Chlorine analytical method

The ICP-MS system with quadrupole filters and a reaction cell efficiently separates and quantifies chlorine isotopes, addressing the limitations of conventional methods by providing rapid and accurate analysis of Cl-36 in nuclear decommissioning.

JP2024158327APending Publication Date: 2024-11-08FUKUSHIMA UNIVERSITY +4
View PDF 1 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2023073447
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2023-04-27
Publication Date
2024-11-08

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Conventional methods for quantifying chlorine-36 (Cl-36) are time-consuming and lack the sensitivity to distinguish between different chlorine isotopes, making them unsuitable for the rapid analysis required in decommissioning nuclear reactors.

Method used

An inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer (ICP-MS) system with a first and second quadrupole mass filter and a reaction cell is used to generate polyatomic ions, allowing for the separation and detection of chlorine isotopes (Cl-35, Cl-36, and Cl-37) by removing interfering ions and using hydrogen or deuterium gas to enhance detection accuracy.

Benefits of technology

The method enables rapid and precise quantification of multiple chlorine isotopes, including Cl-36, with a significant reduction in analysis time and improved sensitivity compared to conventional methods.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 2024158327000001_ABST
    Figure 2024158327000001_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

To provide a method that quickly analyzes chlorine with high accuracy.SOLUTION: The present invention is a mass number M chlorine analytical method that uses an inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer 1 provided with: an ionization section P; a first quadrupole mass filter Q1; a reaction cell Q2; a second quadrupole mass filter Q3; and a detection unit D. The chlorine analytical method includes the steps of: introducing a sample solution to the ionization section to obtain an ionized ion group; eliminating an ion having a mass number other than the mass number M from the ion group in the first quadrupole mass filter; causing the ion group passing through the first quadrupole mass filter to contact with reaction gas composed of an element of a mass number m to be selected from hydrogen or deuterium gas in the reaction cell, and generating a polyatomic ion of a mass number M+2m; eliminating an ion having the mass number other than the mass number M+2m in the second quadrupole mass filter; and detecting a signal of the ion of the mass number M+2m passing through the second quadrupole mass filter.SELECTED DRAWING: Figure 1
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[Technical field]

[0001] The present invention relates to an analytical method for chlorine, and in particular to an analytical method capable of quantifying chlorine with high accuracy in a short time as compared with conventional methods. [Background technology]

[0002] Chlorine with mass number 36 (also called chlorine-36 or Cl-36) has a half-life of 3.01 × 10 5 It is a long-lived nuclide that undergoes beta decay in years and emits beta rays with a maximum energy of 709 keV with an emission rate of 98.1%. A method for quantitatively analyzing Cl-36 is known to measure beta rays, and an analytical method for Cl-36 in liquid samples has been established.

[0003] In the method of measuring β-rays, the chloride ion concentration in the sample is quantified and confirmed in advance by ion chromatography, etc., and then the chloride ion carrier required for analysis is added. The chlorine in the sample is purified by an oxidation gasification recovery operation in which nitric acid and potassium permanganate are added in sequence and heated. After confirming that elements that interfere with the measurement of β-rays emitted by Cl-36 have been removed by these operations through separation and purification operations, the Cl-36 concentration (Bq / g) in the sample is obtained by measuring the β-rays emitted by Cl-36. This analytical method using β-rays requires a chemical separation operation to separate interfering elements coexisting in the liquid and to isolate Cl-36. This requires complicated processing operations, which are time-consuming.

[0004] Like Cl-36, a radioactive nuclide that is difficult to quantify is strontium (Sr-90), which has a mass number of 90. A method using a quadrupole mass filter is known as a method for analyzing Sr-90 in a short time with high accuracy (see, for example, Patent Document 1). [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]

[0005] [Patent Document 1] JP 2015-87363 A Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]

[0006] Following the revision of the Nuclear Reactor Regulation Act in 2012, it is expected that the number of decommissionings of aging nuclear power plants will increase in the future. The Tokai Nuclear Power Plant, which has already been decided to be decommissioned, uses a graphite-moderated, carbon dioxide-cooled reactor, and this type of reactor generates a large amount of Cl-36 radioactivity compared to other light water reactors. For this reason, rapid Cl-36 measurement is required for decommissioning. Graphite-moderated, carbon dioxide-cooled reactors are commonly found in nuclear power plants in the UK and France, and since an increase in decommissionings is expected in the future, there is an increasing demand internationally for rapid Cl-36 measurement. For this reason, the conventional method of measuring beta rays, which takes about five days to measure, will not be able to keep up with the increasing demand for measurement in the future.

[0007] A rapid analytical method for Sr-90 has been established as shown in Patent Document 1. However, it is difficult to achieve sufficient sensitivity for Cl-36 by mass spectrometry due to the presence of isobars, and the natural abundance ratio of Cl-36 and stable isotopes causes a significant increase in background noise due to tailing. In other words, quantifying Cl-36 with high sensitivity is even more difficult than quantifying Sr-90.

[0008] To address the above-mentioned problems, an analytical method is required that can distinguish between chlorine isotopes with different mass numbers and measure them quickly and accurately. [Means for solving the problem]

[0009] According to one embodiment, the present invention provides a method for analyzing chlorine having a mass number M (M is 1 or more selected from 35, 36, and 37) using an inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer including an ionization unit, a first quadrupole mass filter, a reaction cell, a second quadrupole mass filter, and a detection unit, the method comprising: A step of introducing a sample solution into the ionization unit to obtain an ion group; removing ions having mass numbers other than mass number M from the group of ions in the first quadrupole mass filter; contacting the ions that have passed through the first quadrupole mass filter with a reaction gas consisting of an element having a mass number m (m is 1 for hydrogen gas and 2 for deuterium gas) selected from hydrogen gas and deuterium gas in the reaction cell to generate polyatomic ions having a mass number (M+2m); removing ions having mass numbers other than (M+2m) in the second quadrupole mass filter; detecting a signal of an ion having a mass number of (M+2m) that has passed through the second quadrupole mass filter; The present invention relates to a method for analyzing chlorine, comprising the steps of:

[0010] In the chlorine analysis method, the polyatomic ion is M Cl m H m H is preferred.

[0011] The chlorine analysis method preferably includes a step of removing interfering elements in the sample solution by ion chromatography prior to the ionization step.

[0012] In the chlorine analysis method, the step of detecting the signal of the ion having mass number (M+2m) is preferably a step of detecting chlorine having mass number M based on the intensity of the ion count of mass number (M+2m).

[0013] In the chlorine analysis method, the step of detecting chlorine having a mass number M based on the intensity of the ion count is preferably a step of quantifying chlorine having a mass number M based on an intensity integrated value of a peak area of ​​a peak shape obtained from an ion count of a mass number (M+2m).

[0014] In the chlorine analysis method, the step of detecting chlorine having mass number M based on the intensity of the ion count is preferably a step of quantifying chlorine having mass number M based on the maximum peak height value of a peak shape obtained from the ion count of mass number (M+2m).

[0015] In the above-mentioned chlorine analysis method, it is preferable that M is 35, 36, and 37, and three types of chlorine isotopes are detected simultaneously.

[0016] In the above-mentioned method for analyzing chlorine, it is preferable that M is 36, and a radioactive isotope of chlorine is detected by being distinguished from a stable isotope of chlorine.

[0017] In the chlorine analysis method, the reaction gas is preferably deuterium gas. Effect of the Invention

[0018] According to the chlorine analysis method of the present invention, it is possible to quantify chlorine with high accuracy in a time required for about several tens of times shorter than that required by conventional methods, and it is also possible to quantify each of a plurality of chlorine isotopes separately. [Brief description of the drawings]

[0019] [Figure 1] FIG. 1 is a schematic diagram showing an example of an inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer used in the chlorine analysis method according to the present invention. [Diagram 2] FIG. 2 is a graph showing the relationship between the reaction gas flow rate and the detection intensity for the stable chlorine isotopes Cl-35 and Cl-37 when hydrogen gas is used as the reaction gas. [Diagram 3] FIG. 3 is a graph showing the relationship between the reaction gas flow rate and the detection intensity for the stable chlorine isotopes Cl-35 and Cl-37 when deuterium gas is used as the reaction gas. [Figure 4] FIG. 4 is a graph showing the relationship between reaction gas flow rate and detection intensity for the radioisotope of chlorine, Cl-36. [Diagram 5]FIG. 5 is a graph showing the relationship between reaction gas flow rate and detection intensity for the radioisotope of chlorine, Cl-36, and a blank sample. [Figure 6] Figure 6 is a graph showing the results of a survey of polyatomic ions (product ions) obtained by contacting Cl-36 with oxygen gas as a reaction gas. The dashed line indicates a blank sample. [Figure 7] Figure 7 is a graph showing the results of a survey of polyatomic ions (product ions) obtained by contacting Cl-36 with deuterium gas as a reaction gas. The dashed line indicates a blank sample. [Figure 8] 8 is a graph showing the results of a survey of polyatomic ions (product ions) obtained by contacting Cl-36 with hydrogen gas as a reaction gas. The dashed line indicates a blank sample. [Figure 9] FIG. 9 is a graph showing a calibration curve of Cl-36 when deuterium, hydrogen, and oxygen are used as reaction gases. [Figure 10] FIG. 10 shows a calibration curve for Cl-36 when a sample containing a known concentration of Cl-36 was subjected to ion chromatography to remove sulfur isobars (S-36) and then measured with an ICP-MS / MS device using deuterium as a reaction gas. (a) is a chart plotting the measured intensity of the mass spectrum against the measurement time, and (b) is a graph showing the calibration curve. The mass number of the ion passed through Q1 is 36, and the mass number of the ion passed through Q3 is 40. [Figure 11] FIG. 11 shows a calibration curve for Cl-36 when a sample containing a known concentration of Cl-36 was subjected to ion chromatography to remove sulfur isobars (S-36), and then measured with an ICP-MS / MS device using hydrogen as a reaction gas. (a) is a chart plotting the measured intensity of the mass spectrum against the measurement time, and (b) is a graph showing the calibration curve. The mass number of the ion passed through Q1 is 36, and the mass number of the ion passed through Q3 is 38. [Figure 12]FIG. 12 shows a calibration curve for Cl-36 when a sample containing a known concentration of Cl-36 was subjected to ion chromatography to remove sulfur isobars (S-36), and then measured by an ICP-MS / MS device using oxygen as a reaction gas. (a) is a chart plotting the measured intensity of the mass spectrum against the measurement time, and (b) is a graph showing the calibration curve. The mass number of the ion passed through Q1 is 36, and the mass number of the ion passed through Q3 is 52. [Figure 13] FIG. 13 is a chart plotting the measured mass spectrum intensity versus measurement time when a sample containing a known concentration of Cl-36 was measured with an ICP-MS / MS device using hydrogen and deuterium as reaction gases, after removing sulfur isobars (S-36) by ion chromatography and then containing a known concentration (1 Bq / mL) of Cl-36 with sulfuric acid added to make the concentration 0.1 mass%. [Figure 14] Figure 14 shows a plot of the measured mass spectrum intensity versus measurement time when Cl-36 contained in Adachi groundwater was measured with an ICP-MS / MS device using deuterium as the reaction gas after removing the sulfur isobar (S-36) by ion chromatography. [Figure 15] FIG. 15 is a plot of the measured mass spectrum intensity versus measurement time when Cl-36 contained in mineral water was measured with an ICP-MS / MS device using deuterium as the reaction gas after removing the sulfur isobar (S-36) by ion chromatography. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

[0020] Hereinafter, an embodiment of the present invention will be described. However, the present invention is not limited to the embodiment described below.

[0021] According to one embodiment, the present invention relates to a method for analyzing chlorine. In the present invention, chlorine refers to chlorine having a mass number of 35 (hereinafter, referred to as Cl-35, or Cl-35), which is a stable isotope of chlorine that is abundant in nature. 35Cl), and chlorine with mass number 37 (hereafter, Cl-37, or 37 In addition to the radioisotope chlorine with mass number 36 (hereafter referred to as Cl-36, or 36 Therefore, the chlorine analysis method according to the present invention is capable of detecting the following substances that may be present in a sample: 35 Cl, 36 Cl, 37 This method allows the quantitative determination of Cl, and any combination of these, individually, in a single measurement. Hereinafter, in the present invention, the three types of chlorine isotopes are collectively referred to as Cl-M, or M It may be written as Cl, where M is the mass number of chlorine, which is 35, 36, or 37. Similarly, an isotope of an element may be expressed by "element symbol-mass number".

[0022] In the chlorine analysis method according to one embodiment of the present invention, an inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) device can be used. In particular, a so-called ICP tandem mass spectrometry device (ICP-MS / MS device) that is configured by connecting an ionization unit, a first quadrupole mass filter, a reaction cell, a second quadrupole mass filter, and a detection unit in this order can be used.

[0023] 1 is a schematic diagram showing an example of an ICP-MS / MS device that can be used in this embodiment. In the ICP-MS / MS device 1, an ionization section P, a first quadrupole mass filter Q1, a reaction cell Q2, a second quadrupole mass filter Q3, and devices including a detection section D are connected in series, and a detection target substance in a sample solution S introduced into the ionization section P is subjected to physical and / or chemical action by each device, and is finally quantified in the detection section D. The reaction cell Q2 is also called a collision reaction cell (CRC) or a dynamic reaction cell (DRC).

[0024] More specifically, the ICP-MS / MS device 1 includes a sample introduction section including a nebulizer and a spray chamber for atomizing a sample solution and a carrier gas (Ar gas), and an introduction device for an auxiliary gas (Ar gas) and a plasma gas (Ar gas), in front of an ionization section P including a torch for generating plasma. In addition, an interface and an ion lens are provided in front of the first quadrupole mass filter Q1, in the rear of the ionization section P. As the ICP-MS / MS device, for example, an ICP mass spectrometer manufactured by PerkinElmer Co., Ltd. can be used, but is not limited to a specific device. By using such a device, steps (1) to (5) described below can be fully automated without manual intervention.

[0025] The method for analyzing chlorine having a mass number M according to this embodiment includes the following steps. (1) introducing a sample solution into an ionization section to obtain an ion group; (2) removing ions having mass numbers other than mass number M (M is 1 or more selected from 35, 36, and 37) from the group of ions in a first quadrupole mass filter; (3) contacting the ions that have passed through the first quadrupole mass filter with a reaction gas consisting of an element having a mass number m (m is 1 for hydrogen gas and 2 for deuterium gas) selected from hydrogen gas and deuterium gas in a reaction cell to generate polyatomic ions having a mass number (M+2m). (4) removing ions having mass numbers other than (M+2m) in a second quadrupole mass filter; (5) detecting the signal of the ion having the mass number (M+2m) that has passed through the second quadrupole mass filter

[0026] The sample solution to be measured is a solution-like sample that may contain Cl-M. The solution may be an aqueous solution or a solution containing a solvent other than water. In the ionization step described below, the solution may contain Cl-M in a state in which Cl-M in the sample can be ionized in the ionization unit. Note that, as a measurement result, a solution that contains Cl-M at or below the lower detection limit may also contain Cl-M, and a solution that requires measurement is included in the sample solution. And, as long as the above steps (1) to (4) are performed, regardless of whether or not chlorine is detected as a result, the method for analyzing chlorine with mass number M according to this embodiment can be said to be the same as the method for analyzing chlorine with mass number M according to this embodiment.

[0027] The specific sample solution varies depending on the purpose of the analysis, and is not particularly limited. For example, in the analysis of Cl-36, which is a radioisotope, the sample solution may be, but is not limited to, wastewater from a nuclear power plant, environmental water around a nuclear power plant, liquid in contact with components of a nuclear power plant such as a nuclear reactor, or environmental water (e.g., groundwater, etc.) near a radioactive waste disposal facility. When analyzing solid Cl-36 attached to components of a nuclear reactor or Cl-36 in soil, the components or soil can be washed with an etching solution made of an acid such as nitric acid or sulfuric acid, and the solution in which Cl-36 is eluted can be used as the sample solution. In addition, when measuring a sample in a suspension state, the suspended matter is dissolved to prepare a sample solution, and then the measurement is performed.

[0028] The sample solution may be subjected to steps (1) to (5) after pretreatment, or steps (1) to (5) may be carried out without pretreatment. Pretreatment includes, but is not limited to, concentrating Cl-M and removing interfering elements. The concentration and removal of interfering elements will be described later.

[0029] Hereinafter, a method for quantifying Cl-36 in a sample as the only substance to be detected and distinguishing it from the stable chlorine isotopes Cl-35 and Cl-37 will be described with reference to FIG.

[0030] (1) Ionization process In step (1), the sample solution s is atomized and introduced into the ionization section P for ionization. The amount of the sample solution s introduced in this step varies depending on the ICP-MS / MS device 1 used, and can be appropriately determined by those skilled in the art in accordance with the instructions for the ICP-MS device 1. As an example, the amount can be 10 to 5000 μL, and preferably 400 to 3000 μL, per measurement.

[0031] In this step, argon plasma is generated in the ionization section P of the ICP-MS / MS device 1 to ionize the elements in the sample solution s. This produces an ion group consisting of multiple types of ions including Cl-36 ions, which are the target substance to be detected. These ions include Ar-36 derived from the argon plasma, and may also contain S-36.

[0032] (2) removing ions having mass numbers other than mass number M; In this step, ions with mass numbers other than those of the target substance are removed. This step is performed by specifying the mass number "36" of the ions to be passed through the first quadrupole mass filter Q1 in the ICP-MS / MS device 1. By performing a step to remove ions with mass numbers other than 36, the chlorine isotopes Cl-35 and Cl-37 are removed, but Ar-36 cannot be removed in this step. In addition, depending on the pretreatment conditions, the sulfur isotope S-36 may remain unremoved.

[0033] (3) generating polyatomic ions with mass number (M+2m) In step (3), the ions that passed through the first quadrupole mass filter Q1 in step (2) are brought into contact with a reaction gas g in the reaction cell Q2. In this step, the reaction cell Q2 of the ICP-MS / MS device is set in a reaction mode, and reaction gas g is supplied to the reaction cell Q2 under conditions in which the ions contained in the ions, particularly Cl-36 ions, can react with the reaction gas g. High-purity hydrogen gas ( 1 H2 gas) or deuterium gas ( 2It is preferable to use hydrogen gas (also referred to as H2 gas or D2 gas). Hydrogen gas or deuterium gas is preferable as a reaction gas because it has a low detection limit for chlorine detection, high accuracy, and can reduce background. Among them, it is particularly preferable to use deuterium gas.

[0034] The condition under which Cl-36 ions can react with the reaction gas g refers to a condition in which a high-purity gas is used as the reaction gas g, and in the case of hydrogen gas, the gas is introduced into the reaction cell Q2 at a flow rate of, for example, 1.0 to 2.0 mL / min, and in the case of deuterium gas, the gas is introduced at a flow rate of, for example, 1.5 to 3.0 mL / min. In this way, when the reaction gas g is hydrogen gas, 36 Cl 1 H 1 This produces polyatomic ions, denoted as H. In the case of hydrogen gas, the mass number of the hydrogen is m=1, and the mass number of the polyatomic ion is expressed as M+2m=38. Similarly, when the reaction gas g is deuterium gas, 36 Cl 2 H 2 H or 36 This produces polyatomic ions, denoted as ClDD. The mass number of polyatomic ions is expressed as M+2m=40 in the case of deuterium gas, where m is the mass number of deuterium, m=2. Depending on the flow rate of hydrogen gas or deuterium gas, 36 Cl 1 H and 36 Cl 1 H 1 H 1 In some cases, H and other gases may be generated, but by appropriately controlling the flow rate conditions, if the reaction gas g is hydrogen gas, 36 Cl 1 H 1 When H is reacted with deuterium gas, 36 Cl 2 H 2 H can be selectively generated. Note that the above suitable gas flow rates are merely examples and may vary depending on the specifications of the apparatus. In this case, a person skilled in the art can selectively generate the desired polyatomic ions by prior experiments. M Cl m H m H is produced and polyatomic ions M Clm H and M Cl m H m H m No H is produced and the desired polyatomic ions M Cl m H m It is possible to appropriately determine the flow rate condition of the reaction gas g that is less likely to cause noise in the counting of H.

[0035] At this point, Ar-36 or S-36, which may be present, may react with the reaction gas g, but this rarely affects detection for the following reasons. When reaction gas g is deuterium gas, the mass number is M+m. 36 Ar 2 H is produced in relatively large amounts, 36 Ar 2 H 2 The inventors have experimentally confirmed that H is difficult to generate. When the reaction gas g is hydrogen gas, the mass number is M+m. 36 Ar 1 H is produced in relatively large amounts, 36 Ar 1 H 1 The inventors have experimentally confirmed that H is difficult to generate. It has also been confirmed that S-36 is difficult to react with hydrogen and deuterium, and difficult to form polyatomic ions with a mass number of M+2m. However, when the sulfur concentration in the sample exceeds 10 ppm, it is preferable to remove sulfur by ion chromatography, which will be described later.

[0036] (4) A step of removing ions having mass numbers other than (M+2m) In step (4), the group of ions that may include the polyatomic ions with mass number M+2m obtained in step (3) is introduced into a second quadrupole mass filter Q3. In the second quadrupole mass filter Q3, the mass number to be passed is set to M+2m, so that ions with mass numbers other than M+2m can be removed. By the operation of this step, ions including Ar-36 or polyatomic ions are removed.

[0037] (5) A step of detecting the signal of an ion having a mass number of (M+2m) In step (5), the detection unit D counts the polyatomic ion signals of mass number (M+2m) that have passed through the quadrupole mass filter without being removed in step (4). As a result, when Cl-36 is contained in the sample, it can be detected as a polyatomic ion of (M+2m). The detection can be performed, for example, based on the peak shape of the polyatomic ion of mass number (M+2m) in a plot with the measurement time on the horizontal axis and the ion count per unit time on the vertical axis. More specifically, when hydrogen gas is used as the reaction gas g, the amount can be quantified based on the peak shape of the polyatomic ion of mass number 38, and when deuterium gas is used as the reaction gas g, the amount can be quantified based on the peak shape of the polyatomic ion of mass number 40.

[0038] Therefore, the presence or absence of the peak can be confirmed to detect the presence or absence of the polyatomic ion with mass number (36+2m). Also, the amount of Cl-36 can be quantified based on the peak shape obtained from the ion count. According to one aspect, the quantification based on the peak shape may be quantification based on the maximum value of the peak height of the peak shape. According to another aspect, the quantification based on the peak shape may be quantification based on the intensity integrated value of the peak area of ​​the peak shape. From the viewpoint of the accuracy of the quantification, the quantification method based on the intensity integrated value of the peak area is more preferable. In either case, the amount of Cl-36 can be quantified by obtaining the maximum value of the peak height or the intensity integrated value of the peak area for a plurality of samples with known concentrations such as a standard source of Cl-36 by the method of this embodiment, and creating a calibration curve based on these values.

[0039] According to one embodiment of the present invention, by carrying out the above steps (1) to (5), Cl-36 can be detected separately from chlorine isotopes and argon and sulfur isotopes. In particular, it is possible to quantify Cl-36 more simply and quickly than the conventional method of measuring β-rays. Cl-36 has a low natural abundance, and in the conventional mass spectrometry, it was sometimes difficult to accurately quantify Cl-36 because it overlaps with the peak of Cl-35, which has a high natural abundance. According to the present invention, Cl-36 can be individually quantified with high accuracy, which is particularly useful in quantifying radioisotopes.

[0040] According to another embodiment of the present invention, the method may include a step of removing interfering elements from the sample solution by ion chromatography (IC) prior to the above steps (1) to (5). In this specification, this step is also referred to as an IC pretreatment step.

[0041] The IC pretreatment step can be performed by an ion chromatography device (IC device) equipped with a column capable of selectively extracting chloride ions. Such IC devices and columns capable of selectively extracting chloride ions are commercially available, and any commercially available products can be used. In one embodiment, the IC device may be mainly composed of a liquid delivery section equipped with a pump for delivering an eluent to the device, an introduction section for introducing a sample solution into the device, a separation section equipped with a guard column and a separation column, and a suppressor section for separating the mobile phase. In this embodiment, it is preferable to further include a liquid delivery means for delivering the sample solution from which interfering elements, particularly sulfur S, have been removed to the sample introduction section of the ICP-MS / MS device for carrying out steps (1) to (5).

[0042] The IC pretreatment step can be performed by introducing the sample solution into the IC device. By introducing the sample solution into the column of the IC device, the chloride ions are temporarily retained in the separation column, but are then carried away by the eluent and move through the column. Since the speed at which the ions move through the column differs depending on the valence, ionic radius, hydrophobicity, etc., the chloride ions are separated and concentrated from other ions while passing through the column. The speed of the liquid delivery can be appropriately determined according to the instructions for the device. Note that the chloride ions referred to here include all of the Cl-35 ions, Cl-36 ions, and Cl-37 ions. Since the IC device cannot distinguish between the chlorine isotopes Cl-35, Cl-36, Cl-37, etc., the sample solution that has undergone the IC pretreatment step mainly contains Cl-35 ions, Cl-36 ions, and Cl-37 ions.

[0043] Next, the sample solution that has undergone the IC pretreatment step is sent to the sample introduction section of the ICP-MS device, and steps (1) to (5) are carried out as described above. By carrying out the IC pretreatment step, the main interfering element sulfur S-36 is separated and removed, which is advantageous because it prevents the reaction in the reaction cell Q2 from producing polyatomic ions containing sulfur.

[0044] According to another embodiment of the present invention, a step of applying a sample solution to a concentration column to concentrate Cl-36 can be carried out before the IC pretreatment step, after the IC pretreatment step, or before step (1) when the IC pretreatment step is not carried out. Hereinafter, this step is referred to as the concentration step. The concentration column used in the concentration step may be a resin column capable of extracting Cl-36. For example, CL resin for extraction chromatography manufactured by TRISKEM INTERNATIONAL can be used, but is not limited to a specific concentration column. In more detail, the step when CL resin manufactured by TRISKEM INTERNATIONAL is used can be carried out with reference to the method described in, for example, Journal of Radioanalytical and Nuclear Chemistry volume 286, pages 539-546 (2010).

[0045] In the enrichment process, chlorine is extracted from the sample solution and can be enriched approximately 300 times. Cl-35, Cl-36, Cl-37, and other elements that may be contained in the sample solution are adsorbed to the enrichment column. By carrying out the enrichment process, chlorine can be selectively extracted from the sample solution, and the sample solution with reduced sulfur isobars can be introduced into the IC device or ICP-MS / MS device. This allows for more accurate separation of interfering elements in the IC device.

[0046] Similarly, when the detection target substance is Cl-35 or Cl-37, Cl-35 or Cl-37 can be concentrated by using a resin capable of specifically concentrating these isotopes, distinguishing them from other isotopes. However, the method according to the embodiment of the present invention is advantageous in that it is possible to precisely detect Cl-35, Cl-36, and Cl-37 without performing such a concentration operation, since it has high accuracy and a low detection limit.

[0047] The above explanation is an example of detecting and quantifying only Cl-36, but other types of detection can also be performed using the same device. For example, the following will supplement the case of detecting and quantifying Cl-35 and Cl36, with Cl-37 not being the detection target. The IC pretreatment step can be performed in the same way as in the case of Cl-36. After being introduced into the ICP-MS / MS device, the ionization step of step (1) is performed in the same way as described above. In the step of removing ions having mass numbers other than mass number M of step (2), ions having mass numbers other than mass numbers 35 and 36 are removed by the first quadrupole mass filter Q1. Removal of ions of multiple different mass numbers in the quadrupole mass filter can be performed by changing the settings of the device. Therefore, at this stage, 38 Ar ions, 40 In the step (3) of generating polyatomic ions having a mass number of (M+2m), when the reaction gas is hydrogen, two types of polyatomic ions are generated: 35 Cl 1 H 1 H (mass number 37) 36 Cl 1 H1 H (mass number 38) is produced. When the reaction gas is deuterium, two polyatomic ions are produced: 35 Cl 2 H 2 H (mass number 39) 36 Cl 2 H 2 H (mass number 40) is produced. At this point, as explained above, 36 Ar may be present. Next, in step (4) of removing ions having mass numbers other than (M+2m), the second quadrupole mass filter Q3 removes ions having mass numbers other than 37 and 38 when the reaction gas is hydrogen gas, and removes ions having mass numbers other than 39 and 40 when the reaction gas is deuterium gas. 36 Ar ions, 36 Ions other than those with mass number M+2m obtained by the reaction of Ar with the reaction gas can also be removed at this stage. Then, in the step (5) of detecting the signal of the ion with mass number (M+2m), polyatomic ions with mass numbers 37 and 38 or polyatomic ions with mass numbers 39 and 40 can be detected, and Cl-35 and Cl-36 can be quantified.

[0048] According to the embodiment of detecting and quantifying Cl-35 and Cl-36, Cl-35 and Cl-36 can be simultaneously and individually quantified.

[0049] Similarly, by removing ions having mass numbers other than 35, 36, and 37 in step (2) and removing ions having mass numbers other than 37, 38, and 39 (when the reaction gas is hydrogen gas) or ions having mass numbers other than 37, 38, and 39 (when the reaction gas is deuterium gas) in step (4), it becomes possible to simultaneously and individually quantify Cl-35, Cl-36, and Cl-37. EXAMPLES

[0050] The present invention will be described in more detail below using examples. However, the following examples are not intended to limit the present invention. In the following examples, the operations were performed using PerkinElmer's NexION5000 as an ICP-MS device and Thermo Fisher's (formerly Dionex) DX-800 as an IC device.

[0051] 1. Consideration of reaction gas flow rate The reaction gas flow rate was examined for the stable chlorine isotopes Cl-35 and Cl-37 when hydrogen and deuterium were used as reaction gases. Samples containing Cl-35 and Cl-37 at concentrations of 1 ppm each were ionized and passed through the first quadrupole mass filter Q1 to remove ions of a certain mass number, and then reacted in the reaction cell Q2 by changing the flow rate of hydrogen gas or deuterium gas. The ion counts that passed through the second quadrupole mass filter Q3 were then plotted. Figure 2 shows the plot when the reaction gas was hydrogen gas, and Figure 3 shows the plot when the reaction gas was deuterium gas. In the legend, the notation "NN / nn" following the ion or polyatomic ion indicates "mass number of the ion passed through Q1 / mass number of the ion passed through Q3". In the following examples, 36 / nn in the graph legend indicates the ion count obtained by passing an ion with mass number 36 through Q1 and an ion with mass number nn through Q3.

[0052] From Figure 2, it was confirmed that when the reaction gas is hydrogen gas, if the gas flow rate is about 1.0 mL / min or more, preferably about 1.5 mL / min or more, both Cl-35 and Cl-37 react with two hydrogen atoms to generate polyatomic ions, and can be detected with almost no interference from other polyatomic ions derived from Cl-35 or Cl-37. Note that the plots of ClHHH35 / 38 and ClHHH37 / 40 are close to 0 and overlap.

[0053] From Figure 3, it was confirmed that when the reaction gas is deuterium gas, if the gas flow rate is about 1.5 mL / min or more, preferably about 2.0 mL / min or more, both Cl-35 and Cl-37 react with two deuterium atoms to generate polyatomic ions, and they can be detected with almost no interference from other polyatomic ions derived from Cl-35 or Cl-37. Furthermore, comparing Figures 2 and 3, it was confirmed that the sensitivity is higher when deuterium ions are used as the reaction gas. The plots of ClD3 35 / 41, ClD4 35 / 43, ClD5 35 / 45, and ClD3 37 / 43 are close to 0 and overlap.

[0054] Next, we investigated the reaction gas flow rate for the radioisotope Cl-36, when reacting a sample containing 202 Bq / mL of Cl-36 with hydrogen and deuterium as reaction gases. Figure 4 shows a plot of the ion counts of each mass number that passed through the quadrupole mass filter Q3 when the reaction gas was hydrogen gas and when the reaction gas was deuterium gas. The higher the ion count, the higher the sensitivity.

[0055] FIG. 5 is a graph in which the results of FIG. 4 are superimposed with plots of the ion counts of a blank sample. The blank sample here refers to a sample that does not contain Cl-36. A large ion count of a blank sample indicates a large noise. 36 Cl 2 D 2 D or 36 Cl 1 H 1 It is effective to measure at a reaction gas flow rate at which the sensitivity to H becomes high in order to obtain a net ion count. From FIG. 5, it was confirmed that, under the conditions of the measurement apparatus, it is effective to measure at a reaction gas flow rate of about 1.0 to 3.0 mL / min, preferably about 1.5 to 3.0 mL / min.

[0056] 2.Investigation of product ions generated from Cl-36 Next, we investigated the polyatomic ions generated when reacting oxygen gas, deuterium gas, or hydrogen gas as the reaction gas. A sample containing 202 Bq / mL of Cl-36 was ionized, and the mass number of the ions passing through the first quadrupole mass filter Q1 was set to 36. In the reaction cell Q2, oxygen gas was flowed at a flow rate of 1.1 mL / min, deuterium gas at 2.0 mL / min, and hydrogen gas at 1.0 mL / min. The mass number of the ions passing through the second quadrupole mass filter Q3 was set as scan, and the ion count against the mass number of the product detected by the detection unit was plotted. Here, scan means a setting in which the mass number of the ions passing through is continuously changed to obtain a mass spectrum plotted with the horizontal axis as the mass number and the vertical axis as the ion count.

[0057] FIG. 6 shows a graph of the case where oxygen gas was used as the reaction gas (comparative example), FIG. 7 shows a graph of the case where deuterium gas was used, and FIG. 8 shows a graph of the case where hydrogen gas was used. From FIG. 6, it was confirmed that a large amount of by-products was generated when oxygen gas was used as the reaction gas. From FIGS. 7 and 8, when deuterium gas or hydrogen gas was used as the reaction gas, fewer by-products were generated compared to when oxygen gas was used. Furthermore, compared to hydrogen gas, deuterium gas had no peaks at adjacent mass numbers and the peak was sharp. This means that the accuracy of the measurement using deuterium gas is high. From the results of FIGS. 6 to 8, the relationship between the intensity of the product ions (ClDD, ClHH, ClO) derived from chlorine and the reaction gas was D2>H2>O2.

[0058] 3. Calibration curve and detection limit for Cl-36 Calibration curves were created when a sample containing a known concentration of Cl-36 was reacted with three reaction gases: oxygen gas, deuterium gas, and hydrogen gas. No pretreatment using ion chromatography was performed. The flow rate of each gas was the same as in the previous experiment. The mass numbers of the ions allowed to pass through each mass filter were Q1(36) / Q3(52) for oxygen gas, Q1(36) / Q3(40) for deuterium gas, and Q1(36) / Q3(38) for hydrogen gas. The calibration curves obtained are shown in Figure 9. For deuterium gas, the calibration curve is expressed as y = 94.189x + 75.133, and R 2 For hydrogen gas, the calibration curve is expressed as y = 73.53x + 81.667, and R 2 For oxygen gas, the calibration curve is expressed as y = 6.6728x + 986.4, and R 2 =0.8907. As the calibration curve with a high correlation coefficient was obtained, it was confirmed that highly accurate quantification is possible, especially when hydrogen and deuterium are used as reaction gases. The detection limit was 0.089 Bq / mL when deuterium gas was used, 0.46 Bq / mL when hydrogen gas was used, and 6.2 Bq / mL when oxygen gas was used. These detection limits were calculated by dividing three times the standard deviation of the intensity obtained by repeatedly measuring the blank solution five times by the slope of the calibration curve. From this result, it was confirmed that the detection sensitivity of hydrogen gas is about 10 times that of oxygen gas, and that of deuterium gas is about 100 times that of oxygen gas. From Figure 9, it was confirmed that the intercept value of the calibration curve when deuterium gas and hydrogen gas were used as reaction gases is extremely close to zero and has less noise compared to the calibration curve when oxygen gas is used. In addition, the magnitude of the slope of the calibration curve was deuterium gas > hydrogen gas > oxygen gas. A calibration curve with a steep slope indicates a sharp response to low concentrations, i.e., high sensitivity.

[0059] 4. Ion Chromatography-ICP-MS / MS After removing interferences from samples containing Cl-36 at known concentrations by ion chromatography, a calibration curve was created using the results of measurements with an ICP-MS / MS device. The column used for ion chromatography was a strong basic anion exchange column GL-IC-A23 manufactured by Showa Denko Material Technoservice Co., Ltd. The flow rates of each gas were the same as in the previous experiment. The mass numbers of the ions passed through each mass filter were Q1(36) / Q3(40) for deuterium gas, Q1(36) / Q3(38) for hydrogen gas, and Q1(36) / Q3(52) for oxygen gas.

[0060] FIG. 10(a) is a graph showing the ion count of the product detected in the detection unit versus measurement time when deuterium gas is used as the reaction gas, and FIG. 10(b) shows a calibration curve (height) created based on the maximum peak height value of the peak shape in FIG. 10(a) and a calibration curve (integrated intensity) created based on the intensity integrated value of the peak area. The calibration curve for height is expressed as y=360.63x+20, and R 2 = 0.9947. The calibration curve of the integrated intensity is expressed as y = 5650.6x + 80, and R 2 = 0.9995. In graph (a), time 0 represents the time when ion chromatography started and measurement by ICP-MS / MS started. When deuterium gas was used as the reaction gas, the slope of the calibration curve was 5650 / 218 = 26 times that when oxygen gas was used as the reaction gas.

[0061] FIG. 11(a) is a graph showing the ion count of the product detected in the detection unit versus measurement time when hydrogen gas is used as the reaction gas, and FIG. 11(b) shows a calibration curve (height) created based on the maximum peak height value in FIG. 11(a) and a calibration curve (integrated intensity) created based on the integrated intensity value of the peak area. The calibration curve for height is expressed as y=274.46x+20, and R 2 = 0.9983. The calibration curve of the integrated intensity is expressed as y = 4579.8x + 80, and R 2= 0.9996. When hydrogen gas was used as the reaction gas, the slope of the calibration curve was 4580 / 218 = 21 times that when oxygen gas was used as the reaction gas.

[0062] In Fig. 12, (a) is a graph showing the ion count of the product detected in the detection unit versus measurement time when oxygen gas is used as the reaction gas, and (b) shows a calibration curve (height) created based on the maximum peak height value in (a) and a calibration curve (integrated intensity) created based on the intensity integrated value of the peak area. The calibration curve for height is expressed as y = 14.934x + 166.65, and R 2 = 1. The calibration curve of the integrated intensity is expressed as y = 217.88x + 7093.2, and R 2 =1.

[0063] 10 to 12, it was confirmed that the slope of the calibration curve became larger and the sensitivity was improved.

[0064] Next, 1 Bq / mL Cl-36 containing 0.1 vol% sulfuric acid was measured by ICP-MS / MS as a standard solution sample with a known concentration containing substances containing interfering sulfur atoms. The flow rate of deuterium gas was 2.0 mL / min, and that of hydrogen gas was 1.5 mL / min. The mass numbers of ions passing through each mass filter were Q1(36) / Q3(40) for deuterium gas and Q1(36) / Q3(38) for hydrogen gas. Figure 13 is a graph showing the ion count of the product detected at the detector against time. A sharp peak of Cl-36 was observed at about 105 sec on the horizontal axis. An unclear peak due to ions containing sulfur was confirmed from about 150 to 300 sec, suggesting that Cl-36 was detected without being affected by sulfur.

[0065] The quantitative values ​​of Cl-36 at 1 Bq / mL in a 0.1 vol% sulfuric acid solution are shown in Table 1 below. The units of values ​​in the table are Bq / mL. The results in Table 1 confirmed that quantitative determination was possible for the standard solution samples. [Table 1]

[0066] 5. Determination of Cl-36 in Adachi Groundwater by IC-ICP-MS / MS Cl-36 in Adachi groundwater (groundwater collected near Nihonmatsu City, Fukushima Prefecture) was measured by IC-ICP-MS / MS (n=3). After removing sulfur isobars (S-36) by ion chromatography as in 4 above, measurements were performed with an ICP-MS / MS device using deuterium as the reaction gas. The flow rate of deuterium gas was 2.0 mL / min, and the mass numbers of the ions passed through each mass filter were Q1 (36) / Q3 (40). Figure 14 is a graph showing the ion count of the product detected by the detector versus measurement time. A sample spiked with 1 Bq / mL of Cl-36 and a non-spiked sample were measured. It was found that Adachi groundwater contains almost no sulfate ions.

[0067] The quantitative results for Cl-36 are shown in Table 2 below. The values ​​in the table are in Bq / mL. [Table 2] As shown in Table 2, the quantitative result of Cl-36 in the non-spike sample was less than the detection limit of 0.030 Bq / mL, and the quantitative result of Cl-36 in the sample spiked with 1 Bq / mL of Cl-36 was 0.983 ± 0.016 Bq / mL.

[0068] 6. Determination of Cl-36 in mineral spring water by IC-ICP-MS / MS Cl-36 in mineral water (groundwater collected near Hagi City, Ibaraki Prefecture) was measured by IC-ICP-MS / MS. After removing sulfur isobars (S-36) by ion chromatography as in 4 above, measurements were performed by an ICP-MS / MS device using deuterium as the reaction gas. The flow rate of deuterium gas was 2.0 mL / min, and the mass numbers of the ions passed through each mass filter were Q1 (36) / Q3 (40). Figure 15 is a graph showing the ion count of the product detected in the detector versus measurement time. (a) shows the measurement result of a non-spiked sample, and (b) shows the measurement result of a sample spiked with 1 Bq / mL of Cl-36. As a result of the measurement of mineral water containing a relatively large amount of sulfate ions, in both (a) and (b), the peak of ions derived from sulfur separated from Cl-36 by ion chromatography was observed in a wide range centered around about 360 seconds.

[0069] The quantitative results for Cl-36 are shown in Table 3 below. The values ​​in the table are in Bq / mL. [Table 3] From Table 3, the quantitative result of Cl-36 in the non-spiked sample was less than the detection limit of 0.039 Bq / mL, and the quantitative result of Cl-36 in the sample spiked with 1 Bq / mL of Cl-36 was 1.0275 Bq / mL, which is the average of n4 measurements. In addition, the same mineral water was previously measured by ion chromatography, and the sulfate ion (SO4 - ) concentration was 1040.835 mg / L, and the chloride ion (Cl) concentration was 105.180 mg / L. [Explanation of symbols]

[0070] 1 ICP-MS / MS instrument, s sample solution, g reaction gas P Ionization section, Q1 First quadrupole mass filter, Q2 Reaction cell Q3 Second quadrupole mass filter, D Detector

Claims

1. A method for analyzing chlorine having a mass number M (M is 1 or more selected from 35, 36, and 37) using an inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer including an ionization unit, a first quadrupole mass filter, a reaction cell, a second quadrupole mass filter, and a detection unit, comprising: A step of introducing a sample solution into the ionization unit to obtain an ion group; removing ions having mass numbers other than mass number M from the group of ions in the first quadrupole mass filter; contacting the ions that have passed through the first quadrupole mass filter with a reaction gas consisting of an element having a mass number m (m is 1 for hydrogen gas and 2 for deuterium gas) selected from hydrogen gas and deuterium gas in the reaction cell to generate polyatomic ions having a mass number (M+2m); removing ions having mass numbers other than (M+2m) in the second quadrupole mass filter; detecting a signal of an ion having a mass number of (M+2m) that has passed through the second quadrupole mass filter; A chlorine analysis method comprising:

2. The polyatomic ion is M C m H m The method for analyzing chlorine according to claim 1, wherein H is

3. The method of claim 1 , further comprising the step of removing interfering elements in the sample solution by ion chromatography prior to the ionizing step.

4. 2. The method according to claim 1, wherein the step of detecting a signal of an ion having a mass number of (M+2m) is a step of detecting chlorine having a mass number of M based on the intensity of an ion count of the mass number of (M+2m).

5. The method according to claim 4, wherein the step of detecting chlorine having a mass number M based on the intensity of the ion count is a step of quantifying chlorine having a mass number M based on an intensity integrated value of a peak area of ​​a peak shape obtained from an ion count of a mass number (M+2m).

6. The method according to claim 4, wherein the step of detecting chlorine having a mass number M based on the peak shape of the ion count is a step of quantifying chlorine having a mass number M based on the maximum peak height of the peak shape obtained from the ion count of the mass number (M+2m).

7. 2. The method of claim 1, wherein M is 35, 36, and 37, and three isotopes of chlorine are detected simultaneously.

8. 2. The method of claim 1, wherein M is 36 and a radioactive isotope of chlorine is detected in discrimination with a stable isotope of chlorine.

9. 9. The method of claim 7 or 8, wherein the reaction gas is deuterium gas.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Analytical method of strontium 90, and analyzer

    JP2015087363A