Economic Comparison Method for Multi-Terminal Offshore Wind Power Transmission Projects Throughout Their Life Cycle
By using a life-cycle economic comparison method, and comprehensively considering various costs of multi-terminal offshore wind power transmission projects, the problem of the inability to fully evaluate multi-terminal offshore wind power transmission schemes in existing technologies was solved, the most economical transmission scheme was selected, and system costs were reduced.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202610990446.6
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2026-07-03
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-10
AI Technical Summary
Existing technologies fail to comprehensively evaluate the life-cycle cost of multi-terminal offshore wind power transmission projects, making it impossible to select the most suitable transmission scheme.
A method for economic comparison of multi-terminal offshore wind power transmission projects throughout their entire life cycle is proposed. By calculating one-time investment costs, failure loss costs, periodic maintenance costs, and operating loss costs, the economic efficiency of different transmission schemes is comprehensively evaluated.
It enables full life-cycle cost assessment of multi-terminal offshore wind power transmission schemes, selects the most economical transmission scheme, and reduces system construction and operation costs.
Smart Images

Figure CN123073901A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] This invention belongs to the field of new energy power generation technology, specifically relating to a method for economic comparison of multi-terminal offshore wind power transmission projects throughout their entire life cycle. Background Technology
[0002] Currently, offshore wind power is developing towards deep-sea areas. Power transmission schemes such as power frequency AC transmission, flexible DC transmission, and low frequency AC transmission have been applied in the offshore wind power field. Multi-terminal transmission schemes can significantly enhance the wind energy utilization rate of offshore wind farms and have received widespread attention.
[0003] Multi-terminal offshore wind power power frequency transmission systems are currently the most mature multi-terminal networking solution. However, when offshore wind farms are far from shore, power frequency AC transmission schemes suffer from excessive reactive power consumption due to the equivalent capacitance of submarine cables. Furthermore, the active power transmission capacity of power frequency AC submarine cables is limited, and the cost of submarine cables increases rapidly with transmission capacity and distance. Multi-terminal offshore wind power flexible DC transmission systems are not limited by transmission distance, and single-circuit submarine cables have strong transmission capacity. However, because DC current lacks a zero-crossing point, the structure of DC circuit breakers is very complex, with high size and cost. Additionally, offshore converter stations using the MMC topology are large in size and weight, resulting in high construction and transportation costs. Multi-terminal offshore wind power low-frequency transmission schemes do not require converter valves on offshore electrical platforms, which can significantly reduce the construction cost of offshore platforms. They also retain the zero-crossing characteristic of AC transmission. The circuit breakers are similar to those of power frequency AC circuit breakers, but converter valves with M3C topology are required at onshore stations, which also presents the problem of high equipment costs. The active power transmission capacity of low-frequency submarine cables is between that of power frequency AC and DC.
[0004] The above analysis shows that, for different offshore wind power project application scenarios, multi-terminal power frequency AC transmission, multi-terminal flexible DC transmission, and multi-terminal low-frequency AC transmission each have their own advantages and disadvantages in terms of construction costs. Furthermore, it is necessary to comprehensively consider factors such as system operation loss costs, regular maintenance costs, and failure loss costs to fully evaluate the economics of different transmission schemes and select the most suitable one for offshore wind power. Currently, there is no relevant research on a life-cycle cost comparison method for multi-terminal offshore wind power transmission projects, and there is an urgent need to propose a life-cycle economic comparison method for multi-terminal offshore wind power transmission projects. Summary of the Invention
[0005] The purpose of this invention is to provide a method for economic comparison of multi-terminal offshore wind power transmission projects throughout their entire life cycle. This method can comprehensively evaluate the economics of different transmission schemes by combining the operating modes of different multi-terminal transmission systems under normal operation, regular maintenance, and fault repair conditions, and select the most suitable scheme for multi-terminal offshore wind power transmission systems.
[0006] To achieve the above-mentioned objectives, this method adopts the following technical solution:
[0007] A method for economically selecting multi-terminal offshore wind power transmission projects throughout their entire life cycle is proposed. Based on the capacity and wind farm layout of the multi-terminal offshore wind power transmission project, and considering that even during the fault or periodic maintenance phase of a single branch, the system power can still be transmitted through other branches, thereby reducing fault loss costs and periodic maintenance costs, the method calculates the life cycle costs of multi-terminal offshore wind power power frequency AC transmission scheme, multi-terminal offshore wind power low frequency AC transmission scheme, and multi-terminal offshore wind power flexible DC transmission scheme, and selects the multi-terminal transmission scheme with the lowest life cycle cost as the preferred scheme.
[0008] The total life cycle cost includes one-time investment cost, failure loss cost, periodic maintenance cost, and operating loss cost, etc.
[0009] The one-time investment cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power power frequency AC transmission scheme includes the cost of power frequency aggregation submarine cable and laying, the cost of construction, transportation and installation of power frequency offshore booster station, the cost of power frequency AC transmission submarine cable and laying, the cost of power frequency AC interconnection submarine cable and laying, the construction cost of onshore control center, and the construction cost of offshore reactive power compensation station.
[0010] The one-time investment cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power low-frequency AC transmission scheme includes the cost of low-frequency collection submarine cable and laying, the construction and transportation installation cost of low-frequency offshore booster station, the cost of low-frequency AC transmission submarine cable and laying, the cost of low-frequency AC interconnection submarine cable and laying, the construction cost of onshore frequency converter station, and the increased cost of low-frequency wind turbines compared to power frequency wind turbines.
[0011] The one-time investment cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power flexible DC transmission scheme includes the cost of power frequency collection submarine cable and laying, the construction and transportation installation cost of offshore converter station, the cost of DC transmission submarine cable and laying, the cost of DC interconnection submarine cable and laying, and the construction cost of onshore converter station.
[0012] The failure loss costs of the multi-terminal offshore wind power power frequency AC transmission scheme, the multi-terminal offshore wind power low-frequency AC transmission scheme, and the multi-terminal offshore wind power flexible DC transmission scheme are all calculated based on the principle of minimizing power generation loss during maintenance by utilizing interconnecting submarine cables between multiple offshore platforms.
[0013] The periodic maintenance costs of the multi-terminal offshore wind power power frequency AC transmission scheme, the multi-terminal offshore wind power low-frequency AC transmission scheme, and the multi-terminal offshore wind power flexible DC transmission scheme are calculated based on different transmission schemes, utilizing interconnecting submarine cables between multi-terminal offshore platforms, and following the maintenance principle of minimizing power generation loss during equipment maintenance.
[0014] The operating loss cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power power frequency AC transmission scheme includes the power frequency aggregation submarine cable loss cost, the power frequency AC transmission submarine cable loss cost, the power frequency AC interconnection submarine cable loss cost, the power frequency offshore booster station and onshore control center equipment loss cost, the power frequency aggregation submarine cable marine area usage cost, the power frequency AC transmission submarine cable marine area usage cost, and the power frequency AC interconnection submarine cable marine area usage cost.
[0015] The operating loss cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power low-frequency AC transmission scheme includes the loss cost of low-frequency collection submarine cable, the loss cost of low-frequency AC transmission submarine cable, the loss cost of low-frequency AC interconnection submarine cable, the equipment loss cost of low-frequency offshore booster station and onshore frequency converter station, the marine usage cost of low-frequency collection submarine cable, the marine usage cost of low-frequency AC transmission submarine cable, and the marine usage cost of low-frequency AC interconnection submarine cable.
[0016] The operating loss cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power flexible DC transmission scheme includes the loss cost of power frequency aggregation submarine cable, the loss cost of DC transmission submarine cable, the loss cost of DC interconnection submarine cable, the equipment loss cost of offshore converter station and onshore converter station, the marine usage cost of power frequency aggregation submarine cable, the marine usage cost of DC transmission submarine cable, and the marine usage cost of DC interconnection submarine cable.
[0017] Furthermore, the periodic maintenance cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power AC transmission scheme is calculated according to the following method: the periodic maintenance cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power AC transmission scheme is calculated based on the principle that during the periodic maintenance period, the electrical equipment on each branch is maintained separately, and the active power of the branch where the equipment under maintenance is located is transmitted through other branches to minimize the loss of power generation during the maintenance phase.
[0018] Furthermore, the periodic maintenance cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power low-frequency AC transmission scheme is calculated according to the following method: The periodic maintenance cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power low-frequency AC transmission scheme is calculated based on the principle that during the periodic maintenance, the electrical equipment of the branch where the offshore low-frequency step-up transformer is located or the entire onshore frequency converter station is maintained, the active power of the branch where the equipment under maintenance is located is transmitted through other branches during the periodic maintenance of the offshore low-frequency step-up transformer, and the active power is transmitted through other onshore frequency converter stations through the interconnection submarine cables between the multi-terminal offshore platforms during the periodic maintenance of the single onshore frequency converter station, so as to minimize the loss of power generation during the maintenance phase.
[0019] Furthermore, the periodic maintenance cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power flexible DC transmission scheme is calculated according to the following method: If a symmetrical monopolar topology is adopted, the periodic maintenance cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power flexible DC transmission scheme is calculated based on the principle of maintaining a single converter station as a whole, utilizing other converter stations to transmit active power through interconnecting submarine cables between multiple offshore platforms during maintenance, thereby minimizing the system's power generation loss during the maintenance phase; if a symmetrical bipolar topology is adopted, the periodic maintenance cost is calculated based on the principle of maintaining the equipment of each pole of a single converter station separately, utilizing the other pole of this converter station and other converter stations to transmit active power through other poles during periodic maintenance, thereby minimizing the system's power generation loss during maintenance.
[0020] Furthermore, the on-state losses of the converter valve switching devices in the flexible DC transmission system are calculated using the following method:
[0021]
[0022] Among them, P Tcon , P Dcon These represent the conduction losses of the IGBT and diode in the converter valve, respectively; V CE0 V f0 The on-state voltage biases for the IGBT and diode are respectively; r CE , r f These are the on-state resistances of the IGBT and the diode, respectively; i CE i f These represent the current flowing through the devices during IGBT and diode conduction, respectively.
[0023] Furthermore, the no-load loss of the transformer is calculated using the following method:
[0024]
[0025] Among them, P T0 K represents the no-load loss of the transformer. p0 G is an additional factor for no-load loss. Fe P represents the total mass of the silicon steel sheets. t This refers to the unit mass loss of silicon steel sheets in the iron core column.
[0026] Furthermore, the load loss of the transformer is calculated using the following method:
[0027]
[0028] Among them, P TD For transformer load losses, I 1N I 2N R1 and R2 are the operating currents of the primary and secondary windings, respectively; R1 and R2 are the resistances of the primary and secondary windings, respectively.
[0029] Furthermore, the reactor losses are calculated using the following method:
[0030]
[0031] Among them, P L For reactor losses, I dc For direct current, R dc I is the DC resistance. n R is the nth harmonic current. n Let n be the resistance of the nth harmonic, where n is a natural number between 1 and 50.
[0032] The beneficial effects of this invention are:
[0033] By adopting the technical solution of this invention, and combining the operating modes of different multi-terminal transmission systems under normal operation, regular maintenance, and fault repair conditions, and comprehensively considering factors such as the one-time investment cost, operating loss cost, regular maintenance cost, and fault loss cost of different multi-terminal offshore wind power transmission schemes, the economics of different multi-terminal offshore wind power transmission schemes can be comprehensively evaluated, and the most suitable scheme can be selected for multi-terminal offshore wind power transmission systems. Attached Figure Description
[0034] Figure 1 This is a typical topology diagram of the multi-terminal offshore wind power power frequency AC transmission scheme of the present invention.
[0035] Figure 2 This is a typical topology diagram of the multi-terminal offshore wind power low-frequency AC transmission scheme of the present invention.
[0036] Figure 3 This is a typical topology diagram of the multi-terminal offshore wind power symmetrical single-pole flexible DC transmission scheme of the present invention.
[0037] Figure 4 This is a typical topology diagram of the multi-terminal offshore wind power symmetrical bipolar flexible DC transmission scheme of the present invention. Detailed Implementation
[0038] To describe the present invention in more detail, the technical solution of the present invention will be described in detail below with reference to specific embodiments.
[0039] In this embodiment of the invention, a four-terminal system consisting of two 2000MW offshore wind farms and two onshore access points is used as an example to illustrate the specific implementation of this solution. The distance between the offshore wind farm and the corresponding onshore access point is 100km, the distance between the two offshore wind farms is 20km, and the distance between the two onshore access points is 20km.
[0040] The one-time investment cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power power frequency AC transmission scheme includes the cost of power frequency aggregation submarine cables and laying, the cost of construction, transportation and installation of power frequency offshore booster stations, the cost of power frequency AC transmission submarine cables and laying, the cost of power frequency AC interconnection submarine cables and laying, the construction cost of the onshore control center, and the construction cost of the offshore reactive power compensation station.
[0041] A typical topology diagram of a multi-terminal offshore wind power power frequency AC transmission scheme is shown below. Figure 1 As shown, offshore wind turbines are connected to an offshore booster station via a power frequency collection submarine cable. After voltage boosting, they are connected to an onshore control center via a power frequency AC transmission submarine cable. The onshore control center then connects to the onshore AC power grid. An offshore reactive power compensation station is located in the middle of the power frequency AC transmission submarine cable. Multiple offshore booster stations / onshore control centers are connected by power frequency AC interconnection submarine cables. Power frequency AC circuit breakers are installed at both ends of each power frequency AC transmission submarine cable and power frequency AC interconnection submarine cable. In this embodiment of the invention, the wind farm uses a 66kV power frequency collection submarine cable. Each wind farm constructs two 500kV offshore booster stations with a total of four 500kV transformers, transmitting power through four 500kV power frequency AC submarine cables. Each onshore access point constructs one 500kV onshore control center and two offshore reactive power compensation stations. The total cost of the power frequency aggregation submarine cable and its laying is 3.216 billion yuan; the construction and transportation installation cost of the power frequency offshore booster station is 2.6 billion yuan; the cost of the power frequency AC transmission submarine cable and its laying is 11.502 billion yuan; the cost of the power frequency AC interconnection submarine cable and its laying is 2.3 billion yuan; the construction cost of the onshore control center is 720 million yuan; the construction cost of the offshore reactive power compensation station is 1.04 billion yuan; and the total one-time investment cost of the offshore wind power power frequency AC transmission scheme is 21.378 billion yuan.
[0042] The one-time investment cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power low-frequency AC transmission scheme includes the cost of low-frequency collection submarine cable and laying, the construction and transportation installation cost of low-frequency offshore booster station, the cost of low-frequency AC transmission submarine cable and laying, the cost of low-frequency AC interconnection submarine cable and laying, the construction cost of onshore frequency converter station, and the increased cost of low-frequency wind turbines compared to power frequency wind turbines.
[0043] A typical topology diagram of a multi-terminal offshore wind power low-frequency AC transmission scheme is shown below. Figure 2As shown, offshore wind turbines are connected to a low-frequency offshore booster station via a low-frequency collection submarine cable. After voltage boosting, they are connected to an onshore frequency converter station via a low-frequency AC transmission submarine cable. The onshore frequency converter station converts the frequency to 50Hz before connecting to the onshore AC power grid. Multiple low-frequency offshore booster stations / onshore frequency converter stations are connected by low-frequency AC interconnection submarine cables. Low-frequency circuit breakers are installed at both ends of each low-frequency AC transmission submarine cable and low-frequency AC interconnection submarine cable. In this embodiment of the invention, the wind farm uses a 66kV low-frequency collection submarine cable for collection. Each wind farm constructs one 500kV low-frequency offshore booster station, with a total of three 500kV low-frequency transformers. The power is transmitted through three 500kV low-frequency AC submarine cables, and one 500kV onshore frequency converter station is constructed at each onshore access point. The total cost of low-frequency collection submarine cables and their laying is RMB 2.9 billion; the construction, transportation and installation cost of low-frequency offshore booster stations is RMB 2.5 billion; the cost of low-frequency AC transmission submarine cables and their laying is RMB 8.1 billion; the cost of low-frequency AC interconnection submarine cables and their laying is RMB 1.62 billion; the construction cost of onshore frequency converter stations is RMB 3.8 billion; the cost of low-frequency wind turbines compared to power frequency wind turbines is RMB 400 million; and the total one-time investment cost of the offshore wind power low-frequency AC transmission scheme is RMB 19.32 billion.
[0044] The one-time investment cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power flexible DC transmission scheme includes the cost of power frequency aggregation submarine cable and its laying, the construction and transportation installation cost of offshore converter station, the cost of DC transmission submarine cable and its laying, the cost of DC interconnection submarine cable and its laying, and the construction cost of onshore converter station.
[0045] A typical topology diagram of a multi-terminal offshore wind power symmetrical monopolar flexible DC transmission scheme is shown below. Figure 3 As shown, offshore wind turbines are connected to offshore converter stations via power frequency collection submarine cables. After rectification to DC at the offshore converter station, the DC power is transmitted to an onshore converter station via a DC transmission submarine cable. The onshore converter station then inverts the DC power to AC and connects it to the onshore AC power grid. Multiple offshore / onshore converter stations are interconnected via DC interconnection submarine cables. DC circuit breakers are installed at both ends of each DC transmission submarine cable and DC interconnection submarine cable. In this embodiment, the wind farm uses a 66kV power frequency collection submarine cable. Each wind farm constructs one ±500kV / 2000MW symmetrical monopolar offshore converter station, transmitting power via one ±500kV DC submarine cable. Each onshore access point constructs one ±500kV / 2000MW symmetrical monopolar onshore converter station. The total cost of the power frequency aggregation submarine cable and its laying is 3.308 billion yuan, the construction and transportation installation cost of the offshore converter station is 6.46 billion yuan, the DC transmission submarine cable and its laying cost is 4.8 billion yuan, the DC interconnection submarine cable and its laying cost is 960 million yuan, the construction cost of the onshore converter station is 4.078 billion yuan, and the one-time investment cost of the offshore wind power flexible DC transmission scheme using a symmetrical monopole topology is 19.606 billion yuan.
[0046] A typical topology diagram of a multi-terminal offshore wind power symmetrical bipolar flexible DC transmission scheme is shown below. Figure 4As shown, offshore wind turbines are connected to offshore converter stations via power frequency collection submarine cables. After being rectified into DC at the offshore converter station, the DC power is transmitted to onshore converter stations via DC transmission submarine cables. The onshore converter stations then invert the DC power to AC and connect it to the onshore AC power grid. Compared to the symmetrical monopolar transmission scheme, the symmetrical bipolar scheme uses a symmetrical bipolar topology for both the offshore and onshore converter stations, and requires an additional neutral submarine cable. Multiple offshore / onshore converter stations are connected by DC interconnection submarine cables. DC circuit breakers are installed at both ends of each DC transmission submarine cable and DC interconnection submarine cable, and neutral switches are installed at both ends of the neutral submarine cable. In this embodiment of the invention, the wind farm uses a 66kV power frequency collection submarine cable for power collection. Each wind farm constructs one ±500kV / 2000MW symmetrical bipolar offshore converter station, transmitting power through one ±500kV DC submarine cable and one neutral line submarine cable. Each onshore access point constructs one ±500kV / 2000MW symmetrical bipolar onshore converter station. The cost of the power frequency collection submarine cable and its laying is 3.308 billion yuan, the construction and transportation installation cost of the offshore converter station is 7.33 billion yuan, the cost of the DC transmission submarine cable and its laying is 5.8 billion yuan, the cost of the DC interconnection submarine cable and its laying is 1.16 billion yuan, and the construction cost of the onshore converter station is 4.584 billion yuan. The total one-time investment cost of the symmetrical bipolar topology offshore wind power flexible DC transmission scheme is 22.182 billion yuan.
[0047] The operating loss cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power power frequency AC transmission scheme includes the loss cost of the power frequency collection submarine cable, the loss cost of the power frequency AC transmission submarine cable, the equipment loss cost of the power frequency offshore booster station and the onshore control center, the marine usage cost of the power frequency collection submarine cable, and the marine usage cost of the power frequency AC transmission submarine cable.
[0048] In this embodiment of the invention, the power generation loss of the power frequency collection submarine cable and the power frequency AC transmission submarine cable is calculated by multiplying the current squared by the resistance, and then multiplying by the annual equivalent loss hours; the power generation loss of the power frequency offshore booster station and onshore control center equipment is calculated by multiplying the equivalent loss coefficient of different equipment by the installed capacity, and then multiplying by the annual equivalent loss hours; the sea area usage fee for the power frequency collection submarine cable and the power frequency AC transmission submarine cable is calculated by multiplying the sea area used by the cable by the sea area usage fee per unit area. The calculated operating loss cost of the offshore wind power power frequency AC transmission scheme is 1.486 billion yuan.
[0049] The operating loss cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power low-frequency AC transmission scheme includes the loss cost of the low-frequency collection submarine cable, the loss cost of the low-frequency AC transmission submarine cable, the equipment loss cost of the low-frequency offshore booster station and onshore frequency converter station, the marine usage cost of the low-frequency collection submarine cable, and the marine usage cost of the low-frequency AC transmission submarine cable.
[0050] In this embodiment of the invention, the power generation loss of the low-frequency collection submarine cable and the low-frequency AC transmission submarine cable is calculated by multiplying the square of the current by the resistance, and then multiplying by the annual equivalent loss hours; the power generation loss of the low-frequency offshore booster station and onshore frequency converter station equipment is calculated by multiplying the equivalent loss coefficient of different equipment by the installed capacity, and then multiplying by the annual equivalent loss hours; the sea area usage fee for the low-frequency collection submarine cable and the low-frequency AC transmission submarine cable is calculated by multiplying the sea area used by the cable by the sea area usage fee per unit area. The calculated operating loss cost of the offshore wind power low-frequency AC transmission scheme is 971 million yuan.
[0051] The operating loss cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power flexible DC transmission scheme includes the loss cost of the power frequency collection submarine cable, the loss cost of the DC transmission submarine cable, the equipment loss cost of the offshore converter station and the onshore converter station, the marine usage cost of the power frequency collection submarine cable, and the marine usage cost of the DC transmission submarine cable.
[0052] In this embodiment of the invention, the power generation loss of the power frequency collection submarine cable and the DC transmission submarine cable is calculated by multiplying the current squared by the resistance, and then multiplying by the annual equivalent loss hours; the power generation loss of the offshore converter station and the onshore converter station equipment is calculated by multiplying the equivalent loss coefficient of different equipment by the installed capacity, and then multiplying by the annual equivalent loss hours; the sea area usage fee for the power frequency collection submarine cable and the DC transmission submarine cable is calculated by multiplying the sea area used by the cable by the sea area usage fee per unit area. The calculated operating loss cost of the symmetrical monopolar flexible DC transmission scheme for offshore wind power is 732 million yuan, and the operating loss cost of the symmetrical bipolar flexible DC transmission scheme for offshore wind power is 754 million yuan.
[0053] The periodic maintenance cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power AC transmission scheme is calculated based on the principle that during the periodic maintenance period, the electrical equipment on each branch is maintained separately, and the active power of the branch where the equipment under maintenance is located is transmitted through other branches to minimize the loss of power generation during the maintenance phase.
[0054] In this embodiment of the invention, each wind farm is equipped with four 500kV transformers, which are transmitted through four 500kV power frequency AC submarine cables. Each main transformer can be maintained separately, and the other three 500kV transformers are unaffected during maintenance. Furthermore, power can be transmitted from another submarine cable via interconnecting submarine cables, ensuring the entire transmission system maintains over 87.5% power transmission capacity. Each maintenance session is estimated to take 3.5 days. Given the output characteristics of offshore wind farms, the time when real-time power generation exceeds 87.5% is rare, resulting in minimal power generation loss. Maintenance is performed in months with lower average annual wind power output. Based on typical wind power output curves, the calculated cost of power generation loss due to regular maintenance over the 25-year system lifecycle is 0.03 billion yuan.
[0055] The periodic maintenance cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power low-frequency AC transmission scheme is calculated based on the principle that during the periodic maintenance period, the electrical equipment of the branch where the offshore low-frequency step-up transformer is located or the entire onshore frequency converter station is maintained, the active power of the branch where the equipment under maintenance is located is transmitted through other branches during the periodic maintenance of the offshore low-frequency step-up transformer, and the active power is transmitted through other onshore frequency converter stations through the interconnection submarine cables between the multi-terminal offshore platforms during the periodic maintenance of the single onshore frequency converter station, so as to minimize the loss of power generation in the system during the maintenance phase.
[0056] In this embodiment of the invention, during the maintenance of the onshore M3C converter valve, the corresponding onshore frequency converter station needs to be shut down. At this time, the power of the corresponding offshore wind farm can still be transmitted through another onshore frequency converter station, and the entire power transmission system can still guarantee more than 50% of the power transmission capacity. If the offshore low-frequency booster station is regularly maintained, the entire power transmission system can still guarantee more than 83% of the power transmission capacity. Each maintenance time is considered to be 3.5 days. The maintenance is carried out in the month with the lower average wind power output each year. According to the typical wind power output curve, the cost of power generation lost due to regular maintenance in the 25-year system operation life cycle is calculated to be 0.22 billion yuan.
[0057] The periodic maintenance cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power flexible DC transmission scheme can be calculated as follows: if a symmetrical monopolar topology is adopted, the power generation cost is calculated based on the principle of maintaining a single converter station as a whole, and utilizing other converter stations to transmit active power through interconnecting submarine cables between multiple offshore platforms during the maintenance period, thereby minimizing the power generation loss of the system during the maintenance phase; if a symmetrical bipolar topology is adopted, the power generation cost is calculated based on the principle of maintaining the equipment of each pole of a single converter station separately, and utilizing the principle of transmitting active power through the other pole of this converter station and other converter stations during the periodic maintenance period, thereby minimizing the power generation loss of the system during the maintenance phase.
[0058] In this embodiment of the invention, for a symmetrical monopolar topology, during the maintenance of the MMC converter valve, the corresponding converter station needs to be completely shut down. At this time, the power of the corresponding offshore wind farm can still be transmitted through another flexible DC transmission system. Each maintenance session is considered to last 3.5 days, and maintenance is performed in months with lower average annual wind power output. Based on a typical wind power output curve, the calculated cost of lost power generation due to regular maintenance over the 25-year system lifecycle is 0.72 billion yuan. For a symmetrical bipolar topology, the positive and negative poles can be maintained separately. During maintenance, the entire system can still guarantee 75% of its power transmission capacity. Each maintenance session is considered to last 3.5 days. Based on the output characteristics of offshore wind farms, maintenance is performed in months with lower average annual wind power output. The percentage of time when real-time power generation is greater than 75% is relatively small; therefore, the power generation loss is slightly greater than that of the power frequency AC transmission scheme. Based on a typical wind power output curve, the calculated cost of lost power generation due to regular maintenance over the 25-year system lifecycle is 0.24 billion yuan.
[0059] The failure loss costs of the multi-terminal offshore wind power power frequency AC transmission scheme, the multi-terminal offshore wind power low-frequency AC transmission scheme, and the multi-terminal offshore wind power flexible DC transmission scheme are all calculated based on the principle that during the maintenance period, the system connected to the faulty submarine cable or electrical equipment stops operating, while the other systems operate normally.
[0060] In this embodiment of the invention, for the power frequency AC transmission scheme, a total of four 500kV transformers are installed, transmitting power through four 500kV power frequency AC submarine cables. During a fault, even if a single major device, such as a transformer or submarine cable, fails, the remaining devices can still guarantee 87.5% of the power transmission capacity. Since the timing of the fault is random, the power generation loss during the fault should be calculated based on the annual average power generation. Furthermore, since the location of the fault is also random, and the maintenance time for different devices varies significantly, the outage time caused by a single fault should also be calculated using the average of different fault outage times. Based on typical wind power output curves and combined with practical engineering experience, the cost of power generation loss per fault is calculated to be 0.02 billion.
[0061] For low-frequency AC transmission schemes, a failure in a single major device, such as the M3C converter valve or the bridge arm reactor, will cause the entire system to stop operating, resulting in the loss of all power generation. However, if a failure occurs in the low-frequency transmission submarine cable, the system will still retain more than 83% of its transmission capacity. The wind turbine output during a fault is calculated based on the annual average power generation, and the outage time caused by a single fault is calculated based on the average value. Based on typical wind power output curves and practical engineering experience, the cost of power generation loss per fault is calculated to be 0.04 billion.
[0062] For a symmetrical monopolar flexible DC transmission scheme, if a single major device, such as a converter valve or submarine cable, fails, the corresponding flexible DC system will cease operation. The active power of the corresponding wind farm can still be transmitted through another flexible DC transmission system, maintaining 50% of the system's transmission capacity. Wind turbine output during the fault period is calculated based on the annual average power generation, and the outage time caused by a single fault is calculated using the average value. Based on typical wind power output curves and practical engineering experience, the cost of power generation loss per fault is calculated to be 148 million.
[0063] For a symmetrical bipolar flexible DC transmission scheme, even if a single major device, such as a single-pole converter valve, transformer, or submarine cable fails, the entire system can still guarantee 75% of its power transmission capacity. The wind turbine output during a fault is calculated based on the annual average power generation, and the outage time caused by a single fault is calculated based on the average value. Based on typical wind power output curves and combined with practical engineering experience, the cost of power generation loss per fault is calculated to be 0.23 billion.
[0064] Based on the above calculations, in this embodiment of the invention, the life-cycle cost of different transmission schemes is calculated according to the assumption of one failure within the entire life-cycle. The life-cycle cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power power frequency AC transmission scheme is 22.869 billion yuan, the multi-terminal offshore wind power low-frequency AC transmission scheme is 20.317 billion yuan, the multi-terminal offshore wind power symmetrical monopolar flexible DC transmission scheme is 20.458 billion yuan, and the multi-terminal offshore wind power symmetrical bipolar flexible DC transmission scheme is 22.983 billion yuan. Therefore, for this embodiment of the invention, the multi-terminal offshore wind power low-frequency AC transmission scheme is the most economically efficient transmission scheme throughout its life-cycle.
[0065] The above description of the embodiments is provided to enable those skilled in the art to understand and apply the present invention. It will be apparent to those skilled in the art that various modifications can be made to the above embodiments, and the general principles described herein can be applied to other embodiments without inventive effort. Therefore, the present invention is not limited to the above embodiments, and any improvements and modifications made to the present invention by those skilled in the art based on the disclosure thereof should be within the scope of protection of the present invention.
Claims
1. A method for economic comparison of multi-terminal offshore wind power transmission projects throughout their entire life cycle, characterized in that, Based on the capacity and wind farm layout of multi-terminal offshore wind power transmission projects, and considering the ability to transmit system power through other branches even during single branch failures or periodic maintenance, the life-cycle costs of multi-terminal offshore wind power power frequency AC transmission schemes, multi-terminal offshore wind power low-frequency AC transmission schemes, and multi-terminal offshore wind power flexible DC transmission schemes are calculated. The multi-terminal transmission scheme with the lowest life-cycle cost is selected as the preferred scheme. The life-cycle cost includes one-time investment cost, failure loss cost, periodic maintenance cost, and operating loss cost. The one-time investment cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power power frequency AC transmission scheme includes the cost of power frequency aggregation submarine cable and laying, the cost of construction, transportation and installation of power frequency offshore booster station, the cost of power frequency AC transmission submarine cable and laying, the cost of power frequency AC interconnection submarine cable and laying, the construction cost of onshore control center, and the construction cost of offshore reactive power compensation station. The one-time investment cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power low-frequency AC transmission scheme includes the cost of low-frequency collection submarine cable and laying, the construction and transportation installation cost of low-frequency offshore booster station, the cost of low-frequency AC transmission submarine cable and laying, the cost of low-frequency AC interconnection submarine cable and laying, the construction cost of onshore frequency converter station, and the increased cost of low-frequency wind turbines compared to power frequency wind turbines. The one-time investment cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power flexible DC transmission scheme includes the cost of power frequency collection submarine cable and laying, the construction and transportation installation cost of offshore converter station, the cost of DC transmission submarine cable and laying, the cost of DC interconnection submarine cable and laying, and the construction cost of onshore converter station. The failure loss costs of the multi-terminal offshore wind power power frequency AC transmission scheme, the multi-terminal offshore wind power low-frequency AC transmission scheme, and the multi-terminal offshore wind power flexible DC transmission scheme are all calculated based on the principle of minimizing power generation loss during maintenance by utilizing interconnecting submarine cables between multiple offshore platforms. The periodic maintenance costs of the multi-terminal offshore wind power power frequency AC transmission scheme, the multi-terminal offshore wind power low-frequency AC transmission scheme, and the multi-terminal offshore wind power flexible DC transmission scheme are calculated based on different transmission schemes, utilizing interconnecting submarine cables between multi-terminal offshore platforms, and following the maintenance principle of minimizing power generation loss during equipment maintenance. The operating loss cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power power frequency AC transmission scheme includes the power frequency aggregation submarine cable loss cost, the power frequency AC transmission submarine cable loss cost, the power frequency AC interconnection submarine cable loss cost, the power frequency offshore booster station and onshore control center equipment loss cost, the power frequency aggregation submarine cable marine area usage cost, the power frequency AC transmission submarine cable marine area usage cost, and the power frequency AC interconnection submarine cable marine area usage cost. The operating loss cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power low-frequency AC transmission scheme includes the loss cost of low-frequency collection submarine cable, the loss cost of low-frequency AC transmission submarine cable, the loss cost of low-frequency AC interconnection submarine cable, the equipment loss cost of low-frequency offshore booster station and onshore frequency converter station, the marine usage cost of low-frequency collection submarine cable, the marine usage cost of low-frequency AC transmission submarine cable, and the marine usage cost of low-frequency AC interconnection submarine cable. The operating loss cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power flexible DC transmission scheme includes the loss cost of power frequency aggregation submarine cable, the loss cost of DC transmission submarine cable, the loss cost of DC interconnection submarine cable, the equipment loss cost of offshore converter station and onshore converter station, the marine usage cost of power frequency aggregation submarine cable, the marine usage cost of DC transmission submarine cable, and the marine usage cost of DC interconnection submarine cable.
2. The method for economic comparison of multi-terminal offshore wind power transmission projects throughout their entire life cycle, as described in claim 1, is characterized in that... The periodic maintenance cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power AC transmission scheme is calculated according to the following method: the periodic maintenance cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power AC transmission scheme is calculated based on the principle that during the periodic maintenance period, the electrical equipment on each branch is maintained separately, and the active power of the branch where the equipment under maintenance is located is transmitted through other branches, so as to minimize the loss of power generation during the maintenance phase.
3. The method for economic comparison of multi-terminal offshore wind power transmission projects throughout their entire life cycle, as described in claim 1, is characterized in that... The periodic maintenance cost of the multi-terminal offshore wind power low-frequency AC transmission scheme is calculated according to the following method: During the periodic maintenance period, the electrical equipment of the branch where the offshore low-frequency step-up transformer is located or the entire onshore frequency converter station is maintained. During the periodic maintenance of the offshore low-frequency step-up transformer, the active power of the branch where the equipment under maintenance is located is transmitted through other branches. During the maintenance of the entire onshore frequency converter station, the active power is transmitted through other onshore frequency converter stations via the interconnecting submarine cables between the multi-terminal offshore platforms, in order to minimize the loss of power generation during the maintenance phase.
4. The method for economic comparison of multi-terminal offshore wind power transmission projects throughout their entire life cycle, as described in claim 1, is characterized in that... The periodic maintenance cost of a multi-terminal offshore wind power flexible DC transmission scheme is calculated using the following methods: If a symmetrical monopolar topology is adopted, the cost of lost power generation is calculated based on the principle of maintaining a single converter station as a whole, utilizing the interconnecting submarine cables between multiple offshore platforms during maintenance to transmit active power from other converter stations, thus minimizing power generation loss during the maintenance phase. If a symmetrical bipolar topology is adopted, the cost of lost power generation is calculated based on the principle of maintaining the equipment of each pole of a single converter station separately, utilizing the other pole of the same converter station and other converter stations during periodic maintenance to minimize power generation loss during the maintenance phase.
5. The method for economic comparison of multi-terminal offshore wind power transmission projects throughout their entire life cycle, as described in claim 1, is characterized in that... The on-state losses of the converter valve switching devices in a flexible DC transmission system are calculated using the following method: Among them, P Tcon , P Dcon These represent the conduction losses of the IGBT and diode in the converter valve, respectively; V CE0 V f0 The on-state voltage biases for the IGBT and diode are respectively; r CE , r f These are the on-state resistances of the IGBT and the diode, respectively; i CE i f These represent the current flowing through the devices during IGBT and diode conduction, respectively.
6. The method for economic comparison of multi-terminal offshore wind power transmission projects throughout their entire life cycle, as described in claim 1, is characterized in that... The no-load loss of the transformer is calculated using the following method: Among them, P T0 K represents the no-load loss of the transformer. p0 G is an additional factor for no-load loss. Fe P represents the total mass of the silicon steel sheets. t This refers to the unit mass loss of silicon steel sheets in the iron core column.
7. The method for economic comparison of multi-terminal offshore wind power transmission projects throughout their entire life cycle, as described in claim 1, is characterized in that... The load loss of the transformer is calculated using the following method: Among them, P TD For transformer load losses, I 1N I 2N R1 and R2 are the operating currents of the primary and secondary windings, respectively; R1 and R2 are the resistances of the primary and secondary windings, respectively.
8. The method for economic comparison of multi-terminal offshore wind power transmission projects throughout their entire life cycle, as described in claim 1, is characterized in that... The reactor loss is calculated using the following method: Among them, P L For reactor losses, I dc For direct current, R dc I is the DC resistance. n R is the nth harmonic current. n Let n be the resistance of the nth harmonic, where n is a natural number between 1 and 50.
