Security monitoring device, security monitoring system, security monitoring method, and program
The security monitoring device addresses the inefficiency of extensive whitelist setups by using reference transition information for basic operations to detect unauthorized access, enhancing detection accuracy and reducing setup workload.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- PCT/JP2025/017013
- Authority / Receiving Office
- WO · WO
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2025-05-09
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-12
AI Technical Summary
Existing security monitoring systems require significant workload to set up whitelists for multiple system states, making them inefficient in protecting against unauthorized access.
A security monitoring device that sets reference transition information for normal state transitions based on basic operations, determining abnormal state transitions by comparing actual transitions with predefined reference information, reducing the need for extensive whitelist configurations.
Reduces the workload involved in securing systems by accurately detecting unauthorized access through efficient reference transition information management.
Smart Images

Figure JP2025017013_12112026_PF_FP_ABST
Abstract
Description
Security monitoring device, security monitoring system, security monitoring method, and program
[0001] The present disclosure relates to a security monitoring device, a security monitoring system, a security monitoring method, and a program for monitoring system security.
[0002] In systems such as Factory Automation (FA) systems, unauthorized access is detected to protect the systems from unauthorized access by malicious third parties.
[0003] Patent Document 1 discloses an attack detection device that detects unauthorized access by focusing on the system state, which is the control state of a control system. The attack detection device according to Patent Document 1 stores a whitelist that defines permitted system information for each of a plurality of system states. The system information includes communication data communicated between server devices and equipment within the control system. The system information also includes a definition of permitted system states as system states prior to transition to the system state associated with the whitelist. The attack detection device according to Patent Document 1 estimates the system state based on acquired communication data, and switches the whitelist based on the estimated system state to detect unauthorized access. The attack detection device according to Patent Document 1 detects unauthorized access by switching the whitelist according to the system state, thereby improving the accuracy of unauthorized access detection.
[0004] International Publication No. 2018 / 134939
[0005] The attack detection device described in Patent Document 1 has a whitelist set for each of the multiple system states that the control system can take. In order for a user of the attack detection device described in Patent Document 1 to set a whitelist for each of the multiple system states, the user needs to register system information for all system states that the control system can take with the attack detection device. For this reason, the technology disclosed in Patent Document 1 has the problem that the workload involved in setting up the system to protect it from unauthorized access is heavy.
[0006] This disclosure is made in view of the above and aims to provide a security monitoring device that can reduce the workload of the work performed in setting up a system to protect it from unauthorized access.
[0007] To solve the above-mentioned problems and achieve the objectives, the security monitoring device according to this disclosure includes a setting unit that sets reference transition information indicating a normal state transition of the system due to a basic operation for each of a plurality of basic operations, which are predetermined operations performed on the system or by a user on the system in the operation of the system, including operations on the system by the user; and a state transition determination unit that determines whether or not a state transition of the system is an abnormal state transition by comparing the state before the transition and the state after the transition with the reference transition information when the state of the system transitions.
[0008] The security monitoring device described in this disclosure has the effect of reducing the workload involved in configuring the system to protect it from unauthorized access.
[0009] Figure showing an example configuration of the security monitoring system according to Embodiment 1. Figure showing an example configuration of the security monitoring device included in the security monitoring system according to Embodiment 1. Figure for explaining the reference transition information set by the reference transition setting unit of the security monitoring device according to Embodiment 1. Flowchart showing an example of the operation procedure of the security monitoring device according to Embodiment 1. Figure showing an example of the hardware configuration of the security monitoring device according to Embodiment 1. Figure showing a modified example of the security monitoring device according to Embodiment 1.
[0010] The following describes in detail, with reference to the drawings, the security monitoring device, security monitoring system, security monitoring method, and program according to the embodiment.
[0011] Embodiment 1. Figure 1 is a diagram showing an example configuration of the security monitoring system 1 according to Embodiment 1. In Embodiment 1, the system to be monitored for security is a system in which predetermined basic operations are performed by the system or the system user during system operation. The security monitoring system 1 according to Embodiment 1 detects unauthorized access by detecting state transitions that deviate from the system state transitions due to basic operations. Here, a system state transition refers to a change in the system state due to a condition or event. The system state refers to a state in which the system can perform predetermined functions, such as the system behavior determined by conditions such as parameter values. In other words, a system state transition due to basic operations refers to a transition in the system state according to a pre-set basic operation.
[0012] One example of a system in which basic operations are performed is a factory automation (FA) system. In Embodiment 1, the system that is the target of security monitoring is assumed to be an FA system.
[0013] The security monitoring system 1 comprises a production management system 2, a security monitoring device 3 that monitors the security of the FA system, and a plurality of control devices 4. The production management system 2 is an information technology (IT) system that manages the production of products by the FA system. The production management system 2 performs production management according to the production plan, which is the operational plan of the FA system. The production management system 2, the security monitoring device 3, and the plurality of control devices 4 are connected to each other so as to be able to communicate with one another.
[0014] Each control device 4 is connected to equipment that constitutes production facilities. Each control device 4 controls the equipment connected to it. Examples of control devices 4 include PLCs (Programmable Logic Controllers) and programmable displays. The number of equipment connected to each control device 4 is arbitrary. The production management system 2, the security monitoring device 3, the multiple control devices 4, and the equipment connected to each control device 4 are all included in the FA system.
[0015] Figure 1 shows two of the multiple control devices 4 that the security monitoring system 1 has. The number of control devices 4 provided in the security monitoring system 1 is arbitrary. The security monitoring system 1 only needs to have one or more control devices 4. The security monitoring system 1 may also be equipped with IT systems other than the production management system 2. The security monitoring system 1 may also be equipped with, for example, a data platform.
[0016] Next, an overview of the configuration of the security monitoring device 3 will be described. Figure 2 is a diagram showing an example of the configuration of the security monitoring device 3 included in the security monitoring system 1 according to Embodiment 1. The security monitoring device 3 comprises a document input unit 11 which is a first input unit, a production plan input unit 12 which is a second input unit, a basic operation analysis unit 13, a reference transition setting unit 14, a reference transition storage unit 15, a transition information acquisition unit 16, a state transition determination unit 17, an unauthorized access detection unit 18, and a notification unit 19.
[0017] Documents containing information about the use of the FA system are entered into the document input unit 11. For example, the documents entered into the document input unit 11 may be the FA system's operation manual. The operation manual includes instructions on how to operate each piece of equipment installed on the production line. It also contains information that FA system users must adhere to on the production line. FA system users include, for example, workers on the production line and maintenance personnel who perform maintenance on the production line. Note that the documents entered into the document input unit 11 are not limited to operation manuals; any document containing information about the use of the FA system is acceptable.
[0018] For example, an operation manual read from a device storing the operation manual is input to the document input unit 11. Alternatively, an operation manual read from a storage medium readable by the computer system may be input to the document input unit 11. Information regarding the use of the FA system may also be entered into the document input unit 11 by the user. In this case, the information is entered into the document input unit 11 through an input interface provided in the security monitoring device 3. The input interface is, for example, a GUI (Graphical User Interface). The information entered into the document input unit 11 is not limited to summarized information regarding the use of the FA system, but may also be fragmentary information regarding the use of the FA system. In the following, it will be assumed that an operation manual is entered into the document input unit 11.
[0019] The production plan input unit 12 receives the production plan of the FA system. The production plan includes information about periods when the control device 4 will be shut down, such as the period for maintenance that will be performed by stopping the production line. For example, the production management system 2 stores the production plan created by the management department of the FA system. The production plan read from the production management system 2 is entered into the production plan input unit 12.
[0020] The basic operation analysis unit 13 acquires the operation manual entered into the document input unit 11 and the production plan entered into the production plan input unit 12. The basic operation analysis unit 13 extracts basic operations from the document and production plan by analyzing the acquired operation manual and production plan. In Embodiment 1, basic operations are defined operations performed by each control device 4 of the FA system or by the user on the FA system during the operation of the FA system. For example, operations performed by each control device 4 according to pre-programmed content are basic operations. Also, for example, operations performed by the user to operate each control device 4 according to the procedure defined in the operation manual are basic operations.
[0021] The basic motion analysis unit 13 extracts multiple basic operations based on the operation manual and production plan. At least one of the multiple basic operations extracted by the basic motion analysis unit 13 is the operation of the FA system by the user in accordance with the operation manual. The user operates the FA system by, for example, operating the control device 4. The multiple basic operations include at least one basic operation that refers to the user operating the FA system. The basic motion analysis unit 13 outputs information indicating each of the multiple basic operations to the reference transition setting unit 14.
[0022] The reference transition setting unit 14 sets reference transition information for each of the multiple basic operations, indicating the normal state transition of the FA system due to the basic operation. Details of the reference transition information will be described later. The reference transition information set by the reference transition setting unit 14 is stored in the reference transition storage unit 15.
[0023] The reference transition setting unit 14 may also set the reference transition information by manually inputting the content of the normal state transitions of the FA system based on basic operations. In this case, the reference transition information is input to the reference transition setting unit 14 by the user through an input interface provided in the security monitoring device 3, such as a GUI. The security monitoring device 3 can set the reference transition information including the content to be included in the reference transition information by having the content to be included directly input by the user.
[0024] The transition information acquisition unit 16 acquires transition information indicating the state before and after a transition when the state of the FA system changes. The transition information acquisition unit 16 acquires transition information from, for example, at least one of the multiple control devices 4. The transition information acquisition unit 16 outputs the acquired transition information to the state transition determination unit 17.
[0025] The state transition determination unit 17 reads reference transition information from the reference transition storage unit 15. The state transition determination unit 17 compares the state before and after the transition shown in the transition information obtained from the transition information acquisition unit 16 with the reference transition information to determine whether the state transition of the FA system corresponds to an abnormal state transition. The state transition determination unit 17 outputs the result of the determination to the unauthorized access detection unit 18.
[0026] The unauthorized access detection unit 18 detects unauthorized access by determining whether a state transition determined to be abnormal by the state transition determination unit 17 corresponds to a state transition caused by unauthorized access. The notification unit 19 notifies the user of the information by displaying it.
[0027] The unauthorized access detection unit 18 includes an abnormality determination unit 21, an unauthorized determination unit 22, a level change unit 23, a network determination unit 24, and a simulation unit 25.
[0028] The abnormality determination unit 21 determines whether the access that caused the state transition determined to be abnormal by the state transition determination unit 17 is an abnormal access. For example, the abnormality determination unit 21 determines that an access is an abnormal access when an abnormality is detected in the data definition of a packet received by the control device 4. The method by which the abnormality determination unit 21 determines whether an access is abnormal is arbitrary.
[0029] The network determination unit 24 determines the type of network used for the access that is the target of the abnormality determination unit 21's determination. The network determination unit 24 outputs the determination result to the level change unit 23. The level change unit 23 changes the detection level of abnormal access in the abnormality determination unit 21 based on the type determined by the network determination unit 24. Network security levels differ depending on the network type. By changing the detection level in the level change unit 23, the abnormality determination unit 21 can detect abnormal access at a detection level appropriate to the network security level.
[0030] If the abnormality detection unit 21 determines that the access causing the state transition that was determined to be abnormal is not an abnormal access, it outputs the result of the determination to the notification unit 19. The notification unit 19 notifies the user that there was an abnormal state transition due to a factor other than an abnormal access.
[0031] If the abnormality determination unit 21 determines that the access causing the state transition determined to be abnormal is an abnormal access, it outputs the result of the determination to the fraudulent access determination unit 22. The fraudulent access determination unit 22 determines whether or not the access determined to be abnormal is a fraudulent access.
[0032] The abnormality detection unit 21 determines whether or not a parameter has been changed due to abnormal access. The parameter is defined in the control program executed by each control device 4 when controlling the equipment. If the abnormality detection unit 21 determines that a parameter has been changed, it instructs the simulation unit 25 to execute the simulation. Note that parameter changes due to abnormal access are treated as unconfirmed changes in the FA system.
[0033] The simulation unit 25 simulates the result of executing a control program that includes the modified parameters when the parameters are changed due to an access that has been determined to be abnormal. The simulation unit 25 outputs the simulation results to the fraud detection unit 22.
[0034] The fraud detection unit 22 determines, based on the simulation results from the simulation unit 25, whether the access determined to be abnormal by the abnormality detection unit 21 constitutes unauthorized access. If the fraud detection unit 22 determines that the access determined to be abnormal does not constitute unauthorized access, it considers the access determined to be abnormal not to be an attack and confirms the parameter change. In the control device 4, which executes the control program containing the parameter, the changed parameter is set in the control program.
[0035] If the fraud detection unit 22 determines that an access deemed abnormal is a fraudulent access, it outputs information indicating that a fraudulent access has been detected to the notification unit 19. The notification unit 19 notifies the user that a fraudulent access has been detected. Through this notification, the notification unit 19 prompts the user to take action against the fraudulent access.
[0036] Next, we will explain the details of the reference transition information. Figure 3 is a diagram illustrating the reference transition information set by the reference transition setting unit 14 of the security monitoring device 3 according to Embodiment 1.
[0037] FA systems have the characteristic of operating based on pre-configured processes. In an FA system, basic operations determined in the pre-configured processes are performed by the system or the system user. Pre-configured processes include, for example, a series of processes such as starting up the production line (i.e., powering on), setting up equipment before the production line starts operation, starting the production line, adjusting equipment settings during production line operation, and ending production line operation. Responses to malfunctions during operation are also included in the pre-configured processes. The security monitoring device 3 registers reference transition information representing the state transitions of the FA system due to basic operations performed within the pre-configured processes, and determines that unauthorized access is suspected when a state transition not included in the reference transition information occurs.
[0038] Figure 3 schematically illustrates an example of state transitions in a pre-configured part of a process. States A, B, C, and D shown in Figure 3 represent the states that the FA system can take within that part of the process. The arrows in Figure 3 represent state transitions due to basic operations. For example, the arrow between state A and state B indicates a transition from state A to state B due to a certain basic operation.
[0039] In the example shown in Figure 3, the reference transition setting unit 14 sets reference transition information representing the transition from state A to state B, reference transition information representing the transition from state B to state C, reference transition information representing the transition from state A to state D, and reference transition information representing the transition from state D to state C. The reference transition information consists only of information indicating the state before the transition and information indicating the state after the transition when the basic operation is performed. That is, the reference transition information representing the transition from state A to state B consists only of information indicating state A, which is the state before the transition, and information indicating state B, which is the state after the transition. According to the reference transition information exemplified here, for example, the transition from state B to state D is a state transition that is not included in the reference transition information set by the reference transition setting unit 14. For this reason, the security monitoring device 3 can determine that the transition from state B to state D is suspected to be due to unauthorized access.
[0040] In the security monitoring device 3, the reference transition information stored in the reference transition storage unit 15 corresponds to a whitelist. In the security monitoring device 3, reference transition information is set for each of the basic operations extracted by the basic operation analysis unit 13. That is, as reference transition information for each basic operation, only information indicating the state before the transition and information indicating the state after the transition for each basic operation is stored in the reference transition storage unit 15.
[0041] Here, let's assume that for all possible system states that the FA system can take, system information such as permitted communication data and definitions of permitted system states before transitions are registered as a whitelist. In this case, it would be necessary to set up a lot of information as system information for each whitelist. Furthermore, it would be necessary to set up the same number of whitelists as there are possible system states that the FA system can take up. In the case of Embodiment 1, it is possible to reduce the amount of work required for setting up system information compared to setting up system information for all system states.
[0042] In the above, the basic operations performed by the FA system include functional basic operations, which are basic operations based on the functions of the FA system, and operational basic operations, which are basic operations based on the operation of the system, including the work of the worker. The basic operation analysis unit 13 may extract only the operational basic operations from the functional basic operations and the operational basic operations. In other words, the reference transition setting unit 14 may set reference transition information for operational basic operations only. Functional basic operations refer to the operation of the FA system according to the control program. Operational basic operations are the basic operations that a worker or the FA system would perform in a predetermined process. For example, the work that a worker normally performs on a production line is an operational basic operation.
[0043] Basic operational procedures also include refraining from performing certain tasks while the FA system is in a particular state. For example, refraining from rewriting the control program executed by control device 4 while it is operating is included in basic operational procedures.
[0044] The security monitoring device 3 detects state transitions suspected of being unauthorized access based on standard transition information set focusing on basic operational operations. This enables the security monitoring device 3 to detect unauthorized access based on the characteristics of the FA system, which operates based on pre-configured processes. Compared to setting standard transition information for all basic operational and basic functional operations, the security monitoring device 3 can reduce the amount of work required for configuration.
[0045] The reference transition setting unit 14 sets reference transition information indicating a state transition for each of two or more consecutively performed basic operation actions. The reference transition setting unit 14 can set reference transition information for a series of basic operation actions in a preset process. The security monitoring device 3 can detect all state transitions suspected of unauthorized access for the preset process without omission. As a result, the security monitoring device 3 can detect unauthorized access with high accuracy even when reference transition information for basic function actions is not set.
[0046] Note that in the above description, the reference transition setting unit 14 is configured to set reference transition information only for the basic operation actions. The reference transition setting unit 14 may be configured to set both reference transition information for the basic operation actions and reference transition information for the basic function actions.
[0047] Next, extraction of basic operation actions in the basic action analysis unit 13 will be described. The operation manual describes procedures that a user should follow in a preset process. The basic action analysis unit 13 extracts the procedures described in the operation manual as the basic operation actions. The basic action analysis unit 13 extracts the basic operation actions by replacing the content described as the procedures with content indicating what kind of operation the user performs on the FA system, that is, what kind of command the user inputs. As a result, the security monitoring device 3 can grasp the basic operation actions performed by the user.
[0048] The operation manual may describe matters that the user should pay attention to according to the situation. The matters that the user should pay attention to according to the situation are, for example, matters concerning responses that the user should take when a specific symptom appears in a certain device. The basic action analysis unit 13 extracts such matters as basic operation actions accompanied by conditional branching.
[0049] The operation manual describes the procedures for a pre-configured process as a series of steps. If information that is not described as a series of steps is entered into the document input unit 11, the basic operation analysis unit 13 may combine and analyze the multiple pieces of information entered into the document input unit 11. The combination of multiple pieces of information is performed either by user operation or by the basic operation analysis unit 13 analyzing the relationships between each piece of information. In this way, the basic operation analysis unit 13 can analyze the entered information in the same way as when information that is described as a series of steps is entered.
[0050] The control device 4 operates according to the production plan. The production plan input to the production plan input unit 12 can be said to correspond to the basic operation. The basic operation analysis unit 13 extracts the production line downtime indicated in the production plan as the basic operation. The production line downtime includes the period during which maintenance is performed on the production line, and the period during which the production line is on standby before operation. For example, these periods are described as comments in the production plan. The basic operation analysis unit 13 determines the production line downtime based on these comments. Alternatively, the basic operation analysis unit 13 may extract the entire production plan as the basic operation.
[0051] The reference transition setting unit 14 derives the state before and after the transition for the state transition that occurs when the extracted basic operation is performed, based on the basic operation operation. Based on this, the reference transition setting unit 14 sets the reference transition information for the extracted basic operation operation.
[0052] Next, the operation of the security monitoring device 3 will be described. Figure 4 is a flowchart showing an example of the operation procedure of the security monitoring device 3 according to Embodiment 1.
[0053] In step S1, the security monitoring device 3 acquires the operation manual and the production plan. The security monitoring device 3 acquires the operation manual when it is entered into the document input unit 11. The security monitoring device 3 acquires the production plan when it is entered into the production plan input unit 12.
[0054] In step S2, the basic motion analysis unit 13 extracts multiple basic motions by analyzing the operation manual and production plan. The basic motion analysis unit 13 selects candidate basic motions from the basic rules specified in the operation manual for the production line. The basic motion analysis unit 13 presents the selected candidates to the user and asks the user for approval to register the presented candidates as basic motions. The basic motion analysis unit 13 determines the approved candidates as basic motions. In this way, the basic motion analysis unit 13 extracts basic motions.
[0055] The basic operations extracted by the basic operation analysis unit 13 include basic operations that refer to a user operating the FA system. The extracted basic operations include basic operations concerning the procedures performed when the FA system is operating normally. The extracted basic operations may also include basic operations concerning the procedures performed when a malfunction occurs in the FA system.
[0056] In step S3, the reference transition setting unit 14 sets reference transition information for each of the multiple basic operations extracted in step S2. The reference transition setting unit 14 understands the state of the FA system before the basic operation is performed and the state of the FA system after the basic operation is performed from the basic operation. The reference transition setting unit 14 generates reference transition information, which is a combination of information indicating the state before the transition and information indicating the state after the transition. In this way, the reference transition setting unit 14 sets the reference transition information for each basic operation.
[0057] In step S4, the reference transition setting unit 14 stores the reference transition information set in step S3 in the reference transition storage unit 15. The reference transition information indicates the state transition resulting from the execution of a basic operation, and can be said to represent the basic operation. Storing the reference transition information in the reference transition storage unit 15 is equivalent to registering the basic operation.
[0058] In step S5, the state transition determination unit 17 determines whether the state transition of the FA system corresponds to an abnormal state transition. The transition information acquisition unit 16 acquires transition information from the control device 4 that shows the state before the transition and the state after the transition when the state of the FA system transitions. The state transition determination unit 17 acquires transition information from the transition information acquisition unit 16. The state transition determination unit 17 reads the reference transition information from the reference transition storage unit 15.
[0059] The state transition determination unit 17 determines that a state transition of the FA system is not an abnormal state transition if the state before the transition shown in the transition information is the same as the state before the transition shown in the reference transition information, and the state after the transition shown in the transition information is the same as the state after the transition shown in the reference transition information. On the other hand, the state transition determination unit 17 determines that a state transition of the FA system is an abnormal state transition if the state before the transition shown in the transition information is different from the state before the transition shown in the reference transition information, or if the state after the transition shown in the transition information is different from the state after the transition shown in the reference transition information.
[0060] If the security monitoring device 3 determines that the state transition of the FA system is not an abnormal state transition (step S5, No), it terminates its operation according to the procedure shown in Figure 4. If the security monitoring device 3 determines that the state transition of the FA system is an abnormal state transition (step S5, Yes), it proceeds to step S6.
[0061] For example, if a basic operation that should not occur in a given state is performed while an FA system is in a certain state, a state transition not included in the standard transition information may occur. The security monitoring device 3 determines that such a state transition is an abnormal state transition that may be caused by unauthorized access.
[0062] For example, suppose the operation to switch the FA system's mode between operation mode and maintenance mode is performed by the programmable display unit, which is the control device 4. The control program is never rewritten in any mode other than maintenance mode. If the programmable display unit has not switched from operation mode to maintenance mode, but the programmable display unit is instructed to rewrite the control program, the security monitoring device 3 will determine that the state transition resulting from that instruction is an abnormal state transition that may be due to unauthorized access. Similarly, if the PLC, which is the control device 4, is in operation mode and the PLC is instructed to rewrite the control program, the security monitoring device 3 will also determine that the state transition resulting from that instruction is an abnormal state transition that may be due to unauthorized access.
[0063] For example, suppose a programmable display or PLC is instructed to rewrite the control program during a period in the production plan when maintenance is scheduled and when it is not. In this case, the security monitoring device 3 determines that the state transition caused by this instruction is an abnormal state transition that may be due to unauthorized access.
[0064] For example, if the control program is rewritten, a discrepancy may occur between the production plan and actual production. If a discrepancy occurs between the production plan and actual production, the security monitoring device 3 determines that the discrepancy is an abnormal state transition suspected to be due to unauthorized access and rewriting of the control program.
[0065] For example, the security monitoring device 3 may acquire work history records from the data platform, which include information on the status of work performed by workers. If the status of work shown in the work history deviates from a standard work status format, the security monitoring device 3 determines that the deviation is an abnormal state transition that may be caused by unauthorized access. The standard work status format is created, for example, based on the work history recorded on the data platform.
[0066] Workers may possess know-how regarding the timing and conditions for operating equipment in order to achieve efficient production. Such know-how can be considered unique information for the FA system in which the worker operates. The security monitoring device 3 may set standard transition information based on such know-how as the basic operation. For example, if the timing of an operation deviates from the timing of the basic operation, the security monitoring device 3 may determine that this is an abnormal state transition that may be due to unauthorized access.
[0067] As a result, the security monitoring device 3 can detect state transitions suspected of being due to unauthorized access with high accuracy. The security monitoring device 3 can then confirm whether or not an abnormal state transition is due to unauthorized access by following the procedures from step S6 onward.
[0068] In step S6, the abnormality determination unit 21 determines whether the access that caused the state transition, which was determined to be abnormal in step S5, is an abnormal access. The abnormality determination unit 21 can use general methods applied to detecting abnormal access for its determination. The network determination unit 24 determines the type of network used for the access. The level change unit 23 changes the abnormal access detection level in the abnormality determination unit 21 based on the type determined by the network determination unit 24.
[0069] If the abnormality determination unit 21 determines that the access causing the state transition does not constitute an abnormal access (step S6, No), in step S10, the notification unit 19 notifies the user that there was an abnormal state transition due to a factor other than an abnormal access. This allows the user to know that the abnormal state transition was caused by a factor other than an abnormal access. The user can easily understand that the abnormal state transition was not due to unauthorized access. The security monitoring device 3 completes the operation according to the procedure shown in Figure 4 after completing step S10.
[0070] If the abnormality determination unit 21 determines that the access causing the state transition is an abnormal access (step S6, Yes), in step S7, the simulation unit 25 executes a simulation. The simulation unit 25 simulates the result when a control program including the changed parameters is executed, assuming that the parameters have been changed by the access determined to be abnormal. For example, the simulation unit 25 simulates a production process. The simulation unit 25 outputs the simulation results to the fraud determination unit 22.
[0071] In step S8, the fraud detection unit 22 determines whether the access determined to be abnormal in step S6 constitutes unauthorized access. The fraud detection unit 22 checks whether there are any defects in the simulation results from the simulation unit 25. If there are defects in the simulation results, the fraud detection unit 22 determines that the access determined to be abnormal constitutes unauthorized access. If there are no defects in the simulation results, the fraud detection unit 22 determines that the access determined to be abnormal does not constitute unauthorized access.
[0072] If the unauthorized access detection unit 22 determines that the access detected as abnormal is an unauthorized access (step S8, Yes), in step S9, the notification unit 19 notifies the user that an unauthorized access has been detected. This allows the user to know that an unauthorized access has occurred. Upon completing step S9, the security monitoring device 3 terminates its operation according to the procedure shown in Figure 4.
[0073] If the fraud detection unit 22 determines that the access identified as abnormal does not constitute unauthorized access (step S8, No.), in step S11, the fraud detection unit 22 confirms the parameter change. The control device 4, which executes the control program containing the parameter, sets the changed parameter in the control program. The security monitoring device 3 completes the operation according to the procedure shown in Figure 4 after completing step S11.
[0074] The reference transition setting unit 14 may also update the set reference transition information when the FA system is in standby mode. When the FA system is in standby mode, for example, each control device 4 is in standby mode. For example, if the operation manual is changed or the production line process is changed, the security monitoring device 3 acquires the updated information from the document input unit 11 and the production plan input unit 12. The reference transition setting unit 14 sets the reference transition information for the basic operation extracted based on the updated information. This allows the security monitoring device 3 to update the reference transition information without affecting the operation of the FA system.
[0075] In the above, the state transition determination unit 17 determines abnormalities in state transitions based on reference transition information obtained from information about a pre-set process, that is, information about the production line process. The state transition determination unit 17 may also determine abnormalities in state transitions based on reference transition information obtained from information other than information about the production line process. An example of information other than information about the production line process is information about workers. Information about workers includes, for example, information indicating worker attributes such as skill level, and information indicating worker behavior. In this case, the reference transition setting unit 14 sets reference transition information for basic operations based on information about workers. The security monitoring device 3 can detect abnormalities from a worker-focused perspective, such as whether or not the worker had malicious intent.
[0076] Next, the hardware configuration of the security monitoring device 3 will be described. Figure 5 is a diagram showing an example of the hardware configuration of the security monitoring device 3 according to Embodiment 1. The security monitoring device 3 is realized by a computer system comprising a processing circuit 40, a communication device 41, an input device 44, and a display device 45. The processing circuit 40 comprises a processor 42 and a memory 43. The processing circuit 40 is a circuit in which the processor 42 executes a program stored in the memory 43.
[0077] The processing units of the security monitoring device 3, namely the basic operation analysis unit 13, the reference transition setting unit 14, the state transition determination unit 17, and the unauthorized access detection unit 18, are implemented by software, firmware, or a combination of software and firmware. The software or firmware is written as a program and stored in memory 43. The processing circuit 40 realizes the functions of the processing units by having the processor 42 read and execute the program stored in memory 43. The processing circuit 40 includes memory 43 which stores the program that will ultimately be executed by the processing of the processing unit. It can also be said that the program stored in memory 43 causes the computer to execute the procedures and methods of processing for the security monitoring device 3.
[0078] The processor 42 is a CPU (Central Processing Unit, also known as a processing unit, arithmetic unit, microprocessor, microcomputer, processor, or DSP (Digital Signal Processor)). The memory 43 includes, for example, non-volatile or volatile semiconductor memory such as RAM (Random Access Memory), ROM (Read Only Memory), flash memory, EPROM (Erasable Programmable Read Only Memory), EEPROM® (Electrically Erasable Programmable Read Only Memory), magnetic disks, flexible disks, optical disks, compact disks, minidiscs, or DVDs (Digital Versatile Discs).
[0079] The communication device 41 communicates with external devices of the security monitoring device 3. The communication functions of the document input unit 11, the production plan input unit 12, and the transition information acquisition unit 16 are realized by using the communication device 41. The input device 44 is a device operated by the user to input information. The input device 44 includes, for example, a keyboard, mouse, keypad, or touch panel. When information is input to the document input unit 11 by manual input by the user, the input function of the document input unit 11 is realized by using the input device 44. The display device 45 is a device that displays information. The display device 45 is, for example, an LCD (Liquid Crystal Display) or an organic EL (Electro-Luminescence) display. The display function of the notification unit 19 is realized by using the display device 45. The security monitoring device 3 may be equipped with a GUI that functions as the input device 44 and the display device 45.
[0080] The security monitoring device 3 may include an integrated circuit such as an ASIC (Application Specific Integrated Circuit) or an FPGA (Field Programmable Gate Array). The program according to Embodiment 1 may be provided on a recording medium such as a CD (Compact Disc)-ROM or DVD-ROM. The program may also be provided by being stored on a computer connected to a network such as the Internet and downloaded via the Internet or other network. The program may also be provided or distributed via a network such as the Internet.
[0081] Next, a modified example of the security monitoring device 3 will be described. Figure 6 is a diagram showing a modified example of the security monitoring device 3 according to Embodiment 1. The modified security monitoring device 3 comprises a main unit 5 and a terminal unit 6.
[0082] In the modified security monitoring device 3, the basic transition information is set in the main unit 5. In the modified security monitoring device 3, the state transitions of the FA system and the detection of unauthorized access are performed in the terminal unit 6. The main unit 5 and the terminal unit 6 are connected to each other so as to be able to communicate with each other. The communication means connecting the main unit 5 and the terminal unit 6 may be either wired communication using Ethernet® or a bus, or wireless communication using Wi-Fi® or an optical line.
[0083] The main unit 5 comprises a document input unit 11, a production plan input unit 12, a basic operation analysis unit 13, a reference transition setting unit 14, and a reference transition storage unit 15. The terminal unit 6 comprises a transition information acquisition unit 16, a state transition determination unit 17, an unauthorized access detection unit 18, and a notification unit 19. Both the main unit 5 and the terminal unit 6 are implemented with a hardware configuration similar to the hardware configuration shown in Figure 5.
[0084] The main unit 5 transmits the reference transition information stored in the reference transition storage unit 15 to the terminal device 6. As a result, the main unit 5 outputs the reference transition information set by the reference transition setting unit 14 to the terminal device 6.
[0085] The terminal device 6 receives reference transition information from the main unit 5. The state transition determination unit 17 acquires the reference transition information received by the terminal device 6. The state transition determination unit 17 compares the state before and after the transition when the state of the FA system changes with the reference transition information from the main unit 5 to determine whether the state transition of the FA system corresponds to an abnormal state transition.
[0086] In the modified security monitoring device 3, the terminal device 6 determines whether a state transition of the FA system corresponds to an abnormal state transition based on the reference transition information set by the main unit device 5. Similar to the security monitoring device 3 shown in Figure 2, the terminal device 6 can detect state transitions suspected of being due to unauthorized access with high accuracy. Furthermore, when an abnormal state transition is detected, the terminal device 6 confirms whether the abnormal state transition is due to unauthorized access. If unauthorized access is detected, the notification unit 19 of the terminal device 6 notifies the user that unauthorized access has been detected. The user can learn that unauthorized access has occurred through the notification from the terminal device 6.
[0087] In the modified example shown in Figure 6, one terminal device 6 is connected to one main unit 5. In the modified security monitoring device 3, multiple terminal devices 6 may be connected to one main unit 5. In this case, the modified security monitoring device 3 can detect unauthorized access in each of the multiple terminal devices 6 based on the reference transition information set in the main unit 5.
[0088] According to Embodiment 1, the security monitoring device 3 includes a reference transition setting unit 14, which is a setting unit that sets reference transition information indicating a normal state transition of the system due to a basic operation, for each of a plurality of basic operations, which are predetermined operations performed on the system or by a user on the system during system operation, including system operations by the user. The security monitoring device 3 includes a state transition determination unit 17 that determines whether or not a system state transition is an abnormal state transition by comparing the state before the transition and the state after the transition with the reference transition information when the system state transitions. The security monitoring device 3 can detect abnormal state transitions by setting reference transition information for basic operations performed in the system. The security monitoring device 3 can reduce the amount of work required for setting compared to setting a whitelist for all possible system states the system can take. As a result, the security monitoring device 3 has the effect of reducing the workload of the work performed in setting up the system to protect it from unauthorized access.
[0089] The security monitoring device 3 may include a document input unit 11, which is a first input unit into which a document summarizing information about the use of the system is input, and a basic operation analysis unit 13, which is an analysis unit that extracts basic operations from the document by analyzing the input document. As a result, the security monitoring device 3 can detect state transitions that are suspected of being unauthorized access based on reference transition information about basic operations that follow procedures defined in the document.
[0090] The security monitoring device 3 includes a production plan input unit 12, which is a second input unit into which the system's production plan is entered. The basic operation analysis unit 13 extracts basic operations from the entered documents and production plan by analyzing the entered documents and production plan. As a result, the security monitoring device 3 can detect state transitions that are suspected of being unauthorized access based on the basic operations that follow the procedures defined in the documents and the basic operations shown in the production plan.
[0091] The basic operation analysis unit 13 may set reference transition information indicating the state transitions for each of two or more basic operations performed in succession. The security monitoring device 3 can detect all state transitions suspected of being unauthorized access for a pre-configured process. As a result, the security monitoring device 3 can detect unauthorized access with high accuracy.
[0092] The security monitoring device 3 may also include an unauthorized access detection unit 18 that detects unauthorized access by determining whether a state transition determined to be abnormal by the state transition determination unit 17 corresponds to a state transition caused by unauthorized access. This allows the security monitoring device 3 to detect whether a state transition determined to be abnormal is caused by unauthorized access.
[0093] The unauthorized access detection unit 18 may also include an abnormality determination unit 21 that determines whether the access that caused the state transition determined as abnormal by the state transition determination unit 17 is an abnormal access, and an unauthorized access determination unit 22 that determines whether the access determined as abnormal is an unauthorized access. This allows the security monitoring device 3 to detect whether the state transition determined as abnormal is due to an abnormal access. The security monitoring device 3 can detect whether the access determined as abnormal is an unauthorized access.
[0094] The unauthorized access detection unit 18 includes a simulation unit 25 that simulates the result when a control program containing the modified parameters is executed when the parameters described in the control program executed by the system are modified by an access deemed abnormal. The unauthorized access determination unit 22 may determine whether an access deemed abnormal constitutes unauthorized access based on the results of the simulation by the simulation unit 25. This allows the security monitoring device 3 to determine whether an access deemed abnormal constitutes unauthorized access.
[0095] The security monitoring device 3 may include a main unit 5 equipped with a reference transition setting unit 14, and a terminal device 6 equipped with a state transition determination unit 17 and an unauthorized access detection unit 18. This allows the security monitoring device 3 to detect state transitions suspected of being unauthorized access with high accuracy using the terminal device 6. When unauthorized access is detected, the security monitoring device 3 can notify the user of the detection of unauthorized access using the terminal device 6.
[0096] The reference transition setting unit 14 may update the set reference transition information while the system is waiting to operate. This allows the security monitoring device 3 to update the reference transition information without affecting the operation of the system.
[0097] The reference transition setting unit 14 may also set the reference transition information by manually inputting the content of the normal state transitions of the system based on basic operations. This allows the security monitoring device 3 to set the reference transition information including the content to be included in the reference transition information by having the user directly input that content.
[0098] In the above, the target of security monitoring was assumed to be FA systems. However, the target of security monitoring may also be systems other than FA systems. For example, the target of security monitoring may be water treatment plants, power plants, chemical plants, or building facilities.
[0099] The configurations shown in the embodiments described above are examples of the content of this disclosure. The configurations of the embodiments can be combined with other known technologies. Some parts of the configurations of the embodiments can be omitted or modified without departing from the spirit of this disclosure.
[0100] 1. Security monitoring system, 2. Production management system, 3. Security monitoring device, 4. Control device, 5. Main unit, 6. Terminal device, 11. Document input unit, 12. Production plan input unit, 13. Basic operation analysis unit, 14. Reference transition setting unit, 15. Reference transition storage unit, 16. Transition information acquisition unit, 17. State transition determination unit, 18. Unauthorized access detection unit, 19. Notification unit, 21. Anomaly determination unit, 22. Unauthorized determination unit, 23. Level change unit, 24. Network determination unit, 25. Simulation unit, 40. Processing circuit, 41. Communication device, 42. Processor, 43. Memory, 44. Input device, 45. Display device.
Claims
1. A security monitoring device comprising: a setting unit that sets reference transition information indicating a normal state transition of the system due to a basic operation, for each of a plurality of basic operations which are predetermined operations performed on the system or by a user on the system, including operations on the system by the user; and a state transition determination unit that determines whether or not a state transition of the system is an abnormal state transition by comparing the state before the transition and the state after the transition with the reference transition information when the state of the system transitions.
2. The security monitoring device according to claim 1, comprising: a first input unit into which a document containing information about the use of the system is input; and an analysis unit that extracts the basic operations from the document by analyzing the input document.
3. The security monitoring device according to claim 2, further comprising a second input unit into which the production plan of the system is input, wherein the analysis unit extracts the basic operations from the document and the production plan by analyzing the input document and the input production plan.
4. The security monitoring device according to any one of claims 1 to 3, characterized in that the setting unit sets the reference transition information indicating the state transition for each of the two or more basic operations that are performed in succession.
5. The security monitoring device according to any one of claims 1 to 4, further comprising an unauthorized access detection unit that detects unauthorized access by determining whether a state transition determined to be abnormal by the state transition determination unit corresponds to a state transition caused by unauthorized access.
6. The security monitoring device according to claim 5, wherein the unauthorized access detection unit comprises an abnormality determination unit that determines whether the access that is the cause of a state transition determined to be abnormal by the state transition determination unit is an abnormal access, and an unauthorized access determination unit that determines whether the access determined to be abnormal is an unauthorized access.
7. The security monitoring device according to claim 6, wherein the unauthorized access detection unit includes a simulation unit that simulates the result when the control program including the modified parameters is executed when the parameters described in the control program executed by the system are modified by an access determined to be abnormal, and the unauthorized determination unit determines whether or not the access determined to be abnormal constitutes unauthorized access based on the results of the simulation by the simulation unit.
8. A security monitoring device according to any one of 5 to 7, comprising: a main unit device equipped with the setting unit; and a terminal device equipped with the state transition determination unit and the unauthorized access detection unit, wherein the main unit device outputs the reference transition information set by the setting unit to the terminal device; and the state transition determination unit determines whether the state transition of the system corresponds to an abnormal state transition by comparing the state before the transition and the state after the transition when the state of the system transitions with the reference transition information from the main unit device.
9. The security monitoring device according to any one of claims 1 to 8, characterized in that the setting unit updates the set reference transition information when the system is waiting to operate.
10. The security monitoring device according to any one of claims 1 to 9, characterized in that the setting unit sets the reference transition information by manually inputting the contents of the normal state transitions of the system based on the basic operation.
11. A security monitoring system comprising: a control device for controlling the equipment constituting the system; and a security monitoring device for monitoring the security of the system, wherein the security monitoring device includes: a setting unit for setting reference transition information indicating a normal state transition of the system due to a predetermined operation performed on the system or by a user in the operation of the system, which includes operation of the system by the user; and a state transition determination unit for determining whether a state transition of the system is an abnormal state transition by comparing the state before the transition and the state after the transition with the reference transition information when the state of the system transitions.
12. A security monitoring method characterized by comprising: setting reference transition information indicating a normal state transition of the system due to a basic operation, for each of a plurality of basic operations which are predetermined operations performed on the system or by a user on the system, including operations on the system by the user; and determining whether or not a state transition of the system is an abnormal state transition by comparing the state before the transition and the state after the transition with the reference transition information when the state of the system transitions.
13. A program characterized by causing a computer system to perform the following steps: setting reference transition information indicating a normal state transition of the system due to a predetermined operation performed by the system or a user on the system in the operation of the system, including the operation of the system by the user; and determining whether or not the state transition of the system is an abnormal state transition by comparing the state before the transition and the state after the transition with the reference transition information when the state of the system transitions.
