Fault current calculation method for hybrid multi-terminal direct current power transmission system
By combining the current limit control of LCC and MMC converter stations in a hybrid multi-terminal DC transmission system, using complex frequency domain and Laplace transform to calculate the fault current, the problem of the neglected impact of current limit control in the prior art is solved, and the problem of the current limit control is realized. More accurate fault current evaluation and system stability improvement.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202411002417.1
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-07-25
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-12
AI Technical Summary
The existing fault current calculation method ignores the impact of the current limit control strategy of the converter station, resulting in an increase in the error of the fault current calculation, making it difficult to accurately evaluate the short-circuit current, affecting the equipment selection and formulation of control strategies.
A method for calculating fault current of hybrid multi-terminal DC transmission system is proposed. Through the current limit control of LCC and MMC converter stations, combined with complex frequency domain and Laplace transformation, the time domain solution of fault current is calculated, and the influence of the current limiting link is considered. , accurately reflects the dynamic changes of the fault current.
It effectively reduces the error in fault current calculation, provides more accurate fault current evaluation, helps formulate scientific equipment selection and control strategies, and improves the stability and safety of the system.
Smart Images

Figure CN118944168A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention relates to the field of power supply, and in particular to a method for calculating fault current in a hybrid multi-terminal direct current transmission system. Background Art
[0002] Hybrid multi-terminal DC transmission technology fully combines the technical and economic advantages of conventional DC transmission (Line Commutated Converter-High Voltage Direct Current, LCC-HVDC) and flexible DC transmission (Modular Multilevel Converter-High Voltage Direct Current, MMC-HVDC), and has become the preferred solution for large-capacity and long-distance power transmission at this stage. However, hybrid multi-terminal DC transmission lines are long, the working environment is complex, and most of them use overhead lines. Their failure probability is greater than that of cable lines, and they will generate fault currents several times the rated current in a short time after the fault, posing a serious threat to the safe operation of the system. The fault current of the multi-terminal hybrid DC transmission system develops rapidly, and the current limiting control strategy is often used in actual operation to suppress the current development and maintain the stable operation of the system.
[0003] Most of the existing fault current calculation methods ignore the impact of the converter station current limiting control strategy on the fault current, resulting in an increase in the fault current calculation error after the current limiting link is started, which is not conducive to the quantitative evaluation of the short-circuit current and brings difficulties to the equipment selection and control and protection strategy formulation, and needs to be improved. Summary of the invention
[0004] The object of the present invention is to provide a method for calculating fault current in a hybrid multi-terminal direct current transmission system to solve the problems raised in the above background technology.
[0005] To achieve the above object, the present invention provides the following technical solutions:
[0006] A method for calculating fault current in a hybrid multi-terminal direct current transmission system comprises the following steps:
[0007] Step 1, constructing a hybrid multi-terminal DC transmission system;
[0008] Step 2: When the hybrid multi-terminal DC transmission system fails, the fault current limiting control is performed through the LCC converter station; the LCC converter station starts the low-voltage current limiting link to reduce the DC current reference value, and the DC current changes with the DC current reference value, thereby suppressing the rapid increase of the current (fault current) during the fault period, and reducing the reactive power demand of the system, thereby avoiding commutation failure in the receiving-end AC power grid;
[0009] Step 3, performing fault current limiting control through the MMC converter station; suppressing the rising speed and peak value of the DC short-circuit current (fault current) by changing the DC voltage of the MMC converter station;
[0010] Step 4, consider the impact of current limiting control of LCC converter station and MMC converter station on fault current; calculate the fault current in the complex frequency domain through the fault additional network, and then obtain the time domain solution of the fault current through Laplace transform;
[0011] The hybrid multi-terminal direct current transmission system comprises an LCC converter station and an MMC converter station, wherein the MMC converter station comprises an MMC1 converter station and an MMC2 converter station; one end of the LCC converter station is connected to a power source S1, and the other end of the LCC converter station is connected to a smoothing reactor L P One end of the smoothing reactor L P The other end is connected to the DC filter Z filter One end of the DC line l AB One end of the DC filter Z filter The other end of the DC line is grounded. AB The other end is connected to the DC line l BC One end of the smoothing reactor L P1 One end of the smoothing reactor L P1 The other end of the DC line is connected to one end of the MMC1 converter station, and the other end of the MMC1 converter station is connected to the power supply S2. BC The other end is connected to the smoothing reactor L P2 One end of the smoothing reactor L P2 The other end is connected to one end of the MMC2 converter station, and the other end of the MMC2 converter station is connected to the power supply S3 (the current limiting control of the LCC station is a low-voltage current limiting link, and the current limiting control of the MMC1 and MMC2 stations is an active current limiting link).
[0012] As a further solution of the present invention: In step 1, the complex frequency domain equivalent impedance of the LCC converter station is calculated; the LCC converter can be regarded as an equivalent voltage source u of the converter valve s With equivalent impedance R s Series connection; the DC filter can be regarded as an inductor and capacitor circuit with concentrated parameters, and the values of each part are shown in formula (1):
[0013]
[0014] Among them, X σ is the leakage reactance of the converter transformer, N is the number of 6-pulse converter bridges per pole in the LCC converter station, E r is the effective value of the bus voltage on the AC side of the converter station, α is the trigger angle of the LCC converter station, k is the ratio of the converter transformer; L1, L2, L3, C1, C2, C3 are the parameters related to the DC filter; s is the Laplace operator;
[0015] The LCC converter station can be regarded as a converter and a smoothing reactor L p And neutral line reactor L g In series, then with the DC filter Z filter The complex frequency domain equivalent impedance Z of the LCC converter station is obtained by connecting in parallel. LCC As shown in formula (2):
[0016] Z LCC =[R s +s(L p +L g )]||Z filter (2).
[0017] As a further solution of the present invention: in step 1, the complex frequency domain equivalent impedance of the MMC converter station is calculated; the three-phase circuit on the AC side remains symmetrical in a short time after the DC line fails, so the influence of the AC side current feed-in on the DC side fault current can be ignored. The DC side fault current of the MMC converter station is mainly determined by the capacitor discharge current of each submodule, wherein the submodule voltage is kept balanced under the influence of capacitor voltage control. According to the principle of energy conservation, the equivalent capacitance value C of the single-phase bridge arm is j As shown in formula (3):
[0018]
[0019] Among them, C0 is the submodule capacitance value, N1 is the number of cascaded single-phase bridge arm submodules;
[0020] The MMC converter station can be obtained by connecting three identical RLC series phase units in parallel. Its equivalent model can be expressed as an RLC series circuit:
[0021] Where R arm , L arm is the equivalent resistance and equivalent inductance of each bridge arm, R eq , L eq and C eq is the equivalent parameter of the MMC converter station, and its calculation formula is shown in formula (4):
[0022]
[0023] The DC side of the MMC converter station is also connected in series with a smoothing reactor L p1 and neutral line reactor L g1 , so the equivalent impedance of the converter station is as shown in formula (5):
[0024]
[0025] As a further solution of the present invention: In step 1, the DC line is calculated as equal value. When a single-pole fault occurs in the DC line, the line mode and ground mode networks are in series relationship. At this time, the resistance value per unit length of the DC line R l And the inductance per unit length L l Formula (6) can be used to obtain:
[0026]
[0027] When there is a short circuit between the poles, the positive pole and the negative pole are completely symmetrical, and each parameter only has line mode components but no ground mode components. Therefore, the inductance per unit length of the DC line is L. X , the resistance per unit length is R X , where R D and R X is the ground mode and line mode resistance of the DC line per unit length, L D and L X are the ground mode and line mode inductance per unit length of the DC line.
[0028] As a further solution of the present invention: in step 2, after the DC side fault occurs, the DC voltage decreases, and the LCC converter station starts the low voltage current limiting link (voltage dependent current order limiter, VDCOL) to reduce the DC current reference value. The DC current changes with the DC current reference value, which can suppress the rapid increase of the current during the fault period, and at the same time reduce the reactive power demand of the system, thereby avoiding the phase change failure of the receiving end AC power grid;
[0029] I ref Indicates the DC current reference value at the LCC converter station outlet, U LCC Indicates the DC voltage at the LCC converter station outlet, U high , U low Respectively represent the high and low threshold values of DC voltage, I high ,I low Respectively represent the maximum and minimum values of DC current;
[0030] The voltage-current relationship of the low-voltage current limiting link is derived as shown in formula (7):
[0031]
[0032] From formula (7), we can see that U high , U low ,I high ,I low The values of the four parameters will affect the current limiting characteristics of the system, among which the current limiting upper limit parameter U high ,I high Mainly affects the start-up time of current limiting; the current limiting lower limit parameter U low ,Ilow It mainly affects the operating state when entering the steady state after current limiting; the slope parameter of current limiting mainly affects the speed of current limiting; usually, U high and U low Take 0.9U respectively N 、0.4U N , I high and I low I N , 0.55I N ;
[0033] In order to avoid the rapid rise of DC current during DC fault, the DC voltage type VDCOL (DC-VDCOL) link is still retained in the rectifier-side LCC converter station in the hybrid multi-terminal DC transmission system;
[0034] Among them, I LCC are the DC current at the LCC converter outlet, I order is the given value of DC current, its magnitude is 1, ΔI ref is the current change, G1, G2, G3 are gain coefficients, T1, T2, T3 are delay coefficients;
[0035] When the system is operating normally, the DC voltage and current remain basically constant, the low-voltage current limiting link does not start, and I ref with I order The values are close, the current change is small, and the trigger angle basically does not change; after a period of time after the DC side fault, the DC voltage drops to the starting threshold of the low-voltage current limiting link, I ref Start to decrease, ΔI ref The change causes the trigger angle to change, suppressing the rise of DC current; the following relationship can be obtained:
[0036]
[0037] As a further solution of the present invention: in step 3, under normal circumstances, the three-phase bridge arm of the MMC converter is balanced, and the number of submodules invested in the upper and lower bridge arms of each phase is the same, and the DC voltage can be kept balanced at this time; the number of upper and lower bridge arm submodules is determined according to the nearest level approximation modulation:
[0038]
[0039]
[0040]
[0041] Where N jp 、N jn are the number of submodules put into use in the upper and lower bridge arms respectively; V refjp 、V refjnare the upper and lower bridge arm voltage reference values respectively; V cn is the rated voltage of the capacitor of a single submodule; U dc is the DC side voltage of the converter; V refj The j-phase unit outputs the AC voltage reference value; u cirdj is the j-phase circulating current voltage;
[0042] The DC fault current after the DC side fault occurs and before the converter station is locked is mainly determined by the discharge of the submodule capacitor. It can be seen from formula (11) that the number of submodules put into operation in the converter is determined by the DC voltage, the rated voltage of a single submodule and the circulating current voltage. The circulating current voltage value has little effect on the number of submodules put into operation and its influence can be ignored in the calculation. Therefore, formula (11) can be simplified as follows:
[0043]
[0044] The magnitude of the DC short-circuit current is mainly related to the DC voltage, the initial value of the DC current fault and the equivalent impedance of the fault loop. The latter two are determined by the operating state of the system itself and the system design, and are usually difficult to change. Therefore, the current rise speed and peak value can be suppressed by changing the MMC DC voltage. It can be seen from formula (12) that the DC voltage can be reduced by reducing the number of sub-modules put into the bridge arm. Therefore, the active current limiting control introduces the active current limiting factor K to achieve current limiting. The voltage after current limiting is shown in formula (13):
[0045] U dck =KN1V cn (13);
[0046] After the active current limiting link is introduced, the complete control link of the MMC converter station includes constant DC voltage control, constant active power control, constant reactive power control, inner loop current control, circulating current suppression and active current limiting control;
[0047] The principle of active current limiting is: the DC current I at the MMC converter station outlet dc With the DC current reference value I dcref After the DC current change is obtained by subtracting it from I dcref The current change per unit value is obtained by comparison, which is related to the current limiting parameter K B The current correction deviation is obtained by multiplying them, and the active current limiting factor K is obtained by subtracting the current correction deviation from the upper limit amplitude 1 and passing through the limiting link. Its expression is shown in formula (14):
[0048]
[0049] Among them, I dc is the actual value of DC current, I dcref is the DC current rating;
[0050] When the system is operating normally, the DC current remains near the rated value, and the active current limiting factor K is always 1. At this time, the current limiting link will not work. After a short circuit fault occurs on the DC side, the active current limiting link starts adaptively as the fault current increases. The active current limiting factor K gradually decreases within the adjustable range, reducing the number of submodules put into operation and thus reducing the DC side voltage of the MMC converter station, suppressing the rapid rise of the DC current; the current limiting parameter K B It will affect the current limiting effect of the active current limiting link. Its value needs to consider both the current limiting effect and the AC outlet voltage drop level. Therefore, its value range is given as shown in formula (15):
[0051]
[0052] Among them, I dcmax It is the maximum rated current under normal operating conditions.
[0053] As a further solution of the present invention: in step 4, the influence of the current limiting control of the LCC converter station and the MMC converter station on the fault current is considered; the fault current is calculated in the complex frequency domain through the fault additional network, and then the time domain solution of the fault current is obtained through Laplace transformation:
[0054]
[0055] Step 4 includes:
[0056] Step 41, calculating the fault current in the complex frequency domain through the fault additional network, and then obtaining the time domain solution of the fault current of the low voltage current limiting link through Laplace transformation;
[0057] Step 42, the fault current is calculated in the complex frequency domain through the fault additional network, and then the time domain solution of the fault current of the active current limiting link is obtained through Laplace transformation.
[0058] As a further solution of the present invention: in step 41, after the low-voltage current limiting link of the LCC converter station is started, the complex frequency domain expression of the fault component of the LCC converter outlet current when the current limiting link is ignored is obtained as shown in formula (17):
[0059]
[0060] Among them, Z L , Z R They represent the complex frequency domain impedance on the left and right sides of the fault point respectively, and their expressions are shown in formula (18):
[0061]
[0062] The fault current is obtained by superimposing the current fault component and the steady-state operation component as shown in formula (19):
[0063] I LCC =ΔI LCC +I s.LCC (19);
[0064] The DC voltage U at the outlet of the LCC converter after the fault can be obtained: LCC As shown in formula (20):
[0065] U LCC =I LCC ×Z LCC (20);
[0066] The slope in the low-voltage current limiting link is a certain value, and the dynamic characteristics of the change of electrical quantity are not fully considered. Therefore, the current command value obtained by the low-voltage current limiting link cannot dynamically respond to the needs of the system. LCC and U′ LCC , and further obtain the voltage [U low ,U high ] after the DC current command value I ref As shown in formula (21):
[0067]
[0068] DC voltage U LCC and current I LCC All change dynamically with time, and the reference current I ref with I' LCC The dynamic change of current ΔI is obtained by subtracting ref , the trigger angle α that changes dynamically with the current command is calculated;
[0069] For LCC converter station, the voltage at the converter station outlet drops to 0.9U N When the low-voltage current limiting link is started, the DC voltage measured at the measuring point fluctuates greatly due to the different arrival times of the high-frequency and low-frequency components of the traveling wave at the measuring point. There is a large error between the calculated value and the actual value of the DC voltage. The reference current calculated from the DC voltage changes smoothly, and its variation range is as small as 0.55 to 1. The error is small during calculation. Therefore, the start-up time of the low-voltage current limiting link can be determined by the change of the calculated reference current.
[0070] After determining the start time, the DC voltage u on the rectifier side is obtained through the dynamically changing trigger angle α s ,u s To characterize the influence of LCC control system on DC line fault, it can be approximately regarded as the fault voltage source of the system, and the calculation formula of DC current fault component can be approximately expressed as:
[0071]
[0072] The current fault component after the trigger angle changes is obtained by formula (22), and added to the steady-state component to obtain the fault current taking into account the influence of the low-voltage current limiting link.
[0073] As a further solution of the present invention: in step 42, when the fault current of the MMC converter station exceeds the rated current, the active current limiting link is started, and whether the active current limiting control is started is judged by observing the fault current size, and the complex frequency domain expression of the fault component of the MMC1 converter outlet current when the current limiting link is ignored is obtained as shown in formula (23):
[0074]
[0075] The fault current is obtained by superimposing the current fault component and the steady-state operation component as shown in formula (24):
[0076] I MMC1 =ΔI MMC1 +I s.MMC1 (twenty four);
[0077] Considering the dynamic change of fault current, the time domain solution of fault current is obtained by Laplace transform. MMC1 And determine the current limiting start time t0, select the time range of 10ms after the fault to calculate the fault current. If t0 exceeds this range, directly take i MMC1 As the current calculation result; if t0 is within this range, then take the period from t0 to 10ms for calculation, and take 1ms as the time interval to get t n , iterate the active current limiting factor K and the fault current based on time;
[0078] To calculate t n-1 The fault current affected by the current limiting control in the time period is taken as the fault current in the whole time period and t n-2 Calculation results of fault current affected by time-limited current control i” n-2 Substituting into equation (25), we can obtain t n-1 Active current limiting factor group K for the time period n-1 As shown in formula (26):
[0079]
[0080] K n-1 =[K n-1,0 K n-1,1 ··· K n-1,m ] (26);
[0081] Among them, K n-1,0 ~K n-1,m Represents t n-1 The active current limiting factor K value corresponding to m moments in the time period;
[0082] Find tn-1 The fault current of the time period and the current limiting link is:
[0083] i′ n-1 =K n-1 ×i″ n-2 (27);
[0084] The influence of the current limiting link on the fault current gradually increases as the fault develops. n When calculating the fault current of the time period, t n-1 The role of the time-limited current link, so find K n-1 The mean As shown in formula (28):
[0085]
[0086] Using formula (29), we can obtain the total time period and t n-1 Calculation result of fault current with time-limiting link i” n-1 :
[0087]
[0088] Afterwards, use i" n-1 Repeat the above calculation process to obtain t n The time period takes into account the fault current of current limiting control, and realizes the iteration of fault current over time.
[0089] Compared with the prior art, the beneficial effects of the present invention are as follows: the present invention obtains an approximate solution of the fault current after the fault based on the fault additional network calculation; uses the fault current approximate solution to calculate the conventional DC converter station (Line Commutated Converter, LCC) trigger angle and the flexible DC converter station (Modular Multilevel Converter, MMC) current limiting factor, obtains the dynamic solution of the two parameters changing with the fault current, and substitutes them into the fault current calculation formula to obtain the fault current size considering the influence of the current limiting link. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0090] Figure 1 The schematic diagram of a hybrid multi-terminal DC transmission system.
[0091] Figure 2 This is the circuit diagram of the equivalent circuit of the LCC converter station.
[0092] Figure 3 This is the circuit diagram of the equivalent circuit of the MMC converter station.
[0093] Figure 4 This is the low voltage current limiting characteristic curve.
[0094] Figure 5This is the control logic diagram of the low-voltage current limiting link.
[0095] Figure 6 This is the logic diagram of active current limiting control.
[0096] Figure 7 Attach a network diagram for the fault.
[0097] Figure 8 The schematic diagram of a fault current calculation method for a hybrid multi-terminal DC transmission system.
[0098] Fig. 9 This is the simulation diagram of LCC outlet current when faults occur at different locations.
[0099] Fig.10 This is the simulation diagram of MMC1 output current when faults occur in different locations.
[0100] Fig.11 This is the simulation diagram of LCC outlet current under different transition resistances.
[0101] Fig.12 This is the simulation diagram of MMC1 export current under different transition resistances.
[0102] Fig.13 This is the simulation diagram of the converter station outlet current when there is a pole-to-pole fault.
[0103] Fig.14 This is the simulation diagram of MMC1 export current under different current limiting parameters. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0104] The technical solutions in the embodiments of the present invention will be clearly and completely described below in conjunction with the drawings in the embodiments of the present invention. Obviously, the described embodiments are only part of the embodiments of the present invention, rather than all the embodiments. Based on the embodiments of the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without making creative work are within the scope of protection of the present invention.
[0105] Existing technology:
[0106] Domestic and foreign research teams have conducted extensive research on the analytical calculation of fault currents. The paper "Accurate and efficient estimation of short-circuit current for MTDC grids considering MMC control" combines the MMC equivalent model with the lumped DC line model to establish a flexible multi-terminal DC transmission model, solves the equivalent model based on the accompanying circuit, and obtains the analytical formulas for the fault voltage and current at the outlet of each converter station. However, the solution process of this method is relatively complicated and the calculation speed is slow; the paper "Approximate calculation method for short-circuit fault current of MMC DC transmission grid line" obtains the DC current fault component based on the simplified model of the flexible four-terminal DC transmission grid, and then superimposes it with the steady-state operating current to obtain an approximate solution for the fault current; the paper "A pole-to-pole short-circuit fault current calculation method for DC-HVDC system considering line capacitance" considers the line-to-ground capacitance and different grounding methods to model the system, establishes the system's differential equation based on Kirchhoff's law, and solves the system's fault current, but only considers the case of single-pole grounding fault; the paper "A pole-to-pole short-circuit fault current calculation method for DC-HVDC system considering line capacitance" considers the line-to-ground capacitance and different grounding methods to model the system, establishes the system's differential equation based on Kirchhoff's law, and solves the system's fault current, but only considers the case of single-pole grounding fault; grids》After simplifying the system, the differential equations of each branch are listed, and the final result of the fault current is obtained by solving the differential equations; the above fault current calculation method is mainly aimed at conventional DC transmission systems and flexible DC transmission systems, and its applicability in hybrid multi-terminal DC transmission systems needs to be verified, and the influence of converter station control strategy on fault current is ignored. Literature "Overview of Relay Protection Technology of High-Voltage DC Transmission Lines". In this regard, the document "Analysis of transient characteristics of LCC-HVDC DC current considering control system and approximate analytical method of AC short-circuit current" establishes the DC control transient response transfer function in segments according to the transient response characteristics, uses the transfer function to obtain the control parameter expression, and substitutes it into the fault current calculation formula to obtain the approximate analytical solution of the DC fault current; the document "Calculation method of short-circuit current of hybrid MMC-HVDC transmission system considering zero DC voltage control" uses state space equations to calculate the DC short-circuit current before and after the zero voltage control is put into operation, but does not give the specific time of control input; the document "Approximate calculation method of short-circuit current of multi-terminal hybrid DC transmission system considering control response" considers the control characteristics of different types of converter stations, reasonably simplifies the multi-terminal network according to the fault type and the operation characteristics of the power grid, and obtains the approximate expression of the short-circuit current of each node; the document "Fault transient calculation method of multi-terminal hybrid DC transmission system considering converter station control characteristics" is based on the equivalent model of the converter station considering the control link, and establishes the node impedance matrix of the system after the fault and the node current source to calculate the complex frequency domain expression of voltage and current. The above method takes into account the influence of the basic control strategy in the converter station and can better describe the changing trend of the fault current.However, in actual projects, current limiting links are often configured to suppress the development of fault current. The above methods do not consider the current limiting control link of the converter station, and the fault current value is large and does not fully conform to the actual project. For this reason, the document "Analytical calculation of DC short-circuit fault current in MMC-HVDC power grid with active current limiting control" is based on the mapping relationship between the DC voltage drop at the outlet of the MMC converter station and the virtual impedance voltage drop. The DC bipolar short-circuit equivalent circuit with current limiting control and the time-domain analytical expression of the DC fault current are derived, but the calculation process is relatively complicated and only the current limiting control link of the MMC converter station is analyzed. The hybrid multi-terminal DC transmission system contains two types of converters, LCC and MMC. When analyzing the fault characteristics, the influence of the low-voltage current limiting link of the LCC converter station and the active current limiting link of the MMC converter station should be considered at the same time. The document "Design of backup protection for multi-terminal hybrid DC lines considering the control response of the converter station"
[0107] To this end, the present invention considers the influence of the current limiting link of the LCC and MMC converter stations in the hybrid multi-terminal DC transmission system to calculate the fault current at the outlet of each converter. First, the approximate solution of the DC current after the fault is calculated based on the fault additional network; then, the DC current approximate solution is used to calculate the trigger angle of the LCC converter station and the active current limiting factor of the MMC converter station, and the dynamic solution of the two parameters changing with the fault current is obtained, and the fault current calculation formula is substituted to obtain the fault current size considering the influence of the current limiting link; finally, a hybrid multi-terminal DC transmission system model is built in PSCAD / EMTDC to verify the proposed calculation method.
[0108] In this example, see Figure 1 and Figure 8 , a method for calculating fault current in a hybrid multi-terminal direct current transmission system, comprising the following steps:
[0109] Step 1, constructing a hybrid multi-terminal DC transmission system;
[0110] Step 2: When the hybrid multi-terminal DC transmission system fails, the fault current limiting control is performed through the LCC converter station; the LCC converter station starts the low-voltage current limiting link to reduce the DC current reference value, and the DC current changes with the DC current reference value, thereby suppressing the rapid increase of the current (fault current) during the fault period, and reducing the reactive power demand of the system, thereby avoiding commutation failure in the receiving-end AC power grid;
[0111] Step 3, performing fault current limiting control through the MMC converter station; suppressing the rising speed and peak value of the DC short-circuit current (fault current) by changing the DC voltage of the MMC converter station;
[0112] Step 4, consider the impact of current limiting control of LCC converter station and MMC converter station on fault current; calculate the fault current in the complex frequency domain through the fault additional network, and then obtain the time domain solution of the fault current through Laplace transform;
[0113] The hybrid multi-terminal direct current transmission system comprises an LCC converter station and an MMC converter station, wherein the MMC converter station comprises an MMC1 converter station and an MMC2 converter station; one end of the LCC converter station is connected to a power source S1, and the other end of the LCC converter station is connected to a smoothing reactor L P One end of the smoothing reactor L P The other end is connected to the DC filter Z filter One end of the DC line l AB One end of the DC filter Z filter The other end of the DC line is grounded. AB The other end is connected to the DC line l BC One end of the smoothing reactor L P1 One end of the smoothing reactor L P1 The other end of the DC line is connected to one end of the MMC1 converter station, and the other end of the MMC1 converter station is connected to the power supply S2. BC The other end is connected to the smoothing reactor L P2 One end of the smoothing reactor L P2 The other end of is connected to one end of the MMC2 converter station, and the other end of the MMC2 converter station is connected to the power supply S3.
[0114] The hybrid multi-terminal DC transmission system uses LCC converters at the sending end and MMC converters at the receiving end. P , L P1 , L P2 They are the smoothing reactors at the outlets of LCC, MMC1 and MMC2 converter stations, and Z filter It is the DC filter at the outlet of LCC converter station. AB , l BC The lengths are 932km and 557km respectively.
[0115] In this embodiment: In step 1, the complex frequency domain equivalent impedance of the LCC converter station is calculated; the LCC converter can be regarded as the equivalent voltage source u of the converter valve s With equivalent impedance R s Series connection; the DC filter can be regarded as an inductor and capacitor circuit with concentrated parameters, and the values of each part are shown in formula (1):
[0116]
[0117] Among them, X σ is the leakage reactance of the converter transformer, N is the number of 6-pulse converter bridges per pole in the LCC converter station, E r is the effective value of the bus voltage on the AC side of the converter station, α is the trigger angle of the LCC converter station, k is the ratio of the converter transformer; L1, L2, L3, C1, C2, C3 are the parameters related to the DC filter; s is the Laplace operator;
[0118] The equivalent model of LCC converter station is as follows Figure 2 As shown in the figure, the LCC converter station can be regarded as a converter and a smoothing reactor L p And neutral line reactor L g In series, then with the DC filter Z filter connected in parallel; Figure 2 The complex frequency domain equivalent impedance Z of the LCC converter station is obtained LCC As shown in formula (2):
[0119] Z LCC =[R s +s(L p +L g )]||Z filter (2).
[0120] In this embodiment: In step 1, the complex frequency domain equivalent impedance of the MMC converter station is calculated; the three-phase circuit on the AC side remains symmetrical in a short time after the DC line fails, so the influence of the AC side current feed-in on the DC side fault current can be ignored. The DC side fault current of the MMC converter station is mainly determined by the capacitor discharge current of each submodule, wherein the submodule voltage is kept balanced under the influence of capacitor voltage control. According to the principle of energy conservation, the equivalent capacitance value C of the single-phase bridge arm is j As shown in formula (3):
[0121]
[0122] Among them, C0 is the submodule capacitance value, N1 is the number of cascaded single-phase bridge arm submodules;
[0123] The MMC converter station can be obtained by connecting three identical RLC series phase units in parallel, and its equivalent model can be expressed as follows: Figure 3 The RLC series circuit shown:
[0124] Where R arm , L arm is the equivalent resistance and equivalent inductance of each bridge arm, R eq , L eq and C eq is the equivalent parameter of the MMC converter station, and its calculation formula is shown in formula (4):
[0125]
[0126] The DC side of the MMC converter station is also connected in series with a smoothing reactor L p1 and neutral line reactor L g1 , so the equivalent impedance of the converter station is as shown in formula (5):
[0127]
[0128] In this embodiment: in step 1, the DC line equivalent is calculated;
[0129] Overhead lines are mostly used in high-voltage direct current power grids. Since the transmission lines and the earth will produce high-frequency skin effect under the action of alternating electromagnetic fields, the line parameters will change with the frequency. Most of the simulations use distributed parameter models to model the lines. However, the calculation process of using the line distributed parameter model to calculate the fault current is complicated and it is impossible to directly use mathematical processes to analyze the fluctuation law of transient current. Therefore, the present invention uses concentrated line parameters to calculate the fault current. Although the calculation using concentrated line parameters cannot describe the details of the travel wave reflection, it can correctly reflect the changing law of the fault current, and the calculated fault current is not much different from the result calculated using distributed parameters, which can meet the requirements of system parameter design, etc.
[0130] When a single-pole fault occurs in a DC line, the line mode and ground mode networks are in series. At this time, the resistance per unit length of the DC line is R l And the inductance per unit length L l Formula (6) can be used to obtain:
[0131]
[0132] When there is a short circuit between the poles, the positive pole and the negative pole are completely symmetrical, and each parameter only has line mode components but no ground mode components. Therefore, the inductance per unit length of the DC line is L. X , the resistance per unit length is R X , where R D and R X is the ground mode and line mode resistance of the DC line per unit length, L D and L X are the ground mode and line mode inductance per unit length of the DC line.
[0133] The values of various parameters are given in Table 1.
[0134] Table 1 DC line parameters
[0135] Parameter name Numeric <![CDATA[Ground model resistor R D > 0.209Ω / km <![CDATA[Wire model resistance R X > 0.0304Ω / km <![CDATA[Ground model inductor L D > 1.78mH / km <![CDATA[Wire-wound inductor L X > 0.86mH / km
[0136] In this embodiment: in step 2, after the DC side fault, the DC voltage decreases, and the LCC converter station starts the low voltage current limiting link (voltage dependent current order limiter, VDCOL) to reduce the DC current reference value. The DC current changes with the DC current reference value, which can suppress the rapid increase of the current during the fault period, and at the same time reduce the system reactive power demand, avoiding the phase change failure of the receiving end AC power grid; the voltage-current characteristic curve of the VDCOL link is as follows: Figure 4 shown.
[0137] I ref Indicates the DC current reference value at the LCC converter station outlet, U LCC Indicates the DC voltage at the LCC converter station outlet, U high , U low Respectively represent the high and low threshold values of DC voltage, I high ,I low Respectively represent the maximum and minimum values of DC current;
[0138] Depend on Figure 4 The voltage-current relationship of the low-voltage current limiting link can be deduced as shown in formula (7):
[0139]
[0140] From formula (7), we can see that U high , U low ,I high ,I low The values of the four parameters will affect the current limiting characteristics of the system, among which the current limiting upper limit parameter U high ,I high Mainly affects the start-up time of current limiting; the current limiting lower limit parameter U low ,I low It mainly affects the operating state when entering the steady state after current limiting; the slope parameter of current limiting mainly affects the speed of current limiting; usually, U high and U low Take 0.9U respectively N 、0.4U N , I high and I low I N , 0.55I N ;
[0141] In order to avoid the rapid rise of DC current during DC fault, the rectifier-side LCC converter station in the hybrid multi-terminal DC transmission system still retains the DC voltage type VDCOL (DC-VDCOL) link; its control logic is as follows: Figure 5 shown.
[0142] Among them, I LCC are the DC current at the LCC converter outlet, I order is the given value of DC current, its magnitude is 1, ΔI ref is the current change, G1, G2, G3 are gain coefficients, T1, T2, T3 are delay coefficients;
[0143] Depend on Figure 5 It can be seen that when the system is operating normally, the DC voltage and current remain basically constant, the low-voltage current limiting link does not start, and I ref with I orderThe values are close, the current change is small, and the trigger angle basically does not change; after a period of time after the DC side fault, the DC voltage drops to the starting threshold of the low-voltage current limiting link, I ref Start to decrease, ΔI ref The change causes the trigger angle to change, suppressing the rise of DC current; the following relationship can be obtained:
[0144]
[0145] In this embodiment: In step 3, under normal circumstances, the three-phase bridge arm of the MMC converter is balanced, and the number of sub-modules invested in the upper and lower bridge arms of each phase is the same, and the DC voltage can be kept balanced at this time; the number of sub-modules of the upper and lower bridge arms is determined according to the nearest level approximation modulation:
[0146]
[0147]
[0148]
[0149] Where N jp 、N jn are the number of submodules put into use in the upper and lower bridge arms respectively; V refjp 、V refjn are the upper and lower bridge arm voltage reference values respectively; V cn is the capacitor rated voltage of a single submodule; U dc is the DC side voltage of the converter; V refj The j-phase unit outputs the AC voltage reference value; u cirdj is the j-phase circulating current voltage;
[0150] The DC fault current after the DC side fault occurs and before the converter station is locked is mainly determined by the discharge of the submodule capacitor. It can be seen from formula (11) that the number of submodules put into operation in the converter is determined by the DC voltage, the rated voltage of a single submodule and the circulating current voltage. The circulating current voltage value has little effect on the number of submodules put into operation and its influence can be ignored in the calculation. Therefore, formula (11) can be simplified as follows:
[0151]
[0152] The magnitude of the DC short-circuit current is mainly related to the DC voltage, the initial value of the DC current fault and the equivalent impedance of the fault loop. The latter two are determined by the operating state of the system itself and the system design, and are usually difficult to change. Therefore, the current rise speed and peak value can be suppressed by changing the MMC DC voltage. It can be seen from formula (12) that the DC voltage can be reduced by reducing the number of sub-modules put into the bridge arm. Therefore, the active current limiting control introduces the active current limiting factor K to achieve current limiting. The voltage after current limiting is shown in formula (13):
[0153] U dck =KN1V cn (13);
[0154] After the introduction of active current limiting link, the complete control link of MMC converter station includes constant DC voltage control, constant active power control, constant reactive power control, inner loop current control, circulating current suppression and active current limiting control; the logic between each control link is as follows Figure 6 shown.
[0155] Depend on Figure 6 It can be seen that the principle of the active current limiting link is: the DC current I at the MMC converter station outlet dc With the DC current reference value I dcref After the DC current change is obtained by subtracting it from I dcref The current change per unit value is obtained by comparison, which is related to the current limiting parameter K B The current correction deviation is obtained by multiplying them, and the active current limiting factor K is obtained by subtracting the current correction deviation from the upper limit amplitude 1 and passing through the limiting link. Its expression is shown in formula (14):
[0156]
[0157] Among them, I dc is the actual value of DC current, I dcref is the DC current rating;
[0158] When the system is operating normally, the DC current remains near the rated value, and the active current limiting factor K is always 1. At this time, the current limiting link will not work. After a short circuit fault occurs on the DC side, the active current limiting link starts adaptively as the fault current increases. The active current limiting factor K gradually decreases within the adjustable range, reducing the number of submodules put into operation and thus reducing the DC side voltage of the MMC converter station, suppressing the rapid rise of the DC current; the current limiting parameter K B It will affect the current limiting effect of the active current limiting link. Its value needs to consider both the current limiting effect and the AC outlet voltage drop level. Therefore, its value range is given as shown in formula (15):
[0159]
[0160] Among them, I dcmax It is the maximum rated current under normal operating conditions.
[0161] In this embodiment: in step 4, the influence of the current limiting control of the LCC converter station and the MMC converter station on the fault current is considered;
[0162] After a DC fault occurs, the system can be regarded as a superposition of a faulty additional network and a normal operating network. The fault current can be calculated only in the faulty additional network, and then the calculation result is superimposed with the steady-state current to obtain the fault current. However, the converter current limiting control link will respond to the development of the fault, affecting the calculation result of the fault current. Therefore, the impact of the current limiting control strategy on the fault current needs to be further considered during the calculation.
[0163] The fault current is calculated in the complex frequency domain through the fault additional network, and then the time domain solution of the fault current is obtained through Laplace transform:
[0164]
[0165] Step 4 includes:
[0166] Step 41, calculating the fault current in the complex frequency domain through the fault additional network, and then obtaining the time domain solution of the fault current of the low voltage current limiting link through Laplace transformation;
[0167] Step 42, the fault current is calculated in the complex frequency domain through the fault additional network, and then the time domain solution of the fault current of the active current limiting link is obtained through Laplace transformation.
[0168] Line l AB Taking a single-pole grounding fault as an example, the current calculation method of the present invention is described. The fault additional network is as follows: Figure 7 shown.
[0169] Among them, U F / s is the additional fault component power, R F is the fault transition resistance; Z LCC , Z MMC1 and Z MMC2 are the complex frequency domain equivalent impedances of the three converter stations; Z l11 , Z l12 The DC lines are AB The equivalent impedance in the complex frequency domain on the left and right sides of the fault point, Z l2 For DC line l BC The complex frequency domain equivalent impedance; ΔI LCC , ΔI MMC1 , ΔI MMC2 The short-circuit current fault components at the outlets of LCC, MMC1 and MMC2 converter stations are respectively. In case of inter-pole fault, the fault additional network only needs to Figure 7 The transition resistance in becomes R F / 2 and recalculate the line parameters.
[0170] Generally, the action time of DC line protection and DC circuit breaker is less than 6ms. The present invention selects a time range of 10ms after the fault to calculate the fault current, and the obtained result can meet the requirements of system design and protection setting of the power grid.
[0171] In this embodiment: in step 41, after the low-voltage current limiting link of the LCC converter station is started, the Figure 6 The complex frequency domain expression of the fault component of the LCC converter output current when the current limiting link is ignored is shown in formula (17):
[0172]
[0173] Among them, Z L , Z R They represent the complex frequency domain impedance on the left and right sides of the fault point respectively, and their expressions are shown in formula (18):
[0174]
[0175] The fault current is obtained by superimposing the current fault component and the steady-state operation component as shown in formula (19):
[0176] I LCC =ΔI LCC +I s.LCC (19);
[0177] The DC voltage U at the outlet of the LCC converter after the fault can be obtained: LCC As shown in formula (20):
[0178] U LCC =I LCC ×Z LCC (20);
[0179] From formula (7), we can see that the slope in the low-voltage current limiting link is a certain value, which does not fully consider the dynamic characteristics of the change of electrical quantity. Therefore, the current command value obtained by the low-voltage current limiting link cannot dynamically respond to the needs of the system. Substituting the above results into formula (8), we can get I′ LCC and U′ LCC , and substitute it into formula (7), we get the voltage at [U low ,U high ] after the DC current command value I ref As shown in formula (21):
[0180]
[0181] DC voltage U LCC and current I LCCThe parameters and slope of the above formula fully consider the dynamic characteristics of electrical quantities, enhance the dynamic performance of the VDCOL link in regulating the current command, and enable the system to present different dynamic response characteristics during the fault period. The reference current calculated by the above formula is more in line with the actual needs of the system. After that, the reference current I is calculated. ref with I' LCC The dynamic change of current ΔI is obtained by subtracting ref , substitute it into formula (8) and calculate the trigger angle α that changes dynamically with the current command.
[0182] For LCC converter station, the voltage at the converter station outlet drops to 0.9U N When the low-voltage current limiting link is activated, the low-voltage current limiting link will be activated. Due to the different arrival times of the high- and low-frequency components of the traveling wave at the measuring point, the DC voltage measured at the measuring point fluctuates greatly, and there will be a large error between the calculated value and the actual value of the DC voltage. However, the reference current calculated from the DC voltage changes more smoothly, and its variation range is relatively small, 0.55 to 1, and the error is small during calculation. Therefore, the start-up time of the low-voltage current limiting link can be determined by the change of the calculated reference current.
[0183] After determining the start time, substitute the dynamically changing trigger angle α into formula (1) to calculate the rectifier side DC voltage u s ,u s To characterize the influence of LCC control system on DC line fault, it can be approximately regarded as the fault voltage source of the system, and the calculation formula of DC current fault component can be approximately expressed as:
[0184]
[0185] The current fault component after the trigger angle changes is obtained by formula (22), and added to the steady-state component to obtain the fault current taking into account the influence of the low-voltage current limiting link.
[0186] In this embodiment: in step 42, when the fault current of the MMC converter station exceeds the rated current, the active current limiting link is activated, so whether the active current limiting control is activated can be determined by observing the fault current. Figure 7 The complex frequency domain expression of the fault component of the MMC1 converter output current when the current limiting link is ignored is shown in formula (23):
[0187]
[0188] The fault current is obtained by superimposing the current fault component and the steady-state operation component as shown in formula (24):
[0189] I MMC1 =ΔI MMC1 +I s.MMC1 (twenty four);
[0190] It can be seen from formula (14) that the change of active current limiting factor K is related to DC current, rated current and current limiting coefficient. Among them, the rated current and current limiting coefficient are determined by the operating state of the system itself and the system design, and are generally fixed values. However, the DC current will change greatly after the fault, which is the main reason for the change of active current limiting factor. Since formula (23) does not take into account the effect of the control system, the fault current value calculated by it will be higher than the actual value. The K calculated using this current has a large deviation and cannot accurately reflect the inhibitory effect of the current limiting link on the fault current.
[0191] The present invention considers the dynamic change of fault current and uses Laplace transform to obtain the time domain solution of fault current. MMC1 The present invention selects the time range of 10ms after the fault to calculate the fault current. If t0 exceeds this range, then directly take i MMC1 As the current calculation result; if t0 is within this range, the time period from t0 to 10ms is taken for calculation. In order to take into account both calculation accuracy and calculation efficiency, 1ms is taken as the time interval to obtain t n (n=1, 2, ..., N), the active current limiting factor K and the fault current are iterated based on time.
[0192] To calculate t n-1 The fault current affected by the current limiting control in the time period is taken as the fault current in the whole time period and t n-2 Calculation results of fault current affected by time-limited current control i” n-2 Substituting into equation (25), we can obtain t n-1 Active current limiting factor group K for the time period n-1 As shown in formula (26):
[0193]
[0194] K n-1 =[K n-1,0 K n-1,1 ··· K n-1,m ] (26);
[0195] Among them, K n-1,0 ~K n-1,m Represents t n-1 The active current limiting factor K value corresponding to m moments in the time period.
[0196] Find t n-1 The fault current of the time period and the current limiting link is:
[0197] i′ n-1 =K n-1 ×i′ n-2 (27);
[0198] The influence of the current limiting link on the fault current gradually increases as the fault develops. n When calculating the fault current of the time period, t n-1 The role of the time-limited current link, so find K n-1 The mean As shown in formula (28).
[0199]
[0200] Using formula (29), we can obtain the total time period and t n-1 Calculation result of fault current with time-limiting link i” n-1 :
[0201]
[0202] Afterwards, use i" n-1 Repeat the above calculation process to obtain t n The time period takes into account the fault current of current limiting control, and realizes the iteration of fault current over time.
[0203] Experimental verification:
[0204] Use PSCAD / EMTDC to build Figure 1 The hybrid multi-terminal DC transmission system shown in the figure verifies the proposed calculation method. Among them, the transmission line adopts the Bergeron model, the LCC station current limiting control is the low-voltage current limiting link, the MMC1 and MMC2 station current limiting control is the active current limiting link, and the relevant parameters of each converter station are shown in Table 2.
[0205] The DC transmission lines of hybrid multi-terminal systems are hundreds of kilometers long. It takes a certain amount of time for the fault wave to be transmitted to the converter station and for the fault current to rise to the starting value of the current limiting link. Therefore, the converter station far away from the fault location may not start within the transient time scale (10ms). Through simulation tests, it is found that when a DC line fault occurs, only the current limiting link of the converter station directly connected on both sides of the line may be started. Since the converter stations directly connected on both sides of the two sections of the hybrid multi-terminal DC transmission system are different, simulation verification is carried out according to the different lines where the fault is located, and the fault current at the outlet of the converter station on both sides of the line is calculated respectively.
[0206] Table 2 Converter station parameters
[0207]
[0208] Line AB Fault:
[0209] Line ABThe converter stations on both sides are LCC and MMC1 respectively. The fault current at the exits of the two converter stations is calculated by considering the influence of the low-voltage current limiting link of the LCC converter station and the active current limiting link of the MMC1 converter station.
[0210] Fig. 9 , Fig.10 The following are the LCC converter near end (20km) and line l AB Fault current at the exit of LCC converter station and MMC1 converter station when metallic single-pole grounding fault occurs at three locations: midpoint and near end of MMC1 converter station (20km). In the figure, time 0 is the fault start time, curve A is the fault current simulation result, curve B is the fault current calculated without control, and curve C is the fault current calculated with current limiting control. Curve 1 is the reference current of the low-voltage current limiting link obtained by simulation, and curve 2 is the reference current of the low-voltage current limiting link obtained by calculation.
[0211] Fig. 9 The fault location shown in a) is close to the LCC converter station, and the time required for the fault traveling wave to be transmitted to the LCC converter outlet measurement point is short. The fault current rises rapidly in a short time. From the reference current in the figure, it can be seen that the low-voltage current limiting link has been started at about 2ms, and as time increases, the difference between the calculation result taking into account the current limiting control and the calculation result without taking into account the current limiting control increases. This shows that the method proposed in the present invention can effectively reflect the influence of the current limiting control on the fault current calculation result and reduce the calculation error; Fig. 9 The fault shown in b) is located at the midpoint of the line. It can be seen from the figure that the fault traveling wave is transmitted to the LCC converter outlet measurement point at about 3ms, and the current rise level is low, so the low-voltage current limiting link starts late; Fig. 9 As shown in c), the fault location is far away from the LCC, the reference current value remains unchanged, and the low-voltage current limiting link is not activated within 10ms.
[0212] Fig.10 a)-10b) In the MMC1 outlet fault current, the active current limiting link does not start because the MMC1 current limiting link does not start; Fig.10 In c), the fault occurs near the MMC1 converter. After the fault current exceeds the rated value of 2kA, the active current limiting link is activated, and has a strong inhibitory effect on the fault current. Since the transmission line in the simulation adopts a distributed parameter model, the line equivalent impedance will have a resonance point in the high-frequency range, so the fault current will produce a small amplitude oscillation, but the concentrated parameter model of the line is used in the calculation. Therefore, although the calculation results cannot describe the details of the traveling wave refraction reflection, they can reflect the development trend of the fault current. The closer the fault point is to the LCC, the earlier the LCC low-voltage current limiting link responds, and the greater the degree of influence of the LCC low-voltage current limiting link on the fault current. If the current limiting control is not taken into account for the calculation, a large error will be introduced.
[0213] Fig.11 , Fig.12 The figures show the fault currents at the exits of the LCC converter station and the MMC1 converter station when a single-pole grounding fault occurs at the midpoint of the line through a 50Ω and 100Ω transition resistor. Fig.11 It can be seen that compared with the fault current when a metallic single-pole grounding fault occurs, the fault current when the line is grounded through a transition resistor develops more slowly and has a smaller value. It takes a long time for the outlet current of the LCC converter station to reach the starting value of the current limiting link. Fig.12 It can be seen that under the influence of fault distance and transition resistance, the outlet current of MMC1 converter station cannot reach the starting value of the current limiting link within 10ms.
[0214] Metallic inter-pole fault is the most serious fault on the DC side. Fig.12 The fault currents at the two converter station outlets when a metallic fault occurs between poles at the near end (20 km) of the MMC1 converter are given.
[0215] from Fig.13 It can be seen that the fault current of the LCC converter station develops slowly due to its distance from the fault location, and the fault current at the outlet of the MMC1 converter station rises rapidly in a short time, and the current limiting link is activated in about 1ms. In the second half of the fault, the calculation results without considering the influence of the current limiting link have a large error with the simulation results, while the results obtained by the calculation method proposed in the present invention can better track the simulation current and more accurately depict the development trend of the current.
[0216] Current limiting parameter adaptability analysis:
[0217] From formula (14), we can see that the value of active current limiting factor K is related to the current limiting parameter K B For the analysis of different control parameters K B The feasibility of the proposed method is investigated for different K B The fault current at the MMC converter station outlet is analyzed by taking the following values. B 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, MMC2 converter station K B When the line l BC The simulation is carried out for the case of a metallic single-pole grounding fault at the midpoint, and the simulation results are similar to the calculation results. Fig.14 shown.
[0218] from Fig.14 It can be seen that with the increase of K B As the value of the fault current obtained by simulation increases, it gradually decreases, which shows that within a certain range, K BIncreasing can improve the current limiting effect, but the error between the simulation current and the fault current calculation result without current limiting control will increase. The fault current calculated by the proposed method with current limiting control can be adaptively adjusted with the change of current limiting parameters. B The values taken can better reflect the changing trend of the fault current.
[0219] Calculation error:
[0220] To further verify the calculation accuracy of the fault current, let the line l in the previous article AB The six fault conditions verified by the simulation are fault conditions 1-6. The maximum calculation errors of the converter station outlet fault current calculated with and without the current limiting link are shown in Table 3.
[0221] Table 3 Maximum calculation error of fault current
[0222]
[0223] It can be seen from Table 3 that the change of fault current can be effectively reduced when the influence of the control system is taken into account, making the calculation result closer to the simulation result, and reducing the error of calculating the fault current using the complex frequency domain algorithm. The results in Table 3 show that under different fault types, fault locations and transition resistances, the quantitative calculation of the fault current using the method proposed in the present invention can better reflect the development trend of the current, and the calculation result error within 10ms can basically be kept within 10%.
[0224] in conclusion:
[0225] Aiming at the problem that the current fault current calculation of multi-terminal hybrid DC transmission system ignores the current limiting control, which leads to the increase of the error of the short-circuit current calculation result, the present invention proposes a fault current calculation method taking into account the current limiting control response based on the equivalent modeling of the multi-terminal hybrid DC transmission system, and the conclusions are as follows:
[0226] 1. The multi-terminal hybrid DC transmission system involves the LCC low-voltage current limiting link and the MMC active current limiting link, both of which are related to the dynamic changes of the fault current in the system. The fault current calculation results without current limiting control can be used to dynamically update the current limiting control parameters to obtain the fault current taking into account the current limiting control link;
[0227] 2. The simulation data show that the proposed calculation method can accurately describe the transient characteristics and change trends of the fault current at the outlets of adjacent converter stations of the line when the current limiting link is activated within 10ms after the fault occurs, which can provide a reference for equipment parameter selection and protection setting, and has good theoretical and engineering application value.
[0228] 3. The present invention takes a multi-terminal hybrid DC transmission system as an example for analysis, but the method is applicable to the fault current calculation of other systems including low-voltage current limiting links and active current limiting links.
[0229] It is obvious to those skilled in the art that the present invention is not limited to the details of the exemplary embodiments described above, and that the present invention can be implemented in other specific forms without departing from the spirit or essential features of the present invention. Therefore, the embodiments should be considered as exemplary and non-restrictive in all respects.
[0230] In addition, it should be understood that although the present specification is described according to implementation modes, not every implementation mode contains only one independent technical solution. This description of the specification is only for the sake of clarity. Those skilled in the art should regard the specification as a whole. The technical solutions in each embodiment may also be appropriately combined to form other implementation modes that can be understood by those skilled in the art.
Claims
1. A method for calculating fault current in a hybrid multi-terminal direct current transmission system, characterized in that: The hybrid multi-terminal direct current transmission system fault current calculation method comprises the following steps: Step 1, constructing a hybrid multi-terminal DC transmission system; Step 2: When the hybrid multi-terminal DC transmission system fails, the fault current limiting control is performed through the LCC converter station; the LCC converter station starts the low-voltage current limiting link to reduce the DC current reference value, and the DC current changes with the DC current reference value, thereby suppressing the rapid increase of the current during the fault period, and reducing the reactive power demand of the system, thereby avoiding commutation failure in the receiving-end AC power grid; Step 3, performing fault current limiting control through the MMC converter station; suppressing the rising speed and peak value of the DC short-circuit current by changing the DC voltage of the MMC converter station; Step 4, consider the impact of current limiting control of LCC converter station and MMC converter station on fault current; calculate the fault current in the complex frequency domain through the fault additional network, and then obtain the time domain solution of the fault current through Laplace transform; The hybrid multi-terminal direct current transmission system comprises an LCC converter station and an MMC converter station, wherein the MMC converter station comprises an MMC1 converter station and an MMC2 converter station; one end of the LCC converter station is connected to a power source S1, and the other end of the LCC converter station is connected to a smoothing reactor L P One end of the smoothing reactor L P The other end is connected to the DC filter Z filter One end of the DC line l AB One end of the DC filter Z filter The other end of the DC line is grounded. AB The other end is connected to the DC line l BC One end of the smoothing reactor L P1 One end of the smoothing reactor L P1 The other end of the DC line is connected to one end of the MMC1 converter station, and the other end of the MMC1 converter station is connected to the power supply S2. BC The other end is connected to the smoothing reactor L P2 One end of the smoothing reactor L P2 The other end of is connected to one end of the MMC2 converter station, and the other end of the MMC2 converter station is connected to the power supply S3.
2. The method for calculating fault current of a hybrid multi-terminal direct current transmission system according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step 1, the complex frequency domain equivalent impedance of the LCC converter station is calculated; the LCC converter can be regarded as the equivalent voltage source u of the converter valve s With equivalent impedance R s Series connection; the DC filter can be regarded as an inductor and capacitor circuit with concentrated parameters, and the values of each part are shown in formula (1): Among them, X σ is the leakage reactance of the converter transformer, N is the number of 6-pulse converter bridges per pole in the LCC converter station, E r is the effective value of the bus voltage on the AC side of the converter station, α is the trigger angle of the LCC converter station, k is the ratio of the converter transformer; L1, L2, L3, C1, C2, C3 are the parameters related to the DC filter; s is the Laplace operator; The LCC converter station can be regarded as a converter and a smoothing reactor L p And neutral line reactor L g In series, then with the DC filter Z filter The complex frequency domain equivalent impedance Z of the LCC converter station is obtained by connecting in parallel. LCC As shown in formula (2): Z LCC =[R s +s(L p +L g )]||Z filter (2)。 3. The method for calculating fault current of a hybrid multi-terminal direct current transmission system according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step 1, the complex frequency domain equivalent impedance of the MMC converter station is calculated; the three-phase circuit on the AC side remains symmetrical in a short period of time after the DC line fails, so the influence of the AC side current feed-in on the DC side fault current can be ignored. The DC side fault current of the MMC converter station is mainly determined by the capacitor discharge current of each submodule, among which the submodule voltage is kept balanced under the influence of capacitor voltage control. According to the principle of energy conservation, the equivalent capacitance value C of the single-phase bridge arm is j As shown in formula (3): Among them, C0 is the submodule capacitance value, N1 is the number of cascaded single-phase bridge arm submodules; The MMC converter station can be obtained by connecting three identical RLC series phase units in parallel. Its equivalent model can be expressed as an RLC series circuit: Where R arm , L arm is the equivalent resistance and equivalent inductance of each bridge arm, R eq , L eq and C eq is the equivalent parameter of the MMC converter station, and its calculation formula is shown in formula (4): The DC side of the MMC converter station is also connected in series with a smoothing reactor L p1 and neutral line reactor L g1 , so the equivalent impedance of the converter station is as shown in formula (5):
4. The method for calculating fault current of a hybrid multi-terminal direct current transmission system according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step 1, the DC line is calculated as equal value. When a single-pole fault occurs in the DC line, the line mode and ground mode networks are in series relationship. At this time, the resistance per unit length of the DC line is R l And the inductance per unit length L l Formula (6) can be used to obtain: When there is a short circuit between the poles, the positive pole and the negative pole are completely symmetrical, and each parameter only has line mode components but no ground mode components. Therefore, the inductance per unit length of the DC line is L. X , the resistance per unit length is R X , where R D and R X is the ground mode and line mode resistance of the DC line per unit length, L D and L X are the ground mode and line mode inductance per unit length of the DC line.
5. The method for calculating fault current in a hybrid multi-terminal direct current transmission system according to any one of claims 1 to 4, characterized in that: In step 2, after the DC side fault occurs, the DC voltage decreases, and the LCC converter station starts the low-voltage current limiting link to reduce the DC current reference value. The DC current changes with the DC current reference value, which can suppress the rapid increase of the current during the fault period, while reducing the system reactive power demand and avoiding commutation failure in the receiving-end AC power grid. I ref Indicates the DC current reference value at the LCC converter station outlet, U LCC Indicates the DC voltage at the LCC converter station outlet, U high , U low Respectively represent the high and low threshold values of DC voltage, I high ,I low Respectively represent the maximum and minimum values of DC current; The voltage-current relationship of the low-voltage current limiting link is derived as shown in formula (7): From formula (7), we can see that U high , U low ,I high ,I low The values of the four parameters will affect the current limiting characteristics of the system, among which the current limiting upper limit parameter U high ,I high Mainly affects the start-up time of current limiting; the current limiting lower limit parameter U low ,I low It mainly affects the operating state when entering the steady state after current limiting; the slope parameter of current limiting mainly affects the speed of current limiting; usually, U high and U low Take 0.9U respectively N 、0.4U N , I high and I low I N , 0.55I N ; In order to avoid the rapid rise of DC current during DC fault, the DC voltage type VDCOL link is still retained in the rectifier-side LCC converter station in the hybrid multi-terminal DC transmission system; Among them, I LCC are the DC current at the LCC converter outlet, I order is the given value of DC current, its magnitude is 1, ΔI ref is the current change, G1, G2, G3 are gain coefficients, T1, T2, T3 are delay coefficients; When the system is operating normally, the DC voltage and current remain basically constant, the low-voltage current limiting link does not start, and I ref with I order The values are close, the current change is small, and the trigger angle basically does not change; after a period of time after the DC side fault, the DC voltage drops to the starting threshold of the low-voltage current limiting link, I ref Start to decrease, ΔI ref The change causes the trigger angle to change, suppressing the rise of DC current; the following relationship can be obtained:
6. The method for calculating fault current in a hybrid multi-terminal direct current transmission system according to any one of claims 1 to 4, characterized in that: In step 3, under normal circumstances, the three-phase bridge arm of the MMC converter is balanced, and the number of submodules put into the upper and lower bridge arms of each phase is the same, so that the DC voltage can be balanced; the number of submodules of the upper and lower bridge arms is determined according to the nearest level approximation modulation: Where N jp 、N jn are the number of submodules put into use in the upper and lower bridge arms respectively; V refjp 、V refjn are the upper and lower bridge arm voltage reference values respectively; V cn is the rated voltage of the capacitor of a single submodule; U dc is the DC side voltage of the converter; V refj The j-phase unit outputs the AC voltage reference value; u cirdj is the j-phase circulating current voltage; The DC fault current after the DC side fault occurs and before the converter station is locked is mainly determined by the discharge of the submodule capacitor. It can be seen from formula (11) that the number of submodules put into operation in the converter is determined by the DC voltage, the rated voltage of a single submodule and the circulating current voltage. The circulating current voltage value has little effect on the number of submodules put into operation and its influence can be ignored in the calculation. Therefore, formula (11) can be simplified as follows: The magnitude of the DC short-circuit current is mainly related to the DC voltage, the initial value of the DC current fault and the equivalent impedance of the fault loop. The latter two are determined by the operating state of the system itself and the system design, and are usually difficult to change. Therefore, the current rise speed and peak value can be suppressed by changing the MMC DC voltage. It can be seen from formula (12) that the DC voltage can be reduced by reducing the number of sub-modules put into the bridge arm. Therefore, the active current limiting control introduces the active current limiting factor K to achieve current limiting. The voltage after current limiting is shown in formula (13): IN dck =KN1V cn (13); After the active current limiting link is introduced, the complete control link of the MMC converter station includes constant DC voltage control, constant active power control, constant reactive power control, inner loop current control, circulating current suppression and active current limiting control; The principle of active current limiting is: the DC current I at the MMC converter station outlet dc With the DC current reference value I dcref After the DC current change is obtained by subtracting it from I dcref The current change per unit value is obtained by comparison, which is related to the current limiting parameter K B The current correction deviation is obtained by multiplying them, and the active current limiting factor K is obtained by subtracting the current correction deviation from the upper limit amplitude 1 and passing through the limiting link. Its expression is shown in formula (14): Among them, I dc is the actual value of DC current, I dcref is the DC current rating; When the system is operating normally, the DC current remains near the rated value, and the active current limiting factor K is always 1. At this time, the current limiting link will not work. After a short circuit fault occurs on the DC side, the active current limiting link starts adaptively as the fault current increases. The active current limiting factor K gradually decreases within the adjustable range, reducing the number of submodules put into operation and thus reducing the DC side voltage of the MMC converter station, suppressing the rapid rise of the DC current; the current limiting parameter K B It will affect the current limiting effect of the active current limiting link. Its value needs to consider both the current limiting effect and the AC outlet voltage drop level. Therefore, its value range is given as shown in formula (15): Among them, I dcmax It is the maximum rated current under normal operating conditions.
7. The method for calculating fault current in a hybrid multi-terminal direct current transmission system according to any one of claims 1 to 4, characterized in that: In step 4, the influence of current limiting control of LCC converter station and MMC converter station on fault current is considered; the fault current is calculated in the complex frequency domain through the fault additional network, and then the time domain solution of the fault current is obtained through Laplace transform: Step 4 includes: Step 41, calculating the fault current in the complex frequency domain through the fault additional network, and then obtaining the time domain solution of the fault current of the low voltage current limiting link through Laplace transformation; Step 42, the fault current is calculated in the complex frequency domain through the fault additional network, and then the time domain solution of the fault current of the active current limiting link is obtained through Laplace transformation.
8. The method for calculating fault current of a hybrid multi-terminal direct current transmission system according to claim 7, characterized in that: In step 41, after the low-voltage current limiting link of the LCC converter station is started, the complex frequency domain expression of the fault component of the LCC converter outlet current when the current limiting link is ignored is obtained as shown in formula (17): Among them, Z L , Z R They represent the complex frequency domain impedance on the left and right sides of the fault point respectively, and their expressions are shown in formula (18): The fault current is obtained by superimposing the current fault component and the steady-state operation component as shown in formula (19): I LCC =ΔI LCC +I s.LCC (19); The DC voltage U at the outlet of the LCC converter after the fault can be obtained: LCC As shown in formula (20): IN LCC =I LCC ×Z LCC (20); The slope in the low-voltage current limiting link is a certain value, and the dynamic characteristics of the change of electrical quantity are not fully considered. Therefore, the current command value obtained by the low-voltage current limiting link cannot dynamically respond to the needs of the system. LCC and U′ LCC , and further obtain the voltage [U low ,U high ] after the DC current command value I ref As shown in formula (21): DC voltage U LCC and current I LCC All change dynamically with time, and the reference current I ref with I' LCC The dynamic change of current ΔI is obtained by subtracting ref , the trigger angle α that changes dynamically with the current command is calculated; For LCC converter station, the voltage at the converter station outlet drops to 0.9U N When the low-voltage current limiting link is started, the DC voltage measured at the measuring point fluctuates greatly due to the different arrival times of the high-frequency and low-frequency components of the traveling wave at the measuring point. There is a large error between the calculated value and the actual value of the DC voltage. The reference current calculated from the DC voltage changes smoothly, and its variation range is as small as 0.55 to 1. The error is small during calculation. Therefore, the start-up time of the low-voltage current limiting link can be determined by the change of the calculated reference current. After determining the start time, the DC voltage u on the rectifier side is obtained through the dynamically changing trigger angle α s ,u s To characterize the influence of LCC control system on DC line fault, it can be approximately regarded as the fault voltage source of the system, and the calculation formula of DC current fault component can be approximately expressed as: The current fault component after the trigger angle changes is obtained by formula (22), and added to the steady-state component to obtain the fault current taking into account the influence of the low-voltage current limiting link.
9. The method for calculating fault current of a hybrid multi-terminal direct current transmission system according to claim 7, characterized in that: In step 42, when the fault current of the MMC converter station exceeds the rated current, the active current limiting link is started. By observing the magnitude of the fault current, it is determined whether the active current limiting control is started. The complex frequency domain expression of the fault component of the MMC1 converter outlet current when the current limiting link is ignored is obtained as shown in formula (23): The fault current is obtained by superimposing the current fault component and the steady-state operation component as shown in formula (24): I MMC1 =ΔI MMC1 +I s.MMC1 (24); Considering the dynamic change of fault current, the time domain solution of fault current is obtained by Laplace transform. MMC1 And determine the current limiting start time t0, select the time range of 10ms after the fault to calculate the fault current. If t0 exceeds this range, directly take i MMC1 As the current calculation result; if t0 is within this range, then take the period from t0 to 10ms for calculation, and take 1ms as the time interval to get t n , iterate the active current limiting factor K and the fault current based on time; To calculate t n-1 The fault current affected by the current limiting control in the time period is taken as the fault current in the whole time period and t n-2 Calculation results of fault current affected by time-limited current control i” n-2 Substituting into equation (25), we can obtain t n-1 Active current limiting factor group K for the time period n-1 As shown in formula (26): K n-1 =[K n-1,0 K n-1,1 ··· K n-1,m ] (26); Among them, K n-1,0 ~K n-1,m Represents t n-1 The active current limiting factor K value corresponding to m moments in the time period; Find t n-1 The fault current of the time period and the current limiting link is: i′ n-1 =K n-1 ×i″ n-2 (27); The influence of the current limiting link on the fault current gradually increases as the fault develops. n When calculating the fault current of the time period, t n-1 The role of the time-limited current link, so find K n-1 The mean As shown in formula (28): Using formula (29), we can obtain the total time period and t n-1 Calculation result of fault current with time-limiting link i” n-1 : Afterwards, use i" n-1 Repeat the above calculation process to obtain t n The time period takes into account the fault current of current limiting control, and realizes the iteration of fault current over time.
Citation Information
Cited By
Constant value setting method and system for single-ended transient voltage energy type direct current line protection
CN120749665A
Single-end transient voltage energy type direct current line protection setting method and system
CN120749665B
Virtual complex impedance collaborative treatment method based on improved droop
CN122576993A
