Health status evaluation method of radar and reactance equipment based on weight optimization
By using a weight optimization method, a performance parameter sample matrix is constructed and objective and subjective weights are calculated to quantify the health status of radar and reactive equipment. This solves the problems of inaccurate evaluation results and time-consuming and labor-intensive processes in existing technologies, and achieves efficient and accurate health status evaluation.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202411087587.4
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-08-09
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-08
- Estimated Expiration
- 2044-08-09
AI Technical Summary
In the existing technology, the health status evaluation methods for radar and reactor equipment lack scientific theoretical guidance, resulting in more qualitative than quantitative evaluation results. Furthermore, traditional detection methods are time-consuming and labor-intensive, making it difficult to accurately reflect the actual operating status of the equipment and affecting its guiding value for future operation.
A weight-based optimization method is adopted to construct a performance parameter sample matrix, calculate objective and subjective weights, and combine the geometric mean method to quantitatively evaluate the health status of radar and electronic reactor equipment, including performance parameter normalization, comprehensive weight allocation and similarity calculation.
It improves the accuracy and efficiency of health status assessment, provides quantitative guidance for the future operation of equipment, overcomes the drawbacks of traditional methods, simplifies data sources, and reduces damage to equipment during disassembly and assembly.
Smart Images

Figure SMS_103 
Figure QLYQS_13 
Figure QLYQS_24
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to the field of radar, and in particular to a radar and reactance equipment health status evaluation method based on weight optimization. Background Art
[0002] With the rapid application of digital signal processing and software radio, most functions can be realized by software. The closer the D / A and A / D converters are to the antenna, the higher the degree of digitization of the system. On this basis, when comparing the radar system and the reactance system, it is found that the working principles and system composition of the two are highly similar. The difference lies mainly in the signal processing method, which can be realized by software, while the hardware such as transmitters, antennas, and receivers can be fully shared. Therefore, the premise of realizing the integrated design of radar and reactance has been met. Without changing the hardware design, the radar and reactance signals can be processed separately through software radio.
[0003] Accurately understanding the health status of radar and reactance equipment is an important prerequisite and basic condition for the rational use of equipment. With the development of radar reactance integration technology, as well as the similarity and commonality of radar and reactance equipment in health status evaluation, in the existing technology, the same health status evaluation method is usually used to achieve the health status evaluation of radar and reactance equipment.
[0004] Health status evaluation is an assessment of the deviation between the current status of radar and reactance equipment and the expected status, which is used to reflect the ability of the equipment to complete work tasks. The traditional equipment health evaluation method is mainly carried out by the equipment maintenance center through regular intensive maintenance, which is highly dependent on the equipment maintenance center. The basis for the maintenance center to evaluate the health of radar and reactance equipment is mainly to detect the performance parameters of the equipment. There are two main ways to detect performance parameters. One is to use offline detection, as described in the paper "Research on the Application of Equipment Health Assessment in the Maintenance of Rail Transit Facilities and Equipment", that is, to remove the radar and reactance equipment from the platform and transport it to the maintenance center workshop for offline detection. The repeated disassembly and assembly of the equipment is not only labor-intensive and time-consuming, but also has a long detection cycle and low detection efficiency. In addition, the integrity of the equipment is easily damaged during the disassembly and transportation process. In addition, the equipment is removed from the platform before testing, which is out of the actual operating environment of the equipment, and the detection indicators are difficult to truly reflect the actual operating status of the equipment. Second, adopting the in-situ detection method, as described in the paper "Research on In-situ Detector of Aircraft DC Motor Commutator Spark", that is, detecting the performance parameters of radar and reactance equipment when the platform is powered on and running. This method requires a lot of manpower and time, a large workload, and easily causes waste of maintenance resources, and the evaluation work efficiency is low. Furthermore, in the prior art, the health status evaluation method of radar and reactance equipment lacks scientific evaluation theory guidance, and the health status evaluation can usually only give qualitative results, but not quantitative results, resulting in the health status evaluation results having no guiding value for the future operation of the equipment.
[0005] Therefore, how to improve the accuracy of radar and reactance equipment health status evaluation and improve the work efficiency of health evaluation is a difficult problem that needs to be solved in the radar and reactance equipment health status evaluation method. Summary of the invention
[0006] Technical purpose: In order to overcome the deficiencies in the prior art, the present invention provides a radar and reactance equipment health status evaluation method based on weight optimization.
[0007] Technical solution: To achieve the above purpose, the radar and reactance equipment health status evaluation method based on weight optimization disclosed in the present invention includes the following steps:
[0008] (S1) Obtain radar and reactance equipment N performance parameters M samples, among which the i A sample of performance parameters is represented as , where , , Indicates i The performance parameter j Sample data;
[0009] (S2) N performance parameters M The samples are normalized and converted into dimensionless values ranging from 0 to 1;
[0010] (S3) Construct the normalized samples into a parameter sample matrix ,in, For the matrix Z The element of i performance parameters j The dimensionless value of samples;
[0011] (S4) Calculation N The comprehensive weight distribution vector of performance parameters ,in, Indicates i The comprehensive weight of the performance parameters ,in Indicates i The objective weight value of each performance parameter, Indicates i The subjective weight value of each performance parameter, represents the weight distribution coefficient;
[0012] (S5) Calculate the similarity between the performance parameter samples of radar and reactance equipment and the equipment's optimal state sequence:
[0013] ,
[0014] Indicates that the independent variable is j Time The minimum value of Indicates that the independent variable is i Time Minimum value, Indicates that the independent variable is j Time The maximum value of Indicates that the independent variable is i Time Maximum value, represents the similarity coefficient;
[0015] (S6) Calculate weighted similarity :
[0016] ;
[0017] (S7) Calculate the health of radar and reactance equipment using the geometric mean method :
[0018] ,
[0019] Health The larger the value, the better the working performance of the radar and reactance equipment.
[0020] Preferably, the objective weight calculation step of the performance parameter comprises:
[0021] (A1) Calculate the variance of the sample data of radar and reactance equipment performance parameters :
[0022] ;
[0023] (A2) Calculate the difference in performance parameters between radar and reactance equipment :
[0024] ;
[0025] (A3) Computational radar and reactance equipment N The objective weight vector of performance parameters :
[0026] ;
[0027] but It is expressed as:
[0028] .
[0029] Preferably, the step of calculating the subjective weight of the performance parameter comprises:
[0030] (B1) Using a scale of 1-9, using expert scoring, construct the N Consistency matrix of performance parameters :
[0031] ,
[0032] Among them, the Indicates radar and reactance equipment i Performance parameters Relative to the j Performance parameters The importance value of k =1,2,… N ;
[0033] (B2) Calculate the starting weight vector :
[0034] The consistency discriminant matrix Transform to get the normalized matrix ,in:
[0035] ,
[0036] The normalized matrix P Each element in is added row by row to get the starting weight vector Q :
[0037] ,
[0038] in It is expressed as:
[0039] ;
[0040] (B3) Calculate the normalized subjective weight vector of radar and reactance equipment performance parameters β :
[0041] For the starting weight vector Q Perform normalization processing to obtain the normalized subjective weight vector β , expressed as:
[0042] ,
[0043] It is expressed as:
[0044] .
[0045] The present invention has the following technical effects:
[0046] (1)Improved the accuracy of health status assessment
[0047] In the technical solution disclosed in the present invention, by reasonably selecting equipment performance parameters, based on N performance parameters M The parameter sample matrix is constructed by using samples, and the similarity between the performance parameter samples and the equipment's optimal state sequence is calculated to quantify the closeness between the sample data and the equipment's optimal state sequence. The comprehensive weight is reasonably set based on the objective weight and subjective weight, and the weighted similarity is calculated, and then the geometric mean method is used to calculate the health of the radar and reactance equipment. The technical solution disclosed in the present invention is based on the equipment performance parameter data samples, uses objective weights and subjective weight allocation, and calculates the quantitative evaluation results of the health status of the radar and reactance equipment based on scientific evaluation theory. Compared with the prior art, it not only improves the accuracy of the health status evaluation results of the radar and reactance equipment, improves the evaluation work efficiency, but also overcomes the drawbacks of the traditional health status evaluation method, which also has a certain reference value for guiding the future state operation of the equipment.
[0048] (2) Improved the work efficiency of health status assessment
[0049] In the technical solution disclosed in the present invention, based on N performance parameters M samples are used to evaluate the health status of the equipment. The sample data of the performance parameters come from a variety of sources, including historical operation data, periodic detection data, and maintenance and guarantee data, etc., so as to accurately cover the working range of the equipment; based on the above performance parameter data samples, a scientific evaluation method is adopted to calculate the quantitative detection results of the health status of the equipment. In the prior art, the detection data of the equipment status mainly comes from two methods, one is from on-site in-situ detection, and the other is from offline detection. These two equipment health status detection methods in the prior art are either prone to inaccurate health status evaluation results, or are prone to time-consuming and labor-intensive evaluation processes, and low work efficiency. Therefore, compared with the prior art, the technical solution disclosed in the present invention, under the premise of ensuring the accuracy of the equipment health status evaluation, has diverse data sources, a simple evaluation process, and a scientific evaluation method, which greatly improves the work efficiency of the equipment health status evaluation. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0050] The principles and features of the present invention are described below in conjunction with embodiments. The examples given are only used to explain the present invention and are not used to limit the scope of the present invention.
[0051] In the prior art, the traditional equipment health status evaluation method is mainly carried out by the equipment maintenance center through regular intensive maintenance. Performance parameter detection mainly adopts two methods: first, offline detection is not only time-consuming and labor-intensive, but also has a long detection cycle and low detection efficiency. In addition, it is easy to damage the integrity of the equipment during disassembly and transportation. In addition, it is difficult for the detection indicators to truly reflect the actual operating status of the equipment without the actual operating environment of the equipment. Second, the in-situ detection method is adopted, which has a large workload, easily causes waste of maintenance resources, and has low evaluation efficiency. Furthermore, in the prior art, the health status evaluation method of radar and reactance equipment lacks scientific evaluation theory guidance. The health status evaluation can usually only give qualitative results, but not quantitative results, resulting in the health status evaluation results having no guiding value for the future operation of the equipment.
[0052] In order to solve this problem, an embodiment of the present invention discloses a radar and reactance equipment health status evaluation method based on weight optimization. The method comprises the following steps:
[0053] (S1) Obtain radar and reactance equipment N performance parameters M samples, among which the i A sample of performance parameters is represented as , where , , Indicates i The performance parameter j Sample data;
[0054] (S2) N performance parameters M The samples are normalized and converted into dimensionless values ranging from 0 to 1;
[0055] (S3) Construct the normalized samples into a parameter sample matrix ,in, For the matrix Z The element of i performance parameters j The dimensionless value of samples;
[0056] (S4) Calculation N The comprehensive weight distribution vector of performance parameters ,in, Indicates i The comprehensive weight of the performance parameters ,in Indicates i The objective weight value of each performance parameter, Indicates i The subjective weight value of each performance parameter, represents the weight distribution coefficient;
[0057] (S5) Calculate the similarity between the performance parameter samples of radar and reactance equipment and the equipment's optimal state sequence:
[0058] ,
[0059] Indicates that the independent variable is j Time The minimum value of Indicates that the independent variable is i Time Minimum value, Indicates that the independent variable is j Time The maximum value of Indicates that the independent variable is i Time Maximum value, Represents the similarity coefficient, with a value range of 0~1 and a typical value of 0.5;
[0060] (S6) Calculate weighted similarity :
[0061] ;
[0062] (S7) Calculate the health of radar and reactance equipment using the geometric mean method :
[0063] ,
[0064] In the technical solution disclosed in the embodiment of the present invention, the health The larger the value, the better the working performance of the radar and the reactance equipment. Typically, in the technical solution disclosed in the embodiment of the present invention, according to the health The size of the device is divided into four types using the four-point method. When ≥0.9, the health status level is excellent, the radar and reactance equipment can operate stably for a long time, and can ensure the smooth completion of the work task; when 0.75≤ <0.9, the health status level is good, the radar and reactance equipment can operate for a long time without affecting the completion of work tasks; when 0.6≤ <0.75, the health status level is qualified. During the operation, radar and reactance equipment may have slight faults and cannot operate continuously, which will affect the completion of high-intensity work tasks. The supervision of the working status of the equipment should be strengthened. When it is <0.6, the health status level is severely degraded. The radar and reactance equipment will have serious faults during operation and there will be major safety hazards. The work tasks cannot be completed and fault troubleshooting or equipment replacement should be carried out immediately.
[0065] Furthermore, in the technical solution disclosed in the embodiment of the present invention, by reasonably selecting the performance parameters of the equipment, based on N performance parameters M A parameter sample matrix is constructed by using samples, and the sample data of each performance parameter is regarded as an uncertain sequence. The similarity between the performance parameter sample and the equipment optimal state sequence is calculated to quantify the closeness between the sample data and the equipment optimal state sequence. The greater the similarity, the smaller the distance from the equipment optimal state sequence, that is, the better the health state. Furthermore, in order to reasonably evaluate the status of each performance parameter sample in the equipment health state evaluation, it is necessary to reasonably assign weights to each performance parameter. In the technical solution disclosed in the embodiment of the present invention, on the basis of scientifically calculating the objective weight and subjective weight of each performance parameter, the weights of the performance parameters are assigned to the performance parameters. N The comprehensive weights of the performance parameters are reasonably set, and on this basis, the weighted similarity is calculated to comprehensively evaluate NThe geometric mean method is used to calculate the health of the radar and reactance equipment by taking the performance parameters as a whole and comparing them with the optimal state sequence of the equipment. The technical solution disclosed in the embodiment of the present invention is based on the equipment performance parameter data sample, adopts objective weight and subjective weight distribution, and calculates the quantitative evaluation results of the health status of the radar and reactance equipment based on scientific evaluation theory. Compared with the prior art, it not only improves the accuracy of the health status evaluation results of the radar and reactance equipment, improves the evaluation work efficiency, but also overcomes the drawbacks of the traditional health status evaluation method, which also has a certain reference value for guiding the future operation of the equipment.
[0066] In the prior art, for the weight allocation of multiple performance parameters of radar and reactive equipment, subjective weight allocation is usually performed by expert scoring. This allocation method is greatly affected by personal subjective consciousness, and weakens the importance of objective data in the evaluation basis of equipment health status. Furthermore, in the process of weight allocation of multiple performance parameters of radar and reactive equipment, if only subjective weight allocation is performed by expert scoring, it will be greatly affected by individual differences in scoring; however, if only objective data is used for objective weight allocation, and the subjective tendency of expert scoring is ignored, it is also easy to cause mismatch with the evaluation object.
[0067] In order to overcome the shortcomings of the prior art in the weight allocation of performance parameters, the technical solution disclosed in the embodiment of the present invention adopts a method of combining subjective weights with objective weights. N The comprehensive weight distribution vector of performance parameters is expressed as ,in, Indicates i The comprehensive weight value of the performance parameters is expressed as:
[0068] ,
[0069] Where i=1,2,… N , represents the objective weight value of the i-th performance parameter, represents the subjective weight value of the i-th performance parameter, represents the weight distribution coefficient, typically, The value of is 0.5.
[0070] Furthermore, in the technical solution disclosed in the embodiment of the present invention, the objective weight calculation step of the performance parameter includes:
[0071] (A1) Calculate the variance of the sample data of radar and reactance equipment performance parameters :
[0072] ;
[0073] (A2) Calculate the difference in performance parameters between radar and reactance equipment :
[0074] ;
[0075] (A3) Computational radar and reactance equipment N The objective weight vector of performance parameters :
[0076] ;
[0077] but It is expressed as:
[0078] .
[0079] In the technical solution disclosed in the embodiment of the present invention, the distribution of objective weights is based on the radar and reactance equipment. N performance parameters M Based on samples, we can calculate N The variance of each performance parameter is used to describe the fluctuation of the difference between the sample data of each performance parameter. On this basis, the difference between the performance parameters of radar and reactance equipment is calculated to measure the correlation between the performance parameters, and then the normalized method is used to calculate the variance of each performance parameter. N The objective weight allocation scheme is to allocate objective weights to each performance parameter. In this objective weight allocation scheme, the objective weight of each performance parameter is completely controlled by the data sample, is not affected by subjective factors, and has good objectivity.
[0080] Furthermore, in the technical solution disclosed in the embodiment of the present invention, the step of calculating the subjective weight of the performance parameter includes:
[0081] (B1) Using a scale of 1-9, using expert scoring, construct the N Consistency matrix of performance parameters :
[0082] ,
[0083] Among them, the Indicates radar and reactance equipment i Performance parameters Relative to the j Performance parameters The importance value of k =1,2,… N ;
[0084] Further, the "1-9" scale is shown in Table 1:
[0085] Table 1: "1-9" scale
[0086]
[0087] Regarding how to construct a discriminant matrix that satisfies consistency, reference may be made to the relevant theories of the hierarchical analysis method. For those skilled in the art, this is existing knowledge and conventional technical means, and will not be elaborated here.
[0088] (B2) Calculate the starting weight vector :
[0089] The consistency discriminant matrix Transform to get the normalized matrix ,in k =1,2,… N ;
[0090] ,
[0091] The normalized matrix P Each element in is added row by row to get the starting weight vector Q :
[0092] ,
[0093] in It is expressed as:
[0094] ;
[0095] (B3) Calculate the normalized subjective weight vector of radar and reactance equipment performance parameters β :
[0096] For the starting weight vector Q Perform normalization processing to obtain the normalized subjective weight vector β , expressed as:
[0097] ,
[0098] It is expressed as:
[0099] .
[0100] Through the above analysis, it can be seen that in the technical solution disclosed in the embodiment of the present invention, the subjective weight distribution of performance parameters is completed by expert scoring, and the objective weight distribution is realized based on the data sample variance and difference. On this basis, weight priority is performed to realize the comprehensive weight distribution of performance parameters. This weight distribution not only reflects the subjective tendency of expert scoring, but also takes objective data as the basis, thereby improving the rationality of the weight proportion of each performance parameter in the health status evaluation process of radar and reactance equipment, which is conducive to improving the accuracy of health status evaluation.
[0101] Furthermore, in order to further improve the accuracy of the health status evaluation of radar and reactance equipment, the performance parameter type should be reasonably selected. In the technical solution disclosed in the embodiment of the present invention, the performance parameters involve the transmission performance detection, receiving performance detection and working environment detection of radar and reactance equipment, so as to achieve comprehensive and accurate detection of the health status of radar and reactance equipment. Specifically, in the technical solution disclosed in the embodiment of the present invention, the radar and reactance equipment N performance parameters M samples, respectively, are represented as:
[0102] Transmit power: ;
[0103] Excitation power: ;
[0104] Antenna standing wave ratio: ;
[0105] Instantaneous bandwidth: ;
[0106] Receiving sensitivity: ;
[0107] Operating Temperature: .
[0108] Among them, the size of the transmission power directly affects the coverage and signal quality of the electromagnetic wave signals of radar and reactance equipment; the excitation power is used to describe the power provided by the amplifier to the transmission output, and is an important indicator for detecting the amplifier performance of the transmitter; the antenna standing wave ratio is a typical negative indicator data type, which is used to reflect the degree to which the radio frequency energy of radar and reactance equipment is reflected, and directly affects the radiation capability of the equipment; the instantaneous bandwidth is used to describe the spectrum width occupied by the transmission signals of radar and reactance equipment; the receiving sensitivity is a typical scalar parameter, which is used to describe the minimum intensity that radar and reactance equipment can receive and still process the received signal normally, and directly affects the receiving capability of the equipment receiver; the operating temperature is used to describe the equipment temperature when the radar and reactance equipment are working, and is used to measure the heat dissipation or cooling capacity of the equipment.
[0109] Further, in the technical solution disclosed in the embodiment of the present invention, the sample data of the performance parameters are obtained from multiple channels, abandoning the traditional maintenance center detection method. The sample data comes from historical operation data, periodic detection data and maintenance guarantee data, etc., so as to accurately cover the equipment working range; based on the above data samples, a scientific evaluation method is adopted to calculate the quantitative detection results of the equipment health status. In the prior art, the data samples of the equipment health status mainly come from two methods. First, the offline detection method is adopted, which is not only labor-intensive and time-consuming, has a long detection cycle and low detection efficiency, but also easily destroys the integrity of the equipment during disassembly and transportation; in addition, it is separated from the actual operating environment of the equipment, and the detection indicators are difficult to truly reflect the actual operating status of the equipment. Second, the in-situ detection method is adopted, which has a large workload, is easy to cause a waste of maintenance resources, and has low evaluation efficiency. Therefore, compared with the prior art, the technical solution disclosed in the embodiment of the present invention has a variety of data sources and a simple detection process under the premise of ensuring the accuracy of equipment health status detection, which greatly improves the evaluation work efficiency.
[0110] Furthermore, in the technical solution disclosed in the embodiment of the present invention, there are various types of performance parameters used for health status evaluation. Different types of performance parameters reflect different aspects of the status of radar and reactance equipment, but the sizes or magnitudes of the above performance parameters also vary greatly. In order to reasonably evaluate the health status of radar and reactance equipment, it is necessary to normalize and dimensionlessly process different types of performance parameter samples and convert them into dimensionless values in the range of 0 to 1.
[0111] In the prior art, the types of performance parameters can be divided into three types: benefit type, cost type and interval type. Among them, the benefit type attribute is also called a positive attribute, which means that the larger the value, the better the performance; the cost type is also called a negative attribute, which means that the smaller the value, the better the performance; the interval type is also called a moderate type, which means that the closer the value is to a certain constant, the better the performance. In the technical solution disclosed in the embodiment of the present invention, the normalization method can adopt a linear change method, a range transformation method, a vector transformation method, a trigonometric function transformation method, and a logarithmic transformation method. As for how to normalize to a dimensionless value of 0~1, for those skilled in the art, it belongs to existing knowledge or common practices and will not be repeated here.
[0112] The above description is only a preferred embodiment of the present invention and is not intended to limit the present invention. Any modifications, equivalent substitutions, improvements, etc. made within the spirit and principle of the present invention should be included in the protection scope of the present invention.
Claims
1. Radar and reactance equipment health status evaluation method based on weight optimization, It is characterized in that The following steps are involved: (S1) Obtain radar and reactance equipment N performance parameters M samples, among which the i A sample of performance parameters is represented as , where , , Indicates i The performance parameter j Sample data; (S2) N performance parameters M The samples are normalized and converted into dimensionless values ranging from 0 to 1; (S3) Construct the normalized samples into a parameter sample matrix ,in, For the matrix Z The element of i performance parameters j The dimensionless value of samples; (S4) Calculation N The comprehensive weight distribution vector of performance parameters ,in, Indicates i The comprehensive weight of the performance parameters ,in Indicates i The objective weight value of each performance parameter, Indicates i The subjective weight value of each performance parameter, represents the weight distribution coefficient; (S5) Calculate the similarity between the performance parameter samples of radar and reactance equipment and the equipment's optimal state sequence: , Indicates that the independent variable is j Time The minimum value of Indicates that the independent variable is i Time Minimum value, Indicates that the independent variable is j Time The maximum value of Indicates that the independent variable is i Time Maximum value, represents the similarity coefficient; (S6) Calculate weighted similarity : ; (S7) Calculate the health of radar and reactance equipment using the geometric mean method : , Health The larger the value, the better the working performance of the radar and reactance equipment.
2. The radar and reactance equipment health status evaluation method based on weight optimization according to claim 1, It is characterized in that The objective weight calculation step of the performance parameter comprises: (A1) Calculate the variance of the sample data of radar and reactance equipment performance parameters : ; (A2) Calculate the difference in performance parameters between radar and reactance equipment : ; (A3) Computational radar and reactance equipment N The objective weight vector of performance parameters : ; but It is expressed as: 。 3. The radar and reactance equipment health status evaluation method based on weight optimization according to claim 1, It is characterized in that The step of calculating the subjective weight of the performance parameter comprises: (B1) Using a scale of "1-9", using expert scoring, construct the N Consistency matrix of performance parameters : , Among them, the Indicates radar and reactance equipment i Performance parameters Relative to the j Performance parameters The importance value of k =1,2,… N ; (B2) Calculate the starting weight vector : The consistency discriminant matrix Transform to get the normalized matrix ,in: , The normalized matrix P Each element in is added row by row to get the starting weight vector Q : , in It is expressed as: ; (B3) Calculate the normalized subjective weight vector of radar and reactance equipment performance parameters β : For the starting weight vector Q Perform normalization processing to obtain the normalized subjective weight vector β , expressed as: , It is expressed as: 。
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Radar transmitter state evaluation method based on fuzzy comprehensive evaluation and comprehensive weighting
CN114118789A
Radar equipment health state evaluation method based on fuzzy analytic hierarchy process
CN114841576A
Ship-borne radar active jamming system effectiveness evaluation method
CN115372912A
Method and system for evaluating health state of main equipment of large-scale transformer substation
CN117454131A
Radar device and performance deterioration discriminating method of radar device
JP2013068571A
