IGCT device pairing method applied to direct current converter valve
By matching the shutdown delay time and loss of the shutdown device, the problem of poor voltage equalization effect during active shutdown is solved, and voltage consistency is improved, and the grid voltage and power fluctuations are reduced.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202410914016.7
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-07-09
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-08
AI Technical Summary
In the prior art, the voltage equalization effect between devices during the active shutdown process is poor, resulting in fluctuations in the grid voltage and power in the DC transmission system. The existing matching methods cannot effectively solve this problem.
By obtaining the shutdown delay time and shutdown loss data of the shutdown device, matching it, ensuring that the shutdown delay time difference and loss difference of the matching device are within ±5%, so that the device can be shut down synchronously, thereby achieving the Improve voltage consistency in the active shutdown process.
It effectively reduces voltage inconsistency during active shutdown, reduces from 20% to less than 5%, and improves the voltage equalization effect.
Smart Images

Figure CN118920890A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present application relates to the field of direct current power transmission, and in particular to an IGCT device pairing method applied to a direct current converter valve. Background Art
[0002] With the development of the power system, high-voltage direct current transmission technology has become popular for its advantages in long-distance and large-capacity transmission. Among them, the traditional grid-commutated converter direct current transmission technology (Line-Commutated Converter based high voltage direct current, LCC-HVDC) has more obvious advantages in this regard. However, due to the use of semi-controlled devices such as thyristors in LCC, commutation failures may occur on the inverter side, and continuous commutation failures will lead to DC locking, causing fluctuations in grid voltage and power. In order to solve the inherent problem of commutation failure, a switchable converter topology is proposed in the prior art. The difference between this converter and the traditional grid-commutated converter is that each bridge arm is composed of a switchable valve string. The existing switchable converter topology is as follows: Figure 1 (a) and Figure 1 As shown in (b), a turn-off device-thyristor series structure is formed, and the turn-off device includes but is not limited to an insulated gate bipolar transistor IGBT, a gate turn-off thyristor GTO, an integrated gate-commutated thyristor IGCT, an injection enhanced gate transistor IEGT, etc.
[0003] For traditional thyristor commutator valves, since they do not need to consider the active shutdown process, they only need to match the parameters for reverse recovery voltage balancing. The previous method used reverse recovery charge parameters for matching.
[0004] The existing matching method for device reverse recovery charge has no obvious effect on active shutdown voltage balancing, and the active shutdown voltage balancing effect between devices is poor. Different devices are matched by reverse recovery charge parameters, and the matched devices have no obvious effect on active shutdown voltage balancing, and the active shutdown voltage balancing effect between devices is poor. Therefore, it is necessary to propose a matching method that can achieve voltage balance during the active shutdown process.
[0005] In summary, it is particularly important to design an IGCT device pairing method suitable for DC converter valves. Summary of the invention
[0006] In order to solve the deficiencies in the prior art, the purpose of the present application is to provide a pairing method for turn-off devices to solve the problem of poor voltage balancing during active shutdown. This matching method pairs devices according to shutdown delay time and shutdown loss data, connects successfully paired devices in series and then shuts them down synchronously, thereby improving the voltage consistency during the active shutdown process and achieving voltage balancing.
[0007] In order to achieve the above objectives, this application provides the following technical solutions:
[0008] A method for pairing a switchable device, the method comprising the following steps:
[0009] Acquire a plurality of turn-off parameters of each turn-off device among the plurality of turn-off devices, wherein the plurality of turn-off parameters include a current change parameter and a voltage change parameter;
[0010] Determining a turn-off delay time and a turn-off loss of each of the plurality of turn-off devices according to the plurality of turn-off parameters;
[0011] Determine the turn-off delay time difference and turn-off loss difference between two turn-off devices among the plurality of turn-off devices according to the turn-off delay time and turn-off loss of each turn-off device;
[0012] Matching the turn-off devices whose turn-off delay time difference is within a first predetermined range and whose turn-off loss difference is within a second predetermined range.
[0013] Furthermore,
[0014] The first predetermined range is -5% to 5%; and / or,
[0015] The second predetermined range is -5% to 5%.
[0016] Furthermore,
[0017] The shutdown delay time is: the time from when a shutdown instruction is issued to the switchable device to when the current flowing through the switchable device drops to a third predetermined value; and / or,
[0018] The turn-off loss is: the energy lost during the period from when the voltage of the turn-off device starts to rise to when the current flowing through the turn-off device drops to a predetermined value after a turn-off instruction is issued to the turn-off device.
[0019] Furthermore, the turnable device includes: one or more than two of an insulated gate bipolar transistor IGBT, a gate turn-off thyristor GTO, an integrated gate-commutated thyristor IGCT and an injection-enhanced gate transistor IEGT.
[0020] Furthermore,
[0021] The third predetermined value is 0.01-0.95 times the steady-state value of the current before issuing a shutdown instruction to the switchable device; and / or,
[0022] The fourth predetermined value is 0.01-0.20 times of the steady-state value of the current before issuing a shutdown instruction to the switchable device.
[0023] Furthermore,
[0024] The third predetermined value is 0.9 times the steady-state value of the current before issuing a shutdown instruction to the switchable device; and / or,
[0025] The fourth predetermined value is 0.1 times the steady-state value of the current before issuing a shutdown instruction to the switchable device.
[0026] Furthermore,
[0027] Firstly, a plurality of turn-off devices are matched according to a plurality of turn-off delay time differences, and then a plurality of turn-off devices are matched according to the matched plurality of turn-off delay time differences; or,
[0028] Firstly, a plurality of turn-off devices are matched according to a plurality of turn-off delay time differences, and then a plurality of turn-off devices are matched according to a plurality of turn-off delay time differences.
[0029] Furthermore,
[0030] An acquisition module is configured to acquire a plurality of shutdown parameters of each of the plurality of shutdown devices;
[0031] An analysis module is configured to determine a turn-off delay time and a turn-off loss of each of the plurality of turn-off devices according to the plurality of turn-off parameters; and determine a turn-off delay time difference and a turn-off loss difference between two of the plurality of turn-off devices according to the plurality of turn-off delay times and the plurality of turn-off losses;
[0032] The matching module is configured to match a plurality of turn-off devices whose turn-off delay time difference is within a first predetermined range and whose turn-off loss difference is within a second predetermined range.
[0033] Furthermore,
[0034] The shutdown parameters include current change parameters and voltage change parameters; and / or,
[0035] The shutdown delay time is: the time taken from issuing a shutdown instruction to the switchable device to the time when the current of the switchable device drops to a third predetermined value; and / or,
[0036] The turn-off loss is: the energy lost during the period from when the voltage starts to rise to when the current drops to a predetermined value times the current steady-state value after a turn-off instruction is issued to the turn-off device.
[0037] Furthermore, the matching module is specifically configured to:
[0038] First, determine whether the turn-off delay time difference between the two turn-off devices matches, and if so, then determine whether the turn-off loss difference matches; or,
[0039] First, determine whether the turn-off loss difference of the two turn-off devices matches. If they match, then determine whether the turn-off delay time difference matches.
[0040] An electronic device comprises: at least one processor, and a memory communicatively connected to the at least one processor, wherein the memory stores instructions executable by the at least one processor, and the instructions are executed by the at least one processor so that the at least one processor can be applied to the steps of the pairing method of the above-mentioned device that can be turned off.
[0041] A storage medium stores a computer program, which, when executed by a processor, implements the steps of the pairing method of the above-mentioned switchable device.
[0042] An electronic circuit comprising a plurality of turnable devices, wherein:
[0043] A turn-off delay time difference between each two of the plurality of turn-off devices is within a first predetermined range, and a turn-off loss difference between each two of the plurality of turn-off devices is within a second predetermined range.
[0044] The above-mentioned different switchable device matches include different types of switchable devices and different switchable devices of the same type.
[0045] Beneficial Effects
[0046] The present application discloses a pairing method for turnable devices, which uses turn-off delay time and turn-off loss as matching parameters, solves the problem of poor voltage equalization effect during active turn-off, and reduces the voltage inconsistency during active turn-off from the original 20% to less than 5%.
[0047] The pairing device of the switchable device of the present application uses an acquisition module, an analysis module and a matching module, and uses the switch-off delay time and the switch-off loss as matching parameters to determine whether the switchable devices are matched. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0048] In order to more clearly illustrate the embodiments of the present application or the technical solutions in the prior art, a brief introduction will be given below to the drawings required for use in the embodiments or the description of the prior art. Obviously, the drawings described below are some embodiments of the present application. For ordinary technicians in this field, other drawings can be obtained based on these drawings without paying any creative work.
[0049] Figure 1 A schematic diagram of a switchable converter topology in the prior art;
[0050] Figure 2 A schematic diagram of a method for measuring a turn-off delay time and a turn-off loss in a device pairing method provided in an embodiment of the present application;
[0051] Figure 3 A flowchart of a device pairing method provided in one embodiment of the present application;
[0052] Figure 4 A block diagram of a device pairing method and apparatus provided in an embodiment of the present application;
[0053] Figure 5 A schematic diagram of the structure of an electronic device provided in one embodiment of the present application. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0054] In order to make the purpose, technical solution and advantages of the embodiments of the present application clearer, the technical solution of the present application is clearly and completely described by using embodiments below. Obviously, the described embodiments are part of the embodiments of the present application, not all of the embodiments. Based on the embodiments in the present application, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without creative work are within the scope of protection of the present application.
[0055] In this embodiment, a plurality of turn-off devices to be paired are measured. The measuring device may be an oscilloscope or the like. The turn-off devices include one or more of insulated gate bipolar transistors IGBTs, gate turn-off thyristors GTOs, integrated gate-commutated thyristors IGCTs, and injection-enhanced gate transistors IEGTs.
[0056] In this embodiment, the oscilloscope is only a way to measure current and voltage and observe the changes in current and voltage. Any measuring device or method that can obtain parameters such as current and voltage is acceptable.
[0057] Connect the shutdown device to be tested to the test circuit and ensure that the current and voltage probes are connected correctly.
[0058] Measuring the turn-off delay time
[0059] The controller sends a shutdown command to the test circuit, and uses a measuring device such as an oscilloscope to record the time from when the shutdown command is sent to when the current drops to a predetermined value of the steady-state value, such as 0.9 times. The average value can be taken multiple times to obtain the shutdown delay time.
[0060] It is a preferred method that the current drops to 0.9 times of the steady-state value. Multiples near 0.9 times, such as 0.89 times and 0.91 times, are also acceptable. Generally, it is between 0.01-0.95.
[0061] Measuring Turn-off Losses
[0062] The controller sends a shutdown command to the test circuit, uses an oscilloscope to record the waveforms of voltage and current from the moment when the voltage starts to rise to the moment when the current drops to, for example, 0.1 times of the steady-state value, calculates the integral of the power during this period, and takes the average value of multiple measurements to obtain the shutdown loss;
[0063] The time when the current drops to 0.1 times of the steady-state value is a preferred mode, and multiples near 0.1 times, such as 0.09 times and 0.11 times, are also acceptable, and are generally between 0.01-0.20.
[0064] The measurement of the turn-off delay time and the measurement of the turn-off loss can be performed simultaneously or successively, and there is no restriction on the order.
[0065] According to the multiple turn-off delay times and the multiple turn-off losses, the turn-off delay time difference and the turn-off loss difference between two turn-off devices among the multiple turn-off devices are determined.
[0066] Power-off device pairing
[0067] According to the difference in turn-off delay time and turn-off loss between two turn-off devices among multiple turn-off devices, the turn-off devices are paired, and the turn-off devices with matching turn-off delay time and turn-off loss are selected. The turn-off delay time is matched so that the turn-off delay time of the turn-off devices is controlled within ±5%; the turn-off loss is matched so that the turn-off loss difference of the turn-off devices is controlled within ±5%;
[0068] Among them, controlling the turn-off delay time difference within ±5% and the turn-off loss difference within ±5% is a preferred method, and values around ±5% are all acceptable, such as ±4.9%, ±5.1%, etc.;
[0069] The turn-off delay time matching and the turn-off loss matching can be performed simultaneously or one after the other, with no restriction on the order.
[0070] Pressure equalization detection
[0071] During the electronic circuit design process, the successfully paired turn-off devices are connected in series and connected to the above-mentioned measuring equipment, and then actively shut down. The voltage of each turn-off device is obtained through the measuring equipment and the voltage is analyzed; it is found that during the active shutdown process, the voltage inconsistency is within 5%.
[0072] For the turn-off delay time and turn-off loss of the turn-off device, refer to Figure 2 ; Carry out active shutdown test on the switchable device and obtain the following Figure 2 The shutdown waveform shown;
[0073] Figure 2 Middle Sig off(Shutdown signal) The green curve represents the shutdown control signal given to the power-shutdown device. When the control signal changes from high to low, the power-shutdown device starts to shut down.
[0074] V DM (Turn-off voltage) The blue curve shows the voltage change of the turn-off device during the turn-off process. As the turn-off device is turned off, the voltage gradually rises to the maximum value; V D Indicates the voltage value after the current drops to the minimum value;
[0075] I T (Turn-off current) The red curve shows the current change of the device during the shutdown process. The current changes from the initial value (I T ) gradually decreases to the lowest value, and when the current drops to the position where 0.9 times the initial value and 0.1 times the initial value are marked, it is used to obtain the shutdown parameters;
[0076] P off (Shutdown power) The purple curve shows the power change of the shut-down device during the shutdown process. The power increases from the stable value at the beginning of the shutdown and then gradually decreases to the stable value.
[0077] t doff (turn-off delay time) from Sig off (Shutdown signal) drops to the lowest point when the current I T Down to 90% (0.9I T )The time taken for this period of time.
[0078] E off (Shutdown loss energy): During the shutdown process, during the period when the current and voltage change simultaneously, the turn-off device will generate power loss. The integral of the power during the period from when the voltage starts to rise to when the current drops to 0.1 times the steady-state value is E. off , that is, the power curve P during the period from when the voltage starts to rise to when the current drops to 0.1 times the steady-state value off The area formed by the power stability value is the turn-off loss energy E off This part of energy is released in the form of heat during the shutdown process, which has an important impact on the turn-off devices.
[0079] The technical solution adopted in this application is to use the shutdown delay time (t doff) and turn-off loss (E off ) is used as a matching parameter to control the turn-off consistency between different devices. The two parameters specifically refer to Figure 2 The specific implementation method is to carry out active shutdown test on each device and obtain the following Figure 2The shutdown waveform shown in the figure should include the device current, device voltage and device shutdown command signal. The shutdown delay time and shutdown loss parameters are calculated based on the measured signals, where the shutdown delay time refers to the time from the falling edge of the shutdown command to the current falling to, for example, 0.9 times the steady-state value, and the shutdown loss refers to the integral of the power from the voltage starting to rise to the current falling to, for example, 0.1 times the steady-state value. After measuring the shutdown delay time and shutdown loss of different devices, the two devices with similar parameters can be connected in series for synchronous shutdown to ensure shutdown consistency. The specific matching method can be to first match the shutdown delay time so that it is controlled within a certain range (for example, ±5%), and then match the shutdown loss within the same group; or to first match the shutdown loss and then match the shutdown delay time. The number of matching devices can be two or more.
[0080] Please refer to Figure 3 , which shows a flow chart of an embodiment of a method for pairing turnable devices of the present application. The pairing method of this embodiment is suitable for matching the turn-off consistency between different turn-off devices.
[0081] like Figure 3 As shown:
[0082] Acquire a plurality of turn-off parameters of each turn-off device among the plurality of turn-off devices, wherein the plurality of turn-off parameters include a current change parameter and a voltage change parameter;
[0083] Determining a turn-off delay time and a turn-off loss of each of the plurality of turn-off devices according to the plurality of turn-off parameters;
[0084] Determine the turn-off delay time difference and turn-off loss difference between two turn-off devices among the plurality of turn-off devices according to the turn-off delay time and turn-off loss of each turn-off device;
[0085] Matching the turn-off devices whose turn-off delay time difference is within a first predetermined range and whose turn-off loss difference is within a second predetermined range.
[0086] In the embodiments of the present application, although the above steps are introduced in a chronological order, it does not mean that the pairing method steps of the present application must be strictly executed in the order of the above steps, nor does it mean that there will be no other steps between the steps. For example, a shutdown parameter screening step may be added between obtaining multiple shutdown parameters of the shutoff device and analyzing the shutdown parameters, etc., as long as the purpose of the present application can be achieved.
[0087] Based on the above method, this application also provides further reference Figure 4 , which shows that the present application provides a turnable device matching device.
[0088] Figure 4 As shown, the switchable device matching device 400 includes a receiving module 401, an analyzing module 402 and a matching module 403, wherein;
[0089] An acquisition module 401 is configured to acquire a plurality of turn-off parameters of each turn-off device among a plurality of turn-off devices;
[0090] The analysis module 402 is configured to determine a turn-off delay time and a turn-off loss of each of the plurality of turn-off devices according to the plurality of turn-off parameters; and determine a turn-off delay time difference and a turn-off loss difference between two of the plurality of turn-off devices according to the plurality of turn-off delay times and the plurality of turn-off losses;
[0091] The shutdown delay time refers to the time from when the shutdown command is issued to when the current drops to, for example, 0.9 times the steady-state value; wherein the current drops to 0.9 times the steady-state value as a preferred method, and multiples near 0.9 times, such as 0.89 times and 0.91 times, are also acceptable, generally between 0.01-0.95.
[0092] The turn-off loss is the integral of the power from the start of the voltage rising to the point where the current drops to, for example, 0.1 times the steady-state value. The point where the current drops to 0.1 times the steady-state value is a preferred method, and multiples near 0.1 times, such as 0.09 times or 0.11 times, are also acceptable, and is generally between 0.01 and 0.2.
[0093] The matching module 403 is configured to match a plurality of turn-off devices whose turn-off delay time difference is within a first predetermined range and whose turn-off loss difference is within a second predetermined range.
[0094] The matching module 403 first matches the multiple turnable devices according to the turn-off delay time difference of the multiple turnable devices, and then matches the multiple turnable devices according to the turn-off losses of the multiple turnable devices; or, first matches the multiple turnable devices according to the turn-off losses of the multiple turnable devices, and then matches the multiple turnable devices according to the multiple turn-off delay times; matches the turn-off delay times so that the turn-off delay time of the turnable devices is controlled within, for example, ±5%, and matches the turn-off losses so that the turn-off loss difference of the turnable devices is controlled within, for example, ±5%; wherein the turn-off delay time difference is controlled within ±5% and the turn-off loss difference is controlled within ±5% is a preferred method, and values near ±5% are all acceptable, such as ±4.9%, ±5.1%, etc.
[0095] It is worth noting that the relevant functional modules can also be implemented by a hardware processor and will not be described in detail here.
[0096] Figure 5 is a schematic diagram of the structure of an electronic device provided in an embodiment of the present application, such as Figure 5 As shown, the device includes: one or more processors 510 and a memory 520, Figure 3 A processor 510 is taken as an example. A switchable device pairing device may also include: an input device 530 and an output device 540. The processor 510, the memory 520, the input device 530 and the output device 540 may be connected via a bus or other means. Figure 5 In the example, the connection through the bus is taken as an example. The memory 520 is the above-mentioned non-volatile computer-readable storage medium. The processor 510 executes various functional applications and data processing of the server by running the non-volatile software programs, instructions and modules stored in the memory 520, that is, the above-mentioned method embodiment is used for a method of matching a device that can be turned off. The input device 530 can receive input digital or character information, and generate key signal input related to user settings and function control of a device that can be paired with a device that can be turned off. The output device 540 may include a display device such as a display screen.
[0097] The above-mentioned product can execute the method provided in the embodiment of the present application, and has the functional modules and beneficial effects corresponding to the execution method. For technical details not fully described in this embodiment, please refer to the method provided in the embodiment of the present application.
[0098] The device embodiments described above are merely illustrative, wherein the units described as separate components may or may not be physically separated, and the components shown as units may or may not be physical units, i.e., they may be located in one place, or they may be distributed on multiple network units. Some or all of the modules may be selected according to actual needs to achieve the purpose of the scheme of this embodiment. Those of ordinary skill in the art may understand and implement it without creative effort.
[0099] Finally, it should be noted that the above embodiments are only used to illustrate the technical solutions of the present application, rather than to limit it. Although the present application has been described in detail with reference to the aforementioned embodiments, those skilled in the art should understand that they can still modify the technical solutions described in the aforementioned embodiments, or make equivalent replacements for some of the technical features therein. However, these modifications or replacements do not deviate the essence of the corresponding technical solutions from the spirit and scope of the technical solutions of the embodiments of the present application.
Claims
1. A method for pairing a switchable device, the method comprising the following steps: Acquire a plurality of turn-off parameters of each turn-off device among the plurality of turn-off devices, wherein the plurality of turn-off parameters include a current change parameter and a voltage change parameter; Determining a turn-off delay time and a turn-off loss of each of the plurality of turn-off devices according to the plurality of turn-off parameters; Determine the turn-off delay time difference and turn-off loss difference between two turn-off devices among the plurality of turn-off devices according to the turn-off delay time and turn-off loss of each turn-off device; Matching the turn-off devices whose turn-off delay time difference is within a first predetermined range and whose turn-off loss difference is within a second predetermined range.
2. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The shutdown delay time is: the time from when a shutdown instruction is issued to the switchable device to when the current flowing through the switchable device drops to a third predetermined value; and / or, The turn-off loss is: the energy lost during the period from when the voltage of the turn-off device starts to rise to when the current flowing through the turn-off device drops to a predetermined value after a turn-off instruction is issued to the turn-off device.
3. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that The turn-off device comprises: one or more than two of an insulated gate bipolar transistor IGBT, a gate turn-off thyristor GTO, an integrated gate commutated thyristor IGCT and an injection enhanced gate transistor IEGT.
4. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The first predetermined range is -5% to 5%; and / or, The second predetermined range is -5% to 5%.
5. The method according to claim 2, characterized in that: The third predetermined value is 0.01-0.95 times the steady-state value of the current before issuing a shutdown instruction to the switchable device; and / or, The fourth predetermined value is 0.01-0.20 times of the steady-state value of the current before issuing a shutdown instruction to the switchable device.
6. The method according to claim 5, characterized in that The third predetermined value is 0.9 times the steady-state value of the current before issuing a shutdown instruction to the switchable device; and / or, The fourth predetermined value is 0.1 times the steady-state value of the current before issuing a shutdown instruction to the switchable device.
7. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that Firstly, a plurality of turn-off devices are matched according to a plurality of turn-off delay time differences, and then a plurality of turn-off devices are matched according to the matched plurality of turn-off delay time differences; or, Firstly, a plurality of turn-off devices are matched according to a plurality of turn-off delay time differences, and then a plurality of turn-off devices are matched according to a plurality of turn-off delay time differences.
8. A pairing device for a switchable device, the device comprising: An acquisition module is configured to acquire a plurality of shutdown parameters of each of the plurality of shutdown devices; An analysis module, configured to determine a turn-off delay time and a turn-off loss of each of the plurality of turn-off devices according to the plurality of turn-off parameters; Determine, according to the plurality of turn-off delay times and the plurality of turn-off losses, a turn-off delay time difference and a turn-off loss difference between two of the plurality of turn-off devices; The matching module is configured to match a plurality of turn-off devices whose turn-off delay time difference is within a first predetermined range and whose turn-off loss difference is within a second predetermined range.
9. The device according to claim 8, characterized in that The analysis module is configured to: The shutdown parameters include current change parameters and voltage change parameters; and / or, The shutdown delay time is: the time taken from issuing a shutdown instruction to the switchable device to the time when the current of the switchable device drops to a third predetermined value; and / or, The turn-off loss is: the energy lost during the period from when the voltage starts to rise to when the current drops to a predetermined value times the current steady-state value after a turn-off instruction is issued to the turn-off device.
10. The device according to claim 8, characterized in that The matching module is specifically configured to: First, determine whether the turn-off delay time difference between the two turn-off devices matches, and if so, then determine whether the turn-off loss difference matches; or, First, determine whether the turn-off loss difference between the two turn-off devices matches. If they match, then determine whether the turn-off delay time difference matches.
11. An electronic device, characterized in that: The electronic device includes: at least one processor, and a memory communicatively connected to the at least one processor, wherein the memory stores instructions executable by the at least one processor, and the instructions are executed by the at least one processor to enable the at least one processor to perform the steps of the pairing method of the switchable device according to any one of claims 1 to 7.
12. A storage medium having a computer program stored thereon, characterized in that: When the program is executed by a processor, the steps of the pairing method of the turnable device according to any one of claims 1 to 7 are implemented.
13. An electronic circuit comprising a plurality of switchable devices, wherein: A turn-off delay time difference between each two of the plurality of turn-off devices is within a first predetermined range, and a turn-off loss difference between each two of the plurality of turn-off devices is within a second predetermined range.
