Substation network security monitoring capability evaluation method and system
The method and system address the lack of comprehensive evaluation in substation network security by using DEMATEL, anti-entropy weight analysis, and VIKOR algorithms to assess monitoring capabilities, enhancing threat detection and response for power grid stability.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202411078250.7
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-08-07
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-06
AI Technical Summary
Current methods lack indicators and comprehensive evaluation algorithms for assessing substation network security monitoring capabilities, which are crucial for ensuring the safe and stable operation of power grids.
A method and system using DEMATEL and anti-entropy weight analysis to determine subjective and objective weights, combined with game theory, and VIKOR decision algorithms for evaluating substation network security monitoring capabilities, incorporating performance metrics like monitoring device reliability and alarm triggering capabilities.
Enhances the evaluation of substation network security, improving threat detection and response, ensuring the safe and stable operation of power systems by providing a scientific framework for monitoring capability assessment.
Smart Images

Figure CN119094168A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention belongs to the field of substation security, and in particular relates to a substation network security monitoring capability evaluation method and system. Background Art
[0002] Substations are the core components of the power grid. Avoiding network security incidents in substations is the basis for ensuring the safe and stable operation of the power grid. Therefore, substations have put forward higher and higher requirements for network security monitoring capabilities. Strengthening network security monitoring capabilities can timely detect network security threats and risks and ensure the safe and stable operation of the power system. A reasonable evaluation of the network security monitoring capabilities of substations can help timely discover system weaknesses and loopholes, strengthen the system's security protection capabilities, and ensure the safety and reliability of the power system.
[0003] However, network security monitoring capabilities involve many factors. Currently, there are no indicators for calculation and analysis, nor is there a reasonable comprehensive evaluation algorithm for comprehensive evaluation of substation network security monitoring capabilities. Summary of the invention
[0004] In order to solve the deficiencies in the prior art, the present invention provides a method and system for evaluating the network security monitoring capability of a substation, so as to solve the technical problem of evaluating the network security monitoring capability of a substation.
[0005] In order to solve the above technical problems, the present invention adopts the following technical solutions.
[0006] The present invention first discloses a method for evaluating the network security monitoring capability of a substation, the method comprising the following steps:
[0007] Step 1: Obtain the performance information of the substation monitoring device, the host equipment configuration information and the substation alarm sending capability information to construct a substation safety monitoring indicator set;
[0008] Step 2: Determine the subjective impact weight of each indicator in the substation safety monitoring indicator set using the DEMATEL analysis method;
[0009] Step 3: Determine the objective impact weight of each indicator in the substation safety monitoring indicator set by using the anti-entropy weight analysis method;
[0010] Step 4: Combining the subjective influence weight and the objective influence weight according to game theory to obtain a combined weight of each indicator;
[0011] Step 5: Comprehensively evaluate the safety monitoring indicators of multiple substations based on the VIKOR decision algorithm, obtain the safety monitoring capability evaluation results, and rank the evaluation results;
[0012] Step 6: Analyze and adjust the substation according to the safety monitoring capability evaluation results.
[0013] The present invention further includes the following preferred embodiments:
[0014] The performance information of the substation monitoring device includes the monitoring device operation life index, the monitoring device historical failure rate, the monitoring device time accuracy, the monitoring device connection status score, the monitoring device asset access rate and the monitoring device data retrieval capability score; the host device configuration information includes the host Agent version inspection rate, the host whitelist configuration accuracy rate and the host key directory configuration accuracy rate; the substation alarm sending capability information includes the user login alarm triggering capability, the peripheral access alarm triggering capability, the network access alarm triggering capability, the suspicious operation alarm triggering capability, the intelligent alarm triggering capability, the alarm time scale accuracy and the useless alarm clearing capability.
[0015] The obtaining of performance information of the substation monitoring device further includes:
[0016] The operating life index of the monitoring device is determined according to the ratio of the expected life of the monitoring device and the number of years in operation. The historical failure rate of the monitoring device is determined according to the product of the total operating time of the monitoring device and the total number of failures. The timing accuracy of the monitoring device is determined according to the system time deviation of the monitoring device. The connection status score of the monitoring device is determined according to whether the monitoring device meets the grounding requirements or adopts dual independent power supplies. The asset access rate of the monitoring device is determined according to the ratio of the total number of assets actually connected to the monitoring device to the total number of assets that should be connected. The data retrieval capability score of the monitoring device is determined according to whether the monitoring device correctly imports the certificate issued by the electric power dispatching digital certificate system and performs data retrieval.
[0017] The obtaining of host device configuration information further includes:
[0018] The host Agent version inspection rate is determined based on the ratio of the number of hosts that have passed the inspection to the total number of hosts. The host whitelist configuration accuracy is determined based on the ratio of the number of hosts that meet the minimum whitelist configuration requirements to the total number of hosts. The host key directory configuration accuracy is determined based on the ratio of the number of hosts that have correct key directory configuration to the total number of hosts.
[0019] The step of obtaining the substation alarm sending capability information further includes:
[0020] The user login alarm triggering capability score is determined by checking whether the network security platform correctly records the user login and logout situations and issues an alarm. The peripheral access alarm triggering capability score is determined by checking whether the network security platform correctly records the USB device access or CD loading situations and issues an alarm. The network access alarm triggering capability score is determined by checking whether the network security platform can correctly record the access node, access path and operation instruction information and correctly record the illegal network access situation and issue an alarm. The suspicious operation alarm triggering capability score is determined by checking whether the network security platform can correctly record the corresponding operation situation when changing key directories and files and issue an alarm. The intelligent alarm triggering capability score is determined by checking whether the network security platform can generate IP scans, port scans and password cracking and issue an alarm based on multiple original logs. The alarm time stamp accuracy score is determined by checking whether the alarm information time stamp is consistent with the standard time. The useless alarm clearing capability score is determined by checking whether meaningless or erroneous alarms are sent.
[0021] The method of using the DEMATEL analysis method to determine the subjective impact weight of each indicator in the substation safety monitoring indicator set further includes:
[0022] Step 2.1: Construct the initial direct impact matrix A of the impact degree between each indicator:
[0023]
[0024] Where a ij Representation factor X i X j The degree of influence of ij =0;
[0025] Step 2.2: Normalize the initial direct impact matrix A to obtain the standard impact matrix B:
[0026]
[0027] Step 2.3: Calculate the comprehensive impact matrix T based on the normative impact matrix:
[0028]
[0029] Where I is the unit matrix;
[0030] Calculate the influence, influence, centrality and cause of each indicator; influence D i It refers to the sum of the values of each row in the matrix T, which represents the comprehensive impact of each row indicator on all other indicators:
[0031]
[0032] Influence C iRefers to the sum of the values in each column in the matrix T, indicating the comprehensive impact of each column indicator on all other indicators:
[0033]
[0034] Centrality M i It indicates the position of the indicator in the evaluation system and the size of its role. The centrality of an indicator is the sum of its influence and its influence:
[0035] M i =D i +C i
[0036] Determine the subjective weight w of the i-th indicator using the DEMATEL method i :
[0037] W i =M i / ∑M i .
[0038] The method of using the anti-entropy weight analysis method to determine the objective impact weight of each indicator in the substation safety monitoring indicator set further includes:
[0039] Standardize the indicator matrix data to facilitate comparative analysis of the data and obtain the standardized decision matrix Y = {y ij}m×n:
[0040] The larger the value, the better. The standardized data y ij for:
[0041]
[0042] The smaller the value, the better. The standardized data y ij for:
[0043]
[0044] Calculate the anti-entropy value h j ':
[0045]
[0046] in And assuming that p ij =0, lnp ij =0
[0047] Calculate the objective weight of the jth indicator:
[0048]
[0049] The combining of the subjective influence weight and the objective influence weight according to the game theory to obtain the combined weight of each indicator further includes:
[0050] The initial combined weight is constructed according to the linear combination of the subjective influence weight and the objective influence weight:
[0051]
[0052] Where: w1={w 11 , w 12 , ..., w 1n} and w2={w 21 , w 22 , ..., w 2n} are the subjective influence weight and the objective influence weight respectively, α1 and α2 are the initial combination coefficients of the subjective and objective weights respectively;
[0053] According to the principles of game theory, the Nash equilibrium point is solved, that is, to find a balance between different weights and minimize the deviation between the initial combination weight and the subjective and objective weights. The objective function and constraints are:
[0054]
[0055] Solve the minimum under the equality constraints and construct the Lagrangian function:
[0056]
[0057] Where λ is the penalty factor of the Lagrangian function;
[0058] Solve a system of linear equations:
[0059]
[0060] Get the combination coefficients α1 and α2 and perform normalization:
[0061]
[0062] The final combined weight is
[0063]
[0064] The method of comprehensively evaluating the safety monitoring indicators of multiple substations based on the VIKOR decision algorithm to obtain safety monitoring capability evaluation results and sorting the evaluation results further includes:
[0065] There are m substations Y i , i = 1, 2, ..., m, forming a substation set Y = {Y1, Y2, ..., Y m}, the evaluation index of each substation is G j , j = 1, 2, ..., n, the index set is G = G1, G2, ..., G n , index G j The weights are known, ω=(ω1,ω2,...,ω n ) T is the indicator weight vector:
[0066] Step 5.1: According to the substation set Y = {Y1, Y2, ..., Y m} and the index set G = {G1, G2, ..., G n}, construct the decision matrix F = (f ij ) m×n ;f ij Indicates substation Y i ∈Y in index G j ∈G’s evaluation index value;
[0067] Step 5.2: Using the standard 0-1 transformation, the decision matrix F = (f ij ) m×n After normalization, the normalized decision matrix F′=(f′ ij ) m×n , f′ ij The specific calculation formula is:
[0068]
[0069] Step 5.3: According to the normalized matrix F′=(f′ ij ) m×n , determine the positive ideal solution f + and negative ideal solution f - :
[0070]
[0071] in,
[0072] Step 5.4: Calculate Y of each substation using grey correlation theory i ∈Y group benefit value S i 、Individual regret value R i And the compromise value Q i
[0073]
[0074] Where, ρ∈[0,1];
[0075] w j is the combined weight of each indicator, S + =mini (S i ), S - =max i (S i ), R + =min i (R i ), R - =max i (R i );v is the decision mechanism coefficient, v∈[0,1];when v>0.5, it means that the decision is made according to the decision mechanism of maximum group utility;when v=0.5, it means that the decision is made according to the decision mechanism in which the decision makers reach a consensus through consultation;when v<0.5, it means that the decision is made according to the decision mechanism of minimum individual regret.
[0076] The present invention also discloses a substation network security monitoring capability evaluation system using the above substation network security monitoring capability evaluation method, comprising:
[0077] The safety monitoring indicator building module is used to obtain the performance information of the substation monitoring device, the host equipment configuration information and the substation alarm sending capability information to build a substation safety monitoring indicator set;
[0078] A subjective impact weight determination module, used to determine the subjective impact weight of each indicator in the substation safety monitoring indicator set by using a DEMATEL analysis method;
[0079] An objective impact weight determination module, used to determine the objective impact weight of each indicator in the substation safety monitoring indicator set by using an anti-entropy weight analysis method;
[0080] A combined weight determination module, used to combine the subjective influence weight and the objective influence weight according to game theory to obtain a combined weight of each indicator;
[0081] Safety monitoring comprehensive evaluation module, which is used to comprehensively evaluate the safety monitoring indicators of multiple substations based on the VIKOR decision algorithm, obtain the safety monitoring capability evaluation results, and sort the evaluation results;
[0082] The post-processing module is used to analyze and adjust the substation according to the safety monitoring capability evaluation result.
[0083] Accordingly, the present application also discloses a terminal, including a processor and a storage medium;
[0084] The storage medium is used to store instructions;
[0085] The processor is used to operate according to the instructions to execute the steps of the aforementioned substation network security monitoring capability evaluation method.
[0086] Correspondingly, the present application also discloses a computer-readable storage medium on which a computer program is stored, and when the program is executed by a processor, the steps of the aforementioned substation network security monitoring capability evaluation method are implemented.
[0087] The beneficial effect of the present invention is that, compared with the prior art, the present invention provides a method and system for evaluating the network security monitoring capability of a substation, which can improve the network security monitoring capability of the substation, strengthen the prevention and response to network security threats, and ensure the normal operation and data security of the substation. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0088] Figure 1 It is a schematic diagram of the substation network security monitoring structure in the present invention.
[0089] Figure 2 It is a flow chart of the substation network security monitoring capability evaluation method in the present invention.
[0090] Figure 3 It is a schematic diagram of the substation safety monitoring indicator system in the present invention.
[0091] Figure 4 It is a schematic diagram of the key directory of the substation host in the present invention.
[0092] Figure 5 It is a schematic diagram of the centrality and causality of each indicator in the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0093] In order to make the purpose, technical solution and advantages of the present invention more clear, the technical solution of the present invention will be clearly and completely described below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings in the embodiments of the present invention.
[0094] The embodiments described in this application are only some embodiments of the present invention, not all embodiments. Based on the spirit of the present invention, other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without creative work are all within the protection scope of the present invention.
[0095] In view of the shortcomings of the prior art, the present invention proposes a method and system for evaluating the network security monitoring capability of a substation, which uses a scientific evaluation method to perform network security monitoring on the substation to ensure the safe and stable operation of the power grid.
[0096] The present invention deploys monitoring devices in the real-time control area and the non-real-time control area of the substation respectively. Probes (agents) or SNMP are configured on the network equipment (data network switches, station control layer switches, etc.), host equipment (monitoring hosts, five-defense machines, integrated application servers, fault recorders, data communication gateways, etc.), and security equipment (firewalls, horizontal isolation devices, etc.) within the station to enable the network security monitoring device to monitor the network equipment, host equipment, and security equipment within the substation. The monitoring scope involves all equipment at the station control layer and data network layer of the substation secondary system, and real-time collection of equipment asset access status, equipment whitelist, key directories, alarm information, etc. The network security monitoring device communicates with the dispatching master station platform through the dispatching data network, and synchronously sends the collected equipment asset access status, equipment whitelist, key directories, alarm information, etc. to the master station monitoring platform. The master station monitoring platform can also realize functions such as information retrieval and parameter configuration of the monitoring device. The connection structure is as follows: Figure 1 shown.
[0097] See also Figure 2 As shown, the substation network security monitoring capability evaluation method disclosed in the present invention includes the following steps:
[0098] Step 1: Obtain the performance information of the substation monitoring device, the host equipment configuration information and the substation alarm sending capability information to build a substation safety monitoring indicator set.
[0099] The performance information of the substation monitoring device includes the monitoring device operation life index, the monitoring device historical failure rate, the monitoring device time accuracy, the monitoring device connection status score, the monitoring device asset access rate and the monitoring device data retrieval capability score; the host device configuration information includes the host Agent version inspection rate, the host whitelist configuration accuracy rate and the host key directory configuration accuracy rate; the substation alarm sending capability information includes the user login alarm trigger capability, the peripheral access alarm trigger capability, the network access alarm trigger capability, the suspicious operation alarm trigger capability, the intelligent alarm trigger capability, the alarm time scale accuracy and the useless alarm clearing capability.
[0100] According to the relevant requirements of the State Grid and the actual situation of the substation, the following evaluation indicators are formulated, including monitoring device performance, asset access, host equipment configuration correctness, alarm sending capability, etc., to comprehensively evaluate the substation network security monitoring capabilities. Figure 3 As shown, including:
[0101] 1.1、Monitoring Equipment Operation Age Index (EAI):
[0102] EAI = ∑ (expected life / number of years in operation)
[0103] The number of years in operation is greater than or equal to 1, and those less than one year are recorded as 1. The expected life is the standard operating life of the equipment, provided by the manufacturer or industry standard.
[0104] Larger EAI values indicate newer equipment. Values close to or less than 1 indicate aging equipment that may require closer monitoring, maintenance, or replacement. This metric helps proactively manage maintenance schedules and plan replacements or upgrades.
[0105] 1.2. Historical failure rate (HFR) of monitoring device:
[0106] HFR = 50-(total operating time * total number of failures)
[0107] This indicator measures the number and frequency of failures of the monitoring device during its service life. It reflects the reliability and performance of the device. The total number of failures is the cumulative number of failures that have occurred since the device was installed. The total operating time is the total time the device has been in operation, in years.
[0108] The lower the HFR value, the lower the reliability of the device and the more frequent failures it has. The higher the HFR value, the more reliable the device and the fewer historical failures it has. This indicator is used for maintenance planning, reliability analysis, and decision-making on repair or replacement of devices.
[0109] 1.3. Timing accuracy of monitoring device:
[0110] The monitoring device time synchronization accuracy is used to calculate the monitoring device system time deviation. The monitoring device should be synchronized to ensure that the system time is accurate and consistent. For example, the initial score is 2 points. If there is a system time deviation of more than 3 seconds in any monitoring device, 1 point will be deducted for each case.
[0111] 1.4. Monitoring device connection status score
[0112] This score is used to determine whether the monitoring device meets the grounding requirements or uses dual independent power supplies. The monitoring device should meet the requirements of reliable grounding and dual independent power supplies. For example, if the initial score is 4 points, if there are devices that do not meet the grounding requirements or the device does not use dual independent power supplies, 1 point will be deducted for each case.
[0113] 1.5. Monitoring device asset access rate
[0114] Asset access rate = (total number of actual assets accessed / total number of assets to be accessed) × 100%,
[0115] The asset access rate in the monitoring device should reach 100%, and all access assets should be online. If there are access assets that are not online, they are considered not accessed.
[0116] The monitoring device should be connected to the assets as shown in Table 1:
[0117]
[0118]
[0119] Table 1
[0120] 1.6. Monitoring device data access capability score:
[0121] The data retrieval capability score is used to verify whether the monitoring device has correctly imported the certificate issued by the electric power dispatching digital certificate system and conduct data retrieval. Select the substation to modify the asset information on the main station network security platform side, verify on-site whether the monitoring device is synchronously updated, and check whether the data response time of the substation monitoring device is less than 5 seconds. For example, if there is a device that has not imported the digital certificate, 4 points will be deducted for each case; if there is a certificate that is not issued by the electric power dispatching digital certificate system, 2 points will be deducted for each case; if the substation monitoring device fails to be retrieved or the retrieval information is incomplete, 2 points will be deducted for each case; if the retrieval data is not synchronously updated, 2 points will be deducted; if the retrieval response times out, 2 points will be deducted.
[0122] 1.7. Host Agent version inspection rate:
[0123] Version inspection rate = number of host agents that have passed the inspection of China Electric Power Research Institute / total number of hosts.
[0124] 1.8. Host whitelist configuration accuracy:
[0125] Host whitelist configuration accuracy = number of hosts with accurate whitelist configuration / total number of hosts
[0126] Configure host whitelist rules based on the actual business needs of the host, restrict only trusted programs and processes to run on the host, and send alarms to the monitoring device when malware and unauthorized applications invade and attack the system, effectively improving the host security level. Incomplete whitelist configuration will cause ports and services required for normal work to report false alarms during operation, resulting in a large number of invalid alarms being sent; excessive whitelist configuration will result in risky ports and services not being effectively monitored and controlled.
[0127] Check whether the whitelist rules of the Agent on the host meet the minimum requirements through the substation management function of the network security platform. As an important means of monitoring illegal access behaviors of the host, the whitelist rules need to be specifically configured according to the actual business of the host. The configuration rules are as follows:
[0128] 1.8.1.IP Address Whitelist
[0129] When the host acts as a client, each whitelist should be configured as a fixed protocol, with a fixed destination IP and port. When the host acts as a server, each whitelist should be configured as a fixed protocol, with a source IP of one IP or an IP segment with less than 20 addresses, and a source port of 1024-65535.
[0130] 1.8.2. Service port whitelist
[0131] It is forbidden to enable services not related to the power monitoring system: FTP (21), TELNET (23), SMTP (25), DNS (53), DHCP (67), TFTP (69), POP (109), POP3 (110), RPC (111, 135), NetBIOS (137, 138, 139), SMB (445), Remote Desktop (3389), Mysql (3306), mDNS (5353).
[0132] When checking the host whitelist configuration, for Linx Agent, ssh log in to the test host to view the Agent configuration file cat / usr / share / smp / linx_config, check that the IP address whitelist configuration IP_WHITELIST and the service port whitelist configuration NETPORT_WHITELIST meet the minimization requirements; for Kylin Agent, ssh log in to the terminal and enter the command gd_kylin_Agent_setting_tool to start the Agent configuration interface, and check whether the network connection whitelist and service port whitelist meet the minimization requirements.
[0133] 1.9. Correctness of configuration of key host directories:
[0134] That is, the correctness rate of host key directory configuration = the number of hosts with correct key directory configuration / the total number of hosts. This indicator is used to ensure the security and stability of the host system. Once there is a malicious intrusion or attack to delete or change the key directory file, an alarm will be sent to the monitoring device, effectively improving the host security level. If there are too many key directories configured, it will cause false alarms of key directory changes when the host is running normally or restarting, resulting in a large number of invalid alarms being sent; if the key directory is insufficiently configured, it will lead to the inability to effectively monitor the changes in key directories and files. By configuring the host key directory, you can limit the access rights to these key files, prevent unauthorized users or malicious software from tampering with or damaging system files, thereby ensuring the security and integrity of the system, restricting only authorized users or administrators to access and modify key files, preventing unauthorized users or attackers from maliciously operating or tampering with the system, improving the security of the system, backing up key files or setting up recovery mechanisms, timely repairing or restoring damaged or lost files, reducing the impact of erroneous operations on the system, improving the stability and reliability of the system, and helping system administrators better manage the file and directory structure of the system, facilitating system maintenance and management. Administrators can classify and organize key files according to actual needs, establish a clear directory structure, facilitate the search and management of system files, and improve work efficiency and management effects.
[0135] 1.10. Security Alert Triggering Capability Scoring
[0136] 1.10.1 User login alarm trigger capability score, used to record security events such as user login and logout of hosts, network devices, databases, and security devices in real time.
[0137] Through the simulation of login operations on the host and switch, determine whether the network security platform correctly records the user login and logout, and obtain the user login alarm triggering ability score. For example, if the user login and logout behavior of any of the host, network equipment, database, and security equipment cannot be recorded, it will be recorded as unsatisfactory; 1 point will be deducted for each case. If there is missing, incorrect or incomplete log information, 1 point will be deducted for each case.
[0138] 1.10.2 Peripheral access alarm triggering ability score, including host USB device access, CD loading, switch network port access and other security events and alarms. For the host to access the USB device or load the CD, check whether the network security platform correctly records the USB device access or CD loading and alarms. Select a host with Agent deployed in the substation, insert a USB device that is not in the whitelist or load the CD; wait for the network security platform to feedback whether it has received the host peripheral access alarm. Simulate device access behavior on the switch, and check whether the network security platform correctly records the switch network port access and alarms. The switch opens the port. Use a dedicated mobile debugging terminal to access the switch port; wait for the network security platform to feedback whether it has received the switch peripheral access alarm; close the switch port. If it is impossible to record any of the host USB device access and CD loading, 2 points will be deducted for each case. If there is missing, incorrect or incomplete alarm information, 2 points will be deducted for each case. If it is impossible to record the switch network port access, it will be recorded as unsatisfactory; 2 points will be deducted for each case. If the warning information is missing, incorrect or incomplete, 2 points will be deducted for each case.
[0139] 1.10.3 Network access alarm trigger capability scoring, real-time monitoring of security events such as logging into the control center at this level through the dispatching data network and illegal access that violates the host whitelist configuration, and alarms.
[0140] The substation simulates logging into the communication gateway of the control center at the same level through the dispatching data network and executing some operation instructions to verify whether the network security platform can correctly record the access nodes, access paths, operation instructions and other related information. Within the safe and controllable range, according to the whitelist rules configured by the host, the corresponding illegal network access is executed to verify whether the network security platform can correctly record the illegal network access and issue an alarm.
[0141] Configure the relevant access control policies for access testing in the longitudinal encryption devices (cards) of the dispatching master station and substation to be evaluated, simulate the substation's access behavior to the master station, check the network security platform's monitoring of external access, and delete the temporary test policy after the inspection is completed. Sort out the substation's host IP whitelist and network port whitelist in advance and confirm the host Agent version; according to the whitelist rules, perform the corresponding illegal network access, test the host to access the host IP not in the whitelist through the TCP protocol, or use other hosts to access the medium and high-risk ports not in the whitelist through SSH; wait for the network security platform to verify whether the station-side illegal access alarm is received.
[0142] By triggering external access data: the host connected to the dispatching data network connects to the main station communication gateway through ssh; executing operation instructions: executing operation commands such as cd, ls-l, pwd on the communication gateway. If it is impossible to monitor external access, 10 points will be deducted; if any type of information such as access nodes, access paths and operation instructions is missing, incorrect or incomplete, 5 points will be deducted. If it is impossible to record illegal network access, it will be recorded as unsatisfactory, and 3 points will be deducted for each case. If there is missing, incorrect or incomplete alarm information on the network security platform, 1 point will be deducted for each case.
[0143] 1.10.4 The suspicious operation alarm triggering capability score corresponds to the host key directory and file tampering behavior, and determines that the key directory and files are changed within the safe and controllable range, and verifies whether the network security platform can correctly record the corresponding operation and issue an alarm. Figure 4 .
[0144] For the Ningsi Agent, first log in to the host via ssh to view the Agent configuration file cat
[0145] / usr / share / smp / linx_config, check the key directory / file list configuration MONPATH; for Kylin Agent, ssh login terminal input command gd_kylin_Agent_setting_tool, start the Agent configuration interface, check the key directory file configuration; substation to check the key directory configuration; through the command line to enter the key directory (such as / usr / bin / ), create a new test file (touch test.txt), delete the test file (rm test.txt) and other operations. If it is not possible to record the host key directory, file tampering behavior, it will be recorded as unsatisfactory, and 3 points will be deducted for each case. If there is missing, incorrect or incomplete alarm information on the network security platform, 1 point will be deducted for each case.
[0146] For host execution of dangerous operation commands, determine that they are within the safe and controllable range, execute the corresponding operation commands according to the configured host dangerous operation commands, and verify whether the network security platform can correctly record the execution of dangerous operation commands and issue an alarm. Dangerous operation commands should include aspects such as system start and stop, key operations and user permissions, and support regular expression configuration. The reference configuration is as follows, and each site should refer to the above principles to supplement and improve the configuration according to its actual situation.
[0147] ① Linux dangerous commands
[0148] System startup commands: ^poweroff.*, ^reboot.*, ^shutdown.*, ^halt.*, ^restart.*, ^init[\s]+0.*
[0149] Operational system commands: rm / *, rm-rf / *, ^format.*, ^mount[\s]+.*, ^umount[\s]+.*, ^kill[s]+.*, pkill*, ^mkfs\*.*
[0150] User permission commands: chmod*, chown*, userdel*, usermod*, useradd*, chgrp*
[0151] ②Windows dangerous commands
[0152] System startup commands: shutdown-r*, shutdown-s*
[0153] Operational system commands: del*, ^rd / s / q[\s]+.*, ^taskkill[\s]+.*, ^reg delete[\s]+.*, ^net start[\s]+.*, ^net use[\s]+.*
[0154] User permission commands: ^net user[\s]+.*, runas / user:administrator*, ^netlocalgroup[\s]+.*
[0155] First, obtain the high-risk operation command configuration list of the substation host through the network security platform; execute a high-risk instruction that matches the list rules within the controllable range, such as rm-rf, umount (non-real drive letter) and other commands; wait for the network security platform to verify whether the dangerous operation alarm is received. If it is impossible to record the host's dangerous operation commands, it will be recorded as unsatisfactory, and 1 point will be deducted for each case. If there is missing, incorrect or incomplete alarm information on the network security platform, 1 point will be deducted for each case.
[0156] For configuration changes of databases, network equipment, and special security equipment, determine the simulated configuration changes of switches and verify whether the network security platform can correctly record the configuration change log.
[0157] First, change the switch configuration and enable the switch snmp function: enter the system-view command to enter the system view, enter the snmp-agent command to enable the snmp function, and then enter the quit command to exit the system view; wait for the network security platform to check whether the switch configuration change event is received. If it is not possible to record any configuration changes of the database, network equipment, and dedicated security equipment, it will be recorded as unsatisfactory; 1 point will be deducted for each case. If there is missing, incorrect or incomplete configuration change log information, 1 point will be deducted for each case.
[0158] 1.10.5 Intelligent alarm triggering capability scoring supports intelligent generation of high-level attack alarms based on the integrated controlled asset logs and original alarm information of security equipment. Within a controllable range, simulate the scanning of live IPs, scanning of single IP open ports, and blasting of login passwords to verify whether the network security platform can accurately generate high-level alarms such as IP scanning, port scanning, and password blasting based on multiple original logs.
[0159] Connect the scanning test equipment in Zone II, or simulate it through NC on the deployed agent host. Use the system's own network access tools such as Telent and SSH. If the system is not installed or cannot be used due to hardening, use lightweight software, nc green version to build data packets to achieve network access. The relevant commands are as follows:
[0160] TELNET: The format is telnet IP port, such as Telnet 127.0.0.18080
[0161] SSH: The format is ssh-p port username@ip, such as: ssh-p 22root@192.168.0.1
[0162] NC: (1) Open the local port, format: nc-lp port, such as: nc-lp 23
[0163] (2) Access TCP port format: nc-vz IP port, such as: nc-vz 127.0.0.18080
[0164] (3) Access UDP port format: nc-uz IP port, such as: nc-uz 127.0.0.18080
[0165] (4) Scan host, format: nc-nv-w1 IP, such as: nc-nv-w1192.168.1.5
[0166] Within the controllable range, simulate the live IP scan, and generate an IP scan alarm when the number of IPs accessed by a source IP address within 60 seconds exceeds 5; within the controllable range, simulate the single IP open port scan, and generate a port scan alarm when the number of ports accessed by a source IP address within 60 seconds exceeds 5; within the controllable range, simulate the login password cracking, and simulate the user's continuous login failure of more than 5 times within 15 minutes on a single device, and generate a password cracking alarm; verify whether the network security platform side receives network scanning or password cracking alarms. If multiple original alarms cannot be integrated into a corresponding high-level alarm, 2 points will be deducted for each case.
[0167] 1.10.6 Alarm time stamp accuracy score: Actively trigger the alarm information of the host, network equipment, and security equipment within the controllable range, and verify whether the alarm information time stamp is consistent with the standard time. For example, if there is an alarm information time stamp deviation of more than 3 seconds, 0.5 points will be deducted for each case.
[0168] 1.11. Useless alarm clearing is used to check whether there are meaningless or erroneous alarms being sent. 1 point will be deducted for each case.
[0169] Step 2: Determine the subjective impact weight of each indicator in the substation safety monitoring indicator set using the DEMATEL analysis method.
[0170] The DEMATEL method (decision laboratory analysis method) analyzes the logical relationship between all factors in the system and the degree of influence and being influenced on each other, breaking the hierarchical barriers between the indicator sets of the layer analysis method, so as to make the results more accurate. The present invention uses the expert scoring method. The arithmetic mean method is used to calculate the expert's score value, and a direct impact matrix A is established for the indicator layer. The quantitative scores between each indicator are divided into 5 levels, 0 means no influence, 1 means very small influence, 2 means small influence, 3 means large influence, and 5 means very large influence. Considering the characteristics of the original data, the maximum value method is used for normalization, that is, each row of the matrix A is summed, the maximum value is taken from these values, and the elements in the matrix A are divided by the maximum value to obtain the normalized direct influence matrix B formula (6). The algorithm of the DEMATEL method is implemented using the programming language Python3.10, NumPy1.23.5, and pandas1.5.3, including the following sub-steps:
[0171] Step 2.1: Construct the initial direct impact matrix A of the impact degree between each indicator:
[0172]
[0173] Where a ij Representation factor X i X j The degree of influence of ij =0;
[0174] Step 2.2: Normalize the initial direct impact matrix A to obtain the standard impact matrix B:
[0175]
[0176] Step 2.3, calculate the comprehensive impact matrix T:
[0177] The comprehensive impact matrix reflects the comprehensive effects of various indicators in the system. After the standardized impact matrix is continuously multiplied by itself, all values of the matrix will approach 0, that is, Calculate the comprehensive impact matrix based on the normative impact matrix:
[0178]
[0179] Where I is the unit matrix.
[0180] Calculate the influence, influence, centrality and cause of each indicator.
[0181] Impact D i It refers to the sum of the values of each row in the matrix T, which represents the comprehensive impact of each row indicator on all other indicators:
[0182]
[0183] Influence C i Refers to the sum of the values in each column in the matrix T, indicating the comprehensive impact of each column indicator on all other indicators:
[0184]
[0185] Centrality M i It indicates the position of the indicator in the evaluation system and the size of its role. The centrality of an indicator is the sum of its influence and its influence:
[0186] M i =D i + C i
[0187] Centrality is used to determine the importance of indicators in risk assessment, and causality is used to determine the strength of the causal relationship between the current indicator and other indicators. The causal relationship between the indicators in the risk assessment indicator system is drawn based on the calculated centrality and influence values.
[0188] Determine the subjective weight w of the i-th indicator using the DEMATEL method i :
[0189] W i =M i / ∑M i
[0190] Step 3: Use the anti-entropy weight analysis method to determine the objective impact weight of each indicator in the substation safety monitoring indicator set.
[0191] According to the characteristics of entropy, the anti-entropy weight method can be used to determine the randomness and disorder of an event by calculating the entropy value. The entropy value can also be used to determine the degree of dispersion of a certain indicator. According to the definition of the anti-entropy weight method, the greater the dispersion of the indicator, the greater the influence of the indicator on the comprehensive evaluation, that is, the weight. If the sample data has the same value under a certain indicator, the influence (contribution) of the indicator on the overall evaluation is 0, so its weight should also be 0.
[0192] In order to eliminate the influence of dimension, it is necessary to standardize the indicator matrix data so as to conduct comparative analysis of the data and obtain the standardized decision matrix Y = {y ij} m×n :
[0193] The larger the value, the better. The standardized data y ij for
[0194]
[0195] The smaller the value, the better. The standardized data y ij for
[0196]
[0197] Calculate the anti-entropy value h j ':
[0198]
[0199] in And assuming that p ij =0, lnp ij =0
[0200] Calculate the objective weight of the jth indicator:
[0201]
[0202] Step 4: Combine the subjective influence weight and the objective influence weight according to game theory to obtain a combined weight of each indicator.
[0203] Drawing on the ideas of game theory, the subjective and objective weights are regarded as decision-making subjects in non-cooperative games. Both parties seek a balance of interests in constant conflict and achieve the optimal weight combination, making the indicator weighting more scientific and reasonable. The specific process is as follows:
[0204] The index weights obtained by the DEMATEL method and the anti-entropy weight method are respectively denoted as w1=(w 11 , w 12 , ..., w 1n ) and w2=(w 21 , w 22 , ..., w 2n ), and then construct the initial combination weight by the linear combination of w1 and w2:
[0205]
[0206] Where: α1 and α2 are the initial combination coefficients of subjective and objective weights respectively.
[0207] According to the principles of game theory, the Nash equilibrium point is solved, that is, to find a balance between different weights and minimize the deviation between the initial combination weight and the subjective and objective weights. The objective function and constraints are:
[0208]
[0209] By solving the model, the optimal combination weights that comprehensively consider subjective human factors and objective data rules are obtained. This problem is to solve the minimum value under the equality constraint conditions, and the Lagrangian function is constructed as follows:
[0210]
[0211] Where λ is the penalty factor of the Lagrangian function.
[0212] According to the differential principle, the optimal first-order derivative condition of the above formula is:
[0213]
[0214] The corresponding linear equations are
[0215]
[0216] Calculate the combination coefficients α1 and α2 and perform normalization:
[0217]
[0218] The final combined weight is
[0219]
[0220] Step 5: Based on the VIKOR decision algorithm, the safety monitoring indicators of multiple substations are comprehensively evaluated to obtain the safety monitoring capability evaluation results, and the evaluation results are ranked.
[0221] The VIKOR method is a multi-attribute decision-making method based on ideal solutions. The VIKOR method first determines the positive ideal solution (PIS) and the negative ideal solution (NIS), and then sorts the alternatives according to the closeness of the index evaluation value of each alternative to the ideal solution under the conditions of acceptable advantages and stability of the decision-making process. The solution obtained by the VIKOR method is a compromise solution, which is the feasible solution closest to the optimal solution among all solutions, and is also the result of mutual concession between the best and worst attributes.
[0222] There are m substations Y i(i=1,2,...,m), forming a substation set Y=(Y1,Y2,...,Y m ), the evaluation index of each substation is G j (j=1, 2, ..., n), the index set is G=G1, G2, ..., G n , index G j The weights of (j=1, 2, ..., n) are known, w*=(w1*, w2*, ..., w n *) T is the indicator weight vector. The comprehensive evaluation steps of the VIKOR method under the condition that the indicator weight is known are as follows:
[0223] Step 5.1: According to the substation set Y = {Y1, Y2, ..., Y m} and the index set G = {G1, G2, ..., G n}, construct the decision matrix F = (f ij ) m×n .f ij Indicates substation Y i ∈Y in index G j ∈G’s evaluation index value;
[0224] Step 5.2: Using the standard 0-1 transformation, the decision matrix F = (f ij ) m×n After normalization, the normalized decision matrix F′=(f′ ij ) m×n , f′ ij The specific calculation formula is:
[0225] When the indicator G j When it is a benefit indicator,
[0226]
[0227] The indicators of the present invention are all benefit-type indicators.
[0228] Step 5.3: According to the normalized matrix F′=(f′ ij ) m×n , determine the positive ideal solution f + and negative ideal solution f - :
[0229]
[0230] in,
[0231] Step 5.4: Calculate Y of each substation using grey correlation theory i ∈Y group benefit value S i 、Individual regret value Ri And the compromise value Q i
[0232]
[0233] Where, ρ∈[0,1];
[0234] w j is the combined weight of each indicator, S + =min i (S i ), S - =max i (S i ), R + =min i (R i ), R - =max i (R i );v is the decision mechanism coefficient, v∈[0,1]. When v>0.5, it means that the decision is made according to the decision mechanism of maximum group utility; when v=0.5, it means that the decision is made according to the decision mechanism in which the decision makers reach a consensus through consultation; when v<0.5, it means that the decision is made according to the decision mechanism of minimum individual regret.
[0235] Group benefit value S i It represents the ratio of the comprehensive score of each evaluation object to the "best" option. That is, a "best" applicant will be simulated in the analysis, and then the ratio of the comprehensive scores of each current evaluation object (applicant) to the "best" applicant will be found. The smaller the value, the closer it is to the "best".
[0236] Individual regret value R i It represents the maximum value of the ratio of the scores of various indicators of each evaluation object to the "best" solution when comprehensively evaluating it. That is, a "best" applicant will be simulated in the analysis, and then the maximum value of the ratio of the scores of various indicators of each current evaluation object (applicant) to the score of the "best" applicant will be found. The smaller the value, the closer it is to the "best".
[0237] Regardless of the final solution distance ratio S i Or the maximum value of the optimal solution distance ratio R i , whose purpose is to calculate the final benefit ratio Q i Value, Q i The value represents the distance between the evaluation object and the "best".
[0238] Step 5.5: S i , R i and Q iThe values are used as the evaluation results of substation network security monitoring capabilities, and the substations are ranked.
[0239] Compared with the traditional VIKOR algorithm, the group benefit value and personal regret value calculated by using the given weight value and grey correlation degree can more comprehensively consider the correlation of indicators, handle incomplete information, more accurately evaluate the group benefit and personal regret, and improve the credibility of the decision-making results. In summary, compared with the traditional VIKOR algorithm, the group benefit value and personal regret value calculated by using the given weight value and grey correlation degree have certain advantages in comprehensively considering the correlation of indicators, handling incomplete information and evaluating the group benefit, and can make decision evaluation more comprehensively and accurately.
[0240] Step 6: Analyze and adjust the substation according to the safety monitoring capability evaluation results.
[0241] The following analysis and measures can be taken for the evaluation results and ranking of each station obtained from the evaluation of substation network security monitoring capabilities.
[0242] Analyze the sites with scores above and below the threshold in the evaluation results, find out the differences and characteristics between them, so as to understand the advantages and successful experiences of highly rated sites, as well as the problems and shortcomings of low-rated sites. For sites with scores below the threshold in the evaluation results, conduct in-depth analysis of the specific indicators of their network security monitoring capability evaluation, and find out the specific points of the problems, which may involve equipment aging, insufficient asset access rate, monitoring device configuration, host equipment configuration, incomplete alarms, etc.
[0243] According to the identification results of the problem points, formulate corresponding improvement plans and measures. According to the problem points of different sites, formulate personalized improvement plans, clarify the improvement goals, responsible persons and timetables; strengthen the security awareness training of employees to improve their understanding of network security risks and their ability to respond. Educate employees on how to correctly identify security threats, security alerts, report security incidents and take appropriate response measures;
[0244] Establish a sound network security emergency response mechanism, and clarify the handling process and division of responsibilities for security incidents and security alerts. Ensure that security incidents and security alerts can be responded to and effectively handled quickly to reduce the impact of security incidents on site operations; for sites with insufficient monitoring capabilities, strengthen monitoring work. Establish a daily inspection system to regularly inspect and evaluate host equipment, network equipment, and security equipment to promptly discover and solve problems; establish a regular network security drill and evaluation mechanism to test the effectiveness of the security response mechanism and the response capabilities of employees. According to the drill results and evaluation feedback, timely adjust and improve network security strategies and measures.
[0245] Through the above analysis and implementation of measures, the network security monitoring capabilities of substations can be gradually improved, the prevention and response to network security threats can be strengthened, and the normal operation and data security of substations can be ensured.
[0246] The method of the present invention is described below with a specific example. 10 substations were selected for comprehensive evaluation of network security monitoring capabilities. The original values of substation indicators and key information are shown in Table 2:
[0247]
[0248]
[0249] Table 2 uses the anti-entropy weight method to obtain the objective weights, as shown in Table 3.
[0250] index Weight Equipment operating life 0.1104 Historical failure statistics 0.0844 Timing accuracy 0.0874 Reliable grounding, dual independent power supply 0.0889 Version inspection rate 0.0820 Asset access rate 0.1021 Data access ability score 0.0870 Host whitelist configuration accuracy 0.0893 Key Catalog 0.0893 Useless alarm 0.0846 Security Alert Triggering Capability Scoring 0.0946
[0251] Table 3 uses the DEMATEL method based on the expert scores, and the direct impact matrix is shown in Table 4.
[0252]
[0253]
[0254] Table 4
[0255] The indicator centrality and cause degree diagrams are as follows Figure 5 The indicator influence, influence, centrality, cause and calculated subjective weight are shown in Table 5.
[0256] Impact Influence Centrality Cause Weight Equipment operating life 0.926603 0.000000 0.926603 0.926603 0.139924 Historical failure statistics 0.174772 0.153635 0.328407 0.021137 0.049592 Timing accuracy 0.174772 0.074074 0.248846 0.100698 0.037578 Reliable grounding, dual independent power supply 0.087020 0.074074 0.161094 0.012946 0.024326 Version inspection rate 0.410849 0.166436 0.577285 0.244414 0.087175 Asset access rate 0.598732 0.246879 0.845611 0.351852 0.127694 Data access ability score 0.229199 0.391380 0.620579 -0.162182 0.093712 Host whitelist configuration accuracy 0.257720 0.168733 0.426454 0.088987 0.064398 Key Catalog 0.211809 0.168733 0.380542 0.043076 0.057465 Useless alarm 0.000000 0.702727 0.702727 -0.702727 0.106117 Security Alert Triggering Capability Scoring 0.239612 1.164416 1.404028 -0.924804 0.212019
[0257] Table 6
[0258] Game theory obtains the combined weights, as shown in Table 7.
[0259] index Weight Equipment operating life 0.1426 Historical failure statistics 0.0464 Timing accuracy 0.0331 Reliable grounding, dual independent power supply 0.0185 Version inspection rate 0.0876 Asset access rate 0.1300 Data access ability score 0.0943 Host whitelist configuration accuracy 0.0621 Key Catalog 0.0546 Useless alarm 0.1081 Security Alert Triggering Capability Scoring 0.2227
[0260] Table 7 The Vikor method is used for comprehensive evaluation to obtain the group utility value and individual regret value, as shown in Table 8.
[0261] Group utility value (S) Individual regret value (R) Substation 1 0.128 0.084 Substation 2 0.327 0.169 Substation 3 0.449 0.148 Substation 4 0.870 0.212 Substation 5 0.826 0.222 Substation 6 0.326 0.085 Substation 7 0.428 0.106 Substation 8 0.405 0.127 Substation 9 0.053 0.053 Substation 10 0.021 0.021
[0262] Table 8
[0263] The final scores of each solution are obtained, as shown in Table 9.
[0264] Compromise rating Ranking Substation 1 0.219 3 Substation 2 0.548 7 Substation 3 0.567 8 Substation 4 0.973 9 Substation 5 0.974 10 Substation 6 0.338 4 Substation 7 0.449 5 Substation 8 0.488 6 Substation 9 0.096 2 Substation 10 0 1
[0265] Table 9
[0266] From the evaluation results, it can be seen that substations 9 and 10 have higher comprehensive evaluations and stronger network security monitoring capabilities, while substations 4 and 5 have lower monitoring capability evaluations and a large gap with other stations. Targeted measures should be taken to accelerate equipment transformation, strengthen host reinforcement, increase routine inspections, and strengthen professional inspections to improve network security levels and avoid network security incidents caused by insufficient network security monitoring capabilities, which will affect the safe and stable operation of the power monitoring system. Other substations also have their own room for improvement, and appropriate methods should be taken to improve network security monitoring levels to ensure the safe and stable operation of the power monitoring system.
[0267] The beneficial effect of the present invention is that, compared with the prior art, the present invention provides a method and system for evaluating the network security monitoring capability of a substation, which can improve the network security monitoring capability of the substation, strengthen the prevention and response to network security threats, and ensure the normal operation and data security of the substation.
[0268] The present invention may be a system, a method and / or a computer program product. The present invention also discloses a substation network security monitoring capability evaluation system based on the above-mentioned substation network security monitoring capability evaluation method, comprising:
[0269] The safety monitoring indicator building module is used to obtain the performance information of the substation monitoring device, the host equipment configuration information and the substation alarm sending capability information to build a substation safety monitoring indicator set;
[0270] A subjective impact weight determination module, used to determine the subjective impact weight of each indicator in the substation safety monitoring indicator set by using a DEMATEL analysis method;
[0271] An objective impact weight determination module, used to determine the objective impact weight of each indicator in the substation safety monitoring indicator set by using an anti-entropy weight analysis method;
[0272] A combined weight determination module, used to combine the subjective influence weight and the objective influence weight according to game theory to obtain a combined weight of each indicator;
[0273] Safety monitoring comprehensive evaluation module, which is used to comprehensively evaluate the safety monitoring indicators of multiple substations based on the VIKOR decision algorithm, obtain the safety monitoring capability evaluation results, and sort the evaluation results;
[0274] The post-processing module is used to analyze and adjust the substation according to the safety monitoring capability evaluation result.
[0276] Based on the spirit of the present invention, those skilled in the art can easily think that a computer program product can be obtained based on the aforementioned substation network security monitoring capability evaluation method. The computer program product may include a computer-readable storage medium, which carries computer-readable program instructions for enabling a processor to implement various aspects of the present disclosure. That is, the present application also includes a terminal, including a processor and a storage medium; the storage medium is used to store instructions; the processor is used to operate according to the instructions to execute the steps according to the aforementioned substation network security monitoring capability evaluation method.
[0277] Computer readable storage medium can be a tangible device that can keep and store the instructions used by the instruction execution device. Computer readable storage medium can be, for example, - but not limited to - electrical storage device, magnetic storage device, optical storage device, electromagnetic storage device, semiconductor storage device or any suitable combination of the above. More specific examples (non-exhaustive list) of computer readable storage medium include: portable computer disk, hard disk, random access memory (RAM), read-only memory (ROM), erasable programmable read-only memory (EPROM or flash memory), static random access memory (SRAM), portable compact disk read-only memory (CD-ROM), digital versatile disk (DVD), memory stick, floppy disk, mechanical encoding device, for example, punch card or groove protrusion structure with instructions stored thereon and any suitable combination of the above. Computer readable storage medium used here is not interpreted as instantaneous signal itself, such as radio wave or other free propagating electromagnetic wave, electromagnetic wave propagated by waveguide or other transmission medium (for example, light pulse by optical fiber cable) or electrical signal transmitted by wire.
[0278] The computer-readable program instructions described herein can be downloaded from a computer-readable storage medium to each computing / processing device, or downloaded to an external computer or external storage device via a network, such as the Internet, a local area network, a wide area network, and / or a wireless network. The network can include copper transmission cables, optical fiber transmissions, wireless transmissions, routers, firewalls, switches, gateway computers, and / or edge servers. The network adapter card or network interface in each computing / processing device receives the computer-readable program instructions from the network and forwards the computer-readable program instructions for storage in the computer-readable storage medium in each computing / processing device.
[0279] The computer program instructions for performing the operation of the present disclosure may be assembly instructions, instruction set architecture (ISA) instructions, machine instructions, machine-related instructions, microcode, firmware instructions, state setting data, or source code or object code written in any combination of one or more programming languages, including object-oriented programming languages-such as Smalltalk, C++, etc., and conventional procedural programming languages-such as "C" language or similar programming languages. Computer-readable program instructions may be executed completely on a user's computer, partially on a user's computer, as an independent software package, partially on a user's computer, partially on a remote computer, or completely on a remote computer or server. In the case of a remote computer, the remote computer may be connected to the user's computer via any type of network-including a local area network (LAN) or a wide area network (WAN), or may be connected to an external computer (e.g., using an Internet service provider to connect via the Internet). In some embodiments, an electronic circuit, such as a programmable logic circuit, a field programmable gate array (FPGA), or a programmable logic array (PLA) may be personalized by utilizing the state information of a computer-readable program instruction, and the electronic circuit may execute a computer-readable program instruction, thereby realizing various aspects of the present disclosure.
[0280] Finally, it should be noted that the above embodiments are only used to illustrate the technical solutions of the present invention rather than to limit it. Although the present invention has been described in detail with reference to the above embodiments, ordinary technicians in the relevant field should understand that the specific implementation methods of the present invention can still be modified or replaced by equivalents, and any modifications or equivalent replacements that do not depart from the spirit and scope of the present invention should be covered within the scope of protection of the claims of the present invention.
Claims
1. A method for evaluating the network security monitoring capability of a substation, characterized in that: The following steps are involved: Step 1: Obtain the performance information of the substation monitoring device, the host equipment configuration information and the substation alarm sending capability information to construct a substation safety monitoring indicator set; Step 2: Determine the subjective impact weight of each indicator in the substation safety monitoring indicator set using the DEMATEL analysis method; Step 3: Determine the objective impact weight of each indicator in the substation safety monitoring indicator set by using the anti-entropy weight analysis method; Step 4: Combining the subjective influence weight and the objective influence weight according to game theory to obtain a combined weight of each indicator; Step 5: Comprehensively evaluate the safety monitoring indicators of multiple substations based on the VIKOR decision algorithm, obtain the safety monitoring capability evaluation results, and rank the evaluation results; Step 6: Analyze and adjust the substation according to the safety monitoring capability evaluation results.
2. The method for evaluating substation network security monitoring capability according to claim 1, characterized in that: The performance information of the substation monitoring device includes the monitoring device operation life index, the monitoring device historical failure rate, the monitoring device time accuracy, the monitoring device connection status score, the monitoring device asset access rate and the monitoring device data retrieval capability score; the host device configuration information includes the host Agent version inspection rate, the host whitelist configuration accuracy rate and the host key directory configuration accuracy rate; the substation alarm sending capability information includes the user login alarm triggering capability, the peripheral access alarm triggering capability, the network access alarm triggering capability, the suspicious operation alarm triggering capability, the intelligent alarm triggering capability, the alarm time scale accuracy and the useless alarm clearing capability.
3. The method for evaluating substation network security monitoring capability according to claim 2 is characterized in that: The obtaining of performance information of the substation monitoring device further includes: The operating life index of the monitoring device is determined according to the ratio of the expected life of the monitoring device and the number of years in operation. The historical failure rate of the monitoring device is determined according to the product of the total operating time of the monitoring device and the total number of failures. The timing accuracy of the monitoring device is determined according to the system time deviation of the monitoring device. The connection status score of the monitoring device is determined according to whether the monitoring device meets the grounding requirements or adopts dual independent power supplies. The asset access rate of the monitoring device is determined according to the ratio of the total number of assets actually connected to the monitoring device to the total number of assets that should be connected. The data retrieval capability score of the monitoring device is determined according to whether the monitoring device correctly imports the certificate issued by the electric power dispatching digital certificate system and performs data retrieval.
4. The method for evaluating substation network security monitoring capability according to claim 3 is characterized in that: The obtaining of host device configuration information further includes: The host Agent version inspection rate is determined based on the ratio of the number of hosts that have passed the inspection to the total number of hosts. The host whitelist configuration accuracy is determined based on the ratio of the number of hosts that meet the minimum whitelist configuration requirements to the total number of hosts. The host key directory configuration accuracy is determined based on the ratio of the number of hosts that have correct key directory configuration to the total number of hosts.
5. The method for evaluating substation network security monitoring capability according to claim 4 is characterized in that: The step of obtaining the substation alarm sending capability information further includes: The user login alarm triggering capability score is determined by checking whether the network security platform correctly records the user login and logout situations and issues an alarm. The peripheral access alarm triggering capability score is determined by checking whether the network security platform correctly records the USB device access or CD loading situations and issues an alarm. The network access alarm triggering capability score is determined by checking whether the network security platform can correctly record the access node, access path and operation instruction information and correctly record the illegal network access situation and issue an alarm. The suspicious operation alarm triggering capability score is determined by checking whether the network security platform can correctly record the corresponding operation situation when changing key directories and files and issue an alarm. The intelligent alarm triggering capability score is determined by checking whether the network security platform can generate IP scans, port scans and password cracking and issue an alarm based on multiple original logs. The alarm time stamp accuracy score is determined by checking whether the alarm information time stamp is consistent with the standard time. The useless alarm clearing capability score is determined by checking whether meaningless or erroneous alarms are sent.
6. The method for evaluating substation network security monitoring capability according to claim 5, characterized in that: The method of using the DEMATEL analysis method to determine the subjective impact weight of each indicator in the substation safety monitoring indicator set further includes: Step 2.1: Construct the initial direct impact matrix A of the impact degree between each indicator: Where a ij Representation factor X i X j The degree of influence of ij =0; Step 2.2: Normalize the initial direct impact matrix A to obtain the standard impact matrix B: Step 2.3: Calculate the comprehensive impact matrix T based on the normative impact matrix: Where I is the unit matrix; Calculate the influence, influence, centrality and cause of each indicator; influence D i It refers to the sum of the values of each row in the matrix T, which represents the comprehensive impact of each row indicator on all other indicators: Influence C i Refers to the sum of the values in each column in the matrix T, indicating the comprehensive impact of each column indicator on all other indicators: Centrality M i It indicates the position of the indicator in the evaluation system and the size of its role. The centrality of an indicator is the sum of its influence and its influence: M i = D i + C i Determine the subjective weight w of the i-th indicator using the DEMATEL method i : W i =M i / ∑M i 。 7. The method for evaluating substation network security monitoring capability according to claim 6 is characterized in that: The method of using the anti-entropy weight analysis method to determine the objective impact weight of each indicator in the substation safety monitoring indicator set further includes: Standardize the indicator matrix data to facilitate comparative analysis of the data and obtain the standardized decision matrix Y = {y ij }m×n: The larger the value, the better. The standardized data y ij for: The smaller the value, the better. The standardized data y ij for: Calculate the anti-entropy value h j ': in And assuming that p ij =0, ln p ij =0 Calculate the objective weight of the jth indicator:
8. The method for evaluating substation network security monitoring capability according to claim 7, characterized in that: The combining of the subjective influence weight and the objective influence weight according to the game theory to obtain the combined weight of each indicator further includes: The initial combined weight is constructed according to the linear combination of the subjective influence weight and the objective influence weight: Where: w1={w 11 , w 12 , ..., w 1n {and w2={w 21 , w 22 , ..., w 2n } are the subjective influence weight and the objective influence weight respectively, α1 and α2 are the initial combination coefficients of the subjective and objective weights respectively; According to the principles of game theory, the Nash equilibrium point is solved, that is, to find a balance between different weights and minimize the deviation between the initial combination weight and the subjective and objective weights. The objective function and constraints are: Solve the minimum under the equality constraints and construct the Lagrangian function: Where λ is the penalty factor of the Lagrangian function; Solve a system of linear equations: Get the combination coefficients α1 and α2 and perform normalization: The final combined weight is 9. The method for evaluating substation network security monitoring capability according to claim 8, characterized in that: The method of comprehensively evaluating the safety monitoring indicators of multiple substations based on the VIKOR decision algorithm to obtain safety monitoring capability evaluation results and sorting the evaluation results further includes: There are m substations Y i , i = 1, 2, ..., m, forming a substation set Y = {Y1, Y2, ..., Y m }, the evaluation index of each substation is G j , j = 1, 2, ..., n, the index set is G = G1, G2, ..., G n , index G j The weights are known, ω=(ω1,ω2,...,ω n ) T is the indicator weight vector: Step 5.1: According to the substation set Y = {Y1, Y2, ..., Y m } and the index set G = {G1, G2, ..., G n }, construct the decision matrix F = (f ij ) m×n ;f ij Indicates substation Y i ∈Y in index G j ∈G’s evaluation index value; Step 5.2: Using the standard 0-1 transformation, the decision matrix F = (f ij ) m×n After normalization, the normalized decision matrix F′=(f ij ′) m×n , f ij The specific calculation formula of ′ is: Step 5.3: According to the normalized matrix F′=(f ij ′) m×n , determine the positive ideal solution f + and negative ideal solution f - : in, Step 5.4: Calculate Y of each substation using grey correlation theory i ∈Y group benefit value S i 、Individual regret value R i And the compromise value Q i Where, ρ∈[0,1]; w j is the combined weight of each indicator, S + =min i (S i ), S - =max i (S i ), R + =min i (R i ), R - =max i (R i );v is the decision mechanism coefficient, v∈[0,1];when v>0.5, it means that the decision is made according to the decision mechanism of maximum group utility;when v=0.5, it means that the decision is made according to the decision mechanism in which the decision makers reach a consensus through consultation;when v<0.5, it means that the decision is made according to the decision mechanism of minimum individual regret.
10. A substation network security monitoring capability evaluation system, characterized in that: include: The safety monitoring indicator building module is used to obtain the performance information of the substation monitoring device, the host equipment configuration information and the substation alarm sending capability information to build a substation safety monitoring indicator set; A subjective impact weight determination module, used to determine the subjective impact weight of each indicator in the substation safety monitoring indicator set by using a DEMATEL analysis method; An objective impact weight determination module, used to determine the objective impact weight of each indicator in the substation safety monitoring indicator set by using an anti-entropy weight analysis method; A combined weight determination module, used to combine the subjective influence weight and the objective influence weight according to game theory to obtain a combined weight of each indicator; Safety monitoring comprehensive evaluation module, which is used to comprehensively evaluate the safety monitoring indicators of multiple substations based on the VIKOR decision algorithm, obtain the safety monitoring capability evaluation results, and sort the evaluation results; The post-processing module is used to analyze and adjust the substation according to the safety monitoring capability evaluation result.
11. A terminal comprising a processor and a storage medium; characterized in that: The storage medium is used to store instructions; The processor is used to operate according to the instructions to execute the steps of the substation network security monitoring capability evaluation method according to any one of claims 1-9.
12. A computer-readable storage medium having a computer program stored thereon, characterized in that: When the program is executed by a processor, the steps of the substation network security monitoring capability evaluation method described in any one of claims 1 to 9 are implemented.
Citation Information
Cited By
Security comprehensive management method and system for energy station
CN120013319A
