Ethylene production via ethane oxidative dehydrogenation
By employing a shell-and-tube reactor design with multiple catalyst beds in the ethane oxidative dehydrogenation process, and optimizing the catalyst mass, cooling surface ratio, and linear velocity, the problem of excessive acetic acid byproducts was solved, achieving efficient ethylene production and process intensification.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202280020962.6
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2021-03-15
- Filing Date
- 2022-03-14
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-17
- Estimated Expiration
- 2042-03-14
AI Technical Summary
In the existing technology for producing ethylene from ethane through oxidative dehydrogenation, excessive acetic acid byproducts result in low ethylene yield, and existing catalyst and reactor designs cannot be effectively optimized to achieve process intensification for large-scale industrial applications.
The shell-and-tube reactor design employing multiple catalyst beds achieves efficient ethane conversion and ethylene production by optimizing the ratio of catalyst mass to cooling surface and linear velocity, combined with appropriate cooling media.
It significantly improved ethylene yield and process intensity, ensured reactor stability and safety, and reduced equipment costs and energy consumption.
Smart Images

Figure CN117015433B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] This invention relates to a method and apparatus for producing ethylene via the oxidative dehydrogenation of ethane. Background Technology
[0002] Oxidative dehydrogenation (ODH) of kerosene having two to four carbon atoms is known in principle. In ODH, the kerosene reacts with oxygen to form the corresponding olefins and water, etc. This invention relates to the oxidative dehydrogenation of ethane to ethylene, hereinafter also referred to as ODHE.
[0003] ODH offers advantages over established olefin production processes such as steam cracking or catalytic dehydrogenation. For example, there are no thermodynamic equilibrium constraints due to the exothermic nature of the reactions involved and the almost irreversible formation of water. ODH can be carried out at relatively low reaction temperatures. In principle, catalyst regeneration is not required, as the presence of oxygen enables or induces in-situ regeneration. Finally, compared to steam cracking, it produces significantly less of the worthless byproducts, such as coke.
[0004] For further details on ODH, please refer to relevant literature, such as Ivars, F. and López Nieto, JM, Light Alkanes Oxidation: Targets Reached and Current Challenges, in Duprez, D. and Cavani, F. (eds.), Handbook of Advanced Methods and Processes in Oxidation Catalysis: From Laboratory to Industry, London 2014: Imperial College Press, pp. 767-834, or CA et al, Oxidative Dehydrogenation of Ethane: CommonPrinciples and Mechanistic Aspects, ChemCatChem, vol.5, no.11, 2013, pages 3196-3217, and X. Li, E. Iglesia, Kinetics and Mechanism of Ethane Oxidation to AceticAcid on Catalysts Based on Mo-V-Nb Oxides, J. Phys. Chem. C, 2008, 112, 15001-15008.
[0005] In ODH, under industrially relevant reaction conditions, especially when using MoVNbO-based reactions... x and MoVNbTeO x When using a catalyst, a significant amount of the corresponding carboxylic acid is formed from the kerosene used, particularly acetic acid in the case of ODHE, as a byproduct. Therefore, for economical equipment operation, the co-production of olefins and carboxylic acids is often unavoidable when using the aforementioned catalyst type.
[0006] The potential applications of ODHE are limited by the fact that this byproduct does not always offer a usable option, and for ethylene, significantly larger quantities are typically required. Only in exceptional cases is it possible to directly link ODHE with processes that simultaneously require ethylene and acetic acid, such as in the production of vinyl acetate monomer (VAM), as described in WO 2018 / 114747A1 and WO 2018 / 114752 A1. However, such methods only address the utilization of acetic acid and do not resolve the co-production issue.
[0007] Although WO2018 / 115416A1 describes the possibility of adjusting the product ratio between ethylene and acetic acid in ODHE within certain limits by adjusting the moisture pressure in the product gas as needed, even with appropriate adjustments, a large amount of acetic acid will continue to be produced.
[0008] WO 2018 / 114900 A1 describes reactor geometries for tubular reactors, with a particular requirement for protection of tube geometries with lengths from 4 m to 12 m and diameters from 15 mm to 25 mm. Different catalyst geometries are also disclosed. MoVNbO is used as a catalyst. x The catalyst, and also specifically mentions MoVNbTeO x Catalysts are an option. However, no references were found regarding the effect of parameter variations (e.g., increased linear velocity) on product distribution. WO 2018 / 114900 A1 is set against the backdrop of a reactor system capable of achieving adequate isothermal reaction control with minimal pressure loss. In this context, the document notes that particularly high linear velocities are often detrimental because they lead to increased pressure loss, which is especially harmful in low-pressure processes such as ODHE. Therefore, in another document, US 9,963,412 B2 or WO 2015 / 082598 A1, the linear velocity is limited to 500 cm / s, as claimed.
[0009] WO 2020 / 074750 A1 contains details of a pilot-scale test conducted in a single-tube reactor with a diameter of 19 mm and a length of 5.6 m. The subject matter disclosed in this document relates to compositions of inert fractions in process gases. No information is given regarding linear velocity; furthermore, in all three experiments conducted, the conditions remained virtually unchanged except for the inert composition and reactor temperature.
[0010] WO 2017 / 144584 A1 discloses a method and related reaction system for the oxidative dehydrogenation of alkanes, preferably ethane or propane, more preferably ethane, having 2 to 6 carbon atoms. Specifically, a method is provided comprising supplying a feed gas containing alkane and oxygen to a reactor vessel including upstream and downstream catalyst beds. Furthermore, the feed gas is contacted with an oxidative dehydrogenation catalyst in the upstream catalyst bed, and subsequently contacted with an oxidative dehydrogenation / oxidation catalyst in the downstream catalyst bed to obtain a reactor effluent containing olefins. An upstream coolant is supplied from an upstream coolant loop to the upstream shell space of the reactor vessel, and a downstream coolant is supplied from a downstream coolant loop to the downstream shell space of the reactor vessel.
[0011] US2016 / 304432 A1 relates to a method for the oxidative dehydrogenation of alkanes comprising 2 to 6 carbon atoms and / or for the oxidation of olefins comprising 2 to 6 carbon atoms, wherein an oxygen and an alkane and / or olefin gas stream are contacted with a mixed metal oxide catalyst comprising molybdenum, vanadium, niobium and optionally tellurium, and wherein the linear velocity of the gas stream is at least 10 cm / s.
[0012] According to WO 93 / 01155A1, a method for producing maleic anhydride by catalytic oxidation of a non-aromatic hydrocarbon having at least four carbon atoms in its straight chain is known, wherein a gas containing oxygen and hydrocarbons is passed through a fixed catalyst bed in a tubular reactor. The activity of the catalyst bed is graded.
[0013] In summary, it can be said that the catalyst optimizations and process optimizations known to date have only led to limited improvements in ethylene yield. Therefore, further measures beyond the existing technology are needed, which to date only allows for adjustments to co-products or the use of two products in downstream processes, to a certain extent, as needed.
[0014] Therefore, the object of this invention is to provide reactor setups and operating conditions that enable maximum ODH-E process enhancement under large-scale conditions, with particular focus on optimized ethylene yield. Summary of the Invention
[0015] The above-mentioned objectives are achieved by methods and systems having the features of the respective independent claims. Preferred embodiments of the invention are the dependent patent claims and the subject matter described below.
[0016] Before explaining the features and advantages of the present invention, other basic principles of the invention will be explained first, and the terminology used to describe the invention will be introduced.
[0017] As is customary in the art, catalyst mass is understood herein to mean, for example, the mass of active catalyst material expressed in kg (i.e., without inert particulate or support material and / or inert binder components), see also the explanation below regarding the catalyst bed used.
[0018] Weight hourly space velocity (WHSV) is the amount of gas (expressed in kg) containing reactants, including possible inert gas additives, passing through a given amount of catalyst (expressed in kg) per hour. Therefore, WHSV is equal to the quotient of the mass flow rate (expressed in kg / h) and the mass of the active catalyst (expressed in kg), or kg gas / (kg catalyst × h). This definition corresponds to the convention used in WO 2015 / 082602A1.
[0019] Linear velocity is defined as the amount of free space available for flow in the catalyst bed, the velocity (expressed in cm / s) of the gas flow along the axial direction or along the flow path through the reactor or reaction tube. Therefore, linear velocity, expressed in m / h, is the gas volumetric flow rate (in m³ / h) at the start of the active catalyst bed. 3 / h (represented) divided by the internal cross-sectional area of the reaction tube (in m) 2 The value is calculated by dividing the linear velocity (in meters per second) by the average porosity (dimensionless) in the catalyst bed. This definition corresponds to the convention used in WO 2015 / 082598 A1. The linear velocity is converted from the unit m / h to the unit cm / s used for numerical data in this application through normal mathematical conversion.
[0020] The term shell-and-tube reactor describes a type of chemical reactor in which an exothermic reaction (in this case, oxidative dehydrogenation) takes place in the gas phase. The gas mixture to be reacted is converted by means of a catalyst in several fluidly connected in parallel and typically straight, and particularly vertical, tubes, with one or more cooling media (particularly molten salt) flowing around the tubes in an outer container (shell).
[0021] As used herein, the term catalyst bed refers to a bed or solid structure comprising catalyst material and optionally an inert material as a support or binder. Furthermore, at least a portion of the catalyst bed may optionally comprise inert bulk particles. When multiple catalyst beds are involved, they may be arranged one after another in the flow direction, with or without intermediate regions, particularly inert regions without catalyst material. Typically, the flow direction of the gas containing the reactants corresponds in the present case to the axial direction of the reaction tube.
[0022] Throughout this text, the ratio of the total length of the multiple catalyst beds between the ends of one or more reaction tubes to the diameter of each reaction tube is referred to repeatedly, also simply as the "total length-to-diameter ratio." Here, the total length of the multiple catalyst beds between the ends of one or more reaction tubes should be understood as the length occupied by a single reaction tube or multiple (active) catalyst beds within each reaction tube. If there is no catalyst-free region, this corresponds at most to the total length between the ends of the respective reaction tubes. For the above values, (only) those regions where the active catalyst material is provided at a mass fraction greater than 1%, 2%, or 5% are always considered. In the case of multiple catalyst beds or catalyst layers, their lengths are summed. In commonly used vertical shell-and-tube reactors, the length or total length of the reaction tubes is equal to the height or total height of the reaction tubes. The diameter should be understood as the inner diameter of the respective reaction tube under consideration.
[0023] The effective or highly efficient cooling surface of one or more reaction tubes (the terms "effective" and "highly efficient" are used synonymously herein) refers, respectively, to the sum of all the inner surfaces of the reactor tubes surrounding the catalytically active layer (with the minimum mass fraction of the active catalyst material just mentioned) in one or more reaction tubes. Therefore, the inner surfaces of the reactor tubes surrounding the inert layer or empty reactor tube sections are not included here. In this context, the effective or highly efficient cooling surface of a single catalyst bed should be understood as either the inner surface of the reaction tube or the inner surface of the reactor tube surrounding the active layer. Since multiple catalyst beds exist, the effective or highly efficient cooling surfaces of these catalyst beds are the sum of the inner surfaces of the reaction tubes surrounding these multiple catalyst beds. These can be continuous or discontinuous, especially the latter if the catalytically active catalyst bed is discontinuous by inert beds, empty tube sections, etc.
[0024] "Active catalyst mass" can specifically refer to the total mass of the catalyst in the corresponding catalyst bed. If there is an intentional or unintentional uneven distribution of catalyst mass in the catalyst bed, this is not important, as the total mass of the active catalyst is considered here.
[0025] The ratio of the active catalyst mass to the effective cooling surface can be defined as a single value for a single catalyst bed or a reaction tube with only one catalyst bed. In this case, it is the quotient of two quantities (i.e., the active catalyst mass in the catalyst bed and its effective cooling surface) that are associated with the catalyst bed or reaction tube under consideration and determined according to the previously given definition.
[0026] In the case of one or more reaction tubes having multiple catalyst beds, for this one or more tubes, the average ratio of the active catalyst mass to the effective cooling surface can be further considered. In particular, this average ratio is calculated by taking the quotient between the sum of the active catalyst masses of all catalytically active beds in one or more reaction tubes and the sum of the inner surfaces of all reactor tubes surrounding these catalytically active beds in one or more reaction tubes.
[0027] As explained below with reference to specific embodiments, the area-specific ethylene yield can be used as a measure of the process strength of a process for producing ethylene from ethane via oxidative dehydrogenation in a shell-and-tube reactor, and should be understood here as the ethylene yield per effective cooling surface (see immediately preceding). Specifically, the area-specific ethylene yield is expressed in kg ethylene per hour per square meter of effective cooling surface, in units of kg / (h × m²). 2 This metric is particularly significant because the total cooling surface area provided in the reactor is crucial for reactor construction and investment costs. A higher area-to-ethylene yield, i.e., higher process intensity in the sense understood here, allows for higher yields with the same installed cooling surface, resulting in desired process intensification and positively impacting the economics of the production facility. The term process intensification is used to describe an increase in process strength.
[0028] Features and advantages of the present invention
[0029] Surprisingly, in the context of this invention, it has been recognized that, under certain conditions, significant process intensification can be achieved for large-scale reactors compared to existing technologies, while maintaining high stability and safety of process control.
[0030] The example given in US 9,963,412 B2 illustrates linear velocity values less than 100 cm / s. No mention is made of the accompanying formation of acetic acid. Therefore, the aforementioned literature does not draw any conclusions regarding a particularly advantageous velocity range for ethylene / acetic acid co-production. Furthermore, no conclusions regarding a preferred velocity range for a commercial-scale reactor can be drawn from the laboratory-scale examples mentioned in that publication. The same applies to, for example, US 10,017,432 B2, where a preferred range of weight-dependent space-time velocities is given solely based on laboratory tests.
[0031] In fact, laboratory reactors differ significantly from reactors used in large-scale equipment, particularly in terms of the overall length-to-diameter ratio of the aforementioned one or more reaction zones. In this respect, the example shown in the just cited literature has a ratio of less than 100. However, within the scope of this invention, reactors having the aforementioned overall length-to-diameter ratio of one or more reaction zones relevant to large-scale applications are considered.
[0032] As further explained below with reference to the accompanying drawings, some of the data determined by the prior art are compared with the data according to the present invention. At the aforementioned relatively low overall length-to-diameter ratio of less than 100, the methods proposed in the prior art and the examples given therein result in approximately 2 kg / (h×m). 2 The yield of ethylene.
[0033] Similar degree of process intensification can be achieved with industrial-scale reactors and an overall length-to-diameter ratio of 200 to 300 for one or more reaction zones, as disclosed and experimentally confirmed in, for example, WO 2018 / 115416 A1. This also applies to pilot-scale operations in the prior art. WO 2018 / 115416A1 further indicates that the specific ethylene yield can be increased to approximately 2.5 kg / (h×m²) by increasing the flow rate and corresponding temperature adjustments. 2 The value of ) is shown. However, it can be seen that the increase achieved in this method is relatively flat because at higher flow rates, the maximum ethane conversion must be reduced, otherwise reactor runaway cannot be avoided. Due to this thermal limitation, further increases in ethane loading will therefore result in relatively smaller increases in process intensity.
[0034] In WO 2019 / 243480 A1, it was shown that significant process enhancement can be achieved by using a three-layer catalyst bed compared to a single-layer catalyst bed. Here, the specific ethylene yield was also achieved to a high level of 2.5 kg / (h×m²). 2 The value of ). Again, refer to the explanation of the attached diagram for further details.
[0035] An overall assessment of the data from the aforementioned publications indicates that the linear velocity required for large-scale reactors to achieve similar ethylene yields is significantly higher than that required for laboratory reactors.
[0036] For example, the values given in US 9,963,412 B2 are therefore not suitable for direct transfer to large-scale reactors. It also shows that, in comparisons between single-layer and three-layer catalyst beds, the same or better process intensity can be achieved at lower linear velocities. Therefore, catalyst bed design is highly relevant, especially at industrial scale.
[0037] Similar concepts apply to weight-dependent spacetime velocities, as explained in more detail with reference to the accompanying figures, since the same level of process intensity can be achieved in large-scale reactors at much lower weight-dependent spacetime velocities than in the laboratory. Incidentally, a comparison of data from US 10,017,432 B2 and US 9,963,412 B2 also indicates that a clear relationship cannot be established between weight-dependent spacetime velocities and achievable process intensity.
[0038] This invention generally relates to a method for producing ethylene from ethane via oxidative dehydrogenation using a shell-and-tube reactor having reaction tubes extending between a first end and a second end, wherein multiple catalyst beds are arranged in each reaction tube, and the ratio of the total length of the multiple catalyst beds between the first and second ends in each reaction tube to the diameter of each reaction tube (i.e., the total length-to-diameter ratio of one or more reaction zones) has a value between 150 and 400, particularly between 200 and 280. Therefore, this invention explicitly relates to large-scale tube-and-tube reactors associated with large-scale industrial applications. When referred to herein as “reaction tube,” this can also refer to a subset of all existing reaction tubes. In other words, the statement that “each reaction tube” is designed in a certain way may also mean that each reaction tube of such a subset can be designed accordingly, but not all reaction tubes need to be designed in this way.
[0039] According to the present invention, the shell-and-tube reactor operates at a linear velocity of 250, 300, 400, or 500 cm / s to 800 cm / s, and the plurality of catalyst beds are further configured such that the average ratio of the active catalyst mass to the effective cooling surface of the plurality of catalyst beds in each reaction tube is 1.5 kg / m. 2 Up to 5kg / m 2 Especially 2kg / m 2 Up to 4kg / m 2 Within the range. In other words, in this invention, multiple reaction tubes are provided, wherein each reaction tube has more than one catalyst bed, and all catalyst beds are surrounded by the inner surface of the respective reaction tube. Here, the ratio of the total mass of active catalyst in all catalyst beds in the reaction tube to the total inner surface area of the reaction tube surrounding all the considered catalyst beds is within 1.5 kg / m². 2 Up to 5kg / m 2 Within the range.
[0040] For example, in an embodiment of the invention, if there are n reaction tubes (which may be a subset of the total m reaction tubes in the entire reactor), each of these n reaction tubes may have x catalyst beds, then each of the x catalyst beds is surrounded by y inner surfaces of the n reaction tubes that contain the x catalyst beds. In this case, n and x can be independent integers greater than 1, where y equals x. The total active catalyst mass of all x catalyst beds divided by the sum of the y inner surfaces gives the average ratio (when x is greater than 1).
[0041] Therefore, according to the present invention, in a reaction tube having more than one catalyst bed with different activities and / or compositions, in embodiments of the present invention, it is possible that the ratio of the active catalyst mass to the effective cooling surface, calculated individually for each bed, is within the aforementioned 1.5 kg / m². 2 Up to 5kg / m2 Especially 2kg / m 2 Up to 4kg / m 2 The range is outside of that range, but the average ratio of the reaction tubes is within that range.
[0042] In embodiments of the invention, as expressed in other words, the average ratio of the active catalyst mass to the effective cooling surface at the plurality of catalyst beds in each reaction tube can be the quotient between the sum of the active catalyst masses in all the respective catalyst beds and the sum of the masses of all the inner surfaces of the reaction tube surrounding these catalyst beds.
[0043] According to the present invention, a shell-and-tube reactor having multiple reaction tubes is used, wherein multiple catalyst beds are disposed in each reaction tube. In addition to the range of the average ratio of active catalyst mass to effective cooling surface explained above and below (and corresponding embodiments), it is also specified that, in each case, at least one catalyst bed considered individually also has a ratio of active catalyst mass to effective cooling surface (for that bed) within this range, i.e., particularly within 1.5 kg / m³. 2 Up to 5kg / m 2 Within the range.
[0044] Preferably, the shell-and-tube reactor used according to the invention is a shell-and-tube reactor with a fixed catalyst bed in each individual reaction tube. To achieve overall economic efficiency and improved operational reliability, according to the invention, a single reaction tube is therefore equipped with multiple catalyst beds, particularly 1, 2, 3, 4, or 5 catalyst beds with different activities and / or compositions. Cooling or heating is carried out using a suitable cooling medium, particularly hot oil or preferably molten salt, thereby proceeding in a co-current or counter-current manner with the flow direction of the reaction feed, preferably counter-current.
[0045] On the one hand, different reaction zones can be achieved through catalyst layers of varying activity (with activity increasing in the direction of the reaction feed flow) and / or through different cooling zones, i.e., different coolant or molten salt circuits (in each case, these are either co-current or counter-current, if necessary). For example, the reactor can be designed as shown in WO 2019 / 243480 A1.
[0046] Typical operating conditions are given in WO 2018 / 115416A1 and WO 2018 / 115418 A1 and Tables 1A and 1B below.
[0047] The advantageous combination of reaction conditions and structural design proposed according to the present invention describes for the first time a combination of design variables (i.e., the aspect ratio of the catalyst bed and the ratio of catalyst mass to cooling surface) and operating parameters (i.e., particularly the linear velocity) for large-scale reactor operation, which significantly increases the process intensity of oxidative dehydrogenation of ethane. According to the present invention, it is recognized that significant improvements in process intensification are only possible within a very specific range spanned by multiple parameters.
[0048] See the attached figures below (especially the following). Figure 5 and Figure 6 (and related explanations), strong process enhancement was achieved only for a mid-range range of the ratio of the required catalyst mass to the cooling surface by increasing the linear velocity. In contrast, there is no potential for further increasing the yield under conditions where each cooling surface selected in the prior art has a high specific catalyst loading.
[0049] Of particular surprise is the fact that, in the design according to the invention, thermal runaway is not expected even for very high specific ethylene yields. For all considerations based on a 20 mm tube diameter, ethane conversion exceeding 50% is always achieved, with a maximum temperature rise of less than 45 K at the hot spot (i.e., the hottest point in the corresponding reaction tube) relative to the outlet temperature of the coolant used (here, particularly molten salt).
[0050] Reactors with a tube diameter of 26 mm typically result in higher temperature rises in the catalyst bed, which could potentially lead to thermal runaway at the highest reactor loading point if the coolant temperature increases further. Therefore, only through appropriate catalyst bed design and a suitable catalyst mass-to-cooling surface ratio can the potential for increased linear velocity be fully realized.
[0051] The effects of the reaction control according to the present invention can be vividly described based on the effects explained below.
[0052] With its higher linear velocity, the ODHE reactor can operate at higher reaction temperatures, but still within the moderate range of 450°C to 500°C. The higher reaction temperature is crucial for improving both conversion and ethylene selectivity. On the one hand, this results in a sharp increase in specific ethylene yield with increasing feed loading (see, in particular...). Figure 9 (and related explanations). Not being too bound by theory, the explanation for this is given in WO 2019 / 243480A1. This effect can also be reproduced in the context of this invention.
[0053] A moderate average catalyst loading per cooling surface is beneficial for heat removal, especially in hot spots, thus achieving greater reaction stability in terms of thermal runaway. However, at large-scale production rates, this ratio must exceed 1.5, preferably 2, to ensure economical operation.
[0054] High linear velocities can be achieved by increasing the total volumetric flow rate while keeping the composition at the catalyst bed inlet constant, or, in particular, by selecting a reaction tube with the smallest possible diameter. However, the latter must still be large enough to allow a sufficient amount of commercial catalyst bulk to be loaded into the reaction tube or across its cross-section in order to keep the bypass flow rate as low as possible and the catalyst utilization as high as possible.
[0055] If the tube cross-section is too small, it means that the effective diameter of the catalyst body must also be significantly reduced, resulting in an unacceptable high pressure drop on the corresponding tube.
[0056] If the tube cross-section is too large, the gas loading, and therefore the catalyst loading, will have to be increased too much to achieve a high linear velocity in order to keep the ethane conversion within an economically reasonable range. This is related to the very strong thermal conditioning of the reaction and the low heat dissipation of the cooling medium from the tube to the reactor due to the large tube cross-section. This increases the risk of thermal runaway. Therefore, cooled tube bundle reactors are used, wherein the inner diameter of the individual tubes is preferably 10 mm to 32 mm, particularly 12 mm to 26 mm, and especially 15 mm to 21 mm.
[0057] If necessary, the linear velocity can also be increased by increasing the total feed gas flow while altering the initial composition of the catalyst bed. To avoid excessive thermal conditioning of the reaction, the increase in gas loading can be achieved, in particular, by diluting with an inert gas. In this case, a gas or gas mixture from the group consisting of rare gases (i.e., He, Ne, Ar, Kr, or Xe), carbon dioxide, nitrogen, or methane can be used as the inert gas. However, carbon dioxide, nitrogen, or methane is particularly suitable for the process. In particular, high linear velocities can be achieved by combining the dilution of the reactant gas with the use of the smallest possible reaction tube cross-section. Further increases in the water (vapor) content of the reactant gas beyond what is required for catalyst stability, as described in WO 2018 / 115418 A1, should be avoided in order to maintain the ethylene selectivity advantage achievable according to the invention.
[0058] This invention significantly enhances the economic benefits of ODHE technology because, for the same equipment capacity, the reactor can be constructed to be smaller (see Tables 1A and 1B for the number and length of individual tubes in a shell-and-tube reactor) and has a smaller heat exchange surface, resulting in higher process strength. Furthermore, it facilitates the implementation of technologies with larger equipment capacities (for ethylene products).
[0059] In a particularly advantageous embodiment of the invention, the shell-and-tube reactor is operated at a weight-dependent space-time velocity of more than 3 kg or 5 kg and less than 20 kg of feed per hour per kg of catalyst. The specific advantages of this operating mode and its various aspects, as further indicated below, arise particularly in combination with further features according to the invention and are provided according to advantageous embodiments, and are explained below with reference to the accompanying drawings.
[0060] According to the invention, the linear velocity used in the shell-and-tube reactor is advantageously greater than 250, 300, 400 or 500 cm / s, but less than 800 cm / s.
[0061] Advantageously, operating the shell-and-tube reactor allows the highest temperature in the multiple catalyst beds to be below 500°C or 450°C.
[0062] In shell-and-tube reactors, multiple catalyst beds advantageously utilize packing materials selected from rings (particularly Raschig rings), pellets (particularly cylindrical pellets), and extrudates, or combinations thereof. In particular, extrudates can have high surface areas, which can be achieved through appropriate geometries such as so-called cloverleaf structures.
[0063] In the method according to the invention, multiple catalyst beds with different catalyst activities are used, such as those disclosed in WO2019 / 243480 A1 and those already mentioned above.
[0064] A particularly advantageous embodiment of the invention includes metering water (vapor) (hereinafter also referred to as water feed) added to the feed stream of the shell-and-tube reactor based on catalyst activity detected in the reactor (e.g., determined by measured temperature), as also disclosed in WO 2018 / 115418A1. The metering of the water feed can also be used to control the product ratio between ethylene and acetic acid, as disclosed in WO 2018 / 115416A1, particularly based on the water pressure determined in the product gas at the reactor outlet.
[0065] A method according to a particularly preferred embodiment of the invention includes flowing one or more cooling media through a shell-and-tube reactor to cool different regions of the reactor, particularly to different degrees.
[0066] An apparatus for producing ethylene via the oxidative dehydrogenation of ethane is also an object of the present invention, comprising a shell-and-tube reactor having a reaction tube extending between a first end and a second end. Multiple catalyst beds are disposed in each reaction tube, and the ratio of the total length of the multiple catalyst beds between the first and second ends in each reaction tube to the diameter of each reaction tube is between 150 and 400. According to the present invention, the shell-and-tube reactor of the apparatus is configured to operate at a linear velocity of 250 cm / s to 800 cm / s, and the multiple catalyst beds are configured such that the ratio of the active catalyst mass to the effective cooling surface is 1.5 kg / m². 2 Up to 5kg / m 2 Within this range. In at least one catalyst bed in each reaction tube, considered individually, the ratio of active catalyst mass to effective cooling surface area falls within this range. Multiple catalyst beds in each reaction tube exhibit different catalytic activities.
[0067] With regard to the apparatus and its features provided according to the invention, explicit reference is made to the above explanation of the method according to the invention, since these relate to the corresponding apparatus in the same manner. This is equally applicable to embodiments in which the corresponding apparatus is advantageously configured to perform the corresponding method in any implementation.
[0068] One embodiment of the method according to the invention includes oxidative dehydrogenation at a catalyst temperature in the range of 240°C to 500°C, preferably 280°C to 450°C.
[0069] In another embodiment, one or more reactors are used for oxidative dehydrogenation, and the total pressure of the reaction feed stream at the reactor inlet is selected in the range of 1 to 10 bar (absolute value), preferably 2 to 7 bar (absolute value).
[0070] Advantageously, the water content of the reaction feed stream is in the range of 5 vol% to 95 vol%, particularly 10 vol% to 50 vol%, and especially 14 vol% to 35 vol%. The molar ratio of water to ethane in the reaction feed stream can be at least 0.23.
[0071] The catalyst used may contain at least the elements molybdenum, vanadium, niobium, and optionally tellurium, particularly in the form of mixed oxides.
[0072] The present invention will be further explained below with reference to specific embodiments and comparative examples, in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, which illustrate one embodiment of the invention. Brief description of the attached diagram
[0074] Figures 1 to 9 The data determined according to the present invention and the comparative data not based on the present invention are shown in the form of charts.
[0075] Figure 10An apparatus for producing ethylene by oxidative dehydrogenation of ethane according to one embodiment of the present invention is shown.
[0076] Detailed description of the attached diagram
[0077] Figures 1 to 9 The data obtained according to the present invention and the comparative data not based on the present invention are shown in the form of charts.
[0078] As mentioned above, prior art laboratory reactors, such as those used according to US10,017,432B2 and US 9,963,412B2, have a side-length ratio of less than 100. However, in the context of this invention, the focus is on reactors with a side-length ratio between 150 and 400, which is particularly relevant for large-scale applications.
[0079] Figure 1 Data determined based on the repeatedly mentioned disclosure of US 10,017,432B2 (hereinafter referred to as Publication 1) is shown, along with further data determined based on the repeatedly mentioned disclosure of US 9,963,412 B2 (Publication 2). Additionally, data determined based on the mentioned WO 2020 / 074750A1 (Publication 3) is shown. Data from Publication 1 is shown in the form of circles, where solid circles represent data from comparative examples. Data from Publication 2 is shown in the form of triangles, where solid circles represent data from comparative examples. Squares on one side correspond to data from the pilot-scale device disclosed in Publication 3 or therein. Data determined based on WO 2018 / 115416 A1 (Publication 4) is shown as rhombuses or oblique squares connected by lines.
[0080] Figure 1 The charts in the figure and all subsequent charts show the specific ethylene yield, mentioned several times above, as a measure of process intensification on the vertical axis; that is, the ethylene yield per effective cooled surface, in kg / (h×m²). 2 ). Figure 1 The horizontal axis displays the total length / diameter ratio in dimensionless units.
[0081] Figure 1 This indicates that the positive examples (hollow circles and triangles) based on laboratory data in publications 1 and 2 above result in a specific ethylene yield of approximately 2 kg / (h×m) at a small aspect ratio of less than 100. 2 ).
[0082] For industrial-scale reactors and aspect ratios of 200 to 300, a slightly higher level of process strength can also be achieved, with a specific ethylene yield of approximately 2.5 kg / (h×m). 2 This can also be demonstrated by data from publications such as 4 (diagonal square) and 3 (horizontal square).
[0083] Apart from Figure 1 In addition to the data already explained, Figure 2 Data obtained under different reaction tube diameters according to WO 2019 / 243480 A1 (Publication 5) are also shown. The data are presented in the form of a vertical cross, where the data point in the lower left corresponds to a reaction tube diameter of 26 mm, and the data point in the upper right corresponds to a reaction tube diameter of 20 mm. Publication 5 shows that significant process enhancement can be achieved by using a three-layer catalyst bed compared to a single-layer bed. The corresponding data points were determined under these conditions. The vertical axis corresponds to... Figure 1 The vertical axis is shown. On the horizontal axis, the feed load for each cooling surface is expressed in kg / (h×m). 2 The expression is given as the quotient between the feed gas mass flow rate and the effective cooling surface.
[0084] As can also be seen from the data in Publication 4 (diagonal square), by increasing the flow rate and adjusting the temperature accordingly, the specific ethylene yield can be increased to approximately 2.5 kg / (h×m). 2 Furthermore, according to Publication 5 (vertical cross), the specific ethylene yield can reach as high as 2.5 kg / (h×m). 2 The value of ). However, it can be particularly seen that the increase achieved in this case is relatively flat, because at higher flow rates (test point 56 according to Publication 4), the maximum ethane conversion is low, since reactor runaway cannot be avoided otherwise. Due to this limitation, further increases in ethane loading will result in relatively smaller increases in process intensification.
[0085] Figure 3 It shows Figure 2 The data has already been explained, with linear velocity expressed in cm / s shown on the horizontal axis. Data from Publication 5 is again shown in a crosshair, with the upper left data point corresponding to a reaction tube diameter of 20 mm and the lower right data point corresponding to a reaction tube diameter of 26 mm.
[0086] from Figure 3 It can be seen that the linear velocity required for large-scale reactors to achieve similar ethylene yields is significantly higher than that required for laboratory reactors. The linear velocity was determined using the definition given in Publication 2. The values given in Publication 2 are not suitable for direct transfer to large-scale reactors. It is also shown that, in a comparison between single-bed and three-bed reactors (according to the vertical cross in Publication 5), the same or better process strength can be achieved at lower linear velocities. Therefore, as already explained, the design of the catalyst bed is highly relevant, especially at industrial scale.
[0087] Figure 4 It shows Figure 2 and Figure 3The data already explained are presented on the horizontal axis as kg gas / (kg catalyst × h). Data from Publication 5 are again represented in a crosshair, with the lower left data point corresponding to a 26 mm reaction tube diameter and the upper right data point corresponding to a 20 mm reaction tube diameter.
[0088] Figure 4 This indicates that, for example, according to Figure 3 The linear velocity, and the distinction between laboratory and large-scale reactors, also apply to WHSV, because in large-scale reactors, the same level of process intensity can be achieved with a much lower WHSV than in the laboratory. Furthermore, a comparison of the data (circles and triangles) in publications 1 and 2 also indicates that a clear relationship cannot be established between WHSV and achievable process intensity.
[0089] Now, the present invention allows for further process intensification of large-scale reactors in embodiments according to the invention, while maintaining the maximum possible stability and safety of process control.
[0090] Figure 5 The chart shows the previous targets Figures 1 to 4 The data is part of the interpretation, in which linear velocity, expressed in cm / s, is plotted on the horizontal axis.
[0091] Again, data obtained according to the invention are shown in the form of a vertical cross for tube diameters of 26 mm (a curve starting at approximately 2.2 on the vertical axis and ending at approximately 7.5 on the vertical axis) and 20 mm (a curve starting at approximately 2.5 on the vertical axis and ending at approximately 8.9 on the vertical axis). The risk of thermal runaway increases at the location enclosed by the dashed rectangle.
[0092] Figure 6 Again, it is shown in a chart. Figure 5 The data shown, where the graph is plotted on the horizontal axis in kg / m³ 2 The specific catalyst loading is represented for each cooled surface.
[0093] Again, data obtained according to the invention are shown in the form of a vertical cross, with tube diameters of 26 mm (for the higher value on the horizontal axis) and 20 mm (for the lower value on the horizontal axis). The risk of thermal runaway increases at the locations enclosed by the dashed rectangles.
[0094] exist Figure 7 middle, Figure 6 The data shown is supplemented by data (horizontal squares) obtained from publication 3, and has the same representation in all other respects.
[0095] Especially from Figure 5 and Figure 6In summary, it is evident that by increasing the linear velocity, strong process enhancement is achieved only within the intermediate range of the catalyst mass / cooling surface ratio claimed according to the present invention. Figure 7 It was also shown that even under conditions with high specific catalyst loading for each cooling surface selected according to Publication 3, there was no potential to demonstrate further increases in yield.
[0096] Of particular surprise is the fact that, in the design according to the invention, thermal runaway is not expected even at very high specific ethylene yields. For all considerations regarding the 20 mm reactor tube, ethane conversion exceeding 50% was consistently achieved, with a maximum hotspot temperature rise of less than 45 K compared to the salt outlet temperature. For the 26 mm reactor tube, the higher temperature rise typically causes the catalyst bed to start from the point of highest reactor load, which could also lead to thermal runaway if the salt temperature increases further.
[0097] Therefore, it is evident that only through appropriate catalyst bed design, and with a suitable ratio of catalyst mass to cooling surface, can the potential for increasing linear velocity be fully realized.
[0098] When observing Figure 8 and Figure 9 This can also be seen in time, and Figure 2 In comparison, Figure 8 In the case of [the situation], the data obtained according to the present invention (cross, upper data point corresponding to a pipe diameter of 20 mm in each case) is supplemented, and [further details are needed]. Figure 9 In this case, further information is provided based on data from Publication 3. For these designs, an almost linear increase in specific ethylene yield can be achieved with increasing loading, up to a very high range. This contrasts particularly sharply with the rather flat increase described for monolayer beds with a high catalyst mass to cooling surface ratio.
[0099] Tables 1A and 1B show reactor data comparing reaction parameters and product performance for standard design (basic case) and several comparative cases at high linear velocities for tube diameters of 20 mm (Table 1A) and 26 mm (Table 1B), respectively. The catalyst used was a MoVNbTe-based mixed oxide supported on a ring-shaped support. The catalyst beds were 6.6 m (26 mm tube) and 4.6 m (20 mm tube) long, respectively, and were filled into three layers of different activities, with activity increasing along the flow direction. For the same tube diameter, the length of the different activity zones, catalyst particle geometry, and activity level were the same. Upstream of the catalyst bed was an inert material bed (1.4 m long, also a ring of the same size), which served as a preheating zone.
[0100] As previously stated, according to the present invention, for reaction tubes having multiple layers or catalyst beds, the ratio of active catalyst mass to effective cooling surface calculated individually for a single layer or catalyst bed may be outside the range provided by the average ratio of active catalyst mass to effective cooling surface for the reaction tube in the corresponding embodiments of the present invention. This also applies, for example, to the reactor tube design given herein as an example:
[0101] In the case of a 20 mm diameter tube, the average ratio of active catalyst mass to effective cooling surface area in the three catalyst beds is 2.33 (see Table 1A), while the ratios of the catalyst beds arranged along the flow direction are 0.91, 1.83, and 4.11, respectively. Therefore, the ratio of the first catalyst bed here is less than 1.5.
[0102] In the case of a 26 mm diameter tube, the average ratio of active catalyst mass to effective cooling surface area in the three catalyst beds is 3.84 (see Table 1B), while the ratios for catalyst beds arranged along the flow direction are 2.44, 3.74, and 5.35, respectively. Therefore, the ratio of the last catalyst bed here is higher than 1.5.
[0103] Table 1A - Reactor diameter 20mm, reactor length 6m, total height of active layer 4.6m, total length-to-diameter ratio 230, active catalyst mass 0.675kg.
[0104]
[0105] Table 1B - Reactor diameter 26mm, reactor length 8.05m, total height of active layer 6.6m, total length-to-diameter ratio 254, active catalyst mass 2.07kg.
[0106]
[0107]
[0108] Figure 10 An apparatus for producing ethylene by oxidative dehydrogenation of ethane according to an embodiment of the present invention is shown in a highly simplified diagram and is designated as 100. The entire apparatus is shown schematically only.
[0109] System 100 has a shell-and-tube reactor 10 with multiple, and only partially indicated, reaction tubes 11, to which an ethane-containing gas mixture, obtained in any manner, is fed in the form of material stream A. Material stream A may be taken from a distillation unit (not shown). Material stream A may, for example, be taken from a distillation unit (not shown) that separates higher hydrocarbons from the starting mixture. For example, feed stream A may also be preheated and treated in other ways. Material stream A may already contain oxygen, and, if necessary, a diluent, such as steam; however, corresponding media may also be added upstream or inside the shell-and-tube reactor 10, as shown herein in the form of material streams B and C.
[0110] The reaction tube 11 operates through multiple, in the illustrated example, three reaction zones 10A, 10B, and 10C, and is surrounded by a jacket area 12. Catalyst beds are disposed in the corresponding reaction zones 10A, 10B, and 10C within each reaction tube 11 and are shown in different shaded areas. A gaseous mixture containing ethane, oxygen, and possibly a diluent passes sequentially through reaction zones 10A to 10C in the form of material stream A or combined material streams A to C, respectively. An inert zone, not separately designated, precedes reaction zones 10A to 10C. The reaction tube 11 extends between a first end 11A and a second end 11B (distinguished only in the case of a reaction tube), and reaction zones 10A to 10C are disposed between these ends 11A and 11B.
[0111] The reaction zones 10A, 10B, and 10C are characterized in particular by the different catalytic activities in the catalyst bed, as previously explained in detail. Non-inventive embodiments can also be implemented without the corresponding formation of different reaction zones 10A, 10B, 10C or catalyst beds. Alternatively or additionally, temperature control with different or uniform zones can be implemented.
[0112] The process gas exits from the shell-and-tube reactor 10 in the form of a process gas stream D containing ethylene formed by the partial oxidative dehydrogenation of ethane in the shell-and-tube reactor 10. Additionally, the process gas contains acetic acid, also formed from ethane in the shell-and-tube reactor 10, as well as water, carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, unreacted oxygen, and diluents and other compounds (if added or pre-formed in the shell-and-tube reactor 10). The reaction tube 11 is temperature-controlled by a flow of a temperature-regulating agent E flowing through the shell region, exiting from the shell region as effluent F. As not shown here, multiple temperature-controlled medium loops can be specifically provided for segmented temperature control or cooling of the reaction tube 11. In each case, the wall of the reaction tube 11 defines a cooling surface for the active catalyst bed in the region of the respective catalyst bed.
[0113] It should be understood that the apparatus 100 may include one, as shown, but may also include multiple (e.g., operating in parallel) shell-and-tube reactors 10. In the latter case, these shell-and-tube reactors 10 are each supplied with a corresponding reaction feed, which may have the same or different compositions, and in each case form a corresponding process gas flow D. The latter may be combined and supplied together as process gases to subsequent process steps or equipment sections.
[0114] Downstream of the shell-and-tube reactor 10, the moisture pressure can be detected. This can be achieved, for example, by adding water or steam to the gas mixture of material stream A or by adjusting material streams B or C. The moisture pressure can also be regulated. Further effects, particularly fine-tuning, can be achieved by adjusting the temperature within the shell-and-tube reactor 10.
[0115] Subsequent process steps or equipment components are not shown. In these, the process gas may be contacted with wash water or a suitable aqueous solution, thereby specifically cooling the process gas and washing away acetic acid. At least a majority of the acetic acid-free process gas may be further processed and subjected to ethylene separation. The ethane contained in the process gas may be recycled to reactor 10.
Claims
1. A method for producing ethylene by oxidative dehydrogenation of ethane using a shell-and-tube reactor (10) having a reaction tube (11) extending between a first end (11A) and a second end (11B), wherein each of the reaction tubes (11) is provided with a plurality of catalyst beds, and in each of the reaction tubes (11), the ratio of the total length of the plurality of catalyst beds between the first end (11A) and the second end (11B) to the diameter of each of the reaction tubes (11) is between 150 and 400, characterized in that, The shell-and-tube reactor (10) operates at a linear velocity of 250 cm / s to 800 cm / s, and the plurality of catalyst beds are configured such that the plurality of catalyst beds in each of the reaction tubes (11) have different catalytic activities, and the ratio of the active catalyst mass to the effective cooling surface of the plurality of catalyst beds in each of the reaction tubes (11) is in the range of 1.5 kg / m² to 5 kg / m², wherein, in at least one catalyst bed in each reaction tube (11) considered individually, the ratio of the active catalyst mass to the effective cooling surface is within this range. The ratio of the active catalyst mass to the effective cooling surface in each of the plurality of catalyst beds in each of the reaction tubes (11) is the quotient between the sum of the active catalyst masses in all the respective catalyst beds and the sum of the sum of the inner surfaces of the reaction tubes (11) surrounding these catalyst beds.
2. The method according to claim 1, wherein the shell-and-tube reactor (10) is operated at a weight hourly space velocity of more than 3 kg and less than 20 kg of feed per kg of catalyst.
3. The method according to claim 1, wherein the shell-and-tube reactor (10) operates at a linear velocity greater than 300 cm / s.
4. The method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the shell-and-tube reactor (10) is operated such that the highest temperature in the plurality of catalyst beds is less than 500°C.
5. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein a packing material selected from rings, pellets and extrudates or combinations thereof is used in the plurality of catalyst beds.
6. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein water is metered into the shell-and-tube reactor (10) based on the catalyst activity detected in the shell-and-tube reactor (10).
7. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein one or more cooling media flow through the shell-and-tube reactor (10).
8. The method according to claim 7, wherein different regions of the shell-and-tube reactor (10) are cooled to different degrees.
9. An apparatus (100) for producing ethylene by oxidative dehydrogenation of ethane, comprising a shell-and-tube reactor (10) having a reaction tube (11) extending between a first end (11A) and a second end (11B), wherein each of the reaction tubes (11) is provided with a plurality of catalyst beds, and in each of the reaction tubes (11), the ratio of the total length of the plurality of catalyst beds between the first end (11A) and the second end (11B) to the diameter of each of the reaction tubes (11) is a value of 150 to 400, characterized in that, The shell-and-tube reactor (10) is adapted to operate at a linear velocity of 250 cm / s to 800 cm / s, and the plurality of catalyst beds are configured such that the plurality of catalyst beds in each of the reaction tubes (11) have different catalytic activities, and the ratio of the active catalyst mass to the effective cooling surface of the plurality of catalyst beds in each of the reaction tubes (11) is in the range of 1.5 kg / m² to 5 kg / m², wherein, in at least one catalyst bed in each reaction tube (11) considered individually, the ratio of the active catalyst mass to the effective cooling surface is within this range. The ratio of the active catalyst mass to the effective cooling surface in each of the plurality of catalyst beds in each of the reaction tubes (11) is the quotient between the sum of the active catalyst masses in all the respective catalyst beds and the sum of the sum of the inner surfaces of the reaction tubes (11) surrounding these catalyst beds.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Alkane oxidative dehydrogenation and / or alkene oxidation
US10017432B2
Alkane oxidative dehydrogenation and / or alkene oxidation
US20160304432A1
Alkane oxidative dehydrogenation and / or alkene oxidation
US9963412B2
Alkane oxidative dehydrogenation and / or alkene oxidation
WO2015082598A1
Alkane oxidative dehydrogenation and / or alkene oxidation
WO2015082602A1
