Single-phase phase-locked loop for grid connection of distributed photovoltaic power generation
By using single-phase phase-locked loop technology, combined with an orthogonal generator and a nonlinear saturation PI control module, the problem of filtering out DC and harmonic components when the grid voltage is unstable is solved, thus realizing stable grid connection and rapid response of distributed photovoltaic power generation.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202611343441.0
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2026-09-01
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-17
AI Technical Summary
In existing technologies, single-phase phase-locked loops cannot effectively filter out DC and harmonic components when the grid voltage is unstable, leading to phase-lock failure and consequently causing distributed photovoltaic grid disconnection, which affects energy security.
Employing single-phase phase-locked loop technology, the system utilizes an orthogonal generator, a pre-compensator, a phase detector, a nonlinear saturation PI control module, and a feedback closed-loop module to achieve real-time monitoring and tracking of the grid voltage frequency and phase. Combined with a second-order generalized integrator to filter out DC components, and an integral separation algorithm performed by the nonlinear saturation PI control module, the system quickly eliminates the influence of DC components.
It improves the stability and anti-interference capability of distributed photovoltaic grid connection, ensures that distributed photovoltaic power generation is synchronized with the grid, reduces grid connection impact, and improves the control stability and response speed of the system.
Smart Images

Figure CN123122533A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] This invention belongs to the field of photovoltaic power generation technology, and in particular relates to a single-phase phase-locked loop for grid connection of distributed photovoltaic power generation. Background Technology
[0002] Against the backdrop of current fossil fuel shortages, the rapid development of distributed renewable energy generation, microgrids, and energy storage devices has led to the widespread use of power electronic equipment, such as single-phase grid-connected inverters, frequency converters, and single-phase energy storage converters. The extensive integration of these power electronic devices has resulted in a decline in grid-connected power quality, further impacting the system stability of distributed power sources.
[0003] Existing technology employs a single-phase phase-locked loop (PLL) that suppresses DC components and incorporates an anti-saturation loop filter. By adding a DC filter circuit to the second-order generalized integrator, DC component isolation is achieved. The addition of an anti-saturation PI controller improves the PI filtering range, eliminating the need for a separate filter within the PLL, effectively accelerating response speed and simplifying the PLL structure. Simultaneously, it can achieve phase-locked tracking under various operating conditions such as grid voltage distortion, DC offset, and harmonic interference, enabling distributed photovoltaic grid-connected power generation and maximizing the solution to the renewable energy consumption problem. An anti-saturation loop filter PLL typically consists of four parts: an orthogonal signal generator (OSG), a phase detector (PD), a loop filter (LF), and a voltage-controlled oscillator (VCO). (See [link to relevant documentation]). Figure 1 The acquired single-phase voltage signal is input into an orthogonal generator (SOGI), and two orthogonal sinusoidal signals are obtained through virtual orthogonal decomposition. Assume the input voltage signal is... ,but and Represented as:
[0004] ;
[0005] In the above formula The actual phase of the input voltage signal; This is the input voltage signal.
[0006] Two sinusoidal signals obtained by orthogonal decomposition and It contains the phase, amplitude, and frequency information of the input voltage signal, and then obtains the phase information through Park transform. The transform matrix is:
[0007] ;
[0008] get The relationship between the components and the input is as follows:
[0009] ;
[0010] The relation matrix can be obtained by simplification:
[0011] ;
[0012] In the control system obtained through Park's synchronous rotating coordinate transformation The axis represents the amplitude signal component. The axis represents the phase signal component.
[0013] Through voltage The magnitude represents the actual phase. Phase-locked loop phase The difference When V q When = 0, it indicates that the grid voltage phase and the phase-locked loop phase are the same, that is... At this point, the phase-locked loop (PLL) phase follows the grid voltage phase, achieving phase locking. At that time, that is The magnitude of its error , decided The value of is then used to control the output phase via PI regulation. Phase with the power grid Consistent, while outputting angular frequency error By introducing the grid reference angular frequency, the response speed is accelerated, and the angular frequency is corrected. Finally, through the integration stage, the instantaneous phase of the phase-locked loop is obtained, thereby achieving phase tracking and locking.
[0014] However, when the power grid experiences unstable fluctuations, and the voltage contains both DC and harmonic components, the DC and harmonic components cannot be completely filtered out due to the saturation coefficient of the PI controller. This causes errors in the phase-locked loop (PLL) results, and in severe cases, it can lead to PLL failure, which in turn causes distributed photovoltaic (PV) grid disconnection. Disconnection of distributed PV grids will further exacerbate voltage and frequency fluctuations in the power grid, thereby causing a large-scale collapse of the power system and seriously affecting energy security.
[0015] Therefore, there is an urgent need for a single-phase phase-locked loop for grid connection of distributed photovoltaic power generation to solve the aforementioned energy security problems. Summary of the Invention
[0016] To address the technical deficiencies of the existing technologies, this invention proposes a single-phase phase-locked loop (PLL) for grid-connected distributed photovoltaic (PV) power generation. By employing PLL technology, the distributed PV power connected to the system is synchronized with the grid voltage. Leveraging its ability to monitor grid frequency changes, phase angle abrupt changes, and harmonic effects in real time, the PLL tracks the grid voltage frequency and phase, thereby improving the grid-connected stability of distributed PV power generation.
[0017] To solve the above-mentioned technical problems, the present invention provides the following technical solution:
[0018] In a first aspect, the present invention provides a single-phase phase-locked loop for grid connection of distributed photovoltaic power generation, comprising:
[0019] An orthogonal generator is used to obtain a first sine signal and a second sine signal from an input single-phase voltage signal through virtual orthogonal decomposition, and the first sine signal and the second sine signal are orthogonal.
[0020] A pre-compensator is installed on the first sine signal circuit to perform negative feedback elimination on the DC component generated by the sine generator;
[0021] The phase detector obtains phase information from the first and second sinusoidal signals through Park transform.
[0022] The nonlinear saturation PI control module performs an integral separation algorithm on the PI controller. It compares the current value of the input signal with the set saturation value. If the current value is greater than the saturation value, the module accumulates a negative error; otherwise, it accumulates a positive error.
[0023] A voltage-controlled oscillator adjusts the angular frequency of the output of the nonlinear saturation PI control module, and the phase angle is obtained by integrating the angular frequency.
[0024] The feedback closed-loop module is used to feed the phase angle back to the phase detector.
[0025] As a further technical solution of the present invention, the quadrature generator filters the DC component of the input voltage, and after decomposition by a second-order generalized integrator, the second sinusoidal signal... It functions like a bandpass filter, effectively filtering out DC components and the first sinusoidal signal. This acts like a low-pass filter, preserving the DC component of the input voltage, thus causing the phase-locked loop to exhibit second-order oscillations. Therefore, in the first sinusoidal signal... A negative feedback loop is added to the circuit. When a DC component appears, negative feedback is used to eliminate it, thereby suppressing the DC component and preventing it from affecting the subsequent phase-locked loop.
[0026] Among them, the closed-loop transfer function for:
[0027] (1);
[0028] In formula (1) , The two parameters of the PI controller are given by the following formula:
[0029] (2);
[0030] In formula (2) Indicates the natural oscillation frequency, This represents the damping coefficient.
[0031] As a further technical solution of the present invention, it also includes a phase error detection module, wherein the phase error detection module is configured to detect when phase locking is successful. If there is a phase deviation, This generates an error signal.
[0032] As a further technical solution of the present invention, the pre-compensator is used to provide negative feedback to suppress the DC component; the pre-compensator includes a proportional module and an integrator, wherein the proportional module and the integrator are connected in series.
[0033] As a further technical solution of the present invention, the nonlinear saturation PI control module includes: a proportional module, an integral module, a limiting module, and a nonlinear saturation difference module;
[0034] The proportional module and the integral module perform proportional and integral operations on the input phase error signal, respectively, and then superimpose the control quantities output by the two modules to generate the original control signal.
[0035] The limiting module receives the original control signal, limits it to a preset upper and lower threshold range, and outputs a limited control signal to drive the subsequent actuator.
[0036] The nonlinear saturation difference detection module simultaneously receives the original control signal and the limited control signal, calculates the difference between the two, and sends the difference as a feedback signal to the input of the integration module.
[0037] As a further technical solution of the present invention, the nonlinear saturation PI control module specifically performs an integral separation algorithm on the PI controller, compares the current value of the input signal with the set saturation value, and accumulates a negative error when the current value is greater than the saturation value; otherwise, it accumulates a positive error. Specifically:
[0038] PI output The expression is:
[0039] (3);
[0040] Where L is the highest value of the saturation module, equal to PI input Caused output change Represented as:
[0041] (4);
[0042] Where E is a constant error; if For a linear equation with slope A, the first-order differential equation can be obtained from equation (3):
[0043] (5);
[0044] From equation (5), we can obtain its general solution as:
[0045] (6);
[0046] As shown in equation (6), the saturation limiting capability of the integrator can be adjusted by changing the value of the coefficient k. The larger k is, the better. The smaller the value, the stronger the integrator's ability to exit saturation and the faster it is; conversely, the larger the value, the weaker and slower it is.
[0047] Furthermore, the range of values for k is: .
[0048] As a further technical solution of the present invention, the nonlinear saturation difference detection module specifically comprises: detecting the saturation error The product with k is fed back to the integration module, and the feedback is... Represented as:
[0049] (7);
[0050] As can be seen from equation (7), when the PI controller reaches saturation for the first time, a saturation error is generated. And by providing negative feedback to the integral module to weaken it, the controller immediately enters a desaturation state.
[0051] The beneficial effects of this invention are as follows:
[0052] 1. The nonlinear saturation PI control module of the present invention performs an integral separation algorithm on the PI controller through internal comparison logic. It compares the current value of the input signal with the set saturation value. When the current value is greater than the saturation value, the module accumulates a negative error; otherwise, it accumulates a positive error. This effectively solves the saturation problem, expands the filtering range of the PI, and at the same time plays a role in converging the signal, reducing the gain, and improving stability.
[0053] 2. Add a pre-compensator to suppress DC components, and work with the nonlinear saturation module to quickly and accurately complete phase-locking.
[0054] 3. By setting appropriate coefficients for integral weakening, the PI filter's capability can be improved, the phase-locked loop's anti-interference ability can be enhanced, its dynamic response speed can be strengthened, its overshoot amplitude can be reduced, it can quickly reach the exit saturation state, the recovery time is rapid, the system control is stable, and it will not cause the system to run away from control.
[0055] 4. The single-phase phase-locked loop provided by this invention can quickly and accurately obtain phase signals for distributed photovoltaic power generation grid-connected control under grid distortion conditions, improve the anti-interference and reliability of distributed photovoltaic power generation grid connection, and at the same time ensure the synchronization of distributed grid-connected power supply, reduce the impact on the grid during grid connection, and provide reliable technical conditions for distributed energy grid connection. Attached Figure Description
[0056] To more clearly illustrate the technical solutions of the embodiments of the present invention, the accompanying drawings used in the description of the embodiments will be briefly introduced below. Obviously, the drawings described below are merely some embodiments of the present invention. For those skilled in the art, other drawings can be obtained based on these drawings without any creative effort.
[0057] Figure 1 A schematic diagram of a single-phase phase-locked loop structure for grid connection of distributed photovoltaic power generation provided by the present invention;
[0058] Figure 2 A schematic diagram of a single-phase phase-locked loop circuit for grid connection of distributed photovoltaic power generation provided by the present invention;
[0059] Figure 3 The schematic diagram of the nonlinear saturation PI control module provided by the present invention. Detailed Implementation
[0060] To make the above-mentioned objects, features and advantages of the present invention more readily understood, the specific embodiments of the present invention will be described in detail below with reference to the accompanying drawings.
[0061] Many specific details are set forth in the following description in order to provide a full understanding of the invention. However, the invention may also be practiced in other ways than those described herein, and those skilled in the art can make similar extensions without departing from the spirit of the invention. Therefore, the invention is not limited to the specific embodiments disclosed below.
[0062] It should be noted that, unless otherwise defined, the technical or scientific terms used in the embodiments of this invention should have the ordinary meaning understood by one of ordinary skill in the art to which this disclosure pertains. The terms "comprising" or "including," and similar terms as used in this disclosure, mean that the element or object preceding the word encompasses the elements or objects listed following the word and their equivalents, but do not exclude other elements or objects. Those skilled in the art can understand the specific meaning of the above terms in this invention according to the specific circumstances.
[0063] Secondly, the term "one embodiment" or "embodiment" as used herein refers to a specific feature, structure, or characteristic that may be included in at least one implementation of the present invention. The phrase "in one embodiment" appearing in different places in this specification does not necessarily refer to the same embodiment, nor is it a single or selective embodiment that mutually excludes other embodiments. It should be noted that the embodiments of the present invention can be applied to any applicable scenario.
[0064] See Figure 1 This is a schematic diagram of a single-phase phase-locked loop (PLL) structure for grid-connected distributed photovoltaic (PV) power generation, provided by the present invention. In this embodiment, the single-phase PLL for grid-connected distributed PV power generation includes:
[0065] An orthogonal generator is used to obtain a first sine signal and a second sine signal from an input single-phase voltage signal through virtual orthogonal decomposition, and the first sine signal and the second sine signal are orthogonal.
[0066] A pre-compensator is installed on the first sine signal circuit to perform negative feedback elimination on the DC component generated by the sine generator;
[0067] The phase detector obtains phase information from the first and second sinusoidal signals through Park transform.
[0068] The nonlinear saturation PI control module performs an integral separation algorithm on the PI controller. It compares the current value of the input signal with the set saturation value. If the current value is greater than the saturation value, the module accumulates a negative error; otherwise, it accumulates a positive error.
[0069] A voltage-controlled oscillator adjusts the angular frequency of the output of the nonlinear saturation PI control module, and the phase angle is obtained by integrating the angular frequency.
[0070] The feedback closed-loop module is used to feed the phase angle back to the phase detector.
[0071] See Figure 2 In this embodiment of the invention, the quadrature generator filters the DC component of the input voltage, and after decomposition by a second-order generalized integrator, the second sinusoidal signal... It functions like a bandpass filter, effectively filtering out DC components and the first sinusoidal signal. This acts like a low-pass filter, preserving the DC component of the input voltage, thus causing the phase-locked loop to exhibit second-order oscillations. Therefore, in the first sinusoidal signal... A negative feedback loop is added to the circuit. When a DC component appears, negative feedback is used to eliminate it, thereby suppressing the DC component and preventing it from affecting the subsequent phase-locked loop.
[0072] Among them, the closed-loop transfer function for:
[0073] (1);
[0074] In formula (1) , The two parameters of the PI controller are given by the following formula:
[0075] (2);
[0076] In formula (2) Indicates the natural oscillation frequency. This represents the damping coefficient.
[0077] A PI controller is essentially a filter, used to eliminate steady-state errors and filter signals. In a single-phase phase-locked loop, the second-order integrator will resonate during orthogonal decomposition. Furthermore, due to the presence of nonlinear loads and DC components, the decomposition transformation yields… It contains 2nd and 6th harmonics. These harmonics cause the system to deviate in one direction. Through the integral action of the PI controller, the output continuously accumulates, increasing the overshoot. This leads to the data processing reaching its limit, slowing down the response speed, until the output control quantity exceeds the calculation range and enters the saturation region. When the system deviation direction changes, producing a reverse deviation, the increase in control quantity ends. As the reverse deviation increases, the control quantity gradually exits the saturation region. According to the saturation characteristic principle, the deeper the control quantity enters the saturation region, the longer it takes to exit. Because it is in the recovery period, the PI controller cannot immediately respond to the reverse deviation during this time. The system appears to lose control, resulting in decreased system stability and response speed, thus limiting the PI filtering function. The nonlinear saturation PI control module uses internal comparison logic to perform an integral separation algorithm on the PI controller. It compares the current value of the input signal with the set saturation value. If the current value is greater than the saturation value, the module accumulates a negative error; otherwise, it accumulates a positive error. It effectively solves the saturation problem, effectively expands the filtering range of PI, and at the same time plays a role in converging the signal, reducing gain, and improving stability.
[0078] The phase detector also includes a phase error detection module at its output. When phase locking is successful, If there is a phase deviation, This generates an error signal.
[0079] In this embodiment of the invention, the pre-compensator is used to provide negative feedback elimination and suppress DC components; the pre-compensator includes a proportional module and an integrator, the proportional module and the integrator being connected in series.
[0080] This single-phase phase-locked loop (PLL) enhances the loop's filtering capability and improves phase-locking accuracy and speed by adding a nonlinear saturation PI control module to the PI control of the loop filter. This allows it to accurately acquire the phase signal and complete the phase-locking process even under simultaneous harmonic interference. However, when the quadrature generator system generates a DC component, the system cannot quickly and accurately filter out the DC component. Therefore, a pre-compensator is added to suppress the DC component, working in conjunction with the nonlinear saturation module to quickly and accurately complete phase-locking.
[0081] See Figure 3 In this embodiment of the invention, the nonlinear saturation PI control module specifically performs an integral separation algorithm on the PI controller. By comparing the current value of the input signal with the set saturation value, if the current value is greater than the saturation value, the module accumulates a negative error; otherwise, it accumulates a positive error. The nonlinear saturation PI control module includes a proportional module, an integral module, a limiting module, and a nonlinear saturation difference module.
[0082] The proportional module and the integral module perform proportional and integral operations on the input phase error signal, respectively, and then add the control quantities output by the two modules to generate the original control signal.
[0083] The limiting module receives the original control signal, limits it to a preset upper and lower threshold range, and outputs a limited control signal to drive the subsequent actuator.
[0084] The nonlinear saturation difference detection module simultaneously receives the original control signal and the limited control signal, calculates the difference between the two, and sends the difference as a feedback signal to the input of the integration module.
[0085] Depend on Figure 3 Therefore, the PI output is... The expression is:
[0086] (3);
[0087] Where L is the highest value of the saturation module, equal to PI input Caused output change Represented as:
[0088] (4);
[0089] Where E is a constant error; if For a linear equation with slope A, the first-order differential equation can be obtained from equation (3):
[0090] (5);
[0091] From equation (5), we can obtain its general solution as:
[0092] (6);
[0093] As shown in equation (6), the saturation limiting capability of the integrator can be adjusted by changing the value of the coefficient k. The larger k is, the better. The smaller the value of k, the stronger the integrator's ability to exit saturation and the faster it operates; conversely, the larger the value, the weaker and slower it is. Generally, the range of k values is... .like Then, multiple feedback cycles are needed for integration and weakening, resulting in a slower dynamic response speed; if Excessive attenuation can lead to reverse saturation, causing the system to alternate between forward and reverse saturation, resulting in cyclic saturation. Therefore, by setting appropriate coefficients for integral attenuation, the PI filter's capability can be significantly improved, enhancing the PLL's anti-interference ability and accelerating its dynamic response.
[0094] When the output has not reached saturation, there is ,at this time Therefore, it will not affect the integrator. When the PI controller reaches saturation, then... Assuming positive saturation occurs, at this time Then there is .
[0095] See Figure 3 saturation error The product with k is fed back to the integration module, and the feedback is... Represented as:
[0096] (7);
[0097] As can be seen from equation (7), when the PI controller reaches saturation for the first time, it generates a saturation error Δy, which is weakened by negative feedback to the integral module. Therefore, the controller immediately enters the desaturation state. Since the time to enter the saturation state is short and there are no multiple consecutive integrations, the controller can still work and quickly make corresponding changes to the deviation. The controller performs a saturation error calculation before each integration. Therefore, once saturation is reached, the system immediately weakens the integration, reduces its overshoot, and quickly exits the saturation state. The recovery time is short, the system control is stable, and the system will not run out of control.
[0098] The single-phase phase-locked loop of the anti-saturation loop filter can quickly and accurately obtain phase signals for the grid-connected control of distributed photovoltaic power generation when grid distortion occurs, thereby improving the anti-interference capability and reliability of distributed photovoltaic power generation grid connection. At the same time, it can ensure the synchronization of distributed grid-connected power supply, reduce the impact on the grid during grid connection, and provide reliable technical conditions for distributed energy grid connection.
[0099] Furthermore, the functional modules in the various embodiments of the present invention can be integrated into one processing unit, or each unit can exist physically separately, or two or more units can be integrated into one unit. The integrated unit can be implemented in hardware or in the form of hardware plus software functional modules.
[0100] The above description has been provided for purposes of illustration and description. Furthermore, this description is not intended to limit the embodiments of the invention to the forms disclosed herein. Although numerous exemplary aspects and embodiments have been discussed above, those skilled in the art will recognize certain variations, modifications, alterations, additions, and sub-combinations thereof.
Claims
1. A single-phase phase-locked loop for grid connection of distributed photovoltaic power generation, characterized in that, include: An orthogonal generator is used to obtain a first sine signal and a second sine signal from an input single-phase voltage signal through virtual orthogonal decomposition, and the first sine signal and the second sine signal are orthogonal. A pre-compensator is installed on the first sine signal circuit to perform negative feedback elimination on the DC component generated by the sine generator; The phase detector obtains phase information from the first and second sinusoidal signals through Park transform. The nonlinear saturation PI control module performs an integral separation algorithm on the PI controller. By comparing the current value of the input signal with the set saturation value, the module accumulates a negative error when the current value is greater than the saturation value, and a positive error when the current value is less than the saturation value. A voltage-controlled oscillator adjusts the angular frequency output by the nonlinear saturation PI control module, and the phase angle is obtained by integrating the angular frequency. The feedback closed-loop module is used to feed the phase angle back to the phase detector.
2. The single-phase phase-locked loop for distributed photovoltaic power generation grid connection according to claim 1, characterized in that, The quadrature generator filters the DC component of the input voltage, and after decomposition by a second-order generalized integrator, the second sinusoidal signal... It functions like a bandpass filter, effectively filtering out DC components and the first sinusoidal signal. This acts like a low-pass filter, preserving the DC component of the input voltage, thus causing the phase-locked loop to exhibit second-order oscillations. Therefore, in the first sinusoidal signal... A negative feedback loop is added to the circuit. When a DC component appears, negative feedback is used to eliminate it, thereby suppressing the DC component and preventing it from affecting the subsequent phase-locked loop. Among them, the closed-loop transfer function for: (1); In formula (1) , The two parameters of the PI controller are given by the following formula: (2); In formula (2) Indicates the natural oscillation frequency, This represents the damping coefficient.
3. The single-phase phase-locked loop for distributed photovoltaic power generation grid connection according to claim 1, characterized in that, It also includes a phase error detection module, which detects phase errors when phase locking is successful. ; If there is a phase deviation This generates an error signal.
4. The single-phase phase-locked loop for distributed photovoltaic power generation grid connection according to claim 1, characterized in that, The pre-compensator is used to provide negative feedback elimination and suppress DC components; the pre-compensator includes a proportional module and an integrator, with the proportional module and integrator connected in series.
5. The single-phase phase-locked loop for grid connection of distributed photovoltaic power generation according to claim 1, characterized in that, The nonlinear saturation PI control module includes: a proportional module, an integral module, a limiting module, and a nonlinear saturation difference module; The proportional module and the integral module perform proportional and integral operations on the input phase error signal, respectively, and then superimpose the control quantities output by the two modules to generate the original control signal. The limiting module receives the original control signal, limits it to a preset upper and lower threshold range, and outputs a limited control signal to drive the subsequent actuator. The nonlinear saturation difference detection module simultaneously receives the original control signal and the limited control signal, calculates the difference between the two, and sends the difference as a feedback signal to the input of the integration module.
6. The single-phase phase-locked loop for distributed photovoltaic power generation grid connection according to claim 1, characterized in that, The nonlinear saturation PI control module specifically performs an integral separation algorithm on the PI controller. It compares the current value of the input signal with a set saturation value; if the current value is greater than the saturation value, the module accumulates a negative error; otherwise, it accumulates a positive error. PI output The expression is: (3); Where L is the highest value of the saturation module, equal to PI input Caused output change Represented as: (4); Where E is a constant error; if For a linear equation with slope A, the first-order differential equation can be obtained from equation (3): (5); From equation (5), we can obtain its general solution as: (6); As can be seen from equation (6), the saturation limiting capability of the integrator can be adjusted by changing the value of the coefficient k. The larger, The smaller the value, the stronger and faster the integrator can exit saturation; conversely, the larger the value, the weaker and slower it is.
7. The single-phase phase-locked loop for distributed photovoltaic power generation grid connection according to claim 6, characterized in that, The The range of values is .
8. The single-phase phase-locked loop for distributed photovoltaic power generation grid connection according to claim 1, characterized in that, The nonlinear saturation difference detection module specifically performs the following: it detects the saturation error. and The product is then fed back to the integration module. Represented as: (7); As can be seen from equation (7), when the PI controller reaches saturation for the first time, it generates a saturation error Δy, which is weakened by negative feedback to the integral module. Therefore, the controller immediately enters a desaturation state.
