044] The scheduler considers user-scheduled loads as mandatory and overriding all priorities. Climate control, except for splurge loads, is left to the user to schedule and dictate as decisions regarding climate are user-specific and whimsical in particular. The user is expected to be aware of the scheduling status (visible on the scheduler panel) and can exceed P also in his scheduling, but that’s his prerogative, which may well lead to an inverter shutdown that he has to then recover from (the reset in Figure 2).
[0045] On a meagre solar input day, e.g. during cloudy weather, or during late afternoon when the batteries are somewhat charged and sunset is approaching reducing solar input, E2 - Ei is small, so a scheduled load almost always dips into the batteries charge. The scheduler monitors the batteries charge and if the threshold T is crossed, shuts down the load, and then searches for a resumption time using binary search as follows: it lets the batteries charge for a time period Y using the grid and then resumes the load so that either the new charge or a changed solar status can sustain the load. If in this process T is crossed again within an observation time of KY, where K is a small multiplier, then a Z = Y time of waiting is carried out before this process is repeated, with Z being doubled to 2Y, and then 4Y and so on. Within a few doublings, a persistently dark time is passed by without much wasted solar day, as the wasted post-dark period is roughly capped by the latest value of Z while the grid charge incurred is proportional to log2Z, a minor amount. If Z is small, compared to the rest of the solar day, near optimality is maintained, To keep Z small, the doublings nature of the algorithm can be reduced to a smaller factor than 2 as discussed in the heuristic variations later. Amortized over the year, large Z values and the doubling algorithm still yield near optimal performance.
[0046] If in the above, T is not crossed within KY time, then the history of doublings of Z is scrapped by the scheduler and a new history is started with Z set to Y again. Such rescheduling is carried out for loader-scheduled loads in particular, while rescheduling user mandated loads can be left to the user as an option. If the solar day runs out, as per the provided graph, then the load is left unscheduled by the automatic scheduler. A user can of course schedule it then, and in such a case, the load runs to completion on grid supply once T is crossed (see Figure 3).
[0047] After a solar day’s end, once the batteries charge dips below T, the system switches to grid and remains there till the batteries are charged enough to be able to sustain the remaining night load on the stored charge (Figure 3). If the night later causes more expense, then grid charging is carried out again to another quitting time such that the stored charge can sustain the remaining expected load. This process proceeds till the day begins, as per the bright day graph, and then the day-time scheduling of Figure 2 resumes.
[0048] For a large enough Y, the method above will work well even on a patchy dark / bright day. The user can of course intervene to dictate terms with user mandates of his own volition, e.g. whether the next doubling is likely to cross the end of the day, by checking in the afternoon.
[0049] A meagre solar day can force its loads to shift to the night to schedule, which the nightly scheduling can happily do, as it seeks to maximize its load for better battery charging. Since grid supply is sized to be able to handle all user load, unlike solar, the ability of the night to schedule such loads is always there, with no system resetting or shutdown. Forcing daytime scheduling under bad solar, using grid at daytime can be done with user mandate always, if the load requirements are urgent.
[0050] Many constants fed to the system can be tuned to more precise values using machine learning over a long period of system operation. For example, the bright day graphs vary by location and deployment settings, the shadows of neighbouring objects on the panels, etc. So tuning the graphs for the custom settings of a site makes sense. Similarly, the power rating of a load may be improved for a specific load machine, by observing its behaviour over time, conjecturing an improvement and then verifying that over time. User feedback may also be taken in such tuning enterprise.
[0051] The performance of the scheduler, implemented approximately and manually for now, has been verified in our deployed inverter system, a Su-Kam Colossal 10 KVA inverter of 2010 purchase date, with Vikram and Waaree photovoltaic panels numbering 24 with a peak generation capacity P of just under 10 KW, a UTL solar controller, and 15 12- Volt batteries arranged in series to aggregate 180V for the bank using LivGuard LGL FF 100 batteries of 100 AH rated capacity each, designed for tractors by the manufacturer. We purchased these batteries on dealer hearsay that they work well in inverters and the low price that the large segment for the large tractor market offered. Warranty is of course denied for our use, but that is not surprising given that we’re de-segmenting the market. These batteries were deployed on March 4, 2023. The electricity bill for the period of 11 February to 15 May of 93 days, Figure 3, shows a grid charge of 463 KWH. Prior to March 4, the system was running on a mixture of somewhat defective mostly 200 AH batteries that were awaiting replacement, costing 63 KWH of grid charge then in the bill period. Although the weather this year has been unusually pleasant, and further a host of technologies other than the one disclosed here have been deployed to reduce energy costs, the charges for the 3 months of expense are the lowest we have ever faced in this 2010 onwards smart home / office of ours, of approximately 7800 sq foot covered area size in a 500 sq yard plot, or for that matter any prior residence of ours, i.e.: no charges to the best of our memory have fallen in the subsidized billing slab, as done in this bill, at Rs. 2.75 / KWH here, as opposed to Rs. 7+ per KWH slab in the prior bills. As regards the batteries desegmentation, the 200 AH SMF batteries designed for UPS that were in use before the tractor ones cost us over Rs. 2 lakh in February 2021 but did not last. The tractor batteries now cost us less than a third of the 200 AH ones, net, at Rs. 66000 net. The net costs include recycling deduction for the batteries being replaced which were bought back by the vendor of the new ones reducing the new ones’ cost. The tractor batteries have a warranteed life of 3 years, for tractor use. If these batteries survive that long in our deployment, clearly we would have paid only Rs. 22000 per annum for the batteries, or less, if they last longer. If the 463 KWH for the 3 months here costing Rs. 1274 as energy charges in the total bill, rise even ten-fold for the remaining year of 9 months, they cost only about half the batteries cost per annum. Clearly, minimizing batteries cost is of high priority and de-segmentation is a laudable goal.
[0052] The scheduler disclosed here is a recent development of ours that was not being practiced by us largely, during the period of the 200 AH batteries, which may be one reason for their limited life, but regardless, their prohibitive cost, for just twofold increase in rated capacity makes them uneconomical in our context.
[0053] The near optimal heuristic of the scheduler can be varied in many ways to tune it for specific embodiments, for example using a tripling Z heuristic, or a less than doubling heuristic. Such variations are a part of the invention disclosed herein.
[0054] The entire design here is based on minimality. Monitoring is reduced to just the battery charge / voltage status, even which can be eschewed in specific embodiments by playing safe within the bright day curves and letting the user handle threshold T crossings just before the inverter low alarm triggers before shutdown. Additionally, battery sizes are sought to be minimized / reduced, the battery specializations removed and generic batteries used.
[0055] Benefits, other advantages, and solutions to problems have been described above with regard to specific embodiments. However, the benefits, advantages, solutions to problems, and any component(s) that may cause any benefit, advantage, or solution to occur or become more pronounced are not to be construed as a critical, required, or essential feature.
[0056] While specific language has been used to describe the disclosure, any limitations arising on account of the same are not intended. As would be apparent to a person in the art, various working modifications may be made to the process in order to implement the inventive concept as taught herein.
Claims
WE CLAIM:
1. A load scheduling system for increased utilization and storage of solar energy in electrical form2. The system as claimed in claim 1, wherein loading of the system is increased to force the solar generation to address the load, directly, or in conjunction with the charge stored in batteries.
3. The system as claimed in claim 2, wherein the stored charge in batteries is replenished by solar generation later, or charging by the grid.
4. The system as claimed in claim 3, wherein charge replenishment by the grid leads to improved battery performance because of the non-fluctuating, stable nature of the grid supply and its voltage.
5. A solar inverter system, comprising a load scheduling system for increased utilization and storage of solar energy in electrical form.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Power Management System
US20170256949A1
Cited By
Optical storage system scheduling method based on data analysis driving and related device
CN121461520A
