A method for analog modulation recognition based on time-frequency characteristic parameters

By using a time-frequency characteristic parameter-based method, which utilizes the segmented average instantaneous envelope variance and the maximum prominence of the power spectrum lines, the problem of analog signal modulation identification in complex communication environments is solved, achieving efficient identification under harsh conditions and demonstrating good practical value.

CN118764352BActive Publication Date: 2024-11-08龙文华丰(北京)科技有限公司
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202411249888.2
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2024-09-06
Publication Date
2024-11-08
Estimated Expiration
2044-09-06

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing technologies struggle to effectively identify analog signal modulation schemes in complex communication environments, especially when Doppler frequency offset is large and nonlinear effects are severe. Traditional methods are computationally intensive and have poor noise immunity, while machine learning-based methods require a large amount of labeled data and perform poorly in harsh channel environments.

Method used

By obtaining the segmented average instantaneous envelope variance of the signal, and combining the measures of the maximum prominence of the power spectrum line and the maximum prominence of the square spectrum line, a method based on time-frequency characteristic parameters is used to classify the signal into constant envelope signals and non-constant envelope signals, and further distinguish different types of analog modulation methods.

Benefits of technology

In harsh communication environments characterized by Doppler frequency offset, high dynamics, and nonlinear distortion, the identification of analog signal modulation methods was achieved. The computational load was moderate, the real-time performance was good, the identification accuracy was high, and it was suitable for low signal-to-noise ratio conditions.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN118764352B_ABST
    Figure CN118764352B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention discloses an analog modulation recognition method based on time-frequency characteristic parameters, including: obtaining the instantaneous envelope variance of the segmented average of the signal; classifying the signal into a constant envelope signal and a non-constant envelope signal according to the instantaneous envelope variance; classifying the constant envelope signal into a CW signal, an FM signal, and a PM signal according to the measurement value of the maximum protrusion degree of the power spectrum line; classifying the non-constant envelope signal into an AM signal, an SSB signal, and a DSB signal according to the measurement value of the maximum protrusion degree of the power spectrum line; distinguishing the DSB signal from the SSB signal according to the measurement value of the maximum protrusion degree of the square spectrum line of other non-constant envelope signals. The invention can identify the analog signal modulation mode under the condition of a low signal-to-noise ratio in a harsh communication environment with large Doppler frequency deviation, high dynamics, and nonlinear distortion, with moderate calculation amount, good real-time performance, and good practical value.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present invention relates to the field of communication technology, and in particular to an analog modulation recognition method based on time-frequency characteristic parameters. Background Art

[0002] Modulation recognition technology is a technology that uses signal prior information or statistical information to identify the modulation mode of a signal. Correctly identifying the modulation mode of a signal is a prerequisite for signal demodulation. Although we have entered the era of digital communications, analog modulation still has a wide range of applications in many applications, such as satellite measurement and control, satellite broadcasting, etc. In addition, in actual complex communication scenarios, the channel may have problems such as large Doppler frequency deviation and serious nonlinear effects, which undoubtedly poses a huge challenge to analog signal modulation recognition. In the face of the above challenges, it is particularly important to design analog signal modulation recognition technology with good robustness in complex communication environments.

[0003] Traditional analog modulation recognition schemes are usually implemented by extracting instantaneous characteristic parameters of the signal, such as zero-centered normalized instantaneous amplitude, zero-centered normalized instantaneous frequency, etc. This type of scheme has the advantages of small computational complexity and simple threshold demarcation. However, this type of method often has certain requirements for baseband signals. For example, when the envelope of the amplitude modulation signal (AM) changes slowly, the recognition method based on the zero-centered normalized instantaneous amplitude variance cannot distinguish it well from the single carrier signal (CW). In addition, the instantaneous frequency parameters often have poor anti-noise performance. Therefore, the universality and overall anti-noise performance of this type of method still have room for improvement.

[0004] On the other hand, with the development of artificial intelligence technology, analog modulation recognition algorithms based on machine learning have gradually become an emerging research topic. Such algorithms include those based on graph neural networks, incremental learning, and support vector machines. However, such algorithms require a large amount of labeled training data, which is often difficult to obtain. At the same time, such algorithms perform poorly when facing signals with abnormal distortion and are not suitable for communication systems with harsh channel environments. Summary of the invention

[0005] In order to solve the limitations and defects of the prior art, the present invention provides an analog modulation recognition method based on time-frequency characteristic parameters, comprising:

[0006] Step S1, obtaining the instantaneous envelope variance of the segmented average of the signal;

[0007] Step S2, comparing the instantaneous envelope variance with a first preset threshold;

[0008] If the comparison result is that the instantaneous envelope variance is less than the first preset threshold, execute step S3; if the comparison result is that the instantaneous envelope variance is greater than or equal to the first preset threshold, execute step S6;

[0009] Step S3, classifying the signal into a constant envelope signal, wherein the constant envelope signal includes a CW signal, an FM signal, and a PM signal;

[0010] Step S4, obtaining a measurement value of the maximum prominence degree of the power spectrum line of the constant envelope signal;

[0011] Step S5, comparing the measurement value of the maximum prominence degree of the power spectrum line with a second preset threshold;

[0012] If the comparison result is that the measurement value of the maximum protrusion degree of the power spectrum line is greater than the second preset threshold, the constant envelope signal corresponding to the measurement value of the maximum protrusion degree of the power spectrum line is classified as a CW signal; if the comparison result is that the measurement value of the maximum protrusion degree of the power spectrum line is less than or equal to the second preset threshold, the constant envelope signal corresponding to the measurement value of the maximum protrusion degree of the power spectrum line is classified as other constant envelope signals, and the other constant envelope signals include FM signals and PM signals;

[0013] Step S6, classifying the signal into a non-constant envelope signal, wherein the non-constant envelope signal includes an AM signal, an SSB signal, and a DSB signal;

[0014] Step S7, obtaining a measurement value of the maximum prominence degree of the power spectrum line of the non-constant envelope signal;

[0015] Step S8, comparing the measurement value of the maximum prominence degree of the power spectrum line with a third preset threshold;

[0016] If the comparison result is that the measurement value of the maximum prominence degree of the power spectrum line is greater than the third preset threshold, the non-constant envelope signal corresponding to the measurement value of the maximum prominence degree of the power spectrum line is classified as an AM signal; if the comparison result is that the measurement value of the maximum prominence degree of the power spectrum line is less than or equal to the third preset threshold, the non-constant envelope signal corresponding to the measurement value of the maximum prominence degree of the power spectrum line is classified as other non-constant envelope signals, and the other non-constant envelope signals include SSB signals and DSB signals;

[0017] Step S9, obtaining a measure of the maximum prominence of the square spectrum lines of the other non-constant envelope signals;

[0018] Step S10, comparing the double frequency carrier component in the square spectrum with a fourth preset threshold;

[0019] If the comparison result is that the double frequency carrier component in the square spectrum is greater than the fourth preset threshold, the other non-constant envelope signals are classified as DSB signals; if the comparison result is that the double frequency carrier component in the square spectrum is less than or equal to the fourth preset threshold, the other non-constant envelope signals are classified as SSB signals.

[0020] Optionally, the step S1 includes:

[0021] Step S11, calculating the zero-center normalized instantaneous amplitude of the signal, wherein the zero-center normalized instantaneous amplitude is the instantaneous envelope of the signal;

[0022] Step S12, averaging the non-overlapping segments of the instantaneous envelope of the signal;

[0023] Step S13: Calculate the variance of the segmented average instantaneous envelope to obtain the segmented average instantaneous envelope variance of the signal.

[0024] Optionally, step S4 includes:

[0025] Step S41, setting a sliding window length of a preset length;

[0026] Step S42, recording the value of the central spectrum line of the sliding window;

[0027] Step S43, removing a preset number of spectral lines on both sides of the central spectral line of the sliding window;

[0028] Step S44, calculating the mean of other spectral lines in the sliding window, where the other spectral lines in the sliding window are spectral lines other than the central spectral line and the discarded spectral line;

[0029] Step S45, dividing the value of the central spectral line of the sliding window by the average of other spectral lines in the sliding window to obtain a measure of the prominence of the central spectral line of the current sliding window;

[0030] Slide the window to the next central spectral line, repeat steps S42 to S45, and obtain the prominence measurement value of all spectral lines in the power spectrum;

[0031] Step S46: Select the maximum value among the measurement values ​​of the prominence of all spectral lines as the measurement value of the maximum prominence of the power spectrum line of the constant envelope signal.

[0032] Optionally, step S7 includes:

[0033] Step S71, setting a sliding window length of a preset length;

[0034] Step S72, recording the value of the central spectrum line of the sliding window;

[0035] Step S73, removing a preset number of spectral lines on both sides of the central spectral line of the sliding window;

[0036] Step S74, calculating the mean of other spectral lines in the sliding window, where the other spectral lines in the sliding window are spectral lines other than the central spectral line and the discarded spectral line;

[0037] Step S75, dividing the value of the central spectral line of the sliding window by the average of other spectral lines in the sliding window to obtain a measure of the prominence of the central spectral line of the current sliding window;

[0038] Slide the window to the next central spectral line, repeat steps S72 to S75, and obtain the prominence measurement value of all spectral lines in the power spectrum;

[0039] Step S76: Select the maximum value among the measurement values ​​of the prominence degree of all spectral lines as the measurement value of the maximum prominence degree of the power spectrum line of the non-constant envelope signal.

[0040] Optionally, step S9 includes:

[0041] Step S91, setting a sliding window length of a preset length;

[0042] Step S92, recording the value of the central spectrum line of the sliding window;

[0043] Step S93, removing a preset number of spectral lines on both sides of the central spectral line of the sliding window;

[0044] Step S94, calculating the mean of other spectral lines in the sliding window, where the other spectral lines in the sliding window are spectral lines other than the central spectral line and the discarded spectral line;

[0045] Step S95, dividing the value of the central spectral line of the sliding window by the average of other spectral lines in the sliding window to obtain a measure of the prominence of the central spectral line of the current sliding window;

[0046] Slide the window to the next central spectral line, and repeat steps S92 to S95 to obtain the prominence measurement values ​​of all spectral lines in the power spectrum;

[0047] Step S96: Select the maximum value among the measurement values ​​of the prominence of all spectral lines as the measurement value of the maximum prominence of the square spectrum lines of the other non-constant envelope signal.

[0048] The present invention has the following beneficial effects:

[0049] The present invention provides an analog modulation recognition method based on time-frequency characteristic parameters, including: obtaining the instantaneous envelope variance of the segmented average of the signal; classifying the signal into a constant envelope signal and a non-constant envelope signal according to the instantaneous envelope variance; classifying the constant envelope signal into a CW signal, an FM signal, and a PM signal according to the measurement value of the maximum protrusion degree of the power spectrum line; classifying the non-constant envelope signal into an AM signal, an SSB signal, and a DSB signal according to the measurement value of the maximum protrusion degree of the power spectrum line; and distinguishing the DSB signal from the SSB signal according to the measurement value of the maximum protrusion degree of the square spectrum line of other non-constant envelope signals. The present invention can identify the analog signal modulation mode under the condition of a low signal-to-noise ratio in a harsh communication environment with large Doppler frequency deviation, high dynamics, and nonlinear distortion, with moderate calculation amount, good real-time performance, and good practical value. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0050] Figure 1 This is a flow chart of an analog modulation recognition method based on time-frequency characteristic parameters provided in the first embodiment of the present invention.

[0051] Figure 2 The figure is a schematic diagram of a curve showing a change in the analog modulation recognition accuracy rate versus the signal-to-noise ratio provided by the first embodiment of the present invention under a linear channel.

[0052] Figure 3 The figure is a schematic diagram of a curve showing a change in the analog modulation recognition accuracy rate versus the signal-to-noise ratio provided by the first embodiment of the present invention under a nonlinear channel. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0053] In order to enable those skilled in the art to better understand the technical solution of the present invention, the analog modulation recognition method based on time-frequency characteristic parameters provided by the present invention is described in detail below with reference to the accompanying drawings. Embodiment 1

[0054] This embodiment conducts research around the time-frequency characteristic parameters of analog signals, combines the instantaneous characteristics of analog signals with the spectrum characteristics, and proposes an analog signal modulation recognition method based on time-frequency characteristic parameters on the basis of traditional recognition algorithms. This method can recognize analog signal modulation modes under conditions of low signal-to-noise ratio in harsh communication environments with large Doppler frequency deviation, high dynamics, and nonlinear distortion, while having moderate computational complexity, good real-time performance, and good practical value.

[0055] Figure 1 Flow chart of the analog modulation recognition method based on time-frequency characteristic parameters provided in the first embodiment of the present invention. Figure 1 As shown, this embodiment proposes a method for identifying the modulation mode of an analog signal based on time-frequency domain characteristic parameters. This method is aimed at analog signals with unknown modulation modes and can effectively identify the modulation mode of the signal when the signal undergoes nonlinear distortion and has a high dynamic Doppler frequency deviation.

[0056] Step 1: Calculate the instantaneous envelope variance of the segmented average

[0057] The calculation process of the instantaneous envelope variance of the segmented average is as follows:

[0058] (1) Calculate the zero-centered normalized instantaneous amplitude of the signal, that is, the instantaneous envelope of the signal;

[0059] (2) Average the non-overlapping segments of the signal's instantaneous envelope. For example, take every 32 sampling points as a segment and average the sampling points within the segment. There are no repeated sampling points between segments.

[0060] (3) Calculate the variance of the segmented average instantaneous envelope.

[0061] For constant envelope signals, the ideal instantaneous envelope variance is zero, while the instantaneous envelope variance of non-constant envelope signals is often larger. Based on this, signals can be divided into two categories: constant envelope signals {CW, FM, PM} and non-constant envelope signals {AM, SSB, DSB}.

[0062] In addition, for non-constant envelope signals with slow envelope changes, directly calculating the instantaneous envelope variance will be too small, which will lead to misjudgment. By performing segmented averaging on the instantaneous envelope of the signal, local envelope information can be extracted, and the variance can be enhanced to reflect the change of the overall envelope of the signal, thereby increasing the envelope variance of the slow-changing non-constant envelope signal. Segmented averaging effectively expands the application range of the algorithm.

[0063] Step 2: Calculate the maximum prominence measure of the power spectrum line

[0064] This step first needs to calculate the power spectrum of the signal, and then slide and search for the maximum prominence of its spectrum line. The metric value reflecting the maximum prominence of the spectrum line is calculated as follows:

[0065] (1) Set an appropriate sliding window length;

[0066] (2) Record the value of the central spectral line of the sliding window;

[0067] (3) Eliminate several spectral lines on both sides of the central spectral line of the sliding window, for example, 2;

[0068] (4) Calculate the mean of all spectral lines in the window except the central spectral line and the excluded spectral line;

[0069] (5) Divide the central spectral line value by the mean value obtained in step (4) to obtain the prominence measure of the central spectral line of the current sliding window;

[0070] (6) Slide the window to the next central spectral line and repeat the above steps (2) to (5) to obtain the prominence measurement values ​​of all spectral lines in the power spectrum;

[0071] (7) Select the maximum value in step (6) as the measure of the maximum prominence of the signal power spectrum line.

[0072] In the constant envelope signal set {CW, FM, PM}, the CW signal is a single-carrier signal, and the maximum prominence of its power spectrum line is much greater than that of FM and PM signals; while in the non-constant envelope signal set {AM, SSB, DSB}, the AM signal is a non-carrier suppressed modulation signal, and its power spectrum contains a significant carrier component, so the maximum prominence of its power spectrum line is much greater than that of carrier suppressed signals such as SSB and DSB. Therefore, through this step, CW signals can be distinguished from FM and PM signals in the constant envelope signal set, and AM signals can be distinguished from SSB and DSB signals in the non-constant envelope signal set.

[0073] It is worth noting that since the prominence metric of the CW signal is significantly greater than that of the AM signal, and the prominence metric of the FM and PM signals is slightly greater than that of the SSB and DSB signals, different threshold parameters need to be used when this method is applied in different sets to achieve effective signal identification.

[0074] Step 3: Calculate the maximum prominence measure of the square spectrum line

[0075] This step first needs to calculate the square power spectrum of the signal, and then perform a sliding search for the maximum prominence of the spectrum line. The calculation method of the metric value reflecting the maximum prominence of the spectrum line is the same as step 2, and will not be repeated here.

[0076] In this step, the DSB signal will have a significant double frequency carrier component in its square power spectrum due to its symmetry with respect to the carrier frequency; while the SSB signal suppresses one of the sidebands when generating the signal, and its symmetry with respect to the carrier frequency is destroyed, so there will be no significant double frequency carrier component in its square spectrum. Therefore, the DSB signal can be distinguished from the SSB signal through this step.

[0077] This embodiment can identify the analog signal modulation mode under conditions of low signal-to-noise ratio in a harsh communication environment with large Doppler frequency deviation, high dynamics, and nonlinear distortion, with moderate calculation amount, good real-time performance, and good practical value.

[0078] This embodiment simulates and tests the performance of the method under linear channels and nonlinear channels respectively. The linear channel adopts a single-path Gaussian white noise channel model with Doppler frequency deviation, and the nonlinear channel is generated by cascading a linear channel and a Volterra nonlinear channel. The linear channel test environment parameters are shown in Table 1, and the Volterra nonlinear channel parameters are shown in Table 2. The modulation mode set of the test signal is {CW, FM, PM, AM, DSB, SSB}. Among them, FM is divided into narrowband FM (NBFM) and wideband FM (WBFM), and their modulation indexes are 0.01 and 3 respectively; the PM signal modulation index is 1.5; the AM signal modulation index is 0.3; the SSB signal is divided into an upper sideband signal (USB) and a lower sideband signal (LSB). Under the conditions of linear channels and nonlinear channels, the recognition accuracy curves of various modulation modes obtained by testing are shown as follows. Figure 2 and Figure 3 shown.

[0079] Table 1 Method test environment parameters

[0080]

[0081] Table 2 Volterra nonlinear channel parameters

[0082]

[0083] from Figure 2 It can be seen that the method proposed in this embodiment can accurately identify analog modulation modes with low signal-to-noise ratio under conventional linear channel conditions. When the signal-to-noise ratio is only 0dB, the recognition accuracy of all modulation modes reaches more than 99%.

[0084] from Figure 3 It can be seen that the method proposed in this embodiment can still realize the recognition of analog modulation with low signal-to-noise ratio even under relatively poor communication conditions. When tested under nonlinear channel conditions, the proposed method can achieve recognition accuracy of all modulation modes above 99% for the 8 analog modulation signals studied when the signal-to-noise ratio is only 4dB.

[0085] In summary, the method proposed in this embodiment realizes analog modulation recognition under channel conditions with large Doppler frequency deviation and obvious nonlinear effect, and has good performance. At the same time, the method has moderate complexity, is easy to implement, and has good practical value in actual communication systems.

[0086] It is to be understood that the above embodiments are merely exemplary embodiments used to illustrate the principles of the present invention, but the present invention is not limited thereto. For those skilled in the art, various modifications and improvements can be made without departing from the spirit and essence of the present invention, and these modifications and improvements are also considered to be within the scope of protection of the present invention.

Claims

1. A method for analog modulation recognition based on time-frequency characteristic parameters, characterized in that: include: Step S1, obtaining the instantaneous envelope variance of the segmented average of the signal; Step S2, comparing the instantaneous envelope variance with a first preset threshold; If the comparison result is that the instantaneous envelope variance is less than the first preset threshold, executing step S3; If the comparison result is that the instantaneous envelope variance is greater than or equal to the first preset threshold, executing step S6; Step S3, classifying the signal into a constant envelope signal, wherein the constant envelope signal includes a CW signal, an FM signal, and a PM signal; Step S4, obtaining a measurement value of the maximum prominence degree of the power spectrum line of the constant envelope signal; Step S5, comparing the measurement value of the maximum prominence degree of the power spectrum line with a second preset threshold; If the comparison result is that the measurement value of the maximum protrusion degree of the power spectrum line is greater than the second preset threshold, classifying the constant envelope signal corresponding to the measurement value of the maximum protrusion degree of the power spectrum line as a CW signal; If the comparison result is that the measurement value of the maximum protrusion degree of the power spectrum line is less than or equal to the second preset threshold, classify the constant envelope signal corresponding to the measurement value of the maximum protrusion degree of the power spectrum line as other constant envelope signals, and the other constant envelope signals include FM signals and PM signals; Step S6, classifying the signal into a non-constant envelope signal, wherein the non-constant envelope signal includes an AM signal, an SSB signal, and a DSB signal; Step S7, obtaining a measurement value of the maximum prominence degree of the power spectrum line of the non-constant envelope signal; Step S8, comparing the measurement value of the maximum prominence degree of the power spectrum line with a third preset threshold; If the comparison result is that the measurement value of the maximum protrusion degree of the power spectrum line is greater than the third preset threshold, classifying the non-constant envelope signal corresponding to the measurement value of the maximum protrusion degree of the power spectrum line as an AM signal; If the comparison result is that the measurement value of the maximum protrusion degree of the power spectrum line is less than or equal to the third preset threshold, the non-constant envelope signal corresponding to the measurement value of the maximum protrusion degree of the power spectrum line is classified as other non-constant envelope signals, and the other non-constant envelope signals include SSB signals and DSB signals; Step S9, obtaining a measure of the maximum prominence of the square spectrum lines of the other non-constant envelope signals; Step S10, comparing the double frequency carrier component in the square spectrum with a fourth preset threshold; If the comparison result is that the double frequency carrier component in the square spectrum is greater than the fourth preset threshold, the other non-constant envelope signal is classified as a DSB signal; if the comparison result is that the double frequency carrier component in the square spectrum is less than or equal to the fourth preset threshold, the other non-constant envelope signal is classified as an SSB signal; The step S1 comprises: Step S11, calculating the zero-center normalized instantaneous amplitude of the signal, wherein the zero-center normalized instantaneous amplitude is the instantaneous envelope of the signal; Step S12, averaging the non-overlapping segments of the instantaneous envelope of the signal; Step S13, calculating the variance of the segmented average instantaneous envelope to obtain the segmented average instantaneous envelope variance of the signal; The step S4 comprises: Step S41, setting a sliding window length of a preset length; Step S42, recording the value of the central spectrum line of the sliding window; Step S43, removing a preset number of spectral lines on both sides of the central spectral line of the sliding window; Step S44, calculating the mean of other spectral lines in the sliding window, where the other spectral lines in the sliding window are spectral lines other than the central spectral line and the discarded spectral line; Step S45, dividing the value of the central spectral line of the sliding window by the average of other spectral lines in the sliding window to obtain a measure of the prominence of the central spectral line of the current sliding window; Slide the window to the next central spectral line, repeat steps S42 to S45, and obtain the prominence measurement value of all spectral lines in the power spectrum; Step S46: Select the maximum value among the measurement values ​​of the prominence of all spectral lines as the measurement value of the maximum prominence of the power spectrum line of the constant envelope signal.

2. The analog modulation recognition method based on time-frequency characteristic parameters according to claim 1 is characterized in that: The step S7 comprises: Step S71, setting a sliding window length of a preset length; Step S72, recording the value of the central spectrum line of the sliding window; Step S73, removing a preset number of spectral lines on both sides of the central spectral line of the sliding window; Step S74, calculating the mean of other spectral lines in the sliding window, where the other spectral lines in the sliding window are spectral lines other than the central spectral line and the discarded spectral line; Step S75, dividing the value of the central spectral line of the sliding window by the average of other spectral lines in the sliding window to obtain a measure of the prominence of the central spectral line of the current sliding window; Slide the window to the next central spectral line, repeat steps S72 to S75, and obtain the prominence measurement value of all spectral lines in the power spectrum; Step S76: Select the maximum value among the measurement values ​​of the prominence of all spectral lines as the measurement value of the maximum prominence of the power spectrum line of the non-constant envelope signal.

3. The analog modulation recognition method based on time-frequency characteristic parameters according to claim 2 is characterized in that: The step S9 comprises: Step S91, setting a sliding window length of a preset length; Step S92, recording the value of the central spectrum line of the sliding window; Step S93, removing a preset number of spectral lines on both sides of the central spectral line of the sliding window; Step S94, calculating the mean of other spectral lines in the sliding window, where the other spectral lines in the sliding window are spectral lines other than the central spectral line and the discarded spectral line; Step S95, dividing the value of the central spectral line of the sliding window by the average of other spectral lines in the sliding window to obtain a measure of the prominence of the central spectral line of the current sliding window; Slide the window to the next central spectral line, and repeat steps S92 to S95 to obtain the prominence measurement values ​​of all spectral lines in the power spectrum; Step S96: Select the maximum value among the measurement values ​​of the prominence degree of all spectral lines as the measurement value of the maximum prominence degree of the square spectrum spectral lines of the other non-constant envelope signal.