ORDER FOR THE CONDITION OF IN-VITRO BIOCOMPATIBILITY TESTS

DE502019012406D1Active Publication Date: 2024-11-21FRAUNHOFER GESELLSCHAFT ZUR FORDERUNG DER ANGEWANDTEN FORSCHUNG EV
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
DE502019012406
Authority / Receiving Office
DE · DE
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2018-12-11
Filing Date
2019-09-12
Publication Date
2024-11-21
Estimated Expiration
2039-09-12

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Current in-vitro biocompatibility testing methods for materials, especially in medical technology, face challenges in standardizing surface area and volume ratios, handling sterility, and accommodating varying sample geometries and sizes, leading to inaccurate and labor-intensive biological evaluations.

Method used

A modular arrangement featuring a base plate with a receiving element and a cover element that forms a high-cavity structure with a fluid-tight seal, allowing precise alignment and deformation to create standardized cavities for biological testing, eliminating the need for adhesives and ensuring easy sterile handling.

Benefits of technology

This solution enables precise, reproducible biological evaluations by standardizing the surface area and volume for each sample, reducing errors, and facilitating the testing of diverse materials with varying geometries and sizes, while ensuring sterility and gas exchange.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.
Patent Text Reader
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[0001] The invention relates to an arrangement for conducting in vitro biocompatibility tests for preferably different, at least one-sidedly planar, dense material samples that can be examined with a liquid or solution containing biological material. Investigations on materials that can be used in medical technology are of particular interest. These can be, for example, materials for implants or coated surfaces in cell culture and for diagnostic tests.

[0002] The biological evaluation of solid, solvent-impermeable test materials generally takes place within a solution according to the current state of the art. This means that a sample / test material is placed in a microtiter plate and embedded in a suitable solution (e.g., cell culture medium), allowing the solution to completely surround the sample.

[0003] When considering the entire sample, significant differences in the specific surface area occur between different materials or even between different manufacturers, due to the size and height of the sample. Even within the same material, it is technically highly challenging to produce two identical material samples. In addition, a sample usually has only one "good" side, which represents the surface properties of the material. The described differences and influencing factors have an impact on quantifiable biological results.

[0004] There is a lack of a standardized, low-labor methodology that exclusively offers a defined surface on the good side of a sample for biological evaluation, creates a base area-to-volume ratio within a cavity suitable for cell culture tests, and at the same time is easy to handle in a sterile manner and ensures that this defined surface can be transferred to other test specimens at the same time.

[0005] For the biological assessment of materials in the medical device context, there are currently clear instructions provided by the DIN EN ISO 10993 standard. This standard specifies that a sample / test material is placed in a microtiter plate and embedded in a solution, and relevant testing procedures are performed on the entire volume of the solution. Since a standard prescribes the minimum testing requirements, it has not been necessary to expand the testing approach from the manufacturer's / testing laboratory's perspective.

[0006] The invention standardizes the testing procedure by applying the same surface area and volume of liquid to each sample, and ensuring that the biological material only comes into contact with the solution on the good side of the sample. Biological results, even between materials, thus become quantifiable, and comparisons become significantly more precise.

[0007] Microtiter plates are frequently used in biological testing scenarios. There are various formats, such as 6-well, 12-well, 24-well, and 96-well plates. The wells (cavities) of a microtiter plate are all the same size. Typically, the smallest possible well size is selected that accommodates the sample to be tested. Therefore, it is disadvantageous for microtiter plates to test different sample geometries or samples with the same geometry but slight size differences in the same well format, as this leads to a high, multifactorial error rate. Furthermore, the interaction of the biological material with the surrounding plastic microtiter plate is completely neglected.

[0008] Adhesive solutions are also known that have cavities up to 2.5 mm deep. The adhesive effect is released when a sample is pressed onto them. They are only used on relatively smooth surfaces and frequently for cell microscopy purposes. Due to the shallow depth of the cavity alone, this solution is unsuitable for our material testing purposes, as it does not offer an adequate surface area-to-volume ratio for cell culture preparations. A further significant disadvantage could be that the adhesive migrates into the cell culture medium and potentially has a cytotoxic effect or interacts with dissolved biological material. Furthermore, adhesive residues could remain on the material sample after use, requiring subsequent cleaning.

[0009] In addition to adhesive and printing solutions, there is the physical barrier solution (hydrophobic barrier), which relies on the generation of hydrophobic properties in the boundary region. These hydrophobic regions can have a negative impact on the overall growth and cultivation of cells on the material surfaces being tested. Further disadvantages of these barrier solutions include the insufficient height of the cavities and their general suitability only for relatively smooth surfaces.

[0010] Published pressure solutions allow up to 100 µL of volume to be stored in a single cavity. For example, a screw cap presses elastic material onto a glass slide. These designs are intended for small volumes on glass slides. They do not offer sufficient flexibility for samples, especially those with different geometries and sizes. Furthermore, cell culture experiments lasting several days are not possible in these small volumes without ensuring gas exchange.

[0011] All solutions listed were developed for glass slides or relatively smooth surfaces and may be unsuitable for other surfaces, particularly due to varying degrees of roughness. The hydrophobic barrier solution, in particular, may sometimes lose its impermeability on rough surfaces. Furthermore, all of the solutions listed are very labor-intensive when processing multiple specimens simultaneously. Some of the solutions listed also lack easy sterile handling of the specimens with the created cavity, requiring additional "packaging" in Petri dishes or similar.

[0012] For example, US 2008 / 0293157 A1 discloses a device and a method for conducting cell culture studies of biomaterials.

[0013] US 2005 / 0135974 A1 relates to a device for preparing multiple samples with multiple array surfaces.

[0014] US 2004 / 0071605 A1 describes an analysis device for a large number of samples.

[0015] US 2007 / 0054273 A1 discloses a microarray device having controllable reaction volumes.

[0016] It is therefore an object of the invention to provide possibilities for testing samples when carrying out in-vitro biocompatibility tests, in which a standardized surface is produced on test specimens of different roughnesses, a less labor-intensive production of these cavities is possible even across several test specimens for comparison, and a simple sterile handling of the test specimens with produced cavities is ensured.

[0017] According to the invention, this object is achieved by an arrangement having the features of claim 1. Advantageous embodiments and further developments can be realized with features specified in subordinate claims.

[0018] At least one sample is arranged on a surface of a base plate. However, the at least one sample can also form a surface or a surface area of ​​the base plate. A receiving element having at least one opening can preferably be placed precisely.

[0019] A receiving element having at least one aperture can be placed on the at least one sample such that a first opening of the at least one aperture, facing toward the base plate, is located in the region of the at least one sample. The at least one sample and the at least one aperture form the hollow space of a cavity.

[0020] A cover element can be placed and secured onto the receiving element in such a way that a compressive force acts on the receiving element, resulting in at least partial deformation of the receiving element and the fluid-tight closure of the first opening of the at least one aperture, which is arranged toward the base plate. Thus, no fluid can escape there during an examination.

[0021] The sample should be dimensioned in such a way that its side, which is at least planar on one side, covers the edges of at least one opening pointing towards the base plate.

[0022] To compensate for different sample heights, plate- or disc-shaped elements with appropriately adjusted thickness can be advantageously arranged in the area of ​​one or more openings on the surface of the base plate facing the receiving element, between the base plate and the material sample. A sample can then be placed on such a plate- or disc-shaped element, as described above. This allows, in particular, height differences to be compensated. The insertion of positioning aids for easy alignment of samples on the surface of the base plate is possible.

[0023] The cavity of the respective at least one opening of the receiving element and the sample should form a cavity at least 5 mm high (undeformed state), whereby the inner surface of the opening should form the side wall and the sample should form the bottom of the cavity.

[0024] The lid element can be provided with matching openings for the receiving element, through which the respective cavity can be filled with a liquid that may contain, for example, living cells. The lid element can be provided with markings to facilitate the identification of the openings.

[0025] The base plate and lid element are connected to one another at one side, preferably by a hinge, and can also be interchangeable. This allows the lid element to be opened and closed to load the assembly, and examinations to be carried out while closed. When clamping the holding element between the base plate and lid element, the compressive forces can be exerted, for example, using a click-lock mechanism as an example of a positive connection. This eliminates the need for adhesive materials such as glue.

[0026] Closure elements are formed on the base plate and the cover element, with which a positive connection between the base plate and the cover element and a pressure force can be exerted on the receiving element.

[0027] The closure elements and a connection to the base plate and lid element are connected to each other, with the corresponding elements being arranged on opposite sides of the assembly. Thus, at least one joint, such as a film or hinge joint, can be arranged on one side and the closure elements on an opposite side.

[0028] This type of connection between the base plate and the lid element eliminates the need for additional elements that would otherwise be required to close the assembly, as these elements would have to be attached to the assembly as individual parts. For example, screw connections are critical due to their handling. Furthermore, additional elements complicate sterilization, and they may even require replacement after each examination. The arrangement according to the invention advantageously eliminates the need for additional, individually handled connecting elements that would have to be used to connect the base plate to a lid element.

[0029] To facilitate closing and opening the arrangement, a handle may be provided.

[0030] The receiving element is formed from or with an elastically deformable material, preferably having a Shore hardness in the range of 30 to 50. It can therefore be formed entirely from deformable material, particularly preferably from an elastically deformable material, or as a composite material, provided with elastically deformable material at least on the surface that rests against the base plate or at least one sample. This eliminates the need for additional sealing elements that must be secured with a positive and / or non-positive fit, which would also be disadvantageous during sterilization.

[0031] At least one opening should be arranged on the cover element in such a way that it leaves a second opening of the respective opening of the receiving element, which is arranged in the direction of the cover element, at least partially open.

[0032] A closure lid can also be placed on the lid element and preferably at least one construction element for a positive alignment is provided for a defined, predeterminable positioning and / or alignment on a surface of the closure lid and / or lid element.

[0033] A preferably at least partially optically transparent closure lid can be placed on the loaded and closed assembly. This allows the cover element openings to be sealed, thus ensuring sterile handling of the closed assembly outside of a sterile workbench. The closure lid should be able to be placed in a predetermined orientation and allow gas exchange between the environment and the cavity contents.

[0034] The lid element and the receiving element can have perforations that correspond to common corrugated formats and are modularly interchangeable. This also applies to the lid element and the matching receiving element.

[0035] A lid element may contain elements that enable gas exchange with the ambient atmosphere. This may be at least one opening. An opening may also be provided with a membrane that should be gas-permeable. A membrane can advantageously also be selectively permeable to at least one selected gas or gas mixture.

[0036] The holding element should be held in a form-fitting manner in the base plate and / or the cover element. This allows for a defined fixation of the apertures in relation to the arrangement of the respective samples.

[0037] Multiple apertures can be configured or arranged in assigned groups. Depending on the sample size, a group of apertures in a receiving element can be used for each sample. Identical groups of cavities can be created on multiple samples. This allows for multiple determinations on a single sample and multiple determinations across multiple samples. Likewise, different tests can be performed on a single sample in parallel.

[0038] Several different samples can also be arranged on one surface of a base plate, or the different samples can each form a surface or a surface area of ​​the base plate. At least one opening can be provided on the base plate for inserting and removing objects, in particular slides. Through such an opening, objects can be specifically inserted into the arrangement from the outside, moved within it, and removed again. At least one edge present on the opening can facilitate the insertion and removal of an object into or from the arrangement.

[0039] To date, the microtiter plate formats commonly used in molecular / cellular biology have been chosen as standardized surfaces. Microtiter plates utilize small, defined, round cavities for standardized molecular biological testing. This provides a very good reference point or comparison to established biological evaluation methods in the laboratory. The invention advantageously utilizes mounting elements whose format corresponds to or is close to conventional microtiter plates.

[0040] The invention provides a confined, watertight space with a standardized surface area and at least one opening for at least one sample or test specimen. The height of the resulting cavities is ≥ 5 mm. By creating standardized or identical surfaces on the samples and adjusting the liquid volume in these cavities, biological evaluation of samples can be made far more accurate than previously possible. The invention systematically eliminates the possibility of edges, walls, and backs of openings with the corresponding surfaces of the base plate and lid element, as well as associated sources of error with regard to quantifiable biological results.

[0041] A contact pressure solution eliminates the need for adhesives or similar substances that diffuse into the liquid upon contact with solutions. Furthermore, the receiving element remains completely untreated, as the elastic material leaves no residue on a sample or test specimen. The receiving element is preferably made of a biocompatible and, if necessary, a chemically inert material, so that interactions with solvents or biological material can be minimized during the test period. Furthermore, the invention can be reliably solvent-tight, even on rough surfaces, as the elastic material easily presses against the surfaces.

[0042] The invention can be used to compare samples / test specimens of various material compositions and dimensions in a standardized, biological context. Material testing in the field of medical technology (including implants) in particular offers a wide range of material compositions and material properties, for which such a comparison method that delivers representative and reproducible results is urgently required.

[0043] The invention can also be used to carry out biological investigations with samples coated with a material, degradable materials and material coatings in which the described arrangement can be adapted to ensure the relative fluid density during the experiment.

[0044] The invention allows for the biological assessment of materials to be used / offered in routine laboratories. In the future, patient-specific reactions to different materials can also be tested, allowing for customized material compositions to be offered.

[0045] The invention offers a vast range of applications in biological and materials science research, as in principle all materials that are impermeable for the duration of the study can be subjected to standardized biological testing. Using the inventive setup, the molecular biological assays established for microtiter plates can be directly transferred to material testing, and the resulting quantitative measurement data can be used to directly compare the material with the microtiter plate as a reference.

[0046] In the field of biological testing of medical devices (ISO 10993), the invention could enable the use of new quantitative methods that would not be possible without the creation of a standardized surface on the good side of a test specimen.

[0047] The invention will be explained in more detail below by way of example.

[0048] Showing: Figure 1 a-c an example of a base plate with a suitable receiving element and a sample in perspective view; Figure 2 a perspective view of a base plate with inserted sample; Figure 3 a perspective view of a base plate with inserted sample and attached receiving element; Figure 4 an example of a cover element that can be used in the arrangement according to the invention; Figure 5 an assembly drawing of an example of an arrangement according to the invention; Figure 6an example of a closure cap and Figure 7 a closure lid which is placed on an arrangement consisting of a base plate, a sample with a receiving element and a cover element.

[0049] In Figure 1a An example of a base plate 1 is shown. The base plate 1 contains receptacles 1.3 for a positive fit of samples 3.

[0050] In addition, a slit-shaped opening 1.1 for the insertion and removal of objects, in particular slides, and an edge 1.2, which is intended to simplify this process, are provided.

[0051] Figure 1b shows an example of a sample 3 that can be placed on a surface of the base plate 1. This preferably takes place in the area of ​​a receptacle 1.3.

[0052] After inserting at least one sample 3, a Figure 1cThe receiving element 2 shown is placed on the base plate 1. Openings 2.1 are provided on the receiving element 2 and are arranged in such a way that they communicate with a surface area of ​​a sample 3 and can thus form a cavity that can be filled with a liquid, in particular containing biological material, in order to be able to examine the respective sample 3 in biological or biochemical scenarios. This structure is shown in Figure 3 shown.

[0053] The Figure 4The cover element 4 shown can be pivotally connected to the base plate 1 at one end face. In this example, the cover element 4 also has openings 4.2 arranged such that they communicate with the samples 3 and the openings 2.1 in the receiving element 2, allowing liquids to be filled into and removed from the openings 2.1 and gas exchange to take place. In addition, the contents of the cavities can be visually monitored. On the end face of the cover element 4, which is arranged opposite the pivotal connection, an edge 4.4 is formed which, when assembled, can engage behind a lower edge 1.4 of the base plate 1 for a positive connection. This allows compressive forces to be exerted on the elastically deformable receiving element 2, causing it to be compressed and seal the cavities in a fluid-tight manner. The receiving element 2 is elastically deformed in the process.To facilitate opening and closing of the assembly, a handle element 4.3 may be provided on this front edge.

[0054] Figure 5 shows an assembled closed state.

[0055] Markings or identification elements, for example in the form of letters and / or numbers, may be present on the lid element 4 to facilitate the assignment and identification of specific samples 3.

[0056] The Figure 6 The closure cover 5 shown can be placed on the cover element 4 and fastened to the cover element 4 and / or the base plate 1 in a form-fitting manner, as shown in Figure 7 is shown. For this purpose, the closure lid 5 has a circumferential edge 5.1, which, in interaction with the edge 4.1 of the lid element 4, enables it to be placed on the lid element 4 in a predetermined orientation.

[0057] The closure cover 5 should be optically transparent at least in the area covering openings 2.1 and 4.2.

[0058] The receiving element 2 can, for example, consist of a silicone and have dimensions as mentioned in the general part of the description.

[0059] The surface of the base plate 1 on which the receiving element 2 is placed has web-shaped elevations against which outer edges of the receiving element 2 can rest, thus achieving a positive fit of the receiving element 2 on the base plate 1.

[0060] Web-shaped elevations in the direction of the receiving element 2 can also be formed on the cover element 4, with which a positive hold of the receiving element 2 can be achieved.

[0061] At one end, base plate 1 and cover element 4 can be hinged together, allowing the cover element 4 to be opened and closed. On the opposite end, closure elements can be formed on base plate 1 and cover element 4. These can form a type of clip or snap closure when the cover element 4 closes the assembly.

[0062] The closure elements can be designed, dimensioned and arranged in such a way that when the cover element 4 is closed and the closure elements engage positively between the base plate 1 and the cover element 4, the compressive forces act on the receiving element 2, with which the necessary deformation leads to the closing of the openings of perforations 2.1 arranged on the surface of the respective sample 3.

[0063] With the compressive forces acting between the base plate 1 and the cover element 4 on the receiving element 2 and the surface of the sample(s) 3 facing the receiving element 2, a fluid-tight seal can be achieved between the surface of the receiving element 2 and the surface of the sample(s) 3 facing it in the area of ​​the cavities when the receiving element 2 is appropriately deformed. To this end, the respective surface areas of the sample(s) 3 in the area of ​​the first openings and the design in this area should be dimensioned and selected such that no liquid can escape.

[0064] Openings 4.2 are provided on the lid element 4, which are dimensioned and arranged such that second openings of perforations 2.1 arranged on the lid element 4 are kept free, so that gas exchange with the environment can take place. The cavities formed by the perforations 2.1 and the sample(s) 3 can be filled with biological material and solvent via the second openings, which are arranged on the surface of the receiving element 2 opposite the first openings, i.e. on the side facing the lid element 4, before the respective test is carried out. During or after a test, liquid can also be removed through the perforations 2.1 and 4.2, so that washing steps of the cavities are also possible.

[0065] In this example, base plate 1, lid element 4 and closure lid 5 are made of autoclavable plastic (polycarbonate).

Claims

1. An assembly for performing in-vitro biocompatibility tests with a receiving element (2) and a cover element (4), in which at least one sample (3) is arranged on a surface of a base plate (1) or in which the at least one sample (3) forms a surface or a surface area of the base plate (1) and the receiving element (2) having at least one through-hole (2.1) can be placed on the at least one sample (3) such that a first opening, which is disposed pointing in the direction of the base plate (1), of the at least one through-hole (2.1) is arranged in the region of the at least one sample (3), wherein the at least one through-hole (2.1) with its hollow area and the sample (3) form a cavity, and the receiving element (2) is made from or with an elastically deformable material; and the cover element (4) can be placed and fixed onto the receiving element (2) such that a pressure force acts on the receiving element (2), which leads to an at least partial deformation of the receiving element (2) and the fluid-tight closure of the first opening, which is disposed pointing in the direction of the base plate (1), of the at least one through-hole (2.1); and closure elements (1.4, 4.4) are formed on the base plate (1) and on the cover element (4) in order to achieve a positive connection between the base plate (1) and the cover element (4) and to exert a compressive force on the receiving element (2), wherein the closure elements (1.4, 4.4) and a connection between the base plate (1) and the cover element (4) are connected to one another and are arranged on opposite sides of the arrangement.

2. The assembly according to claim 1, characterized in that the receiving element (2) is made from a biocompatible and / or sterilizable material.

3. The assembly according to any one of the preceding claims, characterized in that the receiving element (2) is made from or with an elastically deformable material which has a Shore hardness in the range of 30 to 50.

4. The assembly according to any one of the preceding claims, characterized in that the at least one sample (3) can be fixed positively on the surface of the base plate (1).

5. The assembly according to any one of the preceding claims, characterized in that at least one opening (4.2) is arranged on the cover element (4) such that it leaves at least partially open a second opening of the respective through-hole (2.1) of the receiving element (2) which is arranged in the direction of the cover element (4).

6. The assembly according to any one of the preceding claims, characterized in that the base plate (1) and the cover element (4) are connected to one another on one side by at least one joint.

7. The assembly according to any one of the preceding claims, characterized in that according to the current well formats in cell culture research, the cover element (4) and the receiving element (2) adapted thereto are exchangeable in a modular manner.

8. The assembly according to any one of the preceding claims, characterized in that the at least one sample (3) can be inserted in a cavity (1.3) which is formed in the base plate (1) and, after placing the receiving element (2) one or more through-holes (2.1) are provided in the region of a sample (3) and the respective sample (3) does not thereby contact the inner wall of the adjacent through-holes (2.1) of the receiving element (2).

9. The assembly according to any one of the preceding claims, characterized in that a plurality of through-holes (2.1) are formed or arranged in associated groups.

10. The assembly according to any one of the preceding claims, characterized in that the receiving element (2) is retained positively in the base plate (1) and / or the cover element (4).

11. The assembly according to any one of the preceding claims, characterized in that a closure cover (5) can be placed onto the cover element (4), allows gas exchange with the environment and, preferably for a defined predeterminable positioning and / or orientation on a surface of the closure cover (5) and / or cover element (4), at least one construction element (4.1, 5.1) is provided for a positive orientation.

12. The assembly according to any one of the preceding claims, characterized in that on the base plate (1), at least one opening (1.1) is provided for guiding objects in and out, in particular object carriers.

13. The assembly according to any one of the preceding claims, characterized in that elements which allow gas exchange with the ambient atmosphere are provided on the cover element (4) and / or on the closing cover (5).

14. The assembly according to any one of the preceding claims, characterized in that a plurality of different samples (3) are arranged on a surface of a base plate (1) or the various samples (3) respectively form a surface or a surface area of the base plate (1).