Power distribution network carbon reduction measure decision and comprehensive benefit evaluation method
By building a carbon reduction decision-making system and comprehensive benefit evaluation method for distribution networks, the problem of lack of comprehensive distribution network evaluation model is solved, and a multi-faceted evaluation of economic, low-carbon and social benefits has been achieved, and the low-carbon distribution network has been optimized. Operation and carbon emission management improve the accuracy and reliability of the assessment.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202410845918.X
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-06-27
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-03
AI Technical Summary
The existing distribution network evaluation model mainly focuses on economic benefit analysis, lacks a comprehensive comprehensive benefit evaluation, and it is difficult to cope with the complexity and in-depth evaluation of distribution network projects, especially in low-carbon governance and renewable energy utilization. There are shortcomings in terms of aspects.
A method for deciding on carbon reduction measures and comprehensive benefits evaluation of distribution networks is proposed. By establishing a carbon emission reduction model and building a carbon reduction decision system, the evaluation indicators of economic, low-carbon and social benefits are selected, and the indicators are determined by the improved AHP-CRITIC method. Weight, and combine demand response, energy storage power stations, wind power generation and photovoltaic power generation, design the carbon market and green certificate market mechanism, and optimize the evaluation method.
It has improved the comprehensive benefit evaluation level of distribution network projects, reduced carbon emissions, enhanced economic and social benefits, provided a scientific basis for the optimization of distribution networks, and improved the accuracy and reliability of evaluation.
Smart Images

Figure CN119067484A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to the technical field of distribution network, and in particular to a method for making decisions on carbon reduction measures and evaluating comprehensive benefits of distribution network. Background Art
[0002] As an important part of the power system, the distribution network accounts for a large proportion of carbon emissions. The implementation of carbon reduction measures for the distribution network can optimize the structure and operation of the power grid, improve the utilization rate of renewable energy, reduce the energy consumption and operating costs of the power grid, and promote the transformation of the energy structure towards a clean and low-carbon direction.
[0003] At present, the power supply form and grid structure in the distribution system are becoming increasingly complex. At the same time, the expansion of flexible loads on the demand side makes demand response more critical. In addition, the connection between the electricity market, carbon market and green certificate market is becoming increasingly close. In order to ensure the sustainable development and efficient operation of the power grid, the comprehensive evaluation of the distribution network planning is particularly important. This evaluation process involves in-depth analysis and quantitative evaluation of the economic, technical, environmental and other attributes of the planning scheme. By constructing a scientific and reasonable evaluation model, we can integrate various influencing factors into a comprehensive system evaluation value, so as to more accurately evaluate the overall performance of the distribution network. This not only helps to optimize resource allocation, but also provides strong support for the future development of the power grid.
[0004] The traditional distribution network evaluation model mainly focuses on economic benefit analysis. The existing evaluation index system has shortcomings and often only focuses on a specific aspect of the distribution network. With the increasing complexity and comprehensiveness of distribution network projects, a single evaluation dimension and method has become difficult to comprehensively and systematically evaluate its comprehensive benefits. Therefore, there is an urgent need to optimize the evaluation method. At the same time, as a key area for carbon emission reduction, we need to further increase the intensity of low-carbon governance to lead the distribution network towards a green and low-carbon direction. Summary of the invention
[0005] In view of the above problems, the present invention provides a method for decision-making on carbon reduction measures and comprehensive benefit evaluation of distribution networks. Based on the decision-making on carbon reduction measures of distribution networks, evaluation indicators of the comprehensive benefits of distribution networks are determined, and the indicator weights are optimized, thereby improving the comprehensive benefit evaluation level of distribution network projects, strengthening the low-carbon operation of distribution networks, improving economic and social benefits, and providing a scientific basis for the optimization of distribution networks.
[0006] The present invention provides a distribution network carbon reduction measure decision-making and comprehensive benefit evaluation method, comprising the following steps:
[0007] Establish a carbon emission reduction model for distribution networks;
[0008] Based on the carbon emission reduction model of the distribution network, a distribution network carbon reduction measures decision system is constructed; the distribution network carbon reduction measures decision system includes a first-level carbon reduction decision indicator and a second-level carbon reduction decision indicator; the first-level carbon reduction decision indicator is a distribution network carbon reduction measures decision item that considers the low-carbon economy of the distribution network; the second-level carbon reduction decision indicator is a specific method for corresponding carbon reduction measures from the first-level carbon reduction decision indicator;
[0009] Select distribution network project evaluation indicators to construct a distribution network comprehensive benefit evaluation indicator system; the distribution network comprehensive benefit evaluation indicator system includes primary indicators and secondary indicators; the secondary indicators are specific indicators extended from the primary indicators; the primary indicators include: economic benefits, low-carbon benefits and social benefits;
[0010] The improved AHP-CRITIC method is used to determine the comprehensive weights of each indicator in the distribution network carbon reduction measures decision-making system and the distribution network comprehensive benefit evaluation index system;
[0011] Score each indicator; obtain the economic benefit score, low-carbon benefit score, social benefit score and comprehensive benefit score based on the comprehensive weight and score of each indicator and using a comprehensive benefit scoring model; the comprehensive benefit scoring model includes an economic benefit scoring model, a low-carbon benefit scoring model, a social benefit scoring model and a comprehensive benefit scoring model.
[0012] According to the economic benefit score, low-carbon benefit score, social benefit score and comprehensive benefit score, the economic benefit, low-carbon benefit, social benefit and comprehensive benefit of the distribution network can be evaluated and analyzed.
[0013] Preferably, the distribution network carbon emission reduction model includes a carbon emission reduction model considering demand response users and energy storage power stations, a carbon emission reduction model for photovoltaic power stations considering tiered carbon trading and green certificate mechanisms, and a carbon emission reduction model for wind power generation.
[0014] Preferably, the first-level indicators for carbon reduction decision-making include improving energy utilization efficiency, developing clean energy, implementing tiered carbon trading, implementing a green certificate market mechanism, demand-side management, optimizing grid structure and operation mode, and expanding distribution network investment.
[0015] Preferably, the secondary indicators for carbon reduction decision-making are specifically:
[0016] The secondary indicators of carbon reduction decision-making corresponding to improving energy efficiency include optimizing transmission lines, reducing transmission distance and loss;
[0017] The secondary indicators for carbon reduction decisions corresponding to the development of clean energy include promoting photovoltaic and wind power, and balancing the grid load with energy storage systems;
[0018] The secondary indicators of carbon reduction decision-making corresponding to the implementation of the carbon emission trading system include establishing a carbon emission rights trading market and incentivizing enterprises to reduce carbon emissions;
[0019] The secondary indicators of carbon reduction decision-making corresponding to the implementation of the green certificate market mechanism include investment in the construction of photovoltaic power stations and the purchase of green certificates;
[0020] The secondary indicators of carbon reduction decision-making corresponding to the demand-side management include setting peak and valley electricity prices;
[0021] The secondary indicators of carbon reduction decision-making corresponding to the optimization of the grid structure and operation mode include reducing the energy loss of the grid and improving the ability to accept renewable energy.
[0022] Preferably, the secondary indicators include: the net present value and internal rate of return corresponding to economic benefits; the proportion of distributed photovoltaic power generation, distributed photovoltaic rated output duration, photovoltaic storage configuration ratio, energy storage power station participation rate, charging load proportion, charging efficiency and photovoltaic storage and charging integration rate corresponding to low-carbon benefits; environmental benefits, reliability benefits, customer service benefits, development promotion benefits and social welfare benefits corresponding to social benefits.
[0023] Preferably, the improved AHP-CRITIC combined weighting method is used to evaluate the indicators as follows:
[0024] First, the hierarchical analysis method is used to compare the indicators of each layer, construct the indicator judgment matrix D, perform transformation processing, and calculate the subjective weight of the evaluation indicator; among them, d ij Indicator d i Relative to the index d j Importance:
[0025]
[0026] The consistency test of CR size judgment matrix is adopted; the maximum eigenvalue λ is directly calculated using Matlab program max ; The critical value of the maximum eigenvalue λ' is derived from the critical value of CR max , the consistency is judged by comparing the maximum eigenvalue and the critical value:
[0027] λ' max =CR×RI×(n-1)+n;
[0028] If λ max Less than λ' max , indicating that each indicator in the judgment matrix has passed the consistency test;
[0029] Second, use the CRITIC method to determine the objective weights, specifically:
[0030] (1) Dimensionless processing of raw data;
[0031] (2) Calculation of volatility and conflict, specifically:
[0032]
[0033] in, is the average data of the jth indicator, S j is the variability of the jth indicator, R j is the conflict of the jth indicator, r ij is the correlation coefficient between indicator i and indicator j;
[0034] (3) Calculate the amount of information C contained in index j j :
[0035] C j =S j ×R j ;
[0036] (4) When evaluating the degree of correlation between indicators, use (1-|r ij |) instead of (1-r ij );Measure the discrete degree of indicator data and use the indicator weight formula to obtain the objective weight W j as follows:
[0037]
[0038] Among them, ew j is the entropy value obtained by entropy weight method;
[0039] The third aspect is to select the subjective and objective combined weighting method to obtain the comprehensive weight, specifically:
[0040]
[0041] Among them, w i is the subjective weight, w h is the objective weight, w ij is the comprehensive weight.
[0042] Preferably, the economic benefit scoring model is:
[0043] M eb,t =ω npv M npv,t +ω irr M irr,t ;
[0044] Where: npv and M npv,t are the net present value indicator weight and score respectively; ω irr and M irr,tThey are the internal rate of return indicator weight and score respectively;
[0045] The low-carbon benefit scoring model is:
[0046] M cb,t =ω PVg M PVg,t +ω PVo M PVo,t +ω LSa M LSa,t
[0047] +ω ES M ES,t +ω CL M CL,t +ω CE M CE,t +ω LSC M LSC,t ;
[0048] Where: PVg ,M PVg,t are the weight and score of the distributed photovoltaic power generation ratio indicator; ω PVo ,M PVo,t are the weight and score of the rated output duration of distributed photovoltaics respectively; ω LSa ,M LSa,t are the weight and score of the PV-storage configuration ratio indicator respectively; ω ES ,M ES,t are the weight and score of the energy storage power station participation rate indicator; ω CL ,M CL,t are the weight and score of charging load proportion indicator respectively; ω CE ,M CE,t are the charging efficiency index weight and score respectively; ω LSC ,M LSC,t They are the indicator weight and score of the photovoltaic storage and charging integration rate indicator;
[0049] The social benefit scoring model is:
[0050] M se,t =ω E M E,t +ω R M R,t +ω CS M CS,t +ω BE M BE,t +ω SW M SW,t ;
[0051] Where: E ,M E,t are the weight and score of environmental benefit indicators respectively; ω R ,MR,t are the reliability benefit index weight and score respectively; ω CS ,M CS,t are the weight and score of customer service benefit index respectively; BE ,M BE,t are the weights and scores of indicators for promoting development benefits; SW ,M SW,t They are the weight and score of social welfare benefit indicators;
[0052] Fourthly, the comprehensive benefit scoring model is:
[0053] Comprehensive benefit evaluation of distribution network projects ob,t It consists of economic benefit score, low-carbon benefit score and social benefit score:
[0054] M ob,t =ω eb M eb,t +ω cb M cb,t +ω se M se,t ;
[0055] Where: eb ,ω cb ,ω se are the weights of economic benefit, low-carbon benefit and social benefit scores respectively.
[0056] Beneficial effects of the present invention:
[0057] (1) Based on the decision-making of carbon reduction measures of the distribution network, the present invention selects indicators of the comprehensive benefits of the distribution network and constructs a more comprehensive evaluation index system for the comprehensive benefits of the distribution network, which is of great significance to the evaluation of the comprehensive benefits of the distribution network.
[0058] (2) The present invention proposes an optimized AHP-CRITIC combined weighting method, which integrates the essence of subjective weighting method and objective weighting method, effectively reducing the subjective bias and weight discrepancy caused by the traditional single weighting method, thereby improving the accuracy and reliability of the evaluation.
[0059] (3) The present invention takes into account the impact of user participation in demand response and energy storage power stations, wind power generation and photovoltaic power generation on carbon emission reduction in the distribution network. At the same time, it designs distribution network enterprises to participate in the carbon market and the green certificate market, thereby reducing carbon emissions in the distribution network, improving economic and social benefits, and providing a scientific basis for the optimization of the distribution network. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0060] Figure 1 A flow chart schematically shows a method for evaluating the comprehensive benefits of a distribution network;
[0061] Figure 2 A topological diagram of a distribution network is schematically shown;
[0062] Figure 3 Schematically showing a net present value diagram obtained according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0063] Figure 4 Schematically showing an internal benefit graph obtained according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0064] Figure 5 An economic benefit scoring diagram obtained according to an embodiment of the present invention is schematically shown;
[0065] Figure 6 A carbon net ratio diagram obtained according to an embodiment of the present invention is schematically shown;
[0066] Figure 7 A low-carbon benefit scoring diagram obtained according to an embodiment of the present invention is schematically shown;
[0067] Figure 8 A social benefit scoring diagram obtained according to an embodiment of the present invention is schematically shown. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0068] The above contents and other objects, features and advantages of the present invention will become more apparent from the description of the embodiments of the present invention with reference to the accompanying drawings.
[0069] Example 1
[0070] The embodiment of the present invention provides a method for evaluating the comprehensive benefits of a distribution network. Figure 1 shown.
[0071] 101: Establish a carbon emission reduction model for distribution networks;
[0072] 102: Based on the carbon emission reduction model of the distribution network, a decision-making system for carbon reduction measures in the distribution network is established;
[0073] 103: Select distribution network project evaluation indicators and build a comprehensive benefit evaluation indicator system for distribution network;
[0074] 104: Use the improved AHP-CRITIC method to determine the comprehensive weights of each indicator in the distribution network carbon reduction measures decision-making system and the distribution network comprehensive benefit evaluation index system;
[0075] 105: Score each indicator; obtain the economic benefit score, low-carbon benefit score, social benefit score and comprehensive benefit score based on the comprehensive weight and score of each indicator and using the comprehensive benefit scoring model; evaluate and analyze the economic benefit, low-carbon benefit, social benefit and comprehensive benefit of the distribution network based on the economic benefit score, low-carbon benefit score, social benefit score and comprehensive benefit score.
[0076] Based on the decision-making of carbon reduction measures of the distribution network, the present invention determines the evaluation index of the comprehensive benefit of the distribution network, optimizes the index weight, and improves the comprehensive benefit evaluation level of the distribution network project. At the same time, it reduces the carbon emissions of the distribution network, improves the economic and social benefits, and can provide a scientific basis for the optimization of the distribution network.
[0077] Example 2
[0078] 201: Parameter settings:
[0079] Taking a regional distribution network project in a province as an example, its network topology is as follows: Figure 2 The relevant parameter settings are shown in Table 1.
[0080] Table 1 Parameter setting table:
[0081] parameter Numeric Carbon emission factor 0.56kg / kWh Fuel carbon emission coefficient 0.60kg / L Carbon quota per unit of electricity 0.58kg / kWh Carbon emission interval division length 3000t Green Certificate Interval Division Length 2000 copies
[0082] 202: Scenario setting:
[0083] Taking 2026 as the base year, a five-year simulation cycle is set, and the distribution network benefit evaluation is analyzed based on the following three specific scenarios:
[0084] Scenario 1: Traditional distribution network system, which does not consider the impact of users and energy storage power stations participating in demand response on the distribution network’s carbon emissions;
[0085] Scenario 2: Considering the impact of users participating in demand response and energy storage power stations on the carbon emissions of the distribution network, but not considering the participation of distribution network companies in the carbon market and green certificate market;
[0086] Scenario 3: Consider the impact of users participating in demand response and energy storage power stations on carbon emissions in the distribution network, and consider the participation of distribution network companies in the carbon market and green certificate market based on a tiered trading mechanism.
[0087] 203: Construction of distribution network carbon emission reduction model: 2031: Consider the user and energy storage power station model participating in demand response;
[0088] Carbon reduction model for industrial and commercial users participating in demand response:
[0089]
[0090] Where: P gg,t , P gf,t , P DRg,t A is the peak-valley shifting amount and demand response amount of industrial and commercial users respectively; DRg,t Carbon emission reductions brought about by industrial and commercial users participating in demand response.
[0091] Carbon reduction model for EV users participating in demand response:
[0092]
[0093] Where: P EVc,t , P EVf,t , P EVy,t are the average annual charging, discharging and power consumption of EV users; ΔP EV,t is the charging increment; P EV,t0 is the initial value of EV battery capacity; P EVd,t , P EVN,t S are the minimum battery capacity of EV to accept dispatch and the rated capacity of EV battery; oc,t is the real-time charge state of EV; ξ is the EV user response enthusiasm; A DREV,t Carbon emissions reductions brought about by EV users participating in demand response.
[0094] The carbon emission reduction model for distribution network projects investing in energy storage power stations is as follows:
[0095]
[0096] Where: β1, β2, β3 are charge and discharge depth, efficiency and annual charge and discharge times respectively; R ES,t is the income of energy storage power station; C ES,t is the cost of energy storage power station; I ES,t Additional investment for energy storage power station, C ESy,t Operation and maintenance cost; ES,t A is the energy storage capacity; ES,t The carbon emission reduction brought about by energy storage participating in demand response.
[0097] 2032: Model for distribution network enterprises to participate in the carbon market and green certificate market
[0098] First, the specific model of distribution network enterprises participating in the carbon market is as follows:
[0099] A quo,t =α2P CT,t
[0100] A PV,t =α1P PV,t
[0101] A' real,t =A real,t -A PV,t
[0102] A pgc,t =A' real,t -A quo,t
[0103] Where: α2 is the carbon quota per unit of electricity; A PV,t , P PV,tare the carbon emission reduction and power generation of photovoltaic power stations respectively; A' real,t is the actual carbon emissions under the multi-market; A pgc,t The carbon emission rights trading volume of distribution network enterprises. When the actual carbon emissions of distribution network enterprises exceed their carbon quotas, they need to purchase additional carbon emission rights in the carbon market to meet the demand beyond the free quota; conversely, if the enterprises have surplus carbon emission rights, they can choose to sell them in the carbon market to achieve profits. Such a mechanism is designed to ensure that enterprises make reasonable resource allocation according to their own carbon emissions and promote the balance and efficient operation of the carbon market.
[0104] In order to promote the enthusiasm of distribution network enterprises for low-carbon emission reduction, a ladder-type carbon trading mechanism was introduced:
[0105]
[0106] In the formula: λ1 is the basic carbon price; l is the length of the carbon emission rights interval; σ1 and σ2 are the reward coefficient and penalty coefficient respectively; C CET,t >0 indicates carbon emission cost, C CET,t <0 indicates carbon emission benefits.
[0107] Second, the model for distribution network enterprises to participate in the green certificate market is as follows:
[0108] N real,t =μ1P PV,t
[0109] N quo,t =μ2P y,t
[0110] N pgc,t =N real,t -N quo,t
[0111] Where: N pgc,t is the number of green certificates traded by distribution network enterprises; μ1 and μ2 are the quantitative coefficient and green certificate quota coefficient of photovoltaic power generation converted into green certificates. real,t Exceeding the specified quota requirement N quo,t When the demand is insufficient, the remaining green certificates can be sold for profit; otherwise, the missing green certificates need to be purchased.
[0112] In order to control carbon emissions and promote the consumption of renewable energy, a tiered green certificate trading mechanism has been introduced. It is similar to the tiered carbon trading mechanism and will not be elaborated here.
[0113] 2033: Carbon emission reduction model for photovoltaic power station investment in distribution network projects
[0114] Photovoltaic power stations are closely linked to the carbon market and the green certificate market. The electricity they generate can not only be converted into green certificates, but also, when photovoltaic power generation is connected to the power grid, it effectively increases the proportion of clean energy in the distribution network and the ability to absorb renewable energy, thereby playing a positive role in reducing the overall carbon emission level.
[0115] I PV,t =k PV γ CET γ TGC γ ES I t
[0116] C PV,t =I PV,t +C PVy,t +C PVq,t
[0117]
[0118] P' PV,t =θP PV,t
[0119] R PV,t =S PV P' PV,t
[0120] A PV,t =α l P' PV,t
[0121] Where: γ CET , γ TGC , γ ES They are carbon emission impact factor, green certificate impact factor and energy storage flexibility impact factor; I PV,t , k PV are the additional investment of distribution network enterprises in photovoltaic power stations and the investment proportion of photovoltaic power stations; C PVy,t , C PVq,t , C PV,t are the operation and maintenance cost, abandoned light cost and total cost of photovoltaic power station respectively; C PV is the unit power generation cost of the photovoltaic power station; ΔP PV,t , P PV,t0 are the newly added photovoltaic power generation and the initial value of photovoltaic power station power generation; θ is the abandoned light rate; P' PV,t and S PV are photovoltaic grid-connected electricity and grid-connected electricity price respectively; R PV,t is the total income of the photovoltaic power station; A PV,t Carbon emission reduction brought by photovoltaic power stations.
[0122] 2034: Wind power carbon reduction model
[0123] AW,t =P W,t × Ι E
[0124] A W,t Carbon emissions reduction brought by wind power generation, P W,t is the grid-connected electricity generated by wind power, I E is the emission intensity of coal-fired power pollutants (or greenhouse gases). The model of wind power participating in the carbon green market is similar to that of photovoltaic power stations, which will not be elaborated here.
[0125] 204: Decision-making system for carbon reduction measures in distribution networks
[0126] Based on the carbon emission reduction model of the distribution network, a decision-making system for carbon reduction measures in the distribution network is constructed.
[0127] The first-level indicators take into account the low-carbon economy of the distribution network, and explain its performance in terms of improving energy utilization efficiency, developing clean energy, implementing a tiered carbon trading and green certificate market mechanism, demand-side management, optimizing the grid structure and operation mode, and expanding distribution network investment. This is used as the basis for the comprehensive benefit evaluation index system of the distribution network.
[0128] The secondary indicators start with the attributes corresponding to the primary indicators and explain the specific methods of carbon reduction measures, including:
[0129] The improvement of energy efficiency includes optimizing transmission lines and reducing transmission distance and loss.
[0130] The development of clean energy includes the promotion of photovoltaic and wind power, and the use of energy storage systems to balance the load on the power grid.
[0131] The implementation of the carbon emission trading system includes establishing a carbon emission rights trading market to encourage enterprises to reduce carbon emissions. In the green certificate market, in order to meet the green certificate quota requirements, distribution network enterprises can adopt methods such as investing in power stations and purchasing green certificates, among which the electricity generated by photovoltaic power stations can be applied for redemption of green certificates.
[0132] The demand side management includes guiding users to use electricity rationally through peak and valley electricity prices.
[0133] The optimization of the grid structure and operation mode includes reducing the energy loss of the grid and improving the ability to accept renewable energy.
[0134]
[0135] Where P loss is the distribution network loss including distributed photovoltaic, energy storage power station and electric vehicle load, P i,loss is the line loss of the i-th section, P j is the active power of the load at node j, P PV is the power of distributed photovoltaic power source, P EScCharging power for energy storage station, P ESd is the discharge power of the energy storage station, Q j is the reactive power of the load at node j, U i is the voltage at node i, r is the resistance per unit length of the line, n i is the number of nodes.
[0136] 205: Comprehensive benefit evaluation index system for distribution network
[0137] 2051: Building a comprehensive evaluation system
[0138] The first-level indicators include: economic benefits, low-carbon benefits and social benefits.
[0139] Secondary indicators include: economic benefits include net present value and internal rate of return. Low-carbon benefits include the proportion of distributed photovoltaic power generation, rated output duration of distributed photovoltaic, photovoltaic storage configuration ratio, participation rate of energy storage power stations, proportion of charging load, charging efficiency and photovoltaic storage and charging integration rate; social benefits include environmental benefits, reliability benefits, customer service benefits, development promotion benefits and social welfare benefits.
[0140] 2052: Calculate indicator value
[0141] Based on the constructed evaluation system, specific numerical calculations are performed for each evaluation indicator.
[0142] 2053: Setting indicator weights
[0143] After completing the construction of the evaluation system and the calculation of indicator values, the improved AHP-CRITIC combined weighting method is used to assign weights to each indicator.
[0144] 2054: Indicator Rating
[0145] Based on the calculated indicator values, score each level and indicator in the evaluation system.
[0146] 2055: Summary score
[0147] Combined with the determined indicator weights and scoring values, the evaluation object is scored as a whole to obtain a comprehensive evaluation result.
[0148] 206: Comprehensive Benefit Evaluation and Analysis
[0149] 2061: Economic Benefit Assessment
[0150] The changing trends and scores of economic benefit indicators under different scenarios are as follows: Figure 3 , Figure 4 , Figure 5As shown in the figure, scenario 3 performs best in terms of net present value and internal rate of return, followed by scenario 2, while scenario 1 is relatively low. This is mainly attributed to the significant economic benefits brought by energy storage power stations, EV charging stations, photovoltaic power generation and wind power generation, although demand response is accompanied by certain dispatching costs while increasing electricity consumption and electricity sales revenue. In addition, the carbon emission reduction effect of photovoltaic power stations and wind power generation enables distribution network companies to enhance their own economic benefits by participating in the carbon market and green certificate market.
[0151] From the perspective of economic benefit scores, the scores under the three scenarios have shown an upward trend year by year. After expert evaluation, the weights of net present value and internal rate of return were set to 0.5 respectively, and the economic benefit scores were calculated accordingly. Overall, the scores increased rapidly and steadily, and the scores in the later period were particularly outstanding. In the long run, the economic benefits under scenario 3 are the most considerable and are expected to reach the highest score.
[0152] In summary, EV charging stations, energy storage power stations, photovoltaic power generation and wind power generation have a positive role in promoting the economic benefits of distribution network companies. Although the introduction of demand response has brought certain costs, it still helps to improve economic benefits overall. In addition, by implementing a reward-penalty ladder-type carbon trading and green certificate trading mechanism, the economic benefits and scores of distribution network projects can be further significantly improved.
[0153] 2062: Low Carbon Benefit Assessment
[0154] The carbon net ratio indicates the carbon emissions corresponding to the unit load energy consumption, which can offset the impact of the distribution network's own load scale. The carbon net ratio and low-carbon benefit index scores in different scenarios are as follows: Figure 6 and Figure 7 shown.
[0155] Compared with scenario 1, scenarios 2 and 3 have significantly lower net carbon ratios, with scenario 3 having the lowest net carbon ratio. This result shows that the introduction of energy storage power stations, EV charging stations, photovoltaic power generation, and wind power generation has significantly promoted low-carbon benefits, due to the reduced dependence on fossil energy, which reduces carbon emissions. The optimization and adjustment of the photovoltaic storage configuration ratio, charging load ratio, charging efficiency, and photovoltaic storage and charging integration rate improves energy utilization efficiency and also brings carbon emission reduction benefits. Driven by the ladder-type trading mechanism, distribution network companies actively participate in the carbon market and the green certificate market, further improving the carbon emission reduction benefits. The carbon market constrains the purchase of electricity from traditional energy through carbon emission costs, while the green certificate market encourages power stations to increase power generation through green certificate revenue. The two work together to reduce carbon emissions.
[0156] In terms of low-carbon benefit scores, the three scenarios show a trend. This score reflects the significant impact of user participation in demand response and energy storage power stations, wind power generation, and photovoltaic power generation on carbon emissions in the distribution network, and also illustrates the positive impact of the carbon market and green certificate market of the ladder-type trading mechanism on low-carbon benefits.
[0157] In summary, users participating in demand response and energy storage power stations, photovoltaic and wind power generation have a positive impact on carbon emission reduction in the distribution network. The carbon market and green certificate market based on the ladder trading mechanism have shown significant results in promoting low-carbon benefits, and the low-carbon benefits are more obvious.
[0158] 2063: Social Benefit Assessment
[0159] The scores of social benefit indicators in different scenarios are as follows: Figure 8 . In terms of social benefits, all three scenarios have high benefit levels, and the social benefit scores are on an upward trend. This is because users participating in demand response, EV charging stations and energy storage power stations, wind power generation and photovoltaic power generation have a positive driving effect on the social benefits of distribution network companies. In addition, through the implementation of the ladder-type carbon trading and green certificate trading market mechanism, the driving effect is more obvious. Therefore, the environmental benefits, reliability benefits, customer service benefits, development promotion benefits, and social welfare benefits are at a high level, and the social benefit level obtained from the above is also high.
[0160] 2064: Comprehensive Benefit Evaluation
[0161] The comprehensive benefit scores under different scenarios are shown in Table 2. As can be seen from the figure, scenario 3 has the highest comprehensive benefit score, followed by scenario 2, and scenario 1 is relatively low. This difference is mainly due to the consideration of user participation in demand response and the impact of energy storage power stations, photovoltaic power generation and wind power generation on carbon emissions of distribution networks. When these factors are taken into account, the score is significantly improved.
[0162] Further analysis shows that the carbon market and green certificate market with a ladder-type trading mechanism have shown significant advantages in economic benefits, low-carbon benefits and social benefits, surpassing the performance of a single electricity market. This shows the positive role of a diversified market mechanism in improving comprehensive benefits.
[0163] Table 2 Comprehensive benefit rating table:
[0164] Scenario 1 2 3 2026 73.0 77.6 81.3 2027 73.5 78.3 82.6 2028 77.0 82.6 83.2 2029 80.1 82.8 83.6 2030 81.5 83.2 83.8
[0165] The present invention is based on the decision-making of carbon reduction measures in the distribution network, selects indicators of the comprehensive benefits of the distribution network, and constructs a more comprehensive distribution network comprehensive benefit evaluation index system, which is of great significance to the comprehensive benefit evaluation of the distribution network. The optimized AHP-CRITIC combined weighting method integrates the essence of the subjective weighting method and the objective weighting method, effectively reducing the subjective bias and weight discrepancy caused by the traditional single weighting method, thereby improving the accuracy and reliability of the evaluation. At the same time, considering the impact of user participation in demand response and energy storage power stations, wind power generation and photovoltaic power generation on carbon emission reduction in the distribution network, the distribution network enterprises are designed to participate in the carbon market and the green certificate market, which achieves the reduction of carbon emissions in the distribution network, improves economic and social benefits, and can provide a scientific basis for the optimization of the distribution network.
[0166] It will be appreciated by those skilled in the art that the features described in the various embodiments and / or claims of the present invention may be combined and / or combined in various ways, even if such combinations and / or combinations are not explicitly described in the present invention. In particular, the features described in the various embodiments and / or claims of the present invention may be combined and / or combined in various ways without departing from the spirit and teachings of the present invention. All of these combinations and / or combinations fall within the scope of the present invention.
[0167] The embodiments of the present invention are described above. However, these embodiments are only for the purpose of illustration, and are not intended to limit the scope of the present invention. Although each embodiment is described above, it does not mean that the measures in each embodiment cannot be used in combination. The scope of the present invention is defined by the attached claims and their equivalents. Without departing from the scope of the present invention, those skilled in the art may make various substitutions and modifications, which should all fall within the scope of the present invention.
Claims
1. A method for decision-making and comprehensive benefit evaluation of carbon reduction measures in distribution networks, characterized in that: The following steps are involved: Establish a carbon emission reduction model for distribution networks; Based on the carbon emission reduction model of the distribution network, a distribution network carbon reduction measures decision system is constructed; the distribution network carbon reduction measures decision system includes a first-level carbon reduction decision indicator and a second-level carbon reduction decision indicator; the first-level carbon reduction decision indicator is a distribution network carbon reduction measures decision item that considers the low-carbon economy of the distribution network; the second-level carbon reduction decision indicator is a specific method for corresponding carbon reduction measures from the first-level carbon reduction decision indicator; Select distribution network project evaluation indicators and build a comprehensive benefit evaluation indicator system for distribution networks; The comprehensive benefit evaluation index system of distribution network includes primary index and secondary index; The secondary indicators are specific indicators extended from the primary indicators; the primary indicators include: economic benefits, low-carbon benefits and social benefits; The improved AHP-CRITIC method is used to determine the comprehensive weights of each indicator in the distribution network carbon reduction measures decision-making system and the distribution network comprehensive benefit evaluation index system; Score each indicator; obtain the economic benefit score, low-carbon benefit score, social benefit score and comprehensive benefit score based on the comprehensive weight and score of each indicator and using a comprehensive benefit scoring model; the comprehensive benefit scoring model includes an economic benefit scoring model, a low-carbon benefit scoring model, a social benefit scoring model and a comprehensive benefit scoring model.
2. A method for decision-making and comprehensive benefit evaluation of carbon reduction measures in distribution networks, characterized in that: The distribution network carbon emission reduction model includes a carbon emission reduction model for users and energy storage power stations considering demand response, a carbon emission reduction model for photovoltaic power stations considering a tiered carbon trading and green certificate mechanism, and a carbon emission reduction model for wind power generation.
3. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that The first-level indicators for carbon reduction decisions include improving energy utilization efficiency, developing clean energy, implementing tiered carbon trading, implementing a green certificate market mechanism, demand-side management, optimizing grid structure and operation methods, and expanding distribution network investment.
4. The method according to claim 3, characterized in that The specific secondary indicators for carbon reduction decision-making are: The secondary indicators of carbon reduction decision-making corresponding to improving energy efficiency include optimizing transmission lines and reducing transmission distance and loss; The secondary indicators for carbon reduction decisions corresponding to the development of clean energy include promoting photovoltaic and wind power, and balancing the grid load with energy storage systems; The secondary indicators of carbon reduction decision-making corresponding to the implementation of the carbon emission trading system include establishing a carbon emission rights trading market and incentivizing enterprises to reduce carbon emissions; The secondary indicators of carbon reduction decision-making corresponding to the implementation of the green certificate market mechanism include investment in the construction of photovoltaic power stations and the purchase of green certificates; The secondary indicators of carbon reduction decision-making corresponding to the demand-side management include setting peak and valley electricity prices; The secondary indicators of carbon reduction decision-making corresponding to the optimization of the grid structure and operation mode include reducing the energy loss of the grid and improving the ability to accept renewable energy.
5. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that The secondary indicators include: the net present value and internal rate of return corresponding to economic benefits; the proportion of distributed photovoltaic power generation, distributed photovoltaic rated output duration, photovoltaic storage configuration ratio, energy storage power station participation rate, charging load proportion, charging efficiency and photovoltaic storage and charging integration rate corresponding to low-carbon benefits; environmental benefits, reliability benefits, customer service benefits, development promotion benefits and social welfare benefits corresponding to social benefits.
6. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that The improved AHP-CRITIC combined weighting method is used to evaluate the indicators as follows: First, the hierarchical analysis method is used to compare the indicators of each layer, construct the indicator judgment matrix D, perform transformation processing, and calculate the subjective weight of the evaluation indicator; among them, d ij Indicator d i Relative to the index d j Importance: The consistency test of CR size judgment matrix is adopted; the maximum eigenvalue λ is directly calculated using Matlab program max ; The critical value of the maximum eigenvalue λ' is derived from the critical value of CR max , the consistency is judged by comparing the maximum eigenvalue and the critical value: l' max =CR×RI×(n-1)+n; If max Less than λ' max , indicating that each indicator in the judgment matrix has passed the consistency test; Second, use the CRITIC method to determine the objective weights, specifically: (1) Dimensionless processing of raw data; (2) Calculation of volatility and conflict, specifically: in, is the average data of the jth indicator, S j is the variability of the jth indicator, R j is the conflict of the jth indicator, r ij is the correlation coefficient between indicator i and indicator j; (3) Calculate the amount of information C contained in index j j : C j =S j ×R j ; (4) When evaluating the degree of correlation between indicators, use (1-|r ij |) instead of (1-r ij );Measure the discrete degree of indicator data and use the indicator weight formula to obtain the objective weight W j as follows: Among them, ew j is the entropy value obtained by entropy weight method; The third aspect is to select the subjective and objective combined weighting method to obtain the comprehensive weight, specifically: Among them, w i is the subjective weight, w j is the objective weight, w ij is the comprehensive weight.
7. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that The economic benefit scoring model is: M eb,t =ω npv M npv,t +oh irr M irr,t ; Where: npv and M npv,t are the net present value indicator weight and score respectively; ω irr and M irr,t are the internal rate of return indicator weight and score respectively.
8. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that The low-carbon benefit scoring model is: M cb,t =ω PVg M PVg,t +oh PVo M PVo,t +oh LSa M LSa,t +oh ES M ES,t +oh CL M CL,t +oh CE M CE,t +oh LSC M LSC,t ; Where: PVg ,M PVg,t are the weight and score of the distributed photovoltaic power generation ratio indicator; ω PVo ,M PVo,t are the weight and score of the rated output duration of distributed photovoltaics respectively; ω LSa ,M LSa,t are the weight and score of the PV-storage configuration ratio indicator respectively; ω ES ,M ES,t are the weight and score of the energy storage power station participation rate indicator; ω CL ,M CL,t are the weight and score of charging load proportion indicator respectively; ω CE ,M CE,t are the charging efficiency index weight and score respectively; ω LSC ,M LSC,t They are the indicator weight and score of the photovoltaic storage and charging integration rate indicator respectively.
9. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The social benefit scoring model is: M se,t =ω E M E,t +oh R M R,t +oh CS M CS,t +oh BE M BE,t +oh SW M SW,t ; Where: E ,M E,t are the weight and score of environmental benefit indicators respectively; ω R ,M R,t are the reliability benefit index weight and score respectively; ω CS ,M CS,t are the weight and score of customer service benefit index respectively; BE ,M BE,t are the weights and scores of indicators for promoting development benefits; SW ,M SW,t are the weight and score of social welfare benefit indicators respectively.
10. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that The comprehensive benefit scoring model is: Comprehensive benefit evaluation of distribution network projects ob,t It consists of economic benefit score, low-carbon benefit score and social benefit score: M ob,t =ω eb M eb,t +oh cb M cb,t +oh se M se,t ; Where: eb ,ω cb ,ω se are the weights of economic benefit, low-carbon benefit and social benefit scores respectively.
Citation Information
Cited By
Shared energy storage power station scheduling method based on benefit evaluation
CN120106521A
Energy storage comprehensive benefit evaluation method and system
CN120875659A
