Routing method and device for a twin-engine aircraft with an economical operating mode
The routing method for twin-engine aircraft optimizes flight routes by considering AEO and economical modes, addressing increased costs and safety concerns, and ensuring efficient fuel use and maintenance, using a computer to calculate and compare routes based on flight plan parameters and environmental data.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- FR2023004721
- Authority / Receiving Office
- FR · FR
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-05-12
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-15
- Estimated Expiration
- 2043-05-12
AI Technical Summary
The use of an economical operating mode in twin-engine aircraft, where one engine is idle, can lead to increased flight time and maintenance costs, and its effectiveness is influenced by operational conditions and energy costs, making it a complex decision for operators.
A routing method and system that considers both AEO and economical operating modes, using a computer to calculate and compare routes based on flight plan parameters, aircraft performance, environmental data, and cost models to optimize operational costs, including emergency landing areas if necessary.
The method optimizes flight routes to minimize operational costs by judicious use of the economical mode, balancing engine usage and maintenance, while ensuring safety and compliance with environmental considerations.
Smart Images

Figure 00000000_0001_ABST 
Figure 00000000_0000_ABST
Abstract
Description
Title of the invention: Routing method and device for a twin-engine aircraft having an economical operating mode
[0001] The present invention is in the field of aircraft navigation assistance systems.
[0002] The present invention relates to a routing method and device for a twin-engine aircraft having an economical operating mode.
[0003] The present invention is intended for rotary wing aircraft equipped with at least two heat engines and at least one rotor, the heat engines driving the respective rotor(s) of these aircraft in rotation.
[0004] A rotary wing aircraft comprises at least one rotor that can be driven in rotation by at least two heat engines. The heat engines are further oversized to allow the rotor to be driven with a single engine, in the event of failure of another engine. Such an aircraft comprises a so-called "total" or "AEO" operating mode for the English designation "All Engines Operative" in which each heat engine provides non-zero mechanical power to said at least one rotor, the heat engines jointly and substantially symmetrically providing the required mechanical power to said at least one rotor.
[0005] In order to reduce the fuel consumption of the aircraft's thermal engines, a so-called "economical" operating mode can be used, mainly during a cruising flight phase. According to this economical operating mode, a single thermal engine provides the power necessary to drive the rotor of the aircraft in rotation. The other thermal engine(s) do not provide significant mechanical power, or even provide no power at all. This economical operating mode is therefore an asymmetrical operation of the thermal engines, the thermal engines not operating in an identical manner.
[0006] Such an economical operating mode is interesting but must be used judiciously. Indeed, the economical operating mode can make it possible to obtain a gain in consumption to directly reduce the cost of the flight, its environmental footprint or to improve the performance of the aircraft by increasing the distance that can be covered by the aircraft or its transportable mass. However, the economical operating mode can be limited to a certain flight envelope, on the one hand so that flight safety is always ensured, and on the other hand so that the power plant provides the power required for the current flight phase.
[0007] For example, the economic operating mode must be engaged with a minimum safety height above the ground flown over in order to allow, in the event of failure of the motor driving the rotor, the reactivation of another motor.
[0008] According to another example, during high-speed forward flight phases, the aircraft requires significant engine power that cannot be provided by the economical operating mode without the risk of specific damage to the thermal engine and / or the mechanical transmission chain, this damage then being likely to generate additional maintenance costs.
[0009] Thus, the economical operating mode results in a reduction in the speed of the aircraft, consequently increasing the flight time and, consequently, the operational cost of this flight.
[0010] In these cases, the costs induced by the increased flight time and / or by the additional maintenance costs may prove to be greater than the gain obtained by the reduction in fuel consumption or the improvement in the performance of the aircraft.
[0011] According to another example, depending on the operational conditions of the aircraft, such as the wind, the outside temperature or even the altitude, the performance of a heat engine fluctuates. These conditions can have an influence on the power developed by the heat engine and / or its fuel consumption. In fact, the use of the economical operating mode may prove less economical under these conditions than a traditional operating mode of heat engines in flight, or even impossible.
[0012] Finally, the introduction of new energies such as biofuels, which allow a reduction in polluting emissions but whose costs are significantly higher than those of fossil fuels, as well as the introduction of new carbon emission taxation schemes, bring additional variability which must be integrated into the thinking of an aircraft operator on the best use which can be made of these biofuels within the framework of this economical mode of operation.
[0013] Therefore, choosing whether or not to use the economic operating mode turns out to be a complex technical problem, both in terms of safety issues and economic issues for the operator.
[0014] Furthermore, establishing a routing involves establishing a flight plan between the departure and arrival points, a route between the departure and arrival points comprising successive waypoints to which an altitude, or even a forward speed, are associated. Estimated departure and arrival times or even the estimated flight duration may also be associated with the route. A flight plan may also include possible intermediate stages.
[0015] The data and parameters typically involved in establishing a routing include, in particular, current and forecast weather conditions. between the departure and arrival points as well as terrain data containing the relief and any known obstacles. Aircraft performance information can also be taken into account when establishing the flight plan.
[0016] Ecology and environmental preservation are also increasingly taken into account today in order to establish the routing of an aircraft, for example to limit its polluting emissions and / or the generation of noise, particularly near inhabited areas.
[0017] Document US 10262545 describes a system for determining operational parameters of a rotary-wing aircraft, including the flight plan, while optimizing its operating cost. In particular, the system receives input data, and provides, in particular in flight and in real time, operational parameters of the aircraft by applying a cost model. The input data taken into account include mission strategies, data from aircraft sensors, such as the speed, altitude, attitude, speeds and angular accelerations of the aircraft as well as damage data of aircraft equipment, for example engines, maintenance costs. The operational parameters include for example a flight plan and a plurality of optimized parameters associated with the flight plan.These optimized parameters include, for example, the operating mode of the aircraft's engines, for example by balancing the power supplied by several engines or by using an operating mode in which one engine is stopped in flight in order to reduce fuel consumption.
[0018] Document EP 2763083 relates to a route processing method generating several routes based on points of interest and environmental characteristics, in particular air pollution and noise pollution generated by the aircraft and / or economic characteristics, in particular its fuel consumption or its flight duration. Performance values can be associated with each new route.
[0019] The present invention then relates to a method and a routing system for an aircraft comprising at least two thermal engines allowing optimal consideration of an economical operating mode of the aircraft to optimize the fuel consumption of the aircraft, and consequently the operational cost of the flight.
[0020] First of all, the present invention relates to a routing method for an aircraft provided with at least one rotor and at least two thermal engines rotating said at least one rotor, the aircraft having a regulator configured to regulate the thermal engines at least according to an AEO operating mode in which each thermal engine provides non-zero mechanical power to said at least one rotor, the thermal engines jointly and substantially symmetrically providing the required mechanical power to said at least one rotor, and an economic operating mode in which at least one of the two engines thermal does not provide mechanical power to said at least one rotor. The method comprises the following steps: - setting parameters of a flight plan including: • a starting point of the flight plan, and • an arrival point of the flight plan, - determination using a computer of several possible routes between the departure point and the arrival point, based on the parameters of the flight plan and several data including at least aircraft performance data, aircraft health data, meteorological data, and environmental data, the determination including: • determination of at least one AEO route using only the AEO operating mode, • determination of at least one economic route using the economic operating mode and the AEO operating mode, - estimation using the calculator of an operational cost of each possible route, based on cost models associated with the different operating modes of the aircraft, the estimation including: • estimation of at least one AEO cost associated respectively with said at least one AEO route, • estimation of at least one economic cost associated respectively with said at least one economic route, - comparison of AEO and economic costs, - selection using the calculator of a route among the AEO and economic routes according to the comparison of AEO and economic costs.
[0021] The method according to the invention thus makes it possible to automatically select the route making it possible to minimize the operational cost of the flight, or to optimize this operational cost in combination with one or more other criteria, and by taking into account during the flight the AEO and economic operating modes as well as the conditions of use of the economic operating mode.
[0022] The method according to the invention thus advantageously makes it possible to assist an aircraft operator in preparing the flight by enabling optimization of the operational cost of the flight, thanks to optimized use of the operating modes of the aircraft and in particular the economic operating mode.
[0023] Indeed, inappropriate use of this economical mode of operation can generate more disadvantages than benefits, causing for example an extension of the flight duration not economically compensated by a reduction in fuel consumption.
[0024] For this purpose, several possible routes are calculated in parallel and independently. depending on the parameters of a flight plan, namely the departure and arrival points and possibly one or more waypoints and / or one or more passage corridors. Other constraints may also have to be respected for the flight plan, such as a maximum flight duration, an arrival time and / or a payload to be carried, for example.
[0025] The passage corridors define areas in which the aircraft must operate, for example with a minimum altitude and a maximum altitude for the cruise flight phases. The passage corridors also make it possible to define areas where flight is prohibited. Preferably, several AEO routes and several economic routes are calculated.
[0026] The possible routes are also calculated based on several data relating on the one hand to the aircraft and on the other hand to the flight environment.
[0027] Thus, aircraft performance data can be taken into account. This performance data makes it possible to define the performance of the aircraft, such as the limitations of the authorized flight envelope, the maximum speed of the aircraft, the power available at each thermal engine as well as their consumption and includes, for example, first performance data corresponding to the AEO operating mode of the aircraft, and second performance data corresponding to the economic operating mode of the aircraft.
[0028] These performance data include, for example, charts or laws making it possible to know the maximum speed of the aircraft, the power available for each thermal engine and its fuel consumption, as a function of operational conditions, such as the altitude, the total mass of the aircraft, the outside temperature as well as the atmospheric pressure, the heat capacities of the fuel used. These performance data may also include engine margins linked to the use or damage of the thermal engines as well as the specific configuration of the aircraft, including in particular the type of air intake and nozzle to recalibrate the theoretical performances on the real performances of each thermal engine.
[0029] Aircraft health data may also be taken into account and include data relating in particular to the use and damage of the heat engines and a mechanical transmission chain mechanically connecting said at least two heat engines and said at least one rotor. Such a mechanical transmission chain may include in particular a main transmission box responsible for transmitting the mechanical power delivered by the heat engines to the rotor. This health data includes, for example, one or more so-called “engine” counters associated with each heat engine, each engine counter characterizing usage data linked to the use or damage to a heat engine. An engine counter can, for example, record the operating hours of the heat engine, the damage it has suffered due to finning, as well as the number of cycles of a gas generator and a free turbine of a turboshaft engine.
[0030] This health data may include at least two so-called counters "transmission" associated for example respectively with input shafts of the main gearbox, the input shafts being mechanically connected respectively to the thermal engines, each transmission counter characterizing usage data linked to the use or damage of an input shaft. A transmission counter can for example count the number of input-output cycles of the economic operating mode of a freewheel of the main gearbox or the number of operating hours of an input shaft or its duration of use in economic mode.
[0031] Meteorological data may also be taken into account and include data relating to wind and temperature between the starting and finishing points inclusive as well as possibly at the crossing points and / or in the crossing corridors. These meteorological data may also include the presence of icing or bad weather areas between the starting and finishing points which may be incompatible with the use of the economical operating mode. These meteorological data may include measured data as well as forecasts.
[0032] Finally, environmental data can also be taken into account and include a terrain database allowing the relief to be taken into account as well as possibly artificial obstacles to establish possible routes. The terrain database can also include inhabited areas, possibly with the associated population density, in order to be able to take into account, if necessary, environmental nuisances, whether they relate to noise or air pollution with respect to these inhabited areas.
[0033] These different data can be stored in a memory of the computer or a memory connected to the computer.
[0034] The possible routes can be established in parallel and independently by the computer, for example by applying a known route calculation algorithm. A possible route can be defined by a succession of navigation points connected to each other by flight segments. These flight segments can be formed for example by straight lines, by curvilinear lines or by circular arcs.
[0035] Then, the estimation of an operational cost of each possible route can be carried out, based on cost models associated with the different operating modes of the aircraft. These cost models include an AEC cost model associated with the AEO operating mode and an economic cost model associated with the economic operating mode. The AEO and economic cost models include, in particular, the costs related to the fuel used, the hourly flight costs of the aircraft, the maintenance costs of the aircraft as well as the cost related to the aircraft crew.
[0036] The AEO and economic cost models make it possible to estimate the AEO and economic operational costs of possible AEO and economic routes based on the characteristics of these possible routes. For example, the operational cost of a route is estimated in particular based on the altitude of the waypoints, the duration of the flight as well as the operating mode used on each segment of these possible routes.
[0037] Comparing AEO and economic costs can thus make it possible to classify the different AEO and economic routes according to the values of their respective AEO and economic costs. This comparison of AEO and economic costs can also make it possible to determine the lowest AEO cost among the AEO costs and the lowest economic cost among the economic costs and / or the lowest operational cost among the AEO costs and the economic costs.
[0038] Finally, the method according to the invention makes it possible, from the plurality of possible routes calculated, to select a route from among all the AEO and economic routes established according to the operational costs of these possible routes. The route thus selected allows an optimized integration of the economic operating mode in the flight plan making it possible, for example, to minimize the operational cost of the flight, or to optimize this operational cost in combination with one or more other criteria. This selection step is carried out automatically, via the computer, for example by applying a “Monte Carlo” simulation possibly carried out in an oriented and non-random manner by a sampler called TPE for the English expression “Tree-structured Parsen Estimator”.Depending on the situation, the selected route may or may not include at least one segment requiring the implementation of the economic operating mode.
[0039] The aircraft routing method according to the invention may further comprise one or more of the following characteristics, taken alone or in combination.
[0040] According to one possibility, the comparison of AEO and economic costs can be carried out on the sole criterion of operational cost, the selected route being the possible route having the lowest operational cost among the AEO and economic costs.
[0041] Alternatively, the comparison of AEO and economic costs can be carried out on the criterion of operational cost combined with a complementary criterion.
[0042] This additional criterion can be, for example, chosen from flight duration, environmental nuisances, namely noise or air pollution, conditions weather conditions, to avoid a storm for example, the availability of emergency landing areas.
[0043] According to another possibility compatible with the previous ones, the economical operating mode may comprise a first operating mode, for which a single heat engine among said at least two heat engines operates and ensures the sole rotational drive of said at least one rotor, said at least one other heat engine being stopped and not supplied with fuel, and a second operating mode, for which a single heat engine among said at least two heat engines supplies mechanical power to said at least one rotor, to drive it in rotation, said at least one other heat engine being started and supplied with fuel, supplying no mechanical power to said at least one rotor.
[0044] According to another possibility compatible with the previous ones, each economic route can comprise several successive flight segments between the departure and arrival points, and the computer can determine for each segment an operating mode of the aircraft, from among the economic operating mode and the AEO operating mode, as a function of the characteristics of the segment, for example its altitude, its position, its orientation, its length, and the previously cited data. In particular, the economic operating mode is associated with a segment whose characteristics correspond to the authorized domain of this operating mode. Similarly, all the flight segments of an AEO route are associated with the AEO operating mode.
[0045] Furthermore, the calculator can determine, for each segment with which the economical operating mode is associated, information indicating the heat engine among the heat engines which must supply mechanical power to said at least one rotor.
[0046] This information can thus make it possible to alternate the operation of several engines during several successive flights, or even on the same flight, in order to balance the use and / or damage to the engines as well as the associated input shafts of a main transmission box to which each heat engine is connected. This information can be determined based on the health data of the aircraft, and in particular the engine counters and the transmission counters. Consequently, the maintenance of the heat engines and the main transmission box can be optimized.
[0047] According to another possibility compatible with the previous ones, the method can include a step of moving the aircraft between the departure and arrival points according to the selected route. In this way, this flight is carried out with a minimum operational cost or optimized according to an additional criterion.
[0048] For this purpose, the method may also comprise a step of transmitting the selected route to a flight management device of the aircraft with a view to implementing this step of moving the aircraft.
[0049] According to another example compatible with the previous ones, the method may comprise a step of displaying the selected route on a viewing device, such as a screen for example, in order to allow the operator to view the selected route.
[0050] According to another example compatible with the previous ones, the performance data may be specific to the thermal engines of the aircraft concerned, taking into account in particular the actual performances, in particular in terms of power, consumption, and damage, specific to each of these thermal engines, or even the aging of the transmission chain between each thermal engine and the rotor. An update of this performance data may, for example, be carried out following a maintenance operation, a monitoring operation or a health diagnosis carried out on the aircraft or on the thermal engine more specifically.
[0051] According to another example compatible with the previous ones, the method may comprise a step of identifying one or more emergency landing areas on the economic route(s), in the case where the economic operating mode cannot be carried out on at least part of the selected route.
[0052] Indeed, in the case where at least a part of said selected route cannot be carried out by requesting the planned economic operating mode, the fuel consumption of the aircraft will increase, and the aircraft may not be able to reach the arrival point. For example, a change in weather conditions, such as an increase in wind speed or a change in temperature, or the occurrence of a failure of a system of the aircraft may prevent the use of the planned economic operating mode.
[0053] The identification of one or more emergency landing areas then makes it possible to determine one or more emergency landing areas located near an economical route to which the aircraft can be diverted if the economical operating mode cannot be carried out on at least part of the selected route.
[0054] The present invention also relates to a computer program comprising instructions which, when the program is executed, lead to implementing the method according to the invention previously described. The program is for example executed by a computer or a calculator, comprising at least one processor, at least one integrated circuit, at least one programmable system, at least one logic circuit, and a memory, these examples not limiting the scope given to the expression "computer" or "calculator".
[0055] The memory allows the computer program to be stored as well as various in data used by the computer program, namely aircraft performance data and health data, cost models associated with the aircraft, weather data and environmental data.
[0056] The present invention also relates to a routing system for an aircraft provided with at least one rotor, and at least two thermal engines rotating said at least one rotor, the aircraft having an economical operating mode in which at least one of said at least two thermal engines does not provide mechanical power to said at least one rotor. This routing system comprises at least one computer, and at least one memory storing at least one database, for example performance data and health data of the aircraft, cost models associated with the aircraft, meteorological data and environmental data.
[0057] This routing system is configured to implement the method described above.
[0058] The routing system may be equipment not belonging to the aircraft and in fact independent of the aircraft. The routing system may then comprise at least one information transmitter and the aircraft may comprise at least one reception device and at least one flight management device connected to the reception device.
[0059] The routing system may alternatively be integrated into the aircraft and as such constitute equipment of the aircraft. The routing system may then be connected to a flight management device of the aircraft. In addition, the selected route may be displayed on a screen of the flight management device or on a screen of the aircraft.
[0060] The routing system may include a display device, such as a screen, to display the selected route to an aircraft operator.
[0061] The present invention also relates to a routing assembly comprising an aircraft and such a routing system not belonging to the aircraft. The aircraft comprises at least one reception device and at least one flight management device connected to the reception device. The routing system comprises at least one information transmitter configured to cooperate with the reception device of the aircraft in order to transmit the characteristics of the flight plan and the selected route to the reception device which transfers them to the flight management device of the aircraft.
[0062] The present invention finally aims at an aircraft comprising a routing system.
[0063] The invention and its advantages will appear in more detail in the context of the description which follows with examples given for illustrative purposes with reference to the appended figures which represent: - [Fig. 1], an aircraft routing assembly, - [Fig.2], a block diagram of an aircraft routing process, - [Fig.3], a graph showing corridors of a flight plan, and - [Fig.4], a graph representing the operational costs of possible routes based on two criteria.
[0064] Elements present in several distinct figures are assigned a single reference.
[0065] An aircraft routing system 50 is shown in [Fig. 1]. The routing system 50 comprises a computer 55 and a memory 56. Such a routing system 50 may also comprise a display device 59, such as a screen, as well as an information receiver 52 and an information transmitter 51. The information transmitter 51 and the information receiver 52 are, for example, respectively a receiver and a transmitter of radio waves of a wireless communication device of the routing system 50.
[0066] An aircraft 1 for which the routing system 50 is intended is a rotary wing aircraft, as shown in [Fig.l], comprising a fuselage 4, a landing gear 6, a power plant 10 and at least one rotor 2, 3 driven in rotation by the power plant 10. The power plant 10 comprises at least two heat engines 11, a regulator 14, regulating the operation of the heat engines 11, and a main gearbox 12 arranged between the heat engines 11 and the rotor(s) 2, 3. The main gearbox 12 comprises input shafts 13 each mechanically connected and distinctively to one of the heat engines 11 for example using a freewheel of the main gearbox 12.
[0067] By way of example, the aircraft 1 shown in [Fig.l] comprises two thermal engines 11 and two rotors 2, 3, namely a main rotor 2 arranged above the fuselage 4 and a rear rotor 3 arranged on a tail boom of the aircraft 1.
[0068] The regulator 14 may, for example, comprise as many engine controllers as the power plant 10 comprises thermal engines 11. Each engine controller may control the operation of a thermal engine 11 and record the usage data relating to this thermal engine 11. Such an engine controller is, for example, a controller of a system known by the acronym FADEC for the English designation “Full Authority Digital Engine Control”.
[0069] Furthermore, the aircraft 1 may also comprise a display device 17, a reception device 18 and a flight management device 15 connected to the reception device 18.
[0070] Finally, the aircraft 1 has a memory 19 responsible for recording the usage data of the main transmission box 12.
[0071] The power plant 10 can implement several operating modes in order to drive the rotors 2, 3. For example, in a so-called “total” or “AEO” operating mode, the regulator 14 regulates the operation of the thermal engines 11 so that all the engines 11 are used and each provide a power non-zero mechanical power to jointly provide the mechanical power necessary for the proper operation of rotors 2, 3 and aircraft 1.
[0072] Alternatively, the regulator 14 can regulate the operation of the thermal engines 11 so that a single engine 11 provides the mechanical power necessary for the proper operation of the rotors 2, 3 and of the aircraft 1 in a so-called “economical” operating mode. The other thermal engine(s) 11 of the power plant 10 then do not provide significant mechanical power to the rotors 2, 3. This economical operating mode aims to reduce the fuel consumption of the power plant 10. The economical operating mode is particularly intended for cruising flight.
[0073] The economical operating mode may comprise a first economical operating mode, in which the thermal engine(s) 11 do not provide mechanical power to the rotors 2, 3, and are stopped and are not supplied with fuel. In the case where the thermal engines 11 are free turbine turboshaft engines, the rotating members of the gas generator of this stopped turboshaft engine may however be kept rotating using an electrical machine to facilitate and accelerate the restarting of this turboshaft engine.
[0074] The economical operating mode may also include a second economical operating mode, in which the thermal engine(s) 11 not providing mechanical power to the rotors 2, 3 are started and operate in an idle state, thus not providing any mechanical power to the rotors 2, 3.
[0075] The economical operating mode can, when used wisely, make it possible to obtain financial savings by reducing fuel consumption, possibly in order to increase the range that can be covered by the aircraft 1 or the payload for a given quantity of fuel.
[0076] However, under unsuitable conditions, the economical operating mode may be counterproductive. For example, in the economical operating mode, the forward speed of the aircraft 1 is reduced, which lengthens the flight time and may contribute to increasing the total cost of the flight. In addition, in the economical operating mode, the power plant 10 operates asymmetrically, which may have an effect on maintenance operations and the associated cost.
[0077] The routing system 50 according to the invention makes it possible to address this problem by assisting an operator of the aircraft 1 in establishing a flight plan by taking into account the AED and economic operating modes. The routing system 50 is in fact configured to implement an aircraft routing method, a block diagram of which is shown in [Fig.2].
[0078] For this purpose, the memory 56 can store instructions and / or a computer program allowing in particular to execute this routing method. The computer 55 of the routing system 50 allows the execution of this routing method for aircraft.
[0079] Furthermore, the routing system 50 may be independent of the aircraft 1 and may cooperate with the aircraft 1 as shown in [Fig.l].
[0080] The receiving device 18 of the aircraft 1 can cooperate with the information transmitter 51 of the routing system 50 in order to receive characteristics of a flight plan, and in particular the characteristics of a route selected by the routing system 50, then to transfer them to the flight management device 15 of the aircraft 1 with a view to carrying out a flight of the aircraft 1 following this selected route.
[0081] In addition, the routing system 50 and the aircraft 1 may form a routing assembly 20.
[0082] Alternatively, the routing system 50 can be integrated into the aircraft 1 and constitute equipment of this aircraft 1.
[0083] The routing method comprises the following steps.
[0084] First of all, during a parameter setting step 110 of the flight plan parameters, the flight parameters of the envisaged mission are defined. This parameter setting step 110 makes it possible to define a starting point 31 and an arrival point 35. This parameter setting step 110 thus makes it possible to initialize the flight plan.
[0085] The starting point 31 and arrival point 35 are shown in [Fig. 1], on the display device 59 and in [Fig. 3]. In addition, corridors 32-34 are also shown in [Fig. 3] and define areas in which the aircraft 1 must operate. For example, the flight plan may include a takeoff corridor 32 starting at the starting point 31, a cruising corridor 33 and an arrival corridor 34 ending at the arrival point 35. The cruising corridor 33 makes it possible, for example, to define a minimum height ALTMin and a maximum height ALTMax relative to the ground flown over for the cruising flight phases.
[0086] Minimum height limitations ALTMinEco and maximum ALTMaxEco relative to the ground flown over relating to the flight envelope authorized in the economic operating mode are also shown in [Fig.3].
[0087] The minimum height ALTMin and the minimum height limitation ALTMinEco respond in particular to safety parameters in order to ensure a sufficient height margin for regaining control of the aircraft 1 in the event of an engine failure. These heights are therefore different depending on the operating mode and the number of engines in operation. In addition, the minimum altitude limitation ALTMinEco may include different and specific limitations for the first and second economic operating modes.
[0088] Other parameters of the flight plan may be defined during the parameterization step 110. For example, a maximum duration of the flight, one or more points of passage, and / or a fixed time or time interval for departure and / or arrival can be set. Mission-specific parameters, such as payload or flight type, e.g., visual or instrument flight, can also be defined.
[0089] These flight parameters are generally set by an operator of the aircraft 1. For example, the departure 31 and arrival 35 points can for example be entered directly on a map displayed on the display device 59 or by entering their coordinates via a suitable input device.
[0090] Then, the method comprises a determination step 120 to determine, with the computer 55 and using a known route calculation algorithm, several possible routes 37, 38 connecting the starting point 31 to the arrival point 35 as a function of several data and taking into account the parameters of the flight plan. This calculation step 120 is carried out prior to the takeoff of the aircraft 1.
[0091] The calculation step 120 comprises a first calculation sub-step 121 for calculating, with the calculator 55, one or more AEO routes 37, during which the aircraft 1 would use only the AEO operating mode.
[0092] The calculation step 120 comprises a second calculation sub-step 122 for calculating, with the computer 55, one or more economic routes 38, during which the aircraft 1 would at least partially use the economic operating mode and the AEO operating mode. In this case, as soon as the conditions for using the economic operating mode, and in particular the authorized flight envelope, are met over a part of the route, the economic operating mode is retained. Otherwise, the AEO operating mode is chosen.
[0093] A single AEO route 37 and a single economic route 38 are shown in [Fig.l]. However, the determination step 120 makes it possible to determine several AEO routes 37 and several economic routes 38, or even a multitude of AEO routes 37 and economic routes 38 covering the corridors 32-34.
[0094] The data allowing the determination of these possible routes 37, 38 comprise at least data relating to the aircraft 1 and data relating to the environment. These data are, for example, stored in the memory 56.
[0095] The data relating to the aircraft 1 comprise performance data of the aircraft 1 which comprise first performance data corresponding to the AEO operating mode, and second performance data corresponding to the economic operating mode. Some performance data may be common to both operating modes, such as a power required in flight to reach a given speed or the heat capacities of the fuel used, and others may be different and specific for each operating mode. For example, the limitations of the authorized flight envelope, such as the height and forward speed, as well as the available power and fuel consumption are specific for each operating mode. This performance data may also include engine margins specific to each thermal engine 11 making it possible to define the actual performance of each thermal engine 11.
[0096] These performance data can be taken into account in the form of charts determining, for example, the available power and fuel consumption of each thermal engine 11 as a function of the mass of the aircraft 1, its altitude, its speed and / or the external atmospheric conditions.
[0097] The data relating to the aircraft 1 also include health data of the aircraft 1, in particular at least two engine counters respectively characterizing usage data of the thermal engines 11, and at least two transmission counters respectively characterizing the usage data relating respectively to the input shafts 13, and including in particular the number of input-output cycles of the economic operating mode of the freewheel of the main transmission box 12, or the number of hours of operation in economic mode of the input shafts 13 of the main transmission box 12. Other health data may also be taken into account for the calculation 120 of the possible routes 37, 38, such as the use of electrical machines responsible for supporting one or more thermal engines 11 in economic operating mode for example.
[0098] The data relating to the environment include meteorological data including in particular data relating to wind and temperature, or even atmospheric pressure and the presence of bad weather between the departure points 31 and arrival points 35 as well as in the passage corridors 32-34. These meteorological data can be taken into account by the performance data of the aircraft 1, for example the charts mentioned above.
[0099] The environmental data also includes environmental data such as a terrain database. This terrain database lists permanent natural or artificial obstacles, or even temporary artificial obstacles. For example, the terrain database includes a mountain 70 as shown in [Fig.l].
[0100] The AEO route 37 and the economic route 38 represented in [Fig.l] are thus calculated according to these different data and the flight parameters.
[0101] However, the determining step 120 may conclude that only one type of possible routes is feasible among the AEO 37 and economic 38 routes, depending on the flight data and parameters. For example, given the distance between the departure 31 and arrival 35 points possibly combined with a large payload, it may be impossible to carry out the flight in AEO operating mode.
[0102] For similar reasons, the calculation step 120 may conclude that no possible route exists, either for an AEO mode of operation or for an economic mode of operation.
[0103] The possible routes 37, 38 may comprise several successive flight segments 41 between the departure 31 and arrival 35 points, as shown in [Fig. 1]. Each flight segment 41 corresponds to a part of the possible route 37, 38 and characteristics of the flight of the aircraft 1 are associated with each of these flight segments 41. These characteristics of the flight of the aircraft 1 associated with each of these flight segments 41 are elements of the flight plan, such as the altitude, the forward speed, the position, the heading for example, and are defined during the determination step 120.
[0104] For the AEO routes 37, the computer 55 associates the AEO operating mode with each flight segment 41. For the economic routes 38, the computer 55 associates an operating mode from among the economic operating mode and the AEO operating mode with each flight segment 41, as well as possibly information indicating which thermal engine 11 from among the thermal engines 11 must supply the mechanical power to the rotors 2, 3.
[0105] According to the examples of possible routes 37,38 displayed in [Fig.l], the environmental data made it possible to identify the mountain 70 located between the starting point 31 and the arrival point 35. The summit 72 of the mountain 70 has an altitude greater than the maximum height ALTMax defined by the corridor 33. The altitude of the flank 71 of this mountain 70 is lower than this minimum height ALTMin, and higher than the maximum height limitation ALTMaxEco.
[0106] Consequently, the AEO route 37 displayed in [Fig.l] was defined according to four flight segments 41 during the calculation step 121, these four flight segments 41 being flown with the aircraft 1 in AEO operating mode. A takeoff segment 42 starts at the departure point 31 and respects the departure corridor 32. Then, two cruise segments 45, 46 fly over the flank 71 and around the apex 72 while respecting the departure corridor 32. Finally, a landing segment 44 ends at the arrival point, respecting the arrival corridor 34.
[0107] The economic route 38 displayed in [Fig.l] has been defined according to three flight segments 41 during the calculation step 122. The takeoff segment 42 and the arrival segment 44 are identical to those of the AEO route 37 and traveled with the aircraft 1 in AEO operating mode. Then, a cruise segment 48, located between the takeoff segments 42 and the arrival segment 44, goes around the mountain 70 while respecting the cruise corridor 33 as well as the minimum height limitations ALTMinEco and maximum ALTMaxEco. From then on, the cruise segment 48 can be traveled with the aircraft 1 in economic operating mode.
[0108] In addition, the determining step 120 may comprise an additional identification sub-step 125 for identifying one or more emergency landing areas 36 in the vicinity of each economic route 38 calculated in the determining step 122. Such an emergency landing area 36 may be necessary for flight safety. A diversion point 39 located on the economic route 38 may also be defined, the aircraft 1 having to proceed to the emergency landing area 36 from this diversion point 39. For example, according to the example displayed in [Fig.l], if the aircraft 1 cannot be operated with the economic operating mode over the entire flight segment 41, for example in the event of a change in weather conditions, it might not have enough fuel to reach the arrival point 35.Therefore, the flight plan includes an emergency landing area 36 and a diversion point 39 calculated during the determination sub-step 125 allowing the aircraft 1 to divert from the economic route 38 from the diversion point 39 to head towards the emergency landing area 36 in order to land there before running out of fuel.
[0109] Then, the method according to the invention comprises an estimation step 130 carried out using a calculator 55 to estimate an operational cost of each possible route 37, 38 previously determined, as a function of cost models associated with the different operating modes of the aircraft 1.
[0110] The cost models comprise an AEO cost model associated with the AED operating mode and an economic cost model associated with the economic operating mode. These cost models make it possible to determine the cost of a flight or part of a flight for each possible route 37,38 as a function of the operating mode of the aircraft 1 used on each segment of this possible route 37,38. Economic data may be common to both the AEO and economic cost models, such as for example the cost of fuel, the cost of the flight hour of the aircraft 1 and / or the cost of the flight hour of a pilot.
[0111] During this estimation step 130, the calculator 55 can for example apply the following formula to estimate the operational cost of an AEO 37 or economic 38 route:
[0112] Mission cost = fuel consumption x fuel cost + flight duration x (pilot hourly cost + aircraft hourly flight cost) + engine maintenance cost + aircraft maintenance cost
[0113] Operational costs reflect the effect of each of the parameters influencing the performance of the flight. However, these operational costs may be associated with the characteristics of the flight, in particular the duration of the flight, the environmental conditions and the payload carried, to judge and select the best compromise on these operational costs.
[0114] This estimation step 130 comprises a sub-step 131 of estimating using the AEO cost model an AEO cost for each AEO route 37. An AEO route 37 is entirely carried out in AEO operating mode. Therefore, only the AEO cost model is necessary to estimate the operational cost of an AEO route 37.
[0115] This estimation step 130 also comprises an estimation sub-step 132 using the AEO cost model and the economic cost model of an economic cost for each economic route 38. An economic route 38 is carried out partially in AEO operating mode and in economic operating mode. Therefore, both the AEO and economic cost models are necessary to estimate the operational cost of an economic route 38.
[0116] The method according to the invention then comprises a comparison step 140 carried out using the calculator 55 to compare the AEO and economic costs previously estimated.
[0117] This comparison step 140 makes it possible to classify the different AEO and economic routes according to their respective AEO and economic costs based on one or more criteria. For example, a comparison of the AEO and economic costs can be carried out on the sole criterion of the value of each of the AEO and economic costs of the determined AEO and economic routes. Alternatively, a comparison of the AEO and economic costs can additionally take into consideration at least one additional criterion, chosen for example from flight duration, environmental nuisances, weather conditions, and the availability of emergency landing areas.
[0118] Finally, a selection step 150 is carried out with the calculator 55 to select a route from among the possible routes 37,38 previously determined following the comparison step 140 of the AEO and economic costs.
[0119] The selected route may for example be chosen from the AEO 37 and economic 38 routes based solely on the operational cost criterion. The selected route is in this case the possible route 37,38 having the lowest operational cost.
[0120] Alternatively, the selected route may be chosen from the AEO route(s) 37 and the economic route(s) 38 by combining the operational cost criterion with at least one complementary criterion.
[0121] In all cases, the selection step 150 may comprise, for example, a Monte Carlo simulation in order to choose during a first iteration a finite quantity of route. This choice is made in a directed and non-random manner by a TPE sampler advantageously making it possible to select possible routes 37, 38 so as to converge towards the required objective. Then, during the following iteration(s), using the results of the previous simulations, the computer 55 can then directly obtain the route having the lowest operational cost among the the AEO routes 37 and the economic route(s) 38. The calculator 55 may optionally alternatively identify the AEO route 37 having the lowest operational cost among several AEO routes 37 and the economic route 38 having the lowest operational cost among several economic routes 38.
[0122] Alternatively, the selected route may be chosen from the AEO route(s) 37 and the economic route(s) 38 by combining the operational cost criterion with at least one of the complementary criteria.
[0123] For example, [Fig.4] represents the operational costs of a multitude of possible routes, including AEO routes 37 and economic routes 38, in a reference frame having for example the operational cost of the possible routes 37, 38 on the abscissa and a complementary criterion on the ordinate. In the example shown, the operational costs Xi and x2 are those representing the best compromises between the operational cost and this complementary criterion. In this example, a TPE sampler dedicated to multi-objective can be used to identify these two operational costs xi and x2, which belong to the Pareto front of the results of the Monte Carlo simulation. The selection between the operational costs xi and x2 can then be made according to the criterion to be favored among the operational cost and this complementary criterion, this selection preferably being made automatically by the computer 55 to obtain the selected route.
[0124] The method may comprise an optional display step 155 for displaying the selected route on the display device 59 in order to inform, for example, the operator of the aircraft 1. The optional display step 155 may possibly comprise a display of the AEO route 37 having the lowest operational cost among several AEO routes 37 and of the economic route 38 having the lowest operational cost among several economic routes 38. The operator can thus become aware of the differences between these two possible routes 37, 38 having the optimum operational costs.
[0125] Each route 37,38 can be displayed in two dimensions, according to a top view on the display device 59.
[0126] The method may then comprise a step 170 of moving the aircraft 1 to perform a flight between the departure points 31 and arrival points 35 according to the selected route.
[0127] For this purpose, the method may also comprise a step 160 of transmitting the flight plan, and in particular the selected route, to a flight management device 15 of the aircraft 1 with a view to carrying out the movement step 170. The transmission of the characteristics relating to the flight plan is carried out using the information transmitter 51 which cooperates with the reception device 18 of the aircraft 1. The reception device 18 thus receives the characteristics of the flight plan, and in particular the characteristics of the selected route, then transfers them to the flight management device 15 of the aircraft 1. flight management 15 of aircraft 1 with a view to carrying out a flight of aircraft 1 following this selected route.
[0128] Naturally, the present invention is subject to numerous variations as to its implementation. Although several embodiments have been described, it is understood that it is not conceivable to exhaustively identify all possible modes. It is of course conceivable to replace a means described by an equivalent means without departing from the scope of the present invention and the claims.
Claims
Claims
1. Routing method for an aircraft (1) equipped with at least one rotor (2, 3) and at least two thermal engines (11) driving said rotor in rotation at least one rotor (2, 3), said aircraft (1) having a regulator configured to regulate said thermal engines (11) at least according to an AEO operating mode in which said thermal engines (11) each provide non-zero mechanical power to said at least one rotor (2, 3) and jointly a required mechanical power to said at least one rotor (2, 3), and an economic operating mode in which at least one of said thermal engines (11) does not provide mechanical power to said at least one rotor (2, 3), characterized in that said method comprises the following steps: setting (110) of parameters of a flight plan comprising: a starting point (31) of said flight plan, and • an arrival point (35) of said flight plan, and determination (120) using a computer (55) of several possible routes (37, 38) between said departure point (31) and said arrival point (35), as a function of said parameters of said flight plan and of several data comprising at least performance data of said aircraft (1), health data of said aircraft (1), meteorological data, and environmental data, said determination (120) comprising: • determination (121) of at least one AEO route (37) using only said AEO operating mode, • determination (122) of at least one economic route (38) using said economic operating mode and said AEO operating mode, estimation (130) using a calculator (55) of an operational cost of each possible route (37,38) based on cost models associated with the different operating modes of said aircraft (1), said estimation (130) comprising: estimate (131) of at least one associated AEO cost res- respectively to said at least one AEO route, • estimation (132) of at least one economic cost associated respectively with said at least one economic route, - comparison (140) of said AEO and economic costs, - selection (150) using said calculator (55) of a route from among said AEO (37) and economic (38) routes according to said comparison of said AEO and economic costs.
2. A method according to claim 1, wherein said method comprises moving (170) said aircraft (1) between said departure (31) and arrival (33) points along said selected route.
3. A method according to claim 2, wherein said method comprises transmitting (160) the selected route to a flight management device (15) of said aircraft (1).
4. Method according to any one of claims 1 to 3, for which said performance data of said aircraft (1) comprise: • first performance data corresponding to said AEO operating mode of said aircraft (1), and • second performance data corresponding to said economic operating mode of said aircraft (1), said health data of said aircraft (1) comprise: • an engine counter associated with each heat engine (11), said engine counter counting at least one usage data of said heat engine (11), and • at least two transmission counters associated respectively with input shafts (13) of a main transmission box (12) arranged between said heat engines (11) and said at least one rotor (2, 3), said input shafts (13) being mechanically connected respectively to said heat engines (11),each transmission counter recording at least one usage data item from one of said trees (13), input, said meteorological data comprises data relating to wind and temperature between said starting (31) and arrival (35) points, and said environmental data comprises a terrain database.
5. Method according to any one of claims 1 to 4, for which said at least one economic route comprises several successive flight segments between said departure (51) and arrival (55) points, and said computer (55) determines for each segment an operating mode of said aircraft (1) from among said economic operating mode and said associated AEO operating mode as a function of characteristics of said segment and said data.
6. Method according to claim 5, for which said calculator (55) determines for each segment for which said economical operating mode is associated information indicating said heat engine (11) among said heat engines (11) supplying said mechanical power to said at least one rotor (2, 3).
7. Method according to any one of claims 1 to 6, for which said economical operating mode comprises a first operating mode for which a single heat engine (11) among said heat engines (11) operates and ensures the rotational drive of said at least one rotor (2, 3) alone, said at least one other heat engine (11) being stopped and not supplied with fuel and a second operating mode for which a single heat engine (11) among said heat engines (11) provides mechanical power to said at least one rotor (2, 3) to drive it in rotation, said at least one other heat engine (11) being started and supplied with fuel, providing no mechanical power to said at least one rotor (2, 3).
8. Method according to any one of claims 1 to 6, for which said selection (150) of a route from among said AEO (37) and economic (38) routes is carried out on the sole criterion of said operational cost, the selected route being the possible route (37,38) having said lowest AEO or economic cost.
9. Method according to any one of claims 1 to 6, for which said selection (150) of a route from among said AEO (37) and economic (38) routes is carried out on the criterion of operational cost combined with at least one complementary criterion.
10. Method according to claim 9, for which said at least one additional criterion is chosen from a flight duration, environmental nuisances, weather conditions, availability of emergency landing areas.
11. A method according to any one of claims 1 to 10, wherein said method comprises a step of identifying (125) one or more emergency landing areas (36) on said at least one economic route (38), in the event that said economic mode of operation cannot be carried out on at least a portion of said selected route.
12. A computer program comprising instructions which, when said program is executed, lead to implementing the method according to any one of claims 1 to 11.
13. Routing system (50) for an aircraft (1) provided with at least one rotor (2, 3) and at least two thermal engines (11) driving said at least one rotor (2, 3) in rotation, said aircraft (1) having an economical operating mode in which at least one of said thermal engines (11) does not provide mechanical power to said at least one rotor (2, 3), said system (50) comprising: - at least one computer (55), and - at least one memory (56) storing at least one database, characterized in that said routing system (50) is configured to implement the aircraft routing method according to any one of claims 1 to 11.
14. Routing assembly (20) comprising an aircraft (1) and a routing system (50) according to claim 13, characterized in that said aircraft (1) comprises at least one receiving device (18) and at least one flight management device (15) connected to said receiving device (18), said routing system (50) comprises at least one information transmitter (51) configured to cooperate with said receiving device (18) of said aircraft (1) in order to transmitting characteristics of said flight plan and said selected route to said receiving device (18) which transfers them to said flight management device (15).
15. Aircraft (1), characterized in that said aircraft (1) comprises a routing system (50) according to claim 13.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Route modeler for improving desired environmental and economic flight characteristics
EP2763083A1
Optimal flight planner
US10262545B2
System and method for operating multi-engine rotorcraft
US20200362753A1
Dynamic aircraft routing
US20220122468A1
Predictable and required time of arrival compliant optimized profile descents with four dimensional flight management system and related method
US9193442B1
