A method, system and medium for multi-dimensional technology evaluation of a perception device
By constructing a six-dimensional evaluation index system and the analytic hierarchy process, the problems of single evaluation dimensions and subjectivity in the evaluation of sensing equipment in grassroots communities have been solved. This has enabled multi-dimensional quantitative evaluation of equipment selection and full life-cycle cost accounting, reduced equipment selection risks and trial-and-error costs, and improved the level of digitalization in grassroots governance.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202611220515.1
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2026-08-12
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-10
AI Technical Summary
Existing technologies for selecting and evaluating sensing devices in grassroots communities suffer from problems such as a single evaluation dimension, strong subjectivity, lack of standardization, and incomplete life-cycle cost accounting. This leads to poor adaptability of the devices in different regions and communities, difficulties in maintenance, and performance degradation.
A six-dimensional comprehensive evaluation index system was constructed. The analytic hierarchy process was used to determine the dimension weights, and a quantitative scoring formula was formulated. The comprehensive score of the equipment was calculated through a weighted summation algorithm, and the equipment was classified according to the scoring results. The quantitative evaluation included dimensions such as technicality, economy, ease of use, reliability, maintainability, and portability.
This has enabled equipment evaluation to shift from a single subjective experience to a multi-dimensional quantitative scientific assessment, reducing selection risks, improving the objectivity and comparability of evaluation results, reducing total life cycle costs, and enhancing the adaptability and maintenance efficiency of equipment in different scenarios.
Smart Images

Figure CN123070874A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] This invention relates to the field of smart community sensing equipment technology, and in particular to a multi-dimensional technical evaluation method, system and medium for "one-sensor-multiple-knowledge" sensing equipment. Background Technology
[0002] With the deepening of digital and intelligent construction in grassroots community governance, the types and numbers of smart community sensing devices continue to grow. Multimodal sensing terminals, such as visible light cameras, microwave radar, lidar, near-infrared imaging equipment, pulsed electronic fences, environmental sensors, and drone inspection equipment, are widely used in scenarios such as community security, traffic control, environmental monitoring, and emergency response. The performance of these sensing devices directly determines the data quality and intelligent recognition results of the digital governance platform; therefore, the scientific and rational selection of equipment is a key prerequisite for the successful construction of the entire system.
[0003] However, the selection and evaluation of sensing equipment in grassroots communities currently suffers from the following problems: First, the evaluation dimensions are too narrow. Existing equipment evaluations are mostly based on manufacturer technical parameters, focusing only on single indicators such as detection accuracy or procurement cost, lacking a systematic evaluation of the overall performance throughout the equipment's lifecycle. Second, the evaluation methods are subjective. Equipment selection decisions mainly rely on engineers' experience and judgment, lacking quantitative scoring models and standardized testing procedures, making it difficult to compare evaluation results across projects. Third, the evaluation system is lacking. Existing domestic and international technical standards have not yet established multi-dimensional technical evaluation specifications specifically for community governance sensing equipment, resulting in inconsistent equipment evaluation standards across regions and projects. Fourth, the scenario adaptability assessment is insufficient. The applicability of equipment deployment in different regions and types of communities lacks objective evaluation criteria, leading to problems such as poor on-site adaptability, maintenance difficulties, and performance degradation after actual deployment of some equipment. Fifth, the full lifecycle cost accounting is incomplete. Existing evaluations only consider one-time procurement costs, ignoring full lifecycle cost factors such as operation and maintenance costs, energy consumption, and spare parts availability, resulting in the actual total cost of ownership (TCO) exceeding the budget.
[0004] Existing technologies include: some research institutions have proposed evaluation standards for video surveillance equipment based on a single detection accuracy index, and IoT equipment procurement evaluation models based on cost analysis. However, the above solutions are all aimed at a single dimension in a specific field and cannot meet the comprehensive evaluation needs of community governance sensing equipment across all dimensions and multiple scenarios.
[0005] The shortcomings of the existing technology are mainly reflected in the following five aspects: (1) The evaluation system is incomplete or the evaluation dimensions are one-sided, and the weight of a certain dimension is too high; (2) The weight determination method is subjective, lacks scientific weight quantification methods, and the evaluation results are significantly affected by personal experience; (3) The quantitative scoring indicators are missing, and no calculation formulas and scoring standards are further designed for each evaluation dimension, making it impossible to achieve cross-device horizontal comparison; (4) The scenario adaptability evaluation is insufficient, and the applicability of the equipment in different types of communities cannot be objectively evaluated, resulting in high selection risk; (5) The full life cycle cost accounting is incomplete, neglecting the comprehensive evaluation of operation and maintenance costs and cost-effectiveness, making it difficult to accurately predict the actual total cost of ownership. Summary of the Invention
[0006] This invention provides a multi-dimensional technical evaluation method, system, and medium for sensing devices. It aims to establish a six-dimensional comprehensive evaluation index system, determine scientifically reasonable dimension weights through the analytic hierarchy process, and formulate quantitative scoring formulas and data collection specifications for secondary indicators of each dimension. This enables quantitative evaluation of the entire process of sensing devices, from selection and procurement to operation and maintenance management. It addresses the core issues of incomplete evaluation systems, subjective methods, and inconsistent standards. This provides reusable and scalable technical means for scientific decision-making regarding sensing devices in grassroots community governance, effectively reducing equipment selection risks and trial-and-error costs, and improving the level of digitalization in grassroots governance.
[0007] This invention provides a multi-dimensional technical evaluation method for sensing devices, the method comprising the following steps: Step S10: Construct a six-dimensional comprehensive evaluation index system for sensing devices, and define specific quantitative evaluation indicators for each. The six-dimensional comprehensive evaluation indicators include technical dimension, economic dimension, ease of use dimension, reliability dimension, maintainability dimension and portability dimension. Step S20: Determine the weights of each dimension of the sensing device using the analytic hierarchy process (AHP). Step S30: Calculate the overall score of the sensing device using a weighted summation algorithm; Step S40: Classify the sensing devices according to the scoring results.
[0008] A further technical solution of the present invention is that the technical dimension includes four secondary indicators: detection accuracy indicator P, detection distance indicator D, environmental adaptability indicator E, and response time indicator R; Among them, the detection accuracy index P is calculated by the mean accuracy mAP using a standard test set, and the calculation formula is P=(1 / N)Σ i AP i ×100%; The detection distance index D is based on the ratio of the actual effective detection distance to the nominal distance. The calculation formula is D_score=min(D_actual / D_nominal,1)×100 points; The environmental adaptability index E comprehensively evaluates the performance retention rate of equipment under different lighting and weather conditions. The calculation formula is E=(1 / M)Σ j (S_Working Condition) j / S_benchmark)×100 points; The response time metric R is evaluated by comparing the device's end-to-end latency with industry benchmarks. The comprehensive score for the technical dimension is T = 0.35 × P + 0.25 × D + 0.25 × E + 0.15 × R_score.
[0009] A further technical solution of the present invention is that the economic dimension includes three secondary indicators: unit purchase cost C_p, operation and maintenance cost C_m, and cost-effectiveness C_v; Among them, the unit purchase cost index C_p adopts the cost tier scoring method; the operation and maintenance cost index C_m assesses the proportion of annual operation and maintenance costs to purchase costs, and the calculation formula is C_m=max(0,100-(R_operation and maintenance / 15%)×100); the cost-effectiveness index C_v is scored by benchmarking the ratio of comprehensive equipment testing accuracy to the average annual total cost of ownership; the comprehensive score of the economic dimension is C=0.40×C_p+0.30×C_m+0.30×C_v.
[0010] A further technical solution of the present invention is that the usability dimension includes three secondary indicators: deployment complexity U_i, configuration ease of use U_c, and human-computer interaction friendliness U_h; The deployment complexity U_i is scored according to deployment time, the configuration ease U_c is scored according to configuration method, and the human-computer interaction friendliness U_h is converted to a percentage system based on the user experience score of grassroots community management personnel. The overall usability score is U = 0.35 × U_i + 0.35 × U_c + 0.30 × U_h.
[0011] A further technical solution of the present invention is that the reliability dimension includes three secondary indicators: mean time between failures (MTBF) R_mtbf, fault recovery capability (R_rec), and data integrity (R_int). The mean time between failures (MTBF) R_mtbf is calculated as R_mtbf = min(MTBF_measured / MTBF_benchmark, 1.5) × 100 points; the fault recovery capability R_rec is based on the MTTR comparison score; and the data integrity R_int is based on the data integrity recovery rate score in abnormal scenarios. The overall reliability score is R = 0.45 × R_mtbf + 0.30 × R_rec + 0.25 × R_int.
[0012] A further technical solution of the present invention is that the maintainability dimension includes three secondary indicators: modularity M_mod, remote maintenance capability M_rem, and spare parts availability M_spare; Among them, the modularity M_mod is scored based on the proportion of modular pluggable design of key components, the remote maintenance capability M_rem is scored based on the support rate of functions such as remote firmware upgrade, parameter adjustment, and fault diagnosis, and the spare parts availability M_spare is scored based on the comprehensive score of spare parts spot supply rate and supply cycle. The overall score for maintainability is M = 0.30 × M_mod + 0.40 × M_rem + 0.30 × M_spare.
[0013] A further technical solution of the present invention is that the portability dimension includes three secondary indicators: scenario adaptation flexibility P_s, interface standardization degree P_if, and power supply and communication adaptability P_pc; Among them, the scenario adaptation elasticity P_s is based on the pass rate score of multiple types of community verification; the power supply and communication adaptability P_pc is based on the weighted score of the number of optional power supply methods and communication methods supported by the device; the comprehensive score of the portability dimension P=0.40×P_s+0.35×P_if+0.25×P_pc.
[0014] A further technical solution of the present invention is that step S20 includes: The 1-9 scale method is used to compare and score each dimension pairwise, and a judgment matrix A=(a ij ) 6x6 , where a ij This represents the importance scale of the i-th dimension relative to the j-th dimension; The judgment matrix is normalized to calculate the weight vector, and a consistency check is performed. The weights are considered valid when the consistency ratio CR < 0.1. Among them, the technical weight is represented by ω_T, the economic weight by ω_C, the usability weight by ω_U, the reliability weight by ω_R, the maintainability weight by ω_M, and the portability weight by ω_P. Step S30 includes: calculating the comprehensive score S of a single sensing device using a weighted summation method, the calculation formula being: S = ω_T×T + ω_C×C + ω_U×U + ω_R×R + ω_M×M + ω_P×P, where the score for each dimension ranges from 0 to 100. When the result of a certain dimension exceeds 100, the upper limit of 100 is taken. Step S40 includes: classifying the equipment into four levels based on the comprehensive score S: Level A is excellent and recommended for priority purchase; Level B is good and recommended for purchase; Level C is qualified and can be selected under limited conditions; Level D is unqualified and not recommended for purchase.
[0015] To achieve the above objectives, the present invention also proposes a multi-dimensional technology evaluation system for sensing devices. The system includes a memory, a processor, and a multi-dimensional technology evaluation program for sensing devices stored in the memory. The multi-dimensional technology evaluation program for sensing devices is executed by the processor to perform the steps of the method described above.
[0016] To achieve the above objectives, the present invention also proposes a computer-readable storage medium storing a multi-dimensional technical evaluation program for sensing devices, wherein the multi-dimensional technical evaluation program for sensing devices is executed by a processor to perform the steps of the method described above.
[0017] The multi-dimensional technical evaluation method, system, and medium for sensing devices of this invention transform the evaluation of sensing devices from a single subjective experience judgment to a multi-dimensional quantitative scientific evaluation by constructing a six-dimensional multi-dimensional technical evaluation system. The specific beneficial effects are as follows: (1) The scientific nature of the evaluation has been significantly improved: the weight coefficients determined based on the analytic hierarchy process have undergone consistency testing to ensure the mathematical rationality of the weight allocation, eliminate subjective bias, and make the evaluation process reproducible and auditable; (2) The evaluation results are objective and comparable: the standardized calculation formulas for secondary indicators and the data source specifications ensure the horizontal comparability of the evaluation results across equipment and projects, support the competition of multiple models of equipment, and provide a quantitative ranking basis for procurement decisions; (3) Complete life cycle cost accounting: The economic dimension covers three sub-indicators: purchase cost, operation and maintenance cost and cost-effectiveness, to achieve comprehensive quantitative accounting of total cost of ownership (TCO) and effectively reduce the risk of actual construction cost exceeding the budget; (4) The scenario adaptability assessment is based on evidence: the scenario adaptability elasticity index of the portability dimension has been verified through field tests in multiple types of communities, providing an objective basis for equipment deployment decisions in different scenarios and reducing the risk of on-site adaptation failure; (5) Flexible and adaptive weights: The evaluation system supports flexible adjustment of the weight coefficients of each dimension according to the differentiated needs of different regions and different types of communities, and has strong scenario adaptability and scalability. (6) Reduce selection risks and trial and error costs: By using quantitative scoring and grade classification standards, clear recommendations or non-recommendations are provided for equipment procurement decisions, reducing actual usage risks such as substandard equipment performance and maintenance difficulties from the source. This can reduce the equipment selection rework rate by more than 30% and save trial and error costs. Attached Figure Description
[0018] Figure 1 This is a flowchart illustrating a preferred embodiment of the multi-dimensional technical evaluation method for sensing devices of the present invention; Figure 2This is a schematic diagram of the hardware architecture of the multi-dimensional technical evaluation system for sensing devices of the present invention. Detailed Implementation
[0019] To make the objectives, technical solutions, and advantages of this invention clearer, the invention will be further described in detail below with reference to the accompanying drawings and embodiments.
[0020] This invention proposes a multi-dimensional technical evaluation method for "one-sensor-multiple-knowledge" sensing devices. Its purpose is to establish a six-dimensional comprehensive evaluation index system, determine scientifically reasonable dimension weights through the analytic hierarchy process, formulate quantitative scoring formulas and data collection specifications for secondary indicators of each dimension, and achieve quantitative evaluation of the entire process of sensing devices from selection and procurement to operation and maintenance management. This addresses the core issues of incomplete evaluation systems, subjective methods, and inconsistent standards, providing reusable and scalable technical means for scientific decision-making regarding sensing devices in grassroots community governance. It effectively reduces equipment selection risks and trial-and-error costs, and improves the level of digital intelligence in grassroots governance.
[0021] This invention uses a six-dimensional evaluation index system as its core, determines the weights of each dimension through the analytic hierarchy process, calculates the comprehensive score of the equipment using a weighted summation algorithm, and classifies the equipment according to the score results, thus providing scientific decision support throughout the entire process. The overall method consists of four key steps: constructing the evaluation index system, determining the dimension weights, calculating the comprehensive score, and determining the grade.
[0022] Specifically, such as Figure 1 As shown, a preferred embodiment of the multi-dimensional technical evaluation method for sensing devices of the present invention includes the following steps: Step S10: Construct a six-dimensional comprehensive evaluation index system for sensing devices, and define specific quantitative evaluation indicators for each dimension. The six-dimensional comprehensive evaluation indicators include technical dimension, economic dimension, ease of use dimension, reliability dimension, maintainability dimension, and portability dimension.
[0023] Step S20: Determine the weights of each dimension of the sensing device using the analytic hierarchy process (AHP).
[0024] Step S30: Calculate the comprehensive score of the sensing device using a weighted summation algorithm.
[0025] Step S40: Classify the sensing devices according to the scoring results.
[0026] In the evaluation index system construction phase, this embodiment defines specific quantitative evaluation indicators and data collection methods for six evaluation dimensions: technicality, economy, ease of use, reliability, maintainability, and portability.
[0027] Specifically, in this embodiment, the technical dimension (T) includes four secondary indicators: detection accuracy indicator P, detection distance indicator D, environmental adaptability indicator E, and response time indicator R.
[0028] Among them, the detection accuracy index P is calculated by the mean accuracy mAP using a standard test set, and the calculation formula is P=(1 / N)Σ i AP i ×100%.
[0029] The detection distance index D is based on the ratio of the actual effective detection distance to the nominal distance. The calculation formula is D_score=min(D_actual / D_nominal,1)×100 points.
[0030] The environmental adaptability index E comprehensively evaluates the performance retention rate of equipment under different lighting and weather conditions. The calculation formula is E=(1 / M)Σ j (S_Working Condition) j / S_benchmark)×100 points.
[0031] The response time metric R is evaluated by comparing the device's end-to-end latency with industry benchmarks.
[0032] The comprehensive score for the technical dimension is T = 0.35 × P + 0.25 × D + 0.25 × E + 0.15 × R_score.
[0033] The economic dimension (C) has three secondary indicators: unit purchase cost C_p, operation and maintenance cost C_m, and cost-effectiveness C_v.
[0034] Among them, the unit purchase cost index C_p adopts a cost tiered scoring method (100 points for being more than 20% below the industry average price, 80 points for being within ±20% range, and 60 points for being more than 20% above the average price); the operation and maintenance cost index C_m assesses the proportion of annual operation and maintenance costs to purchase costs, and the calculation formula is C_m=max(0,100-(R_Operation and Maintenance / 15%)×100); the cost-effectiveness index C_v is scored by benchmarking the ratio of comprehensive equipment testing accuracy to the average annual total cost of ownership; the comprehensive score of the economic dimension is C=0.40×C_p+0.30×C_m+0.30×C_v.
[0035] The usability dimension (U) has three secondary indicators: deployment complexity U_i, configuration ease U_c, and human-computer interaction friendliness U_h.
[0036] The deployment complexity U_i is scored according to deployment time (≤1 hour 100 points, 1~4 hours 80 points, 4~8 hours 60 points, >8 hours 40 points), the configuration convenience U_c is scored according to configuration method, and the human-computer interaction friendliness U_h is converted into a percentage system based on the user experience score of grassroots community management personnel.
[0037] The overall usability score is U = 0.35 × U_i + 0.35 × U_c + 0.30 × U_h.
[0038] The reliability dimension (R) has three secondary indicators: mean time between failures (MTBF) R_mtbf, fault recovery capability (R_rec), and data integrity (R_int).
[0039] The mean time between failures (MTBF) R_mtbf is calculated as R_mtbf = min(MTBF_measured / MTBF_benchmark, 1.5) × 100 points; the fault recovery capability R_rec is based on the MTTR comparison score; and the data integrity R_int is based on the abnormal scenario data integrity recovery rate score.
[0040] The overall reliability score is R = 0.45 × R_mtbf + 0.30 × R_rec + 0.25 × R_int.
[0041] The maintainability dimension (M) has three secondary indicators: modularity M_mod, remote maintenance capability M_rem, and spare parts availability M_spare.
[0042] The modularity M_mod is scored based on the proportion of modular and pluggable design of key components; the remote maintenance capability M_rem is scored based on the support rate of functions such as remote firmware upgrade, parameter adjustment, and fault diagnosis; and the spare parts availability M_spare is scored based on the combined score of spare parts spot supply rate and supply cycle.
[0043] The overall score for maintainability is M = 0.30 × M_mod + 0.40 × M_rem + 0.30 × M_spare.
[0044] The portability dimension includes three secondary indicators: scenario adaptation flexibility P_s, interface standardization degree P_if, and power supply and communication adaptability P_pc.
[0045] Among them, the scenario adaptability elasticity P_s is scored based on the pass rate of multi-type community verification; the interface standardization degree P_if is scored based on the proportion of interfaces of industry common standards; and the power supply and communication adaptability P_pc is scored based on the weighted score of the number of optional power supply methods and communication methods supported by the device.
[0046] The overall score for portability is P = 0.40 × P_s + 0.35 × P_if + 0.25 × P_pc.
[0047] Furthermore, in step S20, this embodiment invites experts in the field of smart communities (including community managers, system integration engineers, equipment maintenance personnel and university researchers) to form an expert group, and uses the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) to determine the weights of each dimension.
[0048] Step S20 specifically includes: An expert panel was formed by inviting experts in the field of smart communities (including community managers, system integration engineers, equipment maintenance personnel, and university researchers). A 1-9 scale was used to compare and score each dimension pairwise, constructing a judgment matrix A=(a ij ) 6x6 , where a ij This represents the importance scale of the i-th dimension relative to the j-th dimension; The judgment matrix is normalized to calculate the weight vector, and a consistency check is performed. Weights with a consistency ratio CR < 0.1 are considered valid. The weights are denoted as follows: technical weight ω_T, economic weight ω_C, usability weight ω_U, reliability weight ω_R, maintainability weight ω_M, and portability weight ω_P. The weights for each dimension are determined as follows: technical weight ω_T = 0.30, economic weight ω_C = 0.20, usability weight ω_U = 0.15, reliability weight ω_R = 0.18, maintainability weight ω_M = 0.10, and portability weight ω_P = 0.07, satisfying Σω = 1.
[0049] Step S30 includes: calculating the comprehensive score S of a single sensing device using a weighted summation method, the calculation formula being: S = ω_T×T + ω_C×C + ω_U×U + ω_R×R + ω_M×M + ω_P×P, where the score for each dimension ranges from 0 to 100. When the result of a certain dimension exceeds 100, the upper limit of 100 is taken. Step S40 includes: classifying the equipment into four levels based on the comprehensive score S: Level A (S≥85 points) is excellent and recommended for priority purchase; Level B (70≤S<85 points) is good and recommended for purchase; Level C (55≤S<70 points) is qualified and can be selected under limited conditions; Level D (S<55 points) is unqualified and not recommended for purchase.
[0050] This embodiment verifies the feasibility of the method with a complete evaluation example. Using a TDS-3000 dual-spectrum thermal imaging camera as the evaluation object, after 30 days of continuous operation and data collection, scores were calculated dimension by dimension according to the above formula: T=91.76, C=48.30, U=81.20, R=100 (maximum score above 100), M=70.30, P=81.75. Substituting the weights, the comprehensive score was calculated as: S=0.30×91.76+0.20×48.30+0.15×81.20+0.18×100+0.10×70.30+0.07×81.75=80.12, which belongs to Grade B (Good, recommended for purchase). Differential deployment suggestions were proposed for cases where the score in the economic dimension was low. This example verifies the operability and credibility of the evaluation method of this invention.
[0051] The multi-dimensional technical evaluation method for sensing devices in this invention transforms the evaluation of sensing devices from a single subjective experience judgment to a multi-dimensional quantitative scientific evaluation by constructing a six-dimensional multi-dimensional technical evaluation system. The specific beneficial effects are as follows: (1) The scientific nature of the evaluation has been significantly improved: the weight coefficients determined based on the analytic hierarchy process have undergone consistency testing to ensure the mathematical rationality of the weight allocation, eliminate subjective bias, and make the evaluation process reproducible and auditable; (2) The evaluation results are objective and comparable: the standardized calculation formulas for secondary indicators and the data source specifications ensure the horizontal comparability of the evaluation results across equipment and projects, support the competition of multiple models of equipment, and provide a quantitative ranking basis for procurement decisions; (3) Complete life cycle cost accounting: The economic dimension covers three sub-indicators: purchase cost, operation and maintenance cost and cost-effectiveness, to achieve comprehensive quantitative accounting of total cost of ownership (TCO) and effectively reduce the risk of actual construction cost exceeding the budget; (4) The scenario adaptability assessment is based on evidence: the scenario adaptability elasticity index of the portability dimension has been verified through field tests in multiple types of communities, providing an objective basis for equipment deployment decisions in different scenarios and reducing the risk of on-site adaptation failure; (5) Flexible and adaptive weights: The evaluation system supports flexible adjustment of the weight coefficients of each dimension according to the differentiated needs of different regions and different types of communities, and has strong scenario adaptability and scalability. (6) Reduce selection risks and trial and error costs: By using quantitative scoring and grade classification standards, clear recommendations or non-recommendations are provided for equipment procurement decisions, reducing actual usage risks such as substandard equipment performance and maintenance difficulties from the source. This can reduce the equipment selection rework rate by more than 30% and save trial and error costs.
[0052] To achieve the above objectives, this invention also proposes a multi-dimensional technical evaluation system for sensing devices, such as... Figure 2As shown, the system includes a processor 1001, a CPU, a network interface 1004, a user interface 1003, a memory 1005, a communication bus 1002, and a multi-dimensional technical evaluation program for sensing devices stored on the processor. The communication bus 1002 is used to enable communication between these components. The user interface 1003 may include a display screen or an input unit such as a keyboard. Optionally, the user interface 1003 may also include a standard wired interface or a wireless interface. The network interface 1004 may optionally include a standard wired interface or a wireless interface (such as a Wi-Fi interface). The memory 1005 may be high-speed RAM or non-volatile memory, such as a disk drive. Optionally, the memory 1005 may also be a storage device independent of the aforementioned processor 1001.
[0053] Those skilled in the art will understand that Figure 2 The system structure shown does not constitute a limitation on the system and may include more or fewer components than shown, or combine certain components, or have different component arrangements.
[0054] like Figure 2 As shown, the memory 1005, which serves as a computer storage medium, may include an operating device, a network communication module, a user interface module, and a multi-dimensional technical evaluation program for sensing devices.
[0055] exist Figure 2 In the system shown, the network interface 1004 is mainly used to connect to the network server and communicate with the network server; the user interface 1003 is mainly used to interact with the user terminal and receive user input commands; and the processor 1001 can be used to call the multi-dimensional technical evaluation program for sensing devices stored in the memory 1005.
[0056] To achieve the above objectives, the present invention also proposes a computer-readable storage medium storing a multi-dimensional technical evaluation program for sensing devices. When the multi-dimensional technical evaluation program for sensing devices is run by a processor, the steps of the method described above are executed, and will not be repeated here.
[0057] The above description, in conjunction with specific preferred embodiments, provides a further detailed explanation of the present invention. It should not be construed that the specific implementation of the present invention is limited to these descriptions. For those skilled in the art, various simple deductions or substitutions can be made without departing from the concept of the present invention, and all such modifications and substitutions should be considered within the scope of protection of the present invention.
Claims
1. A multi-dimensional technical evaluation method for sensing devices, characterized in that, The method includes the following steps: Step S10: Construct a six-dimensional comprehensive evaluation index system for sensing devices, and define specific quantitative evaluation indicators for each. The six-dimensional comprehensive evaluation indicators include technical dimension, economic dimension, ease of use dimension, reliability dimension, maintainability dimension and portability dimension. Step S20: Determine the weights of each dimension of the sensing device using the analytic hierarchy process (AHP). Step S30: Calculate the comprehensive score of the sensing device using a weighted summation algorithm; Step S40: Classify the sensing devices according to the scoring results.
2. The multi-dimensional technical evaluation method for sensing devices according to claim 1, characterized in that, The technical dimension includes four secondary indicators: detection accuracy indicator P, detection distance indicator D, environmental adaptability indicator E, and response time indicator R; Among them, the detection accuracy index P is calculated by the mean accuracy mAP using a standard test set, and the calculation formula is P=(1 / N)Σ i AP i ×100%; The detection distance index D is based on the ratio of the actual effective detection distance to the nominal distance. The calculation formula is D_score=min(D_actual / D_nominal,1)×100 points; The environmental adaptability index E comprehensively evaluates the performance retention rate of equipment under different lighting and weather conditions. The calculation formula is E=(1 / M)Σ j (S_Working Condition) j / S_benchmark)×100 points; The response time metric R is evaluated by comparing the device's end-to-end latency with industry benchmarks. The comprehensive score for the technical dimension is T = 0.35 × P + 0.25 × D + 0.25 × E + 0.15 × R_score.
3. The multi-dimensional technical evaluation method for sensing devices according to claim 2, characterized in that, The economic dimension includes three secondary indicators: unit purchase cost C_p, operation and maintenance cost C_m, and cost-effectiveness C_v. Among them, the unit purchase cost index C_p adopts the cost tier scoring method; the operation and maintenance cost index C_m assesses the proportion of annual operation and maintenance costs to purchase costs, and the calculation formula is C_m=max(0,100-(R_operation and maintenance / 15%)×100); the cost-effectiveness index C_v is scored by benchmarking the ratio of comprehensive equipment testing accuracy to the average annual total cost of ownership; the comprehensive score of the economic dimension is C=0.40×C_p+0.30×C_m+0.30×C_v.
4. The multi-dimensional technical evaluation method for sensing devices according to claim 3, characterized in that, The usability dimension includes three secondary indicators: deployment complexity U_i, configuration ease U_c, and human-computer interaction friendliness U_h; The deployment complexity U_i is scored according to deployment time, the configuration ease U_c is scored according to configuration method, and the human-computer interaction friendliness U_h is converted to a percentage system based on the user experience score of grassroots community management personnel. The overall usability score is U = 0.35 × U_i + 0.35 × U_c + 0.30 × U_h.
5. The multi-dimensional technical evaluation method for sensing devices according to claim 4, characterized in that, The reliability dimension includes three secondary indicators: mean time between failures (MTBF) R_mtbf, fault recovery capability (R_rec), and data integrity (R_int). The mean time between failures (MTBF) R_mtbf is calculated as R_mtbf = min(MTBF_measured / MTBF_benchmark, 1.5) × 100 points; the fault recovery capability R_rec is based on the MTTR comparison score; and the data integrity R_int is based on the data integrity recovery rate score in abnormal scenarios. The overall reliability score is R = 0.45 × R_mtbf + 0.30 × R_rec + 0.25 × R_int.
6. The multi-dimensional technical evaluation method for sensing devices according to claim 5, characterized in that, The maintainability dimension includes three secondary indicators: modularity M_mod, remote maintenance capability M_rem, and spare parts availability M_spare. Among them, the modularity M_mod is scored based on the proportion of modular pluggable design of key components, the remote maintenance capability M_rem is scored based on the support rate of functions such as remote firmware upgrade, parameter adjustment, and fault diagnosis, and the spare parts availability M_spare is scored based on the comprehensive score of spare parts spot supply rate and supply cycle. The overall score for maintainability is M = 0.30 × M_mod + 0.40 × M_rem + 0.30 × M_spare.
7. The multi-dimensional technical evaluation method for sensing devices according to claim 6, characterized in that, The portability dimension includes three secondary indicators: scenario adaptation flexibility P_s, interface standardization degree P_if, and power supply and communication adaptability P_pc; Among them, the scenario adaptation elasticity P_s is based on the pass rate score of multiple types of community verification; the power supply and communication adaptability P_pc is based on the weighted score of the number of optional power supply methods and communication methods supported by the device; the comprehensive score of the portability dimension P=0.40×P_s+0.35×P_if+0.25×P_pc.
8. The multi-dimensional technical evaluation method for sensing devices according to claim 7, characterized in that, Step S20 includes: The 1-9 scale method is used to compare and score each dimension pairwise, and a judgment matrix A=(a ij ) 6x6 , where a ij This represents the importance scale of the i-th dimension relative to the j-th dimension; The judgment matrix is normalized to calculate the weight vector, and a consistency check is performed. The weights are considered valid when the consistency ratio CR < 0.
1. The technical weights are represented by ω_T, the economic weights by ω_C, the usability weights by ω_U, the reliability weights by ω_R, the maintainability weights by ω_M, and the portability weights by ω_P. Step S30 includes: calculating the comprehensive score S of a single sensing device using a weighted summation method, the calculation formula being: S = ω_T×T + ω_C×C + ω_U×U + ω_R×R + ω_M×M + ω_P×P, where the score for each dimension ranges from 0 to 100. When the result of a certain dimension exceeds 100, the upper limit of 100 is taken. Step S40 includes: classifying the equipment into four levels based on the comprehensive score S: Level A is excellent and recommended for priority purchase; Level B is good and recommended for purchase; Level C is qualified and can be selected under limited conditions; Level D is unqualified and not recommended for purchase.
9. A multi-dimensional technical evaluation system for sensing devices, characterized in that, The system includes a memory, a processor, and a multi-dimensional technology evaluation program for sensing devices stored in the memory, wherein the multi-dimensional technology evaluation program for sensing devices is executed by the processor to perform the steps of the method as described in any one of claims 1 to 8.
10. A computer-readable storage medium, characterized in that, The computer-readable storage medium stores a multi-dimensional technology evaluation program for sensing devices, which, when executed by a processor, performs the steps of the method as described in any one of claims 1 to 8.
