A comprehensive energy system energy supply reliability assessment method and computer system
Through the energy supply reliability index system established through the sequential Monte Carlo method and node marking method, the problem of difficulty in evaluating the energy supply reliability of the integrated energy system in the existing technology is solved, and more accurate and Comprehensive evaluation improves the safe and efficient operation of the system.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202010593403.7
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2020-06-27
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-22
- Estimated Expiration
- 2040-06-27
AI Technical Summary
The existing reliability evaluation method for comprehensive energy systems has not yet established a complete reliability index system, and it is difficult to consider the purpose and position of users of energy use, and it is impossible to effectively evaluate the energy supply reliability of the integrated energy system.
Using the method based on sequential Monte Carlo method and node marking method, we obtain the simulation model of the comprehensive energy system, and establish an energy supply reliability index system based on energy use purposes and user positions, including load point reliability indicators and system-level reliability Indicators, optimize the evaluation results through load reduction strategies.
It improves the accuracy and comprehensiveness of energy supply reliability assessment of the integrated energy system, takes into account the energy usage purposes and user positions of different types of users, enhances the accuracy and reliability of the evaluation results, and ensures the safe and efficient operation of the system.
Smart Images

Figure CN111798111B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to the field of integrated energy, and in particular to an integrated energy system energy supply reliability assessment method and a computer system. Background Art
[0002] As the global energy crisis continues to intensify and environmental problems become increasingly severe, the traditional high-carbon energy development and utilization methods will be difficult to sustain. In "The Third Industrial Revolution", the famous American scholar Jeremy Rifkin pointed out that the industrial model based on the large-scale utilization of fossil fuels established in the Second Industrial Revolution is coming to an end. In recent years, information support technologies represented by big data, cloud computing, the Internet of Things, and mobile Internet and energy technologies represented by renewable energy, distributed power generation, energy storage, microgrids, electric vehicles, etc. have developed rapidly. The energy Internet, characterized by the deep integration of information technology and energy technology, has become the focus of academia, industry, and government.
[0003] In the context of energy internet, regional integrated energy systems that consider multiple energy coupling, aim to improve energy efficiency and make full use of renewable energy have become a hot topic of research at home and abroad. Regional integrated energy systems can break the existing model of separate planning, design and operation of various energy supply systems such as power supply, gas supply, heating and cooling, and can organically coordinate and optimize the production, transmission, distribution, conversion, storage and consumption of various energy sources during the planning, design, construction and operation stages.
[0004] With the development of economy and society, people have higher and higher requirements for the reliability of energy supply. It is particularly important to ensure the reliability of energy supply of integrated energy systems such as electricity, gas, heat and cold. It is of great significance to carry out research on its reliability assessment. Therefore, how to evaluate the reliability of integrated energy systems to ensure the safe and efficient operation of integrated energy systems is a problem that technicians in this field need to solve. The existing integrated energy system reliability evaluation method has not yet established a complete reliability index system, nor can it take into account the user's energy use purpose and energy use position. Summary of the invention
[0005] The purpose of the present invention is to overcome the defects of the above-mentioned prior art and to provide a comprehensive energy system energy supply reliability assessment method and computer system with high assessment accuracy.
[0006] The purpose of the present invention can be achieved by the following technical solutions:
[0007] A method for evaluating the reliability of energy supply of an integrated energy system comprises the following steps:
[0008] Obtain the original parameters and topology of the integrated energy system to be evaluated;
[0009] Obtaining a simulation model of the integrated energy system to be evaluated based on a sequential Monte Carlo method;
[0010] A node labeling method is used to perform a topological analysis on the system state of the simulation model to obtain a plurality of connected domains;
[0011] The status of each of the connected domains is analyzed respectively, and the reliability of the integrated energy system to be evaluated is evaluated using an energy supply reliability index system based on energy use purpose and user standpoint.
[0012] Furthermore, the energy supply reliability index system based on energy use purpose and user standpoint includes load point reliability index and system-level reliability index.
[0013] Furthermore, the load point reliability index includes the load point failure rate, the average outage duration of the load point, the annual average outage duration of the load point and the annual average thermal comfort time of the load point, wherein:
[0014] The load point failure rate is expressed as:
[0015]
[0016] In the formula, λ α,j is the failure rate of load node j of subsystem α, T is the total simulation time, is the total number of failures of load node j in subsystem α during the entire simulation period;
[0017] The average outage duration of the load point is expressed as:
[0018]
[0019] In the formula, γ α,j is the average outage duration of load node j in subsystem α, is the failure time of load node j of subsystem α in the i-th simulation, and N is the number of random states of the system during the entire simulation period;
[0020] The average annual outage duration of the load point is expressed as:
[0021] U α,j =λ α,j γ α,j
[0022] Where U α,j is the annual average outage duration of load node j in the α subsystem;
[0023] The annual average thermal comfort time of the load point is expressed as:
[0024]
[0025] Where U h,j Refers to the average annual thermal comfort time of the jth load point of the thermal system, F h,j (X i ) is the random state of the system X i The corresponding thermal comfort coefficient is 0 or 1, t i is the random state of the system X i Duration.
[0026] Furthermore, the thermal comfort coefficient F h,j (X i ) is determined by the following formula:
[0027]
[0028] Among them, PMV is the predicted mean thermal sensation index.
[0029] Furthermore, the system-level reliability index includes the average system outage frequency, the average system outage duration, the average system energy supply reliability, the system supply shortage expectation and the system heat user satisfaction, wherein:
[0030] System average outage frequency SAIFI α It is expressed as:
[0031]
[0032] Where, subscript α represents the subsystem energy type, N α,j is the number of users of load node j in subsystem α, N α is the total number of load nodes in the α subsystem, λ α,j is the failure rate of load node j in the α subsystem;
[0033] System average outage duration SAIDI α It is expressed as:
[0034]
[0035] Where U α,j is the annual average outage duration of load node j in the α subsystem;
[0036] System average energy supply reliability rate ASAI α It is expressed as:
[0037]
[0038] System supply is insufficient to expect EPNS α It is expressed as:
[0039]
[0040] In the formula, C α,j (X i ) is the system in state X i The load reduction amount of load node j in the next α subsystem, t i is the random state of the system X i Duration, T is the total simulation time, N is the number of random states of the system during the entire simulation period;
[0041] System thermal user satisfaction P h It is expressed as:
[0042]
[0043] Where N h is the total number of heat load nodes, N h,j is the number of users of load node j in the thermal subsystem, U h,j Refers to the average annual thermal comfort time of the jth load point in the thermal system.
[0044] Furthermore, in the Sequential Monte Carlo method, all components adopt a two-state model of working and faulty, and the fault-free working time TTF and repair time TTR of each component are random variables that obey exponential distribution, and the system operation state sequence is obtained based on the random variables.
[0045] Furthermore, the node marking method distinguishes the connected domains by sequentially searching and marking the numbers of the nodes at both ends of the branch.
[0046] Furthermore, the state analysis of each of the connected domains is specifically performed as follows:
[0047] If the energy supply in the region is 0, all loads in the region will not receive energy supply;
[0048] If the energy supply in the area is not zero and is greater than or equal to the load, all loads in the area will receive normal energy supply and no load reduction is required;
[0049] If the energy supply in the area is not zero and is less than the load, the load in the area will be reduced until the energy supply is greater than or equal to the load.
[0050] Furthermore, a load reduction strategy based on thermal inertia is adopted to reduce the load in the area, and different reduction methods are adopted for different loads, which is highly targeted and effective.
[0051] The present invention also provides a computer system for evaluating the reliability of energy supply of an integrated energy system, comprising a processor and a memory, wherein the memory stores a computer program, and the processor calls the computer program to implement the steps of the method for evaluating the reliability of energy supply of an integrated energy system.
[0052] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following beneficial effects:
[0053] 1. The present invention establishes an energy supply reliability index system for an integrated energy system based on energy use purposes and user standpoints, which can conduct a more comprehensive and complete evaluation of the integrated energy system with high evaluation accuracy to ensure the safe and efficient operation of the integrated energy system.
[0054] 2. Considering the thermal load characteristics and user comfort, a load reduction strategy considering the thermal inertia of the load is proposed. Based on the sequential Monte Carlo method, an integrated energy system energy supply reliability assessment process is formed, which can consider the energy use purposes and user positions of different types of users, further improve the accuracy of the assessment results, facilitate the use of the integrated energy system, and improve the energy supply reliability. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0055] Figure 1 It is a schematic diagram of the sequential Monte Carlo method simulation of the present invention;
[0056] Figure 2 This is a flow chart of the node labeling method of the present invention;
[0057] Figure 3 It is a schematic diagram of the evaluation process of the present invention;
[0058] Figure 4 This is a structural diagram of the energy supply system of the comprehensive energy system in an embodiment of the present invention;
[0059] Figure 5 is a structural diagram of Energy hub I in an embodiment of the present invention;
[0060] Figure 6 It is a structural diagram of Energy hub II in an embodiment of the present invention;
[0061] Figure 7 is the system-level reliability indicator convergence speed in the embodiment of the present invention;
[0062] Figure 8 is the average value of the indicators under different simulation years in the embodiment of the present invention;
[0063] Fig. 9 is the standard deviation of the indicator under different simulation years in the embodiment of the present invention;
[0064] Fig.10 Schematic diagram of reliability index of load points of distribution system in an embodiment of the present invention, wherein (10a) is the failure rate of load points, (10b) is the average outage duration of load points, and (10c) is the average annual outage duration of load points;
[0065] Fig.11Schematic diagram of reliability index of load points of natural gas system in an embodiment of the present invention, wherein (11a) is the failure rate of load points, (11b) is the average outage duration of load points, and (11c) is the average annual outage duration of load points;
[0066] Fig.12 Schematic diagram of reliability index of load point of thermal system in an embodiment of the present invention, wherein (12a) is the failure rate of load point, (12b) is the average outage duration of load point, (12c) is the annual average outage duration of load point, and (12d) is the annual average thermal comfort time of load point. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0067] The present invention is described in detail below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings and specific embodiments. This embodiment is implemented based on the technical solution of the present invention, and provides a detailed implementation method and specific operation process, but the protection scope of the present invention is not limited to the following embodiments.
[0068] like Figure 3 As shown, the present invention provides a method for evaluating the energy supply reliability of an integrated energy system, comprising the following steps: obtaining original parameters and topological structure of the integrated energy system to be evaluated; obtaining a simulation model of the integrated energy system to be evaluated based on a sequential Monte Carlo method; performing a topological analysis on the system state of the simulation model using a node labeling method to obtain a plurality of connected domains; performing a state analysis on each of the connected domains respectively, and performing reliability evaluation on the integrated energy system to be evaluated using an energy supply reliability index system based on energy use purpose and user standpoint.
[0069] (1) Energy supply reliability index system based on energy use purpose and user standpoint
[0070] The energy supply reliability index system established in the present invention includes load point reliability index and system level reliability index, as shown in Table 1.
[0071] Table 1 Comprehensive energy system energy supply reliability index system
[0072]
[0073] 1) Load point reliability index
[0074] a. Load point failure rate λ (times / a)
[0075]
[0076] In the formula, λ α,j is the failure rate of load node j of subsystem α, T is the total simulation time, is the total number of failures of load node j in subsystem α during the entire simulation period.
[0077] For electricity and gas loads, if the energy that the system can supply in the current time period is lower than the load demand of the load point, it is considered that there is a power supply or gas supply failure. For heat loads, the load temperature can be calculated by equations (14) to (18). If the temperature in the current time period is lower than the minimum allowed temperature, it is considered that there is a heat supply failure at the load point.
[0078] b. Average outage duration of load point γ (h / time)
[0079]
[0080] In the formula, γ α,j is the average outage duration of load node j in subsystem α, is the failure time of load node j of subsystem α in the i-th simulation, and N is the number of random states of the system during the entire simulation period.
[0081] c. Annual average outage duration of load point U (h / a)
[0082] U α,j =λ α,j γ α,j (3)
[0083] Where U α,j is the annual average outage duration of load node j in subsystem α.
[0084] d. Annual average thermal comfort time at load point U h (h / a)
[0085]
[0086] Where U h,j Refers to the average annual thermal comfort time of the jth load point of the thermal system, F h,j (X i ) is determined by the following formula:
[0087]
[0088] 2) System-level reliability indicators
[0089] a. System average interruption frequency index (SAIFI) (times / user / a)
[0090]
[0091] Where, subscript α represents the subsystem energy type, N α,j is the number of users of load node j in subsystem α, N αis the total number of load nodes in the α subsystem.
[0092] b. System average interruption duration index (SAIDI) (h / user·a)
[0093]
[0094] c. Average service availability index (ASAI)
[0095]
[0096] d. Expected energy not supply (EENS) (MWh / a)
[0097]
[0098] In the formula, C α,j (X i ) is the system in state X i The load reduction amount of load node j in the next α subsystem, t i is the random state of the system X i Duration.
[0099] e. System thermal user satisfaction P h
[0100] System thermal user satisfaction P h Refers to the probability that users of the thermal system are in thermal comfort throughout the year.
[0101]
[0102] Where N h is the total number of heat load nodes, N h,j is the number of users of load node j in the thermal subsystem.
[0103] The calculation method of user thermal comfort is as follows.
[0104] Since the user's perception of thermal comfort is fuzzy, that is, when the indoor temperature changes within a certain range, the user will not feel a significant difference, the user's heating load demand curve is an interval. The requirements of thermal users for thermal environment quality are generally characterized by thermal comfort, and the predicted mean vote (PMV) index is selected to quantify the impact of temperature on user thermal comfort. The PMV index is a comprehensive evaluation index based on the basic equation of human thermal balance and the level of subjective thermal sensation in psychophysiology, and takes into account many relevant factors of human thermal comfort. The PMV index shows the average index of the group's vote for seven levels of thermal sensation. The corresponding relationship between human sensation and the PMV index is shown in Table 2.
[0105] Table 2 Correspondence between human sensation and PMV index
[0106]
[0107] The PMV value can be obtained by the following formula:
[0108]
[0109] Where M is the energy metabolism rate of the human body, W is the mechanical power of the human body, and f cl h is the ratio of the body area covered by clothing to the exposed area, c is the surface heat transfer coefficient, P a is the water vapor partial pressure of the air around the human body, t n is the air temperature around the human body, t r is the mean radiation temperature, t cl The outer surface temperature of the garment.
[0110] According to the "Design Code for Heating, Ventilation and Air Conditioning of Civil Buildings", PMV should be between [-1, +1]. When heating in winter, based on the principle of energy saving, energy saving should be considered as much as possible while meeting the conditions of thermal comfort. Therefore, a relatively cold environment should be selected, and PMV should be between [-1, 0].
[0111] (2) Sequential Monte Carlo Simulation Model
[0112] Assume that all components of the system adopt the working-failure two-state model, and the failure rate and repair rate of the components are constants λ and μ respectively. At this time, the fault-free working time (time to failure, TTF) and repair time (time to repair, TTR) of the components are random variables that obey exponential distribution. They can be sampled in turn according to equations (12) and (13) to form a component operation state duration sequence. By integrating all components, the system operation state sequence can be obtained.
[0113]
[0114]
[0115] Where δ1 and δ2 are random numbers uniformly distributed on [0, 1].
[0116] Assuming that a simple system consists of two components A and B, the state transition process of the entire system is determined by simulating the state sequence of the two components as follows: Figure 1 In the figure, the "1" state indicates the running state of the component, and the "0" state indicates the shutdown state of the component. "00", "01", "10" and "11" indicate the system combination state composed of two components.
[0117] (3) Comprehensive energy system topology analysis
[0118] The topological analysis of the system state obtained by Monte Carlo simulation is mainly to analyze how many subsystems the system nodes are connected into by branches and energy conversion equipment. The node marking method is used here to identify the connectivity of the system. The node marking method classifies each node in the system, and the nodes belonging to the same area (that is, there is a path between the nodes that can be connected) are classified into one category. It distinguishes the connected domain by searching and marking the numbers of the nodes at both ends of the branch in turn, and the number of searches is only the total number of branches.
[0119] For a system with N nodes and M branches, use the matrix A M×2 Record the physical connection relationship between branches and nodes, that is, if the i-th branch is connected between nodes j and k, then A(i,1) = j, A(i,2) = k. Use matrix C N×1 Record the region to which the node belongs, that is, if the i-th node is in region 1, then C(i,1) = 1. The specific implementation of the node marking method includes the following steps, as shown in the flowchart Figure 2 shown.
[0120] Step 1: Input the number of nodes N, the number of branches M, and the matrix A M×2 . Initialize C N×1 It is a zero matrix, i=1, x=0 (x represents the number of regions).
[0121] Step 2: If C(A(i,1),1) and C(A(i,2),1) are both 0, that is, the i-th branch is not connected to the existing area, then x=x+1, C(A(i,1),1)=x, C(A(i,2),1)=x, that is, the number of independent areas increases by 1, and the area to which the nodes at both ends of the branch belong is x, and go to step 5; if one of C(A(i,1),1) and C(A(i,2),1) is 0, that is, one and only one of the nodes at both ends of this branch is connected to the existing area, then the node with area 0 at the two ends of the current branch is assigned to the area where the other node is located, C(A(i,1), 1)=C(A(i,1),1)+C(A(i,2),1), C(A(i,2),1)=C(A(i,1),1), go to step 5; if C(A(i,1),1) and C(A(i,2),1) are not 0 and are not equal, that is, this branch connects two independent areas, then reduce the number of areas by 1 and update the areas to which the relevant nodes belong, big=max{C(A(i,1),1),C(A(i,2),1)}, sma=max{C(A(i,1),1),C(A(i,2),1)}, x=x-1, k=1, go to step 3.
[0122] Step 3: If C(k,1)>big, then C(k,1)=C(k,1)-1; if C(k,1)=big, then C(k,1)=sma.
[0123] Step 4: k=k+1, if k≤N, go to step 3, otherwise go to step 5.
[0124] Step 5: i=i+1, if i≤M, go to step 2, otherwise go to step 6.
[0125] Step 6: Output matrix C.
[0126] (3) Load thermal inertia
[0127] The thermal inertia of a building heating system reflects the ability of the building maintenance structure to maintain the current room temperature. It is related to factors such as the building envelope area, indoor and outdoor temperatures, etc. The heat loss of a building heating system is a very complex process, including convection, conduction, and radiation. When the room temperature of the heating user changes within the allowable range, the heat loss can be calculated using a simple steady-state algorithm, which is mainly composed of three parts: the heat load of the building envelope, the heat load of cold air infiltration, and the heat load of ventilation, which are expressed as:
[0128]
[0129]
[0130]
[0131] In the formula, is the building envelope heat load corresponding to the heating user at node k in period t, S k is the building envelope area of the heating user corresponding to node k, F e is the heat transfer coefficient of the building envelope corresponding to the heating user at node k, is the indoor temperature of the heating user corresponding to node k in period t, is the outdoor temperature of the heating user corresponding to node k in period t, is the floor height correction coefficient of the heating user corresponding to node k in period t, is the building orientation correction coefficient of the heating user corresponding to node k in period t, is the cold air penetration heat load of the heating user corresponding to node k in period t, Num is the number of air changes per hour, V k is the building envelope volume of the heating user corresponding to node k, c p is the constant-pressure specific heat capacity of cold air, is the outdoor air density during period t, is the ventilation heat load of the heating user corresponding to node k in period t, and Ven is the ventilation volume per hour.
[0132] When considering the dynamic change process of room temperature, taking the indoor temperature as the state quantity, the equation representing the thermal inertia of heating load can be expressed as:
[0133]
[0134]
[0135] Where, Q is the heating load power of the node k corresponding to the heating user in period t, C M is the specific heat capacity of indoor air, M k is the indoor air quality of the heating user corresponding to node k, is the indoor temperature of the heating user corresponding to node k in period t+1.
[0136] (4) Load reduction strategy considering load thermal inertia
[0137] When a fault occurs in the integrated energy system and the system cannot fully meet all load demands, load reduction is required to ensure the normal energy supply of the remaining load. The load reduction factor is defined here to determine the priority of load reduction. Taking into account the importance and location of the load, the load reduction factor is defined as shown in the following formula:
[0138]
[0139] In the formula, α i is the importance coefficient of load point i, L Ci is the importance factor of load point i, βi is the location reduction factor of load point i. is the load point i and the electricity (gas, heat) source point s j The minimum distance is related to the system topology and has nothing to do with the branch length. The distance between two adjacent load points is 1. s is the total number of electricity (gas, heat) source points. Li is the reduction coefficient of load point i. The smaller its value is, the higher the priority is for reducing the load at that load point.
[0140] Based on the above load reduction factor, the load reduction strategy considering load thermal inertia is set as follows:
[0141] A topological analysis is performed on the system state obtained by the Monte Carlo simulation, and a state analysis is performed on each of the n connected domains obtained after the topological analysis. If the energy supply in the i-th connected domain cannot fully meet the energy demand of all loads, the load must be reduced in turn according to the load reduction coefficient. After the load reduction work of each node is completed, the power balance analysis is performed again until the energy supply in the i-th connected domain is greater than or equal to the load.
[0142] For electric load and gas load, the load at the load point is reduced to zero each time. For thermal load, when the load at a certain load point is to be reduced, it is first assumed that the load at this load point is reduced to zero, and the temperature at the next moment is calculated by equations (14) to (18). If the temperature at the next moment is higher than the set minimum allowable temperature, the load at this load point is reduced to zero; if the temperature at the next moment is lower than the set minimum allowable temperature, the temperature at the next moment is set to the minimum allowable temperature, and the load power is calculated by equations (14) to (18), thereby obtaining the load reduction power.
[0143] (5) Integrated energy system supply reliability assessment process
[0144] The main steps of the integrated energy system energy supply reliability assessment flow chart based on sequential Monte Carlo simulation are as follows: Figure 3 As shown, specifically including:
[0145] Step 1: Input the original system parameters and topology.
[0146] Step 2: Data initialization, determine the simulation period, initialize the system simulation time, number of load point failures, etc.
[0147] Step 3: Randomly generate a random number that is consistent with the number of components, and calculate the trouble-free working time TTF of each component based on the random number.
[0148] Step 3: Select the component with the smallest TTF as the faulty component and accumulate the simulation time.
[0149] Step 4: Generate another random number and calculate the repair time of the faulty component.
[0150] Step 5: Use the node marking method to perform topological analysis on the system status.
[0151] Step 6: Perform state analysis on the n connected domains obtained after topological analysis:
[0152] If the energy supply in the area is 0, the state of the area is determined as: all loads in the area cannot get energy supply;
[0153] If the energy supply in the area is not zero and is greater than or equal to the load, the state of the area is determined as follows: all loads in the area are supplied with normal energy and no load reduction is required;
[0154] If the energy supply in the area is not zero and is less than the load, it is necessary to reduce the load in the area based on a load reduction strategy that considers thermal inertia until the energy supply is greater than or equal to the load.
[0155] Step 7: For the heat load node, calculate the temperature at the next moment.
[0156] Step 8: Determine whether the simulation lifespan has been reached. If so, proceed to step 9; if not, return to step 3.
[0157] Step 9: Calculate the load point reliability index and system level reliability index.
[0158] Step 10: Evaluate the energy supply reliability of the integrated energy system based on the calculation results of step 9.
[0159] Example
[0160] (1) Parameter setting
[0161] 1) System Overview
[0162] like Figure 4 As shown, the energy types in the system of this embodiment include electricity, natural gas, and heat. The power system is an IEEE 33-node system, the natural gas system is an 11-node system, and the thermal system is a 32-node system. The embodiment system includes two Energy hubs. Node EB24, node GB10, and node HB3 are connected through Energy hub I. The input of Energy hub I is electricity and natural gas, and the output thermal energy is used to supply energy to the thermal system load. Energy hub II is connected to node GB11 and node HB6, and these two nodes provide natural gas and thermal energy to Energy hub II respectively.
[0163] 2) Power distribution system parameters
[0164] Table 3 Distribution system node data
[0165]
[0166]
[0167] Table 4 Distribution system line data
[0168]
[0169]
[0170] 3) Natural gas system parameters
[0171] Table 5 Natural gas system node data
[0172]
[0173] Table 6 Natural gas system pipeline data
[0174]
[0175] 4) Thermal system parameters
[0176] Table 7 Thermal system node data
[0177]
[0178] Table 8 Thermal system piping data
[0179]
[0180]
[0181] 5) Energy Hub Parameters
[0182] Figure 4 The system shown includes two energy hubs, namely Energy hub I and Energy hub II. The structure diagram of Energy hub I is shown in Figure 5 shown.
[0183] Where T is the transformer, AC is the air conditioning system, and GF is the gas boiler.
[0184] Energy hub I parameter matrix is as follows:
[0185]
[0186] Energy hub II structure diagram Figure 6 shown.
[0187] HE is an electric heater and MT is a micro gas turbine.
[0188] The Energy hub II parameter matrix is shown below:
[0189]
[0190] 6) System component reliability parameters
[0191] Consider the failure of the main feeder of the distribution system, distribution lines, gas sources, natural gas pipelines, heat sources, thermal system pipelines and energy conversion equipment in the Energy Hub. Figure 4 The reliability of the integrated energy system power supply system shown is evaluated, and the reliability parameters of the system components are shown in Table 9.
[0192] Table 9 System component reliability parameters
[0193]
[0194] 7) Heat load related parameters
[0195] Assuming that the heat loads in the embodiments are all heating building heat loads, the relevant parameters in the thermal inertia equation are shown in Table 10, and the relevant parameters in the PMV equation are shown in Table 11.
[0196] Table 10 Parameters related to thermal inertia equation of heating buildings
[0197]
[0198] Table 11 PMV equation related parameters
[0199]
[0200]
[0201] (2) Implementation results
[0202] 1) Indicator convergence analysis
[0203] Since the energy supply reliability of the integrated energy system is evaluated within a specified simulation period, the convergence of the simulation is verified first. For sequential Monte Carlo simulation, the convergence rate β of the statistical indicator can be calculated according to the following formula:
[0204]
[0205] Where X is a statistical indicator, σ(X) is the standard deviation of X, E(X) is the mean of X, and N is the number of simulation years.
[0206] Since SAIFI needs to be calculated in this embodiment eThe convergence speed of all system-level reliability indicators is calculated according to formula 22: Figure 7 As shown in the figure, EPNS g 、SAIDI g 、SAIFI g and SAIDI e The four indicators converge slowly, among which EPNS g The indicator converges the slowest.
[0207] On this basis, the simulation convergence is verified from two aspects: the first aspect is to simulate multiple times with the same simulation period, and the second aspect is to compare and verify the results of different simulation periods. The simulation period is set to 1000, 2000 and 3000 years, and ten simulations are performed respectively. g 、SAIDI g 、SAIFI g and SAIDI e The results of four representative system-level reliability indicators with slow convergence are statistically analyzed, as shown in Table 12, Table 13 and Table 14. The mean and standard deviation of ten simulations under different simulation years are shown in Figure 8 , Fig. 9 shown.
[0208] Table 12 Calculation results of representative system-level reliability indicators when the simulation period is 1000 years
[0209]
[0210] Table 13 Calculation results of representative system-level reliability indicators when the simulation period is 2000
[0211]
[0212] Table 14 Calculation results of representative system-level reliability indicators when the simulation period is 3000 years
[0213]
[0214] Through Table 12, Table 13, Table 14, Figure 8 and Fig. 9 It can be seen that when EPNS is simulated multiple times under different simulation years, g The standard deviation of the indicator is always the largest, indicating that its convergence speed is the slowest, which is consistent with Figure 7 When the simulation period increases from 1000 to 2000 and then to 3000, the statistical standard deviation of the system reliability index gradually decreases, and the convergence of the index gradually improves. When the simulation period is 3000 years, the statistical standard deviation of the system reliability index is small, among which EPNS with the slowest convergence speedg The statistical standard deviation of the indicator is also below 0.9, reaching a good convergence level. In addition, by comparing the mean values of the calculation results of the system reliability indicators under different simulation years, it can be seen that when the simulation years are 1000, 2000 and 3000, the mean values of the indicator calculation results are basically consistent. Therefore, the simulation year can be set to 3000 years, at which time the system reliability indicator has a good convergence.
[0215] 2) Calculation results of energy supply reliability index
[0216] Given that the probability of multiple failures in the system is relatively small, only single failures of the system are considered here, including failures of the main feeder of the distribution system, distribution lines, gas sources, natural gas pipelines, heat sources, thermal system pipelines, and energy conversion equipment in the Energy Hub. Based on the sequential Monte Carlo simulation, the simulation period is selected as 3000 years, the minimum temperature allowed by the heat load is 18 degrees, and the maximum temperature is 25 degrees. Figure 4 The system operation status is shown, and the energy supply reliability index is calculated, including the load point reliability index and the system level reliability index.
[0217] The calculation results of the reliability index of the load point of the distribution system are as follows: Fig.10 As shown, (10a) is the load point failure rate, (10b) is the average outage duration of the load point, and (10c) is the average annual outage duration of the load point. It can be seen from (10a) that since the load power of node 1 is 0, its failure rate is 0, and the failure rates of all other load points are below 0.4 times / a. In addition, from node 1 to node 18, node 19 to node 22, node 23 to node 33, the load point failure rate gradually increases, which is consistent with the energy supply characteristics of the radial distribution network. The load point failure rate gradually increases from the feeder head to the feeder end. It can be seen from (10b) that the average outage duration of all load points in the distribution system is about 8h / time, which is consistent with the given reliability parameters (the main feeder repair time of the distribution system is 2h, and the distribution line repair time is 8h). It can be seen from (10c) that the annual average outage duration of all load points is less than 3h / a, and the overall law of the annual average outage duration of load points is consistent with the overall law of the load point failure rate. The annual average outage duration of load points gradually increases from the feeder head end to the feeder end.
[0218] The calculation results of the reliability index of the natural gas system load point are as follows: Fig.11 As shown in Figure 1, (11a) is the load point failure rate, (11b) is the average outage duration of the load point, and (11c) is the average annual outage duration of the load point. First, it can be seen from the figure that the load point failure rate, average outage duration, and average annual outage duration of nodes 2 to 8 are all equal, which is due to the special topological structure of the natural gas system. Figure 4The natural gas system in the figure has a ring-branch topology, which has both ring and branch structures. The pipeline connection from node 2 to node 8 is ring-shaped. When only the gas source and natural gas pipeline failures are considered, the failures from node 2 to node 8 are all caused by gas source failures or pipeline 1 failures, so their load point reliability indicators are equal.
[0219] From (11a), it can be seen that the failure rate of node 1 is 0, which is because the load of node 1 is 0; the failure rate of all load points in the system is less than 0.35 times / a; the failure rate of the load points increases gradually from node 9 to node 11, which is because the pipeline connection from node 9 to node 11 is a single branch, and the farther away from the gas source, the lower the load reliability; and the load point failure rate of nodes 9, 10, and 11 is greater than that of nodes 2 to 8, because in addition to the gas source failure or pipeline 1 failure that will cause load points 9, 10, and 11 failures, pipeline 12, 13, and 14 failures will also cause load points 9, 10, and 11 failures.
[0220] From (11b), it can be seen that except for the average outage duration of node 1, which is 0, the average outage duration of all other load points is between 25h / time and 31h / time, which is consistent with the given reliability parameters (gas source repair time is 30h, natural gas pipeline repair time is 20h). In addition, the average outage duration of load points from node 9 to node 11 gradually decreases, and the average outage duration of load points of nodes 9, 10, and 11 is shorter than that of nodes 2 to 8. The reasons are as follows: By analyzing the causes of load point failures, it can be seen that except for gas source failure or pipeline 1 failure, which will cause all failures from node 2 to node 11, pipeline 12 failure will cause load points 9, 10, and 11 failures, pipeline 13 failure will cause load points 10 and 11 failures, and pipeline 14 failure will cause load point 11 failures. In the reliability parameter setting, the gas source repair time is greater than the natural gas pipeline repair time. During the simulation time period, the total fault time and total number of faults of nodes 9, 10, and 11 increase successively, and are all greater than those of nodes 2 to 8, but the growth rate of the total fault time is lower than the growth rate of the total number of faults. Therefore, the average outage duration of the load points from node 9 to node 11 gradually decreases, and are all lower than the average outage duration from node 2 to node 8.
[0221] From (11c), it can be seen that the annual average outage duration of all load points in the system is less than 9h / a, and the overall law of the annual average outage duration of the load points is consistent with the overall law of the load point failure rate.
[0222] The calculation results of the reliability index of the thermal system load point are as follows: Fig.12 As shown in Figure 1, (12a) is the load point failure rate, (12b) is the average outage duration of the load point, (12c) is the annual average outage duration of the load point, and (12d) is the annual average thermal comfort time of the load point. Figure 4 A simple analysis of the thermal system in Figure 1 is performed. This thermal system has three heat sources, and Energy hub I can also provide some heat energy for it. Its topological structure is also ring-branch, with both ring and branch structures. On this basis, the reliability index of the load point of the thermal system is analyzed. First, it can be seen from the figure that for nodes with a load power of 0, the load point reliability index is 0. Although the load power of node 3 is not 0, its failure rate, average outage duration, and annual average outage duration are all 0. The reason for the analysis is that node 3 and Energy hub IL h1 The heat energy input of Energy hub I improves the energy supply reliability of node 3.
[0223] From (12a), it can be seen that the failure rate of all load points in the thermal system is below 0.4 times / a. The failure rates of nodes 8, 21, and 24 are relatively high. This is because the load reduction coefficients of nodes 8, 21, and 24 are relatively small. When load reduction is performed, the smaller the load reduction coefficient, the higher the priority of load reduction. Therefore, the failure rates of these three nodes are relatively high. From (12b), it can be seen that the average outage duration of all load points in the system is about 30h / time, which is consistent with the given reliability parameters (heat source repair time is 30h, and thermal pipeline repair time is 25h). From (12c), it can be seen that the annual average outage duration of all load points in the system is less than 14h / a, and the overall law of the annual average outage duration of the load point is basically consistent with the overall law of the load point failure rate. From (12d), it can be seen that the annual average thermal comfort time of all load points in the system is above 8700h / a.
[0224] The reliability indexes of the three independent load nodes output by the Energy hub are shown in Table 15. By analyzing the structures of Energy hub I and Energy hub II, it can be seen that the reliability of the output electric load node of Energy hub I is related to the input electric energy of Energy hub I and the reliability of the transformer in Energy hub I; the reliability of the output electric load node of Energy hub II is related to the input natural gas of Energy hub II and the reliability of the micro gas turbine in Energy hub II; the reliability of the output heat load node of Energy hub II is related to the input natural gas and input heat energy of Energy hub II, the micro gas turbine in Energy hub II, and the reliability of the heat exchanger.
[0225] As can be seen from Table 15, Energy hub IL e1 Node, Energy hub II-L e2Node and Energy hubII-L h2 The load point failure rate and annual average outage duration of the node are gradually increasing, indicating that the Energy hub IL e1 Highest node reliability, Energy hub II-L e2 Node is second, Energy hub II-L h2 The node reliability is the worst. Among them, Energy hub II-L h2 The node failure rate and the average annual outage duration are relatively large, which is related to the high failure rate of the micro gas turbine and heat exchanger in Energy hub II, and the low reliability of the heat input of Energy hub II. h2 The average annual thermal comfort time of the node is 8688.5183h / a, and the thermal satisfaction is still at a relatively high level.
[0226] Table 15 Reliability index of energy hub output load point
[0227]
[0228] Figure 4 The system-level reliability indicators of the energy supply system of the comprehensive energy system are shown in Table 16. It can be seen from the table that the average energy supply reliability rates of the three energy subsystems are all above 0.999, and the system reliability level is relatively high. For the power distribution system, natural gas system and thermal system, the average outage frequency of the system gradually increases, the average outage duration of the system gradually increases, the average energy supply reliability rate of the system gradually decreases, and the expectation of insufficient supply of the system gradually increases, indicating that the reliability level of the power distribution system is the highest, followed by the natural gas system, and the thermal system has the lowest reliability level. In addition, for the thermal system, the system thermal user satisfaction is 0.996278, which is at a relatively high satisfaction level. In summary Figure 4 The energy supply reliability of the integrated energy system shown is at a high level.
[0229] Table 16 System-level reliability indicators
[0230]
[0231] The preferred specific embodiments of the present invention are described in detail above. It should be understood that a person skilled in the art can make many modifications and changes based on the concept of the present invention without creative work. Therefore, any technical solution that can be obtained by a person skilled in the art through logical analysis, reasoning or limited experiments based on the concept of the present invention on the basis of the prior art should be within the scope of protection determined by the claims.
Claims
1. A method for evaluating the reliability of energy supply of an integrated energy system, characterized in that: The following steps are involved: Obtain the original parameters and topological structure of the integrated energy system to be evaluated, where the integrated energy system is an energy system including electricity, gas, heat and cold; Obtaining a simulation model of the integrated energy system to be evaluated based on a sequential Monte Carlo method; A node labeling method is used to perform a topological analysis on the system state of the simulation model to obtain a plurality of connected domains; Performing status analysis on each of the connected domains respectively, and using an energy supply reliability index system based on energy use purpose and user standpoint to perform reliability evaluation on the comprehensive energy system to be evaluated; The energy supply reliability index system based on energy use purpose and user standpoint includes load point reliability index and system level reliability index; The load point reliability index includes load point failure rate, load point average outage duration, load point annual average outage duration and load point annual average thermal comfort time, among which: The load point failure rate is expressed as: In the formula, λ α,j is the failure rate of load node j of subsystem α, T is the total simulation time, is the total number of failures of load node j in subsystem α during the entire simulation period; For electricity and gas loads, if the energy that the system can supply in the current time period is lower than the load demand of the load point, it is considered that there is a power supply or gas supply failure. For heat loads, if the temperature in the current time period is lower than the minimum allowed temperature, it is considered that there is a heat supply failure at the load point. The average outage duration of the load point is expressed as: In the formula, γ α,j is the average outage duration of load node j in subsystem α, is the failure time of load node j of subsystem α in the i-th simulation, and N is the number of random states of the system during the entire simulation period; The average annual outage duration of the load point is expressed as: U α,j =λ α,j c α,j Where U α,j is the annual average outage duration of load node j in the α subsystem; The annual average thermal comfort time of the load point is expressed as: Where U h,j Refers to the average annual thermal comfort time of the jth load node of the thermal system, F h,j (X i ) is the random state of the system X i The corresponding thermal comfort coefficient is 0 or 1, t i is the random state of the system X i Duration, the thermal comfort factor F h,j (X i ) is determined by the following formula: Where PMV is the predicted mean thermal sensation index, which is obtained by the following formula: PMV=(0.303e -0.036M +0.028){M-W-3.05×10 -3 ×[5733-6.99(M-W)-P a ]-0.42[(M-W)-58.15]-1.7×10 -5 M(5867-P a )-0.0014M(34-t n )-3.96×10 -8 ×f cl [(t cl +273) 4 -(t r +273) 4 ]-f cl h c (t cl -t n )} Where M is the energy metabolism rate of the human body, W is the mechanical power of the human body, and f cl h is the ratio of the body area covered by clothing to the exposed area, c is the surface heat transfer coefficient, P a is the water vapor partial pressure of the air around the human body, t n is the air temperature around the human body, t r is the mean radiation temperature, t cl is the outer surface temperature of the garment; The system-level reliability indicators include the average outage frequency of the system, the average outage duration of the system, the average energy supply reliability of the system, the system supply shortage expectation and the system heat user satisfaction, among which, System average outage frequency SAIFI α It is expressed as: Where, subscript α represents the subsystem energy type, N α,j is the number of users of load node j in subsystem α, N α is the total number of load nodes in the α subsystem, λ α,j is the failure rate of load node j in the α subsystem; System average outage duration SAIDI α It is expressed as: Where U α,j is the annual average outage duration of load node j in the α subsystem; System average energy supply reliability rate ASAI α It is expressed as: System supply is insufficient to expect EPNS α It is expressed as: In the formula, C α,j (X i ) is the system in the random state X i The load reduction amount of load node j in the next α subsystem, t i is the random state of the system X i Duration, T is the total simulation time, N is the number of random states of the system during the entire simulation period; System thermal user satisfaction P h It is expressed as: Where N h is the total number of load nodes, N h,j is the number of users of load node j in the thermal subsystem, U h,j Refers to the average annual thermal comfort time of the jth load node of the thermal system; The simulation life of the simulation model when performing simulation is determined by comparing and verifying the convergence of indicators; Adopt load reduction strategy considering load thermal inertia to reduce load in the area; The node marking method is used to perform topological analysis on the system state obtained by Monte Carlo simulation. The task is to analyze how many subsystems the system nodes are connected into by branches and energy conversion equipment. The node marking method classifies each node in the system, and nodes belonging to the same area are classified into one category. The connected domains are distinguished by searching and marking the numbers of the nodes at both ends of the branch in turn. The number of searches is only the total number of branches. The specific implementation of the node marking method includes: Step 1: Input the number of nodes, the number of branches and the matrix A, initialize C to a zero matrix, m = 1, x = 0, x represents the number of regions; Step 2: If both C(A(m,1),1) and C(A(m,2),1) are 0, that is, the i-th branch is not connected to the existing area, then x=x+1, C(A(m,1),1)=x, C(A(m,2),1)=x, that is, the number of independent areas increases by 1, and go to step 5; if one of C(A(m,1),1) and C(A(m,2),1) is 0, that is, only one of the two end nodes of this branch is connected to the existing area, then the node with area 0 at the two end nodes of the current branch is classified as the area where the other node is located, C(A(m,1),1)=C(A(m, 1),1)+C(A(m,2),1),C(A(m,2),1)=C(A(m,1),1), go to step 5; if C(A(m,1),1) and C(A(m,2),1) are not 0 and are not equal, that is, this branch connects two independent areas, then reduce the number of areas by 1 and update the areas to which the relevant nodes belong, big=max{C(A(m,1),1),1),C(A(m,2),1)}, sma=min{C(A(m,1),1),1),C(A(m,2),1)}, x=x-1, k=1, go to step 3; Step 3: If C(k,1)>big, then C(k,1)=C(k,1)-1; if C(k,1)=big, then C(k,1)=sma; Step 4: k = k + 1, if k ≤ the number of nodes, go to step 3, otherwise go to step 5; Step 5: m=m+1, if m≤number of branches, go to step 2, otherwise go to step 6; Step 6: Output matrix C; The energy supply reliability assessment of the integrated energy system based on sequential Monte Carlo simulation specifically includes: Step 1: Input the original system parameters and topology; Step 2: Data initialization, determine the simulation years, initialize the system simulation time, and the number of load point failures; Step 3: Randomly generate a random number that is consistent with the number of components, and calculate the trouble-free working time TTF of each component according to the random number; Step 3: Select the component with the smallest TTF as the faulty component and accumulate the simulation time; Step 4: Generate another random number and calculate the repair time of the faulty component; Step 5: Use node marking method to perform topological analysis on the system status; Step 6: Perform state analysis on the n connected domains obtained after topological analysis: If the energy supply in the area is 0, the state of the area is determined as: all loads in the area cannot get energy supply; If the energy supply in the area is not zero and is greater than or equal to the load, the state of the area is determined as follows: all loads in the area are supplied with normal energy and no load reduction is required; If the energy supply in the region is not zero and is less than the load, a load reduction strategy based on load thermal inertia is required to reduce the load in the region according to the load reduction coefficient until the energy supply is greater than or equal to the load; After each node load reduction is completed, the power balance analysis is performed again until the energy supply in the connected domain is greater than or equal to the load; The load reduction factor is as follows: In the formula, α j is the importance coefficient of load node j, L Cj is the importance factor of load node j, β j is the location reduction factor of load node j, is the load node j and the electricity / gas / heat source point s n The minimum distance is related to the system topology and has nothing to do with the branch length. s is the total number of electricity / gas / heat source points, I Lj is the reduction coefficient of load node j. The smaller its value is, the higher the priority is for reducing the load at this load point. Step 7: For the heat load node, calculate the temperature at the next moment; Step 8: Determine whether the simulation lifespan has been reached, if so, proceed to step 9, if not, return to step 3; Step 9: Calculate the load point reliability index and system level reliability index; Step 10: Evaluate the energy supply reliability of the integrated energy system based on the calculation results of step 9; In the load thermal inertia, when the room temperature of the heating user changes within the allowable range, the heat loss is composed of three parts: the heat load of the building envelope, the heat load of cold air infiltration, and the heat load of ventilation, which are expressed as follows: In the formula, is the building envelope heat load corresponding to the heating user at node k in period t, S k is the building envelope area of the heating user corresponding to node k, F e is the heat transfer coefficient of the building envelope corresponding to the heating user at node k, is the indoor temperature of the heating user corresponding to node k in period t, is the outdoor temperature of the heating user corresponding to node k in period t, is the floor height correction coefficient of the heating user corresponding to node k in period t, is the building orientation correction coefficient of the heating user corresponding to node k in period t, is the cold air penetration heat load of the heating user corresponding to node k in period t, Num is the number of air changes per hour, V k is the building envelope volume of the heating user corresponding to node k, c p is the constant-pressure specific heat capacity of cold air, is the outdoor air density during period t, is the ventilation heat load of the heating user corresponding to node k in period t, and Ven is the ventilation volume per hour; When considering the dynamic change process of room temperature, taking the indoor temperature as the state quantity, the equation characterizing the thermal inertia of the heating load is expressed as: In the formula, Q t,k is the heating load power of the heating user corresponding to node k in period t, C M is the specific heat capacity of indoor air, M k is the indoor air quality of the heating user corresponding to node k, is the indoor temperature of the heating user corresponding to node k in period t+1.
2. The method for evaluating the reliability of energy supply of an integrated energy system according to claim 1, characterized in that: In the Sequential Monte Carlo method, all components adopt a two-state model of working and faulty. The trouble-free working time TTF and the repair time TTR of each component are random variables that obey exponential distribution. The system operation state sequence is obtained based on the random variables.
3. A computer system for evaluating the reliability of energy supply of an integrated energy system, comprising a processor and a memory, wherein the memory stores a computer program, characterized in that: The processor calls the computer program to implement the steps of the integrated energy system energy supply reliability assessment method as described in any one of claims 1-2.
