Asymmetric floating platform architectures for off-centered loaded platforms

WO2024249392A2PCT designated stage expired Publication Date: 2024-12-05NATIONAL TECHNOLOGY & ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS OF SANDIA LLC
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
PCT/US2024/031218
Authority / Receiving Office
WO · WO
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2024-05-28
Filing Date
2024-05-28
Publication Date
2024-12-05

Smart Images

  • Figure 000014
    Figure 000014
  • Figure 000015
    Figure 000015
  • Figure 000016
    Figure 000016
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

This disclosure relates to floating platforms with multiple columns where mass and cost can be reduced through the use of asymmetric hull configurations, such as through asymmetric column volumes, for example by having asymmetric diameters for circular columns. Studies for a three-column platform reveal mass reductions on the order of 25% and the opportunity for platform designs with shallower draft than is possible with the use of symmetric platform hulls.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Attorney Docket No.: SD16498.2 / S180092-PCT ASYMMETRIC FLOATING PLATFORM ARCHITECTURES FOR OFF-CENTERED LOADED PLATFORMS RELATED APPLICATIONS

[0001] This application claims priority to U.S. Patent Application No. 18 / 675,349, entitled “ASYMMETRIC FLOATING PLATFORM ARCHITECTURES FOR OFF-CENTERED LOADED PLATFORMS,” filed May 28, 2024, which claims priority to U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 63 / 469,185, entitled “ASYMMETRIC FLOATING PLATFORM ARCHITECTURES FOR OFF-CENTERED LOADED PLATFORMS AND OFF-SHORE PLATFORM SYSTEMS,” filed May 26, 2023, the disclosure of both which are incorporated herein in their entireties. STATEMENT OF GOVERNMENT INTEREST

[0002] The United States Government has rights in this invention pursuant to Contract No. DE- NA0003525 between the United State Department of Energy and National Technology & Engineering Solutions of Sandia, LLC, both for the operation of the Sandia National Laboratories. FIELD

[0003] The present disclosure is directed to off-shore floating platforms and more particularly to off-shore wind turbine platforms having asymmetric designs. BACKGROUND

[0004] Floating platforms must meet two fundamental requirements to (1) maintain buoyancy and (2) maintain stability. Maintaining buoyancy relates to displacing water (typically by air) such that buoyant forces equal the gravitational forces at the desired draft. To maintain stability, there are three fundamental mechanisms: (1) ballast (locating stabilizing mass sufficiently below the water level), (2) buoyancy (having a sufficiently large water plane area), and (3) mooring (having mooring or tendon forces that sufficiently prevent overturning).

[0005] Maintaining platform stability while minimizing hull mass and hydrodynamic forces and exposure often results in multi-column platform hull designs. As is understood in the field, columns are vertical elements which are separated from each other that are partially submergedAttorney Docket No.: SD16498.1 / S180092 and partially above water level. These designs to date have been symmetric in nature, where the individual columns and connecting pontoons are equivalent in dimensions and where the angles between the columns are equivalent based on the number of columns (360 degrees / N_columns).

[0006] The platforms to date have not been designed to optimally respond to off-centered loading. Many floating platform designs are derivatives from the oil and gas industry where the platform is mostly controlled by wave excitation and carries a more symmetric payload relative to the overall footprint. These platforms typically have a single-unit production and the cost of the platform is relatively small compared to the revenue generated for the oil and gas industry. These distinctions are not consistent for floating wind turbines, where: wind loading dominates, platform payload can be largely off-centered, hundreds of units can be produced, and cost is the key design driver to overcome with the integrated design. Applying the standard symmetric platform design approach for floating or offshore wind can result in platforms that are more massive, more costly, and have reduced performance for the loading conditions of offshore wind turbines.

[0007] What is needed are platforms that overcome one or more of these deficiencies and / or provides other advantageous features. Other features and advantages will be made apparent from the present specification. The teachings disclosed extend to those embodiments that fall within the scope of the claims, regardless of whether they accomplish one or more of the aforementioned needs. SUMMARY OF THE DISCLOSURE

[0008] The present disclosure is directed to an asymmetric hull for a floating platform, the hull includes three or more columns; a frame connecting the three or more columns; and pontoons connecting the three or more vertical columns, the pontoons disposed underneath the frame. One or more of the three or more columns, frame and pontoons are asymmetrical.

[0009] The present disclosure is further directed to an asymmetric hull for a floating platform that includes three columns; a frame connecting the three columns; and pontoons connecting the three columns, the pontoons disposed underneath the frame. One or more of the columns, frame and pontoons are asymmetrical.

[0010] The present disclosure is further directed to an asymmetric hull for a floating platform that includes four columns; a frame connecting the four columns; and pontoons connecting the fourAttorney Docket No.: SD16498.1 / S180092 columns, the pontoons disposed underneath the frame. One or more of the columns, frame and pontoons are asymmetrical.

[0011] The present disclosure provides asymmetric platform configurations that satisfies system stability and design requirements. The asymmetric platform configurations can be used on three or more column platform configurations. In an embodiment, the asymmetrc platform or hull configurations can be used for three or four column platform configurations. In this disclosure, hull and platform are used interchangeably to reference the overall platform structure. The designs provide improved stability and / or reduced mass for direct weight loads / payloads and loads created by wind and wave forces.

[0012] Increasing the diameter or cross-sectional area of a primary column that receives most of the load or reducing the diameter or cross-sectional area of the secondary columns is done such that the buoyancy forces and gravitational forces for all columns (with and without the turbine payload) are equalized while reducing the amount of additional water ballast required in the secondary columns, and reducing the mass and cost of the secondary columns. The diameter, or equivalent diameter for non-circular columns, of the primary column is up to 150% greater than any secondary column. In other embodiments, the primary column may have a diameter or equivalent diameter of between 50% and 150% greater than the largest secondary column. As understood, equivalent diameter would pertain to non-circular cross-sections. In other embodiments, the primary column may have a diameter or equivalent diameter 100% greater than one or more secondary columns. In an embodiment, there may be up to a 25% platform mass reduction. In other embodiments, the reduction may be higher or lower dependent upon a configuration that satisfies system stability and design requirements. In addition to reducing the platform mass at a specified draft, the arrangement can provide a shallower draft using column diameter or cross-sectional asymmetry than is allowed for symmetric platform designs while satisfying the design constraints. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE FIGURES

[0013] Figure 1 illustrates a floating offshore wind turbine system including a multi-column platform and wind turbine configuration according to an embodiment of the present disclosure.

[0014] Figure 2 is a simplified perspective view of the platform of Figure 1 having asymmetric column dimensions.Attorney Docket No.: SD16498.1 / S180092

[0015] Figure 3 is a top view of the asymmetric platform of Figure 2.

[0016] Figure 4 is a top view of another embodiment of a platform according to an embodiment of the disclosure.

[0017] Figure 5 is a top view of a four column platform of an embodiment of the disclosure. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE DISCLOSURE

[0018] According to this disclosure, floating platforms that support off-centered loading are shown to benefit from a corresponding asymmetry in the platform design, either through the dimensions of the platform hull or through the position or dimensions of the mooring or tendon attachment points to the platform hull. The platform hull (hereinafter referred to as “hull”) includes columns, pontoons, an upper frame and leg extensions. Off-centered loading can result from an unequal payload, where center of mass of the payload is located away from the geometric center of the platform or from directionality of wind and wave loading where higher loads occur from consistent directional sectors for ultimate or fatigue loading. In this disclosure, the center of mass of the payload is located above the central axis of a primary column having a column diameter larger than the other platform columns. Above the central axis means directed above or up to 25% off of the cental axis. For example, a floating wind turbine system includes an asymmetric platform where the turbine is installed over a primary column and not on secondary columns. Asymmetric platforms can also support loads other than wind turbines, such as but not limited to power generators, cranes, fuel generation or storage, electrical substations. Additionally, off-centered loading can arise from directional loading distributions relative to the installation orientation, such as storms that are predominantly from a sector of the incoming wind direction.

[0019] According to various embodiments of the disclosure, the platform may be asymmetric by: i. Varying the column diameter so the primary column has a larger diameter than the secondary columns and the pontoons form an isosceles or equilateral triangle. ii. Varying the relative position of the columns and angles formed by reference lines passing through adjacent column midpoints (with symmetric or asymmetric column diameters), with pontoon lengths that vary. Asymmetry in the relative position of the columns means that the angles measured between connecting pontoons on eachAttorney Docket No.: SD16498.1 / S180092 column can be distinct from each other (varying from the equiangular value of 180 degrees divided by the number of columns). iii. Varying pontoon cross-sectional dimensions to alter the buoyancy of the pontoon connecting the secondary columns, such that it is higher or lower than the pontoons connecting to the primary column. iv. Varying the length of leg extensions (when present) or mooring attachment points so that the tendon / mooring connection points form an isosceles or equilateral triangle, independent of the column and pontoon symmetry or asymmetry. v. Varying the pontoon lengths with or without constant column diameter of a non- equilateral triangle while keeping the column diameters equal. As such, pontoon lengths can be varied to create a non-equilateral triangle for positioning of the tendon / mooring connection points. vi. Using a four column platform design in a square or diamond configuration having a primary column having a larger diameter than the secondary columns. Pontoon lengths can also be varied to create various configurations of diamond configurations to satisfy directional stability requirements. vii. Asymmetry may be any combination of column, frame / pontoon and leg extension asymmetry.

[0020] Figure 1 illustrates an offshore wind turbine system 10 that includes a wind turbine 12 and a floating platform (platform) that includes an overstructure (removed for clarity) and a platform hull (hull) 14. As understood in the art, the overstrucure includes but is not limited to decking, pumps, pipes, motors, generators, cables and other components as are known in the art for the support and operation of the wind turbine and hull. In this example, the wind turbine 12 is a vertical axis wind turbine (VAWT) as is known in the art. For example, the VAWT may be that as disclosed in U.S. Patent No. 11,421,650, issued August 23, 2022, which is incorporated by reference in its entirety. In other embodiments, the wind turbine 12 may be but is not limited to a VAWT, horizontal axis wind turbine (HAWT), or airborn wind energy system as are known in the art. The columns, pontoons and optional leg extensions have internal hollow volume that are partially filled with ballast (water) to stabilize the hull and platform. Components to control and fill / empty ballastAttorney Docket No.: SD16498.1 / S180092 are part of the overstructure and are well known in the art and will not be discussed in any further detail herein.

[0021] As can be seen in Figure 1, the hull 14 includes three upright or vertical columns (columns) 16 connected by an upper column frame (frame) 18 and pontoons 20. The pontoons 20 have optional leg extensions 22 for locating tendons or mooring connection points and / or additional buoyancy. In this exemplary embodiment, the frame 18 includes three frame portions 18x connected to the columns 16 and three portions 20x conntected to the columns 16. Attached to the leg extensions are mooring connections 21. In this exemplary embodiment, the three frame portions 18x have the same length and design and are thus symmetrical. In other embodiments, the three frame portions 18x may have different lengths and designs and thus be asymmetrical. In this exemplary embodiment, the three pontoons 20x have the same length and design and are thus symmetrical. In other embodiments, the pontoons 20x may have different lengths and designs and be asymmetrical.

[0022] In this exemplary embodiment, the leg extensions 22 are symmetrical. In other embodiments, the leg extensions 22 may be asymmetrical is size and / or shape. For example, the leg extensions 22 may be of different lengths, wherein length is measured from the connection point to a column 16 to the opposing end of the leg extension 22.

[0023] In this exemplary embodiment, the mooring connections 21 are external to the leg extensions 22. In other embodiments, the mooring connections 21 may be internal and / or external to the leg extensions 22. In this exemplary embodiment, the mooring connections 21 are symmetrical. In other embodiements, the mooring connections 21 may be asymmetrical. For example, the one or more mooring connections may be placed at greater or lesser distance along the length of the leg extension.

[0024] In this exemplary embodiment, a primary column 16a supports the primary load of the turbine 12 as the central axis of the primary column 16a is directly aligned with the center of mass of the turbine 12. In this exemplary embodiment, the columns have a circular diameter or cross- section with the primary column diameter greater than the two equal diameter secondary columns. The primary column 16a therefore having a larger internal volume. In other embodiments, the secondary column diameters may not be equal.

[0025] In other embodiments, the column cross-sections may be circular, oval, square, rectangularAttorney Docket No.: SD16498.1 / S180092 or other geometric shape. For non-circular columns, the columns have an equivalent diameter as is understood in the art. In this exemplary embodiment, the lower pontoons 20 are attached to leg extensions 22. In other embodiments, the platform 20 may or may not include leg extensions on one or all of the lower pontoons. In this exemplary embodiment, the leg extensions are equal. In other embodiments, the leg extensions size and shape may vary. In this exemplary embodiment, the positioning of the mooring connections is the same for all three leg extensions 22. In other embodiments, the positioning of the attachment points 21 may vary along the leg extension lenths.

[0026] The primary and secondary columns 16a,16b provide stability to a platform hull and the associated platform to resist overturning resulting from weight and wind loading and / or angular roll / pitch displacement. As is understood in the art, ballast (typicaly in the form of water) can be used in portions of the columns 16, pontoons 20 and / or extensions 22 to lower the center of gravity and achieve the operational draft. Ballast volume in one or more of the columns, pontoons and extensions, as known in the art, may be modified as loading conditions change. As shown in this exemplary embodiment, the pontoons and extensions have the same structure, but in other embodiments, cross-sections, size and shape of these components may vary based on the structural demands or optimal buoyancy positioning.

[0027] In this exemplary embodiment, the primary column has a diameter that is 100% greater than the secondary columns. In other embodiments, the primary column may have a diameter or diameter equivalent up to 150% greater than the largest secondary column. In other embodiments, the primary column may have a diameter or diameter equivalent between 50% and 150% greater than the largest secondary column.

[0028] Modeling results have determined that for minimum mass hull design from hull geometry variable sampling studies versus the column ratio (secondary column diameter divided by the primary column diameter) for three discrete draft levels 10m, 15m, and 20m that hull mass can be reduced by around 25% with the use of asymmetric hulls through the column diameter ratio (or cross-sectional area for non-circular columns) compared to symmetric hulls (column ratio equal to one). In addition to a reduction in total hull mass through the use of asymmetric platforms, it is also observed that the use of asymmetry can enable shallower draft levels as is observed for the 10m draft results, where there were no feasible solutions that satisfy the stability and design requirements for symmetric hull designs (column ratio equal to one).Attorney Docket No.: SD16498.1 / S180092

[0029] Figure 2 illustrates a simplified perspective view of hull 14 having asymmetric column diameters but with relative positions such that the tendon / mooring connection points form a symmetric, equilateral triangle.

[0030] Figure 3 shows a top view of the hull of Figure 2. As can be seen in Figure 3, the frame 18 and pontoons (not shown as they are underneath) form a slight isosceles triangle while the outer position of the leg extensions form an equaliateral triangle.

[0031] Figure 4 shows a top view of a hull 414 with a non-equilateral frame 18 and pontoon (pontoons are not shown as they are underneath the frame and of the same lengths) triangle design wherein the frame portion 18y and pontoon directly opposite the primary column 16a has longer length than the frame 18x and pontoons connecting the secondary columns 16b to the primary column 16a. As can be seen in Figure 4, the columns and upper frame form an isosceles triangle, and the outer position of the leg extensions also form an isosceles triangle.

[0032] Figure 5 illustrates a platform hull 514 having one primary column and 3 secondary columns 516b. As can be seen in Figure 5, the hull 514 includes a primary column 516a and three secondary columns 516b. The columns are connected by a frame 518 including four frame portions 518x having equal connecting frame portion lengths. Similarly, pontoons (not shown) are directly underneath the connecting frame portions 518x and are similarly sized in length. In this exemplary embodiment, the frame 518 includes four frame portions 518x connecting the columns 516 and four pontoon portions connecting the columns 516. In this exemplary embodiment, the distance between the primary and opposing secondary column is greater than the distance between the two opposing secondary coluumns. In other embodiments, the distance between the two opposing secondary columns may be greater than the distance between the primary column and the opposing secondary column. In this exemplary embodiment, the asymmetry is in a primary column. In other embodiments, the asysmmetry may be the pontoon lengths. For example, the frame portions / pontoons connected to the primary column 516a may be of greater or lesser length that the frame portions / pontoons connecting secondary columns. Other embodiments include the cross- sectional dimension of pontoons connecting secondary columns versus the two pontoons connecting the primary column.

[0033] As can be seen from the above figures, the optimal platform hull design that reduces the hull mass and cost occurs with asymmetric platform hulls, shown with optimal column diameterAttorney Docket No.: SD16498.1 / S180092 ratios from 0.5 to 0.75 where the hull mass is minimized, depending on the draft. The results also reveal that shallower drafts can be realized using asymmetric hull configurations, shown with the 10m draft case where feasible solutions that satisfy the design constraints were not identified above column ratios of 0.8, where a value of 1.0 is a symmetric configuration.

[0034] This exemplary embodiment shows the use of asymmetric column diameters, but the results apply for non-circular columns where the cross-sectional area and volume varies between primary and secondary columns. The asymmetry could also be incorporated in the submerged members of the hull, such as the underwater pontoons. The hull asymmetry could also be incorporated through angular variation between adjacent columns where the angles formed by the column center points are not equivalent at the symmetric value (180 degrees / number of columns, for three column platforms). Asymmetry in the platform hull footprint and / or the tendon / mooring connection points can be used to enable tailoring of the system response to directionally variable wind and wave loading, considering extreme or fatigue loads response.

[0035] While the exemplary embodiments illustrated in the figures and described herein are presently preferred, it should be understood that these embodiments are offered by way of example only. Accordingly, the present application is not limited to a particular embodiment, but extends to various modifications that nevertheless fall within the scope of the appended claims. The order or sequence of any processes or method steps may be varied or re-sequenced according to alternative embodiments.

[0036] It is important to note that the construction and arrangement of the various exemplary embodiments is illustrative only. Although only a few embodiments have been described in detail in this disclosure, those skilled in the art who review this disclosure will readily appreciate that many modifications are possible (e.g., variations in sizes, dimensions, structures, shapes and proportions of the various elements, values of parameters, mounting arrangements, use of materials, colors, orientations, etc.) without materially departing from the novel teachings and advantages of the subject matter recited in the claims. For example, elements shown as integrally formed may be constructed of multiple parts or elements, the position of elements may be reversed or otherwise varied, and the nature or number of discrete elements or positions may be altered or varied. Accordingly, all such modifications are intended to be included within the scope of the present application. The order or sequence of any process or method steps may be varied or re- sequenced according to alternative embodiments. In the claims, any means-plus-function clause isAttorney Docket No.: SD16498.1 / S180092 intended to cover the structures described herein as performing the recited function and not only structural equivalents but also equivalent structures. Other substitutions, modifications, changes and omissions may be made in the design, operating conditions and arrangement of the exemplary embodiments without departing from the scope of the present application.

[0037] It should be noted that although the figures herein may show a specific order of method steps, it is understood that the order of these steps may differ from what is depicted.

Claims

Attorney Docket No.: SD16498.1 / S180092 CLAIMS What is claimed is:

1. An asymmetric hull for a floating platform, comprising: three or more columns; a frame connecting the three or more columns; and pontoons connecting the three or more vertical columns, the pontoons disposed underneath the frame; wherein one or more of the three or more columns, frame and pontoons are asymmetrical.

2. The hull of claim 1, wherein the three or more columns are asymmetric because one column of the three or more columns has an increased cross-sectional diameter or equivalent diameter.

3. The hull of claim 1, wherein the pontoons are asymmetrical.

4. The hull of claim 3, wherein pontoons are asymmetrical because a pontoon portion of the pontoons has a greater length and / or cross-sectional area than other pontoon portions.

5. The hull of claim 1, further compising leg extensions connected to the column.

6. The hull of claim 1, wherein the leg extensions are asymmetrical in length and / or cross- sectional area.

7. The hull of claim 1, wherein the asymmetry is by angular variation between adjacent columns, wherein the angles formed by the column center points are not equivalent at the symmetric value.

8. An asymmetric hull for a floating platform, comprising: three columns; a frame connecting the three columns; and pontoons connecting the three columns, the pontoons disposed underneath the frame; wherein one or more of the columns, frame and pontoons are asymmetrical.

9. The hull of claim 8, wherein the three columns are asymmetric because one column of the three columns has an increased cross-sectional diameter or equivalent diameter.

10. The hull of claim 8, wherein the pontoons are asymmetrical.

11. The hull of claim 10, wherein pontoons are asymmetrical because a pontoon portion ofAttorney Docket No.: SD16498.1 / S180092 the pontoons has a greater length and / or cross-sectional area than other pontoon portions.

12. The hull of claim 8, further compising leg extensions connected to the column.

13. The hull of claim 8, wherein the leg extensions are asymmetrical in length and / or cross- sectional area.

14. The hull of claim 8, wherein the asymmetry is by angular variation between adjacent columns, wherein the angles formed by the column center points are not equivalent at the symmetric value.

15. An asymmetric hull for a floating platform, comprising: four columns; a frame connecting the four columns; and pontoons connecting the four columns, the pontoons disposed underneath the frame; wherein one or more of the columns, frame and pontoons are asymmetrical.

16. The hull of claim 15, wherein the columns are asymmetric because one column of the four columns has an increased cross-sectional diameter or equivalent diameter.

17. The hull of claim 15, wherein the pontoons are asymmetrical.

18. The hull of claim 17, wherein pontoons are asymmetrical because a pontoon portion of the pontoons has a greater length and / or cross-sectional area than other pontoon portions.

19. The hull of claim 15, wherein the four column, the frame and the pontoons are arranged in a diamond shape.

20. The hull of claim 15, further comprising leg extensions connected to the column.

21. The hull of claim 15, wherein the leg extensions are asymmetrical in length and / or cross- sectional area.

22. The hull of claim 15, wherein the asymmetry is by angular variation between adjacent columns, wherein the angles formed by the column center points are not equivalent at the symmetric value.