PROCEDE DE PURIFICATION D’ACRYLATES LEGERS
The described process addresses the challenge of purifying light (meth)acrylic esters by using azeotropic distillation and continuous evaporation with multiple condensations to effectively eliminate methyl methoxy propionate, ensuring high purity and efficient material recovery.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- FR2023005029
- Authority / Receiving Office
- FR · FR
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-05-22
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-29
- Estimated Expiration
- 2043-05-22
AI Technical Summary
Existing processes for producing light (meth)acrylic esters, such as methyl or ethyl acrylate, face challenges in effectively eliminating methyl methoxy propionate (MPM) due to its close boiling temperature to acrylic acid and formation of azeotropes with water, leading to complex and costly purification processes.
A process involving azeotropic distillation followed by continuous evaporation and multiple condensations of the gas phase in a purification column, combined with specific separation assemblies like dividing wall columns, to separate and recycle alkyl acrylate while eliminating a concentrated fraction of alkyl alkoxy propionate.
This process minimizes losses of alkyl acrylate and recycles stabilizers, achieving high purity alkyl acrylate with reduced material losses and simplified operations.
Smart Images

Figure 00000000_0000_ABST
Abstract
Description
Title of the invention: PROCESS FOR PURIFYING LIGHT ACRYLATES Technical field
[0001] The present invention relates to the production of light (meth)acrylic esters such as methyl or ethyl (meth)acrylate, by direct esterification of (meth)acrylic acid with the corresponding light alcohol.
[0002] The invention more particularly relates to a process for the recovery / purification of C1-C2 alkyl acrylate comprising evaporation and partial condensation steps making it possible to eliminate a fraction rich in alkyl alkoxy propionate by-product, which cannot be recovered by a cracking process and is very difficult to eliminate, whether when it is pure, because its boiling temperature is close to that of acrylic acid, or when it is in the form of an azeotrope with water, because its boiling temperature is close to that of the acrylic ester. PRIOR ART AND TECHNICAL PROBLEM
[0003] It is known to produce (meth)acrylic esters by carrying out an esterification reaction between an alcohol and a (meth)acrylic acid. This reaction is a balanced catalyzed reaction with generation of water. It is also accompanied by side reactions producing impurities.
[0004] It is necessary to remove the produced water to shift the equilibrium, remove impurities, as well as recycle unreacted reagents.
[0005] To this end, a set of distillations and / or extractions and decantations are generally carried out, which is both relatively complex to implement, in particular due to the presence of azeotropic mixtures, and costly in terms of energy.
[0006] The problems which arise during the manufacture of light (meth)acrylic esters, in particular C1-C2 alkyl acrylic esters, will now be explained, for convenience, on the basis of the example of methyl acrylate obtained by esterification of acrylic acid with methanol. However, the problems and the solution proposed by the invention can be applied to the use of ethanol in the esterification reaction.
[0007] As side reactions during the manufacture of methyl acrylate, unreacted acrylic acid may form oligomers, such as 3-acryloxypropionic acid (n=2) or 3-acryloxy 3-propioxy propionic acid, (n=3), which are heavy by-products with a higher boiling point than acrylic acid.
[0008] As another side reaction, Michael addition can produce Michael adducts, particularly methyl methoxy propionate formed between methyl acrylate and methanol.
[0009] Methyl methoxy propionate (MPM) is a so-called heavy by-product that is formed in significant quantities in the process as the esterification reaction progresses along with the acrylic acid oligomers. Its boiling point is close to that of acrylic acid (144°C, atmospheric P), but it can also form an azeotrope with water (97.3°C, atmospheric P) during azeotropic distillation.
[0010] MPM is the lightest of the heavy by-products compared to acrylic acid oligomers, it can interfere in the final purification of methyl acrylate (80°C, atmospheric P) and alter the quality of the finished product.
[0011] In order to limit the formation of MPM, it has been proposed in document US 6,025,520 to carry out the esterification reaction under reduced pressure with an excess of acid. These conditions make it possible to improve the yield and selectivity of the esterification reaction and to significantly reduce the formation of heavy by-products such as MPM, which is problematic for the purification process of the desired ester.
[0012] The process described in document WO 2015 / 063388 proposes to significantly reduce the formation of alkyl alkoxy propionate during the synthesis of methyl (meth)acrylate by carrying out the esterification reaction in a fixed bed reactor under atmospheric pressure and under conditions where the acid is in excess relative to the alcohol and where the hourly volumetric velocities are high.
[0013] In document FR 3083233, the applicant company has shown that it is possible to eliminate the MPM by side withdrawal during the azeotropic distillation of the reaction mixture carried out in a single distillation column equipped with a side withdrawal. This solution remains, however, difficult to implement because it requires very stable operating conditions, both at the level of the esterification reaction and at the level of the azeotropic distillation column.
[0014] There is still a need to eliminate methyl methoxy propionate, which is detrimental to the material balance of the process (loss of raw materials during purges) and to the purification train (complexity in achieving high purity).
[0015] One of the objectives of the present invention is therefore to provide an improved process for the recovery / purification of methyl acrylate, and more generally of methyl or ethyl acrylate, allowing efficient removal of methyl methoxy propionate, by continuously implementing evaporation of the bottom of the methyl acrylate purification column and at least two successive condensations of the gas phase. A methyl acrylate stream, a methyl methoxy propionate stream and an inhibitor-rich evaporator bottom stream are thus obtained. Summary of the invention
[0016] The subject of the present invention is a process for the recovery / purification of C1-C2 alkyl acrylate from a reaction mixture resulting from the esterification of acrylic acid with an alcohol chosen from methanol and ethanol carried out in the presence of polymerization inhibitor(s), said process comprising the azeotropic distillation of said reaction mixture using a distillation column, and the purification of the alkyl acrylate using a separation assembly comprising at least one alkyl acrylate purification column, characterized in that it comprises a continuous treatment consisting of an evaporation of the bottom of said at least one purification column and at least two successive condensations of the gaseous phase resulting from said evaporation.
[0017] This process makes it possible to minimize alkyl acrylate losses and to recycle the stabilizers contained at different points in the process while eliminating a concentrated fraction rich in alkyl alkoxy propionate by-product.
[0018] According to various embodiments, said method comprises the following characteristics, possibly combined. The contents indicated are expressed by weight, unless otherwise indicated. Within the ranges of values indicated, the limits are included.
[0019] Azeotropic distillation means the separation of an azeotrope (or azeotropic mixture) consisting of a ternary mixture of alkyl acrylate / alcohol / water.
[0020] According to one embodiment, the alcohol is methanol, the alkyl acrylate is methyl acrylate, and the alkyl alkoxy propionate is methyl methoxy propionate (MPM).
[0021] According to one embodiment, the alcohol is ethanol, the alkyl acrylate is ethyl acrylate, and the alkyl alkoxy propionate is ethyl ethoxy propionate (EPE).
[0022] According to one embodiment, the azeotropic distillation column can be provided with a side withdrawal.
[0023] According to one embodiment, the azeotropic distillation column does not have a side draw-off.
[0024] According to one embodiment, the final purification to obtain commercial grade alkyl acrylate (purity greater than 99.5% by weight) is carried out by using at least one purification column such as a tailing column and a topping column.
[0025] According to one embodiment, said at least one purification column is a dividing wall column (DWC).
[0026] According to one embodiment, said at least one purification column is a side-draw column.
[0027] According to one embodiment, when the alkyl acrylate is methyl acrylate, obtaining methyl acrylate having a purity greater than 99.5% by weight is carried out in a distillation column called a tailing column or a partition column operating in a pressure range of 10000 Pa to 50000 Pa and temperatures ranging from 80°C to 110°C.
[0028] According to one embodiment, the method according to the invention comprises the following steps:
[0029] a) azeotropic distillation of the reaction mixture using a first distillation column making it possible to separate at the top an azeotropic mixture comprising the alkyl acrylate, the unreacted alcohol and water, and at the bottom a fraction comprising the unreacted acrylic acid and heavy by-products,
[0030] b) separation of the bottom stream from the first distillation column into a stream comprising essentially the unreacted acrylic acid, this stream being all or part recycled into the esterification reactor,
[0031] c) liquid / liquid extraction of the top stream of the first distillation column by an aqueous stream making it possible to separate an organic phase essentially comprising alkyl acrylate, and an aqueous phase,
[0032] d) purification of said organic phase using a separation assembly comprising at least one alkyl acrylate purification column, such as a tailing column and a topping column, a side draw column or a separating wall column (DWC), making it possible to recover the purified alkyl acrylate at the top and at the bottom a stream containing heavy by-products such as alkyl alkoxy propionate,
[0033] e) treatment of the bottom flow of this purification column, on a thin-film evaporator in order to recycle the alkyl acrylate to the purification column, to eliminate a final residue comprising the stabilization inhibitors and to send to the purge for incineration a flow very concentrated in alkyl alkoxy propionate.
[0034] According to one embodiment, when the alkyl acrylate is methyl acrylate, the bottom stream of the purification column making it possible to obtain methyl acrylate is subjected to successive evaporation and condensation of the gas phase of the evaporator. This evaporation operation generates three streams:
[0035] - a stream of methyl acrylate to be recycled to the purification column,
[0036] - a flow of MPM, and
[0037] - a residue stream containing the stabilization inhibitors which can be advantageously carefully recycle in the process.
[0038] Reaction temperature and evaporator pressure are linked so that methyl acrylate and MPM are removed by evaporation.
[0039] According to one embodiment, the evaporation is carried out in a temperature range from 80°C to 110°C and more especially between 90°C and 100°C.
[0040] According to one embodiment, the maintained pressure of the evaporator is between 10000 Pa and 80000 Pa.
[0041] According to one embodiment, the head flow of this evaporator is cooled in two successive stages: - Partial condensation in a temperature range from 70 to 110°C, preferably between 80°C-90°C, at the same pressure as that of the evaporator, to obtain on the one hand a liquid flow of Michael adducts to be purged and on the other hand a flow of vapor; - Condensation of this vapor flow in a temperature range from 20°C to 50°C, more specifically 30°C-40°C, before recovery of this liquid flow by a pump and feeding of the purification column.
[0042] The mass composition of the feed product to the evaporator at the bottom of the purification column in the case of the manufacture of methyl acrylate in the presence of hydroquinone as a polymerization inhibitor is as follows:
[0043] - Methyl acrylate (60-100%),
[0044] - Butyl methoxy propionate (MPM) 5-40%,
[0045] - Hydroquinone: 0.1 to 2%.
[0046] According to one embodiment, the fraction rich in alkyl alkoxy propionate contains alkyl alkoxy propionate at a mass content which can range from approximately 20% to approximately 80%.
[0047] According to one embodiment, the reaction mixture is obtained from the esterification of acrylic acid with a stoichiometric excess of alcohol.
[0048] According to one embodiment, the reaction mixture is obtained from the esterification of acrylic acid with an alcohol under conditions of stoichiometric excess of acid.
[0049] According to one embodiment, the azeotropic distillation is carried out under slight vacuum under a pressure which can range from 200 to 600 mm Hg.
[0050] According to one embodiment, the temperature at the bottom of the azeotropic distillation column is less than 110°C, preferably less than 100°C.
[0051] The reaction is carried out in the presence of one or more polymerization inhibitors which are introduced into the reactor, at a rate of 500 to 5000 ppm relative to the crude reaction mixture. As polymerization inhibitors which can be used, mention may be made, for example, of phenothiazine, hydroquinone, hydroquinone monomethyl ether, diterbutyl para-cresol (BHT), paraphenylenediamine, TEMPO (2,2,6,6-tetramethyl-1-piperidinyloxy), di-tert-butylcatechol, or TEMPO derivatives, such as OH-TEMPO, alone or their mixtures in all proportions. An additional addition of polymerization inhibitor is generally carried out at the level of the subsequent purification treatment.
[0052] The effectiveness of inhibitors is also linked to the injection of air or depleted air in the different columns implemented.
[0053] According to one embodiment, the separation assembly comprises at least one alkyl acrylate purification column such as a tailing column and a topping column.
[0054] According to one embodiment, the separation assembly comprises at least one alkyl acrylate purification column such as a separating wall column (DWC).
[0055] According to one embodiment, the separation assembly comprises at least one alkyl acrylate purification column such as a side-draw column.
[0056] According to one embodiment, purification step d) is carried out by distillation, using a purification column comprising at least one distillation column, preferably two distillation columns in series.
[0057] The invention makes it possible to limit the losses of recoverable materials such as acrylic acid, alcohol or alkyl acrylate in a process for producing light alkyl acrylate by direct esterification.
[0058] According to one embodiment, the final purification making it possible to obtain methyl acrylate can be carried out using a topping column and a tailing column.
[0059] The invention makes it possible to effectively remove the alkyl alkoxy propionate, and to reduce the losses of recoverable products caused by the purges imposed by the accumulation of alkyl alkoxy propionate in the purification train and to recycle the polymerization inhibitors advantageously in the process.
[0060] Thus the invention provides a simplified process for producing high purity methyl or ethyl acrylate, and optimizes the material balance of the process. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE FIGURES
[0061] [Fig. 1] schematically represents an installation for producing methyl acrylate including the recovery / purification process according to the invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
[0062] The invention is now described in more detail and in a non-limiting manner in the following description. For simplification, the description is based on the example of methyl acrylate obtained by esterification of acrylic acid with methanol. The solution proposed by the invention applies in the same way to the use of ethanol in the esterification reaction, as well as to other configurations of the purification train (process with an azeotropic distillation equipped with a side draw-off, partition column for the final purification)
[0063] A methyl acrylate production facility is shown in [Fig. 1].
[0064] The reaction section comprises an esterification reactor R. The reactor R is fed by an acrylic acid supply line 1, a methanol supply line 2. The reactor preferably contains a heterogeneous catalyst of the acid cation exchange resin type. In the case of homogeneous catalysis, the reactor is further fed by a catalyst supply line (not shown). The esterification reaction can be carried out in excess methanol or in excess acrylic acid.
[0065] At the outlet of the reactor R, the reaction mixture 3 is sent to an azeotropic distillation unit shown in [Fig.l] by two distillation columns in series C1 and C3, the first column C1 being connected to the second column C3 by the gas phase 9, and the second column C3 separating at the bottom a flow 10 of water consisting of a part of the water formed by the esterification reaction and water injected in the form of steam into the column C3.
[0066] According to one embodiment, the azeotropic distillation unit comprises a single distillation column C1 operating under vacuum under the same conditions.
[0067] According to one embodiment, the azeotropic distillation unit comprises a distillation column equipped with a side draw-off.
[0068] The distillation column C1 separates, at the bottom, a stream 6 comprising essentially unreacted acrylic acid, traces of light products (boiling temperature lower than that of acrylic acid), and heavy products having a boiling temperature higher than acrylic acid (oligomers of acrylic acid and Michael adducts).
[0069] Stream 6 is sent to a distillation column C2 which separates a stream 7 comprising the residual acrylic acid and the lighter products, and a stream 8 consisting essentially of the heavy products. Stream 7 is advantageously recycled into the reactor R.
[0070] The head stream 11 from the azeotropic distillation unit is sent to a liquid / liquid L / L extraction section (decanter or contactor) which generates, on the one hand, an aqueous phase 17 containing essentially methanol and on the other hand, an organic phase 12.
[0071] In the installation described in [Fig.l], the aqueous phase 17 is subjected to distillation on a distillation column C5 to separate the methanol which is recycled into the reactor (stream 5), and an aqueous stream 18 depleted in methanol which can be partially recycled into the liquid / liquid extraction phase.
[0072] The organic phase 12 may be subjected to one or more additional serial distillation steps. For example, a topping column C6 extracts the residual light compounds 13 at the top, and a tailing column C7 which separates at the bottom a stream 16 essentially comprising the residual heavy compounds with methyl acrylate and a stream 15 of purified methyl acrylate at the top.
[0073] According to one embodiment, columns C6 and C7 can be replaced by a partition column (DWC).
[0074] The stream concentrated in heavy 16 and treated on a film evaporator. The bottom of the evaporator 19 rich in stabilizers can be mixed and recycled with the stream 4. The gaseous phase from this EP evaporator is partially condensed to obtain a first liquid stream 20 rich in Michael adducts and after a second condensation a stream 21 of methyl acrylate which can advantageously be recycled in the feed stream 14 of the C7.
[0075] With reference to [Fig. 1], the C7 column has an equivalent of 10 and 30 theoretical trays, preferably 10 to 15 theoretical stages, and operates in a pressure range of 10000 Pa to 50000 Pa and temperatures ranging from 80°C to 110°C at the column bottom. The internals used for the column can be valve trays or perforated trays with overflow, cross-flow trays such as Dual Flow, Ripple Trays, Turbo Grid Shell, or ordered packing. The bottom flow is concentrated on a thin-film evaporator very well suited to viscous, fouling products and dirty liquids. Evaporation is carried out in a temperature range from 90°C to 110°C, and more specifically between 90°C and 100°C, in a pressure range between 10000 Pa and 80000 Pa.
[0076] When the purification system used comprises a partition column according to WO2017 / 125637, the film evaporator will treat the same flow 16 at the bottom of the DWC column by generating a flow of stabilizer at the bottom to be recycled at the inlet of the reactor R, two liquid condensation products: the purged and eliminated MPM and the methyl acrylate recycled to the feed of the partition column.
[0077] The process for the recovery / purification of methyl acrylate according to the invention applies to a reaction mixture 3 resulting from the esterification of acrylic acid 1 with methanol 2 in reactor R.
[0078] The following examples illustrate the present invention and are not intended to limit the scope of the invention as defined by the appended claims. EXPERIMENTAL PART
[0079] In the examples, the percentages are given by weight unless otherwise indicated and the following abbreviations have been used:
[0080] AM: Methyl acrylate
[0081] MPM: methyl methoxy propionate
[0082] HQ: polymerization inhibitor
[0083] Simulations using a thermodynamic model were carried out for a reaction mixture obtained by reacting methanol with excess AA, on an acidic cationic resin.
[0084] The inlet flow rate of the reaction mixture into the purification train is adjusted to ensure production of methyl acrylate AM of approximately 160t / d.
[0085] The flow rate of methyl methoxy propionate MPM to be purged is of the order of 65 kg / h corresponding to the quantity of MPM formed in the reaction at the rate of 160 t / d.
[0086] Two configurations were compared; they differ in the implementation of the treatment of the C7 column foot: - A direct purge of the C7 column foot to eliminate the MPM and prevent its accumulation, and - A treatment of the foot prior to purging the MPM to limit the loss of AM and polymerization inhibitor (HQ) according to the invention using a film evaporator and partial condensation of the vapor.
[0087] Table 1 below compares the distribution of the different MPM purge flow rates, expressed in kg / h, in the two configurations: according to the prior art (Reference) and according to the invention.
[0088] [Tableauxl] Reference Invention MPM (%) 17.5 37.4 AM (%) 79.1 59.4 Stabilizer (%) 0.9 0.03
[0089] Table 2 indicates the material balance of the MPM purge point in each of the two processes, respectively stream 16 at the bottom of column C7 in the reference process and stream 20 at the bottom of the first condenser of the EP section in the process according to the invention.
[0090] [Tables2] Reference Purge Invention Purge Overall flow rate (kg / h) 250 117 MPM (kg / h) 43.8 43.6 AM (kg / h) 198 69 HQ (kg / h) 2.1 0
[0091] In the reference process, the simulation indicates significant losses of AM which is concentrated at 79% in the bottom of the C7 tailing column. On the contrary, the process according to the invention makes it possible to limit the content of recoverable product in the purge.
Claims
Claims
1. Process for the recovery / purification of C1-C2 alkyl acrylate from a reaction mixture resulting from the esterification of acrylic acid with an alcohol chosen from methanol and ethanol carried out in the presence of polymerization inhibitor(s), said process comprising the azeotropic distillation of said reaction mixture using a distillation column, and the purification of the alkyl acrylate using a separation assembly comprising at least one alkyl acrylate purification column, characterized in that it comprises a continuous treatment consisting of evaporation of the bottom of said at least one purification column and at least two successive condensations of the gaseous phase resulting from said evaporation.
2. A process according to claim 1, wherein the azeotropic distillation column is provided with a side draw of the fraction rich in alkyl alkoxy propionate.
3. A method according to either of claims 1 and 2, wherein the evaporation is carried out in a temperature range from 80°C to 110°C, more especially between 90°C and 100°C.
4. A method according to any preceding claim, wherein the maintained pressure of the evaporator is between 10000 Pa and 80000 Pa.
5. A process according to any preceding claim, wherein the azeotropic distillation is carried out under slight vacuum at a pressure ranging from 200 to 600 mm Hg.
6. A process according to any one of the preceding claims, said process comprising the following steps: a) azeotropic distillation of the reaction mixture using a first distillation column making it possible to separate at the top an azeotropic mixture comprising the alkyl acrylate, the unreacted alcohol and water, and at the bottom a fraction comprising the unreacted acrylic acid and heavy by-products, b) separation of the bottom stream of the first distillation column into a stream essentially comprising the unreacted acrylic acid, this stream being all or part recycled into the esterification reactor, c) liquid / liquid extraction of the top stream of the first distillation column by an aqueous stream making it possible to separate an organic phase essentially comprising the alkyl acrylate, and a phase aqueous, d) purification of said organic phase using a separation assembly comprising at least one alkyl acrylate purification column, such as a tailing column and a topping column, a column equipped with a side draw-off or a separating wall column (DWC), making it possible to recover the purified alkyl acrylate at the top and at the bottom a stream containing heavy by-products such as alkyl alkoxy propionate, e) treatment of the bottom stream of this purification column on a thin-layer evaporator in order to recycle the methyl acrylate to this column, to recycle the final residue comprising the stabilization inhibitors and to send to the purge for incineration a stream very concentrated in alkyl alkoxy propionate.
7. The method of claim 6, wherein said at least one alkyl acrylate purification column comprises a tailing column and a topping column.
8. The method of claim 6, wherein said at least one alkyl acrylate purification column comprises a partition wall column.
9. The method of claim 6, wherein said at least one alkyl acrylate purification column comprises a side draw column.
10. Method according to claim 6, in which the overhead flow of the evaporator is cooled in two successive stages: - Partial condensation in a temperature range from 70 to 110°C, preferably between 80°C-90°C, at the same pressure as that of the evaporator, to obtain on the one hand a liquid flow of Michael adducts to be purged and on the other hand a vapor flow; - Condensation of this vapor flow in a temperature range from 20°C to 50°C, more especially from 30°C-40°C, before taking up this liquid flow by a pump and feeding the purification column.
11. A method according to claim 6, wherein step d) of purification is carried out by distillation, using a purification column comprising at least one distillation column, preferably two distillation columns in series.
12. A method according to any one of claims 1 to 11, wherein the alcohol is methanol, the alkyl acrylate is methyl acrylate, and alkyl alkoxy propionate is methyl methoxy propionate.
13. A process according to claim 12, wherein the production of methyl acrylate having a purity greater than 99.5% by weight is carried out in a so-called tailing distillation column or a partition column operating in a pressure range of 10000 Pa to 50000 Pa and temperatures ranging from 80°C to 110°C.
14. A method according to any one of claims 1 to 11, wherein the alcohol is ethanol, the alkyl acrylate is ethyl acrylate, and the alkyl alkoxy propionate is ethyl ethoxy propionate.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Method for preparing (meth)acrylic acid ester
US6025520A
Process for producing light (METH)acrylic esters
WO2015063388A1
Device for dosing volatile substances
WO2017125637A1
PROCEDE DE PURIFICATION D'ACRYLATES LEGERS.
FR3083233A1
