A CrC multilayer coating, its preparation method and application

By using ion source-assisted magnetron sputtering and plasma nitriding techniques, the ionization of reactive gases is controlled in stages to prepare CrC multilayer coatings. This solves the problems of interface oxidation, compositional abrupt changes, and stress concentration in chromium carbide coatings, and improves the bonding strength and stability of the coatings, making them suitable for high-precision bearings and heavy-duty molds.

CN123108478APending Publication Date: 2026-11-17BEIJING JIAOTONG UNIV
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202611197377.X
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2026-08-07
Publication Date
2026-11-17

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing chromium carbide coating preparation processes suffer from problems such as interface oxidation, adsorption contamination, abrupt changes in interlayer composition, and stress concentration, resulting in insufficient coating bonding strength and failing to meet the long-life service requirements of high-precision bearings and heavy-duty molds.

Method used

An ion source-assisted magnetron sputtering process is employed, in which Cr, CrN, CrCN and CrC layers are deposited sequentially by selectively ionizing the reactive gas through staged control of the ion source. Combined with plasma nitriding technology, a continuous performance transition region is formed, avoiding interfacial oxidation and abrupt compositional changes, thereby improving the film density and bonding strength.

Benefits of technology

It improves the adhesion and interfacial stability of the coating, reduces interfacial stress concentration, and enhances the film-substrate bonding strength, meeting the long service life requirements of high-precision bearings and heavy-duty molds.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN123108478A_ABST
    Figure CN123108478A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

This invention relates to the field of surface coating technology, and discloses a CrC multilayer coating, its preparation method, and its application. The disclosed method for preparing a CrC multilayer coating includes using an ion-source assisted magnetron sputtering process in a vacuum chamber, selectively ionizing the reactive gases in stages, and sequentially depositing a Cr layer, a CrN layer, a CrCN layer, and a CrC layer. Nitrogen gas is ionized during CrN layer deposition, only nitrogen gas is ionized during CrCN layer deposition, acetylene is directly introduced without ionization, and acetylene is ionized during CrC layer deposition. This invention, by differentially controlling the ionization state of the reactive gases in stages, avoids excessive acetylene decomposition in the CrCN layer to generate a carbon-rich phase, ensuring a continuous and smooth transition of coating components, reducing residual stress at the interface, and, combined with a continuous nitriding process in the same furnace, avoiding oxidation contamination during workpiece transfer, effectively improving the film-substrate bonding stability and the coating's wear resistance and anti-stripping performance.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] This invention relates to the field of surface coating technology, specifically to a CrC multilayer coating, its preparation method, and its application. Background Technology

[0002] Rolling bearings are core components in the transmission systems of high-end equipment. Operating under prolonged conditions of high temperature, high speed, and high torque, rolling bearings are prone to friction and wear. The coating on the rolling elements is easily peeled off due to impact loads, making wear a major cause of bearing failure. To overcome this challenge, researching bearing protective coatings with strong adhesion is crucial for controlling friction, improving equipment precision, and extending service life.

[0003] Chromium carbide coatings possess advantages such as high hardness, wear resistance, and chemical stability, and are currently widely used in surface protection applications for bearings, molds, and rolling contact components. However, existing chromium carbide coating preparation processes have significant drawbacks: Currently, the main process for preparing chromium carbide coatings is physical vapor deposition (PVD). While PVD has a lower deposition temperature compared to chemical vapor deposition (CVD), making it more suitable for surface strengthening of parts with high dimensional stability requirements, existing PVD processes for preparing chromium carbide coatings suffer from significant differences in hardness and elastic modulus between the hard chromium carbide coating and the steel substrate. This leads to interfacial stress concentration under rolling contact or impact loads, resulting in film cracking, peeling, and service failure. To improve the substrate's load-bearing capacity, current technologies perform nitriding before deposition. However, traditional nitriding and coating deposition processes are often carried out in steps. After nitriding, the workpiece needs to be transferred to the coating chamber in an open furnace. The substrate surface rapidly forms an oxide film and absorbs oil and impurities upon contact with air, disrupting the substrate's activation state and significantly weakening the bond strength between the nitrided transition layer and the Cr layer. Under heavy loads, this makes the entire layer prone to peeling off.

[0004] Current chromium carbide coating preparation processes suffer from abrupt changes in the composition of the gradient transition layer and internal stress concentration issues. In conventional processes for depositing the CrCN transition layer, nitrogen and acetylene are simultaneously ionized using an ion source. However, the low acetylene ionization energy leads to excessive decomposition under high-energy ion bombardment, prematurely generating a large amount of carbon-rich hard phase in the CrN-CrC transition region. This results in a precipitous drop in carbon and nitrogen content, a sharp increase in interlayer residual stress, and a tendency for transverse microcracks to initiate under frictional loads, shortening component lifespan. If no ion source is used throughout the process, the gas ionization rate is low, resulting in insufficient energy for deposited particles, leading to a porous and poorly dense coating with significantly reduced wear resistance.

[0005] In summary, there is currently a lack of an integrated process that effectively combines plasma nitriding, continuous operation in the same furnace, and segmented selective ionization to prepare multilayer gradient chromium carbide coatings. This makes it impossible to simultaneously solve problems such as workpiece oxidation contamination and abrupt changes in interlayer composition, and it is difficult to meet the long service life requirements of high-precision bearings and heavy-duty molds. Summary of the Invention

[0006] The present invention provides a method for preparing CrC multilayer coatings, which avoids the problems of interface oxidation, adsorption contamination and surface activation state decay caused by the exposure of the workpiece to air in traditional step-by-step processes. It can also alleviate interface stress concentration, improve the film-substrate bonding stability, and reduce residual stress concentration caused by compositional abrupt changes at the gradient interface, thereby improving the interfacial stability and anti-peeling ability of the film layer.

[0007] In a first aspect, the present invention provides a method for preparing a CrC multilayer coating. In a vacuum chamber, an ion source-assisted magnetron sputtering process is used to sequentially deposit a Cr layer, a CrN layer, a CrCN layer and a CrC layer on the substrate surface by selectively ionizing the reactive gas in stages. When depositing the CrN layer, nitrogen was selected as the reaction gas. The nitrogen was ionized by the ion source and then introduced into the vacuum chamber. When depositing the CrCN layer, nitrogen and acetylene are selected as the reaction gases. Nitrogen is ionized by an ion source and then introduced into the vacuum chamber, while acetylene is directly introduced into the vacuum chamber without being ionized by an ion source. When depositing the CrC top layer, acetylene is selected as the reaction gas. The acetylene is ionized by an ion source and then introduced into the vacuum chamber.

[0008] The carbon source for CrC coatings prepared by traditional magnetron sputtering technology is usually derived from reactive gases such as methane and acetylene. The reactive gases are mainly dissociated and activated through electron collisions. The proportion of high-energy active particles formed is relatively low compared with thermionic and multi-arc ion plating technologies. Furthermore, in the process of preparing CrC coatings by low-temperature magnetron sputtering, due to the relatively limited energy of the deposited particles and the low gas ionization rate, the film layer is prone to forming internal pores and loose structures during growth, which limits the improvement of film density and film-substrate bonding strength. On the other hand, CrC coatings prepared using the high ionization rate of cathode arc ion plating technology have a rough structure, are prone to forming large particles, and have poor film quality. To address the aforementioned issues, this invention introduces an ion source-assisted mechanism during the magnetron sputtering deposition process. By adjusting the ion source parameters, nitrogen and acetylene reactive gases are activated to generate high-energy N ions and carbon-containing active ions, thereby increasing the ionization rate of the working gas and promoting bonding with metal Cr ions. Simultaneously, high-energy ion bombardment provides additional surface energy to the deposited particles, enhancing the surface migration and diffusion capabilities of the deposited atoms. This promotes the filling of pores and densification of the film, reducing the loose structure and defects formed during film growth. For weakly bonded particles formed during deposition, high-energy ion bombardment can also resputter or inhibit adhesion, thus improving the coating adhesion.

[0009] The ion source-assisted magnetron sputtering process used in this invention utilizes a strengthening scheme that enhances the substrate's load-bearing capacity, designs a gradient transition layer structure, improves the ionization rate of the working gas, and uses high-energy particle bombardment to form a dense surface. The resulting CrC thin film has advantages such as excellent adhesion, dense structure, smooth surface, controllable composition, and excellent mechanical properties.

[0010] In existing ion source-assisted coating methods, the ion source employs a uniform gas ionization mode throughout the coating process. However, this uniform mode cannot adapt to the actual needs of different functional films. To solve the above problems, this invention uses a staged control method to selectively ionize the reactive gas with the ion source on the substrate surface, sequentially depositing Cr, CrN, CrCN, and CrC layers.

[0011] This invention employs a unique "staged, selective" ion source-assisted method. During gradient coating deposition, the ionization degree of the reactant gas is dynamically controlled in stages according to the composition and performance requirements of different film layers. In the CrN layer deposition stage, the ionization rate of the N2 reactant gas is preferentially increased to promote the dense growth of the high-hardness nitride layer. In the CrCN gradient layer deposition stage, only N2 is ionized with assisted ion source, while C2H2 is directly introduced into the vacuum chamber to participate in the deposition reaction without ion source ionization. This is because acetylene has a low first ionization energy; if acetylene is ionized, it will lead to excessive acetylene decomposition, causing a rapid increase in the concentration of highly reactive carbon particles in the CrCN layer. This can easily lead to the premature formation of a carbon-rich CrC phase in the CrCN layer, thereby disrupting the continuous gradient transition between the CrN and CrC layers and causing residual stress concentration at the interface. Secondly, by controlling the ionization degree of the acetylene reactant gas, the tendency for excessive deposition of highly reactive carbon particles on the target surface can be reduced, which is beneficial to improving the stability of the deposition process. During the CrC top-layer deposition stage, the acetylene reactive gas ionization rate is further increased to enhance the compactness and lubrication performance of the top low-friction functional layer. Through the above-mentioned staged and selective reactive gas activation control, the residual stress concentration caused by abrupt changes in composition at the gradient interface can be effectively reduced, thereby improving the interfacial stability and anti-stripping ability of the film layer.

[0012] In one alternative implementation, the base material may be GCr15 or ZGCr15 bearing steel.

[0013] In one alternative embodiment, a nitriding layer prepared using plasma nitriding technology is further provided between the substrate surface and the Cr layer.

[0014] In one alternative implementation, the nitriding layer and the Cr layer, CrN layer, and CrCN layer are completed in the same vacuum environment.

[0015] Although existing technologies have designed gradient structures for Cr / CrN / CrC multilayer coatings, the significant difference in hardness and elastic modulus between the hard CrC coating and the steel substrate makes them prone to interfacial stress concentration under rolling contact or impact load conditions, leading to film cracking, peeling, and service failure. To improve the substrate's load-bearing capacity, existing technologies perform nitriding treatment before deposition. However, traditional nitriding and coating deposition processes are often carried out in steps, requiring the workpiece to be exposed to air after nitriding before being transferred to the coating equipment. This results in oxidation, adsorption contamination, and deactivation of the activated state on the nitrided layer surface, weakening the bonding strength between the nitrided layer and subsequent coatings.

[0016] To address the aforementioned issues, this invention incorporates nitriding between the substrate surface and the Cr layer to enhance surface load-bearing capacity. Simultaneously, ion source-assisted magnetron sputtering is used to construct a multi-layer coating. Through the synergistic effect of these two methods, the properties of both the substrate and the coating continuously transition to the interface region, ultimately creating a continuous performance transition zone between the substrate and the coating. This alleviates interfacial stress concentration and improves the stability of the film-substrate bond. Furthermore, in this invention, both ion nitriding and multi-layer composite coating deposition are based on the same ion source-assisted system and are continuously completed under the same vacuum environment. After nitriding, there is no need to open the furnace and transfer the workpiece; subsequent coating deposition can be performed directly in the existing vacuum environment. This avoids problems such as interfacial oxidation, adsorption contamination, and surface activation state decay that occur when the workpiece is exposed to air in traditional step-by-step processes, thus facilitating process stability control and improving coating consistency.

[0017] In one alternative embodiment, the nitriding layer has a thickness of 0.1-3 μm; the total thickness of the Cr layer, CrN layer and CrCN layer is 0.5-3 μm; and the thickness of the CrC layer is 1-5 μm.

[0018] In one optional embodiment, before applying the nitriding layer to the substrate surface, the substrate needs to be pretreated by placing it in a vacuum chamber for fixation and then evacuating it to a vacuum level of 2×10⁻⁶. -3 -8×10 -3 Pa, using an ion source to etch the substrate surface for 10-90 minutes.

[0019] In this invention, pretreatment of the substrate can remove the oxide layer on the substrate surface, activate and keep the substrate surface clean, remove weakly bonded particles, and reduce surface roughness.

[0020] In one optional embodiment, during the preparation of the nitriding layer, the ambient temperature for plasma nitriding of the substrate is 250-400℃, nitrogen gas is introduced for nitriding for 300-500 min, the bias voltage is 300-500V, the gas pressure is 0.3-0.7Pa, the ion source voltage is 800-1500V, and the ion current is 100-200mA.

[0021] In one optional embodiment, the deposition process of the Cr layer is as follows: in an argon atmosphere, the Cr target is turned on, the sputtering current of the Cr target is 5-10A, the temperature is 100-300°C, the bias voltage is 60-100V, the gas pressure is 0.3-0.7Pa, and the deposition time is 10-40min.

[0022] In one optional embodiment, the deposition process of the CrN layer is as follows: the argon gas flow rate is adjusted to 100-200 sccm, the Cr target sputtering current is 5-10A, the temperature is 100-300°C, the bias voltage is 60-100V, nitrogen gas is ionized by an ion source and then introduced into the vacuum chamber, the nitrogen gas flow rate is gradually increased from 0 to 50-90 sccm, the ion source voltage is 500-1500V, the ion current is 50-200mA, the gas pressure is 0.3-0.7Pa, and the deposition time is 30-150min.

[0023] In one optional embodiment, the deposition process of the CrCN layer is as follows: the argon gas flow rate is adjusted to 100-200 sccm, the Cr target sputtering current is 5-10 A, the acetylene flow rate is gradually increased from 0 to 30-60 sccm, the temperature is 100-300°C, the bias voltage is 60-100 V, nitrogen gas is ionized by an ion source and then introduced into the vacuum chamber, the nitrogen gas flow rate is adjusted to gradually decrease from 60-90 sccm to 0, the ion source voltage is 500-1500 V, the ion current is 50-200 mA, the gas pressure is 0.3-0.7 Pa, and the deposition time is 10-60 min.

[0024] In one optional embodiment, the CrC top-layer deposition process is as follows: the argon gas flow rate is adjusted to 100-200 sccm, the Cr target sputtering current is 5-10 A, the deposition temperature is 100-300℃, the bias voltage is 60-100 V, acetylene is ionized by an ion source and then introduced into the vacuum chamber, the acetylene flow rate is 30-120 sccm, the ion source voltage is 500-1500 V, the ion current is 50-200 mA, the gas pressure is maintained at 0.3-0.7 Pa, and the deposition time is 10-60 min.

[0025] Secondly, the present invention provides a CrC multilayer coating prepared by the above-described CrC multilayer coating preparation method.

[0026] The multilayer coating prepared by this invention exhibits excellent adhesion. During the deposition process, selective ion source activation of the working gas increases the energy of the deposited particles, enabling them to migrate and diffuse more fully on the surface, thus forming a dense film. Furthermore, the high-energy ions generated by the ion source continuously bombard the growing film, sputtering away large, weakly bonded particles and enhancing the film's adhesion. In addition, the synergistic effect of the nitriding layer and the multilayer coating structure creates a two-way performance match, effectively mitigating stress concentration at the film-substrate interface and improving the stability of the film-substrate bond.

[0027] Thirdly, the present invention also provides an application of a CrC multilayer coating preparation method in improving the bonding stability of the film substrate (i.e., chromium carbide coating and steel substrate).

[0028] The technical solution of this invention has the following advantages: 1. The CrC multilayer coating preparation method provided by this invention adopts a staged control method for selectively ionizing reactant gases using an ion source. Based on the different composition and performance requirements of the Cr, CrN, CrCN, and CrC layers, the method differentiates whether the reactant gases undergo ion source ionization. During the CrCN transition layer deposition stage, acetylene is not ionized, avoiding premature formation of the carbon-rich phase due to excessive acetylene decomposition. This ensures a continuous transition of the composition gradient between the CrN and CrC layers, reducing residual interfacial stress caused by abrupt compositional changes. In the CrN and CrC top layer deposition stages, nitrogen and acetylene are selectively ionized, respectively, improving the density and lubrication performance of the corresponding functional layers. Simultaneously, ion source-assisted magnetron sputtering is used throughout the process to complete the multilayer film deposition, increasing the gas ionization rate, promoting bonding with metallic Cr ions, and continuously bombarding the deposition surface with high-energy ions. This enhances the surface migration and diffusion capabilities of deposited atoms, filling the internal pores of the film. Sputtering removes weakly bonded particles from the surface, significantly improving the coating density and interfacial bonding strength.

[0029] 2. The CrC multilayer coating preparation method provided by the present invention adopts a continuous diffusion plating process in the same furnace. Plasma nitriding and multilayer coating deposition share a set of ion source systems and are completed continuously in the same vacuum environment. After nitriding, there is no need to open the furnace and transfer the workpiece, which avoids interface contamination problems such as oxidation of the workpiece when it comes into contact with air, adsorption of surface impurities, and decay of the active state of the substrate. At the same time, it is conducive to achieving stable control of the process and improving the consistency of coating preparation.

[0030] 3. The CrC multilayer coating prepared by the above-described CrC multilayer coating preparation method provided by this invention has a dense structure, tight interlayer bonding, and good adhesion. Through the synergistic effect of the nitriding layer and the multilayer coating structure design, a two-way performance matching is formed, which can alleviate stress concentration at the membrane-substrate interface and further improve the membrane-substrate bonding stability. According to the VDI 3198 criterion, the membrane-substrate bonding strength can reach HF1. Attached Figure Description

[0031] To more clearly illustrate the specific embodiments of the present invention or the technical solutions in the prior art, the drawings used in the description of the specific embodiments or the prior art will be briefly introduced below. Obviously, the drawings described below are some embodiments of this application. For those skilled in the art, other drawings can be obtained from these drawings without creative effort.

[0032] Figure 1 This is a process flow diagram of the technical solution described in Embodiment 1 of the present invention; Figure 2 This is a schematic diagram of the structure of the coating prepared by the preparation method of Example 1 of the present invention; Figure 3 This is a diagram showing the indentation morphology results of the indentation test in Embodiment 1 of the present invention; Figure 4 This is a diagram showing the indentation morphology of Embodiment 2 of the present invention; Figure 5 This is a diagram showing the indentation morphology of Example 3 of the present invention; Figure 6 This is a diagram showing the indentation morphology of Example 4 of the present invention; Figure 7 This is a diagram showing the indentation morphology of Example 5 of the present invention; Figure 8 This is a diagram showing the scratch test results of Embodiment 1 of the present invention; Figure 9 This is a diagram showing the scratch test results of Embodiment 2 of the present invention; Figure 10 This is a diagram showing the scratch test results of Embodiment 3 of the present invention; Figure 11 This is a diagram showing the scratch test results of Embodiment 4 of the present invention; Figure 12 This is a diagram showing the scratch test results of Embodiment 5 of the present invention; Figure 13 This is a cross-sectional topographic view of Embodiment 1 of the present invention; Figure 14 This is a cross-sectional topographic view of Embodiment 2 of the present invention; Figure 15 This is a cross-sectional topographic view of Embodiment 3 of the present invention; Figure 16 This is a cross-sectional topographic view of Embodiment 4 of the present invention; Figure 17 This is a cross-sectional topographic view of Embodiment 5 of the present invention. Detailed Implementation

[0033] The following embodiments are provided to better understand the present invention, but the following embodiments do not constitute a limitation on the content and scope of protection of the present invention. Any product that is the same as or similar to the present invention, derived by any person under the guidance of the present invention or by combining the features of this application with other prior art, falls within the scope of protection of the present invention.

[0034] Unless otherwise specified, all experimental steps or conditions in the examples were performed according to conventional experimental procedures and conditions in the art. Reagents or instruments whose manufacturers are not specified are all commercially available products.

[0035] Example 1 This embodiment provides a method for preparing a CrC multilayer gradient composite coating on the surface of a GCr15 substrate, such as... Figure 1 and Figure 2 As shown, the specific preparation process is as follows: (1) Matrix pretreatment After grinding and polishing the GCr15 substrate, the surface oil was first removed by immersion in industrial alcohol and then ultrasonically cleaned in deionized water for 30 minutes to thoroughly remove surface grease, wax, and dust impurities. The cleaned and dried substrate was then fixed to the workpiece holder in the vacuum chamber, and the vacuum chamber was evacuated to 8×10⁻⁶. -3 Pa is used to etch the GCr15 substrate.

[0036] Argon gas with a purity greater than or equal to 99.999% was introduced into the vacuum chamber, with 50 sccm of argon gas being directly introduced into the vacuum chamber and 30 sccm of argon gas being ionized by the ion source before being introduced into the vacuum chamber; the vacuum chamber pressure was adjusted to 0.2 Pa, and the ion source voltage was set to 1700 V and the ion current to 170 mA; a pulsed negative bias voltage of 200 V was applied to the substrate, with a bias pulse frequency of 10 kHz and a pulse duration of 90 μs, and the etching was continued for 40 min to remove the surface oxide layer.

[0037] (2) Plasma nitriding After etching is completed, the ion nitriding process begins. The etching argon gas is turned off, and all nitrogen gas is ionized through the ion source and then introduced into the vacuum chamber. The nitrogen flow rate is kept constant at 170 sccm, and the vacuum chamber pressure is 0.3 Pa. The ion source voltage is set to 1000 V, the ion current to 140 mA, the substrate bias voltage to be kept constant at 400 V, and the furnace temperature is kept stable at 300 °C. Ion nitriding is carried out continuously for 5 hours to prepare a nitrided layer on the substrate surface.

[0038] (3) Cr deposited layer After nitriding, the furnace temperature was allowed to cool naturally to 200℃ before Cr layer deposition was initiated. Argon gas was directly introduced into the vacuum chamber at a constant flow rate of 160 sccm to maintain the working pressure of the vacuum chamber at 0.4 Pa. The Cr planar target was activated, and the sputtering current was set to a constant 7 A. A pulsed negative bias of 80 V was applied to the substrate, with a pulse frequency of 10 kHz and a pulse duration of 90 μs. Continuous deposition was carried out for 15 min to prepare a dense Cr layer.

[0039] (4) Deposition of CrN layer Maintain a constant furnace temperature of 200℃ and a constant working pressure of 0.4Pa in the vacuum chamber. Turn on the Cr planar target and set the sputtering current to a constant 7A. Apply a pulsed negative bias voltage of 80V to the substrate, with a pulse frequency of 10kHz and a pulse duration of 90μs. Directly introduce argon gas into the vacuum chamber at a flow rate of 150sccm. Nitrogen gas is introduced into the vacuum chamber after being ionized by the ion source. The initial flow rate of nitrogen gas is set to 0sccm, and the final flow rate is set to 60sccm, which is increased linearly during the deposition process. Set the ion source voltage to 1000V, the ion current to 140mA, and the deposition time to 105min.

[0040] (5) Deposition of CrCN layer The furnace temperature was kept constant at 200℃, the working pressure of the vacuum chamber was 0.4Pa, the sputtering current of the Cr target was 7A, the substrate pulse bias voltage was 80V, the pulse frequency was 10KHZ, and the pulse time was 90μs.

[0041] Argon gas was directly introduced into the vacuum chamber at a flow rate of 140 sccm; acetylene was introduced directly into the vacuum chamber without passing through an ion source, with an initial flow rate of 0 sccm and a final flow rate of 50 sccm, which increased linearly during the deposition process; nitrogen gas was ionized through an ion source before being introduced into the vacuum chamber, with the flow rate decreasing linearly from 90 sccm to 0 sccm during the deposition process. The ion source voltage was set to 1000V, the ion current to 140mA, and the deposition time was 30 min.

[0042] (6) Deposited CrC layer The furnace temperature was kept constant at 200℃, the working pressure of the vacuum chamber was 0.4Pa, the sputtering current of the Cr target was 7A, the substrate pulse bias voltage was 80V, the pulse frequency was 10KHZ, and the pulse time was 90μs.

[0043] Argon gas was directly introduced into the vacuum chamber at a flow rate of 160 sccm; acetylene was ionized by an ion source and then introduced into the vacuum chamber at a flow rate of 70 sccm. The ion source voltage was set to 1000V, the ion current to 100mA, and the deposition time was 60 min.

[0044] Example 2 This embodiment provides a method for preparing a CrC multilayer gradient composite coating on the surface of a GCr15 substrate. The specific preparation process is as follows: (1) Matrix pretreatment After grinding and polishing the GCr15 substrate, the surface oil was first removed by immersion in industrial alcohol and then ultrasonically cleaned in deionized water for 60 minutes to thoroughly remove surface grease, wax, and dust impurities. The cleaned and dried substrate was then fixed to the workpiece holder in the vacuum chamber, and the vacuum chamber was evacuated to 8×10⁻⁶. -3 Pa is used to etch the GCr15 substrate.

[0045] Argon gas with a purity greater than or equal to 99.999% was introduced into the vacuum chamber, with 50 sccm of argon gas being directly introduced into the vacuum chamber and 30 sccm of argon gas being ionized by the ion source before being introduced into the vacuum chamber; the vacuum chamber pressure was adjusted to 0.2 Pa, and the ion source voltage was set to 1700 V and the ion current to 170 mA; a pulsed negative bias voltage of 200 V was applied to the substrate, with a bias pulse frequency of 10 kHz and a pulse duration of 90 μs, and the etching was continued for 40 min to remove the surface oxide layer.

[0046] (2) Plasma nitriding After etching is completed, the ion nitriding process begins. The etching argon gas is turned off, and all nitrogen gas is ionized through the ion source and then introduced into the vacuum chamber. The nitrogen flow rate is kept constant at 170 sccm, and the vacuum chamber pressure is 0.3 Pa. The ion source voltage is set to 1000 V, the ion current to 140 mA, the substrate bias voltage to be kept constant at 400 V, and the furnace temperature is kept stable at 300 °C. Ion nitriding is carried out continuously for 5 hours to prepare a nitrided layer on the substrate surface.

[0047] (3) Cr deposited layer After nitriding, the furnace temperature was allowed to cool naturally to 200℃ before Cr layer deposition was initiated. Argon gas was directly introduced into the vacuum chamber at a constant flow rate of 160 sccm to maintain the working pressure of the vacuum chamber at 0.4 Pa. The Cr planar target was activated, and the sputtering current was set to a constant 7 A. A pulsed negative bias of 80 V was applied to the substrate, with a pulse frequency of 10 kHz and a pulse duration of 90 μs. Continuous deposition was carried out for 10 min to prepare a dense Cr layer.

[0048] (4) Deposition of CrN layer Maintain a constant furnace temperature of 200℃ and a constant working pressure of 0.4Pa in the vacuum chamber. Turn on the Cr planar target and set the sputtering current to a constant 7A. Apply a pulsed negative bias voltage of 80V to the substrate, with a pulse frequency of 10kHz and a pulse duration of 90μs. Directly introduce argon gas into the vacuum chamber at a flow rate of 150sccm. Nitrogen gas is introduced into the vacuum chamber after being ionized by the ion source. The initial flow rate of nitrogen gas is set to 0sccm, and the final flow rate is set to 60sccm, which is increased linearly during the deposition process. Set the ion source voltage to 1300V, the ion current to 75mA, and the deposition time to 105min.

[0049] (5) Deposition of CrCN layer The furnace temperature was maintained at 200℃ and the working pressure in the vacuum chamber at 0.4Pa. The Cr planar target was turned on, and the sputtering current was set to a constant 7A. A pulsed negative bias of 80V was applied to the substrate, with a pulse frequency of 10kHz and a pulse duration of 90μs. Argon gas was directly introduced into the vacuum chamber at a flow rate of 140sccm. Acetylene was introduced directly into the vacuum chamber without passing through an ion source. The initial flow rate of acetylene was set to 0sccm, and the final flow rate was set to 50sccm, increasing linearly during the deposition process. Nitrogen gas was ionized through an ion source before being introduced into the vacuum chamber. During the deposition process, the flow rate decreased linearly from 60sccm to 0sccm. The ion source voltage was set to 1300V, the ion current to 75mA, and the deposition time was 30min.

[0050] (6) Deposited CrC layer Maintain a constant furnace temperature of 200℃ and a constant working pressure of 0.4 Pa in the vacuum chamber. Turn on the Cr planar target and set a constant sputtering current of 7 A. Apply a pulsed negative bias of 80 V to the substrate, with a pulse frequency of 10 kHz and a pulse duration of 90 μs. Argon gas is directly introduced into the vacuum chamber at a flow rate of 160 sccm. Acetylene is ionized by an ion source and then introduced into the vacuum chamber at a flow rate maintained at 70 sccm. Set the ion source voltage to 1300 V and the ion current to 75 mA, and deposit for 60 min.

[0051] Example 3 This embodiment provides a method for preparing a CrC multilayer gradient composite coating on the surface of a GCr15 substrate. The specific preparation process is as follows: (1) Matrix pretreatment After grinding and polishing the GCr15 substrate, the surface oil was first removed by immersion in industrial alcohol and then ultrasonically cleaned in deionized water for 60 minutes to thoroughly remove surface grease, wax, and dust impurities. The cleaned and dried substrate was then fixed to the workpiece holder in the vacuum chamber, and the vacuum chamber was evacuated to 8×10⁻⁶. -3 Pa is used to etch the GCr15 substrate.

[0052] Argon gas with a purity greater than or equal to 99.999% was introduced into the vacuum chamber, with 50 sccm of argon gas being directly introduced into the vacuum chamber and 30 sccm of argon gas being ionized by the ion source before being introduced into the vacuum chamber; the vacuum chamber pressure was adjusted to 0.2 Pa, and the ion source voltage was set to 1700 V and the ion current to 170 mA; a pulsed negative bias voltage of 200 V was applied to the substrate, with a bias pulse frequency of 10 kHz and a pulse duration of 90 μs, and the etching was continued for 40 min to remove the surface oxide layer.

[0053] (2) Plasma nitriding After etching is completed, the ion nitriding process begins. The etching argon gas is turned off, and all nitrogen gas is ionized through the ion source and then introduced into the vacuum chamber. The nitrogen flow rate is kept constant at 170 sccm, and the vacuum chamber pressure is 0.3 Pa. The ion source voltage is set to 1000 V, the ion current to 140 mA, the substrate bias voltage to be kept constant at 400 V, and the furnace temperature is kept stable at 300 °C. Ion nitriding is carried out continuously for 5 hours to prepare a nitrided layer on the substrate surface.

[0054] (3) Cr deposited layer After nitriding, the furnace temperature was allowed to cool naturally to 200℃ before Cr layer deposition was initiated. Argon gas was directly introduced into the vacuum chamber at a flow rate of 160 sccm to maintain the working pressure of the vacuum chamber at 0.4 Pa. The Cr planar target was activated, and the sputtering current was set to a constant 7 A. A pulsed negative bias of 80 V was applied to the substrate with a pulse frequency of 10 kHz and a pulse duration of 90 μs. Continuous deposition was carried out for 11 min to prepare a dense Cr layer.

[0055] (4) Deposition of CrN layer The furnace temperature was kept constant at 200℃ and the working pressure in the vacuum chamber was kept constant at 0.4Pa. The Cr planar target was turned on and the sputtering current was set to a constant 7A. A pulsed negative bias voltage of 80V was applied to the substrate, with a pulse frequency of 10kHz and a pulse duration of 90μs. Argon gas was directly introduced into the vacuum chamber at a flow rate of 150sccm. Nitrogen gas was introduced into the vacuum chamber after being ionized by the ion source. The initial flow rate of nitrogen gas was set to 0sccm and the final flow rate was set to 60sccm, which was increased linearly during the deposition process. The ion source voltage was set to 1500V, the ion current to 50mA, and the deposition time to 79min.

[0056] (5) Deposition of CrCN layer Maintain a constant furnace temperature of 200℃ and a constant working pressure of 0.4Pa in the vacuum chamber. Turn on the Cr planar target and set the sputtering current to a constant 7A. Apply a pulsed negative bias voltage of 80V to the substrate, with a pulse frequency of 10kHz and a pulse duration of 90μs. Directly introduce argon gas into the vacuum chamber at a flow rate of 140sccm. Introduce acetylene directly into the vacuum chamber without passing through an ion source. Set the initial flow rate of acetylene to 0sccm and the final flow rate to 50sccm, increasing linearly during deposition. Ion gas is ionized through an ion source before being introduced into the vacuum chamber. During deposition, the flow rate decreases linearly from 60sccm to 0sccm. Set the ion source voltage to 1500V and the ion current to 50mA. Deposition time is 23min.

[0057] (6) Deposited CrC layer Maintain a constant furnace temperature of 200℃ and a constant working pressure of 0.4Pa in the vacuum chamber. Turn on the Cr planar target and set the sputtering current to a constant 7A. Apply a pulsed negative bias voltage of 80V to the substrate, with a pulse frequency of 10kHz and a pulse duration of 90μs. Directly introduce argon gas into the vacuum chamber at a flow rate of 160sccm. Ionize acetylene through an ion source and then introduce it into the vacuum chamber at a flow rate of 70sccm. Set the ion source voltage to 1500V and the ion current to 50mA. Deposition time is 45min.

[0058] Example 4 This embodiment provides a method for preparing a CrC multilayer gradient composite coating on the surface of a GCr15 substrate. The specific preparation process is as follows: (1) Matrix pretreatment After grinding and polishing the GCr15 substrate, the surface oil was first removed by immersion in industrial alcohol and then ultrasonically cleaned in deionized water for 60 minutes to thoroughly remove surface grease, wax, and dust impurities. The cleaned and dried substrate was then fixed to the workpiece holder in the vacuum chamber, and the vacuum chamber was evacuated to 8×10⁻⁶. -3 Pa is used to etch the GCr15 substrate.

[0059] Argon gas with a purity greater than or equal to 99.999% was introduced into the vacuum chamber, with 50 sccm of argon gas being directly introduced into the vacuum chamber and 30 sccm of argon gas being ionized by the ion source before being introduced into the vacuum chamber; the vacuum chamber pressure was adjusted to 0.2 Pa, and the ion source voltage was set to 1700 V and the ion current to 170 mA; a pulsed negative bias voltage of 200 V was applied to the substrate, with a bias pulse frequency of 10 kHz and a pulse duration of 90 μs, and the etching was continued for 40 min to complete the surface activation and impurity removal of the substrate.

[0060] (2) Cr deposited layer After nitriding, the furnace temperature was allowed to cool naturally to 200℃ before Cr layer deposition was initiated. Argon gas was directly introduced into the vacuum chamber at a constant flow rate of 160 sccm to maintain the working pressure of the vacuum chamber at 0.4 Pa. The Cr planar target was activated, and the sputtering current was set to a constant 7 A. A pulsed negative bias of 80 V was applied to the substrate, with a pulse frequency of 10 kHz and a pulse duration of 90 μs. Continuous deposition was carried out for 15 min to prepare a dense Cr layer.

[0061] (3) Deposition of CrN layer Maintain a constant furnace temperature of 200℃ and a constant working pressure of 0.4Pa in the vacuum chamber. Turn on the Cr planar target and set the sputtering current to a constant 7A. Apply a pulsed negative bias voltage of 80V to the substrate, with a pulse frequency of 10kHz and a pulse duration of 90μs. Directly introduce argon gas into the vacuum chamber at a flow rate of 150sccm. Nitrogen gas is introduced into the vacuum chamber after being ionized by the ion source. The initial flow rate of nitrogen gas is set to 0sccm, and the final flow rate is set to 60sccm, which is increased linearly during the deposition process. Set the ion source voltage to 1000V, the ion current to 200mA, and the deposition time to 105min.

[0062] (4) Deposition of CrCN layer Maintain a constant furnace temperature of 200℃ and a constant working pressure of 0.4Pa in the vacuum chamber. Turn on the Cr planar target and set the sputtering current to a constant 7A. Apply a pulsed negative bias voltage of 80V to the substrate, with a pulse frequency of 10kHz and a pulse duration of 90μs. Directly introduce argon gas into the vacuum chamber at a flow rate of 140sccm. Introduce acetylene directly into the vacuum chamber without passing through an ion source. Set the initial flow rate of acetylene to 0sccm and the final flow rate to 50sccm, increasing linearly during the deposition process. Ion gas is ionized through an ion source before being introduced into the vacuum chamber. During the deposition process, the flow rate decreases linearly from 60sccm to 0sccm. Set the ion source voltage to 1000V, the ion current to 200mA, and the deposition time to 30min.

[0063] (5) Deposited CrC layer Maintain a constant furnace temperature of 200℃ and a constant working pressure of 0.4Pa in the vacuum chamber. Turn on the Cr planar target and set the sputtering current to a constant 7A. Apply a pulsed negative bias voltage of 80V to the substrate, with a pulse frequency of 10kHz and a pulse duration of 90μs. Directly introduce argon gas into the vacuum chamber at a flow rate of 160sccm. Ionize acetylene through an ion source before introducing it into the vacuum chamber at a flow rate of 70sccm. Set the ion source voltage to 1000V and the ion current to 200mA. Deposit the ion current for 60min.

[0064] Example 5 This comparative example provides a method for preparing a CrC multilayer gradient composite coating on the surface of a GCr15 substrate. The specific preparation process is as follows: (1) Matrix pretreatment After grinding and polishing the GCr15 substrate, the surface oil was first removed by immersion in industrial alcohol and then ultrasonically cleaned in deionized water for 30 minutes to thoroughly remove surface grease, wax, and dust impurities. The cleaned and dried substrate was then fixed to the workpiece holder in the vacuum chamber, and the vacuum chamber was evacuated to 8×10⁻⁶. -3 Pa is used to etch the GCr15 substrate.

[0065] Argon gas with a purity greater than or equal to 99.999% was introduced into the vacuum chamber, with 50 sccm of argon gas being directly introduced into the vacuum chamber and 30 sccm of argon gas being ionized by the ion source before being introduced into the vacuum chamber; the vacuum chamber pressure was adjusted to 0.2 Pa, and the ion source voltage was set to 1700 V and the ion current to 170 mA; a pulsed negative bias voltage of 200 V was applied to the substrate, with a bias pulse frequency of 10 kHz and a pulse duration of 90 μs, and the etching was continued for 40 min to remove the surface oxide layer.

[0066] (2) Plasma nitriding After etching is completed, the ion nitriding process begins. The etching argon gas is turned off, and all nitrogen gas is ionized through the ion source and then introduced into the vacuum chamber. The nitrogen flow rate is kept constant at 170 sccm, and the vacuum chamber pressure is 0.3 Pa. The ion source voltage is set to 1000 V, the ion current to 140 mA, the substrate bias voltage to be kept constant at 400 V, and the furnace temperature is kept stable at 300 °C. Ion nitriding is carried out continuously for 5 hours to prepare a nitrided layer on the substrate surface.

[0067] (3) Cr deposited layer After nitriding, the furnace temperature was allowed to cool naturally to 200℃ before Cr layer deposition was initiated. Argon gas was directly introduced into the vacuum chamber at a constant flow rate of 160 sccm to maintain the working pressure of the vacuum chamber at 0.4 Pa. The Cr planar target was activated, and the sputtering current was set to a constant 7 A. A pulsed negative bias of 80 V was applied to the substrate, with a pulse frequency of 10 kHz and a pulse duration of 90 μs. Continuous deposition was carried out for 15 min to prepare a dense Cr layer.

[0068] (4) Deposition of CrN layer Maintain a constant furnace temperature of 200℃ and a constant working pressure of 0.4Pa in the vacuum chamber. Turn on the Cr planar target and set the sputtering current to a constant 7A. Apply a pulsed negative bias voltage of 80V to the substrate, with a pulse frequency of 10kHz and a pulse duration of 90μs. Directly introduce argon gas into the vacuum chamber at a flow rate of 150sccm. Nitrogen gas is introduced into the vacuum chamber after being ionized by the ion source. The initial flow rate of nitrogen gas is set to 0sccm, and the final flow rate is set to 60sccm, which is increased linearly during the deposition process. Set the ion source voltage to 1000V, the ion current to 140mA, and the deposition time to 105min.

[0069] (5) Deposition of CrCN layer The furnace temperature was kept constant at 200℃, the working pressure of the vacuum chamber was 0.4Pa, the sputtering current of the Cr target was 7A, the substrate pulse bias voltage was 80V, the pulse frequency was 10KHZ, and the pulse time was 90μs.

[0070] Argon gas was directly introduced into the vacuum chamber at a flow rate of 140 sccm. Acetylene was ionized by an ion source and then introduced into the vacuum chamber. The initial flow rate of acetylene was set to 0 sccm, and the final flow rate was set to 50 sccm, which increased linearly during the deposition process. Nitrogen gas was ionized by an ion source and then introduced into the vacuum chamber. During the deposition process, the flow rate decreased linearly from 60 sccm to 0 sccm. The ion source voltage was set to 1000V, the ion current to 140mA, and the deposition time was 30 min.

[0071] (6) Deposited CrC layer The furnace temperature was kept constant at 200℃, the working pressure of the vacuum chamber was 0.4Pa, the sputtering current of the Cr target was 7A, the substrate pulse bias voltage was 80V, the pulse frequency was 10KHZ, and the pulse time was 90μs.

[0072] Argon gas was directly introduced into the vacuum chamber at a flow rate of 160 sccm; acetylene was ionized by an ion source and then introduced into the vacuum chamber at a flow rate of 70 sccm. The ion source voltage was set to 1000V, the ion current to 100mA, and the deposition time was 60 min.

[0073] The process parameters for each embodiment and comparative example are shown in Table 1.

[0074] Table 1. Process parameters for each embodiment

[0075] Experimental Example 1 The composite coating samples prepared in Example 1 were tested for coating performance using the Rockwell indentation method. Figure 3The indentation morphology of Example 1 is shown. The film-substrate adhesion strength of the coating was evaluated as HF1 according to the VDI 3198 standard. A scratch tester was used to perform scratch testing on Example 1. Figure 8 The results of the scratch test in Example 1 are shown in the figure. According to the ASTM C1624–05 standard, the coating Lc2 is approximately 21N and Lc3 is approximately 92N. Figure 13 The cross-sectional morphology of Example 1 shows that the coating exhibits a columnar structure and a tight interlayer bonding.

[0076] Experimental Example 2 The composite coating samples prepared in Example 2 were tested for coating performance using the Rockwell indentation method. Figure 4 The indentation morphology of Example 2 is shown. The film-substrate adhesion strength of the coating was evaluated as HF1 according to the VDI 3198 criterion. A scratch tester was used to perform a scratch test on the sample. Figure 9 Based on the scratch test results of Example 2, according to the ASTM C1624–05 standard, the coating Lc2 is approximately 22N and Lc3 is approximately 93N. Figure 14 The cross-sectional morphology of Example 2 shows that the coating exhibits a columnar structure and a tight interlayer bonding.

[0077] Experimental Example 3 The composite coating samples prepared in Example 3 were tested for coating performance using the Rockwell indentation method. Figure 5 The indentation morphology of Example 3 is shown. The film-substrate adhesion strength of the coating was evaluated as HF1 according to the VDI 3198 criterion. A scratch tester was used to perform a scratch test on the sample. Figure 10 Based on the scratch test results of Example 3, according to the ASTM C1624–05 standard, the coating Lc2 is approximately 31N and Lc3 is approximately 95N. Figure 15 The cross-sectional morphology of Example 3 shows that the coating structure is dense and the interlayer bonding is tight.

[0078] Experiment Example 4 The composite coating samples prepared in Example 4 were tested for coating performance using the Rockwell indentation method. Figure 6 The indentation morphology of Example 4 is shown. The film-substrate adhesion strength of the coating was evaluated as HF2 according to the VDI 3198 criterion. A scratch tester was used to perform a scratch test on the sample. Figure 11 Based on the scratch test results of Example 4, according to the ASTM C1624–05 standard, the coating Lc2 is approximately 14N and Lc3 is approximately 60N. Figure 16 The cross-sectional morphology of Example 4 shows that the coating structure is dense and the interlayer bonding is tight.

[0079] Experimental Example 5 The composite coating samples prepared in Example 5 were tested for coating performance using the Rockwell indentation method. Figure 7 The indentation morphology of Example 5 is shown. The film-substrate adhesion strength of the coating was evaluated as HF2 according to the VDI 3198 criterion. A scratch tester was used to perform a scratch test on the sample. Figure 12 Based on the scratch test results of Example 5, according to the ASTM C1624–05 standard, the coating Lc2 is approximately 14N and Lc3 is approximately 48N. Figure 17 The cross-sectional morphology of Example 5 shows that the coating structure is dense and the interlayer bonding is tight.

[0080] Obviously, the above embodiments are merely illustrative examples for clear explanation and are not intended to limit the implementation. Those skilled in the art will recognize that other variations or modifications can be made based on the above description. It is neither necessary nor possible to exhaustively list all possible implementations here. However, obvious variations or modifications derived therefrom are still within the scope of protection of this invention.

Claims

1. A method for preparing a CrC multilayer coating, characterized in that, Inside the vacuum chamber, an ion-assisted magnetron sputtering process was used to sequentially deposit Cr, CrN, CrCN, and CrC layers on the substrate surface by selectively ionizing the reactive gas in stages. When depositing the CrN layer, nitrogen is selected as the reaction gas. The nitrogen is ionized by the ion source and then introduced into the vacuum chamber. When depositing the CrCN layer, nitrogen and acetylene are selected as the reaction gases. Nitrogen is ionized by an ion source and then introduced into the vacuum chamber, while acetylene is directly introduced into the vacuum chamber without being ionized by an ion source. When depositing the CrC layer, acetylene is selected as the reaction gas. After being ionized by an ion source, the acetylene is introduced into the vacuum chamber.

2. The method for preparing a CrC multilayer coating according to claim 1, characterized in that, The Cr layer, CrN layer, and CrCN layer are formed in the same vacuum environment.

3. The method for preparing a CrC multilayer coating according to claim 1, characterized in that, A nitriding layer with a thickness of 0.1-3 μm is provided between the substrate surface and the Cr layer; The total thickness of the Cr layer, CrN layer and CrCN layer is 0.5-3 μm; The thickness of the CrC layer is 1-5 μm.

4. The method for preparing a CrC multilayer coating according to claim 3, characterized in that, During the preparation of the nitrided layer, the ambient temperature for plasma nitriding of the substrate is 250-400℃, nitrogen gas is introduced for nitriding for 300-500 min, the bias voltage is 300-500V, the gas pressure is 0.3-0.7Pa, the ion source voltage is 800-1500V, and the ion current is 100-200mA.

5. The method for preparing a CrC multilayer coating according to any one of claims 1-4, characterized in that, The deposition process of the Cr layer is as follows: in an argon atmosphere, the Cr target is turned on, the sputtering current of the Cr target is 5-10A, the temperature is 100-300℃, the bias voltage is 60-100V, the gas pressure is 0.3-0.7Pa, and the deposition time is 10-40min.

6. The method for preparing a CrC multilayer coating according to any one of claims 1-4, characterized in that, The deposition process of the CrN layer is as follows: the argon flow rate is adjusted to 100-200 sccm, the Cr target sputtering current is 5-10 A, the temperature is 100-300℃, the bias voltage is 60-100 V, nitrogen gas is ionized by the ion source and then introduced into the vacuum chamber, the nitrogen flow rate is gradually increased from 0 to 60-90 sccm, the ion source voltage is 500-1500 V, the ion current is 50-200 mA, the gas pressure is 0.3-0.7 Pa, and the deposition time is 30-150 min.

7. The method for preparing a CrC multilayer coating according to any one of claims 1-4, characterized in that, The deposition process of the CrCN layer is as follows: the argon flow rate is adjusted to 100-200 sccm, the Cr target sputtering current is 5-10 A, the acetylene flow rate is gradually increased from 0 to 30-60 sccm, the temperature is 100-300℃, the bias voltage is 60-100 V, nitrogen gas is ionized by the ion source and then introduced into the vacuum chamber, the nitrogen flow rate is gradually decreased from 60-90 sccm to 0, the ion source voltage is 500-1500 V, the ion current is 50-200 mA, the gas pressure is 0.3-0.7 Pa, and the deposition time is 10-60 min.

8. The method for preparing a CrC multilayer coating according to any one of claims 1-4, characterized in that, The CrC top-layer deposition process is as follows: the argon flow rate is adjusted to 100-200 sccm, the Cr target sputtering current is 5-10 A, the deposition temperature is 100-300℃, the bias voltage is 60-100 V, acetylene is ionized by the ion source and then introduced into the vacuum chamber, the acetylene flow rate is 30-120 sccm, the ion source voltage is 500-1500 V, the ion current is 50-200 mA, the gas pressure is maintained at 0.3-0.7 Pa, and the deposition time is 10-60 min.

9. A CrC multilayer coating, characterized in that, It is prepared by the preparation method according to any one of claims 1-8.

10. The application of the preparation method according to any one of claims 1-8 in improving the stability of membrane-substrate bonding.