Damage tolerance design method for dirty white spot defects in nickel-based superalloys
Through stress analysis and finite element model, the crack initiation and expansion life of dirty white spot defects of nickel-based high-temperature alloy wheels was evaluated, which solved the problem of excessive conservative results of dirty white spots in the existing technology, and realized the nickel-based high-temperature alloy wheels. The effective damage tolerance assessment of the plate meets the airworthiness requirements.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202410994778.2
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-07-24
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-05
- Estimated Expiration
- 2044-07-24
AI Technical Summary
The existing method analyzes the equivalent of dirty white spots in nickel-based high-temperature alloys into cracks, resulting in the results being too conservative and unable to meet the airworthiness requirements, and lacks an effective design method for damage tolerance for dirty white spots.
The first main stress distribution of the nickel-based high-temperature alloy roulette wheel was obtained through stress analysis, and fatigue samples containing dirty white spot defects were prepared. The crack initiation life of dirty white spots was determined through low-cycle fatigue test, and fracture mechanics were simulated in combination with the finite element model. Dirty white spots extend their lifespan, and the fatigue life of nickel-based high-temperature alloy roulette is finally evaluated.
Provides a design method for damage tolerance for dirty white spots that meets airworthiness requirements, evaluates the fatigue life of nickel-based deformation high-temperature alloy roulettes, supplements the gaps in the existing technology, and provides theoretical and material support for the autonomous airworthiness system of aircraft engines. .
Smart Images

Figure CN118533463B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention relates to the technical field of aero-engines, and in particular to a method for designing damage tolerance of dirty white spot defects in nickel-based high-temperature alloys. Background Art
[0002] White spots are negative segregation formed by the reduction of carbides and carbide-forming elements or strengthening elements. After corrosion, they are light-colored areas. White spots can be divided into separated white spots, dendritic white spots and solidified white spots. Separated white spots are bright in color and have a clear boundary with the matrix. They usually appear from the 1 / 2 radius to the center of the cross section of the billet. Their crystal size is greater than or equal to the matrix and their hardness is lower than that of the matrix. Dendritic white spots are in the form of dendrites and have a diffuse interface with the matrix. They usually exist in the central area of the billet. The causes of separated and dendritic white spots are: the ingot crown falls off and the electrode falls off during vacuum consumable remelting. The depletion of elements such as Nb, Ti and Al in dendritic white spots is less than that of separated white spots, and there are no inclusions and they are relatively clean. Solidified white spots appear in the bottom area of the ingot (from the surface to 1 / 2R). Its interface with the matrix is unclear and is linear, ring-shaped or hook-shaped. In the past, they were also called white corrosion points, small white spots, white circles, etc. The cause is the slowdown of solidification rate. In solidification white spots, the depletion of elements is very small. Current research shows that dendritic white spots and solidification white spots have little effect on the performance of high-temperature alloys, and similar defects can be well eliminated through the control of triple smelting process and solidification conditions.
[0003] Some studies have shown that when the crystal size of the separated white spot is too different from that of the matrix, the low-cycle fatigue life of the material will be reduced. In addition, when the separated white spot contains carbides or other impurities, a "dirty white spot" will be formed. The existence of "dirty white spots" seriously affects the low-cycle fatigue life of high-temperature alloys. On October 28, 2016, a plane on the AA383 flight mission from Chicago to Miami broke the second-stage high-pressure turbine disk of the engine during takeoff, causing a serious accident. Subsequent investigations found that there was a 3.81mm×2.54mm dirty white spot on the crack source of the disk center. The existence of this defect reduced the actual service life of the disk by one third.
[0004] The accident caused by dirty white spots has attracted the attention of major certification departments around the world, prompting the civil aviation field to increase research on failure probability assessment technology for deformed high-temperature alloy wheel discs. In 2022, the "Aero Engine Certification" Advisory Notice AC33.70 issued by the domestic authorities also officially included nickel-based alloy dirty white spots as the object of damage tolerance assessment. The certification requirements of the newly developed engine show that nickel-based deformed high-temperature alloy wheel discs have the ability to tolerate dirty white spots. The national military standards and airworthiness regulations only provide assessment requirements and guidance methods for surface defects for nickel-based deformed high-temperature alloys. The general practice is: assume that there is an initial crack with a depth of 0.38mm at the maximum position of the first principal stress of the wheel disc, calculate its remaining crack growth life, and compare the relationship between the crack growth life and the maintenance cycle to indicate the damage tolerance of the wheel disc.
[0005] When dirty white spots exist on the surface of nickel-based deformed high-temperature alloys, they are easily detected by non-destructive testing methods. They are generally found as internal material defects in life-limited parts of wheel discs. The surface defect damage tolerance design method does not conform to objective facts. Dirty white spots have a certain crack initiation life. The existing method of directly equating dirty white spots with cracks for analysis may lead to overly conservative results. At present, there is no recognized damage tolerance design method for dirty white spots defects in nickel-based high-temperature alloy wheel discs that meets airworthiness requirements. Summary of the invention
[0006] The present invention provides a method for designing the damage tolerance of dirty white spot defects in nickel-based high-temperature alloys, so as to solve the technical problem that the existing method directly equates dirty white spots with cracks for analysis, which may lead to overly conservative results and thus fail to meet airworthiness requirements.
[0007] According to one aspect of the present invention, a method for designing damage tolerance of dirty white spot defects in nickel-based high-temperature alloys is provided, comprising the following steps:
[0008] Step 1: According to the engine reference cycle, stress analysis is performed on the nickel-based high-temperature alloy wheel disc to obtain the first principal stress distribution of the wheel disc, and the near-surface position of the maximum point of the first principal stress is selected as the dirty white spot location;
[0009] Step 2: prepare fatigue specimens containing dirty white spot defects, and determine the dirty white spot crack initiation life of the specimens containing dirty white spot defects through low cycle fatigue tests;
[0010] The method for obtaining the dirty white spot crack initiation life of a sample containing dirty white spot defects comprises the following steps:
[0011] Step 2.1: Obtain the fatigue life of the fatigue specimen containing dirty white spot defects through low cycle fatigue test;
[0012] Step 2.2: Establish a finite element model of a high-temperature alloy fatigue specimen, implant an initial crack with the same position and size as the target dirty white spot, perform a fracture mechanics simulation using the same load conditions as step 2.1, and obtain the crack extension life of the specimen with the same size as the dirty white spot;
[0013] Step 2.3: The crack initiation life of dirty white spot is obtained by subtracting the crack propagation life of the dirty white spot specimen with the same size from the fatigue life of the dirty white spot specimen;
[0014] Step 3: Carry out crack propagation analysis on the dirty white spot defect near the surface of the maximum point of the first principal stress of the wheel, and calculate the corresponding crack propagation life when the dirty white spot propagates to the instability of the wheel;
[0015] Step 4: The sum of the dirty white spot crack initiation life of the sample containing dirty white spot defects in step 2 and the dirty white spot defect crack propagation life near the surface of the maximum point of the first principal stress of the wheel in step 3 is taken as the fatigue life of the nickel-based high-temperature alloy wheel containing dirty white spot defects.
[0016] Furthermore, the stress analysis in step 1 includes performing two-dimensional transient stress calculation on the nickel-based high-temperature alloy wheel disc to obtain the time when the maximum first principal stress of the wheel disc occurs during the reference cycle, and selecting this time to perform three-dimensional stress analysis on the wheel disc.
[0017] Furthermore, the low cycle fatigue test is conducted using the minimum detectable dirty white spot size as the initial crack size for damage tolerance analysis, and a database of dirty white spot crack initiation life at different stress levels is established.
[0018] Furthermore, if the fatigue life of the nickel-based high-temperature alloy wheel disc containing dirty white spot defects is greater than the design life or twice the maintenance cycle, then the wheel disc has the dirty white spot damage tolerance capability.
[0019] Furthermore, the method for preparing a fatigue specimen containing dirty white spot defects in step 2 includes: cutting a high-temperature alloy rod, implanting dirty white spot defect material, and then obtaining a dirty white spot-implanted high-temperature alloy rod of a determined size through welding and hot isostatic pressing, and obtaining a fatigue specimen with dirty white spot defects of the size through forging and machining.
[0020] Furthermore, the method for preparing the dirty white spot defect material comprises the following steps:
[0021] S1: First smelting: put the master alloy raw materials Ni, Fe, C, Mo, Cr, Nb into a container, evacuate, heat up to melt the raw materials, then refine, cool down to the surface to form a film, wash the film after the film is formed, then add the upper charge Al and Ti to melt the materials, and then cast them to obtain the master alloy;
[0022] S2: Second smelting: Wrap the inclusion raw material with nickel foil and place it at the bottom of the crucible, place the master alloy on top of the inclusion, evacuate the material to melt it, and cast the raw material after it melts to obtain the dirty white spot defect material.
[0023] Further, the amount of the master alloy raw material is 50.0-55.0wt% Ni, 0.02-0.06wt% C, 2.8-3.3wt% Mo, 17-21wt% Cr, 2.5-4.5wt% Nb, and the balance is Fe;
[0024] The amounts of Al and Ti in the upper charge are 0.2-0.8wt% Al and 0.65-1.15wt% Ti respectively.
[0025] Furthermore, the amount of the inclusion raw material is 10-20% of the weight of the dirty white spot defect material.
[0026] Furthermore, in step S1, the alloy refining temperature is 1500-1540°C, the refining time is 5-20 minutes, and the casting temperature is 1400-1450°C.
[0027] Furthermore, in step S2, the inclusion raw materials are mullite powder and magnesium oxide powder, and the amount of the inclusion raw materials is 10-20% of the weight of the ingot.
[0028] The present invention has the following beneficial effects:
[0029] 1. The present invention uses the sum of the crack initiation life of the sample containing dirty white spot defects and the crack propagation life of the dirty white spot defects near the surface of the maximum point of the first principal stress of the wheel as the fatigue life of the wheel containing dirty white spot defects, so as to evaluate the damage tolerance of nickel-based deformed high-temperature alloys for dirty white spot defects, which fills the gap in the prior art. The present invention has been successfully applied to the damage tolerance assessment of dirty white spot defects in the limited life parts of nickel-based deformed high-temperature alloy wheel discs of a certain civil turboshaft engine.
[0030] 2. The preparation method of the dirty white spot defect material of the present invention can be used to obtain dirty white spot materials containing uniformly distributed inclusions in a relatively convenient and controllable manner, providing a material basis for subsequent research on material defect data accumulation, defect detection probability, etc., and also providing theoretical and material support for the establishment of an independent airworthiness system for my country's aero-engines.
[0031] In addition to the above-described purposes, features and advantages, the present invention has other purposes, features and advantages. The present invention will be further described in detail with reference to the accompanying drawings. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0032] The drawings constituting a part of this application are used to provide a further understanding of the present invention. The exemplary embodiments of the present invention and their descriptions are used to explain the present invention and do not constitute an improper limitation of the present invention. In the drawings:
[0033] Figure 1 This is a comparison chart of the crack growth life of the near-surface and internal dirty white spot defects in the key parts of the wheel disc;
[0034] Figure 2 The flowchart for the preparation of fatigue specimens containing dirty white spot defects is shown in FIG.
[0035] Figure 3 It is a fatigue specimen with dirty white spot defects;
[0036] Figure 4 Simulate the principal stress distribution of the disk for a gas turbine;
[0037] Figure 5 This is the first principal stress distribution of the 194s turbine disk;
[0038] Figure 6 Analyze the initial position for dirty white spots;
[0039] Figure 7 To simulate the stress of the specimen under the test load;
[0040] Figure 8 An initial crack with a diameter of 1 mm was implanted into the model;
[0041] Fig. 9 The crack propagates to the point where the test section is about to break;
[0042] Fig.10 This is the crack extension to the test section about to break;
[0043] Fig.11 To implant an initial crack near the surface at the maximum point of the first principal stress;
[0044] Fig.12 The dirty white spots have expanded to the point where the wheel is about to break;
[0045] Fig.13 The dirty white spots extend to the roulette wheel and are about to break;
[0046] Fig.14 The morphology of the dirty white spot defect material in Example 3;
[0047] Fig.15 This is the morphology of the dirty white spot defect material in Comparative Example 3. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0048] The embodiments of the present invention are described in detail below with reference to the accompanying drawings. However, the present invention can be implemented in many different ways as defined and covered below.
[0049] An embodiment of the first aspect of the present invention provides a method for designing the damage tolerance of dirty white spot defects in a nickel-based high-temperature alloy, comprising the following steps:
[0050] Step 1: According to the engine reference cycle, stress analysis is performed on the nickel-based high-temperature alloy wheel disc to obtain the first principal stress distribution of the wheel disc, and the near-surface position of the maximum point of the first principal stress is selected as the dirty white spot location;
[0051] Step 2: prepare fatigue specimens containing dirty white spot defects, and determine the dirty white spot crack initiation life of the specimens containing dirty white spot defects through low cycle fatigue tests;
[0052] The method for obtaining the dirty white spot crack initiation life of a sample containing dirty white spot defects comprises the following steps:
[0053] Step 2.1: Obtain the fatigue life of the fatigue specimen containing dirty white spot defects through low cycle fatigue test;
[0054] Step 2.2: Establish a finite element model of a high-temperature alloy fatigue specimen, implant an initial crack with the same position and size as the target dirty white spot, perform a fracture mechanics simulation using the same load conditions as step 2.1, and obtain the crack extension life of the specimen with the same size as the dirty white spot;
[0055] Step 2.3: The crack initiation life of dirty white spot is obtained by subtracting the crack propagation life of the dirty white spot specimen with the same size from the fatigue life of the dirty white spot specimen;
[0056] Step 3: Carry out crack propagation analysis on the dirty white spot defect near the surface of the maximum point of the first principal stress of the wheel, and calculate the corresponding crack propagation life when the dirty white spot propagates to the instability of the wheel;
[0057] Step 4: The sum of the dirty white spot crack initiation life of the sample containing dirty white spot defects in step 2 and the dirty white spot defect crack propagation life at the near-surface position of the maximum point of the first principal stress of the wheel in step 3 is taken as the fatigue life of the nickel-based high-temperature alloy wheel containing dirty white spot defects.
[0058] The driving force for crack propagation is the first principal stress. The greater the driving force, the higher the crack propagation rate and the shorter the crack propagation life. Therefore, the position with the maximum first principal stress is selected as the key part of the wheel. Since the key part of the wheel is generally on the surface of the wheel, and dirty white spots are easily detected if they exist on the surface of the wheel, it is necessary to further confirm the position of the dirty white spots for analysis. Through a large number of analytical calculations, it is known that in general, dirty white spots are located near the surface of the key parts, and the crack propagation life is the shortest. For relatively thin discs, such as gas turbine guide discs, dirty white spots are located at the center of the thickness near the key parts, and the crack propagation life is also relatively short. Therefore, for conventional wheels, the near surface of the maximum point of the first principal stress can be selected as the dirty white spot part; in addition, for some thinner wheels, the dirty white spot part is selected as the center of the wheel thickness near the maximum point of the first principal stress.
[0059] When considering the fatigue life of high-temperature alloys containing material defects, ignoring the life of defect-induced cracks generally results in overly conservative analysis results. The present invention artificially prepares fatigue specimens containing dirty white spot defects, and through fatigue tests, the crack initiation life of dirty white spot defects of a certain size under different stress levels can be determined, and the crack initiation life of dirty white spot defects of different sizes can also be obtained through fatigue tests.
[0060] According to the crack propagation parameters of high-temperature alloys, crack propagation analysis was carried out with the smallest industrially detectable dirty white spot size as the initial crack, and the corresponding crack propagation life when the crack became unstable was calculated.
[0061] The present invention uses the sum of the crack initiation life of the sample containing dirty white spot defects and the crack propagation life of the dirty white spot defects near the surface of the maximum point of the first principal stress of the wheel as the fatigue life of the wheel containing dirty white spot defects, so as to evaluate the damage tolerance of nickel-based deformed high-temperature alloys for dirty white spot defects, which fills the gap in the prior art. The present invention has been successfully applied to the damage tolerance evaluation of dirty white spot defects in the limited life parts of nickel-based deformed high-temperature alloy wheel discs of a certain civil turboshaft engine.
[0062] In an embodiment of the present invention, the stress analysis in step 1 includes performing two-dimensional transient stress calculation on the nickel-based high-temperature alloy wheel disc, obtaining the time when the maximum first principal stress of the wheel disc occurs during the reference cycle, and selecting this time to perform three-dimensional stress analysis on the wheel disc.
[0063] Damage tolerance analysis generally selects the life calculation condition (maximum takeoff state) as the load condition for damage tolerance analysis; the selection of the load condition of the present invention comes from the stress history analysis of the wheel under the engine reference cycle, which can better reflect the actual working state of the engine.
[0064] The specific steps are:
[0065] First, based on the stress analysis results of typical working conditions of the wheel (conventional method of engineering calculation), the position with the maximum first principal stress is selected as the key part of the wheel, generally the wheel center or the eccentric hole. This is because the driving force for crack propagation is the first principal stress. The greater the driving force, the higher the crack propagation rate and the shorter the crack propagation life.
[0066] Then, the two-dimensional transient stress of the wheel under the reference cycle is calculated (this transient stress analysis method is a conventional method and is not protected by this patent) to obtain the first principal stress history of the key parts.
[0067] Finally, the moment when the maximum value of the first principal stress in the stress history occurs is selected as the load condition for damage tolerance analysis.
[0068] According to the selected load conditions, a detailed three-dimensional stress analysis of the wheel disc is performed. The maximum position of the first principal stress is generally located on the surface of the wheel disc. However, according to industry common sense, if dirty white spots exist on the surface of the wheel disc, they can be easily detected by current non-destructive testing methods, and the damage tolerance analysis of surface dirty white spots is not very meaningful. Damage tolerance analysis is generally aimed at dirty white spots that exist inside the wheel disc, so their position needs to be further confirmed through analysis. First, through theoretical judgment, the driving force for crack propagation is the first principal stress. The near-surface of the wheel disc where the first principal stress is maximum is generally the second largest position of the first principal stress. For internal dirty white spots, the crack propagation life is the shortest. A large number of analytical calculations have also confirmed that dirty white spots of the same size are located near the surface where the first principal stress is maximum, and the crack propagation life is the shortest, see. Figure 1 . Damage tolerance analysis dirty white spot location selection method: the near-surface position of the maximum point of the first principal stress.
[0069] In an embodiment of the present invention, the low cycle fatigue test is conducted using the minimum detectable dirty white spot size as the initial crack size for damage tolerance analysis, and a database of dirty white spot crack initiation life at different stress levels is established.
[0070] The method for obtaining the dirty white spot crack initiation life of the dirty white spot defect sample in step 2 of the present invention further comprises the following steps:
[0071] Step 2.1: After determining the size of the dirty white spot defect, process the fatigue specimen with the defect, and obtain the fatigue life of the fatigue specimen with the dirty white spot defect through a low-cycle fatigue test; the fatigue test conditions should be the same as the working conditions of the target part of the wheel (stress, temperature, stress ratio, etc.), and the test process and data recording of the fatigue test should meet the relevant national standards or industry standards for fatigue testing, "GBT 15248-2008 Axial Constant Amplitude Low Cycle Fatigue Test Method for Metallic Materials", "GB / T6398-2017 Fatigue Crack Propagation Method for Fatigue Test of Metallic Materials";
[0072] Step 2.2: Establish a finite element model of a high-temperature alloy fatigue specimen, implant an initial crack with the same position and size as the target dirty white spot, and conduct a low-cycle fatigue test using the same load conditions (stress, temperature, stress ratio, etc.) as step 2.1 to obtain the extension life of a crack specimen with the same size as the dirty white spot; assume that the dirty white spot defect on the fatigue specimen containing the dirty white spot defect is replaced by the crack, and calculate the extension life of the test under the same test conditions;
[0073] Step 2.3: Crack initiation life of dirty white spot = fatigue life of specimen containing dirty white spot – crack propagation life of specimen with the same size of dirty white spot.
[0074] If you want to obtain the crack initiation life of dirty white spot defects of different sizes, you can change the size of the dirty white spot defects in the sample in step 2.1, and keep the other processes the same; you can use crack propagation calculation to determine the test size before processing the fatigue specimen containing dirty white spots to ensure that there is a certain crack propagation life after the crack initiates at the dirty white spot, so as to prevent the crack from breaking immediately after extending beyond the dirty white spot.
[0075] In this embodiment, step 3 performs crack propagation analysis on the dirty white spot defect near the surface of the maximum point of the first principal stress of the wheel disc, and calculates the corresponding crack propagation life when the dirty white spot propagates to the instability of the wheel disc, specifically:
[0076] According to the crack propagation parameters of high-temperature alloys, an internal initial crack is implanted near the surface of the maximum point of the first principal stress of the wheel to carry out crack propagation analysis. Crack propagation analysis can be carried out based on Franc3D three-dimensional crack propagation software to calculate the corresponding crack propagation life when the dirty white spot propagates to the instability of the wheel. The basic process of crack propagation calculation is as follows:
[0077] 1) Establish a complete finite element model of the wheel to be analyzed;
[0078] 2) Introducing cracks: Read the sub-model, introduce initial cracks, re-mesh the sub-model, and reintegrate the sub-model containing cracks and the global model;
[0079] 3) Perform finite element calculation: automatically submit the mesh with initial cracks to finite element software such as ABAQUS and ANSYS for calculation;
[0080] 4) Crack propagation prediction: read the stress analysis results and calculate the stress intensity factors of all crack front nodes, perform crack propagation analysis, update the crack front position, and re-divide the sub-model mesh;
[0081] 5) Perform crack growth iteration analysis: If the convergence condition of the crack growth analysis is not met (the stress intensity factor at a point on the final front edge exceeds the fracture toughness of the material), a new round of analysis will be submitted until the convergence condition of the crack growth analysis is met.
[0082] Finally, the sum of the dirty white spot crack initiation life of the sample containing dirty white spot defects and the dirty white spot defect crack propagation life at the near-surface position of the maximum point of the first principal stress of the wheel is taken as the fatigue life of the wheel containing dirty white spot defects. If this life is greater than the design life or twice the maintenance cycle, the wheel has the dirty white spot damage tolerance capability. Otherwise, the wheel can eventually obtain damage tolerance capability by controlling the stress level, adjusting the product material, controlling the manufacturing process or improving the inspection method.
[0083] In an embodiment of the present invention, the method for preparing a fatigue specimen containing dirty white spot defects comprises: cutting a high-temperature alloy bar, implanting the prepared dirty white spot defect material, and then welding and hot isostatic pressing to obtain a high-temperature alloy bar with a determined size of dirty white spot implants, and forging and machining to obtain a fatigue specimen with dirty white spot defects of the determined size (see Figure 2 and Figure 3 ).
[0084] In an embodiment of the present invention, the method for preparing the above-mentioned dirty white spot defect material comprises the following steps:
[0085] S1: First smelting: 50.0-55.0wt% Ni, 0.02-0.06wt% C, 2.8-3.3wt% Mo, 17-21wt% Cr, 2.5-4.5wt% Nb, and the balance Fe are loaded into the bottom of the crucible, and evacuated to a vacuum degree of ≤6.67Pa. First, the material is dried at a power of 10-20kw to remove moisture, and then the power is increased to 90-100kw to smelt the material. After the raw material is melted, it is refined at an alloy refining temperature of 1500-1540℃ for 5-20 minutes. The temperature is lowered to form a film on the surface, and the film is washed after the film is formed. Then, 0.2-0.8wt% Al and 0.65-1.15wt% Ti of the upper charge are added for smelting, and then cast at a casting temperature of 1400-1450℃ to obtain the mother alloy;
[0086] S2: Second smelting: Wrap the inclusion raw material with nickel foil and place it at the bottom of the crucible, place the master alloy above the inclusion, evacuate to a vacuum degree of ≤6.67Pa for melting, melt the raw material and cast it to obtain the dirty white spot defect material. The amount of inclusion raw material is 10-20% of the weight of the ingot (dirty white spot defect material); the volume percentage of inclusions in the dirty white spot defect material is not less than 1%.
[0087] In an embodiment of the present invention, the inclusion raw materials are mullite powder and magnesium oxide powder in a ratio of 1:1, and the main components thereof are aluminum oxide, magnesium oxide and silicon oxide.
[0088] Dirty white spots are a defect in the smelting process. The present invention is aimed at how to use artificial means to add inclusions to the alloy to form a state similar to white spots. The change of the basic raw materials of the white spot material within the above-mentioned value range will not affect the state of inclusions added. The present invention adopts two smelting processes. The purpose of the first smelting process is to obtain a master alloy with accurate component control and good uniformity. The purpose of the second smelting process is to dissolve the inclusions into the master alloy to obtain dirty white spot defective materials. By analyzing the data of turbine disk accidents in foreign countries, it is determined that the proportion of inclusions in the white spot material should exceed 1%.
[0089] This method can be used to obtain dirty white spot materials containing uniformly distributed oxide inclusions in a relatively convenient and controllable manner, providing a material basis for subsequent research on material defect data accumulation, defect detection probability, etc., and also providing theoretical and material support for the establishment of an independent airworthiness system for my country's aero-engines.
[0090] The following examples describe the present disclosure in more detail, and these examples are intended for illustrative purposes only.
[0091] Example 1
[0092] This embodiment provides a method for analyzing the damage tolerance of dirty white spot defects on a simulated gas turbine disk. Finite element analysis software is used to select a typical working condition, conduct three-dimensional or two-dimensional stress analysis, and determine the maximum point of the first principal stress. Here, the cruise state is selected, the three-dimensional stress analysis, the speed is 40000r / min, the temperature is an average temperature of 300°C, and the first principal stress cloud diagram obtained by analysis is shown in FIG. Figure 4 The location of maximum principal stress is the wheel center, so this location is selected as the key location.
[0093] The two-dimensional transient stress of the wheel under the reference cycle is calculated, and the first principal stress history of the key parts is obtained, as shown in Table 1. Among them, the first principal stress of the key part at 194s is the largest, and this condition is selected as the damage tolerance analysis condition. At this moment, the wheel speed is 46000r / min and the temperature is 420℃.
[0094] Table 1 is an example of the transient stress history analysis results of the key parts of the wheel under a certain reference cycle
[0095]
[0096] According to the selected working condition, a detailed three-dimensional stress analysis is performed to obtain the first principal stress distribution of the wheel in this state. Figure 5 The point near the surface where the first principal stress is the maximum is selected as the dirty white spot location for damage tolerance analysis. Figure 6 .
[0097] The minimum detectable white spot size used in this analysis is 1mm in diameter, and the fatigue specimen of GH4720Li with 1mm diameter white spot is processed. The fatigue test conditions should be the same as the working conditions of the target part of the wheel. The stress of the test section in this example is 628MPa (the corresponding load is 45896N determined by simulation), the temperature is 420℃, and the stress ratio R=0.05, see Figure 7 .
[0098] Record the number of fatigue tests until the specimen breaks. In this example, the number of fatigue tests is 63,000. Based on the Franc3D software, a circular crack with a diameter of 1 mm is implanted in the test section of the model. Figure 8 , automatically submit the mesh with the initial crack to finite element software such as ABAQUS and ANSYS for calculation, read the stress analysis results and calculate the stress intensity factors of all crack front nodes, perform crack propagation analysis, update the crack front position, and re-divide the sub-model mesh until the crack almost runs through the test section, see Fig. 9 and 10 , it can be calculated that the expansion life of the dirty white spot after crack initiation is 28223 times (the specific calculation method comes from the Franc3D calculation manual, not the protection point of this patent). Therefore, the crack initiation life of the dirty white spot with a diameter of 1mm under a stress of 628MPa is the number of fatigue tests minus the number of crack extensions: 63000-28223=34777 times.
[0099] At the same time, based on the Franc3D software, the crack propagation of a dirty white spot defect with a diameter of 1mm near the surface of the first principal stress point of the wheel was simulated, and the dirty white spot propagation life was obtained to be 32312 times, see Figures 11 to 13 .
[0100] Finally, the sum of the crack initiation life and the crack propagation life is taken as the fatigue life of the wheel containing dirty white spot defects, that is, 34777 (initiation life) + 32312 (propagation life) = 67089 (times).
[0101] Assume that the fatigue life with defects is greater than the design life or twice the maintenance cycle to meet the damage tolerance standard. If the design life is 50,000 times, the disk has damage tolerance for dirty white spots.
[0102] Comparative Example 1
[0103] Without considering the crack initiation life, assuming that the analysis of dirty white spot crack extension is consistent with the above example, the fatigue life of the wheel with dirty white spot defects is an extended life of 32312 times, which is lower than the design life of 50000 times. The conclusion is that the wheel does not have damage tolerance for dirty white spots. In fact, there is still a considerable life from dirty white spot defects to crack initiation. Ignoring this life will result in an overly conservative result.
[0104] Example 2
[0105] A method for preparing a dirty white spot defect material comprises the following steps:
[0106] S1: First smelting: 53.0wt% Ni, 0.025wt% C, 3.0wt% Mo, 18wt% Cr, 4wt% Nb, and the remainder Fe are loaded into the bottom of the crucible, and the vacuum is evacuated to a vacuum degree of ≤6.67Pa. The material is first dried at a power of 10-20kw to remove moisture, and then the power is increased to 90-100kw to smelt the material. After the raw materials are melted, they are refined at an alloy refining temperature of 1500℃ for 5 minutes. The temperature is lowered to form a film on the surface, and the film is washed after the film is formed. Then, 0.5wt% Al and 1.0wt% Ti are added to the upper charge, and the material is cast after the material is smelted. The casting temperature is 1400℃ to obtain the mother alloy;
[0107] S2: Second smelting: Wrap the inclusions with nickel foil and place them at the bottom of the crucible, place the master alloy on top of the inclusions, evacuate to a vacuum degree of ≤6.67Pa for melting, melt the raw materials and cast them to obtain dirty white spot defect materials. The amount of inclusion raw materials used is 10% of the weight of the ingot (dirty white spot defect material).
[0108] The volume percentage of inclusions in the ingot analysis is 1.12%.
[0109] Example 3
[0110] A method for preparing a dirty white spot defect material comprises the following steps:
[0111] S1: First smelting: 53.0wt% Ni, 0.025wt% C, 3.0wt% Mo, 18wt% Cr, 4wt% Nb, and the remainder Fe are loaded into the bottom of the crucible, and the vacuum is evacuated to a vacuum degree of ≤6.67Pa. The raw materials are first dried at a power of 10-20kw to remove moisture, and then the power is increased to 90-100kw to smelt the raw materials. After the raw materials are melted, they are refined. The alloy refining temperature is 1540℃, and the refining time is 20 minutes. The temperature is lowered to the surface to form a film, and the film is washed after the film is formed. Then, 0.5wt% Al and 1.0wt% Ti of the upper charge are added, and the materials are cast after the materials are smelted. The casting temperature is 1450℃ to obtain the mother alloy;
[0112] S2: Second smelting: Wrap the inclusions with nickel foil and place them at the bottom of the crucible, place the master alloy on top of the inclusions, evacuate to a vacuum degree of ≤6.67Pa for melting, melt the raw materials and cast them to obtain dirty white spot defect materials. The amount of inclusion raw materials used is 15% of the weight of the ingot (dirty white spot defect material).
[0113] The volume percentage of inclusions in the ingot analysis is 1.14%.
[0114] Example 4
[0115] A method for preparing a dirty white spot defect material comprises the following steps:
[0116] S1: First smelting: 53.0wt% Ni, 0.025wt% C, 3.0wt% Mo, 18wt% Cr, 4wt% Nb, and the balance Fe are placed at the bottom of a crucible, and evacuated to a vacuum degree of ≤6.67Pa. The raw materials are first dried at a power of 10-20kw to remove moisture, and then the power is increased to 90-100kw to smelt the raw materials. After the raw materials are melted, they are refined at an alloy refining temperature of 1540°C for 5 minutes. The temperature is lowered to form a film on the surface, and the film is washed after the film is formed. Then, 0.5wt% Al and 1.0wt% Ti are added to the upper charge, and the materials are cast after smelting at a casting temperature of 1450°C to obtain a mother alloy.
[0117] S2: Second smelting: Wrap the inclusions with nickel foil and place them at the bottom of the crucible, place the master alloy on top of the inclusions, evacuate to a vacuum degree of ≤6.67Pa for melting, melt the raw materials and cast them to obtain dirty white spot defect materials, see Fig.14 The amount of inclusion raw material is 20% of the weight of the ingot (dirty white spot defect material).
[0118] The volume percentage of inclusions in the ingot analysis is 1.14%.
[0119] Comparative Example 2
[0120] The difference between this comparative example and Example 3 is that only one smelting is adopted, and the operation method is as follows: 53.0wt% Ni, 0.025wt% C, 3.0wt% Mo, 18wt% Cr, 4wt% Nb and the balance Fe of the master alloy raw materials are loaded into the bottom of the crucible, and evacuated to a vacuum degree of ≤6.67Pa, firstly, the material is dried at a power of 10-20kw to remove moisture, and then the power is increased to 90-100kw to chemically process the material, and the raw materials are refined after being melted, the alloy refining temperature is 1540°C, the refining time is 5 minutes, the temperature is lowered to the surface to form a film, and the film is washed after the film is formed, and then the upper charge of 0.5wt% Al, 1.0wt% Ti and inclusion raw materials are added to chemically process the material, and then cast at a casting temperature of 1450°C to obtain the master alloy.
[0121] Since the inclusion powder is relatively light, it all floats to the surface of the melt, leaving almost no inclusions in the ingot.
[0122] Comparative Example 3
[0123] The difference between this comparative example and Example 3 is that only one smelting is adopted, and the oxide powder is placed at the bottom of the crucible before smelting. The process is as follows: the inclusion raw material is loaded into the bottom of the crucible, and then the mother alloy raw materials of 53.0wt% Ni, 0.025wt% C, 3.0wt% Mo, 18wt% Cr, 4wt% Nb, and the balance Fe are loaded into the bottom of the crucible, and evacuated to a vacuum degree of ≤6.67Pa, firstly, the material is dried at a power of 10-20kw to remove moisture, and then the power is increased to 90-100kw to chemically process the material, and the raw material is refined after melting, the alloy refining temperature is 1540℃, the refining time is 5 minutes, the temperature is lowered to the surface to form a film, the film is washed after the film is formed, and then the upper charge of 0.5wt% Al and 1.0wt% Ti is added for chemical processing, and the material is cast after chemical processing, and the casting temperature is 1450℃ to obtain the mother alloy.
[0124] Due to the refining process, most of the inclusions are adsorbed on the crucible wall, and a small amount floats to the surface of the melt, leaving almost no inclusions in the ingot.
[0125] Comparative Example 4
[0126] The difference between this comparative example and Example 3 is that the amount of inclusion raw material used is 8% of the weight of the ingot (dirty white spot defect material). Fig.15 .
[0127] The volume percentage of inclusions in the ingot analysis was 0.63%, which did not exceed 1%.
[0128] Comparative Example 5
[0129] The only difference between this comparative example and Example 4 is that the amount of inclusion raw material used is 25% of the weight of the ingot (dirty white spot defect material).
[0130] Ingot analysis showed that the volume percentage of inclusions was 1.14%. A large amount of oxide powder failed to melt into the melt, splashed during the casting process, and polluted the smelting equipment.
[0131] The above description is only a preferred embodiment of the present invention and is not intended to limit the present invention. For those skilled in the art, the present invention may have various modifications and variations. Any modification, equivalent replacement, improvement, etc. made within the spirit and principle of the present invention shall be included in the protection scope of the present invention.
Claims
1. A method for designing the damage tolerance of dirty white spot defects in nickel-based high-temperature alloys, characterized in that: The following steps are involved: Step 1: According to the engine reference cycle, stress analysis is performed on the nickel-based high-temperature alloy wheel disc to obtain the first principal stress distribution of the wheel disc, and the near-surface position of the maximum point of the first principal stress is selected as the dirty white spot location; Step 2: prepare fatigue specimens containing dirty white spot defects, and determine the dirty white spot crack initiation life of the specimens containing dirty white spot defects through low cycle fatigue tests; The method for obtaining the dirty white spot crack initiation life of a sample containing dirty white spot defects comprises the following steps: Step 2.1: Obtain the fatigue life of the fatigue specimen containing dirty white spot defects through low cycle fatigue test; Step 2.2: Establish a finite element model of a high-temperature alloy fatigue specimen, implant an initial crack with the same position and size as the target dirty white spot, perform a fracture mechanics simulation using the same load conditions as step 2.1, and obtain the crack extension life of the specimen with the same size as the dirty white spot; Step 2.3: The crack initiation life of dirty white spot is obtained by subtracting the crack propagation life of the dirty white spot specimen with the same size from the fatigue life of the dirty white spot specimen; Step 3: Carry out crack propagation analysis on the dirty white spot defect near the surface of the maximum point of the first principal stress of the wheel, and calculate the corresponding crack propagation life when the dirty white spot propagates to the instability of the wheel; Step 4: The sum of the dirty white spot crack initiation life of the sample containing dirty white spot defects in step 2 and the dirty white spot defect crack propagation life near the surface of the maximum point of the first principal stress of the wheel in step 3 is taken as the fatigue life of the nickel-based high-temperature alloy wheel containing dirty white spot defects.
2. The method for designing the damage tolerance of dirty white spot defects in nickel-based high-temperature alloys according to claim 1, characterized in that: The stress analysis in step 1 includes performing two-dimensional transient stress calculation on the nickel-based high-temperature alloy wheel disc, obtaining the time when the first principal stress of the wheel disc reaches the maximum during the reference cycle, and selecting this time to perform three-dimensional stress analysis on the wheel disc.
3. The method for designing the damage tolerance of dirty white spot defects in nickel-based high-temperature alloys according to claim 1, characterized in that: The low cycle fatigue test is conducted using the minimum detectable dirty white spot size as the initial crack size for damage tolerance analysis, and a dirty white spot crack initiation life database under different stress levels is established.
4. The method for designing the damage tolerance of dirty white spot defects in nickel-based high-temperature alloys according to claim 1, characterized in that: If the fatigue life of the nickel-based high-temperature alloy wheel disc containing dirty white spot defects is greater than the design life or twice the maintenance cycle, then the wheel disc has the dirty white spot damage tolerance capability.
5. The method for designing the damage tolerance of dirty white spot defects in nickel-based high-temperature alloys according to claim 1, characterized in that: The method for preparing the fatigue specimen containing dirty white spot defects in step 2 includes: cutting a high-temperature alloy rod, implanting the dirty white spot defect material, and then obtaining a dirty white spot-implanted high-temperature alloy rod of a determined size through welding and hot isostatic pressing, and obtaining a fatigue specimen with dirty white spot defects of the size through forging and machining.
6. The method for designing the damage tolerance of dirty white spot defects in nickel-based high-temperature alloys according to claim 5, characterized in that: The method for preparing the dirty white spot defect material comprises the following steps: Step S1: First smelting: put the master alloy raw materials Ni, Fe, C, Mo, Cr, and Nb into a container, evacuate, heat up to melt the raw materials, and then refine, cool down to the surface to form a film, wash the film after the film is formed, then add the upper charge Al and Ti to chemically combine, and then cast to obtain the master alloy; Step S2: Second smelting: Wrap the inclusion raw material with nickel foil and place it at the bottom of the crucible, place the master alloy above the inclusion, evacuate the material to melt it, and cast the raw material after it is melted to obtain a dirty white spot defect material.
7. The method for designing the damage tolerance of dirty white spot defects in nickel-based high-temperature alloys according to claim 6, characterized in that: The amount of the master alloy raw material is 50.0-55.0wt% Ni, 0.02-0.06wt% C, 2.8-3.3wt% Mo, 17-21wt% Cr, 2.5-4.5wt% Nb, and the balance is Fe; The amounts of Al and Ti in the upper charge are 0.2-0.8wt% Al and 0.65-1.15wt% Ti respectively.
8. The method for designing the damage tolerance of dirty white spot defects in nickel-based high-temperature alloys according to claim 6, characterized in that: The amount of the inclusion raw material is 10-20% of the weight of the dirty white spot defect material.
9. The method for designing the damage tolerance of dirty white spot defects in nickel-based high-temperature alloys according to claim 6, characterized in that: In step S1, the alloy refining temperature is 1500-1540°C, the refining time is 5-20 minutes, and the casting temperature is 1400-1450°C.
10. The method for designing the damage tolerance of dirty white spot defects in nickel-based high-temperature alloys according to claim 6, characterized in that: In step S2, the inclusion raw materials are mullite powder and magnesium oxide powder, and the amount of the inclusion raw materials is 10-20% of the weight of the ingot.
