Observation point position estimation system, observation point position estimation method, and program
The observation point position estimation system enhances estimation accuracy by using Delaunay triangulation to strategically place observation points, ensuring maximum estimation points are within triangles with minimal area and uniform distribution.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- PCT/JP2025/016848
- Authority / Receiving Office
- WO · WO
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2025-05-08
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-12
AI Technical Summary
Conventional methods do not clearly indicate the optimal placement of observation points to improve estimation accuracy of radio communication quality when the number of observable points is limited.
An observation point position estimation system that uses Delaunay triangulation to select observation points such that as many estimation points as possible are enclosed within triangles, minimizing the total area of the triangles and equalizing the number of estimation points within each triangle.
Improves estimation accuracy by identifying effective observation point locations that minimize triangle area and uniformize the distance to nearest points, reducing measurement gaps and elongated triangles.
Smart Images

Figure JP2025016848_12112026_PF_FP_ABST
Abstract
Description
Observation Point Position Estimation System, Observation Point Position Estimation Method, and Program
[0001] The present invention relates to a technique for estimating the radio communication quality at estimation points by interpolation or the like from measurement data of the radio communication quality at observation points.
[0002] In recent years, with the advancement of mobile communications, there is a growing need to estimate the radio communication quality (e.g., received power, etc.) of the entire area with high accuracy and at low cost.
[0003] In general, the following two steps are taken for estimation: (1) A receiver is installed at a predetermined observation point, and radio communication quality such as received power is measured. (2) Using the obtained measurement data, the radio communication quality at unmeasured points (estimation points) is estimated by spatial interpolation (e.g., Kriging, etc.).
[0004] Mitsuya Sato, Takeo Fujii, Katsuya Sudo, "Visualization of Radio Wave Environment", IEICE Journal, Vol. 104, No. 12, 2021.
[0005] In the estimation of radio communication quality in the conventional art, it is unclear at which positions the observation points should be arranged to improve the estimation accuracy at the estimation points. Therefore, especially when the number of observation points that can be arranged is limited, it is impossible to determine how the observation points should be arranged.
[0006] The present invention has been made in view of the above points, and an object of the present invention is to provide a technique for identifying effective observation point positions that can improve estimation accuracy even when the number of observable points is limited, in the estimation of radio communication quality at estimation points using measurement data at observation points.
[0007] According to the disclosed technique, there is provided an observation point position estimation system comprising: an input unit for inputting position candidates for a plurality of observation points and positions of a plurality of estimation points; and a calculation unit that selects observation points from among the candidate positions of the plurality of observation points such that when Delaunay triangulation is performed using the selected observation points, as many of the plurality of estimation points as possible are enclosed within triangles, and the total area of the plurality of divided triangles is reduced.
[0008] According to the disclosed technology, when estimating wireless communication quality at an estimation point using measurement data at an observation point, it becomes possible to identify the location of an effective observation point that can improve estimation accuracy, even when the number of observable points is limited.
[0009] This is a diagram illustrating the problem. This is a diagram illustrating the configuration of the observation point location estimation system 100. This is a diagram illustrating the configuration of the observation point location estimation system 100. This is a flowchart illustrating the operation of the observation point location estimation system 100. This is a diagram illustrating an example of observation point location selection. This is a diagram illustrating an example of observation point location selection. This is a diagram illustrating an example of observation point location selection. This is a diagram illustrating an example of the system's hardware configuration.
[0010] Hereinafter, embodiments of the present invention (this embodiment) will be described with reference to the drawings. The embodiments described below are merely examples, and the embodiments to which the present invention is applied are not limited to the embodiments described below.
[0011] In this embodiment, the wireless communication quality to be estimated includes, for example, received power, SINR, throughput, etc. However, the wireless communication quality to be estimated is not limited to these, and other parameters may also be used for estimation.
[0012] The following will provide a more detailed explanation of the problem with reference to the diagrams, followed by a more detailed explanation of the technology related to this embodiment.
[0013] (Regarding the problem) In estimating wireless communication quality at a target point using measurement data from observation points, as mentioned above, conventional techniques do not clearly indicate where to place observation points to improve the estimation accuracy of the target point. Therefore, when the number of observation points that can be placed is limited due to survey costs or personnel constraints, it is impossible to determine how to place the observation points.
[0014] The upper part of Figure 1 shows an image illustrating how the wireless communication quality at a given point is estimated by interpolation using measurement data from an observation point. The lower part of Figure 1 illustrates a problem with conventional technology: it is unclear where to place observation points to accurately estimate the entire area.
[0015] The following describes techniques for identifying effective observation point locations that can improve estimation accuracy, even when the number of observable points is limited, when estimating wireless communication quality at estimation points using measurement data from observation points.
[0016] (Regarding Delaunay triangulation (Delaunay diagram) and Voronoi tessellation (Voronoi diagram)) In this embodiment, we will use Delaunay triangulation, so here we will explain the outline of Delaunay triangulation.
[0017] First, we will explain the outline of the Voronoi tessellation used in the explanation of the Delaunay triangulation. This explanation is based on the content disclosed at "https: / / club.informatix.co.jp / ?p=1298" (Glossary of terms at the Spatial Information Club).
[0018] Voronoi tessellation is a method for analyzing the sphere of influence of each point (generator). When the set of points that are closest to a given generator is represented by a single polygon, it is called a "Voronoi region," and the Voronoi regions calculated for all generators are called a "Voronoi diagram." In a two-dimensional Voronoi tessellation, the boundary lines of each Voronoi polygon are the perpendicular bisectors of the line segments connecting the generators.
[0019] Next, we will explain the outline of Delaunay triangulation. The explanation here is based on the content disclosed at "https: / / mogist.kkc.co.jp / word / d2730b77-3730-4ed3-8749-05c2dac71266.html" (Geographic Information Technology Museum, MoGIST Terminology / Index).
[0020] In the created Voronoi diagram, connecting the parent points that share an edge of the Voronoi domain boundary with a line segment (called a Delaunay edge) divides the given set of points into a convex hull (the smallest convex polygon that contains all points either inside or on its boundary) and a triangle (Delaunay triangle). This planar partitioning is called a Delaunay triangulation, and the Delaunay diagram is a diagram illustrating the result of this Delaunay triangulation.
[0021] (System Configuration Example, Operation Overview) Figure 2 shows an example configuration of the observation point location estimation system 100 in this embodiment. As shown in Figure 2, the observation point location estimation system 100 includes an observation point location estimation unit 110. The operation overview of the observation point location estimation unit 110 is as follows.
[0022] The observation point position estimation unit 110 receives input for multiple candidate observation point positions and the position of one or more estimated points. It is possible that one or more points have the same location as both a candidate observation point and an estimated point. Furthermore, all candidate observation point positions may be identical to the estimated point positions.
[0023] The observation point position estimation unit 110, when performing Delaunay triangulation using the selected observation point position as the parent point, selects an observation point position from among multiple candidate observation point positions so that the estimated points are contained within triangles as much as possible, the sum of the areas of the triangles is minimized, and the number of estimated points contained within each triangle is as equal as possible between triangles, and outputs the result.
[0024] By arranging the points as described above, the observation points can be positioned to spatially influence each estimation point, thereby improving estimation accuracy. Furthermore, this method makes it possible to identify observation points solely from the positional relationships of the points, without observing data at each location.
[0025] (Detailed System Configuration Example) Figure 3 shows a more detailed configuration example of the observation point location estimation system 100. As shown in Figure 3, the observation point location estimation system 100 includes an input unit 210, a calculation unit 220, an output unit 230, and a data storage unit 240. The observation point location estimation system 100 may also be called an observation point location estimation device 100. The observation point location estimation system 100 may be a system consisting of multiple computing devices (computers) or a system consisting of one computing device.
[0026] In the observation point location estimation system 100, data (e.g., candidate observation point locations and estimated point locations) is input from the input unit 210, and the calculation unit 220 performs a calculation to select an observation point location from among multiple candidate observation point locations. The output unit 130 outputs the calculation result obtained by the calculation unit 120.
[0027] The data storage unit 240 stores the data input by the input unit 210. The calculation unit 120 reads the data from the data storage unit 240 and performs calculations. Alternatively, the calculation results may be stored in the data storage unit 240 by the calculation unit 220.
[0028] (Example) Below, we will describe a more specific example of the operation of the observation point position estimation system 100 shown in Figure 3. The operation example will be explained according to the procedure in the flowchart in Figure 4.
[0029] <S1 (Step 1): Input> In S1, the input unit 210 inputs candidate positions for multiple observation points and positions for multiple estimated points. An example of candidate positions for multiple observation points and positions for multiple estimated points is shown in Figure 5. In Figure 5, ○ indicates an estimated point, and × indicates a candidate position for an observation point. In the example in Figure 5, some of the candidate positions for multiple observation points overlap with some of the positions for multiple estimated points.
[0030] <S2: Selecting points and performing Delaunay triangulation> In S2, the calculation unit 220 performs Delaunay triangulation using multiple observation points selected from candidate observation point positions. More specifically, the calculation unit 220 creates Delaunay triangles by selecting observation points such that all estimated points are contained within the created Delaunay triangles (one or more triangles). At this time, the calculation unit 220 selects observation points such that the total area of the triangles is minimized (the area of the entire Delaunay diagram is minimized). Each of the multiple observation points selected from candidate observation point positions corresponds to a generator point in the Voronoi diagram described above.
[0031] Furthermore, when selecting observation points, instead of selecting them so that all estimated points are contained within a triangle, it is also acceptable to select them so that at least a predetermined threshold (e.g., 95%) of the total candidate locations are contained within a triangle. Additionally, if the number of candidate locations for observation points is small and it is not possible to contain all estimated points, it is acceptable to select them in a way that contains as many estimated points as possible.
[0032] <S3: Additional selection of observation points> In S3, the calculation unit 220 selects additional observation points such that the number of estimated points contained within each triangle is as equal as possible between triangles. Note that the number of observation points added in S3 is one. However, the number of observation points added in S3 is not limited to one, and multiple points may be added.
[0033] As an example, the calculation unit 220 counts the number of estimated points contained within each Delaunay triangle obtained in S2, and when the Delaunay triangulation is performed again after adding observation points, it adds observation points that divide the triangle containing the most estimated points.
[0034] <Repetitive Processing> The calculation unit 220 repeatedly executes S2 and S3 until the number of observation points selected from the candidate positions reaches the predetermined number of observation points.
[0035] In the processing of S2 after the additional selection in S3, the calculation unit 220 performs the Delaunay triangulation again using the observation points used in the previous S2 and the observation points added in S3.
[0036] In the processing of S2 here, the calculation unit 220 checks whether the conditions are met that "all estimated points are contained within the Delaunay triangle (or that more than a predetermined threshold (e.g., 95%) of the points are contained within the triangle)" and "the total area of the triangle is the smallest." If these conditions are not met, the unit may adjust the positions of the selected observation points to satisfy these conditions.
[0037] <S4: Output> After the number of observation points selected from the candidate positions reaches the predetermined number of observation points, the output unit 230 outputs the positions of the selected observation points.
[0038] In the example shown in Figure 5, the selection results when 10 observation point locations are derived are shown in Figure 6. Figures 7 and 8 show examples where all candidate observation point locations are the same as the estimated points.
[0039] In the example shown in Figures 5 and 6, for example, the minimum number of observation points that satisfy the conditions in S2 (e.g., 4 observation points) is selected, and then, in order to mitigate the variability in the estimated number of points, the number of observation points is increased sequentially until there are 10 observation points, at which point the process is terminated.
[0040] (Example Hardware Configuration) The observation point position estimation system 100 described in this embodiment can be realized, for example, by having a computer run a program. This computer may be a physical computer or a virtual machine on the cloud.
[0041] In other words, the observation point position estimation system 100 can be realized by using hardware resources such as the CPU and memory built into the computer to execute a program corresponding to the processing performed by the observation point position estimation system 100. The above program can be recorded on a computer-readable recording medium (such as portable memory), saved, and distributed. It is also possible to provide the above program via a network such as the Internet or email.
[0042] FIG. 9 is a diagram illustrating an example of the hardware configuration of the above computer. The computer in FIG. 9 includes a drive device 1000, an auxiliary storage device 1002, a memory device 1003, a CPU 1004, an interface device 1005, a display device 1006, an input device 1007, an output device 1008, and the like, which are mutually connected via a bus B. Note that the computer may further include a GPU.
[0043] A program for realizing processing on the computer is provided by, for example, a recording medium 1001 such as a CD-ROM or a memory card. When the recording medium 1001 storing the program is set in the drive device 1000, the program is installed from the recording medium 1001 to the auxiliary storage device 1002 via the drive device 1000. However, the installation of the program does not necessarily need to be performed from the recording medium 1001, and may be downloaded from another computer via a network. The auxiliary storage device 1002 stores the installed program, as well as necessary files, data, and the like.
[0044] The memory device 1003 reads the program from the auxiliary storage device 1002 and stores the program when there is an instruction to start the program. The CPU 1004 implements the functions related to the observation point position estimation system 100 in accordance with the program stored in the memory device 1003. The interface device 1005 is used as an interface for connecting to a network or the like. The display device 1006 displays a GUI (Graphical User Interface) or the like by the program. The input device 1007 is configured with a keyboard, a mouse, buttons, a touch panel, or the like, and is used for inputting various operation instructions. The output device 1008 outputs calculation results.
[0045] Furthermore, the functions of the elements disclosed herein may be implemented using circuits or processing circuitry that include general-purpose processors, special-purpose processors, integrated circuits, ASICs (Application Specific Integrated Circuits), FPGAs (Field Programmable Gate Arrays), conventional circuits, and / or combinations thereof that are programmed using one or more programs stored in one or more memories, or otherwise configured to perform the disclosed functions. A processor is considered processing circuitry or circuitry because it includes transistors and other circuits. A processor may be a programmed processor that executes programs stored in memory. In this disclosure, circuits, units, or means are hardware that performs the enumerated functions, or hardware programmed to perform the enumerated functions. Hardware may be any hardware disclosed herein that is programmed or configured to perform the enumerated functions.
[0046] The system includes memory for storing computer programs, which include computer instructions. These computer instructions provide logic and routines that enable hardware (e.g., processing circuitry or circuitry) to perform the methods disclosed herein. The computer programs can be implemented in commonly known forms, such as computer-readable storage media, computer program products, memory devices, recording media such as CD-ROMs and DVDs, and / or memory in FPGAs and ASICs.
[0047] (Effects of the technology according to the embodiment) As described above, the technology described in the present embodiment makes it possible to identify the positions of observation points (effective observation point positions) that improve estimation accuracy in the estimation target area. At that time, it is possible to identify the observation points solely from the positional relationship of the points, without observing data at each position.
[0048] More specifically, the technology according to the present embodiment minimizes the total area of triangles, so the triangle to which each estimation point belongs becomes smaller, and the distance to the nearest observation point can be uniformly kept short. In addition, since the estimation points are included inside the triangles and the variation in the number of estimation points is equalized, measurement blank areas can be reduced. Furthermore, since Delaunay triangulation is used, elongated triangles are less likely to be generated. Through these features, estimation accuracy can be improved.
[0049] Regarding the above embodiments, the following additional notes are further disclosed.
[0050] <Notes> (Note 1) An observation point location estimation system comprising: an input unit that inputs multiple candidate observation point locations and multiple estimated point locations; and a calculation unit that selects observation points from among the multiple candidate observation point locations such that, when Delaunay triangulation is performed using the selected observation points, as many of the multiple estimated points as possible are contained within the triangles, and the sum of the areas of the divided triangles is small. (Note 2) The observation point location estimation system according to Note 1, wherein the calculation unit selects observation points such that the number of estimated points contained within each triangle is as equal as possible between the triangles. (Note 3) The observation point location estimation system according to Note 1, wherein the calculation unit selects observation points such that a number of estimated points greater than or equal to a predetermined threshold are contained within the triangles. (Appendix 4) An observation point location estimation method to be performed by an observation point location estimation system, comprising: an input step of inputting a plurality of candidate observation point locations and a plurality of estimated point locations; and a calculation step of selecting an observation point from among the plurality of candidate observation point locations such that, when Delaunay triangulation is performed using the selected observation point, as many of the plurality of estimated points as possible are contained within the triangles and the sum of the areas of the divided plurality of triangles is small. (Appendix 5) A non-temporary storage medium storing a program for causing a computer to function as a component in the observation point location estimation system described in any one of Appendix 1 to 3.
[0051] Although this embodiment has been described above, the present invention is not limited to this specific embodiment, and various modifications and changes are possible within the scope of the gist of the invention as described in the claims.
[0052] 100 Observation point position estimation system 110 Observation point position estimation unit 210 Input unit 220 Calculation unit 230 Output unit 240 Data storage unit 1000 Drive device 1001 Recording medium 1002 Auxiliary storage device 1003 Memory device 1004 CPU 1005 Interface device 1006 Display device 1007 Input device 1008 Output device
Claims
1. An observation point location estimation system comprising: an input unit that takes input of multiple candidate observation point locations and multiple estimated point locations; and a calculation unit that selects observation points from among the multiple candidate observation point locations such that, when Delaunay triangulation is performed using the selected observation points, as many of the multiple estimated points as possible are contained within the triangles, and the sum of the areas of the divided triangles is small.
2. The observation point position estimation system according to claim 1, wherein the calculation unit selects observation points such that the number of estimated points contained within each triangle is as equal as possible among the triangles.
3. The observation point position estimation system according to claim 1, wherein the calculation unit selects observation points such that a number of estimated points equal to or greater than a predetermined threshold are contained within a triangle.
4. An observation point location estimation method to be performed by an observation point location estimation system, comprising: an input step of inputting a plurality of candidate observation point locations and a plurality of estimated point locations; and a calculation step of selecting an observation point from among the plurality of candidate observation point locations such that, when Delaunay triangulation is performed using the selected observation point, as many of the plurality of estimated points as possible are contained within the triangles and the sum of the areas of the divided plurality of triangles is small.
5. A program for causing a computer to function as a component in the observation point position estimation system described in any one of claims 1 to 3.
