A method, storage medium and device for suppressing commutation torque pulsation based on shut-off phase current control
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202111325257.0
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2021-11-10
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-29
- Estimated Expiration
- 2041-11-10
AI Technical Summary
[0005]本发明是为了解决目前并没有一种既能克服切换又能有效控制成本的控制方法的问题
[0020] The present invention can simultaneously overcome the two problems of control method switching and design cost increase, namely:
Smart Images

Figure CN114123874B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention belongs to the technical field of motors, and in particular relates to a method for suppressing commutation torque pulsation. Background Art
[0002] Brushless DC motors have high power density, high efficiency, and simple control. They have been applied to various fields, such as high-power fans, high-speed magnetic levitation gyroscopes, underwater robot propulsion motors, drones, electric vehicles, industrial robots, etc. There is torque pulsation during the operation of brushless DC motors, which causes vibration and noise in the motor. The factors causing torque pulsation mainly include current commutation, cogging effect, armature reaction, processing technology, etc. Among them, the maximum value of torque pulsation caused by current commutation can reach 50% of the average torque. Therefore, suppressing the commutation torque pulsation of brushless DC motors can effectively reduce the motor torque pulsation, reduce vibration and noise, and improve the operating performance of the motor, which has important application value.
[0003] The current research methods can be mainly divided into the following types, including PWM modulation method, direct torque control method, advanced control strategy, DC / DC converter method, etc. PWM modulation method, direct torque control method, advanced control strategy and other methods use different control methods during the non-commutation period and the commutation period of the motor, and there is switching of control methods, which increases the control complexity and reduces the reliability of the control method. The DC / DC converter method uses the same control method as the non-commutation period during the motor commutation, avoiding the switching of control methods and improving the stability of the controller. However, the introduction of the DC / DC converter in front of the three-phase inverter increases the design cost.
[0004] In current research methods, it is difficult to find a way to overcome both the switching of control methods and the increase in design costs. Summary of the invention
[0005] The present invention aims to solve the problem that there is currently no control method that can overcome switching and effectively control costs.
[0006] A commutation torque pulsation suppression method based on off-phase current control, when the commutation signal is detected, the commutation signal is delayed by θ d , to achieve the suppression of commutation torque pulsation; θ d is the hysteresis angle of the commutation signal;
[0007] Get the hysteresis angle θ of the commutation signal d The process includes the following steps:
[0008] During motor operation, the motor speed ω is calculated based on the commutation signal, and the back electromotive force E is obtained based on the motor speed ω; then the lag time t is obtained based on the back electromotive force E. d , and according to the motor speed ω and the lag time td Get the commutation signal lag angle θ d .
[0009] Furthermore, the motor is a brushless DC motor.
[0010] Furthermore, the commutation signal lag angle
[0011] Furthermore, the lag time Among them, U dc Indicates the power supply voltage.
[0012] Furthermore, the back electromotive force E=k e ω, k e Represents the back electromotive force coefficient.
[0013] Furthermore, the voltage equation of the motor is as follows:
[0014]
[0015] In the formula, u a 、u b 、u c is the motor terminal voltage, e a 、e b 、e c is the motor back EMF, i a 、i b 、i c is the motor phase current, R is the winding resistance, and L is the winding inductance.
[0016] Furthermore, the electromagnetic torque of the motor
[0017] A storage medium stores at least one instruction, which is loaded and executed by a processor to implement a method for suppressing commutation torque pulsation based on off-phase current control.
[0018] A device comprises a processor and a memory, wherein at least one instruction is stored in the memory, and the at least one instruction is loaded and executed by the processor to implement a method for suppressing commutation torque pulsation based on off-phase current control.
[0019] Beneficial effects:
[0020] The present invention can simultaneously overcome the two problems of control method switching and increased design cost, namely:
[0021] (1) The present invention uses the same control method during commutation and non-commutation, thereby avoiding switching of control methods and improving controller stability;
[0022] (2) The present invention does not require additional hardware, thus reducing design costs. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0023] Figure 1 This is the structure diagram of the motor control system;
[0024] Figure 2 It is the timing diagram of phase current and commutation signal;
[0025] Figure 3 Phase current and back electromotive force under the condition of commutation signal lag;
[0026] Figure 4 It is the equivalent circuit diagram of the commutation process;
[0027] Figure 5 The simulation results of accurate commutation when the speed n = 1500r / min and the load torque TL = 24N·m;
[0028] Figure 6 The simulation results of the commutation with a lag of 11.8 degrees when the speed n = 1500r / min and the load torque TL = 24N·m;
[0029] Figure 7 The simulation results of accurate commutation when the speed n = 1500r / min and the load torque TL = 15N·m;
[0030] Figure 8 The simulation results of the commutation with a lag of 11.8 degrees when the speed n = 1500r / min and the load torque TL = 15N·m;
[0031] Fig. 9 The simulation results of accurate commutation when the speed n = 1400r / min and the load torque TL = 15N·m;
[0032] Fig.10 The simulation results of the commutation with a 4.2 degree lag when the speed n = 1400r / min and the load torque TL = 15N·m;
[0033] Fig.11 The simulation results of accurate commutation when the speed n = 1400r / min and the load torque TL = 24N·m;
[0034] Fig.12 The simulation results of the commutation with a 4.2-degree lag when the speed n = 1400 r / min and the load torque TL = 24 N·m;
[0035] Fig.13 For the experimental environment, Fig.13 (a) is a physical picture of the sensor and controller circuit board. Fig.13 (b) is a physical picture of the load controller. Fig.13(c) is a real picture of the brushless DC motor load;
[0036] Fig.14 is the experimental result corresponding to the speed n = 1200r / min and the load torque TL = 20N·m, where Fig.14 (a) is the accurate commutation experiment result. Fig.14 (b) is the experimental result of 7.8 degree delayed commutation;
[0037] Fig.15 is the experimental result corresponding to the speed n = 1500r / min and the load torque TL = 15N·m, where Fig.15 (a) is the accurate commutation experiment result. Fig.15 (b) is the experimental result of delayed commutation of 11.8 degrees. DETAILED DESCRIPTION Specific implementation method one:
[0039] This embodiment is a method for suppressing commutation torque ripple based on shut-off phase current control.
[0040] The motor control system structure diagram corresponding to the commutation torque pulsation suppression method based on the off-phase current control described in this embodiment is as follows: Figure 1 As shown, Figure 1 Middle,U dc Represents the power supply voltage, VT1-VT6 are the power switches of the three-phase inverter, and VD1-VD6 are diodes.
[0041] Assuming that the motor magnetic circuit is not saturated, the windings are evenly distributed and completely symmetrical, and hysteresis and eddy current losses are ignored, the voltage equation of the motor is:
[0042]
[0043] In the formula, u a 、u b 、u c is the motor terminal voltage, e a 、e b 、e c is the motor back EMF, i a 、i b 、i c is the motor phase current, R is the winding resistance, and L is the winding inductance.
[0044] The electromagnetic torque equation is
[0045]
[0046] Where ω is the mechanical angular velocity.
[0047] Figure 2This is a timing diagram of back electromotive force, phase current, and commutation signal when a brushless DC motor is running. In the figure, Ha, Hb, and Hc represent commutation signals.
[0048] When the commutation signal is delayed, the phase current shows an upward trend in the delay interval. Figure 3 It is the phase diagram of phase current and back electromotive force under the condition of commutation signal lag. Figure 3 In the figure, the 60-degree electrical angle can be divided into three intervals: interval a (t0-t1), the motor is in the normal conduction state; interval b (t1-t2), the commutation signal lag interval, the back electromotive force e a The amplitude of the phase current i a The amplitude increases; in interval c (t2-t3), the motor is in the commutation interval. Among them, the lag time t of the commutation signal d =t2-t1, commutation time t com =t3-t2.
[0049] The method for suppressing commutation torque pulsation based on off-phase current control comprises the following steps:
[0050] During the commutation process, if the on-phase and off-phase currents are modulated by the power switch PWM, the commutation time will inevitably be prolonged.
[0051] The present invention deduces the hysteresis time of the switching signal under the condition that the power switch does not perform PWM modulation (duty cycle D=1) during the switching process. The specific analysis process is given below.
[0052] In the interval c (t2~t3), the motor changes phases, VT1 is turned off, VT3 is turned on, and VT2 remains on. Figure 4 This is the equivalent circuit diagram of the commutation process. In the motor commutation interval, the power switch VT1 is turned off, the a-phase current is continued through VD4, and VT3 and VT2 are modulated. The three-phase terminal voltage satisfies: u a =0,u b =D c U dc ,u c =(1-D c ) dc , D c is the duty cycle of the c interval. Since the PWM frequency is high and the period is much smaller than the time constant of the motor, the influence of the winding resistance can be ignored, and the expression of the voltage equation is
[0053]
[0054] According to formula (3), the expression of the motor midpoint voltage is:
[0055]
[0056] Normally, the motor commutation time is short, and it can be assumed that the magnitude of the back electromotive force remains constant in the commutation interval (t2-t3), that is, e a ≈E α , E α is the reverse electromotive force amplitude during the commutation period. At this time, e b =E,e c =-E, E is the amplitude of the flat-top part of the back electromotive force, such as Figure 3 Substituting the analyzed back electromotive force relationship, equation (4) into equation (3), the expression of the rate of change of the current of phases a and b is solved as follows:
[0057]
[0058] At t2, the motor starts to change phases, and the current of phase a increases from the peak value I p The current amplitude of phase a and phase b starts to decrease, while the current amplitude of phase b starts to increase from 0. According to equation (5), the expressions of the currents of phase a and phase b are:
[0059]
[0060] The time t that the current of phase a decays to 0 can be obtained by solving equation (6): af The time t for the current of phase b to rise from 0 to I (I represents the steady-state value of the current) br The expression is
[0061]
[0062] In order to maintain the non-commutation current constant, t af =t br , calculate the commutation interval duty cycle D according to formula (7) c The expression is
[0063]
[0064] Formula (8) is the duty cycle of the motor commutation interval, where I p With E α is the commutation signal delay time t d The function of I is given below. p With E α The solution process.
[0065] In interval b (t1-t2), this interval is the hysteresis interval of the commutation signal. At this time, the amplitude of the back electromotive force of a begins to decrease. The PWM modulation duty cycle of interval b is defined as D b , then the voltage equation satisfies
[0066]
[0067] from Figure 3It can be seen that in the b interval, the back electromotive force amplitude of a begins to decrease, and the back electromotive force amplitudes of b and c remain constant. The back electromotive force in this interval is expressed as
[0068]
[0069] Where, E represents the amplitude of the flat-top portion of the back electromotive force.
[0070] Substituting equation (10) into equation (9), the expression of the midpoint voltage is
[0071]
[0072] Substituting equations (10) and (11) into equation (9), the expression of the rate of change of phase a current is solved as follows:
[0073]
[0074] When entering interval b, the initial currents of phases a and c satisfy i a =-i c =I, solve the equation, the expression of phase a current is
[0075]
[0076] Expanding equation (13) using Taylor series and ignoring higher order series, equation (13) is simplified to
[0077]
[0078] Substituting equation (10) and equation (14) into equation (2), the electromagnetic torque T in interval b is eb The expression is
[0079]
[0080] The electromagnetic torque T of the motor in interval a ea =2EI / ω, in order to keep the electromagnetic torque constant, T ea =T eb , combined with (15) and T ea =2EI / ω and simplify, duty cycle D in interval b b The expression is
[0081]
[0082] Substituting equation (16) into equation (14), the phase current expression in interval b is simplified to
[0083]
[0084] It is known that the commutation signal delay time is t d , then the phase current ia In t d The peak value is reached at time t d Substituting into formula (17), the peak current I p The expression is
[0085]
[0086] According to the previous analysis, it can be considered that the amplitude of the back electromotive force a remains constant in the commutation interval (t2~t3), that is, e a (t d )=E α , t d Substituting into equation (10), the back electromotive force E in commutation interval a is α It can be approximately expressed as
[0087]
[0088] Let D c =1 and substitute equations (18) and (19) into equation (8), then the lag time t d The expression is
[0089]
[0090] Commutation signal lag angle θ d The expression is
[0091]
[0092] When the motor is running, the controller calculates the motor speed ω according to the commutation signal, and according to E=k e ωCalculate the back electromotive force E, k e Represents the back electromotive force coefficient. Then, according to formula (21), the commutation signal lag angle θ is calculated d When the commutation signal is detected, the commutation signal is delayed by θ d Angle, can effectively reduce the commutation torque pulsation.
[0093] The method proposed by the present invention detects the motor speed and lags the commutation signal by a specific time t d , the off-phase current in the delayed conduction interval increases. When the lag time ends, the motor starts to commutate, the on-phase current begins to increase, and the off-phase current begins to decay. At the end of the commutation process, the on-phase and off-phase currents complete the commutation at the same time, keeping the non-commutation current stable and reducing torque pulsation. In order to shorten the commutation time, the present invention takes the duty cycle of the power switch during the commutation process as the goal to be equal to unity 1, and derives the lag time of the commutation signal.
[0094] Compared with the prior art, the advantages of the present invention are as follows: (1) the same control method is used during commutation and non-commutation, thus avoiding the switching of control methods and improving the stability of the controller; (2) no additional hardware is required, thus reducing the design cost. Specific implementation method 2:
[0096] This embodiment is a storage medium, in which at least one instruction is stored. The at least one instruction is loaded and executed by a processor to implement a method for suppressing commutation torque pulsation based on off-phase current control. Specific implementation method three:
[0098] This embodiment is a device, which includes a processor and a memory, wherein the memory stores at least one instruction, and the at least one instruction is loaded and executed by the processor to implement a method for suppressing commutation torque pulsation based on off-phase current control.
[0099] Example
[0100] 1. Simulation analysis
[0101] In order to verify the effectiveness of the method proposed in the present invention, the present invention has been simulated and experimentally verified. The control system uses the traditional speed and current dual closed-loop control method, with the outer loop being the speed loop and the inner loop being the current loop. The H_PWM_L_PWM modulation mode is used. In order to verify the effectiveness of the method proposed in the present invention, a simulation environment is built using matlab / simulink. The simulation and experiment use the same parameters, as shown in Table 1.
[0102] Torque ripple K r Defined as:
[0103]
[0104] Where, T P-P is the peak-to-peak torque, T avg is the average torque value.
[0105] Table 1 Main parameters of experimental motor
[0106]
[0107] In the simulation, the phase switching from phases a and c to phases b and c is taken as an example for analysis. Figure 5 The simulation results for accurate commutation, speed n = 1500r / min, load torque T L =24N·m. In the figure, i a 、i b 、i c Represents the phase current, T erepresents the electromagnetic torque, VT3 and VT2 represent the control signals of the corresponding power switches. As can be seen from the figure, the turn-off phase current i a The transition process is completed first and decays to 0. At this time, the conducting phase current i b The steady-state value has not yet been reached, resulting in the synthetic non-commutation current i c The amplitude decreases, causing the torque T e Pulsation during the commutation process. In order to maintain the stability of the non-commutation current, the PI regulator controls the power switches VT3 and VT2 to speed up the current rise. At this time, the motor speed is high and the bus voltage is less than 4 times the back electromotive force amplitude. In order to speed up the conduction phase current i b The PI regulator keeps VT3 and VT2 turned on in the switching interval, that is, the duty cycle D c =1. At this time, the PI controller is saturated, but it is still unable to maintain the stability of the non-commutation current. At this time, the average torque T avg =25.2N·m, peak-to-peak torque T p-p =5.4N·m, and the commutation torque ripple K is calculated according to formula (22): r =21.8%.
[0108] Figure 6 The simulation results are shown for the case of 11.8 degrees of delayed commutation. At this time, the speed n = 1500r / min and the load torque T L =24N·m, the hysteresis angle θ at this time is calculated according to formula (21): d = 11.8 degrees. It can be observed from the figure that at the lag θ d During this period, due to the reverse electromotive force a The amplitude decreases. In order to maintain constant torque, the phase current i a The amplitude shows an upward trend in the hysteresis interval. a The amplitude of is increased before commutation so that it is consistent with the conduction phase current i b At the end of commutation, the steady-state value is reached almost simultaneously, resulting in the resultant non-commutation current i c The pulsation is reduced, and the commutation torque pulsation is also suppressed. At this time, the average torque T avg =25.2N·m, peak-to-peak torque T p-p =1.7N·m, torque ripple K r =6.7%. Compared with accurate commutation, the commutation torque ripple K r The method proposed in the present invention is based on the duty cycle D of the power switch during the commutation process. c =1 proposed, but Figure 6 The duty cycle D of the two power switches VT3 and VT2 involved in the phase change is c<1. This is because in the derivation of the commutation signal lag angle, an approximate calculation is performed and the motor winding resistance is ignored, so it is difficult to achieve the duty cycle D c = 1. However, the commutation torque ripple can still be effectively reduced.
[0109] Figure 7 The simulation results for accurate commutation, speed n = 1500r / min, load torque T L =15N·m. As can be seen from the figure, the torque pulsation is obvious during the commutation process, and the power switches VT3 and VT2 involved in the commutation are in a saturated conduction state (D c =1). At this time, the average torque T avg =16.7N·m, peak-to-peak torque T p-p =3.4N·m, torque ripple K r =21.8%. The hysteresis angle θ at this time is calculated according to formula (21): d =11.8 degrees, Figure 8 The speed is n = 1500r / min, the load torque is T L =15N·m under the condition of 11.8 degrees of hysteresis. At this time, the average torque T avg =16.7N·m, peak-to-peak torque T p-p =1.5N·m, torque ripple K r =9.1%. Compared with accurate commutation, the torque ripple K r That’s a drop of about 12.7%.
[0110] Fig. 9 , Fig.10 The speed is n = 1400r / min, the load torque is T L =15N·m when the simulation results of accurate commutation and delayed commutation. Fig.11 , Fig.12 The speed is n = 1400r / min, the load torque is T L =24N·m, the simulation results of accurate commutation and delayed commutation. According to formula (21), the delayed angle θ is calculated as d =4.2 degrees. Comparing the simulation results, we can see that at the lag θ d =4.2 degrees, the commutation torque pulsation decreases significantly. The specific parameters are shown in Table 2.
[0111] Table 2 Torque ripple under different torque load conditions
[0112]
[0113] From the results, it can be seen that the method proposed by the present invention is effective for different speeds and different loads. Although approximate calculation is used, the delayed commutation according to the calculated formula can still effectively suppress the commutation torque ripple.
[0114] 2 Experimental results and analysis:
[0115] In order to verify the effectiveness of the present invention, an experimental environment was established, such as Fig.13 As shown, Fig.13 (a) is a physical picture of the sensor and controller circuit board. Fig.13 (b) is a physical picture of the load controller. Fig.13 (c) is a real picture of the brushless DC motor load. The digital signal processor TMS320F28335 is used as the controller, the DC motor is used as the load, and the main circuit uses an intelligent power module to drive the motor.
[0116] Fig.14 , Fig.15 Comparison results of experiments under different conditions. Fig.14 The speed is n = 1200r / min, the load torque is T L =20N·m, the hysteresis angle θ is calculated according to formula (21) d =7.8 degrees. Torque ripple K when accurate commutation r =15.3%, e.g. Fig.14 (a) shows the hysteresis angle θ d =7.8 degrees, the commutation torque ripple K r =7.4%, such as Fig.14 (b) Compared with accurate commutation, torque ripple K r That’s a drop of about 7.9%. Fig.15 The speed is n = 1500r / min, the load torque is T L =15N·m, the hysteresis angle θ is calculated according to formula (21) d =11.8 degrees. Torque ripple K when accurate commutation r = 38.3%, such as Fig.15 (a) shows the hysteresis angle θ d =11.8 degrees, the commutation torque ripple K r =14.8%, such as Fig.15 (b) Compared with accurate commutation, torque ripple K r It has dropped by about 23.4%. It can be seen from the experimental results that the method proposed by the present invention is effective for different speeds and different loads. Although approximate calculation is used, the delayed commutation according to the calculated formula can still effectively suppress the commutation torque pulsation.
[0117] The present invention may also have many other embodiments. Without departing from the spirit and essence of the present invention, those skilled in the art may make various corresponding changes and modifications based on the present invention, but these corresponding changes and modifications should all fall within the scope of protection of the claims attached to the present invention.
Claims
1. A method for suppressing commutation torque ripple based on off-phase current control, It is characterized in that When the commutation signal is detected, the commutation signal is delayed by θ d , to achieve the suppression of commutation torque pulsation; θ d is the hysteresis angle of the commutation signal; Get the hysteresis angle θ of the commutation signal d The process includes the following steps: During motor operation, the motor speed ω is calculated based on the commutation signal, and the back electromotive force E is obtained based on the motor speed ω; then the lag time t is obtained based on the back electromotive force E. d , and according to the motor speed ω and the lag time t d Get the commutation signal lag angle θ d ; The lag time Among them, U dc Indicates the power supply voltage.
2. A method for suppressing commutation torque ripple based on off-phase current control according to claim 1, It is characterized in that The motor is a brushless DC motor.
3. A method for suppressing commutation torque ripple based on off-phase current control according to claim 1 or 2, It is characterized in that The commutation signal lag angle 4. A method for suppressing commutation torque ripple based on off-phase current control according to claim 3, It is characterized in that The back electromotive force E=k e ω, k e Represents the back electromotive force coefficient.
5. A method for suppressing commutation torque ripple based on off-phase current control according to claim 4, It is characterized in that The voltage equation for the motor is as follows: In the formula, u a 、u b 、u c is the motor terminal voltage, e a 、e b 、e c is the motor back EMF, i a 、i b 、i c is the motor phase current, R is the winding resistance, and L is the winding inductance.
6. A method for suppressing commutation torque ripple based on off-phase current control according to claim 5, It is characterized in that The electromagnetic torque of the motor 7. A storage medium, It is characterized in that The storage medium stores at least one instruction, and the at least one instruction is loaded and executed by the processor to implement a method for suppressing commutation torque pulsation based on off-phase current control as described in any one of claims 1 to 6.
8. A device, It is characterized in that The device includes a processor and a memory, wherein the memory stores at least one instruction, and the at least one instruction is loaded and executed by the processor to implement a method for suppressing commutation torque pulsation based on off-phase current control as described in one of claims 1 to 6.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Delay control method for inhibiting torque ripple of brushless direct-current motor
CN104796050A
Method for suppressing torque pulsation of brushless direct current motor based on delayed Hall signal
CN106059406A
